2296 Shipon-Blum Elisa
2296 Shipon-Blum Elisa
2296 Shipon-Blum Elisa
The talker
Verbal child
Background of SM
We know that…
Anxiety can affect a person’s
word retrieval ability
verbal working memory for more complex
material
sentence formulation ability
response time
In addition,
Communication deficits may increase
a person’s anxiety when asked to speak!
Anxiety and Selective Mutism (SM) appear to
go hand-in-hand.
(Anstendig, 1999)
According to the DSM-IV-TR (2000), SM…
involves a consistent failure to speak in specific
social situations and is not thought to be due to a
lack of knowledge with spoken language.
Non-standardized testing
at home using videotaping for language sample analysis
parent-elicited story-retelling using the SNAP
(Strong Narrative Analysis Procedure, Strong, 1998)
ne
x
Px
Px
en
qP
qP
ce
/o
/o
Sc
Se
Se
y1 S
s?W
W
s?1
s?-
y
to r
o ry
to r
An
An
An
llS
lS t
l lS
Te
Te
t el
Re
The child’s ability to speak to the SLP (an
unfamiliar adult) was not related to order of
testing (parent or SLP first).
12 10.56
10 8.4
8.17
8
6 4.53 TNL-C
TNL-O
4
Mean=10
2 SD=3
n=20 n=18 n=13 n=15
0
Spoke to SLP Didn't Speak to SLP
Number of Children with SM Who Had
Speech-Language Difficulties
9
14 ExpLang
Rec+Exp
Fluency
4 Artic
Note: Some children did
not have difficulties in
more than one speech or
9 language areas.
ExpLang
Rec+Exp
Fluency
Artic
24
Note: Some children with
fluency or articulation
29 problems also had
language difficulties.
- Anxiety in family
Genetic, neurodevelopmental
-Inhibited temperament ÆSocial Anxiety
- Bilingualism
- Speech/Language Disorder or Delay
- Learning Difficulty
- Developmental Concerns
- Neurodevelopmental Delay
- Sensory Processing Disorder/Difficulty
MAINTAINING FACTORS
- Misinterpretation of ‘testing’
- Avoidant behavior
‘Just pointing or nodding can elicit feelings of anxiety and be impossible to do!’
SM is a complex disorder. Many explanations
for it’s development have been given including
psychodynamic, behavioral, family systems,
trauma-related, and genetic.
They may in fact be inadequate.
TALK
STAGES
of
Selective Mutism
BASIS of SOCIAL COMMUNICATION
ANXIETY TREATMENT (SCAT)
Understanding the
Social Communication Bridge
Each Child has UNIQUE BRIDGE
Child moves BACK and FORTH across the BRIDGE
based on setting and people present.
TO BEGIN helping the child in the REAL
WORLD
QUIET environment
less stimulation
Modify the Environment
Behavior therapy
emphasizes environmental factors affecting behavior and
helps the child unlearn conditioned responses
(Stone, Kratochwill, Sladezcek, & Serlin, 2002)
found to have the largest effect size of the major various
treatment approaches including psychodynamic, family
systems, and biological in effectively treating children with
SM (Stone, Kratochwill, Sladezcek, & Serlin, 2002)
SCAT Helps the Child acknowledge/assess
Feelings
using charts
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
5 4 3 2 1 0
IS SM About ‘CONTROL?’
Yes, absolutely!
HOW?
Tools To Transition From
Nonverbal Into Verbal
(Going from stage 2Æ3)
ABCDEFGHIJKL
MNOPQRSTUVW
XYZ
Go through the entire alphabet making no eye contact in a
matter-of-fact way.
Progress to other ‘simple CVC words’
Use rhyming words (keep words in view)
Progress to sentences
The CAT SAT on the HAT
Letter Alphabet Yes/No Sit Word Sentence
People I want Game Pit chart chart
to feel more P Hit
comfortable H Mit
with S
T
--->Relaxed body language
--->Better eye contact
--->Smiling more
--->Child laughing (with or without sounds)
--->Initiating without effort
--->Increased communication interaction
(responding and initiating)
Sample Yes/No Question
Ask child to provide answers to Yes/No questions.
Give the child a chance to ask you questions.
Use sound YYY or SSS for Yes, NNN for No or whole word if
possible.
Procedures:
Communication partner(s) circle words with crayon or marker.
Increase speed of circling over time.
______ says word and X/crosses word out.
Procedures
Ask _____ choice Question and give 2 possible
responses.
______ is to respond in writing or verbally.
Example:
1. Your sister had a play date with girls from her class at your house for
the very first time. Who came over?
2. What toy did the girls take turns riding?
3. The girls played with something your Mom keeps in a big plastic box.
What did all the girls play with all afternoon?
Working on expanding expressive
language and improving pragmatic
skills are often needed in treatment
as children continue to
work toward improved discourse
and conversational abilities.
Key to Treatment Involves:
(1) Addressing the causes/propagating factors of
Selective Mutism
(2) Parent Education to rid negative reinforcement
and to enable for ‘understanding,’ consistency, routine
and structure at home.
(3) School Education and school-based
accommodations/interventions
(4) Helping the child unlearn conditioned/learned
behaviors
(5) Helping the child develop long term coping skills
to combat anxious feelings & to increase comfort in
socializing and progression of communication in ALL
settings.
SM is an anxiety based
communication disorder.