Heart J: Outcome of Primary Percutaneous Coronary Intervention With Early and Late ST Resolution - Earlier Is Better!
Heart J: Outcome of Primary Percutaneous Coronary Intervention With Early and Late ST Resolution - Earlier Is Better!
Heart J: Outcome of Primary Percutaneous Coronary Intervention With Early and Late ST Resolution - Earlier Is Better!
Pak Heart J
Muhammad Tariq Farman1, Abdul Malik2, Qurban Ali Rahu3, Jawaid Akbar Sial4,
Naveedullah Khan5, Waheed Murad Shaikh6, Tahir Saghir7, Khan Shah Zaman8
1
Department of Cardiology, Jinnah
Medical College Hospital (JMCH), ABSTRACT
Karachi, Pakistan
2 Objective: To compare the outcome of Primary PCI in patients presenting with
Depar tment of Cardiovascular
Surgery, Lady Reading Hospital, early ST resolution versus those presenting late ST resolution after the procedure.
Peshawar Methodology: This observational prospective study was conducted in the
3
Department of Cardiology, People Catheterization Laboratory of a Tertiary Care Cardiovascular Centre of Pakistan.
Medical University, Nawabshah, Those patients who under went primary PCI were enrolled. All patients were pre
Pakistan treated with Aspirin 300 mg, and Clopidogrel 600mg. Platelet glycoprotein IIb IIIa
4
Department of Cardiology, Chandka inhibitor was given in the Catheterization Laboratory before the commencement
Medical College Hospital, Larkana,
Pakistan of procedure. Primary PCI was done in a standard fashion. Procedural details,
5-8 angiographic and electrocardiographic signs were recorded after PCI and clinical
Department of Cardiology, NICVD,
Karachi, Pakistan follow up was documented up to 1 year.
Address for Correspondence: Results: A total of 150 consecutive patients underwent primary PCI. 112 patients
Dr. Muhammad Tariq Farman, showed ST resolution within 60 minutes while 38 patients showed ST resolution
after 60 minutes. Patients with early ST resolution showed significant procedural
C-45, Block-2, KAECHS, Karachi, success (100 % vs. 94.7 %; P=0.014), and stable follow up at 30 days (92 % vs.
Pakistan 50 %; P= <0.001) and one year (88.3 % vs. 60.6 %; P=< 0.001). Mortality at
E-Mail: tariqfarman@yahoo.com 30 days was significantly lower (0.9% vs. 7.9 %; P=0.019) in patients with early
ST resolution while coronary artery bypass surgery was also significantly lower
Date Received: November 17, 2014
at 30 days (1.7 % vs. 15.8 %; P=0.001) and one year (2.7 % vs. 15.8 %;
Date Revised: December 23, 2014
P=0.004). Patients with late ST resolution were significantly aged (54.5±8.1 vs.
Date Accepted:December 26, 2014
50.4±12.9; P=0.023), more diabetic (39.5 % vs. 19.6 %; P=0.014), having
Contribution longer (>120 minutes) chest pain to ER time (34.2 % vs. 17.9%; P=0.03), and
All the authors contributed significantly having diffusely diseased vessels (73.7% vs. 52.7%; P=0.023). Three vessel
to the research that resulted in the disease was also more frequently seen in patients with late ST resolution (36.9%
submitted manuscript. vs. 17.9%; P=0.015).
All authors declare no conflict of Conclusion: Outcome of patients showing early ST resolution is significantly
interest. better than those showing late ST resolution. Elderly, diabetes, longer chest pain
This article may be cited as: Farman to ER time and diffuse three vessel disease are associated with late ST resolution.
MT, Malik A, Rahu QA, Sial JA, Khan N, Key Words: Outcome, Primary Percutaneous Coronary Intervention, ST
Shaikh WM, et al. Outcome of primary Resolution
percutaneous coronary intervention
with early and late ST resolution -
earlier is better! Pak Hear t J
2014;48(01):42-47.
occlusion but with delay, 3 - normal complete perfusion of ST resolution was defined as any resolution or no resolution
entire vessel without any delay. 13 after 60 minutes of Primary PCI. Complete ST resolution
was defined as ≥ 70% ST resolution compared to baseline
TMP grades were defined as: Zero - minimal or no
ECG. No ST segment resolution was defined as persistent
myocardial blush, 1 - dye stains the myocardium and this
ST segment elevation or ≤ 30 % resolution of ST segment.15
stain persists on the next injection, 2 - dye enters the
myocardium but washes out slowly and strongly persists at Patients were followed in outpatient department (OPD) after
the end of injection, 3 - normal entrance and exit of dye in the one month, and at 1 year. Those patients who could not
myocardium.14 come in OPD, they were contacted through telephone and
follow up documented.
Early ST resolution was defined as ≥ 50% ST segment
resolution within 60 minutes of primary PCI, whereas, late All the data was entered and analyzed through SPSS
version17. Categorical variables like gender, diabetes,
Table 1: Baseline Demographic and Angiographic features hypertension, smoking, history of previous MI, cardiogenic
of Patients Underwent Primary PCI within 60 and shock, inotropic support, IABP, infarction territory, route of
after 60 Minutes of ST Resolution access etc were presented in frequencies and percentages.
ST Resolution ST Resolution Whereas continuous variables like age, height, weight, BMI,
Variables within 60 mins after 60 mins P-value symptom onset to ER and door to balloon time were
n=112 n=38 presented as mean ± SD. Chi square test was used for
Age in years [Mean ±SD] 50.4 +12.9 54.5 +8.1 0.023 significant association. Independent t-test for normally
Gender Male 103 (92%) 32 (84%) 0.169
distributed data and Mann Whitney U test were used for not
normally distributed data to compare mean (±SD) values of
Height in cm [Mean ±SD] 172.2 +7.1 170 +7.2 0.093
with and without aspiration of thrombus. P-value < 0.05
Weight in Kg [Mean ±SD] 77.8 +12.2 75.8 +8.4 0.281 was considered as statistically significant.
Diabetes 22 (19.6%) 15 (39.5%) 0.014
RESULTS
Hypertension 54 (48%) 16 (42%) 0.514
Table 2: Procedural Characteristics of the Groups of Patients STR group was worse than the early STR group. They were
Underwent Primary PCI Showing ST Resolution aged and majority of them having diabetes, multivessel
within 60 and After 60 Minutes disease and type C lesions. As a result this was not
surprising when they demonstrated a poor prognosis and
ST Resolution ST Resolution quite a few of them showed a suboptimal TIMI flow grades
Variables within 60 mins after 60 mins P-value immediately after PCI (Table 2). It is a well known fact that
n=112 n=38
aged population has got worse atherosclerotic
Grade of stenosis cardiovascular disease. They have poor microvasculature,
Total (100 %) 66 (59%) 26 (68.4%) 0.298 and badly diseased endothelium that may not be responded
well even following the restoration of coronary blood flow
Sub-total (91-99%) 11 (10%) 04 (10.5%) 0.900
after the primary PCI.16, 17 Similarly, diabetes badly damages
Severe (70-90%) 35 (31%) 08 (21.1%) 0.229 the vascular system in general and microvasculature in
Lesion length particular. Therefore, even after the restoration of coronary
vessel myocardium may not be well perfused due to
≤ 20 mm 71 (63.4%) 22 (58%) 0.546 diseased microvasculature and hence, late STR ensued.18
> 20 mm 41 (36.6%) 16 (42%) Recent studies have shown the increased risk of major
Size of culprit artery adverse cardiovascular events after primary PCI in case of
multivessel disease if the other vessels are not
≤ 3 mm 36 (32%) 10 (26.3%) 0.501
intervened.19,20 Therefore recently published landmark
> 3 mm 73 (68%) 28 (73.7%) Complete versus Lesion-only Primary PCI Trial (CvLPRIT)
Clot retrieved 38 (34%) 14 (37%) 0.752 study have shown a 55% reduction in major adverse
cardiovascular events in those patients presenting for
Adenosine used 23 (20.5%) 09 (23.7%) 0.682 primary percutaneous coronary interventions when the non-
Size of stent deployed
Table 3: Outcomes of the Patients Underwent
≤ 20 mm 49 (43.7%) 13 (34.2%) 0.303
Primary PCI within 60 and After
> 20 mm 48 (42.9%) 16 (42.1%) 0.939 60 Minutes of ST Resolution
> one stent 09 (8%) 07 (18.4%) 0.079 ST Resolution ST Resolution
06 (5.4%) 02 (5.3%) 0.999
Variables within 60 mins after 60 mins P-value
stenting not done n=112 n=38
TIMI flow Immediate after Procedure
Zero – I 67 (59.8%) 25 (65.8%) 0.514 Stable 103 (92%) 19 (50%) < 0.001
II & III 45 (40.2%) 13 (34.2%) 0.514 CABG 02 (1.7%) 06 (15.8%) 0.001
showing late or no STR after primary PCI is dismal. This MACE 03 (2.7%) 01 (2.6%) 0.999
group did not show stable follow up and encountered more Death 01 (0.9%) 03 (7.9%) 0.019
frequent adverse cardiac events like CABG and death. This
Lost follow up 03 (2.7%) 09 (23.7%) < 0.001
finding is consistent with previous studies in which the same
issue of STR was addressed. It was previously reported that Follow up after 1 year
patients with early STR had more preserved LVEF and Stable 99 (88.3%) 23 (60.6%) < 0.001
smaller infarct size compared to patients with late or no
STR.9 Therefore it is understandable if the patients with late CABG 03 (2.7%) 06 (15.8%) 0.004
STR showed poor outcome results in our study. MACE 05 (4.5%) 01 (2.6%) 0.630
Within 60 minutes of time window three fourths (74.7%) of Death 04 (3.6%) 04 (10.5%) 0.093
our patients showed satisfactory STR. While 28 (18.7%)
Lost follow up 01 (0.9%) 04 (10.5%) 0.005
patients showed STR after 60 minutes and 10 (6.7%)
patients did not show any resolution. The risk profile of late PCI=Percutaneous coronary intervention; CABG=Coronary artery bypass grafting;
MACE=Major adverse cardiovascular events
Table 4: Comparison Between ST Resolution between the government and health care authorities.
within & after 60 Mins Who's Door to
Balloon Time < 90 mins CONCLUSION
Outcome of patients showing early ST resolution is
ST Resolution ST Resolution significantly better than those showing late ST resolution.
Variables within 60 mins after 60 mins P-value Elderly age, diabetes, longer chest pain to ER time and
n=55 n=23
diffuse three vessel disease are associated with late ST
Age in years [Mean ±SD] 50.1 ± 12.6 53.6 ± 8.8 0.165
resolution. Outcome of late presenter (patients who have
Gender Male 49 (89%) 20 (87%) 0.999 longer chest pain to ER time) remains poor even after
achieving standard DBT of 90 minutes.
Height in cm [Mean ±SD] 172.1 ± 7.3 168.8 ± 7.3 0.072
Diabetes 11 (20%) 08 (35%) 0.165 Authors wish to thanks Mr. Jaffer Bin Baqar for his help in
data management and analysis.
Hypertension 26 (47%) 10 (43.5%) 0.759