Section 6 - Torque - Tension

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 23

SECTION 6

Torque/Tension Relationship
Developing Torque

• Things you need to know


– Strength of the bolt
– Strength of the nut
– Size and pitch
– Condition of the bolt… lubed or not
Torque Definitions
TORQUE =
FORCE X DISTANCE

DISTANCE
Meter FORCE
Foot Kilogram
Newton
Pound

• Twisting effort applied to an object in order to make the object turn about
its axis of rotation
Torque Variables
Clamp
Load
10%
Thread
Friction
Under 45%
Head
Friction
45%
Strengths
• Tensile Strength = Minimum strength before the bolt breaks…
Pounds per Square Inch (psi)
• Yield Strength = Level at which the steel is permanently
deformed… no elasticity
• Proof Strength = A strength designating “usable range” for the
bolt. Think of this as yield strength with a safety factor included.
Common Bolt Strengths
Bolt Grade Tensile Yield Proof
Strength Strength Strength
Grade 5, 1” 120,000 psi 92,000 psi 85,000 psi
diameter and
under
Grade 5, 105,000 81,000 74,000
larger than 1”
diameter
Grade 8 all 150,000 130,000 120,000
diameters
Converting PSI to Pounds
• Strength in PSI x Area
• Or Pounds / Square inch x Square inches

• Area of smallest cross section of a bolt is in


the thread and is called Tensile Stress Area
Tensile Stress Area
Tensile Stress Area:
.7854(D-.9743/n)²

Appendix 6
Proof Strength Example

3/8” diameter Grade 5 Bolt


Proof Strength = 85,000 psi
Tensile Stress Area = .0775 sq. in.
85,000psi x .0775 sq. in. = 6,587.5 lbs Proof
Target Clamp Load
• 75% of Proof Strength of a bolt
– There is significant error or inconsistency in torque which requires the
target load to be lower than the proof strength to insure that the bolt
isn’t over tightened
• Thus for 3/8” Grade 5. Proof Strength of 6,587.5lbs x 75% =
4,940 lbs target clamp load
Torque Formula

T=KDF
K = Nut Factor (dimensionless)
D = Bolt Diameter
F = Desired Bolt Tension (75% of Proof load)

The K factor will be the major player in torque variability


Variables that Affect K
• Lubricant; type, amount, method of application, contamination,
temperature, etc.
• Number of times the fastener was used
• Which is torqued; the nut or the bolt
• Plating; thickness and type
• Class of thread fit
• Type of tool used for installation
• Speed of tightening
• Washers; present or not
• Hardness of all parts
Estimated K Values
Bolt Condition K
Non-Plated, Black Finish 0.20 - 0.30
Zinc-Plated 0.18 - 0.25
Lubricated (oil) 0.15
Cadmium-Plated 0.11 - 0.15
Thread Locker 0.16 - 0.18
Ecoguard 0.12 - 0.14
Torque Formula Example
Grade 5, 3/8-16x 2-1/2, zinc-plated
Torque = KDF
D = 0.375 in.
F = 75% of the Proof Load = 4940 lbs..
K = 0.20
Torque = 0.375in. x 4940 lbs. x 0.20
Torque = 370 in-lbs. = 31 ft-lbs.
Torque Charts A7-A10
Tensile SAE J429 Grade 5 SAE J429 Grade 8
threads
Nominal Stress
per
Dia. (in.) Area Clamp Tightening Torque Clamp Tightening Torque
inch
(sq. in.) Load K = 0.15 K = 0.17 K = 0.20 Load K = 0.15 K = 0.17 K = 0.20
(Lbs.) (ft-lbs) (ft-lbs) (ft-lbs) (Lbs.) (ft-lbs) (ft-lbs) (ft-lbs)
Unified Coarse Thread Series
1/4 20 0.0318 2029 6 7 8 2864 9 10 12
5/16 18 0.0524 3342 13 15 17 4719 18 21 25
3/8 16 0.0775 4940 23 26 31 6974 33 37 44
7/16 14 0.1063 6777 37 42 49 9568 52 59 70
1/2 13 0.1419 9046 57 64 75 12771 80 90 106
5/8 11 0.2260 14408 113 128 150 20340 159 180 212
3/4 10 0.3345 21322 200 227 267 30101 282 320 376
7/8 9 0.4617 29436 322 365 429 41556 455 515 606
1 8 0.6057 38616 483 547 644 54517 681 772 909
1 1/4 7 0.9691 53786 840 952 1121 87220 1363 1545 1817
1 1/2 6 1.4053 77991 1462 1657 1950 126473 2371 2688 3162
Issues With Torque
• Without a lubricant, the actual torque to clamp load relationship
is not very accurate!
• Actual loads can vary +/- 25%
• Bolts can be “accidentally” lubricated by oil or grease on the
installers hands from other jobs or even the pizza or fried
chicken from lunch
Clamp Load
Clamp load is what is important, torque
is just an inaccurate way of trying to
achieve proper clamping force

Using a fastener with “Pizza Grease” from


lunch on threads could result in cutting the
required torque in half compared to the non-
lubricated torque suggestion!
Same Example Gone Wrong
Using 31 ft-lbs. on a fastener that was excessively lubricated, reducing
the K to 0.13.
If Torque = K D F, then
F = Torque / K D, or
Load = 31 ft-lbs. / (0.13)(0.375 in.)
Load = 7600 lbs. = 98,000 PSI

This is 6,000 lbs. above the yield strength of the bolt!


Other Potential Issues
• High speed installation created heat and thus
more friction and if bolts are not lubricated,
the required torque would increase
• Most high speed tightening methods do not
control torque! This includes impact
wrenches, drills and drivers etc.
• Hand wrenches are most accurate
Other Tightening Methods
• Turn of Wrench (angle of turn)
• Bolt Stretch (ultrasonic equipment)
• Tension Control Bolts
• Load indicating washers
• Special load indicating bolts (very expensive)
Cross Talk-Defined
Cross Talk
Four Bolt Pattern:
1 Tightening of sequence 1,
3,2,4 will result in a lower
residual torque reading in 1
and 3 due to the crossing
of the clamp load pattern
4 2 with 2 and 4.

3
Torque Recap
• Nut strength (proof) should always be equal or greater than bolt
strength so if anything fails it will be the bolt
• Use appropriate torque chart for size and strength of bolt being
used
• Always use a lubricant and a lubricated torque value. Any
lubricant is better than nothing. Pre-applied lubricants can be
put on bolts
End of Section 6

You might also like