Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 293 views

    POC Evaluation Form PDF

    Uploaded by

    pulkit
    The document provides guidelines and evaluation criteria for submissions to the Proof of Concept (PoC) stage of the IIC National Innovation Contest 2020. It describes the parameters that will be used to evaluate PoCs, including relevance of problem/solution, feasibility of the solution, applicability, and intellectual property. PoCs will be evaluated on a 50 point scale. Successful PoCs scoring 25 points or more will advance to the next stage. Themes of the contest include healthcare, agriculture, transportation, food, robotics, waste management, water, energy, IoT, and other emerging technologies. Institutions are encouraged to submit PoCs developed for problems identified in society or through campus programs.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    POC Evaluation Form PDF

    Uploaded by

    pulkit
    293 views3 pages
    The document provides guidelines and evaluation criteria for submissions to the Proof of Concept (PoC) stage of the IIC National Innovation Contest 2020. It describes the parameters that will be used to evaluate PoCs, including relevance of problem/solution, feasibility of the solution, applicability, and intellectual property. PoCs will be evaluated on a 50 point scale. Successful PoCs scoring 25 points or more will advance to the next stage. Themes of the contest include healthcare, agriculture, transportation, food, robotics, waste management, water, energy, IoT, and other emerging technologies. Institutions are encouraged to submit PoCs developed for problems identified in society or through campus programs.

    Original Description:

    POC-Evaluation-Form-PDF

    Original Title

    POC-Evaluation-Form-PDF

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    The document provides guidelines and evaluation criteria for submissions to the Proof of Concept (PoC) stage of the IIC National Innovation Contest 2020. It describes the parameters that will be used to evaluate PoCs, including relevance of problem/solution, feasibility of the solution, applicability, and intellectual property. PoCs will be evaluated on a 50 point scale. Successful PoCs scoring 25 points or more will advance to the next stage. Themes of the contest include healthcare, agriculture, transportation, food, robotics, waste management, water, energy, IoT, and other emerging technologies. Institutions are encouraged to submit PoCs developed for problems identified in society or through campus programs.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf or txt
    293 views3 pages

    POC Evaluation Form PDF

    Uploaded by

    pulkit
    The document provides guidelines and evaluation criteria for submissions to the Proof of Concept (PoC) stage of the IIC National Innovation Contest 2020. It describes the parameters that will be used to evaluate PoCs, including relevance of problem/solution, feasibility of the solution, applicability, and intellectual property. PoCs will be evaluated on a 50 point scale. Successful PoCs scoring 25 points or more will advance to the next stage. Themes of the contest include healthcare, agriculture, transportation, food, robotics, waste management, water, energy, IoT, and other emerging technologies. Institutions are encouraged to submit PoCs developed for problems identified in society or through campus programs.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf or txt
    You are on page 1of 3
    At a glance
    Powered by AI
    The key takeaways are about submitting Proof of Concepts (PoCs) for solutions developed to address problems identified. PoCs will be evaluated based on various criteria and can address different themes.

    The different types of PoCs that can be submitted are: introduction of new or improved services, introduction of new method of production/process, opening of new market, exploration of a new source & supply, and reengineering/organization of business management process.

    The criteria used to evaluate the PoCs are: relevance and validation of problem & solution, feasibility of solution, applicability of solution. PoCs need to score a minimum of 25 to be considered for the next level.

    IIC National Innovation Contest 2020

    Institution’s Innovation Council (IIC), MHRD’s Innovation Cell


    All India Council for Technical Education, New Delhi
    Guideline and Evaluation Criteria Sheet for Proof of Concept (PoC) Submission

    Proof of Concept (PoC) Title:


    Team Leader Name: Email:
    PoC Type: (Multiple Select, Tick Appropriates) Contact no:
    �Introduction of new or improved services
    �Introduction of new method of production/ process
    �Opening of new market
    Theme Name:
    �Exploration of a new source & supply
    �Reengineering/ organization of business management
    process
    Sl. Marks
    Parameters Total Marks
    No. Obtained
    Relevance and Validation of Problem & Solution 15 Marks
    (a) Is the proposed Solution/Concept having ability
    (is effective) to address the Identified problem to 10 Marks
    1. a major extent?
    (b) Is the proposed Solution/Concept considered to
    be one of best alternative (or) Only Solution to 5 Marks
    the Identified Problem?
    Feasibility of solution (SMART)
    25 Marks
    (to Check the appropriateness of the proposed
    solution)
    (a) Specific- Does the PoC set the objectives and
    delineate the objectives of solutions clearly? 5 Marks
    (b) Measurable- Does the PoC explained the
    approach or method with milestones to
    5 Marks
    achieve objectives mentioned above to
    develop the Solutions?
    (c) Attainable- Does the solution with objectives
    2. and millstones provided by PoC team is
    5 Marks
    attainable/doable if enough time and
    resources will be provided?
    (d) Realistic- Does the solution with objectives
    and millstones provided by PoC team is
    5 Marks
    attainable in the time, with available resource
    and skillset of the team?
    (e) Timeline- Does the time period for
    millstones give is realistic and level of
    confidence of team to complete the stages to 5 Marks
    reach prototype/Innovation in the given time
    period. (TRL 2 or TRL 3 in 2-3 months)
    Applicability of Solution 10 Marks
    (a) Usability: Level of acceptance of
    2.0 Marks
    Solution/Features among target group
    (b) Scalability: Adoption Potential of Solution as
    2.0 Marks
    Business Model/Startup
    (c) Economic Sustainability: Potential of solution to
    3. 2.0 Marks
    Become profitable or financially viable
    (d) Environment Sustainability: Potential of solution
    to become environment friendly or address 2.0 Marks
    environment problems
    (e) Existence of Intellectual Property Component, if
    2.0 Marks
    any?
    Total 50 Marks
    Important Note:

     IIC-institute and members are requested to disseminate and encourage students to take part
    in submission of PoCs for the solutions developed for the problem encountered/identified
    by students during their visits to Society, market industry etc.
     Please note that, submissions of solutions or PoCs developed for the problems for various
    programs such as SIH, internal Hackathons and other campus hackathons/competitions can
    be considered.
     Ideas submitted at Ideation Stage with minimum score of 25 or above (as per the evaluation
    criteria provided to evaluate ideas) can be considered for PoC level participation. i.e. IIC-
    Institute can upgrade/select the ideas for POC level.
     If any interested students’ teams have not participated at Idea Level, still they can
    participate. If student team have developed PoC and want to participate directly at PoC level
    can submit their Solution/PoC directly at PoC stage. (Both Idea and PoC submission portal
    will remain open till May 2020). i.e. IIC-Institute can accept entries directly at POC stage
    if any team missed submission at Idea stage.
     PoC may be technical and (or) non-technical solution of an Idea and can be fit into any one
    or multiple themes and also can be fit into different PoC types (as given in evaluation page).
     IIC Institute need to organize PoC validation workshop for participants and evaluate the
    PoCs received.
     No limit on number of PoCs and student teams and team size. No gender reservation but
    gender balance is encouraged.
     All PoCs need to be carefully evaluated by committee setup by IIC Institute for next level of
    hand holding and support through IC institute. IIC Institute should consider external experts
    of IIC – Institute and (or) member’s representation incubation and startup in the committee
    to evaluate.
     Above evaluation criteria can be used to evaluation and PoCs and Pocs which receives a
    minimum score of 25 or above can be considered for next level (Prototype/innovation
    level).
     At the end, the detail of PoCs received with evaluation score allocated to each POC need to
    be uploaded in the link named as Innovation Contest tab on portal.
     PoC Validation workshop can be reported as MIC driven activity in IIC portal and eligible to
    obtain certain reward points for it.

    Themes:
    1. Healthcare & Biomedical devices.
    2. Agriculture & Rural Development.
    3. Smart Vehicles/ Electric vehicle/ Electric vehicle motor and battery technology.
    4. Food Processing/Nutrition/Biotechnology
    5. Robotics and Drones.
    6. Waste management/Waste to Wealth
    7. Clean & Potable water.
    8. Renewable and affordable Energy.
    9. IoT based technologies (e.g. Security & Surveillance systems etc.)
    10. ICT, cyber physical systems, Block chain, Cognitive computing, Cloud computing, AI & ML.
    11. Other Emerging areas of Innovation/Startup
    Please make students and faculties aware about Technology Readiness Levels (TRLs).

    You might also like