CDC Built Environment Assess
CDC Built Environment Assess
CDC Built Environment Assess
Unless otherwise indicated, all pictures in this document were taken by Kenneth Goodman.
Appendices
A Development of the DCH BE Tool
B Experts Who Participated in the Tool Development Process
C Built Environment Assessment Sources Used to Inform the Development of the BE Tool
D DCH Built Environment Assessment Tool
E DCH BE Tool Instructions
F Data Coding and Scoring Table
Commercial Corridor
If your interest is in the built environment around an intersection (or set of 4-way Intersection
intersections), then you may want to use the tool for each segment around
the intersection. By doing this, you will assess the intersection, all crossings
around the intersection, and the street segments leading to the intersection.
For a 4-way intersection, four separate tools would be used, with the
questions on intersection geometry and intersection control overlapping.
D4 D4
C4 E4
D1 C1 B4 A4 C3 D3
D1 B1 B3 D3
E1 B2 A3 E3
E2 C2
D2 D2
D1 C1 G1 C2 D2 G2 C3 D3
D1 B1 B2 D2 B3
E1 A1 F1 A2 E2 F2 A3 E3
As represented in the above graphics, assessing an intersection will require completing four BE Tools and assessing
the corridor as shown above would require three BE Tools plus extra crossing sections for F1, G1, F2, and G2. When
moving from one segment to the next, either as a corridor or as intersections, some sections of the tool will not need
to be repeated. By completing one tool you will have already assessed the intersection geometry and controls, and will
not need to repeat that assessment for the same intersection. For example, when assessing the segments around an
intersection, A1 is sufficient for assessing the intersection, and A2-4 would be unnecessary to repeat. For the corridor,
A1 assesses the intersection so that it is not necessary to repeat it in A2, while D2 assesses the next intersection so that
A3 is not necessary. In these cases, you may either repeat the intersection questions so they can be combined later, or
make a note that it is already assessed in Segment ID#_____.
Background
The impetus for the development of the BE Tool was related to requests by DCH awardees for a tool that assesses
features of the built environment related specifically to health behaviors that impact obesity. A wide array of tools
exists for measuring different features of the built environment, many of them well validated. However, it is often
difficult for DCHs local program staff and evaluators to know which features of the built environment are most
important to measure on the basis of the health behaviors and outcomes they are trying to affect. It is also difficult
to know which tool or tools to choose to best assess those features, and the feasibility of assessing them given limited
resources. For this reason, the BE Tool was developed to provide an observational tool that DCH awardees and others
can use to assess core features of the built environment related specifically to health behaviors that impact obesity.
This effort builds on a CDC-funded project that reviewed the existing built environment assessment tools to determine
which features of the built environment are measured by these tools; which tools measured which features; and which
tools are well validated (UIC, 2009). We used the list of built environment features from the UIC report, supplemented
by subject matter experts, to guide the expert input process.
Sources
The third step of expert input helped to select questions for each built environment feature. The questions selected for
inclusion in the BE Tool were adapted from five existing built environment assessment tools. For further information,
links to the Web sites for these tools can be found in Appendix C.
MAPS (Microscale Audit of Pedestrian Streetscapes)
PRC-HAN (Prevention Research Centers Healthy Aging Research Network) Environmental Audit Tool
Analytic Audit Tool (St. Louis University)
QPAT (Quick Pathways Accessibility Tool)
BRAT-DO (Bedimo-Rung Assessment Tools Direct Observation)
The top three tools from which questions were taken are closely related to each other. The PRC-HAN tool and MAPS
tool were developed as refinements of the Analytic Audit Tool, with the MAPS tool also building on the PRC-HAN
tool. Because of this progression of refinement and validation, and through our process of expert input, we found that
the MAPS tool was the best source for questions, response options, and well-developed scoring guidance. A majority
of questions taken from the MAPS tool, however, were modified so that the response options were from MAPS but the
response format was similar to PRC-HAN, in order to rate both sides of the street segment separately for certain items.
This modification was made because for some features of the built environment the MAPS tool only assesses one side
of the street, and many of these features are related to walkability and bikability (e.g., sidewalks, bike lanes, curb cuts),
! 0 ! 1 ! 2+ ! 0 ! 1 ! 2+ Check one
! T-intersection
u. Post office ii. Sports/playing field or court (e.g., baseball or
tennis at park or school) ! 4-way intersection
! 0 ! 1 ! 2+ ! 5-way star
! 0 ! 1 ! 2+
v. Senior center ! 6-way (e.g., three streets)
jj. Sports track
! 0 ! 1 ! 2+ 67) Intersection Control:
! 0 ! 1 ! 2+
w. Place of worship (e.g., church, synagogue, Check items present
convent, mosque, etc.) kk. Body of water (e.g., lake, ocean) ! None
! 0 ! 1 ! 2+ ! 0 ! 1 ! 2+ ! Yield signs/Flashing yellow
x. School ll. Other recreational facility (e.g., skating rink, ! Stop signs/Flashing red light
miniature golf) ! Traffic signal
! 0 ! 1 ! 2+
! 0 ! 1 ! 2+ ! Traffic circle, Roundabout
! Yes ! No
Many of the response options in the BE Tool are formatted to provide separate responses for each block face of the
street segment. For those questions, use your map (and compass) to properly indicate the orientation of each block face
when marking responses. After completing assessment for one block face and crossing the second intersection, mark
responses for the opposing block face from the one you already assessed.
Complete the information about date, day, start and end times, and data collector name for each instance in which the
tool is used for . Rather than pre-populating this section prior to going into the field, it is best if you complete this part
immediately prior to rating the street segment to be sure it accurately reflects when the data collection was completed.
Date:
Day of week:
Start time: AM/PM
End time: AM/PM
Data collector:
This section of street segment information should be pre-populated prior to going into the field to rate street segments.
To ensure accuracy, this information should come from maps (or GIS), as well as the data collection management
database. Raters should confirm this information in the field.
Street Name:
Segment ID:
Segment length:
Segment primary direction North-South East-West
Cross streets at intersections:
Intersection 1: Intersection 2:
Street Name: Street Name:
(at N E S W end of street. Circle one) (at N E S W end of street. Circle one)
Zoning type:
Crossing from N S E W to N S E W
Curb cut (w tactile Paving/truncated dome) Curb cut (w tactile Paving/truncated dome)
Ramp does not line up with crossing Ramp lines up with crossing
Slope (or grade) is the measurement of rise over run. An 8.33% slope is 1ft (or 1) vertical rise per 12ft (or 12)
horizontal distance. It is the maximum allowable slope under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). The
horizontal run of the curb ramp should be measured from where it intersects with the sidewalk to where it meets
the road. Tools to measure this include a tape measure (or yard stick), a level, and potentially a length of string.
Making sure that the tool being used to measure run is level (using the level), you can then measure the vertical
distance from the street to that string, tape measure, or yard stick for the rise. A simple formula can then be used to
determine slope. This resource can provide guidance: http://www.fhwa.dot.gov/environment/recreational_trails/
publications/fs_publications/01232833/appenb.cfm
Road Configuration
15) Is the street predominantly one-way or two-way?
1-way 2-way
16) What type of road is present?
Check one
Divided highway > 4 lanes
Undivided > 4 lanes
3 lanes (or two plus center turn lane)
2 marked lanes
No marked lanes
Unpaved roadway
Speed Limit
18) Is there a posted speed limit along the route?
If multiple, select the highest
Regular
Yes mph No
Special school zone speed limit
Special school zone
Yes mph No
Be sure to only count windows on buildings within 40 feet of the sidewalk/walkway. A good estimate of 40
feet is two full-sized car lengths. If the buildings on the segment only cover a portion of the segment (e.g., one
building that covers one-fourth of the segment), and it has full window coverage, you would indicate that
25% of the segment is covered by windows, rather than 100%.
Building Setbacks
33) What is the smallest building setback from the sidewalk?
North/East South/West
No building No building
<10 feet <10 feet
1020 feet 1020 feet
2150 feet 2150 feet
51100 feet 51100 feet
>100 feet >100 feet
34) What is the largest building setback from the sidewalk/walkway?
North/East South/West
No building No building
<10 feet <10 feet
1020 feet 1020 feet
2150 feet 2150 feet
51100 feet 51100 feet
>100 feet >100 feet
39) Is there a buffer present? (Separation between the walkway and road; does not apply to roadway walking)
N/E Yes No N/A
S/W Yes No N/A
No buffer
Buffer width measures the distance between the sidewalk and curb or edge of street.
Non-continuous sidewalk
43) How steep is the sidewalk at the steepest point in the segment (excluding heaves)?
N/E Level Moderate Steep No sidewalk
S/W Level Moderate Steep No sidewalk
45) If answer to Q44 is Little, provide a steepness measure that represents the majority of the segment.
N/E Level Moderate Steep
S/W Level Moderate Steep
48) Are there temporary obstructions in the sidewalk (e.g., parked cars, sandwich boards, garbage cans)?
North/East South/West
None None
Some Some
Many Many
No sidewalk No sidewalk
For each side of the street segment, if the response to question 37 (presence of sidewalk) is Yes, then the
response for this question 49 should be N/A Sidewalk present. A street shoulder can be marked as a safe place
to walk only if it is marked with street lines. A bicycle lane should not be considered as a safe place to walk.
50) If no sidewalk, what is the width of the place on which one could safely walk? (Not in possible path of traffic)
North/East South/West
None None
< 4 ft. < 4 ft.
> 4 ft. > 4 ft.
N/A N/A
Pedestrian Lighting
53) Are street lights installed?
North/East South/West
None None
Some (e.g., overhead street lights on utility poles Some (e.g., overhead street lights on utility poles
with wide spacing) with wide spacing)
Ample (e.g., regularly spaced pedestrian lampposts) Ample (e.g., regularly spaced pedestrian lampposts)
56) Levelness and condition of bike lane (e.g., heaves, alignment, cracks, broken sections, weeds)?
North/East South/West
Does not apply Does not apply
None None
A little A little
Some Some
A lot A lot
57) Obstructions in bike lane (e.g., artificial cars, rumble strips, drainage grates or natural trees, bushes, rocks)?
North/East South/West
Does not apply Does not apply
None None
A little A little
Some Some
A lot A lot
Multi-use path
6 ft.
61) Obstructions (e.g., artificial cars, trash cans or natural trees, bushes, rocks)?
North/East South/West
Does not apply Does not apply
None None
A little A little
Some Some
A lot A lot
lanes wide
C1_1d Traffic circle Traffic circle, Roundabout Intersection Control and No = 0; Yes = 1
No = 0; Yes = 1 Signage Positive Subscale
C1_5b Ramp lines up w/xing (b) Post-crossing curb Curb Quality/Presence Ramp lines up
= 1; Ramp does not line (on N E S W side of street) Positive Subscale; w/xing = 1;
up = 2; No ramp = 3 Crossing Impediments Ramp does not
Negative Subscale line up =1; No
ramp = 0
C1_5b_ Ramp lines up with crossing Curb Quality/Presence
positive Positive Subscale
C2_1b Stop signs Stop signs/Flashing red light Intersection Control and No = 0; Yes = 1
No = 0; Yes = 1 Signage Positive Subscale
C2_1d Traffic circle Traffic circle, Roundabout Intersection Control and No = 0; Yes = 1
No = 0; Yes = 1 Signage Positive Subscale