PIL 149 Direct-Drive AC Start Systems PDF
PIL 149 Direct-Drive AC Start Systems PDF
PIL 149 Direct-Drive AC Start Systems PDF
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1. NEC Temperature Correction............................................................................ 15
Figure 2. NEC Grouping Derating .................................................................................... 15
Figure 3. Max Power Consumption of Saturn CS&MD ................................................... 18
Figure 4. Max Power Consumption of Saturn GS ............................................................ 18
Figure 5. Max Power Consumption of Centaur 40 -Taurus 60 CS&MD ......................... 19
Figure 6. Max Power Consumption of Mercury 50 .......................................................... 19
Figure 7. Max Power Consumption of Centaur 40, Centaur 50 GS ................................. 20
Figure 8. Max Power Consumption of Centaur 40, Centaur 50 GS ................................. 20
Figure 9. Max Power Consumption of Taurus 60 GS ...................................................... 21
Figure 10. Max Power Consumption of Taurus 65 GS .................................................... 21
Figure 11. Max Power Consumption of Taurus 70 CS&MD ........................................... 22
Figure 12. Max Power Consumption of Taurus 70 GS .................................................... 22
Figure 13. Max Power Consumption of Mars .................................................................. 23
Figure 14. Max Power Consumption of Titan 130 CS&MD ............................................ 23
Figure 15. Max Power Consumption of Titan 130 GS 60 Hz .......................................... 24
Figure 16. Max Power Consumption of Titan 130E GS 60 Hz ........................................ 24
Figure 17. Max Power Consumption of Titan 250 ........................................................... 25
LIST OF TABLES
Table 1: PowerFlex 750 Power Ratings.............................................................................. 4
Table 2. PowerFlex 750 Series Maximum Transformer kVA ............................................ 5
Table 3. PowerFlex750 Series Line Reactor Dimensions and Weights ............................. 6
Table 4. PowerFlex 755 380 - 480 VAC VFD-to-Motor Distances ................................... 7
Table 5. PowerFlex753 380 – 480V Minimum Conductor Ampacity and Terminal Sizes 8
Table 6. Comparison of Motor Nameplate Ratings and Actual Peak Load...................... 12
Table 7. Duty Cycle Service, NEC Code Table 430.22(E) .............................................. 13
1. Introduction
1.1 Basic Description
The Direct-drive Alternating Current (DAC) start system is a proven configuration for Solar® gas
turbine packages. Since its introduction in 1994, the DAC start system has demonstrated high
reliability, and low maintenance, across all of Solar’s gas turbine product lines.
The system consists of a solid-state, pulse-width-modulated VFD that converts three-phase utility
voltage to a variable voltage, variable frequency supply. This power is applied to a rugged,
intermittent duty, AC induction motor that was designed exclusively for this application. The motor
is coupled directly to the gearbox through an overrunning clutch and shaft.
The system initiates engine rotation, maintains engine purge speed, assists acceleration to self-
sustaining speed, and perpetuates a slow roll speed. Assuming a four-minute purge, the system
is designed to provide three consecutive full-speed start cycles with 10-minute motor rest periods
between attempts. Fewer or more consecutive start attempts may be possible, depending upon
ambient temperature, turbine conditions, purge time, and motor rest time. For an example, see
Service Bulletin 2.3/108A DAC start information for the Mars® gas turbine.
Because the load on the motor at engine purge / wash speed is below its nameplate rating, the
system is capable of extended purge cycles for exhaust Heat Recovery Unit (HRU) applications,
and water wash cycles, without concern of overheating.
Slow roll is required on Taurus™ 70 and larger engines. Slow roll speeds range from 3-12% NGP,
and are required for up to 4 hours. The Titan™ 250 Onshore product is equipped with a ride thru
device that maintains rotor rotation, in the event of an AC power outage. Other products rely on a
constant speed AC or DC motor for slow roll.
The DAC system is certified to the following codes and standards, provided that the VFD is installed
in a Motor Control Center (MCC) room or other suitable ordinary (non-hazardous) location:
• National Electrical Code (NEC)
• Underwriters’ Laboratories (UL)
• Canadian Standards Association (CSA) Class I, Division 1, Group D, T3
• International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC) and Comité Européen de Normalisation
Électrotechnique (CENELEC) Zone 1 Exde IIA T3, ATEX
Additionally, the Centaur® 40, Centaur 50, and Taurus 60 generator set applications are equipped
with DAC start systems suitable for NEC Class 1, Group D, Division 1 locations, when the VFD is
in an MCC or other suitable ordinary (non-hazardous) location.
A user-supplied fused disconnect, or circuit breaker, is required at the VFD input; filters, line
reactors, or transformers may also be necessary.
1.2 Availability
Solar has leveraged more than two decades of experience with Reliance/Allen-Bradley VFDs to
develop the configurations used today in the DAC start system. VFD’s that are ordered through
Solar Turbines are configured specifically for seamless integration with our equipment. While it is
possible to order a PowerFlex VFD from a different source, there may be differences in firmware,
option cards, etc., which may result in substantial work on-site to modify the VFD system to function
successfully in this application.
Once installed, Solar’s proprietary Turbotronic™ system downloads all the configuration
parameters to the VFD for operation in the intended application.
1.2.1 Standard DAC Start System
The standard DAC start system is available on all of Solar’s gas turbine packages. It
requires a three-phase power supply from 380 to 480 VAC, 50 or 60 Hz. A Custom Feature
is required for 600 to 690 VAC supply. This document primarily focusses on the 380-480
VAC systems, but information for 600-690 VAC systems can be provided upon request,
and is provided in the same Rockwell documents that are referenced herein.
Saturn GS 5 55 71.3
Centaur GS
331 13 331 13 331 13 37 81
(Low Torque)
Centaur GS
331 13 331 13 331 13 68 151
(High Torque)
Mercury 50 GS 331 13 331 13 331 13 68 151
No Reactor Reactor
Package
m (ft) m (ft)
Table 5. PowerFlex753 380 – 480V Minimum Conductor Ampacity and Terminal Sizes
used in a continuous duty application, the VFD produces heat for a fraction of the operating life of
the package.
2.7 Grounding Systems
The VFDs are designed to operate using a symmetrical three-phase supply. To comply with IEEE
C62.41, the VFD is equipped with Metal Oxide Varistors (MOV) to provide phase-to-phase and
phase-to-ground voltage surge protection. The MOV circuit is designed for transient surge
protection and not for continuous operation. In ungrounded distribution systems, the phase-to-
ground MOV connection can become a continuous current path to ground. Exceeding the published
phase-to-phase voltage, phase-to-ground voltage, or energy ratings can damage the MOV.
Suitable isolation is required for the VFD when there is potential for high phase-to-ground voltages
(exceeding 125% of nominal line-to-line voltage), or when the supply ground is connected to
another system or equipment that could cause the ground potential to vary. Solar recommends an
isolation transformer when any of these conditions exist.
The VFD contains common mode noise suppression capacitors that are referenced to ground. In
installations with ungrounded or high resistance ground systems, the capacitors can capture high
frequency common mode or ground fault currents. This can cause bus overvoltage conditions that
lead to VFD faults or damage. Systems that are ungrounded, high resistance grounded, or have
one phase grounded apply higher than normal voltage stresses directly to the capacitors and can
lead to shortened drive life or damage.
When installing a PowerFlex 750 series drive in an ungrounded, high-resistance, or B-phase
grounded distribution system, disconnect the phase-to-ground MOV circuit and the common mode
capacitors from ground. Refer to Rockwell Automation Publication:
Drives-in001, Wiring and Grounding for Pulse Width Modulated (PWM) AC Drives,
Installation Instructions.
3. Line Harmonics
VFDs introduce current and voltage harmonics into the electrical supply system. The VFD is a
nonlinear load that draws current from the supply for very short periods of time. Line harmonics
result because the voltage of the input power is sinusoidal, but the current draw is not.
Even-order harmonics (such as the 2nd and 4th) are not a problem: although the load is nonlinear,
it is symmetric about the x-axis. Harmonics, divisible by three (such as the 3rd and 9th), are very
small when the supply is a balanced three-phase system. With each higher order, the magnitude
of the distortion is smaller and usually insignificant beyond the 13th harmonic. The harmonics of
concern are the 5th, 7th, 11th, and 13th. The Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE)
standard 519 states that in general, system voltage distortion should be limited to 5% Total
Harmonic Distortion (THD). THD is a ratio of harmonic and total voltage or current: at low loads
(low current flow), very high harmonic current will be measured. THD measurement should be
conducted with the VFD as close to rated current as practicable.
The voltage THD introduced by the drive itself should not exceed 5%. THD examples provided by
Rockwell Automation for a PowerFlex 753 100 hp drive are 1.18% (Vrms) and 36.85% (Irms), and
for a PowerFlex 755 600 hp drive 4.93% (Vrms) and 32.72% (Irms).
If a large percentage of the plant load includes VFDs, Solar highly recommends that a power
system analysis, with an emphasis on harmonics, be conducted. Rockwell Automation provides
harmonic simulation tools, available online, as an aid to model a power system and estimate
harmonic distortion.
There are several methods to mitigate THD; these vary in cost and effectiveness. Line reactors
are a simple and common method. If a more aggressive method of attenuation is required,
transformers, filters or 12/18 pulse input rectifiers are available. See Rockwell Automation
Publication: DRIVES-WP011C: Straight Talk about PWM AC Drive Harmonic Problems and
Solutions. for more information.
5. Conductor Sizing
ATTENTION: The following example is merely a guide for proper installation.
Solar Turbines cannot assume responsibility for the compliance or the
noncompliance to any code, national, local or otherwise for the proper
installation of this drive or associated equipment. A hazard of personal injury
and/or equipment damage exists if codes are ignored during installation.
These guidelines are for use by licensed, professional engineers and
electricians. The customer’s electrical designers are responsible for
compliance to all applicable codes. It is strongly recommended that the
customer, electrical engineer, and contractor read the VFD manufacturer’s
documentation referenced in Section 6.
Due to the unusual duty cycle of the DAC system, Solar provides an EXAMPLE of how to select
conductor size between the VFD and motor. These sample recommendations are based upon
NFPA70 Articles 310 & 430 of the United States National Electrical Code (NEC), 2017 edition, and
the VFD and motor supplier. The same general approach can be taken to size conductors
according to the International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC).
Inappropriate wiring can cause start-up difficulties, as well as unwanted interaction with other
systems. It is recommended that the VFD use copper conductors with an insulation composed of
XLPE Type RHW-2, or XHHW-2. Shielding is required for the conductors connecting the VFD to
the start motor. Shielded cabling is also strongly recommended at the input to the VFD. Using
unshielded cabling on the input can result in disruption of sensitive control components, such as
the overspeed monitor.
The VFD conductors should be rated based on supply voltage, NEC Type TC, AC or MC. At least
one ground wire must connect the VFD to the start motor. Ground wire(s) should be spaced
equidistant to the power wires (such as in the center of a triangular arrangement of power wires).
A cable with three symmetrical ground conductors should be used for drives larger than 200 hp
(150kW).
Solar DAC start motors are designed for 15-minute inverter duty, and the required power during
slow roll is significantly less than the start motor nameplate rating. The ampacity rating of
conductors can be sized to 120% or greater than motor nameplate current rating.
Conservative sizing of conductors, such as using the continuous output current rating of the VFD,
is unnecessary and the increased cable diameter can pose significant challenges to cable
termination at the motor. A few products use a motor that has a nameplate current rating that is
greater than the VFD continuous rating (for example, T60 CS/MD). In this case, the VFD
continuous current rating should be used as the baseline amperage, prior to derating, for conductor
sizing. This is because the VFD will not allow the motor to continuously draw more current than
this limit, even under high load conditions. Refer to Table 6 for a comparison of motor nameplate
and VFD continuous current ratings.
Refer to NEC Table 310.15(B)(16) to size conductors based on ampacity. Conductors rated to 90ºC
with XHHW-2 insulation are recommended for NEC Solar Packages. Table 310.15(B)(16) uses
the following assumptions:
127.2 𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴
= 155.1 𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴
0.82
For this example, we assume that 6 conductors are being used in parallel (i.e. that conductors from
another system are run together with the start cables), and derating for 6 conductors using Table
310.15(B)(3)(a) leads to:
155.1 𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴
= 193.9 𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴
.8
In this example, the derating factors account for an increased current of 66 amps. Prior to final
selection of the conductor size, it is necessary to consider the voltage drop. The following equation
is used to calculate voltage drop:
11.4
D=
Ω
1.732 × × I max
d
where:
D = Distance between the VFD and motor, m (ft)
11.4 = Maximum voltage drop (3% of 380 VAC)
1.732 = Decimal representation of the square root of 3
Ω/d = Conductor resistance per m (ft)
Imax = VFD continuous current rating
Independent of voltage drop, the conductor size needs to be 2/0 according to 310.15(B)(16). Most
cable manufacturers provide a voltage per amp per distance loss, which simplifies the voltage drop
calculation. Solar’s preferred cable supplier provides this information, and 2/0 cable has a 0.193
Volts/Amp/1000 ft drop. To determine voltage drop, multiply the continuous amperage rating of the
VFD by the voltage drop by the distance divided by 1000.
𝑉𝑉𝑉𝑉𝑉𝑉𝑉𝑉𝑉𝑉
260 𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴 × 0.193 × 200 𝑓𝑓𝑓𝑓
𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴 ∗ 1000 𝑓𝑓𝑓𝑓
This results in a value of 10 volts, which is less than a 3% voltage drop. Hence, the 2/0 AWG
conductor is the appropriate selection for this example. If the distance between VFD and motor is
increased beyond 227 ft, larger conductors would be needed.
6. Summary
The DAC start system is a proven configuration for Solar gas turbine compressor sets, mechanical-
drive packages, and generator sets. Since introduction, it has demonstrated high reliability and low
maintenance on Solar’s packages across all products.
Despite the simplicity, it requires consideration for the environment, conductor selection, grounding,
inter-connections, and the effects the VFD might have on other electrical components. It is
important that electrical engineers, familiar with site conditions and requirements, be engaged in
the system design, selection of supporting components, and installation requirements, to ensure
success. The modern technology of the VFD provides many advantages for the DAC start system,
when compared to other gas turbine start systems.
8. Appendix
Figures 3 thru 17 depict the maximum power consumption for the start system for each product.
Load profiles for each product are approximate. Constant acceleration rates and a four-minute
purge at 20% NGP are assumed.
Note: This curve is different than the others due to the unique starting
characteristics of these products
500
450
400
350
300
Power (kVA)
250 Power
%NGP
200
Slow Roll
150
100
50
0
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450
Time (s)
This information is intended as a general overview and is not intended to be, and should not be used as, a substitute for obtaining
advice in any specific situation. This document is accurate as of the publication date and any discussion of a particular issue may
become outdated
Cat and Caterpillar are registered trademarks of Caterpillar Inc. Solar, Saturn, Centaur, Taurus, Mercury, Mars, Titan, SoLoNOx,
Turbotronic, InSight System, and InSight Connect, are trademarks of Solar Turbines Incorporated. All other trademarks are the
intellectual property of their respective companies.
© 2019 Solar Turbines Incorporated. All rights reserved. Specifications are subject to change without notice.