Sun Tzu' The Art of War (PDFDrive) PDF
Sun Tzu' The Art of War (PDFDrive) PDF
Sun Tzu' The Art of War (PDFDrive) PDF
TZU’s ART
OF
WAR
Tr a nslation, Introduction, Explanations,
a n d Adaptations of Concepts
b y Gary Gagliardi
Sin ce rel y,
Award Recognition for Strategy Books by Gary Gagliardi
(Click on the book title to read more about it on the web.)
The Art of War Plus Making Money by Speaking: The Ancient Bing-fa:
The Golden Key to Strategy The Ancient Chinese Revealed The Spokesperson Strategy Warrior Marketing Martial Arts Strategy
ScienceOfStrategy.com
StrategySchool.com
Strategy-Shop.com
StrategyEvents.com
StrategyTrainers.com
StrategyAffiliates.com
types of numbers. The same is true in Sun Tzu’s work. When we read “fight,” “conflict,” “battle,”
and “attack” we assume we know what is being said. We quickly forget—and often do not even
notice—Sun Tzu’s very specific definitions of terms.
My notes in this edition exist to call attention to what you are missing and how easy it is to
forget the defined terms and their real meaning. As the work goes on, Sun Tzu uses his specialized
vocabulary to express more complex ideas. Most of these ideas are difficult to explain without this
specialized vocabulary. However, since casual readers do not master the vocabulary, they cannot
see the points that are being made. People can see fine distinctions in strategic situations when
they are trained. That training strategy with learning a precise vocabulary.
The book defines a complex array of relationships among the concepts defining a strate-
gic position and how it is advanced in a competitive environment. Chinese scientific tradition
taught—as modern science does—that most concepts are beyond words. They are best expressed
in formal relationships of formulas. A good example is E=MC2, which can be generally described
as the relationship between energy and matter. See this web page for a short explanation of the
specific meaning in what seems on the surface like a very general statement in Sun Tzu’s work.
Because of depth of meaning in each character and every line has a wealth of useful applica-
tions. This however, does not mean that you can make up your own interpretation. The concepts
and their connections are rigorous. The only real secret to Sun Tzu is that it takes time and effort
to learn his system just like it takes time to master any mathematical or scientific skills. This is
why we invite people to join our organization, set up their own local chapters and on-line groups,
10
meet to discuss our books, and join on-line courses, and live training.
Sun Tzu discusses three aspects of strategy in his work. The first two chapters and the final
one concentrate on positioning. The middle chapters concentrate on identifying and exploring
opportunities to advance and build up positions. The penultimate and largest section of the book
explores the responses required to address a specific competitive situations. Since you retain only
5 percent of what you read, the chances that you will remember the right prescriptions for a specific
situation when that situation arises in your life are small after only reading the book.
We hope that reading the book will interest you further in joining our organizations and
understanding and using these techniques. We designed the our membership on-line training
to make mastering these ideas quick, easy, and even fun. Of course, we also offer membership
for organizations and schools. Every organization in the world can profit from its people making
better front-line decisions. In our training, we provide the examples, illustrations, exercises,
and activities, and that you would expect in learning a science, but we do it in an adult learning
environment where our attendees draw from their real-life experiences to illustration Sun Tzu’s
methods. We have Institute trainers all over the world training individuals within organizations
in these techniques. For more information about our live training, visit our training site where we
explain our program. If you are a trainer or consultant yourself (or want to become one, visit our
trainers site, where we explain our licensing program.
11
Chapter 1: Analysis
1 This is war.
It is the most important skill in the nation.
It is the basis of life and death.
It is the philosophy of survival or destruction.
You must know it well.
Many of our members find the cultural aspects
of the work fascinating. The original Chinese is
6Your skill comes from five factors. much more like formulas than sentences. For
example: Competition = survival + destruction
Study these factors when you plan war. Position = philosophy + climate + ground +
leadership + method
You must insist on knowing your situation.
Sun Tzu’s system is the interaction of all these
1. Discuss philosophy. formulas together. You can use the same
2. Discuss the climate. formulas to analyze any challenging situation.
Sun Tzu’s system is the interaction of all these
3. Discuss the ground. formulas together. The five elements described
here are based on the five classical elements
4. Discuss leadership. in Chinese science and philosophy.
5. Discuss military methods.
Command your people in a way that gives them a higher shared purpose.
You can lead them to death.
You can lead them to life.
They must never fear danger or dishonesty.
1 3 Chapter 1: Analysis
BONUS MATERIAL: General is,
The Chinese Revealed Intelligence, trust, love, bravery, strict also.
For our members who are
interested in the original Method is,
Chinese, we offer a Chinese
transliteration in The Art of Bend system,
War Plus The Ancient Chinese Government official philosophy,
Revealed. This book is the
only book that shows English Ruler use also.
readers what Sun Tzu actu-
ally wrote. It was also the first
book to use our “side-by-side” All here five are,
system, showing the Chinese
with our English translation. General not no hear,
By letting you see the original
text, you can compare differ- Knowledge of is victory,
ent translations of The Art of
War to see for yourself what
No knowledge of is no victory.
2
is gained and often lost in
translation. All of our books
on Sun Tzu are based on the Make school by plans,
Chinese formulas, not our
English translation. And yet demand this situation.
Says:
Ruler that has philosophy,
General that has ability,
The Art of War 1 4
28Next is the commander.
34All five of these factors are critical. Sun Tzu’s Adaptive Response Strategy
(STARS) teaches pattern recognition. These
As a commander, you must pay attention to them. five elements are the foundation for the other
Understanding them brings victory. eight key formulas in the system. In training
our members, we organize Sun Tzu’s les-
Ignoring them means defeat. sons into nine areas of skill, position aware-
ness, perspective development, opportunity
5 Manage to avoid battle until your organization can count on certain victory.
You must calculate many advantages.
Before you go to battle, your organization's analysis may indicate that you might not win.
You can count few advantages. Don’t be misled when Sun Tzu’s
Many advantages add up to victory. stanzas seem like vague aphorisms.
The problem is that many ideas are
Few advantages add up to defeat. difficult to translate and require the
next step, education, which teaches
How can you know your advantages without analyzing them? you all the elements of strategy and
We can see where we are by means of our observations. their interconnections. This verse,
for example, describes “counting,”
We can foresee our victory or defeat by planning. but once you master Sun Tzu’s sys-
tem, you know instantly when the
elements in a situation don’t add up
in your favor. This is how you make
better decisions quickly.
25You can fight a war for a long time or you can make your nation strong.
The nation impoverishes itself shipping to troops that are far away. 3
Distant transportation is costly for hundreds of families.
Buying goods with the army nearby is also expensive.
High prices also exhaust wealth.
If you exhaust your wealth, you then quickly hollow out your military.
Military forces consume a nation’s wealth entirely.
War leaves households in the former heart of the nation with nothing.
3 Warriors who move too far from what they know find that they are poorer for it.
Distance is another form of cost that makes success unlikely.
The further you go, the higher the price you must pay.
You cannot afford the cost of far-flung projects.
The efforts you put into traveling cannot also be used to build up your position.
Moving too far afield can destroy your position completely.
Long-distance campaigns erode dependable forms of support and erode your position.
2 3 Chapter 2: Going to War
8War destroys hundreds of families.
The tangible resources of war—horses,
armor, helmets, etc.—are also a meta- Out of every ten families, war leaves only seven.
phor for all the resources that you can-
not afford to lose, especially your time. War empties the government’s storehouses.
All resources are limited
Broken armies will get rid of their horses.
The point here is that conflict is costly.
You cannot predict its outcome. Every
They will throw down their armor, helmets, and arrows.
move is an experiment. We master Sun They will lose their swords and shields.
Tzu’s system so that you can learn how
to experiment safely. They will leave their wagons without oxen.
War will consume 60 percent of everything you have.
Because of this, it is the intelligent commander’s duty to feed off the enemy. 4
2Use a cup of the enemy’s food.
Take the enemy’s strength from him by stealing away his money.
4 Warriors maintain their resources through campaigns that return more than they consume.
12Unity works because it enables you to win every battle you fight.
Still, this is the foolish goal of a weak leader.
Avoid battle and make the enemy’s men surrender.
This is the right goal for a superior leader.
2 7 Chapter 3: Planning an Attack
2 The best policy is to attack while the enemy is still planning.
The next best is to disrupt alliances.
The next best is to attack the opposing army.
The worst is to attack the enemy’s cities. Institute members get the opportunity to learn
about these concepts in depth. For example,
these four policies connect to the four steps in
5This is what happens when you attack a city. advancing a position, Learn-Aim-Move-Claim.
There are many such numbered cross refer-
You can attempt it, but you can’t finish it. ences in this work. “Five” connects to the five
key factors. “Six” connects to the six dimen-
First you must make siege engines. sions of an opportunity, and so on. This tradi-
You need the right equipment and machinery. tion goes back to the I Ching and the bagua
as we explain in this article on the sources of
It takes three months and still you cannot win. Sun Tzu.
Then you try to encircle the area.
You use three more months without making progress.
Your command still doesn’t succeed and this angers you.
You then try to swarm the city.
This kills a third of your officers and men.
You are still unable to draw the enemy out of the city.
This attack is a disaster.
The Art of War 28
3 Make good use of war.
Make the enemy’s troops surrender.
Strategic awareness not only wins advances.
You use its leverage to prevent opponents
from contesting your advances.
8You must use total war, fighting with everything you have.
5The army's position is made more difficult by politicians in three different ways.
6 We say:
“Know yourself and know your enemy.
elements in classical Chinese science.
These interconnections make it easier
to internalize all the moving parts of
Sun Tzu’s system. As you integrate
this system into your thinking, it auto-
You will be safe in every battle. matically pops out the right decisions
You may know yourself but not know the enemy. just when you need them.
You will then lose one battle for every one you win. The real wisdom isn’t in using the sys-
tem, which becomes almost automatic,
You may not know yourself or the enemy. but in taking the time to master it.
You will then lose every battle.”
You see the opportunity for victory; you don’t create it.
3 5 Chapter 4: Positioning
Sun Tzu teaches you how to make much
better decisions. This starts by putting your
You are sometimes unable to win.
You must then defend.
2
decisions into the framework of advanc- You will eventually be able to win.
ing or defending positions. When do you
defend your position? When do you try to You must then attack.
advance it? Do you ever abandon it?
Defend when you have insufficient strength.
Much of strategic cognition is based Attack when you have a surplus of strength.
instantly choosing between two opposite
courses—here, attacking (advancing) and
defending. In classical strategy, we call 7You must defend yourself well.
these elements complementary opposites:
two sides of the same situation. Save your forces and dig in.
You must attack well.
Move your forces when you have a clear advantage.
11You must always protect yourself until you can completely triumph.
Success depends totally upon our ability to protect ourselves and survive
long enough for an opportunity to present itself.
3 7 Chapter 4: Positioning
4Some can struggle to a victory and the whole world may praise their winning.
ck
o rt
that will cost us everything. Bing-fa is a patient, careful philosophy that doesn't
Atta
u n it
force success.
rces y
The two key ideas—winning without effort and attacking only when you
Defe
sou
will win—are intimately connected. We always win by preventing our defeat (S
nd
Re
h te
because good defense allows us to be extremely particular about picking our ou) Genera
3 9 Chapter 4: Positioning
Fight when your position must win. In Sun Tzu’s usage, “fight” specifically
You always win by preventing your defeat. means using all your resources. Did you
notice that definition earlier in the text? Did
you remember it when reading this sec-
21You must engage only in winning battles. tion? Again, the specific way Sun Tzu uses
language is different from the more general
Position yourself where you cannot lose. usage in English. In Chinese, characters
are not verbs, nouns, or adjectives. They
Never waste an opportunity to defeat your enemy. are concepts that we have to translate into
verbs, nouns, and adjectives in English,
which waters them down.
24You win a war by first assuring yourself of victory.
15Creating a winning war is like balancing a coin of gold against a coin of silver.
Creating a losing war is like balancing a coin of silver against a coin of gold.
4 1 Chapter 4: Positioning
Chapter 5: Momentum
9If you are defeated, you can recover. All the images involved—weather,
land, days, months, seasons, notes,
You must use the four seasons correctly. the scale, colors, shades, flavors,
etc.—are tied clearly and specifically
11There are only a few notes in the scale. to the five factors of strategic analy-
sis via the five Chinese elements and
Yet you can always rearrange them. their connections. Knowing those
connections makes the specific
You can never hear every song of victory.
meaning clear.
4 3 Chapter 5: Momentum
17There are only a few flavors.
This is momentum.
Your momentum must be overwhelming. The key is that Sun Tzu has
Your timing must be exact. defined momentum much more
specifically than its usual use
in English. It is not winning. It is
10Your momentum is like the tension of a bent crossbow. taking control of the situation by
combining standard approaches
Your timing is like the pulling of a trigger. with an innovation.
You create it with your men during battle. Strategic cognition connects the
rules of basic physics to the rules of
This is comparable to rolling trees and stones. human psychology, especially the
Trees and stones roll because of their shape and weight. psychology of groups. This makes
it easier to predict the most likely
Offer men safety and they will stay calm. course events will take.
Endanger them and they will act.
In classical strategy, the same rules
Give them a place and they will hold. defined physical and psychological
Round them up and they will march. momentum.
This should be like rolling round stones down over a high, steep cliff.
Momentum is critical.
You are now only about a third of the way through the
text.
1 Always arrive first to the empty battlefield to await the enemy at your leisure.
After the battleground is occupied and you hurry to it, fighting is more difficult.
3 Be subtle! Be subtle!
Arrive without any clear formation.
detailed explanations and put more of a
burden on study by the reader.
When the enemy divides, he creates many small groups. Sun Tzu never gives ex-
You want your large group to attack one of his small ones. amples of how to use his
principles to make it easy to
Then you have many men where the enemy has but a few. master his ideas. He never
Your larger force can overwhelm his smaller one. talks about specific weapons
Then go on to the next small enemy group. or troop formations.
5 You must keep the place that you have chosen as a battleground a secret.
The enemy must not know.
Force the enemy to prepare his defense in many places.
You want the enemy to defend many places.
Then you can choose where to meet the enemy.
His forces will be weak there.
15We say:
When you form your strategy, know the strengths and weaknesses of your plan. 7
The Art of War 56
Opposition on different issues must not unite. BONUS MATERIAL:
The Art of War for the Manage-
General opposition must not focus on one issue. ment Warrior applies Sun Tzu’s
lessons in a way that those who
Productivity must not disguise weaknesses. are responsible for a team of
Weaknesses must not stop productivity. people within a larger orga-
nization can appreciate. This
People won’t oppose changes that they don’t expect. adaptation uses our line-by-line,
side-by-side format as shown
How can unknown plans be opposed? here. We developed this book
training the management teams
for some of the world’s most suc-
You decide the balance of emotion. cessful companies.
People may vaguely oppose doing what is needed.
How can they stop you from succeeding?
7 When you plan your strategy, know the strengths and weaknesses of your analysis.
5 7 Chapter 6: Weakness and Strength
When you execute a plan, know how to manage both action and inaction.
When you take a position, know the deadly and the winning grounds.
When you enter into battle, know when you have too many or too few men.
What does Sun Tzu mean
by a “war’s centerpiece”? 5Use your position as your war’s centerpiece.
You have to know what
factor Sun Tzu puts at the
Arrive at the battle without a formation.
center of his compass for Don’t take a position in advance.
mapping a position. In clas- Then even the best spies can’t report it.
sical Chinese, the center
was the ground, but for Sun Even the wisest general cannot plan to counter you.
Tzu, it was your philosophy. Take a position where you can triumph using superior numbers.
Keep opposing forces ignorant.
Everyone should learn your location after your position has given you success.
No one should know how your location gives you a winning position.
Make a successful battle one from which the enemy cannot recover.
You must continually adjust your position to his position.
18If you make your army travel without good supply lines, your army will die.
21Do not let any of your potential enemies know what you are planning.
Making yourself seem less successful than you are protects your
resources. In situations in which you might be challenged, appearing
weak is an advantage. Don’t worry about what others think; focus on
your own progress. Be creative about finding an easy way around the
dangerous people who might confront you. Outmaneuvering opponents
is how you are successful in real-world fights.
When it is night, you must make more noise. During the day, you use
motion to signal others. You must expect others to interpret their situ-
ation, whether it is safe to attack you or join you, based upon what they
see and hear you do.
67 Chapter 7: Armed Conflict
5 You control your army by controlling its morale.
As a general, you must be able to control emotions.
7 1 Chapter 8: Adaptability
3 You can deter your potential enemy by using his weaknesses against him.
You can keep your potential enemy’s army busy by giving it work to do.
You can rush your potential enemy by offering him an advantageous position.
7 3 Chapter 8: Adaptability
5 You can exploit five different faults in a leader.
If he is willing to die, you can kill him.
The five key factors are again
the basis for this statement
about leadership, especially
leadership as specifically de-
If he wants to survive, you can capture him. fined in Chapter 1.
You can’t do that if you are caught in water when you meet an invader.
Position yourself upstream, facing the sun.
Never face against the current.
Always position your army upstream when near the water.
The Art of War 76
15You may have to move across marshes.
Notice that Sun Tzu doesn’t list
Move through them quickly without stopping. the four ground conditions he
is discussing.
You may meet the enemy in the middle of a marsh.
You must keep on the water grasses. Technically, these conditions
Keep your back to a clump of trees. represent three problems plus
their absence. The first is an
This is how you position your army in a marsh. excess of ground, mountains.
The second an excess of
climate, water. The third is an
21On a level plateau, take a position that you can change.
excess of ground and climate
Keep the higher ground on your right and to the rear. combined, marshes. The fourth
is the lack of excess. This is
Keep danger in front of you and safety behind. important because the number
This is how you position yourself on a level plateau. three is connected to barriers
to progress, not to four skills
for advancing a position.
25You can find an advantage in all four of these situations.
Learn from the great emperor who used positioning to conquer his four rivals.
3 Stop the march when the rain swells the river into rapids.
You may want to ford the river.
that you can map to these
classical competitive situa-
tions.
4All regions can have seasonal mountain streams that can cut you off.
16Danger can hide on your army’s flank. Here, we have the three chal-
lenges that limit progress. They
There are reservoirs and lakes. are called “distance,” “dan-
gers,” and “obstacles.” They
There are reeds and thickets. map to mountains, waters,
There are mountain woods. and marshes. Each concept
Their dense vegetation provides a hiding place. has a precise meaning but
these concepts are specifically
You must cautiously search through them. defined later in the text.
They can always hide an ambush.
Your competitors make silly claims and talk about new markets.
Prepare your salespeople for competitors consolidating business.
He is plotting.
He is in trouble.
41Your enemy first acts violently and then is afraid of your larger force.
6 If you are too weak to fight, you must find more men.
In this situation, you must not act aggressively.
swer to that question, but there
are at least three other condi-
tions that can affect that deci-
sion. You have already seen
You must unite your forces. one related to the environment,
when “rivers swell with rain,” in
Prepare for the enemy. other words, when conditions
Recruit men and stay where you are. in the environment are chang-
ing too rapidly.
6You must be cautious about making plans and adjust to the enemy.
7 With new, undedicated soldiers, you can depend on them if you discipline them.
They will tend to disobey your orders.
If they do not obey your orders, they will be useless.
2 In fighting terror, we must make certain that our own forces have none of
these weaknesses while spotting these weaknesses in terrorist organizations.
Thus far, we have managed to outmaneuver the terrorists by moving into the
Middle East. Their armies have either fallen apart, been disorganized, or had to
retreat. However, we must be wary of our weaknesses on the media battleground.
Terrorist leaders, in contrast, make strong threats, but they can seldom back them up, so their
credibility suffers.
A flaw in the network of terror is that terrorist groups are fragmented. They vent their frustra-
tion at military setbacks at the hands of America by attacking fellow Muslims in countries such as
Saudi Arabia. This reaction undermines support for their cause.
Before 9/11, America's leadership was weak and too accepting of attacks on our people. Our
military response to repeated terrorist attacks was indifferent. Because we weren't trying to estab-
lish clear positions, we couldn't make any progress against the terrorists. Our efforts were half-
hearted and disorganized.
9 5 Chapter 10: Field Position
This shows in his military formations.
This means that his army is disorganized.
The first one to arrive there can gather a larger group than anyone else.
This is intersecting terrain.
13Tell him:
Officers and men may sit and weep until their lapels are wet.
When they stand up, tears may stream down their cheeks.
Put them in a position where they cannot run.
They will show the greatest courage under fire.
12To command and get the most out of proud people, you must study adversity.
People work together when they are in the same boat during a storm.
In this situation, one rescues the other just as the right hand helps the left.
This is like climbing high and being willing to kick away your ladder.
You must be able to lead your men deep into different surrounding territory.
And yet, you can discover the opportunity to win.
This verse sounds repetitive and
poetic, but notice that pattern of six.
16You must drive men like a flock of sheep. This relates to the unobstructed,
entangling, supporting, constricted,
You must drive them to march. barricaded, and spread-out field
You must drive them to attack. positions we discussed earlier. Could
it be that each line says something
You must never let them know where you are headed. important about managing people on
these terrains? There is also a con-
You must unite them into a great army. nection of the six field positions to the
You must then drive them against all opposition. nine terrains here, but it would require
more explanation than I can put in
This is the job of a true commander. these side notes.
25Make your men feel like an army. Here is another list of the nine ter-
rains and how to use them. What is
Surround them and they will defend themselves. different here? How does this differ-
ence relate to the people with whom
If they cannot avoid it, they will fight. you are working? These situations
If they are under pressure, they will obey. are based on how interactions with
people change over time.
7 Do the right thing when you don’t know your different enemies’ plans.
Don’t attempt to meet them.
The Art of War 1 1 2
back again and again, year after year. As you move up through the levels of this Making Money by
speaking hierarchy, you may not be have the time to work lower levels, but you Speaking came
researching the
may still want to visit them to safely test new ideas. Jay Leno has one of the world’s most suc-
cessful trainers
positions in the world on the Tonight show, but he still works small clubs to try as part of our
new material and refine his skills in working with an audience. In this chapter, building our Sci-
ence of Strategy
we examine ten key steps in moving up the speaking ladder. These steps are: Institute live train-
ing network. You
1. Unaffiliated Organizations can find out more
2. Affiliated Organizations about joining
our network as a
3. Local Businesses and Other Organization trainer here.
4. Colleges and Other Educators
5. Local Conventions and Visitors Bureaus
6. Seminar and Event Promoters
7. Your Own Public Seminars
8. The Corporate Marketplace
Though not one of the key steps in building a speaking career, you also need
to know about two other very visible entities in the speakers universe, speakers
showcases, and speakers bureaus and agents.
1 1 3 Chapter 11: Types of Terrain
3You don’t know the position of mountain forests, dangerous obstructions, and reservoirs?
Then you cannot march the army. For Sun Tzu, alliances were a double
edged sword. There are times when
You don’t have local guides? they are needed but they also create
You won’t get any of the benefits of the terrain. a potential opening for opponents.
The basic approach is to only create
alliances when they are needed for
7There are many factors in war. a specific situation and not to get
entangled in them.
You may lack knowledge of any one of them.
If so, it is wrong to take a nation into war.
If you divide a big nation, it will be unable to put together a large force.
Increase your enemy’s fear of your ability.
Prevent his forces from getting together and organizing.
14Do the right thing and do not arrange outside alliances before their time.
If you fall behind, however, you can still turn defeat into victory.
1 1 5 Chapter 11: Types of Terrain
You must use the skills of war.
To survive, you must adapt yourself to your enemy’s purpose.
You must stay with him no matter where he goes.
It may take a thousand miles to kill the general.
If you correctly understand him, you can find the skill to do it.
Do it quickly.
Trample any border to pursue the enemy.
Use your judgment about when to fight.
The Art of War 1 16
12Doing the right thing at the start of war is like approaching a woman.
15You can tell the proper days by the stars in the night sky.
17 Every army must know how to adjust to the five possible attacks by fire.
Use many men to guard against them.
When you use fire to assist your attacks, you are clever.
Water can add force to an attack.
3
You can also use water to disrupt an enemy.
It does not, however, take his resources.
You must master the previous five approaches to using market desires.
You defend your customers by guarding them.
10As leader, you cannot let your anger interfere with the success of your forces.
As commander, you cannot let yourself become enraged before you go to battle.
Join the battle only when it is in your advantage to act.
If there is no advantage in joining a battle, stay put.
You must never let your emotions affect the success of a marketing campaign.
You must never go after a market simply because you want to humble the competition.
Go up against the competition only when it is profitable to do so.
If you cannot make money in competition, stay out of it.
20Your philosophy must be to keep the nation peaceful and the army intact.
You must move your troops to the right places to beat others.
You must accomplish your attack and escape unharmed.
This requires foreknowledge.
You can obtain foreknowledge.
You can’t get it from demons or spirits.
You can’t see it from professional experience.
You can’t check it with analysis.
You can only get it from other people.
You must always know the enemy’s situation.
5If you aren’t clever and wise, you can’t use spies.
10Spies are the first to hear information, so they must not spread information.
Spies who give your location or talk to others must be killed along with those to whom they have
talked.