Day Trading Stocks - The Market - Meir Barak
Day Trading Stocks - The Market - Meir Barak
Day Trading Stocks - The Market - Meir Barak
Foreword
The Crash
Upward Trend
It was harder than I imagined!
Score: 1-0 for the Market
The Breakthrough
Success!
Who Is This Book For?
Introduction
The Stock Exchange Is for Pros
Stock Exchange or Casino?
Who Knows How the Market Will Move?
For Success, Advantage is Vital
Precise Knowledge or Art?
The Difference between Trade and Investment
What Will You Learn from This Book?
What’s Needed for Success?
How Much Can I Earn?
How Many of You Will Make It?
Chapter 1 - Allow Me to Introduce You… to the
Stock Exchange
Who Needs the Stock Exchange?
What is a Stock?
The Stock Exchange’s Early Days
The Netherlands
London
The First Bubble
Wall Street – The Wall and the Money
Establishing the SEC – Securities and Exchange
Commission
Meet the Stock Exchanges
The New York Stock Exchange (NYSE)
The AMEX Stock Exchange
Founding NASDAQ
Crises
The Great Depression: Black Monday and Tuesday,
1929
Black Monday, 1987
The Dot-Com Crisis
The Credit Crunch (Sub-Prime)
Crises of the Past Decade (S&P 500 Index)
Crises and Traders
Who’s Selling to You?
“Market Makers”
Specialists
The ECN Revolution
Chapter 2 - Day Trading and How to Get Started
Eight Stages on Your Path to Success
Hardware, Software, and the Internet
The Advantage of the Group: Using Trading Rooms
Your Guide to Opening a Trading Account
How to Open an Account with a Broker
Can Your Bank Be Your Broker?
How to Choose a Broker
How to Choose a Trading Platform
With Which Brokers Should You Never Work?
Should You Trade on Margin?
How Much Should be Deposited in the Trading Account?
Chapter 3- Market Analysis Fundamentals
The Price Says it All!
The Market Is Always Right!
Market Forces: Bidders and Askers
“Go in! Go in!”… When Does the Public Buy?
The Role of the Professional
Science or Art?
Who’s Afraid of Technical Analysis?
So What Is Technical Analysis?
Fundamental Economic Analysis: What Does ItIncorporate?
Fundamental Economic Analysis Versus TechnicalAnalysis
Why Do I Never the less Use Fundamental EconomicAnalysis?
Chapter 4 - The Chart: Money’s Footprint
How to Read Millions of Peoples' Thoughts
Line Chart
Point and Figure Chart
Bar Chart
Japanese Candlestick Chart
Presentation of Candles over Varying Lengths of Time
Chapter 5 - Principles of Technical Analysis
The Basis
The Trend
Defining the Trend
Support and Resistance
When Support Turns into Resistance, and Vice Versa
High and Low Points
Analyzing Japanese Candles
Narrow Range Candle
Wide Range Candle
Candle Tail
Reversal Patterns
Common Reversal Patterns
When to Hit the Button
Breakout and Breakdown Patterns
Bull Flag
Bear Flag
Cup and Handle Formation
Inverse Cup and Handle
Head and Shoulders
Inverse Head and Shoulders
Pennant
Chapter 6 - Indices, Sectors and Crystal Balls
How to Predict Movement
The Most Important Market Index: S&P 500
SPY – The S&P 500 ETF
ES – The S&P 500 Futures
Should You Trade in Futures?
What is the ES Symbol?
Summary: SPX, SPY, ES
NASDAQ 100: The Second Most Important Index
NASDAQ 100 Symbol
NASDAQ 100 ETF: QQQ
NASDAQ 100 Futures Contract: NQ
The Forgotten Index: Dow Jones, DJI
The Dow Jones ETF: DIA
The Dow Jones Futures Contract: YM
Rebalance: How to Profit from Index Updates
Sectors and Industries
Chapter 7 - Indicators: The Trader’s Compass
Volume of Trade
Volume Precedes Price
Average Volume
What Volume Changes Mean
How to Interpret Volume Increase Prior to Daily Breakout
How to Interpret Volume Increase Prior to IntradayBreakout
How to Interpret Volume in an Uptrend
How to Interpret Volume in a Downtrend
How to Interpret Large Volume without Any PriceMovement
How to Interpret Large Volume at the Daily High
How to Interpret Climactic Volume at the Intraday High
Moving Averages
“Fast” and “Slow” Averages
How to Apply the MA
The Unique Significance of the 200MA
Oscillators
The Relative Strength Index – RSI
The MACD Index
Fibonacci Sequence
Bollinger Bands
TRIN
TICK
The VWAP Indicator
PIVOT POINTS
Which Indicators Should You Use?
Chapter 8 - Shorts: Profit from Price Drops
Crises always provided the best opportunities.
The History of Shorts
Shorting: Why?
Shorts for Advanced Traders
Short Squeeze
Naked Shorts
Chapter 9 - The Trading Platform
Practical Steps to Choosing, Configuring, and Operating Your
Trading Platform
My Trading Platform
Choosing a Trading Platform
First Activation and Screen Configuration
Screen Configuration
1 – The Main Stock Chart
2 – The Market Index Chart
3 – The Secondary Chart
4 – The Trade Window
5 – The T&S Window – Time & Sales
6 – The Account Manager Window
7 – The Trade Manager Window
The Trading Orders
Limit
Market order
Stop order
Complex Orders
Order Routing
Routing to Different Destinations
Automated Routing
Manual Routing
Adding and Removing Liquidity
The Trading Room
Chapter 10 - Winning Trades
It’s Time To Click the Button: Best Entry and Trade Management
Methods
How to be a Breakout Winner
Consolidation
Planning and Execution
What is the Stock Volume?
How and When to Click that Button
Buying Before Breakout
Pre-Breakout Volume
The Fear of Clicking the Button
When to Sell?
How Much to Buy? To Sell?
What Happens When a Breakout Fails?
How to Short at Breakdowns
Winner Reversals
When are Reversals Preferable to Breakouts andBreakdowns?
Entering a Reversal: Market Rules
The Entry Point
Trading Gaps
Gaps Almost Always Close
Why Do Gaps Form?
Why Do Gaps Close?
Never Chase Gaps
Gaps in Dual Stocks
Market Index Gaps
Trading the QQQ
Scalping
When are Scalps Executed?
The Scalping Technique
The One Cent Scalp
The Little Red Riding Hood Trap
Pre and Post-Market Trading
Using VWAP at Opening of Trade
Taking Advantage of Round Numbers
Trading Small Caps
How Can Small Caps Be Found?
The Russell 2000 – Market Index for Small Caps
Reciprocal Range Play
Trading at Financial Reports and Announcements
How to Take Advantage of Retest
The Top Down Analysis Method
Chapter 11 - Risk Management
Learning to Play Defense
Fundamental Risks
Risk Management and Loss Management
Fundamental Capital Risk
Psychological Risk
Leverage Risk
Technical Risk
Exposure-derived Risk
The “Stop Loss” Protective Order
Not All Stop Orders are Stop-loss Orders
How to Set the Stop Point
The Importance of the Stop
Time-based Stop
The Five-Minute Reversal Stop
Hard Stop or Mental Stop
Risk Reward Ratio
Money Management
The 3x3 Method
Noise Cancelling
Points, Not Percentages – Quantity, Not Sums of Money
Learn from Your Experiences…Keep a Diary
Chapter 12 - Choosing a Winner Stock
From the Thousands of Stocks Traded, how Can We Choose the
Best?
Using Analysts’ Reports
Managing a Watch List
Following Up on “Stocks in the News”
Mergers & Acquisitions
Staying Loyal to a Stock
Intraday Search for Stocks
Using Special Stock Screening Platforms
Chapter 13 - How to Get Ready for Your First Day
of Trading
Important Tips Before You Click the Button for the First Time
Ever
Starting Slowly
Making Millions…with a Demo
Preparing for the Day of Trading, Step by Step
How Much Time Should You Devote to Preparation?
Will the Market Go Up or Down?
The Workday Components
Chapter 14 - The Demons are Coming!
Market Psychology
Behavioral Models
Are You Psychologically Suited to Trading?
Take Maximum Advantage of Your Tuition Fees
Succeeding…the Wrong Way
Handling Loss
Identifying Loss-Derived Behaviors
Know Thy External Foe
And Know, Too, Thy Home-Grown Foe!
The Rules of Psychological Conduct
The Top Ten: 10 Things Failing Traders Say
Chapter 15 - Special Occasions, Special Rules
Prepare for the Expectable
The Last Day of the Week
Options Expiration Days
Interest Rate Day
End of Quarter Window Dressing
The Market at Year’s End
Holidays
Chapter 16 - Preparedness and Empowerment
The Fear of Taking Risks
Self-confidence
Boosting Self-esteem through Internal Communication
External Communication
Aspiring to Be Powerful
Knowledge and Action
A Role Model
Believing in Success
Coping with Obstacles
Commitment to Success
Control Your Mood
Controlling Frustration
Accepting Responsibility
Do You Like Your Job?
Preparedness and Opportunity
Success is an Avalanche
So, Make a Decision!
Meir Barak
Contento de Semrik
Meir Barak
THE MARKET WHISPERER
A New Approach to Stock Trading
All rights reserved. No part of this book may be translated, reproduced, stored
in a retrieval system or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic,
photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior permission
in writing from the author and publisher.
ISBN: 978-965-550-310-4
Please Note: The information presented in this book is for learning purposes only. None of
the content is to be seen as recommendations to be followed precisely, but as general concepts
intended to expand your knowledge and personal abilities. The author is not responsible for
any direct and/or indirect damage that may be caused as a result of any topic detailed in this
book. None of the information in this book is to be seen as an investment recommendation or
as an alternative to individually adapted consultancy. Meir Barak does not offer investment or
profile consultancy, and may hold or activate stocks mentioned in this book. In any event, it is
recommended you contact a legal, financial, or professional qualified consultant. Stock
trading is not suited to everyone, and is considered a tough field.
Dedicated with love to my dear partner Carina and our gorgeous
girls Sharon, Adi and Arielle, who are always supportive and have
never doubted me, no matter what idea I came up with (and there
were many) or how crazy it sounded.
To all of you who are willing to turn your lives around in order to
succeed
Foreword
The Crash
In my thirty-sixth year, I became a penniless father of three little girls,
the youngest of whom was three months old. The business I’d
nurtured for thirteen years had just slipped between my fingers.
Identifying the brewing problems before I did, my business partner
had embezzled the last few thousands of dollars left in our bank
accounts. Our employees jumped ship. I was saddled with a debt of
some half-million dollars to banks and suppliers. What did I have in
abundance? Tears.
To fall so low is a situation I’d wish upon no one. Money pressures,
I quickly discovered, cause psycho-emotional pressures: depression
that manifests in loss of appetite, lack of motivation to work, and a
growing inability to sleep. I had no clue how to cope with these
problems. All the business management literature I’d been exposed to
dealt with “how to succeed” and “how to earn millions.” But when did
you ever see a book of tips for those owing millions? No doubt this is
because “losers” aren’t expected to write books and are not assumed to
have interesting life stories. And who would want to read a loser’s
story, anyhow…
Fascinatingly, all the business consultants who’d earned income
from me over the years evaporated as soon as the fountains of money
dried up. I’d hoped that at least the police would help in retrieving the
funds my partner had stolen; I hoped in vain. With very apparent
indifference, they completed the complaint forms, had me sign a
declaration, and sent me away to fend for myself. Three years later,
when I decided to lodge a complaint against the police department’s
handling of my file, an investigator called me in and threatened that if
I didn’t withdraw my objections, I’d be charged with submitting a false
claim. Clearly, all the taxes I’d paid over the years were also of no avail
in protecting me.
The downward spiral continued. Initially, banks sent me politely-
worded payment demands. Next, lawyers sent somewhat less polite
letters. They wanted their money, and they wanted it pronto. They,
too, began to air threats while foreclosing my accounts and
simultaneously adding fuel to the fire with more fines, commissions,
and interest at gray market rates. In less than a year, a half-million
dollars ballooned into one million. What does one do? How can the
debt be covered? What about the house and mortgage? How can
interest be repaid when it charges ahead at the speed of a red Ferrari
Turbo?
Most people who find themselves in this situation declare
bankruptcy, raise their hands in despair, and disappear from the
market. Today, I understand them. Very few of them ever return to
business activities. But I was never part of the majority crowd. Instead,
I took the advice of a lawyer who deftly gave me one of the best, most
effective pearls of wisdom I had ever heard: “Don’t seek the protection
of the courts of law. Don’t deny the debts. Admit they exist, speak to
the debtors, reach an arrangement, and pay them off!”
I did as he had suggested. The banks gave me some breathing
space, reduced the debts and interest, and left me some room to
maneuver, hoping that I’d repay the debts. That was all I needed.
Instead of weeping over my bitter plight, their flexibility was a huge
motivator to return to business activities and take my future in hand.
Upward Trend
It was 2000, the slowdown of the tempestuous hi-tech run-up to Y2K.
A short while before the dot-com bubble burst, I held rich business
experiences and numerous ideas for innovative Internet products that
would conquer the world during the period when millions of dollars
still flowed freely to Internet startups. Within just a few short months,
I established a fantastic startup, recruited partners, and raised several
million dollars. Money was flowing again.
The hi-tech life was good to me. But like so many others in hi-tech,
especially after the bubble had burst, the market collapsed, and
investor funds ran dry, I felt as though I was stuck in one place. I was
bored with waking up early every morning, getting to work before
traffic started, returning home late after the traffic jams, and catching
up with my family pretty much only on weekends. I experienced a
mini-crisis one day when my wife asked me to take our little girl to
kindergarten, which I happily did. But when we arrived, my daughter
turned to me and said, “Daddy, that was my kindergarten two years
ago…”
I sought a way to leave the rat race, pay back my debts, and make
that one big hit. I also wanted to move into a lower gear and be closer
to my family. In short, I wanted to make millions without working too
hard.
There are very few legal ways to earn large sums quickly. I reviewed
the options, and chose an area I’d always loved: stock trading. From
short-term trading, so I’d heard, you could get rich quick.
I did very well. Within five years I was able to leave hi-tech, repay
all my debts, and become very comfortable. I went from a negative
balance of millions of dollars to a surplus of several million. I live the
American dream. The stock market made my dream come true. How
did it happen?
The Breakthrough
Call me persistent, call me stubborn, but I wouldn’t give in. I
continued buying, selling, and losing for almost an entire year. As time
passed, more and more questions surfaced, yet remained unanswered.
A year of losses taught me one certain thing: trading is a profession
like any other, and like all professions, you need to learn to become
successful. I set out looking for help.
To be a stock trader, you don’t need a diploma. Everyone can open
an account, trade, and make pointless moves, just like I did. That’s
also why most traders fail. I knew there were those who succeeded,
however, and I believed I could find ways to become part of that group.
I sought them. I found them.
Before the Internet, trading rooms could be found throughout the
United States. This is where traders met, working together as
professionals. In today’s Internet age, most trading rooms have closed
down, and activities have moved to chat rooms which any trader can
join for a monthly fee. These rooms are where you can hear
professional traders, whom we at Tradenet call “analysts,” discuss
trends, listen to their instructions, ask questions and basically trade
with them in real time without ever leaving your home. I was so happy
to join one of those trading rooms, and immediately felt like I’d come
to the right place.
What an amazing world I’d discovered. The analysts bought and
sold, in real time, successfully. Two analysts, Mark and Chris, are well
known and have become my friends. They are the people to whom I
owe most of my basic training. It seemed my path to success was
paved. All I needed to do now was to listen to the analysts and copy
their moves. So simple!So why was it so difficult?
What can be so difficult about copying a professional trader’s
actions? The answer is simple: because we all have our own level of
comprehension about what is unfolding before us, and we decide to
do things differently for our own reasons. Here’s an example: Chris
buys a stock that goes up 4% today, based on his feeling that it will
continue to rise, whereas I think, “Is he crazy? He’s going to lose. It’s
already gone up a lot!” Over time I saw that whenever I couldn’t
precisely understand Chris’s decision, I couldn’t accept it either.
During that period, my trades looked more or less like this: Chris
bought. I bought. I flee with my small profit, afraid to lose what I’d
already profited. Chris waits, and makes a handsome profit. In other
instances, when the stock was trending down, Chris would quickly get
out, while I would stay, hoping that it would come back to my cost.
Eventually, I’d be forced to exit with an unpleasant loss. In short, Chris
would profit and I’d lose. Yes. It was definitely time to start learning.
Statistics famously tout the figure that 90% of active traders lose
money. If you are among them, the solution is simple: do exactly the
opposite of what you think. At first I had trouble figuring the upside
down logic of the profession. I found that precisely those stock trades
I considered risky, if not downright dangerous, revealed themselves as
the biggest winners, whereas the ones I would choose and which
appeared to be less scary and more reliable, were less successful. Of
course, in my early trading history, I chose only those that failed.
But over time, I also discovered this tendency was not exclusive to
me. It’s very natural for an experienced trader to view the market
completely different than a beginner. To succeed, the beginner needs
to learn the basic principles, and slowly undergo a psychological
revolution. Because I’d skipped the stage of learning fundamentals and
jumped straight into the deep end, I concluded that I needed to
understand the market. It was time to “go back to the drawing board”
and learn the basics.
I knew what I had to do. I contacted Chris, the head analyst of the
trading room, presented myself as a member, and asked him to be my
personal mentor. I was very happy when he agreed, and we settled on
a fee. I packed a bag and took the first flight out to his home in
Phoenix, Arizona.
I remember our first meeting like it was yesterday. I was shocked to
meet a “boy” in his early thirties, who already had many years of Wall
Street experience under his belt serving as a “market maker” for a
well-known trading company, and later as an independent, successful
day trader. Two black cars, both Lexus models, were parked at his
luxurious home in a wealthy suburb of Phoenix, making it perfectly
clear with whom I was dealing. Chris came from an average family,
and had made most of his money as a day trader. Like so many others
I met over the years, Chris left an excellent job that brought him
hundreds of thousands of dollars each year, in order to earn his own
way as a day trader!
SMART The market operates according to known
rules. There is no need to invent a new
MONEY method in order to earn money. Just adopt
the existing ones.
Success!
Within just a few months of my return home, I went from losing to
breaking even, and then from breaking even to profit. Some two years
after I made my first transaction, I succeeded in generating a monthly
income that allowed me to leave my job. Within just a few years, I
moved from hi-tech employment to the freedom of a home on the sea,
playing golf, swimming in my private pool--and no more than two to
three hours a day of pleasant trading. I had just achieved the
American dream.
I was proud of my achievements and loved trading, but more than
all else, I enjoyed teaching new traders. At first I taught several friends
at home, using the same method Chris had taught me. Friends I’d
taught for free brought their friends, who became paying members.
Some were from the hi-tech realm who wanted precisely what I had
done: to change the course of their lives.
They studied, they traded, and they joined the trading room
alongside Chris and Mark, until that remarkable moment when most
of the trading room’s members were… my students! At this stage I was
awarded a position as an analyst, together with Chris and Mark.
Example
Let’s examine what might have happened had you bought the ETF
(Exchange Traded Fund) of the S&P 500 known as SPY in January
1999, and sold it in August 2011:
In January 1999, you would have paid the identical amount for this
ETF as in August 2011, whereas in that same timeframe, you could have
received a risk-free yield from any bank of at least 50% based on
interest rates at the time.
The Mid-Term
A range of several weeks to months is the inherent advantage for
hedge funds. They operate with large sums, making it difficult for
them to maneuver in the short term, and they are justifiably fearful of
the long term. Due to the capital they hold, they can support stock
prices for periods of time, which increases their chance of profit. Their
advantage is in shifting large amounts of money and being somewhat
skilled at knowing where money is currently flowing. Although
sometimes they also lose.
The Short Range
The very short term, measured in seconds or minutes, is the market
makers’ and specialists’ advantage, which we will learn more about
later. They, in contrast to the rest of the general public, pay no
commissions. They receive the commissions! Because their role
involves coordinating real-time buy and sell commands, they know far
better than we do which direction the wind is blowing, and they take
advantage of the very short term. You will never find them buying a
stock because they believe in the company’s product or management!
An Example of “Advantage”
When long-term investors want to protect their investment in a stock,
they generally use a protective “stop order,” which will automatically
perform a sale if the stock price drops lower than a specific figure. The
stock exchange’s hours of activity overlap the working hours of the
average investor, making it difficult for such a person to constantly
follow the price movementin real time. The average investor relies on
the broker to carry out the automated stop order.
How does that help us? Average investors, whom we will call “retail
investors,” review their investments at the end of each week and place
protective stop orders into the system according to the price
movement during the week that passed. These stop orders await
automatic execution while the retail investors are at their day jobs.
The automated stop orders will be executed when the preset
conditions appear.
Our advantage:
• Looking at the stock’s graph, it’s easy to estimate the point where
automated stop orders will be executed. Can this information be
used to someone’s advantage? Of course it can!
• Let’s say that at a certain price, we see a strong chance for a heavy
concentration of stop orders.
• In other words, if the stock price drops to this figure, a large number
of stop orders will go live, which could likely push the stock price
down further.
• Can we profit from the expected drop? Of course! We can sell “short”
(which we’ll learn more about later) and profit from the price drop.
This is how making use of information can be an advantage.
I relate to stock trading just as any other business. I won’t trade
without an advantage. I know that competitors are operating against
me and want my money no less than I want theirs. I know that to
survive and profit, I must identify my advantage and maximize it. I
recommend that you, too, relate to your money with due respect and
conduct yourselves accordingly.
Welcome!
… to the fascinating world of stock trading. It’s the most realistic
virtual reality on earth, a reality in which every person with a
computer and Internet access can earn a living from any location in
the world. It’s the fairest profession in the world, in which everyone
has the chance to become a millionaire through his or her own
personal capabilities, without regard to race, gender, age, nationality,
or language. Best of luck!
Chapter 1 - Allow Me to Introduce
You… to the Stock Exchange
e Stock Exchange: My Place of Work
A Devoted Fan
We’re such strange creatures. We identify with our city, root for our
favorite football team, and even feel proud of our place of work, as
long as our salary keeps rolling in. The stock exchange is my place of
work, and it makes me feel proud. It’s because of traders like me that
it continues to exist and flourish. I contribute to its existence by
increasing trading volume, and in return, I get the chance to earn my
income. As future fans, here’s the history of your future place of work.
What is a Stock?
The IPO is an event in which a company sells shares of stock to the
public in return for the public’s money. What is a stock? It’s a
document that gives its owner the right to a part of the company.
When a company is formed, the company’s owners decide the number
of shares that comprise the company. If this is a new company, with no
performance, we can presume the value of its shares is zero. Once the
company begins operations, accumulating contracts, patents, income
and profit, its value rises. The value of its shares rises accordingly. But
the “value of a stock” is an abstract concept. A company’s transactions
fluctuate frequently, which makes it difficult to determine the true
value of its stock.
When a company offers shares to the public, it is selling part of its
stock. The sale is a recruitment of money by the company which the
company does not need to return. Buyers believe they are purchasing
cheaply, and hope that in the future they will sell for more. From this
point on, the shares are traded between buyers and sellers who for the
most part are not the company’s original owners. To protect the
interests of both buyers and sellers, and to improve reliability and
create greater fluidity, it was decided that stock trading would be
conducted within the controlled environment of the stock exchange.
Can any company offer shares to the public and become a
“public company?” No. A company wishing to recruit money through
the stock exchange must meet tough criteria related to sales turnover,
profits, and financial stability. Not every company needing money is
interested in going public, because after making the offering, it will
need to continue upholding tough regulatory standards which might
limit its progress; it will be required to become transparent, which
exposes its secrets to the public including its competitors. This is a
costly endeavor, and the company will also be required to include the
public that holds its shares in its decision-making processes. In short,
there are no free lunches.
The Stock Exchange’s Early Days
The Netherlands
The essential difference in this case was the fact that from the outset,
the company’s stocks were meant to be sold to the public. In actuality
the public had little impact on the company’s management, which
remained in the managers’ control. The Dutch East India Company
was highly successful and for decades, from its inception through 1650,
paid its stockholders an average annual dividend of 16%. Over the
years, additional public companies were established in Amsterdam,
and stock trading took on an organizational nature. In 1688, the first
book in history dealing with stock trading was published. Its author,
Joseph de la Vega, was a successful Spanish-Jewish trader. He wrote
the book using a dialogue format between a stock holder, a trader, and
a philosopher. The book described in fine detail the relatively
ingenious conduct of the Amsterdam Bourse, and even offered
valuable tips to its readers.
London
Some few years later in London, 1693, the first bonds began to be
traded. Immediately afterwards, several British public companies
began trading. London’s first stock traders operated in coffee shops on
Change Street, adjacent to the Royal Exchange, the trading center they
were not allowed to enter because of their known “bad habits.” In
1698, one John Casting, whose preferred spot was in “Jonathan’s Coffee
House,” began hanging a list of stocks and their prices outside the
coffee house. This list is considered the first milestone in establishing
London’s stock exchange.
Wall Street has taken on many different semblances since its first
transaction. Most of the changes arose from the ongoing struggle
between two immensely powerful parties: the investment houses and
the government. The former has constantly sought to operate without
supervision, taking advantage of any and every opportunity for
stretching their long arms deep into the public’s pocket. They have
never been averse to any dirty trick: trading with insider knowledge,
disseminating misinformation or incorrect data through media
channels, or organizing raids on a specific stock are all examples of the
commonly-known methods of manipulation that have made Wall
Street professionals so loathsome to the public. More than two
centuries after Wall Street’s establishment, the 2008 financial crisis
shows us that nothing has changed.
In 1789, to cover debts of the government and its colonies, the first
United States Congress, via its central bank, issued what were known
as Treasury Bonds to the value of $80 million. These were sold to the
general public. In those days, Manhattan’s population numbered
around 34,000 and Wall Street was still an unpaved dirt road. Along its
sides, trading houses stood and transacted international commodity
sales. Very quickly, Wall Street’s trading houses also began selling
lottery tickets, stocks, and bonds. The hottest items during that
period, and in fact the item around which speculative trading began,
were bonds. In those days, a person wishing to buy or sell stocks or
bonds had to issue a public notice or sell to friends. As demand
developed, two renowned trading houses of the time, Leonard
Bleecker at 16 Wall Street, and Sutton & Harry at 20 Wall Street, began
holding supplies of bonds and stocks.
Stock trading began to develop. Investors assisted in setting up and
developing companies by investing their money in return for a Deed
of Shares confirming their investment in writing and providing them
with a holding in part of the company. These deeds served as security
and proof of ownership, and assured the investor’s stock in the
company. This led to several synonyms that would come into use over
time, among them Securities (signifying they were securely held by
their owner) and Equities (indicating entitlement to part of the
capital).
In March of 1792, a New York trader named William Duer, who also
served as the US Assistant Secretary of the Treasury at the time, was
investing in a scheme to buy up the US debt to France at a discount.
The plan failed and Duer lost his entire wealth and more, but the
ramifications of his failed investments contributed to the Panic of
1792, where he fell into bankruptcy. The term “crash” was applied to
these events. It was one of many that would take their place in Wall
Street’s history. Following this crash, traders decided to
institutionalize their activities and establish one place where it would
be possible to control and document all transactions. In May of 1792,
the traders and market makers signed the “Buttonwood Agreement,”
named such because it took place beneath the sycamore (buttonwood)
tree that stood outside 68 Wall Street. The agreement saw the formal
establishment of the New York Stock Exchange and the setting of
standardized trade commissions.
The famous NYSE (New York Stock Exchange) edifice was built in
1827 on the corner of Wall Street and Hannover Street. In 1842, a
competing stock exchange was established known as AMEX, the
American Stock Exchange. Simultaneous to the worldwide economic
prosperity, Wall Street developed its role as the most important
international financial center.
In the late 1890s and early 1900s, a new phenomenon began to pick
up steam. Throughout the United States, “stock shops,” also known as
“bucket shops,” sprouted up. The term was imported from Britain,
where it had clear connotations of illegal activities. Clients of these
shops traded in stocks for speculative purposes without actually
making a stock exchange transaction: in actuality, gambling. A trader
“played” on the stock price without actually buying the stock. When
the trader profited, the shop lost, and vice versa: a casino for all
intents and purposes. The stock rates were continually telegraphed in
from New York throughout the entire trading day. They were called
out by one clerk and simultaneously written down by another on a
large board facing the public. Because the shop’s interests were
diametrically opposed to those of the trader, swindling was endless,
and these shops were perceived as unreliable. A detailed description of
these activities is found in Edwin Lefèvre’s Reminiscences of a
Stock Operator, mentioned earlier as a biography of one of the
biggest traders, Jesse Livermore. In 1930, during the Great Depression,
these shops were made illegal, and the fun and games came to an end.
Founding NASDAQ
1971 saw an important change take place. The NASDAQ stock
exchange was established, and unlike the NYSE, NASDAQ
computerized all its trade processes. The NASDAQ computers are in
Connecticut and link to more than 500 market makers’ computers,
allowing electronic trade in one click. From that point on, market
makers no longer needed to compete over each other’s shouts on the
trading floor. Everything was push-button. The result: commissions
slowly dropped, the quality of service improved, competition grew,
and companies of a new type issued stocks and raised trillions of
dollars. Within two decades, and with the proliferation of the
Internet, NASDAQ was accessible in the home of every trader. For the
first time, the road to private trading was opened. We can, in fact, say
that the profession of day trading as we know it now was born with
NASDAQ’s founding.
Crises
If you run a statistical check of the average period between each crisis
throughout market history, you’ll discover that during your own adult
lifetime, at least three crises will occur. In other words, if you’re a
short-term investor, there’s a reasonable chance that sooner or later
you’ll lose a sizeable portion of your capital. That’s one of the risks of
the market for investors. For someone with the good luck to
experience a first crisis around the age of forty, there’s a good chance
of survival, but if it catches you when you’re sixty-five, I’m not certain
you’ll manage to save your pension. An exception is the last decade,
2000-2010, during which two of biggest crises in market history
occurred in close proximity: the Dot-Com Crash and the Sub-Prime
Crash.
The bubble was structured around the euphoria which peaked with
the invention of new, unprecedented economic models based on
“market penetration” instead of profits and on “unadvertised costs”
and other innovations that matched the spirit of the times. For as long
as money flowed into the hi-tech industry, especially in light of the
low interest rates of 1998 and 1999, the boom kept growing. In 1999
and the start of 2000, when the government increased the interest
rates six times in succession, money was made more expensive, and
the new economic models began to collapse like a house of cards.
At the peak of the crisis, the NASDAQ index representing the
technological stocks lost some 80% of its value, and the S&P 500 lost
46%. I personally experienced this crash as a hi-tech entrepreneur and
beginning trader. I recruited millions of dollars from investors for
startups I established, and rode the peaks and valleys of that period
from every angle possible. These were also my initial years as a trainee
trader. In fact, I owe the positive change in my life to the Dot-Com
Crisis, which left me, as so many others like me, unemployed, and
forced me to seek an alternative in the world of stock trading.
When you buy or sell a stock, someone is on the other side, selling to
you or buying from you. Who is that person, what’s his or her role,
and what’s guiding him or her?
“Market Makers”
When you want to buy or sell a stock, you need someone with whom
to make that transaction. Have you ever thought about what might
happen if you want to sell, but there’s no buyer? At what price would
the sale order be executed? Can you and several more sellers cause the
crash of a stock because, for a short period, there was no buyer on the
other side? Market makers are the people always willing to fulfill the
role of “the other party,” even if they don’t buy and sell the way you do.
The role of market makers is to constantly stand behind the stock.
They set buy and sell orders in advance, with fixed spreads, and hence,
they “make the market” for that stock.
How do market makers profit? Their profit derives from the spread
(the difference) between the sale and purchase prices. For a company
with a volume of millions of stocks per day, a profit of one cent can
amount to $10,000 per day for every million shares traded. Not a bad
income at all!
It’s not always that simple in the market makers’ world. They take
no small amount of risks in that the stock moves in the opposite
direction from the actions they execute. On the NASDAQ exchange, to
ensure that the market will remain competitive and that the spreads
set by the market makers will remain as limited as possible, the stock
exchange encourages activity by a large number of market makers for
the same stock. When a specific stock is being handled by dozens of
market makers, the individual investor is assured of high volume and
competitive spreads.
Specialists
Specialists are the NYSE’s version of NASDAQ’s market makers. In
contrast to the NASDAQ, in the NYSE each stock is allocated to only
one specialist. The specialist may be allocated several stocks to trade
simultaneously, but each stock will be traded by only that single
specialist.
Specialists hold a dual role. Firstly, they must provide reasonable
liquidity when there are no buyers or sellers for the stock, by buying
and selling to their own accounts. This prevents fluctuation during
periods when there are no other buyers or sellers. Secondly, they serve
as brokers for the brokers, by setting buy and sell orders and carrying
them out at the best price possible, known as “best execution.” For
example: when a certain broker is interested in executing a sell order
for a client for a stock priced at $50, but the client’s order is to buy at
$49 in the hope that the stock will drop to this level, the specialist
keeps the order on his or her book, called “booking the order,” and
executes it when the price reaches the client’s preference. The law
requires that specialists must respect the client’s interests over their
own at all times. Until just a few years ago, prior to computerization,
every buy and sell order went through a specialist. Currently, most
NYSE executions take place via automated trading, similar to the
NASDAQ format.
Due to the lack of liquidity that led to the 1987 collapse, laws were
passed forcing market makers to respect electronic orders. These laws
saw the first usage of ECN systems by the public. Currently, the
majority of orders we execute are placed through ECNs.
Have you heard the claim that ninety percent of traders lose? It’s
one hundred percent correct! In fact, I’m sure the number is even
higher. The greater majority of those losing traders are people who
think they can trade without learning the trade! There’s no need for a
license or diploma to become a day trader. The conditions for joining
the profession are simple, and anyone without the slightest previous
experience can learn to uphold them: open a trading account, deposit
funds, buy, and sell. Anyone filling these criteria can be defined as a
“day trader.” Is it any wonder, then, that the probability of success is so
low? I was there too, and made the same mistake. I faced failure any
number of times. It would have placed me squarely in the sad statistic
of losers. I survived, but no more than ten percent of new traders will
be stubborn enough to survive. The ones that do, accruing experience
and knowledge, are the ones that will profit from the funds of those
who don’t invest in knowledge. My job is to ensure that you learn, and
that you join the winners. The more you learn, the greater your
chances of success.
You can acquire theory from books, but you need more than that.
You need to take a course. Courses cost money, but they save you more
than you spend. Sometimes, a tip from an experienced instructor is
worth far more than the cost of the course. Even if you feel that you
already have that basic knowledge and fairly broad experience in the
capital markets, the additional information you will learn in a course
is worth the effort of joining one. Without an optimal education,
you’ll be forced to rely on your good luck. And if that’s the case, you
might as well forget trading and just take a joy ride to Las Vegas.
There, at least, you’ll lose with a smile as you sip drinks on the house
.
Hardware, Software, and the Internet
Reliable hardware is an essential link. It is very worthwhile making a
clear distinction between the old home-use computer containing tens
of programs and possibly even dormant viruses, and your trading
computer, though that’s not a necessity at the outset.
When you buy a stock, for both technological and regulatory reasons,
you need the services of an agent known as the broker. The broker
mediates between you and the stock exchange. When you deposit
your money with your chosen brokerage company, you receive (usually
free of charge) trading software that connects your buy and sell orders
to the various stock exchange computers.
The broker might be the bank that enables buying and selling
stocks along with additional banking services, or it may be an
independent company specializing solely in providing brokerage
services. Usually a specialized broker will be cheaper and more
effective than the bank.
In the not too distant past, people wishing to buy or sell stocks had
to take themselves off to the broker’s offices, wait in a queue, and pay
a hefty commission. In short, a loss of no small amount of money even
before the stock rose by just one cent. Active traders bought and sold
stocks at cheaper prices through phone calls with the broker’s
transaction room, and highly active traders set up expensive
communications systems connecting them directly with the various
brokers. Those days are well over. The Internet revolution brought the
stock exchange directly into the personal computer of every single
person in the world who wishes to buy and sell stocks. In fact, the
public now has access to the most advanced trading systems which,
not so long ago, served only the professionals. Data that once could be
accessed by only the privileged few is now open to public use.
As the Internet continued to develop, trading programs developed,
procedures were totally computerized, and commissions dropped. The
minimum commission when I started out as trader stood at $15, and
it’s now $1.50 with ample room for it to drop further. The more the
commission fees dropped, the more useless brokers’ phone-in
transaction rooms became. Rooms that were populated by tens if not
hundreds of employees turned into a desert of screens and computers,
serving only a small number of traders who still have not internalized
the Internet revolution, and are willing to pay exorbitant commissions
for an unnecessary phone call. Commission markdowns and Internet
penetration, together with new technological developments such as
mobile phone applications that allow buying and selling, have led the
trading world to the portals of additional population strata.
Margin also has its disadvantages. Let’s say you deposited $10,000 in
your account and bought 1000 shares at $10 each, using all your
deposit. In other words, you’ve used your own deposit without using
any margin. A drop of 25% in a stock price from $10 to $7.5 will cause
you a loss of $2500, or 25% of your money. On the other hand, if you
use a 4:1 margin, buying 4000 shares for $40,000 followed by a drop of
25% in price will cause $10,000 worth of damage and wipe out your
account! And what would have happened if you’d slept on Lehman
Bros stocks after the Sub-Prime Crisis when they plummeted to $3 and
the next day were worth mere cents? When you sleep on a margin of
2:1 and the stock price drops more than 50%, this is the stage in which
you are losing not only your own money but that of the broker too.
The broker’s job, of course, is to prevent risks of this kind. This is why
brokers maintain a risk department whose job it is to keep tabs on
your account and warn of potentially hazardous situations. In
actuality, it rarely happens that a client loses more than the amount in
his or her account.
Does margin sound risky? To experienced professionals, not at all.
They will never endanger more than a pre-defined sum of money. This
sum, which they are willing to risk, will have nothing to do with
margin. As we will learn further on, they use stop orders as
protection, and plan in advance the maximum dollar loss they are
willing to absorb. They never absorb losses of tens of percent, and
never endanger their trading account. If you remain disciplined and
operate according to the rules, you will learn as we progress, and
margin will become a gift at your service when wisely used. By
contrast, if you are not sufficiently self-disciplined and have a
tendency to gamble, beware!
Brokers are at risk and do not share in the profits you can make
from margin: so why would they bother to provide you with margin?
There are two main reasons. The first is the fact that interest is profit.
When you buy on margin beyond the trading day on which you
purchased the stock, you pay interest, from which the brokers make a
profit. The second reason is that the greater the sum of money
accessible to you, the more probable it is that you will execute more
transactions with greater volume. Why would you be happy with
buying just 200 shares if you can profit from buying 800? In short,
margin benefits both sides: the trader can put in just one quarter of
the amount needed and enhance his or her potential on each trade by
double or quadruple, while the brokers benefit from greater volume of
activity which creates more commissions.
As a day trader, I’m very active within the day’s trading hours and
often use the entire margin capability available to me. I tend not to
use the full margin available for purchasing one stock, but for several
stocks simultaneously purchased: for example, I might buy stock A
without any margin, identify a good opportunity, and buy stock B with
margin, and possibly even stock C and D until my money’s full margin
is maximized.
When I sleep on a stock for a range of several days, it will usually be
after successfully taking a partial profit of at least 75% of the shares I
bought. The same would apply, too, if I slept on four different stocks: I
would use almost no margin.
Summarizing: the disadvantage of margin is the interest it bears
beyond one day’s trading and the risk of losing four times more than
you might have lost if trading without the margin. In actuality, the risk
is no higher, as we will learn later, as there is little significance to the
sum with which you’re trading as long as you use stop orders that limit
the amount any transaction can lose. The advantage of margin is that
you don’t need to make a much larger deposit in order to trade with
higher sums. In light of the dangers inherent to using margin, day
trading rules prevent brokers supervised by American regulations to
provide margin greater than a 4:1 ratio on any single trading day and a
2:1 ratio for more than one day. In fact, the condition for being allowed
to use margin is that you are required to deposit a minimum of
$25,000 in your account. In any case, even if you do find a way to reach
higher margin, as new traders I would advise you to make do with the
4:1 ratio. A too-high margin might go out of control in risky situations
where you feel you absolutely “must have” a certain stock. That’s
precisely when it’s best to take a deep breath and minimize the risk. A
reasonable margin prevents mishaps of this kind. In short, be satisfied
with a little less and you will save a great deal.
Trading CFD’s
What is a CFD? A CFD (Contract for Difference) is a contract between
a “buyer” and a “seller” certifying that the seller will pay the buyer the
difference between the stock price at time of purchase and its price at
time of sale. In other words, buying a CFD allows the buyer to profit
(or lose) from the difference in stock price without actually buying the
stock itself.
Under certain conditions, as described below, and if your broker
allows you to choose between stock or CFD trading, choose CFD
without a moment’s hesitation! CFD is executed in exactly the same
way as stock trading. In fact, if your broker does not expressly state
what you’re trading in, I’m prepared to vouch for the fact that you
wouldn’t even sense the difference.
So how does CFD trading differ from stock trading? When you buy
stocks, you buy them through the stock exchange from a person
interested in selling them at the exact same time you’ve decided to
buy. One of the biggest issues with the stock exchange is the scope of
supply and demand. But we don’t always find the buyer or seller with
the required amount, and we often need to “chase the stock.” Chasing
stock generally costs us both money and health. But when you buy
CFD, you’re not buying stock at the exchange; you’re buying a contract
identical to the stock from your broker.
The advantage of this method is that your broker can allow you to
buy or sell any quantity without linking it to stock exchange liquidity.
Think of it this way: Let’s say you want to buy 1000 shares, but
sellers are currently only offering 100. You would have to wait for
additional sellers, or possibly pay a higher price for additional stock.
When you trade in CFDs you are not limited by quantity, and
therefore the instant you hit BUY, you receive the full amount you
wanted even if that supply of shares is not currently available in the
stock exchange. Similarly, when you wish to sell 1000 shares, you will
not have to wait for buyers to take the full quantity. You just sell by
hitting the SELL button. If you have experience in the market, as I
have, you must agree that it’s impossible to tag this method with any
description other than “amazing!”
Have you ever heard the claim that students in trading courses who
use the “demo” (which allows practicing how to trade without actually
involving money) almost always profit? That’s a true claim. One of the
main reasons explaining their success is the fact that training
programs, like CFD trading platforms, do not limit the trader to
market liquidity. You press the button – you’ve bought! You press the
button – you’ve sold! Any quantity, and at lightning speed. Traders in
the real market can only dream of such immediacy. Ask any
experienced trader what his or her biggest problem is, and probably
the complaint topping the list will be speed of execution and liquidity.
A Word of Warning
For good reason, the United States has set day trade regulations
requiring a minimum of $25,000. In the past, when this standard was
determined, commissions were far higher. When the minimum
commission stood at tens of dollars per transaction, the trader had no
choice but to operate in large amounts of money to offset the impact
of these commissions. If a trader did not have a serious deposit in the
account, the commissions would gobble up all the trader’s profits.
Now, with commissions far lower and the minimum currently at about
$1.50, the trader can buy and sell small quantities without lessening
his or her chances of success. In some countries where Tradenet is
active, such as areas of Eastern Europe, the monthly profit target is
$1000, which equates to twice the average monthly salary. In short:
America is not the whole world, nor is the entire world American.
Nonetheless, relative to the profit levels and your cost of living,
years of experience have taught me that the higher the initial deposit,
the greater your survivability and reaching success.
Once you’ve found a broker of your liking, check his website for
where to begin the process of opening your trading account. Once
that’s completed, deposit your money, receive the trading platform,
and continue with the learning process described in this book, while
learning the platform you’ve chosen.
Chapter 3- Market Analysis
Fundamentals
Prices move in only three directions: up,
down & sideways.
The Price Says it All!
The stock market is like a huge giant that constantly changes its
appearance. Every trading day is different from the preceding one,and
every trading hour is different from the hour before. As the ancient
Greek philosopher Heraclitus once said, “You cannot step in the same
river twice.”
The stock market is the outcome of the sum of all persons
operating on and in it. Each has an individual opinion and thoughts,
and individually, each pushes the market in the direction he or she is
able, whether as a buyer or seller.
Can we nonetheless know what the sum total of persons operating
in the market is thinking? Of course we can. A quick glance at that
most important piece of information gives us the answer: the price.
A dynamic market which constantly changes is inherently
challenging. Our human thinking processes are very standardized.
Most people wish to demarcate concepts within boundaries, and sort
and catalog things, whereas the market is highly dynamic. To cope
with this challenge, you will need to become closely familiar with the
market, the principles of stock trading, and how markets behave. This
will enable you to establish your own work program, your own rules
and limitations, and apply them when you join the market.
The pros have a clear role: they take the public’s money. And they have
plenty of creative ways to do that. Their biggest advantage is the fact
that they’re pros. That’s their profession. The public generally arrives
at work in the morning, answers phones, writes e-mails, and believes
its money is hard at work. The public receives a salary at the end of
the month, because each member of the public has a profession. Each
person earns his or her income because of an advantage that has no
connection to the capital market.
As with the public, so too with the professional: the pro knows that
the public will behave in a certain way. The public feels pressured and
sells hysterically when the market comes close to a low, and buys
enthusiastically when the market’s upward movement is already too
tense and about to correct.
Stock exchange trading is my profession. It’s a profession that does
not require knowledge of economics, but rather of psychology alone.
In fact, the less you know about economics, the better off you are. As
an amateur psychologist, I know how to predict the public’s behavior.
The simple outcome is that if both of us invest in the market, the
probability is higher than in most cases I will come out the winner.
Just as I cannot replace a professional in some other field, there is no
reason to assume that such a professional can replace me in my sphere
and take my money.
The professionals are not mere stock traders. They are also fund
managers and investment bankers and anyone who makes a living
from the capital markets. They also have creative ways of taking the
public’s money. They manage it in return for management fees,
commissions, and other kinds of income without ever promising any
results! Based on the past, we can see that over the last twenty years,
80% of the world’s managed funds earned their clients less than
market index yields: in other words, fund managers know they are
taking the public’s funds in vain, but with every advertisement they
continue to promise: “Give us your money and everything will be fine.”
One simple and valid conclusion can be drawn in respect to every
profession in the world: amateurism costs money, professional brings
money in. The dream of money working for you is not realistic, and in
best-case scenarios, works solely during occasional periods that can be
pinpointed only in retrospect.
In short: no one is prepared to work on your behalf! If you want to
earn profits, you need to press those buttons yourself. Learning is the
key to success. This book is just one part of the process.
Science or Art?
There are four ways to reach a decision on transacting in stocks:
• Technical analysis, which is how traders operate
• Fundamental economic analysis, the method for long-term investors
• Random walk, the mode of operation for those who claim there is
no method
• Gambling, the method used by the public which thinks it’s found
“the formula” for turning a profit
Stock trading is not an exact science. If it were, it would be handled
by accountants. No method is complete in and of itself. Even if you
learn a 300-page manual on technical analysis by heart, I can assure
you that you’ll still lose money. The winning recipe is a combination of
winning components. The question then becomes: how do I
proportion the components? That differs from one execution to
another, from one stock to another, from one set of market conditions
to the next. Getting the proportions right is, in fact, the art of trading.
Stock trading is midway between an exact science and art.
Sometimes the very title of a specific field causes people to fear it and
feel alienated from it without even knowing that field’s content. Too
often this is the case with the phrase “technical analysis.”
Random Walk
Gambling, Anyone?
This long-standing dispute began when the first analyst drew a line
between two points representing a stock’s price changes over the axis
of time, thereby creating the very first price graph.
The essence of the dispute is whether to buy a stock based on
company and market performance, such as the company’s balance
sheet, or based on the stock’s behavior as illustrated by graph alone.
Both methods attempt to predict price trends. As already noted,
the fundamental economic investor examines the stock’s value relative
to company performance and market performance, and concludes
whether its price is above or below its true value. If, in the long-term
investor’s opinion, the price is currently below its true value, he or she
will buy, and vice versa. The technical trader does not ask “why,” but
tries to predict price trends according to graphs, that is, results in the
real-time field.
At this point, I will cease being objective and say outright that I do
not believe in the sole credibility of one or another method. I believe
that their integration is the winning method. In reality, I choose to be
80% technical and 20% fundamental. Most technical analysts arrived
at this preference through fundamental economic analysis. I can
promise you that if you try to earn profits by reading financial reports
in newspapers and watching them on television programs, you will
discover sooner or later that you’re wasting your time.
Why do most people believe in fundamental economic analysis?
Because we’re educated to invest in the long term. And why is that?
Very likely because someone has to make a living from teaching
economics in universities, because funds must find legitimate
justifications for erroneous purchases, because stock market colleges
want to continue existing, because we as humans must peg everything
into some kind of mathematical, organized framework, and because
none of the educators are willing to admit that basically, they know
just about nothing even when history indisputably proves that they’ve
erred throughout the long term! Teaching methods and attitudes have
not changed over decades, and sometimes even over centuries.
Most of those involved in the stock market define themselves as
purely fundamental or purely technical. In reality, there is no small
amount of overlap between the two methods. The problem arises
when the two methods oppose each other. History has proven that the
technical method has always preceded the economic analysis. Most of
the largest market trends occurring throughout history were ascribed
no significant explanation according to economic data, yet most could
be predicted based on technical conduct. Experienced technical
traders learn over time to trust their own considerations, which will
often stand in direct opposition to those proposed by fundamental
economic analysts. Technical traders will be enjoying the benefits of
changes when fundamental investors have long since missed the train.
Would you like an example? Was it possible to profit from hi-tech
companies’ stocks at the end of the 1990s? Of course, and abundantly!
Could even one fundamental investor be found able to justify buying
stocks in technology companies that have no income, only
expenditures and dreams? Of course not! Technical traders knew
where the public’s emotions would lead the market, whereas
fundamental investors chose to ignore the expected change.
At some point, they nonetheless found justification for joining.
Remember the phrase “profit without advertising costs”? Several more
illustrious economic concepts came into being along the duration of
the hi-tech bubble, meant to justify late-entry into a teeming market.
Funds simply could not tell their clients they were not buying when all
competitors presented astronomical profits, therefore they invented a
financial justification, and happily bought in. Those who wasted their
time with analyses of hi-tech companies’ financial reports prior to and
during the rush, left opportunities wide open for technical analysts to
enjoy alone. Those who continued justifying their erroneous
fundamental holdings when the stock exchange changed direction
and crashed, lost out.
Over time, once the market had absorbed these large shifts, the two
methods caught up with each other and once again presented a united
front. We ask: must some compromise be found between them? As a
novice, I thought the answer was no. Now, with years of experience
under my belt, I believe I was wrong. As noted, I’m currently operating
on an 80% technical and 20% fundamental mix. I’ve moved a little to
the other side because I found that when sticking with only one
approach, the market seems in many cases to operate as though it has
a mind of its own. I found that relying on technical data alone did not
provide me the advantage I sought. By contrast, it’s completely clear to
me that relying on economic data alone is nothing more than a
gamble. If you’ve ever tried to watch how a stock behaves after its
financial reports are publicized, whether good or bad, you’ll
understand exactly to what I refer.
Note that I used the very specific terms “fundamental investor” and
“technical trader.” In the past, when the world was chiefly industrial, it
was possible to rely on economic data for the long term. In the past, it
wasn’t possible to change the rules of the game overnight. When a
mega-corporation like General Motors or IBM presented good balance
sheets, it was clear that no competitor could surface overnight and
take their top status from them. Therefore, these economic data
points were reliable for the long term. To compete with GM or IBM, an
unimaginable investment would be needed, therefore in the short
term, no change could be expected that would endanger the investor
too greatly.
In today’s technological reality, every young entrepreneur living in
student dorms can topple a conglomerate like IBM from the top of the
pyramid. Remember when IBM preferred to develop hardware, and
some young guy named Bill Gates developed DOS for them? Just
check Microsoft’s market cap against IBM’s to understand how the
world can change. And who used technological innovation to topple
Microsoft from its top position as the company with the largest
market value? Apple, which was dormant for years but reached new
peaks with the iPhone and iPad, leaving Microsoft behind at the
curve. And what of Google, sprinting ahead? Will Facebook, breathing
hard down Google’s neck, overtake the lead? In the current business
world, any technological or biological innovation can change market
structure overnight. The days when our parents would buy a stock
such as IBM, place the paper deed (yes, once upon a time a written
deed was issued to the stock owner) beneath their pillow and go to
sleep knowing all would be fine, have long since disappeared. Nor
have we yet begun to discuss the impact of wars and terror attacks…
I believe that long-term investment is dead, together with the
world of absolute control and the fundamental economic analysis
method. The short term is what to watch, which is why technical
analysis is currently the controlling method. We live in a time when
we need to trade with fast changes and remain wary of dangerous
long-term investments. The technical trader who buys stocks that
unfortunately move in the wrong direction (yes, that can happen, too)
realizes he or she has erred, sells them and moves on to the next
stock. When fundamental investors buy a stock, they hold onto them
for as long as it has yet to be proven that the fundamental economic
data have altered. Such investors believe that the stock’s value is
actually higher than its market value, and therefore when it drops in
price, it can actually increase their holdings. It’s true that not so many
years ago, the method did work. Remember the dot-com bubble that
burst in 2000? That’s where the method stopped working. That’s
where the technical trader profited from shorts and the fundamental
investor crashed in a market which, to date, has yet to fully recover. It
was the trader’s opportunity, not the gambler’s.
If you need further persuasion, let me present another question: is
there any link between a company’s balance sheet and reality? Older
readers may well recall Enron, one of the largest energy corporations
in the world. Enron collapsed when its CEO chose to present the
balance sheet in a “creative” manner, and made sure he found an
accountant who would not stand in his way. Even if we allow that the
balance was legitimate, it nonetheless reflected the company’s status
in the previous quarter, which commenced just three months earlier.
Who is interested in it today? I’m sure that most balance sheets
presented to us are legitimate and correct, but should we gamble on
them with our money?
As traders, we rely chiefly on clear technical data. In the past, we
have come across a stock that rose multiple percentages in one trade
day, and only the next day the economic data causing the rise become
clarified. This does not imply we have no trust in economic data. We
just feel that they are already incorporated into the stock’s chart.
As if all that is not enough, there’s another important difference.
Technical analysis can be applied to every stock, sector, and market.
Give me a yearly graph for Japan’s Nikkei index, and within seconds I
can analyze the Japanese market. Show me the yearly graph for the
DAX index and in the blink of an eye, I will analyze the German
market. Can fundamental analysts, who need to read mountains of
material before buying any stock, do that? No! They cannot specialize
in every market, sector, and stock. They are limited to a specific sector
and even a specific company in some cases, and will never review the
entire market, but only a slim segment of it.
First and foremost, because most of the public uses it. Whether
there is any meaning to fundamental analysis or not is as pointless as
asking whether there is meaning to technical analysis. As soon as a
large enough number of people believe so, and operate on the basis of
economic data with predictable outcomes, the experienced trader will
know how to take advantage of the predicted movement and earn a
livelihood from it. Over the years, I have learned to appreciate the
power of the fundamental herd and rein it in for my own purposes. I
take no small number of technical decisions based on economic
factors alone. For example: I focus a lot on stocks influenced by
extreme economic analysis, such as an analyst’s upgrade, but then I
choose a technical entry and exit point. Using fundamental economic
analysis does not in any way indicate that I believe in that method, but
I’m definitely a firm believer in the predictable behavioral outcomes of
those who do use them. I have no need to deny any kind of prediction.
Rather, I need to evaluate whether it will be self-fulfilling.
The laws of technical trading are known to all trading parties. The
specialists and market makers in the New York Stock Exchange know
your stop loss order point and your entry orders points, and will often
take advantage of this information for their own benefit. Take this into
account when you’re trading. The resistance line is not a solid wall,
and the support line is not stable ground. This is why we first talk
about “support levels” and “resistance levels” rather than precise
science. Young traders in the trading room often tell me they have sold
a stock because it broke the support level, while experienced traders
and I have held the stock and in the end, profited. Don’t let your hand
be too easy with the mouse. Remember that trading is a battle of the
minds and always involves two parties: buyer and seller.
This is also why I guide my traders not to place a stop order, but to
wait for that moment when the stock reaches the stop and then exit
manually. The specialists and market makers know where most
traders’ stop orders are, and use them to their own advantage.
Using charts now seems to me the most natural and obvious thing.
How can we possibly manage without them? But that is not how
things were in the past. Up until one hundred years ago, almost no
charts were used. Quotes of stock prices reached the trading room by
telegraph, a designated clerk wrote them down on a large board, and
the previous price was erased. Successful traders were those blessed
with excellent memories. Over time, it became understood that a
connection exists between the past and future behavior of a stock
price.Some traders began charting the information, seeking recurring
outcomes. The use of charts began to make greater headway as famous
chart-based theories began developing, such as the Dow Theory and
the Elliot Waves. In the 1960s, charts became increasingly prevalent
with the advent of the first industrialized computers.
Line Chart
The line chart is useful and most frequently used in the media. It is
especially convenient for comparing the prices of several stocks in one
chart, or comparing a stock and its sector index. If, for example, we
wish to check a stock’s Apple (AAPL) chart and compare the AAPL
behavior to the hi-tech sector stocks, a line chart makes the job easier
and allows determining whether a specific stock is stronger or weaker
than its sector.
Summary:
A nice chart, but completely useless to the trader. I use this kind of
chart only when I write articles for newspapers or when television
program producers request a simple chart prior to going on air that
viewers can understand. You’ve seen it, you’ve made this chart’s
acquaintance, and now you should forget it altogether.
The X and O chart is a very old method first written about in 1898.
Its popularity rose in the 1940s with the publication of A. W. Cohen’s
1947 guidebook on point and figure stock market timing. By contrast
with other price presentation methods where price is dependent on
time, the point and figure method marks a rising price as X and a
dropping price as O. This method chiefly serves long-term investors,
since it presents prices over just one timeframe (for example, the
closing prices of a period of trading days).Therefore it sifts out
intraday trading fluctuations, based on the premise that intraday
changes are no more than distracting noises that cause the investor to
implement unnecessary actions. Here is an example of a point and
figure chart:
Summary:
If you really want to anger me, read Cohen’s 1947 book, which can
be ordered online, and try to use this method on intraday trading.
There’s a good chance that instead of making money, you’ll end up in
tears. If you’re interested in long-term investment, there might be
something to gain from reading the book, but long term does not
interest me and is not the field we’re dealing with here, so it will not
be discussed further.
Bar Chart
Now we’re moving up a level! Unlike the line chart, the bar chart
displays a good amount of useful information and is the most
common chart in use by investors. Note that I used the term
“investors” and not “traders.” On a bar chart, every vertical bar
represents price behavior for a specific timeframe, as follows: the
uppermost extreme of the vertical bar indicates the highest price for
the specific time unit (HIGH), and the bottom point indicates the
lowest price (LOW). The small horizontal mark on the left shows the
start price (OPEN) and the horizontal on the right shows the (CLOSE)
price
Let’s say that the bar chart above indicates price changes of a stock
over one day: its opening, highest, lowest, and closing price for one
day. Because the closing price is higher than the opening price, we
understand that we are looking at a chart showing a day in which the
price rose.
[1] shows the stock price on July 29 starting at its high (peak),
dropping, then ending slightly above the low
[2] shows the AAPL price on July 7 opening slightly above its lowest
point, dropping, then ending at a high
[3] shows AAPL on July 12 showing no change. The open and
closing prices are identical.
A bar can indicate any length of time, from a single day as in the
chart above, to a week, a month, and of course much shorter intraday
trading periods from five minutes, fifteen, a half hour or full hour.
Intraday traders will choose bar charts illustrating from two to thirty
minutes. By contrast, an investor wanting to examine a stock’s long-
term behavior will likely choose bars showing daily or weekly periods.
Note the disparity between the open and closing prices on the
AAPL bar chart shown above. Note also that from one day to the next,
the opening price is different from the closing price of the previous
day; for example, on the day marked [1] you can see that the opening
price is lower than the closing price of the previous day.
Here, too, each candlestick represents one day of trade: [1] a day of
falling prices, [2] a day of rising prices, [3] a day of no change. Take a
couple of minutes and compare this chart with the bar chart. Try to
understand the way prices are presented in this chart, as compared to
the bar chart. I promise you that within a short time, you will
understand the concept without having read any explanation. This is
important. Please stop reading and make that comparison.
Did you continue reading without stopping? If so, you’ve just failed
the most important test for any trader: self-discipline. This time I’ll
forgive it, but let’s agree that this will be the last time you breach
discipline. Without strong discipline, you will pay a costly price.
So how do we read a Japanese candle? As with bars, Japanese
candlesticks indicate the movement of prices over a specific period
chosen by the trader, which can be a minute, a month, and even a
year. But instead of a vertical line with two horizontal bars, the candle
has a “‘body.”
• The top and bottom parts of the body show the opening and closing
prices.
• When the candle is a light color, usually green, white or transparent
(but other possibilities exist), the closing price was higher than the
opening price. In other words, the price for the represented period
rose.
• When the candle body is red, black or any other dark color, it means
the closing price was lower than the opening price. In other words,
the price dropped.
Most of the candles have a tail, sometimes also called a shadow.
• At the upper end, it is called the topping tail, and indicates the
highest price for the period represented by the candle (for example,
the day’s high).
• A tail at the lower end is called the bottoming tail, and indicates the
lowest price for the specific period.
Later we will learn that the length of the tail is very important for
analyzing the expected stock price movement.
To the right of the bar chart you see a dark candle, meaning
dropping prices. Because the candle is dark, you immediately
understand that the opening price is the top of the candle’s body, the
closing price is the bottom of the body, and the two tails, topping and
bottoming, show the day’s high and low.
You might want to claim that the Japanese candle provides the
exact same information as the bar chart: the opening price, closing
price, highest and lowest prices. This is true, nonetheless there are two
differences:
• Because of the different colors, in a split second we can identify
whether the stock rose or fell. Compare again with the AAPL chart
and see which makes identifying stock price movement easier.
• The second and more essential difference is that Japanese candles
developed over time with additional techniques that add a further
dimension to the method.
A third reason exists for using Japanese candles: Because most
professionals have shifted to using this method, it is very worthwhile
that you look at the market exactly the way they do, so that you can
operate in exactly the same way they do. If you operate before them,
they will not be buying together with you, and your risks increase. If
you buy after them, you will be buying at too high a price.
Without a doubt, Japanese candles light the way for traders who
know how to use them effectively. Here is another example:
Japanese Candle Showing No Change in Price
When a stock’s open and closing prices are identical, the candle
will not be green or red or any other light or dark color, and its “body”
will shrink, as you see, to no more than a horizontal line. This candle
is called a “doji,” and indicates indecision: a perfect balance of power
between buyers and sellers. In the chart above, you see that the
opening and closing prices are the same: $20. The stock did move
around, from a low of $19.5 to a high of $20.2, but in the end, closed
with no change.
Presentation of Candles over Varying
Lengths of Time
Summary:
When making your decision to buy a stock, and also determining the
best entry point (professionally known as a “trigger”), it is vital to
switch between different timeframes, examine the stock’s behavior
using Japanese candles of different intervals, and even elaborate on
market activity during the same timeframes. In weekly candles, I see
less “noise” than in daily candles, and in daily candles I see less “noise”
than in intraday thirty-minute candles, and so on. As an intraday
trader, I will make my trade decision within the day’s trading
according to candles of five-minute intervals, and occasionally
according to candles of two-minute intervals.
Swing traders buy stocks for ranges of several days up to several
weeks. They will make their decision based on daily charts. Long-term
investors, known as core traders, who hold stocks for months and even
years, will base their decisions on weekly charts.
The Result
I couldn’t resist. Almost three months have passed since I wrote
this section, and now, as I make my final editorial adjustment, I
decided to complete the picture with the results. Of course, you would
not have gotten to see them if I had failed…
The Trend
We have already mentioned that prices move in three directions: up,
down, or forward. The market does not move backwards, because time
does not move backwards. The market’s directional movement is
called its “trend.” When the market rises over a period of time, we call
this the uptrend; dropping over a period of time is called downtrend,
and when it “moves sideways” with insignificant deviations, it is called
a trendless market. It is easy to profit when there is a trend, and very
difficult when the market has no trend. Generally, those who make
money in a trendless market are the brokers who profit from
commissions.
The trend is the direction that the market is taking. Because the
market, like a snake, never moves in a straight line but always zigzags,
the trend is structured from a series of highs and lows.
• A series of highs and lows, where each low is nonetheless higher
than the previous one, and each high is higher than the previous
one, creates an upward trend. This series is defined by higher highs
and higher lows.
• A series of highs and lows where each new low is lower than the
previous one, and each new high is also lower than the previous
one, creates a downward trend. This series is defined by lower
highs and lower lows.
The public generally hears only about rises and drops in the
market, but according to conservative estimates, about one-third of
the time the market is neither moving up or down, but rather staying
the same. A series of similar highs and similar lows creates this
movement. In the trading room, we often describe this situation as
moving sideways or moving in the range.
When a series forms of two rising highs and two rising lows, it
defines the uptrend. In the chart above, we see three rising lows and
four rising highs, which is a very clear upward movement. Notice that
the fifth high is lower than the fourth. Does this indicate that the
uptrend has stopped? No, but it is definitely gives cause to watch for
changes.
UpwardTrend:
Downtrend
When a series forms of two dropping lows and two dropping highs,
this defines a downtrend. In the chart above, we see a series of four
dropping lows and three dropping highs: a very clear downtrend.
Notice that the fifth low is higher than the fourth low. Does this mean
that the downtrend has ended? No, but there is definitely room to
suspect an upcoming change.
Think for a moment: what does the trader always wish to know?
• A trader always wants to know the ratio of buyers to sellers: in other
words, which of these two opposing groups is winning the endless
tug-of-war.
• When buyers are winning, we see uptrends.
• When sellers are winning, we see downtrends.
• When there is balance between buyers and sellers, the stock will
move sideways, with slight upward and downward movements but
no real trend.
When technical analysts talk about support and resistance, they are
usually referring to “lines of support and resistance,” but, as is
presented further on, support and resistance can also be found at high
and low points, in moving averages, and in round numbers. Support
and resistance are also linked to another phrase: breakouts and
breakdowns.
• A sharp drop in price can be a support breakdown
• A sharp rise in price can be a resistance breakout
• The area of support is the price where the stock stops on its way
down: in other words, the point at which buyers outnumber sellers.
• The area of resistance is the price where the stock has stopped on
its way up: in other words, the point at which sellers outnumber
buyers.
Summary:
In the support area, the majority think that the stock’s price is cheap.
In the resistance area, the majority feel that the stock’s price is
expensive.
Professional traders seek to buy a stock on the way up after it
breaks through the area of resistance, and will seek to short (sell)
when a stock breaks through the area of support.
I want to emphasize that these are areas, not lines, of support and
resistance. The term “line” represents a rigid, unfeasible reality. Is it
reasonable that all people active in the market will constantly buy at
the same support price and always sell at the same resistance price? Of
course not. This is even truer for a large market. Additionally, as
noted, the principles of technical analysis are known to all people
active in the market, and frequently “lines” will be broken out
purposely in order to execute automatic buy and sell orders fed into
computers, or to tempt innocent traders into buying and selling a
stock.
1. Traders like buying stocks that break out through resistance. When
a stock breaks out through resistance [1], they buy it, hoping it will
go up. When to their joy it does rise and creates a new high [2],
they’re sorry they didn’t buy a larger quantity at the outset… Now
the stock is too expensive to make it worth buying more, but they
would love to increase the amount they hold if the stock price
would drop to its breakout figure [3]. When it does, they buy,
establishing support [3].
2. Other traders who missed the breakout see that the stock is rising,
and are sorry they missed joining the festivities. They won’t buy the
stock at its peak [2] because it is too costly, but they’re happy to buy
it when it returns to the breakout price [3]. When it does, they buy.
Buying indicates that they support that price: in other words, they
establish support [3].
3. The last ones in on the support list are the “short sellers,” who
hoped that the stock would not rise, but were caught with a stock
that hit new highs [1] and were sorry they did not close the shorts
before the breakout. They lose money, but psychologically they have
trouble admitting their error and closing the short all the way to the
high [2]. Of course they would be delighted if they were given a
chance to exit their short position at the pre-breakout price, that is,
buy at that price (we will explain later how a short is closed by
buying). When the stock does drop down, they will wipe the sweat
from their brow, buy, and also be among those establishing [3]
support.
Summary:
If a stock drops back down to its “retest” point [3], then all the
traders have a common interest: to buy. This shared interest is what
turns resistance into support.
Why does support turn into resistance? For the exact reverse
reasons to those detailed above:
1. Traders love to sell short stocks that break down through support.
When a stock breaks down through support [1], they execute a
short, that is, they sell the stock (more on this later) and hope that
it will go down. When, to their joy, it does, and reaches a new low
[2], they’re sorry they didn’t short at the outset with a greater
quantity… But now it has gone down too low for them to sell
another amount. However, they’d be happy to increase the amount
of their short if the price returns to its breakdown point [3]. If it
does return, they will increase the quantity of shorts, that is, sell
more, and be among those creating resistance [3].
2. Other traders who missed the breakdown [1] see that the stock is
dropping and are sorry they didn’t join the shorting festivities. They
won’t execute a short when the price is at its lowest [2] because it
has already “dropped down too much,” but they would be happy to
execute a short (i.e. to sell) if the price returns to its breakdown
point [3]. If it does go back up, they will short and be among those
establishing resistance [3].
3. The last group establishing resistance is the “long traders” (in
contrast with “short traders”). Long traders are those who believed
in the stock and bought it before its breakdown, believing it would
go up. Long traders are currently caught with a losing stock: they
watch it reach a new low and are sorry they didn’t sell it before the
breakdown. They are sustaining large losses and have difficulty in
admitting their mistake and selling when the stock price is low [2].
They pray that it will go back up to its breakdown point [3] when
they will happily sell. When it does, they will also be among the
sellers establishing resistance [3].
Summary:
If a stock rises to its retest point [3], it will usually encounter
resistance originating in the common interest of all those operating in
the market at the time: sellers. This shared interest turns support into
resistance.
The high and low points also serve as areas of support and resistance,
both on intraday charts and daily charts.
In a straight line!
Just as a snake will never crawl in a straight line, a stock will never
move in a straight line, but always in ups and downs and in highs and
lows.
Remember this when a stock is moving in the opposite direction to
what you want. Usually a stock moves “against” your wishes because
that is its nature, which does not necessarily imply that the trend has
changed.
Differentiate between episodic noise in a stock’s movement and
real change in trend. We will discuss “noise” regarding stock prices
later.
Analyzing Japanese Candles
So far, we have seen how prices are presented using Japanese candles.
Now we will discuss the components of the candle: the candle body,
and the tail. Each candle contains information about the balance of
power between buyers and sellers.
In the narrow range candle [1], the distance between the opening
and closing price is very small and almost insignificant. The narrow
range, as noted, is a relative term. For AAPL, a range of five cents
between opening and closing prices, as we see in this candle, is a
miniscule range, but in other stocks such as Microsoft (MSFT), it may
indicate a relatively wide range.
When we compare the narrow range candle [1] with the wide
range candle [2], the narrow and wide ranges become clear
specifically for AAPL. In the wide range candle [2], the range between
opening and closing prices is 50 cents. Observing this candle relative
to adjacent candles, we have no doubt that in that five-minute
timeframe, sellers strongly controlled the stock. The very fact that
after five minutes of seller control a balance was reached between
sellers and buyers, as expressed by the narrow range candle [1],
indicates that the battle for control is peaking and could shift to the
opposite group. In this case, we can see immediately following the
narrow range candle that the buyers did take over. Very often, a
narrow range candle does indicate a change of direction, known as
“price reversal.”
Candle Tail
Based on its light color, candle [1] indicates a rise in price: in other
words, the stock’s closing price is higher than its opening price. But a
price rise does not disclose the full story. This candle has more to tell
us: it also has a long topping tail.
What does the tail signify? As already noted, the tail indicates the
stock’s peak price in the fifteen-minute timeframe represented by the
candle. At some point during those fifteen minutes, the stock price
reached the high of the tail, and buyers were in full control. The tail
also indicates that buyers did not manage to maintain that high price.
In fact, the tail actually shows that sellers took over control of the
stock! We see that the length of the tail is almost the full length of the
entire candle. Conclusion: there is a high probability of price reversal,
i.e. a drop in price, as indicated in the candles that follow [1].
Now, to understand the meaning of the tail even better, let’s spread
that fifteen-minute interval between 15:15 and 15:30 into candles of
one-minute long, and examine what really happened more closely.
Does the color of the candle have meaning relative to the tail? In
the fifteen-minute AAPL chart, the candle is clear: this indicates a rise
in price. If it were dark, indicating a drop in price, then the tail would
even more strongly imply change of control.
A topping tail indicates that sellers have taken control. The longer
the tail, the stronger and clearer the control. The candle color makes
no difference.
A bottoming tail indicates an expected upward reversal. Here, too,
the position of the candle with the tail within the formation of candles
provides the tail with its significance. A long tail pointing down
reminds us that there used to be complete seller control, but control
has now been taken by the buyers.
Reversal Patterns
Candles very loyally tell us of the battles between buyers and sellers
for any given timeframe, but these are just a small part of the total
picture of patterns they create.
To understand where a stock originates and to try and predict
where it is going, we must look at much more than a single candle
within a group of candles, and try to make our decisions based on
patterns comprised of several candles. When we learn to identify
patterns, we can “understand” a stock with just a glance, and take
decisions accordingly.
Homework
Below is a day of trading in AAPL stock, represented in five-minute
candles. Name each of the patterns marked on the chart:
It’s not so very difficult, right? So what’s the problem? You can
make millions this way! But… unfortunately, it’s not quite that simple.
The question is not only whether you can identify pattern reversal, but
how long that reversal will last. For example: if you correctly identify
the reversal pattern [1] and execute a short there but do not turn a fast
profit, you will find yourself losing when the stock reverses direction
toward [2]. Identifying the pattern is the basis, but it is not the entire
picture. Later we will also learn that the pattern must be integrating in
the stock’s trend. In other words, we would not short at [1] because at
the start of the day, the stock was running up and therefore the
probability is high that the downward reversal would be relatively
short compared to the next upward reversal (with the trend)
immediately following [1] and before [2].
In fact, the example I chose is a dreadful sampling of a stock that
traded most of the day without a trend. If you try to make a profit
from the outcomes of these reversals on a day like that, you are
destined to failure! In short, don’t let me catch you trying to make
“fast money.” Believe me, I was there, I tried it, I lost enough until I
eventually learned that I must never get involved in a trendless stock.
Success requires that you identify the outcomes of reversal patterns
in stocks with a clear trend. One good yield from a stock with a clear
up or down trend may be enough to provide your daily profits.
Intraday Pattern Reversal for Sears, SHLD
On the day that AAPL went nowhere, Sears began its first hour of
trade with a clear upward trend. The day actually began with two dark
candles, but experienced traders know that during the first ten
minutes of trade (the first two candles), a stock’s trend is still
undetermined and derives chiefly from automated orders given by the
public to brokers before the day’s trading begins. When the third
candle rises higher than the high of the two dark candles, we can
assume that from here on, the stock will go up.
Has an uptrend been established yet? Absolutely not. We will wait.
After the first up trending candle are two dark “corrective” candles.
These are then followed by a new high, and we now have two higher
highs. Now we can see the trend. Now we await the trend correction,
and buy on the first reversal which appears at [1]. At this point the
stock is showing the classic reversal pattern with a long bottoming tail
and is simply begging us to buy. SHLD closes the day’s trading with a
high of 4.4% above the open!
Summary:
One trade with the trend is worth a thousand failed intraday
attempts at finding the reversal pattern of a trendless stock.
Later in the book, we will apply the more common name for these
pattern changes: reversals.
• A reversal that brings the stock back to trending up is called a roll-
up
• A reversal that bring stock back to trending down is called a roll-
over
Homework
Traders will often look at fifteen-minute candles in order to reduce
the influence of “noise” on their decisions. On a clean page, sketch a
fifteen-minute candle that replaces Sear’s first three 5-minute candles.
Get the picture?
Bull Flag
In this intraday chart showing two days of trade, we see Philip Morris
rising strongly at the start of trade from $49.7 to $50.5, which is a
sharp rise of some 2% lasting for just fifteen minutes. This is the area
that forms the flagpole. Now it consolidates around the high and
completes the bull flag formation. Note that in this case, we can
clearly see over time how the candles around the consolidation
become increasingly shorter, i.e. the price is consolidating towards a
possible breakout. This is the area of the flag.
Another interesting point is that the stock consolidates beneath the
price of $50.5, which we call a semi-round number. As we will learn
later, at round numbers as well as sometimes semi-round numbers,
many sellers inhibit the stock’s further rise. The stock breaks out of [1]
the bull flag’s head (resistance) and rises a little more than 1% [2]
“without looking back.”
Bear Flag
A bear flag is the reverse pattern of the bull flag. The pattern
comprises one or more downward trending candles representing the
flagpole, and several candles (usually three to five) consolidating
around the bottom of the pattern to create the flag shape. A stock will
be shorted when the price drops below the flag’s low. The pattern’s
strength derives from the stock price dropping below the low, but
instead of correcting upwards, as would be expected of a stock that
has completed a sharp series of drops, the stock breaks down under
the low. The significance of a new low is an unequivocal victory of
sellers over buyers. Buyers are very pressured, do not wait for the
correction, and are willing to sell at any price. On the other hand,
buyers who prayed for a correction to save them are disappointed by
the stock’s further drop to a lower low, and sell under pressure, which
causes the stock to drop further. The bear flag formation allows us to
short scalp (speedy entry and exit), because the stock price is
stretched downwards even before the breakdown, and we are afraid
that the stock will drop to a new low but then immediately correct
itself upwards.
The cup & handle formation is a bullish pattern that suggests the
shape of a cup and handle. The pattern is comprised of a stock
reaching its high, encountering resistance and correcting downwards.
The stock returns to the high, and in this way forms the cup. At the
high, the stock once again encounters resistance (remember when we
learned the term “double top”?) and corrects downward again while
creating the shape of the handle. This time, when it returns to a high
for the third time, it breaks through the resistance and rises to a new
high. The breakout point is the point where we should buy the stock.
What have we learned about the stock prior to its breakout? The
stock reached a high, so we realize it is strong. It corrected downwards
but returned to the same high, from which we learn that buyers are
still in control. The stock drops again, but this time drops less than
the previous time and for a shorter period. The stock returns to its
high a third time.
In the intraday chart for X, we can see that the stock is rising
strongly at the start of trading and meets resistance at the price of
$54.49. It retreats, drops [1] but returns again to the resistance point,
and in this way forms the cup. Now it drops to a new low [1], which
shapes the handle, but this time the low is higher than the previous
low, since buyers are becoming more aggressive. It returns again to its
high within a shorter timeframe than when forming the cup. The
stock breaks through the resistance [2] and climbs to a new high.
Pennant
In the chart above, you can see Apple’s intraday movement in five-
minute candles. If you thought Apple had a life of its own…you were
wrong! All intraday movement is determined at the outset by the
market movement. The market moves first, and individual companies’
shares follow. Certainly an important stock such as Apple carries
serious weight in the market index, but its weight is still relative to
499 other companies comprising the index. In other words, Apple
does not have the power to move the index on its own. This is not true
for the NASDAQ 100 index in which Apple is currently a 20%
component.
I can well imagine how you are taking a deep breath and saying,
“Just WHAT does he mean? Am I supposed to know in advance when
a stock is about to rise even before it has?”
The answer is: Yes!
Is it easy to make money this way?
The answer is: No!
Apple should move in the direction that the market is trending, but
you can never know how much the market will move, how far behind
it Apple will move, and when the market will reverse.
How can we nonetheless take advantage of this information? In
several ways:
Buying
Let’s assume Apple is about ready to break out through intraday
resistance and you are weighing the risk of buying at the breakout.
Now let’s assume that just before Apple breaks out, the market also
broke out to a new high. Does the market breakout help you decide
whether to buy Apple in the breakout? Of course! Let’s also assume
that the market showed a strong breakout. Would you now consider
buying a larger quantity than what you might have initially intended?
Yes! You would have considered entering Apple because of a nice
technical formation, but you reached that decision and the quantity
you chose because of the market’s “support.” Think about the reverse
case: You are considering buying Apple at the breakout, but just before
Apple’s breakout, the market breaks down. What would you do? Yes,
you must forego entering.
Turning a Pro t
Let’s assume that simultaneous to the market rising, you bought
Apple, the stock rose, reached the area of profit you set, and now
you’re trying to “squeeze” a fraction more profit from the uptrend.
Your finger is poised on the mouse, and you wonder whether you
should press that sell button. The market stops moving up, and
suddenly begins to correct down. This will usually occur just before
Apple will also correct. Is this the time to sell and turn a profit? Of
course it is. Because we have already learned that 60% of Apple
movement is tied to market movement, so Apple will almost certainly
drop following the market’s drop. It is true that stocks do very
occasionally “have a life of their own” and Apple could go up even if
the market is dropping, but the risk in trading will be much higher.
Sideways Movement
Let’s assume that you’re interested in buying a stock that is about to
break out, when the market starts moving sideways. Should you buy
when the stock breaks out? I have no perfect answer, but if there is no
market support, the breakout will be much weaker, and the risk high
to very high. The wisest decision in such cases is to buy smaller
quantities.
Trend
Let’s assume you wish to buy a stock which is up trending when the
market is downtrending. Should you buy? Most likely, you should not.
The most feasible eventuality is that the market will continue trending
down, and sooner or later your stock will follow the market direction.
Institutional investors buy only in accordance with market direction,
and if they don’t help you, it is better that you don’t buy.
Exceptions
Sometimes I break my rules on purpose. If, for example, I believe
something special is happening to a stock and its chances of rising are
particularly high, I might buy it even when the market is down
trending. Of course there is high risk when I buy against market
direction, and therefore my stop order, which is my protective
backstop, will be closer to the buy price, and of course I will buy a
smaller quantity.
Independent Stocks
There are very few stocks which have what is known in professional
jargon as “a life of their own,” meaning that they are not influenced
by the market direction. They are usually stocks with low volume in
which institutional funds do not invest, and are therefore less sensitive
to the moods of institutional traders as these moods manifest in
market direction. Usually these are stocks priced at less than $10,
which we will learn more about later. Be wary of these stocks unless
you have gained a lot of experience.
Sometimes a stock will have “a life of its own” when special
announcements are made. An example would be the publicizing of an
important announcement concerning a stock, when an analyst’s
recommendation goes live or is changed, when quarterly reports are
made public, and so on. In such cases, the stock may move
irrespective of market direction, though it will still be affected by
market direction. For example, the market may drop while a specific
stock rises. Nonetheless, if you compare the stock’s movement relative
to that of the market, you will see that every time the stock executed
an intraday reversal, it was closely synchronized with the market’s
intraday reversal. In other words, when the market corrects down
during a downtrend, the independent stock will correct down even
though it is showing an uptrend. This means that even if you are
trading in a stock that is moving against the market trend, you still
need to examine every move in the market’s trend.
Note:
All the principles noted above are also relevant in reverse for stocks
that are in a downtrend, i.e. for shorts instead of longs. If, for example,
the market is rising and on that same day, a certain stock in which we
wish to execute a short is dropping, it is still moving according to
market direction. While it is dropping, despite its direction being
the opposite of the market direction, it will correct up each time that
the market index goes up, and will go back to dropping each time that
the market index drops. By the end of the day, the market could end
with highs and the stock with lows, but the intraday movement will be
strongly influenced by market direction.
Index Symbol
Different trading platforms may present the same index under
different names, but with the same basis. If you wish to find the SPX
index, you may need to search for an identical or closely similar
symbol: SPX, $SPX or SPX$ - the same symbol with a dollar sign before
or after it. If none of these symbols matches your graph software, use
the symbol search field to look for the term: S&P 500.
Summary
The market index known as the S&P 500 represents not only the
market direction but also the mood of private and institutional
investors, and of traders. Institutional traders do not buy stocks when
the market index drops, but wait patiently until the index downtrend
causes the stock they are waiting for to drop, allowing them to buy it
at a cheaper price after the correction. When you buy a stock, you
should look for support from the institutional investors. You want
their mood to be as happy as possible, and you want their money to
enter the stock you have just purchased. Don’t expect that to happen
when the market index is dropping. Don’t fight the direction of the
market!
ETFs are financial instruments traded exactly like stocks, and are
therefore given symbols just like stocks. The SPY price is very similar
to its value in points with the deletion of one zero. In other words, if
the SPX stands at 1500 points, the SPY price will be in the vicinity of
$150. ETFs are more sensitive to supply and demand fluctuations.
Unlike the SPX, the SPY can be graphed to show volume, which
does not exist for an index.
If I haven’t yet confused you with the difference between the non-
traded index represented by SPX and the tradable ETFs represented
by SPY, I will likely succeed in confusing you now when I present the
most important variation of the S&P 500, represented by ES.
The ES is the S&P 500’s futures contract, or as it is professionally
known: E-mini S&P 500 Futures.
Without going into a detailed explanation at this point of “future
contracts,” I do wish to differentiate between a stock and a futures
contract: a futures contract is a “financial product” which can be
bought and sold just like stocks, but with one difference: its expiration
date is at the end of each quarter.
The price of the futures contract represents the “anticipated future”
of the S&P 500. In other words, the ES represents the anticipated
market direction. In actuality, the ES is a tradable contract, traded by a
crazy bunch of experts in the CME – Chicago Mercantile Exchange.
These traders operate in transactions with a volume of billions of
dollars daily. It’s commonly accepted on Wall Street that futures
traders know better than anyone else on the face of the earth whether
the market will go up or down. If you check the ES at the end of a
day’s trading, you will see that it precedes the SPX or SPY by several
seconds, and therefore allows you to note market direction earlier, too.
Since we have already understood that the S&P 500 is THE most
important index for the day trader and determines 60% of the
direction of stocks you are trading, if you also use the ES, you will
definitely know before others which way the market is moving. In
short, it’s worth money.
Not every broker or chart provider allows display of the ES, since
they need to pay for the information coming from the Chicago Futures
Exchange. If your broker does supply this information, you will likely
be charged some $50 per month for it.
Another advantage of the ES is the fact that it is electronically
traded almost 24 hours a day (it closes for 15 minutes at 4:15 pm EST)
except on weekends, which goes far beyond normal trading times of
stock exchanges, operating between 9.30 am to 4 pm EST. This means
that the ES is traded before other trading sessions open. Therefore, if
you look at the pre-market chart about one hour before the start of
trade, which is what I do, you will know whether the market will open
positively or negatively as compared to the prior day’s close. But of
course, you are not the only ones able to check the pre-market chart:
every decent financial site or television channel, such as CNBC, will
keep you updated prior to the trade session opening as to what kind of
opening the futures are “signaling,” adding a warning statement such
as: “Futures do not always represent market direction.”
Should You Trade in Futures?
Futures expire every three months, at the end of the third Friday of
any quarter. Simultaneous to their expiration, new futures contracts
are being formed and traded: their expiration date will be at the end of
the third Friday of the next quarter. Unlike a stock which carries a
fixed symbol, each future has its own symbol. Your broker can help
you find the current symbol of a future, but you can also do that
yourself, as will be explained.
An example of a futures symbol with an expiration date of the first
quarter of 2013 would be /ESH3.
Explanation of the Symbol
The slash always precedes the letters “ES,” which are the two letters
in the symbol that will never vary. The “H” represents the quarter,
which in this case is the first quarter of the year, i.e. this future expires
at the end of March. The digit indicates the year, i.e. 2013. The digit
will always be single: 3 is 2013, 4 will be 2014, 5 will be 2015, etc.
The quarters are represented as follows:
H – futures contracts expiring at the end of March
M – futures contracts expiring at the end of June
U – futures contracts expiring at the end of September
Z – futures contracts expiring at the end of December
I taught myself to remember which letter represents which quarter
by linking it with the name of a much loved food, “hummus,” as well
as the fact that the letters are in alphabetic order.
Question: It is currently September 2, 2013, and you wish to view
the relevant futures charts. What symbol will it carry?
Answer: You can already view futures expiring in December 2013,
but they will show lower liquidity than those expiring in September,
and therefore you will choose futures expiring in September. After the
third Friday in September, all trading volume will be on the December
contract, although most professionals “roll” to the new contract more
than a week before expiration.
The symbols will be:
Futures expiring in September: /ESU3
Futures expiring in December: /ESZ3
The market index is the most important index for intraday traders. If
I’m on holiday in Thailand and forced to forego my entire array of
screens in my trading room and make do with my 12-inch laptop, the
only index I will display, other than the chart for the stock I’m trading,
is the five-minute intraday SPY chart or the five-minute intraday ES
chart. Every market index movement will be important in helping me
decide whether I need to buy or sell a stock. I will use the SPX only
when I need to quote a change in the market for a professional article
I am preparing for the media.
I choose not to waste expensive paper on samples of the SPY or ES
charts, since they will look identical to those of the SPX, and you will
only see differences when you starting tracking them in real time.
NASDAQ 100: The Second Most
Important Index
The NASDAQ stock exchange also receives a good share of display
space on my computer screens. The NASDAQ 100 index, with its NDX
symbol, is the second most important index for day traders. The index
was developed by the NASD, National Association of Securities
Dealers, which established the NASDAQ stock exchange. This index
represents the price of the leading 100 NASDAQ companies. Since the
NASDAQ stock exchange contains a very high proportion of
technology companies, the index closely reflects the state of affairs in
these companies. A unique phenomenon for our times, in light of the
sharp rise in price of Apple’s stock [AAPL], developed when Apple
covered some 20% of the index’s movement. We often joke that if you
buy NASDAQ 100 ETFs, you get Apple, plus a bonus of some 99 other
stocks…
At this point it is not necessary to list the entire 100 important
companies represented by the index, which you can find easily on any
financial site, but you surely realize that in addition to Apple, the
NASDAQ 100 includes other well-known companies such as Microsoft
[MSFT], Intel [INTC], and Google [GOOG]. As with the S&P 500, here,
too, each stock carries a different weight. If Apple goes up some 3%, it
will have stronger influence on index performance than a similar rise
by a less important stock.
Since the S&P 500 contains the 500 most important stocks in the
market, clearly a significant proportion of NASDAQ 100 stocks will be
among the S&P 500. This explains why the S&P is considered more
important and reliable than the NASDAQ 100. Why, then, do I give
this index a central position on my trading screens? Is the S&P 500 not
sufficient?
The answer relates to the volatility of the NASDAQ 100. It is
comprised chiefly of stocks from technology companies. It is well
known that these stocks show high volatility relative to the lack of
volatility typical of most of the “solid” stocks in the broader S&P
market index. Technology stocks are more volatile because the “dream
element” embodied in their price is higher than the same“dream
element” in a company unrelated to the sphere of technology. For
example, the impact of a new electronic gadget on Apple’s stock price
will be more significant than on shares of Ford [F] when it announces
a new model. A volatile index cannot necessarily be relied upon,
therefore the NASDAQ 100 is given second place in the list of
important indices, but its second place is by virtue of its volatility.
As noted, 60% of market movement is dictated chiefly by the S&P
500. Therefore, it is important for me to analyze index direction. Since
the NASDAQ 100 is more volatile than the S&P 500, the NASDAQ
index will often indicate the expected direction before the S&P. As an
example, let’s assume that the NASDAQ 100 breaks out first to a new
high. Does that mean the stock I bought will also reach a new high?
No. As we learned, it will move chiefly according to the S&P 500 rather
than the NASDAQ 100, but the NASDAQ breakout may certainly hint
at the direction that the S&P 500 will take. To summarize: an early
NASDAQ 100 breakout causes me to suspect that the S&P 500 will
follow suit. The NASDAQ 100 early breakout is often like an advance
warning system of what will happen with the S&P 500.
The NASDAQ 100 symbol is NDX. As with the SPX, it may appear on
your charts with a $ sign before, after, or absent from the symbol:
NDX$, NDX, or $NDX. If one of these symbols does not match your
trading platform, use the symbol search field to find the symbol by
entering this term: NASDAQ 100.
The NDX, like the SPX, is not a traded index, which means you
cannot see its volume. It moves only during trading hours, as it is
computed based on the price of the 100 stocks that comprise it and are
traded in real time.
The NQ Symbol
As with the ES, NQ contracts expire every three months on the third
Friday at the end of each quarter.
An example of the symbol for futures expiring at the end of the
second quarter would be /NQM3. The slash and the letters “NQ” will
always remain part of the symbol. The rest decodes precisely the same
way as for the ES: “M” represents contracts expiring at the end of the
second quarter, and “3” represents the year 2013.
The Forgotten Index: Dow Jones, DJI
The Dow Jones Industrial Average [symbol: DJI], also known
simply as the “Dow,” was developed by Dow Jones & Company. It is
the most veteran and famous of indices on Wall Street. The index is
comprised of thirty of America’s larger companies over a variety of
sectors and is meant to act as a “bell weather” index for the economy.
Large numbers of investors worldwide view the Dow as the main tool
for following the US market’s mood. It is most often quoted in
financial media, but the Dow is the last index that needs to interest
you as traders. Stock exchange traders are often smug when they come
across investors who mention the Dow, which these traders often call
“the forgotten index.” The only reason it ranks in the third (yet still
highly respectable) position is not because you are meant to use it, but
because you will hear it abundantly quoted.
Keep in mind that Dow Jones & Company publicizes hundreds of
different indices relating to diverse sectors and various states. The DJI
is indeed the most famous of them all, but it remains only one of the
many indices.
Why do we not use the DJI? Firstly, because it is comprised of only
30 stocks, therefore is not truly representative of the market. Secondly,
the thirty stocks comprising the index are often the most “tired”
stocks of mega-companies which are highly lethargic. As traders, we
need volatile indices representing future expectations and not old
histories of mega-corporations. The Dow simply does not deliver the
goods.
The DJI may appear in your trading platform without the $ symbol, or
preceded by or following the letter symbol: $DJI, DJI$ or DJI. If one of
these symbols does not match your trading platform, use the symbol
search field to find the symbol by entering this term: Dow Jones
Industrial Average.
The DJI, like the SPX and the NDX, is not a tradable index, so you
cannot see any trade volume. None exists. The index moves during
trading session times and is a derivative calculated for 30 stocks traded
in real time.
The YM is the Dow Jones futures index and is professionally known as:
E-mini Dow Jones Industrial Average Futures contract. As with
the other futures described, the YM represents the expected futures
outcomes of the Dow. It is also electronically traded 24 hours a day on
the Chicago CME.
The YM Symbol
This, too, follows the pattern of the ES and NQ. The YM expires on
the third Friday of the last month of each quarter. An example of aYM
for the fourth quarter of 2010 is: /YMZ0.
Rebalance: How to Pro t from Index
Updates
Once each year, the research organizations Standard & Poor’s, Dow
Jones, and NASDAQ undertake a joint review of the composition of
companies included in the indices they manage. When a specific
company is encountering difficulties and its stock has plummeted, it is
highly probable that this company will be removed from the list and
replaced by a “new star.” Stocks such as Apple and Google did not
always appear on the index, but made their entrance due to strong
successes and to ousting stocks that were doing poorly or were
completely inactive.
Why does this need to interest you? For two reasons: first, never
believe a person who says something like, “If you had invested $1000 in
the Dow Jones 30 years ago, you’d be rich today.” That’s no less than
fraud, used by Wall Street salespersons and fund managers trying to
solicit you into a long-term investment. In actuality, the index changes
annually since stronger stocks replace those doing poorly. If you’d have
invested in the original index, you’d have lost a lot of money by now.
It’s time to make some order out of all the information above.
If you’re working with just one screen (which I hope won’t be for
too much longer), the chart that needs to cover nearly one-quarter of
the screen is the ES if you have access to futures, or the SPY if not.
If you have two or more screens, devote between one-third to half
of one screen to the ES alongside the NQ (or the SPY and QQQ). I
allocate about three-fourths of a 23-inch screen to these two indices.
Display the information in five-minute intraday candles. The larger
your screen is, the more trading days you’ll be able to display at once. I
suggest your display covers at least three trading days. Showing a
three-day history helps me search for the support and resistance
points over the last few, most current days.
Spot Test
Answers follow.
1. You are about to buy a stock that is about to break out, whereas
the ES index jumped a few minutes ago to a new high. Should you
buy?
2. You want to buy a stock currently running up, whereas the S&P
500 is trending down. Should you buy the stock?
3. You want to buy a stock, and at the same instant, the S&P 500
breaks out to a new high. Should you buy?
4. You want to execute a short on a stock, and it looks to you that the
S&P 500 index is about to break down to a new low, whereas the
NASDAQ 100 is trending up in a reverse pattern to the market
index. What should you do?
5. You want to buy a stock just as the NASDAQ 100 is breaking out,
but the S&P 500 has not broken out yet. Should you buy?
Answers:
1. As noted, 60% of a stock’s movement is dictated by the movement
of the market index. If the index has gone up and your stock didn’t
jump higher together with it, something doesn’t sound right. Maybe
a large-quantity seller is preventing it from going up? Maybe other
buyers aren’t interested? It is reasonable to assume that the market
will self-correct fairly soon for at least part of the highs, which
means the stock will likely drop rather than rise.
Conclusion: don’t buy, or buy only a small amount with a close stop
order, to protect yourself.
2. In your first three years of trading, I do not permit buying stocks
moving in the opposite direction to the market’s movement. If you
do, or if you execute a short on stocks not following the market
direction, the chances of you losing money are at least 60%. Once
you have amassed experience, you will learn how to operate against
market direction in some cases, but only under unique
circumstances and in specific stocks which show extreme movement
and ignore market conditions. First, gain much more experience.
3. Of course! If you’re about to press the buy button just as the
market breaks out to a new high, buying is a correct move that
reduces risk and significantly improves opportunity. It is reasonable
to assume that the market will strongly impact your stock and the
price will go up, even if you’ve made a wrong choice.
4. The NASDAQ 100 very often precedes the market index. If the
NASDAQ 100 is rising when it looks to you as though the market is
about to trend down, there is a reasonable chance that the market
will not break down, which increases your risk. Wait for the market
index’s breakdown to occur, and only then press the short button. If
the stock breaks down before the market cooperates, short for a
smaller quantity and be constantly on the watch for reversals.
5. Since it appears that here, too, the NASDAQ 100 may precede the
market index, it is indeed better to buy, but with great caution. Buy,
for example, half the total amount you might want in the hope that
the market index will also break out to a new high. If this does
occur, buy the second half of the quantity you had in mind, on the
condition that the stock’s price has not run too far ahead.
Sectors and Industries
So far, we have learned that 60% of price movement is influenced by
the market index (S&P 500) movement. But this is only partial
information. Of the remaining, 30% of the influence on movement is
derived from the movement of the sector to which the stock belongs.
Only 10% of the time will a stock “take itself into its own hands” and
make its own way in the market independently.
Stocks belong to industries, which together comprise a sector. The
financial sector, known simply as financials, is subdivided into four
industries: banks, various finance organizations, insurance companies,
and real estate companies.
When you are about to buy a stock, first check to which industry it
belongs. This may take a few seconds before you reach a decision, but
they are definitely a few seconds well spent. Over time, you will come
to recognize most of the stocks and will not need to check each one’s
industry. For example, to which industry does TEVA Pharmaceuticals
(symbol: TEVA) belong? Drugs. To which industry does INTEL
(symbol: INTC) belong? Semiconductors. The next time you
encounter these two, for instance, you should be able to remember
them. Within two to three years, you should be fluent in the sectors
for 70% of the stocks in which you trade.
Exercise in Comprehension:
On the daily chart, Southwest Airlines’ (LUV) stock shows a nice
pattern while trending up, and you wish to buy for a range of several
days (remember that several days is called “swing”). You’re waiting for
the best possible conditions.
When the trading session opens, you notice that the market is
rising strongly and the Oil & Gas sector is rising even more strongly
than the market. You check the reason and discover that fuel prices
are rising. An immediate outcome of rising fuel prices is a drop in
Airline sector stocks which are highly dependent on fuel costs.
Conclusion: today is not the right day to buy Airlines sector stocks.
Symbol Sector/Industry
DJI$ Industrial
BKX$ Banks
NBI$ Biotechnology
SOX$ Semiconductors
MVR$ Retail
NDXT$ Technology
QNET$ Internet
DJT$ Transportation
DJUSAR$ Airlines
DJU$ Utilities
DJUSAP$ Autos
DFX$ Defense
RXS$ Pharmaceuticals
IXTC$ Telecom
Multiple Symbols
To check the status of banks, it is possible to follow several
different symbols, sourced in the various indices developed by the
different companies. Dow Jones, for example, has its own banking
index, which is different from the index produced by Merrill Lynch.
This simply means that the Dow Jones analysts grade certain banks
differently from Merrill Lynch’s analysts. The symbols in the table
above are the most commonly used among traders, but individual
traders may have other preferences.
Integrating Tools
The most successful formula calls for cleverly integrating all the tools
described above. The ideal trade will integrate buying at the correct
technical entry point for the stock, while monitoring the market and
the industry to which the stock belongs. If you choose to buy a stock
that is stronger than the market and that belongs to an industry
showing strength on a day of an up trending market, you will greatly
enhance your chances of success.
Chapter 7 - Indicators: The
Trader’s Compass
Indicators, like a compass, show the
direction but not the path.
Reading a Million Individuals’ Thoughts
We have learned about trends, chart patterns, and indices, and now
we will discuss indicators, which are generally derived from the trend.
Indicators do not usually add new information which cannot be
learned from the chart, but sharpen and clarify the information
inherent in the chart. Let’s say, for example, that you have bought a
stock running up, and you wish to know when to sell it as close as
possible to its high. What defines the high? How can you use the
index to identify the high?
Volume of Trade
The volume of trade, or as it is simply known, volume, notes the
number of shares being traded at any given moment. Volume is
marked by bars at the base of the chart. Beneath each Japanese candle
is the volume bar appropriate to that timeframe. If the Japanese
candle represents five minutes, the volume will present five minutes,
and if the candle is green, the bar will also be green. Occasionally,
according to the trader’s choice or the platform’s limitations, the color
of all volume bars will be identical and it will not be possible to
distinguish between down volume and up volume.
Average Volume
Conclusion
A professional day trader will usually not trade stocks with an average
volume of less than one million shares per day. Not to worry: there are
thousands of stocks with a day volume in excess of that figure.
In summary, a professional trader looks for stocks trading over one
million shares per day on average, but also with volume better than
the prior day’s volume.
How can we know, after an hour of trading, whether the day
volume is going to top one million? Switch quickly from the intraday
five-minute candle chart to the daily chart, and check the volumes
over the previous few days. With just a glance you should be able to
see whether volume is only several thousand shares, or above one
million. If the volume is borderline, compare the volume of the
current day’s opening with that of the previous day’s opening, and try
to assess the current day’s potential on that basis.
Pay attention to another phenomenon which may mislead you.
Sometimes, a considerable portion of the volume derives from several
trades, or one single large trade. In other words, you might believe
that the intraday volume is large enough, but in actuality most of it
derives from one trade of hundreds of thousands of shares. To check if
this status is relevant, check the volume indicator and look for a single
candle that represents an extremely high volume.
When the volume of activity for a stock increases before the daily
breakout, we should suspect something significant happening to the
stock. Daily volume grows for a reason. Sometimes, it indicates news
that has yet to be publicized formally but has already leaked to “those
in the know.” It could also indicate a large institutional buyer who has
accumulated shares. As is customary in funds, once 90% of their target
is reached, the institutional buyers release the brakes and want to let
you know, by making large purchases, that they are interested in
supporting the stock. The trader is hoping that you, and many others
like you, are noticing that volume increase, and will join in and help
drive the stock price up.
Growth in daily volume can be simply identified using free Internet
screening software such as Yahoo Screener or Stock Fetcher. For
identifying intraday volume change, you will need to buy a more
advanced program such as Metastock. Most new traders should not
feel the need to buy these software packages and do all of the work
themselves. Trading is enough work. Use professionals and the tips
that they are willing to share to find stocks until you become
successful enough to try to find stock patterns for entry yourself.
One of the differences between the professional and amateur trader
is the former’s ability to correctly identify the entry price. Volume
growth helps us locate the entry price. An amateur will analyze several
indices (usually an unnecessary action) and make the buy decision
with a delay, only after his or her confidence level is sufficiently strong.
It is a known fact that the amateur’s confidence rises in direct relation
to the stock’s price rise, so that in most instances, the amateur’s entry
price will be lagging. A pro trader knows how to ignore extraneous
indices and reliably evaluate the correct entry price, with the stock
about to break out. Volume growth right before breakout is, in many
cases, the earliest sign of the impending breakout. Amateurs join later,
while professional traders are watching the stock’s price rise. To a
great extent, this is also the difference between profit and loss.
Big breakout volume represents the point of change in the public’s
perception of the stock’s worth. During pre-breakout consolidation,
very few are interested in buying the stock. The more the volume
grows, the greater the number of newly-interested parties. The more
buyers there are who believe that the stock will continue its new
trend, the greater the chances of success.
A stock that breaks out with a small volume does not catch the
“radar” of traders, and its chances of succeeding in the new trend are
much lower. After the breakout, investors are more skeptical, seeking
additional “proof” supporting the move. Large volume is definitely one
of the more important signs assisting us in deciding whether to hold
the stock. A stock not showing a volume increase will generally
encounter intraday institutional sellers for up to three days from the
breakout. Institutional supply will create a new area of resistance
which the stock will find hard to break.
SMART Funds hold stocks for the long term and are
therefore not sensitive to intraday price
MONEY changes. Traders buying before the
intraday breakout are highly sensitive to
even the slightest price change.
Large volume without any significant price movement can come about
from an institutional trader’s demand. The decision-making processes
of institutional traders are very different from those of day traders or
private investors. Institutional traders will give some weeks, if not
months, of consideration to buying a stock. During that time period,
they conduct an in-depth economic study, known as fundamental
research, on the company and its products, its financial reports, its
market status, and much more. As institutional traders manage huge
sums of money, they need to purchase extremely large quantities of
stocks, typically in the hundreds of thousands if not millions of shares,
in order to “move money.” That kind of quantity, if bought in the
market from random sellers, will create high demand and cause price
spikes before the fund has managed to collect the required amount.
The solution is arrived at through several avenues. First of all, the
fund will try to locate sellers holding large quantities and buy them
direct in “out of exchange” transactions. These usually cover hundreds
of thousands of shares in one transaction. Large-quantity buyers are
prepared to pay a little more than the market price based on the
premise that if they try to buy within market activity, the price will be
pushed up. A seller approached by an institutional trader knows that if
he or she tries to sell a very large quantity within regular market
activity, it will force the price down, and the seller will then receive
much less than the price offered by the fund.
However, by law, these out-of-exchange transactions must be
reported to the stock exchange, which means that the trade volume
will appear on your trading screen without its impacting the balance
between buyers and sellers, and therefore does not affect the stock
price even if the trade was executed at a price higher or lower than the
price currently traded on the market. A fund will try to obtain 80% of
the total planned quantity in this way. It will then go about trying to
purchase the remaining 20% slowly, carefully, quietly, in small
quantities each time, direct from stock exchange sellers. This volume-
dependent process may take from several days to several weeks.
The next stage is of great interest. The fund is already holding a
large quantity, and is now interested in signaling its interest to the
market, which causes the stock price to rise. The fund starts buying in
the market, creating volume and price highs which arouse interest and
draw the stock price to greater highs. The price trends up even more
strongly, and additional buyers, noticing the resonance, join the
trading. This in turn thrusts the price to even higher highs. Since a
large portion of liquidity is already held by the fund, the path has been
paved for the stock to climb virtually without resistance.
Does this sound a bit fishy to you? Who said the stock exchange is
the epitome of fairness?
How to Interpret Large Volume at the Daily High
When a stock breaks to a high on the daily chart, we can often see at
the high an extreme volume increase, known as climactic volume. It
usually takes some time until the public is convinced there is a real
story behind the breakout, and begins to buy. The reason for the
climactic volume is public enthusiasm. When, usually with some
delay, the public is finally persuaded and buys en masse, the “big
money players” move in: these are institutional sellers taking
advantage of the highs and large volumes in order to be rid of large
“blocks” of stock while the uptrend is at its highest. We call this
phenomenon “selling into the power.” Sellers cause resistance to
continued highs, creating the climactic volume. Large supply invites
short sellers, and price correction begins to appear. The last group of
sellers, the public, is the biggest loser. They feel pressured, sell, the
stock drops to near support level where it is again accumulated
cheaply by the institutional traders, and begins to reach highs again
with large volumes.
Moving Averages
As we learned, stocks do not rise in a straight line, but in zigzags. This
is the nature of the trend. Part of the natural process of reaching highs
involves pullbacks. A stock in an uptrend and correcting is still a stock
following its trend, and this is how we should view it.
Of course, not every low will be accepted with forgiveness, which
means we need an assistive tool for defining the trend. Moving
averages (MA) are tools that assist in Screen Configurationtrend
and warning of possible reversals. Their role is to flatten the zigzag
and make it easier to read the trend. Unlike other indicators that will
be described further on, the information provided by the MA is
unequivocal and makes reaching conclusions easy.
The MA is computed according to the averages of closing prices
for a defined period, and appears on the line chart as a continuous
line. By way of reminder, the “closing price” is the price at which the
last trade was made for the period being examined. For example, this
could be the closing price for the trading day if the timeframe is in
days, or the price of the last trade if the timeframe is five-minute
candles.
The average is called moving because the average of closing prices
is computed for each time within the period being checked. An
example is a moving average known as a “10 period MA” on the daily
chart. The average of closing prices for the past ten days is computed.
In this way, the average “moves” each day according to the closing
price of the day being added on to the previous nine days. The closing
price is the basis for calculating the MA, since the closing price is the
most important data.
Sample Calculation
Exercise: Calculate the 10 period moving average (10MA) at the
end of the 10th day for a stock that rose from $10 to $20 with a spread
of $1 per day over 10 consecutive days.
Answer: Let’s add up the closing prices of the past ten days:
11 + 12 + 13 + 14 + 15 + 16 + 17 + 18 + 19 + 20 = 155
The average for 10 days is 155/10 = 15.5
In other words, the MA at the end of the tenth day is 15.5, and is
written as follows:
10MA=15.5
If we also knew the trading data for a few days prior to this group of
ten, we would be able to calculate the MA for the 9th day, the 8th day,
and so on, connect all these results using a continuous line, and arrive
at the MA for 10 periods.
First and foremost, you should expect an up trending stock to ride the
20MA exactly as Akamai does over several months, starting at [1] and
up until the breakdown of the moving average. Riding above the 20MA
is considered a classic uptrend.
The 20MA line is therefore the line of support. When I look for an
entry point on a stock trending up, I need to find it as the stock is
close to the 20MA. This assumes that a strong stock will separate from
the 20-period line of support but will return back to support as it
continues to trend up. When the stock drops clearly below the 20MA
line, we expect it to be supported by the 50MA line, but this is also the
stage where we begin suspecting a reversal may be occurring. Breaking
down under the 50-period line almost always means a trend reversal.
Additional support should come from the 200MA line.
For upward trending stocks, when the chart crosses below the
20MA line, it means the uptrend could be about to reverse. Similarly,
for stocks trending down, when the chart crosses above the 20MA
line, it means the downtrend is about to reverse.
A formal reversal can be defined when both the slow and the fast-
moving average lines converge: for example, in the chart of Akamai,
we see where the 50-period and 20-period lines converge at [2]. The
significance of the reversal is that in the short range of 20 periods, the
stock has dropped, while at the longer range of 50 periods, the stock is
still holding the uptrend. Some traders wait for this convergence point
to sell, but in my opinion that is already too late. Checking the Akamai
chart, we see clearly that the decision to exit could be made long
before then.
Moving averages that parallel each other and are known as
“railway tracks” indicate a long, continuous trend. Distancing of MA
lines from each other indicates a strengthening trend, while closeness
indicates a weakening trend. At [1] we see the start of distancing
(divergence), and near [2] we see signs of closeness which ends with
convergence of the lines.
When to Sell?
You sell when the stock’s closing price for two consecutive days is
lower than the 20MA line.
Remember that you, too, should follow the behavior of the majority
of traders. If you choose to work with an MA that is different than
what the majority of traders use, you won’t receive the support of that
majority.
In the end, I couldn’t resist. Here is the outcome, just weeks after I
wrote the paragraphs above: a jump of 9% within several days.
Sometimes it seems that this game is just too easy…
Oscillators
The oscillator is a technical tool that assists in identifying
overbought and oversold statuses, and signals that the current trend
is reaching its end before the change shows on the chart. In other
words, the oscillator is a kind of indicator which helps identify when
“stupid money” is entering the market, contrasted with “smart
money” leaving the market; and vice versa.
When overlaid on a chart, oscillators are very useful for identifying
the extreme points and overbought and oversold prices of stocks.
Sometimes, though, oscillators can be too effective and cause
unnecessary and even mistaken trade activity. This is why an initial
signal for entry is insufficient, and it is best to wait for the second,
confirming signal. When the oscillator does not move in the same
direction as the trend, it is alluding to an approaching trend reversal.
Unlike trend-following technical tools, oscillators are very effective
when the stock is moving sideways. As the field of technical analysis
develops, there are increasing numbers of oscillators. In general,
because I am a total fan of “understanding the stock” and because I
don’t like a lot of “noise” on the chart during the trading session other
than volume, I tend not to use oscillators. At the outset of my trading
experience, I was far from understanding the stock and needed
oscillators just as you will during your initial stages. Hopefully, over
time, you will no longer need them either. Some years down the line,
when you’re completely free of dependence on oscillators, you will be
able to operate faster and more effectively.
Despite the above, however, when it comes to screening stocks,
there is no substitute for oscillators. Identifying candidates for trade at
the end of the trading session, before the new session opens, or during
the trading day all require using oscillators to help you prepare a
filtered, useful list of choice stocks.
Now is the time for an important cautionary note: sometimes new
traders attempt to use multiple oscillators simultaneously, magnifying
the “noise” as they work: usually, the result can be summed up as “not
seeing the forest for the trees.”
Fibonacci Sequence
The Italian mathematician Leonardo Fibonacci (1170 – 1250) wished to
find a mathematical depiction for the way rabbits reproduce. From his
experiments, he created a mathematical sequence bearing his name.
The sequence is as follows: 1, 2, 3, 5, 8, 13, 21, 34 and so on. The
sequence is based on several interesting rules: from the third number
on, each new number is the sum of the two previous numbers; from
the fifth number on, the ratio of any number to the preceding number
is approximately 1.618, and for any number and the number following
it, the ratio is 0.618.
So what is fascinating about 1.618? It is known as the “golden ratio,”
and amazingly, it can be found in multiple areas of our lives, from
natural phenomena to artistic works, and all the way to the behavior
of stock prices.
Followers of the “golden ratio” theory will claim that the ratio is
highly common in art and architecture. In actuality, it is a little
difficult to prove or refute this claim, chiefly because of the difficulty
in measuring it. Among buildings claimed to have been structured
according to the golden ratio are the ancient pyramids of Giza, the
Athenian Parthenon, and even the Dome of the Rock in Jerusalem.
Since the pervading opinion for many years now is that the golden
ratio is the most proportionate and hence attractive balance perceived
by humanity, architects and artists have adopted it in their works of
art and structures. It is known that Leonardo da Vinci applied it to
several of his most famous works, among them the facial features of
the Mona Lisa.
So just what is the connection between rabbits, culture and art, and
stock trading? The trader Ralph Elliott published a theory in 1932
known as the “Elliott Wave Principle.” I won’t describe the theory in
full detail, since I do not consider it important for short-term stock
traders, but will mention that according to this theory, the most
common ratios between the market waves are 38.2%, 50% and 61.8%,
the latter being the golden ratio. Being able to recognize this ratio
assists in estimating how the next wave will look, and determining the
appropriate entry and exit points. From that time on, the golden ratio
in short-term trading also grew in importance, as will be explained
further.
Bollinger Bands
When you define Bollinger bands on your charts, you will need to
take into account the following data: the MA should be set to ten
periods and the SD (standard deviation) should be set at 1.5. In other
words, the Bollinger bands wrapped around the movement of the
stock you are watching will be calculated according to volatility over
the past ten trading days. The mathematical value of the SD is that
90% of the stock’s movements will be captured between the two
bands.
Note how 90% of the stock’s movement is caught between the two
bands. Notice also that the distance between the bands widens as
volatility increases. In my personal opinion, Bollinger bands are the
most interesting and useful of all indicators that I display on my
intraday charts.
TRIN
Examine the TRIN and the market chart and try to “understand”
the relationship between these two indices. I do not expect you to
reach conclusions at this stage, but I do expect that when you start
trading, you will carefully observe both and try to understand the
balance and influence on anticipated trade patterns, especially at the
points of extremities.
Reservation: the TRIN is not a reliable stand-alone indicator. It is
only one of several indicators which together provide insight for a
trader. The TRIN must be integrated with additional indicators, and
all the information weighed to create a more informed comprehension
of anticipated market patterns.
Further note: The TRIN operates well on normal days. On days
when Wall Street is really riled up, many indicators, including the
TRIN, may show extreme outputs such as a 3 reading. The trader
needs plenty of experience to know just when to use the indicators for
a market that is beyond normal activity and operating chiefly on the
emotions of fear or greed. Such days can indeed be highly successful
for your trading account, as they are days on which it is relatively easy
to guess market patterns without the use of indicators.
TICK
The symbol on your charts will be $TICK, although the dollar sign
might be on either side of the word. Displaying the indicator can be a
problem. Few platforms know how to display it properly, since the
regular chart usually is unable to display a negative outcome. For this
reason you may need to make do with only the positive TICK results.
We display the TICK in five-minute intraday candles.
Even though the TICK indicator shows NYSE data and not
NASDAQ data, you should relate to it as though it represents data for
the entire market.
Exercise
The market is rising, the trend is up, and the TICK shows a strong
up reading of 1000. The stock you want to buy has just reached the
trigger point. Should you buy, or not?
2. TICK trend
Summary
The TICK primarily warns of points of exhaustion where the market is
about to undergo a short-term reversal lasting some minutes. Since
the market direction influences 60% of the movement of stocks you
are trading, you need to know if the stock you are buying is at the
point of extremity and about to return.
In special cases, despite the explanation above, we may buy a stock
for intraday trade even though a TICK reading hints at an anticipated
reversal. In such a case you need to relate to the action as a scalp,
which is buying and selling for a brief period of seconds to minutes. In
other words, you must be aware of the fact that the stock may
suddenly return and you must be more attentive and take some profit
at the first moment of weakness, when the stock appears about to
reverse. With a little luck, it won’t return.
The VWAP calculation. Take a deep breath, and then read this
twice: the VWAP is the average intraday price of a stock as a function
of volume at all levels of price. To calculate the VWAP at any given
moment, a sampling of the price of every transaction made up to the
calculation point is taken, the price is multiplied by the volume of
each transaction, all values are added up to the sampling point, and
the result is divided by the accrued number of shares traded up to that
same point (volume). If this explanation is too complex, don’t try too
hard to understand: skip it and just make do with the example below.
Example: Let us say that when the trading session opens, the first
trade in the stock of ABC is made at $30, for a quantity of 100 shares.
Multiplying those two figures produces 3,000, therefore the VWAP
(dividing the outcome by volume) is $30. Let’s say that the second
trade in ABC is at $30.10 for 1000 shares. The result of multiplying
those two figures is 30,100. Now the sum of those two first trades is
[3,000 + 30,100 =33,100] and the total trade volume is [100 stocks +
1000 = 1,100]. Dividing the accrued result of 33,100 by the trade volume
of 1,100 produces a quotient of $30.09.
Had we calculated a regular average of two trades without
encompassing the different volumes of trade for each transaction, the
result would have been $30.05. Does this figure reliably reflect the
stock price? Of course not. It is clear that a transaction of 1000 shares
carried far greater weight than a trade of 100 shares. The VWAP
produces a higher average as a function of including the volume in
each trade. It produces what is known as “the fair price” for ABC.
Now let us return to the institutional traders: when they receive an
instruction to buy 100,000 shares “on the cheap,” their clients and
managers are hoping that they will be able to make most of the
purchases at the lowest possible price below the intraday “fair price.” If
we draw the VWAP line across the stock chart, it will show us the
price above and below which 50% of the stock’s volume occurred. In
other words, if institutional traders succeeded in purchasing the stock
at lower than the VWAP line, they will enjoy a bonus, and if they
bought it at above that line… perhaps they need to find a different job.
Practical Applications
From our viewpoint, the VWAP indicator begins to get interesting
only after the first half hour of trading, once significant volume has
already been traded. Our starting point is that a stock being traded
above the VWAP can be expected to “return” to the VWAP. This is
because institutional traders instructed to buy the stock will not buy
when its price is above that level, and institutional traders instructed
to sell receive incentives for selling above the “fair price,” i.e., above the
indicator level. The opposite will occur when the stock is beneath the
VWAP: it will receive support by institutional traders buying “cheaply,”
while on the other hand sellers will wait for it to go over the VWAP.
For us, the meaning is clear and simple: a stock above the VWAP can
be expected to drop, and a stock below it can be expected to rise. The
VWAP therefore serves as a magnetic point over the course of the day.
PIVOT POINTS
Too many cooks spoil the broth, says the proverb. Too many indicators
are not helpful, but harmful! If you try to reach decisions using a
number of indicators, it is probable that I would buy and sell a stock
before you’ve even managed to say “Fibonacci.” While still novices at
trading, I suggest you use the following indicators:
• On the intraday chart in five-minute candles:
1. Volume
2. Moving Averages for 8 or 10 periods
3. VWAP on one chart and Pivot Points on a second chart
Shorting: Why?
Two-thirds of the time, the stock exchange trends up, and one-
third of the time it drops. Sometimes the periods of dropping markets
are long, and as with the Dot-Com Crash of 2000, can last for several
years. Crises occurred in the past, and crises will occur in the future.
Even during periods of dropping markets, a trader has to earn a living.
During such periods, I have no intention of looking for a new job in
hi-tech. This is when shorting comes into play. When you buy a stock,
it is called going “long.” A “short” is the opposite action.
• We use shorts to try and profit from down trending stocks.
• Usually the laws of entry for long buying are valid in reverse for
shorts.
We will learn more about this later. In this chapter, we will examine
how shorts operate.
The potential for profiting from shorts is far greater than from
longs. In fact, most of my profit as a trader derives from shorts. Why is
there greater chance of profit? For two main reasons:
• First, because stocks fall faster than they rise.
Why? A pressured investor will sell faster than it took a greedy
investor to buy a rising stock.
• Second, shorts are a superior means for making a profit, since 99%
of the public does not understand them nor knows how to execute
them.
As usual, the big money is where the public doesn’t know what to
do.
Checkpoint sank below the line of support at $35. Let’s say I want to
sell 100 shares short, and I press the short button at [1]. What
happens? I have just sold 100 stocks I don’t have!
How can I do that? Very simply, because my broker loaned them to
me. How does my broker have 100 Checkpoint shares? The broker
manages the accounts of multiple clients. Since Checkpoint is a high-
volume stock, it is reasonable to assume that some of the broker’s
clients hold Checkpoint shares.
Now let us say that one of the broker’s clients, a fellow named
David, holds 300 Checkpoint shares in his account. David bought
them two years ago, and believes in their long-term future. When I
pressed the short sale button, the broker took 100 of David’s shares
and sold them for me according to my instructions.
In actuality, I sold 100 authentic shares, but they are not mine. If
David were to suddenly check his account, would he find 300 or 200
shares? Since no one bothered to update David that I sold 100 shares
belonging to him, David still thinks he has 300 in his account, even
though in reality there are only 200. What would happen if David
decided to sell all 300, right then? The broker would simply shift 100
from someone else. Legal? Absolutely.
In one of the conferences where I taught, a young woman raised
her hand and said in all seriousness that she felt the system of selling
short did not withstand the test of integrity. Perhaps not; but it
definitely does hold up to the test of the market and the law. Markets
are not socialist by nature. The market is not intended to assist
anyone, and no shorter gives consideration to the best interests of the
public, only to his or her own interests. We can think about that
situation in the following way: I borrow David’s shares and sell them.
David has an interest in his shares going up in value, but by selling his
shares, I increase the supply and cause a drop in stock price. Not only
does David have no idea he is helping me, but by selling his shares, I
cause him damage. Pure capitalism.
Summary
When we expect a stock to rise, we can buy low and sell high. When
we expect a stock to drop, we still buy low and sell high but in reverse
order: first we sell high, then buy low. As you see, no one has yet
come up with a better way to make a profit other than the ancient
method of buying cheaply and selling at a higher price.
In light of the fact that stocks drop faster than they rise, shorts
work better and are faster and more reliable than longs: from my point
of view, intraday trading in shorts is less risky. The risk in shorts may
ambush you if and when you swing trade a short, holding it for days at
a time, since you can never know what the situation will be when you
wake up. We execute shorts on weak stocks. When a weak stock
reverses, the effect of the upward correction can be sharp. (Later we
will learn about the “short squeeze.”)
Another aspect is the potential for loss. If you are holding a long
position, the maximum potential for loss is the value of the stock. A
stock worth $20 can drop to $0, so the maximum loss is limited to $20
per share. By contrast, when you hold a short, the potential for loss is
unlimited since a stock worth $20 can also rise to $200, or in theory,
“to infinity.” This occurs in very rare cases and your likelihood of ever
experiencing such a situation is very low, but it is definitely a risk that
must be taken into consideration and recognized.
Summary
During the day’s trading, shorts are not any more risky than longs.
However, if you choose to hold shorts for several trading days, they
can definitely become dangerous and will require a high level of skill
and caution.
How long does a broker let you hold a short? This varies from one
broker to another. Some require closing shorts within three trading
days, while others set no limitations.
So far, I have reviewed the principles of short selling, why they exist
(the need to profit from dropping stock prices), and how the
procedure is conducted. Now it’s time to look deeper.
You know that when executing a short, you are selling shares that
are not yours in the hope that when the stock drops, you will buy it
back at a lower price than what you sold. Up to this point, it sounds
simple, and for many traders and investors that is all you need to
know. But from the viewpoint of those who like to understand how
trading works, there is a lot more to learn.
Can short selling be executed with every stock? What might
happen if you were interested in shorting on a stock your broker does
not hold? In actuality, you will discover that you cannot execute a
short on all stocks. The limitation is tied to the stock’s public
ownership and the number of open shorts on it. In other words, a
stock with low public ownership will not be held by a great many
clients, and therefore the possibility of your broker loaning it to you is
limited. A second limitation often occurs when a stock with high
tradability drops sharply, usually as a result of a newsworthy event.
Sometimes the quantity of shorts on a stock is so large that all
available shares have been leant to other shorters. However, for 95% of
the stocks with high tradability, which is the only type in which we
trade, shorts can be executed and any limitation is actually fairly
uncommon.
In this daily chart, you can see a rare example of a large percentage
crash in Goldman Sachs (GS) stock, resulting from the publicized
criminal investigation into the company’s conduct based on the fear of
investor fraud during the 2008 financial crisis. In the Tradenet trading
room, we shorted at the start of the process, when the stock dropped
to below $174. Two days later, when we saw that the downtrend was
continuing and we wished to increase the quantity of shorts, we found
that this was not possible because all available shares had already
been taken by other shorters.
Regulatory limitations can occur, although very infrequently. In
cases such as the financial meltdown of 2008, shorts were prevented,
based on political considerations. Once every few years, usually during
crises, the public’s voice rises to a shout against shorters, and a moral
argument ensues concerning the contribution or harm shorters wield
on market stability. In some rare instances, shorts were prohibited on
certain financial stocks for several weeks. In actuality, the limitation
was set only towards the close of the crisis at points in time that no
healthy shorter would execute new shorts. So in actuality, the
prohibition barely affected traders. As traders, we have become
accustomed to the resurfacing every few years of the time-honored
dispute between supporters and detractors of shorting. Each side has
its “justifiable reasons,” but in the final run, history has proven that
the voice of logic overcomes opposition.
How can you know that it is not possible to execute shorts in a
certain stock? When you press the SHORT button, the trading
platform will display a message, usually of one word: Unshortable.
Some trading platforms allow accessing this information even before
you give the order.
Example
Let’s say a company called ABC has a high quantity of shorts.
• Does the large quantity of traders executing shorts on the stock
mean that the stock must drop?
• Or does it mean that with so many shorts executed, the shorters
eventually needing to buy the shares in order to return them to the
owner will cause the stock to rise?
• The answer is: both situations can occur, and it all depends on
timing.
The truth is that for a company losing value, with its price
plummeting towards zero, it may get to that point irrespective of the
quantity of shorted shares. The reverse can also occur: if there are a
large number of shorters and for some reason the stock begins to rise,
shorters will panic since they will need to buy high. As a result, short
covering may begin: shorters, pressured by the need to return the
shares and seeing the price rising, will need to “cover” open shorts.
You can never know what is happening behind the scenes without
checking the stock chart. And this issue brings us to the next, very
important topic.
Short Squeeze
Summary
Naked Shorts
We will now take a look at the dark side of short selling and learn
about the phenomenon known as “naked shorts,” so called because
they have no real cover. The phenomenon occurs when a large
organization, usually a hedge fund, interested in shorting a very large
quantity, sells shares it cannot borrow!
How can it do this? After all, we have just learned that shorts
cannot be executed on shares that cannot be borrowed. But as we
know too well, nothing stands in the way of those who really desire
something, and market makers can make that something happen.
They do this by selling shares they do not have, and transferring these
“naked shorts” from one account to another for periods so short that
the regulatory body cannot follow the trail. They can also do this by
executing shorts in stocks of US dual-traded companies which are
simultaneously traded on stock exchanges outside America. These
foreign stock exchanges are not concerned with enforcing the
regulations.
Why would organizations make a naked short trade? It often
creates big business, especially during periods when the economy is
weak and the dollar has dropped heavily compared to its competitors.
In such times, company values drop, they weaken, and eventually are
forced to issue more shares in order to recruit funds. This works in the
shorters’ favor. Even shareholders may eventually be forced to sell
more shares which until that point had not been in circulation in the
market.
Summary
The bulk of the public loses money during economic crises. You and I
will also lose when the economy collapses, inflation runs wild, and the
funds in which our money is invested are negatively affected by a
dropping market. In short, during crises we all lose out, and we have
no control over that. By contrast, however, as traders we must learn
how to profit from dropping markets, and not merely profit, but profit
big. The learning process is long, and you will not be able to start it
during the next crisis or just weeks in advance of it. You need to
prepare for the next crisis years before it happens. In other words, you
need to start preparing right now.
Chapter 9 - The Trading Platform
Practical Steps to Choosing,
Con guring, and Operating Your
Trading Platform
My Trading Platform
First, you need to open an account with a broker and deposit money
in it. This issue was covered in Chapter Two. Once you have completed
the account opening process, which should take no more than a few
minutes, you will have to wait for the broker’s authorization, which
could take a few days. You will receive an e-mail congratulating you for
joining, and a platform download link. The download process is
simple and identical to that of any program, and therefore needs no
explanation. The questions begin to surface after installation and with
the first time you open the platform, since at this stage you still have
no clue, really, about what to do. More on that later.
On the market index chart I display the SPY, which as we have already
learned is the most important index for traders. The chart will display
intraday information and five-minute candles for a two-day period.
Note the perforated line separating the two days.
Level II
Beneath the personally defined buttons is the data area known as
Level II. It displays buyer demand [5] and seller supply [6] or, as it is
known by traders, “market depth.”
In the instance shown above, you can see that the best purchase,
known as BID (on the upper left) stands at $54.25, whereas the best
selling price, known as ASK (upper right) stands at $54.26. In other
words, the difference between buyers and sellers, known as between
ask and bid, and called SPREAD, is one cent. To the left of the price
column is the MMID (market maker ID) column. This contains
identity details of the buyer or seller. The buyer’s or seller’s source may
be an ECN, as with ARCA or NASDAQ; or a market maker like SBSH
(Salomon Smith Barney). Sometimes, you can find the market maker
for both parties: for buyer and seller simultaneously. In the case that
both a buyer and seller are available on an ECN, this usually indicates
different clients of the same ECN, and in the case of a market maker
for both parties, the market maker is trying to profit from the one cent
spread. One cent, in very large quantities that only market makers
generally see, can end up being a lot of money!
The market depth (that is, the quantity of buyer demand and
quantity of seller supply) is very significant. We see how the buyers
(the bid) at $54.25 spread across three lines which are emphasized
with the same color. Each price layer receives its own color. The total
demand quantity at that level of demand is 2900 shares. Notice how
the accepted display form of quantities is in units representing
hundreds. In other words, 14 + 14 + 1 = 29 represents a demand of 2900
shares at $54.25. Demand, in this case, is divided among three
different buyers. On the sellers’ (ask) side, you can see a relatively
smaller supply of 1700 shares at $54.26. The meaning of larger demand
than supply is clear: when there are more buyers than sellers, there is
a good probability that the stock price will rise. On the other hand, if
the surplus demand has caused you to decide to buy, then it is first
worth glancing at the number of sellers found at two cents above the
current supply price. Notice that at $54.28, two sellers are trying to sell
a quantity of 2900 shares. In other words, if you buy the stock and it
goes up only two cents, it may have difficulty in crossing the resistance
of the next batch of sellers. Have you already cancelled your buy
order? Or is it worthwhile buying only if it passes $54.28?
Let’s say that despite the resistance, you are considering buying.
Before that, you must check your escape path. If you check the buyer
depth, which is below the price of $54.25, you will discover that
demand is very low. In other words, if you purchase several thousand
shares, you will find great difficulty in exiting at a reasonable price.
The solution may be in buying a smaller amount, or perhaps not
buying at all. On the other hand, if you are planning to execute a short
on the stock and when pressured, may need to exit the short (that is,
buy), you can rely on a large number of sellers from whom to buy.
Every stock has a different tradability, which means you need to check
each one from the point of view of quantity you are willing to risk, and
adapt it to the number of bids and asks as displayed in the Level II
market depth.
Hiding information
Large quantity buyers and sellers tend to hide the real quantities they
are offering since they do not want others reading their intentions. For
example, when I want to sell a quantity of up to 1000 shares, I use a
command known as RESERVE which displays a sale of only 100 shares
even though the amount in actuality is far larger. The buyers, who do
not know they are watching a large quantity seller, buy a small amount
each time, until eventually they buy the entire amount I intended to
sell. What might happen if I displayed an amount of 3000 shares, for
example? Without doubt I would scare away small buyers who would
avoid buying, since they know that if they buy a small quantity, the
stock will not move until a large buyer would come along and
purchase all the stocks I am trying to sell.
Sometimes, when you hold a stock whose price has stopped at a
certain position and refuses to continue trending up when you are
long, or refuses to trend down when you are short, try to discover in
the MMID column who the seller is, insisting on adding quantities, or
in the case of a short, who the buyer is that insists on renewing
quantities. The phenomenon is very common in cases when the stock
is trending up and reaches a round number, and heavy sellers can
often be found who are not interested in revealing the true quantity
they are offering for sale.
The T&S window shows every transaction executed for a stock. The
usual display is for the latest trade to appear in the window’s upper
section. As you see, the latest trade occurred at $54.25 for a quantity of
shares listed as “1”, in other words, 100 shares. The trade before that
was for 400 shares. If you look a little further down, you will find a
trade at $54.249, a transaction that only market makers are capable of
making as they “cut” the price between buyers and sellers, and it is the
first in the list between the spread. This is their advantage area, since
you and I have no legal ability to perform trades with fractions of
cents.
Practical examples
• A sequence of green trades: the stock is strong, and trending up.
Buyers are pressuring.
• A sequence of red trades: the stock is weak. Sellers are getting rid of
the merchandise at any price.
• A sequence of red trades but the stock price is not dropping: a large
scale buyer hiding a large amount.
• A sequence of green trades but the stock price is not rising: a large
scale seller hiding a large amount.
• A sequence of white trades: market makers are trading at an
intermediate price. It is hard to interpret the meaning of this, but it
is interesting to know that market makers are involved.
Executing orders
The main use of the stock box is to execute buy, sell, short, and
additionally, more complex orders such as defining profit and
protection targets.
The account manager window contains two tabs in the lower bar: one
is the open positions marked as POSITION, and the other is the
ACCOUNT tab. In the first, you will be able to see the profit and loss
status of every open trade. In the account tab, you can find a summary
of all open or closed activities. The image above shows a realized profit
of $136; buying power available to the account during the trading day,
where BP stands for buying power; the overnight BP; the number of
trades, which here is two, and is also known as Tickets; and the
volume of trading day sales and purchases, here showing 1200 under
the Shares tab, which in this case refers to a purchase of 600 shares
and a sale of 600 shares.
This window displays real time information derived from various data
suppliers. The window shows the notification’s time, the stock’s symbol,
and a summary of the information. Clicking the button on the summary
line allows me to see an image, opening an additional window
displaying the detailed information. I do not tend to follow market
notifications. The rate at which they enter is very high and it is difficult
to efficiently scan them and focus only on the important, impactful
notices. For me, working with this window wastes precious time. On the
other hand, perhaps I am not providing a good example, since one of
the traders in our trading room insists that he absolutely makes his
living from the real time information coming through. So the choice is
up to you.
The limit order is very common and very useful. Its simple meaning is
“Buy (or, sell) at this price limit.” The two commands are called buy
limit order and sell limit order.
Here is an example: when I look at the Level II window, I see that
the ask (ie: sellers) are offering stock of TEVA for $54.26. I decide to
buy 1000 shares at no higher than that price. To do this I will use the
limit order, which I feed in and execute in the stock box as follows:
1. I enter the stock symbol TEVA [1]
2. Enter the amount of shares wanted: 1000 [2]
3. Enter the limit ($54.26) in the order execution window [3]. It is also
possible to choose this price by clicking on it in the Level II window
on a seller at that price.
4. I choose the limit order [4]. For example, ARCAL. There are
several limit options possible, which will be detailed later.
5. Lastly, I click the BUY button [5]
• Notes
If there are sufficient sellers to supply the 1000 shares I seek, I will
receive the entire amount. However, if someone else hit the buy
button faster than I did, the full size that I want might not be
available. For example, if someone else gets to 300 shares before me, I
will be executed on 700 shares and an open buy order is created for
the 300 shares I still want. My demand for 300 shares will now appear
as the highest BID and will wait until sellers come along. At any time,
I can cancel the bid for 300 shares by clicking the cancel button.
• Practical example
In the market depth image (Level II), you see that the number of
sellers at $54.26 stands at 1700 shares. What would happen if I wanted
to buy 2000 shares with a limit of $54.26?
Answer: since only 1700 shares are offered there, that is the
maximum quantity I could buy at the limit price I have set. The only
way I can receive all 2000 is if there are sellers hiding their real supply.
Outcome: since there are insufficient sellers at $54.26, the ASK
price will go up by one cent to $54.27 and the BID price will also go up
one cent to $54.26. My bid price will display as an open order for 300
shares. It will remain open until someone is willing to sell at my limit,
or until I cancel the open order.
What would happen if I tried to buy 2000 shares at a limit of
$54.27? Note that at this price, one seller is offering 100 shares. In
other words, I would receive 1800 shares total: the 1700 shares at
$54.26 and 100 at $54.27.
What would happen if I had set a limit of $54.28? Judging by the
number of sellers at $54.28 you can see that I would have received the
whole amount of 2000 shares from the moment I clicked BUY. I could
even have received more than 2000, if I had wanted them.
Would it not have been worth buying some of that quantity of 2000
shares from the beginning, at the higher price? Not necessarily; it
depends on how much you really want the entire amount. It is usually
better to take the smaller quantity, and wait a few seconds, or a little
longer, for more sellers willing to meet your lower limit.
Market order
The market order, by contrast to the limit order, indicates: “I want
to buy or sell now, no matter what the price is!” This order is executed
immediately when the button is clicked, hitting all shares available for
sale until I am filled. For example, if I try to buy 2000 TEVA shares via
a market order, I will immediately get the quantity I want, but at what
price? According to the supply we saw in the Level II window, I will
receive 1700 at $54.26, 100 more at $54.27 and 200 more at $54.28.
That’s not bad for shares with high liquidity. If I try to buy 2000 shares
with low liquidity using the market order, I may in extreme instances
jump the stock price by tens of cents, and then discover that when I
want to sell, there are not enough buyers. The market order is
therefore very effective and fast, but useful only when you want stock
with high volume.
Stop order
Let us say you are holding 400 shares of ABC and are interested in
entering a stop market order if the stock drops to $29.70. The
sequence of actions you need is as follows:
1. Enter the stock symbol [1]
2. Enter the quantity of shares you want to protect in case of falling
prices [2]. You don’t need to enter the entire amount you hold.
3. Choose the order type [3]. In this case, ARCAS was chosen. We
will learn more on this later.
4. Click the SELL button [4].
5. An additional window will open: enter the type of order – market
or limit – to be executed if the price drops to the stop price [5].
6. Enter the stop price [6], which in this case is $29.7.
7. If at step [5] you chose a limit order, now you need to enter the
limit (e.g. $29.67). Not recommended!
8. Authorize the execution by clicking OK.
9. Check in the trade manager window, under the Orders tab, that
the order was lodged. If it does not appear, check why in the
Messages box and correct any errors.
• Short Stop Loss Order - When you short a stock, you are selling a
stock you borrowed from the broker, and you will want to protect your
account should the stock price go up. Your stop order will be a BUY
rather than a SELL (step 4 above), and your stop price (step 6 above)
will be higher than the stock’s current price. Other than that, the
procedure is identical. It implies that if the stock price rises to price X,
please buy according to your choice of a limit or market.
With a trailing stop order, the stop price moves up with the stock.
In other words, the stop will always maintain the distance of 30 cents
below the stock’s peak price, no matter how much it goes up. In other
words, you can enter the trailing stop and go on vacation. This, by the
way, is the only time I would recommend using the trailing stop –
when you are on vacation. Its disadvantage is that it is based on
nothing: not on areas of support or resistance, and not on intraday or
daily reversals. If you’re going to be away from the computer for
several hours, enter a stop order at one single, lower price for a while,
according to the stock’s behavior, and suited to the right technical
area. A trailing stop is usually a bad idea.
Complex Orders
Not all trading platforms are able to execute complex orders, but the
COLMEX Expert system can. These orders are structured from several
different steps that, when activated, cancel other steps. For example,
Stop Limit +TTO does the following: (1) buys the stock at a specific
price (stop price), but not for more than a defined price (limit), and
then (2) if the stock was bought, activates a profit or loss order. Then,
(3) if the price goes up to profit target, sells and (4) if the price drops
to the stop loss, sells. When either the stop loss or profit target is
reached, it cancels out the other.
The significance of this complex order is clear: it makes defining all
parameters of the trade possible by defining both the trigger price,
controlling the maximum execution price (the limit), and then the
target or loss prices. These orders can be entered before trading hours,
and then you can go on vacation. Amazing!
Here is an example of a complex stop order for buying 1000
SanDisk shares, SNDK:
When you buy or sell a stock, you need to decide how you want to
route the orders. Routing is a topic on which entire books can be
written. At this stage, I do not suggest you delve too deeply into it,
since it is particularly interesting for those who trade in very large
quantities of thousands or tens of thousands of shares.
First, we need to understand what routing is. In Chapter 1, we
learned that when you are interested in buying or selling a stock, you
need to find a buyer or seller willing to take the role of the other party
in the transaction. One possibility is to route your orders to the
market makers. We learned that they make their profit within the
spread between buy and sell prices. We also learned that we might
encounter the specialists, the NYSE version of the NASDAQ market
makers. Another routing option is direct to the ECN (Electronic
Communication Network). The ECN is a network of computers that
links buyers and sellers and in which you can set buy and sell orders
without the agency services of market makers.
As stock traders, in contrast to investors, you need to use a Direct
Market Access (DMA) trading platform. This allows you to route your
orders to whomever you choose: direct to market makers, or to the
ECNs. The advantage in market makers is that they do not take
commissions for executing the order, but they will be a little slower. By
contrast, the ECN options are much faster, but if you remove liquidity
(to be explained later), they will take a commission which is currently
$3 for every 1000 shares.
Automated Routing
Manual Routing
When I open the routing dropdown list [1], I can choose my order
type (limit, market or stop) and where to route it. As you see above,
the first three orders are the ones I generally use. If, however, I want to
direct my orders to other destinations, I can choose from many
options.
Why might I want to change the destination? Notice the amount of
sellers on the ASK side. You can see that the first seller, with an
amount of 2100 shares, is ARCA, and the second, with 1200 shares, is
NASDAQ. If I am interested in buying up to 2100 shares, I would
choose the ARCAL navigation, click the button and buy the shares
direct and fast via ARCA. On the other hand, if I want a larger
quantity, I would need to buy shares via the other, NASDAQ ECN
marked as NSDQ.
The advantage of ARCA over many other ECNs is the speed and
nature of its operation. If the entire amount sought is not on ARCA,
they commit to finding it for me from another ECN or market maker.
In other words, they will supply me with 2100 shares which they are
holding, and then buy the rest from another ECN. In my opinion,
ARCA does the work better and faster than other ECNs, although if
you are buying very large quantities, you may need to route your
orders direct to different destinations.
Adding and Removing Liquidity
ECNs compete with each other and try to attract traders to their
services. The more one ECN’s market depth increases relative to a
competitor, the more traders will use its services and pay its
commissions. When I buy stock displayed by a buyer in the ASK
column, I am “removing liquidity,” meaning that I reduce the number
of sellers of the stock I bought, which is not good from the ECN’s
point of view. When I sell shares to a buyer on the BID side, I am
removing liquidity of buyers, which decreases market depth. For
removing liquidity, I pay the ECN a commission of $3 for every 1000
shares. This commission is in addition to that which I pay to my
broker, and the broker passes that extra commission down to me.
These are known as pass through commissions and are collected
separately from the regular commission agreed upon between me and
my broker.
Another cheaper possibility is to position my buy order on the BID
side and wait for a seller to offer shares to me, instead of buying direct
via the ASK. When I do that, I am actually adding liquidity, and for
that the ECN gives me $2 for every 1000 shares, which the broker also
passes along to my trading account. In other words, I have just
reduced the costs of my trade. The advantages of this method are dual:
I receive a commission instead of paying it, and I buy the stock at one
cent less, which is a saving of $10 for every 1000 shares. The
disadvantage of adding liquidity arises from my needing to wait until a
buyer comes along who is willing to sell the shares at my BID price.
From my experience, if you want to exit, it is almost always
preferable to remove liquidity and pay the surplus commission, since
in most cases the price will just “take off” and you could be left with
even greater damage.
Summary
Order Routing
Working directly with the ECN, adding or removing liquidity, is
usually the most appropriate mode of operation for advanced traders
operating with large quantities of shares. It is reasonable to assume
that as you start out, you have sufficient other details to pay attention
to, therefore I recommend once again that you choose the automatic
routing provided by your broker. If you have no such option, choose
the ARCAL default.
Trade Orders
You can’t see the forest for the trees? The bottom line is very
simple. This is the best way to get ahead: your trading platform should
always be set to the limit order, since you will be using it 90% of the
time. In special cases, you will use the market order, and generally,
only after you have bought a stock or are planning a complicated
entry, will you use the stop order. As you accrue experience, you will
find that it’s not as scary as it sounds.
My trading room
Scary? Since taking this photo, I have added another screen, which
is outside the frame. Together with the projector, I use no less than ten
screens. Sometimes I do wonder if I need them all, or whether I buy
them just to impress the pool cleaner who, with every visit, tells me
how he dreams of being a trader, “but never finds the time for it.”
I use a lot of screens because I like to see what’s happening in the
market. Sectors, indicators, and dozens of stocks can be displayed at
once. As the head analyst of the Tradenet trading room, I must be
constantly up to date in real time with every event. In addition, this is
my profession and my hobby. Every professional invests in good work
tools, whether that’s a quality drill which is effective, reliable and
therefore saves time, or any other kind of tool in constant use.
Similarly, I invest in quality computers and screens. Can you guess
how much it costs to set up three desktops, two laptops, seven 23-inch
screens and a projector? Approximately $4000. A builder/renovator’s
toolbox costs a great deal more!
If you’ve made the decision to become a trader, invest in the
infrastructure. You can start with a computer linked to two screens,
although very quickly you will move to a desktop linked to four. Trying
to save money? Like the ”chicken or the egg” argument, buying cheap
will end up expensive. If you do not invest in a quality infrastructure,
you may never succeed. If you are still unsure whether this is the
profession you want to pursue, start with just two screens but be ready
to add more fairly quickly.
My Screen Setup
Let’s start from left to right. The projector is hooked up to my old
laptop which should long ago have made its way into the trash can,
but it serves well for displaying content from financial sites. The
projector is also linked to the cable converter, and occasionally, when
there is important news or when planning the trading day, I display
CNBC on it. The other screens display the following information:
1. Charts of the two market indices: SPY and QQQ, as well as three
sector charts: Bioteck (NBI$), Banks (BKX$) and semiconductors
(SOX$)
2. Screens 1 to 4 are operated by two dual screen cards in one desktop
computer. Screen 2 follows 15 stocks. In the lower quarter of the
screen are my Account Manager and my Open Orders.
3. Two stock boxes, each linked to a Time and Sale (T&S) window and
the chart for their relevant stock. Along the right of the screen are
charts for four stocks for intraday follow-up. That section of the
screen is where I usually display several open trades.
4. Two stock boxes, each of which is linked to Time and Sale (T&S)
and their relevant charts.
5. This screen follows stocks trending up: charts for some 16 strong
stocks I am following during trading hours. These are stocks for
which I seek opportunities to enter in reversal in an up trend, or buy
at breakout. This screen is linked to a laptop for which screen 6 is its
main screen.
6. Stock box linked to the Time and Sale (T&S) window and a chart
showing the stock, my second account manager (my second
brokerage account), and orders. It displays the leading 20 rising or
dropping stocks: my Top 20.
7. This screen follows stocks trending down: charts for 16 weak stocks
I am following during trading hours. These are stocks for which I
seek opportunities to short a reversal in a down trend or short at a
breakdown.
8. A stock box linked to the Time and Sale (T&S) window and chart
displaying the stock, my third account manager (my third brokerage
account), and orders; a follow-up list for sectors; and a real-time
stock scanner operating to predefined parameters, meaning stocks
that have risen or dropped by certain percentages and stocks
reaching new highs or lows.
Chapter 10 - Winning Trades
It’s Time To Click the Button: Best
Entry and Trade Management
Methods
How Many Times Will You Need to Read This Chapter?
Before we start the most important chapter of this book, let me share
some of my concerns with you. I am afraid you might miss something
important, something huge! Why? Because naturally, the first time
you read this book you will not understand its significance in the same
way you will after several months of experience. When I ask myself
what the chances are of you reading this chapter a second and even a
third time, I fear the chances are slim. And I am fairly certain that on a
first reading alone, you will not grasp the real meaning of this chapter.
Integrating Tools
We have learned why we need to trade with the trend, the meaning of
the important trading indicators, and what to be careful of, but does
that now imply that we can find any stock trending up and buy it? Can
we enter the stock at any moment while it is trending up and the
indicators support continued uptrend?
No!
The market direction and use of indicators are important
components, and even critical to success, but they are not enough. To
succeed, we need to choose the right stocks under the right market
conditions, and most important, at the right points!
You need to know when to click the button and when to get out.
The purpose of this chapter is to integrate these tools, trends,
indicators, and most vital of all, entry points.
Remember! The right entry point is responsible for 80% of your
trade’s success.
In the image above, we see that PCAR begins the day’s trading at
$46.40, rises, encounters resistance at $47.5, and consolidates [1]
beneath the upper price range until the breakout [2]. The interesting
point in this breakout is the fact that the volume did not increase. The
reason is simple: notice the time that the breakout occurred. It was at
the start of the lunch hour break, when most market players (usually
the institutional traders) have gone out to eat.
Consolidation
The more a stock consolidates prior to its breakout, the stronger the
breakout will generally be. A well-known snippet of wisdom states:
the longer the base - the higher into space.
Simply put, consolidation is the breakout’s energy source. The
longer the consolidation, the more attention people will pay to the
stock; the more people there are following the stock, the more people
there will be buying it at the breakout, thus increasing the chances of
success. As the consolidation lengthens, one can almost feel the steam
building up and waiting to burst through!
The entry point is simple and clear: we buy a stock that has gone up in
price one cent above the breakout formation.
Later, we will learn that it is occasionally possible to buy even
before the breakout if we are able to assess that there is a strong
chance the breakout will occur. Breakout buying is a very common
method of trading, but requires nerves of steel, the concentration of a
fighter pilot, and high-level technical skills.
Prior to breakout, we need to plan our target price. We estimate
this in cents, and not in percentages: in other words, how many cents
will the price rise after breakout? Estimating the target is based on
integrating market direction and market force, the stock’s force on the
breakout day, and the stock’s history of breakouts. Its history refers to
its intraday behavior over the past two or three days.
It is reasonable to assume that if we look back, we will see that this
is not the only breakout over the past few days. By how many points
did it jump in the previous breakouts: 20 to 40 cents, or perhaps 50 to
70? Every stock has its own unique “‘personality,” and you need to get
to know your stocks “personally.” For some, an amazing breakout is
just a few cents, and therefore will not tend to interest us. Others
breakout often with a range of tens of cents.
What happens if you buy pre-breakout and the price does not
breakout? This does not mean the stock will not breakout later on.
Most stocks eventually do, and the only question is if you are able to
cope with the loss until it does. The solution is simple: before the
breakout, buy only half the total amount you had planned on, and at
the breakout, buy the rest if you can. When you estimate that the
chance of the price breaking out is not as good as it initially seemed,
you can generally sell at a loss of just a few cents.
Pre-Breakout Volume
When to Sell?
Every trader must operate within his or her limitations: the amount of
money in the account is one factor, and the other more important
limitation is his or her psychological ability to gain or lose money.
There are several more factors that dictate the correct mode of
operation, and which have nothing to do with your own limitations.
The minimum amount of a breakout purchase must be 400 shares,
and the maximum is generally thousands of shares and dependent on
liquidity and the amount of money in your account.
• Why the minimum of 400? The main reason that I like to use 400
shares is because I prefer to take a partial of at least three-quarters
of the amount bought at breakout. An amount of 400 allows you to
execute a partial with a round figure of 300 shares. A smaller
amount, such as 300, will not allow you to sell three-quarters which
would be 225, and a round figure of 200 is not three-quarters but
only two-thirds.
• Another reason to use 400 shares is the dollar profit target: an
amount of 400 shares should contribute an average of $100 profit at
breakout. If you are day trading, you should not be satisfied with
less than this.
After closing out 300 shares, you need to continue managing the
100 shares that remain. I tend to realize three-quarters of the amount
in the first partial, since I am a firm believer of “putting that money in
my pocket” when I am shown to be right. I am also aware of the fact
that holding the remaining 100 shares is like a gamble without any
apparent advantages, since the real advantage was reaped at the
breakout. The rest depends on the trend and fate. Sometimes those
remaining shares will allow me to reach a greater profit than the
partial, and sometimes they will drop beneath the entry price and
cause some minor damage. In any event, the 100 shares left after a
partial of 300 are never meant to bring you to a loss. Remember this
fundamental important rule: We never return our profits to the
market!
You’ve bought at the breakout. The price goes up several cents, and to
your sorrow, begins to drop. Why did the breakout fail?
The answer is simple: there are more sellers than buyers. But that is
not enough an explanation, so let us look a little deeper at who these
sellers are. There are two possibilities: the first is that you have simply
made a mistake and gone for the wrong stock at the wrong time. In
other words, the stock you chose was weak, or the market or its sector
dropped at precisely the breakout moment. In such cases, you should
exit as quickly as possible and absorb the loss. Another explanation is
that the big players are trying to shake out buyers like you. The big
players, who know your entry point and know how pressured you will
be over a drop in price before making any profit, may take advantage
of the expected volume at a strong breakout in order to sell large
amounts, which would otherwise be difficult to sell. The result is a
drop in price that snowballs and brings the price down to where large
market players are buying up again, much more cheaply. Perhaps from
that point on they will allow the stock to rise safely.
When I find myself in this situation, I tend to wait until the
hysteria has died down, and then happily increase the amount of
shares which are now 15 to 20 cents beneath my entry price, before the
stock price begins to pull back to the breakout level. This kind of
situation generally occurs within several minutes. If the stock does not
return to its high within several minutes, get out!
During the opening hours of the trading day, when the trade volume is
relatively high, both methods work well. However, the closer it gets to
lunch hour, the volume of trade decreases, together with chances of
breakouts and breakdowns working. This does not mean we cease
trading breakdowns and breakouts in later hours of the day, but as
time passes and volume decreases, we will also lessen our risks by
trading in smaller quantities.
For this reason, beyond the first ninety minutes of trading we
prefer not to enter a stock at a breakout or breakdown, but wait for it
to pull back, knowing that almost certainly the correction, or pull
back, will occur. Stock prices never rise in a straight line. They always
pull back, which allows you to buy them more cheaply. Buying at
pullbacks reduces the risk of loss and provides a greater range of
security. When the stock has ceased pulling back and once again
reaches the breakout point, we are already in a position of good profit.
The stop point is still a way off, and the chances of a second breakout
where the stock will peak are much higher.
The correct entry point is responsible for 80% of a trade’s success. The
entry point in reversal is not a precise science, but I will try to define it
in a way that allows you to come as close as possible.
We buy a reversal only when the stock has made a real pullback
from its peak. The way to “feel” the right entry point is to try and
imagine when you might sell the stock if you had bought it at its peak,
but it trended against you. Observe the entry point and imagine where
you would feel pressured and want out. If the stock has dropped below
that point, it means that most of the weak buyers have already sold,
and that this is therefore the correct position for clicking the button.
You need to do the exact opposite of what pressured buyers who
bought at the peak did.
Since I tend not to buy stock during the first ten minutes of
trading, and definitely do not “pursue” a stock rising quickly, I waited
patiently for the painful pullback. Why “painful”? Read what I wrote at
the start of this section: imagine a situation where you made the
mistake of so many novices and bought during the stock’s first jump,
or even at its peak at $89, then saw the stock drop halfway back to its
starting point. How would you feel to watch a pullback of $1.50?
Would you stay steadfast, or sell? Would you feel pressured? Try to
imagine where you would feel pressured: that is the buy point! If you
also need visual assistance, you can use the Fibonacci lines for entry at
pullback with a range of 30% to 60% from the peak.
In some cases, however, the price will not recover and I will lose
money. When that happens, it is definitely not pleasant, but it is part
of the statistics which overall work in our favor. It pays to absorb a few
losses if more frequently we generate handsome profits. It is better to
occasionally suffer and frequently profit. Remember that intraday
changes of direction, even if based on clear reversals in five-minute
candles as you see in the stock chart, are significant but do not
necessarily indicate the correct entry point. It is enough for one large
seller to want to drop a large quantity at the click of one button to
change the chart’s ideal status. My suggestion is simple: believe in the
stock, even if it continues to drop after you bought it. Remember that
when that happens, it has still done “nothing wrong.” That’s what
stocks do. The stock does not care whether you have erred in
estimating the entry point and bought a little too high. You must keep
in mind that strong stocks reverse back to highs in most cases. Period.
Summary: Reversals
Unlike buying at a breakout or shorting at breakdown, buying at a
reversal is a more correct and calmer entry point, less risky, and with a
better risk/reward ratio. Its disadvantage is its psychological strain. It
is far more natural and simple to buy at the breakout of a new high. At
the breakout, we buy a stock reaching new highs, while in reversals we
buy stocks trending down during their overall uptrend. Buying a stock
trending down will always be more difficult psychologically than
buying a stock trending up. We need to overcome our natural
emotions and hesitation, understand that strong stocks almost always
pull back, and that their chances of returning to highs are far greater
than their chances of continuing to drop. Be courageous, and click the
button. Don’t worry: with a little practice and experience, it will all
become clear.
Trading Gaps
First we need to define the term “gap.” It is the difference between one
day’s closing price and the next day’s opening price. When a gap
forms, the first trade of the day will be higher or lower than the
closing price of the previous day.
• A GAP UP forms when the stock opens at a higher price than the
previous day’s close
• A GAP DOWN refers to an opening price which is lower than the
previous day’s close
In fact, a gap almost always forms, and the first trade of the day in
any stock will be different even by one cent than the previous day’s
close. Small gaps are insignificant, so we will describe how the more
fundamental gaps come into being. These are usually in the range of a
half-percent or more.
Why would a price open differently than the previous day’s close?
Usually this is the result of news or rumors circulating between
closing time and the next day’s opening of trade, such as when a
company publicizes its financial reports during the after hours. In
other cases, it may be no more than a pullback from a day of sharp
lows or highs, or due to market news that is not related to the stock
itself but to the mood of investors.
Gaps have expectable behaviors. This means you need to learn how to
handle them, whether you are holding stock you bought the day
before and which opens the new day with a gap, or whether you are
planning an entry into a new stock opening with a gap.
Important note: the above is valid for gaps less than 3%. Higher
gaps will not close to the same degree, and in many cases will
continue moving in the direction of the gap rather than towards
closing the gap.
Most gaps close by the first hour of trading. It all depends on the
quantity of institutional traders taking advantage of the chance to
profit from the gap, and the competition among themselves as to who
will sell first.
In this chart, we see the gap up for BBBY which closed its prior day
of trading at $46.03 [1] and opens the second day at $46.22 [2]. Notice
how it dropped and closed the gap within just fifteen minutes. The
point where the gap closed [1] is the point where institutional traders
ceased selling and the stock receives the “green light” to keep trending
up. Remember that 80% of the gaps close on the day of trading itself,
and over 90% close within ten days!
Let us say you decided prior to trade that you wish to buy BBBY if it
goes higher than $46.3. You check at the start of trading and find it
opens with a gap up, and in just a few more cents it is likely to reach
your trigger price. Looking wonderful! Should you buy?
At this point, an alarm should sound in your mind. Remember the
saying: “We never chase gaps!” Even if your heart says “buy,” the
hours of study we’ve spent together should be enough to loudly ring
“stop!” Why? Because the chances are high that the gap will close.
Breaking the norm are stocks traded on more than one stock
exchange, such as Toyota, which is traded on both Wall Street and the
Tokyo Stock Exchange. These are known as dual-exchange traded
stocks.
Since the trading times on Wall Street and Tokyo do not overlap,
Toyota will almost always begin the day with large gaps in accordance
with the closing price of the other stock exchange.
In the daily chart above for Toyota, we can clearly see that every
trading day opens with a gap. This is a distinct formation indicating a
dual-exchange traded stock.
Market Index Gaps
Since the S&P 500 market index represents the 500 leading stocks, it
will display the cumulative gaps for all the stocks it encompasses.
When the market index opens with a gap up of a half-percent, what
does this imply for all the stocks comprised on the index? The
cumulative meaning must also be a gap up of a half-percent. Of
course, some stocks may open with a greater gap up, some with less,
and perhaps even some with a reverse gap, but the average must be at
least equal to a half-percent.
Let us presume that the 500 top Wall Street stocks open with a gap.
What should happen next? Eighty percent of the money in those
stocks belongs to institutional rather than private players. Since the
institutional players, as we have learned, are interested in selling as
long as the gap is open, in most cases the market index gap will close
exactly the same way as the gap for a single stock comprising the
index will close.
Notice the openings for the last six trading days on this chart. They
all open with gaps, and they all close. Days 1, 3, 5 and 6 already close
perfectly on the same day, and days 2 and 4 close partially the same
day and complete the close by the next day. Based on these gap
closings, can we define a winning trade strategy? Of course we can!
Strategy Label: Closing the Gap for the ETF – SPY
• Entry point: at opening of trade, long or short in the direction of the
gap closing
• Entry conditions: the SPY must open with a gap of at least 20 cents,
on condition that the gap is no greater than 85% of the range of
movement of the previous day’s trading (the difference between the
highest high and lowest low of the day’s trading), nor less than 15%
of the previous day’s trading. Reason: a gap that is too large
indicates extreme events which may lead the market into sharp
movement, increasing risk. A too-small gap is not interesting.
• Exit point:
1. Sell at the end of the day’s trading if the gap has not closed; OR
2. Sell when the gap closes.
• Outcomes: during the three years between October 2007 and
October 2010, 471 gaps upheld these criteria.
Assuming you had invested $16,000 in each trade, these are the
results:
o Maximum profit per trade: $373.9
o Maximum loss per trade: $778
o Average profit: $55.86
o Average loss: $145.01
o Success rate: 81.95%
o Weighted success rate: 63.62%
o Overall profit for three years: $9,236
o Average annual yield: 17.58%
Summary
The method works. The method’s Achilles heel is the 18.05% of cases
where the gap does not close: days when the market opens with a gap
and keeps moving, or as the phenomenon is known, Gap & Go. On
rare days when the market “escapes” us, the average loss is far greater
than the average profit, thus the weighted success rate is lower.
Trading the QQQ
In the chapter detailing indicators, we learned the importance of using
Bollinger Bands. We also learned that when a stock price reaches the
upper band, it is in a state of overbought territory and must return
down. By contrast, when it drops to the lower band, it is in oversold
territory and there is a strong chance of it retracing upwards.
We also learned that you need to define the band data in your
trading platform to calculate 10 periods and a standard deviation of
1.5, which means that the Bollinger Bands will be calculated according
to stock’s volatility over the previous ten trading days. The
mathematical significance of a 1.5 standard deviation is that 90% of
the stock’s movement will be caught between the two bands.
Based on the above, we should be able to assume that a stock or
ETF which moves beyond the boundaries of the bands will return to
these boundaries. Here is an amazing trade method which takes
advantage of this premise:
For four months, I wrapped the daily chart for QQQ (known as the
Qs) with Bollinger Bands according to the definitions above. Notice
how the bands expand or contract as the Qs’ volatility increases or
decreases. You can see how the bands “wrap up” most of the Qs’
movement. Notice also that every time the Qs break the bands, they
return.
SMART Hedge funds use similar strategies. The
advantage of the Qs for hedge funds is in
MONEY the large volume, which allows reliable
entries and exits with large sums of money.
Scalping
Traders can be divided into three types: swing traders, day traders,
and scalpers. The three methods can be integrated, which is my
preferred mode of operation.
Scalping refers to very short-term trades. Swing traders hold stocks
over to the next day, and day traders generally try to get as much from
the stock as possible within one day of trading. Both swing and day
traders generally base their systems on technical analysis with a touch
of fundamental analysis.
• Lunch hours
Often enough, I encounter a winning formation during New York’s
lunch break (11:30 to 13:30). During this timeframe I do not expect
considerable market movement and therefore I know that if I buy a
stock at the breakout, I should not expect continued strong movement
in the breakout direction, but rather a very short breakout often
followed by quick failure. Lack of trust in the breakout continuity does
not mean I am unwilling to take a profit of 10 to 20 cents and quickly
flee before the stock breaking out changes its mind! Lunch break is
also the time when the “one cent traders” are most active: more on
that method later.
• Close of trading
For scalping, this is the best time possible. During the last hour of
trade, and especially during its second half, volumes grow due to end-
of-day institutional fund activity. The problem with this last hour is
the lack of continuity. Continued movement cannot be expected, so
developing profit can’t either, since the day’s trading simply ends.
During this timeframe, reverse formations are usually most successful:
for example, a stock that rose strongly may pull back for part of the
high since many investors may wish to realize part of the profits,
lessen risks, and “go to sleep” with fewer open trades. The reverse
occurs with a stock price dropping strongly, when short sellers that
pushed it down all day begin to realize profits (i.e. they are now
buyers) and the stock pulls back part of its drop.
The first condition: you need to keep your finger on the mouse, and
your eyes glued to the screen. You need to give your full attention to
the stock. You must buy and sell with precise LIMIT orders. You must
absolutely NOT chase the stock, because with scalping, profit or loss is
measured in just a few cents. In many cases, I place an exit order in
advance. For example: if I buy 3000 shares at $20 and anticipate an
increase of 30 cents, I will set a sell limit order in my trading platform
of:
o 1000 shares at 20.15
o 1000 shares at 20.25
o And wait with my finger on the mouse for the first sign of
weakness in order to sell the remaining 1000 shares
The simplest way to choose a stock is to fish it out of the list that
always contains the “top ten” high volume stocks traded on NASDAQ
or NYSE. Notice that I do not relate to stocks that made it into the list
by chance, but those which are on that listing constantly. On some
days, you might choose Bank of America (BAC) or Intel (INTC),
Microsoft (MSFT) or others. Citigroup (C) used to be the scalpers’
favorite as long as its price hovered around the $4 mark in volumes of
hundreds of millions of shares per day, before the reverse split was
executed, as already described.
When you bring these stocks up on your screen, you will see
intraday volumes of tens if not hundreds of millions of shares, and
enormous numbers of bidders and askers. Many of them are playing
the one cent game.
Who in fact shifts the stock if no one wants it to move more than
one cent? Of course this would not be the scalpers working at the
single cent level, because they are basically locking the price and
preventing movement. The real change comes from the public and
from funds bidding and asking with long-term investment in mind,
and they are not interested in whether the stock has gone up or down
one cent.
Let’s assume you have chosen your stock and it’s time to trade. The
operation itself is fairly simple but requires a good deal of experience.
First, even if the price is moving sideways, examine the overall market
trend and the stock’s trend. If the trend is up, you will want to execute
a long rather than a short, and vice versa. Now you need to enter your
buy limit order in the BID, and wait patiently until sellers hit your bid.
The moment you have bought the desired quantity, you enter a sell
limit order on the ASK side, with a profit target of 1 to 3 cents, and
wait for buyers to hit your ask in the reverse direction.
Notice that there is no need to use the short order, since for most of
the trading platforms the regular SELL will operate exactly like a short.
Now that you have sold the quantity you bought at a profit, and added
to that sale a double quantity, you are in a short and therefore need to
position a double quantity on the BID side with a targeted profit of 1
to 3 cents, repeating the cycle. Once the market becomes more
volatile, and based on the premise that you are on the right side of
market direction, you need to cancel the exit order and try to profit
from a few more cents beyond the original profit target.
I wish to stress, yet again, that this method sounds simple. In
reality, it requires a great deal of patience, self-discipline, and deep
familiarity with the market. You need to follow the stock chart in one-
minute candles. You also need to watch the market chart which will
indicate if you need to flee the trade with an unexpected loss, or
cancel an exit order and let the market take you to unanticipated
profits of a few additional cents. For the same reasons, you need to be
following the stock’s sector chart. You should be avoiding any trade
when the stock is at a breakout or a breakdown point which may shift
the stock into dangerous territory.
Types of Orders
Generally we do not route orders direct to market makers, but for
quantities of tens of thousands of shares, you will find that it is the
market makers who will provide the fastest execution. Market makers
are pleased with large quantities, so you should consider executing
your orders through businesses such as NITE (Knight Capital Group)
and SBSH (Salomon Smith Barney). For example, with a quantity of
100,000 shares, it is preferable to place two separate orders of 50,000
with each of these two market makers, and during trading, observe
which of them fills the order faster. The advantage of this method of
using market makers is execution speed; the disadvantage is that you
will not receive the ECN’s refund commission.
How can market makers fill orders faster than the ECN? Because
they themselves are trading within these small spreads. The role of
market makers, as we have learned, is to provide the market with
liquidity, which they do not do in return for a guaranteed place in
heaven. They provide liquidity since they want to profit, just like you
do, from the gaps between the bid and ask prices. What you are doing
with thousands or tens of thousands of shares, they do with millions.
Relative to stocks traded at locked prices, they do this best and easily
because they have one advantage over you: they are allowed to trade in
fractions of a cent.
The phenomenon of trading in fractions of a cent will anger you
deeply. For example, you may be waiting to get rid of a stock with a
one cent profit. Let’s say you bought at $8.01 and are planning to sell at
$8.02, but in your trading platform you notice thousands of shares
being sold at $8.019. In other words, someone has “overtaken” you at a
better price of just one tenth of a cent. This is one of the market
makers’ advantages, and you will simply have to wait your turn
patiently. On the other hand, since they’re playing in the gap, they will
most likely be the ones who will buy from you and sell to someone
else. At some point, they could very well buy your stock at $8.02 and
sell it to other market makers in the gap for $8.019, aiming to profit
from a little less than a cent, but in gargantuan quantities.
One Cent Scalp Trading is Toxic
What identifies a red riding hood formation? It’s usually one that
looks too good to be true: for example, when a stock consolidates at a
distance of just a few cents from the breakout line for several long
minutes, or even a few hours, it may look as though it is consolidating
nicely in the short term, readying for the perfect, full breakout. But in
many cases it is a trap. When you see a really good-looking formation,
try to ask yourself what is making it so attractive. A stock stuck in the
narrow range beneath the line of resistance is a very clear sign of one
thing: a large seller. The stock wants to rise, but the seller is not done
just yet. Even if the stock breaks resistance, there is a good chance that
the seller will renew quantities, buyers will panic, unload their
merchandise, and the stock will fall enough to shake you into a loss.
What should you do in this case? First, thoroughly examine the
resistance point. Take a careful look at the Level II window, check the
quantity of shares being offered for sale, and try to identify the seller.
Is this a market maker attempting to refresh stock all the time? Since
it is often difficult to access clear data through the Level II window
because sellers can hide their sell orders, carefully check the T&S
(time and sales) window where you will find the flow of trades actually
being executed. No one can hide the amount of shares being sold at
the resistance point! If you see a large quantity changing hands
without being able to identify a seller renewing stocks, you will
understand that this is a smart seller concealing sale instructions.
How Do We Make Money from this Situation?
As noted, buying a red riding hood at breakout is not a good idea, but
buying it after its failure is a whole different story. Wait for the
breakout, wait for the failure, and buy when disappointed buyers are
getting rid of their stock at a loss of 12 to 25 cents beneath the
breakout point. In most cases, the stock will return to the resistance
level where you will be able to sell at one to two cents below the
original breakout point. You may be able to do this several times, as
long as the stock has not broken out. It is a nice, simple intraday
scalping method with relatively high success rates.
Be warned, however: the method requires psychological stamina,
since it involves buying as a stock is trending down. If this is a strong
stock, it will want to go up. The reason for its temporary drop beneath
the breakout point is because a large number of buyers have suddenly
fallen in love with the formation and bought before the breakout, then
panic when the stock direction moves against them by a few cents.
You need to train yourself to operate against your natural instincts and
buy precisely when inexperienced traders are selling at a loss. On the
other hand, if you bought the stock at the breakout and it gets stuck at
up to ten cents above the resistance point and seems to be showing
signs of dropping beneath your buy point, flee it as fast as you can.
Exiting a stock which is not doing what it should be doing is also a
tough psychological demand, since we tend to convince ourselves that
“if we just wait a little longer, it will be ok.”
Summary
I realize that on the face of things, trading before and after regular
market hours--especially following financial announcements--sounds
exciting, and indeed it is. That’s also why I tried my hand in pre- and
post-market trading. I developed my own special techniques, got
enthused over financial announcements, bought and sold, and in the
end… lost! I am well aware that you might very well succeed, unlike
me, but I strongly recommend avoiding unnecessary problems. So I
stand by my initial advice: steer clear of these hours. You can believe
me when I say they’re nothing but big trouble. Save your time, and
you’ll be saving a lot of money over the years. After my cumulative
experiences, I developed my own special rule: never touch the button
during pre- and post-market trading, no matter how seductive the
situation looks.
I recall instances where I held stocks over from the previous day’s
trading, and during pre-market trade saw them being traded for
amazing profits or searing losses. In both cases, the psychological
pressure requires bringing the situation to a close as quickly as
possible. The brain demands that you realize the profit or the loss,
driven by just one thought: get past the pressure! Wrong! That’s about
the worst mistake you can make. In the greatest majority of situations,
you will receive a better price during the first five to fifteen minutes
following the opening of trade.
In 2010, with the stock exchange reaching peak prices over a 14-
month period, and after eight straight weeks of unstoppable price
rises, I was invited to a television financial program in my capacity as
analyst. While all other analysts predicted continued increases, I
predicted a 10% pullback. The next day, the market rose another 1.1%.
The next day, the wheel came full circle. I was spot on! Within several
days, the market dropped by 8% and provided us with an amazingly
successful week of shorts. By the weekend, I realized that the drop had
been extremely sharp, and must retrace at least a little. For the
weekend, then, I positioned myself in three stocks which I estimated
would retrace upwards more than all others: Apple (AAPL), Goldman
Sachs (GS), and TEVA. I waited patiently for the opening of trade on
Monday. An hour before trading opened, I took a look at the pre-
market status. I couldn’t believe what I saw on the trading platform:
the market was opening with gap up, the size of which I had never
seen before…4.5%! For my account, the gap established a pre-market
profit of $28,000! That’s when my hands started to sweat and my pulse
began to race: what to do next, sell at pre-market or wait?
I have already taught you that at this stage you must never sell, but
instead wait. But just for this one occasion, I wondered if I should
bend my own rules. That would require no more than hitting the sell
button and all the pressures would evaporate. And such a lot of
money! I didn’t give in. I waited. One hour later, some ten minutes
after the opening of trade, the profit jumped to $36,000 and I locked
in almost all of it. For the first time that day, I took a deep breath. Not
bad for one hour’s work. What might have happened if I were a novice
trader? I have no doubt that I would not have been able to withstand
the pressure, and would have sold in the pre-market. Remember that
pre-market buyers buy in the pre-market because they believe they
will see a better sale price during regular trading hours. They are
usually the top level professionals, and they are almost always right.
The chart above shows regular trading hours as well as pre- and
post-market trading [3]. Apple ends Friday’s trading at $235.63 and is
traded post-market with a slight downward bias [1]. I buy 900 Apple
shares before trading ends, assuming that on Monday they will open
at a higher price. During Monday’s pre-trading [2], I am happy to see
Apple traded between $247 to $249. Pressure is increasing! The
question is: to realize profits or to hold the stock? Notice the low
volumes of trade [3] in the post- and pre-market. I managed to stay in
control, and sell after the initial price spike at opening of trade,
around $251, for a profit of $15 per share [4].
Let us presume that an average investor has bought the ABC stock
at $44.28. Generally, following the purchase, the broker or banker will
ask that investor, “If the stock rises, at what price do you wish to
realize your profit?” Most likely, the investor’s answer will be a round
number, such as $50. Can you imagine a situation in which the
investor will tell the broker to sell at $49.98? Since the majority of
investors makes the same exact mistake and sets their sale orders at
round numbers, when the stock reaches that number, a stream of sell
orders accrued by brokers over anywhere from months to years is
automatically set into motion and the large supply of sellers at the
precise round number stops the stock from moving. When that
happens, buyers who bought at the peak begin to lose their patience
and sell. The number of sellers eventually outweighs the number of
buyers, and the most likely outcome is that the stock price will drop.
How far might it go down? No one knows that.
In the daily chart, we can see the behavior of TEVA over three years.
Twice on its way up, it ceased progress at the round number of $50.
The first time, in January 2008 [1], it dropped back to $43; the second
time, a month later, it dropped back to $36 [2]. The third time, 18
months from the first attempt to break the $50 mark, buyers finally
succeeded in outweighing sellers and the stock rose. Automatic orders
fixed at the round number by sellers succeeded in holding the stock
back for a full year-and-a-half!
How do we, as traders, make use of the round number
phenomenon? If you bought a stock and are considering when to
execute a partial (lock in part of the profit), you need to consider the
option of setting your order at one or two cents below the round
number, staying wary of the fact that the stock may be likely to fail
there. As it reaches the round number, you need to keep your finger
on the mouse and check the quantity of buyers and sellers carefully.
Give the stock a chance to move past the round number, since if it
does, the momentum of success may send it into highs of several tens
of cents. But at even the most minimal sign of failure, lock in the gain
immediately. On the other hand, if you have decided to buy a stock
which is currently being traded just below the round number, it is
preferable to wait until that round number is passed.
We bought MFB in the trading room when it broke out above the
round number of $25. Before the stock broke out, it reached the round
number and stopped there several times [1]. The breakout sent it
upwards by 30 cents, allowing us to take a good partial of three-
quarters of the quantity bought. Notice the increase in volume [2] at
the breakout point. The final quarter was closed at a loss of ten cents
[3]. Not a big trade, but definitely some nice clean work there, taking
advantage of the round number breakout in the correct way.
Summary
When we are in a long, we should consider realizing profits a little
before the anticipated round-number resistance. When we plan to buy
a stock trading just below the round number, it is preferable to buy if
and when it gets past the round number resistance point. When we
long a stock, it is preferable to enter a stop order a little below the
round number. Traders wishing to short will prefer to execute the
short below the round number, and place their stop orders a little
above the round number.
Small caps are generally dormant stocks that “awaken” for a few days.
When they do, they can be identified on the first significantly volatile
day based on volume increase or sharp price changes, or on the
following day. We can expect that the momentum will keep them
moving for some days. Every day you should make a list of the small
caps that appear interesting on that day. You can identify them in
various ways: by a follow-up list, or by using free, simple programs
called stock screening software which we will learn more about
later. Define these programs according to the following filters: stocks
priced $3 to $10, with trade volumes growing exponentially, and which
rose in one day by more than 10%. To find small caps during trading, I
use my COLMEX Pro tool called the Top 20 which identifies and
displays the leading 20 stocks in the market at any given moment,
many of which are small caps.
Summary
To reduce risk, professional day traders will generally trade in large
and medium caps with high liquidity and narrow spreads. It is
definitely possible to trade in small caps, but prior to entering the
stock, be very sure of your choice and handling decisions.
Professional, precise handling will generally produce higher yields
relative to the stock’s price.
The chart shows MYGN’s behavior over two days of trading. MYGN
closed the first day at [1] and opened the next day with a gap up [2].
Several minutes after trading opened, it became clear that the stock
was moving down to close the gap. We have already learned that there
is a clear tendency for gaps to close on the same day of trading.
Experienced traders know how to take good advantage of this known
opportunity, and many execute shorts, “helping” the stock drop
further.
As we see in the chart above, closing the gap is only half of the
stock’s movement. Sometimes, as in the case above, a “bi-directional”
or reciprocal opportunity forms when the strong gap-closing
momentum breaks after the close [3] and causes the stock to continue
trending down [4]. Note how the distance between points 3 and 4 is
identical to that of between points 2 and 3.This is the basis for the
term reciprocal range.
Lexmark breaks out above $46 [1], and within four days reaches the
planned target price. On reaching a 3% profit I sold 75% of the
quantity I had bought, knowing that the quarterly report would
appear the next day. During the day following the report’s publication,
I discovered that Lexmark had opened with a wild down gap of 9%
below my entry price. The stop order intended for the entry price of
$46 executed at the shocking low of $42, and the 25% of shares
evaporated at a huge loss.
Now check the bottom line: a profit of 3% on three-quarters of the
stock together with a loss of 9% on one-quarter of the quantity of
stock leads to the grand total of…zero! Overall summary: I didn’t lose,
I didn’t win. Moral of the story: very simply, do you want to take huge
risks and sleep on a stock right before its quarterly report is
publicized? Make sure that you have realized a handsome profit
beforehand for the greater portion of the shares you are holding and
take a calculated risk only on a very small percentage, if at all.
What might have happened had Lexmark not reached my profit
target before the report’s appearance? I would have sold the entire
quantity. In the long term this is not a problematic phenomenon,
since statistically in half the instances, when a gap is to your
detriment, you will lose; whereas in the other half of instances, when
the gap benefits you, you will profit. The cumulative result of dozens
of such gaps will, most likely, be zero.
By contrast to quarterly earnings reports, the outcomes of analyst
recommendations can be fairly well predicted: for example, a “strong
buy” recommendation by a Goldman Sachs analyst will generally
cause a price spike. The “sell” recommendation, or a significant legal
claim, will generally cause drops in the stock’s price. The problem with
financial announcements is that you can never know when to expect
them. Here, too, statistics comes to your aid. Unlike the completely
unpredictable market reactions to the publication of quarterly reports,
when you buy a strong stock which is rising, it is highly presumable
that one reason for its uptrend is a positive announcement which until
publication had been known only to a few with insider knowledge
who began buying before the public. True, they are not operating
legally, but do not be naïve. If you have bought the stock because it is
demonstrating strength rather than because you know a positive
announcement is about to go public, then following the
announcement the stock will generally continue moving in the
direction in which you are trading.
So far, we have analyzed a situation in which you “sleep” on a stock
for a swing of several days. Next, we will relate to intraday trading.
Intraday Trading at Announcements
Question: Can you identify a good technical intraday entry point for
a long? I see the “inverted head and shoulders” formation at $24.40.
Can you also see it?
Crises are an inseparable part of stock exchange life. Once every few
years, the stock exchange crashes due to one crisis or another.
Statistically, the average investor experiences at least three major
crashes during his or her lifetime. During the past decade alone,
markets crashed due to two mega-crises: the Internet Bubble of 2000,
and the Financial Crisis of 2008. Second-level shakeups appear as
mini-crises, such as with the collapse of the Twin Towers on 9/11, or
the Dubai crisis, the Greek crisis, the Japanese tsunami, and other
events which I have already forgotten.
At the peak of the market’s reaction to the March 2009 Sub-Prime
Crisis, very few people actually identified the bottom. Nor could they
have even imagined in their wildest dreams that in just over a year, the
market would lurch from the bottom with a meteoric rise of 100%,
with hardly a backward glance. Buyer opportunities at the bottom are
extremely rare, but allow us, if we identity the bottom correctly, to
utilize trading methods for longer than the short term to which this
book relates. I believe that as traders, we must be open to all types of
opportunity, even if it sometimes deviates from the limitations of our
short–term approach. We must operate as day traders, yet hold stocks
for periods of several days to several weeks using swing methods, and
in special instances, try to profit from longer-term volatility of several
months.
Since 90% of the public loses in the stock market, we need to
conclude that the public tends to buy stocks when they are at peak,
and dumps them when they reach “rock bottom.” What can we
conclude? That we need to do exactly the opposite to what the general
public is doing. The way to do that is to identify the peak or bottom,
neither of which are simple tasks. I will try to provide you with several
rules for identifying a bottom. They are not perfect mathematical
rules, but they will help you consolidate your views when you next
encounter a crisis.
These rules are very simple, but somewhat difficult to master. The
greatest difficulty is psychological. Our brains tell us it is time to act,
but our hearts resist. This resistance may derive from fear of loss, from
social pressure, from being spooked by the unknown, and more.
Resistance derives from the simple fact that we are human. Although
the physical distance between mind and heart is short, for most
people it presents a gap that cannot be bridged. Success requires you
to undergo a mental shift that merges thought and emotion into a
single path. It is a tough mental process which generally takes some
years to internalize.
In October 2008, the markets crashed. The SPY (the S&P 500 ETF)
dropped from a peak of $175.52 to a low of $67.1 [2]. Then it shot up by
82% in 14 months [3]. Notice that the first bottom [1] was not the real
one. Could you have identified the bottom and profited from the highs
that followed? That would have been very difficult. Even if you had
identified it, most likely you, like many others, would still have been
filled with fear that prevented you from thinking clearly. Like many
others during that period, I also felt as though the sky had fallen and
the world was about to come to an end, and that the entire financial
system was about to sink. I had no idea whether the ATMs would still
provide cash the following day.
As traders, we profited well from the continuing price drops, but
were fearful that we were in a crisis of a scope the world had never
experienced, and hence were afraid to buy. That does not mean we did
not profit from some of the upward movement, especially once it
became absolutely clear that the market trend was indeed upward. But
we did not join in the uptrend festivities as investors who bought at
the bottom and held out for the long term. On the other hand, how
many investors really identified the bottom and bought? Very
carefully, however, as short-term traders we profited from a long streak
of days with upward trends.
When the market started trending up continuously and
determinedly, as it has done since March 2009 [2], a rare situation
occurred in which the long-term trader could profit more from the
market than the short-term trader. The sadder aspect is that generally
such investors also absorb all the lows. The overall outcome is that
they tend to cover their losses, and no more. I have yet to meet a long-
term investor who knew how to exit prior to the collapse, and buy
exactly at the bottom.
Integrating Tools
The conclusion is simple: all the players in the market share the
same goal of buying at the retest point [4]. No one is interested in
selling there, so that in most cases, a stock which has broken out and
pulled back to the breakout price will receive the support of buyers
and return to highs.
The retest point can be used to our advantage in two ways: by
placing a stop order below the retest area in case the stock should
suddenly not receive the anticipated support; or to increase our
position in a stock based on the assumption that it will return to
highs.
Summary
This was one very heavy chapter! We studied breakouts and
breakdowns, volume change, buy and sell points, reversals, gaps,
trading strategies, scalps, pre- and post-market trading, VWAP, small
caps, reciprocal ranges, how to use financial announcements,
identifying the bottom, retesting, and more…So, where do we start?
It would not be normal to be fluent with all this information at this
stage. As novice traders, you should choose one method and get to
know it well before moving on to new methods.
A practical suggestion: focus on reversals. Look for stocks with a
clear trend, very strong for buying or very weak for shorting, which
display daily reversals (one-day candles) if you are interested in a
swing of several days, or intraday reversals (five-minute candles) if you
are interested in trading within the same day. Trading with reversals is
simple, slower and clearer than trading at breakouts and breakdowns,
or any other method. Once you have reversals pretty much under
control, move on to the next method.
Chapter 11 - Risk Management
Large volume stocks usually have small spreads and high liquidity.
This means you can use automatic orders to realize profits or losses
and rely on the computer to provide you with fast, effective executions
as close as possible to your chosen entry or exit point.
Several stop orders can be applied, the most familiar and important
being a defensive order known as a stop loss, which we discussed in
the section detailing trading platform orders. In this chapter, we will
understand their significance and how to use them.
Fundamental Risks
Every occupation carries its inherent risks. The athlete’s risk is a
physical injury; the surgeon’s risk is human error. Every profession is a
world unto itself, which makes it difficult to comprehend the risks
until we dive deep into that profession.
An athlete’s risks or those of a surgeon can be estimated, and
therefore they can be insured. Athletes insure themselves against
injury, doctors are covered by medical malpractice insurance, but no
company in the world will agree to insure a stock trader’s accounts.
Insurance companies employ professionals to calculate and manage
risk. Since insurance companies will not insure us, it is up to us to
manage our risks. We cannot do that unless we understand just what
the risks are.
Psychological Risk
Willingness to absorb risk does not derive from our financial status,
but rather from our psychological stamina. “Hating to lose” features
strongly in research which unequivocally concludes: we hate to lose far
more than we love to win, at a 2:1 ratio (Kahneman & Tversky, 1991).
Research indicates that loss is perceived as a change in our financial
wealth relative to a neutral status. Each of us has a different relative
status, derived from both our actual financial status and our
perception of the significance of loss. For example, when we buy stock
at a higher than normal price but do not sell at a profit, we tend not to
see the buying stage as an expensive error, but rather focus on our lack
of profit when we sell.
By contrast, when we buy an item at a higher than usual price for
personal usage, we tend to view the transaction as a loss.
What significance do you apply to losses derived from stock
trading? A pro will absorb losses as an inseparable part of the
profession. This does not meant the pro reaches a 1:1 psychological
balance between love of profit and hate of loss, but it is reasonable to
presume that his or her psychological stability will be greater than
that of an amateur for whom loss holds greater weight, even if the
amateur loses the same amount as the professional trader and their
point of neutrality is identical. In short, we can conclude that the
amateur trader’s red line will be different to that of the professional, or
simply put, each person’s red line will be different.
This is why it is essential for you to define your own, private red
lines in advance. Doing so will improve your chances of success. Your
red line should be based on the amount of available money you are
prepared to lose. Money intended for buying a new car or for the
family’s vacation is not available money and should not be used to
fund your trading account.This is scared money, which you are
scared to lose. Later we will discuss mental management more deeply.
Leverage Risk
If you open a trading account with a US broker, you will be able to
get margin of 4:1 by simply signing a margin agreement with the firm.
If you are not a US resident and you open a trading account with a
non-US broker, you will be able to get a margin of up to 20:1. A 4:1
margin means that if you deposit $10,000, you will receive leverage
when you execute intraday trading of up to $40,000. This is called
intraday margin. By contrast, if you hold stocks overnight, you will
be able to receive margin of only 2:1, called overnight margin. A 2:1
margin will let you sleep on stocks valued at double the amount you
deposited in your account. The reason for the broker reducing margin
on overnight usage is due to the fear of financial announcements that
may go public after trading hours, endangering your money as well as
the leveraged funds, which are the broker’s money.
A 2:1 margin held overnight will cost interest, but the 4:1 intraday
margin or even 20:1 margin does not. Most traders use margin. If you
also plan to do so, you need to be aware of the risks involved and
manage them correctly.
Using leverage correctly brings successful traders much higher
returns on their investment. Here, too, the correct way of coping with
leverage risk is to define your red lines for leveraged trading. Avoiding
any deviation beyond the red line will prevent you from suffering
heavy losses in the future. If you are not cautious, one heavy loss can
take you completely out of the game forever.
Are you familiar with the double-down roulette method? It’s very
simple: you place $10 on the red in the hope of winning. If you lose
and black shows, you gamble on the red again, this time with $20, and
so on. Each time you lose, you double the bet until eventually red
comes around again, returning all your losses with the addition of a
small profit. The problem is that if you do this for a long time, sooner
or later you will get a sequence of the same color. I met someone who
lost a huge amount of money when red came up 24 times in
succession! That’s definitely enough to put the kibosh on what could
have been a pleasant evening.
Now, back to stocks. By way of example, let us assume you are
using personal capital to the tune of $25,000. You set your loss red line
for any single trade at no more than 2% of your trading account: in
other words, you are not willing to risk more than $500 for any single
trade. Strong self-discipline is one of the most important aspects of
trading, and you will need to stick to this maximum loss factor which
you yourself have defined.
Note that following a loss of $500, your trading account balance will
be $24,500, so that now 2% of that new balance will be $490. If you
adopt the 2% factor, you will always be able to calculate in advance the
amount of money left in your account after a losing trade, however
many sequential trades may end up as losses:
• Following 10 successive losses, there will be $20,486 left in your
account
• 100 successive losses will leave just $3,315 in your trading account
The probability of losing 100 times in succession is extremely low,
but nonetheless you need to be aware of your red line at all times from
the angle of maximum loss as well as the single-trade loss figure.
Technical Risk
Correct entry and exit points must be determined, first and foremost,
according to the stock chart’s technical behavior. The exit point must
be planned in advance and cannot be set according to a figure you are
willing to lose, but rather based on volatility and the unique technical
behavior of each of the stocks in which you are trading. As we have
already learned, when you buy a stock, you must set your exit (stop) in
advance. For example, let us say that your entry point is at $30 and
your stop is planned for $29. If you buy 100 shares at $30 and the price
drops by one dollar to $29, you have taken a loss of $100. But if the
maximum loss you are willing to absorb is no more than $50, then you
must limit yourself to buying only 50 shares and not allow yourself to
buy 100 and “self-compensate” by setting a stop at $29.50, which was
not the correct technical stop in the first place.
In addition to the calculation you have set in advance, you also
need to understand that your actual exit point might be further than
the planned exit. For example, if the price dropped to $29 but has not
yet executed a five-minute reversal, you may have to absorb a greater
loss than planned. Therefore, you need to take into account in advance
an additional margin of error that allows you to operate correctly at
the technical level and wait for the reversal, while still preserving your
planned reasonable-loss framework.
Exposure-derived Risk
Since day traders operate with large quantities, they exit most of
their transactions during the trading day. Holding stocks means taking
risks. Swing traders buy smaller quantities and are therefore willing to
take the risk, which can last several days until they close part of the
transaction. But even swing traders will try to sell 75% of their
quantity as early as possible to reduce the risk of exposure to market
mood shifts. Medium and long-term investors who hold stocks for
weeks, months, and years are even more exposed. Conclusion: the
more you reduce exposure, the more you are reducing risks, allowing
you to increase your trading quantity.
The loss exit point should already be set at the trade planning stage,
but as we will understand soon, we cannot always know in advance
exactly where the exit will be. In any case, even if we cannot pinpoint
the actual exit with certainty, we can plan it in advance. We do this for
two reasons: it is correct professionally, and it is good psychologically.
• Professionally: Before each trade you need to check the risk/reward
ratio. How can you figure the risk if you do not know where the stop
is? Traders who do not set their stop point before entering the trade
are operating very unprofessionally. A pro first calculates the risk,
not the reward.
• Psychologically: Can you set a reliable stop after entering the stock?
No. Once you’ve bought, you are no longer the same clear-thinking
person.Greed taunts you, and fear of loss plays with your emotions,
infringing on the ability to stay rational, and possibly causing you to
realize profits too early or cut losses too late.
Some traders will set their stop before entering the trade, but then
the demon gets to work: as the price approaches their stop, they
cancel it and set a new one further off. What do they do as the price
approaches their new stop? Correct, they reset it. The greater the loss,
the harder it is for them to admit losing. Exiting at loss is a painful
event. The human body has a psychological trait of protecting against
pain. Is exiting the stock painful? Then let’s not hit the button. When
they need to choose between the hope that the stock will turn about
and begin showing profits versus the pain of loss, they choose hope.
As the scope of the loss increases, they turn from short-term traders to
long-term investors. They ask themselves, “Why did this happen?” and
then begin searching for reasons to explain the dramatic change in the
stock’s direction. They deny the truth and seek to justify the situation
in which they are caught with any excuse possible: “The company has
good products,” or “It’s got top management,” and so on.
In my view, the stop can move only in one direction, and that is
NOT towards increasing a loss. As explained in the section dealing
with trade management, after realizing the first profit, the stop can be
moved as close as possible to the entry point or above it, in order to
prevent a profitable trade from becoming a failed one.
Over time, I learned that the main error enacted by failed traders was
the difficulty in cutting losses on time. Your main resource is the
capital you deposited in your account. If you do not do everything
possible to preserve it, you are doomed to a complete wipeout.
“Everything possible” means ensuring losses are as minimal as
possible. Always.Without any allowances or excuses. Without “just
this once,” and without, “I’m just testing…” Without “I trust myself, I
know what I’m doing,” or “I’m prepared to pay the market for my
education.” Small losses. First and foremost, play correctly from the
defensive position. Always.
Time-based Stop
It may happen that you entered a stock and it has gotten stuck. It
makes no difference if that occurs when you have made a small profit
or loss. It is just not conducting itself in the way that you had
anticipated.
First, you need to understand that there is a good reason the stock
has stopped moving. Generally, you will not know the reason, but it is
probable that something is happening. For example, when you buy an
up-trending stock and it gets stonewalled by sellers, it is reasonable to
assume that the buyers will soon despair and start looking for the exit
door.You, like others, have noticed the perfect technical formation and
bought, hoping for success, but it is best that you are among the first
to exit.
How much time should pass between your entry and your exit? The
answer depends on each trader’s personal experience, but if you want
a guideline I would say that if it has not “provided the goods” within
ten minutes, then something not good is going on. When a stock stops
moving, I exit! When stocks are not moving fast, they usually will not
move at all.
I realize that sounds very simple: “Not moving, so exit.” In reality, it
is not simple at all. Our brains resist clicking the button. We believe
we have made a good choice, and we are afraid that in the end it will
be a success but without us if we exit. Yes, this is a tough psychological
decision, but you need to persevere and click the button. If you stay
with the stock, chances are high that first it will “visit” your stop point
and then it will either succeed or fail. Remember that you entered the
stock because you believed that it needs to move fast in the planned
direction. If that did not happen, you have made a mistake. Now you
are in casino territory. You leave nothing to luck. Take your money,
even if you are in loss, or no more than a small profit, and invest it in a
more successful stock. Keep in mind that discipline is the name of the
game.
This is the correct technical stop, but it is not necessarily the correct
stop for every trade. This is the stop that requires the toughest nerves
of steel, which are not usually in the arsenal of novice traders. When I
enter a stock, I never know if I have chosen the precise entry point. I
enter a strong stock trending up at a correct technical point or execute
a short in a weak stock, but the stock or the market may not “agree”
with my entry choice.
On the market’s ETF (SPY), it is clear that [1] was the turning point
for upward movement, which matches [1] on Moody’s chart, the point
at which it dropped and stopped at the round number. At [1] Moody’s
“wants to continue down,” but gives in to the changed market
direction and trends up. When the market executes a reversal [2], the
same reversal point [2] shows on Moody’s chart, where Moody’s
capitulates and returns to lows.
Summarizing, if I had not kept the five-minute reversal rule in
mind, I would have panicked from the uptrend, exited with losses
higher than planned, and missed out on the later lows. The five-
minute reversal was my protection. It gave the stock time to cool off
from the market’s movement up, and allowed bears to keep in mind
that it is basically a weak stock. The five-minute reversal rule let me
realize the trade with a nice profit.
Now I return to the intraday chart and see that Aon’s high is $39.44,
which is a difference of some 30 cents between the intraday high and
the planned entry point [1]. Conclusion: based on a check of past
volatility, we can reasonably assume that Aon is able to move another
70 cents or so below the breakdown price. Since the risk is 20 cents
and the profit target is 70 cents, the risk to reward ratio is 1:3.5. Very
decent! In actuality, as you have seen, the stock moved 82 cents, a little
more than the expected figure. I executed a careful short of 1000
shares, added another 1000 at the start of the fall, and locked in
several pieces of profit on the way down. In short, I risked $300 but
profited $752.05.
Money Management
You have chosen a stock correctly, and bought or shorted it at the
correct point. What happens next? Correct money management is
the difference between the professional trader who earns a living from
trading, and the amateur who provides the pros with their earnings!
Many new traders place too much weight on technical and financial
aspects and view money management as extraneous, although it is an
imperative tool.
Ask yourselves what you would do when a stock you bought at the
correct point breaks out and trends up strongly. Amateurs will look at
the stock’s chart, rub their hand with glee, admit their good fortune,
and perhaps even increase the amount. What does the pro do
following a breakout? Certainly not shout out, “I’ve got a winner!” The
pro shouts out, “Who’s the sucker I can now push this stock onto?”
If you have ever bought stocks, try to remember and reconstruct
the trades you executed in recent years. Let me describe the process. I
am familiar with the stocks you bought and your methods of
managing them. Is this what you did? You usually bought at the right
time. I will also give you credit and say that shortly after buying, you
almost always were in the money and were even quite pleased with
your decision to buy: am I correct? The only problem was that you
held on to them for a fraction too long, enough for the whole episode
to end in a loss.
Correct money management allows you to profit even if your
success rates are below 50%. One day recently, as I was writing this
book, I closed a day’s trading in profits even though I lost over eight
trades and gained in just three. Correct money management lets me
exit a failed trade with a small loss, and milk a successful trade to the
maximum.
As noted, you must take a partial at the first pullback beyond your
first target. How will you know this is the correct partial point? At first
you won’t know: that comes with the “art of trading” as you gain
experience and insight. Generally, I would say that a partial for a share
priced between $20 to $60 should be between 20 to 40 cents from the
breakout price. The problem with a generalization of this kind is that
sometimes the price will break out without looking back for up to one
dollar from the breakout point, so that realizing 20 cents is far less
than the potential profit. To identify the correct partial point, you
need to “feel” the stock, understand it and have tens if not hundreds of
attempts at figuring that point until you come to understand naturally
where to take the partial piece. Sometimes, the difference between the
successful and the unsuccessful trader shows precisely at the first
partial. New traders, unlike the experienced hands, exit too quickly
from a stock running up and too slowly from a failing stock.
How and when should you buy more? Once you have taken the
partial of 3/4 of the quantity you are holding, set a limit order at a
lower price but which is just slightly above the original buy price, and
wait for the pullback. For example: you bought 1000 shares at $29 and
took a partial with 800 shares at $29.25. Set a buy order for 400 more
at $29.05, using the limit order which waits in the BID column and
will execute only if the stock reverses. In many cases, you will find that
in a short time, the stock will execute a retest (described in earlier
chapters) close to the initial breakout point.
Why is it necessary to enter a limit order rather than simply wait
for the stock to pull back, and then click the button if and when it
starts to trend up again? The answer is simple: when a stock retests, it
usually drops, then shows rapid upward movement. Usually, you
simply will not have a chance to wait for the clear technical reversal in
five-minute candles, nor even in two-minute candles. The correct way
to buy more and increase quantities at the retest point is to set a limit
at a low price. The limit waits for the price to drop and will execute
only when the preset conditions are fulfilled.
What is the correct price for adding shares? That depends on the
breakout point. For example: if I took a partial of 20 cents per share for
a stock that rose by 25 cents, I would be happy if the stock pulled back
to just five cents above the breakout. If I took a partial of 50 cents out
of a high of 60 cents, I would be happy to buy more even at 15 cents
above breakout. In other words, I am willing buy more if the price
pulls back by 70% to 80% of its post-breakout movement.
As with the partial point, the point at which we buy more is also
part of the “art of trading.” Until you reach that level of capability,
think in these terms: “After realizing a profit of x cents per share, what
is the highest price at which I am willing to buy this stock again?” This
is a simple business management question which has nothing to do
with stock trading.
• You sold “merchandise” for profit at a certain price. You are sorry
you did not have a greater quantity of that same merchandise at the
original price, and now someone is offering you the chance of
buying at slightly above your original purchase price.
• You already know that this is good merchandise since the stock
broke out and you booked a profit, and you believe that you are able
to sell more of this merchandise at a profit. You see that the price is
now a little higher, and do not wish to take too much risk by buying
the same amount that you bought the first time around.
• How much should you be willing to pay? How much should you be
willing to buy? Answer this question for yourself, and that is where
you will place your buy limit order for the additional quantity you
wish to buy.
• The quantity I buy at the retest will never endanger my profits from
the original partial. In other words, the maximum quantity I will
buy is about half of the quantity I already locked in with the partial.
I shorted Illumina below $42.30 [1] for 1000 shares, and took a
partial with 800 when the price dropped towards the round number
support level of $42. I was left with 200 shares. Next, the price rose
and executed a retest several cents above the entry point [2]. Imagine
how you would have felt had you not taken a partial! Around the retest
area [2], I increased my short position by 400 shares so that I was now
short 600 shares. The price dropped and I took a second partial with
300 of those shares [3] just above the round number support line. I
have now taken two partials and am holding 300 shares in short. The
price continues to trend down, to 90 cents below the entry point. The
psychological calm I was afforded by taking the first two partials gave
me the focus needed to realize a full profit for these remaining 300
shares.
Why would you want to reduce that quantity a little more? To avoid
too great a risk. It is really dangerous to “go to sleep” with stock in
hand, since you can never know the reality you will wake up to in the
morning. I have already seen situations in which a stock shot up one
morning and plummeted the next. Leaving yourself a small quantity,
based on the fact that you have sufficiently profited from all the stock
you have sold so far, greatly reduces risks. I tend to decrease quantities
as a matter of course. If you have chosen to “sleep on” the stock,
known in trader jargon as Swing Trading, you will need to continue
managing it correctly in the coming days. More on that later.
1. Stop Point
Enter a stop order 3% below the entry point. Why 3%? When a
stock you believed would trend up goes against you by 3%, it would
seem you’ve made a mistake. You thought you bought at the right
entry point, you thought it would break out strongly and put money
in your pocket, and that’s not what happened. Of course, with a
little luck it will return to its uptrend, but usually you’ll do better
admitting the error, abandoning that stock and focusing on another
stronger one. Should you ignore the support and resistance lines?
No. If you identify a clear support line in a 2 to 4 percent range
below the entry point, use it.
Why 3% rather than 5%, for example? Stock prices rise, but always
pull back. The question is only one of when and how much. From
my experience, the pullback generally occurs after a high of 3 to 4%.
Why? Prices pull back once the public begins buying: the public
never buys at the start of the uptrend. They only buy once the stock
has “proven itself.” Usually the public is persuaded that the stock
has proven itself only after a 3-4% rise. At that point, why is the
price not going up further? Because it is convenient for institutional
traders to take advantage of the large quantity of buyers in order to
unload large quantities of shares. Since the institutional traders
comprise 80% of the money involved in all the stocks we trade in,
when they sell, we can reasonably presume that the price will drop.
In short: over the years, my records repeatedly show that 3% is the
figure.
3. Rising Stop Order
After selling three-quartersof the stock, you need to raise the stop
order for the last quarter to the entry price. Since our law states
“never return your money to the market,” you want to be sure that
the profits of that three-quarter quantity stayin your pocket. If the
last quarter returns to the entry point, you’ve lost profit only on that
quarter. But if you let the remaining quarter drop to below the entry
point, then you’ll be doling out money that you’ve earned to cover
the loss, and that of course is against our rules!
4. Second Target
Lock in the remaining quarter at 6%, or manage it according to
methods we have already learned. For example: raise the stop a little
below the previous day’s low each day that you remain in the trade.
Q&A
• What should you do if you have bought stock, but it is moving
sideways and deciding to go nowhere over several days?
Sell it! Remember, when you bought it, you thought differently:
that it would shoot up to your target. It didn’t. What does that mean?
Simple: you have made a bad choice. Admit it quickly, and sell. If the
price has not chosen your direction, you are in a gambler’s territory.
Remember the rule: if the price does not reach its profit target by the
end of the second week of trading from its purchase, sell three-
quarters of the quantity, regardless of whether you have made a profit
or loss. Continue managing the remaining quarter according to swing
principles.
• Price gaps
When you are about to buy a stock for a swing at the start of the
trading day and a gap shows of up to 1% above the trigger, you can still
buy the stock. In this case, calculate your profit or loss point according
to the 3x3 rule relative to the actual entry point. When a gap of more
than 1% develops, cancel the buy order.
• Earnings reports
Before publication of quarterly earnings reports, we will always sell
our full quantity. As we learned in previous chapters, you need to
carefully check which reports are expected and sell the day before
anything major is to be released. It is common knowledge that the
results of these reports are not known in advance, and the risk to the
price is too great.
• Time of purchase
I never enter a swing later than the middle of the week’s last
trading day. We are looking to buy stock with strong chances of
reaching its target already within the first week of trading. If we buy
stock at the end of the last day of the trading week, its chances of
reaching the first target or even moving far from the entry point are
far less. Going to sleep over the weekend with a full quantity of shares
that still endanger my trading account is just not on my agenda.
Summary
The 3x3 method works well! Using automated buy and sell orders
solves a good deal of the psycho-emotional aspects of money
management, and therefore, coupled with good choices of stocks,
should virtually guarantee success. If you have a limited time only for
trading and cannot find suitable opportunities for active intraday
trading, you can at least devote one hour each week to trading with
this method.
The Tradenet investors club is very successful when it applies the
3x3 method. As these lines are being written, average monthly returns
over the past six months have been 8.4%. Is there any good reason
not to invest an hour each week in trading this way?
Noise Cancelling
With due respect to classic technical analysis, stocks do not need to
behave “by the book.” Most of the money in the market belongs to the
long-term investors, to funds, and of course to a group of Warren
Buffet-type folk. They do not always check the chart before they buy a
stock. Did the stock breakdown in the perfect “head and shoulders”
formation? Why on earth would that interest them!? They may be
buying right when you sell, for entirely different reasons. Technical
analysis does have its limitations. In fact, I can assure you that if you
operate according to perfect technical rules, you will end up losing.
Technical analysis states that the uptrend is defined as a succession
of higher highs and higher lows. Let’s say you bought a stock currently
trending up, and its price has now dropped to a new low. Would you
sell it at precisely the point where it drops under the last low?
Technically speaking, yes; but in reality, no.
It is most likely that everything you have experienced during the
price’s drop under the last low is nothing more than “noise”. It could
be that you are seeing the first signs of a direction change, but in
many cases it is nothing more than a temporary pullback caused by
someone selling thousands of shares without checking the chart. At
the start of my trading career, I would set the stop order one cent
under the last low. I would forget that the stock owes me nothing:
neither behavior according to the technical analysis, nor according to
the price I bought at. The reason it may drop several cents under the
last low can be very simple: someone might have sold 1000 shares with
a market order, which drops the price by several cents under the last
low. Does every small change in price draw you out of the game?
Sometimes, yes; generally, no.
Noise in stocks is also one of the reasons why I try to avoid, as far as
possible, using hard stop orders. Stock prices constantly show spikes
in either direction. To understand the stock’s general direction, we
need to relate to its overall framework of movement rather than
chance price volatility, since the latter may cause you to imagine all
kinds of unrealistic statuses. I am not saying that in such cases you
should bury your heads in the sand. You do need to be cautious, and
remain ready for a change of direction, while not fleeing or buying on
the basis of any small price change.
How can sharp fluctuations be neutralized? Switch to displaying
fifteen-minute candles and try to see the bigger picture. Jerky behavior
seen in five-minute candles will look completely calm in fifteen-
minute candles. That’s one reason why we hardly use two-minute
candles except when trading the first hour. The amount of noise after
the bell is unbearable!
When you ask traders what sums they trade in, they will find it
hard to answer, since they operate in quantities and not in sums of
money. A novice trader will start off trading in quantities of 100 shares
per trade, and over a year of accruing experience will gradually
increase towards the 1000 shares per trade mark. Old hands at trading
with several years of experience up their sleeves buy stock by the
thousands of shares per trade, and in even more advanced stages, may
even reach single trades involving tens of thousands of shares.
I realize it sounds a bit odd to you: a trader may buy 1000 shares at
$20 each, for a total of $20,000 and then on another occasion, without
even blinking, he may buy 1000 shares at $50, operating with a figure
of $50,000.
And that is how it really works.
Here are three main reasons for referring to trades in these terms:
Summary
Be disciplined about buying according to quantity rather than
sum of money. If you are comfortable with buying in multiples of 500
shares, then do that always, irrelevant of the share price. The
exceptions to this norm are for shares at $70 and up, or small caps
with clear, very low volatility. Remember that every stock has its own
“personality.” Therefore, a good rule of thumb is to always buy a fixed
quantity. Before clicking the buy button, just check the stock’s
volatility thoroughly and take your decision on whether to increase or
decrease the quantity.
Learn from Your Experiences…Keep a
Diary
No infant learns to walk without falling. The infant keeps trying until
the sequence of actions called walking becomes embedded in the
brain and turns automatic. Every trader undergoes “infanthood” and
“childhood” as he or she learns. Mistakes are part and parcel of a
trader’s learning curve and a very important aspect of shaping the new
trader’s capabilities and resilience.
Mistakes are a vital asset in learning how to succeed. Even old
hands make mistakes, but to lesser degrees than new traders. When I
started out, I made far more mistakes than I do now. I remember days
filled with self-directed anger. There were days when I would lecture
to students, teaching them what to avoid, then go and do exactly that
action I had warned against! Of course I felt like a complete idiot.
Now, years later, I still make mistakes, but far less frequently. The
fascinating thing about trading mistakes is that they are known and
familiar, but we make them anyway, even though we know we are
crossing into forbidden territory. It’s as though something stronger
than us is pushing us against our will.
The first step in coping with mistakes is to know what you should
and shouldn’t do. This book is meant to help you a lot in that respect.
The second step is your own determination to correct your mistakes
and strengthen your psychological stamina towards eradicating them
one by one. Traders need to know how to take best advantage of
mistakes rather than waste them. Mistakes, by virtue of their
unavoidability, are a valuable asset. As with any valuable asset, they
need to be documented and conclusions reached. The only way to do
that is to keep an activities diary.
My wife, without even realizing it, helped me realize the need for
an activities diary. When I started my trading career, I would repeat
one of the most common mistakes of new traders: I would buy at the
right time but then sell at too small a profit or too great a loss. Every
evening I would tell my wife more or less the same story, “If only I had
done this… or not done that… I would have made a bigger profit…”
Every day it was the same thing, until she got sick of hearing how I
“almost” made money. What was abundantly clear to my wife, but not
to me, was that I described the exact same mistake, over and over. It
was time to look that mistake in the eye. It was time to make a change.
An interesting thing happened once I started keep a diary. I found
that the range of mistakes I made was limited. I found that I
consistently make the same classic mistakes of new traders. But I
found these things out only after I started my activities diary. At the
end of each day, I jotted down my trading activities, and once a week I
would sit with the diary and review the outcomes recorded there.
Most of my failures derived from a small range of repetitive common
mistakes.
From this point on, the path to success was shorter and sweeter. All
I needed to do was decide to kill off those mistakes, one by one. The
biggest, toughest battle, obviously, is psychological. But by the end of
the first week in which I declared war on my mistakes, armed with my
trusty diary, I was amazed by the results. By the end of the second
week, I was convinced that this was the best method, and the war got
easier. All I needed to do was keep a diary. So simple, and so amazing.
Do Your Homework
Before each day of trading, do homework. Start the day with a list of
candidates. Sometimes I get lazy and don’t prepare in advance. On one
such day, trading opened with a sharp gap up, and I had no candidates
on my non-existent list. As trading progressed, I quickly reviewed my
favorite stocks in search of a good opportunity, but to no avail. The
feeling that everyone else is making easy money and you’re the only
one wasting time is one of the worst psychological states for a trader.
It is fertile ground for stupid moves… and this mistake didn’t take long
to become apparent. I convinced myself that a certain stock was
looking great, and with an impulsive click, placed the trade. For a very
short time I did well, but in the long run I took a searing loss.
Important moral to the story: when you really want to hit the
button, you’ll find that you possess awesome powers of self-
persuasion. Every so-so stock looks great. Remember this: sometimes
we profit more by not trading at all!
The conclusion is simple: for each day of trading you need to have a
list ready with stocks you have analyzed, which will prepare you
mentally for the market. These are the stocks which would offer the
lowest risk of disappointment and the highest chances of success.
Later on, we’ll look at several ways of searching for stocks.
Many traders prepare a list of stocks for follow up. Generally, the list
runs from dozens to hundreds of stocks, sometimes up to two
hundred. Later I will explain how to prepare your own list. What
characterizes these stocks as desirable is their high volume and
volatility. The symbols are entered into the trading platform under the
Watch List field. At one click on any symbol, that stock’s chart opens.
Every day before trading begins, traders manually check the charts
for those stocks they are following as they look for technical entry
points. Stocks identified as having potential for trading will be divided
into three sub-groups:
1. Hot shares – which are close to their trigger point (planned entry
point) and seem likely to be traded that day
2. Rising shares – showing an uptrend and which could enter the
“hot” list over the coming days
3. Falling shares – showing a downtrend and which might enter the
“hot” list over the coming days for shorts
Every so often, the main list should be checked and updated
according to the three follow-up divisions. List the stocks you plan to
trade over the current day in a separate table, including organized
columns for the trigger point (entry price), stop loss point, first profit
target (the partial), and final profit target.
Filters
• Remove from your follow-up list all stocks priced at over $100, as
they will not only be too expensive but also too volatile for novice
traders.
• Remove all stocks below $10. We have already discussed the fact that
as beginners, it is best to avoid trading in small caps which
institutional traders are generally prohibited from buying.
• Remove all stocks with intraday ranges of less than 30 cents per day,
including the “heavy” stocks that show little volatility, such as
Microsoft (MSFT).
• Remove all stocks with very low volumes, initially those showing less
than 2 million shares per day, and later as you expand your list, to
those showing less than 1 million shares per day.
• Compile your list from what is left.
Over time, once you get to know the stocks you like most, and even
if they are not included in either of those indexes, you can add them
to your list while removing others, as you see fit. Most likely, after
some months of trading you will have developed your winner list.
In addition to stocks you have identified through your watch list, you
also need to keep an eye open for “hot” stocks from the previous day
and add them to your daily list.
Don’t make the mistake that the bulk of the public makes: don’t
think, even for a moment, that there’s any simple way to profit from
shares that trend up quickly because of some announcement, or that
crash because of bad news. Usually, these are stocks that will start the
day with a gap and the ability to move either way, sometimes
completely against all logic. In principle, they are unpredictable, but
sometimes a good technical entry point can be found and the
resulting move can be strong because of the interest generated by
news.
When a significant article appears on a specific stock in such
prestigious media as the Wall Street Journal, and you make the
mistake of buying the stock along with millions of others, you no
longer have any advantage as far as price. Will a million readers all
make good profits on the same stock? How will the market react to the
news item? Will the price go up or down? One guess is as good as the
other. In most cases, a stock in the news has already seen its uptrend
prior to any public announcements, based on insider information or
the grapevine. If you are on either of those radars, you have an
advantage. If not, forego the urge to buy.
The well-known catchphrase “buy the rumor, sell the news”
alludes to the principle where the herd buys on hearing the news and
therefore the herd loses. The ones who profit are usually those who
break the law. They have received information from a friend inside the
company, or had access to the company quarterly report printed some
few days before the official publication. If you thought the stock
market does not operate like this – think again. Manipulation and
corruption abound in such subtle ways that the regulatory bodies
simply cannot catch the criminals.
In that case, should we buy a stock in the news because of an
analyst’s recommendation or removal of recommendation? Do
analysts know how to choose good stocks better than you do? Every
year, research is published that examines the outcomes of analyst
recommendations. Can you guess what your situation would be if you
based yourself on the analysts? It’s a certain way to lose your money.
If so, why should you be scanning for stocks in the news? I read the
news for a different purpose altogether: I want to know what the herd
is up to. I want to understand the herd, but I would never operate
automatically the way it would expect me to. I want to know which
stocks are in the news so I can follow them and perhaps find good
technical entry points during the day’s trading, no matter which way
prices are moving. Stocks in the news tend to be highly volatile. And
high volatility is important to me. Every day, I prepare a list of some
five to ten stocks in the spotlight and keep checking them for
technical opportunities. Sometimes I get lucky, sometimes I don’t.
An example of a stock in the news is British Petroleum, BP. The
price crashed due to the leak from the company’s drilling rig near
America’s shores in an event that came to be labeled “the worst
ecological catastrophe in American history.” Anticipated
compensation claims reached the billions of dollars, and a potential
total bankruptcy hovered over the company’s head. For several days we
monitored BP in the trading room, and finally, due to the alertness of
an analyst, its day arrived!
Trade Details
Summary
Every day, dozens of stocks can be found in the news for a variety of
reasons. It makes no difference if the news is good or bad, since there
will always be strong volatility which provides interesting trading
opportunities.
Traders will often become “familiar” with stocks they feel more
confident in than with others. Each timeframe has its “stars,” stocks
with prices that are continuously trending up, drawing traders,
investors and funds to buy in for varying periods of time. Should we
get to know the more popular stocks and join the party?
First, I don’t believe in marrying any stock. Realistically, during any
timeframe, some will be defined as “wild kids” in the market. These
are traded in gigantic volumes and with crazy volatility. As I write
these lines, I can say that the two currently most popular ones are AIG
and SEED. By the time this book reaches the printer, most certainly
others will be the public’s favorites.
AIG’s story belongs to the financial crisis, that amazing crash and
the swift recovery. At such times, emotions work overtime. Some will
remember the company’s good days as a leader in the international
insurance market, and might buy AIG “for the children’s future.”
Others, like us traders, take advantage of this outpour of emotion to
trade the stock through days of fantastic volatility and high volumes.
Daily Behavior of AIG over Several Months
In August 2009, the share’s price leapt from $12 to $55 [1] during
crazy trading days and in volumes of hundreds of millions of shares
per day. In fact, AIG’s story began some time earlier, but without a
doubt, August and September of that year showed the wildest moves
in stock trading.
AIG, along with other “public favorites,” can show highly volatile
movement within a single trading day with high volumes and liquidity,
which is why many day traders earn a great deal of money from them.
Public interest causes price spikes, the company is usually assessed at
far above its real value, and most often will not uphold market
expectations. In most cases the share price will drop [2], volumes will
fall sharply [3] and the price will cease showing its earlier volatility. If
and when interest renews in the stock, it will likely “go crazy” once
more.
I find about one half or slightly more of the stocks I trade in during
the trading day by staying tuned to several sources. The most
important for me is the online trading room where I trade together
with hundreds of other traders every day. Many of them present
interesting stocks from their watch lists, or stocks they identified
during trading hours. The suggestions are inexhaustible! The hard
thing is to know which ones to choose.
Every few seconds, the scanner executes a data update, so that any
particular stock may be replaced by any other. Displayed data can also
be filtered to suit your individual requirements. If your trading
platform does not display these details, you can find the information
gratis on a number of financial sites constantly updated in real time,
such as searching Google for stock gainers and losers, and
choosing the site you find most comfortable to use.
Most traders who use special stock screening platforms are assisted by
programs geared to locating them at the end of the trading day. Very
few use them for intraday searches.
A wide range of stock screening platforms are available. Some are
Internet freebies and others can be purchased for anything from
hundreds to thousands of dollars along with a monthly fee. Paid
programs are generally geared toward professional traders.
Two useful sites are www.stockfetcher.com and www.finviz.com,
and both provide free basic services and paid advanced services.
Summary
My recommendation to you, the novice trader, is not to get involved in
intraday stock searches. Just do the end-of-day search, prepare
interesting stocks for the coming day of trading, learn from your
mistakes, and improve your formulas until you attain reasonably good
control over the search results. The majority of traders do not activate
intraday searches at all.
Chapter 13 - How to Get Ready for
Your First Day of Trading
Why is demo trading unlike real life trading? After all, it’s the same
program, the same market, and the same trader using it. So where
does the difference lie? One of my students, a pro basketball player,
described it in these words, “I know players who get the most amazing
hoops all through training. The big question is what happens when
they’re on the playing field. Pressure, the shouting crowd, whether
your salary check is going to go through this month… all these
influence the game. How many of them can shoot incredibly during a
real time game? Very few!” Here too, it’s the same basket, the same
player, and the same game… but the outcome in competition is very
different. There’s a well-known story about a dueling champion who
was invited to a pistol duel. Beforehand, he warned his foe that he was
able to hit the stem of a champagne glass from a distance of ten
strides. The foe, more experienced with real battles, answered, “Let’s
see if you can hit the stem of the champagne glass when the glass is
aiming a loaded pistol at you…”
One vital component is absent in demo trading: emotion. When
you play with real money, a loaded pistol is being aimed at your brain.
Basic weaknesses such as fear and greed make it much harder for you
to remain cool and rational. You simply will not be the same person in
real time as you were in demo time, and even though right now you
are certain I’m wrong, you will quickly discover how profits on the
demo easily turn into losses in real time trading with real money.
Don’t be mistaken: I’m not saying you shouldn’t use the demo. If
you keep its disadvantages in mind, you will benefit well from its
advantages. A trader profiting “on paper” during the study period will
always remember that in an environment without pressures, it is easy
to beat the market. If and when that trader loses money in real time
trading, he or she will smartly seek the differences between demo
training time and real money trading, analyze them, internalize them,
and correct what needs correcting. Sometimes the new trader may
even stop trading in real money and go back to the demo for a very
short period, to better understand the differences now that some real
experience has been gained. Demo trading trains the trader to execute
technical actions quickly, and more importantly, teaches that it is
possible to make money if you maintain the rules and do not involve
emotion.
Avoid internalizing bad habits when you practice with the demo.
Use the demo to improve your reaction speed, practice trade orders,
and learn the trading program inside out. Even when using the demo
program, trade in small quantities and small numbers of trades, as
though you were dealing in real money. Analyze each trade well, as
though it was executed with real money. Stay tuned to experienced
traders in the online trading room. Don’t trade alone. And don’t bite
off more than you can chew.
The work of day traders begins a while before trading opens. Readying
yourself from the technical and fundamental aspects is important for
both choosing advance stocks suited to trading, and preparing yourself
emotionally, which improves your degree of success.
In theory, you can spend hours preparing, without any real benefit
from so much time invested. If you want to read financial news, you
will find its scope on a daily basis can fill entire libraries, and in the
long run, most of it is meaningless. By contrast, if you want to execute
technical analysis on hundreds of stocks, you will be spending
unnecessarily long hours at your computer screens. To focus on the
core requirements and not waste time on activities that at best will
not assist and at worst cause damage, I recommend you follow these
outlines, adapting them to suit your own personality.
Currently, as an experienced trader, thirty minutes is enough for me
to ready myself. It may be that if I devote more time, my results will
improve, but that is true for everything in life. If you roll out of bed
one hour earlier in the mornings for any business activity, you will
almost certainly earn more. But thirty minutes is the balance I set for
myself between work and play. Golfers (my real occupation…) tend to
say “a bad day at golf is better than a good day at the office.” As you
start out, I recommend devoting more time, perhaps a full hour, to
preparing for your day of trading. A good one hour of preparation
should greatly assist in shortening your learning curve. Spending a
great deal longer than that on preparing will not contribute to your
success.
SMART Devote no more than one hour to preparing
for your day of trading. More than one hour
MONEY contributes nothing and may even prove
harmful.
Several times each month, about one hour before trading, various
financial data are publicized such as the previous month’s inflation
rates, the status of unemployment, and so on. These data influence
early trading on futures, and you can see pre-market direction very
clearly. Good news will often influence the market open with a gap up.
Even if there is no news, you will be able to see the market trending
one way or another. For example, after a very strong day of highs
closing with peaks, there is a good chance the market will open lower
than the highest high and pull back for part of that high at least at the
opening of trade. By contrast, after a day of sharp lows, buyer hysteria
and pressure may dictate an even lower opening. As we learned,
opening above or below the previous day’s close is called a gap, and we
know that gaps generally close on the same day they occur, helping us
evaluate market direction during trading.
Market Direction and the Psychological Component
Market direction is determined by an encompassing range of
psychological aspects reflecting the views of all market components.
My recommendation, therefore, is not to belittle your gut feelings.
Stock trading is far from being a precise science, and in fact is much
more of an art than a science. Even if your “artistic” sensibilities are
not at all developed when you start trading, I recommend trying to
assess market direction and you will be surprised how often you are
right. When I was young, before I had a sight corrective operation, I
needed distance glasses. Every year I would go to a well-known
ophthalmologist who would trouble himself to point out that he is not
an optometrist. At the stage of the annual test where I needed to
identify the row of smallest letters, he would say, “You’re also allowed
to guess.” The interesting thing was that although I knew I couldn’t see
a thing, my guesses were very often right! The conclusion is simple: we
know a lot more than we are consciously willing to admit. Multiple
and often concealed components help us consolidate our views. Even
if you do not have easy use of all the tools, take a guess! You’ll be
surprised at your higher-than-expected success rate.
Announcements Calendar
Choose your favorite financial site, search for the “Announcements
Calendar” link, and jot down topics of interest and important
announcements for the coming week of trading. Remind yourself
every day when the announcement will be appearing. We will deal
with announcements and publication behavior separately.
Take a Rest: the Quiet before the Storm
Intraday trading is a process requiring a great deal of mental
energy. After the first two hours of trading, I tend to feel very tired. To
ready myself for another two hours of rigorous activity, I freshen up,
equip myself with strong coffee, and get back to work.
The Workday Components
1. Opening
Between 9:30 to 11:30AM, New York time, are the most significant
hours of the trading day. These two hours can be further subdivided
into two parts: the first thirty minutes, and the remaining ninety
minutes up until the lunch break.
The first half hour is typified by high volatility, particularly high
volumes and noticeable difficulty in determining market direction.
Our goal during this timeframe is to establish the trade that should
accompany us throughout most of the trading day.
After this half hour, and for the remaining hour- and-a-half until
the lunch break, market trend is more clarified and traders seek
winning trades which will yield their daily earnings. In these trades,
both the quantity of shares and the target will be relatively high.
2. Lunch Break
Between 11:30 AM to 1:30 PM, New York time, we usually see light
volume since many of the big players,the institutional traders, are out
to lunch.The market is calmer and generally consolidates.
This is a good time to rest, take care of existing trades, realize
profits, set new stops and targets, and prepare trades for the last part
of the trading day. Meanwhile we can trade in small caps. Since they
are not traded by the institutional traders who are on lunch hour, but
by the public, these stocks are not affected by the decreased volumes.
3. Close
The close is from 1:30 to 4:00 PM, New York time. It can also be
divided into two parts:
The first is the trading session following the lunch break, between
1:30 to 3:30 PM. It is typified by increasing volumes and sometimes a
strengthening of the trend from the day’s opening. This stage is very
suited to expanding existing trades or for scalping (trades with narrow
defined goals of 20 to 30 cents).
During the second timeframe, between 3:30 to 4 PM, we avoid
starting new trades, close the ones we do not intend to take for a
swing into the next day, and take advantage of this time to check
trades for the following day, based on interesting patterns identified as
the trading day closes.
Each timeframe has its own particular characteristics as far as
trading potential, specific methods, opportunities and risks.
Professional traders will adapt themselves to the timeframe in order to
take maximum advantage of the inherent potential offered by the
different parts of the trading day. Other traders may specialize at
trading during a particular timeframe and invest all their effort there.
Summary
Just as an attorney must prepare for a court hearing, you must also
prepare for the day of trading, your “hour of judgment.” Practice
trading techniques with the demo program, prepare lists of stocks as
suitable candidates for trades, get into the atmosphere of the trading
day ready and confident in your preparations. Self-confidence
improves your mental state and increases your success rate.
Chapter 14 - The Demons are
Coming!
Market Psychology
Behavioral Models
Since we are dealing with flesh and blood humans, we need to check
the basic psychological models according to which these humans
conduct themselves. Let me name a few:
• Opportunity assessment: in many cases we tend to ignore
information we hold, and judge events only according to our
assessment of our ability to succeed or fail
• Conservatism: despite new information and events, we change our
views too slowly
• Distortion of truth: we tend to credit ourselves with successes, but
blame failures on events or external factors
• Excessive self-confidence: we tend to overestimate our abilities.
Understanding our shortcomings will help us comprehend why the
illogic can be perfectly logical, or as they say, “When the sun shines
on Wall Street, open your umbrella.”
I’m going to ask some questions, and you need to answer them with
complete honesty. Don’t try to bluff yourself. Many people are not able
to examine themselves objectively. For them, this is a useless test.
Losses are part and parcel of the market’s “tuition fees.” Few traders
are able to sustain themselves within just months of starting to trade.
Most lose money as novices. Keep this in mind before you start
trading. Why do I expect you to lose? Because trading with real money
is unlike anything you are familiar with, and because despite all my
warnings, you will make every mistake possible on your way to
success. Reading the book, taking the course, and participating in the
online trading room are all important, useful elements that reduce the
period of losses and the amounts you will lose. Never trade without
knowledge or practice, but these are not enough for success. To earn
real money consistently, you must accrue real life “screen time,” invest
effort, and be determined. There is no profession in the world that can
be learned and attained within just a few months.
Losses are not the aftereffect of trading, but an inseparable part of
trading. Becoming a winning trader rather than a losing trader, you
need to learn from every loss. Wring every bit of advantage possible
from the “tuition fees” you “pay” to the market. Analyze every failed
trade: its entry and exit points, the reason for entering, the reason for
the loss and so on, as explained in the section on keeping a trading
diary. I highly recommend printing out the stock’s chart and
analyzing it. Once a week, go over the data you have accumulated and
try to understand the reasons for your mistakes. Very quickly you will
learn enough to avoid repeating them. Leverage each loss and turn
that knowledge into a gain.
Handling Loss
Losing Hurts
The human body is built to resist pain. It is therefore natural that
we deny loss and hope for the best. When hoping for good is illogical,
it is reasonable to presume that we will experience further damage. If
you check the investment portfolio of the average investor, you will
almost always find at least one stock showing a loss of 50% or more.
In my view, there is no logical reason to let any stock cause a loss of
this scope. Denying loss at the outset and moving to inexplicable,
somewhat euphoric optimism are the reasons for losses of this scope.
Another interesting phenomenon is that the stocks that have lost
the most are those that the investor ceases following. The
psychological handling of loss by most inexperienced traders is to
ignore that stock. This is when self-justification steps in, and the
investor spouts such phrases as, “it will make a comeback,” or “the
company has good products,” “the organization’s management is
strong,” or “it’s no more than a paper loss.” How about: “the prices
always go up in the long run” or even pleading with the price itself:
“please, just go up 10% and I swear I’ll stop smoking!” Occasionally
self-justification turns out to be a self-fulfilling prophecy. Generally,
though, it doesn’t.
A few weeks ago, a golfer friend told me about his 92-year-old
father-in-law who recently lost $150,000 in the stock market. That was
half his capital. He lost it on a failed investment in several stocks
showing price drops over the past few months of trading. Concerned
for his father-in-law’s psychological state, my friend invited him to
dinner, and was surprised to discover he was in an excellent mood.
Asking how that was possible, the old man said, “I’m not worried. In
the long term, the prices will go back up…”
Here’s a possible scenario: you bought a stock and discover you’ve
made a mistake. The price drops and comes very close to your planned
exit (stop loss). When you bought the stock, the exit point seemed
very far off and perhaps unreasonable, but now it is threatening you
with a searing loss. The stock continues to new lows, and you think: “I
didn’t make a mistake, I chose a good stock. It will change direction
for sure. I’ll just give it a bit more time…” The greater the loss is
shaping up to be, the stronger your powers of self-persuasion become.
You’re certain that this is not the time to sell, and move the stop
down a bit, then a bit more… and the stock keeps dropping till you’re
losing so much that if you exit, the loss will be almost lethal. Realizing
the loss at this point translates into strong pain. Keeping the stock
translates into hope. And hope suppresses pain.
5. I’m not taking partials. I buy and sell one stock, once.
Maintaining correct money management will help you succeed. If
you take a partial on a winning stock, you will build up a good
“profit cushion” which will allow you to take better care of the
remaining quantity of shares. Yes, this is no more than a
psychological solution meant to assist in overcoming the need to
sell when the stock is still doing well, but remember: correct money
management will avoid arousing those dormant demons buried
deep within us all.
The last day of the trading week is Friday. A drop in tension is felt by
stock traders on this day, and the volume of activity usually plummets
during the second half of Friday’s work hours. As activity thins on the
stock exchange floor, it signals the time for us, the traders, to close our
week as well. Without volume and other traders, there is no volatility
or direction, and the market is open to the manipulations of the big
players and the market makers who go to work in the “vacuums.”
These are very significant days. Every third Friday of the month, on
the Chicago Stock Exchange, stock options expire. This book does not
describe trading options, which is an entire profession in itself, but we
do need to understand the meaning of these expirations. This is when
the big options players, professional organizations, can dictate market
direction. Of course you may ask what connection exists between
options expiration and intraday trading. Well, there is a connection.
Options trading is highly varied, and much of the trading is impacted
by the activities in the options market. Therefore, as I will explain
later, options expiration noticeably influences intraday trading,
especially on the actual day of expiration.
What is an Option?
To understand the influence of options on stock prices, I will try to
give a definition at the most superficial level for options. An option is
a contract between the writer (seller) and the buyer, according to
which the seller allows the buyer, in return for a set price (the option
price), to buy or sell a stock for a predetermined quantity and price
(the strike price). Instead of trying to understand the previous
sentence, let’s focus on the following example: Assume that you
believe that Apple’s stocks will drop in price. You can profit in two
ways from this drop: by shorting it (which we learned) or by buying
options called put options. By contrast, if you believe the stock price
will rise, you can either buy the shares or buy the options, known as
call options. Let’s say you bought a put option and the price did
indeed fall. When the option expires (the third Friday of the month),
you can realize a nice profit. But if the price did not fall, or even if it
fell slightly less than what you expected, you may lose the entire cost
of the option purchase, and the seller of the option will profit. Of
course the total process is somewhat more complex and includes
various expiration dates and strike prices, but the above is sufficient to
grasp the concept.
What happens when the majority of the public believes Apple will
fall, buys large quantities of put options, and towards expiration date
Apple does indeed drop? Does this mean the pros have taken a loss?
Occasionally, yes, but not always. The pros who write the options have
deep pockets and are capable of shifting almost any stock back to the
price where most options expire worthless. Moreover, their way of
protecting themselves from any fall in the price of Apple stock is to
short the stock. When they short Apple, they profit from the drop in
the share price and can pay you your profit on the put option. When
do they close (i.e. buy) their short? On expiration day itself. When
they close shorts, which means they are buying stocks, they help the
stock price rise, and often cause the price to return to exactly that
point where most put options expire as worthless.
An exercise in logic: Let’s say that the public buys a large quantity
of put options on the market index. In other words, most of the public
thinks the market is going to go down. What do you think will happen
in the market towards expiration of the options? You’re right: the
market will go up! Since the options writers could lose from a drop in
market prices, they will bring the market to the price level where the
options expire as worthless. Remember that the options writers are
serious pros, and pros never lose.
When will we feel the professionals’ activities? Usually, they start
shifting market direction towards the required price over Tuesday and
Wednesday of the expiration week. After reaching the required price
during the first half of the week, Thursday and Friday will generally be
“flat” days.
Conclusion: expect a very volatile market on Tuesday and/or
Wednesday of options expiration week.
The period is the week ending on July 18, 2010. It is a fairly erratic
time, towards the end of the financial crisis, and several weak
European countries are on the verge of bankruptcy. There is real
concern over a sharp fall in the stock market. Many funds and
investors fear market plunges, and by way of protection buy SPY put
options to hedge their long-term investments.
These heavy investors presume that if the market drops, they will
lose on their stocks, but will cover these losses through the profits on
options. It’s a bit like buying insurance meant primarily to cover your
own back rather than to actually help your clients. Who is selling
options to the heavy investors? The pros! With the period above being
a highly agitated one, the quantity of put options is far greater than
call options. All that is left for the pros to do is bring the market price
up on Tuesday [1] to where most of the put options expire as
worthless, and maintain that target until Friday [2]. It doesn’t take a
genius to predict the likely outcome. One only needs to be familiar
with the rules of the market.
Note the Behavior of the SPY ETF during Expiration Week (daily
chart)
Now let’s take a look at the quantity of options on Legg Mason Inc.,
the capital management company:
As you see, the last trade on expiration day was executed at thirty-
two dollars. [1]. Now, pay attention to the thirty-two dollar line
running across the chart. LM is drawn to this price already at the start
of the day, and all it has to do once it reaches thirty-two dollars is to
consolidate above or below this figure until the day ends at thirty-two
dollars [1]. The pros know exactly where they need to bring the price,
and that’s where you will find it.
SMART Because the options writers want to pro t
on expiration day, they will try to shift the
MONEY stock price on that day close to the strike
price of the largest open position of options.
What happens at the end of the year to a stock that showed strength
throughout the year? Will it pull back? Will buyers realize profits?
Indeed, for reasons generally tied to taxation, the pullback will
generally not come at year’s end. In the US, taxes are paid only on
profits from stocks sold at a profit during the calendar year from
January 1 to December 31. An investor postponing the sale of stocks
showing a profit to the start of the next tax year can delay paying the
tax by a full tax year, and perhaps end up not paying it at all,
depending on the overall status of the next tax year.
Conclusion: strong stocks which rose during the year are expected
to continue rising in the final weeks of the year, since investors avoid
selling due to tax laws. By contrast, weak stocks are expected to sell in
order to “lock the loss.” In other words, a strong year will generally end
with continuing new highs and a weak year will typically see
continued lows until the end of the tax year.
It is commonly believed that investors who avoided “locking
profits” at the end of the year will realize their profits at the start of
January. This is not necessarily true. Strong stocks do not sell easily.
The more their price rises, the more the interest in selling them
decreases. The greater probability is that investors will continue
holding winning stocks well into the new tax year.
For how long will they hold these stocks? Until there is no choice
but to sell. April 15th is the date by which tax returns must be filed,
together with any payment due. Deposits to the IRS account can also
be made only until April 15th. As a result, many investors sell their
stocks only towards the end of March or early April to raise money to
pay their taxes.
An investor who needs the cash will execute sales generally up until
the first week of April, since brokers take three days to release cash to
their clients. The third day is known as settlement day. It takes
another two days until the settlement actually shows in the client’s
bank account.
Holidays
The stock exchanges are open most days of the year, other than certain
holidays. About a week before any of these, your broker will send you
a “short trading week” reminder with details.
Pay attention to the fact that sometimes trades will be executed
only during the first half of the day. You should receive information
from the broker on that as well. Shortened trading days are usually
“bridges” between vacations and are known to have low volumes,
making it best to avoid trading altogether.
Naturally, the risk of holding stocks for a swing over several
consecutive days of holidays is greater than for a regular weekend.
More days off means a greater risk that something bad could happen.
Towards vacations and long weekends, I tend to reduce the quantities
of stock I hold for a swing.
Summary
Self-con dence
External Communication
This is the way you express yourself, the words you say, your body
language, your facial expressions. External communication is power. It
is your power to impact others and the way they perceive you.
Everything you wish to achieve, everything you lack, you can reach
through those very same people. First, you need to find them and
connect to them. If you mingle with people who have money, sooner
or later something of it will cling to you too. If you mingle only with
the people you grew up with, you won’t get far. During the most
challenging financial timeframe of my life (see what I mean? I swap
“difficult” for “challenging”) when I had not a penny to my name, I
joined an exclusive golf club. That was my way of mingling with the
haves rather than the have-nots.
Despite my dreadful financial state, how did I manage suitable
external communication with millionaires as an equal among equals?
When you come from a lower economic class, it’s not so easy to
communicate naturally with someone who is leagues above you. Try
imagining how you’d behave if invited to lunch, one-on-one, with
Donald Trump. Would your external communication be natural? Now
try to imagine the lines of communication between Trump and
Warren Buffet. Would they be more natural? Of course they would.
How does one millionaire approach another? Does he look him
straight in the eye when speaking, or look down? My way of
structuring good external communication was to structure
constructive internal communication. I constantly repeated to myself,
“I’m a millionaire. A check for one million dollars is on its way to my
account, but hasn’t been deposited yet.” Once I convinced myself I was
a millionaire and that the check was merely delayed in the mail, being
a millionaire was a given. With that problem behind me, my external
communication altered. The expensive membership fees quickly paid
off and were dwarfed by the scope of deals in millions of dollars I
closed on the golf course.
External communication puts amazing power into the hands of
those who know how to use it. Look how far external communication
led people like Barack Obama, or at the other extreme entirely,
Mussolini and Hitler. Strong external communication is the outcome
of correctly applying internal communication, which is the source of
power in individuals who succeed.
Aspiring to Be Powerful
The aspiration for power has impacted human history more than all
the forces of nature put together. For those doing the controlling, their
power is positive; for those being controlled, that power is generally
negative. It makes no difference how you feel about power. You need
to accept the fact that in the world we live in, the powerful control and
the powerless are controlled. So what is it that you prefer: to set your
own agenda, or live your life according to an agenda set by someone
else? Simply put: are you the sheep or the wolf?
Power itself can be controlled. Power does not necessarily mean
controlling the fate of other people. We can accumulate great power,
but use it only to the degree where we have absolute control over our
own fates. Power does not have to carry negative connotations, but
can be used positively by assisting others. I tend to lecture free of
charge to high school students, college students, and soldiers. The
demand for my knowledge gives me a great feeling of being powerful
in a different way.
The significance of power altered as civilization developed. In
prehistoric human history, the powerful individual was the physically
strongest. Over time, as the world developed into an economic
organization, the focus of power shifted to those with capital. The
wealthiest was the most powerful. At some point, an interesting shift
became apparent when the socially-accepted norm determined that
power would be passed down by inheritance from the nobleman to his
son. If you were not born into nobility, your chances of succeeding,
influencing, and accumulating power and assets were zero. The only
way that might happen was if you were close to the nobleman in some
way. These dark times, in which nobility was richly remunerated and
the commoner found no positive incentive, typified the Middle Ages, a
time in which the world almost stopped progressing. The Industrial
Revolution, when the holders of capital and therefore power were
those who owned machines, put an end to the power of nobility.
In our own times, power once again changed hands, moving from
those who held capital and assets to those who also held knowledge.
Up until some decades ago, it would have been impossible to compete
with heavily-invested companies such as General Motors or IBM. To
compete with a giant like IBM, a dreamy capital in the billions of
dollars would have been needed. All this was true until a “geek” in
jeans named Bill Gates overthrew IBM from the top by the use of
initiative and knowledge. So too for Apple, Facebook, Google and tens
of other companies that now control our lives, but were established
not by holders of capital but by holders of knowledge. The beauty of
our current times is that the chances of success are open to every
single person, even if you have no physical power, capital, or title of
nobility. Knowledge is power. Knowledge is the key to success. And
knowledge can be bought.
Knowledge moves the world. Until the end of the nineteenth century,
if you had neither capital nor title, you could never break out from the
class into which you were born. In those times, knowledge was for the
privileged few, and banks funded the upper classes rather than those
with knowledge. Our world is completely different: we live in an era
where knowledge is readily accessible, and capital seeks good ideas
even if the person presenting them is a youngster with a ponytail who
never even finished college. Billionaires like Bill Gates and Steve Jobs
were not born into the nobility--they were simply born into the right
time. And they didn’t have a college degree.
Knowledge and ideas are available to anyone seeking them. If
knowledge is available to all, how is it that there are not more people
who are successful, happy, driving Ferraris and living in Beverly Hills
villas? Because knowledge in itself is not enough. Knowledge is the
potential for power, but to realize it, actions are needed. Success
begins with knowledge and ends in actions.
Knowledge in stock trading is also available to anyone seeking it, so
why isn’t everyone rich? Because operating in the stock market also
requires integrating knowledge with action. The world is full of people
with broad knowledge but who are inactive. What is unique about the
successful individuals is that they, unlike the bulk of the public, take
action. Their success, their power to control their own futures, derives
from accrued knowledge and cumulative actions.
If you want to succeed, use other people’s knowledge and emulate
the successful. You don’t even need to come up with an original idea.
Did Steve Jobs invent Apple’s graphic interface, the mouse or the iPad?
No. He took existing ideas and upgraded them to such a state of
perfection that he created an entirely new market. He fine-tuned
solutions and took action. Nor did Bill Gates invent the DOS system
which turned him into such a wealthy individual. He bought it from
an inventor who did not realize its inherent potential.
A Role Model
Success does not require you to reinvent the wheel. Find a working
model and copy it. I am not suggesting you give up on being the next
inventor of a dot-com enterprise. I am just trying to stay practical.
From the experience of decades of business activity, I’ve learned that
the chances of success are higher when emulating and improving
upon existing products, knowledge and methods. During the dot-com
bubble era, I failed in my attempts at inventing products and services
which I was sure would change the world. But I did succeed in
improving on existing ideas and products. Nor did I invent day
trading, but I was the first to turn it into a model for schools and
brokerage companies operating in various countries outside the
United States. This was a successful model I initiated, which did not
require my own capital. I brought knowledge and entrepreneurial
initiative to the table, and recruited investor funds. My life was not
one of successes only. I experienced some tough failures, but I always
kept one thing in mind: if I don’t try, I won’t succeed.
Success does not need to follow a model of worldwide scope such
as Facebook. If a business is doing incredibly well in Los Angeles,
there’s no reason it should not do well in San Diego. I suggest you
keep your eyes wide open, find a worthy role model, copy and
upgrade. If a stock trader is a role model for success, there is no good
reason why you shouldn’t contact that person, learn from him or her,
and try to emulate his or her success. You have to believe that if
someone succeeds, you can too! If you don’t believe that, then first
work on improving your self-esteem.
It is difficult to hide success. Successful people leave clear
footprints. Go after those footprints and try to copy the steps, one
after the other. You can do more than just copy: you can improve to
such a degree that one day you may be the role model for someone
else. Never forget that for every action you take, there is a price tag.
The price is measured in resources such as money and time, where
money is the cheaper of the two. Time is your most costly resource
which, if wasted, can never be recovered.
For success, you must have true, burning faith in your ability. You
must infuse yourself with this faith every day. Talk to yourself, tell
yourself how strong, smart and successful you are. Convince yourself,
believe in yourself, and simultaneously gain knowledge, knowhow, and
take a risk…take action.
Believing in Success
A Five-Step Plan
Here are five steps to formulating, internalizing and realizing a new
belief:
FIRST, repeatedly embed your new belief into your mind. Like
every belief you’ve developed over your lifetime, a new belief must be
meticulously implanted within your mindset. Repeat your goal over
and over to yourself until you firmly believe in your ability to achieve
it.
Your parents may have said umpteen times, “You need to learn a
profession.” The media relentlessly penetrates the political messages
you adopt, day after day, year after year. Even your religious beliefs
were not absorbed in just one day. Now your job is to choose a goal
and hammer that ability to achieve it deep within yourself. No one can
do this for you.
SECOND, try to imagine success. How would you look if you were a
whole lot lighter? What sort of clothes would you buy? How proud
would you be when you join friends who knew you as a smoker and
they see you no longer disappear every twenty minutes to grab a
smoke? Imagining helps reinforce determination and helps cope with
the process of reaching your goal.
My golf coach, Ricardo, actually trained as a psychiatrist before
becoming a pro golfer. During one lesson, Ricardo taught me that a
successful golf shot requires me to imagine the outcome. “Before
hitting, imagine the flight of the ball and your target,” he would
repeat. And it works! The body amazingly moves according to what we
imagine.
THIRD, spread your belief. Tell everyone you can about your goal
and your determination to achieve it. Start with people close to you
and then expand the circle. The more people you tell, the more
committed you will feel to upholding your stated goal. At age twelve
when I decided to be a millionaire, I told all my friends, and kept
reminding them over the years. I joked with them that they would end
up working for me, which is indeed what happened to some. The
more I shared my goal with others, the more obligated I felt to
overcome the obstacles encountered on my way to realizing it.
Will you be able to overcome all the obstacles along your path to
realizing success, and realize your belief?
The answer is YES, YES, YES!
Sounds crazy? But that’s the truth. It is a historically and
scientifically proven truth. Nothing stands in the way of our will.
Commitment to Success
Controlling Frustration
Accepting Responsibility
Did you make a mistake? Blow it? Don’t look for those responsible for
your failure. Take responsibility for your actions. We naturally tend to
blame our parents, teachers, employers, and the government. The
starting point for many who achieved success was much tougher than
for the average person. Many experienced extremely tough times in
their lives, and nonetheless succeeded. Did the obstacles they
encounter diminish their commitment to their goals, or reinforce
them? For most successful people, the obstacles are what drive them
to greater strength. The desire to succeed is greater than the need for a
warm meal at the end of the day. Successful people hold their own
ability to succeed in high regard, which is often viewed by others as
arrogance. Successful people can rightly be proud of their success, but
they are equally prepared to assume responsibility for their mistakes.
This willingness to accept responsibility derives from power; evading
responsibility derives from weakness.
Eric Schmidt, former CEO of Google, said, “I screwed up” when he
and other Google top-level staff did not handle the fledgling Facebook
startup and fight back at a company that dared take on the biggest
possible competitor in the Internet. By contrast, Bill Clinton with his
famous statement, “I did not have sexual relations with that woman”
evaded responsibility and paid by almost losing the presidency. The
public relates to acceptance of responsibility with understanding and
respect, and to evasion as a sign of failure. Accepting responsibility is a
sign of power and maturity. It also reinforces your faith in your ability
to overcome obstacles, and understand that they are an inseparable
part of the path to success. What do author Mark Twain, ketchup king
Henry Heinz, and automobile giant Henry Ford share in common? At
some point on their way to success, they all went broke, took
responsibility, recovered and came back bigger and better than ever.
To succeed, you need a good reason to get out of bed in the morning.
You need to love your work. If salary is the only thing keeping you in
the workplace, you will not get far. Having worked for years in the
high-tech industry, I can tell you that the greatest aspiration held by
most high-tech employees is “not to work anymore in high-tech.” In
other words, even high salaries and great benefits are not enough to
make an employee love the job, let alone excel at it.
To succeed, you don’t need to be brilliant. You just need to be a
little better than average, and to do that, your work needs to interest
you. Your work needs to more closely resemble a game than a chore.
Find the job that pleases you so much that you never look at the clock.
If salary is what guides you, you could likely end up finding you’ve
devoted most of your life to a reality that has not led you to a greatly-
improved financial situation. At some point when you reach the end of
your tether with your job, you will discover that you’re too scared to
try and change your field or place of employment.
I’m very aware of the fact that changing your place of employment
is not easy. We acclimate easily to a particular routine and
environment, and any change rocks us. If, on one hand, you’re dying to
leave your job but find that hard to do, how should you overcome the
dilemma? Very simple: plan the future, define the goals, and create the
belief that you can achieve those goals. Remember the five steps to
formulating your belief? Establishing, imagining, spreading, applying,
evaluating. The process is slow and requires a lot of patience, but you
have no choice: you must start somewhere, and if not now, when?
Choose work that you love, and you will never need to
work another day in your life. – Confucius
Success is an Avalanche
You need to make a decision, right now, a decision that will change
your life. You know that doubting moment of “dive into the deep end,
or don’t dive into the deep end…” After you jump, you discover that the
water is fine, even if it was a tad cold at first. My advice to you? Take
the plunge! Now! Change your life. If not now, when? I’ve helped you
up to this point, and want to help you further. But now… it’s all up to
you!
To your success!
Special offers for readers:
Visit Tradenet
Visit Tradenet’s website where you will find a vast array of useful free
resources, tutorials and updated information on interesting new
products.
to visit Tradenet website
Click here
Contact me
If you would like to know more about these offers, or have any other
question for me, feel free to email me at any time:
meir@tradenet.co.uk