Faiz Febrianto (24844) 29 December 2016

COMPARISON CALYA, SIGRA, YR9 AND YL8

1. Purpose
Comparison Calya, Sigra, YR9 and YL8 to get information about cost, weight, engine type,
transmission type and chasis type.

2. Abstract
1) Price and weight comparison
2) Dimension comparison
3) Transmission and engine comparison
4) Chassis comparison

3. Details
1) Price and weight comparison
- Detail of comparison is shown by the table below:

- The most expensive for M/T car is YL8(GX) and the cheapest is YR9(GA).
- The most expensive for A/T car is YL8(GX) and the cheapest is YR9(GL).
- The heaviest for M/T car is YL8(GL,GX) and the lightest is YR9(GA).
- The heaviest for A/T car is YL8(GL,GX) and the lightest is YR9(GL).
2) Dimension Comparison

● YL8 has the largest length and the smallest one is YR9.
● YL8 has the largest width and the smallest one is YR9.
● YR9 (GL) has the largest height and the smallest one are Calya and Sigra.
● YL8 has the largest wheelbase and the smallest one is YR9.
● YL8 has the largest ground clearance and the smallest one is YR9.

3) Transmission and engine comparison

4) Chassis comparison
 CALYA
Type G
M/T
Price (Rp) 138000000
Dimension
Length (mm) 4,070
Width (mm) 1,655
Height (mm) 1,600
Wheelbase (mm) 2,525
Front Tread (mm) 630
Rear Tread (mm) 915
Ground Clearance (mm) 180
Curb Weight (kg) 975
Chasis
Transmition 5-Speed Manual
1st Gear Ratio 3.417
2nd Gear Ratio 1.96
3rd Gear Ratio 1.25
4th Gear Ratio
0.917

5th Gear Ratio 0.707

Reverse Gear Ratio 3.143
Final Gear Ratio 5.077
Front Suspension
MacPherson Strut with
Coil Spring and Stabilizer

Rear Suspension
Semi Independent
Torsion Axle Beam with
Coil Spring and Stabilizer

Front Brake Ventilated Disc

Rear Brake Drum
Additional Brake System ABS
Steering Gear Rack and Pinion
Tires Size 175/65R14 Two-Tone
Machining Alloy
Machine
Seri Mesin / Machine Serial 3NR
Tipe Mesin / Engine Type In-line 4 Cylinder, 16
Valve, DOHC, Dual VVT-i
Isi Silinder / Displacement (cc) 1,197

Diameter x Langkah / Bore X 72.5 x 72.5

Stroke (mm)
Daya Maksimum / Maximum 88 / 6,000
Output (Ps/rpm)
Torsi Maksimum / Maximum 11 / 4,200
Torque (Kgm/rpm)
Kapasitas Tangki / Fuel 36
Capacity (liter)
Steering (Power Steering) Electronic Power Steering
(EPS)
 CALYA
G E D
A/T M/T A/T M/T
150000000 132450000 145450000 106600000

4,070 4,070 4,070 4,070

1,655 1,655 1,655 1,655
1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600
2,525 2,525 2,525 2,525
630 630 630 1470
915 915 915 1475
180 180 180 180
1000 975 1000 935

4-Speed Automatic 5-Speed Manual 4-Speed Automatic

2.731 3.417 2.731
1.526 1.96 1.526
1 1.25 1

0.696 0.917 0.696

- 0.707 -
2.29 3.143 2.29
4.839 5.077 4.839

MacPherson Strut with MacPherson Strut with MacPherson Strut with

Coil Spring and Stabilizer Coil Spring and Stabilizer Coil Spring and Stabilizer

Semi Independent Semi Independent Semi Independent

Torsion Axle Beam with Torsion Axle Beam with Torsion Axle Beam with
Coil Spring and Stabilizer Coil Spring Coil Spring

Ventilated Disc Ventilated Disc Ventilated Disc

Drum Drum Drum
ABS ABS ABS
Rack and Pinion Rack and Pinion Rack and Pinion
175/65R14 Two-Tone 175/65R14 Two-Tone 175/65R14 Two-Tone
Machining Alloy Machining Alloy Machining Alloy

3NR 3NR 3NR

In-line 4 Cylinder, 16 In-line 4 Cylinder, 16 In-line 4 Cylinder, 16
Valve, DOHC, Dual VVT-i Valve, DOHC, Dual VVT-i Valve, DOHC, Dual VVT-i
 1,197 1,197 1,197

72.5 x 72.5 72.5 x 72.5 72.5 x 72.5

88 / 6,000 88 / 6,000 88 / 6,000

11 / 4,200 11 / 4,200 11 / 4,200

36 36 36

Electronic Power Steering Electronic Power Steering Electronic Power Steering

(EPS) (EPS) (EPS)
 SIGRA
M X
M/T M/T M/T (Deluxe) A/T M/T
115500000 124850000 130350000 137650000 130750000

4,070 4,070 4,070 4,070 4,070

1,655 1,655 1,655 1,655 1,655
1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600 1,600
2,525 2,525 2,525 2,525 2,525
1470 1470 1470 1470 1470
1475 1475 1475 1475 1475
180 180 180 180 180
935 965 965 985 965
 Y
R GA GL
M/T (Deluxe) A/T A/T (Deluxe) M/T M/T
134550000 143550000 147350000 103000000 115,500,000

4,070 4,070 4,070 3,600 3,600

1,655 1,655 1,655 1,475 1,475
1,600 1,600 1,600 1,670 1,700
2,525 2,525 2,525 2,400 2,400
1470 1470 1470 1295 1295
1475 1475 1475 1290 1290
180 180 180 170 170
965 990 990 825 830

Karimun Wagon R GA Airbag

Karimun Wagon R GL Airbag

Karimun Wagon R GS Airbag
Karimun Wagon R BLIND VAN Airbag

Karimun Wagon R GL AGS Airbag

Karimun Wagon R GS AGS Airbag

 YR9
GL GS
A/T M/T M/T (Blind Van) A/T
124,000,000 124,500,000 115,800,000 133,000,000

3,600 3,635 3,635 3,635

1,475 1,475 1,475 1,475
1,700 1,670 1,670 1,670
2,400 2,400 2,400 2,400
1295 1295 1295 1295
1290 1290 1290 1290
170 170 170 170
835 835 835 840

Rp 103,000,000,-
SALES HARGA ON
GROUP MODEL
MODEL THE ROAD
Rp 115,500,000,- New Ertiga Airbag GA Rp 184,000,000,-
Rp 124,500,000,- New Ertiga Airbag GL M/T Rp 200,500,000,-
Rp 115,800,000,- New Ertiga Airbag ABS GX M/T Rp. 212.000.000,-

Rp 124,000,000,- New Ertiga Airbag GL A/T Rp 213,000,000,-

Rp 133,000,000,- New Ertiga Airbag ABS GX A/T Rp. 224.500.000

 PESIFIKASI
D M X R

Spesifikasi Teknis MT MT AT MT

Dimensi

Panjang x Lebar x Tinggimm 4070 x 1655 x 1600

Jarak Sumbu Rodamm 2.525

Jarak Pijak Roda Depanmm 1.47

Jarak Pijak Roda Belakangmm 1.475

Tinggi dari Tanahmm 180

Kapasitas Penumpang 7 Orang

Radius Putar Minimumm 4,5

Berat Kosong/Berat Total 965/1.50 985/1.50 965/1.50

Kendaraankg 935/1.480 0 0 0
Mesin
1KR-VE, DOHC
Tipe VVT-i 3NR-VE, DOHC Dual VVT-i
Kapasitas Mesincc 998 1.197
Jumlah Silinder 3 - Segaris 4 - Segaris
Jumlah Katup 12 16

Diameter x Langkah 71,0 x 84,0 72,5 x 72x5

Tenaga MaksimumPS/rpm 67/6.000 88/6.000

Torsi MaksimumNM/rpm 89/4.400 108/4.200

Sistem Bahan Bakar EFI

Jenis Bahan Bakar Bensin tanpa timbal
Kapasitas Tangki Bahan
BakarLiter 36
Transmisi
 Otomatis Manual,
,4- 5-
Kecepat Kecepat
Tipe Manual, 5 - Kecepatan Maju an Maju an Maju
Perbandingan Roda Gigi I 3,417 3,417 2,731 3,417
Perbandingan Roda Gigi II 1,960 1,960 1,526 1,960
Perbandingan Roda Gigi III 1,250 1,250 1,000 1,250
Perbandingan Roda Gigi IV 0,865 0,917 0,696 0,917
Perbandingan Roda Gigi V 0,707 0,707 - 0,707
Perbandingan Roda Gigi R 3,143 3,143 2,290 3,143
Rasio Gigi Akhir 5,545 5,077 4,839 5,077
Sistem Kemudi
Tipe Rack & Pinion dengan Electric Power Steering

Sistem Pengereman
Ventilated Disc Brake / Drum, Leading - Trailing / Mekanis
Depan / Belakang / Rem Parkir pada Roda Belakang
Suspension
Depan / Belakang MacPherson Strut / Semi Independent Torsion Axle Beam
Ban
155/80
Ukuran R13 175/65 R14 175/65 R14
Velg Steel Polished Alloy
Ukuran - V -
 SIGR 1.0 D Rp
R A M/T 106.600.000
SIGR 1.0 M Rp
AT A M/T 115.500.000
SIGR 1.2 X Rp
A M/T 124.850.000
1.2 X
SIGR M/T Rp
A DELUXE 130.350.000

SIGR Rp
2.525 A 1.2 X A/T 137.650.000

SIGR 1.2 X A/T Rp

1.47 A DELUXE 143.150.000

SIGR Rp
1.475 A 1.2 R M/T 130.750.000

SIGR 1.2 R M/T Rp

180 A DELUXE 134.550.000

SIGR Rp
A 1.2 R A/T 143.550.000

SIGR 1.2 R A/T Rp

A DELUXE 147.350.000

990/1.57
0

ual VVT-i
1.197

16

36
 Otomatis
,4-
Kecepat
an Maju
2,731
1,526
1,000
0,696
-
2,290
4,839

Steering

- Trailing / Mekanis

Torsion Axle Beam

175/65 R14
Polished Alloy
-
 R R GS
Panjang Keseluruhan 3.600 mm 3.635 mm
Lebar Keseluruhan 1.475 mm 1.475 mm
Tinggi Keseluruhan 1.670 - 1.700 mm 1.670 mm
Jarak Poros Roda 2.400 mm 2.400 mm
Jarak Pijak Depan 1.295 mm 1.295 mm
Jarak Pijak Belakang 1.290 mm 1.290 mm
Jarak Terendah 170 mm 170 mm
Radius Putar Minimum 4.6 m 4.6 m
Type

G E

M/T A/T M/T A/T

Price (Rp)
138.000.000150.000.000 132.450.000 145.450.000
 PRICE (IDR)
CAR TYPE
M/T A/T
G 138000000 150000000
CALYA
E 132450000 145450000
D 106600000 -
M 115500000 -
X 124850000 137650000
SIGRA
X (Deluxe) 130350000 -
R 130750000 143550000
R (Deluxe) 134550000 147350000
GA 103000000 -
GL 115500000 124000000
YR9
GS 124500000 133000000
GS (Blind van) 115800000 -
GA 184000000 -
YL8 GL 200500000 213000000
GX 212000000 224500000
Maximum 212000000 224500000
Minimum 103000000 124000000
 D M X

M/T M/T M/T (Deluxe)

106.600.000 115.500.000 124.850.000 130.350.000

PRICE

CALYA SIGRA
230000000

210000000

190000000

170000000

150000000
IDR

130000000

110000000

90000000
E ) ) GL n)
G D M X xe R xe GA GS va
le u le u d
(D (D Bl
in
X R (
GS
 150000000

IDR
130000000

110000000

90000000
E ) ) GL n)
G D M X xe R xe GA GS
le u le u va
d
(D (D Bl
in
X R (
GS

CURB WEIGHT (Kg)

M/T A/T
975 1000
975 1000
935 -
935 -
965 985
965 -
965 990
965 990
825 -
830 835
835 840
835 -
1155 -
1175 1185
1175 1185
1175 1185
825 835
X R

A/T M/T M/T (Deluxe) A/T A/T (Deluxe)

137.650.000 130.750.000 134.550.000 143.550.000 147.350.000

PRICE

YR9 YL8

M/T
A/T
Column H

) GL n) GL
xe GA GS va GA GX
le u d
(D Bl
in
(
GS
 Column H

) GL n) GL
xe GA GS GA GX
le u va
d
(D Bl
in
(
GS
Karimu GA Rp
n Airbag 103,000, HAR
Wagon 000,- GRO SALE GA
R
UP S ON
MOD MOD THE
EL EL ROA
D
Karimu GL Rp New GA Rp
n Airbag 115,500, Ertiga 184,000,
Wagon 000,- Airbag 000,-
R
Karimu GS Rp New GL M/T Rp
n Airbag 124,500, Ertiga 200,500,
Wagon 000,- Airbag 000,-
R
Karimu BLIND Rp New GX M/T Rp.
n VAN 115,800, Ertiga 212.000.
Wagon Airbag 000,- Airbag 000,-
R ABS

Karimu GL AGS Rp New GL A/T Rp

n Airbag 124,000, Ertiga 213,000,
Wagon 000,- Airbag 000,-
R
Karimu GS AGS Rp New GX A/T Rp.
n Airbag 133,000, Ertiga 224.500.
Wagon 000,- Airbag 000
R ABS
Type

G E

M/T A/T M/T A/T

Price (Rp)
138.000.000150.000.000 132.450.000
145.450.000

CURB WEIGHT (Kg)

CAR TYPE
M/T A/T
G 975 1000
CALYA
E 975 1000
D 935 -
M 935 -
X 965 985
SIGRA
X (Deluxe) 965 -
R 965 990
R (Deluxe) 965 990
GA 825 -
GL 830 835
YR9
GS 835 840
GS (Blind van) 835 -
GA 1,155 -
YL8 GL 1,175 1,185
GX 1,175 1,185
 D M X

M/T M/T M/T (Deluxe) A/T

106.600.000 115.500.000 124.850.000 130.350.000 137.650.000

Crub Weight

1200

CALYA SIGRA YR9

1000

800

600
Kg

400

200
 600

Kg
400

200

0
G E D M X X (Deluxe) R R (Deluxe) GA GL GS GS (Blind va
 Karimu
n
Wagon
R
R

Karimu
M/T M/T (Deluxe) A/T A/T (Deluxe) n
Wagon
R
Karimu
130.750.000 134.550.000 143.550.000 147.350.000 n
Wagon
R
Karimu
n
Wagon
R

Karimu
n
Wagon
R
Karimu
n
Wagon
R

ight

YR9 YL8

M/T
A/T
 M/T
A/T

) GA GL GS GS (Blind van) GA GL GX
GA Rp
Airbag 103,000, HAR
000,- GRO SALE GA
UP S ON
MOD MOD THE
EL EL ROA
D
GL Rp New GA Rp
Airbag 115,500, Ertiga 184,000,
000,- Airbag 000,-
GS Rp New GL M/T Rp
Airbag 124,500, Ertiga 200,500,
000,- Airbag 000,-
BLIND Rp New GX M/T Rp.
VAN 115,800, Ertiga 212.000.
Airbag 000,- Airbag 000,-
ABS

GL AGS Rp New GL A/T Rp

Airbag 124,000, Ertiga 213,000,
000,- Airbag 000,-
GS AGS Rp New GX A/T Rp.
Airbag 133,000, Ertiga 224.500.
000,- Airbag 000
ABS
 TRANSMISSION
CAR TYPE
M/T A/T
G 5-Speed Manual 4-Speed Automatic
CALYA
E 5-Speed Manual 4-Speed Automatic

D 5-Speed Manual -

M 5-Speed Manual -

SIGRA X 5-Speed Manual 4-Speed Automatic

X (Deluxe) 5-Speed Manual -

R 5-Speed Manual 4-Speed Automatic
R (Deluxe) 5-Speed Manual 4-Speed Automatic
GA 5-Speed Manual -

GL 5-Speed Manual 5-Speed AGS

YR9
GS 5-Speed Manual 5-Speed AGS
GS (Blind van) 5-Speed Manual -
GA 5-Speed Manual -

YL8 GL 5-Speed Manual 4-Speed Automatic

GX 5-Speed Manual 4-Speed Automatic

ENGINE
CAR TYPE
M/T A/T
G In-line 4 Cylinder, DOHC, Dual VVT-
CALYA
E i, 1197 cc
In-line 3
D -
Cylinder, 1KR-
VE, DOHC VVT-
M -
i, 998 cc
SIGRA X
In-line 3 Cylinder, 3NR-VE, DOHC
Dual VVT-i
SIGRA
X (Deluxe) In-line 3 Cylinder, 3NR-VE, DOHC
R Dual VVT-i
R (Deluxe)
GA -
In-line 3
GL Cylinder, K10B , In-line 3 Cylinder,
YR9 K10B , DOHC
DOHC VVT-i,
GS VVT-i, 998 cc
998 cc
GS (Blind van) -
GA In-line 4 -

GL Cylinder, K14B , In-line 4 Cylinder,

YL8
DOHC VVT-i, K14B , DOHC
GX 1.373 cc VVT-i, 1.373 cc
 ENGINE FUEL SYSTEM
M/T A/T M/T A/T
In-line 4 Cylinder, DOHC, Dual VVT-
EFI
i, 1197 cc

In-line 3 Cylinder, - -
1KR-VE, DOHC EFI
VVT-i, 998 cc - -

In- Line 4
cylinders DOHC EFI
In- Line 4 Dual VVT-i
cylinders DOHC - EFI -
Dual VVT-i
In- Line 4
cylinders DOHC EFI
Dual VVT-i
- -

In-line 3 Cylinder, In-line 3 Cylinder,

K10B , DOHC K10B , DOHC MPI MPI
VVT-i, 998 cc VVT-i, 998 cc

- -
- -
In-line 4 Cylinder,
K14B , DOHC In-line 4 Cylinder, MPI
VVT-i, 1.373 cc K14B , DOHC MPI
VVT-i, 1.373 cc
 FRONT SUSPENSION
CAR TYPE
M/T A/T
G
MacPherson Strut
CALYA
with coil and stabilizer
E
D -
M -

MacPherson
X
Strut
MacPherson
SIGRA
Strut
X (Deluxe) -

R
MacPherson
Strut
R (Deluxe)

GA -
GL MacPherson MacPherson
YR9
GS Strut Strut
GS (Blind van) -
GA -
MacPherson
YL8 GL MacPherson
Strut
GX Strut

TRANSMISSION
CAR TYPE
M/T A/T
G 5-Speed Manual
4-Speed Automatic
CALYA
E 5-Speed Manual
4-Speed Automatic
D 5-Speed Manual -
M 5-Speed Manual -
X 5-Speed Manual
4-Speed Automatic
SIGRA
X (Deluxe) 5-Speed Manual -
R 5-Speed Manual
4-Speed Automatic
SIGRA

R (Deluxe) 5-Speed Manual

4-Speed Automatic
GA 5-Speed Manual -
GL 5-Speed Manual5-Speed AGS
YR9 GS 5-Speed Manual5-Speed AGS
GS (Blind van) 5-Speed Manual -
GA 5-Speed Manual -
YL8 GL 5-Speed Manual
4-Speed Automatic
GX 5-Speed Manual
4-Speed Automatic
 REAR SUSPENSION FRONT BREAK REAR BREAK
M/T A/T M/T A/T M/T A/T
Semi independent torsion axle
beam with coil spring and
Ventilated disc Drum
stabilizer
with coil and stabilizer
-
-
Semi
independent
Semi torsion axle
independent beam Ventilated disc Drum, leading-
torsion axle brake trailing
beam -
Semi
independent
torsion axle
beam
-
3 Link rigid 3 Link rigid Ventilated disc Drum
-
-
Drum,
Torsion beam Ventilated disc
Torsion beam leading-trailing

d Automatic
d Automatic

d Automatic

d Automatic
d Automatic

d Automatic
d Automatic
 FRONT SUSPENSION
CAR TYPE
M/T A/T
G MacPherson Strut
CALYA
E with coil and stabilizer
D -
M -
X MacPherson Strut
SIGRA MacPherson Strut
X (Deluxe) -
R
MacPherson Strut
SIGRA MacPherson Strut

MacPherson Strut
R (Deluxe)
GA -
GL
MacPherson Strut
YR9 GS MacPherson Strut
GS (Blind van) -
GA -
YL8 GL MacPherson Strut
MacPherson Strut
GX
 REAR SUSPENSION
CAR
M/T A/T
Semi independent torsion axle beam with coil spring and stabilizer
CALYA
with coil and stabilizer
-
-
Semi independent Semi independent torsion axle beam
SIGRA
torsion axle beam -
Semi independent torsion axle beam
Semi independent
SIGRA
torsion axle beam

Semi independent torsion axle beam

-
3 Link rigid
3 Link rigid YR9
-
-
Torsion beam YL8
Torsion beam
 FRONT BREAK REAR BREAK
TYPE
M/T A/T M/T
G Ventilated disc
Drum
E with coil and stabilizer
D -
M -
X Ventilated disc brake
Ventilated disc brake Drum, leading-trailing
X (Deluxe) -
R
Ventilated disc brake
 Ventilated disc brake Drum, leading-trailing

Ventilated disc brake

R (Deluxe)
GA -
GL
Ventilated disc
GS Ventilated disc Drum
GS (Blind
-
van)
GA -
GL Ventilated disc Drum, leading-trailing
Ventilated disc
GX
REAR BREAK
A/T
Drum
-
-
Drum, leading-trailing
-
Drum, leading-trailing
Drum, leading-trailing
-
Drum

-
-
Drum, leading-trailing
 LENGTH (mm) WIDTH (mm) HEIGHT (mm)
CAR TYPE
M/T A/T M/T A/T M/T A/T
G 4070 4070 1655 1655 1600 1600
CALYA
E 4070 4070 1655 1655 1600 1600
D 4070 - 1655 - 1600 -
M 4070 - 1655 - 1600 -
X 4070 4070 1655 1655 1600 1600
SIGRA
X (Deluxe) 4070 - 1655 - 1600 -
R 4070 4070 1655 1655 1600 1600
R (Deluxe) 4070 4070 1655 1655 1600 1600
GA 3600 - 1475 - 1670 -
GL 3600 3600 1475 1475 1700 1700
YR9
GS 3635 3635 1475 1475 1670 1670
GS (Blind van) 3635 - 1475 - 1670 -
GA 4265 - 1695 - 1685 -
YL8 GL 4265 4265 1695 1695 1685 1685
GX 4265 4265 1695 1695 1685 1685
Maximum 4265 4265 1695 1695 1700 1700
Minimum 3600 3600 1475 1475 1600 1600
WHEELBASE (mm) GRD CLEARANCE (mm)
M/T A/T M/T A/T
2525 2525 180 180
2525 2525 180 180
2525 - 180 -
2525 - 180 -
2525 2525 180 180
2525 - 180 -
2525 2525 180 180
2525 2525 180 180
2400 - 170 -
2400 2400 170 170
2400 2400 170 170
2400 - 170 -
2740 - 185 -
2740 2740 185 185
2740 2740 185 185
2740 2740 185 185
2400 2400 170 170