Chapter 20: Options Markets: Introduction: Problem Sets
Chapter 20: Options Markets: Introduction: Problem Sets
Chapter 20: Options Markets: Introduction: Problem Sets
PROBLEM SETS
3. An investor who writes a call on an existing portfolio takes a covered call position.
If, at expiration, the value of the portfolio exceeds the exercise price of the call, the
writer of the covered call can expect the call to be exercised, so that the writer of
the call must sell the portfolio at the exercise price. Alternatively, if the value of the
portfolio is less than the exercise price, the writer of the call keeps both the
portfolio and the premium paid by the buyer of the call. The trade-off for the writer
of the covered call is the premium income received versus forfeit of any possible
capital appreciation above the exercise price of the call.
4. An option is out of the money when exercise of the option would be unprofitable.
A call option is out of the money when the market price of the underlying stock is
less than the exercise price of the option. If the stock price is substantially less than
the exercise price, then the likelihood that the option will be exercised is low, and
fluctuations in the market price of the stock have relatively little impact on the
value of the option. This sensitivity of the option price to changes in the price of
the stock is called the option’s delta, which is discussed in detail in Chapter 21. For
options that are far out of the money, delta is close to zero. Consequently, there is
generally little to be gained or lost by buying or writing a call that is far out of the
money. (A similar result applies to a put option that is far out of the money, with
stock price substantially greater than exercise price.)
20-1
CHAPTER 20: OPTIONS MARKETS: INTRODUCTION
A call is in the money when the market price of the stock is greater than the
exercise price of the option. If stock price is substantially greater than exercise
price, then the price of the option approaches the order of magnitude of the price of
the stock. Also, since such an option is very likely to be exercised, the sensitivity of
the option price to changes in stock price approaches one, indicating that a $1
increase in the price of the stock results in a $1 increase in the price of the option.
Under these circumstances, the buyer of an option loses the benefit of the leverage
provided by options that are near the money. Consequently, there is little interest in
options that are far in the money.
5.
Cost Payoff Profit
a. Call option, X = $145.00 $5.18 $5.00 -$0.18
b. $100.00¤$$100.00¤¤$$
Put option, X = $145.00 0.48 0.00 -0.48
c. Call option, X = $150.00 1.85 0.00 -1.85
d. Put option, X = $150.00 1.81 0.00 -1.81
e. Call option, X = $155.00 0.79 0.00 -0.79
f. Put option, X = $155.00 5.95 5.00 -0.95
20-2
CHAPTER 20: OPTIONS MARKETS: INTRODUCTION
–100
b. Purchase a straddle, i.e., both a put and a call on the stock. The total cost of the
straddle is $10 + $7.65 = $17.65
c. Buy the call, sell (write) the put, lend $50/(1.10) 1/4
20-3
CHAPTER 20: OPTIONS MARKETS: INTRODUCTION
9. a. i. A long straddle produces gains if prices move up or down and limited losses
if prices do not move. A short straddle produces significant losses if prices move
significantly up or down. A bullish spread produces limited gains if prices move
up.
b. i. Long put positions gain when stock prices fall and produce very limited
losses if prices instead rise. Short calls also gain when stock prices fall but create
losses if prices instead rise. The other two positions will not protect the portfolio
should prices fall.
10. Note that the price of the put equals the revenue from writing the call, net initial
cash outlays = $38.00
Position ST < 35 35 ST 40 40 < ST
Buy stock ST ST
X2X2XX 2X2 ST
Write call ($40) 0 0 40 - ST
Buy put ($35) 35- ST 0 0
Total $35 ST $40
20-4
CHAPTER 20: OPTIONS MARKETS: INTRODUCTION
Profit
$2
$35 $40
-$3
11. Answers may vary. For $5,000 initial outlay, buy 5,000 puts, write 5,000 calls:
12. a.
Outcome ST ≤ X ST > X
Stock ST + D ST + D
Put X – ST 0
Total X+D ST + D
b.
Outcome ST ≤ X ST > X
Call 0 ST – X
Zeros X+D X+D
Total X+D ST + D
The total payoffs for the two strategies are equal regardless of whether S T
exceeds X.
20-5
CHAPTER 20: OPTIONS MARKETS: INTRODUCTION
Therefore:
S0 + P = C + PV(X + D)
This result is identical to equation 20.2.
13. a.
Position S T < X1 X 1 S T X2 X 2 < S T X3 X3 < S T
Long call (X1) 0 S T – X1 S T – X1 S T – X1
Short 2 calls (X2) 0 0 –2(S T – X2) –2(S T – X2)
Long call (X3) 0 0 0 S T – X3
Total 0 S T – X1 2X2 – X1 – S T (X2 –X1) – (X3 –X2) = 0
Payoff
X2 – X 1
ST
X1 X2 X3
b.
Position S T < X1 X 1 S T X2 X2 < S T
Buy call (X2) 0 X2X2XX
0 2X2 S T – X2
Buy put (X1) X1 – S T 0 0
Total X1 – S T 0 S T – X2
20-6
CHAPTER 20: OPTIONS MARKETS: INTRODUCTION
Payoff
X1
ST
X1 X2
14.
Position S T < X1 X 1 S T X2 X2 < S T
Buy call (X2) 0 XX02 S T – X2
Sell call (X1) 0 –(S T – X1) –(S T – X1)
Total 0 X1 – S T X1 – X2
Payoff
0
ST
X1 X2
Payoff
–(X2 – X1)
15. a. By writing covered call options, Jones receives premium income of $30,000.
If, in January, the price of the stock is less than or equal to $45, then Jones
will have his stock plus the premium income. But the most he can have at that
time is ($450,000 + $30,000) because the stock will be called away from him
if the stock price exceeds $45. (We are ignoring here any interest earned over
this short period of time on the premium income received from writing the
option.) The payoff structure is
Stock price Portfolio value
less than $45 10,000 times stock price + $30,000
greater than $45 $450,000 + $30,000 = $480,000
This strategy offers some extra premium income but leaves Jones subject to
substantial downside risk. At an extreme, if the stock price fell to zero, Jones
20-7
CHAPTER 20: OPTIONS MARKETS: INTRODUCTION
would be left with only $30,000. This strategy also puts a cap on the final
value at $480,000, but this is more than sufficient to purchase the house.
b. By buying put options with a $35 strike price, Jones will be paying $30,000 in
premiums in order to ensure a minimum level for the final value of his
position. That minimum value is ($35 × 10,000) – $30,000 = $320,000.
This strategy allows for upside gain, but exposes Jones to the possibility of a
moderate loss equal to the cost of the puts. The payoff structure is:
Stock price Portfolio value
less than $35 $350,000 – $30,000 = $320,000
greater than $35 10,000 times stock price – $30,000
c. The net cost of the collar is zero. The value of the portfolio will be as follows:
Stock price Portfolio value
less than $35 $350,000
between $35 and $45 10,000 times stock price
greater than $45 $450,000
If the stock price is less than or equal to $35, then the collar preserves the
$350,000 principal. If the price exceeds $45, then Jones gains up to a cap
of $450,000. In between $35 and $45, his proceeds equal 10,000 times the
stock price.
The best strategy in this case would be (c) since it satisfies the two
requirements of preserving the $350,000 in principal while offering a chance
of getting $450,000. Strategy (a) should be ruled out since it leaves Jones
exposed to the risk of substantial loss of principal.
Our ranking would be: (1) strategy c; (2) strategy b; (3) strategy a.
Stock Prices
Beginning Market Profit
Price 116.5 Price
Ending Market Price 130 Ending Straddle
Buying Options: 50 42.80
Call Options Strike Price Payoff Profit Return % 60 32.80
110 22.80 20.00 -2.80 -12.28% 70 22.80
120 16.80 10.00 -6.80 -40.48% 80 12.80
130 13.60 0.00 -13.60 -100.00% 90 2.80
140 10.30 0.00 -10.30 -100.00% 100 -7.20
110 -17.20
Put Options Strike Price Payoff Profit Return % 120 -27.20
110 12.60 0.00 -12.60 -100.00% 130 -37.20
120 17.20 0.00 -17.20 -100.00% 140 -27.20
130 23.60 0.00 -23.60 -100.00% 150 -17.20
140 30.50 10.00 -20.50 -67.21% 160 -7.20
170 2.80
20-8
CHAPTER 20: OPTIONS MARKETS: INTRODUCTION
20-9
CHAPTER 20: OPTIONS MARKETS: INTRODUCTION
17. The farmer has the option to sell the crop to the government for a guaranteed
minimum price if the market price is too low. If the support price is denoted PS and
the market price Pm then the farmer has a put option to sell the crop (the asset) at
an exercise price of PS even if the price of the underlying asset (Pm) is less than PS.
18. The bondholders have, in effect, made a loan that requires repayment of B dollars,
where B is the face value of bonds. If, however, the value of the firm (V) is less
than B, the loan is satisfied by the bondholders taking over the firm. In this way,
the bondholders are forced to “pay” B (in the sense that the loan is cancelled) in
return for an asset worth only V. It is as though the bondholders wrote a put on an
asset worth V with exercise price B. Alternatively, one might view the bondholders
as giving the right to the equity holders to reclaim the firm by paying off the B
dollar debt. The bondholders have issued a call to the equity holders.
19. The manager receives a bonus if the stock price exceeds a certain value and
receives nothing otherwise. This is the same as the payoff to a call option.
20. a.
Position S T < 145 145 S T 150 S T > 150
Write call, X = $150 0 0 –(S T – 150)
Write put, X = $145 –(190 – S T) 0 0
Total S T – 145 0 150 – S T
Payoff
145 150
ST
20-10
CHAPTER 20: OPTIONS MARKETS: INTRODUCTION
If IBM sells at $160 on the option expiration date, the call option expires in
the money –cash outflow of $10, resulting in profit of:
$7.70 – $10.00 = -$2.30
c. You break even when either the put or the call results in a cash outflow of
-$1.24. For the put, this requires that:
$7.70 = $145.00 – S T S T = $137.30
For the call, this requires that:
$7.70 = S T – $150.00 S T = $157.70
d. The investor is betting that IBM stock price will have low volatility. This
position is similar to a straddle.
21. The put with the higher exercise price must cost more. Therefore, the net outlay to
establish the portfolio is positive.
5 Payoff
0
ST
90 95
Profit
22. Buy the X = 62 put (which should cost more but does not) and write the X = 60 put.
Since the options have the same price, your net outlay is zero. Your proceeds at
expiration may be positive, but cannot be negative.
20-11
CHAPTER 20: OPTIONS MARKETS: INTRODUCTION
0
ST
60 62
24. a. The following payoff table shows that the portfolio is riskless with time-T value
equal to $10:
Position S T ≤ 10 S T > 10
Buy stock ST ST
Write call, X = $10 0 –(S T – 10)
Buy put, X = $10 10 – S T 0
Total 10 10
b. Therefore, the risk-free rate is: ($10/$9.50) – 1 = 0.0526 = 5.26%
25. a., b.
20-12
CHAPTER 20: OPTIONS MARKETS: INTRODUCTION
10
Payoff
0
ST
100 110
Profit
c. The value of this portfolio generally decreases with the stock price. Therefore,
its beta is negative.
b. Sally does better when the stock price is high, but worse when the stock price
is low.
c. Sally’s strategy has greater systematic risk. Profits are more sensitive to the
value of the stock index in that case.
20-13
CHAPTER 20: OPTIONS MARKETS: INTRODUCTION
c. Breakeven occurs when the payoff offsets the initial proceeds of $6, which
occurs at stock price S T = $56. The investor must be bearish: the position does
worse when the stock price increases.
0 60
50 ST
-4 Profit
-10 Payoff
28. Buy a share of stock, write a call with X = $50, write a call with X = $60, and buy a
call with X = $110.
Position S T < 50 50 S T 60 60 < S T 110 S T > 110
Buy stock ST ST ST ST
Write call, X = $50 0 –(S T – 50) –(S T – 50) –(S T – 50)
Write call, X = $60 0 0 –(S T – 60) –(S T – 60)
20-14
CHAPTER 20: OPTIONS MARKETS: INTRODUCTION
29. a.
Position S T ≤ 1,179 S T > 1,170
Buy stock ST ST
Buy put 1,170 – S T 0
Total 1,170 ST
b. The bills plus call strategy has a greater payoff for some values of S T and
never a lower payoff. Since its payoffs are always at least as attractive and
sometimes greater, it must be more costly to purchase.
c. The initial cost of the stock plus put position is $1,350 + $9 = $1,359
The initial cost of the bills plus call position is: $1,215 + $180 = $1,395
20-15
CHAPTER 20: OPTIONS MARKETS: INTRODUCTION
Profit
Protective put
Bills plus calls
1170 1260
ST
-135
-189
d. The stock and put strategy is riskier. This strategy performs worse when the
market is down and better when the market is up. Therefore, its beta is higher.
e. Parity is not violated because these options have different exercise prices.
Parity applies only to puts and calls with the same exercise price and
expiration date.
20-16
CHAPTER 20: OPTIONS MARKETS: INTRODUCTION
CFA PROBLEMS
1. a. Donie should choose the long strangle strategy. A long strangle option
strategy consists of buying a put and a call with the same expiration date and
the same underlying asset, but different exercise prices. In a strangle strategy,
the call has an exercise price above the stock price and the put has an exercise
price below the stock price. An investor who buys (goes long) a strangle
expects that the price of the underlying asset (TRT Materials in this case) will
either move substantially below the exercise price on the put or above the
exercise price on the call. With respect to TRT, the long strangle investor
buys both the put option and the call option for a total cost of $9 and will
experience a profit if the stock price moves more than $9 above the call
exercise price or more than $9 below the put exercise price. This strategy
would enable Donie's client to profit from a large move in the stock price,
either up or down, in reaction to the expected court decision.
b. i. The maximum possible loss per share is $9, which is the total cost of the
two options ($5 + $4).
ii. The maximum possible gain is unlimited if the stock price moves outside
the breakeven range of prices.
iii. The breakeven prices are $46 and $69. The put will just cover costs if the
stock price finishes $9 below the put exercise price
(i.e., $55 − $9 = $46), and the call will just cover costs if the stock price
finishes $9 above the call exercise price (i.e., $60 + $9 = $69).
20-17
CHAPTER 20: OPTIONS MARKETS: INTRODUCTION
ii. Market conversion price is the price that an investor effectively pays for the
common stock if the convertible bond is purchased:
Market conversion price = Market price of the convertible bond/Conversion ratio
= $1,050/22
= $47.73
20-18
CHAPTER 20: OPTIONS MARKETS: INTRODUCTION
20-19