Overture Essay
Overture Essay
Overture Essay
19th century.
The origins of the concert overture can be found in overtures to works of theatre such as
Beethoven’s Egmont (1787) and Coriolan (1807), often performed in concert halls divorced from
the theatrical setting which has now been largely forgotten. This gave way to the concert overture:
a work that depicts a source such as a literary theme as a programmatic piece intended for
performance in concert hall only. Mendelssohn’s A Midsummers Night’s Dream (1826) is largely
considered to be the first concert overture, depicting a play written by Shakespeare. Though not
intended for the theatre, the piece depicts elements of the play programmatically such as the use
of shimmering strings to depict fantasy elements like goblins and fairies. Another work by
Mendelssohn, his Hebrides Overture (1830), is a concert overture that combines a well known
structure, the mood of an opera and the artist’s interpretation of the external world. This is evident
as Mendelssohn changed the development section, saying it ‘tasted more of counterpoint than of
rain oil, gulls and salted cod. The success of this piece could be attributed in part to the rise of
popularity within the concert overture, inspiring composers to continue this genre of writing.
Berlioz Les Francs Juges (1826), uses a diverse range of techniques for mood painting to convey
the narrative, making use of a 3/4 timpani passage over the orchestra playing in 4/4, majestic
brass themes, and blasts from percussion instruments, conveying fury and mystery. Berlioz’s later
work Roman Carnival Overture (1843) is an excellent example of how the concert overture used a
fairly well known structure: principle subject, subsidiary subject, recapitulation, and a coda to end
the work. This said, within the structure are certain features such as the fragmentation of themes
starting the recapitulation, to fit the programmatic nature of the piece.
Three main features can be seen within the symphonic (or tone) poem: it combines the structure
of multiple symphonic movements into one, it relates to outside sources, and it has an elevated
instrumental programme giving it a similar level of importance to opera. Liszt’s Les Préludes
(1854), the third of his 12 symphonic poems is evident of this, with Hugh MacDonald stating that
Liszt’s intent was ‘to display the knowledge of traditional symphonic thought’. Symphonic poems
also related to symphonic writing in that they had similar tonal landscapes and the works
compared in size to the movement of a symphony, in some cases a full symphony. Smetna’s
Vltava (1875) is a symphonic poem from his six work cycle Má vlast that shows how the
programmatic nature of the work often dictated the structure in this case depicting the course of
the river Moldau, emerging from two springs then unifying as a single current. Liszt’s Héroïde
Funèbre (1854), described as a ‘Heroic Elegy’ is programatic in its depiction of pain, death and
futility of war using hymn and anthems to depict various people. Similarly, Schoenberg’s Verklärte
Nacht (1899) is described by Schoenberg as ‘programme music’ illustrating a poem by Richard
Dehmel.
Though the concert overture and Symphonic poem are similar in many ways, such as their mood
painting, programmatic depictions, influence from external sources such as literature and nature,
and their settings as a concert work. There are some fundamental differences such as the use of
structure, in which the concert overture uses more traditional structures whereas the symphonic
poem uses a structure to fit the programmatic nature of the work. Another difference is the scale
of the work, the symphonic poem considered to be of a larger scale.