Manuscript PDF
Manuscript PDF
Manuscript PDF
net/publication/257132504
CITATIONS READS
4 163
1 author:
June Keeling
31 PUBLICATIONS 238 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
PhD South Asian Women- Victims of Abuse and Mental Health View project
All content following this page was uploaded by June Keeling on 21 April 2016.
Abstract
This research paper reports on a qualitative study involving fifteen women who had
experienced domestic violence in pregnancy. Findings from the general literature on this
subject have illuminated many of the effects of domestic violence. There is, however, a gap
in the literature on how this violence affects a woman’s perceptions towards herself, and the
resultant impact on infant feeding. The women participants in this study were resident or
supported by women’s refuges within the United Kingdom, and consented to a narrative
interview. Following verbatim transcription, the process of thematic analysis assisted in the
development of themes. Three interlinking themes emerged and are presented in this paper;
physical injuries sustained through domestic violence, the impact of these injuries on a
woman’s self-perception, and the influences of the injuries self-perception on infant feeding.
The findings suggest that women may experience a body dysmorphia as consequence of the
physical effects of domestic violence which may then affect the woman’s choice on infant
feeding.
Introduction
Violence against women is increasing on a global scale, identified by the World Health
2011). Globally, approximately one in three women have been physically assaulted,
abused or coerced into sex at some stage in their life, by a known perpetrator in the
majority of incidents (United Nations Human Rights 2011). Within developing and
industrialised countries, women experience a divergence in both their experiences of, and
1
responses to domestic violence (Ceballo et al 2004). The accountability for these
discrepancies may lie within their specific ethnic groups (Goodwin et al 2000);
In the USA, it has been estimated that 9.8% of women had experienced abuse within the
previous two years (Walton-Moss et al 2005). However in the UK, the British Crime Survey
of 2009-2010 identified 29% of women experienced some form of domestic violence during
their lifetime (Hall 2011), whilst Feder et al (2009) identified rates of between 13 to 31%.
The effects of domestic violence also have significant cost implications, in excess of £1.2
Perinatal domestic violence refers to any violence occurring before, during and after
pregnancy (up to one year after childbirth) and being committed by an intimate partner
(Sharps et al 2007). During this period of time the violence may commence or worsen
(Garcia-Moreno et al 2006) with some studies suggesting prevalence rates of between 6-21
% in pregnancy and between 13-21% prevalence in the post partum period (Campbell et al
2000). Moreover, a synthesis of results from 13 studies found prevalence rates of domestic
violence in pregnancy ranging between 0.9% (Sampselle et al 1992) and 20.1% (Gazmararian
et al 1996).
The birth of a baby may lead to a rise in tensions in a relationship where domestic violence
features, especially if the woman does not comply with the perpetrators demands for sex
immediately after childbirth (Dutton and Goodman 2005). In this postnatal period new
mothers may face unique challenges (Averbuch & Spatz 2009) including breastfeeding
Centre Victoria 2012), and domestic violence (Keeling & Mason 2011). The juxtaposition of
2
domestic violence onto existing postnatal challenges serves to further complicate the
mother’s situation.
Breast feeding rates in the UK have increased from 76% in 2005 to 81% in 2010 with rates
increasing across all socio economic groups (The NHS Information Centre, 2011). Although
infant feeding may be complicated by the presence of violence in a relationship, many other
factors are also influential. Women with a higher Body Mass Index are less likely to breast
feed (Krause, Lovelady & Østbye 2011); women in lower socio economic groups (Kelly &
Watt 2005), women who leave full time education before the age of 18 years and women
The Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists (2001), the Royal College of
Midwives (1999) and the Department of Health (DH, 2010), have all advocated the inclusion
of education and training for all professionals working in the health care arena, and the
routine investigation for domestic violence. Davison (1997) identified that the personal
experiences of violence within the context of an intimate relationship will have a direct effect
on the health professional’s capability of making a clinical decision, and further, that health
care professionals do not want to ask about domestic violence due to lack of awareness
(Mezey et al 2004). Stark et al (2007) argues that the responses afforded to victims of domestic
violence by the health service serve to ensure it remains a private issue, with Feder, Hutson,
Ramsay and Taket (2006) highlighting the issue that only of survivors of domestic violence are
identified by health professionals. Aston (2004) argues that midwives usually do not raise the
subject of domestic violence, leaving women to take the lead in initiating discussion about it
with their midwife. This lack of communication between the woman and the midwife may
3
revolve around the midwives' own personal experiences of domestic violence (Mezey et al
2004).
Whilst there is a plethora of evidence identifying the negative sequalae to the physical effects
of domestic violence to both non pregnant and pregnant women (Bair-Merritt et al 2006,
Kendall-Tackett 2007), there are few studies that explore whether domestic violence directly
impacts on a woman’s perception of her own body and how this affects her choice of infant
feeding.
Research Aim
The aim of this study was to gain a deeper understanding of the impact of domestic violence
in pregnancy; how the violence affects a woman’s perceptions towards herself, and the
Method
The study was initially discussed with the managers of two refuges at different locations
within the United Kingdom. Due to the experiences of subordination and coercion by an
abusive and controlling partner in the context of domestic violence, the autonomy of the
woman remained of concern. Therefore, any woman who chose to participate self-referred to
the manager who then contacted the primary researcher, ensuring an autonomous choice in
participation.
A qualitative approach using a single narrative interview was chosen for this study. With no
preset questions, this approach enabled the woman herself to decide on what to disclose and
when to terminate the interview with the locus of control remaining with the woman. Supported by
4
Riessman (1993), this approach is relevant for exploring difficult life transitions, gender inequalities
Ethical issues
The World Health Organisation (1999) considerations when researching violence against
women were implicit in the research study development. These specifically address
maintaining the safety of the women. Following verbal consent to participate and audio
record their stories, all meetings took place within a women’s safe house or refuge that
offered twenty four hour security. Ethical approval was granted by the author’s academic
participation and all participants were informed to the choice to opt out at any stage. The
study was independent of the refuge. Anonymity was assured with women choosing their
own pseudonym. The potential for individual researcher bias impacting on thematic analysis
Sample
A total of fifteen women aged between twenty one and fifty four participated in the study, all
of whom had lived with domestic violence perpetrated by a male partner. Of these 15 women,
six chose to talk in detail about how the physical violence had impacted on both their self-
image and attitudes to infant feeding. Twelve of the women had left their violent relationship
in the preceding twelve months; whist three had left longer than twelve months before. All of
the women had children by the violent partner, or a previous partner. The duration of this
violence lasted between twelve months and thirty six years. Based on women being classified
5
into socio-economic groups based on either their current or previous jobs, all were from a
Data Collection
Using a narrative approach to interviewing, all the participants were interviewed once. The
interviews lasted between twenty five minutes and one and a half hours, at the discretion of
the woman. All interviews were conducted within a refuge/safe house, and audio recorded
Data Analysis
Braun and Clarke’s (2006) six phases to thematic analysis was used to analyse the transcripts.
After immersion within the data by reading and re-reading the transcripts, initial codes were
generated. From these initial codes, themes were developed in a continuous and iterative
process. The use of a thematic map enhanced the clarity of the developing themes, which
were themselves checked for relevance to the coded data and entire data set by the principle
investigator and a supervisory team. Through the iterative process of analysis, the themes
emerged from the data itself, each theme remained strongly linked with the data itself (Patton
2002)
Findings
The findings presented are main themes that emerged from the data. The headings within the
findings sections represent each theme. The findings revealed the women’s emotional
midwife. Further, the women’s narratives reveal the impact of domestic violence in
pregnancy and how this has affected their choice of infant feeding.
6
Physical violence in pregnancy
Pregnancy may, for some women, be a period in their lives in which domestic violence
begins or escalates (RCOG 2001) and these narratives reveal the violence within a specific
period of time, during pregnancy. This violence has a causative effect on two lives, the
I have lost two children previously at three months but he was violent to me
when I lost those as well. But now my cervix doesn't shut properly because
like I went through so much violence, so, that's why my cervix doesn't shut
My mum died… and I were pregnant and two days after she died he did a
rocky on me, right on my stomach when I was pregnant hitting either side
and ended up the baby died and I had to have it removed (pause) I was 16
weeks (P2).
There was a time when I was pregnant with my daughter when he threw,
you know those big bottles of juice, he threw one of those at me, he threw
cups at me, hit me in the face with a remote, he's flicked ciggies at me and
When I was six months’ pregnant, the beating me up, that was the worst
because it got to the point where I thought ‘I can't let him do this when I
have a child inside me’… you know I thought what if I stay here, he is
going to end up delivering the baby you know what I mean. He would say I
need a Caesarean and cut me open and stuff, something sick like that (P4).
7
Two of the women explicitly revealed the impact of the physical violence directed against
their pregnancy. Pregnancy is a particularly high risk life event for women experiencing
domestic violence with some suggesting that actual physical violence may be initiated or
escalate at this time (Amaro et al 1990; McGee 2000). All these women talked of their
experiences and the effects on the pregnancy, with two women experiencing miscarriages
A psychological revulsion to the women’s own bodies was a direct consequence of the
physical abuse and associated scarring. The longevity of the psychological effects of these
injuries was evident from the women’s narratives. The women talked of their perceptions of
their body following injuries sustained from the physical violence. They revealed an
appearance related dislike of parts of their body following scarring and injuries resulting from
physical assaults.
I wouldn’t show my legs and I wouldn’t show a bit of my body… I'm all
horrible with all the scars on me basically from the violent relationship.
There's just so many I wish they would just go really. It's the contact and
touching. At the time I had him [baby] I couldn't let anyone touch me I
I hate myself. I hate my body. You see I have to wear things like this
[baggy trousers and top] all the time. I have scars on me and my legs have
permanent bruises. I always wear shell suits or long pants and baggy tops. I
8
can’t wear tops and shorts. You see some people out who hardly wear
anything, but I can’t even wear shorts. I hate my body. I am even worried
about if I find someone else how will the bed thing be because he has made
I hate it [body]. I hate everything about me. I think it is probably the way he
has made me fee… I feel disgusting. I think you know how much you have
washed, they are still there. You want a new body to get rid of them… and
the fact of being a perfect size that he [partner] wanted me to be, I don’t like
Some of the women experienced a generalised negative effect on their body image following
domestic violence, a repulsion of their own bodies. To explain this phenomenon, in the
context of a violent relationship, Weaver argues that a woman’s appearance may be altered
due to scarring and injury following domestic violence, and this may result in an appearance-
related residual injury (Weaver et al 2007). Women appear to experience some residual
dislike towards their bodies after pregnancy generally, based on BMI (Mednelson et al 2001)
and urinary symptoms (Pauls et al 2008). For the women in this study, they talked of a more
specific or zonal body dysmorphia relating to the site of the physical violence perpetrated by
their male partner. The first two excerpts both identify the causative factor of zonal
dysmorphia as being the resultant effects from scarring following physical injuries.
Physical violence has been acknowledged as a component of domestic violence (Krug 2002),
and been the focus of contemporary literature (Beck, Freitag and Singer 1996; Bacchus et al
2004). However, the excerpts from the women’s narratives illuminate the psychological
9
How women feel about breastfeeding their baby
Whilst the women did not talk of the partners feelings towards infant feeding, they shared
their own feelings towards breast feeding in the context of their violent relationships.
He used to grab my breasts, he used to grope me and pull my breast all the
time. Every time we sat down he would do it. So I feel they are dirty now
The women experience a dislike towards their own bodies, specifically directed towards at
their own breasts. The previous section illuminated women’s aversion of their own bodies
following physical violence. This dislike appears to extend beyond personal feelings,
projecting onward towards their baby influencing their feelings towards breast feeding.
DISCUSSION
Breastfeeding requires the woman to be self confident enough to protect her needs, including
support whilst feeding (Van Esterik 2006). Based on the premise that women living with
domestic violence experience a range of controlling and coercive behaviours thereby limiting
autonomy and undermining self confidence (Harne & Radford 2008), these women’s
narratives reveal how the experiences of domestic violence have impacted on breast feeding
10
through a psychological revulsion to a part or parts of their bodies. This negative perception
of their body appears to impact on a woman’s choice to breast feed and the longevity of the
psychological effects of these injuries are evident from the women’s narratives. The women
talk of their perceptions of their body following injuries sustained from the physical violence
revealing an appearance related dislike to the areas targeted and scarred. These findings may
Limitations
The main limitation with this study is the small sample size. However despite this study’s
limitations in generalizability, the women’s narratives do offer a useful insight into how their
experiences of domestic violence negatively affected their decision to disclose the abuse, and
CONCLUSION
Despite the plethora of literature regarding the effects of domestic violence, there has been
minimal attention regarding how physical abuse in the context of domestic violence, has
affected women and their feelings towards breast feeding. Indeed, there are few studies that
explore a correlation between domestic violence and a woman’s choice of infant feeding.
This paper suggests that women experience a body dysmorphia as a direct result of domestic
violence, with their excerpts revealing a dislike of their breasts being linked to the physical
violence and assaults. It is not known if pre existing body dysmorphia existed before
11
pregnancy, or preceded the violence. Future research may focus in the transposition of
The complexities surrounding a women’s desire to breast feed are not yet fully understood
(Lau & Chan 2007). These women’s narratives have however contributed to this arena by
illuminating their feelings towards their bodies and choice in infant feeding. This study then
offers healthcare providers a useful perspective on this important issue. Furthermore, the
subtle signs of domestic violence that revolve around body image and breast feeding may
midwife.
Acknowledgments
The author wishes to thank the women who participated in the study and the staff within the
two refuges for their support. The author is also grateful to the study’s supervisory team for
Key Phrases
1. The subtle signs of domestic violence recognised by a woman’s body
dysmorphia may be indicative of a deeper psychological trauma for which the
woman requires support and intervention from the multi-disciplinary team.
2. The effects of domestic violence may negatively affect a woman’s self
perception of her body.
3. Women may experience a dislike to a specific part of the body as a direct
result from physical violence experienced within a violent relationship.
12
4. Experiencing body dysmorphia may impact on a woman’s’ choice of infant
feeding.
References
13
Amaro H, Fies LE, Cabral H, Zucherman B (1990) Violence during pregnancy and substance
Aston G (2004). The silence of domestic violence in pregnancy during women's encounters
Averbuch T, Spatz D (2009) Breastfeeding mothers and violence: what nurses need to know.
and associations with physical and psychological health. Eur J Obstet Gynecol Reprod Biol.
113, 6-11.
Exposure to Intimate Partner Violence: A Systematic Review. Pediatr 117 (2) e278-e290
Braun V, Clarke V (2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qual Res Psychol, 3(2),
77-101.
Beck SR, Freitag SK, Singer N (1996) Ocular injuries in battered women. Ophthalmol,
Campbell JC, Woods BA, Choauf KL, Parker B (2000) Reproductive health consequences of
intimate partner violence: A nursing research review. Clin Nurs Res 9: 217-237
Ceballo R, Ramirez C, Castillo M, Caballero GA, Lozoff B (2004). Domestic Violence and
Davison J (1997). Domestic Violence: the nursing response. Comm Health, 12(9), 632-633
Department of Health (2010) Interim Government Response to the Report of the Taskforce
on the Health Aspects of Violence Against Women and Children (VAWC). Department of
14
Health. London pg 10 Accessed 29/02/11 from http://www.nmc-
uk.org/Documents/Safeguarding/England/Interim%20Government%20Response%20to%20th
e%20Report%20of%20the%20Taskforce%20on%20the%20Health%20Aspects%20of%20Vi
olence%20Against%20Women%20and%20Children%20(VAWC).pdf
advice/sexual-abuse-in-childhood/pregnancy-to-parenting/
Dutton MA, Goodman LA (2005) Coercion in Intimate Partner Violence: Toward a New
Violence; Expectations and Experiences When They Encounter Health Care Professionals.
assn.org/cgi/reprint/166/1/22.pdf
Feder G, Ramsay J, Dunne D, et al (2009). How far does screening women for domestic
(partner) violence in different health-care settings meet criteria for a screening programme?
partner violence: findings from the WHO multi-country study on women's health and
Gazmararian JA, Lazorick S, Spitz AM, Ballard TJ, Saltzman LE, Marks JS (1996)
15
Goodwin MM, Gazmararian JA, Johnson CH, Gilbert BC, Saltzman LE (2000). Pregnancy
intendedness and physical abuse around the time of pregnancy: findings from the pregnancy
risk assessment monitoring system, 1996-1997, PRAMS Working Group. Pregnancy Risk
Goulding N, Duggal A (2011). Commisioning Services for Women and Children who
experience violence or abuse-a guide for health commissioners. (p. 13). Retrieved from
http://www.dh.gov.uk/en/Publicationsandstatistics/Publications/PublicationsPolicyAndGuida
nce/DH_125900
Hall P (2011). Intimate violence: 2009/10 BCS. In K. Smith (Ed.), Homicides, Firearm
Offences and Intimate Violence 2009/10. Supplementary Volume 2 to Crime in England and
Violence: What we can learn from Survivors’ Personal Narratives. Br J Soc Work, 41,1-17.
Kendall-Tackett KA (2007). Violence against women during the perinatal period: The impact
Krause KM, Lovelady CA, Østbye T (2011) Predictors of Breastfeeding in Overweight and
Obese Women: Data From Active Mothers Postpartum (AMP). Matern Child Health J. 15(3),
p.367–375.
16
Kelly YJ, Watt RG (2005) Breast-feeding initiation and exclusive duration at 6 months by
social class – results from the Millennium Cohort Study. Public Health Nutr 8(4), p. 417-421
Krug EG (2002). Violence and Injury Prevention and Disability (VIP).World Report on
Violence and Health: summary (pp. 5). Geneva: World Health Organization
Lau Y, Chan KS (2007) Influence of Intimate Partner Violence During Pregnancy and Early
Mendelson BK, Mendelson MJ, White DR (2001) Body-Esteem Scale for Adolescents and
Patton M Q (2002). Qualitative evaluation and research methods (3rd ed.). Thousand Oaks,
Pauls RN, Occhino JA, Dryfhout VL (2008) Effects of Pregnancy on Female Sexual Function
and Body Image: A Prospective Study. Jour Sex Med 5(8), pp 1915-1922
Royal College of Midwives (1999). Domestic abuse in pregnancy: Position Paper 19a.
Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists (2001) Why Mothers Die. Confidential
Enquiry into Maternal Deaths in the United Kingdom, RCOG Press, London
17
Sampselle CM, Peterson BA, Murtland TL, Oakley DJ (1992). Prevalence of abuse among
Sarker NN (2008) The impact of intimate partner violence on women's reproductive health
Sharps P, Laughon K, Giangrande S (2007) Intimate Partner Violence and the Childbearing
Year. Maternal and Infant Health Consequences. Trauma Violence Abuse 8, 105-116.
Stark E (2007). Coercive control: How men entrap women in personal life. New York:
The NHS Information Centre, IFF Research (2011). Infant Feeding Survey 2010: Early
Results. The Health and Social Care Information Centre. Retrived from
http://www.ic.nhs.uk/webfiles/publications/003_Health_Lifestyles/IFS_2010_early_results/In
fant_Feeding_Survey_2010_headline_report2.pdf
United Nations Human Rights (2011) Reports on the Special Rapporteur on violence against
women, its causes and consequences. A/hrc/17/26. General Assembly. Human Rights
ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/G11/130/22/PDF/G1113022.pdf?OpenElement
Van Esterik P (2006) Breastfeeding and feminism. Int J Gynaecol Obstet 47, S41-S54.
Walby S (2004). The cost of domestic violence. London: Women and Equality Unit.
18
Walton-Moss BJ,Manganello J, Frye V, Campbell JC (2005). Risk factors for intimate
partner violence and associated injury among urban women. J Community Health, 30(5),
377-389.
Weaver TL, Resnick HS, Kokoska MS, Etzel JC (2007) Appearance-related residual injury,
posttraumatic stress, and body image: Associations within a sample of female victims of
World Health Organization (1999). Putting women’s safety first: Ethical and safety
World Health Organisation (2011) International Day for the Elimination of Violence against
http://www.who.int/mediacentre/events/annual/elimination_vaw/en/
19