Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 688 views

    RMG-D Graham-Chicago Letter 03-24-20

    Uploaded by

    Hannah Alani
    The letter from Reserve Management Group to the Assistant Commissioner of the Chicago Department of Public Health argues that its subsidiary General Iron should be considered an essential business under the state's COVID-19 executive order. It details General Iron's role in recycling metal and its stringent environmental controls. It warns that shutting down General Iron could have negative consequences for waste collection, recycling, city residents' livelihoods, and the environment. The letter provides facts about General Iron's emissions testing results and their minimal health and safety impacts. It asks the Assistant Commissioner to make decisions based on facts rather than inaccurate claims made by opponents on social media.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    RMG-D Graham-Chicago Letter 03-24-20

    Uploaded by

    Hannah Alani
    688 views3 pages
    The letter from Reserve Management Group to the Assistant Commissioner of the Chicago Department of Public Health argues that its subsidiary General Iron should be considered an essential business under the state's COVID-19 executive order. It details General Iron's role in recycling metal and its stringent environmental controls. It warns that shutting down General Iron could have negative consequences for waste collection, recycling, city residents' livelihoods, and the environment. The letter provides facts about General Iron's emissions testing results and their minimal health and safety impacts. It asks the Assistant Commissioner to make decisions based on facts rather than inaccurate claims made by opponents on social media.

    Original Description:

    Reserve Management Group CEO Steve Joseph letter to Chicago Dept. of Public Health

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    The letter from Reserve Management Group to the Assistant Commissioner of the Chicago Department of Public Health argues that its subsidiary General Iron should be considered an essential business under the state's COVID-19 executive order. It details General Iron's role in recycling metal and its stringent environmental controls. It warns that shutting down General Iron could have negative consequences for waste collection, recycling, city residents' livelihoods, and the environment. The letter provides facts about General Iron's emissions testing results and their minimal health and safety impacts. It asks the Assistant Commissioner to make decisions based on facts rather than inaccurate claims made by opponents on social media.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf or txt
    688 views3 pages

    RMG-D Graham-Chicago Letter 03-24-20

    Uploaded by

    Hannah Alani
    The letter from Reserve Management Group to the Assistant Commissioner of the Chicago Department of Public Health argues that its subsidiary General Iron should be considered an essential business under the state's COVID-19 executive order. It details General Iron's role in recycling metal and its stringent environmental controls. It warns that shutting down General Iron could have negative consequences for waste collection, recycling, city residents' livelihoods, and the environment. The letter provides facts about General Iron's emissions testing results and their minimal health and safety impacts. It asks the Assistant Commissioner to make decisions based on facts rather than inaccurate claims made by opponents on social media.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf or txt
    of 3

    RESERVE MANAGEMENT GROUP

    March 24, 2020

    Via Electronic Mail


    Mr. David Graham
    Assistant Commissioner
    Department of Public Health
    City of Chicago
    333 S. State, Suite 200
    Chicago, IL, 60604
    dave.graham@cityofchicago.org

    Dear Assistant Commissioner Graham:

    In response to the city and state emergencies prompted by the COVID-19 crisis, Reserve Management
    Group and its operating subsidiaries, including GII, LLC, doing business as General Iron (“GII”), is
    continuing operations as an “essential business” under provisions of the statewide Executive Order 2020-
    10.

    As we informed the City Law Department via email on Saturday, the ongoing operations at GII, located at
    1909 N. Clifton Ave., fall squarely under two exemptions in the Order pertaining to “Essential
    Infrastructure” and “Essential Businesses and Operations.” Regarding “Essential Infrastructure,” Section
    9 authorizes leaving home “to provide any services or perform any work necessary to offer, provision,
    operate, maintain, and repair” essential infrastructure, including “solid waste and recycling collection and
    removal.” Section 9 further states that “Essential Infrastructure shall be construed broadly….” Regarding
    “Essential Businesses and Operations,” Section 12(t) deems, as essential businesses, “[m]anufacturing
    companies, distributors, and supply chain companies producing and supplying essential products and
    services in and for industries such as … waste pickup and disposal,…steel and steel products…as well as
    products used by other Essential Businesses and Operations.”

    Further, GII plays a vital role in the critical manufacturing supply chain detailed in the updated Guidance
    issued yesterday by the U.S. Department of Homeland Security’s Cyber and Infrastructure Security
    Agency. GII’s products are necessary raw materials used by steel manufacturers and iron and non-ferrous
    foundries in the production of all manner of metal goods, including commercial, industrial, military, and
    consumer products. Limiting the supply of raw materials will result in a corresponding reduction of
    overall manufacturing capacity.

    Unfortunately, since Saturday, a few individuals on social media have used the COVID-19 crisis to
    question the essential operations of GII and, advancing a false narrative, have called upon the Mayor and
    other public officials to shut down the company’s operations. Regrettably, these individuals are
    continuing to misrepresent GII’s potential impact on the health and safety of our neighbors, when, in fact,
    GII is doing more to protect the environment and public health than any other metal shredding facility in
    the city or area.

    In our ongoing effort to set the record straight, GII’s highly respected environmental consultants at RK &
    Associates, Inc., have compiled the following essential facts about GII’s operations and its impact on the
    health and safety of the city and its residents:

    4550 Darrow Road  Stow, Ohio 44224


    Phone: 440.519.1768  Fax: 440.519.1769  www.reserve-group.com
     GII operates the only metal shredder in Chicago and the Midwest equipped with a particulate filter,
    regenerative thermal oxidizer (RTO) for control of volatile organic material (VOM) and a packed
    tower scrubber for control of acid gases;

     VOM emission testing performed in November 2019 demonstrated that the RTO destroys 99% of
    VOM;

     In absolute terms, General Iron’s VOM emissions are a mere fraction of the overall VOM emissions
    from stationary sources in Cook County. The company’s projected actual annual VOM emissions
    represent only about 0.08 percent of the VOM emissions from all stationary sources across Cook
    County, based on Illinois Environmental Protection Agency data submitted for 2017 to the U.S.
    EPA’s National Emissions Inventory;

     Although GII’s shredder is larger than that of its nearest competitor, located just six miles away,
    GII’s permitted shredder VOM emissions are more than 70% lower than the competing facility.

     Testing performed in November 2019 demonstrated that shredder particulate matter emissions were
    less than 3% of the levels in GII’s current IEPA Operating Permit;

     The observed plume from the scrubber exhaust stack is water vapor (steam). This is clearly
    demonstrated by U.S. EPA Method 9 opacity testing, performed in November 2019 by a certified
    visible emissions observer, that reported zero visible emissions beyond the steam plume;

     Air emissions testing supervised by the Illinois EPA and the U.S. EPA in June 2018 demonstrated
    that no emissions of 17 specific metals or filterable particulate matter (PM) from shredding
    operations violated any permitted levels or applicable requirements. As stated by the U.S. EPA on
    its website, the results of the metals emissions test indicated that the “emission rates are low
    compared to EPA emission limits.” The tests confirmed the effectiveness of the shredder’s high-
    efficiency air filter, consisting of a capture hood, cyclone, and roll-media filter system, to control
    PM and metals emissions;

     An off-site impact analysis for shredder metal emissions measured in June 2018 was performed
    using USEPA approved air dispersion modeling. The results showed that the predicted impacts met
    or exceeded risk-based standards identified in Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources
    (WDNR) air emission regulations. WDNR standards were used because the Illinois Environmental
    Protection Agency (IEPA) does not have corresponding regulations; and

     The GII shredder’s advanced pollution control system results in shredder emission rates that are
    significantly lower than emission rates from any other shredder in the Chicago area.

    GII recycles approximately 740,000 tons of obsolete metal products annually, which is about the same
    quantity as all of the garbage collected each year in the City of Chicago. Shuttering GII would have severe
    consequences, especially in this period of civic emergency. Among the dire consequences, are the
    following:
     The City’s Department of Streets and Sanitation would find it difficult, at best, to meet the burden
    of handling thousands of additional tons of household appliances and items discarded in alleys;
     Scrap metal may be sent to other facilities in the region, none of which have air quality controls
    for metals, particulate matter, or VOM. GII is currently the only scrap metal recycler in the Midwest
    with a filter, RTO, and scrubber;

     Peddlers, who are predominately city residents of limited means, will be financially impaired and
    have to travel farther to reach a scrap metal recycling facility;

     Marginally recyclable materials will get left behind. These materials may end up being disposed of
    in landfills or otherwise handled/disposed of improperly; and

     GII and its 100-plus employees, who are predominately minority residents of the city, will
    experience severe economic hardship.

    Please know that we take the health and safety of our employees, customers, and neighbors very seriously.
    In addition to measures required by federal and state air quality and safety regulations, we have taken further
    precautionary measures consistent with current COVID-19 guidelines provided to businesses and
    employers by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, including social distancing practices, extra
    cleaning, and other mitigation measures. Additionally, employees are not allowed to report to work if they
    feel sick, manifest symptoms, or have been diagnosed with or exposed to any person diagnosed with
    COVID-19. GII believes that it is imperative that we continue to support America’s critical infrastructure,
    knowing that we have taken and will continue to take appropriate measures to protect our employees,
    customers, and other stakeholders.
    GII appreciates its neighbors’ concerns and continually strives to ensure that its operation is the best in class
    compared to any similar facility in the United States. The company trusts and relies on public officials to
    seriously consider the facts we have addressed, grounded on legitimate science, and the company welcomes
    any genuine dialogue on that basis. Unfortunately, rather than engage in constructive dialogue rooted in
    facts, it appears that certain opponents would prefer to drive governmental decision-making based on
    inaccurate, incomplete and false information.
    Under the provisions of the Term Sheet entered with the City last September, the parties agreed to “use best
    efforts to engage in public discourse that is fact-based and reasonable.”

    Please do not hesitate to contact us if you or your Administration have any questions. We extend our sincere
    best wishes to you and your team during these unprecedented and trying circumstances.

    Best regards,

    Steve Joseph
    CEO, Reserve Management Group

    Cc: Mr. Jeffrey Levine, City of Chicago Department of Law

    You might also like