Kirch Media (Germany) : How It Happened?

Download as docx, pdf, or txt
Download as docx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 3

KIRCH MEDIA (GERMANY)

Kirch Media was established in the 1970s as the primary subsidiary of Bavarian
based Kirch Gruppe. In the 194, the German government ended its own television
monopoly and opened its broadcasting market to competition. Leo Kirch, Kirch
Gruppe’s CEO, established fIrst private channel Sat. 1 in Gemrnay. It was the
second-largest media company in Germany, after Bertelsmann.

How it happened?
In 19916, Kirch Media purchased all movie rights from the major Hollywood
studios for the next ten years. During 1990s, Kirch Gruppe also entered digital
television services segment. The company invested $3 billion to develop the
platform Pay-TV business, but failed to predict demand properly. This created
significant financial and cash flow pressures and ultimately led to the Gruppe’s
downfall. Financial Flexibility was affected further when Kirch bought broadcast
rights for sports events and movies from various foreign companies.

By the late 1990s, the group’s leverage became difficult to manage. Despite its
weak financial position and growing debt burden, the company continued to
borrow enough money to keep operating. State-owned banks were instructed to
continue lending to Kirch Group by Kirch’s close friend Stoiber’s CSU party. By
providing funds to Kirch’s ill-advised projects, the government wanted to ensure
the generation of jobs in the state beset by the growing unemployment problems.

Kirch’s financial problems mounted in the beginning of 2002. Administrators came


forward to help Kirch Media with growing crisis and created a plan in February
2002. According to this plan Kirch Media was merged with Sat. 1. Kirch Media
filed for bankruptcy in April 2002 mainly due to the debts related with the
purchase of sports rights for its television channels and the launch of digital
television services. Its television broadcasting segment was subsequently
acquired by a group led by the US media investor Haim Saban. Kirch’s exit marked
the end of an era that began in 1980s. The Pay-TV segment, which contributed
largely to the financial problems of Kirch Group was revived and benefitted by the
new management.
The major causes of the collapse of Kirch Media have been explained below.

i. Lack of Transparency. Kirch Gruppe and Kirch Media lacked transparency in


their financial statements, high degree of secrecy were maintained which
made it difficult for the stakeholders to understand the company’s true
financial position.
ii. Ill-advised Projects. The company was involved in some expensive and ill-
advised projects as digital television division and failed to gather realistic
projections of its demand and supply. This project brought a loss of $900
million to Kirch Media.
iii. Long-term Commitments. The company entered into various long-term
commitments which reduced its financial flexibility. It became difficult for
the company to manage its leverage.
iv. Heavy debt. The company continued to borrow despite its weak financial
position and growing debt burden. Kirch Media had bank debts of around
$4.8 billion and billions of dollars in other liabilities.
v. Defamation. Deutsche Bank CEO Rolf Breuer expressed concerns over the
creditworthiness of the group. Kirch Media’s financial situation was further
affected nu the negative comments by CEO of Deutsche Bank.
vi. Regulators’ Complicity. State-owned banks were directed to provide
uninterrupted credit to the company. Massive leverage created a conflict of
interest among bankers, government officials and the company. State
taxpayers were made to pay for the flaws and weaknesses of the company.
vii. Over-expansion. CEO Kirch expanded its business rapidly without proper
strategic planning. Funds were invested in many ventures in a reckless
manner and as a result, most of these ventures failed to generate sufficient
revenue for the company. CEO Kirch’s lust for power was ultimately
responsible for the downfall of Kirch Group.
viii. Audit Failure. The company’s external auditors KPMG failed to make
proper assessment of the debt incurred by the company. The auditors
should have warned the company against the excessive leverage
undertaken by it.
Legal Fight with Deutsche Bank
After the collapse of Kirch Media, Leo Kirch sued the Deutsche bank and its
former CEO Rolf Breuer for the negative comments about the Kirch Group’s
finances that fostered its collapse. Leo Kirch passed away in 2011. The case
was settled in February 2014 and Deutsche Bank agreed to make a
payment of $775 million to Kirch’s heirs, without admitting guilt to the
charges.

You might also like