Pharmaceuticals As Pollutants: A Threat For Pharmacy Profession
Pharmaceuticals As Pollutants: A Threat For Pharmacy Profession
Pharmaceuticals As Pollutants: A Threat For Pharmacy Profession
CITATIONS READS
3 74
4 authors, including:
Apeksha Shrivastava
Jamia Hamdard University
3 PUBLICATIONS 4 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Apeksha Shrivastava on 15 February 2016.
Apeksha Shrivastava et al / Journal of Pharmaceutical Science and Technology Vol. 2 (3), 2010, 163-170
Apeksha Shrivastava et al / Journal of Pharmaceutical Science and Technology Vol. 2 (3), 2010, 163-170
165
Apeksha Shrivastava et al / Journal of Pharmaceutical Science and Technology Vol. 2 (3), 2010, 163-170
a
River number corresponding to highest value is egg yolk precursor protein) by male fish,
designated within parentheses. and other changes that may affect
b
Concentration estimated – value greater than
highest point on calibration curve.
reproduction or overall health6-8.
c
Concentrations estimated – reference standard Concentrations at which these effects were
prepared from a technical mixture. observed were lower than concentrations
d
Estimated value detected in some surface waters sampled
by the USGS2. Aquatic environments are a
average compared to the streams sampled major concern because organisms in this
in Massachusetts. This list gives some environment are subject to continual low-
insight into what is likely to be detectable dose exposure1.
in the MWRA system, not necessarily With respect to pathogen resistance, the
what is present or even biologically World Health Organization (WHO) warns
active. Simply because you can test for that increasing drug resistance could
something does not make it relevant and if significantly reduce our ability to cure
a compound was not detected it does not illness and stop epidemics. Curable
mean it is not present or significant. diseases, varying from sore throats to
Impacts and effects: tuberculosis and malaria, may become
There is limited documentation regarding incurable as our once-effective medicines
the direct cause and effect relationships of become increasingly ineffective9. Possibly
pharmaceuticals in the environment. The development of antibiotic resistance is a
major concerns to date have been the result of active pharmaceutical compounds
promotion of pathogen resistance to present in wastewater.
antibiotics and disruption of endocrine For humans, consumption of potable water
systems, but many other active that may contain trace amounts of various
pharmaceutical compounds make their pharmaceuticals has been identified as one
way into the water and have unknown of the primary potential routes of
consequences. To date, most of the exposure2. While some pharmaceuticals
research of pharmaceuticals as pollutants have been measured in drinking water10-11,
has been focused on aquatic environments. a number of scientists believe that
The possible effects of these substances on pharmaceuticals at the low levels detected
aquatic life are currently not well do not pose an appreciable risk to human
understood. Potential adverse aquatic health12. Sensitive populations, particularly
effects in field populations are usually pregnant woman and children, are believed
predicted from laboratory acute and to be more susceptible to any negative
chronic toxicity data in species such as effects, but studies have not shown any
algae, crustaceans, and fish5. These tests impacts on human health as of yet. The
generally look at one organism’s response exposures found thus far are well below
to one particular chemical, but in the therapeutic levels for human consumption.
environment organisms are simultaneously Because of the trace concentrations of
exposed to a host of different chemicals these drugs, it would take a significant
over multiple generations making the period of time, consuming approximately a
extrapolation from the laboratory to the gallon of water a day, to achieve a single
field exceedingly difficult. therapeutic dose of most chemicals:
Current research suggests endocrine consuming the equivalent of one tablet of
disrupting chemicals (EDC), mainly Diazepam would take 3.5 years; a capsule
synthetic steroids and other hormones, can of diphenhydramine 14.5 years; and one
lead to changes in sex ratios in fish and tablet of Tylenol 58 years13. However, the
other aquatic organisms, “feminization” of potential effects from continuous low dose
male fish, production of vitellogenin (an chronic exposure to active pharmaceutical
166
Apeksha Shrivastava et al / Journal of Pharmaceutical Science and Technology Vol. 2 (3), 2010, 163-170
compounds in humans are not clearly report15 on how expired medications are
understood. being disposed of found that 1.4% of
Solutions ahead: residents returned medications to a
It is true to say that a pharmacist is not pharmacy, 54% disposed of medications in
legally bound to take any action for the garbage, 35.4% flushed medications
minimizing the pharmaceutical affluent in down the toilet or sink, 7.2% did not
environment. However, as the citizen he/ dispose of medications, and 2% related
she is supposed to make environment they used all medication before expiration
clean. In only a few countries such (See Figure 2 below).
measures have been taken place sooner or Studies have reported that approximately
later such actions will also be implemented one third of the total volume of
in about all the countries of the world. pharmaceuticals sold in Germany and
Here we strict ourselves to the discussion about 25% of that sold in Austria are
pertaining to pharmacists and patient only. disposed of with household waste or down
Disposal of Unwanted Pharmaceuticals: the drain16. This significant contribution
Consumer pharmaceutical wastes are from private individuals turns the focus
created from prescription drugs for a from industry to the activities, actions, and
variety of reasons, e. g., a change in behavior of consumers on their
prescription; patient’s health improves surrounding environment. Some consider
before finishing treatment, patient death, flushing unwanted medications down the
and patient non-compliance. OTC toilet preferable to throwing medications
medicines are often sold in bulk and may in the trash where children or illicit drug
contain more than is needed before the users might get a hold of them, but
expiration date or the consumer may flushing in particular may be more closely
switch brands or prescriptions. Many of associated with causing environmental
these expired of unwanted medications are damage. By recommending the
disposed of in the trash or down the drain. medications be crushed, combined with
With few exceptions, countries do not another substance, and placed in the trash
have clear and consistent guidelines on reduces the poisoning risk but it has the
how to properly dispose of unwanted potential to enter the water through land
pharmaceuticals, especially when it comes fill leaching. Even pharmaceuticals
to the general public. In February 2007, captured in leachate at lined landfills are
the White House Office of National Drug typically transported to wastewater
Control Policy released the Federal treatment plants, where some pass through
regulations on the Proper Disposal of untreated.
Prescription Drugs14. These general Prescription Drug Abuse and Poisoning:
recommendations suggest unused Prescription and OTC drugs can be safe
pharmaceuticals be mixed with coffee and helpful to people when used in the
grounds or kitty litter, placed in an right way, but many can also be abused
impermeable bag, and thrown out in the and remain a serious public health
trash. They also recommend certain drugs concern. Medications account for the most
be flushed down the toilet. Coming in last common poison exposure category in the
on their list, they suggest taking unused United States17. They can cause addiction,
medications to a community increased blood pressure and heart rate,
pharmaceutical take-back program. seizures, organ damage, and even death.
Incineration is now regarded as the best The massive number of medications
disposal option for expired or unwanted available presents a substantial accidental
medications, but it is not a commonly poisoning risk if they are not properly
available option for the general public. A stored or disposed. Unsecured disposal to
167
Apeksha Shrivastava et al / Journal of Pharmaceutical Science and Technology Vol. 2 (3), 2010, 163-170
the garbage or using improper facilities sell or use. The returns industry (or
increases the risk of drug abuse or reverse distribution) was created to
poisoning. facilitate the return of unwanted or expired
Hospital Survey Summary: medications to the manufacturer for
In hospitals and nursing homes, credit. The unwanted or expired
pharmaceutical waste is generally medication remains a product until the
discarded down the drain or land filled, decision is made to dispose of it, therefore
except chemotherapy agents, which are the pharmacy or medical distributor can
often sent to a regulated medical waste potentially return them and receive credit
incinerator. Pharmacies and drug for them without the product being
providers usually send unused or expired considered hazardous waste18. Licensed
pharmaceuticals back to the manufacturer, reverse distributors are permitted by the
in other cases they use a reverse DEA (USA) to handle and dispose of
distribution company which disposes of controlled pharmaceuticals to be sure that
the products that are non-returnable17. all controlled substances are accounted for
Pharmaceutical Take Back Measures: from their creation until their consumption
Improper management of unwanted or or destruction.
expired residential pharmaceuticals poses The general public does not traditionally
hazards to both human health and the have access to a reverse distributor for the
environment. Some medicines may enter disposal of their unwanted or expired
the environment from human excretion, medications and many of the services are
but others enter the environment from the too expensive for smaller facilities. A
direct disposal of unused or expired reverse distribution scheme for a
products through the waste water stream pharmaceutical take back program
that could have been disposed of in a more executed at a local pharmacy appears
responsible way. ideal, but pharmacists are unable to accept
In certain countries like USA, Canada, controlled substances for return and are
Australia, EU etc. take back programs often unwilling to bother with setting up a
provide the legal framework and the non-controlled pharmaceutical return
logistic resources required to allow health program due to high costs.
care facilities, patients, and the general Waste and Drinking Water Treatment
public to return unused or expired of Pharmaceuticals:
pharmaceuticals so that they can either be Pharmaceuticals primarily enter
reused or disposed of safely in incineration wastewater treatment plants from
facilities. However, in India such households through excretion or improper
Programme run in the goodwill of disposal, but also through inputs from
pharmacist patient relationship, no hospitals and industry sewers. Existing
concrete legal binding has yet been wastewater treatment processes are
imposed. Over two dozen different optimized to reduce human waste which is
initiatives in USA are either studying the primarily biological in origin, not
problem or implementing ways to solve it, pharmaceutical waste. Currently the major
including take back initiatives at pollutants of concern in domestic waste
pharmacies or other collection points. solids are nitrates, phosphates, dissolved
Reverse Distribution: organic carbon, and pathogens. Treatment
Drug manufacturers, in an effort to facilities do not traditionally monitor or
encourage pharmacies or medical centers measure organic microcontaminants such
to purchase their new medications, may as pharmaceutical residues.
offer to buy back certain drugs the Influent and effluent waters can be tested
pharmacy or medical center is not able to for active pharmaceutical compounds, but
168
Apeksha Shrivastava et al / Journal of Pharmaceutical Science and Technology Vol. 2 (3), 2010, 163-170
there are many complications. It has only still other compounds may be completely
been in the past few years that continually degraded in the treatment process.
improving chemical analysis Other factors, besides biological treatment,
methodologies have lowered the limits of affecting removal of substances from the
detection to allow researchers to identify waste stream include weather related
these compounds and their metabolites at incidents such as wet-weather overflow or
very low levels, particularly in a mixed the opposite, low inflow during dry
waste stream matrix. Consequently, conditions, which leads to higher
extensive extraction, cleanup, and concentrations due to a low volume of
sophisticated instrumentation are usually water. As a result, some portions can be
required to analyze these complex directly released into the environment via
compounds and mixtures. Because of wastewater effluent due to vary levels of
these advanced methodologies required, treatment and may have adverse
samples can only be sent to a limited set of ecotoxicological effects.
laboratories and can often be very References:
expensive to process. [1] Daughton, C.G. and Ternes, T.A (1999)
Due to the complexity of the tests and the Pharmaceuticala and Personal Care Products in
the Environment: Agents of Subtle Change.
low concentrations present, not detecting Environmental Health Perspectives, Vol 107,
active pharmaceutical compounds in the Supplement 6: 907-938
wastewater effluent does not necessarily [http://epa.gov/nerlesdl/chemistry/ppcp/images
mean that the water is clean and in these /errata.pdf\
precise tests you only find what you are [2] Kolpin, D.W., Furlong, E.T., Meyer, M.T.,
Thurman, E.M., Zaugg, S.D., Barber, L.B., and
looking for. With the vast array of Buxton, H.T. Pharmaceuticals, Hormones, and
possible chemicals that could be present Other Organic Wastewater Contaminants in
and possible interfering compounds, U.S. Streams, 1999-2000: A National
narrowing the range of what is to be tested Resonnaissance. Environmental Science and
for is challenging. The overall Technology. 2002. 36, 1202-1211.
[3] Gualtero, S. 2005. Pollution Prevention
understanding of pharmaceutical removal Measures for Unwanted Pharmaceuticals.
during treatment is limited because “the Columbia University web site.
analyses for these compounds are rare, and [www.seas.columbia.edu/earth/wtert/sofos/Gu
when detected, they are present at altero_IETerm_.pdf]
fluctuating concentrations near analytical [4] Tabak, H.H. and Bunch, R.L. 1970. Steroid
hormones as water pollutants. In:
method detection limits19.” Most of our Developments in Industrial Microbiology,
knowledge about the removal of these Washington, pp 367-376
compounds is derived from the laboratory. [5] Versteeg DJ, Alder AC, Cunningham VL,
Wastewater discharged to sewage Kolpin DW, Murray-Smith R, and Ternes T.
treatment plants is subject to various levels 2005. Environmental Exposure Modeling and
Monitoring of Human Pharmaceuticals in the
of treatment depending on the setup of the Environment. In Human Pharmaceuticals:
facility, before being discharged to Assessing the Impacts on Aquatic Ecosystems;
receiving waters. Pharmaceutical Williams, R. T., Ed.; SETAC Press: Pensacola,
compounds in wastewater display a broad FL; pp 71–110.
range of removal efficiencies by waste and [6] Palace, V.P., Wautier, K.g., Evans, R.E.,
Blanchfield, P.J., Mills, K.H., Chalanchuk,
water treatment technologies20. Some S.M., Godard, D., McMaster, M.E., Tetreault,
pharmaceuticals are not degraded G.R., Peters, L.E., Vandenbyllaardt, L., and
completely and travel through water Kidd, K. 2006. Biochemical and
treatment facilities with only minor Histopathological Effect in Pearl Dace
reductions in concentrations, while other (Margariscus margarita) Chronically Exposed
to a Synthetic Estrogen in a Whole Lake
are transformed into new compounds and Experiment. Environmental Toxicology and
Chenistry. 25: (4) 1114 – 1125
169
Apeksha Shrivastava et al / Journal of Pharmaceutical Science and Technology Vol. 2 (3), 2010, 163-170
[7] Schultz, R.I., Skillman, A., Nicolas, J.M., Cyr, [13] Seiler, R.L., 2003. Chemicals from consumers.
D.G., and Nagler, J.J. 2003. Short-term In Dasch, E.J. (ed.) Water and Science Issues.
Exposure to Ethynylestradiol Decreases the Macmillan Reference USA, The Gale Group,
Fertility of Sexually Maturing Male Trout pp. 155-158.
(Oncorhynchus mykiss). Environmental [14] White House Office of National Drug Control
Toxicology and Chemistry. 22: (6) 1272 – Policy
1280 [http://www.whitehousedrugpolicy.gov/drugfa
[8] Zillioux, E.J, Johnson, I.C., Kiparissis, Y., ct/factsht/proper_disposal.html]
Metcalfe, C.D., Wheat, J.V., Ward, S.G., and [15] Kuspis DA, Krenzilok EP. 1996. What
Liu, H. 2001. The Sheephead Minnow as an in happens to expired medications? A survey of
Vivo Model for Endocrine Disruption in community medication disposal. Veterinary
Marine Teleosts: A Partial Life-Cycle Test and Human Toxicology. 38: 48 - 49.
with Ethynylestrodial. Environmental [16] Krummerer, Klaus. Pharmaceuticals in the
Toxicology and Chemistry. 20: (9) 1968 - 1978 Environment: Sources, Fate, Effects, and
[9] World Health Organization. Risks. Springer. 2nd edition. 2004
[www.who.int/multimedia/antibiotic_res/index [17] Bowe, Leah, Investigating Emergent
.html] Contaminants: Pharmaceutical impacts and
[10] Stackelberg PE, Furlong ET, Meyer MT, possible solutions,
Zaugg SD, Henderson AK, and Reissman DB. [18] 21 CFR Parts 1300, 1301, 1304, 1305, and
2004. Persistence of Pharmaceutical 1307. The Definition and Registration of
Compounds and Other Organic Wastewater Reverse Distributors from the Department of
Contaminants in a Conventional Drinking- Justice
Water-Treatment Plant. Science of the.Total [19] Snyder, S.A., Westerhoff, P., Yoon, Y., and
Environment. 329: 99 – 113. Sedlak, D.L. 2003. Pharmaceuticals, Personal
[11] Jones, O. A.; Lester, J. N.; Voulvoulis, N. Care Products, and Endocrine Disruptors in
2005. Pharmaceuticals: A Threat To Drinking Water: Implications for the Water Industry.
Water? Trends Biotechnogyl. 23: 163 – 167. Environmental Engineering Science. 20, (5):
[12] Schwab BW, Hayes EP, Fiori JM, Mastrocco 449 – 469
FJ, Roden NM, Cragin D, Meyerhoff RD, [20] Daughton, C.G. 2003. Cradle to Cradle
D’Aco VJ, and Anderson PD. 2005. Human Stewardship of Drugs for Minimizing Their
Pharmaceuticals in U.S. Surface Water: A Environmental Disposition While Promoting
Human Health Risk Assessment. Regul. Human Health – Rationale for and Avenues
Toxicol. Pharmacol. 42: 296 – 312. toward a Green Pharmacy. Environmental
Health Perspectives. 111, (5): 757 – 774.
170