TV Journalism: Basic Guidelines For
TV Journalism: Basic Guidelines For
TV Journalism: Basic Guidelines For
TV Journalism
Introduction
Prepared by
Michael Delahaye
(Consultant)
1
Michael Delahaye is a
consultant/trainer with the Thomson
Foundation, a UK- based organization
which specializes in media training
worldwide. He began his broadcasting
career with the BBC in 1970 as a
Graduate News Trainee. Since then,
he has worked as a reporter,
correspondent and producer in news,
current affairs and documentaries –
mostly for BBC Television. He is also
the author of three novels. In his role
as a media consultant for The
Thomson Foundation, Delahaye works
in more than a dozen countries across
Europe, Africa and Asia, specializing
in Human Rights issues.
• The Story: In choosing a story for television, you should ask four
questions: 1) what is the subject or issue? 2) What is the angle or focus?
3) Do the basic facts and figures support the story? 4) Is it possible to tell
the story in television terms – i.e. do we have or can we get the necessary
pictures? A failure to answer Question 3 before shooting is a particularly
2
common fault. For example, there is no point in making a film about the
shortage of doctors in your country if, upon checking the figures, you
discover that, far from a shortage, the supply of doctors actually exceeds
the demand. All too often, such key information is checked only after
filming has started…too late.
3
• Subjective, Objective: Every shot can be rated on a linear scale
between subjective and objective. Close-ups tend to be more subjective
than wide shots; moving hand-held shots more subjective than static tripod
shots. Ask yourself what style is appropriate to the subject you are dealing
with – and choose accordingly.
• The Tripod: Some cameramen like to hand-hold the camera all the
time. But some shots must be done on a tripod – e.g. a close-up on the
end of a zoom. Insist – but remember that it’s the reporter’s job to carry the
tripod.
4
conflict with some people ‘for’ and others ‘against’, it is useful to have all
the ‘for’s looking in one direction and all the ‘agalnst’s looking in the other.
This makes it easier for the viewer to identify the protagonists and the side
they are on – and also helps when cutting straight from one interview to
another. The impression will be that the protagonists are face-to-face
trading arguments and counter-arguments, as though across a table in a
studio.
• The Line: This is the axis that runs between two people, two objects
or that follows the main line of action. In interviews the line runs between
the noses of the two participants. In a soccer match it follows the line of
play, bisecting the pitch from the centre of one goal to the other. When
filming and editing, avoid ‘crossing the line’ if you possibly can. If you have
to cross it, separate the two shots by a close-up or a shot straight down the
line.
5
the safest is to cast their shadow on a wall and shoot that. Be imaginative
– see photo on last page.
6
the camera helps create a sense of perspective. And if you are doing a
walking stand-up, remember to walk before you talk – just a couple of
paces before you open your mouth to synchronies your words and your
walk. It just looks more natural.
• The Paper Edit: Many reporters hate doing this – because it takes
time. But in fact it saves time. Thinking out on paper the intellectual and
visual structure of your video-report can save hours wasted in the cutting-
room trying ‘to find the story’. Also, if you do a paper edit, you can quickly
see when one element doesn’t lead logically into another – and rearrange
the elements accordingly. This is more difficult, more time-consuming and
more costly to do in the cutting-room – particularly if you are working in
linear mode. The greatest sculptors in history prepared drawings before
7
taking a chisel to the marble. To try to cut a video-report without first doing
a paper-edit is like attacking a block of marble in the belief that ‘there’s a
statue in there somewhere’!
8
• Story-telling: A video-report is a story and should be structured like
one. Remember Jean-Luc Godard’s quote: “Every film should have a
beginning, middle and an end – but not necessarily in that order.” And
remember that most of the best stories are about people – real people.
Always ask yourself: who will be most affected by this issue? If you are
making a video-report about the closure of a television station, don’t talk
only to the General Manager; interview also the workers who will lose their
jobs and the viewers who will lose their favorite programmes.
There are two competing theories about writing for television: ‘Picture-first
Editing’ and ‘Text-first Editing’. Television channels around the world are
divided between those who believe the words are more important when
editing a news video-report and those who believe the pictures are more
.important
:TEXT-FIRST EDITING
9
METHOD: The reporter writes the text [usually after viewing the raw pictures]
and records the text on to tape, leaving spaces for pieces of interview or
‘sound-bites’. The tape-editor then cuts the pictures to the reporter’s recorded
text [and drops in the pieces of interview]. In other words, the tape-editor has
to make the pictures fit the words. If the pictures are too long for the script,
.they have to be shortened; if too short, they have to be lengthened
:PICTURE-FIRST EDITING
METHOD: The pictures are edited first and the reporter then writes his words
to fit the picture sequences that the tape-editor has cut. Finally, he records
.his script against the pictures
ADVANTAGES: The pictures take precedence and are given their full
aesthetic value. Television after all is a visual medium. Generally, the report
.looks more polished and professional
.DISADVANTAGES: The scripting process takes time, skill and practice
1. The reporter views the rushes – i.e. the raw pictures shot by the
cameraman.
2. He writes his text and times each piece of text to the second [if
necessary using a stopwatch]. But he does NOT record his words.
3. He shows his written text, with timings, to the tape-editor. The
tape-editor then cuts the pictures with these in mind.
4. When there is a conflict between the reporter’s text and the
tape-editor’s sequences, the reporter shortens, lengthens, rearranges
or re-writes his words to fit the edited pictures. He may also add
pauses for natural sound to act as a form of punctuation. In
10
exceptional cases he may ask the tape-editor to change or re-edit the
shot(s). But, given a choice between changing the words and
changing the pictures, the reporter should always try first to change his
words.
5. When both the reporter and the tape-editor are satisfied that the
words fit the pictures, the reporter records his text.
• Write the studio introduction first – before you start writing the script.
This will help you focus on the story and will avoid your first piece of text
being a repetition of what has just been said by the presenter in the studio.
It is possible that your news editor will change it but he/she will still be
grateful for your suggestion. Remember: you know your story better than
anyone.
• Generally, scripts are for conveying facts and figures; interviews for
conveying opinion, emotion, anecdotes and examples. This is not an
absolute rule, but a useful guideline.
• Keep your text SHORT! You are not writing a newspaper article. In
television the pictures tell the story. The total length of your script should
be between a third and a half of the total length of the report.
11
• Do not describe what the picture already shows. Don’t tell me what I
can see but why I am seeing it [BBC Trainer, Frank Ash]. For example,
don’t tell me that ‘the President arrived in a large black Mercedes with four
motorbikes’ – when I can see that for myself on the screen.
• Have the pictures in your head as you write the words – like a cinema
projector inside your skull.
• Sometimes the pictures ‘speak for themselves’. If so, let them. There
are times when the best script is no script. Learn to ‘write silence’ [Former
BBC War Correspondent, Martin Bell]
• When leading into an interview, be careful not to say in your script what
is about to be said in the interview.
12
• The last piece of text is the most difficult – because by then you’ve said
everything you have to say. A useful trick is to look forward, to say
something about how the story is likely to develop over the next days,
weeks, months, years. Informed speculation is permissible.
• When you have finished writing, ‘fact-check’ every single word. Pay
particular attention to time references – ‘tomorrow’, ‘this week’, ‘next
month’, etc.
• When recording your script, get the right pace – not too fast, not too
slow. Remember: urgency and importance are conveyed by the tone of
the reporter’s voice not by the speed of his/her delivery.
• Always read your script out loud before recording it. If it sounds like
writing being read, re-write it. If a combination of words is difficult to say,
re-write the words.
• Remember that your script should fit the pictures and take advantage
of natural sound. If you have a choice between changing the words and
changing the pictures, first try to change the words.
INTERVIEW CHECK-LIST –
SETTING UP AN INTERVIEW:
• Be sure you’ve chosen the right person – one with the authority,
experience and knowledge to answer your questions. The boss isn’t
always the best person, though he may think he is.
13
• Don’t be lazy. Don’t take the first person who agrees to be
interviewed. For example, it’s often worth talking to two or three
different ‘experts’ to decide which is best.
• Put the interviewee at ease – don’t let him/her sit alone and ‘boil’.
14
• Beware of sheets of paper in the interviewee’s hand – what is
he/she intending to do with them?
• Safety: Take care with light stands and their cables – particularly
when children are around. A light falling on a person can cause severe
and permanent burns. Remember, you are responsible for safety.
• Avoid swivel chairs – or jam them against the table or desk so the
interviewee cannot swivel.
• Remember that you are aiming for the third dimension. Use
perspective & depth to achieve it.
15
establishing 2-shot over which you can re-voice the first question in
your text.
• Avoid officials sitting behind desks and too close to walls behind.
Get the interviewee out from behind the desk. Consider putting
him/her in front of the desk and use the desk as a background symbol
of authority. If he/she won’t move, move the camera to get a diagonal
shot and so remove the ‘barrier’ created by the desk.
• Tip: frame the background first and then adjust the position of the
interviewee – forward, backward, left, right. The same principle applies
with pieces-to-camera.
• The reporter or producer has the right to ‘check’ the shot for framing
and content. In particular, check for objects ‘growing out’ of
interviewee’s head – lamp-posts, trees, pot plants, etc. This is one of
the most common mistakes.
• Ensure the camera is positioned just behind but close to the reporter
to avoid a profile shot. The viewer must see both eyes of the
interviewee [exception: in-car interviews]. The viewer feels distanced
or cheated if he/she can’t see both eyes.
• Children and old people: try to ensure the camera is on the same
level as them.
16
• To zoom or not to zoom? Communicate with cameraman before.
Generally, zoom on the reporter’s questions only – unless the
interviewee starts to show extreme emotion, such as tears.
17
• Generally, ask ‘open’ questions – ‘How? Why? To what extent?’, etc.
Not questions that can be answered by ‘Yes’ or ‘No’.
• Avoid routine factual questions – these are for text not sync.
• Listen to the answers! It’s easy to stop listening because you are
busy thinking of your next question.
18
• Some reporters like to repeat their questions with the camera on
them, after the ‘master’ interview. This is a potentially dangerous and
unfair practice – particularly if the subject of the interview is political,
sensitive or controversial. It is hard to ensure, for example, that the
words of the question will be repeated accurately, or even the tone of
voice. But it’s acceptable if the subject is non-controversial – e.g. an
interview with an artistic performer or a sports personality.
• Take care that the cameraman doesn’t cross ‘the line’! - particularly
when doing a wide, establishing 2-shot.
19