Issue 34 MFSB Oi
Issue 34 MFSB Oi
Issue 34 MFSB Oi
NEWS
Myanmar Financial ANALYSIS
COMPANIES
Services Brief DATA
DOWNLOAD THE
MYANMAR FINANCIAL DATA
SERVICES REPORT
Selected local banks by saving and fixed deposit rates
Read FMR’s flagship Local banks and insurers by branch network
report on the sector by
Selected investment deals in Myanmar since 2018
clicking here
Foreign exchange rates
YSX stock prices
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 19 December 2018 2
We note that the Myanmar Times own MFSM has reported several times on the
Burmese edition also reported this. central bank's drafting of five new regulatory
directives, which it plans to issue in 2019.
Both 7Day Daily and Daily Eleven articles cited
U Soe Thein, one of the deputy governors, as It is possible that U Soe Thein's comments
making the comments after the signing mean the regulator plans to issue a statement
ceremony between the Myanmar Credit on interest rate liberalisation along with
Bureau and Equifix New Zealand Services and its five directives in January.
Solutions.
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 19 December 2018 3
In conclusion, we have multiple media reports Allowing banks to expand into unsecured cash-
that the central bank is planning to liberalise flow based lending at a higher interest rate
the interest rate on unsecured lending in 2019, would raise the NIM and ultimately - if used
and that we should expect a communication sensibly - improve banks' profitability.
from the central bank early next year.
But there are reasons to be cautious about
Banks have been pushing for some form of giving banks greater freedoms to set their own
interest rate liberalisation for years, and so to lending rates.
that extent the news is positive.
GIZ's latest banking report, for instance,
But it is worth outlining the arguments both doubts whether banks are able to
for and against liberalising interest rates at this demonstrate the "sound risk management"
stage, even if it risks irritating some members that would be a reasonable precondition for
of the banking community. interest rate liberalisation.
The arguments in favour are straightforward. Their report suggests that banks might first be
At present, the 13% cap stops banks properly required to demonstrate that they have not
pricing risk, whether the loan is unsecured or only proper risk management but adequate
not. loan appraisal systems in place before being
able to take advantage of interest rate
As a corollary, banks find it hard to expand liberalisation.
into riskier sectors like SMEs, which in
Myanmar make up the vast majority of There is no reason to think that the central
registered companies. bank will not set such requirements in its
forthcoming announcement.
The same is true of designing new products for
the consumer sector, or simply lending in In fact, the regulator has made similar
longer maturities. In each instance, the statements in the past to the effect that banks
inability to adjust the interest rate creates are free to experiment with unsecured lending
problems. provided they have proper risk management
systems.
Another related issue is the effect this 13% cap
- together with the 8% floor on deposits - has Some of the larger lenders, including CB
on bank's net interest margin (NIM). Bank, Myanmar Apex Bank and Yoma Bank,
have received support on designing modern
This 5% NIM is not particularly low for the credit appraisal systems and are already
region, but banks repeatedly claim that their experimenting with cash-flow based lending to
true NIM is around 1%. If true this would make the SME sector.
it easily the lowest in the region.
We believe that a modest adjustment in
Reasons why the true NIM might be very low unsecured rates, reliant on demonstrating
include: many banks are not actually receiving systems like these are in place and running,
interest payments on the bulk of their loans would be a sensible first step on the path to
(often actually overdrafts not term loans) interest rate liberalisation.
and loan-deposit ratios are very low.
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 19 December 2018 4
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 19 December 2018 5
Joint ventures would likely be faster, but at “When we [in Thailand] moved to RCB it was
this rate the first 100% foreign-owned life complete havoc,” he said, adding that the Thai
insurers will be appearing in the middle of regulator gave firms a four year staggered
2020. adoption period. Part of the reason for the
havoc was that the Thai insurance market was
When it comes to tariff liberalisation, beyond larger and more developed when it moved to
the fact the FRD knows it needs to happen, RBC. Myanmar has the advantage of very low
things are less clear. insurance penetration, very low outdated
premiums and relatively high capitalisation.
Speaking on an insurance panel, U Aung Htun,
co-founder and director of Myanmar “Better to move to RBC now when you have so
Investments International, said he was nervous little premium and risk and you are over-
at the idea of Myanmar developing new capitalised,” U Aung Htun said.
policies at the same time as changing tariff
pricing. The bad
“There is a lot of risk,” he said. The FRD’s U Thant Zin had to listen to several
complaints from the insurance sector
Although not a fan of a set tariff market - in throughout the panel.
Thailand firms found ways around them and
competed on price anyway - it is only possible One was that the regulator’s reticence to allow
to set pricing if you have data, U Aung Htun firms to experiment was “killing” innovation,
told attendees. particularly when it came to new products.
“I have consultants that do product design, but “[Right now] product design does not cater to
they do not have Myanmar data,” he said. the public [and then] regulatory framework is
“They have a proxy for Myanmar data.” holding things back,” said AMI Managing
Director U Myo Min Thu.
U Aung Htun suggested Myanmar follow
Thailand, which also started with a tariff set by Another key complaint from insurers is that
the regulator but turned this into a pricing the regulator does not allow firms to have
band. their own agents.
“Over time when you see real results [you can] “We have no tied agents, just general agents,”
change the band,” he said. “But it’s all about said U Myo Min Thu. “So it’s hard for
data.” companies to commit to [training and
investing in ] agents and help their company
Another uncertain regulatory issue is the move grow.
to risk-based capital (RBC). Grand Guardian
Insurance, one of the few commercial insurers U Aung Htun agreed. “The whole distribution
with even a partly digital operating system, has model in Myanmar is totally flawed,” he said,
completed a trial of the new RBC system. But pointing different company strategies will
rolling this out to other insurers still reliant on necessitate different agent strategies. “Allow
manual spreadsheet-based calculations will be companies to develop their own agency model
difficult. with their own agents.”
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 19 December 2018 6
Banking
Data analysis: Yoma Bank loan growth
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 19 December 2018 7
Yoma Bank discounts the receivables of an JZü is an interest bearing account categorised
input suppliers’ top dealers, and this extension within the "call" family of accounts, but with a
of credit allows the input supplier to increase sweepstake reward scheme. The product was
sales. "Through the product, the payment soft launched in July and as of mid-December
obligation of the dealer to the input supplier is total JZü deposits totalled Ks18bn.
essentially financed by the bank," it said.
Capital Market
Government to bolster bond market with
Dealers must have a "satisfactory track record" DIFID funding
of at least two years with the supplier in order
to qualify for programme. The regulators are working on a bond market
masterplan and the creation of a bond market
FMI has also provided a breakdown of trade association in order to address the other half
financing separated from other of loans and of Myanmar’s underdeveloped capital
advances, although trade finance only market.
accounts for a very small percentage of the
portfolio. The UK Government’s Department for
International Development (DFID) is funding
£4m to help support development which will
be carried out through the Asian Development
Bank (ADB).
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 19 December 2018 8
After an assessment phase the ADB and DFID Fellow panellist Neville Daw, head of the YSX
will work with the government on a capital special task force, said that he was “a great
market development plan. This will provide a believer in bond market associations. [They]
stronger legal and regulatory framework for can really make market development better.
bond issuance. [The] idea is that they are there to assist
ministries around obstacles.”
Financial industry executives have frequently
pointed out Myanmar’s unfortunate decision He added that in this case it was being pushed
to build up an equity market first before because people from “outside” think it best,
developing a bond market. and that it was important the association was
“done at a Myanmar level.”
There also seems to be a lack of clarity at the
regulatory level about what the key issues
around bond market development are.
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 19 December 2018 9
Whether these developments should be At the panel discussion, Daw Tin May Oo said
viewed as positive may depend on one’s faith that the SECM had “encouraged securities
in regulatory committees and masterplans. companies to conduct a secondary market but
only two [had participated].” She also noted
Panellist Liew Chee Seng, deputy managing that nine branches of Myanma Economic Bank
director at CB Bank, said he encouraged are allowed to trade government bonds.
“frequent consultation with the private sector
players.” So the securities companies, branches of state
banks and commercial banks are all allowed -
“I have the feeling the authorities can’t in theory - to trade government bonds.
develop the idea of a bond market among
themselves,” he said. “If you have feedback “Even though trading volumes are not very big,
from an early stage the market gets on with it, they have [been] trading,” Daw Tin May Oo
rather than waiting for regulations to be argued at the panel discussions. “So still
drafted and reviewed internally.” trading markets exist.”
The comments from Daw Tin May Oo and Daw This statement, however, runs slightly counter
Thin Thin Su, however, give little hope the to what commercial banks say is happening.
government regulators share this perspective. Bank executives say there is no government
bond trading on the interbank market.
The state of the secondary market
One commercial bank executive said the only
The government bond market master plan and secondary trading he was aware of was one of
the committee hinted at by the SECM’s Daw the securities firms, which we understand to
Tin May Oo will both deal with improving the be the Myanmar Securities Exchange Centre
secondary market for government bonds. (MSEC).
But the parts of the panel discussion around The moderator, ADB financial sector
the current state of the secondary government economist Sophie Duong Nguyen, said that in
did not suggest that the government is dealing its support for bond market development the
with the issues or is even aware of the ADB plans to start with a diagnostic phase to
problems. identify the key challenges and understand
what is happening.
MFSM notes that in February, the ADB
published its ASEAN+3 Bond Market Guide “Right now I see that the private sector is
2018: Myanmar. In it, the ADB states that: saying it [the secondary market] is not working
and the public sector says it already allows
“The trading of bonds and notes in the [trading],” she said. “So maybe the ADB and
Myanmar bond market presently occurs only other development partners need to bridge
in the interbank market, between CBM and its the gap.”
constituents, among participating financial
institutions and securities companies, and as Our understanding of the situation is that
purchase and sale transactions at the counter government bonds continued to be issued at
of Authorised Selling Agents appointed by highly unattractive interest rates. This
CBM.” inevitably reduces their demand as an
investment product.
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 19 December 2018 10
The new prudential regulations in the banking But this anomaly was due to the participation
sector have given banks other ways to meet of state-owned Myanma Economic Bank as a
capital requirements, which has also reduced competitive bidder.
appetite.
Former CBM deputy governor U Set Aung said
The general demand for bonds is minimal, and at a lower house of parliament meeting in
there is, to our understanding, no regulation 2015, that MEB had been undercutting
governing secondary market trading or a deposit auction bids because its excess
dedicated trading platform that banks or other liquidity came from current accounts held by
entities could use. governmental departments on which MEB
pays no interest. Government deposits can
Monetary Policy only open current accounts with MEB.
CBM to boost deposit auctions
This allowed MEB to accept deposit auction
The Central Bank of Myanmar (CBM) is to interest rates far lower than commercial
make more funds available through its deposit banks, which have to pay interest rates to their
auction in order to maintain financial stability, depositors.
the deputy governor U Soe Thein said in a
news video posted by The Irrawady. "The auction became more successful after
setting MEB as a non-competitive bidder", said
"Banks have excess [liquidity], and thus, the U Set Aung.
central bank is absorbing money [from banks]
through deposit auctions to help them reduce From 2012 to date, the central bank has
losses, as well as [for the central bank] to cut accepted total deposits of Ks31.6trn, according
inflation", said U Soe Thein. to central bank data.
The central bank launched deposit auctions The central bank sells - and less often buys - US
back in early 2012, as part of its contractionary dollars at daily auctions. Ostensibly, this is
monetary policy, and it accepts deposits in done to help it set a daily reference rate for
four maturities: 7, 14, 28 and 42 days. dollar-kyat conversion, although since 2017
the central bank has relied on the more active
Since the facility began, the weighted average interbank market to set its rate
interest rate (WAR) of commercial bank bids
has ranged between 0.25% to 7.5%. Banks are usually net buyers of dollars because
several factors reduce the availability of
The 0.25% figure - substantially lower that the foreign currency in the banking system.
market savings and call deposit rates - was
recorded for the period between 2013 and Myanmar runs a large trade deficit, trade
2015, according the central bank statistics. receipts are often either not repatriated or
held in the informal sector and the interbank
currency market functions poorly.
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 19 December 2018 11
MFSM notes that deputy governor also The aim is to eventually introduce an open e-
appeared to distance himself from the dollar platform that companies and finance providers
purchasing, perhaps suggesting there was can use to create an efficient and formal
some division at the bank over what to do. supply chain finance market for Myanmar.
"I am not sure that the central bank's decision MFSM spoke to Shwe Lan CEO Eleonora
[to purchase dollars in that period] is right or Castaldo about the challenges and benefits of
wrong, and it depends on how you see, as introducing new supply chain products.
[foreign exchange management] is not under
my operation [at the central bank]", U Soe
Thein said. Can you describe the main areas of operation
for Seedstars in Myanmar?
We also note that the central bank has made
similar and even larger purchases in recent Seedstars has a wide range of investment and
years when the exchange rate has been capacity-building activities, all aiming to
volatile. impact lives in emerging markets through
technology and entrepreneurship. In
In early 2016, the regulator purchased over Myanmar, this will manifest mainly through
$40m in just five days to calm the market after ecosystem and capacity-building activities.
the kyat rallied strongly against the dollar.
In mid-February we will be opening a
"Profit is not the priority [for the central bank] coworking space as the launch of the Yangon
for spending money, but financial stability is. Innovation Center, in partnership with the
People should largely bear in mind that," U Yangon Region Government and CB Bank- right
Soe Thein said. across from the Stand Hotel and right on the
river, so a great view!
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 19 December 2018 12
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 19 December 2018 13
They can repay the facility after few weeks, But the cost is enormous. They are often afraid
after they have sold their inventory. To of formalising this debt in case it gets them
facilitate this we generally work with the into trouble, so this is the situation we’re
company in question, which we call an dealing with. We can definitely offer a better
“anchor”. service, but we need to win this general
distrust.
Is it relatively straightforward to bring this
concept into the Myanmar market? Do you need a certain level of sophistication
in the anchor company or the distributors ?
There is a lot of demand for this product. Most
of the companies we have spoken with are Although we do connect with distributors our
interested in the product and there is a huge main focus is on the anchor company, where
need. an higher level of sophistication is expected.
How easy it will be is a different question. It The beauty of our model is that we can help
will require education at various levels, at the the anchor increasing its sales, by providing
company level for the company to understand financing to its distributors, while at the same
how this product can be introduced into their time use its help to disseminate and receive
operations without impacting their day to day information. So there is some flexibility there.
activity.
The heavier technological components are
At the distributor level, we need to explain required at the anchor company. But if it’s a
how the product works, the advantages and medium sized company that has regular orders
how they can apply for it. it will have, in one form or another, a system
already in place.
What are the main challenges? For the distributors, we are developing tech
solutions that will allow them to request the
I think one challenge is the distrust towards financing product.
the formal financial sector.
How large is the merchant financing you
In Myanmar, there is a high level of provide?
informality. It’s not that there isn’t financing
for MSMEs, but it is all informal. In some We are targeting the MSME segment, although
conversations we’ve had, people begin by in Myanmar that is more than 90% of
saying that don’t want a loan or financing. companies. Within this segment, we are
aiming at small and very small companies, so
But as the conversation progresses, they anything larger than the microfinance sector.
disclose that they have five, 10 even 15 loans Regulation has capped microfinance loans at
from family and friends. Ks10m, so we will start at that number and
above.
The monthly interest rate ranges anywhere
from 3% to 10%. So they are heavily indebted To clarify, we are not a lending company. We
from informal sector. work as operators with a network of
companies that have lending licenses. Right
This informal sector is very convenient as it’s now we have a partnership with a non-bank
on their doorstep and has very low or non- financing institutions (NBFI).
existent requirements.
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 19 December 2018 14
Is there a time frame for rolling out the Myanmar's largest commercial bank is moving
system out? away from manual treasury processing
operations, and Fusion Treasury will enable
We are piloting merchSant financing now. We straight-through-processing (STP), the firm
started that in November in Yangon and said.
Mandalay. We pilot with different companies
and smooth the process out. "Finastra is helping us to overcome high
operational overheads associated with manual
A pilot takes three to four months depending processes, reduce time-to-market for new
on the length of financing we provide. It’s products and bring our operations and systems
mostly working capital so it’s meant to be in line with the standards of sophisticated
repaid and then retaken as a facility later on. developed markets," said KBZ managing
director Win Lwin.
If it’s longer term financing we need to wait
and see the effects. If you are financing fast
moving consumer goods that have a shelf life
of a few days then maybe the financing is only
for a few weeks. If the product has shelf life of
a two months then the pilot needs to cover
that.
In the future can the merchant and invoice This is the fifth software system deal in the
products get more complex? Myanmar banking sector announced this year.
There are two answers, one is that things Fusion Treasury is built to handle "all aspects
become more complex because you work with of a bank’s operations in treasury, capital
more sophisticated companies that have more markets, derivatives, and risk and compliance,"
sophisticated products. the press release said.
The other longer term plan is that we know Finastra's regional partner Big Byte
who these merchants are and we know their International helped arrange the deal, and that
purchasing and repayment capacities, so we firm's CEO Amit Johari noted that Myanmar is
feel more comfortable offering them other - a "key growth market" for Big Byte.
more complex - financing products.
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 19 December 2018 15
Yoma Bank, AYA Bank and First Private Bank In addition to traditional mobile money
have also signed partnerships with Finastra in services such as mobile top-up and money
the past. transfer, Ongo provides digital payment,
invoicing, and disbursement capabilities for
Click here to view a list of selected banking the fast moving consumer goods (FMCG) and
system transactions that have taken place in microfinance sectors.
recent years.
Ongo CEO Allen Gilstrap said, "FMCG
Digital Payment distributors like Coca-Cola use Ongo digital
Ongo partners with internet service provider cash collection services to digitize payments
from deliveries to their retailers and
Digital payment firm Ongo signed a wholesalers, which completely removes the
partnership agreement with 4G+ mobile need for cash collection".
broadband internet service provider Ananda
on 19 December. The firm also serves the microfinance and
consumer lending sector by providing digital
Ananda users will be able to add credit to their cash collection for loan disbursements and
accounts at Ongo agents as well as through repayments, said Allen.
Ongo and Ananda mobile applications. Ananda
products will also soon become available at Myanmar Financial Services Monitor notes
the Ongo agents. that in July, Ongo launched a digital payroll
service in partnership with Myanmar Oriental
Bank (MOB), which allows employers to pay
their employees into an MOB bank account
and withdraw their salary using an Ongo-MOB
MPU debit cards.
Banking
We note that Ananda formed a partnership Bank branch network round up, 18 December
with the leading mobile financial services
provider Wave Money in October for a top-up In recent weeks, four local banks, Myanmar
service. Ananda began providing broadband Citizens Bank (MCB), Global Treasure Bank
internet in Yangon in early 2018, and is (GTB), First Private Bank (FPB) and Ayeyarwady
planning to extend its network to Mandalay by Farmers Development Bank (A Bank), have
the end of this year, according a 19 December opened nine new branches, in addition to an
press release. SME center.
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 19 December 2018 16
The lender opened the last branch earlier this First Private Bank (FPB)
month, following four new branches in
November. The YSX-listed lender opened its 35th branch
in Ayeyarwady's Maubin township.
Myanmar Financial Services Monitor notes
that MCB has a target of 41 branches by the PFB said in August that it is planning to open
end of 2018, 61 by the close of 2019, and five new branches in Maubin, Myawady,
between 80 to 100 branches by 2020, Myaing, Mindat and Shwebo townships.
according to its "Vision 2020". The branches in Maubin, Myawady and
Myaing townships are already complete, the
one in Shwebo is under construction and
construction has not yet begun at the Mindat
branch.
A Bank
• 159th branch, Pala town, Tanintharyi Click here to view private bank rankings by
region branch network.
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 19 December 2018 17
"This is due in part to the.. Ministry of Labor, There have been several partnerships in the
Immigration and Population raising awareness Myanmar remittance market this year. AYA
for migrant workers and close supervision on Bank inked a strategic partnership agreement
the overseas employment agencies", said U with Singaporean lender DBS on 3 December,
Maung Maung Win. which will see the two banks collaborate on a
remittance service called "Ya Lah!"
MFSM notes that closer supervision of these
employment agencies could reduce their use The agreement allows customers to transfer
of informal hundi networks for remittances funds in their accounts in DBS Bank and POSB
Bank to AYA Bank and through that lender to
U Maung Maung Win said at a lower house any accounts at any local bank in Myanmar.
meeting on 17 December that between 2016 AYA Bank said that initially it will be the
and June 2018, some 1.4m workers sent a only settlement bank for DBS Remittance to
total of $1.4bn (over Ks2trn using current Myanmar.
exchange rates) home through state-owned
and private banks. Fintech firm Everex signed a remittance
partnership with Shwe Than Lwin Group's
Shwe Bank in May. Everex in a post on 30 July
said that it had signed an agreement to
provide a “blockchain-powered digital
remittance services between Myanmar and
Thailand”.
The bulk of this has been in the most recent MySQUAR partnered with Uber Remit and
fiscal year. U Maung Maung Win said that the Myanmar mobile money player OK Dollar to
ratio of migrant remittances to GDP was only implement a Singapore to Myanmar
0.81% in 2016-17 fiscal year, but had increased remittance service, which it soft launched in
to 1.06% in 2017-18. September.
Currently, there are 285 licensed overseas Funds from Uber Remit could be directly
employment agencies, and over 830,000 remitted to a few local banks, post office
workers were recorded to have left the branches, OK Dollar digital wallets and OK
country between 1990 and August 2018, of Dollar’s network of 8,000 agents across
which around 150,000 were recorded in 2018, Myanmar.
according to U Maung Maung Win.
MSQUAR announced it had temporarily closed
Although 19 destinations are approved for that business in December due to financial
migrant workers, they are currently working in problems that saw its shares removed from
only nine countries, including Malaysia, South the London Stock Exchange's AIM.
Korea, Singapore, Thailand, Japan, Macao,
UAE, Qatar and Jordan, mostly in Thailand,
Malaysia and South Korea, said U Maung
Maung Win.
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 19 December 2018 18
Banking U Min Htein said that the bank has made total
CHIDB expands construction loan portfolio, housing loans of Ks40bn ($25.3m) to about
reduces overdrafts 3,000 customers who have already deposited
[20% of unit price] in their saving accounts.
Construction and Housing Infrastructure
Development Bank's total commercial and The Myanmar Times said in May that CHIDB
housing loan portfolio has increased, while has over 30,000 registered housing saving
overdraft lending and hire purchase loans fell accounts, and that, nearly 84% of account
in the 2017-18 fiscal year, the bank's managing holders are actually saving money. This fits
director U Win Zaw said at the annual general with Min Htein's estimate of 25,000 savers.
meeting on 16 December, according to
a Business Television article. MFSM also notes that the lender reduced its
housing loan interest rate from 12% to 10.5%
The article said that CHIDB has made a total of that same month.
Ks121.4bn ($76.9m) construction loans, in
addition to Ks80.8bn ($51.2m) commercial Banking
loans and Ks24.6bn ($15.5m). Yoma's JZü accounts hit Ks18bn in five
months
However, it is unclear if the data is only for the
fiscal year ending 31 March 2018, or the Yoma Bank has seen total deposits of Ks18bn
calendar year to date. ($11.4m) through its JZü accounts over the
past five months said Murray MacDougall, the
Meanwhile, overdraft lending and hire lender's chief performance officer on 17
purchase loan portfolios fell. After the July December.
2017 prudential regulations, the central bank
requires private banks to reduce overdraft JZü is an interest bearing account categorised
loans down to 50% of its loan portfolio by 6 within the "call" family of accounts, but with a
July 2018, to 30% by 6 July 2019 and finally to sweepstake reward scheme. It was soft
20% by 6 July 2020. launched on 2 July.
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 19 December 2018 19
Yoma Bank selects the random winners by a Myanma Apex Bank (MAB) started paying
computer process every month, with a third- interest on in its MAB mobile bank app in early
party law firm hired to oversee the November 2018.
sweepstake. It promises a total monthly
reward of Ks30m at minimal. However, MAB's rate is only 2% per year,
which is equivalent to the standard call deposit
JZü accounts, however, requires a minimum rate used by most local banks.
balance of Ks200,000 in order for savers to be
eligible for the sweepstake. Those that fall
below the sweepstake limit are only eligible
for the 3% interest.
Mobile Money
CB Pay offers interest on mobile wallet
accounts
CB Bank is now offering customers interest on At present, around ten banks have digital
their accounts held on the lender's mobile banking platforms, though only KBZ, CB, MAB
wallet app CB Pay, the bank announced on 12 and AGD have wallet-based apps.
December.
KBZ Pay, CB Pay and MAB mobile bank all offer
The lender introduced CB Pay for customers similar functions and are available to
without CB Bank accounts in July 2018, customers without an existing deposit account
enabling them to register for an account with at those lenders. AGD Pay, however, is not yet
just a mobile number. available for customers who do not have
either an AGD bank accounts or credit card.
A CB Bank official told Myanmar Financial
Services Monitor that the interest rate on the Project Financing
CB Pay accounts is 8.25%, which is the same as Project bank offers hope for infrastructure
CB Bank's traditional saving rate. finance
Interest will be calculated and paid into The government is creating a project
customers' CB Pay accounts through the same information bank that could help it create a
process as CB Bank uses with traditional proper framework for public private
deposit accounts. partnerships (PPP) and pave the way for
improved project financing.
Local banks usually calculate saving interest
based on the lowest month balance, and pay The President’s Office published a Project Bank
interest into the accounts quarterly. notification on 30 November that defined the
project bank as “an interactive, web-based,
MFSM notes that CB Bank is not the first publicly accessible database or project
lender to attract mobile customers with information bank”.
interest rates .
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 19 December 2018 20
This project information bank will include Various issues including the need for “proper
projects that government agencies are assessment, competitive bidding and getting
planning as part of the Myanmar Sustainable the best for the government” should be taken
Development Plan (MSDP), according to the into account before embarking on PPP
notification. projects, Peiris added.
U Soe Win, Minister of Planning and Finance, “If anything there are probably too many
said in October that the project bank was unsolicited projects floating around," he said.
being created with the aim of raising capital
for infrastructure. The President’s Office notification also lays out
plans for a dedicated PPP centre within the
finance ministry to develop, implement and
monitor PPPs.
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 19 December 2018 21
Peiris, however, pointed out that the “banking Starting this winter, MADB has doubled loan
sector is going through a tough time and it’s sizes for non-rice growers to Ks100,000 per
not clear at all they should be doing project acre, though sizes for rice farmers remains
bonds or lending to long term projects”. unchanged at Ks15,000 per acre.
Myanmar’s commercial banks are in the MADB provides three seasonal loans a year -
process of restructuring non-performing winter, pre-monsoon and monsoon.
overdraft debt into term loans and raising
fresh capital in response to prudential The bank began issuing individual loans to
regulations introduced in 2017. farmers in the previous monsoon season, a
switch from its previous policy of using a joint
Banking liability approach.
MADB approves Ks169bn winter loans for
Ayeyarwady Under the new system, borrowers must
submit their original Form-7, a working permit
Myanma Agricultural Development Bank for farmland.
(MAD) has approved a total of Ks169.09bn
($107.1m) winter loans to be made to farmers The timeline for loans are as follows:
across Ayeyarwady Region, according to Daily
Eleven. • Winter loans – from 26 October to 31
December
The lender has only issued around 33% of its
proposed total loans so far. MADB has had to • Pre-monsoon loans – 1 January 2019 to 31
extend the disbursement deadline until the March 2019
end of January 2019, due to late loan
proposals being submitted. • Monsoon loans – 2 May 2019 to 30
September 2019
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 19 December 2018 22
Below is a list of selected banking system transactions that have taken place in recent years:
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 19 December 2018 23
Myawaddy
Bank - 8.25% 8.5% 8.75% 9% 9.5% 10%
(Personal)
Myawaddy
Bank - - - - 8% 8.5% 9%
(Corporate)
Yangon City
- 9.25% 9.5% 9.75% 10% - -
Bank
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 19 December 2018 24
1 Innwa 9%
2 A Bank 8.7%
3 AGD 8.6%
4 SMIDB 8.5%
8 TCB 8.5%
8.25% - 8.45%
9 GTB
(dependent on amount)
10 MD Bank 8.5%
11 MAB 8.25%
12 CHIDB 8.25%
13 Yoma 8.25%
14 MCB 8.25%
15 CB 8.25%
16 MMB 8.25%
17 UAB 8.25%
18 MOB 8.25%
19 G Bank 8.25%
8% (Corporate)
20 Myawaddy
8.25% (Individual)
21 AYA Bank 8%
22 KBZ 8%
23 FPB 8%
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 19 December 2018 25
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 19 December 2018 26
1 Myanma Insurance 39
2 IKBZ 19
3 GGI 19
4 FNI 11
5 AMI 10
6 Capital Life 6
7 Global World 5
8 Aung Thitsa Oo 3
10 EFI 1
12 CB Insurance 1
Total 117
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 19 December 2018 27
Sale price
Date Investment Investors Sector
($m)
January 2014 Asia Beverages Group Yoma Strategic Holdings, Delta Capital 18.4 Alcohol
April 2017 Ruby Hill Microfinance Dragon Capital, Loi Hein Group N/A Financial services
Myanmar Supply
October 2017 Chain and Services and ThaiBev 742 Alcohol
Myanmar Distillery
Digital Classifieds
January 2018 Belt Road Capital Management 1.9 Technology
Group
March 2018 Easy Microfinance Delta Capital 7 Financial services
Belt Road Capital Management, IFC,
April 2018 Oway 14.7 Tech / transport
Daiwa PI Partners
May 2018 Yoma Micro Power IFC, Government of Canada, Norfund 28 Energy
Marathon Myanmar
September 2018 Seed Myanmar Ventures 0.1+ Logistics
Company
Pyramid Solutions
September 2018 N/A N/A Listings/Media
(MyJobs)
September 2018 FMR Research Trust Venture Partners (TVP) N/A Research Firm
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 19 December 2018 28
COMPANY UPDATES
A selection of recently-updated profiles from the Myanmar Financial Services Monitor.
Access is available to Premium Subscribers only.
DATA UPDATES
12-Nov
13-Nov
14-Nov
15-Nov
16-Nov
19-Nov
20-Nov
23-Nov
26-Nov
27-Nov
28-Nov
29-Nov
30-Nov
10-Dec
11-Dec
12-Dec
13-Dec
14-Dec
17-Dec
18-Dec
19-Dec
1-Nov
2-Nov
5-Nov
6-Nov
8-Nov
9-Nov
(19 December 2018) Yangon Stock Exchange (YSX) Quote (Myanmar Kyat)
1Y 1Y Yield Net
Stock Code Vol High Low Close
High Low Div % P/E Chg
13,000 10,000 FMI 00001 100 0.9 14 4,716 10,500 10,000 10,500 +500
3,150 2,750 MTSH 00002 230 7.6 9.6 8,789 3,000 3,000 3,000 -50
8,800 7,000 MCB 00003 200 2.7 23.9 400 7,300 7,300 7,300 0
27,000 22,000 FPB 00004 2,000 8.6 9.1 37 23,500 23,000 23,000 -500
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 19 December 2018 29
About Us
May Lynn
may.lynn@frontiermyanmar.com
+95 9965015389
London address (Frontier MEA Ltd) Includes Weekly Brief PDF, plus full access to
online News, Company Profiles and Data
International House
24 Holborn Viaduct One year rate: $3,700
London
EC1A 2BN Rates are subject to 5% Myanmar sales tax
United Kingdom where applicable.
www.frontiermea.com
For full subscription options and pricing, please
visit our Subscribe page
finance.frontiermyanmar.com