2.5 African Print PDF
2.5 African Print PDF
2.5 African Print PDF
Tunde M. Akinwumi
Department of Home Science
University of Agriculture, Abeokuta, Nigeria
Abstract
The paper investigated the nature of machine-produced fabric commercially termed African
prints by focusing on a select sample of these prints. It established that the general design
characteristics of this print are an amalgam of mainly Javanese, Indian, Chinese, Arab and
European artistic tradition. In view of this, it proposed that the prints should reflect certain
aspects of Africanness (Africanity) in their design characteristics. It also explores the
desirability and choice of certain design characteristics discovered in a wide range of African
textile traditions from Africa south of the Sahara and their application with possible design
concepts which could be generated from Macquet’s (1992) analysis of Africanity. This thus
provides a model and suggestion for new African prints which might be found acceptable for use
in Africa and use as a veritable export product from Africa in the future.
In the commercial parlance, African print is a general term employed by the European textile
firms in Africa to identify fabrics which are machine-printed using wax resins and dyes in order
to achieve batik effect on both sides of the cloth, and a term for those imitating or achieving a
resemblance of the wax type effects. They bear names such as abada, Ankara, Real English
Wax, Veritable Java Print, Guaranteed Dutch Java Hollandis, Uniwax, ukpo and chitenge.
Using the term ‘African Print’ for all the brand names mentioned above is only acceptable to its
producers and marketers, but to a critical mind, the term is a misnomer and therefore suspicious
because its origin and most of its design characteristics are not African. Hence, Jefferson
(1974:95) disregarded the prints as authentically African, but rather European “African Cloths”,
however, there has been no account made on why these cloths are neither African cloths, nor
African prints.
179
Consequently, I will investigate the origins of African prints and the roles played by early
European textile merchants and their African textile trader-collaborators in producing and
exporting modified Indonesian wax batik to Africa in the name of ‘African print’. Second, I
examine the design content of what were produced for the African consumers at the beginning, at
later times and in contemporary time to discover whether the prints are dominantly of
Indonesian aesthetics blended with Dutch, Indian, Chinese, Arab and European influences or not.
And finally, I argue for another alternative design model to Littrell’s; first by exploring certain
features of African indigenous textile designs and second by examining Macquet’s themes on
Africanity (1972) as sources of inspiration for providing a new blue-print.
Thus, Macquet classified them under the rubric of Africanity, defining it as the unique cultural
heritage shared by many of the peoples of black Africa (Macquet 1972). And in Macquet’s
exploration of cultural unit, she observed social, historical and geographical bonds that link the
Black peoples of Africa in the areas of kinship and marriage institutions, political organizations,
religious beliefs and worldviews (Macquet 1972:6).
180
The Javanese developed a high level of batik artistry before they were colonized. They produced
many symbolic and non-symbolic patterns. Parang rusak (dagger point or broken blade) is one
of the most popular patterns developed in the sixteenth century (Forge 1989:104). Also known
as ‘Princely Pattern’, parang rusak was developed for and worn only by male members of
Djakarta royal house (Newman 1977:20, Forge 1989:104).
While under the rule of the Indians, Chinese, Islamic clerics and the Dutch, the Javanese were
influenced by an influx of new ideas from the cultures of their overlords. Consequently, some
Chinese mythology and Buddhist themes were borrowed and incorporated in their batik. They
included the significance of the Chinese mythical snail (Fig. 2) and dogs of Fo, which were the
fabulous beasts usually found in pairs guarding the entrance of Buddhist deities. They copied
from the Indian chintz particularly the ‘Tree of Life’ which was later adopted and used by other
cultures especially the Europeans (Irwin and Bratt 1970:16, 17 – 21). And greater development
of geometric designs was made manifest more than before during the short period Java was made
an Islamic state, because Islam forbade the representation of human forms and the like.
181
By the nineteenth century, styles were derived from European peasant ornamentation and
preserved in the oldest cloths served as inspirational sources for designing wax print (Muller
n.d.). And design motifs universal to all cultures, such as nature-based forms: plants and animals
were drawn and styled in the European format and in the manner of other foreign cultures. For
example, we find decorative in-filled plant motifs on these fabrics. Like in Fig. 3, the flowers
and foliage are of mixture of Indian and European origin. Some of these nature-based motifs are
reminiscent of the seventeenth century Western embroidery and silk styles (Irwin and Brett
1970:19 and 70). All these added to the repertoire of design content of the print, and despite the
non-relationship of the design motifs to African traditions, the cloth bearing the motifs were
introduced to African communities.
In this process, the marketing of the cloth at the retail level was greatly enhanced by the way and
manner attracting indigenous names in form of proverbs, catch phrases, catch words, slogans,
maxims and puns were given to each successful design by African traders, although the names
had no connection with the designs (Beauchamp 1957:209, Nielsen 1980:10, Domowitz 1992:82
– 87). Yet, the practice then became established as one of the strategies for marketing African
prints at various local markets.
182
It may have been observed from the above analysis that African prints were produced at various
places overseas and in Europe, and that their designs had an amalgam of various artistic cultures,
namely Indonesian, Indian, Chinese, Arab, Dutch and European influences. Thus, the cloths
were marketed in Africa, Europe and Asia. Therefore it is worth examining the nature of those
marketed in Africa to be able to appreciate the level of Africanity in their content, thus I will
review a representative sample of commercially successful types referred to in literature and
other well-known prints to determine the level of their Africanity content.
It appears that European producers were more concerned with fabric colour preferences of
various African countries. According to Nielsen, the early years of the twentieth century
witnessed the export of predominantly blue prints for Nigeria while orange and black went to
Gold Coast (now Ghana). Later the eastern part of Nigeria favoured deep red and yellow while
Ivory Coast cherished brown, yellow, red, dark red, yellows and greens. Zaire went for brown
cream, pink, purple and light green (Nielsen 1980:12).
However, the development of specialty African prints seems to have posed a great problem for
the producers. As Butler stated:
It has been the life’s work of many merchant converters in Manchester to produce
specialty African prints for the people … the development of a new design for this
market normally absorbs more time and effort than is taken over one for the transitory
fashion markets (Butler 1958:12, Nielsen 1979:467)
Perhaps it was for this reason that they produced very few designs of Africanity content, with the
exception of the famous Ghanaian sword produced in their early products. Thus, thereafter the
producers concentrated on the terrain they knew best as their design motifs derived from nature
such as plants and animal motifs which are universal to all cultures, to form the majority of
designs produced during the early decades of the twentieth century. However, other attempts
were made in order to produce more Africanity content designs. For example, Beving, a
Manchester textile merchant traveled widely in Africa collecting indigenous hand textiles to
form an important resource for the production of African prints exported to Africa towards the
middle of the twentieth century (Lubell 1976: 35).
183
Considering this, I cursorily assessed African prints using work from Nigerian colleges as
representative examples. The works were not different from those stated above; the works tend
to ape those produced by the textile firms. Figure 4 represents those selected from Ahmadu Bello
University Zaria whose art development is the second oldest in Nigeria. Figure 5 reflects
typically past textile students works from Yaba College of Technology Art Department, Lagos,
the oldest art institution in Nigeria. Granted all these are short of the expectations, but how
should the proposed African print look like? If one takes a cue from African music, much of its
content in terms of song rendition has been in African dialects and languages with the percussion
of many coming from African-derived drums and accessories. Hence, cannot African prints be
derived from its own metaphoric dialect, languages and percussion?
Another source- inducing ideas came from Voice of America’s one hour radio
discussion participation programme held 14 February 2007 involving callers from
Nigeria, Tanzania, Kenya, Uganda, South Africa, Sierra Leone, Rwanda and
Guinea. The radio programme, Straight Talk Africa, which was anchored by Chaka Sali
discussed the theme “Rebranding Africa”. The discussion focused on the misrepresentation of
Africa in many aspects of life especially by the Western media and bodies. The following points
were stressed: That no one would correct these misrepresentations unless Africans themselves
do so through their own media, through dissemination by Africanist scholars and by the African
in Diaspora. That re-writing African history on all facets of life is best handled by Africans and
not outsiders who most often wrote with bias. That at the international level, matters reflecting
the fortunes of the African were often decided with no respect of their feelings and no invitation
to African governments, African experts and other relevant bodies to participate. At the end of
the radio discussion, Africans were called upon by the discussants to boycott the “boycottable”
particularly where there are alternatives to such decisions. Lastly, that Africans should project
what is good about the continent such as what has been achieved so that the African hope could
be kept alive.
184
To put a halt to this African misrepresentation, concerned and dedicated Africanist scholars,
artists, designers and textile magnates should be involved in the re-branding of African print as a
project. One could infer from the foregoing radio discussion that no one would re-brand African
print in its present features unless some Africans and Africanists do so for Africa.
Common to most African handcrafted traditional fabric is its characteristic design having
irregular composition style. This is in form of unlike motifs which are juxtaposed. The style has
an orderly repetition on motifs which are interrupted by a shift in texture, direction or scale
(Adams 1991:35). The style gives ample chance for the distribution of some design variations.
The design elements in the composition are made of irregularities and regularities and these
provide a source of vitality for the people to behold. The asymmetry (i.e. the irregularity) style
also activates a sense of movement for its beholder unlike the symmetrical design characteristics
of European and other traditions (Adams 1991: 37, 43). This characteristic style has more
advantages. The style enables the beholding of varying design component shifts of same theme
on the cloth surface without being bored. A great number of those fabric designers explored and
created componential varieties thus making the final works more aesthetically pleasing to
behold.
185
An intensive study of these African handcrafted textile traditions (Spring 1989; Clarke 1997,
Lamb and Holmes 1980) will also lead to the discovery of a mine of characteristic African
design motifs. It has been mentioned earlier that ‘African print’ motifs were sourced by the
European producers from European, Indian, Java, Chinese and Arab styles, many of which are
on nature-based motifs like birds, plants, etc. On the whole, there is nothing stopping Africanist
designers from deriving a plethora of stylistic motifs from the indigenous African hand textiles
mentioned above. In addition to the above suggestion, certain characteristic patterns/motifs
associated with, for example, Kente fabric (Ghana) could be fused into the main theme of a
chosen design as a secondary booster of the design content. Same use could be made of adire
fabric (Nigeria), Kuba embroidery (Zaire), bogolanfini (Mali), and of others too in combination
with the main theme of a chosen design. An injection of this new horizon into African print
designs will definitely make a difference in future in terms of aesthetic preference.
Another source of inspiration that could be explored is from Jacquet Macquet’s work (1972). An
Africanist anthropologist Macquet defined and explored the concept ‘Africanity’ as the unique
cultural heritage shared by many peoples of black Africa and which is distinct from, and
comparable to, the Western and Asian worlds. In providing details, she observed thus:
186
Macquet also provided a breakdown of the contents of Africanity thus creating a repertoire of
endless themes. It is from these large numbers of subject matter that the writer is suggesting to
fabric designers. The designer is to create art works that are reproducible for African print
production. On kinship and marriage institutions, religion and world view, the designer could
conceive, picture and review through the use and arrangement of decorative symbols on things
like: kinship, dependence on lineage, the playing of roles there, going back to the ancestor and
being influenced by unknown forces (for a Chinese example, see fig. 2). Other themes include
the reaching of adulthood, getting married (for a Javanese example, see fig. 1), exchanging
women, compensating for the gift of fertility, stabilizing matrimonial alliance, marrying several
wives, making the lineage to continue, and living in a village (Macquet 1972:55-80).
In the realm of governance, she identified the governance in territories with each ruler being
associated with the people, succession by heredity, being a courtier, administering the kingdom,
centralizing, being a professional craftsman, producing folk art, hewing wood and drawing
water, existing for others, serving the lord and structuring the African heritage (Macquet 1972:
81 – 112). Finally Macquet observed that the black world tend to struggle together, conquering
poverty, retaining its identity yet borrowing from outside including solving the problems arising
thereof. She asserted that this was the essence of traditional Africanity in the contemporary
times and it will likely be so and many years to come (Macquet 1972: 113 – 131). In sum, her
views on the theme of Africanity is all about the common features which united Black Africa and
the problems arising from them.
Many of them (i.e. the themes) have proved the originality of our cultures, our sense of
creativity and invention. Many have stressed the fact that our languages, our arts, our
wisdom, our religions, our traditional medicine….have not only provided us with the
reasons for our existence in the past, but also helped us in the present liberation of Africa,
and should serve as a spring board for the great leap into the future (Amoda 1972: 164).
187
For the fabric designers to be inspired by this gamut of themes is challenging but desirable
particularly if designers make the themes changing as design trends. Societies in the western
world have benefited from changing fashionable fabric styling based on certain periodic moods
of artists. The changing styles and themes were meant to attract continuous patronage of their
fabric prints. For example, the Arts and Crafts Movement of the late nineteenth century
influenced fabric designers who produced mainly designs with controlled crowding of arranged
motifs (Arte 1998: 425 -6). Fabric designers influenced by Art Nouveau Movement (1890 –
1910) changed the existing state to designs having delicate, sinnous, wavy line-dominated motifs
(Arte 1998: 530; Robinson 1969” 38; Warren 1974: 4 – 7). Art Deco period inspired the
production of prints which had great emphasis upon geometric formalization of motifs in the
1920s (Arte 1998: 611). In the same vein, the proposed African print designs should change in
themes from one period to another but still retaining the design characteristics earlier analysed.
Conclusion
African prints remain essentially Javanese in production techniques. There is a relationship
between the form styling of the present prints and an amalgam of Javanese, India, Chinese, Arab
and European artistic traditions. The marketing of African prints has been greatly enhanced by
the retail traders who were the producers’ collaborators; they developed provocative indigenous
names for each design in their respective communities.
There has been widespread use of nature-based design motifs which were styled from non-
African traditions right from the inception of Africa prints in Africa. This shows that the term
‘African print’, a misnomer was coined by its producers just to deceive the African buyers. The
deception has continued up to the contemporary times.
188
These are the arrowheads which could be persuaded into accepting and accomplishing the
project. In the alternative, the stake-holders could be persuaded into voting certain funds
annually as trust fund, a coffer to be used for prosecuting this project to the stage when the fabric
becomes a product of export drive from Africa. It is most likely that the Nigeria government will
be interested in a project like this. For example, it provided in April 2007 the sum of 80 billion
naira ($650m) for the revival of cotton textile industry as well as for the promotion of textile
export (Aregbesola 2007 : 1, The Nation 2007:17) In sum, the production and utilization of the
proposed fabric should engender within and outside Africa a new image for Africa.
References
Adams, M. 1991, “Beyond Symmetry in Middle African Designs” African Arts, 23, 1:
34
Aregbesola, I. 2007. “Textile Industry gets N80bn Lifeline, “Business Day Newspaper
(Lagos), 27 April
Aronson, L. 1980. “Patronage and Akwete Weaving” African Arts, 13, 3: 62 – 66, 91.
Bohannan, P. 1964. Africa and Africans New York: Natural History Press
189
Beauchamp. P. C. 1957. “A Gay Garb for Ghana”, West Africa, 41: 209
Buttler, R. 1958. “Sales of British Cotton Goods in West Africa”, The Times, August,
13: 12
Clarke, D. 1997. “Aso-Oke, Ceremonial Cloth of the Yoruba” in the author’s The Art of
African Textiles, San Diego C. A.: Thunder Bay Press, 94 – 111
Clarke, D. 1997. “Kente, Royal Cloth of the Ashanti”, in the author’s The Art of African
Textiles. San Diego C. A. Thunder Bay Press, 64 – 75
Clarke D. 1997. “Bogolan, Mud-dyed Cloth of Mali” in the author’s The Art of African
Textiles. San Diego C A: Thunder Bay Press, 86 – 93.
Davidson, B. 1969. The African Genius, An introduction to African and cultural History
Batson: Little Brown.
Diop, C.A 1974. The African origin of Civilization. New York: Lawrence Hill
Diop, C.A 1978. The Cultural Unity of Black Africa. Chicago Third World press
Domowitz, S. 1992. “Weaving Proverbs: Anyi Names in Printed Factory Cloth” African
Arts, 25, 3: 82 – 87
Forge, A. 1989. “Batik Patterns of the Early Nineteenth Century”, in M. Gittinger, (ed.).
To Speak with Cloth: Studies in Indonesian Textiles. Los Angeles: Museum of Cultural
Studies, 91 - 105
Gittinger, M. (ed.), 1989. To Speak with Cloth: Studies in Indonesian Textiles. Los
Angeles: Museum of Cultural Studies
190
Irwin, J. and K. B. Brett. 1970. Origins of Chintz: London: Our Majesty’s Stationery
Office
Jackson, J.G. 1970. Introduction to African civilization New York: Citadel Press
Lindholm, C. 1979. “Gift of the Gods: Textiles from Indonesia” Craft horizon, 32 –
39
Lubell, C. 1976. Textile Collection of the World, vol. 2 London: Studio Vista.
Macquet, J. 1992. Africanity: The Cultural Unity of Black Africa London: Oxford
University Press.
Muller, A. n.d. Der Zengdrwck in Museum des Landes Glarus in Nafels, Glarus
Switzerland: Glarus Museum.
Newman, T. R. 1977 Contemporary southeast Asian Arts and Crafts. NewYork: Crown
Publishers
Nielsen, R. 1979, “The History and Development of Wax-printed Textiles, Intended for
West Africa and Zaire”, in J. M. Cordwell and R. A. Schwarz (eds.), The Fabric of
Culture. The Hague: Mouton Publishers, 467 – 498.
Nielsen, R. 1980. African Wax Prints An Exhibition Catalogue of West African Wax
Prints. Oregon: Horner Museum
Ojo-Ade,F. 1996. Being Black and Being Human. Ile-Ife: O.A.U Press.
191
Stuckey, S. 1972 The Ideological Origins of Black Nationalism Boston: Beacon Press
The Nation. 2007 “Government Approves N80b to Revive Textile Sector” The Nation
2 May 2007, 19
Williams, C. 1974. The Destruction of Black Civilization. Chicago: Third World Press.
192