Republic of The Philippines Manila: Eleventh Division
Republic of The Philippines Manila: Eleventh Division
Republic of The Philippines Manila: Eleventh Division
MANILA
ELEVENTH DIVISION
GUEVARA-SALONGA, J.,
-versus- Chairperson,
ROXAS, V. Q., and
GARCIA, R. R., JJ.:
HON. ARTEMIO S. TIPON,
Presiding Judge of the Regional Promulgated:
Trial Court, Branch 46, Manila,
and BENEDICTO D. LIM,
Respondents. _________________
x---------------------------------x
DECISION
GARCIA, R. R, J.:
THE CASE
1
Vide: Amended Petition for Certiorari; Rollo, pp. 119-131
2
Rollo, pp. 16-17
3
Rollo, pp. 143-147
CA G.R. SP No. 67282 2
Decision
THE FACTS
SO ORDERED.6
6
Rollo, p. 52
7
Rollo, pp. 219-221
8
Rollo, p. 223
9
Rollo, pp. 224-226
10
Rollo, pp. 231-232
11
Rollo, pp. 233-235
CA G.R. SP No. 67282 4
Decision
SO ORDERED.13
12
Supra at Note 3
13
Rollo, pp. 146-147
CA G.R. SP No. 67282 5
Decision
14
Rollo, pp. 282-283
CA G.R. SP No. 67282 6
Decision
IT IS SO ORDERED.15
15
Rollo, pp. 16-17
CA G.R. SP No. 67282 7
Decision
II
THE ISSUE
effect because such action will impair its rights under the old rules
and is contrary to the principles of equity and justice.
20
Semirara Coal Corp. v. HGL Development Corp., G.R. No. 166854, December 6, 2006
CA G.R. SP No. 67282 10
Decision
21
First Global Realty & Dev't. Corp. v. San Agustin, G.R. No. 144499, February 19, 2002
22
Sps. Estares v. Court of Appeals, G.R. No. 144755, June 8, 2005
CA G.R. SP No. 67282 11
Decision
SO ORDERED.
RAMON R. GARCIA
Associate Justice
WE CONCUR:
CERTIFICATION
JOSEFINA GUEVARA-SALONGA
Associate Justice
Chairperson, Eleventh Division