Weimer 1982
Weimer 1982
Weimer 1982
SPE
Society of Petroleum Engineers
Sandstone Reservoirs
Because of its widespread nature, the Cut Bank East in the Cretaceous and 20 East in the Tertiary.
Sandstone is interpreted as a complex of point bar The cross section (Fig. 8) shows the structural and
sandstones within several meander belts of a broad stratigraphic position of the petroleum accumulations.
alluvial valley. The valley is thought to have been Only the Table Rock field is a closed structural
at least 50 miles in width and probably hundreds of trap; Patrick Draw, Desert Springs and West Desert
miles in length (Fig. 5) with flow direction to the Springs fields are stratigraphic traps. The updip
northeast. seal in each stratigraphic trap is the change from
porous and permeable shoreline sandstone to imper-
The Cut Bank field is at the updip eastern margin meable shale and siltstone of coastal plain environ-
of the valley where fluvial sandstones rest on a scour ments. The top seal is marine impermeable Lewis shale
surface cut into the marine Jurassic shale 3 . The up- which may also be the source of oil. Gas may be
dip seal is provided by the impermeable marine shale either biogenic or from coal in the nonmarine portion
(Fig. 6); the top seal is impermeable mudstones of the of the Almond. Each shoreline bar complex contains
flood plain environment. Oil and gas accumulated in water in low stru~tural positions which defines the
the point bar sandstones and dry holes within the downdip limit of production.
field are believed to be in impermeable abandoned
channel fill or channel margin flood plain deposits. Cretaceous exploration in the area started by
drilling in 1955 on the Table Rock anticline, and
Because of the lack of'reliable geological data Almond production was established where shoreline
from cable tool well logs, the width of the alluvial bar 1 crossed the closed structure. Later drilling
valleys and dimensions of individual point bar sand- found the stratigraphic traps to the north and west
stones cannot be determined accurately. Based on the at Desert Springs, Patrick Draw and West Desert
distribution of dry holes, each individual point bar Springs. Production is at depths from 3,500 to
is estimated to be from one to three miles across and 6,500 feet.
the width of each meander belt would be similar. Be-
cause of a stable tectonic setting, younger meander The Patrick Draw field, discovered in 1959, is
belts probably cannibalized older ones and, therefore, one of the most significant oil fields in the Mesa-
an accurate reconstruction of individual systems is verde Group. The Wasatch Formation (Eocene) is ex-
not possible from available data. posed at the surface. Approximately 56 million bbls
of oil and 11 Bcf of gas have been produced over 22
Geologic History of Accumulation years. An estimated 200 to 250 million bbls are in
place in the reservoir. A typical electric-log from
The geologic history of the deposition of the the field of the UA-5 and UA-6 sandstone is shown in
Cut Bank Sandstone is related to the following se- Fig. 9. Reservoir characteristics are summarized in
quence of events. During early Cretaceous a world- Table 1 5 ,6
wide drop in sea level caused the incisement of drain-
age into Jurassic shales on the northwest flank of the Lithology and Distribution of Productive Sandstones
Kevin-Sunburst dome. With a rise in sea level during
the early Cretaceous the alluvial deposits filled the Two different sandstones produce petroleum in
valley and the Cut Bank Sandstone was deposited as a the upper 60 ft of the Almond (Figs. 9 and 10). The
series of coalescing meander belts containing numerous lower sandstone, called the UA-6, is near the middle
point bar sandstones. Abandoned channel fill makes up of the interval and is oil-productive both in the
approximately 15 percent of the area within the Cut West Desert Springs field (T. 20 N., R. 99 W.) and
Bank field. Nonmarine deposits of the Kootenai For- in the northern part of the Patrick Draw field
mation, 500 to 650 ft thick, overlie the Cut Bank (Fig. 8). The sandstone is gray, very fine- to fine-
Sandstone. Overlying marine sandstones and shales of grained .. calcareous, and ranges from a wedge-edge to
the Colorado ~ormation were deposited during an over- more than 25 ft thick. The average thickness of the
all marine transgression in the late Cretaceous. The productive sandstones is about 12 ft. Because of the
Cut Bank Sandstone was buried by several thousand feet erratic distribution of production, the fine grain
of Cretaceous beds prior to the uplift of the Kevin- size, and the close association above and below with
Sunburst dome in the early Tertiary. Oil and gas coal beds and lagoonal shale, the UA-6 sandstone is
believed to have been generated in the marine Ellis interpreted as having been deposited as tidal creek
Shale then migrated to the updip pinchout of the Cut channels and tidal flats west of a shoreline sand
Bank Sandstone where it was trapped at the edge of trend (Fig. 11).
the alluvial valley.
A second sandstone, the UA-S, is the main oil-
PATRICK DRAW FIELD, SWEETWATER COUNTY, WYOMING productive sandstone at Patrick Draw. This sandstone
occurs near the top of the Almond and is overlain by
General Description the marine Lewis Shale (Fig. 9), by oyster-bearing
coquina layers, or by 5-10 ft of carbonaceous shale
Gas accumulations in ancient shoreline sand- and impermeable sandstone. The UA-5 sandstone (bar
stones of the Mesaverde Group are well known in the 2, Fig. 8) is quartzose, gray, fine- to medium-
Cretaceous rocks of the Rocky Mountain area. One grained, calcareous, and contains abundant dark gray
area along the western part of the Wamsutter arch of to black chert grains and minor amounts of feldspar.
south-central Wyoming contains gas and oil in 2 main The mineral percentages in the sandstone are: quartz
shoreline sandstones of the Almond Formation (upper 64; chert 32; feldspar (mostly plagioclase) 4; and
Mesaverde Group) where they cross a broad structural trace amounts of biotite, muscovite, chlorite, and
arch 4 (Fig. 8). Magnitude of dip on the arch is 4 0 zircon. Cement is dominantly silica, but carbonate
4 SANDSTONE RESERVOIRS SPE 10009
(calcite or dolomite) and clay minerals (kaolinite) Because of the widespread occurrence and thickness of
alsq are present. The UA-5 sandstone ranges in thick- the channel sands, the shoreline is interpreted to be
ness from a wedge-edge to more than 30 ft (Fig. 10). within a meso tidal range (4 to S ft). The model on
Coquina layers of the oyster, Ostrea glabra, are Fig. 11 indicates the setting for the 2 different
found near the to~ of the sandstone in the middle part types of shoreline sandstone.
of Patrick Draw field. particularly in the area of
thin sandstone in the middle of the field. In the The reservoir characteristic for the UA-5 sand-
northern part of the field, thin laminae of shale and stone at Patrick Draw is shown by Table 1. A water
siltstone within the sandstone exhibit angles of flood has had poor success in the northern portion of
cross-lamination as much as 20 0 • The UA-5 sandstone the field where the sandstone was deposited mainly in
rests on a coal bed or associated gray laminated silt- tidal channel environment. Discontinuity in the lat-
stone and carbonaceous shale. Thickness variation eral porosity and permeability occurs between dif-
within the UA-5 interval results from addition of ferent tidal channels (genetic units).
sandstone both at the base and top of the unit. How-
ever, the top of the sandstone shows topographic HARTZOG DRAW FIELD, WYOMING
relief of only 5-10 ft in relation to marker beds in
the overlying Lewis Shale (Fig. 9). The relief at the General Description
base of the sandstone is of the same order of magni-
tude. The porous and permeable UA-5 sandstone zone A common sandstone reservoir for oil production
occurs over an area at least 20 mi long and 6 to S from Cretaceous strata in the Rocky MOuntain region
mi wide (Fig. 10). is lenticular marine sa~dstone bars encased in marine
shale. Hartzog Draw field (3, Fig. 2), discovered in
The UA-5 sandstone pinches out updip at the 1975, produces from the Shannon SandstoneS (Upper
western margin of Patrick Draw field into impermeable Cretaceous) and is typical of this type bar. MOdern
coal-bearing shale and siltstone and, in addition, the log suites and good core coverage are available for
interval may be cut out by an unconformity at the base field studies.
of the Lewis Shale 7 • To the north the oil-productive
sandstone grades laterally into impermeable shale, Hartzog Draw, located on the gently sloping east
but, in a nearly identical stratigraphic position and side of the Powder River basin, Wyoming (Fig. 12), is
in a higher structural position, a water-bearing sand- the largest of the several linear northwest-southeast-
stone is found. The trend and thickness variation of trending stratigraphically trapped oil fields in the
this sandstone and its relationship to the Patrick basin. Th,~ field is 1 to 4 mi wide and 22 mi long
Draw field are shown by the isopachs on Fig. 10. Al- with 2S,000 productive acres. The structure conforms
though a separate reservoir, the sandstone is corre- to a general southwest regional dip typical of that
lated with the UA-5 sandstone because of stratigraphic portion of the basin and has minimal to no influence
position, similar lithologic character, and what on production.
appears to be the record of a similar geologic event.
Based on available sparse well control, the size of An isopach map of the net sandstone thickness
this northern sandstone bar averages 4 mi in width shows a narrow linear character (Figs. 12 and 13).
and more than 10 mi in length. The gas-discovery well The average sandstone thickness is 25 ft but ranges
in West Desert Springs field was completed from this up to 65 ft in the central portion of the field.
sandstone; five additional wells in the field have Where thickest, the initial flow potentials were in
been completed with the producing area as shown on excess of 3,000 barrels of oil per day. No water
Fig. 10. The reservoir is interpreted as having a table is apparent in the field and no formation water
gas-water contact, although a narrow oil ring may be is produced. The reservoir drive mechanism is solu-
present which cannot be developed economically. tion gas.
Depositional MOdel A net pay isopach map very closely follows the
distribution of the net sandstone thicknesses. The
Based on core identification of internal sedi- net pay section, as calculated from 17 cores, aver-
mentary structures, geometry based on reservoir con- ages 14 percent por03ity and permeability averages
tinuity and isopach trends, the UA-5 sandstone is about 12 md 9 • These data for a typical well are
interpreted as a shoreline sand deposit. In some shown on Fig. 14. Net pay thickness for the field as
cores the sandstone shows a coarsening upward texture a whole ranges from 1 to 62 ft and closely parallels
with burrowed sandstone near the base, overlain by the net sandstone thickness. Parameters calculated
trough cross-stratification in sets 1 to 3 ft thick, from logs (using a 2.71 grain density with a 9 per-
which is overlain by parallel laminated sandstones. cent density porosity cutoff) average 12.3 percent
These features are typical of a vertical profile effective porosity, 30 percent water saturation and
through a prograding barrier island shoreline deposit. 9 percent clay. The best porosities and permea-
Other cores, especially in the north end of the Pat- bilities are generally associated with thick net pay
rick Draw field, show fining-upward textures, lags of sandstones.
transported oyster shells at the base and within the
sandstone, trough cross-strata in sets 1 to 2 ft thick Oil in place is estimated to be 350 million
with laminae of clay or carbonaceous material within bbls, and with both primary and secondary recovery
the cross lamina. The Ophiomorpha trace fossil occurs methods the field is estimated to have an ultimate
within the sandstone indicating near normal marine recovery of more than 6S.5 million bbls. Oil is 36
water salinity. These features indicate that the API gravity with a paraffinic base. Depth to reser-
sand was deposited in a tidal channel environment. voir varies from 9,000 to 9,600 feet.
5 R. J. WEIMER AND R. W. TILLMAN SPE 10009
REFERENCES
MAP. I NE BAR
~AR I NE BAR (PLANAR LAMI NA TED) BAR MARG I N I NTERRAR BURROWED SHELF SHELF SILTY
(CENTRAL FACIFS) FAC I ES FACIES FAC I ES SIL TSTONE FACIES SHALE FACIES
Litho 1 o~y Fi ne-medi urn grai ned Fi ne-grai ned quartz- Fine-medium 1nterbedded Shal y, sandy )i lty Shal e;
quartzose sandstone, ose <;ancistone. grai ned sand- very fi ne- silt stone, very fi ne-
rooderately glauco- stone. sha 1e gra; !"led slightly grained, thi n
n; ti c; 1oca 1 5; de- and siderite s i 1ty sand- glauconitic. (1/3" ) s i 1ty
rite clasts. rip-up clasts stone and sandstone
and 1enses. si 1ty sha let 1enses.
very 91 auco- sl ightly
nHie. gl duconit; c.
Sedi mentary Predomi nant ly hi gh Mostly srrh-horizontal Mostly high Predomi nant 1y Few physical Current ripples
Structures angl e trough and plane-parallel 1 am- anqle trollghs, ril1f11e-forrn strtlctures sub-horizontal
planar-tangent i al i nated sandstone. some current heddi ng Srrr- preserved. laminae.
cross heddi ng. 0.5'+ thick 1am; na- ripples, face. Cur-
Trough set s common- set s. M;nor shale and shale clasts rent ripples.
ly horizontally sandstone ripples. commonly show
truncated. preferred
orientations.
Rurrov/i ng Sparse Sparse Sra rse Modprate to ~ore than 75% Low to moderate
locally high r.lIrrowed.
rercent
hurrowed.
'000'.' .
~
Fig. 3 - Index map showing
outline of Cretaceous basin of
deposition.
A
LEGEND
"-","-"
MARINE
• SANDSTONE
. .\
D
~'-'"1
SHALE 6 LIMESTONE
SCALES OF SECTION -1wYei:-' -; .
. ! I
f 7
21000 FEET
5 50MILES
A"~ .~B~B
--'l~·-·
NONMARINE
IZ:2J
l~o°;J
SH.,55.COAL
. i CONGL.ass.
UTAH1 ,
'~'-'I"-' ••••••• STAGE BOUNDARIES
miles
SCALE OF INDEX
ki.'~·- COL~~ADO
I, -j .
.
{l_
. KOOTENAI
MADISON GRP
,,
,,
,:
I
:,,
\
\\
\
\
\
,,
\
o'L-_...LI6 _ _12-'-I_---"18 Mil ..
\\.
N
r .. , )
WEST EAST
POINT OF ROCKS TABLE ROCI<
2ON-IOIW
SE r9N-98W
I I
B
SP R
\
<>\
\
\ I
I
/ <>
: <> \
\
\
\
\i
\
I
I
<:> \ o
\
" DISC. WELL:'"f \
I \
\ \
\<:> \f$~WJs
\
\ <:>\
I \
I \
: ¢ t,t. I
I
T I
I
I
I
20 \
: AXIS
N \~ I
I
I
I
I
I
I
,
,.",
I
I
f \
T
19
N
OIL-WATER
CONTACTS
~\
~
~\\
DISC. \\\
WELL \~ "
h\
RIOOW
\!..\ Q,\ \
fTZ1
I....!.!...J
T,ans'UonZ ...... Shaliow N""I,C
S""dsI""" Dopooiled B.I"",9Io0.. laclO
"l \\D
r FS
BRACKISH TO MARINE
Fo, •• he,. Buc~ Sa ..... IMe
TOE ~~~'~~~·~:'~n:"~~:I:::C"
TC T,daICh.nn .. IS.nd~Ion.
TC R T,daIC, •• kSandsion.
DOMINANTLY FRESH
DF,eshW.I.,Me.. hICooU
~Ba"'.rISlandsan'hlone
x x'
MEANDER OF TIDAL BARRIER ISLAND OR SPIT
Q) ~~~O;~~,~~~_r::-"~:=~""._~.~ .',i"«VFOS- - - - S L
, ", ,~: SF
R75W
Ii> '
d'O
o T \
,
"-+\ + \45
\ \N
\ \ \
'
\\ 4',
o 2 4 Mi. R75W
II ,. I I'i ill I I
01 5 Km.