Action Research in Reading
Action Research in Reading
Action Research in Reading
An Action Research
Conducted By:
TABLE OF CONTENTS
I. Abstract 3-31
II. Introduction 32-35
III. Research Problem 36
IV. Objectives of the Study 36-37
V. Scope and Delimitation 38
VI. Methodology 39-42
VII. Findings 43-63
VIII. Solution 64-84
IX. Plan of Actions 85-92
X. Conclusion 93-118
XI. Bibliography 119
XII. Appendix A Questionnaire 120-124
XIII. Appendix B Letter to the Principal 125
2
I. ABSTRACT
Teaching reading comprehension to non-readers and frustration level readers today is different
from the past. Teachers need to focus on extensive comprehension instruction with all students, not just
successful readers.
This action research investigated sixty three grade one pupils of the two classes of grade one.
They have undergone reading assessment test to know their level of reading performance.
This action research discusses the causes and reasons of reading difficulties of non-readers and
frustration level readers. It also presents multiple strategies that have proved to be successful in a first
grade classroom, as well as strategies used and found to be successful by other teachers and
researchers. As new best practices in reading instruction are developed and researched, teaching
strategies need to evolve as well.
RESEARCH PROBLEM
This study aims to make an action plan for the poor reading difficulties of grade one
pupils in Macatoc Elementary School.
2. Why pupils in grade one were at the non-reader and frustration level?
3. How pupils in grade one will be helped by the teacher to address difficulty in learning to read?
Research Design
Descriptive research involves description, recoding, analysis and interpretation of conditions that
currently exist. The main aims are to describe the nature of a condition as it exists at the time of the study
and to explore the causes of the particular situation.
This action research utilized triangulation method as a data gathering procedure through survey
questionnaire, observation, interview and field notes.
3
This study involved sixty three (63) grade one pupils of Macatoc Elementary School. The
respondents attended kindergarten class during the previous school year and had undergone the Early
Childhood Education Curriculum Program (ECECP).
Conclusion
The youngest age of the respondents was 5 and the eldest was 10. The mean age of the
respondents was 6.37. This implies that majority of the parents of the grade one pupils of entered
their child in the school at an early age.
The result reveals that 54.59% of the respondents were male 45.61% were female. It can
be gleaned that male outnumbered the female probably because much number of the enrolees
for S.Y. 2016-2017 were male. This may be because the large number of birth rate from 2004 up
to present was boys.
Majority of the respondents’ nutritional status were beyond the normal status. Probably
the reason was that most of the pupil respondents’ weight and height corresponds normally with
their age and they were healthy enough in entering school.
Majority of the respondents belonged to poor families of Barangay Macatoc with monthly
income that ranged below 8,000 which means that most of parents can’t provide all the necessary
basic needs of their children.
Respondents have difficulty in reading and learning how to read in terms of Phonological and
Phonemic Awareness. Their own perspective was supported by teacher’s perspective. This implies
that the respondents have difficulty in rhyming words, recognizing and producing sounds and
syllabication.
Word decoding and phonics was one of the reasons for reading difficulty experience by the
respondents based on the pupil’s perspective and teacher’s perspective. This implies that the
respondents have difficulty in applying his/her knowledge of letter-sound relationships, including
knowledge of letter patterns, to correctly pronounce written words. This also mean that the
respondents have difficulty in letter-sound relationships, and how to sound out words.
Other sources of reading disability particularly auditory processing, memory and attention
were some of the problems why respondents have a hard time to learn how to read based on the
pupil’s perspective. The same is true with that of the teacher’s perspective. Problems related to
auditory processing implies that there is something in pupil respondents that is affecting the
processing or interpretation of the information a child hears. They often find it difficult to pay attention,
listen to, and remember information presented orally. They may need more time to process
information. This also mean that they often do not recognize subtle differences between sounds in
words, even though the sounds themselves are loud and clear.
Reading difficulty related to memory implies that pupil respondents find it hard to place
information into their memories and retrieve it when needed. Difficulty related to attention implies that
the respondents is often failing to give close attention to details, often does not seem to listen when
5
spoken to directly, often has difficulty organizing tasks and activities, and is often easily distracted by
extraneous stimuli.
4 SOLUTIONS
The following are the solutions to reading difficulties that the pupil respondents experience in
reading.
STAR Collection
As an intervention program, a child will bring home a copy of a reading selection/story to read
at home. His parents will rate his/her ability to read by putting a Star on the copy of his/her selection.
The teacher will validate the rate of his patents by putting another Star on the copy, thus a child will
be earning Stars depending on his/her reading skill. Reading materials will vary according to different
types of readers (non-readers, frustration level, instructional and independent level).
Reading Buddy
A poor reader will be partnered to a good reader who will serve as his/her reading buddy
every lunch break after meal.
Teacher Nanay
The school will ask help or assistance of some volunteer parents who are knowledgeable
enough and willing to serve as reading teacher of poor readers during specified time either in school
or at home.
APAD
Pupils will be asked to read aloud a short paragraph every day before classes start in order to
develop their oral reading skills.
Word Wall
List of words will be posted on one side of the wall inside the classroom for the pupils to read
and master.
II. INTRODUCTION
Proficient reading and writing skills are critical to success. If students are not competent
readers, they are at risk for academic, behavioral, social and emotional difficulties. Students with
reading disabilities have the potential to be unsuccessful academically and socially. (MacInnis,
2004). Children with reading difficulties throughout school and into adulthood, said how
embarrassing and devastating it was to read with difficulty in front of peers and teachers, and to
demonstrate this weakness on a daily basis. It is clear that this type of failure affects children
negatively earlier than we thought. By the end of first grade, children having difficulty learning to
read begin to feel less positive about their abilities than when they started school (Reid Lyon,
2003).
Reading had been a long-lasting and widespread problem among pupils in the primary
level. One of the challenges facing teachers is how to motivate the pupils to read. The
implementation of the K to 12 curriculum also swell with the problem in reading of grade one
pupils. During the first year of its implementation, grade one pupils who cannot read can be
promoted to the second grade. The second grade teachers experience difficulty in teaching due
to poor reading ability of the pupils. This year the product of such curriculum were in grade three
who will also take the National Achievement Exam. The question is with the poor reading ability of
the pupil, will they pass the NAT exam.
Most pupils in grade one experience difficulty in learning how to read. They have difficulty
in learning phonetics, syllables and words. Some of them are scared to attend classes when
reading lessons started. Due to this situation, some of them drop out from school and do not
continue until the next school year begins.
The Department of Education from the national level down to the school level launched
different programs to solve the problem in reading. One of such is the Project READ (Reading
Empowerment for Academic Development) of the Division of Oriental Mindoro and Project Reach
for the STAR (Strive Toward Achievement in Reading) of the District of Victoria on the same
Division. Project READ is a five year program aimed to reduce the frustration readers by 20%
every school year starting S.Y. 2014-2015 to 2018-2019 (D.O. No. 16, S. 2014). Project Reach for
the STAR is designed to address the problem of non-readers and readers under frustration level
in the whole district. It aims to improve reading fluency, reading skills and comprehension skills of
the pupils both in English and Filipino. Currently, it has been implementing and all hoped that the
objectives will be achieved after its implementation and will solve the problems in reading.
7
This study aims to make an action plan for the poor reading difficulties of grade one
pupils in Macatoc Elementary School.
6. Why pupils in grade one were at the non-reader and frustration level?
7. How pupils in grade one will be helped by the teacher to address difficulty in learning to read?
The teachers will also be benefited from this action research for they will learn how to
address the difficulty of grade one pupils to learn how to read. They will also learn the strategies on
how reading comprehension of pupils will be improved. As the pupils’ reading performance elevated
from non-reader and frustration level to instructional and independent level, the teacher will also
improve his/her performance on her Performance Appraisal System for Teachers (PAST) and in the
Individual Performance Commitment and Review Form (IPCRF) under the Result-Based
Performance Management System (RPMS).
The school will also be aided from this action research because the pupils’ performance and
teachers’ performance reflects the school performance. When pupils improve their academic
performance it will reflect on their performance on the National Achievement Test (NAT) as one of the
criteria in the Performance Based Bonus (PBB). Dropout rates will be lessen when pupils’
performance in reading and in all subjects is in average to proficient level.
The respondents of this action research were the pupils from two sections of grade one of the
school during the school year 2016-2017.
This action research will be limited to grade one pupils only and is not conducted to other
pupils of the school.
8
VI. METHODOLOGY
Research Design
Descriptive research involves description, recoding, analysis and interpretation of conditions that
currently exist. The main aims are to describe the nature of a condition as it exists at the time of the study
and to explore the causes of the particular situation.
This action research utilized triangulation method as a data gathering procedure through survey
questionnaire, observation, interview and field notes.
This study involved sixty three (63) grade one pupils of Macatoc Elementary School. The
respondents attended kindergarten class during the previous school year and had undergone the Early
Childhood Education Curriculum Program (ECECP).
The distribution of the grade one pupils which was composed of the respondents of this study
was shown in the table.
Research Locale
This study will be conducted in Macatoc Elementary School. The school is on the District of
Victoria, Division of Oriental Mindoro, Region IV-B MIMAROPA. It is located at Macatoc, Victoria, oriental
Mindoro.
Macatoc Elementary School is headed by one Elementary Grade Principal I and is composed of
one Elementary Grade Master Teacher II, five Elementary Grade Teacher III, three Elementary Grade
Teacher II, six Elementary Grade Teacher, and one Kindergarten Volunteer Teacher, sixteen (16) in all.
The pupil population is five hundred ninety four (594) during the current school year. Each of the grade
levels starting from kindergarten to grade six had two sections except grade two which has three sections.
Research Instrument
A self-prepared questionnaire with four major parts will serve as the data gathering instrument in
this action research.
9
Part I will deal with the profile of the respondents. Part II will deal on items that will measure the
level of reading performance of the respondents. Part III will deal with the difficulties the pupil respondents
have in learning how to read. Part IV will deal on items that exhibits the reasons why the pupil
respondents were on non-reader and frustration level.
A letter of request was secured for from the School Principal with the endorsement of the Master
Teacher. Upon its approval, proper coordination with the class advisers and parents of the pupil
respondents was done by the researcher.
The researcher personally administered the questionnaire to ensure that all items will be
answered and 100% percent retrieval will be attained. The interview, observation and field notes was also
personally done by the researcher.
Descriptive statistics such as mean and rank will be used in the study in treating the data
gathered.
Mean
Formula:
X=
n
Where: X = mean
N
∑X = total score
n = number of respondents
VII. FINDINGS
1. Profile of the Pupil Respondents
The graph presents the profile of the respondents in terms of age. It can be gleaned that 72.63%
of the respondents belonged to 5 to 6 years old. This was followed by 7 to 8 years old which consisted
24.21%. Respondents who were 9 to 10 years old represented 3.16% of the total sample.
According to the graph, the youngest age of the respondents was 5 and the eldest was 10.
The graph also shows that the mean age of the respondents was 6.37. This implies that majority of
the parents of the grade one pupils of entered their child in the school at an early age.
10
Percentage
80
70
60
Percentage
50
40
30
20
10
0
9 to 10 7 to 8 5 to 6
Mean: 6.37
The graph 1.2 reveals that 54.59% of the respondents were male 45.61% were female. It
can be gleaned that male outnumbered the female probably because much number of the
enrolees for S.Y. 2016-2017 were male. This may be because the large number of birth rate from
2004 up to present was boys.
According to the National Statistics Office (2015), the Philippine’s birth rate was 24.98
births/1,000 population. From the rate, 15.56 live births were male while 9.42 were female.
Percentage
56
54
52 Percentage
50
48
46
44
42
40
Male Female
11
As shown on graph 1.3, majority of the respondents’ nutritional status were beyond the
normal status which consisted 65.61% and was the highest. Probably the reason was that most
of the pupil respondents’ weight and height corresponds normally with their age and they were
healthy enough in entering school.
Nearly one percent or 0.70% belonged to the overweight status which was the lowest.
This may be respondents who belong to the families that have the highest monthly income.
According to the World Health Organization (2015) on their Body Mass Index Manual,
nutritional status refers to the Body Mass Index (BMI) of a child. MI is based on the measurement
of the height and weight. It indicates whether or not the weight is within a healthy range for the
height. It has the following categories, severely wasted, wasted, normal, overweight and obese.
Severely wasted is a status which means that a child aged 5 to 9 got a body mass index of less
than 12.0. Wasted body mass index ranges from 12.1 to 12.9, normal body mass index is from
13.0 to 18.3, overweight body mass index ranges from 18.4 to 20.2 and obese body mass index
is from 20.3 and above.
Percentage
70
60
50 Percentage
40
30
20
10
0
Severely Wasted Wasted Normal Overweight
Presented on Graph 1.4 was the monthly income of the respondents’ parents. Almost
forty-five percent or 44.91% of the respondents belonged to a family with 4,0001 to 6,000 monthly
income which was the strongest. The weakest was the 1.75% respondents with monthly income
of below 2,000. As seen on the graph the mean monthly income of the respondents was
4,970.02.
It can be gleaned that majority of the respondents belonged to poor families of Barangay
Macatoc with monthly income that ranged below 8,000 which means that most of parents can’t
provide all the necessary basic needs of their children.
According to the data from the National Statistical Coordination Board (2015), poverty
remains the most critical social problem that needs to be addressed. Philippines' poverty line
marks individuals earning less than 16,841 Peso a year. They added that more than one-quarter
(26.5%) of the population falls below the poverty line in 2009.This figure is a much lower figure as
compared to the 33.1% in 1991. The decline has been slow and uneven, much slower than
neighboring countries who experienced broadly similar numbers in the 1980s, such as People's
Republic of China (PRC), Thailand, Indonesia (which poverty level lies at 8.5%) or Vietnam
(13.5%). This shows that the incidence of poverty has remained significantly high as compared to
other countries for almost three decades now. The unevenness of the decline has been attributed
12
to a large range of income brackets across regions and sectors, and also unmanaged population
growth.
Ramey and Ramey (2015) describe the relationship of family socioeconomic status to
children performance at school. They stressed that across all socioeconomic groups, parents
face major challenges when it comes to providing best care and education for their children. For
families in poverty, these challenges can be alarming. Sometimes, when basic necessities are
lacking, parents must place top priority on housing, food, clothing, and health care. Educational
toys, games, and books may appear to be luxuries, and parents may not have the time, energy,
or knowledge to find innovative and less-expensive ways to foster young children's development.
Percentage
50
45
40
35
30
25
20 Percentage
15
10
5
0
ve 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
bo ,0 ,0
0 ,0 ,0 00
a 10 –6 –4 2,
– – –8 w
1 1 1 1 lo
00 00
1
00 00 00 Be
1 0, 8, 6, 4, 2,
Mean: 4,920.02
Of the 63 respondents, 35.09% of their mothers were high school graduates which ranks
first while 0.70% of the respondents’ mothers attained a post baccalaureate degree which ranks
the last.
From the graph, it can be gleaned that majority of the respondents’ mothers did not finish
a college degree probably because most of them belonged to a poor family and their parents
cannot send and support them for college education.
Percentage
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0 Percentage
The graph exhibits the respondents’ father’s educational attainment. Majority of the
respondents’ fathers were high school graduates which consisted 79 or 27.72% which was the
highest. Three or 1.05% of the respondents’ fathers attained a post baccalaureate degree which
was the lowest. It can be noted that majority of the fathers of the respondents did not finish a
college education maybe because most of them belonged to a poor family and their parents
cannot support their for college education.
Feranil et. al. (2015) in their study about childcare and school performance found out that
parental care for their children is also an important contributing factor to the academic
performance and development of a child in school. In terms of time allocation, more mothers,
being the primary caregiver of these children, spent time with their children in the different
activities compared to the fathers. The study suggested fathers to spend more time for their
children in playing because it is found to be of significant. The authors further recommended that
parents should promote the attendance of their children in pre-school programs and extend
possible help for them to be physically, intellectually, socially and emotionally ready to attend
formal schooling.
Percentage
30
25
20
15
10 Percentage
5
0
ree te ate ate ate ate ate ate ate e
eg ua du du du du du du du No
n
D rad ra ra ra ra ra ra ra
te G rg G rg G rg G rg
rea ge de al de ol de ry de
lau o lle Un ton Un c ho Un enta Un
a C e a l s l y
cc lle
g oc on
a
gh
o m tar
Ba l/V ho Ele en
st Co ica cat Hi Sc m
Po n o gh le
ch l/V Hi E
Te ica
c hn
Te
This implies that almost all of the respondents were having problems in reading or
experiencing difficulty in learning to read.
Proficient reading and writing skills are critical to success. If students are not competent
readers, they are at risk for academic, behavioral, social and emotional difficulties. Students with
reading disabilities have the potential to be unsuccessful academically and socially. (MacInnis,
2004).
Table 3.1 shows the reasons why respondents have difficulty in reading and learning how to
read in terms of Phonological and Phonemic Awareness. As shown on the table from the pupil’s
perspective, sixty or 95.25% of the pupil respondents have experience difficulty in reading because
they have poor phonological awareness. The teacher’s perspective of the respondents’ reading
difficulty related to phonological and phonemic awareness was closely related to that of the pupil’s
perspective which got the same mean percentage as shown on table 3.1.2.
This implies that the respondents have difficulty in rhyming words, recognizing and producing
sounds and syllabication.
15
Table 3.1.1 Reason for Reading Difficulty in Terms of Phonological and Phonemic
Awareness as Pupil’s Perspective
Reading Difficulty Frequency Percentage
Pupil’s Perspective
I. Phonological and Phonemic Awareness 60 95.24%
1. I don't know any words that rhyme with cat. 60 95.24%
2. What do you mean when you say, "What sounds are in the word 60 95.24%
brush?"
3. I'm not sure how many syllables are in my name. 60 95.24%
4. I don't know what sounds are the same in bit and hit. 60 95.24%
Table 3.1.2 Reason for Reading Difficulty in Terms of Phonological and Phonemic
Awareness as Teacher’s Perspective
Reading Difficulty Frequency Percentage
Teacher’s Perspective
I. Phonological and Phonemic Awareness 60 95.24%
5 She doesn't correctly complete blending activities; for example, put 60 95.24%
together sounds /k/ /i/ /ck/ to make the word kick.
6 He doesn't correctly complete phoneme substitution activities; for 60 95.24%
example, change the /m/ in mate to /cr/ in order to make crate
7 He has a hard time telling how many syllables there are in the word 61 95.24%
paper.
8 He has difficulty with rhyming, syllabication, or spelling a new word 60 95.24%
by its sound.
As shown on the table 3.2.1, reading difficulty in terms of word decoding and phonics as one of
the reasons for reading difficulty experience by the respondents got the mean percentage of 90.47%
based on the pupil’s perspective. The same was true with the teacher’s perspective which got a mean
percentage of 92.06% as presented on table 3.2.2.
This implies that the respondents have difficulty in applying his/her knowledge of letter-sound
relationships, including knowledge of letter patterns, to correctly pronounce written words. This also mean
that the respondents have difficulty in letter-sound relationships, and how to sound out words.
Table 3.2.1 Reason for Reading Difficulty in Terms of Word Decoding and Phonics as
Pupil’s Perspective
Table 3.2.2 Reason for Reading Difficulty in Terms of Word Decoding and Phonics as
Teacher’s Perspective
As presented on the table 3.3.1, reading difficulty in terms of vocabulary is one of the reasons for
reading difficulty experience by the respondents which got the mean percentage of 88.89% from the
pupil’s perspective. This result was supported by the teacher’s perspective who got the same mean
percentage.
This denotes that the respondents have difficulty in understanding words to communicate
effectively. This implies that the pupils had a hard time to find the words that they need to know to
understand what they read. This also implies that a reader cannot understand a text without knowing what
most of the words mean.
Table 3.3.1 Reason for Reading Difficulty in Terms of Vocabulary Pupil’s Perspective
This implies that pupil respondents have difficulty to read with speed, accuracy, and proper
expression. They were not confident in reading aloud or silently do not read smoothly and has no
proper expression.
Table 3.4.1 Reason for Reading Difficulty in Terms of Fluency Pupil’s Perspective
Table 3.4.2 Reason for Reading Difficulty in Terms of Fluency Teacher’s Perspective
Table 3.5.1 shows that comprehension is one of the major reasons for reading difficulties the
respondents experience in learning how to read. As shown on the table, the reading difficulty in terms
of comprehension is the problem of the sixty two respondents or a mean percentage of 98.41%. This
result was supported by the teacher’s perspective who got an almost the same mean percentage of
96.83% as presented on table 3.5.2.
18
This implies that pupil respondents have difficulty in understanding and interpretation of what
is read. They find it hard to decode what they read, had a hard time to make connections between
what they read and what they already know, and have difficulty to think deeply about what they have
read. This also mean that they do not have a sufficient vocabulary, or their knowing of the meanings
of words is not enough.
Table 3.5.1 Reason for Reading Difficulty in Terms of Comprehension Pupil’s Perspective
Table 3.6.1 presents that other sources of reading disability particularly auditory processing,
memory and attention were some of the problems why respondents have a hard time to learn how to
read. As presented on the table, the reading difficulty in terms of processing speed is the reason of
the fifty eight respondents or a mean percentage of 0.04% based on the pupil’s perspective. The
same is true with that of the teacher’s perspective which got the same mean percentage as shown on
table 3.6.2.
Problems related to auditory processing implies that there is something in pupil respondents
that is affecting the processing or interpretation of the information a child hears. They often find it
difficult to pay attention, listen to, and remember information presented orally. They may need more
time to process information. This also mean that they often do not recognize subtle differences
between sounds in words, even though the sounds themselves are loud and clear.
Reading difficulty related to memory implies that pupil respondents find it hard to place
information into their memories and retrieve it when needed. Difficulty related to attention implies that
the respondents is often failing to give close attention to details, often does not seem to listen when
spoken to directly, often has difficulty organizing tasks and activities, and is often easily distracted by
extraneous stimuli.
VIII. SOLUTIONS
The following are the solutions to reading difficulties that the pupil respondents experience in
reading.
With the help of parents and teachers, kids can learn strategies to cope with phonological and/or
phonemic awareness problems that affect his or her reading. Below are some tips and specific things to
do.
3. Vocabulary
With the help of parents and teachers, kids can overcome vocabulary limitations that affect
their reading. Below are some tips and specific things to do.
Practice telling stories using the words first, then, and finally.
4. Fluency
With the help of parents and teachers, kids can learn strategies to cope with fluency
issues that affect his or her reading. Below are some tips and specific things to do.
Read aloud to your child to provide an example of how fluent reading sounds.
Give your child books with predictable vocabulary and clear rhythmic patterns so the child can
"hear" the sound of fluent reading as he or she reads the book aloud.
Use books on tapes; have the child follow along in the print copy.
5. Comprehension
With the help of parents and teachers, kids can learn strategies to cope with
comprehension problems that affect his or her reading. Below are some tips and specific things to
do.
Teach students the structure of different types of reading material. For instance, narrative texts
usually have a problem, a highpoint of action, and a resolution to the problem. Informational texts
may describe, compare and contrast, or present a sequence of events.
Discuss the meaning of words as you go through the text. Target a few words for deeper
teaching, really probing what those words mean and how they can be used.
Teach note-taking skills and summarizing strategies.
Use graphic organizers that help students break information down and keep track of what they
read.
Encourage students to use and revisit targeted vocabulary words.
Teach students to monitor their own understanding. Show them how, for example, to ask
themselves "What's unclear here?" or "What information am I missing?" and "What else should
the author be telling me?".
Teach children how to make predictions and how to summarize.
be earning Stars depending on his/her reading skill. Reading materials will vary according to different
types of readers (non-readers, frustration level, instructional and independent level).
7.8 APAD
Pupils will be asked to read aloud a short paragraph every day before classes start in order to
develop their oral reading skills.
The table shows the action plan for eliminating reading difficulties and improving the non-reader
and frustration level to instructional and independent level.
Conclusion
27
The youngest age of the respondents was 5 and the eldest was 10. The mean age of the
respondents was 6.37. This implies that majority of the parents of the grade one pupils of entered
their child in the school at an early age.
The result reveals that 54.59% of the respondents were male 45.61% were female. It can
be gleaned that male outnumbered the female probably because much number of the enrolees
for S.Y. 2016-2017 were male. This may be because the large number of birth rate from 2004 up
to present was boys.
Majority of the respondents’ nutritional status were beyond the normal status. Probably
the reason was that most of the pupil respondents’ weight and height corresponds normally with
their age and they were healthy enough in entering school.
Majority of the respondents belonged to poor families of Barangay Macatoc with monthly
income that ranged below 8,000 which means that most of parents can’t provide all the necessary
basic needs of their children.
Majority of the respondents’ mothers did not finish a college degree probably because
most of them belonged to a poor family and their parents cannot send and support them for
college education.
Majority of the respondents’ fathers were high school graduates and majority of them did
not finish a college education because most of them belonged to a poor family and their parents
cannot support their for college education.
Specifically out of all grade one pupils, majority of the respondents were on the non-
reader level and frustration level.This implies that almost all of the respondents were having
problems in reading or experiencing difficulty in learning to read.
Respondents have difficulty in reading and learning how to read in terms of Phonological and
Phonemic Awareness. Their own perspective was supported by teacher’s perspective. This implies
that the respondents have difficulty in rhyming words, recognizing and producing sounds and
syllabication.
28
Word decoding and phonics was one of the reasons for reading difficulty experience by the
respondents based on the pupil’s perspective and teacher’s perspective. This implies that the
respondents have difficulty in applying his/her knowledge of letter-sound relationships, including
knowledge of letter patterns, to correctly pronounce written words. This also mean that the
respondents have difficulty in letter-sound relationships, and how to sound out words.
Comprehension is one of the major reasons for reading difficulties the respondents
experience in learning how to read. This result from the pupil’s perspective was supported by the
teacher’s perspective. This implies that pupil respondents have difficulty in understanding and
interpretation of what is read. They find it hard to decode what they read, had a hard time to make
connections between what they read and what they already know, and have difficulty to think deeply
about what they have read. This also mean that they do not have a sufficient vocabulary, or their
knowing of the meanings of words is not enough.
Other sources of reading disability particularly auditory processing, memory and attention were
some of the problems why respondents have a hard time to learn how to read based on the pupil’s
perspective. The same is true with that of the teacher’s perspective. Problems related to auditory
processing implies that there is something in pupil respondents that is affecting the processing or
interpretation of the information a child hears. They often find it difficult to pay attention, listen to, and
remember information presented orally. They may need more time to process information. This also
mean that they often do not recognize subtle differences between sounds in words, even though the
sounds themselves are loud and clear.
Reading difficulty related to memory implies that pupil respondents find it hard to place
information into their memories and retrieve it when needed. Difficulty related to attention implies that
the respondents is often failing to give close attention to details, often does not seem to listen when
spoken to directly, often has difficulty organizing tasks and activities, and is often easily distracted by
extraneous stimuli.
16 SOLUTIONS
The following are the solutions to reading difficulties that the pupil respondents experience in
reading.
29
Look at written materials around your house and at road signs to see if you can spot familiar
words and letter patterns.
Write notes, e-mails, and letters to your friends and family. Represent each sound you hear as
you write.
When you're trying to sound out a word, pay close attention to the print. Try to look at all the
letters in the word, not just the first one or two.
16.3 Vocabulary
4.3.1 What pupils can do to help themselves
Find books to read on your own. The more you read, the more new words you'll see, and the
more you'll learn about the words.
Look ahead in textbooks to learn new vocabulary and concepts before your teacher goes over the
section in class.
Keep a list of key vocabulary and transition words.
Practice telling stories using the words first, then, and finally.
Help build your child's understanding of language by playing verbal games and telling jokes and
stories.
Encourage your child to read on his own. The more children read, the more words they encounter
and learn.
16.4 Fluency
4.4.1 What pupils can do to help themselves
Track the words with your finger as a parent or teacher reads a passage aloud. Then you read it.
Have a parent or teacher read aloud to you. Then, match your voice to theirs.
Read your favorite books and poems over and over again. Practice getting smoother and reading
with expression.
Ask the student to match his or her voice to yours when reading aloud or to a tape recorded
reading.
Read a short passage and then have the student immediately read it back to you.
Have the student practice reading a passage with a certain emotion, such as sadness or
excitement, to emphasize expression and intonation.
Incorporate timed repeated readings into your instructional repertoire.
Plan lessons that explicitly teach students how to pay attention to clues in the text (for example,
punctuation marks) that provide information about how that text should be read.
16.5 Comprehension
4.5.1 What pupils can do to help themselves
Use outlines, maps, and notes when you read.
Make flash cards of key terms you might want to remember.
Read stories or passages in short sections and make sure you know what happened before you
continue reading.
Ask yourself, "Does this make sense?" If it doesn't, reread the part that didn't make sense.
Read with a buddy. Stop every page or so and take turns summarizing what you've read.
Ask a parent or teacher to preview a book with you before you read it on your own.
As you read, try to form mental pictures or images that match the story.
Effective and efficient memory is critical for reading and school success. The following ten
general strategies are offered to help students develop a more efficient and effective memory.
4.6.3. Teach students to use visual images and other memory strategies
Another memory strategy that makes use of a cue is one called word substitution. The
substitute word system can be used for information that is hard to visualize, for example, for the word
occipital or parietal. These words can be converted into words that sound familiar that can be
visualized. The word occipital can be converted to exhibit hall (because it sounds like exhibit hall).
The student can then make a visual image of walking into an art museum and seeing a big painting of
a brain with big bulging eyes (occipital is the region of the brain that controls vision). With this system,
the vocabulary word the student is trying to remember actually becomes the cue for the visual image
that then cues the definition of the word.
Pupils are required to look for at least five unfamiliar words a week. They will study how to
read and pronounce them properly, learn the correct spelling and know the meaning of these words
so that they will be able to use them in their own sentences.
16.7.8 APAD
Pupils will be asked to read aloud a short paragraph every day before classes start in order to
develop their oral reading skills.
Bibliography
Fletcher Janis M., Lyon GR, Fuchs LS, Barnes MA., (2015), Learning disabilities: From identification to
intervention. Retrieved on: June 29, 2016, Retrieved from:
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3079378/
Katzir Tim., Kim. Y., Wolf M., (2015), Reading fluency: the whole is more than the parts. Annals
of Dyslexia, Retrieved on: June 29, 2016, Retrieved from: http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?
id=10.1371/journal.pone.0074061
Lyon, Reid G., (2015), Reading Disabilities: Why Do Some Children Have Difficulty Learning to Read?
What Can Be Done About It? Retrieved on: June 29, 2016, Retrieved from:
http://www.education.gov.sk.ca/reading-difficulties-disabilities
MacInnis, Eric., 2015, Teaching Students with Reading Difficulties and Disabilities, Retrieved on: June
29, 2016, Retrieved from: http://www.wrightslaw.com/info/read.disability.lyon.pdf
Wolf, M., & Bowers, P. (2015), The double-deficit hypothesis for the developmental dyslexias (Reading
Disability), Retrieved on: June 29, 2016, Retrieved from:
http://www.templatezone.com/marketing2006/Temp/Carol/carol.htm
36
APPENDIX A
Questionnaire
I. Profile
Gender:________________________
Nutritional Status (Put Check /):__ Severely Wasted ___ Wasted ___ Normal ___ Overweight
Family Monthly Income (Put Check /):___ 2,000 and below, ___ 2001 to 4000, ___4001 to 6000,
___6001 to 8000, 8001 to 10000, ___10001 and above
III. Vocabulary
8. She's unable to tell about her day in a way that makes sense.
9. She misuses common words.
10. He doesn't link words from a book to similar words from another book or
from real life.
11. He's often not able to find the right word to describe something.
12. She has questions about a lot of word meanings in a grade appropriate
text.
13. He seems to have a weak vocabulary.
14. She is not able to make connections among words in various texts.
IV. Fluency
11. He knows how to read words but seems to take a long time to read a short
book or passage silently.
12. She reads a book with no expression.
13. He stumbles a lot and loses his place when reading something aloud.
14. She reads aloud very slowly.
15. She moves her mouth when reading silently (subvocalizing).
16. Her results on words-correct-per-minute assessments are below grade
level or targeted benchmark.
17. She has difficulty and grows frustrated when reading aloud, either because
of speed or accuracy.
18. She does not "chunk" words into meaningful units.
19. When reading, he doesn't pause at meaningful breaks within sentences or
paragraphs.
20. He does not read aloud with expression; that is, he does not change his
tone where appropriate.
V. Comprehension
14. She's not able to summarize a passage or a book.
15. He might be able to tell you what happened in a story, but can't explain
why events went the way they did.
16. She can't explain what a character's thoughts or feelings might have been.
39
17. He doesn't link events in a book to similar events from another book or
from real life.
18. He doesn't link events in a book to similar events from another book or
from real life.
19. He seems to focus on the "wrong" aspect of a passage; for example, he
concentrates so much on the details that the main idea is lost.
20. She can tell the outcome of a story, but cannot explain why things turned
out that way.
21. He does not go behind what is presented in a book to think about what
might happen next or why characters took the action they did.
22. She brings up irrelevant information when trying to relate a passage to
something in her own life.
23. He seems to have a weak vocabulary.
24. She cannot tell the clear, logical sequence of events in a story.
25. He does not pick out the key facts from informational text.
26. He cannot give you a "picture" of what's going on in a written passage; for
example, what the characters look like or details of where the story takes
place.
VI. Other Sources of Reading Disability
5. It seems that she can’t hear me
6. It seems that she can’t talk
7. She doesn’t remember anything
8. She has difficulty in focusing
APPENDIX B
Department of Education
Region IV-B MIMAROPA
Schools Division of Oriental Mindoro
Macatoc Elementary School
JOSEPHINE F. FIEDALAN
The Schools Principal
Macatoc Elementary School
Madame:
Greetings of Peace!
I am at present conducting a proposal for an action research entitled “The Reading Difficulty of
Grade One Pupils of Macatoc Elementary School”.
40
In this connection, may I be allowed to conduct the action research on our school Macatoc
Elementary School? Grade one pupils from the sections of Lotus and Orchids for the School Year 2016-
2017 will be the respondents of my study.
FEMELIEH F. DOCULAN
Master Teacher II
Approved by:
JOSEPHINE F. FIEDALAN
Principal I
Macatoc Elementary School