Excavation Hazards and Control Measures
Excavation Hazards and Control Measures
Excavation Hazards and Control Measures
Site excavation is a necessary part of many construction projects, but can be an extremely dangerous
job if workers are poorly trained, if the proper safety regulations are not followed, or if the construction
company employer or supervisor are in any way negligent.
Excavation:
An excavation as any man-made cut, cavity, trench, or depression in the earth’s surface formed
by earth removal. Sometime excavation is mixed up with another term ‘trench’ but technically
both terms are not identical such as:
Trench:
A trench is defined as a narrow underground excavation that is deeper than it is wide, and is
no wider than 15 feet (4.5 meters).
Incident/Accident Stats:
From 2000 to 2009, an average of 35 workers died every year in trenching or excavation cave-
ins, according to Bureau of Labor Statistics data, USA. About three in every four fatalities
occurred at residential worksites.
Hazards & Risks Associated With Excavation
Excavation on a construction site requires the use of heavy machinery, proper safety measures,
and the careful attention of construction workers and supervisors. Unfortunately, there are a
number of factors that can lead to the occurrence of an excavation accident, which can result
in serious injury and tragic loss of life. The following are hazards & risks associated with
excavation:
Under the WHS Regulations, a risk assessment is not mandatory for excavation work however
it is required for specific situations, for example when working with asbestos. In many circumstances a
risk assessment will assist in determining the control measures that should be implemented. It will help
to:
identify which workers are at risk
determine what sources and processes are causing that risk
identify if and what kind of control measures should be implemented, and
Check the effectiveness of existing control measures.
When assessing the risks associated with excavation work you should consider things such as:
local site conditions including access, ground slope, adjacent buildings and structures, water
courses (including underground) and trees
depth of the excavation
soil properties including variable soil types, stability, shear strength, cohesion, presence of
ground water, effect of exposure to the elements
fractures or faults in rocks including joints, bedding planes, dip and strike directions and angles,
clay seams
any specialised plant or work methods required (e.g. ground support)
the method(s) of transport, haul routes and disposal
what exposures might occur, such as to noise, ultra violet rays or hazardous chemicals
the number of people involved
the possibility of unauthorised access to the work area
local weather conditions, and
The length of time that the excavation will be open.
Some control measures are more effective than others. Control measures can be ranked from the
highest level of protection and reliability to the lowest. This ranking is known as the hierarchy of control.
You must always aim to eliminate a hazard, which is the most effective control. If this is not reasonably
practicable, you must minimise the risk by one or a combination of the following:
Substitution – for example using an excavator with a rock breaker rather than manual method
Isolation – for example using concrete barriers to separate pedestrians and powered mobile
plant to reduce the risk of collision, and
Engineering Controls – for example benching, battering or shoring the sides of the excavation
to reduce the risk of ground collapse.
If risk remains, it must be minimised by implementing administrative controls, so far as is reasonably
practicable, for example by installing warning signs near the excavation.
Any remaining risk must be minimised with suitable personal protective equipment (PPE), such as
providing workers with hard hats, hearing protectors and high visibility vests.
Administrative control measures and PPE rely on human behaviour and supervision and used on their
own tend to be the least effective in minimising risks.
Factors that should be considered when choosing suitable control measures include:
excavating plant - when quantities are large, it may be effective to use different types of plant
for the various materials to be excavated
stockpiling arrangements - another site may need to be found for temporary stockpiling of
materials
material placement - the methods and plant used for excavating, transporting and compacting
the material should be evaluated
dewatering equipment, if required, and the system to be used
Transport of the excavated material - the type of plant used, the length of haul, the nature of
the haul route, and the conditions of tipping and/or spreading.
Chapters 4-6 of this Code provide information on control measures for excavation work.
The control measures that are put in place to protect health and safety should be regularly reviewed to
make sure they are effective.
Regulation 39 You must review your control measures and, if necessary, revise them:
when the control measure is not effective in controlling the risk
before a change at the workplace that is likely to give rise to a new or different health and
safety risk that the control measure may not effectively control
if a new hazard or risk is identified
if the results of consultation indicate that a review is necessary, or
If a health and safety representative requests a review.
Common review methods include workplace inspection, consultation, testing and analysing records and
data. When reviewing control measures, a SWMS must also be reviewed and revised where necessary.
If problems are found, go back through the risk management steps, review your information and make
further decisions about control measures.
Excavation work should be carefully planned before work starts so it can be carried out safely. Planning
involves identifying the hazards, assessing the risks and determining appropriate control measures in
consultation with all relevant persons involved in the work including the principal contractor,
excavation contractor, designers and mobile plant operators. Structural or geotechnical engineers may
also need to be consulted at this stage.
Consultation should include discussions on the:
nature and/or condition of the ground and/or working environment
weather conditions
nature of the work and other activities that may affect health and safety
static and dynamic loads near the excavation
interaction with other trades
site access
SWMS
management of surrounding vehicular traffic and ground vibration
type of equipment used for excavation work
public safety
existing services and their location
the length of time the excavation is to remain open
provision of adequate facilities, and
Procedures to deal with emergencies.
Further information on amenities and emergencies is available in the Code of Practice: Managing the
work environment and facilities.
Where the value of construction work is $250 000 or more, the construction work is considered a
‘construction project’ for which additional duties apply to the principal contractor. There can only be
one principal contractor for a construction project and this will be either the person commissioning the
construction work or a person appointed as the principal contractor by the person commissioning the
construction work.
The principal contractor has a range of duties in relation to a construction project including:
preparing and reviewing a WHS management plan
obtaining SWMS before any high risk construction work commences
putting in place arrangements to manage the work environment including falls, facilities, first
aid, an emergency plan and traffic management
installing signs showing the principal contactor’s name, contact details and location of any site
office, and
Securing the construction workplace.
Where significant excavation work is being carried out and building works have not commenced the
person who commissions the construction work may appoint the excavation contractor as the principal
contractor for the site preparation phase of the project and then replace them with a building expert
after this phase is completed. If the excavation contractor is appointed as the principal contractor the
contractor must comply with all principal contractor duties while undertaking this role.
For further guidance on how to calculate the cost of construction work and on principal contractor
duties refer to the Code of Practice: Construction work.
3.2 Designers
Section 22 Designers must ensure, so far as is reasonably practicable, that the structure is designed to
be without risks to the health and safety of persons who construct the structure
at a workplace.
Regulation 295 The designer of a structure or any part of a structure that is to be constructed must give
the person conducting a business or undertaking who commissioned the design a written report that
specifies the hazards associated with the design of the structure that, so far
as the designer is reasonably aware:
create a risk to the health or safety of persons who are to carry out construction work on the
structure or part, and
Are associated only with the particular design and not with other designs of the same type
of structure.
Designers of structures should consider possible excavation work methods and health and safety
control measures when producing any final design documents and the safety report for the structure.
A person commissioning the construction work must consult, so far as is reasonably practicable, with
the designer of the whole or any part of the structure about eliminating and controlling risks. If the
person commissioning the construction work did not commission the design of the construction
project, they must take all reasonable steps to obtain the designer’s safety report.
Where there is a principal contractor, the person commissioning the construction work must give the
principal contractor any information they have about the hazards and risks associated with the work.
For further guidance on the duties of designers refer to the Code of Practice: Safe design
of structures.
If the excavation work is or involves high risk construction work, a person conducting a business or
undertaking must prepare a SWMS before the high risk construction work starts. The SWMS must:
identify the type of high risk construction work being done
specify the health and safety hazards and risks arising from that work
describe how the risks will be controlled
describe how the control measures will be implemented, monitored and reviewed, and
Be developed in consultation with workers and their representatives who are carrying out the
high risk construction work.
In some circumstances one SWMS can be prepared to cover more than one high risk construction work
activity being carried out at the workplace by contractors and/or subcontractors. For example, where
there is:
a risk of a person falling more than 2 metres, and
A trench with an excavated depth greater than 1.5 metres.
In this case, the contractors or subcontractors can consult and cooperate to prepare one SWMS.
Alternatively they can prepare separate SWMS. If they choose to do this they must consult with each
other to ensure all SWMS are consistent and they are not creating unintended additional risks at the
workplace.
Further guidance on SWMS and an example SWMS template is available in the Code of
Practice: Construction work.
Excavation work may seriously affect the security or stability of any part of a structure at
or adjacent to the location of the proposed excavation which can lead to structural failure
or collapse. Excavation work must not commence until steps are taken to prevent the collapse
or partial collapse of any potentially affected building or structure.
Any excavation that is below the level of the footing of any structure including retaining walls that could
affect the stability of the structure must be assessed by a competent person and secured by a suitable
ground support system which has been designed by a competent person. Suitable supports to brace
the structure may also be required and should be identified by a competent person.
It is also important that other buildings in and around the excavation site are not adversely affected by
vibration or concussion during the excavation work. Special precautions may need to be taken in the
vicinity of hospitals and other buildings containing equipment sensitive to shock and vibration.
Excavation work must be carried out in a way that does not cause flooding or water penetration
to any adjacent building.
3.5 Essential services
Essential services include the supply of gas, water, sewerage, telecommunications, electricity,
chemicals, fuel and refrigerant in pipes or lines. The principal contractor must manage the risks
associated with essential services at the workplace.
Specific control measures must be implemented before using excavators or other earthmoving
machinery near overhead electric lines. The relevant authority should be consulted regarding approach
distances and appropriate control measures implemented to prevent any part of the plant or any load
carried on it from coming too close or contacting overhead electric lines.
Regulation 304 A person with management or control of the workplace must, before directing
or allowing work to commence, take all reasonable steps to obtain current underground essential
services information about the areas at the workplace where the excavation work is to be carried out.
They must also obtain information about underground essential services in areas adjacent
to the site of excavation and have regard for all of the information.
Information on the location of underground services may be obtained by contacting the Dial before You
Dig organisation in your state or territory. Any underground service plans that are obtained including
information on underground essential services must be provided to the principal contractor and/or the
excavation contractor. Other relevant parties including any subcontractors and plant operators carrying
out the excavation work should also be provided
with information about essential services and other plans so the information is considered when
planning all work in the area.
Underground essential services information obtained must be:
Retained until the excavation work is completed or, if there is a notifiable incident relating
to the excavation work, 2 years after the incident occurs.
Available information about existing underground essential services may not be accurate. Therefore it
is important that excavation methods include an initial examination of the area to be excavated, for
example sampling the area by exposing a short section of underground services usually using water
pressure and a vacuum system to excavate or ‘pothole’ the area.
Regulation 43 A person conducting a business or undertaking must ensure that an emergency plan is
prepared for the workplace.
The excavation contractor must ensure that the emergency plan deals with unexpected incidents, such
as ground slip, flooding, gas leaks and the rescue of workers from an excavation.
To ensure a co-ordinated response to an emergency, the plan should be incorporated as part
of the broader construction project emergency plan prepared by the principal contractor.
The following table lists common hazards associated with excavation work and examples
of control measures:
Ground collapse the use of benching or the installation of ground support (e.g. shoring)
Water inrush pumps or other dewatering systems to remove water and prevent build-
up
Falls ramps, steps or other appropriate access into the excavation
Hazardous manual tasks rotating tasks between workers
Airborne contaminants mechanical ventilation to remove airborne contaminants
Buried contaminants (e.g. training to identify buried contaminants and what action to take
asbestos)
Underground services obtain information from the relevant authorities on the location
of underground services
4.1 Excavated material and loads near excavations
Mechanical plant, vehicles, storage of materials (including excavated material) or any other heavy loads
should not be located in the ‘zone of influence’ of an excavation unless the ground support system
installed has been designed by a competent person, for example a geotechnical engineer, to carry such
loads.
The zone of influence will depend on the ground conditions. It is the zone in which there may
be an influence on the excavation including possible ground collapse (see Figure 2).
If excavating in sloping ground decide which side of the excavation to place the excavated material.
Things to consider include:
ground conditions
access to the excavation
existing underground services
the need for earthmoving machinery or vehicles to work or move along beside the excavation
service installation and backfilling requirements, and
Any manual work being undertaken in the excavation.
Placing material on the lower side of the excavation will reduce the effective height of the excavation
(see Figure 3) and the risk of material falling or being washed into the excavation.
Care should be taken to ensure that material placed on the high side of the excavation does
not increase the risk of ground collapse, or flooding by ponding or holding back runoff water. Excavated
material should be placed so that it channels rainwater and other run-off water away from the
excavation.
When a trench is being excavated beside an old service line, the excavated material should
be placed on the side opposite the old service line to prevent excessive loading on previously weakened
ground.
If excavated material is placed close to a trench due to obstructions such as fences, buildings
or trees, the weight of the excavated material may overload the sides of a trench. In this case,
the ground support system should be strengthened at these locations and barriers such as toe boards
may need to be provided to prevent the material falling into the excavation.
Different soils when dumped in heaps, will assume a characteristic shape and settle naturally
at different slopes. The angle which a sloping face of loose earth makes with the horizontal is sometimes
referred to as the angle of repose. However, it is poor practice to relate the safe slope of an excavation
to the angle of repose, even though the safe slope may be similar in some types of soil to the angle of
repose.
Excavation work cannot be carried out safely unless the plant being used is appropriate for the work
and maintained in good condition. A range of plant and equipment may be used for excavation work
including:
powered mobile plant (see section 4.3)
air compressors
electric generators
jack hammers
hydraulic jacks
oxy-acetylene (gas cutting/welding)
scaffolding
ladders, and
Many types of handheld plant such as shovels, picks, hammers, hydraulic jacks
and pinch/lever bars.
You should ensure:
plant is used and operated by a competent person
that appropriate guards and operator protective devices are fitted
that the safe working load is displayed and any load measurement devices are operating
correctly, and
Plant is maintained in accordance with the manufacturer/supplier’s instructions or relevant
Australian Standards.
Further general guidance on plant can be found in the Code of Practice: Managing risks of plant in the
workplace.
Lasers
Lasers must be designed, constructed and installed so that no person is exposed to accidental
irradiation. Lasers that are capable of producing hazardous diffuse reflections or that may constitute a
fire hazard, being laser classes 3B and 4, must not be used in construction work.
Any worker operating lasers must be trained in the use of the equipment. Further information on the
safe use of lasers is available in AS 2397: Safe use of lasers in the building and construction industry.
A wide range of powered mobile plant including earthmoving machinery, may be used for excavation
work. To select plant that is suitable for the task, you should consider:
site access and restrictions
site hazards such as overhead powerlines and underground services
the ground conditions
the type and depth of excavation
the volume of material to be excavated and transported, and
Where the excavated material is to be located and/or stored.
A high risk work licence is required to operate some types of powered mobile plant. However in most
cases earthmoving machinery does not require a licensed operator if it is being used for the purpose
for which it was originally designed. Earthmoving machinery operators must be able to demonstrate
they are competent to operate the specific type of plant being used and any attachments fitted to the
plant.
Traffic management arrangements must be implemented at the workplace when powered mobile plant
is to be used for excavation work to prevent collision with pedestrians or other mobile plant.
Earthmoving machinery
Bulldozers and scrapers are often used to prepare a work area for further specific excavation.
Bulldozers typically excavate and move large amounts of material short distances. Bulldozers
can be equipped with hydraulically operated rippers at the back of the machine which are capable of
loosening the hardest of sedimentary rocks. This material may then be bulldozed away.
This method frequently proves more economical than drilling and blasting softer rock.
Self-propelled rubber tyred scrapers enable very large quantities of material to be excavated and
hauled economically over long distances at relatively high speed. Because of the large potential output
and speeds of modern scrapers, careful attention should be given to job layout, haul roads, vehicle
pathways and overall traffic management to achieve a healthy and safe workplace.
Temporary haul roads should be well constructed and maintained to enable plant operators
to complete the work safely.
Large earthmoving machinery such as bulldozers should not operate close to an overhang
or a deep excavation as the weight may collapse the sides. Equipment should always approach
embankments or trenches from across the line of a trench rather than parallel to it.
Excavation work exceeding 1.5 metres deep is typically done by excavators or specialised
plant such as tunnelling machines and raise-bores. Most of these types of plant have an element of
mobility, although tunnelling machines typically have restricted movement.
Other plant used in excavation work includes backhoes, rubber tyred loaders, skid steer loaders (for
example bobcat), trench diggers, graders and tip trucks.
Blind spots
Operators of powered mobile plant can often have severely restricted visibility of ground workers or
nearby pedestrians, particularly those close to the plant. Figure 4 shows some of the blind spots for
operators of typical excavation equipment.
Figure 4 Mobile plant operator blind spots
Powered mobile plant operating near ground personnel or other powered mobile plant should be
equipped with warning devices (for example reversing alarm and a revolving light).
An effective system of communication based on two way acknowledgement between mobile plant
operators and ground workers should be established before work commences. Relevant workers
should also be trained in the procedures involved prior to the work commencing. The system should
stop ground workers from approaching mobile plant until the operator has agreed to their request to
approach. Similarly the system should stop operators from moving plant closer than
a set distance from ground workers until the operator has been advised by ground workers that they
are aware of the proposed movement.
Mobile plant operators and ground workers should be made familiar with the blind spots of particular
items of plant being used. Induction training programs should emphasise the dangers of workers
working in close proximity to mobile plant, and adequate supervision should be provided.
Mobile plant operators and ground workers should be provided with and required to wear high-visibility
clothing.
Operator protection
Powered mobile plant should be equipped with appropriate combination of operator protection
devices, for example enclosed cabin and seat belts, to prevent the ejection of the operator or
the operator being struck by falling objects.
Any earthmoving machinery weighing more than 1500 kegs, not including attachments, and designed
to have a seated operator must have an appropriate operator protective structure fitted. These are
either in the form of roll-over protective structures (ROPS) or falling object protective structures (FOPS)
or both, depending on the application.
Powered mobile plant should not operate or travel near the edge of an excavation unless the ground
support system installed has been designed by a competent person to carry such loads. Physical
barriers, such as wheel stoppers, can be one way of restricting plant movement near
an excavation (see Figure 5).
Regular planned inspection and adequate maintenance must be carried out in accordance
with the manufacturer’s recommendations to ensure safe operation of mobile plant used
on excavation work, whether leased, hired or owned. Both mechanical and electrical testing should be
done. The following checks should also be carried out:
daily pre-start checks by the plant operator on the general condition and maintenance
of the plant, and
Regular inspections of the plant by a competent person in accordance with the
manufacturer/supplier’s specifications or relevant Australian Standards.
Any plant defects should be reported immediately to the person conducting business
or undertaking. Where a defect is likely to pose an immediate risk to health and safety
the plant should be removed from service until the defect is rectified.
Owners of plant should keep logbooks and inspection check sheets containing a full service and repair
history. These records should include any reported defects, kept current and retained for the life of the
plant. If the plant is sold, the records should form part of the documentation forwarded to the
purchaser of the plant upon its sale.
4.4 Falls
Regulation 78 A person conducting a business or undertaking must manage the risk of a fall from one
level to another that is reasonably likely to cause injury to the person or another person.
In managing the risks of falls, the WHS Regulations require the following specific control measures to
be implemented where it is reasonably practicable to do so:
carry out the work on solid construction that includes a safe means of access and egress
if a fall risk cannot be eliminated, minimise the risk of fall by providing and maintaining a safe
system of work including
using fall prevention devices (e.g. temporary work platforms and guard rails) or
work positioning systems (e.g. industrial rope access systems), or
Fall arrest systems such as catch platforms.
Control measures include:
the support system itself, for example using trench box extensions or trench sheets longer than
the trench depth (see Figure 6)
installing guard rails or covers on trench shields (see Figure 7)
inserting guard rails and toe boards into the ground immediately next to the supported
excavation side
installing landing platforms or scaffold towers inside deep excavations
securing ladders to trench shields
installing effective barriers or barricades
providing clearly defined pedestrian detours
provision of alternative access and egress points to the excavation for emergency use, and
Backfilling the excavation as work progresses.
A SWMS must be prepared for excavation work that involves a risk of a person falling more than 2
metres.
Further guidance on controlling the risk of falls is available in the Code of Practice: How to prevent falls
at workplaces.
Construction work that involves the use of explosives is defined by the WHS Regulations as high risk
construction work and a SWMS must be prepared before this work commences.
A competent person experienced in the controlled application of explosives for the purpose
of carrying out the excavation work should be consulted before deciding whether explosives
may be used for the excavation.
All possession, storage, handling and use of explosives must be carried out in compliance
with the relevant dangerous substances/goods or explosives legislation applicable in your state
or territory.
The transport of explosives must be in accordance with the Australian Code for the Transport
of Explosives by Road and Rail.
Explosives must only be used by a competent person who is licensed in the use of explosives and has
experience in the work to be undertaken. If explosives are used in excavation work,
a licensed competent person must develop the blast management plan and be responsible
for all aspects of the use of explosives.
For further information on the use of explosives for excavation work, refer to AS 2187.2: Explosives –
Storage and Use - Use of Explosives
The risk of atmospheric contamination through a build-up of gases and fumes must be controlled in
excavation work. Gases and fumes heavier than air can collect in tunnels and excavations for example:
gases (such as sulphur dioxide), engine fumes (such as carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide) and
leakage from gas bottles, fuel tanks, sewers, drains, gas pipes and LPG tanks.
Plant that uses a combustion engine (for example air compressors, electrical generators) should never
be used in a confined excavation such as a trench if workers are in the trench. The build-up of exhaust
gases in the excavation, particularly carbon monoxide, can cause death.
Ventilation systems help to maintain adequate oxygen levels and dilute flammable gases, fumes and
certain dusts, such as coal and sulphide which can ignite if in its explosive limits. The use of mechanical
ventilation also reduces dust, fumes, and hazardous contaminants and can control air temperature and
humidity.
The ventilation system should be designed by a competent person to provide adequate ventilation
levels through the excavation (for example a tunnel) during construction. This might include additional
localised extraction ventilation to deal with the production of dust, heat or fumes from the excavation
process and the operation of large plant or other activities like plant maintenance. The design should
allow for the installation of ventilation equipment or ducting as the excavation progresses to maintain
adequate air supply to the working face.
Other methods of controlling the risks associated with atmospheric contamination include:
pre-start checks of atmospheric conditions
using gas monitors including workers’ wearing personal monitors near their airways
ensuring adequate ventilation (either natural or mechanical)
working in pairs, with one person as a safety observer at the surface to monitor conditions
ensuring familiarity with rescue procedures, and
Using PPE.
Further guidance on working in confined spaces is available in Code of Practice: Confined spaces.
4.7 Manual work
Manual excavation methods are generally used for small, shallow excavations (for example less than
1.5 metres deep) in soft soils.
Regulation 60 A person conducting a business or undertaking must manage the risk of a musculoskeletal
disorder associated with hazardous manual tasks.
When working in close proximity, workers should be kept sufficiently far apart to prevent injury from
the use of picks or other hand tools. This applies particularly to work in trenches and small excavations.
Preparatory drilling activity and the use of hand drills may increase the risk of musculoskeletal disorders
including disorders associated with exposure to vibration. For further guidance on controlling the risks
of musculoskeletal disorders, refer to the Code of Practice: Hazardous manual tasks.