Booksand Periodicals
Booksand Periodicals
Booksand Periodicals
for
the Study of
Smart and Resilient Cities
VISAHKAPATNAM TOWARDS SMART AND RESILIENT CITY,
by Dr. Rajendra Krishna Akula, Director, Centre for Cities Development and
Coordination India, 50-14-6/11/5, Seethammapeta, Visakhapatnam – 530 016.
www.ccdcindia.in; e-mail: ark62001@gmail.com;
Ph: +91 891 2701658; (M) +91 8885582589
The publication is only a research study meant for guidance to the academic and
urban development community for making the global cities, ‘ Smart and Resilient’.
by
Dr. Rajendra Krishna Akula
Preface
The concept of Smart Cities is gaining importance in the global context for the
past few years, and also in recent years in India, particularly after the Governments
identifying the need to build urban resilience in cities in view of the increasing global
warming and climate change, and consequential impacts of serious shocks and threats.
We are aware that we are solely responsible for creating this ecological imbalances
through various manmade creations of modern living, which have slowly changing the
global environment leading to a change in the ecological balance. Having experienced
serious risks of severe shocks and threats and consequential heavy loss of person and
property, we have realized our mistakes and started actions for rectifying our mistakes of
anti environmental deeds. At this stage, we are also aware that though we cannot regain
the original shape of God-gifted nature, we can at least start our peaceful living by
adopting such methods, which would adapt to the changed ecological imbalances and
trying to search for ways and means to regain the loss in the beautiful nature created by
the Almighty for our happy living.
The concept of ‘Urban Resilience’ is gaining momentum with the ecological
imbalances created by the mankind, resulting in various challenges of chronic stresses
and acute environmental shocks such as earthquakes, floods, disease outbreaks, terrorist
attacks, high unemployment, chronic food and water shortages, endemic violence and so
on. We have realized that these challenges can be tackled only through building and
enhancing the overall cities resilience systems to withstand, respond and adapt to these
shocks and stresses to emerge stronger of tough times, and leave better in good times, as
postulated by the “100 Resilience Cities” founded by Rockefeller foundation.
Having realized the urgent need to build and enhance the urban resilience by the
cities, which are vulnerable to acute shocks and stresses, the global leaders have
intensified their efforts through a common platform to contribute their share in making
the cities more resilient across the World. The pledge of commitment of controlling the
global warming through implementation of various climate change mitigation and
adaptation systems in global cities, is paving way for formulating sound environmental
policies by the developed and developing nations, particularly with reference to the rapid
urbanization in the developing countries in Asian and African sub-continents.
Incidentally, the Government of India introduced the concept of development of
smart cities, as part of its urban development policy, which strongly encourages the
concept of urban resilience in all the selected smart cities in India. The city of
Visakhapatnam, which has been selected for development as one of the smart cities by the
Government of India is striving to build the city resilience as part of its smart city
planning.
I have made a sincere attempt to explain through my present book titled -
“Visakhapatnam towards Smart and Resilient City”, as to how the beautiful city of
Visakhapatnam situated near the coastal belt of Bay of Bengal in India is building its
resilience for the past several years, and more so after experiencing the recent shock of
Hud Hud cyclone during the year 2014. I have tried to put all my efforts to provide as
much data as possible relating to the present study of important topics of urban
agglomeration, severe shock of Hud Hud cyclone, Smart City practices, Capacity
Building approach for community participation and Resilient City strategies of
Visakhapatnam. The book provides a case study of the city of Visakhapatnam, which I
feel, can be considered as a guiding tool, while framing ‘smart and resilient strategies’
by the global cities having similar vulnerable and urbanization conditions.
I acknowledge my sincere thanks to all the authorities of the Government of
India, Government of Andhra Pradesh and the local Government of Visakhapatnam, who
have extended their valuable support in bringing out this book, which I hope, would be of
a little use by the cities of homogenous in nature, in terms of urbanization, vulnerability
and smart and resilience building.
Chapter -2 provides a detailed description of occurrence of the severe
shock of the recent Hud Hud cyclone in the city of Visakhapatnam together with a
complete description of the cyclonic phenomena in the coast of Bay of Bengal, the
severity and the devastation created by the cyclone and the relief and rehabilitation
action taken by the State and the local Governments.
Chapter -3 tries to explain the smart city concepts introduced by the
Government of India and the steps taken by the local government in transforming the
city of Visakhapatnam as a smart city, besides the need for making space for
building urban resilience in the smart city development process in the context of
vulnerability of the city towards ecological shocks and threats. A brief statement of
smart and resilient city development approach in terms of the proposed projects is
also worked out for a proper understanding of the concept.
. Chapter -4 deals with the purpose, need, scope and objectives of
building urban resilience in the city of Visakhapatnam together with the ongoing
resilience practices in the city, and the projects that are under pipeline for enhancing
the city resilience. An attempt is made to bring out the important document of city
resilience strategy with the help of the ongoing projects and also the future projects
identified in the smart city development of Visakhapatnam.
Chapter -5 concludes with the role of community participation with
reference to capacity building approach implemented in the smart city development
process by the local Government of Visakhapatnam. This chapter explains as to how
the smart and resilient city practices can be implemented successfully through the
capacity building functional system as part of effective local urban governance. The
study concludes that there is a positive relation between resilience and climate
change, between resilience and global warming, between resilience and risk,
between resilience and between resilience and risk based on the behavioral
patterns of the human beings. The hypothesis that urban resilience and recovery
through human behavior has a positive impact on the well being of not only entire
mankind but also the entire living things on the earth.
***
1. URBAN AGGLOMERATION OF VISAKHAPATNAM
3
building yard and the only natural harbour on the east coast of India. Visakhapatnam
is considered as the financial capital of the State of Andhra Pradesh. Vizag is a
fast developing port city with a present population of around 2.00 million and with a
land area of 620 square kilometres. Visakhapatnam is the country’s one of the
largest port cities and the largest urban agglomeration in terms of land and
population in the State of Andhra Pradesh. On account of rapid industrialisation,
there has been significant migration into the city. The city was originally a small
fishing village and because of the existence of natural harbour, it developed into a
major port. It has experienced rapid industrialisation with the growth of major
industries, including steel, petroleum refining and fertiliser. With the formation of
“Greater Visakhapatnam” in the year 2005, and with the proposed status of ‘Smart
City’ by the Government of India, besides the technical support extended by the
Government of United States of America, the urban development of the city is set for
a quantum leap.
Visakhapatnam District
Visakhapatnam district is an
important industrial, commercial and
natural resource centre in the state. It
is the largest district in terms of urban
population in the reorganized State of
Andhra Pradesh. As per Census 2011,
Visakhapatnam district had a
population of 42.90 lakhs, which
accounts for 9% of the total state
population. The population of the
district has increased from 38.32 lakhs
in 2001 to 42.90 lakhs in 2011,
registering a decadal growth of 12%.
The share of urban population is about
47.5%, which is far higher than the state average of 29.6%. As indicated in the table
below, the urban population has increased from 15.31 lakhs in 2001 to 20.36 lakh in
2011 registering a growth rate of 33%.
4
Climatic Conditions of the District
The district has variations in climatic conditions in different parts. Near
Coast, air is moist and relaxing, but gets warmer moving towards interior and cools
down in the hilly areas on account of elevation and greenary. April to June are the
warmest months. The Temperature dropsdown with the onset of South West
Monsoon and tumbles to a mean minimum of 21.0oC by December / January after
which there is reversal trend till the temperature reaches mean maximum of 42oC by
the end of June.
Rainfall
• Visakhapatnam collects an average of 955 mm (37.6 in) of rainfall per
year, or 79.6 mm (3.1 in) per month.
• On average there are 65 days per year with more than 0.1 mm (0.004 in)
of rainfall (precipitation) or 5.4 days with a quantity of rain, sleet, snow etc.
per month.
• The driest weather is in December when an average of 4 mm (0.2 in) of
rainfall (precipitation) occurs.
• The wettest weather is in October when an average of 179 mm (7 in) of
rainfall (precipitation) occurs.
5
Wind Speed Details
Humidity 80 – 96%
Annual Average
0 0
Temperature 19 C - 38 C
Rain Fall
All
time 47.0 21.7
record
6
Physical Features of the District
The District presents two distinct Geographic divisions. The strip of the land
along the coast and the interior called the plains division and hilly area of the
Eastern Ghats flanking it on the North and West called the Agency Division. The
Agency Division consists of hilly regions covered by the Eastern Ghats with an
altitude of about 900 metres dotted by several peaks exceeding 1200 metres.
Sankaram Forest block topping with 1615 metres embraces the Mandals of Paderu,
G. Madugula, Pedabayalu, Munchingput, Hukumpeta, Dumbriguda, Araku Valley,
Ananthagiri, Chinthapalli, G.K. Veedhi, and Koyyuru erstwhile Paderu, Araku Valley
and Chinthapalli taluks in entirety. Machkhand River which on reflow becomes
Sileru, drains and waters the area in its flow and reflow and is tapped for Power
Generation. The other division is the plains division with altitude nowhere
exceeding 75 metres watered and drained by Sarada, Varaha and Thandava
Rivers and rivulets Meghadrigedda and Gambheeramgedda. Since no major
Irrigation system exists significant sub regional agronomic variations exist in this
division. Along side the shore lies a series of salt and sandy swamps. The coast line
is broken by a number of green hills of Eastern Ghats, the important of them being
the Dolphin's Nose which had afforded the establishment of Natural Harbour in
Visakhapatnam besides, Rushikonda Polavaram Rock and the big Narasimha hill
at Bheemunipatnam. Administratively, the District is divided into 3 Revenue
Divisions and 43 Mandals.
Soils
Red Loamy soils predominate with coverage of 69.9% of the villages of the
district. The Soils are poor textured and easily drained. Sandy loamy soils come
next with 19.2% villages coverage, largely confined to the coastal areas of
Nakkapalli, Payakaraopeta,S.Rayavaram, Rambilli, Atchutapuram, Paravada,
Visakhapatnam, Pedagantyada, Gajuwaka and Bheemunipatnam Mandals and to
certain stretches in the interior Mandals of Chodavaram, Narsipatnam, K.Kotapadu
and Madugula. Black cotton soils come up next having sizeable chunks of area in
K.Kotapadu, Devarapalli, Cheedikada, Paderu and Hukumpeta Mandals. 45% of
the soils in the district are low in organic content and 55% in Phosphorous content.
7
and the Integrated Tribals Development Agency to wean out tribal from the
pernicious practices of "Podu Cultivation.”
A rich Bio-diversity index exists in the Visakhapatnam in view of around 43%
of forest area throughout the district. Besides conservation of the social forestry in
the district, the Government maintains a natural Zoo in the city of Visakhapatnam,
which protects the bio-diversity in the city limits having a rich and larger forest area
of more than 44%.
8
Etymology and History
The name Visakhapatnam was
derived from the shrine of God Visakha, built
by a King of Andhra in 4th century. The
history of Visakhapatnam stretches back to
the 6th century B.C.E., and the city finds
mention in ancient texts, such as the 4th
century B.C.E. writings
of Pā ini and Katyayana. Historically
considered part of the Kalinga region, it was
ruled by the Vengi kingdom and
the Pallava and Eastern Ganga dynasties during medieval times. Archaeological
records suggest that the present city was built around the 11th and 12th centuries
C.E. by the Chola Dynasty king Kulothunga I.
Control over the city fluctuated between
the Chola Dynasty of Tamil Nadu and
the Gajapati Kingdom of Odisha until its
conquest by the Vijayanagara Empire in the
15th century. In the 16th century, it was
conquered by the Mughals. European powers
eventually set up trading interests in the city,
and Visakhapatnam came under French rule
at the end of the 18th century.
The city was ruled by Andhra Kings of Vengi and Pallavas. The city is named
after Sri Vishaka Varma, Legend has it that Radha and Viśakha were born on the
same day, and were equally beautiful. Sri Vishaka Sakhi, is the second most
important gopi of the eight main gopikas*. She carries
messages between Radha and Krishna, and is the
most expert gopi messenger. Local residents believe
that an Andhra king, built a temple to pay homage to
his family deity Viśakha. This is now inundated under
sea water near R K Beach. Another theory is that it is
named after a women disciple of Buddha
named Viśakha. Later it was ruled by Qutb
Shahis, Mughal Empire (between 1689–
1724), Nizam (1724–1757) and France (1757–1765)
before being captured by the British in 1765. European
powers eventually set up trading interests in the city,
and Visakhapatnam came under French rule at the end
of the 18th century. The British captured
Visakhapatnam after the 1804 Battle of Vizagapatam, and it remained under British
colonial rule until India's independence in 1947 which was a part of the Northern
Circars.
9
Location and Topography
Visakhapatnam is situated between the Eastern Ghats to its west and the Bay
of Bengal to its east, bordering on the north with the state
of Orissa and Vizianagaram district and East Godavari District to the south. The city
coordinates lies between 17.6883° N latitude, and 83.2186° E longitude. It's
periphery consists of plains along the coast line while the interiors boast of the
beautiful hills of the Eastern Ghats which surround it on the North and the West. This
region is also called the Agency Division. It occupies an area of approximately
11,161 km2.
Vizag is located on the east coast of India, in 17o42' North latitude and 82o02'
East range of hills. Based on topographical
conditions, the city and its environs can be
divided into four categories viz., Hilly region,
Upland tracks, Rolling plains and Plains. The
Kailasa and Yarada are the major hill ranges in
the city. The Kailasa hill range stretches from
Simhachalam to MVP Colony on the north flank
of the city. The city, which appears like a small
basin, is surrounded by the Yarada hill popularly
known as Dolphin’s nose (358m) on the side of the Kailasgiri hills on the north, with
the Bay of Bengal forming the eastern wall. The coastal line runs from north- east to
south west over a distance of six kilometres. On the west there is an extensive tidal
basin called ‘Upputeru’ now under reclamation. Beyond Yarada there is a valley
followed by another range of hills.
Visakhapatnam Today
Visakhapatnam is emerging as a ‘Smart City’ among the hundred Indian
cities selected by the Government of India, and one of the three important Indian
cities identified for support by
the Government of United
States of America for technical
support to develop as an
international smart city in the
Indian subcontinent. The city is
experiencing rapid growth of
urbanization during the past
two to three decades and the
trend is gaining further
momentum after the recent
reorganization of state of
Andhra Pradesh with the active support of Government of India on account of its
strategic importance.
Visakhapatnam is one of the fastest growing cities in Andhra Pradesh,
steadily with a current population of 18.69 Lakhs as per the manual of statistics of
the Visakhapatnam district, 2010-11 and projected to raise around 22.00 lakhs by
10
the end of the year 2022. After merger of the municipalities- Anakapalli and Bheemili
during the year, the total city area has been increased to 620 Sq. Km from 534
Sq.Km. As the city is blessed with a picturesque topography, it is one of the favourite
destinations of domestic and International tourism. Being a second largest port in
Country and a strategic location proposed PCPIR project will boost up the economic
growth of the city in upcoming years.
11
Demography, Economy and Land Use
Visakhapatnam, once a small fishing village, has evolved into a major port city
over the decades. It is also the administrative headquarters of the Visakhapatnam
district. The city is located at a distance of 386 kms from the proposed reorganised
State capital named Amaravathi.
The city is strategically located midway between two metropolitan cities in India,
Calcutta and Chennai. The total area of the city at present is 620 sq.km. It is well
connected by all modes of surface transport - East coast railway, national highway
No.5 and domestic air linkages. This strategic geographical location coupled with the
availability of the other associated factors in logistics has enabled the city to attract
large commercial investments and the major public and private sector industries. In
recent years, there has been a spurt in investments in the city and its surrounding
areas giving further impetus to transform the city as a future mega city.
Population trend of Visakhapatnam City
12
Sl. Area Population
Geographical unit
No. (Sq.kms) (in lakhs/millions)
Land Use
13
The growth rate of population experienced by VMC during 1991 and 2001 will
continue in future though at a lesser rate. The projections indicate that the Greater
Visakhapatnam City area would have a population of 16.61 lakhs in 2011 and 20.99
lakhs in 2021.
Population Projections
Area Total Population Density
Component (sq.km) (in lakhs) (Population /sq. km)
2001 2006 2001 2006 2011 2021 2001 2006 2011 2021
Municipal
111 540 9.69 14.5 16.61 20.99 8765 2685 3075 5537
Corporation
VUDA 1701 1701 22.02 26.21 30.58 34.99 1293 1540 1797 2057
Components of Growth
An analysis of composition of population growth indicates that natural growth
contributed about 70 percent while migration contributed 30 percent between the
years 1981-1991. However, the contribution of natural growth has come down
significantly in the years 1991-2001 to 47 percent, mainly due to jurisdictional
change. The contribution of migration has come down from 30 to 20 percent. This
indicates that the urban growth in GVMC will take place even if measures are taken
to control migration. Hence long term and strategic planning is necessary to promote
equitable economic growth and service delivery.
One of the key reasons for inadequate service delivery outcomes in the local
Government is the overlapping arrangements in functions, roles and responsibilities
of the institutions resulting in poor accountability. The absence of an effective
coordination mechanism, amongst city Government and other State, national and
international level agencies has implications for orderly spatial development,
coordinated infrastructure provision, local economic growth and development.
Keeping in view the urgent need to ensure spatial of this important city in the State,
the present State Government of newly reconstituted Andhra Pradesh is introducing
several reforms for improvement of efficiency levels in governance of local city,
provincial and state administrations and functional innovative institutional
arrangements for achieving better service outcomes.
The Smart City status attained by the city has more implications for
improvement of urban infrastructure facilities as per the norms defined by the
Government of India, and the local government and other administrative centres
such as education, traffic and transport, health and environment, water and
electricity are the key areas for development with active involvement of local
administrations of the city of Visakhapatnam. The local Government is actively
engaged in the preparation of tool kits for implementation of smart city facilities in the
urban environment.
14
Gender Ratio
The gender ratio in Visakhapatnam Municipal Corporation is 971 in 2001,
which is substantially higher than the gender ratio in the year 1991. However, the
ratio in 2001 is below the state average of 978.
Gender ratio
Gender
Year
Ratio
980 1951 978
Sex …
960
940 1961 920
920 1971 921
900
880
1981 925
1951 1971 1991 1991 939
2001 971
Literacy
Census figures for 1991 & 2001 for Visakhapatnam Municipal Corporation
and the rest of the state reveal that general literacy and female literacy have
improved. Visakhapatnam Municipal Corporation leads in literacy in Andhra Pradesh,
with 76.60% in 2001. Male literacy in the agglomeration is approximately 83.46%,
while female literacy is considerably lower at 69.59%.
Literacy Rate
Percentage of Literates
Year
Male Female Total
1971 61.59 39.77 51.12
1981 65.57 45.65 55.96
1991 71.99 57.56 65.00
2001 83.46 69.59 76.60
2011 85.22 73.39 79.30
Source: Census 2011
15
Emerging Issues and Concerns
Visakhapatnam has experienced high growth in population and the same
trend is expected to continue over the next two decades. It is projected that by 2021
Visakhapatnam would emerge as one of the major cities in the country. Most of this
growth would take place in Greater Visakhapatnam area in view of the increasing
trend of urban agglomeration. However, this has serious implications for service
delivery both for city core as well as peripheral areas since the traffic and population
flows occur between them. This calls for integrated planning of the Greater
Visakhapatnam with a focus on equitable provision of services to all the areas and all
the sections of the population, which is the impetus of the proposed smart city status.
Occupational Structure
According to 2001 census, the work force in Visakhapatnam city is about
3,44,729 of which maximum proportion of workers is found to be in tertiary services
which includes services and trade and commerce. The services sector is the largest
sector contributing 30 percent of the workforce while a significant and equal
proportion of workers are found in three sectors viz. trade and commerce,
manufacturing and transport and communications with 13 percent each. A significant
feature of the occupational structure is that the work force in primary sector
constitutes nearly 20 percent of the total workforce. This significant presence is due
to the merging of nearby villages and fishing related activities.
Port&&
Port
Industries
Industries
Education Education
Support
Infrastructure
VIZAG
IT/ITS
IT/ITS Tourism
Tourism
R&D
16
Economic Base Occupational Distribution
No. of
Occupation category workers % of total
(lakh)
Primary sector 69,792 20.24
Household industry 13,943 4.04
Manufacturing 46,137 13.38
Electricity, gas and water 3,829 1.11
supply
Construction 20,289 5.88
Transport, storage and 43,847 12.71
communication
Banking insurance 720 0.20
Trade and business 44,588 12.93
Services 1,01,584 29.46
Total 3,44,729
Source: Annual Report, The Hindu, 2005
ECONOMY
The city is experiencing tremendous
economic growth. The sectors contributing to
city’s economic growth are agriculture and
fishing (primary sector), large, medium and
small scale industries (secondary sector) and
services (tertiary sector) that include trade and
commerce, transport, telecommunication
management and consultancy services,
education, etc. It has experienced rapid
industrialization with the onset of major
industries viz., Oil Refinery -- a private sector
fertilizer factory, Hindustan Zinc Smelter and
Visakhapatnam Steel Plant. The construction
of the outer harbour and Steel Plant has
considerably changed the character of the city.
On account of rapid industrialization, there has been tremendous amount of
migration into the city.
The economic impetus in Visakhapatnam over the past three decades has
provided numerous employment opportunities, which are clearly visible in the
population growth rates for the past three decades. The demographic trends of
growth essentially follow the geographical expansions, which were the result of
various developmental initiatives in the infrastructure and on the industrial front.
During the first quarter of the century', a very slow increase is recorded as there was
no major event except the opening of the East Coast Railway line. During the second
quarter of the century, a steady rise is recorded till Independence was observed, with
the establishment of major institutions under public sector. A significant growth of the
17
city after partition, which lasted during the third quarter of the century, is due to the
development of port activities and industrialization. The policies of the present
Government towards growth of industry, commerce and trade with public private
participation are giving boost to new investors who are willing to invest in Andhra
Pradesh. Visakhapatnam is becoming a city of great opportunities for trade
commerce, and industry in all the areas of manufacturing, information technology
and tourism, etc.
The City having an investment of Rs. 20,000 Crores, is the industrial capital of
the State. The City is recognised as the fifth-fastest growing "Industrial Metropolis" in
the Asian subcontinent and the fastest growing industrial city on the East coast of
India strategically located midway between Calcutta and Chennai. The areas of
economic growth are indicated the geographical advantage with a natural harbour
and bountiful infrastructural facilities helped the city acquire industrial importance
and well known place in the international market. The ideal industrial climate has led
to the development of core industries. Rich deposits of iron and aluminium ores in
close proximity and good rail and road connectivity and Export oriented Zones and
EXIM parks present interesting possibilities for setting up major industries.
The basic requirements which are necessary for establishing an industry are
the power supply, raw materials, transportation facilities etc are available in
Visakhapatnam and very large plants have come to be established in the city. The
industries under public sectors such as Hindustan Ship Yard, Bharat Heavy
Electricals, Vizag Steel Plant, Visakhapatnam Port Trust, etc., are providing potential
employment opportunity for nearly one lakh workers, and there is a further increase
in the employment potential to the extent of two Lakhs persons with formulation of
new trade policies of the present Government.
With its long coast line, fishing, travel and tourism are major economic
activities of Visakhapatnam. There are handful opportunities for development of
brackish water, prawn culture, pisci culture since this is an export oriented and a lot
of investment can be poured into it.
The state as well the city government have made concerted efforts to make
Visakhapatnam the second economic development hub in the areas of Information
Technology Enabled Services, Pharma and Biotechnology, development of
Consumer goods and Ancillary industries including tourism. Significant efforts in this
direction include some of the recent projects supported by the Corporation which
include Up-gradation of the local Airport, setting up of VSEZ, Simhadri Power Plant,
Special Economic Zone, Pharma City at Parawada, Gangavaram Port, Gems and
Jewellery Park and Apparel Export Park amongst other Projects. There is a
possibility of a few more manufacturing units being located in the close proximity to
the City.
18
The transport infrastructure has permitted industrial investment and growth in
the region. In addition to the international and national linkages, the local
government has undertaken several initiatives to upgrade the municipal roads and
public utilities and amenities to international standards.
Industrial Activities
The industrial activities are one of the prime economic activities of the city.
The total number of industrial units in the city stood at 1,775. The total investment of
this sector is about Rs. 8,021.77 crores, of which about 8,005.32 crores (99.79 per
cent) is in large and medium-scale industries alone and the rest is in small-scale
industries. The total work force engaged in industrial activities is about 44,275
persons, of which 30,110 per sons (68.01 per cent) are found in large and medium-
scale industries and the rest in small-scale industries. Among the 55 large and
medium manufacturing industries, 8 units are in the public sector, 42 in the private
sector and 5 in the cooperative sector. Public sector dominates in investment and
employment accounting for 85% of the investment and 68% of employment. Major
public sector undertakings like Visakhapatnam Steel Plant, National Thermal Power
Corporation, Hindustan Petroleum Corporation, Hindustan Zinc, Hindustan Shipyard,
Bharat Heavy Plates and Vessels are located in and around the city. Other projects
in the city periphery are Divi Pharmaceuticals, Thermal Power project of NTPC,
Cement plants, Ancillaries of Visakhapatnam Steel Plant, Jindal Petrochemicals and
Marine based industries. There are 23 medium to major ones in the pipeline. These
basic Industries themselves have played a decisive role in facilitating the expansion
of the private sector industries such as Coramandal Fertilizers, LG Polymers India
Pvt. Ltd, Essar Iron Ore Pelletisation Plant, East India Petroleum Limited and Rain
Calcining Limited in recent years.
The minor industries include manufacturing units of rubber and plastics, coal
products, gas and steam units, automobile workshops, beverages, ship breaking
units, export processing zone, fishing trawlers, communications, aqua culture units,
airport, port conveyer belt across the city and a host of rail lines connecting the
industries for wagon movement. Around 100,000 workers live in the proximity of the
industrial units.
The city has one of the oldest industrial estates in the state providing sites
and services for establishment of small and medium scale industries. In tune with
time, APIIC has developed an Industrial Area of about 1200 acres in five Blocks in
Visakhapatnam. While blocks A, B, C & D have been fully developed.
19
Visakhapatnam Port
The Port has a natural harbour and is one of the major ports on the East
Coast of India. It is situated at the
mouth of the stream Meghadrigedda,
at the confluence point at 17o 41’34” N
latitude and 83o 17’-15” E longitude.
The harbour is protected by “Dolphin’s
nose” projecting into the sea and
having low tidal range with a maximum
of 1.83 mts, offers safe shelter to ships.
The Visakhapatnam Port was opened to
ocean going ships in October 1933.
The Visakhapatnam outer harbour is India’s deepest harbour and can
accommodate bulk carriers of 1.00
lakh DWT and more ships drawing up
to 15.3 mts. and having a length up to
263 mts. can be accommodated at
the outer harbour ore berths. The
Visakhapatnam inner harbour has an
entrance channel, a turning basin and
3 navigable areas known as the
Northern arm, North western arm and
Western arm. The construction of the
harbour was taken up in 1723 and three arms formed by 1933. It has earned
recognition for being one to the top ports for the export of marine products in India.
The volume of seafood exports through Visakhapatnam Port has increased to
26, 637 tone in 2001–02, according to the figures compiled by the Marine products
Exports Development Authority (MPEDA). Among the significant developments in
the port – the Fertilizer berth in the westerns arm of inner harbour, operated by the
Coromondal Fertilizer Ltd has come up for modernization by installing a new ship
unloaded for achieving higher productivity. Other large user groups include
Visakhapatnam Steel Plant (VSP), Steel Authority of India Limited (SAIL), National
Thermal Power Corporation (NTPC), and Export Processing Zone etc.
The statistics indicate that all the major ports of the country handled 281
million tonnes of various cargoes while Visakhapatnam port handled cargoes, which
is 16 percent of the all India quantum. The VPT has two harbours i.e. inner harbour
and outer harbour. It also has Naval Dockyard, Shipyard and submarine yard. At
Visakhapatnam Port, ships from more than 50 countries come every year with 321
days berth occupancy. The Port is obsessed by the dense urban development and
industrial development around. The employment in the port is around Seven
thousand.
20
Gangavaram Port
The State Government is
establishing the new deepwater grass
root port at Gangavaram adjoining the
Steel Plant under Private Public
Partnership and with the
establishment of this port; GVMC
would have two major ports
functioning under its jurisdiction. It is
situated at a distance of 15 km south
of Visakhapatnam Port. Investment planned for the port is around Rs 20,000 million
(US $400m). Construction of the first phase has been completed and the operations
have commenced.
Fishing
Fishing is one of the major
activities in the GVMC area. The
export value of the fishing products in
India is in crores of rupees, 70% of
which is from Andhra Pradesh and
major portion of this is from
Visakhapatnam. It is estimated that
around 6 lakh people of the state
depend on fishing activity of which
one fourth are in Visakhapatnam. According to an estimate, about 50 families directly
or indirectly make their livelihood on each boat that goes for fishing. There are 118
primary fishermen cooperative societies. There were 2800 mechanised boats in the
city. The Visakhapatnam coast is always a hub of fishing activity. A fishing harbour
exists to facilitate marine fishing. There are 22 fish / prawn processing units in and
around the City. These plants have
cold storage capacity ranging from 5
tonnes to 400 tones. The fishing
harbour is likely to be relocated to
Bheemunipatnam for further spatial
expansion of the Port.
A new fish-landing infrastructure
was established at Yarada essentially
to meet the requirements of fishermen
from Dibbalapalem and Gangavaram who have to shift their fishing activities due to
the establishment of the new grass root port of Gangavaram.
21
Commercial Activities
Owing to a high degree of industrial concentration, the complementary sectors
such as commercial, institutional and services sectors have also developed rapidly.
The total number of commercial
establishments in the city is about
20,000 units. The work force
engaged in this sector is about
40,000 persons. The major
categories of commercial
establishments are related to food
products (Hotels, Restaurants and
Parlours, Electronic and Consumer
Products, Construction Materials,
Hardware, Automobiles and
Personal Services. Besides this, the wholesale trading activities have also developed
substantially. The important commercial areas in the city are R.K.Beach Road,
Velampeta, Dabagardens, Suryabagh, Dwarakanagar and Gajuwaka. Similarly the
important market in the city is Poorna Market, Kurupam Market, and RTC. & TSR.
Complexes.
There is a notable shift of commercial business district (CBD) from the then
hub of the city (now old city) to multiple CBDs. The city expanded up to Poorna
Market, the only commercial centre for the entire city up to 1970s. After the
construction of Jagadamba Theatre, the city’s major activities moved towards north
and the commercial activity spread up to the so-called Jagadamba centre in 1970s.
Thereafter the city expanded further northwards after the construction of the RTC
Complex and the tallest LIC building in 1980’s. The entire Dabagardens has become
a hub of electronic goods trade. In 1990’s, the prestigious NH5 road project brought
the city shifts towards further to the north. With the proposed construction of IT
towers in the old TB hospital area, the city is destined to create a hub for IT activity.
The city has developed itself as a cluster of differentiated zones which could
be broadly categorized as follows:
Area Activity
Port area Fishing
Waltair upland Educational
Jagadamba Commercial and Shopping
Dwarakanagar Commercial and Shopping
Beach road Recreation, tourism and Hotels
Gajuwaka Industrial zone
Simchalam Religious Centre
Rushikonda IT Zone
Madhurawada Upcoming Residential Zone
Bhogapuram Proposed International Airport
22
Tourism
Vizag, sandwiched between the promontory called Dolphin’s nose and the
Kailashgiri Hills, is one sea together and that makes for a spectacular view from
even within the city. The beaches of Vizag Rama Krishna, Lawson’s Bay, Rishikonda
and Gangavaram are beautiful beaches of India.
The Simhachalam temple which is
located on the hills of Simhachalam is a 11th
Century temple dedicated to Lord Narasimha,
and Vizag is well endowed with excellent
hotels and restaurants to accommodate
national and international tourists. Recently,
many Buddhist ruins have been discovered in
and around Vizag. A more fascinating site to
visit is the village of Sankaram, where
numerous images of Buddha are seen carved in caves of the hills. Vizag is home to
the Eastern Fleet of the Indian Navy and the Naval presence has cast its influence
over the city. Overlooking the port in all its majesty is the 358 meters high
promontory of Dolphin’s Nose so called because of its uncanny resemblance to the
mammal. The lighthouse atop, which can be
visited with permission, is the highest in
India. Its beams can be seen far out at the
sea and it directs the traffic in the busy
shipping lanes of the Bay of Bengal as well
as the entrance to Vizag port.
Tourism is one of the emerging areas
in the city in terms of attracting national and
international tourists and bringing in foreign currency as well. The sector also
contributes to the increasing employment opportunities. Marketing of local products,
Hospitality and transport services, etc. are some of the areas of employment
generation in connection with tourism. Some
tourist attractions in the city are given in
annexure.
As the area around the city has vast
potential for development of tourism, various
places of historical and religious importance
in the region have been taken into
consideration to prepare a new theme based
initiative for the development of Tourism and
Recreation. It is proposed to develop the following dedicated tourism transits in this
direction. The transits are the following.
23
• Buddhism transit covering various Buddhist sites area in Visakhapatnam.
• Religious transit covering famous religious locations.
• Coastal recreational transit along the coast inclusive of development of
marinas
• Historical and heritage transit covering places of interest.
• Eco transits cover areas like Marsh lands an mangroves,, Zoological parks,
Reserve Forests and the Eastern Ghats and marine faunal occurrences
Surrounded by virgin beaches the city offers immense potential for the hospitality
industry.
Archaeological and historical
monuments play a major role in
enhancing the tourist’s experience of the
City\ region. Since Archaeological
preservation and the development of
tourism are not mutually exclusive
process, there is a strong case for the
Department of Tourism facilitating
preservation and protection of
monuments that have not yet been
taken up by the Archaeological Survey
of India or by the Archaeological
Department of the State. Towards this
end, initiatives taken during the current
year are noteworthy. Driven by the spirit
of “think globally but act locally”, the
local Government, in association with
the Andhra Pradesh Tourism
Department has taken up collaborative
venture for preservation and
enhancement of the common
inheritance.
Visakhapatnam possesses great
potential for tourism development which
is still untapped. It has Eastern Ghats on
one side and the blue waters of Bay of
Bengal on the other, giving the city a
magical touch. Visakhapatnam is
endowed with several rich and natural
tourist spots. Beautiful beaches,
mountains, forests, water bodies,
temples, heritage and Buddhist sites
adorn the region. However, not being a Capital City, the visibility of Vishakhapatnam
24
at International level has been low. This can be catalyzed by promoting tourism in
the region.
The tourist inflow in Vizag has witnessed an impressive growth during last 6
years from 31.75 lakh in 2008 to 67.58 lakh in 2013 registering a CAGR of about
16.3%. However, this increase is mainly attributed to the growth of domestic tourists
(from 31.5 lakh in 2008 to 67.0 lakh in 2013) which comprises more than 99% of the
total tourist arrivals in the district. Though the number of foreign tourists during 2008-
2013 has also increased, yet the number is very low in comparison to other cities
with similar potential and characteristic.
80.00 0.70
No. of Domestic Tourists (in lakh)
No. of Foreign Tourists (in lakh)
70.00 67.01 0.57
0.60
0.54
60.00
52.49 52.73 0.50
50.00 48.40
40.02 0.40
40.00
31.46 0.29
0.30 0.26
30.00 0.22
0.20 0.18
20.00
10.00 0.10
0.00 0.00
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
Year Year
No. of Domestic Tourist Arrivals in Vizag No. of Foreign Tourist Arrivals in Vizag
The various administrative departments in Vishakhapatnam like VUDA,
GVMC, forest etc have taken initiatives to develop tourism in Vizag; however there is
no major project undertaken which could have a large impact on tourism
development in and around the city. One of the main reason hindering the tourism
growth is the stringent CRZ regulations.
IL&FS IDC which was appointed by Ministry of Tourism as national level
consultant for preparing an action plan had identified 4 circuits in Andhra Pradesh
among which the Vishakhapatnam circuit (Vizag – Araku - Vizianagaram –
Srikakulam - East & West
Godavari) was identified as the priority
circuit. The strategy to develop this ARAKU, BORRA SRIKAKULAM
circuit includes:
VIZIANAGARAM
25
• Aquamarine Park - Bheemli
• Arogyadham (Health City) - Madhurawada
• Science and Entertainment Center - Kapuluppada
• Adventure Sports – Rushikonda
• Night Safari – Kambalkonda
• Day Safari – Eco Tourism center
• Beach Front Development – at Yerada & from R K Beach to Bheemli
• Multi Theme Park – Yerada
• Observatory Tower – Near Bheemli
• Bus service connecting major Temples & Tourist spots in and around Vizag
• Botanical Gardens
Arogyadham - Madhurawada
Tourism Park - Madhurawada
Adventure Sports - Rushikonda
Beach Development
26
To Madhurawada
KOLKATA
VISAKHAPATNAM
IT Park
Access/Approach to Baymount Gated
Project Site Community
Vizag Cricket PROJECT SITE – To Bheemili
Stadium 290 Ac
CHENNAI
Visakhapatnam SEZ
The Government of India actively
encourages the setting up of Special
Economic Zones (SEZ). These are
specially delineated duty free enclaves for
the purpose of trade and commerce, with
a liberal tax, fiscal and administrative
regime. The SEZ concept is designed to
enable its resident units to maximize their
production efficiencies through relaxed
policy framework and world-class
infrastructure. The Government has committed itself to the success of these zones
and has come up with attractive benefits for all stakeholders in these SEZ’s. These
include developers, operators, entrepreneurs and residents.
27
VSEZ is located at a distance of 24 kms from the city and 15kms from the Airport.
The broad gauge railway line from Calcutta to Madras passes by the side of the
Zone and the National Highway-5 is
at a distance of 2.6 kms from the
zone. The National Highway is
connected to the Zone. The
Visakhapatnam Port is located at a
distance of 17kms from the Zone.
The Zone is being developed in a
phased manner and accordingly
development of the first phase was
taken up. An extent of 163 acres of land has been taken up for development of
infrastructure and other facilities in the first phase.
EXIM Park
Visakhapatnam Port Trust has established an EXIM Park in 750 acres of land
for the allotment of Port based industries with an objective to promote
industrialization of the hinterland and to facilitate handling of export / import cargoes
of various industries at this Port, and to attract more cargo. The location of the Port’s
EXIM Park has been chosen in the existing industrial belt. The EXIM Park area is
connected to National Highway linking AP with Orissa, West Bengal, Madhya
Pradesh and Tamilnadu. The EXIM Park is situated 4 kms away from the Airport, 8
kms from the railway station and it is adjacent to the Northern arm, which is the main
commercial arm of the Port. The close proximity of the EXIM Park to the Port’s
waterfront area enables the entrepreneurs to have greater operational flexibility and
to reduce transport costs.
The Port’s EXIM Park provides plots to various port based industries
depending upon their requirements. Each industry will be allotted an area of not less
than 10 acres of land. A minimum cargo throughout by way of export / import is to
be guaranteed for handling at this port. GVMC (Visakhapatnam Municipal
Corporation) provides one million gallons per day of water to cater to the needs of
the Port based industries at EXIM Park. The development of Open Stacking areas,
Storage Sheds and Warehouses is also being taken up. The Port developed 20
railway lines for the “Mindi Interchange Yard” and 20 lines for the Sorting Yard with 5
sick lines for servicing and maintenance of locos and a comprehensive railway
network to serve the proposed Open Stacking Area and Storage sheds.
28
Petroleum Corridor Project (VK-PCPIR)
Visakhapatnam-Kakinada Petroleum, Chemical and Petrochemical
Investment Region (VK-PCPIR) is one of the six PCPIRs planned to be promoted in
India. VK-PCPIR is seen to be a catalyst, to position Andhra Pradesh and more
particularly Visakhapatnam as having the largest petrochemical hub of India. VK-
PCPIR spreads over an area of 640 sq. km. across parts of 7 mandals of
Visakhapatnam District and 3 mandals of East Godavari District.
The VK-PCPIR is expected to generate about 1.2 million jobs and a projected
investment of Rs. 34,30,00 crores. The VK-PCPIR region, which has already been
notified will further encourage leap and bound developments in the Visakhapatnam
industrial sector.
Though the draft master plan of VK-PCPIR proposes to have non- processing
area which shall include residential, commercial and other social infrastructure, yet
majority of this support infrastructure needs to be catered by Vizag especially the
skilled manpower requirement.
Information Technology
Information Technology Enabled
Services (IT / ITES) in the pre-
reorganised State of Andhra Pradesh is
the second most affordable place for IT
after in the South Asia sub-continent.
The recent reorganisation of the state of
Andhra Pradesh after separation of
Telangana State, the presence of
reputed national and international IT
companies are planning to commence their activities in the reorganised State of
29
Andhra Pradesh with the active support of the present Government of Andhra
Pradesh through various attractive incentives. The Andhra Pradesh industrial
infrastructure Corporation identified Rushikonda as a special IT zone in
Visakhapatnam, and the ‘start-up’ activities have gained momentum.
The need and prospect for development of IT/ITES sector in Vizag can be
attributed to following factors:
• Use of information technology is imperative for existing industries as well as
anticipated industries in the VK-PCPIR.
• Given the high pollution level in the city due to existing industrial area and with
the development of proposed VK-PCPIR, the level of pollution in the city is
bound to rise. Thus, in order to boost the economy other non-polluting sectors
need to be promoted.
• Vizag has good connectivity with sea, air, rail and road transport systems.
Besides the existing local international Airport, a larger size of International
Airport is under way of commencing its construction activity.
• The cost advantage of tier-two cities should be exploited to promote IT
exports
• The beautiful scenic surrounding and moderate temperature further boost the
prospect for development of this sector.
For over a decade, Vizag has been home to IT sector in this region with the
development of IT SEZ at Rushikonda and Madhurawada area which lies in the
north-east portion of GVMC. Despite its initial growth, the city has got stuck in the
middle of IT development following the global recession in 2008 and some other
reasons. The city has not witnessed any multinational company setting up its unit
here and nearly 75% of the 4 lakh sft built-up area developed by the IT firms at
Rushikonda IT SEZ is lying unutilized. Though Tech Mahindra and Wipro have
started operations, they are running only support systems but not full-fledged
software development operations.
Presently, it is estimated that the city has 102 small and medium software
companies as well as BPOs. With a handful of IT companies in the city, IT industry
registered an impressive growth
in financial year 2012–13.
Visakhapatnam IT/ITeS revenue
rose by 20% to Rs 1,445 crore in
2012–13 as against Rs 1,200
crore in 2011–12. The
employment generated by the
IT/ITeS industry of the city has
also increased to 16,988 jobs
during the same period.
Proposed IT/ITES
Development: A proposal for creation of Information Technology Investment Region
(ITIR) in Visakhapatnam Metropolitan area comprising of IT/ITES/Electronic
Hardware Clusters in an area of 10,995 acres (44.50 sq km) is under active
consideration. The proposal proposed to create external and internal infrastructure in
the ITIR areas with an estimated cost of Rs 19,706 crore and Rs 5,504 crore
respectively and seek financial assistance from the Central government.
30
The Vizag ITIR will be implemented over a period of next 25 years in two
phases and after commissioning, it is expected to provide direct employment to 4.28
lakh people and indirect employment to another 17.11 lakh people. The investment
expected is 45,005 crore and revenues expected are 37,353 crore, when it fully
commences its operations by 2038.
Transportation
Significant improvement is required in both mass and private transportation. In
mass transportation, at present only 28 % population is using public transport in the
city which is proposed to be increased up to 60% with the active launching of Metro
Corridors in the city. A spurt in the usage of Air travel by the citizens of
Visakhapatnam and also the increased usage of public transportation system
indicate the improved environmental sustainability awareness.
Some of the large and mega enterprises include Hindustan Shipyard Ltd,
Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd (HPCL), Rastiya Ispat Nigam Ltd (RINL),
NTPC, Bharat Heavy Plate & Vessels Ltd, National Mineral Development
Corporation Ltd, Ferro Scrap Nigam Ltd, Divis Laboratories Ltd, Sai Pharmaceuticals
(India) Pvt Ltd, Essar Steel India Ltd, Rain CII Carbon (Vizag) Ltd, Coromandel
Fertilisers Ltd, LVS Power Ltd etc.
Other than large and mega enterprises, Vizag has about 6430 operational
Micro, Small & Medium scale Industries with a cumulative investment of Rs. 3340
crores and employing 75047 persons.
No. of Investment
Type Employment
Industries (in Crore)
Large & Mega Industries 89 54347 56636
Micro, Small and Medium 6430 3340 75047
Total 6519 57687 131683
31
Further, about 2570 units are under implementation among which 48 are large
and mega enterprises and the expected cumulative investment is approximately
Rs. 43440 crores. These new establishments are anticipated to generate about
48745 additional jobs in and around Vizag.
The following steps are required to further promote IT / ITEs in Vizag:
• Infrastructure at existing IT SEZs at Rushikonda and Gambheeram should be
improved.
• Speedy implementation of Information Technology Investment Region (ITIR)
in Visakhapatnam Metropolitan area.
• Improvement of skill bank and overall infrastructure in Vizag and so as to
promote bigger corporate companies to make a mark in the city.
• Setting up of International Convention Centre in Vizag will give a boost to the
IT industry.
• International Airport needs to be upgraded.
• High density satellite towns with mixed land use and modern infrastructure
need to be developed around Vizag.
• Total underground cabelling in the power distribution and other
communication net work systems.
32
tracking the development of above mentioned proposed institutes, the other
institutes can also be developed in the city especially to cater the tourism potential
and providing semi skilled / skilled workers to the industries and other
establishments:
33
Low Carbon Mobility Strategies
• Cycling Tracks
• Cycling Zones
• Cycling Clubs
• BRTS transportation through SPVs
• Hawkers Zones
• Cycling Tracks In Visakhapatnam
• LCMP Initiatives
• LED street lighting
• Municipal Street Lighting Project
• Municipal Water Supply Project
• Building EE
• Proposed energy equipment like automatic timers, sensors of energy now
consumed in GVMC
• Replacement of LED street lighting in place of sodium vapour lighting.
• Residential EE Project
• Renewable Energy
• Climate change adaptation strategies
• climate mitigation strategies
• Vizag City Sustainability Review Project
A detailed description of Vizag Smart City practices and proposed projects are
discussed in the concluding sections of the book with regard to vision document of
aspirations of this mega city after experiencing the huge threat of Hud Hud cyclone.
***
34
2. THE IMPACT OF HUD-HUD CYCLONE
35
also been discussed at length. The satellite reports of the pre and post signals of
Hud Hud cyclone have been depicted for proper understanding the severity of the
cyclone for the purpose of preparedness and timely action of the Government.
A detailed description of the quantum of devastation created by the severe
Hud Hud cyclone in the three coastal districts particularly the city of
Visakhapatnam, obtaining data and on-site pictures from various Government
departments, besides the extent of relief operations provided by the Government of
Andhra Pradesh, under the leadership of the Hon’ble Chief Minister, during pre and
post Hud Hud cyclone in the affected areas. The rehabilitation process and the
immediate recovery in terms of quantum of material and human loss of account of
the devastation have been explained at length providing data obtained from the
departments.
The deadly tropical cyclone, Hud Hud caused extensive devastation in the
North Coastal districts of Visakhapatnam, Vizianagaram and Srikakulam in the
State of Andhra Pradesh in India. The wind speed was more than 200kmph for a
few seconds, when it crossed the coast in the heart of the City of Visakhapatnam
on 14th October, 2014. The severe cyclone “Hud Hud” with high speed of winds and
gales created a havoc in the three districts, Visakhapatnam in particular, turned the
proposed Smart City to a situation of collapsed “after war field” leaving ‘nothing’ for
the people to lead their livelihood. The physical damage of the entire public and
private property was colossal. However, the human loss could be minimized with
the precautionary measures taken by the authorities of the State. Thanks to the
‘forecasting technology’ created by the mankind.
The present section deals with the severity of the Hud Hud cyclone that hit
Vizag coast on 12th October, 2014. The Indian Meteorology Department(IMD)in
Visakhapatnam continuously released the cyclone reports from the on setting of the
calamity from 6th October onwards for preparatory action plan of the State and local
Governments. Before the severity of the cyclone with reference to the IMD is
discussed, a brief description of the meaning, definition and classification of
cyclones has been provided for a more understanding regarding the present
Hudhud cyclone.
36
The largest low-pressure systems are cold-core polar cyclones and extra
tropical cyclones which lie on the synoptic scale. According to the National
Hurricane Center glossary, warm-core cyclones such as tropical
cyclones and subtropical cyclones also lie within the synoptic
scale. Mesocyclones, tornadoes and dust devils lie within the smaller mesoscale.
Upper level cyclones can exist without the presence of a surface low, and can pinch
off from the base of the Tropical Upper Tropospheric trough during the summer
months in the Northern Hemisphere. Cyclones have also been seen on
extraterrestrial planets, such as Mars and Neptune. Cyclo genesis describes the
process of cyclone formation and intensification. Extra-tropical cyclones form as
waves in large regions of enhanced mid-latitude temperature contrasts called baro-
clinic zones. These zones contract to form weather fronts as the cyclonic circulation
closes and intensifies. Later in their life cycle, cyclones occlude as cold core
systems. A cyclone's track is guided over the course of its 2 to 6 day life cycle by
the steering flow of the cancer or subtropical jet stream.
Weather fronts separate two masses of air of different densities and are
associated with the most prominent meteorological phenomena. Air masses
separated by a front may differ in temperature or humidity. Strong cold fronts
typically feature narrow bands of thunder storm sand severe weather, and may on
occasion be preceded by squall lines or dry lines. They form west of the circulation
center and generally move from west to east. Warm fronts form east of the cyclone
center and are usually preceded by strati-form precipitation and fog. They
move pole ward ahead of the cyclone path. Occluded fronts form late in the cyclone
life cycle near the center of the cyclone and often wrap around the storm center.
38
Cyclone Phyan (2009) - Cyclonic Storm Phyan developed as a tropical
disturbance in the Arabian Sea to the southwest of Colombo in Sri Lanka on
November 4, 2009 and made landfall in south India on November 7. Joint Typhoon
Warning Center (JTWC) named this cyclonic Storm as Phyan. High Alert was
issued in states of Gujarat and Maharashtra as heavy rainfall of over 25 cm was
expected. Massive damage to property was reported in coastal districts of
Maharashtra, such as Ratnagiri, Raigad, Sindhudurg, Thane and Palghar.
Cyclone Jal (2010) - Jal was the fourth severe cyclonic storm of the year
2010. Jal is a Sanskrit word, meaning water.. Jal brought torrential rains over parts
of Thailand and Malaysia, triggering severe flooding and killing several people. In
Sri Lanka, heavy rainfall with strong winds of up to 110kmph caused flooding
affecting around 80,000 people. Storm warning were hoisted in Ganjam and
Jagatsinghpur districts of Orissa and over 70,000 people were evacuated from four
districts of Andhra Pradesh. Cyclone Jal killed at least 54 people in India alone.
About 300 thousand hectares of cropland was devastated by the cyclone. The
remnants of Jal continued to move northwest, they brought light to moderate spells
of rain in India's warmest state of Rajasthan and also in Gujarat.
Cyclone Laila (2010) - Severe cyclonic storm Laila was the first cyclonic
storm to affect southeast India since the 1990 Andhra Pradesh cyclone. Laila
developed on May 17, 2010 in the Bay of Bengal and made a landfall in Andhra
Pradesh on the 20th of May. Cyclone Laila caused major flooding and damage
along its path. Ongole in Andhra Pradesh recorded heavy rainfall of about 460 mm
in just two days. Another town Addanki received the highest rainfall of 522 mm,
followed by Maddipadu with 510 mm and Kothapatnam 258 mm in just 24 hours.
The state government faced a loss of over Rs 500 crore due to Cyclone Laila.
Cyclone Thane (2011) - Thane was the strongest tropical cyclone of 2011
within the North Indian Ocean. Thane became a Very severe cyclonic storm on
December 28, as it approached the Indian states of Tamil Nadu and Andhra
Pradesh and made landfall at north Tamil Nadu coast between Cuddalore and
Puducherry on December 30. Thane left at least 46 people dead in Tamil Nadu and
Puducherry. Cuddalore and Puducherry were the worst affected areas.
Cyclone Nilam (2012)- Cyclonic Storm Nilam was the deadliest tropical
cyclone to directly affect south India since Cyclone Jal in 2010. It made landfall
near Mahabalipuram on October 31 as a strong cyclonic storm with peak winds of
85 kmph. In Chennai's Marina Beach, strong winds pushed piles of sand ashore
and seawater reached nearly 100m inland. More than 3000 people were evacuated
around Mahabalipuram in the wake of the storm. While damages to property were
considerable, human casualties were very few, Nilam caused economic losses of
around Rs 100 crore because of torrential rain. As sea tides became high, a
'Danger 7' alarm was issued at the Chennai Port to minimize damage.
Cyclone Phailin (2013)–The recent in the list is Cyclone Phailin which is a
category 5 storm- the most powerful. It struck the Odisha and Andhra coast last
month causing massive destruction in the region- affecting 12 million people.
Phailin is a Thai word which means Sapphire. This cyclone prompted India's
biggest evacuation in 23 years with more than 5,50,000 people being moved from
the coastline in Odisha and Andhra Pradesh to safer shelters. Phailin brought very
heavy rain of over 600 mm at many stations of Odisha. It also damaged crops
39
worth Rs 2,400 crore and claimed over 40 lives. Loses due to Cyclone Phailin were
estimated to be around 696 million dollars or rupees 420crore.
While tropical cyclones can produce extremely powerful winds and
torrential rain, they are also able to produce high waves and damaging storm
surge. They develop over large bodies of warm water, and lose their strength if they
move over land. This is the reason coastal regions can receive significant damage
from a tropical cyclone, while inland regions are relatively safe from receiving
strong winds. Heavy rains, however, can produce significant flooding inland, and
storm surges can produce extensive coastal flooding up to 40 kilometres (25 mi)
from the coastline. Although their effects on human populations can be devastating,
tropical cyclones can also relieve drought conditions. They also carry heat and
energy away from the tropics and transport it towards temperate latitudes, which
make them an important part of the global atmospheric circulation mechanism. As a
result, tropical cyclones help to maintain equilibrium in the Earth's troposphere.
History of Tropical Cyclones in Bay of Bengal
40
Severe Cyclonic Storm with core North coastal
15 09-10 Nov 1995
of hurricane winds Andhrapradesh
Severe Cyclonic Storm with core East and West
16 05-07 Nov 1996
of hurricane winds Godavari districts
Severe Cyclonic Storm with core
17 28 Nov-07 Dec 1996 SCAP
of hurricane winds
Visakhapatnam, to
18 23–26 Sep 1997 Severe Cyclonic Storm
Srikakulam, A.P.
East Godavari to
19 13–15 Nov 1999 Very Severe Cyclonic Storm
Srikakulam, A.P.
20 15–18 Oct 1999 Very Severe Cyclonic Storm Srikakulam district
21 27-29 Nov 2000 Very Severe Cyclonic Storm CAP
22 11–16 Dec 2003 Severe Cyclonic Storm
23 17–20 May 2010 Severe Cyclonic Storm (Laila) Coastal, A.P.
Vulnerability
Vulnerability refers to the inability (of a system or a unit) to withstand the
effects of a hostile environment. In relation to hazards and disasters, vulnerability is
a concept that links the relationship that people have with their environment to
social forces and institutions and the cultural values that sustain and contest them.
“The concept of vulnerability expresses the multi-dimensionality of disasters by
focusing attention on the totality of relationships in a given social situation which
constitute a condition that, in combination with environmental forces, produces a
disaster”. It's also the extent to which changes could harm a system, or to which
the community can be affected by the impact of a hazard or exposed to the
possibility of being attacked or harmed, either physically or emotionally.
The city of Visakhapatnam is vulnerable to high temperatures during the
months of March to June and receives South-West monsoon rains from June to
August. However, the city experiences heavy rains due to low pressure,
depressions and cyclones in Bay of Bengal from October to December. Sensitivity
having identified and prepared the exposure profile of the city, a detailed
41
vulnerability assessment has been carried out through sensitivity analysis of the city
systems to the identified exposure levels. Sensitivity is the degree to which a
system or species is affected, either adversely or beneficially, by climate stressors.
The effect may be direct (for e.g., a change in crop yield in response to a change in
the mean, range, or variability of temperature) or indirect (for e.g., damages caused
by an increase in the frequency of coastal flooding due to sea-level rise). An
effective sensitivity analysis has been done in the project on climate adaptation
strategies by ICLEI South Asia during the period 2012-14. A detailed discussion on
‘vulnarability of Visakhapatnam is discussed in a separate section of the present
book.
MAXIMUM WINDS
DESCRIPTION WAVE
STATE EXPECTED
OF THE HEIGHT
OF SEA DAMAGE
SYSTEM mts.
KMPH KNOTS
LOW
NO SIGNIFICANT WIND
PRESSURE < 31 17 SLIGHT 0.5 - 1.25
DAMAGES
AREA
TREE BRANCHES
CYCLONIC BROKEN OFF SOME
63 - 88 34-47 HIGH 6-9
STORM (CS) DAMAGE TO KUTCHA
HOUSES
TREES UPROOTED,
SEVERE PUCCA HOUSES
VERY
CYCLONIC 89 - 117 48-63 9 - 14 DAMAGED,
HIGH
STORM (SCS) COMMUNICATIONS
DISRUPTED
42
BIG TREES
UPROOTED, WIDE
SPREAD DAMAGES TO
VERY SEVERE
PHENOME HOUSES AND
CYCLONIC 118 - 166 64-89 > 14
NAL INSTALLATIONS
STORM (VSCS)
TOTAL DISRUPTION
OF COMMUNICATIONS
EXTREMELY - DO -
SEVERE PHENOME
167-221 90-119
CYCLONIC NAL
STORM (ESCS)
SUPER 120
222 AND PHENOME
CYCLONIC AND - DO -
ABOVE NAL
STORM ABOVE
43
Hudud (Oman) and ones that will follow will be called Nilofar (Pakistan), Priya (Sri
Lanka) and Komen (Thailand).
‘HUDHUD’ was the strongest and most destructive tropical severe cyclonic
storm, in Bay of Bengal, that ever hit any Indian city. It originated from a low
pressure within the North Indian Ocean and was formed under the influence of an
upper-air cyclonic circulation in the Andaman Sea. It converted into Severe
Cyclonic Storm and land fall took place near Visakhapatnam on 12th October. The
wind speed reached its peak of 220 Km/h (as per the information from the Naval
Meteorology Department). Weather forecasters of Indian Meteorological
Department warned that heavy to very heavy rainfall would lash parts of six states
as the remnants of the cyclone moved further inland.
An alert was sounded in nine out of thirteen districts of Andhra Pradesh
where standing crops including paddy, groundnut, sugarcane, and pulses were yet
to be harvested. The storm was expected to attain its highest speed, of 195 kmph,
before landfall. And the north coastal districts of Andhra Pradesh were to be
affected the most; the centre being the district of Visakhapatnam.
The country's official weather forecaster - IMD — in its report on the Hudhud
highlighted the importance of the indigenous satellite data and explained how the
INSAT-3D could be helpful in upgrading various components of early warning
system of cyclones. The products of INSAT-3D satellite were fully utilized for the
first time with the development of new products like enhanced IR imageries and
coloured enhanced imageries and were made available through an exclusive page
for cyclone images in IMD website", said the 66-page report of the Cyclone
Warning Division of the weather forecaster.
The report further stated that all the existing high wind speed recorders were
made operational around the path of cyclone. The satellite, designed for enhanced
meteorological observations, also monitors land and ocean surfaces, and
generates vertical profile of the atmosphere in terms of temperature and humidity
for weather forecasting and disaster warning. It has seven years of mission life. The
report noted that the Hudhud was the first cyclone that crossed Visakhapatnam
coast in the month of October after 1985 and it made landfall on the same day of 12
October, 2013 as Phailin tropical cyclone in the State of Odisha. The cyclone had
developed from a low pressure area which lay over Tenasserim coast and adjoining
North Andaman Sea in the morning of October 6 and concentrated into a
depression in the morning of October 7. Moving west-northwestwards, it finally
crossed north Andhra Pradesh coast over Visakhapatnam between 12 noon and 1
PM on October 12 with the wind speed of 180 kilometer per hour. It finally
weakened into a well-marked low pressure area over east Uttar Pradesh and
neighbourhood on October 14 evening.
The 'Hudhud' could have been more disastrous had it not been the India's
space agency Isro's advanced weather satellite INSAT-3D on the job to give vital
input for accurate forecasting. The satellite, configured with improved imaging
44
system and atmospheric sounder, was launched from Kourou, French Guiana on
July 26 last year and made operational in January. The country's official weather
forecaster - IMD — in its report on the Hudhud highlighted the importance of the
indigenous satellite data and explained how the INSAT-3D could be helpful in
upgrading various components of early warning system of cyclones. "The products
of INSAT-3D satellite were fully utilized for the first time with the development of
new products like enhanced IR imageries and coloured enhanced imageries and
were made available through an exclusive page for cyclone images in IMD
website", said the 66-page report of the Cyclone Warning Division of the weather
forecaster. The report noted that the Hudhud was the first cyclone that crossed
Visakhapatnam coast in the month of October after 1985 and "it made landfall on
the same day as Phailin did in 2013". The details, extended by Andhra Pradesh
government to the Union ministry of earth science and Indian Meteorological
Department (IMD), also show that 2.37 lakh hectare of farm land having 22.14 lakh
tons of food-grains and standing cash crops and 6.89 tons of horticultural crops
suffered damage due to the very severe cyclone.
The report noted that total 4,484 villages of four districts were affected by the
cyclone that damaged 41,269 houses. Total 135,262 persons were evacuated by
the authorities to safer place after getting advance warning of the cyclone from the
IMD. The report also noted that the Hudhud damaged 455 buildings, including 317
primary and secondary schools, before finally crossing over the state. Similar
comprehensive report on Odisha, which also faced the wrath of the cyclone, is
awaited. The maximum damage was, however, reported from Andhra Pradesh. The
'Hudhud' could have been more disastrous had it not been the India's space
agency Isro's advanced weather satellite INSAT-3D on the job to give vital input for
accurate forecasting. The satellite, configured with improved imaging system and
atmospheric sounder, was launched from Kourou, French Guiana on July 26 last
year and made operational in January. The country's official weather forecaster -
IMD — in its report on the Hudhud highlighted the importance of the indigenous
satellite data and explained how the INSAT-3D could be helpful in upgrading
various components of early warning system of cyclones. "The products of INSAT-
3D satellite were fully utilized for the first time with the development of new
products like enhanced IR imageries and coloured enhanced imageries and were
made available through an exclusive page for cyclone images in IMD website.
Preparatory action of the State Government
BASED on the IMD reports, the following preparatory actions were initiated
by the State Government.
The Very Severe Cyclonic Storm ‘HUDHUD’ developed from a low pressure
area which lay over Tenasserim coast and adjoining North Andaman Sea in the
morning of 6th Oct. 2014. It concentrated into a Depression in the morning of the 7th
Oct. over the North Andaman Sea. Moving west-northwestwards it intensified into a
Cyclonic Storm (CS) in the morning of 8th Oct. and crossed Andaman Islands close
to Long Island between 0830 and 0930 hrs IST of 8th Oct.. It then emerged into
Southeast Bay of Bengal and continued to move west-north-westwards. It
45
intensified into a Severe Cyclonic Storm (SCS) in the morning of 09th Oct. and
further into a Very Severe Cyclonic Storm (VSCS) in the afternoon of 10th Oct.. It
continued to intensify while moving towards north-west and reached maximum
intensity in the early morning of 12th with a maximum sustained wind speed (MSW)
of 180 kmph over the West Central Bay of Bengal off Andhra Pradesh coast. It
crossed north Andhra Pradesh coast over Visakhapatnam (VSK) between 1200
and 1300 hrs IST of 12th Oct. with the same wind speed. After landfall, it continued
to move north-west wards for some time and weakened gradually into SCS in the
evening and further into a CS in the same midnight. It then, weakened further into a
Deep Depression in the early morning of 13th and weakened into a depression in
the evening of 13th. Thereafter, it moved nearly northward and weakened into a
well-marked low pressure area over East Uttar Pradesh and neighbourhood in the
evening of 14th Oct. 2014.
46
At the genesis stage, the system was monitored mainly with satellite
observations, supported by meteorological buoys and coastal and island
observations. As the system entered into the east central Bay of Bengal moving
away from Andaman & Nicobar Islands, it was mainly monitored by satellite
observations supported by buoys. From 11th Oct. early morning, as the system lay
within the range of the Doppler Weather Radar (DWR) at Visakhapatnam,
continuous monitoring by this radar started from 0330 hrs IST of 11th Oct. when the
system was at about 350 km east-southeast of Visakhapatnam coast and
continued till 1020 hrs IST of 12th Oct. when the DWR Visakhapatnam products
were not accessible due to disruption of telecommunication in association with the
wall cloud region entering into North Andhra Pradesh. In addition, the observations
from satellite and coastal observations, conventional observatories and Automatic
Weather Stations (AWS) were used. While coastal surface observations were taken
on hourly basis, the half hourly INSAT/ Kalpana imageries and every 10 minute
DWR imageries, available microwave imageries and scatterometry products were
used for monitoring of cyclone HUDHUD. DWR Machilipatnam was also utilized for
monitoring this system when VSCS HUDHUD was lying close to the
Visakhapatnam coast on 12th Oct.
Various national and international Numerical Weather Prediction (NWP)
models and dynamical-statistical model sand including NCMRWF’s global and
mesoIMD’s-scale models, dynamical statistical models for genesis and intensity
were utilized to predict the genesis, track and intensity of the storm. Tropical
Cyclone Module, the digitized forecasting system of IMD was utilized for analysis
and comparison of various models guidance, decision making process and warning
product generation.
47
Monitoring and analysis
In addition to existing 3 hourly
monitoring, hourly monitoring and
analysis was carried out on the date of
landfall.
Prediction Technique
During VSCS HUDHUD, Hurricane Weather Research Forecast (HWRF)
model was run by IMD and IIT Delhi with 27/9/3 km resolution based on 00 and 12
UTC observations and products were made available to Cyclone Warning Division.
Operational Forecasting
Hourly updates on the movement
and intensity of VSCS HUDHUD were
made available to the National and State
level disaster managers and media
persons on the day of landfall from 0530
hrs IST of 12th till landfall.
Warning Dissemination
• During VSCS HUDHUD Agricultural Meteorology Division, IMD, Pune in
coordination with Agro-met Field Units and Cyclone Warning Division, IMD,
New Delhi disseminated Alert and
Agro-met Advisory in the affected
districts of Andhra Pradesh, Odisha
from 9th October onwards and for
the states of Telangana, Bihar,
Chattisgarh, Jharkhand, East Uttar
Pradesh, East Madhya Pradesh and
Gangetic West Bengal from 11th
onwards. Overall 1,91,4872 SMSs
were sent to the farmers and local
48
people of affected states. INCOIS, Hyderabad disseminated warnings
through SMS and Electronic Display Boards (EDB) to coastal population
especially meant for fishermen. Cyclone Warnings issued by IMD were also
incorporated in the bulletins issued by INCOIS.
• SMS to Disaster Managers at National level and upto District
Collector level a new dedicated website for cyclone
(www.rsmcnewdelhi.imd.gov.in) has been developed and was fully
operational during VSCS HUDHUD.
• The Direct to Home (DTH) service through cable service operators
has been installed at 178 places out of proposed 500 stations for
cyclone warning communication in the coastal regions.
• Internet Lease Line Bandwidth was upgraded from 60mpbs to 100
mpbs during the cyclonic storm for free accessibility of ‘HUDHUD’
predictions since IMD website failed its activation.
49
Hourly MSLP recorded at Visakhapatnam during 10-12th Oct. 2014 Hourly
wind direction reported by Visakhapatnam Observatory during the period from 1200
UTC of 10th October 2014 to 2100 UTC of 13th October 2014. Hourly wind speed
reported by Visakhapatnam Observatory during the period from 1200 UTC of 10th
October 2014 to 2100 UTC of 13th October 2014.
Heavy rainfall during HUDHUD
The VSCS, HUDHUD caused isolated heavy to very heavy rainfall over
Andaman & Nicobar Islands, heavy to very heavy rainfall at a few places with
isolated extremely heavy rainfall over North Andhra Pradesh and South Odisha,
heavy to very heavy rainfall over a few places of Chhattisgarh, East Uttar Pradesh,
East Madhya Pradesh, isolated heavy to very heavy rainfall over Jharkand and
Bihar and isolated heavy rainfall over Sub-Himalayan West Bengal (Description of
rainfall terminologies: Heavy: 64.5 to 124.4 mm; Very Heavy: 124.5 to 244.4 mm
and Extremely Heavy: 44.5 mm) as well Isolated as spatial(ISOL):(1-25%
distribution of stations reporting rainfall); Scattered (SCT / A few places) : 26-50%
of stations reporting rainfall; Fairly Widespread (FWS/ Many places): 51-75% of
stations reporting rainfall; Widespread (WS/ Most places): 76-100% of stations
reporting rainfall during the last 24 hours ending at 0300 UTC of every day).
The chief amounts of past 24 hr rainfall realised ending (≥ at70830cm) IST of
date during the period of VSCS HUDHUD are furnished below:
8 October 2014
Activated from Port Blair in Andaman and Nicobar Islands
11 October 2014
High speed winds together with high waves of rough weather in the sea of
three coastal districts.
12 October 2014
The entire coastal district areas of Srikakulam, Vizianagarm and
Visakhapatnam received heavy rain with gale winds of Maximum gale wind of 180
kmph prevailed over Visakhapatnam district and adjoining areas at the time of
landfall. It was about 70-80 gusting to 90kmph over Andaman Islands during first
landfall.
50
Storm Surge
Observed Storm Surge recorded
by the tide gauge (INCOIS) at
Visakhapatnam was 1.4m as recorded
by the tide gauge at Visakhapatnam
port against the forecast of 1-2m.
Considering the landfall point forecast error, the performance of MME and
ECMWF models was the best among the deterministic models. IMD continuously
monitored, predicted and issued bulletins containing track & intensity forecast at
+06, +12, +18, +24, +36, +48, +60,
+72, +84, +96, +108 and +120 hrs or
till the system weakened into a low
pressure area. The above structured
track and intensity forecasts were
issued from the stage of deep
depression onwards. The cone of
uncertainty in the track forecast was
also given for all cyclones. The radius
of maximum wind and radius of ≥28
knots, ≥34 knots, ≥50 knots and four quadrants of cyclone was also issued for
every six hours. The graphical display of the observed and forecast track with cone
of uncertainty and the wind forecast for different quadrants were uploaded in the
51
RSMC, New Delhi website (http://rsmcnewdelhi.imd.gov.in/) regularly. The storm
surge forecast was given based on INCOIS and IIT, Delhi model. The prognostics
and diagnostics of the systems were described in the RSMC bulletins and tropical
cyclone advisory bulletins. The TCAC bulletin was also sent to Asian Disaster Risk
Reduction (ADRR) centre of WMO at Hong Kong like previous year. Tropical
cyclone vitals were prepared every six hourly from deep depression stage onwards
to various NWP modelling groups in India for bog using purpose. Bulletins issued
by Cyclone Warning services of IMD.
To conclude, the IMD’s weather reports and time to time forecasts provided
an effective tool for preparedness and planning for rescue and rehabilitation
operations in the affected districts of north coastal Andhra Pradesh.
52
flooding of isolated areas near rivers and canals, mostly in agricultural areas.
Flooding and debris resulted in some areas being inaccessible in the first few days
after the cyclone.
53
to determine whether determined humanitarian needs are met through local
response mechanisms, and what gaps remain.
18.4 Million 5%
Total population of 5 affected districts of total population affected
(calculations)
920,000 (estimated)
Estimated number of people affected by cyclone Hudhud, mostly in
Vishakhapatnam and Vizianagaram,
due to damage to crops on 450,000 acres agricultural land, infrastructure,
loss of assets, damage to property.
582,156 248,000 12,825+ 46
Directly affected (estimated) Population with Fatalities
(limited loss) (SDMC) urgent unmet (total 90
Directly Affected humanitarian in all
(livelihood losses) needs states)
91,500+ 406,000 19,759
with early recovery needs Evacuated Shelter damage
54
• The Navy was appointed as the lead agency among the armed
forces for relief and response operations that was code-named
'Op Lehar'. Five diving teams dispatched to Srikakulam, 10 teams
to low-lying areas in and around Vishakhapatnam for rescue and
relief operations. 15 satellite phones are arranged and 689
swimmers are positioned across 5 districts. 54 boats have been
kept ready (30 of them are naval boats).
• Government constituted special teams to identify the affected
families and enumerate the losses for further assistance. (15th
October)
• The East Coast Railway and South Central Railway cancelled over
70 trains while short terminating or diverting many others in view
of cyclonic storm Hudhud.
• The PM announced Rs 1,000 Crore worth of aid for the cyclone-
affected areas in Andhra Pradesh by the Centre. Aid of Rs
500,000 will be given to kin of deceased and Rs 50,000 will be
given to the injured along with a provision of 25 kg rice, 1 kg sugar
and 5 litres of kerosene.
• The government has announced (as per GO MS 9) 50 kgs of rice,
5 kgs of kerosene, 2 kgs of dal, 1 kg sugar, ½ kg red chilli powder,
1kg tamarind, ½ kg salt, 2 kgs potato and 3kgs onion for fishing
communities. For other affected communities the relief is reduced
to 25 kgs of rice.
• Andhra Pradesh has formed five special teams to monitor health,
restoration, relief, power and sanitation.
• Response of the humanitarian agencies (attached in the URS
matrix).
The findings of the JRNA assessment (in the 41 assessed villages) are:
• 84% of the assessed community reported that they have lost food stocks
due to cyclone, out of which 34% have experienced severe damage of food
55
stocks. Of these39% of villages reported moderate losses, and 29% low
impact. Assessment teams were concerned that community members do not
have access to sufficient food especially vulnerable groups (SCs, STs,
children under 5, Elders, Pregnant and lactating women) are suffering due to
lack of access to sufficient daily nutritious food.
• 89% of the communities reported that their remaining food stock will last for
less than a week. This will result in severe food scarcity and less
consumption especially by women and children
• In addition, 84% of the assessed villages reported that there is significant
decrease in the total amount of food that they are eating post cyclone and
98% of communities are affected by increases in food prices.
• In the assessed community, the impact of cyclone was most experienced by
non-agriculture day labour sector- (59%) of villages affected, followed by
fisher folks (52%) and then by other agriculture day labour (34%), artisans,
petty shops, small scale entrepreneur (30%).
• 34% of villages assessed indicated that there had been severe crop
damage.
• It was observed that there is a loss of livelihood especially cashew, coconut,
pineapple, banana, tamarind plantation, sugarcane, vegetables, palm oil
trees, horticulture plantations and NTF produces like coffee plantation are
completely wiped out
56
Urgent Needs (Food Security, Nutrition and Livelihood sector)
• Food assistance as 90% of communities not having access to food
beyond one week, with further analysis the gap period where food
insecurity is likely, and what needs are remaining after government food
assistance.
• Cash based assistance may assist with the recovery of local markets
enhancing liquidity.
• Tribal areas are yet to be reached by the aid and hence immediate
support for livelihoods early recovery is needed
• In tribal areas where the crops are damaged, livelihoods are affected and
food security is an issue, alternative short term livelihood options are
needed through cash transfer/ CFW for both agriculture and non-
agriculture based labour.
• Fishermen have faced damage to their boats so they need immediate
money assistance to repair boats, with emphasis on mechanisms to
assist daily wage earners working in the fishing industry who are unable
to work.
• There is an urgent need of safe baby spaces for breastfeeding, can be
met by providing baby tents for establishing baby friendly spaces
Wash
The findings of the JRNA assessment (in the 41 assessed villages) are:
• The major sources of water supply are open well (24%), pond/ open
bodies of water (5%, pipe water (22%) and tube well (54%).
• In 88% of villages, piped water had been affected. In most affected
places due to inundation and clogging
• 51% of communities indicate that the majority of households have limited
access to safe drinking water, while 22% indicate that some are without
access. Only 22% have only a few or 7% have no access to safe drinking
water.
• Only 49% of communities indicated that access to safe water is available
to marginal groups.
• There is need for water containers in 64% of the assessed villages.
• Sanitation practices are almost the same pre and post disaster, with 93%
of the surveyed villages predominantly practicing open defecation, in
fishing communities this is as much as 100%.
57
• More than half of the households have no access to toilet facilities for
both male and female household members.
• Major concerns of 63% of villages relate to solid waste management, and
61% of villages are concerned about wastewater.
• In 93% of villages surveyed, women use cloth for menstrual hygiene, in
32% of villages women use sanitary napkins.
Urgent needs
• A growing, number of people do not have access to safe water are in
urgent need of a range of WASH support, including clean water, storage
containers, hygiene kits, purification materials and various WASH NFIs.
• WASH needs are particularly acute in Vishakhapatnam city, neighbouring
affected villages and in Srikakulam.
• There is also need for soap, and diapers for children.
• Poor menstrual hygiene – use of cloths mostly now needs an intervention
strategy
• Bathing spaces and toilets are in short numbers and hence a problem in
relief camps and in water logged areas.
• A WASH Surveillance grid needs to be put up urgently to alert any
disease outbreak especially in the close urban pockets and the remote
areas as both these clusters are in high risk of rapid spread.
Shelter
Situation Analysis
• Most of the houses are Kaccha- mud houses and some are Pucca
houses, which got damaged during storm surge.
• Affected community took shelter in the schools so schools were closed
during that period (For a week or more than that).
The findings of the JRNA assessment (in the 41 assessed villages) are:
• Affected community staying in shelters is vulnerable to mosquitoes,
snakes and darkness.
• 41% of villages surveyed indicated that they shelters were partially
damaged in their village, 17% of villages indicated that they had fully
damaged shelters in their village.
• Need for non-food items have been felt in 43% villages of assessed
villages during JRNA 7% villages of total assessed 41 villages had
complete shelter damages
DISTRICTS Rains Cold Mosquitoes Darkness Heat Snakes
58
Mosquito nets are required for both displaced population as well as those
who are living in their houses.
Urgent Needs
• Temporary shelter materials, tarpaulins, plastic sheeting and ground sheets/
mats.
• Shelter repair materials for partially and fully damaged shelters.
• Mosquito nets.
• NFIs, including torches/ solar lamps, blankets and utensils.
• Need of new shelters in few villages and shelter repair in some villages.
Health
Situational Analysis:
• As per secondary data, there are 738 pregnant women of 7 to 9 months
gestation including those nursing care in the districts assessed.
• Drugs and essential medical reserves have been affected; the supplies in
general are in shortage and in medical camps due to lack of coordination
and effective supply chain management for medical camps.
• The key reasons for non-functionality of health facilities are due to lack of
human resource and skilled health care providers, interrupted drugs supply
and other essentials and also due to inaccessibility of health facilities by
community accessing the facilities.
The findings of the JRNA assessment (in the 41 assessed villages) are:
• The overall health infrastructure and system in AP region is moderately
affected.
• There were 11 PHCs assessed across 3 districts in A.P. and only 2 PHCs
been severely affected.
• Only 1 ambulance had been damaged
• Out of total 23 health camps organized, 19 (83%) of them got affected due to
water logging.
59
• Equitable access to health facilities is a big concern. The lack of access to
healthcare from PHC, AWC, Rural Health Providers, attributed to facilities
being affected and reduced staffing levels as staff and their families
themselves being affected.
• In almost all PHCs assessed, majority of them (96%) of the damaged portion
could be restored. The total health facilities assessed is 32 and of these, 25
of them would be functional within 15 days (78%); and 5 (15%) of them
would become functional within 30 days while 7% of them could become
functional beyond 30 days period.
• There are limited underlying health concerns in population assessed except
cases of malnutrition and communicable diseases in selective pockets of
Srikakulam and Vishakhapatnam villages as more than 90% of the village
did not have such health concerns.
• Health camps are concentrated in urban pockets of assessed districts, the
appropriate and equitable health services not available to the rural during the
time of the assessment.
• Health surveillance is largely missing. The organised and unorganised
medical camps are not in coordination loop and information on health
surveillance and utilization status is not being maintained.
• Poor water, sanitation and hygiene conditions are increasing health risks for
spread of communicable diseases and epidemics.
• The appropriate measures for information and awareness of people to
prevent communicable diseases are not in place.
• Most pregnant women deliver in the private or the Govt. Hospitals, large
number of which are affected and thereby increasing the load on facilities
that are operational.
• The routine immunization and neo born care is also under pressure in
existing health facilities. SRH services, RH supplies, emergency obstetric
and new-born care, prevention of gender based violence and prevention of
HIV/AIDs.
• High incidence of UTI reported among women by Anganwadi workers.
• All 3 districts teams reported eye infections (maybe conjunctivitis etc.). The
King George Hospital / Victoria hospital houses 3 patients per bed during the
few days before rainfall and could not cater to people. No preparedness for
dealing with the health issues.
60
Protection
Situation Analysis
• During the assessment, cases of looting, theft and breaking of law & order
have been reported in few villages.
• Many villages don’t have left safe and private bathing places & latrines for
women.
The findings of the JRNA assessment (in the 41 assessed villages) are:
On the basis of Joint Rapid Need Assessment collected from various
sources such as affected families, children, govt. officials at local level etc. broader
information has been gathered to provide idea about needs of people there in the
community.
• Villagers have been seen pro-active in helping each other in spite of the
discrimination, which is otherwise observed in non-disaster times. Around
57% of villages were having children in state of stress and no. of people
need counseling and psychosocial support in 55% of 41 villages.
• In the affected villages, most of the pregnant women, children, aged and
persons with disability relocated in the neighborhood habitations situated on
high land areas.
• Lack of adequate and physical protection has been felt in many villages.
• Lack of sufficient hygiene material for women especially in Srikakulam and
Vizianagaram Districts.
• Private bathing spaces and latrines have been found in few villages of
Vishakhapatnam District.
• During the storm surge and subsequent floods, some people in few villages
lost their legal documents.
• Large scale of displacement has been incurred which is again a huge
challenge in the restoring back the normal lives.
Urgent Needs
• Need of toilets/latrines in many villages for safe and hygienic environment.
• Families need to recover back their lost documents during the disaster
situation
Education
Situation Analysis:
• Children under 12 are lack of nutrition food due to no mid-day meal in the
schools.
• Adolescent girls are at risk of privacy.
• No sufficient study material is available with children.
61
The findings of the JRNA assessment (in the 41 assessed villages) are:
• At the time of the JRNA Assessment, 73% schools were used as shelters
whereas 35 primary schools and 17 high schools stopped functioning due to
cyclone storm in all the three assessed districts Srikakulam, Vizianagaram
and Vishakhapatnam.
• There was decrease in proportion of both girl and boy students found from
before to after disaster.
• All schools became functional within 15 days.
• 10% of schools lost their study material during the disaster situation.
• In all the affected districts, most of the children, teachers and community
people reported that due to schools being dysfunctional, the mid-day meal
has been stopped which further has large impact on nutritional condition of
children.
Urgent Needs
• Children in the affected communities need textbooks, notebooks and school
bags.
• Teaching learning materials and teaching aids are needed in the affected
schools
62
Recommendations
63
The severe cyclone HudHud
inflicted a heavy damage in
Visakhapatnam and Srikakulam districts
killing 45 persons and causing injuries to
scores across the north Andhra coast. The
cyclone made the landfall at Kailasagiri at
11.30 a.m. and brought in its wake gales
with speeds about 200 kilometres per hour
and tidal waves three to four meters high
that have battered the Vizag coast for
more than 2 days.
The measures taken on disaster and crisis management by the State
administration have given positive results and huge damage to human life has been
averted. However, the physical damage to the properties in the affected areas
could not be averted for the reasons beyond the human control within the short
span of availability of information. The proposed Smart City of Visakhapatnam,
which was a worst hit area in view of the point of location of landfall of Hud Hud
cyclone, is located in the heart of the City-“Kailasagiri Hills” beautiful city in coastal
Andhra Pradesh and a major Tourist destination was left battered and bruised after
massive cyclone Hudhud struck the port town.
Hundreds of vehicles parked on roads were damaged while heavy rains
inundated a few colonies. Many
Houses and mud Huts have
collapsed and demolished.
Visakhapatnam Air Port, Steel Plant
and other Valuable industries got
affected severely. The city was left
with fallen electrical poles, uprooted
trees and debris strewn all over the
streets. Cell Towers and cable Poles
had collapsed. Train and Cell phone
services were disrupted. Water and
Electricity services became in
operational. Massive destruction of
unimaginable scales left the city completely paralyzed.
All communication and power
network systems were badly
damaged by gales throwing a spanner
in rescue measures. The million-plus
population stayed indoors on account
of calamity. Uprooted trees and flexi-
boards torn and fallen on ground,
blown-up roof tops can be seen
everywhere in and around the city.
Operations at Visakhapatnam and
Gangavaram ports were paralysed
due to the cyclone. Gangavaram port
has suspended its operations.
64
Over 550 out of 600
mechanised boats at Visakhapatnam
fishing harbour have returned to the
anchorage. Fifty boats that went to
Odisha were asked to stay put at
Paradeep port. A huge sea surge
occurred the outskirts of
Visakhapatnam. Visakhapatnam and
Srikakulam district received heavy
rains due to the cyclone which had its
impact on 200-plus villages in 11
mandals such as Etcherla, Srikakulam, Gara, Narasannapeta, Mandasa and
Sompeta.
Road network was cut off to Visakhapatnam and Srikakulam areas for more
than a week from the land fall of the Hud Hud cyclone. The Navy teams have
reached the field for rescue
operations. Many trees fell down in
the entire North coastal districts
Visakhaptnam, Srikakulam and
Vizianagaram routes disrupting the
movement of cyclone-relief vehicles.
The movement of NDRF teams and
ambulances for rescue operations
could move with great difficulty.
Movement of other vehicles except
NDRF and ambulances were
restricted. Nearly 1.25 lakh people
were shifted to 150 shelters.
The Very Severe Cyclonic Storm ‘Hudhud’ disrupted power lines across the
north coastal districts of
Visakhapatnam, Srikakulam and
Vizianagaram in Andhra Pradesh. The
cyclonic storm caused extensive
damage, blacking out all the three
districts and also parts of East and
West Godavari districts, and the
officials are saying that it will take
some time to restore power. It was
estimated long time for more than two
to three months for complete
restoration and recovery of power
lines, and for normal distribution of power to the affected areas. The wind speed
that hovered around 180 to 200 kmph from morning to late in the evening, brought
down about 12,000 poles in Visakhapatnam city alone and it was estimated to be
over 40,000 in the three districts of Visakhapatnam, Srikakulam and Vizianagaram.
65
As per the report submitted by the State Government to the Union ministry of
earth science and Indian Meteorological Department (IMD), indicated that 2.37 lakh
hectare of farm land having 22. 14 lakh
tons of food-grains and standing cash
crops and 6.89 tons of horticultural
crops suffered damage due to the very
severe cyclone. The 'extent of damage'
caused by the cyclone is part of the
report, prepared by IMD's Cyclone
Warning Division on Hudhud. The
report noted that total 4,484 villages of
four districts were affected by the
cyclone that damaged 41,269 houses. Total 135,262 persons were evacuated by
the authorities to safer place after getting advance warning of the cyclone from the
IMD. The report also noted that the Hudhud damaged 455 buildings, including 317
primary and secondary schools, before finally crossing over the state.
The 'Hudhud' could have been more disastrous had it not been the India's
space agency ISRO's advanced weather satellite INSAT-3D on the job to give vital
input for accurate forecasting.
66
Several sub-stations were damaged due to the gales and winds, the details of
which are provided at appropriate paras of the present chapter.
As per the devastation seen it was observed the entire lines were obstructed
by the fallen trees on the poles and it was a bigger challenge for the Power
distribution organization (APEPDCL) for restoration of lines and poles. Most of the
main and service lines pass below the trees and tens of thousands of trees have
fallen down, bringing down the lines. A few of the high tension poles have also
fallen down in the impact.
The chief executive of APEPDCL stated “Before restoring the power, each
line and pole has to be tested, as there could be a chance of short circuit or the
poles getting live. It is a huge task
and about 5,000 people including
officers are on the job”.
Hudhud inflicted
unprecedented damage with gales
crossing 200 km per hour, whereas
the electric poles and other
infrastructure were designed to
withstand a maximum wind velocity of
200 kmph. A total of 15,344 route
kilometres of Low Tension (LT) lines
were destroyed and only 574 kilometres of these lines were pending restoration as
on November 1.
The loss to LT lines alone stood at Rs. 369 crore, which was followed by a
loss of Rs. 200 crores that the twister
caused to 33 sub-stations of which 24
are 132/33 KV facilities. Over 1,360
11KV feeders and 24,993 Dynamic
Thermal Rating (DTR) systems were
destroyed with a financial implication of
Rs 205 crore. The number of electrical
services affected was pegged at a
whopping 25.49 lakh. The Emergency
Restoration Systems (ERS) of Power
Grid Corporation of India helped
EPDCL and SPDCL in speedy restoration of power. Most parts of Visakhapatnam
city could get power back in just three days with transmissions.
Due credit should go to the National Disaster Response Force and Navy
which did their best in bringing back normalcy. The Eastern Naval Command
Helicopters were in action air-dropping manpower of the two DISCOMs in the
inaccessible areas.
67
The Very Severe Cyclonic Storm ‘Hudhud’ disrupted power lines across the
north coastal districts of Visakhapatnam, Srikakulam, Vizianagaram and East
Godavari in Andhra Pradesh on Sunday.
68
Industrial Damages
All major industrial units in Visakhapatnam have suffered extensive damage.
Rashtriya Ispat Nigam Ltd., the corporate identity of the Visakhapatnam Steel Plant,
hit hard by grid failure, has shut down operations. The Chief Minister of the State of
Andhra Pradesh after his visit to Steel Plant, has been informed the estimated total
loss in the plant would be around Rs. 700 crore.
The hull shop and other infrastructure of Hindustan Shipyard Ltd., a Defence
Ministry enterprise, were blown away. Heavy winds not only uprooted
communication installations but also blew away sheds and workshops. Telephones,
both landline and mobile, are dead. It was a colossal loss to the industries. The
Visakhapatnam and the Gangavaram ports, which together handle 85 million
tonnes, have suspended operations.
The major Public Sector industrial units including the Visakhapatnam steel
plant and the two ports –
Visakhapatnam and Gangavaram
have suffered a major damage
during the cyclone. the losses
include both production loss and
infrastructure loss as assessed by
the respective industrial units. The
total loss could be more than
Rs.1,000Crs. as per the initial
approximate estimate. The
Hindusthan Shipyard Limited (HSL)
and other PSUs were in a similar position. The HSL authorities said in a press note
on Wednesday that the estimated loss could be around Rs.500 crore. The HPCL
refinery stopped production since Sunday and power generation also came to a
halt at all the four units at the Simhadri thermal station of the NTPC (each unit with
a capacity of 500 MW). It is learnt that the naval establishments here also suffered
a huge loss, but it is yet to be enumerated. The IT units at Rushikonda and other
places in the city were in a similar plight.
Indian Navy operations
The Navy on Monday morning
launched a P8-I long range maritime
reconnaissance aircraft from INS
Rajali at Arakkonam morning to
gauge the magnitude of damage
caused by the cyclone Hudhud in
Andhra Pradesh and Odisha.
A Dornier aircraft got airborne
from the restored runway of INS
Dega in Vizag to join in the effort.
Naval assets would be deployed for rescue and relief operations on the basis of the
assessment, said a Navy spokesperson.
69
The rescue and relief efforts would be led by the Navy under ‘Operation
Lehar’. Naval personnel at Vizag were working to get the naval base back to being
operational. Damage to the Naval Dockyard was minimal thanks to proactive and
preventive measures undertaken ahead of the cyclone. The airfield at INS Dega
was flooded and damage was reported to almost all structures. Naval aircraft,
however, remained unharmed, said an official.
The Navy was able to get the two runways at naval air station Dega fit to
conduct flying operations on Monday morning itself. Almost all roads in the naval
area remained blocked with uprooted trees lying all over. Power supply to the base,
disrupted owing to damage to transmission lines, was yet to be restored. Only the
Maritime Operations Centre in Vizag had a communication link with Delhi, as BSNL
lines, naval satellite Rukmani and INMARSAT were all down.
Warships INS Ranjit, INS Shivalik, INS Shakti and INS Airawat were ready to
sail with relief material for 5,000 personnel, as four ships remained on standby.
Around 24 diving teams are already carrying out relief operations in and around
Vizag. Naval assets were deployed for rescue and relief operations on the basis of
the assessment.
Airport Operations
All the commercial Air traffic
lines were suspended for more than
five days and only the Navy was able
to get the two runways at naval air
station Dega fit to conduct flying
operations. Almost all roads in the
naval area remained blocked with
uprooted trees lying all over. Power
supply to the Air port has been
completely disrupted due to have
damage to the Air port building and
the surrounding areas. The runway at Visakhapatnam Airport was flooded and the
radar and navigational aids were destroyed. The roof of the terminal was torn apart
due to the speed of the cyclone.
Fishing Harbour
Fishing harbour bore the brunt
of devastation triggered by severe
cyclonic storm Hudhud with an
estimated 60 mechanised boats
getting sunk and 250 partially
damaged. The shell-shocked boat
owners blame the Visakhapatnam
Port for not listening to their pleas to
remove sunken/abandoned trawlers
or evacuating at least half of 500-odd
mechanized boats to the inner
harbour.
70
There are 13 abandoned trawlers and 14 totally sunk occupying almost one-
third of berthing space at the fishing harbour for past three years, which is under
maintenance of the port. Though nearly 4,000 crew members were asked to stay
on-board the boats, later the owners’ associations asked them to vacate due to
unprecedented turbulence in the sea. “I have never seen such menacing waves
and winds with such high speed in my four-decade long fishing career. Each
mechanized boat costs Rs.20-40lakh ($35,000-70,000) depending on its length and
capacity.
10 October, 2014
• Cabinet Secretary reviewed the Cyclone Preparation action.
• District Collector held a meeting
with District Officials and village
level teams regarding cyclone
preparedness.
• The District Administration
evacuated thousands of coastal
village’s people to relief centres /
safer places of cyclone relief
centres. Utmost care was taken to
provide good civic amenities at these cyclone shelters.
71
• Restrictions were imposed on vehicular movement barring emergency
cyclone relief vehicles and ambulances along 350 km of all local and
National Highways in the affected districts of north coastal Andhra Pradesh.
• APSRTC had cancelled long-distance buses.
• All essential commodities were lifted and stocked at or near to relief centres
and safer places.
• NDRF teams were placed at six locations across the district.
• All logistics such as wireless sets, Police VHF Sets were arranged. The state
government also provided satellite phones.
• Navy was alerted for any time deployment and one contingent of Army force
was placed at positions.
• Time to time satellite pictures, were viewed to track the location and speed
of the cyclone. Both Indian and U.S. sites were closely observed. Once in
the range of 200 Nm, Doppler radar was also was fully utilized for assessing
the track, time and rainfall.
• A group on Telegram involving all the district officials was created to share
real time information and pictures.
11 October, 2014
• The Chief Secretary of Andhra Pradesh reviewed the preparedness actions
through Video conference involving all the concerned team leaders of the
above mentioned operations.
• All information about the progress of the cyclone, and its proposed point of
landfall and the precautions to be taken by the state government were
propagated through FM radio, electronic media for regular monitoring of the
relief centres.
12 October, 2014
The eye of the Storm was particularly concentrated around Visakhapatnam town
and crossed through the city. This eventual situation of crossing of the cyclone
created havoc in the city for the
residence of Visakhapatnam. The
winds were severe nearly around 200
Kmph. The continuous heavy down
poring of rainfall for more than 48
hours affected the livelihood of the
citizens of Visakhapatnam. The high
speed winds and gales created an
extensive damage to the domestic,
commercial and Government
properties in entire city, particularly
the lung space of Visakhapatnam
with all-round rich greenery is hardly left out any greenery in the city of
Visakhapatnam. An extensive damage to the property, agriculture and
Infrastructure in the city, are reported after the devastation, which has been dealt
with separately in the subsequent paras.
72
73
Summary of damages
Damages associated with VSCS Hudhud
Sl. Damages
Item
No. No.
1 Districts affected 4
2 Blocks affected 65
3 Villages affected 4484
4 Families affected 20,93,508
5 Persons evacuated 1,35,262
6 Persons rescued 146
7. Human Loss/Injured
Number of Deaths 46
Number of injured 43
8. Loss of livestock
Number of animals
perished 2831
Poultry/duck 24,43,701
9. Agriculture
Expected production
loss (tons)
Food Grains & Cash 22,14,000
crops Mts.
6,89,000
Horticultural crops Mts.
10. Housing
Number of Affected
houses 41,269
Roads
Not
(i)National highway estimated
(ii)State highway 225 Km
(iii)P.R. Road
(iv)others(municipal 648.73
Roads) km
6 Persons rescued 146
74
Deaths & Injuries
Human Loss : 45
Visakhapatnam : 19
Anakapalli Division : 13
Narssipatnam Div : 04
Paderu Division : 09
Total : 45
Inuries : 27
Anakapalli Div : 05
Paderu : 01
Visakhapatnam Div : 21
Total : 27
No. of
S.No. Category
institutions
1 State Government 75
2 Central Government 18
Total 93
Other Departments
The following damages were
reported by other State and Central
Government departments.
Agriculture Department
• No. of Farmers :1,55,712
• Extent damage : 62,709 Ha
75
Horticulture Department
• No. of Farmers : 1,03,376
• Extent of damage : 51,688 Ha
• Uprooted trees : 16,780
• Crown damaged : 2,629
trees
• Tilted trees : 1,648
City Horticulture
Animal Husbandry
76
Roads and Buildings
Municipal Administration
Other
Category GVMC Total
ULBs
No of ULBS affected 1 2 3
Length of Roads damaged 811km 20 km 831km
(retaining wall)
Length of Open Drains & 393km 11 km 404 km
UGD damaged
Length of pipe line 750 km 2 km 752 km
damaged – Water Supply
No of Street lights damaged 60,000 5800 65,800km
km
No of Municipal Buildings 178 190
77
Panchayat Raj Department
Fisheries Dept
EPDCL Damages
78
INDIRA GANDHI ZOOLOGICAL PARK
IMPACT OF “HUDUD” CYCLONE IN INDIRA GANDHI ZOOLOGICALPARK
79
• The compound wall around the Zoo has fallen at many places to a
cumulative length of 1000 mts.
• The fallen trees strewn over the roads, in the moats of the entire area.
80
• Entire transport and communication system collapsed and the management
with great difficulty could able to procure temporary stocks may last for few
days only.
• Electricity and water supply is totally disrupted and we are stretching beyond
human capacity to make the animals as comfortable as possible.
• Since this Zoo is suffering for release of funds especially under the prevailing
situations immediate temporary relief to a tune of Rs.100 Lakhs.
Housing
City Plantation Damages of Local Government (GVMC)
Cyclone Effect :
• Fully damaged Grown up tree
during this Cyclone : 85,000 Nos (Approx.)
• Semi Damaged Grown up trees
during this Cyclone : 1,45,000 Nos
• No. of Parks & Gardens damaged
/ Percentage : 70 % (94 Nos)
• Major Landscaping gardens fully
damaged : 2 Nos
(Sivaji Park & Mudasarlova Park)
81
Other Infrastructural Damages
Statement of Partially Damaged Infrastructure
82
83
Findings
The heavy physical damage that took place due to the severe cyclone is a
natural impact since it is not possible to control or avert the calamity due to
pertinent reasons of manmade mistakes of creating disturbance in the ecological
balance. however, the human loss could be minimized with a great care and
implementation of effective action plan in terms of disaster managemnt and
preparedness of the State authorities, besides involvement, cooperation and
commitment of all the stakeholders-Non Government Organizations, media, student
community and all other sections of the society.
84
3. SMART CITY PLANNING
85
Smart Cities in the Global context
The concept of smart city in the global context is not new as introduced
recently in India. The smart city approach across the global cities has been under
active implementation since a decade back. The term “smart cities” is a bit
ambiguous. Some people choose a narrow definition- i.e., cities that use
information and communication technologies to deliver services to their citizens. A
broader definition according to Boyd Cohen, Smart cities use information and
communication technologies (ICT) to be more intelligent and efficient in the use of
resources, resulting in cost and energy savings, improved service delivery and
quality of life, and reduced environmental footprint-all supporting innovation and the
low-carbon economy.
Now with greater use of technology, a number of cities are accumulating
data delivering innovation, and enhancing lives of citizens”. Juniper Research
recently compiled its list of top-five “smart cities.” Steffen Sorrell focuses on two
overarching benefits of smart cities: sustainability and efficiency. To that end, he
identified five essential components of a smart city.
• Technologies
• Buildings
• Utilities
• Transportation & road infrastructure
• The smart city itself
Forbes, March 2015 releases the list of top five global smart cities:
1. Barcelona - the city scored high on the environment and
smart parking.
2. New York City - scored high of smart street lighting and
smart traffic management
3. London - scored high on technology and open data
4. Nice - the French city scored high on
environment and agency Cohesion
5. Singapore - scored high of smart traffic management
and creative use of technology
86
The smart city challenge is an approach by which the selected smart cities
take part in the strategic planning and implementation of the smart city
development with competitive spirit between the cities. Unlike the conventional
system of DPR driven approach, the smart city development demands the
policymakers of the states and cities to evolve their strategies to be more scientific
in their approach in order to achieve the success of the mission. The effective
competitive spirit among the implementable strategic planning of the cities decides
the success of the smart city project, and this pre-supposes implementation of
certain vital approaches in the governing process. The prime concern of the smart
city management is to ensure grounding and implementation of the projects
approved strictly in accordance with the City Development Plan (CDP), and this
process requires continuous knowledge sharing and skill development of all the
concerned stakeholders of the city for successful outcome of the smart city
program of the Government. This specific vital aspect is frequently ignored by the
States and local Governments, as a result of which the urban development
program outcome is lagging behind the estimated targets. However, it is needless
to emphasize that implementation of capacity building activity as a regular and
continuous internal function in the smart city governance, which is considered as
an important approach to implement the Smart City Challenge.
87
In the approach to the Smart Cities Mission, the objective is to promote
cities that provide core infrastructure and give a decent quality of life to its citizens,
a clean and sustainable environment and application of ‘Smart’ Solutions. The
focus is on sustainable and inclusive development and the idea is to look at
compact areas, create a replicable model which will act like a light house to other
aspiring cities.
The core infrastructure elements in a Smart City can be categorized
under two main headings, viz.,
88
When compared to smart cities governance in India with that of similar
concept in the global context, the implementation of smart city approach in India
involves certain difficulties in view of the socio, economic, political and behavioral
factors prevailing in India. More than one third Indian population lives in slums,
with low economic and civic infrastructural facilities and at the same time more than
80% of total Indian population uses the smart communication technology of mobile
phones. However, the transformation process of smart city development has to
undergo the prevailing situation of socio, economic, political and behavioral factors,
which can be tackled only through effective “capacity building” approach for making
the citizens of India smart.
A detailed study of some of the twenty cities selected in the first phase
reveals that the smart city development is centered around the citizen
participation process. It is needless to state the roles of the citizens, and the
citizen governance based on the active participation of citizens is considered to
be critical for smart city development. The Government is attaching prime
concern from the initial selection phase till the targeted phase of development,
and reiterating the same throughout.
89
Greater Visakhapatnam Municipal Corporation (GVMC) is the local body of
Visakhapatnam city. The city has been qualified for selection for development as
“Smart City”, during the first phase of selection among the 98 Indian cities identified
for smart city development by the Government of India, based on certain important
criteria of selection such as smart city development plan, citizen participation and
the scope for future development. The city has been qualified and placed 8th
position in the list of 20 smart cities selected for funding by the Govt. of India, based
on the existing urban development and infrastructure facilities available in the city in
accordance with the smart city plan document prepared for a specific developed
area of 1650 acres in the city on the basis of ‘retrofit’ approach. After successful
handling of the recent international events like International Fleet Review(IFR) and
Global Investment Summit during the beginning of the year 2016, Visakhapatnam
is considered for attaining the position of one of the international cities in India.
Based on the study conducted by the members of the committee appointed by the
Ministry of Urban Development, Govt. of India, the city has been placed in the 5th
“Best Clean City” in India.
90
5. Urbanization growth of Visakhapatnam
Urbanization is the population shift from rural to city areas, and a gradual
increase in the population of citizens living in urban areas. The rapid urbanization
in India demands improved living
conditions with sound infrastructural
facilities and environmental sustainability.
The beginning of 21st century has seen a
rapid growth of urbanization in the city of
Visakhapatnam. The growth in terms of
population and land area is more than
two fold over a period of three decades.
The population of the city has been
increased from 9.69 lakhs during 2005 to
18.69 lakhs during 2011. The urban
governance of the city has been
strengthened in terms of human and
financial resources which are catering to the primary need of the improved living
conditions of the citizens of Visakhapatnam. A scientific approach in the urban
development and environmental sustainability practices is under active
implementation over the past one decade in order to cope up with the increased
urbanization of the city.
Source: Census 2011
Urbanization of Visakhapatnam
Sl. Area Population
Geographical unit
No. (Sq.kms) (in lakhs)
1 Municipal Corporation of
111 9.69
Vizag (MCV) prior to 2005
2 Greater Visakhapatnam
Municipal Corporation 534 14.5
(GVMC) during 2005
91
Urban Development Projects grounded and
Completed during 2006-12
Projects Cost*
Sl. (Rs. in
Category No.
No. Details Crores / $
in millions)
Replacement of existing
Thatipudi Pipeline
Pipeline from TSR to Yendada
and to Kommadi Junction Rs.
Refurbishment of Water Supply 734.00
Water Distribution in Gajuwaka
1. 7
Supply Augmentation of Drinking $
Water Supply to 32 Peripheral 109.55
areas
Refurbishment of Distribution
of Water Supply Systems
Comprehensive Water Supply
System in Old City
Providing Sewerage in old city Rs.
282.00
2. Sewerage 2 Sewerage System in the $
Central Part of Visakhapatnam 42.08
Regularization of S.L. Canal
Rs.85.00
Storm Regularization of Yerrigedda
3. Water 3 Improvement of Storm Water $
Drainage Drains (Gangulagedda & 12.70
Yerrigedda Branch Canal)
Rs.453.00
Urban
4. Transport
2 BRTS Corridors and Flyover $
67.61
92
Smart City Selection Process
Each aspiring city among the identified 100 cities for development of Smart
Cities competes for selection as a Smart City in what is called a ‘City Challenge’.
The process involves two stages vizi., short listing of cities by States, and the
challenge round for selection under stage 2.
93
Smart City Selection Process
94
Smart City Plan of Visakhapatnam
The following draft smart city proposal has been submitted by the city
government of Visakhapatnam, which has been considered for selection for smart
city development among the twenty cities selected in the first phase, by the
Government of India. The model adopted by the city is under retrofit category, and
the details of smart city plan are given here under:
95
Top Priorities of Vizag Citizens
• Source : www.Mygov.in , www.yourvoiceyourvizag.com
` www.Mygov.in , www.yourvoiceyourvizag.com
SWOT ANALYSIS
Strengths
• Visakhapatnam has a land area of 566.95 sq.km and an overall
population of 18,81,952 with an average density of approximately
3,320 people per sq.km.
• Strong industrial base and port activity (Major port in the Bay of
Bengal)
• Emergence of PCPIR in close proximity
• Presence of International Airport
• Presence of Eastern Naval Command
• Slum relocation and redevelopment has been done in many parts of
the city (VSIP improved the service provision to about 200,000 slum
residents)
• Visakhapatnam has a multitude of tourist destinations ranging from
heritage sites to beaches & owing to its location it offers access to
many other tourist destinations in the larger region
96
• 85% of the city population is covered with treated water supply by
GVMC
• 100 percent coverage of 24x7 power supply
• 100% coverage with LED street lighting
• 52 % trips are walk trips
• BRTS already implemented
• Project on underground wiring along Beach Road has got approval
and will be funded by World Bank
Weaknesses
• Provision of adequate walking infrastructure since 52% trips are made
on foot
• Shift of Public Transport (Buses) and Para-Transit (Auto- Rickshaw)
from fossil fuel to CNG
• City wide comprehensive tourism plan with tourist information
dissemination plan
• Water recycling and reuse
• Smart light poles with sensor system to monitor air pollution, noise
pollution and disaster announcement system
• Public bike sharing system could be explored since it has a direct
impact on the improvement in the health of the citizens
• Power generation through Solar roof top to reduce reliance on thermal
power
• Changes in DCRs to promote Mixed Use Development
• Provision of Public Toilets in public places and Slums
Threats
• Air pollution, due to high vehicular growth rate of 9% annually and due
to coal handling at the Visakhapatnam Port, Steel Plant Operations
and diesel operated para transit, is a major threat to the health of the
citizens (Revised CDP for Visakhapatnam – 2041, Feb 2015)
• Solid waste dumping into the drains has severely altered the natural
drainage of the city, causing water logging during monsoons (Source:
CDP, May 2013) Untreated storm water released directly onto the
beach areas »Proliferation of illegal housing on hill slopes
• Cyclones are seen as a major threat to the coastal city of Vizag
• Water supply and demand gap is resulting in unabated ground water
extraction which will eventually lead to salinity ingress and loss of
aquifers
• Rise in sea water level
VISION STATEMENT
“A Resilient and Healthy Metropolis for People”
• The city of destiny is envisioned to become a leader in sustainability,
healthy living, equality and innovation
Goals
• Safe and healthy City
A Sustainable City
• Minimize environmental footprint
• Minimize waste & waste to energy –align with swatch bharat mission
98
A Dynamic City
• Tourism potential
• Technology connectivity –align with digital india
An Equitable City
• Citizens have access to quality education & health, technology
A Resilient City
• Climate change preparedness
• Strong neighborhood organizations and strong collaboration between
city and citizens
Taking into account the global concern on climate change and climate
resiliency our approach gives due consideration to ‘Resiliency’ in a city such that
climate related challenges are adequately addressed in order to minimize the loss
of life and damage to city infrastructure.
99
Draft Smart City Proposal – Area Basis
Smart City Features Considered for Site Evaluation
Intelligent Traffic
Management and Smart Non-Vehicle Streets /
Parking Zones
Waste Water
Smart Metering
Recycling
Underground Electric
Wiring
Sanitation
Solid Waste
Management Safety and Security of
Citizens
100
Area 2
Area 1
The three
shortlisted sites
based on citizen
responses
Area 3
101
Selected Area
Area 3
The primary objective is to identify locally relevant smart city initiatives and
technologies that could yield measurable benefits.
Inspirations
Area based smart solutions builds upon the ongoing initiatives within the
city, such as speed limit cap, vehicle free zones initiatives by GVMC and Andhra
university, beach front restoration project to enhance tourism potential etc.
Also, the area wide strategies are inspired from a local neighborhood of
Kirlampudi that has taken many smart initiative to enhance their neighbourhood.
Similarly the area-wide idea is to serve as a test bed for smart city initiatives for
brown field cities like Visakhapatnam.
The primary objective is to identify locally relevant smart city initiatives and
technologies that could yield measurable benefits. With a focus on “Prevention is
better than cure” the prominent projects include:
102
Vision Statement
‘A Resilient and Healthy Metropolis for PEOPLE’
103
Area Based Development - Mobility
104
Restriction of Use of Auto Rickshaws
Environmental friendly battery operated
e-rickshaws will be used for transporting
people.
Smart Streets:
Efficient street network connecting all public places from nearest Restriction
transport node having adequate space for on Use of cycling and walking Auto With
walkways and cycle dedicated Rickshaws tracks. Street cross section for
Redesigning Beach Road with Environmental friendly battery operated e-rickshaws
will be used provision of Public for transporting people Realm containing spaces for
walking, cycling, hawker zone and parking of autos.
105
Active Beachfront & Shared Streets
106
Transportation (Public Bike Share and Charging Stations)
107
Renewable Energy-Start By Installing In Public / Institutional Buildings
Area Wide Other Projects Multi-Level Car Park with Retail Outlet
108
Proposed Smart City Projects
The Local Government estimated an amount of Rs.1602 Crores towards
cost of various Smart City projects to be spent during the 5 years period during
2016-2021, as detailed below:
Amount Rs. in
Year
Crores / $ in Millions
Rs. 275.00
2016-17
$ 41.04
Rs. 504.00
2017-18
$ 75.22
Rs. 471.00
2018-19
$70.30
Rs. 263.00
2019-20
$39.25
Rs. 89.00
2020-21
$13.25
Rs. 1602.00
Total
$239. 06
109
Sl. Estimated
No. Proposed Project Cost
(Rs. inCrores)
1 Landscaping and Installation of Digital Boards 95.69
Towards Green Area Development
2 Pollution Control Technologies and Systems 138.00
3 Solar Roofing of Government Buildings 305.00
4 Development of Rajiv Smruithi Bhavan 9.00
including Solar Roofing
5 Modern Smart Electricity Metering System 26.00
6 Smart Signaling and Data Centre Systems for 12.00
Traffic Control
7 Development of VUDA Park 12.00
8 Information, Communication and Technology 50.00
System
9 Installation of Underground Electric Cabling 250.00
System
10 Low Carbon Mobility Vehicles, Cycling Tracks, 50.00
Electric Charging, Stations and Battery
Operated Auto Rickshaws
11 Construction of Multi Level Car Parking Areas 66.00
12 Control of Beach Erosion 125.00
13 Housing and Infrastructure for poor settlements 54.00
14 Coastal Beautification for 240.00
Tourism Development
15 Disaster Management e-governance 141.00
16 e-Rickshaws 2.30
17 e-toilets with solar roofing 6.00
18 Central controlling and monitoring system for 15.00
LED Street `Lighting
19 Science Labs in the Municipal Schools 5.50
Total Rs. 1602.49
($ 239.10
Millions)
`Source: Eenadu Daily dt.27-03-2016
110
4. THE RESILIENCE PRACTICES
The present section tries to explain the city resilience practices followed by
the local government of Visakhapatnam, the strategies evolved for enhancing the
city resilience as part of the Smart City Mission, besides the inherent ecological
natural resilience of the city, which has been experienced during the severe Hud Hud
cyclone, and the recovery of green area of the city within a short period of one year.
Before, we extend our discussion on these lines, it may be necessary to understand
few important concepts of resilience, vulnerability, risks of shocks and threads etc.,
in the context of the recent Hud Hud cyclone faced by the city.
111
Urban Planning and Resilience
In emerging and established cities alike, these trends are changing the spatial
pattern of risk and radically altering perceptions of whether they are ‘safe’ or ‘well
prepared’. Cities have a tremendous challenge to maintain social well-being and
economic vitality in the face of these complex, uncertain and constantly changing
risks. Creating Resilient Cities Technologies alone cannot make urban infrastructure
resilient. They will not be adopted without an appropriate climate for the required
investments, and their potential benefit will not be secured unless system operators
are equipped to use and act upon the information and controls that technologies can
provide. Changing social, political and economic conventions is as fundamental to
the success of city resilience initiatives as is upgrading physical assets.
Implementation of technology solutions often requires a broader ‘enabling’ toolkit,
which includes changes to urban planning, policy and regulation; governance;
knowledge development; and financing models. No single piece of this toolkit can
deliver resilience on its own but a number of actions must be taken. Urban planning
and land use policies can direct development in ways that protect people and
structures from harm. Every city has its own planning constraints related to
topography, historic patterns of growth, land ownership or tenure, and land values.
Improper planning ‘norms’ can deter proactive change and impede progressive
adjustments to changing external conditions. Nevertheless, effective planning and
land use policies can reduce the loss of life and property in the event of a disaster.
Buffers, building codes, easements, transfers of development rights, and no-build
and no-rebuild zones can aid in this goal. Inadequate or poorly performing
infrastructure may not be easily adapted to meet resilience criteria, while the lack of
space may inhibit relocation or renewal of at-risk assets. Resilience practices should
be adopted in policies, planning and construction across all city districts, to ensure
that resilience of the whole city is increased and not enhanced in one community at
the expense of another.
112
Why must cities be resilient?
Rapid population growth, large scale environmental change and a globalized
economy make today’s world one of increasing complexity, uncertainty and
continuous transformation. Directly and indirectly, these factors give rise to the
growing frequency, magnitude and geographic range of major hazards. Hazards
include man-made and natural events, both long term stresses and sudden shocks.
This section focuses on the approach for the strategy and practices followed in the
city of Visakhapatnam for building and enhancing urban resilience in view of
continuous threat of r both natural and manmade risks faced by the city.
Improved knowledge and capacity can help city stakeholders plan for and
recover from emergency situations. There is an information gap at many levels in city
decision making from the top level of government down to individual households.
Since disasters are sporadic and often unpredictable, disaster management
capability such as dedicated personnel and training across organizations can erode
as time passes since the last event. Consequently, institutional knowledge can be
inadequate and, when an event occurs, rapid and coordinated action is inhibited.
Knowledge and the capacity to act also influence the types of infrastructure that a
city is willing or able to adopt. A strong understanding of a city’s dependence on
systems, the interdependencies between systems, regional convergence and
coupling is needed to optimize the selection of new technologies and equipment.
Any new infrastructure must be appropriate to the local skill base, and must be
operable and maintainable by local people. A strategy should be in place before a
disaster occurs, which supports targeted knowledge development and
communications. Knowledge is fundamental to ensure that individuals, communities,
businesses, government and other groups are prepared for sudden events.
Appropriate information should be channeled to specific audiences and
neighborhoods before a crisis occurs. During an event, communications must be
instructive, frequent, clear and accurate, within the constraints of communication
systems available at the time. Failures can occur when policies undermine one
another. Policies and programs may need to be updated to promote resilience. Cities
must clearly signal their goals and ensure consistency in their messaging. In some
cases, individual city policies have acted against resilient outcomes or have proved
too easily influenced to achieve their priorities for urban development. Policies must
be mutually supportive across sectors, pushing towards common objectives of
resilience and long term sustainability. Development of cohesive policy proposals
requires improved communication and shared decision making across sectors,
leveraging the interdependencies between city systems and reflecting them within
policy and regulations. Updates to planning and local development policies must be
considered in tandem with necessary infrastructure improvements to enable change
to be delivered cost effectively as part of scheduled regeneration and development
projects. Planners and designers should be encouraged to prepare sensitivity
analyses, mitigation and response plans for known hazards, to ensure that planned
developments are prepared for events of varying magnitude. Cities must integrate
planning for future demand with plans to retire assets that are redundant or beyond
repair, and those that are increasingly vulnerable to risks. Adapting older cities to
meet new risks will take time. Without a comprehensive understanding of the
potential risks, cities can miss critical opportunities for investing in resilience.
113
Urban design can balance the preservation of local identity with city risk
mitigation.
Compromises must be reached
between the need to preserve existing
urban character, and the need to protect
the city from future hazards. For
example, policies that promote a retreat
from waterfronts or installation of new
physical protection for cities may affect
local identity. Where at-risk buildings
must be raised above historic flood
levels, concern is voiced about the loss
of street activity and retail viability.
Resolving these conflicts implies
innovations in urban design, which offer added value over standard approaches.
Deliberative planning is essential to help cities secure the support of residents while
achieving multiple goals: sustainability, liveability, economic prosperity and
resilience.
From the foregoing discussion it can be derived urban resilience is “the
capability to prepare for, respond to, and recover from significant multi-hazard
threats with minimum damage to public safety and health, the economy, and
security" of a given urban area.
Contemporary academic discussion of
urban resilience focuses on three distinct
threats- Climate Change Natural
Disasters and terrorism. The present
section initially focus on the challenges
and disasters specific to climate change
and consequential threat of disasters with
specific reference to cyclones,
and explains Contemporary academic
discussion of urban resilience focuses on three distinct threats - Climate Change
Natural Disasters and terrorism.
The present section initially focus on the challenges and disasters specific to
climate change and consequential threat of disasters with specific reference to
cyclones, and explains how implementation of various urban resilience strategies will
work towards counter pulling of the adverse effects of threats of climate change,
based on the present case study of Hud Hud cyclone.
The urban impacts of climate change vary widely across geographical and
developmental scales. Resilience-boosting strategies will be introduced and outlined.
Resilience is especially important in urban areas, because over the past century
there has been a considerable increase in urbanisation and urban sprawl. Half of the
world’s population now lives in cities, a figure that is set to rise to 80% by 2050.
Mass density of people makes them especially vulnerable both to the impacts of
114
acute disasters and the slow, creeping effects of the changing climate; all making
resilience planning critically important.
115
Human Impacts on Resilience
Resilience refers to ecosystem's stability and capability of tolerating
disturbance and restoring itself. If the disturbance is of sufficient magnitude or
duration, a threshold may be
reached where the ecosystem
undergoes a regime shift, possibly
permanently. Sustainable use of
environmental goods and services
requires understanding and
consideration of the resilience of the
ecosystem and its limits. However,
the elements which influence
ecosystem resilience are
complicated. For example various
elements such as the water cycle, fertility, biodiversity, plant diversity and climate,
interact fiercely and affect different systems.
There are many areas where human activity impacts upon and is also
dependent upon the resilience of terrestrial, aquatic and marine ecosystems. These
include agriculture, deforestation, pollution, mining, recreation, overfishing, dumping
of waste into the sea and climate change.
Agriculture
Deforestation
The term deforestation has a meaning that
covers crossing the threshold of forest's resilience
and losing its ability to return its originally stable
state. To recover itself, a forest ecosystem needs
116
suitable interactions among climate conditions and bio-actions, and enough area. In
addition, generally, the resilience of a forest system allows recovery from a relatively
small scale of damage (such as lightning or landslide) of up to 10 per cent of its
area.[8] The larger the scale of damage, the more difficult it is for the forest
ecosystem to restore and maintain its balance. Deforestation also decreases
biodiversity of both plant and animal life and can lead to an alteration of the climatic
conditions of an entire area. Deforestation can also lead to species extinction, which
can have a domino effect particularly when keystone species are removed or when a
significant number of species is removed and their ecological function is lost. The
city of Visakhapatnam is experiencing deforestation due to increasing urbanisation.
Vulnerability
Vulnerability is an essential component of the climate resilience discussion
because people that are the most likely to experience the majority of negative
impacts of climate change are
those that are least capable of
developing robust and
comprehensive climate resiliency
infrastructure and response
systems. However what exactly
constitutes a vulnerable community
is still open to debate. The
International Panel on Climate
Change has defined vulnerability
using three characteristics: the
“adaptive capacity, sensitivity, and
exposure” to the effects of climate
change. The adaptive capacity refers to a community’s capacity to create resiliency
infrastructure, while the sensitivity and exposure elements are both tied to economic
and geographic elements that vary widely in differing communities. There are,
however, many commonalities between vulnerable communities.
Vulnerability can mainly be broken down into two major categories, economic
vulnerability, based on socioeconomic factors, and geographic vulnerability. Neither
is mutually exclusive. Visakhapatnam is vulnerable towards heat waves during April
to June, and heavy rain fall and floods due to depressions and cyclones in the
months of August to November.
Urban Resilience
There is increasing concern
on an international level with regard
to addressing and combating the
impending implications of climate
change for urban areas, where
populations of these cities around
the world are growing
disproportionately high. There is
even more concern for the rapidly
growing urban centers in
117
developing countries, where the majority of urban inhabitants are poor or “otherwise
vulnerable to climate-related disturbances.” Urban centers around the world house
important societal and economic sectors, so resiliency framework has been
augmented to specifically include and focus on protecting these urban systems.
Human Resilience
Global climate change is going to increase the probability of extreme weather
events and environmental
disturbances around the world,
needless to say, future human
populations are going to have to
confront this issue. Every society
around the world differs in its
capacity with regards to combating
climate change because of certain
pre-existing factors such as having
the proper monetary and
institutional mechanisms in place to
execute preparedness and
recovery plans. Despite these
differences, communities around the world are on a level-playing field with regards to
building and maintaining at least some degree “human resilience”. Resilience has
two components: that provided by nature, and that provided through human action
and interaction. An example of climate resilience provided by nature is the manner in
which porous soil more effectively allows for the drainage of flood water than more
compact soil. An example of human action that affects climate resilience would be
the facilitation of response and recovery procedures by social institutions or
organizations. This theory of human resilience largely focuses on the human
populations and calls for building towards the overall goal of decreasing human
vulnerability in the face of climate change and extreme weather events. Vulnerability
to climatic disturbances has two sides: the first deals with the degree of exposure to
dangerous hazards, which one can effectively identify as susceptibility. The second
side deals with the capacity to recover from disaster consequences, or resilience in
other words. The looming threat of environmental disturbances and extreme weather
events certainly calls for some action, and human resiliency theory seeks to solve
the issue by largely focusing on decreasing the vulnerability of human populations.
Climate Change
Climate resilience is generally
defined as the capacity for a socio-
ecological system to:
• Absorb stresses and maintain
function in the face of external
stresses imposed upon it by
climate change and
• Adapt, reorganize, and evolve
into more desirable
configurations that improve the
118
sustainability of the system, leaving it better prepared for future climate
change impacts. Increasingly, climate change is
Federation
The marine ecosystem is highly complex and natural fluctuations in species
composition, abundance and distribution are a basic feature of its normal function.
The extent of damage can therefore be difficult to detect against this background
119
variability. Nevertheless, the key to understanding damage and its importance is
whether spill effects result in a downturn in breeding success, productivity, diversity
and the overall functioning of the system. Spills are not the only pressure on marine
habitats; chronic urban and industrial contamination or the exploitation of the
resources they provide are also serious threats.
Resilience and Sustainable Development
There is increasing awareness that a greater understanding and emphasis of
ecosystem resilience is required to reach the goal of sustainable development. A
similar conclusion is drawn by Perman ent al. who use resilience to describe one of 6
concepts of sustainability; "A sustainable state is one which satisfies minimum
conditions for ecosystem resilience through time". Resilience science has been
evolving over the past decade, expanding beyond ecology to reflect systems of
thinking in fields such as economics and political science. And, as more and more
people move into densely populated cities, using massive amounts of water, energy,
and other resources, the need to combine these disciplines to consider the resilience
of urban ecosystems and cities
is of paramount importance.
Academic Perspectives
The interdependence of
ecological and social systems
has gained renewed recognition
since the late 1990s by
academics including Berkes and
Folke and developed further in
2002 by Folke et al. as the
concept of sustainable
development has
evolved beyond the 3 pillars of
sustainable development to
place greater political emphasis
on economic development. This
is a movement which causes
wide concern in environmental
and social forums and which Clive Hamilton describes as "the growth fetish".
120
"Mitigation is a public good; climate change is a case of ‘the tragedy of the
commons’" Effective climate
change mitigation will not be
achieved if each agent (individual,
institution or country) acts
independently in its own selfish
interest, (See International
Cooperation and Emissions
Trading) suggesting the need for
collective action. Some adaptation
actions, on the other hand, have
characteristics of a private good as
benefits of actions may accrue
more directly to the individuals,
regions, or countries that undertake them, at least in the short term. Nevertheless,
financing such adaptive activities remains an issue, particularly for poor individuals
and countries.
Examples of mitigation include switching to low-carbon energy sources, such
as renewable and nuclear energy, and expanding forests and other "sinks" to
remove greater amounts of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere. Energy
efficiency may also play a role, for example, through improving the insulation of
buildings. Another approach to climate change mitigation is climate engineering.
Most countries are parties to the United Nations Framework Convention on
Climate Change (UNFCCC). The ultimate objective of the UNFCCC is to stabilize
atmospheric concentrations of GHGs at a level that would prevent dangerous human
interference of the climate system. Scientific analysis can provide information on the
impacts of climate change, but deciding which impacts are dangerous requires value
judgments.
121
Inter-connectivity between Climate Resilience, Climate Change,
Adaptability, and Vulnerability
A conversation about climate resilience is incomplete without also
incorporating the concepts of adaptations, vulnerability, and climate change. If the
definition of resilience is the ability to recover from a negative event, in this case
climate change, then talking about preparations beforehand and strategies for
recovery (aka adaptations), as well as populations that are more less capable of
developing and implementing a resiliency strategy (aka vulnerable populations) are
essential. This is framed under the assumed detrimental impacts of climate change
to ecosystems and ecosystem services.
Thus it can be seen that to build climate resilience one must work within a
network of related social and economic decisions that can have adverse effects on
the success of a resilience effort given the competing interests participating in the
discussion. Given this, it is clear that the social and economic scale play a vital role
in shaping the feasibility, costs, empirical success, and efficiency of climate
resilience initiatives. There is a wide variety of actions that can be pursued to
improve climate resilience at multiple scales – the following subsections we will
review a series of illustrative case studies and strategies from a broad diversity of
societal contexts that are currently being implemented to strengthen climate
resilience.
122
Effects of Global Warming
The projected effects for the environment and for civilization are numerous
and varied. The main effect is an increasing global average temperature. The
average surface temperature could increase by 3 to 10 degrees Fahrenheit by the
end of the century if carbon emissions aren't reduced. This causes a variety of
secondary effects, namely, changes in patterns of precipitation, rising sea levels,
altered patterns of agriculture, increased extreme weather events, the expansion of
the range of tropical diseases, and the opening of new marine trade routes.
Potential effects include sea level rise of 110 to 770 mm (0.36 to 2.5
feet) between 1990 and 2100, repercussions to agriculture, possible slowing of the
thermo-haline circulation, reductions in the ozone layer, increased intensity and
frequency of extreme weather events, lowering of ocean pH, and the spread
of tropical diseases such as malaria and dengue fever.
A summary of probable effects and recent understanding can be found in the
report made for the IPCC Third Assessment Report by Working Group II. The 2007
contribution of Working Group II detailing the impacts of global warming for the IPCC
Fourth Assessment Report has been summarized for policymakers.
Adaptation is handicapped by uncertainty over the effects of global warming
on specific locations such as the Southwestern United States or phenomena such as
the Indian monsoon.
Types of Disasters
There is no country that is immune from disaster, though vulnerability to
disaster varies. There are four main types of disasters.
• Natural disasters: including floods, hurricanes, earthquakes and volcano
eruptions that have immediate impacts on human health and secondary
impacts causing further death and suffering from (for example) floods,
landslides, fires, tsunamis.
Any disaster can interrupt essential services, such as health care, electricity,
water, sewage/garbage removal, transportation and communications. The
interruption can seriously affect the health, social and economic networks of local
communities and countries. Disasters have a major and long-lasting impact on
123
people long after the immediate effect has been mitigated. Poorly planned relief
activities can have a significant negative impact not only on the disaster victims but
also on donors and relief agencies.
Hence, it is important that physical therapists join established programs rather
than attempting individual efforts. Local, regional, national and international
organizations are all involved in mounting a humanitarian response to disasters.
Each will have a prepared disaster management plan. These plans cover prevention,
preparedness, relief and recovery.
124
Global Biodiversity is the
variety of different types
of life found on Earth and the
variations within species. It is a
measure of the variety
of organisms present in
different ecosystems. This can
refer to genetic variation,
ecosystem variation,
or species variation (number of
species) within an area, biome,
or planet. Terrestrial biodiversity
tends to be highest near
the equator, which seems to be the result of the warm climate and high primary
productivity. Biodiversity is not distributed evenly on Earth. It is the richest in the
tropics. Marine biodiversity tends to be highest along coasts in the Western Pacific,
where sea surface temperature is highest and in the mid-latitudinal band in all
oceans. There are latitudinal gradients in species diversity. Biodiversity generally
tends to cluster in hotspots, and has been increasing through time but will be likely to
slow in the future.
The number and variety of plants, animals and other organisms that exist is
known as biodiversity. It is an
essential component of nature and
it ensures the survival of human
species by providing food, fuel,
shelter, medicines and other
resources to mankind. The
richness of biodiversity depends
on the climatic conditions and area
of the region. All species of plants
taken together are known as flora
and about 70,000 species of plants
are known till date. All species of animals taken together are known as fauna which
includes birds, mammals, fish, reptiles, insects, crustaceans, mollusks, etc.
125
produce biomass, decompose and recycle biologically essential nutrients... There is
mounting evidence that biodiversity increases the stability of ecosystem functions
through time... Diverse communities are more productive because they contain key
species that have a large influence on productivity, and differences in functional traits
among organisms increase total resource capture... The impacts of diversity loss on
ecological processes might be sufficiently large to rival the impacts of many other
global drivers of environmental change... Maintaining multiple ecosystem processes
at multiple places and times requires higher levels of biodiversity than does a single
process at a single place and time."
Conservation biology matured in the mid-20th century
as ecologists, naturalists, and other scientists began to research and address issues
pertaining to global biodiversity declines. The conservation ethic advocates
management of natural resources for the purpose of sustaining biodiversity
in species, ecosystems, the evolutionary process, and human culture and society.
Conservation biology is reforming around strategic plans to protect biodiversity.
Preserving global biodiversity is a priority in strategic conservation plans that are
designed to engage public policy and concerns affecting local, regional and global
scales of communities, ecosystems, and cultures. Action plans identify ways of
sustaining human well-being, employing natural capital, market capital,
and ecosystem services. In the EU Directive 1999/22/EC zoos are described as
having a role in the preservation of the biodiversity of wildlife animals by conducting
research or participation in breeding programs.
Forest Reserves
The forests play a vital role in harboring more than 45,000 floral and 81,000
faunal species of which 5150 floral and
1837 faunal species are endemic. Plant
and animal species confined to a specific
geographical area are called endemic
species. In reserved forests, rights to
activities like hunting and grazing are
sometimes given to communities living
on the fringes of the forest, who sustain
their livelihood partially or wholly from
forest resources or products.
Zoological Park
In zoological parks or zoos, live animals are kept for public recreation,
education and conservation purposes. Modern zoos offer veterinary facilities, provide
opportunities for threatened species to breed in captivity and usually build
environments that stimulate the native habitats of the animals in their care. Zoos play
a major role in creating awareness among common people about the need to
conserve nature.
India’s Biodiversity Profile
• Floral and Faunal diversity India is its flora and fauna
• In terms of plant diversity, India ranks tenth in the world and fourth in Asia.
126
• With over 49,000 plant species, India represents nearly 12% of the world’s
known floral diversity.
• The richness of Indian species is shown in Table
127
Domesticated Biodiversity
Crop Genetic diversity: Agriculture remains one of the dominant drivers and
mainstay of economic growth in India. The large mosaic of distinct agro eco systems,
characterised by variations in edaphic, climatic and Geographic features has
contributed to diverse cropping patterns and systems across the country. India is one
of the eight Vavilov’s centres of origin of cultivated plants in the world. India stands
seventh in the world in terms of contribution of species to agriculture and animal
husbandry.
Animal Genetic Resources (255 Breeds)
Cattle 64 *(7.75%)
Buffalo 23 *(26.5%)
Sheep 63
Goat 34 *(8.6%)
Others 72
*figures in parenthesis denote % global wealth
Diversity in Plant species of Agronomic Value
Cereals 1,123,278
Millets & Farages 40,488
Pseudo Cereals 3,496
Grain Legumes 40,604
Oilseed crops 33,170
Fibre crops 8,387
Vegetables 15,671
Fruits 172
Medicinal & Aromatic 1,551
Plants
128
• The CRF is built on four essential dimensions of urban resilience: Health &
Wellbeing; Economy & Society; Infrastructure & Environment; and Leadership
& Strategy.
• Each dimension contains three “drivers,” which reflect the actions cities can
take to improve their resilience.
129
Visakhapatnam in the international urban map by inviting its participation in the
World Urban Economic Forum-6 Held in Naples, Italy during The Year 2012.
130
• Environmental initiatives with Vehicle free zones, Hawker zones, Bi-cycle
lanes, Free lefts, etc.
• LCMP initiative with UNEP and
ICLEI support.
• CITY URBAN CHALLENGES
• Rapid Rate of Increase in
Urbanization
• Provision of Infrastructure facilities
in Accordance with the
• Increased Growth of Urbanization
• Effective City Planning in
Accordance with the Increased
• Special Growth
• Qualitative Service Delivery in the areas of Public Health, Sanitation, Water
Supply, etc.
• Resource Mobilization to meet the Service and Infrastructural Demands
• Environmental Sustainability through LCMP and Renewable Technologies
• Institutional and Capacity Building
Challenges
• Increased Pollution
• Despite its potentials,
Visakhapatnam City is declared as
the 7th pollutant city in the Country.
• Pollution is more due to Port
Trust, Steel Plant, Petroleum
Refinery, Pharma City, etc.
• Traffic Congestion and more
usage of Private modes of transport
are also contributing to the pollution.
• Minimum usage of Bi-cycles and
increasing number of two wheelers causing the pollution further.
132
• Conducting Seminars and Workshops on implementation of Low Carbon
Mobility Plan in the City,
involving various Stakeholders
with the support of ICLEI and
UNEP.
• Support for VFZ concept by
various Educational Institutions
and industries in the city.
• Support from NGOs, Press and
Electronic Media.
• Introduction of Cycling clubs
involving various NGOs at ward
level in the city.
Under the project, specific activities are currently underway to attain key results such
as:
• City Disaster Management Plans,
• Hazard Risk and Vulnerability Analysis,
• Training of communities to respond to disasters,
• Action plans to strengthen Early Warning systems based on analytical
studies,
133
• Sectoral plans with key focus on mainstreaming of disaster risk reduction and
climate change adaptation in development programs and
• Knowledge management.
This project has recently become a part of the newly approved GOI-UNDP
Programme on Strengthening Institutional and Community Resilience to Disasters
and Climate Change (2013-2017).
134
• Climate change adaptation strategies
• climate mitigation strategies
Cycling Tracks
As a part of Environmental
Management to avoid Pollution Control
and to improve health conditions of the
citizens, the Commissioner, GVMC
introduced a ‘innovative programme’
i.e., “Establishing Cycling Zones
(Tracks)” in Visakhapatnam on 01-11-
2011. A road length of 2.50 Kms. in
beach road is declared as ‘Cycle Zone’
during morning hours from 5-30 a.m. to
7-30 a.m. During this period ‘No Motor
vehicles’ will be allowed. A second
Zone of 1.50 Kms. of length at
Rednam Gardens is also earmarked as Cycling Zone from 27-11-2011 onwards.
To encourage Cyclists and Morning walkers the GVMC introduced the above
programme and to create awareness among the citizens of Visakhapatnam
regarding environmental management and pollution control.
No Vehicle Zone
Greater Visakhapatnam Municipal Corporation introduced a new programme
i.e., ‘No Vehicle Zones’ for the convenience of Visakhapatnam citizens and to bring
awareness and motivate public for Walking.
Three (3) areas are declared as ‘No Vehicle Zone’ in the morning hours from
5-30 a.m. to 8-30 a.m. No Motor Vehicles will be allowed during these hours. The
Cyclists can move freely without any danger from Motor Vehicles. This not only
improves the environment but also Health.
Other Environmental Sustainability Initiatives
Visakhapatnam is declared as one of the Pollutant cities due to
industrialization , Port etc
GVMC as a part of reducing pollution developed four “vehicle free zones” of
about 20 kms. No vehicles will be allowed except pedestrians/ cycles.
Cycling zones were created at four areas in the city.
Encouraged usage of Public transport by GVMC staff for one day in the week,
i.e., on Monday.
Given up official vehicles by GVMC staff for one day.
Prohibited usage of polythene carry bags below 40 microns
Mass plantation of 5 lakh trees in GVMC area in coming two years.
Low Carbon Mobility plan with assistance from UNEP taken up to reduce
carbon emission in the mobility.
135
GVMC Cycling Club
GVMC Cycling club is a non- profit organization managed by the
members.
To create Health, recreation, avoid non motorized vehicles to aware on
environment fuel reduction, etc. by promoting cycling by all ages.
Provide daily, weekend, Monthly programs by involving all ages
irrespective of gender. Get together, dinners, picnics, breakfasts, etc.
To enrich friendship, increase of friends to provide E mails, SMS,
Mobile Numbers for sharing of views.
We can arrange evening cycling on Saturdays, apart from mornings
and long rides on Sundays and other public holidays by increased
resources of riding partners like SHGS, Voluntary organizations, Public
& Private sectors, school, college students etc.
136
Project details
• The World Bank agreed to finance US$ 250 million (Rs.15 Crs.) for the
APDRP vide Credit No.56940-IN dt.22-06-2015. This covers five main
components and will be executed by six Govt. departments i.e.
APEPDCL, GVMC, VUDA, Panchayat Raj, R&B and Forest
Department.
• Revenue (Disaster Management) Department, Govt. of Andhra Pradesh
will be the Project Management Unit (PMU) for the entire Project.
• An amount of US$ 120 million (Rs.720 Crs.) was allocated for
Component-1 (Resilient Electrical Network) and Eastern Power
Distribution Company of A.P Ltd., will be the Project Implementing
Agency (PIU).
• Procurement plan of APEPDCL was approved by World Bank on
31.07.2015.
• APEPDCL is the first department to get their Procurement Plan
approved by World Bank.
• Pilot Technical DPR for 33/11 KV MVP Sub-Station was approved by
World Bank. The total cost estimate of the Pilot Area covering MVP
Substation is Rs. 55 Crores.
• Selection of Environmental consulting firm was initiated as per World
Bank guidelines. Normally it will take nearly 3 months to finalized
selection process. APEPDCL is adhering to the approved time schedule
and it will be finalized by end of October, 2015.
• The environmental
consulting firm has to
study the entire
project area which
will take at least 5
months and has to
submit their
Environmental &
Social Impact
Assessment Report
to APEPDCL. This
ESIA report is
essential to approve
the total DPR of UG Cable Project by the World Bank.
• Within the World Bank approved allocation of US$ 120 Million
(Rs.720 Crs. Approx.), it is planned to cover 21 Nos. 33/11 KV Sub-
Stations in Visakhapatnam city starting from sea coast and going
towards land side.
• As per the World Bank approved time lines, the works are expected to
be commenced by May, 2016.
• APEPDCL is adhering to approved time schedule of World Bank.
• As per World Bank approved time lines, Project implementation start
date is 17-Jun-2015 and Project implementation end date 30-Sep-2020.
• APEPDCL is planning to complete the UG Cabling Project works by the
year 2018.
137
Vizag Metro Transport System
The mega project of Vizag Metro transport system in the Smart City of
Visakhapatnam has been taken up by the Government of Andhra Pradesh with
support of the Government of India, and it is a major project of public transportation
system in the central city of Visakhapatnam.
Metro Proposals:
• Govt. of A.P. in Sept’2014 have appointed Delhi Metro Rail Corporation (DMRC),
Delhi as the consultants for preparation of Detailed Project Report (DPR) for
Vizag Metro and Dr.E.Sreedharan as the Principal Advisor for the Metro.
• The Principal Advisor has visited the city Nov’2014, Jan’2015 and also in
May’2015 along with Director (Business Development) and other officials of
DMRC.
• Government of Andhra Pradesh in January 2015 approved the following 3
corridors of 39km for preparing Detailed Project Report (DPR) duly conducting
relevant studies by DMRC.
138
Status
After conducting all relevant studies like Traffic, Geo-investigation,
Topographical Surveys, Environmental Studies etc., the DMRC has submitted the
draft Detailed Project Report of Visakhapatnam Metro to the Government in the 2nd
week of Aug’2015 and the details in brief are as follows:
Total 42.550
139
LED Street Lighting Project
The Local Government of Smart city of Visakhapatnam, immediately after the
devastation of the entire street lighting system in the city, replaced the entire street
lighting system of sodium vapour lights with LED lighting systems. The salient
features of the project are:
140
Sodium Vapor Lights Replaced
141
Comparative statement of electricity consumption after LED Installation
Sodium vapor
LED lights
lights
Units
Units in
Month Month in
lakhs
lakhs
Jan-14 23.80 Jan-15 12.70
Feb- 23.89 Feb-15 12.72
14
Mar- 17.08 Mar-15 11.85
14
Apr-14 19.60 Apr-15 12.34
May- 18.01 May- 10.92
14 15
Jun-14 17.22 Jun-15 10.79
Jul-14 16.80 Jul-15 10.09
136.40 81.41
Results
• Improvement in quality of illumination of city roads / streets.
• Better monitoring of functions of street lighting by Centrally Controlled
Monitoring System (CCMS).
• Able to maintain standard LUX levels.
142
of the local Governments of India and Philippines. To this end, scientists, ICLEI and
four cities each in both countries will be working together to localize the impacts of
climate change and to develop future scenarios and decision making aids in order to
reduce the risks of climate change impacts.
The goal of the project is to reduce the risks of the climate change impacts
faced by the cities in the target countries through an integrated and cyclic
management approach, thereby increasing their local economic and social
resilience. It further aims to better manage the impacts of climate change about
potential risks at local level; and to promote the exchange of knowledge between
cities in the target countries. With the support of the participating partners, each of
the cities will develop its own local indicators for climate change adaptation.
The city of Visakhapatnam has been identified as one of the Indian cities
among four other cities – Kolkatta, Cochin and Madhurai for implementation of the
project. The project would serve as a basis in order to develop local government
strategies for the adaptation to climate change.
Project Goal
143
In first aid topics covered are unconsciousness, respiratory problems, heart
problems, current shocks, burns, food poisoning, bites by various animals, fevers,
digestion problems, vomiting, breakage of bones, wounds, hot waves, irritations of
sensory organs, trauma etc. The same topics which are covered in resource material
and also local specific issues were explained to participants by trainers.
The participants involved in the urban volunteers training program were from
various educational backgrounds from higher education to some illiterates, various
financial backgrounds and various professions including unemployed youth. Special
care was taken by trainers during training program while explaining the topics to
participants of various backgrounds. Some topics were separately explained to
various groups based on their background and interests on specific topics. The
participants acquired knowledge/skills on the training topics related to climate
change, disasters, CBDRM, search & rescue operations and first aid. During the
training programs it was observed that women were shown more interest to acquire
knowledge on the topics related to climate change, disasters and first aid.
Visakhapatnam being a coastal and industrial city, it has rich experiences with
natural hazards like cyclones, tsunami, erosions, hot waves and industrial accidents
as manmade disasters. In this year 2014, Visakhapatnam experienced ground
vibrations due to an earthquake incident in May, extreme ambient temperatures due
to hot wave incidents during June month and recently on 12th October a super
cyclone called ‘Hud Hud’. People in the city are aware of various disasters which
were happened in India and at other places from last few years.
144
Impact of Hud Hud Cyclone
145
Impact of Hud Hud Cyclone
146
Impact of Hud Hud Cyclone
147
Impact of Hud Hud Cyclone
148
149
Impact of Hud Hud Cyclone
150
Impact of Hud Hud Cyclone
151
10. Observations
Strengths
• The increasing growth of urban agglomeration, vast land area
having around 46 percent of green area, more than 150 Kms long
sea coast with picturesque of green hills is the major strength of
Visakhapatnam for development as Smart city.
• The scope for land use for the targeted urban development with
necessary inbuilt urban resilience of the city is another important
factor in facing the regular environmental threats such as massive
cyclones and floods.
• The local government is able to handle the smart city challenges
with improved urban governance and support from the State and
Central Governments.
• The improved employee performance and commitment levels
together with necessary citizen participation and involvement are
other major strengths in achieving the support for smart city
development.
Weaknesses
• The major weakness of Visakhapatnam is the geographical location
of the city besides a rough Bay of Bengal sea prone to natural
disasters of cyclones with high speed gales every monsoon season
leaving huge devastation in the city and surrounding areas.
• Absence of Inter and intra departmental coordination and
cooperation in handling the smart city challenges after grounding
the projects including efforts for coordination with global
supporting agencies such as USTDA, UNDP, World Bank ADB, etc.
• The existing system of generation of revenues in accordance with
the annual budget estimates of capital and revenue expenditure is
to be redefined.
• Lack of financial accountability and absence of regular policy
making due to long gaps of elected city council is another setback
in launching the developmental projects and completion of the
projects.
152
Opportunities
• Visakhapatnam city has a great opportunity for smart city
development by virtue of the prevailing situation of socio-economic
conditions and its geographical location having a long sea coast
with high resilient vast urban area.
• A major urban development has already been taken place with
grounding of various developmental projects in the urban
rejuvenation mission earlier, which is providing a major opportunity
for smart city development through retrofit approach.
• The inbuilt urban resilience is providing an opportunity to face the
major threats and shocks of natural disasters.
• The city has a regular opportunity of availing support and
cooperation of the citizens, besides the administrative, technical
and financial support extended by the national and international
agencies in times of exigencies.
Threats
• A major threat for the city is always a continuous risk of natural
disasters, and absence of continuity in grounding the urban
resilience projects on account of frequent administrative changes
and discontinuation of capacity building activities.
• The other major threat is insufficient revenue generation to meet the
cost of smart city development projects associated with absence of
inter-departmental coordination and coordination with supporting
global agencies, USTDA in particular, due to discontinuation of
capacity building activities.
• Increased corruption as reported in the local press from time to
time. This may be due to diminishing accountability levels of the
part of employees in the absence of regular training programs and
inter department meets.
• Inadequate citizen response and participation for successful
grounding of smart city projects on account of absence of effective
system of coordination with citizen voluntary groups.
153
Observations
From the discussions in the preceding paras, it would be evident that there is
a positive relation between urban resilience and the recovery of eco system, and the
following conclusions can be derived supporting the hypothesis. The following
physical results are clearly visible in the proposed Smart City of Visakhapatnam
within a short period one year of experiencing the severe tropical cyclone of Hud
Hud:
• The greenery of the city is almost regained with the green urban economy
action plan implementation by the state authorities under the leadership of the
Chief Minister of Andhra Pradesh.
• The local government action of the Smart City administration has been
improved in respect of implementation of citizen services and environmental
sustainability approaches.
• The government of Andhra Pradesh played a crucial role of paying specific
attention towards the recovery process in the city of Visakhapatnam.
• Several sustainable urban development initiatives have been commenced for
developing the Smart City with various programs.
• The response for action plan gained momentum in launching the mega
projects such as Metro rail, underground cabling, and LED street lighting etc.,
in the city of Visakhapatnam.
• The commitment levels of various sections of the society, such as NGOs,
student communities and other institutions have been increased in rebuilding
the Vizag city.
• The Green Visakha Program of the Government of India gained a momentum
with the severe calamity of Hud Hud, which contributed for improving the
urban resilience of the city.
• The transport and traffic system is scientifically developed with revised
designing of traffic lines, bus shelters, signaling systems etc., for an improved
system of traffic control.
• The proposed Smart City of Visakhapatnam is giving a new and rich look after
revival from the Hud Hud cyclone calamity within a short period of one year.
154
5. CITIZEN PARTICIPATION
AND
CAPACITY BUILDING
153
cities. The Smart Cities Mission is meant to set examples that can be replicated
both within and outside the Smart City, catalyzing the creation of similar Smart
Cities in various regions and parts of the country.
Smart Cities Mission Strategy
Pan-city initiative in which at least one Smart Solution is applied city-wide
develop areas step-by-step – three models of area-based developments
• Retrofitting,
• Redevelopment,
• Greenfield
The Core Infrastructure Elements
• Adequate water supply,
• Assured electricity supply,
• Sanitation, including solid waste management,
• Efficient urban mobility and public transport,
Affordable housing, especially for the poor,
• Robust IT connectivity and digitalization,
• Good governance, especially e-Governance and citizen participation,
• Sustainable environment,
• Safety and security of citizens, particularly women, children and the elderly, and
• Health and education.
The Smart Cities Mission is an innovative and new initiative by the
Government of India to drive economic growth and improve the quality of life of
people by enabling local development and harnessing technology as a means to
create smart outcomes for citizens. India faces a wide range of urban challenges—
from serious air pollution and poor local governance, to badly planned cities and a
lack of decent housing. India’s Smart Cities Challenge, which has now selected 98
of the 100 cities that will receive funding, could go a long way in addressing these
issues.
According to Prime Minister of India, Narendra Modi, there are five key
instruments that make a “smart” city: the use of clean technologies, the use of
Information Communications and Technology (ICT) private sector involvement,
citizen participation and smart governance. There are good examples of new
practices for each of these pillars.
For example, the city of Viskhapatnam recently launched a program to
replace streetlights with energy efficient LEDs. The Digital India program is
designed to upgrade the country’s IT infrastructure and includes plans to build
“broadband highways” across the country. As for private sector participation, the
Indian government is trying to encourage it by listing sectors and opportunities
for public-private partnerships.
Citizen participation is one of Modi’s five key instruments, but this is an area
where smart city pilots around the world have tended to perform least well on.
While people are the implied beneficiaries of programs that aim to improve
efficiency and reduce waste, they are rarely given a chance to participate in the
design or delivery of smart city projects, which are usually implemented and
managed by experts who have only a vague idea of the challenges that local
communities face.
154
Citizen Participation
Engaging citizens is especially important in an Indian context because there
have already been several striking examples of failed urban redevelopments that
have blatantly lacked any type of community consultation or participation.
Anticipating some of these criticisms, Union Minister of Urban Development
Venkaiah Naidu recently stressed the need for every candidate Smart City plan to
reflect citizens’ aspirations and be built in consultation with local communities.
A NEW APPROACH
How can Indian cities engage residents in their smart city projects?
There are many tools available to policymakers—from traditional community
engagement activities such as community meetings, to websites
like www.mygov.in that ask for feedback on policies. Now, there are a number of
reasons to think smart phones could be an important tool to help improve
collaboration between residents and city governments in Indian cities.
In Bangalore, an initiative by the MOD Institute, a local nongovernmental
organization, enabled residents to come together, online and offline, to create a
community vision for the redevelopment of Shanthinagar, a neighborhood of the
city. The project, “Next Bengaluru”, used new technologies to engage local
residents in urban planning and tap into their knowledge of the area to promote
a vision matching their real needs. The initiative was very successful. In just three
months, between December 2014 and March 2015, over 1,200 neighbors and
residents visited the on-site community space, and the team crowd sourced more
than 600 ideas for redevelopment and planning both on-site and through the Next
Bangalore website.
The MOD Institute now intends to work with local urban planners to try get
these ideas adopted by the city government. The project has also developed a pilot
app that will enable people to map abandoned urban spaces via smart phone and
messaging service in the future.
155
Finally, to enable a move toward a greater share of online participation
channels, such as through smart phone applications and social media,
municipalities need to make sure they invest in smart people and not only in smart
technologies. A recent Nesta report on bottom-up smart cities highlighted the
necessity for city government employees and citizens to develop a better
understanding of data and technology in order to make the most of the new
opportunities they offer.
The Smart Cities Mission requires smart people who actively participate in
governance and reforms. Citizen involvement is much more than a ceremonial
participation in governance. Smart people involve themselves in the definition of the
Smart City, decisions on deploying Smart Solutions, implementing reforms, doing
more with less and oversight during implementing and designing post-project
structures in order to make the Smart City developments sustainable. The
participation of smart people will be enabled by the Special Purpose Vehicle (SPV)
through increasing use of ICT, especially mobile-based tools.
Smart City Proposal, and recommended MyGov as the core platform for
citizen consultation Citizen consultation Ministry encouraged local governments to
engage citizens as they worked on their city’s is an important pillar of the first phase
of the Smart Cities Mission. The Municipal governments supplemented their online
MyGov activities with meetings, discussions, and other public interactions in their
respective cities.
MyGov facilitated citizen consultation for the Smart Cities Mission in two
stages. During the first round, it offered cities a range of citizen consultation
methodologies, such as discussion forums, tasks, online polls, public talks, and
blogs. These tools served as a catalyst for citizens to participate in the Smart Cities
Mission and the competition, also known as the India Smart Cities Challenge, and
offer suggestions for the development of their city.
156
During the second round of the Smart Cities Mission, municipal authorities
from the shortlisted cities used MyGov to collect suggestions from citizens on their
vision for a Smart City to incorporate these into draft proposals. Of the 98 cities, 57
put the draft proposals online for further comments and inputs from the public.
Overall, the proposals received a total of 1,42,895 comments.
The 98 cities adopted a range of measures to encourage citizen
engagement. Municipalities reached out to young citizens by visiting schools and
colleges to educate them about the Mission. Municipal corporations used popular
social networking platforms like Facebook and Twitter to spread awareness about
the mission. Still others created dedicated websites with detailed updates on
progress. SMS campaigns, voice message campaigns, and airtime on radio
channels helped expand a municipality’s reach. Many cities even created free Wi-Fi
hotspots in crowded areas so that people could access Internet and submit
suggestions. Advertisements in newspapers, pamphlets, hoardings, and the MyGov
app played a significant role in making the Smart City Mission a nationwide
phenomenon.
The Smart Cities Mission – MyGov collaboration is an unprecedented
exercise in urban planning, which has transformed planning from a top-down
centralized activity into a democratic consultative process, taking the citizens’
perspective as the foundation stone on which the city plan is built. MyGov looks
forward to partnering with more cities and citizens in the subsequent rounds of the
Smart Cities Mission play its part in developing Smart Cities across India.
157
How to involve the citizens in the Smart City development process?
The citizens living in a particular region of the country are the key
stakeholders of any form of Government, whether it is national, provincial or local.
Since citizens are the major contributors of valuable financial and human resources
in the form of tax payers and human services to the local bodies, their expectations
with regard to the quality of citizen service delivery by the local government will be
high. The major developmental policies evolved by the governments based on the
positive political will influence the degree of interest of the citizens for their active
involvement in the governing process. The present government as part of
implementation of its urban development policies with a strong political will
introduced the concept of “Smart Cities” in India. The Government is reiterating the
need for active citizen participation in the process of making smart cities, and
appealing the citizens time and again to become “Smart” since the success of the
smart city concept depends to a large extent on the important element of “Citizen
Participation”. It is therefore felt necessary that the city governments of the selected
smart cities are expected to evolve such policies and procedures which would
positively influence the active participation of the citizens. Human psychology is a
complex element to understand and influence for the purpose of achieving positive
targeted results, particularly in a country like India. The behavioral pattern and the
intensity of impact of influential factors vary from city to city depending upon the
leadership style based on various socio, economic, geographical, political and
cultural constraints in the State in which the city is situated. Active citizen
participation is possible through a democratic leadership style with a limited
publicity in a small city having a low population living in cities like Kakinada,
Belagavi and Guwahati. Where as it may be difficult in major cities like
Visakhapatnam, Bhubaneswar, Chennai and so on by virtue of the increased size
of population and urban areas. The city selected on the basis of achieving higher
scoring through active citizen participation in the initial selection phase may find it
difficult to get similar results in the project implementation stage.
158
of categorization based on professional background and other formal social groups
including government and non-government service organizations existing in the
city. Accordingly, various CVT groups have to be formed inviting the citizens and
members belonging to various professional bodies such as educational institutions
and universities, legal, civil engineering, architecture, journalism, political and any
other such professional bodies, which are involved in the service activities. The
members of the CVT groups are to be involved in the smart city development
process right from the phase of strategic planning till the completion of the projects
through regular and frequent interactive sessions. The local government has to
evolve the system of monitoring the Citizen Voluntary Technical Groups, and
entrust the responsibility to the HRD Centres in involving the CVT groups in the
smart city development projects. The role and responsibilities of the HRD Centres
in the smart city government is crucial in so far as the active participation of the
citizens concerned in making the complete success of smart city project.
159
the smart city challenge. It is observed that the capacity building and institutional
building of smart cities through implementation of an effective internal functional
system in the city governance would provide positive results in the development of
smart cities. As per the discussion, it can be derived that the capacity building
approach in smart cities has a twofold objective of (i) improved smart city
development through (ii) effective governance and citizen participation.
160
The capacity building program has two components namely:
• development of smart cities for strengthened urban management, and
• the second component deals with creation of supporting structure and
mechanisms at state and central levels to facilitate capacity building of
smart cities.
The specific objectives of HRD centers are to help the city governments and
States to:
• effectively function as institutions of local governance in accordance with
the governing statues of the State.
• develop capacities in the areas of procurement and project development,
• handle operational management and maintenance, financial
management, budgeting and accounting.
• achieve the benchmarks of reforms on smart city management and
renewal,
• promote urban planning and sustainable urban habitats in the cities
• provide support for the creation of municipal cadre in States.
• create an enabling environment for stakeholder consultations and
participation in service delivery.
• promote the use of information communication technologies and robust
information systems through e-governance.
• support States to strengthen the supply side training and capacity building
institutions, especially State Training institutes to meet the higher level
capacity building and human resource needs of smart cities.
• Strengthen the capacities of smart cities to mainstream gender in all
activities and promote gender budgeting and
• Develop centres of excellence for urban management.
161
Implementation of Capacity Building System in Smart Cities
Based on the present experience of variations in the feedback obtained
through the government portal during the planning phase of smart city development
of the listed cities and the dire need for establishing capacity building through
Project Management Unit (PMU), it is necessary to commence of HRD centres as
internal system of governance in the listed smart cities. The program involves not
only the skill and knowledge improvement of the employees of the ULBs, but also
creating Citizen Voluntary Technical Groups (CVTG) for involvement and
participation of smart city development. The HRD centres have an important role of
comprehensive capacity building of the smart cities, and improve skill and
knowledge of the cities stakeholders in accordance with the guidelines issued by
the ministry of urban development through various training programs, workshops,
seminars and interactive sessions at city government level in the PMU
implementation.
The challenges in capacity building can be divided into institutional and
human resource levels.
The institutional challenges can be tackled by
• accelerated business process re-engineering efforts
• consolidation of data on city governments, supporting institutions
and their services
• strengthening the monitoring and evaluation system, and
• clear demarcation of responsibility between smart cities and the
supporting institutions of capacity building
Summing up, the cities to become smart, require the citizens to be smart
and capacity building plays an important vital role in the process. The capacity
building activity, through inception of HRD centres in the smart cities selected by
the Government, should become an integral part of local governance, and viewed
as a supporting activity with defined functions under the control of a senior
professional HR expert assisted by a team of experienced functional faculty.
162
The primary objectives of the proposed HRD centres in smart cities are
to be aimed at
• a sound HRD manual based on a detailed study of the existing HR
inventory of the smart city,
• a well defined training and development policy in accordance with the
approved City Development Plan of the smart city,
• an effective Citizen Responsive Management system based on the
prevailing socio, economic, demographical and geographical conditions of
the smart city,
• a sustainable urban development policy based on activity analysis of the
smart city,
• an effective environmental policy based on the prevailing climatic and
geographical conditions of the smart city.
The functions of the HRD centres in the smart cities are to be designed so
as to ensure the accomplishment of smart city challenge, as detailed below:
• Regular in-house training and development programs for the entire
human resource of the city government including the council members
and other stakeholders of the smart city.
• Formation of Citizen Volunteer Technical Groups according to nature
of professional activities of the citizens in the smart city, as envisaged in
the previous sections, and regular interactive sessions with the members
of the CVTG groups for their active involvement in the smart city
development process.
• Conducting seminars and workshops on important areas of urban
administration and city management, involving various stakeholders
groups of the city.
• Perpetual inventory of human resource in the smart city.
• Support for implementation of changing organizational and service
deliveries in accordance with the directions issued by the State and
Central Governments from time to time.
• Preparation of important manuals in the areas of HRD, Citizen
Responsive Management, activity analysis for sustainable urban
development and a sound environmental policy of the smart city.
• Supporting the city administration in the areas of newly introduced
concepts of national and international importance in the areas of urban
development, environmental sustainability, poverty alleviation etc.
• Research and development by supporting the city governance in various
studies of urban development and environmental sustainability projects
of national and international organizations, involving all the city
stakeholder groups.
• Supporting the academic community in research and development in the
area of sustainable urban and environmental development.
• Preparation of study reports, notes and presentations on the important
developmental activities for knowledge sharing among the council
members, employees and other stakeholders within the city and between
the smart cities for sharing of best smart city practices.
163
• Coordination of important projects on smart city development and
environmental sustainability practices initiated and handled by the
supporting developed nations and global agencies like World Bank,
Asian Development Bank, UNDP, UNEP, etc.
• Nomination of council members, officers and other city stakeholders to
various capacity building programs conducted by external training
institutions in India and abroad.
• Regular coordination and monitoring of various important projects in the
areas of smart city development, climate and environmental
sustainability, urban resilience, disaster management, etc., grounded by
the central and state governments including various national and
international agencies, for successful and effective handling.
• Documentation of MoUs, feedback reports of important national and
international projects of city development and environmental
sustainability including coordination and monitoring between the
supporting international agencies and the smart cities.
• Conducting regular Interactive sessions with the members of the
supporting international agencies and the smart city functionaries
including providing necessary inputs to the team members of the
supporting agencies and the smart city functionaries.
164
centre within the organization, based on specific recommendations of the study
conducted by the Administrative Staff College of India (ASCI), Hyderabad during
the year 2006 in accordance with the
directions of the State Government.
The purpose creation of HRD centre
in Greater Visakhapatnam Municipal
Corporation, is to
• enhance the institutional building of
the local government through
continuous training and
development of manpower and
stakeholders of the ULB,
• regularly monitor and control of the
project implementation through citizen groups (City Volunteer Technical
Corps),
• improve the citizen delivery system in accordance with the defined urban
norms,
• monitor and control the overall city governance in accordance with the
planned document under the urban rejuvenation program.
165
• Formation of City Volunteer Technical Corps (CVTC) groups based on
the categorization of citizen groups as per their professional background
such as academic, architecture,
environmental, health, journalism,
urban planning, legal, finance,
trade and so on. Involving the
members of CVTC groups through
regular interactive sessions for a
detailed discussion and feedback
on implementation of the mission
projects envisaged under the CDP.
• Conducting seminars and
workshops on important areas of urban administration and city
management, involving various stakeholders groups of the city.
• Perpetual inventory of human resource.
• Support for implementation of changing organizational and service
deliveries in accordance with the directions issued by the State and
Central Governments from time to
time.
• Preparation of important policies
in the areas of HRD.
• Designing and implementation of
concepts for improvement of
quality of service delivery by the
employees.
• Supporting the city
administration in the areas of
newly introduced concepts of
national and international importance in the areas of urban development,
environmental sustainability, poverty alleviation etc.
• Research and development by supporting the city governance in various
studies of urban development and environmental sustainability projects of
national and international
organizations, involving all the
city stakeholder groups.
• Supporting the academic
community in research and
development in the area of
sustainable urban and
environmental development.
• Preparation of study reports,
notes and presentations on the
important developmental
activities for knowledge sharing
among the council members, employees and other stakeholders within
the city and between the mission city under Peers Experience and
Reflective Learning (PEARL) program.
166
• Coordination of important projects on urban development and
environmental sustainability initiated
and handled by various
international supporting agencies
such as World Bank, Asian
Development Bank, Swedish
International Development Agency
(SIDA), Cities Development
Initiative Asia (CDIA), ICLEI for
South Asia, UNDP, UNEP, etc.
• Nomination of council members,
employees and other city
stakeholders to various capacity building programs conducted by various
training institutions in India and abroad as part of knowledge sharing and
learning best urban practices.
• Regular coordination and monitoring of various important projects in the
areas of urban development,
climate and environmental
sustainability, urban resilience,
disaster management, etc.,
grounded by the government
including various national and
international agencies, for
successful and effective
implementation.
• Documentation of MoUs, feedback
reports of important national and
international projects of city development and environmental
sustainability
No. of
No. of Total No. of
Workshops No. of
Year Training Programs/
/Interactive Trainees
Programs Sessions
sessions
2008 32 06 38 1608
2009 48 12 60 2126
2010 24 18 42 2062
2011 45 24 69 2262
2012 26 18 48 1367
2013 02 01 03 67
January
Total 177 79 260 9492
167
Employees nominated for external capacity building programs
No. of No. of
Training Employees/
Year
Programmes/ Council
Conferences members
2008 18 24
2009 38 49
2010 29 38
2011 20 24
2012 22 31
2013
January 2 2
Total 129 168
No. of
Year Study visits Team
members
2009 Coordinated study tour of council members and officials
to Stockholm, Sweden on Vizag City Sustainability
Review project.
2010 Ahmedabad, Bangalore, Mysore, and Cochin Municipal 68
Corporations
2011 • Pune, Pimpri Chinchuwad, Greater Mumbai 26
Municipal Corporations
• Coordinated Study visit to Sweden on waste to 5
energy and world water week-2011 along with
the city Mayor, and other council members and
officials of GVMC 1
• Coordinated study tour of the Commissioner to
Disaster Management training in Bangkok
168
• Coordinated Commissioner’s visit to Euro India 1
Summit in Leuven, Belgium
2012 • Coordinated study tour of the Council members 38
and floor leaders to Bangalore and Mysore
Municipal Corporations
• Coordinated Commissioner’s participation in
ICLEI Workshop on “Climate Change Adaptation
Strategies” held in Kolkatta
• Coordinated visit of the Commissioner to MUD,
New Delhi in connection with Cycling Project
• Coordinated and deputed the Commissioner and
his team members (CCP & CE) to TF-LUPG
Centre for Liveable Studies, Singapore
• Coordinated participation of the Commissioner,
in the World Urban Forum-6 in Naples, Italy.
• Coordinated and participated in the CCC in
Singapore Environment Institute, Singapore
sponsored by GIZ-CDIA
• Coordinated the study visit of the officials in the
International training program on Urban
Governance held in Stockholm, Sweden,
sponsored by Swedish Embassy, New Delhi
169
• Coordination and conducting of meetings, interactive sessions and
power point presentations in various developmental projects of global
agencies such as Swedish
Embassy, SIDA, ICLEI,
CDIA, ASCI, AIILSG, and
other State and Central
Government departments.
• Preparation of HRD
manuals, brochures and
annual books on
developmental activities
from time to time.
• Implementation of Quality
Circle concept.
• Preparation of ward profiles and assembly constituency ward profile
books for the welfare programs of the State.
• Preparation and submission of entries for Performance Awards
instituted at national and international level.
• Participation in the academic and urban development exhibitions
conducted by universities and other training institutions.
• Preparation of DPR on comprehensive capacity building and
institutional building activities.
• Documentation of Housing and Vehicle Free Zones, and
presentations to the Council members and other stakeholders.
• Coordination with the consultants for Revised CDP and Water Supply
Distribution Studies sponsored by CDIA, Manila.
• Preparation of functional operational data files for review and analysis
of the city management from time to time.
• Coordination of national and international workshops and seminars on
Solid Waste Management, housing and poverty alleviation organized
jointly by the State and Central Governments.
170
• The efficiency in local governance together with the quality,
commitment and performance levels of the employees of the local
Government have been considerably improved.
• The public health and sanitation operations have been increased
threefold in relation to the population and area of jurisdiction for the
past ten years.
The city could recover within a span of one year from the major
devastation created by a massive shock of Hud Hud Cyclone crossed
Bay of Bengal in the heart of the city during October 2014. The reasons
for attaining normalcy of urban living in the city can be attributed to
synergic effect of the efforts of the State and local Government
machinery together with the besides the inbuilt urban resilience of the
city.
The total budgetary operations have been increased from Rs.750 Crores in
2004-05 to Rs.2500 Crores in 2014-15.
• The yearly demand of internal revenue generation through property
and other taxes has been increased from Rs.85.00 Crs. in the year
2005-06 to more than Rs.180.00Crs. during the year 2014-2015.
• The total city planning operations have been increased three fold from
building plans issued for a total built up area of 4,70,000 Sq.mts in the
year 2007 to 15,00,000/- Sq.mts in 2014.
• The ICT system has been successfully implemented in respect of all
important functional operations of revenue, accounting, engineering
including smart city governance.
• The status of Visakhapatnam city has been elevated to international
city and recognized as an important Urban Resilience Centre in the
global urban map, as a result of which the city has been selected for
support to make an “International Smart and Urban Resilient City” by
the Government of United States of America.
171
Awards and Appreciations
Besides the above mentioned operational achievements, GVMC is
able to achieve the following national and international performance awards
during the period between 2008 and 2012:
• Best City Award for Internal Earmarking of Budget
for Poor under JNNURM, for the year 2008-09
from the Govt. of India
• Best City Award for BSUP under JNNURM, 2008-
09 from the Govt. of India.
• Best City Award for Implementation of Reforms in
Urban Infrastructure and Governance under
JNNURM for the year 2009-10 from the Govt. of
India
• Best City Award for Implementation of Basic
Services to Urban Poor under JNNURM for the
year 2009-10 from the Govt. of India.
• Nagar Ratna Award–2011 for Best City Reforms –
Received from Her Excellency Hon’ble President
of India, Smt. Pratibha Patil.
• Best Habitat City Award under BSUP category of
JNNURM for the year 2010-11 from the Govt. of
India.
• Euro India Award -2011 for Environmental
Sustainability, from the Euro India Centre, Leuven,
Belgium.
• National Level first prize (Gold) SKOCH Digital
Inclusion Award-2011 for IT operations in GVMC.
• JNNURM Awards for the year 2011-12 from
Government of India
• Recognition of Vizag City as “Green Economy City”
in the World Urban Forum, 2012, participated by
the Commissioner, GVMC in Italy.
• Energy savings award for implementation of LED
street lighting (2015).
• Recognition as 8th position among the 20 Smart
Cities in India by MoUD, Govt. of India (2016).
• Best Clean City Award occupying 5th position
among the best clean cities in India by MoUD, Govt.
of India (2016).
172
10. Observations
A detailed review and analysis of attaining the eligibility for support of
Smart City Reforms and achieving the higher ranks in the ‘Smart City
Challenge’ by Visakhapatnam city is taken up with the SWOT analysis. The
Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities and Threats of Visakhapatnam have
been measured in terms of quantitative and qualitative analysis and the
following observations are made. These observations are useful for future
guidance and for achieving the smart city objectives in accordance with the
expectations and standards fixed by the Govt. of India.
Strengths
• The increasing growth of urban agglomeration, vast land area
having around 46 percent of green area, more than 150 Kms long
sea coast with picturesque of green hills is the major strength of
Visakhapatnam for development as Smart city.
• The scope for land use for the targeted urban development with
necessary inbuilt urban resilience of the city is another important
factor in facing the regular environmental threats such as massive
cyclones and floods.
• The local government is able to handle the smart city challenges
with improved urban governance and support from the State and
Central Governments.
• The improved employee performance and commitment levels
together with necessary citizen participation and involvement are
other major strengths in achieving the support for smart city
development.
Weaknesses
• The major weakness of Visakhapatnam is the geographical
location of the city besides a rough Bay of Bengal sea prone to
natural disasters of cyclones with high speed gales every
monsoon season leaving huge devastation in the city and
surrounding areas.
• Absence of Inter and intra departmental coordination and
cooperation in handling the smart city challenges after grounding
the projects including efforts for coordination with global
supporting agencies such as USTDA, UNDP, World Bank ADB,
etc.
• The existing system of generation of revenues in accordance with
the annual budget estimates of capital and revenue expenditure is
to be redefined.
• Lack of financial accountability and absence of regular policy
making due to long gaps of elected city council is another setback
in launching the developmental projects and completion of the
projects.
173
Opportunities
• Visakhapatnam city has a great opportunity for smart city
development by virtue of the prevailing situation of socio-economic
conditions and its geographical location having a long sea coast
with high resilient vast urban area.
• A major urban development has already been taken place with
grounding of various developmental projects in the urban
rejuvenation mission earlier, which is providing a major opportunity
for smart city development through retrofit approach.
• The inbuilt urban resilience is providing an opportunity to face the
major threats and shocks of natural disasters.
• The city has a regular opportunity of availing support and
cooperation of the citizens, besides the administrative, technical
and financial support extended by the national and international
agencies in times of exigencies.
Threats
• A major threat for the city is always a continuous risk of natural
disasters, and absence of continuity in grounding the urban
resilience projects on account of frequent administrative changes
and discontinuation of capacity building activities.
• The other major threat is insufficient revenue generation to meet
the cost of smart city development projects associated with
absence of inter-departmental coordination and coordination with
supporting global agencies, USTDA in particular, due to
discontinuation of capacity building activities.
• Increased corruption as reported in the local press from time to
time. This may be due to diminishing accountability levels of the
part of employees in the absence of regular training programs and
inter department meets.
• Inadequate citizen response and participation for successful
grounding of smart city projects on account of absence of effective
system of coordination with citizen voluntary groups.
From the entire study, it can be concluded that there is a positive relation
between resilience and climate change, between resilience and global warming,
between resilience and risk, between resilience and between resilience and risk
based on the behavioral patterns of the human beings. The hypothesis that
urban resilience and recovery through human behavior has a positive impact on
the well being of not only entire mankind but also the entire living things on the
earth.
***
174
BIBLIOGRAPHY
********