Batson2017 Otosclerosis
Batson2017 Otosclerosis
Batson2017 Otosclerosis
Otosclerosis:
An update on diagnosis and treatment
Lora Batson, MPAS, PA-C; Denise Rizzolo, PA-C, PhD
Explain the basic histopathology, phases, causes, and risk Hearing Handicap Inventory for the Elderly Screening
factors of otosclerosis. Version (HHIE-S)a 10-question self-administered ques-
tionnaire developed to measure the social and emotional
Discuss the relevant history, physical examination, and effects of hearing loss. Scoring is from 0 (no handicap) to
diagnostic findings consistent with otosclerosis. 40 (maximum handicap).
Suggest appropriate management options, including the Tuning fork teststwo techniques, Rinne and Weber,
use of assistive devices, for patients with otosclerosis. used to measure air and bone conduction at 512 Hz. Both
tuning fork tests can be influenced by user experience
and materials.
Whisper-voice testthe examiner stands an arms length
Key points behind the patient and whispers three random letter and
Otosclerosis causes hearing loss through pathological bone number combinations while also occluding and rubbing
remodeling that affects the otic capsule of the temporal the external auditory canal of the nontest ear. The patient
bone. then repeats the whispered combinations. The test is to be
Screening tests include questionnaires, tuning fork tests, conducted twice, each time with different letter-number
whisper-voice test, and audioscope. combinations. The patient passes if he or she can cor-
rectly repeat three out of the six combinations.
Innovations in hearing aid technology and cochlear
implants may replace stapes surgery, the traditional treat- Audioscopea rechargeable, handheld audiometer and
ment for otosclerosis. otoscope combination that measures hearing thresholds of
500; 1,000; 2,000; and 4,000 Hz at 20, 25, and 40 dB.
Audioscope screenings can be performed in a clinical set-
ting in less than 90 seconds.
PATHOPHYSIOLOGY uHeariPhone application with three components: an
Normal bone remodeling occurs at a rate of 10% per year audiometric hearing screening to be performed in a quiet
throughout skeletal regions; however, a normal otic capsule noise environment (about 5 minutes); evaluation of ability
has very little bone remodelingonly 0.13% per year.2 In to understand speech in noise (1 minute); and 12 multi-
patients with otosclerosis, bone remodeling within the otic ple-choice questions from the Hearing-Dependent Daily
capsule is increased, leading to accumulation of bone Activities Scale to Evaluate Impact of Hearing Loss in Older
deposits that damage audiologic structures and worsen People. All information can easily be accessed using
normal sound transmission. The extent of aberrant bone iPhone, iPad, or iTouch and requires only the use of
remodeling in the otic capsule directly correlates to the iPhone earbuds.
abnormal audiologic findings.
Abnormal bone remodeling in otosclerosis occurs in Clinicians should consider otosclerosis as a cause of hear-
three phases: ing loss in patients who report a family history of the disease.
The otospongiosis phase, which represents an increase Hormonal conditions such as puberty, pregnancy, and
in both osteoclast activity and microvascularity.4 menopause may be associated with exacerbation of hear-
The transitional phase, which begins with deposits of ing loss in patients with preexisting otosclerosis.4 Research-
spongy bone by osteoblasts in areas of previous bone ers found estrogen receptors on otosclerotic cells, although
reabsorption.4 the specific regulatory mechanism of these receptors is
The otosclerotic phase, characterized by spongy bone unknown.7 Lippy and colleagues compared pregnant to
deposits developing into dense bone that narrows the micro- nonpregnant patients with otosclerosis and found no direct
circulation previously developed in the otospongiosis phase.4 association between pregnancy and exacerbation of hear-
These aberrant lesions can occur in many regions in the ing loss.8 Although additional research is needed to identify
following areas: anterior to oval window and stapes footplate the specific influence hormones may exhibit on hearing
(80%), round window (30%), pericochlear region (21%), loss, clinicians should suspect preexisting otosclerosis in
and anterior segment of the internal auditory canal (19%).5 patients who develop hearing loss during times of increased
hormonal production.
CAUSES AND RISK FACTORS Measles exposure is considered a risk factor for develop-
Genetic influences can contribute to otosclerosis; 60% of ing otosclerosis. Recent studies found viral materials in the
patients report a family history of the disease.4 Most nucleic acid of the stapes footplates and antibodies to the
researchers consider otosclerosis to be a condition of auto- measles virus in the inner ears of patients with otosclero-
somal dominant inheritance with an incomplete penetration; sis.9,10 Paradoxically, Komune and colleagues found that
although in 40% to 50% of patients, otosclerosis occurred a complete mRNA sequence of measles had not been
spontaneously or with variable patterns of inheritance.4,6 isolated from any otic sample.11 The exact etiologic function
correlates to hearing loss. When the ossicles stiffen and Vincent and colleagues reviewed 3,050 stapedotomies
the connection between the stapes and oval window begins and found the surgical procedure to be safe and successful
to change, a low-frequency mild conductive loss (small in treating conductive hearing loss in 94.2% of patients.20
air-bone gap) will occur (Figure 1).18 The air-bone gap is Surgical complications are rare but can include deafness,
the difference between air and bone conduction; a value necrosis of the incus, tympanic membrane perforation,
greater than 10 dB is considered abnormal. As the stapes facial nerve injury, disturbance of taste, perilymph gusher,
footplate becomes fixed to the oval window, the conduc- floating or subluxed stapes footplate, and vertigo. The
tive loss worsens (indicated by a widening air-bone gap) surgical failure rate commonly results from prosthesis
and begins to involve all frequencies.18 If cochlear lesions malposition or inappropriate prosthesis length.18
develop, as is the case in 10% of patients, high-frequency Due to the progressive nature of the disease, 10% to
sensory loss results in a mixed sensorineural and conduc- 20% of patients will require surgical revision.21 Who will
tive hearing loss pattern on the audiogram.2,18 Extensive develop disease progression or cochlear involvement can-
cochlear progression will result in mixed hearing loss in not be predicted. Following stapes surgery, hearing loss
all frequencies. can progress at variable and unpredictable rates.22 Redfors
Tympanometry is the measure of acoustic energy trans- and colleagues looked at 30 years poststapedectomy data
mission. Tympanograms often are normal in patients with and found that 88% of patients had bilateral involvement
otosclerosis. Only in extensive cases of otosclerosis may and 66% of patients showed moderate to profound loss
the patients tympanogram demonstrate some flattening secondary to progressive development of sensorineural
secondary to severe ossicular chain fixation.18 involvement.23
High-resolution CT is beginning to be used in diagnosis Hearing aids are an alternative for patients who are not
and surgical planning of otosclerosis due to improvements candidates for stapes surgery or are in need of sensorineu-
in technology allowing for identification of smaller bony ral hearing loss correction. Hearing aids amplify sound,
lesions.17 High-resolution CT has high diagnostic sensitiv- transmitting greater energy through the stiffened ossicles
ity and specificity, and reveals variants in patient anatomy and improving sound transmission into the inner ear.
and severity of disease.17 Common findings of otosclerosis Patients with a hearing loss greater than 25 dB are candi-
on a high-resolution CT include areas of increased bony dates for hearing aids.24 Hearing aids can be customized
radiolucency in the otic capsule around the anterior foot- to amplify only the frequencies that are needed based on
plate, thickening of the stapes, and widening of the oval findings from the patients audiometry. As otosclerosis
window.17 High-resolution CT also can reveal cochlear progresses, additional adjustments in amplification may
involvement by demonstrating a demineralized area outlin- be required. Hearing aid technology has improved greatly
ing the cochlea (double-ring sign).17 The main disadvantage over the last few yearsthey can be used more easily with
to the use of this test is its high cost. telephones, and some interact directly with smartphones
and tablets. Federal Communications Commission rules
TREATMENT require cell phone companies to make phones that are
Stapes surgery restores the mechanical transmission of compatible with hearing aids and cochlear implants.25
sound through the middle ear, correcting conductive hear- Hearing aids can be very expensive and may require mul-
ing loss. It does not correct sensorineural hearing loss tiple visits to an audiologist for sizing and adjustment.
secondary to otosclerotic extension into the cochlea. Patients also may have increased irritation and infection
Stapes surgery is a minimally invasive one-day procedure of the ear canal.
performed under general anesthesia; more recently, some Implantable hearing aids, such as middle ear implants
surgeons have begun to perform stapes surgery under local and bone conduction implants, are now being used in
anesthesia.6 The two variations of the surgery are: patients with otosclerosis who do not tolerate traditional
Stapedectomy, in which the stapes footplate and the crura hearing aids.26 These implantable hearing aids, like tra-
are removed and replaced with a prosthesis. ditional hearing aids, enhance the acoustic signal trans-
Stapedotomy, in which a small hole is made in the central mitted to the cochlea; however, the devices are technically
aspect of the stapes footplate for the prosthesis without very different (Table 2).
the removal of the structure. Middle ear implants amplify sound by mechanically
Indications for stapes surgery include conductive hearing vibrating the ossicles in which they are surgically affixed.
loss, air-bone gap of at least 20 dB, speech discrimination These devices require ossicular chain motion, which is
score of 60% or greater, and good patient health.12 Con- often limited in patients with otosclerosis due to bony
traindications include poor patient physical condition, deposits; therefore, middle ear implants should only be
fluctuating hearing loss with vertigo, tympanic membrane implanted at the time of stapes surgery or after stapes
perforation, infection, and hearing loss of 70 dB or worse surgery.27 Research found similar improvements in hearing
unless the patient has a speech discrimination score of 80% regardless of whether implantation occurred at the time
or better.12 of stapes surgery or after stapes surgery.27 Middle ear