Sinais e Sintomas Vocais e de Fala em Indivíduos Expostos A Agentes Químicos: Uma Análise de Prontuários
Sinais e Sintomas Vocais e de Fala em Indivíduos Expostos A Agentes Químicos: Uma Análise de Prontuários
Sinais e Sintomas Vocais e de Fala em Indivíduos Expostos A Agentes Químicos: Uma Análise de Prontuários
1590/1982-0216201820214717
Artigos originais
(1)
Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro - ABSTRACT
UFRJ, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brasil.
Research support source: Fundação Carlos Objective: to identify voice and speech signs and symptoms in patients exposed to
Chagas Filho de Amparo à Pesquisa do chemical agents.
Estado do Rio de Janeiro – FAPERJ.
Methods: an exploratory and descriptive study analyzing the data from the medical
Conflict of interests: Nonexistent records of patients who sought health services at a toxicology outpatient clinic located
in Southeastern Brazil.
Results: a total of 139 medical records were obtained, 75 being selected. Twelve of
the records selected contained data regarding voice and speech symptoms, including
hoarseness (3), loss of voice (2), chronic throat inflammation (1), sore throat (1),
secretion and burning in the throat (1), dry throat and mouth (1), lump in the throat
associated with difficulty in swallowing (1), difficulty in articulating words (1), and
difficulty in verbal expression (1). Diseases capable of causing phono-articulatory pro-
blems were detected in 6 cases. These symptoms affected individuals with occupa-
tional exposure to different substances, particularly community health agents (7) and
pesticide applicators (7).
Conclusion: individuals exposed to chemical substances experienced voice and
speech problems, either due to a possible irritation caused by chemical agents or due
to diseases developed during or after the exposure.
Keywords: Signs and Symptoms; Voice; Speech Disorders; Chemical Compound
Exposure
Mailing address:
Carina Dias Lisbôa
Avenida Horácio Macedo , S/N, Ilha do
Fundão
CEP: 21044-020 - Rio de Janeiro, Rio de
Janeiro, Brasil
E-mail: carinadelisboa@hotmail.com
210 | Lisbôa CD, Mello MGS
with a history of alcoholism and/or smoking were also sign, including hoarseness (3), loss of voice (2), chronic
excluded. These criteria were assessed in anamnesis, throat inflammation (1), sore throat (1), secretions and
with the clinical evaluation being performed in the first burning sensation in the throat (1), throat and mouth
outpatient consultation, using the data obtained from dryness (1), throat lump associated with difficulty in
medical records. swallowing (1), and difficulty in articulating words (1).
After adopting the inclusion and exclusion criteria, The sign was difficulty in verbal expression (1). Data
64 of the 139 initially obtained records were excluded from the medical records are summarized in Figure 1.
for the following reasons: history of smoking and/or Of the 12 medical records with data regarding
alcoholism (50 cases), respiratory disorders (asthma, voice and speech signs and symptoms, 8 belonged
bronchitis, pneumonia, tuberculosis) (10 cases),
to women and 4 belonged to men. The following age
endocrinological disease (hypothyroidism) (1 case),
groups were identified: 34–35 years (2), 36–40 years
and neurological disorders (ischemic stroke, aneurysm,
(1), 41–45 years (2), 46–50 years (3), 51–55 years (1),
epilepsy) (3 cases). All these disorders were manifested
and 56–59 years (3).
and diagnosed before chemical exposure. Therefore,
75 records, from patients who attended the toxicology The following occupations were retrieved from
outpatient clinic from 1999 to 2015, were selected. the records: health agent (7), production operator
This study was conducted in four stages. First (1) (1), smelting assistant (1), metallurgist (1), chemical
was the preparation of a data collection form, typed on technician (1), and mechanic (1). The study partici-
a computer, and later printed for manual filling of data pants were exposed to the following chemical agents:
from medical records, including the following variables: insecticides (7); toluene (1); toluene, benzene, and
voice and speech signs and symptoms, patient age, trichloroethylene (1); acetone, turpentine, and paints
occupation, gender, chemical agent(s) to which the (1); gasoline, fluorine, aluminum sulfate, and chlorine
patients were exposed, duration of exposure, and other (1), and metallic lead (1). The exposure periods were: 2
information that might be relevant for analyzing phono- years (1), 5 years (1), 8 years (1), 11 years (1), 12 years
articulatory complaints. Second (2), medical records (1), 14 years (5), 17 years (1), and 24 years (1).
were selected following application of the inclusion Only one patient was referred to the otorhinolaryn-
and exclusion criteria; and third (3), manual collection gologist for evaluation of the symptom (sore throat).
of information present in the selected medical records.
In addition, 6 of the 12 medical records containing
Finally (4), descriptive analysis by creating a summary
voice and speech signs and symptoms included
table of data regarding signs and symptoms, gender,
data on diseases that manifested during or after the
age, occupation, chemical agent(s), duration of
exposure to chemical agents had ceased, and could
exposure, and clinical data from the selected records.
have adverse effects on phono-articulation, namely
toxic encephalopathy and ototoxic hearing loss (1),
RESULTS ototoxic hearing loss alone (1), hypothyroidism (1),
A total of 12 out of the 75 records analyzed contained allergic rhinitis (1), systemic lupus erythematosus (1),
data regarding voice and speech symptoms and one and neuropathy due to lead poisoning (1).
Duration of
Signs and
Sex Age Occupation Chemical agent(s) exposure Information
symptoms
(years)
Patient professionally involved in paper printing and
recycling sought health services at the toxicology
outpatient clinic with the following symptoms: headache,
Hoarseness Production Acetone, paints, and nervousness, body tremors, insomnia, loss of vision,
M 50 years 14 years
(symptom) operator turpentine hoarseness, and auditory complaint. He was referred
for neurological and audiological evaluation, and was
later diagnosed with toxic encephalopathy and ototoxic
hearing loss.
Patient professionally involved in insecticide manipulation
and application sought health services at the toxicology
Organophoshate outpatient clinic, with the following symptoms: skin
Hoarseness insecticide Malathion lesions, allergic eye reactions, and hoarseness. He was
M 42 years Health agent 14 years
(symptom) and an unspecified referred for dermatological and immunological evaluation.
pyrethroid However, the immunological and dermatological results
and diagnosis data were not included in the medical
record.
Patient retired 2 years ago from job involving exposure
to insecticides (insecticide handling and application),
and started working as an administrative assistant. After
Organophosphorus retirement from job involving pesticide application, she
Hoarseness insecticides sought health services at the toxicology outpatient clinic
F 58 years Health agent 12 years
(symptom) Malathion and for follow-up. During the outpatient appointment, she
Temephos reported the following symptoms: forgetfulness, hair
loss, hoarseness, and anterior cervical enlargement. She
was referred for endocrinological evaluation, and was
later diagnosed with hypothyroidism.
Patient retired 4 years ago from job involving exposure to
insecticides (insecticide manipulation and application),
and started working as a homemaker. After retirement,
Organophosphorus
she sought health services at the toxicology outpatient
Loss of voice insecticides
F 34 years Health agent 8 years clinic for follow-up, and was diagnosed with allergic
(symptom) Malathion and
rhinitis. During the outpatient appointment, she reported
Temephos
the following symptoms: allergic rhinitis, loss of voice,
and laryngeal irritability. No referrals were made during
this consultation.
Patient professionally involved in insecticide manipulation
and application sought health services at the toxicology
Unspecified
Loss of voice outpatient clinic, with a complaint of headache. During
F 41 years Health agent organophosphate 14 years
(symptom) the outpatient appointment, she reported the following
insecticide
symptoms: swollen ankle and loss of voice. No referrals
were made during this consultation.
Patient retired 4 months ago from job involving
exposure to insecticides (insecticide handling and
application). After retirement, the patient sought health
Chronic throat
Unspecified services at the toxicology outpatient clinic, and was
inflammation F 40 years Health agent 5 years
insecticides diagnosed with changes in visual acuity. During the
(symptom)
outpatient appointment, she complained of chronic
throat inflammation. No referrals were made during this
consultation.
The patient retired 8 months ago from job involving
exposure to toluene. After retirement, she sought health
services at the toxicology outpatient clinic for follow-
up. During the outpatient appointment, she reported
Sore throat Chemistry
F 35 years Toluene 14 years sore throat and burning sensation of the face during
(symptom) technician
occupational exposure to toluene. She was referred
for otorhinolaryngological evaluation. However, the
laryngological evaluation data were not included in the
medical record.
Patient working as a mechanic sought health services
at the toxicology outpatient clinic with complaints of
dizziness. He was diagnosed with ototoxic hearing
Secretion and Gasoline, fluorine,
loss. After retirement from job involving exposure to
burning in the throat M 52 years Mechanic chlorine, and 17 years
chemical agents, and after 7 years of follow-up in the
(symptom) aluminum sulfate
outpatient clinic, the patient complained of secretion and
burning in the throat. No referrals were made during this
consultation.
Duration of
Signs and
Sex Age Occupation Chemical agent(s) exposure Information
symptoms
(years)
Patient working with insecticide handling and application
Organophosphorus sought health services at the toxicology outpatient clinic.
Dry throat and mouth
F 59 years Health agent insecticides 14 years She complained of forgetfulness, and dryness in the
(symptom)
Temephos mouth and throat. She was referred for psychological
examination.
Patient working with insecticide handling and application
sought health services at the toxicology outpatient clinic,
Lump in the throat Organophosphorus with the following symptoms: headache, insomnia, lump
and difficulty insecticides in the throat, and difficulty swallowing. It is of note that
F 56 years Health agent 11 years
swallowing Malathion and the words "lump in the thyroid?" were written next to the
(symptom) Temephos words “lump in the throat.” However, no lumps were
detected in the thyroid gland during physical examination,
and the patient was referred for biochemical examination.
Patient working with cleaning of warfare components
sought health services at the toxicology outpatient
clinic with complaints of cramps. During the outpatient
Difficulty in
Benzene, toluene, appointment, she reported the following symptoms:
articulating words F 50 years Metallurgist 24 years
and trichloroethylene difficulty in articulating words, joint pain, and altered
(symptom)
sensitivity of the hands. No referrals were made during
this consultation. The patient was diagnosed with
systemic lupus erythematosus.
Patient professionally involved in the manufacture
of jewelry sought health services at the toxicology
outpatient clinic. The results of physical examination
Difficulty in verbal
M 47 years Smelting assistant Metallic lead 2 years indicated difficulty in verbal expression and a decrease
expression (sign)
in muscle strength in the limbs. The patient was referred
for clinical tests, and was diagnosed with neuropathy due
to lead exposure.
when she sought outpatient care, after being exposed in the laryngeal mucosa, and these symptoms may
to the organophosphate insecticides Malathion and be due to chronic inflammation triggered by chemical
Temephos for 12 years, and was diagnosed with agents in contact with the airways31.
hypothyroidism, which may have adverse effects on Chlorine is an inorganic compound that causes
the phonatory mechanism, including edema in vocal irritation to the respiratory system32. Gasoline is a
folds26. volatile organic compound that contains a mixture of
Organophosphate insecticides may inhibit chemical substances, including toluene, xylene, and
the enzyme acetylcholinesterase, which leads to benzene, a toxic combination. Gasoline may damage
cholinergic hyperstimulation by the accumulation the respiratory and neurological systems, and gasoline
of acetylcholine in the synapses, with neurological vapors increase the risk of laryngeal and pharyngeal
involvement27. Paralysis of vocal folds is rare, and the cancer33.
etiology is linked to the neurological effects produced
Fluorine is an inorganic substance used to
by organophosphate insecticides28. Pyrethroids cause
manufacture other chemical compounds, and causes
respiratory problems in exposed workers, including
severe irritation to exposed tissues, especially to
nasal and throat irritation, sneezing, and coughing29.
the respiratory mucosa34. Aluminum is used in the
Voice loss was diagnosed in two patients who
manufacture of many products, including pots, pans,
worked as health agents. One of them had been
and cosmetics. Exposure to aluminum dust compro-
exposed to an unspecified organophosphate insec-
mises the respiratory system. In Germany, workers
ticide for 14 years. The second patient had a history
exposed to aluminum dust were diagnosed with respi-
of exposure to Malathion and Temephos for 8 years.
ratory tract dysfunction during a health evaluation35.
After retirement, she sought care in the toxicology clinic
Symptoms of dryness in the throat and mouth were
with vocal complaints, and was diagnosed with allergic
reported by a health agent exposed to the organophos-
rhinitis. Therefore, organophosphates are neurotoxic27.
phate insecticide Temephos for 14 years, an insecticide
Further, insecticides cause rhinitis, which may lead to
class known to cause adverse events27,28. Exposure to
airway irritation30.
chemical agents may cause dryness in the laryngeal
Chronic throat inflammation were reported by
mucosa, and affect the viscosity of the vocal folds, and
a health agent who was exposed to insecticides
their vibration during phonation31.
for 5 years, and sought our service 4 months after
retirement. This symptom may be caused by different Lump in the throat accompanied by difficulty in
etiologic factors, including bacteria, parasites, viruses, swallowing were reported by a health agent who was
and traumas, as well as environmental and chemical exposed to the organophosphate insecticide Malathion
factors. The latter two categories involve continued and Temephos for 11 years. Lumps in the neck are
exposure to irritant agents, which may cause chronic known to possibly indicate different clinical condi-
inflammation31. tions, including thyroid dysfunction36. Further, lumps
It should be emphasized that acute or chronic in the throat, combined with difficulty in swallowing, is
sore throat may be a consequence of inflammatory a symptom usually observed in cases of pharyngeal
processes caused by irritation31. Sore throat was cancer37.
reported by a chemical technician after occupational Difficulty in articulating words may indicate an
exposure to toluene. The detrimental effects of toluene articulatory disorder, and is also observed in patients
include mild or moderate irritation of the respiratory with speech disorders20. This symptom was reported
tract, resulting in sore throat. In this respect, a study by a metallurgist exposed to toluene, benzene, and
conducted in 1987 reported that workers exposed to trichloroethylene for 24 years, and later diagnosed
toluene complained of sore throat8. with systemic lupus erythematosus, which may
Secretion and burning in the throat were reported by trigger neurological disorders, and impair phonation
a mechanic, who was diagnosed with ototoxic hearing and speech38. Toluene and benzene may affect the
loss, and was occupationally exposed to gasoline, respiratory system, and lead to airway irritation8.
fluorine, chlorine, and aluminum sulfate for 17 years. Trichloroethylene is a volatile organic compound
The patient reported these symptoms during an outpa- that may depress the nervous system. Intoxication
tient consultation, 7 years after retirement. Exposure to symptoms include tremors, difficulty swallowing, and
chemical irritants may produce secretions and burning weakness in the oral musculature39.
Difficulty in verbal expression was reported by a Therefore, diagnosing voice and speech disorders
smelting assistant who worked in a jewelry factory, and in the clinical routine of toxicological health services,
was exposed to metallic lead for 2 years. This patient and hiring specialized health professionals, including
was diagnosed with neuropathy due to lead poisoning. speech therapists, is essential for the early identification
Lead is highly toxic to the nervous system, and may and rehabilitation of such dysfunctions.
affect the motor bases of speech40.
In most cases, phono-articulatory problems were REFERENCES
diagnosed in individuals without associated comor-
1. WHO: World Health Organization. The public health
bidities, and those with diseases capable of impacting
impact of chemicals: knowns and unknowns. [cited
voice and speech. This result may suggest that the
2017 Aug 27]. Available from: http://apps.who.int/
unfavorable effects on phonation and vocal production
iris/bitstream/10665/206553/1/WHO_FWC_PHE_
in workers exposed to chemical agents may be due
EPE_16.01_eng.pdf?ua=1
to local and chronic irritation of the vocal tract,31 and
diseases that directly or indirectly affect the speech 2. SINITOX: Sistema Nacional de Informações Tóxico-
apparatus20,21,26,30,38.However, additional clinical studies Farmacológicas. Dados de intoxicação. [cited 2017
are necessary to better establish a causal inference. Aug 26]. Available from: http://sinitox.icict.fiocruz.
It should be emphasized that the present study br/dados-nacionais
relied solely on medical records. Therefore, complaints 3. Williams NR. Occupational voice disorders due to
and/or signs should be acknowledged and recorded workplace exposure to irritants - a review of the
by health professionals as indications of possible voice literature. Occup Med Lond. 2002;52(2):99-101.
and speech disorders, which may not have happened 4. Sataloff RT. Vocal tract response to toxic injury:
in all of the cases. The results indicate that only the clinical issues. J Voice. 1994;8(1):63-4.
patient with sore throat was referred for assessment 5. Ubrig-Zancanella MT, Behlau M. Relação
of the symptom. This low number of referrals may be entre ambiente de trabalho e alteração vocal
due to the lack of professionals in the areas of speech em trabalhadores . Rev Soc Bras Fonoaudiol.
therapy and otorhinolaryngology among the outpatient 2010;15(1):72-9.
toxicology clinic staff. However, an even higher number 6. Ichihara G, Miller JK, Ziolkokwska A, Itohara S,
of observations related to voice and speech disorders Takeuchi Y. Neurological disorders in three workers
could be observed in the presence of professionals exposed to 1-Bromopropane. J Occup Health.
trained to provide care for patients exposed to chemical 2002;44(1):1-7.
substances. 7. Joffres MR, Williams T, Sabo B, Fox RA.
A greater emphasis should be given to studies Environmental sensitivities: prevalence of major
correlating exposure to chemical agents and changes symptoms in a referral center: The Nova Scotia
in voice and speech production3-5. However, imple- Environmental Sensitivities Research Center Study.
menting this strategy in toxicological health services is Environ Health Perspect. 2001;109(2):161-5.
also essential. To assist in this process, we believe the 8. Yin SN, Li GL, Hu YT, Zhang XM, Jin C, Inoue O
application of speech therapy and otorhinolaryngology et al. Symptoms and signs of workers exposed to
in the toxicological clinic is fundamental to promote the benzene, toluene or the combination. Ind Health.
investigation of phono-articulatory symptoms and signs 1987;25(3):113-30.
in individuals with current exposure or with a history of 9. Matsushita T, Goshima E, Miyagaki H, Maeda
exposure to chemical substances, especially occupa- K, Takeuchi Y, Inoue T. Experimental studies for
tional exposure, in addition to encouraging research determining the mac value of acetone: 2. biological
and preventive and rehabilitative actions for vulnerable reactions in the “six-day exposure” to acetone.
populations. Sangyo Igaku. 1969;11(10):507-15.
10. Heydari F, Ghanei M. Effects of exposure to sulfur
CONCLUSION mustard on speech aerodynamics. J Commun
Individuals exposed to chemical substances experi- Disord. 2011;44(3):331-5.
enced voice and speech problems, either due to a 11. Fornander L, Ghafouri B, Lindahl M, Graff P. Airway
possible irritation caused by chemical agents or due irritation among indoor swimming pool personnel:
to diseases developed during or after the exposure. trichloramine exposure, exhaled NO and protein
profiling of nasal lavage fluids. Int Arch Occup laryngeal cancer on the Texas Gulf Coast. Cancer
Environ Health. 2013;86(5):571-80. Res. 1988;48(7):1960-4.
12. Kronholm DK, Jönsson BAG, Axmon A, Nielsen J. 25. CDC: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Work-related airway symptoms, nasal reactivity and Turpentine [cited 2017Aug 27]. Available from:
health-related quality of life in female hairdressers: a http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/npg/npgd0648.html
follow-up study during exposure. Int Arch of Occup 26. Isolan-Curry RW, Silva MAA, Monte O, Cury
and Environ Health. 2014;87(1):61-71. AN. Caracterização vocal de pacientes com
13. Fonte R, Edallo A, Candura SM. Cerebellar atrophy hipertireoidismo e hipotireoidismo. Rev Soc Bras
as a delayed manifestation of chronic carbon Fonoaudiol. 2007;12(2):135-40.
disulfide poisoning. Ind Health. 2003;41(1):43-7. 27. Cavaliere MJ, Calore EC, Perez NM, Puga FR.
14. Doskov D. A system for the objective screening of Organophosphate myotoxicity. Rev. Saúde Pública.
dysphonia and the possibilities for its application in 1996;30(3):267-72.
exposed workers. Int Arch Occup Environ Health. 28. Peter JV, Sudarsan TI, Moran JL. Clinical features of
1998;71(Suppl):S79-80. organophosphate poisoning: A review of different
15. Langevin SM, O’Sullivan MH, Valerio JL, Pawlita M, classification systems and approaches. Indian J
Applebaum KM, Eliot M et al. Occupational asbestos Crit Care Med. 2014;18(11):735-45.
exposure is associated with pharyngeal squamous 29. Moretto A. Indoor spraying with the pyrethroid
cell carcinoma in men from the greater Boston area. insecticide lambda-cyhalothrin: effects on
Occup Environ Med. 2013;70(12):858-63. spraymen and inhabitants of sprayed houses. Bull
16. Khanna S, Gharpure AS. Petroleum carcinogenicity World Health Organ. 1991;69(5):591-4.
and aerodigestive tract: in context of developing 30. Bagatin E, Costa EA. Doenças das vias aéreas
nations. Cureus. 2017;9(4):e1202. superiores. J. Bras. Pneumol. 2006;32(Supl
17. Gil AC. Como elaborar projetos de pesquisa. 4ª ed. 1):S17-S26.
São Paulo: Atlas; 2002. 31. Dworkin JP. Laryngitis: types, causes, and
18. Carvalho LVB, Costa-Amaral IC, Mattos RCOC, treatments. Otolaryngol Clin North Am.
Larentis AL. Exposição ocupacional a substâncias 2008;41(2):419-36.
químicas, fatores socioeconômicos e saúde do 32. Winder C. The toxicology of chlorine. Environ Res.
Trabalhador: uma visão integrada. Saúde Debate. 2001;85(2):105-14.
2017;41(spe2):313-26. 33. Lynge E, Andersen A, Nilsson R, Barlow L,
19. Reiter R, Hoffmann TK, Pickhard A, Brosch S. Pukkala E, Nordlinder R et al. Risk of cancer
Hoarseness - causes and treatments. Dtsch Ärztebl and exposure to gasoline vapors. Am J
Int. 2015;112(19):329-37. Epidemiol.1997;145(5):449-58.
20. Behlau M, Madazio G, Azevedo R, Brasil O, 34. ATSDR: Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease
Vilanova LC. Disfonias neurológicas. In: Behlau M Registry. Toxicological profile for fluorides,
(ed). Voz O Livro do Especialista volume II. Rio de hydrogen, fluoride, and fluorine. [cited 2017 Aug
Janeiro: Revinter; 2005. p. 111-86. 27]. Available from: http://www.atsdr.cdc.gov/
21. Fabron EMG, Garcia YS, Delgado-Pinheiro EMC. toxprofiles/tp11.pdf
The voice of the hearing impaired: a literature 35. Radon K, Nowak D, Szadkowski D. Lack of
review. Distúrb Comum. 2017;29(1):55-67. combined effects of exposure and smoking on
22. Howard MO, Bowen SE, Garland EL, Perron respiratory health in aluminium potroom workers.
BE, Vaughn MG. Inhalant use and inhalant use Occup Environ Med.1999;56(7):468-72.
disorders in the United States. Addict Sci & Clin 36. Jameson JL, Weetman AP. Distúrbios da glândula
Pract. 2011;6(1):18-31. tireóidea. In: Fauci AS, Kasper DL, Hauser SL,
23. Feldman RG, Ratner MH, Ptak T. Chronic Longo DL, Jameson JL, Loscalzo J (ed.). Medicina
toxic encephalopathy in a painter exposed interna de Harrison. 18ª ed. Porto Alegre: AMGH;
to mixed solvents. Environ Health Perspect. 2013. p. 2911-39.
1999;107(5):417-22. 37. Barnes L, Eveson JW, Reichart P, Sidransky D.
24. Brown LM, Mason TJ, Pickle LW, Stewart PA, Buffler Genética e patologia dos tumores de cabeça e
PA, Burau K et al. Occupational risk factors for pescoço. São Paulo: Santos; 2009.