The Potential of Biogas From Apple Juice: Article
The Potential of Biogas From Apple Juice: Article
The Potential of Biogas From Apple Juice: Article
net/publication/332802583
CITATIONS READS
0 183
5 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Udara Arachchige on 02 May 2019.
454
____________________________________________________________________________
Paper Title:- The Potential of Biogas from Apple Juice
the fermenting process can be used as an organic Same time investigate the influence of initial
fertilizer in agriculture [4]. The main aim of the conditions on the process using computer-aided
present study is to quantify the biogas production simulation tool Aquasim 2.0.
from apple juice.
III. THEORY
The waste from fruit and vegetable processing
Modelling of the net energy production of the
industries has been used for the production of
anaerobic fermenter is important for reliable
biogas by the anaerobic digestion process. During
decision making on the efficiency of anaerobic
this process, the complex polymers are first
digestion processes. By using the Anaerobic
hydrolyzed enzymatically into simpler substances
Digestion Model No. 1 (ADM1) the simulation of
and then the resulting matter is converted to
biogas production and estimation of operating
Volatile Fatty Acids (VFA’s) by acidogenic
conditions are possible [5].
bacteria. These VFA’s are further converted to
acetates by acetogenic organisms. At the final stage,
Composite Particulate Material
methanogenic organisms will utilize acetates and
produce biogas (Fig. 1). Disintegration
Acetogenesis
II. OBJECTIVES
In this project, the primary aim was to test the
following hypothesis. Acetic H2
2 ISSN:-2349-3585 |www.ijrdt.org
Paper Title:- The Potential of Biogas from Apple Juice
principal products of fermentation are acetate, Acetogenic bacteria start metabolizing the
hydrogen, CO2, and propionate and butyrate. The intermediary metabolites - volatile fatty acids -
propionate and butyrate are fermented further to converting them into acetic acid, carbon dioxide,
produce hydrogen, CO2, and acetate too. and hydrogen. Anaerobic oxidation at this point is
inhibited by hydrogen gas. With the high hydrogen
TABLE 1: PRODUCTS FROM GLUCOSE DEGRADATION gas partial pressures the reaction becomes
Products Reaction Reference thermodynamically unfeasible, resulting in an
1 Lactate 𝐶6 𝐻12 𝑂6 → 2𝐶𝐻3 𝐶𝐻𝑂𝐻𝐶𝑂𝑂𝐻 5,6,7
increasing amount of volatile fatty acids (VFA) in
2 Ethanol 𝐶6 𝐻12 𝑂6 → 2𝐶𝐻3 𝐶𝐻2 𝑂𝐻 + 2𝐶𝑂2 5
the surrounding liquid phase.
3 Butyrate 𝐶6 𝐻12 𝑂6 → 𝐶𝐻3 𝐶𝐻2 𝐶𝑂𝑂𝐻 5,6
+ 2𝐶𝑂2 + 2𝐻2
Methanogenesis
4 Acetate 𝐶6 𝐻12 𝑂6 + 2𝐻2 𝑂 → 2𝐶𝐻3 𝐶𝑂𝑂𝐻 5,6,7
For successful operation of anaerobic digestion,
+ 2𝐶𝑂2 + 4𝐻2
there is a need to continuously remove hydrogen
propionate and acetate. Stoichiometric reactions of the last step in microbial biogas production. There
lactate acidogenesis are presented in below. are two groups of Methanogens; all of them are
obligate anaerobes. One group - H2-oxidizing
methanogens - reduces CO2 using H2 as the electron
donor to form methane. The second group of
3 ISSN:-2349-3585 |www.ijrdt.org
Paper Title:- The Potential of Biogas from Apple Juice
methanogens cleaves acetic acid into methane and 4. The air in the syringe was removed by
CO2. About 2/3 of the methane produced, comes pressing it through the needle.
from this reaction. Nearly all volatile organic matter 5. Placed the stopper at the needle point to
entering a digester will end up as methane. Small close the syringe.
amounts will be incorporated in newly formed 6. Checked if the syringe is gas-tight by
biomass. pulling the piston, no air sucked into the
IV. Methodology syringe indicates that the system is gas tight.
In this experiment, 60ml medical syringes were 7. Place the syringes on a test tube rack and
used as small scale anaerobic digesters and gas other set placed on the shaker and placed
holders. Apple juice and inoculum were added to both sets in the incubator.
the syringes according to the ratios given below. 8. The temperature at 35 ± 1.0C was kept for
The inoculum was taken from a wastewater better gas production.
treatment plant sludge outlet (filtered sample) Fig. 9. Daily gas production in each syringe was
2. The five different apple juice feed samples tested recorded with temperature data.
with parallels. Two samples used as fixed reactors
(without mixing) and two used with laboratory
shaker (with mixing). The 30 ml inoculum is added
to each reactor (syringe). See Table 3 for detailed
information.
TABLE 3: QUANTITATIVE DOSIN OF APPLE JUICE
AND INOCULUM IN THE REACTORS
Residue Apple
Sample content residue,
Parallels Inoculum(ml)
no. (weight- leachate
%) (ml)
1 0 2 30 0
2 1 2 30 0.3
3 2 2 30 0.6
4 5 2 30 1.5 Fig 2. Biogas reactor with samples placed on a rack
5 10 2 30 3.0
Aquasim
All syringes were prepared for biogas production
according to the following procedure. According to the inoculum volume and type of the
1. The pH of inoculum and apple juice was reactor (batch or CSTR) simulations of the flow
measured. rate, pH, VFA, biomass etc. were carried out with
2. 30 ml inoculum was sucked up into each and Aquasim 2.0 software. AQUASIM allows its users
every syringe. to define the spatial configuration of the system to
3. Apple juice was sucked up according to the be investigated as a set of compartments, which can
above table. be connected to each other by links. Moreover it
allows users to perform simulations using different
4 ISSN:-2349-3585 |www.ijrdt.org
Paper Title:- The Potential of Biogas from Apple Juice
models, to assess the identifiability and to estimate volume with the amount of feed variation indicated
the values of model parameters (using measured in the following Fig. 4.
data), and to estimate prediction uncertainty. The
simulation process was repeatedly checked to fit the
theoretical model into the experimental data and to
estimate initial conditions of the reactor.
Analytical Methods
pH meter is used for measuring the pH of the
inoculum and apple juice. Gas production in each Fig 4. Total Biogas produced from different feed% samples
15.00
Accumulated biogas variations for experimental and
10.00
5.00 simulated figures are given below in Fig 5.
0.00
0 1 2 5 10
% feed
5 ISSN:-2349-3585 |www.ijrdt.org
Paper Title:- The Potential of Biogas from Apple Juice
The Blue colour solid line represents the simulated production flow rate become zero. According to the
accumulated gas production and red line simulated figure, initially shows a high production
represented the experimental accumulated gas rate and then decreasing. After 0.5 days again flow
production. According to the shape of the lines, rate increased and after two days period flow rate
both follow the same pattern. After 3 days of the decreased and after 10 days close to zero value.
period, gas production has stopped. The reason may
be, not enough foods for further gas production. Biomass
According to the simulation graph, after 10 days Reactor biomass concentration variation is given
period gas production has stopped. Experimental below in Fig 7.
data represent some deviations from the simulated
graph. But both figures are approximately equal. So
our experiment followed the theoretical biogas
production procedure.
Gas production rate
Gas production flow-rate for experimental and
simulated results are given in Fig 6.
6 ISSN:-2349-3585 |www.ijrdt.org
Paper Title:- The Potential of Biogas from Apple Juice
decreasing. But other graphs do not represent a
significant effect. So it can be said that butyric and
valeric VFA play an important role in the biogas
production process.
pH
pH variation in the reactor is given below in Fig 10.
Fig 8. Batch reactor simulated results for adjusted gas
percentages pH is one of the most important parameters for
biogas production.
The above Fig. 8 represents the gas production
percentages. Blue colour represents the CH4, the
Green colour line represents the CO2 and red colour
represents the H2. There are around 70% methane
gas is produced and remaining is CO2 gas. There is
no H2 gas production in this step.
7 ISSN:-2349-3585 |www.ijrdt.org
Paper Title:- The Potential of Biogas from Apple Juice
Inhibitors
Simulated Fig 13 for Inhibitors related to the biogas
production process is given below.
Gas flow
Gas flow rate variation in the UASB reactor is
Fig 12. CSTR simulated results for adjusted gas volume given below in Fig 14.
8 ISSN:-2349-3585 |www.ijrdt.org
Paper Title:- The Potential of Biogas from Apple Juice
CSTR there is no big difference with CH4
percentage. In this reactor pH stable around 7.So
reactor conditions are good for biogas production.
Overloaded
This Fig 16, related to the overloaded conditions
Fig 14. UASB simulated results for gas flow simulated results for the pH of the reactor.
Simulated adjusted gas volume figure for UASB is not providing a better environment for
figure indicating the percentage amount of various According to the overloaded conditions reactor,
Fig 15. UASB simulated results for adjusted gas volume Fig 17. Simulated results for overloaded condition (VFA)
According to Fig 15, the blue colour represents the In this Fig 17, acetate VFA level is increasing and
CH4 production percentage, green colour represents both butyric and valeric VFA levels are also
the CO2 production percentage.CH4 production increasing. All acidic VFA levels increasing mean
percentage around 55%. When compared with again acid level increasing and pH level goes down.
9 ISSN:-2349-3585 |www.ijrdt.org
Paper Title:- The Potential of Biogas from Apple Juice
So lower pH is not good for Methanogenesis bacteria metabolize still at high levels at pH 4.5
bacteria. It causes to reduce biogas production. whereas methanogens face decreasing rates at pH
6.0. Fatty acid concentration and subsequent pH
VI. Discussion levels in anaerobic digesters play a vital role in
According to the experiment, different apple juice operating a biogas system. Production of VFAs
compositions fed to the syringe and measured gas leads to a decrease in pH. Normally the drop in pH
production daily. 10% sample indicated the is counterbalanced and buffered by the formation of
maximum gas production (Fig 4). But the yield was alkalinity through CO2 production.
high in 5% sample (Fig 3). Therefore, 5% sample
was selected as the best sample for simulation Organic load
studies. Because of the yield is the important thing The organic loading is one of the most important
when considering large scale biogas production. parameters operating an anaerobic digester.
The organic loading provides information on
A number of bacteria are involved in the process of nutrient supply levels of the microorganisms
anaerobic digestion. Anaerobic organisms digest the involved, overload or undersupply of the system as
initial volatile organic matter, which undergoes well as resulting technical and process control
four-stage microbial processes converting it to measures to be taken. Furthermore, it gives an
intermediate molecules including sugars, hydrogen indication of biological degradation of the
& acetic acid before finally methane - biogas is substrates i.e. it describes the efficiency of the
produced. The substrate mix fed to the digester anaerobic digester. The organic load is defined as
results in a specific biogas composition and biogas the amount of volatile organic dry matter entering
yield. the anaerobic digester over time.
pH, VFA, organic load are the main important
As an example: Irregular feeding intervals or
factors considering about biogas production.
overloading the digester leads to an imbalanced
pH and volatile fatty acids system. Acid-forming bacteria have a higher growth
Volatile fatty acids (VFA) level variation was rate than methanogens. Therefore, they respond
digester process stability. VFA concentration will Production of long chain fatty acids and acetic acid
change according to the changes in hydraulic is increased immediately and leads to a drop in pH
loading, organic loading or temperature. (Fig 16). Methanogens don't tolerate pH values
Bacteria involved have different requirements below 6, have a much lower growth rate and cannot
regarding the biochemical environment. Acid- keep up as well in removing acetic acid and
10 ISSN:-2349-3585 |www.ijrdt.org
Paper Title:- The Potential of Biogas from Apple Juice
Anaerobic digestion systems are complex Reactor Temperature
processes that often suffer from instability. Such Constant process temperature is critical to
instability can usually occur as a drop in the successfully operate an anaerobic digester. An
methane production rate, a drop in pH, a rise in increase in temperature leads to increase bacterial
Volatile Fatty Acid (VFA) concentration (Fig 17), activity with higher growth rates, faster metabolism
finally causing a complete digester failure. The and elevated nutrient demand. If the temperature
anaerobic process is more stable when the volatile falls below a certain optimum bacterial metabolism
fatty acid concentrations approach a minimal level, and subsequent biogas production decelerates.
which can be taken as an indication that a sufficient Methane production decreases or is completely
methanogenic population exists and sufficient time stopped. At the same time, CO2 levels rise.
is available to minimize hydrogen and VFA Acid-forming bacteria respond to an increase in
concentrations. The often rate-limiting step is the temperature with accelerated growth and will
conversion of VFAs by the methanogenic outgrow the methanogenic bacteria. Rapid changes
organisms and not the fermentation of soluble in temperature will result in similar effects as
substrates by the fermenting bacteria. sudden increases in organic loading. Therefore a
constant temperature is critical to the anaerobic
Buffer capacity digester. In our experiment temperature kept as 35
When biogas production was finished, the pH of the centigrade.
sludge was measured. This pH value is very low. Biogas Plant design
According to the very low pH, produced biogas Simulation results can be used to determine the
may not be methane. Because low pH values not potential of biogas generation and energy
well for Methanogenesis bacteria. So this gas may generation from apple juice. According to the
be more consists of H2 and CO2. experimental value, approximately 35ml gas/ml
Reasons for this situation (low pH value) can be feed can be assumed as a yield. Our calculation is
assumed as follows. done for the CSTR reactor.
In the experiment, the inoculum was taken from a Various sized CSTR volumes were simulated by
filtered sample of the wastewater treatment plant assuming different HRT values within this range
outlet. Then more buffering agents were lost to the and check the biogas production with simulated
filter cake. Therefore the buffer capacity of the figures. An HRT 10 simulation result was used to
filtrate is low and pH is low. So initial pH of the get the best fit theoretical curve and that simulation
inoculum should be increased by adding buffering and experimental data were used to scale up this
agents before feeding to the reactor or outlet of the complete mix biogas reactor.
wastewater treatment plant should not be filtered for
inoculum.
11 ISSN:-2349-3585 |www.ijrdt.org
Paper Title:- The Potential of Biogas from Apple Juice
At steady state, mixture. Mixers are specially designed according to
fermenter volume and substrate properties like
Feed flow rate = 2m3/day
viscosity ensuring homogenous digester content and
Yield = 35ml gas/ml feed
the rapid distribution of fresh substrate entering the
35𝑚𝑙 𝑥 𝑚3 𝑔𝑎𝑠 digester.
Yield =1 𝑚𝑙 𝑓𝑒𝑒𝑑 = 2 𝑚3 𝑓𝑒𝑒𝑑/𝑑𝑎𝑦
The constant agitation of the liquids enhances
Energy potential from methane (kWh) more with carbohydrates. Therefore the formation
1,503.6 𝑀𝐽/𝑑𝑎𝑦 of NH3 is negligible.
= = 417.7kWh
3.6𝑀𝐽/1𝑘𝑊ℎ
Effect of mixing for biogas yield (Hypothesis Compare Batch, CSTR and UASB
two) A batch system is the simplest form of digestion. A
According to the experiment, there is no significant batch reactor is good for small scale biogas
effect on mixing. Both group results are generation. If the waste production time period is
approximately equal. But theoretically, there is a large, then the batch reactor can be used. Biomass is
good effect with mixing for biogas generation added to the reactor at the start of the process in a
process (not for yield). Mixing is an important batch and is sealed for the duration of the process.
component within the complete mix digester Batch reactors suffer from odour issues that can be
technology helping to maximize homogeneous a severe problem when they are emptied.
12 ISSN:-2349-3585 |www.ijrdt.org
Paper Title:- The Potential of Biogas from Apple Juice
In the CSTR process, organic matter is continuously
supplied to the reactor equipped with an impeller
while the reactor effluent is removed (Fig 18). At
steady state, the inlet flow rate and outlet flow rate
should be equal; otherwise, the tank will overflow
or go empty. It is economically beneficial to operate
several CSTR in series.
Fig 18. CSTR Biogas reactor Fig 19. UASB Biogas reactor
UASB reactor (Fig 19) uses an anaerobic process The key feature of the UASB process that allows
whilst forming a blanket of granular sludge which the use of high volumetric COD loadings compared
suspends in the tank. Feed flows upwards through to other anaerobic processes is the development of a
the blanket and is degraded by the organisms. dense granulated sludge.
The upward flow combined with the settling action
of gravity suspends the blanket with the aid of VII. Conclusion
flocculants. The blanket begins to reach maturity • UASB reactor is the best reactor for apple
around three months. Small sludge granules begin waste biogas generation. Because reactor
aggregations of bacteria. The UASB reactor is one • Mixing is not important for biogas
of the reactor types with high loading capacity. generation and it does not affect the gas
UASB process is a combination of physical & generation yield. But it is important to prevent
biological processes. The main feature of the the accumulating solid particles bottom of the
gases from the liquid and that of biological process • pH, VFA, organic load are the main
is the degradation of decomposable organic matter important factors considering about biogas
under anaerobic conditions. Reactor volume is production. pH should be around 7 for better
smaller than CSTR. So investment cost is low and gas production.
economically friendly [8]. • The anaerobic process is more stable when
the volatile fatty acid concentrations approach
a minimal level.
13 ISSN:-2349-3585 |www.ijrdt.org
Paper Title:- The Potential of Biogas from Apple Juice
15 ISSN:-2349-3585 |www.ijrdt.org
View publication stats