Vidita Banking Project
Vidita Banking Project
Vidita Banking Project
PERSPECTIVE
Lucknow
Faculty of Law
PROJECT ON
For
Submitted by
DSMNRU,Lucknow 1
GENERAL RELATIONS BETWEEN BANKER AND CUSTOMER –A LEGAL
PERSPECTIVE
TABLE OF CONTENT:
1. Introduction.......................................................................................5
2. Banker-Customer Relationship..........................................................6
3. General Relationship..........................................................................7
4. Special Relationship...........................................................................8
6. Duties of a banker...............................................................................12
7. Rights of a banker...............................................................................16
8. Conclusion..........................................................................................19
9. References...........................................................................................20
DSMNRU,Lucknow 2
GENERAL RELATIONS BETWEEN BANKER AND CUSTOMER –A LEGAL
PERSPECTIVE
INTRODUCTION
The relationship between a banker and a customer depends on the activities; products or
services provided by bank to its customers or availed by the customer. Thus the relationship
between a banker and customer is the transactional relationship. Bank’s business depends much
on the strong bondage with the customer. “Trust” plays an important role in building healthy
relationship between a banker and customer.
Definition of a ‘Banker’
According to section 3 of the NI Act, 1881, banker includes any person acting as a banker and
any post office savings bank.
According to section 5(b) of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949, banking means the accepting,
for the purpose of lending or investment, of deposits of money from the public, repayable on
demand or otherwise, and withdrawable by cheque, draft, order or otherwise.
Money lender is not considered as a banker as mere lending does not constitute banking
business. Banker is an institution which borrows money by accepting deposits from the public
for the purpose of lending to those who are in need of money.
DSMNRU,Lucknow 3
GENERAL RELATIONS BETWEEN BANKER AND CUSTOMER –A LEGAL
PERSPECTIVE
Who is a ‘Customer’?
The term Customer has not been defined by any act. The word ‘customer’ has been derived
from the word ‘custom’, which means a ‘habit or tendency’ to-do certain things in a regular or
a particular manner’s . In terms of Sec.131 of Negotiable Instrument Act, when a banker
receives payment of a crossed cheque in good faith and without negligence for a customer, the
bank does not incur any liability to the true owner of the cheque by reason only of having
received such payment. It obviously means that to become a customer account relationship is
must. Account relationship is a contractual relationship.
Banker-Customer Relationship
Banking is a trust-based relationship. There are numerous kinds of relationship between the
bank and the customer. The relationship between a banker and a customer depends on the type
of transaction. Thus the relationship is based on contract, and on certain terms and conditions.
These relationships confer certain rights and obligations both on the part of the banker and on
the customer. However, the personal relationship between the bank and its customers is the
long lasting relationship. Some banks even say that they have generation-to-generation banking
relationship with their customers. The banker customer relationship is fiducial relationship.
The terms and conditions governing the relationship is not be leaked by the banker to a third
party.
Classification of Relationship
The relationship between a bank and its customers can be broadly categorized in to General
Relationship and Special Relationship.
If we look at Sec 5(b) of Banking Regulation Act, we would notice that bank’s business hovers
around accepting of deposits for the purposes of lending. Thus the relationship arising out of
these two main activities are known as General Relationship. In addition to these two activities
banks also undertake other activities mentioned in Sec.6 of Banking Regulation Act.
Relationship arising out of the activities mentioned in Sec.6 of the act is termed as special
relationship.
DSMNRU,Lucknow 4
GENERAL RELATIONS BETWEEN BANKER AND CUSTOMER –A LEGAL
PERSPECTIVE
General Relationship
Debtor-Creditor: The general relationship between banker and customer is that of a debtor
and creditor i.e. borrower and lender’. In Foley v. Hill1, Sir John Paget remarks, “The
relationship of a banker and customer is primarily that of debtor and creditor, the respective
positions being determined by the existing state of account. Instead of the money being set
apart in a safe room, it is replaced by the debt due from the banker. The money deposited with
him becomes his property, and is absolutely, at his disposal, and, save as regards the following
of the trust funds into his hands, the receipt of money by a banker from or on account of his
customer constitutes him merely the debtor of the customer with ‘super added’ obligation to
honour his customer’s cheques drawn upon his balance, in so far the same is sufficient and
available”.
On the opening of an account a banker assumes the position of a debtor. The money deposited
by the customer with the bank is in legal terms lent by the customer to the banker who makes
use of the same according to his discretion. The creditor has the right to demand back his money
from the banker, and the banker is under an obligation to repay the debt as and when he is
required to do so.
A depositor remains a creditor of his banker so long as his account carries a credit balance. But
he does not get any charge over the assets of his debtor/banker and remains an unsecured
creditor of the banker. Since the introduction of deposit insurance in India in 1962 the element
of risk of the depositor is minimized as Deposit Insurance and Credit Guarantee Corporation
undertakes to insure the deposits upto a specified amount.
Banker’s relation with the customer is reversed as soon as the customer’s account is overdrawn.
Banker becomes creditor of the customer who has taken a loan from the banker and continues
1
(1848) 2 H LC 28).
2
AIR 1964 SC 1023=1963 Supp. (1) SCR 514.
DSMNRU,Lucknow 5
GENERAL RELATIONS BETWEEN BANKER AND CUSTOMER –A LEGAL
PERSPECTIVE
in that capacity till the loan is repaid. As the loans and advances granted by a banker are usually
secured by the tangible assets of the borrower, the banker becomes a secured creditor of his
customer.
2. Creditor–Debtor: Lending money is the most important activities of a bank. The resources
mobilized by banks are utilized for lending operations. Customer who borrows money from
bank owns money to the bank. In the case of any loan/advances account, the banker is the
creditor and the customer is the debtor. The relationship in the first case when a person deposits
money with the bank reverses when he borrows money from the bank. Borrower executes
documents and offer security to the bank before utilizing the credit facility.
In addition to opening of a deposit/loan account banks provide variety of services, which makes
the relationship more wide and complex. Depending upon the type of services rendered and
the nature of transaction, the banker acts as a bailee, trustee, principal, agent, lessor, custodian
etc.
Special Relationship
1. Bank as a Trustee:
3
Indian Trust Act, 1882
DSMNRU,Lucknow 6
GENERAL RELATIONS BETWEEN BANKER AND CUSTOMER –A LEGAL
PERSPECTIVE
In case of trust banker customer relationship is a special contract. In Canara Bank v. Canara
Sales Corporation,4the Supreme Court held that, there is alwys an element of trust between the
bank and its custemer. The banks business depends upon this trust.
2. Bailee – Bailor:
Sec.148 of Indian Contract Act, 1872, defines "Bailment" "bailor" and "bailee". A "bailment"
is the delivery of goods by one person to another for some purpose, upon a contract that they
shall, when the purpose is accomplished, be returned or otherwise disposed of according to the
directions of the person delivering them. The person delivering the goods is called the "bailor".
The person to whom they are delivered is called, the "bailee".
Banks secure their advances by obtaining tangible securities. In some cases physical possession
of securities goods (Pledge), valuables, bonds etc., are taken. While taking physical possession
of securities the bank becomes bailee and the customer bailor. Banks also keeps articles,
valuables, securities etc., of its customers in Safe Custody and acts as a Bailee. As a bailee the
bank is required to take care of the goods bailed.
In Punjab National Bank v K.B. Shetty,5 the bank was held liable for the negligence in taking
care of the maintenance and operation of lockers resulting in the customer losing some
ornaments. Banker is authorised to unilaterally increas locker charges but cannot impose on
existting customer the requirement of advance payment of rent for 5 years.6 Further the bank
has right to revise the locker rent from time to time according to its own cost factors. The hirer
cannot protest against it. He can only withdraw if he does not like it.7
Sec.105 of ‘Transfer of property Act 1882’ defines lease, Lessor, lessee, premium and rent. As
per the section “A lease of immovable property is a transfer of a right to enjoy such property,
made for a certain time, express or implied, or in perpetuity, in consideration of a price paid or
promised, or of money, a share of crops, service or any other thing of value, to be rendered
4
A.I.R. 1987 S.C. : (1987) 62 Com. Cas. 280.
5
(1991) 2 C.P.R. 633.
6
S.L. Bhargava v. U.C.O. Bank, (1993) C.P.J. 958.
7
Mihir Kumar v. U.B.I., (2002) 2 C.P.J. 38 (N.C.).
DSMNRU,Lucknow 7
GENERAL RELATIONS BETWEEN BANKER AND CUSTOMER –A LEGAL
PERSPECTIVE
periodically or on specified occasions to the transferor by the transferee, who accepts the
transfer on such terms.”
Sec.182 of ‘The Indian Contract Act, 1872’ defines “an agent” as a person employed to do any
act for another or to represent another in dealings with third persons. The person for whom
such act is done or who is so represented is called “the Principal”. Thus an agent is a person,
who acts for and on behalf of the principal and under the latter’s express or implied authority
and the acts done within such authority are binding on his principal and, the principal is liable
to the party for the acts of the agent.
In all such cases bank act as agent of the customer and provisions of agency will continue to
apply. Rights and duties of bank vis-avis customer will be agent and principal as provided
under Indian Contract Act, 1872.
DSMNRU,Lucknow 8
GENERAL RELATIONS BETWEEN BANKER AND CUSTOMER –A LEGAL
PERSPECTIVE
In Bank of India v. Official Liquidator,8 it was held that when a customer sends cheques for
collection to the banker. His (banker) role becomes as an agent of the customer.
5. As a Custodian: A custodian is a person who acts as a caretaker of some thing. Banks take
legal responsibility for a customer’s securities. While opening a dmat account bank becomes a
custodian.
6. As a Guarantor: Banks give guarantee on behalf of their customers and enter in to their
shoes. Guarantee is a contingent contract. As per sec 31,of Indian contract Act guarantee is a "
contingent contract ". Contingent contract is a contract to do or not to do something, if some
event, collateral to such contract, does or does not happen. It would thus be observed that
banker customer relationship is transactional relationship.
8. Pawnor and Pawnee: A customer of the bank takes loan from the bank by way of security
of moveable property is called Pawnor (pledgee) and the relation between customer and banker
stands Pawnor (pledgor) or Pawnee (pledgee). A pawn is a sort of bailment in which goods or
chattels are delivered to anather as a pawn, to be a security of money borrowed.
In Vimal Chandra Grover v. Bank of India,9 the Bank provided overdraft facility of Rs. 5 lacs
on the security of sharees of over more than 10 lacs with a condition to sell the shares and set
off the debt. It was held that there was relation of Pawnee and Pawnor between the banker and
the customer.
8
A.I.R. 1915 Bom. 375.
9
A.I.R. 2000 S.C. 2181.
DSMNRU,Lucknow 9
GENERAL RELATIONS BETWEEN BANKER AND CUSTOMER –A LEGAL
PERSPECTIVE
Duties of a Banker
Banker has a duty to maintain secrecy of customers' accounts. Maintaining secrecy is not only
a moral duty but bank is legally bound to keep the affairs of the customer secret. The principle
behind this duty is that disclosure about the dealings of the customer to any unauthorized person
may harm the reputation of customer and the bank may be held liable. The duty of maintaining
secrecy does not cease with the closing of account or on the death of the account holder. As
per Sec. 13 of “Banking Companies Acquisition and Transfer of Undertakings Act 1970”-
DSMNRU,Lucknow 10
GENERAL RELATIONS BETWEEN BANKER AND CUSTOMER –A LEGAL
PERSPECTIVE
“Every corresponding new bank shall observe, except as otherwise required by law, the
practices and usages customary among bankers, and, in particular, it shall not divulge any
information relating to or to the affairs of its constituents except in circumstances in which it
is, in accordance with law or practices and usages customary among bankers, necessary or
appropriate for the corresponding new bank to divulge such information.”
Maintaining secrecy is implied terms of the contract with the customer which bank enters into
with the customer at the time of opening an account.
Bank has not only to maintain secrecy of transactions, but secrecy is also to be maintained in
respect of operations through ATM/ debit cards. Bank has also to maintain secrecy of user ID
pins with due care so that it does fall in wrong hands.
Bank is liable to pay damages to the account holder for loss of money and reputation if it fails
in its duty to maintain secrecy and discloses information relating to a customer's account or
conduct of the account to any unauthorized person.
Bank can also be liable to the third party if its wrongful disclosure harms the interest of the
third party. If bank Knowingly furnishes wrong information. There has been a
misrepresentation over estimation of favourable opinion
DSMNRU,Lucknow 11
GENERAL RELATIONS BETWEEN BANKER AND CUSTOMER –A LEGAL
PERSPECTIVE
In order to ascertain financial position and credit worthiness of the person banks obtain
information from other banks with which they are maintaining accounts. It is an established
practice among bankers and implied consent of the customer is presumed to exist. The opinion
is given in strictest confidence and without responsibility on the part of the bank furnishing
such information. Credit information is furnished in coded terms to other banks on IBA format
and without signatures.
Banks are under duty bound to provide proper accounts to the customer of all the transactions
done by him. Bank is required to submit a statement of accounts / passbook to the customer
containing all the credits and debits in the account.
DSMNRU,Lucknow 12
GENERAL RELATIONS BETWEEN BANKER AND CUSTOMER –A LEGAL
PERSPECTIVE
banker accepts the deposits from the customer with an obligation to repay it to him on demand
or otherwise. The banker is therefore under a statutory obligation to honour his customer’s
cheques because, it is recognized under section 31 of the NI Act, 1881.
The drawee of a cheque having sufficient funds of the drawer in his hands properly applicable
to the payment of such cheque must pay the cheque when duly required so to do, and, in default
of such payment, must compensate the drawer for any loss or damage caused by such default.
Thus the banker is bound to honour his customer’s cheques provided the following conditions
are fulfilled-
(c) Presentation of cheques within reasonable time after ostensible date of its issue
Bank can refuse to honour the cheques if: There is in sufficient balance in the account to
make payment of the cheque. Cheque issued does not pertain to the account on which it has
been drawn.
1. If the cheque is not in order (post dated, stale, payment countermanded, amount in
words and figure differs, etc.)
2. The balances held in account are earmarked for some specific purpose and the
remaining balance is not sufficient to honour the cheque.
DSMNRU,Lucknow 13
GENERAL RELATIONS BETWEEN BANKER AND CUSTOMER –A LEGAL
PERSPECTIVE
Rights of a Banker:
It is not that the bank has only duties to wards its customers, it too has certain rights vis-à-vis
his customers. The rights can broadly be classified as:
One of the important rights enjoyed by a banker is the right of general lien. Lien means the
right of the creditor to retain goods and securities owned by the debtor until the debt due from
him is paid. It may either be general or particular.
In Brando v. Barnet10, it was held that bankers most undoubtedly have a general lien on all
securities deposited with them as bankers unless there is an express or implied contract
inconsistent with lien.
In India sec 171 of the Indian Contract Act confers general lien upon bankers as follows-
bankers…..may in absence of a contract to the contrary, retain as a security for a general
balance of account, any goods bailed to them.
Lien means a legal claim to hold property as security. According to Halsbury, lien may be
defined as “a right in man to retain that which is in his possession belonging to another, until
certain demands of the person in possession is satisfied”.
A particular lien is one which confers a right to retain the goods in connection with a particular
debt only while a general lien is a right to retain all the goods or any property of another until
all the claims of the holder are satisfied. It extends to all transactions and thus more extensive.
10
(1846). 12 C&F 787.
DSMNRU,Lucknow 14
GENERAL RELATIONS BETWEEN BANKER AND CUSTOMER –A LEGAL
PERSPECTIVE
2) Dividend warrants and interest warrants paid to the banker under mandates issued
by the customer.
3) Securities deposited to secure specific loan but left in banker’s hand after loan is
repaid.
4) Securities, negotiable or not, which the banker has purchased or taken up, at the
request of customer, for the amount paid.
4) On deposit account.
5) On stolen bond.
7) On trust account.
DSMNRU,Lucknow 15
GENERAL RELATIONS BETWEEN BANKER AND CUSTOMER –A LEGAL
PERSPECTIVE
The right to set off is a statutory right which enables debtor to take into account a debt owing
to him by a creditor, before the latter could recover the debt due to him from the debtor. Thus
when a customer keeps two or more accounts at the same bank, some of which are overdrawn
and some in credit, the bank has a right to combine such accounts and pay the resultant
balance. In Halesowen Presscook and Assemblies Ltd v. Westminister Bank Ltd,11 it was held
that a banker has the right to combine two accounts and to set off unless he has made some
agreement express or implied to the contrary.
when a debtor owes two or more debts to a creditor and he pays some amount which is not
sufficient to meet any debt to the creditor appropriation is done. It applies to a banker if the
customer has more than one deposit or more than one loan account.
In Devaynes v. Noble,12 famously known as Clayton’s case, a principle was laid down as to
when the customer has current account and deposits and withdraws money frequently the first
item on debit side will be discharged by the first item on credit side. The credit entries in the
account adjust or set off the debit entries in chronological order.
the banker may claim incidental charges on unremunerative accounts such as service charges,
processing charges, ledger folio charges, appraisal charges, penal charges and so on.
A banker has a special privilege to charge compound interest. In Syndicate Bank v. West
Bengal Cement Ltd13, the adding of unpaid interest due to the principal amount is recognized.
However, the SC abolished this in case of agricultural loans in the Bank of India case.
11
[1972] AC 785.
12
(1816) 35 ER 781.
13
99 (2002) DLT 420.
DSMNRU,Lucknow 16
GENERAL RELATIONS BETWEEN BANKER AND CUSTOMER –A LEGAL
PERSPECTIVE
CONCLUSION
The legal relationship between the banker and his customer has varied over the centuries.
Unquestionably, the core banking activities of deposit-taking and lending are not fiduciary in character.
[26] Thus, the legal relationship between a bank and its customers can be distinguished from that between
other service providers and their customers is that of fiduciary relationship. Nevertheless, due to the
complexities of business and banking, the relationship between bankers and customers goes beyond the
primary relationship of creditor and debtor. Some other activities that modern multifunctional banks
frequently engage in are more obviously fiduciary in character, e.g. where the bank manages its customer's
investment portfolio or provides its customer with corporate finance services. Therefore, it is possible that
a banker act as an agent or trustee of the customer like any other service providers.
DSMNRU,Lucknow 17
GENERAL RELATIONS BETWEEN BANKER AND CUSTOMER –A LEGAL
PERSPECTIVE
REFERENCES
BOOKS REFFERED:
Tannan, ML,Tannan’s Banking Law and Practice in India, 23rd Edition 2010, Lexis
Nexis Butterworths Wadhwa, Nagpur.
Varshney P.N., Banking Law and Practice, 13th Edition, 2010, Jain Book Agency,
Delhi.
Gupta S.N., Banking Law in Theory and Practice, 5th Edition, 2010, Universal Law
Publishing Co. Pvt. Ltd.
Shekhar K.C. & Shekhar Lekshmy, Banking-Theory and Practice, 20th Edition, 2011,
Jain Book Agency, Delhi.
Singh Avtar; Banking and Negotiable Instruments, 2nd Edition 2011, Eastern Book
Company.
Myneni Dr. S.R.; Law of Bankings,1st Edition, 2006Asian Law House Hyderabad.
WEBSITES REFFERED:
hanumant.com/Banking%20law%20-%20Meenakshi%20Natesan.html
vidyagyan.blogspot.com/2009/09/relationship-between-banker-and.html
www.indg.in/financial.../relationship_between_banker_and_customer.pd..
www.scribd.com/.../GENERAL-RELATIONSHIP-BETWEEN-BANKER...
http://buildupyourbankingknowledge.blogspot.in/2010/07/banker-customer-general-
relationship.html
DSMNRU,Lucknow 18