1 - Globalization and Intercultural Management

1 Globalization and Intercultural
Management
1.0 Statement of the problem

Globalization and Business issues
(Julia Serdyuk)
Globalization eliminates the boundaries between the countries and provides new opportu-
nities for business: want to open a subsidiary in Egypt? Go ahead! Want to sell your shoes
of high quality in Kazakhstan? You can try! However, as the reality shows, it is not that
simple and in many cases cultural differences, including differences in management style,
can prevent the success of a joint venture.
In spite of all the differences between business cultures, we cannot neglect certain common
grounds that constitute business in general. For example, each business deals with profit-
orientation, professional development of staff, etc. And, thanks to globalization, today var-
ious countries can share and learn from each other in order to adopt new elements in their
own operation. For example, Japanese companies now seem to be picking up lessons from
American management to become more flexible and less avoiding uncertainty; American
companies are learning best practices from their counterparts in other parts of the world,
especially from Japan.
Having been off the market for many years, and under the pressure of “command” authori-
ty, Russia had difficulties to enter the world market. While globalization was already in-
volving all other countries, it did not “touch” Russian business and management style until
the 90’s, when the country started reforming its own business style. Now, Russia consti-
tutes a part of the business world and is interconnected with the world system. Russia
adopted some well-known management models as well as developed its own business
strategies. What model of business style has Russia chosen? It is hard to define the model
itself, as it is still being developed, but we can characterize Russian management style as
more autocratic than democratic. Although the tendency in management here is to get
more people-oriented, less “power-oriented”, employees get more and more appreciation
for their knowledge, experience, and creativity. They are also given more choices and re-
sponsibilities at the workplace. I think, this indicates the development of a new manage-
ment style, which has more similarities with American and European ones.
Unauthenticated
Download Date | 3/24/16 10:17 AM
2 1 Globalization and Intercultural Management
To summarize, globalization provides many opportunities as well as challenges in busi-

ness. In order to better utilize the opportunities for different countries to operate success-
fully, under the conditions of cultural diversity, we need to go beyond our cultural stereo-
types. Curiosity, openness and striving to reach mutual understanding should become good
features for intercultural management. We can learn a lot from each other, but we need to
learn to be tolerant and respectful to all the differences we face, when we do business to-
gether.
In: Cross-Cultural Blog: management style and globalization, in web:

http://web.stanford.edu/group/ccr/blog/2009/02/globalization_and_business_iss.html, ac-
cessed 23/06/2014
1.1 “The Global Challenge”

Every day we hear it on the news, read it in the papers, overhear people talking about it, and
in every single instance the word “globalization” seems to have a different meaning. So,
what is globalization?
At the political and economic level, globalization is the process of denationalization of mar-
kets, politics and legal systems; it is the rise of global economy. At the business level, the
process of globalization is when companies decide to take part in the emerging global econ-
omy and establish themselves in foreign markets. They adapt their products or services to the
linguistic and cultural requirements of different nations. Then, they might take advantage of
the Internet revolution and establish a virtual presence on the international marketplace. E-
commerce has changed traditional business practices by providing direct international access
to information and products.
Whatever their industry or country of origin, all companies are facing the same challenge to
a greater or lesser degree: globalization. It is becoming more and more evident that compa-
nies need to plan ahead and anticipate coming developments if they are to be successful in
the future. Ecological matters have gained in importance at the turn of the century. Climate
change is perceived as the biggest challenge to mankind and affects all industries and socie-
ties alike (Stern, 2008, p. 1).
In the past, it was primarily reductions in tariff and trade barriers that stimulated global trade
and encouraged the integration of international business. Today, however, the key factor is
the global networking that has been made possible by new communication technologies.
Increasingly intense international competition is accelerating structural change throughout
the world. More and more, industries that only “yesterday” limited their production to the
United States, Europe or Japan are feeling the influence of threshold countries. Moreover,
jobs that seemed guaranteed for life some years ago are moving into these low-wage coun-
tries. No longer are they limited to the production of simple toys for children – today compa-
nies in threshold countries are producing luxury consumer goods, consumer electronics and
highly sophisticated machines and vehicles, and with dizzying success (Lippisch/Köppel,
2007, p. 3).
Unauthenticated
1.1 “The Global Challenge” 3
In order to be economically successful in the global market, it is not only the hard facts that
count – such as the general economic and commercial settings, product quality or innovative
products and services. “Soft” competencies, especially social competence and excellent
communication skills, become more and more important. Thus, a balanced consideration of
hard facts and “soft” competencies is increasingly becoming a prerequisite for global suc-
cess. Only companies and organizations with a multicultural structure will succeed beyond
the regional level and will continue to be successful on a global scale. In the future, mono-
structures and mono-cultures will be limited to regional importance. However, multicultural
organizations will not prosper automatically, just because they are multicultural. On the
contrary, if managed badly, they may function worse than mono-cultural organizations.
Thus, the skills to lead a multicultural organization have to be in the focus and are paramount
for the success in the global market.
These consequences of global competition are putting pressure on companies in the devel-
oped Western countries. Companies from Central and Western Europe are faced with the
question of how to respond in order to remain competitive. Market isolation is a strategy that
no longer works in today’s globalized world, and it is likely to do more harm than good.
Instead, today it is crucial to establish a solid competitive position in the global arena and to
defend that position by continually adapting to meet the needs of the market. There is no
doubt that a corporate culture that is open to innovation and shaped by global thinking plays
a key role in this context, a culture in which representatives of different countries and cul-
tures can come together, while giving due regard to the developments and conditions that
influence a company’s actions (Lippisch/Köppel, 2007, p. 3). International business and
professional activity demand movement beyond one particular cultural conditioning into a
transcultural arena.
The technological environment surrounding businesses today is characterized by a soaring
speed of change and innovation. Revolutionizing innovations in the fields such as microelec-
tronic, robotic and generic engineering can be perceived as a threat or chance to the enter-
prise’s competition (Welge/Al-Laham, 2008, p. 295).
If globalization refers to the transmission of ideas, meanings and values across world space
the intercultural aspect is obvious. In the contemporary period, and from the beginning of the
twentieth century, this process is marked by the common consumption of cultures that have
been diffused by the Internet, popular culture media, and international travel. This has added
to processes of commodity exchange and colonization which have a longer history of carry-
ing cultural meaning across the globe. The circulation of cultures enables individuals to par-
take in extended social relations that cross national and regional borders. The creation and
expansion of such social relations is not merely observed on a material level. Cultural global-
ization involves the formation of shared norms and knowledge with which people associate
their individual and collective cultural identities. It brings increasing interconnectedness
among different populations and cultures (Steger/James, 2010, p. 12).
As far as global challenges are concerned, the current developments can be split into four
main categories (Rothlauf, 2004, pp. 25ff), namely:
• new technologies
• new markets
• new environmental drivers
• new global players
Unauthenticated
Within this framework, an intercultural answer has to be given, which includes:

• new corporate culture
• new skills
• new management and working styles
• new company structures
Both, challenges and the intercultural answers will be presented in the following and are also
illustrated in Fig. 1.1.
1.1.1 Global challenges
New
technologies
New corporate
culture
New
global New company New
New skills
players structures markets
New management
and working styles
New environmental
drivers
Fig. 1.1: Challenges and solutions in the global context

Source: Own illustration
New technologies
New information and communication technologies, such as the internet, are ubiquitous and
cheap; they control the markets, permit worldwide access to information, foster global trends
and reach the most distant corner of the world.
Moreover, an emerging technology as distinguished from a conventional technology is a field
of technology that broaches new territory in some significant way with new technological
Unauthenticated
developments. Examples of currently emerging technologies include educational technology,

nanotechnology, biotechnology, cognitive science, robotics, and artificial intelligence.
New markets
Business is always changing and to maximize the relevant business options one have to ex-
plore new markets and to expand the current buiness activities. As resources become scarcer
and scarcer and domestic markets are reaching the saturation point, it is becoming increas-
ingly important to open up new sales, resource and labor markets. A successful search for
geographic or technical alternatives is part of a company’s international strategy. Moving
into new territories and categories is a radical strategy that can create major potential for
incremental business growth. To succeed it requires a precise understanding of market dy-
namics, consumer behaviour and the competitive landscape of the specific markets.
New global players

Companies from threshold countries are developing at a breathtaking speed. They have the
benefit of a plentiful supply of cheap, motivated and well-qualified workers. They are devel-
oping an increasingly accurate sense of where the demand is, and their ability to offer high-
quality products at a reasonable price is growing as well.
A good example for those new global players is BRICS, an acronym for an association of
five major emerging national economies: Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa. The
BRICS members are all developing or nearly industrialised countries, but they are distin-
guished by their large, fast-growing economies. Moreover more and more developing coun-
tries are now entering the international stage and will play a larger role in the future.
New environmental drivers

Climate change and energy supply concerns are the primary drivers in the present debate. It
has now been scientifically proven that climate change is triggered off by the emission of
anthropogenic greenhouse gases; first and foremost CO2. In order to find adequate solutions
to meet the manifold environmental need an urgent global response is demanded. The grow-
ing pollution all around the world has to be taken into account and the focus of all business
activities should move to a higher environmental commitment of all parties involved in this
context. In the long run, only those enterprises will survive that have the right answer in this
very challenging field and can offer environmentally friendly products and services.
The Global Toothbrush

(Ralf Hoppe)
How many employees does it take to manufacture a toothbrush? Forty-five-hundred em-

ployees, 10 countries, five time zones.
Philips and its suppliers produce the electronic toothbrush “Sonicare Elite 7000” and its
sister models at 12 locations and in five time zones. Once or twice a week, some 100,000
fully-functioning circuit boards leave the Manila factory. From Manila’s cargo airport they
are flown via Tokyo to Seattle. A half day’s delay can wreak havoc in the entire system
with a minimum of inventory and extremely tight timelines.
Unauthenticated
The toothbrush is essentially comprised of 38 components. The parts of the energy cell, a
rechargeable nickel-cadmium battery, are supplied by Japan, France and China. The circuit
board, its electronic heart, comes pre-etched from Zhuhai in the Pearl River delta of south
eastern China. The copper coils originate from the Chinese industrial city of Shenzhen, not
far from Zhuhai. They are wound by armies of women with bandaged fingers. Globaliza-
tion is largely a female phenomenon.
The 49 components on the board – transistors and resistors at the size of match heads –
hail from Malaysia. They are soldered and tested in Manila. Then they are flown to Sno-
qualmie on the West Coast of the U.S., the site of the parent plant. Meanwhile, back in
Europe, the more complicated plastic parts are trucked from Klagenfurt in Austria to
Bremerhaven in Germany. Klagenfurt also supplies blades made of special steel produced
in Sandviken, Sweden. A freighter from Bremerhaven takes the half-finished brushes
across the Atlantic to Port Elizabeth, New Jersey. From there they cross the continental
United States by train. And in Snoqualmie, a 40 minute drive from Seattle, the final prod-
uct is assembled and packaged.
Philips is a Netherlands corporation. But there are only two Dutch citizens among the 120
on this carousel of cultures and continents. The foreman in Snoqualmie comes from Gam-
bia. Bernard Lim Nam Onn, the boss in Zhuhai, is Chinese, but was born in Malaysia and
raised in Singapore. There are Irish, Ukrainians, Indians, Cambodians, Vietnamese, Thai.
Globalization is carving out new biographies and cross-referencing them around the world.
In: Spiegel Special – International Edition, Nr. 7/2005, pp. 130ff
1.1.2 The intercultural answer

Given the variety of challenges, the solution must vary as well. Apart from technological
solutions, a specific view on the so-called soft factors enables us to get a better understand-
ing of how the problems can be solved in the future (Lippisch/Köppel, 2007, p. 8).
New company structures

Among the ways in which companies seek enhanced flexibility to meet the challenges of
increasingly volatile markets are the outsourcing of certain services that were not marketable
in the past. This market-driven increase in flexibility needs to be applied at the operational
level; corporate structures as well as management methods need to be adapted to meet the
needs of the future.
New management and working styles

The push towards increasing flexibility, accompanied by an increasing acceptance of person-
al responsibility continues in processes at the human level: decentralization, fluid company
borders, globally organized added value and constant change require alterations in manage-
ment and work models as well. The relevant demands must be taken into account in em-
ployment relationships, work-hour arrangements, incentive systems and further training
programs, especially intercultural training programs.
Unauthenticated
Global managers work with people who have very different ideas about how business gets
done. They must understand and adapt to country differences in unions, corporate govern-
ance, political legislation, investment policies etc. that can have an impact on business.
Moreover, global managers have to be fully aware of the complexity of norms, beliefs, val-
ues and attitudes that distinguish one cultural group from another. Working globally, manag-
ers must address multiple and differing expectations about how people (employees, col-
leagues, customers, suppliers, distributors, etc.) should behave, and how work should get
done. Given the cultural diversity of our world, this is an extremely challenging task and
requires a new thinking as far as the relevant working style is concerned. Today’s leaders
need to adapt to leading and managing people of different cultures. Cultural differences im-
pact everything from inter-personnel communication to health and safety procedures to pro-
ject management. In short, no corner of any business escapes.
New skills
In globally active companies it is becoming more and more important that each employee
shows personal initiative; they also need to be able to adapt their tasks to the changing de-
mands within and outside the company, in order to meet the challenges of global business.
Economically-driven diversity management is one way of ensuring that the various available
human resources are used and combined in a manner appropriate to the specific situation.
As with all businesses success depends upon effective cooperation and commu-
nication within a company, particularly within multicultural teams. Therefore, business struc-
tures have to be radically transformed in the given context. Changes in areas such as com-
munication and information technology and shifts towards global interdependence are obvi-
ous and having resulted in companies that are becoming increasingly international and as a
logical consequence more and more intercultural.
New corporate culture

A global mindset and an innovative spirit should be made an integral part of the company
and its corporate culture. Executives and employees, who understand global contexts and the
need for innovation as well as its consequences for their own behavior, are crucial for estab-
lishing such a corporate culture. Furthermore, a company’s leadership has a responsibility to
encourage, communicate and implement a continuously developing corporate culture with a
specific focus on newly formed multicultural teams. Establishing and implementing ethical
principles constitutes a major challenge in this context – all the more so because such princi-
ples need to be internationally applicable, binding and interculturally accepted.
“The magic in the globalization of the last years

is the mixture of different cultures.”
(Matthew Emmens)
Unauthenticated
Wolfsburg’s Gateway to Asia

(Martin Posth)
We were slowly getting to know our Chinese partners in exciting discussions concerning
special topics and were developing perspectives for Shanghai VWs together. When we
were taking a look at the largely automated body-shell manufacture in Sao Paulo, it quick-
ly dawned on us all that we would not need all that many robots in the production process.
In China, where there was no limit to a very cheap workforce, robots were only supposed
to be employed where the precision of the human hand and the human eye did not meet the
demands for the quality to be safeguarded that we aspired to.
In our Mexican plant in Puebla, which we visited afterwards, everything worked out a bit
differently than in Brazil on account of conditions typical of each particular country. Thus
our Chinese fellow travellers got the impression of a capability of adaptation on the part of
our concern to the different cultural and social conditions prevailing in each country con-
cerned.
Then we headed for Tennessee, whereto the Japanese had succeeded in exporting their kind
of car production to the USA. One of the first “transplants” – that was the term given to
these manufacturing plants – was the subsidiary of Nissan in Smyrna, a small town near
Nashville. Here, the Japanese had managed to adapt their legendary production system –
cost-effectively, swiftly and quality-consciously – to US conditions and, at the same time,
to establish a totally different cultural constellation successfully. We realised that in the
factory halls of Shanghai Volkswagen two cultures would come together. Will we succeed
in mediating constructively and productively between cultures, something that experts
term as “Cross Cultural Management” nowadays?
In: 1000 Tage in Shanghai, 2006, p. 25 (own translation)
1.2 Intercultural management

The economic globalisation, the technological progress and the revolution of the information
and communication technology sector have facilitated the communication among people
around the world. While the psychology and sociology have reacted by studying the relations
deriving from cultural exchanges, the economy developed a new discipline in the 1970s – the
intercultural management – aimed at adapting the marketing rules to the specific cultural
characteristics of a target market. Since then, the scope and object of study have been ex-
panded to include the management at the level of organisations operating in a multi-cultural
environment, especially for companies operating branches outside the country of origin.
Consequently, the intercultural management has rapidly developed the notions of mother-
culture versus enterprise-culture. The first element is specific for the country from which the
company originates, while the second is specific for the country in which the company opens
its branch. In order to avoid possible cultural conflicts, the intercultural management uses
specific tools and methods that mediate between two or more cultures.
Unauthenticated
1.2 Intercultural management 9
1.2.1 Definition of intercultural management

Intercultural Management can be described as a combination of knowledge, insights and
skills which are necessary for adequately dealing with national and regional cultures and
differences between cultures at several management levels within and between organisations
(Burggraaf, 1998). It is not a separate subject but an integral part of general and international
management.
General
Management
International Intercultural
Management Management
Fig. 1.2: Management interrelations

Source: Own illustration
Intercultural Management interleaves with international management as some similarities

occur. It might therefore be relevant to depict those features of international management
that are effective. These features are:
• Teams consist of internationally representative managers
• Structural forms such as organic modes exist
• Leadership includes varied skills appropriate for the global context
• Motivation is appropriate for diversity
• Organisational cultures such as those characterising learning organisations exist
• Communication methods and systems are available and applicable
• Human resource management systems and practices that reflect the dynamic of operat-
ing in the global context are used (Jacob, 2003)
As part of the term intercultural management the expression management is ubiquitous.
Management is the on-going professional composition, steering and development of (com-
plex) structures and processes in order to achieve the goals of the organisations. (Koch,
Speiser, 2008)
For a definition of intercultural management the general management definition needs to be
extended by the cultural component. Therefore, intercultural management can mean to
achieve goals with professional means by persons of other or different cultural influence. It is
the composition, steering and development of structures and processes in order to achieve the
goals of an organisation in a context that is shaped by the coincidence of at least two differ-
ent cultures. (Koch/Speiser, 2008)
Unauthenticated
1.2.2 The importance of intercultural management

If you agree with Elashmawi/Harris (1993, p. 1), who say that “the new world market will
not only be international, but intensely intercultural”, it will become obvious that the inter-
national management of the future will also – or even particularly – make the inclusion of
intercultural management an absolute necessity. Hambrick/Snow (1989, pp. 84ff) arrive at a
similar conclusion and say:
“Integration and human resource management are dependent upon one another to
the degree that structuring a firm’s global activities involves the deployment and use
of human capital and other human aspects.”
The need for a specific intercultural discipline in the management field comes from the fact
that speaking a foreign language is not enough for a sufficient communication between peo-
ple belonging to different cultures. The surface of a process is much more complex than the
simple understanding of what the other says. This is because the communication is not linear,
which means that the transmission of a message is never neutral; the spoken message trans-
mits words and notions, but also norms and values and some of these norms and values may
not be fully shared by the dialogue partner. (Meunier/Zaman, n.y.)
Consequently, managers have to be aware not only of the different language of the business
partner but their diverging attitude, time perception, behaviours, traditions and further as-
pects related to a different culture. At this point, intercultural management provides the op-
portunity to be aware of it and deal with such cultural aspects. Failures in one’s behavior
while doing business or misunderstandings of the business partners’ actions can lead to se-
vere problems and even a termination of the partnership.
Intercultural Management in China
In a study dealing with intercultural management in China conducted by students of the

University of Applied Sciences in Stralsund, 37 companies from China and Germany par-
ticipated filled in the survey. The results show that the majority of companies consider
intercultural management as very important for their German-Chinese business relations.
Question: Do you think intercultural management in China plays a crucial role in
doing your business successfully? If yes, why?
(extract)
– Different cultures implement different working styles No
12% Yes
which should be taken into consideration
88%
– Intercultural management can bridge the different
understanding and thinking between people in China
and Germany or Europe.
– Proper understanding of local culture is essential for
conducting business here. Otherwise, there will be
certainly problems with communication.
In: Golz/Kerwin/Rimaite, Written Assignment, 2013 (unpublished)
Unauthenticated
In recent years, the intercultural management has become particularly important as the phe-
nomena of globalisation has been accompanied by increasing migration flows, enlargement
of the European Union, economic openness of many countries around the world, the emer-
gence of new economies like China and the expansion of economic partnerships between
countries disposing of different economic systems. The cooperation between these different
economic systems, which are based on significant cultural differences, requires a new – in-
tercultural – approach.
Another possibility of integrating intercultural thinking and acting into the existing curricu-
lum can be seen in the job enlargement of international personnel management. Especially in
Anglosaxon literature (Black/Mendenhall, 1990; Phatak, 1997; Teagarden/Gordon, 1994;
Tung, 1981), strong reference is to be found. The authors share the opinion that
“these new roles include international extensions of more traditional human resource
management support functions such as providing country-specific knowledge of union
and labour policies, legal and regulatory requirements, compensation, and benefit
practises. They include preparing people for international assignments, and re-entry
after those assignments are completed.” (Teagarden/Glinow, 1997, p. 8)
30 TIPS ON HOW TO LEARN ACROSS CULTURES (1-2)

(Andre Laurent)
1. Be aware of your own very special culture as a unique peculiarity. When working
across cultures you will often be the “stranger” – perceived by others as being
“strange”.
2. The culture that you ignore most – in terms of its shaping power on yourself – is obvi-
ously your own culture. It is very difficult to look at oneself from the outside. We can
make interesting observations and comments about other cultures. But we often re-
main blind to our own.
In: SIETAR (Hrsg.), Keynote-Speech, Kongress 2000, Ludwigshafen
For companies, this approach means that the consideration of the intercultural issues of all
cross-border activities must no longer be neglected. Far more than before, these issues have
to explicitly find their way into the respective activity’s intercultural orientation. (Perlmutter,
1965, p. 153)
Those who want to succeed on international markets have to deal with unprecedented prob-
lems, which result due to the mere fact that there is contact with foreign countries, cultures as
well as economic and social structures. However, an explicit implication of those factors
does not happen in most cases. At this point, intercultural management comes into place.
At the University of Applied Sciences Stralsund, a study was conducted by the four students
Carolin Boden, Elisabeth Guth, Nelly Heinze and Sarah Lang, who questioned 22 consulting
companies and experts about the influence of cultural aspects on the failure of mergers and
acquisitions (M&A). The results underline the importance of intercultural management and
training during the M&A process, but can be transferred to other fields as well.
Unauthenticated
Please rate the importance of intercultural management in case of

international Mergers and Acquisitions.
(very important) 6 59%
5 14%
4 18%
3 0%
2 5%
(very unimportant) 1 5%
Average rating: 5.09
Fig. 1.3: Importance of intercultural training for international M&A

Source: Boden/Guth/Heinze/Lang, 2011, p. 81
1.2.3 The tasks of intercultural management

The discussion, whether the topic of management has to be seen in a “culture-bound” (hy-
pothesis by culturalist respectively cultural relativists) or “culture-free” context (hyphothesis
by universalists), has shown that the majority – according to Hofstede (1993) – considers
management as a culture-bound phenomenon. Hence, a particular sensibilization for cultural
phenomena is required. (Kumar, 1988, pp. 389ff, Kiechl, 1997, p. 16)
While a few scientists (Thomas, 1996; Kiechl, 1990) have pointed out a global convergence
and have consequently ruled out a connection between ethnoculture and corporate culture,
the majority of scientific studies (Adler, 1983; Perlmutter, 1965; Hofstede, 1993) verify that
undertakings in different nations reveal different corporate cultures, which can be traced back
to the respective ethnocultures. At internationally active companies, the ethnocultural influ-
ence on the corporate culture, which depends on the nature of the relationships between the
subsidiaries and the parent company and between the different subsidiaries, can be monitored
and to a certain degree even steered (Kiechl, 1997, p. 14).
Race
(Barack Obama)
As the child of a black man and a white woman, someone who was born in the racial melt-
ing pot of Hawaii, with a sister who’s half Indonesian but who’s usually mistaken for Mex-
ican or Puerto Rican, and a brother-in-law and niece of Chinese descent, with some blood
relatives who resemble Margaret Thatcher and others who could pass for Bernie Mac, so
that family get-togethers over Christmas take on the appearance of a UN General Assem-
bly meeting, I’ve never had the option of restricting my loyalties on the basis of race, or
measuring my worth on the basis of tribe. Moreover, I believe that part of America’s geni-
us has always been its ability to absorb newcomers, to forge a national identity out of the
disparate lot that arrived on our shores.
In: The Audacity of Hope, New York 2006, p. 231
Unauthenticated
One can conclude that the task of intercultural management includes the concrete design of
functional, structural and personnel management processes. Its aim is to facilitate a success-
ful overcoming of management problems by providing adequate approaches for efficient
international actions. (Perlitz, 1995, p. 318) Therefore, professionals and executives of inter-
nationally operating companies do not only need legal, technical and economic expertise and
speak foreign languages but also have to adjust their behavior to intercultural standards
which enable them to work effectively in a foreign environment.
Whoever wants to remain internationally successful has to be able to assess anticipatorily the
impacts of cultural differences on management practices, individual work attitudes, commu-
nication, the conduct of negotiations etc. (Weidmann, 1995, p. 41) However, this way of
thinking may not be seen as a one-way street. The necessity to observe and apply intercultur-
al principles and behavior is not only vital for external business relations but also for internal
business processes.
In future, one can assume that the number of business meetings where participants come
from different cultural backgrounds will increase (Mauritz, 1996, p. 1). For German compa-
nies, this development means that they will have to integrate more employees from other
cultures into the company – regardless whether they work at the corporate head office or at
foreign subsidiaries. The new questions and solution approaches involved are also part of
intercultural management.
Connecting Intercultural Communication and Management

(Gary R. Weaver)
The workplace of the new millennium will be multicultural and global. With greater inter-
cultural interaction, the differences are not simple going to disappear. We will not link
arms in the office, sing “We are the World”, and find that we can easily overcome the
communication breakdowns or conflicts. As long as we remain within our own culture, we
take it for granted. However, when we leave it and interact with people from other back-
grounds, we become more consciously aware of our own culture, and it becomes more
important to us.
In: Intercultural Management Institute, Washington, DC, Nr. 9, 2001, S. 3
1.2.4 Challenges in the field of intercultural management

Similarities of social habits, tastes and exposure might make managers across nations more
homogeneous, but there are still differences coming from cultures that have to be considered.
Quite a bit of intercultural management today deals with the construction of mechanisms for
integration.
Today there is an increasing preoccupation about the leadership and management styles,
which are appropriate for intercultural management. Another important point regarding the
repertoire of abilities needed by global managers is to feel comfortable in culturally diverse
teams. Cultural orientations are learnt behaviours. Therefore, managers can develop the flex-
ibility and openness which is necessary to transit from one cultural context to another. This is
Unauthenticated
part of the challenge when working for professionally managed and high performance com-
panies. (Jacob, 2003)
Some of these challenges have been described by Nardon/Sanchez-Runde/Steers (2010,
pp. 16ff):
“This evolution from a principally bicultural business environment to a more multicul-
tural or global environment presents managers with at least three new challenges in
attempting to adapt quickly to the new realities on the ground:
1. It is sometimes unclear to which culture we should adapt. Suppose that your
company has asked you to join a global project team to work on a six-month
R&D project. The team includes one Mexican, one German, one Chinese, and
one Russian. Every member of the team has a permanent appointment in their
home country but is temporarily assigned to work at company headquarters in
Switzerland for this project. Which culture should team members adapt to? In
this case, there is no dominant cultural group to dictate the rules. Considering
the multiple cultures involved, and the little exposure each manager has likely
had with the other cultures, the traditional approach to adaptation is unlikely to
be successful. Nevertheless, the group must be able to work together quickly and
effectively to produce results (and protect their careers), despite their differences.
What would you do?
2. Many intercultural encounters happen on short notice, leaving little time to learn
about the other culture. Imagine that you just returned from a week’s stay in India
where you were negotiating an outsourcing agreement. As you arrive in your
home office, you learn that an incredible acquisition opportunity just turned up in
South Africa and that you are supposed to leave in a week to explore the matter
further. You have never been to South Africa, nor do you know somebody from
there. What do you do?
3. Intercultural meetings increasingly occur virtually by way of computers or video
conferencing instead of through more traditional face-to-face interactions. Sup-
pose you were asked to build a partnership with a Korean partner that you have
never met and you know little about Korean culture. Suppose further that this
task is to be completed online, without any face-to-face communication or inter-
actions. Your boss is in a hurry for results. What would you do?
Taken together, these three challenges illustrate just how difficult it can be to work or
manage across cultures in today's rapidly changing business environment. The old
ways of communicating, negotiating, leading, and doing business are simply less ef-
fective than they were in the past.”
“Seven social sins:

politics without principles, wealth without work,
pleasure without conscience, knowledge without character,
commerce without morality, science without humanity,
and worship without sacrifice.”
(Mahatma Gandhi)
Unauthenticated
The Rise of Generation Global – Seizing opportunity in a world economy that ignores
borders
(Roger Cohen)
My son Daniel is working in Vietnam marketing Budweiser beer, an American on. Bud-
weiser may be as American as you can get, but it’s now owned by Anheuser-Busch InBev,
a Belgium-based company. InBev itself was created a few years ago by the merger of a
Brazilian company, Ambev, with Interbrew of Belgium.
That’s a lot of info to crowd into the top of a column, forgive me, but the modern world is
a little like that: a tangled web of cross-border holdings where national icons are not really
that national at all. Daniel, 27, is heading to Brazil for a month to train with Brazilian mar-
keters on how to sell an American beer to the 80 million citizens of fast-growing Vietnam.
He’s part of Generation Global (GG).
The existence of GG is a hopeful thing. Never before have so many young people been so
aware of the shared challenges facing the globe, so determined to get “out there” to learn
about it, or so intent on making a contribution to a more equitable world. The borderless
cyber-communities of social networking have a powerful effect on their views. My son’s
Vietnamese-Brazilian connection is interesting. That’s where the growth is. He's American-
educated, but if he'd stayed in the United States after completing his M.B.A. he might well
have found himself joining the long line of twenty-somethings without a job. The growth
that has helped avert economic meltdown since 2008 has come overwhelmingly from next-
wave countries like China, Vietnam, India, Russia, Brazil, Indonesia and South Africa.
These are the places on which multinational corporations are focused.
Now I’m for a more multipolar world because the United States simply does not have the
resources to assume ad infinitum its current pivotal role in global security. But I’m also
mindful that the worlds of 1914 and 1939 were multipolar – and produced cataclysm.
Careful what you wish for is a useful maxim when radical power shifts, of the sort occur-
ring today, are in progress.
The emergent powers represent a hodgepodge of systems and values, which is one reason
their voices are indistinct, along with the fact that they are for now intensely focused on
their own development. You have the authoritarian systems (in their different forms) of
China, Vietnam and Russia; and the sprawling democracies (one old, one middle-aged, one
newish, one new) of India, Brazil, South Africa and Indonesia. All, in varying degrees,
have misgivings about the western-dominated world whose time is coming to an end.
Another thing they have in common is their burning desire to grow. Many of these nations
know much from their own histories of the struggle for freedom (ongoing in Iran), for
peace (ongoing in Israel-Palestine), for a national reconciliation (Afghanistan), for an end
totalitarian misery (North Korea). How emergent powers assume the responsibility growth
brings seems to me critical.
Unauthenticated
For now, they lag the corporations that knit the world closer and have landed my son in a
Brazilian-Belgian-American-Vietnamese web. I’ll raise a glass to that particular exotic
brew.
In: New York Times, 22nd February 2010, p. 2
1.2.5 The European Union and intercultural dialogue

Even the European Union has recognised the importance of questions related to intercultural
management, which was reflected by the decision of the European Parliament and the Euro-
pean Council to designate the year 2008 as the Euro-
pean Year of Intercultural Dialogue. This year rec-
ognises that Europe's great cultural diversity repre-
sents a unique advantage. It encourages all those
living in Europe to explore the benefits of its rich
cultural heritage and opportunities to learn from
different cultural traditions (interculturaldialogue
2008.eu.406.0.html).
The overall objectives of the European Year of Inter-
cultural Dialogue aim to contribute to (Official Journal of the European Union, 30/12/2006):
• promoting intercultural dialogue as a process in which all those living in the EU can
improve their ability to deal with a more open, but also more complex, cultural envi-
ronment, where, in different Member States as well as within each Member State, differ-
differ-
ent cultural identities and beliefs coexist,
• highlighting intercultural dialogue as an opportunity to contribute to and benefit from a
diverse and dynamic society, not only in Europe but also in the world,
• raising the awareness of all those living in the EU, in particular
particular young people, of the
importance of developing an active European citizenship which is open to the world, re- re-
spects cultural diversity and is based on common values in the EU as laid down in Arti-Arti-
cle 6 of the EU Treaty and the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union,
• highlighting the contribution of different cultures and expressions of cultural diversity to
the heritage and ways of life of the Member States.
The specific objectives of the European Year of Intercultural Dialogue shall be to:
• seek to raise the awareness of all those living in the EU, in particular young people,
people, of
the importance of engaging in intercultural dialogue in their daily lives,
• work to identify, share and give a visible European recognition to best practices in pro-
moting intercultural dialogue throughout the EU, especially among young people and
children,
• foster the role of education as an important medium for teaching about diversity, in-
crease the understanding of other cultures and developing skills and best social practices,
and highlight the central role of the media in promoting the principle of equality and mu-
tual understanding,
• raise the profile, increase the coherence of and promote all Community programmes and
actions contributing to intercultural dialogue and ensure their continuity,
Unauthenticated
• contribute to exploring new approaches to intercultural dialogue involving cooperation

between a wide range of stakeholders from different sectors.
1.2.6 Intercultural management vs. cross-cultural-management

Some research approaches differentiate between an “intercultural” and a “cross-cultural”
point of view. Intercultural studies concentrate on cross-border contacts and relationships,
whereas “cross-cultural” studies compare certain phenomena in different cultural surround-
ings. (Koester/Wiseman/Sanders, 1993, p. 5)
On the one hand, works in culturally comparative psychology have e.g. proved that cultural
factors have a big influence on psychological processes such as perception, motivation, cog-
nition and emotion. Moreover, the results show that some psychological laws hold across
cultural borders but also that such generalizations are not possible without restrictions.
(Thomas, 1993, p. 387) Consequently, the “cross-cultural” perspective always generates
comparative assertations, which means that the focus is on the cultural comparison.
Three Levels of cultural studies

(William B. Hart)
Cultural studies are done at three levels:

Monocultural studies, cross-cultural studies, and
intercultural studies. Monocultural or single cul-
Monocultural Studies
ture studies are common in anthropology and soci-
ology. Cross-cultural studies are studies that com-
pare the characteristics of two or more cultures.
Intercultural studies are studies that focus on the
interaction of two or more cultures and answer the
Comparative or Cross-Cultural
main question of what happens when two or more
Studies
cultures interact (at the interpersonal level, group
level or international level). The focus of intercul-
tural relations is with the intercultural studies.
Monocultural and cross-cultural studies cannot be
ignored, however, because they serve as necessary
Intercultural Studies
precursors to intercultural studies.
In: The E-Journal of Intercultural Relations, Nr. 6, 1998, S. 1
On the other hand, the prefix “inter” is mainly used to decribe connections between individu-
al units, especially in the context of border crossing. International encounters reach across
national borders and intercultural contacts across cultural barriers. The relationships between
social organizations are always of an intercultural nature, since every organization is by defi-
nition a specific culture which distinguishes itself from the culture of other organizations. If
one however assumes that the use of the prefix “inter” – as is to be found e.g. in the words
“inter”-cultural or “inter”-national management (Mauritz, 1996, p. 74) – implies an isolated
Unauthenticated
view on cultures or nations, then this definition fails the holistic approach connected to cross-
border interactions. Intercultural considerations can never be completely independent from
comparative statements but need them as a basis in order to gain qualitatively distinguishable
results. The actions of expatriate managers are influenced by their own as well as foreign
moral concepts.
1.3 The expert’s view: Interview with Dr. Thomas Zenetti

Dr. Thomas Zenetti is the Head of the international Master program “Intercultural Manage-
ment” at the Université de Haute-Alsace Mulhouse-Colmar (recorded 25/07/2014).
Rothlauf: In general, what are the reasons today to deal with questions related
to intercultural issues?
Zenetti: In my understanding, it is all about the way you communicate with people from
another culture. It is not enough to understand the language of your partner.
Somebody from Great Britain thinks and behaves differently compared to a U.S.
citizen, although they both speak English. I myself have made the experience that
our neighbors from the German speaking part of Switzerland react completely dif-
ferent than we Germans. Related to our Master program, it is obvious that such an
exchange between students from different cultures can only function if the peculi-
arities of each culture are taken into consideration. As relevant studies have clear-
ly proven, the neglect of those intercultural issues will not only cause problems in
private life but moreover in business life you will lose a lot of money.
Rothlauf: What were your fundamental ideas behind offering your students an international
Master program entitled “Intercultural Management” and which kind of initial
difficulties did you have to overcome?
Zenetti: Here, several factors play a role and come together: On the one hand, we have a
literature and linguistics program in applied foreign languages on a bachelor level
with a strong focus on business administration, on which we can build on. On the
other hand, our university, located in the Upper Rhine region, has a pioneering
role in cross-border programs, especially as far as interculturally designed work-
ing programs are concerned. As a logical consequence of all these facts, a Master
degree program in intercultural management was the best answer. Still, it was not
that easy to start with this program. It took a lot of hard work to get the support
from the faculty, because the so-called “soft factors” of this program did not corre-
late with the ideas of classical business programs and the linguistics colleagues
had to be convinced that we are not in concurrence to their existing programs but
look for an interdisciplinary co-operation. In the end, we succeeded in bridging the
gap, a really intercultural task.
Rothlauf: Where do you see the special feature of this course and what makes this program
unique compared to other international programs, especially those that are of-
fered in France?
Unauthenticated
1.3 The expert’s view: Interview with Dr. Thomas Zenetti 19
Zenetti: First of all, it is the language program in combination with management courses.
About half of the offered language courses are in French, at least 30 per cent in
English and about 20 percent – depending on the selected elective courses – in
German or Spanish. But if the students are interested in learning more languages,
we give them the opportunity to learn, for example, the Chinese, the Japanese or
the Russian language as well. This variety of languages we do offer is relatively
rare in France, particularly at small universities. For such a program, we do not
only need students with a good command of economics, an interest in learning
three foreign languages, but also faculty members who are capable of transferring
our ideas into reality.
Rothlauf: Who are the students that are enrolled in your Master program and what different
nationalities are represented in this course?
Zenetti: It is clear that Mulhouse has not the same appeal as Paris or Lyon, but there is a
steadily growing demand for this program that allows us to select our students ac-
cordingly. About 25 percent of all students are coming from outside France. So,
we are happy to have not only students from the neighboring countries like Ger-
many and Switzerland but also from Russia, China and from South America.
Rothlauf: How do the students work and live together? Different religious affiliations, dif-
ferent language levels, different notions of time and so on can cause a variety of
problems. How do you cope with all those challenges?
Zenetti: We always analyze the situation and, in a joint effort, we are looking for a solu-
tion, sometimes with the help from members of the group itself, sometimes we of-
fer support from our university. Let me give you an example: A female Russian
student had been elected as the leader of a group and had distributed different
tasks among the members of the group. She then got angry as the Chinese student
did not stick to the deadlines. The problem was caused by an intercultural misun-
derstanding: A simple “niet” is not in line with the Chinese culture, where every-
body tries to be in harmony, which means that the students tried to avoid to say
“no”. At the end, however, they finished the project in a very successful manner.
Rothlauf: Are there any first reactions from the labor market and is it difficult for your
graduates to find a job?
Zenetti: Ninety to ninety-five percent of our graduates get a job in the first three months
after finishing this program. More than half of the students receive a job offer at
the end of their six-month internship. Especially in a country like France with an
unfortunately high rate of youth unemployment, we are proud to publish those
figures. Moreover, the companies tell us that our concept is in line with their per-
ception: instead of focusing on selected issues such as human resource manage-
ment or project management, the variety of courses makes the difference. The
linkage of intercultural aspects with language courses and a holistic approach to
questions that are essential in business administration generate a program that is
pretty well accepted by the companies.
Unauthenticated
Rothlauf: What are your personal experiences in this context?

Zenetti: As a German who has now lived for three and a half decades in France, I have got
to know all the different stages of the acculturation process, without becoming a
100 percent Frenchman. It is very interesting to see how the theories of Hofstede,
Hall and others are in line with my own experiences. Moreover, it is a wonderful
opportunity for me to see the differences as well as similarities among our stu-
dents coming from all around the world. To help them to get a more differentiated
intercultural view is a challenging task and I am proud to be part of this program.
30 TIPS ON HOW TO LEARN ACROSS CULTURES (3–4)

(Andre Laurent)
3. Intercultural situations offer the unique opportunity to reduce our blind spot. Other
cultures act as privileged mirrors in which we can see more of our own cultural make-
up as a result of being confronted and challenged by other cultural models. This leads
to greater understanding of the peculiarities of our own culture.
4. Don’t expect others to think and act as you do. Your culture – and therefore your own
preferred way of getting things done – is just one among many. Expect others to think
and act differently. Recognize that your way can be the exception rather than the
norm.
In: SIETAR (Hrsg.), Keynote-Speech, Kongress 2000, Ludwigshafen
Unauthenticated
1.4 Case Study: Interviewing costumers in Asia – The impact of culture 21
1.4 Case Study: Interviewing costumers in Asia –

The impact of culture
1. Language issues
The choice of the interview language is a very important aspect for cross-cultural research
studies and it needs to be taken into account already in the pre-interview stage.
Relying on English as the only language in a global research limits the access to respondents.
Furthermore, it might also result in the fact that data is collected from respondents who are
fluent in English, but whose attitudes and behavior differ tremendously from the non-English
speaking population.
Even between English-speaking countries, significant linguistical differences may occur.
When interviewing Indian respondents, for example, it becomes clear that some words have
a completely different meaning than in the UK. The word “sincere” which in England signi-
fies “honest” and “true” and which refers to someone who “is honest and says what he really
feels or believes”, is used in India to indicate someone who accepted responsibility. As the
meaning of words is shared only by members of the same culture, people from different
cultural background have a different understanding of the same word. Researchers, therefore,
have to be aware of the fact that there exist many “Englishes” instead of the one English
language. Consequently, when doing cross-cultural studies, it is crucial to compare equiva-
lent expressions in all relevant languages in order to be able to identify the most appropriate
term to fit into the respective context.
2. Individual interviews or focus groups

In many Asian countries, and especially in China, the predominant Confucian philosophy
emphasizes the importance of the group. As a consequence, the unit of analysis of a qualita-
tive research conducted in Asia might be the group itself and not the individual. This means
that focus groups rather than the usual one-to-one interviews need to be carried out as almost
all believes, attitudes and values of the respondents are a result of in-group interaction. By
interviewing Chinese participants in groups, researchers can gain much deeper insights into
their way of thinking than in individual interviews as people feel much more comfortable in
a group setting which enables them to interprete and evaluate things collectively. It is, how-
ever, of great importance that the group under investigation is not randomly formed, but
consists of members of the same peer group. In interdependent cultures, such as China, re-
spondents will only express openly their opinion when the participants of the focus group are
placed in the same position in hierarchy. Otherwise they feel obliged to agree with people
from higher hierarchical positions and change their point of view.
Conducting focus groups in Japan bears some challenges. Compared to other countries, focus
groups in Japan seem to be more structured. While some subjects with which respondents
can easily identify themselves can generate lively discussions, other topics require a consid-
erable amount of involvement on the part of the moderator in order to make participants talk.
Japanese interviewees sometimes hesitate to share their thoughts and opinions if they feel
that they are not in line with the group. This is due to the innate Japanese desire to maintain
harmony. In case that the respondents’ opinions actually are in opposition to those of the
group, they might even answer contrary to their own feelings and attitudes. The Japanese
culture is a rather neutral culture in which people do not show their true feelings and desires
Unauthenticated
openly; instead emotions are kept hidden as they may conflict with what society expects
from the individual. “Tatemae”, literally meaning façade, is the behavior which is shown in
public and which accounts for the fact that Japanese feel the obligation not to express their
opinion freely if this could endanger the social harmony. For Western cultures which are
more individualistic, this seems to be hard to understand since people are used to be very
independent and do not have to render account to anybody for their behavior. In order to
overcome the barriers which make conducting groups in Japan quite difficult, the number of
participants in the group should be reduced to a minimum. This is necessary as the size of the
group increases the pressure of conformity to group opinion enormously. Consequently, it is
sometimes even advisable to conduct triads, a group consisting of only three people.
Source: Dahm, F./Schüle, U., in: UPDATE 12, SS 2011, p. 5–7
Review and Discussion Questions:

1. What is the general message of this article?
2. You are a European manager and currently working in Asia. Are there any significant
hints you have to take into your consideration when doing business in this region?
3. How would you transfer ideas from this article into your everyday business life with a
specific view on working together with Japanese managers?
4. Which kind of cultural information can you gain by taking a look at this article and
compare the relevant information with your home country views!
Unauthenticated

1 - Globalization and Intercultural Management

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

1 - Globalization and Intercultural Management

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

1 - Globalization and Intercultural Management

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

1 Globalization and Intercultural

1.0 Statement of the problem

To summarize, globalization provides many opportunities as well as challenges in busi-

In: Cross-Cultural Blog: management style and globalization, in web:

1.1 “The Global Challenge”

Within this framework, an intercultural answer has to be given, which includes:

1.1.1 Global challenges

Fig. 1.1: Challenges and solutions in the global context

developments. Examples of currently emerging technologies include educational technology,

New global players

New environmental drivers

The Global Toothbrush

How many employees does it take to manufacture a toothbrush? Forty-five-hundred em-

In: Spiegel Special – International Edition, Nr. 7/2005, pp. 130ff

1.1.2 The intercultural answer

New company structures

New management and working styles

New corporate culture

“The magic in the globalization of the last years

Wolfsburg’s Gateway to Asia

In: 1000 Tage in Shanghai, 2006, p. 25 (own translation)

1.2 Intercultural management

1.2.1 Definition of intercultural management

Fig. 1.2: Management interrelations

Intercultural Management interleaves with international management as some similarities

1.2.2 The importance of intercultural management

Intercultural Management in China

In a study dealing with intercultural management in China conducted by students of the

In: Golz/Kerwin/Rimaite, Written Assignment, 2013 (unpublished)

30 TIPS ON HOW TO LEARN ACROSS CULTURES (1-2)

In: SIETAR (Hrsg.), Keynote-Speech, Kongress 2000, Ludwigshafen

Please rate the importance of intercultural management in case of

Fig. 1.3: Importance of intercultural training for international M&A

1.2.3 The tasks of intercultural management

In: The Audacity of Hope, New York 2006, p. 231

Connecting Intercultural Communication and Management

In: Intercultural Management Institute, Washington, DC, Nr. 9, 2001, S. 3

1.2.4 Challenges in the field of intercultural management

“Seven social sins:

In: New York Times, 22nd February 2010, p. 2

1.2.5 The European Union and intercultural dialogue

• contribute to exploring new approaches to intercultural dialogue involving cooperation

1.2.6 Intercultural management vs. cross-cultural-management

Three Levels of cultural studies

Cultural studies are done at three levels:

In: The E-Journal of Intercultural Relations, Nr. 6, 1998, S. 1

1.3 The expert’s view: Interview with Dr. Thomas Zenetti

Rothlauf: What are your personal experiences in this context?

30 TIPS ON HOW TO LEARN ACROSS CULTURES (3–4)

In: SIETAR (Hrsg.), Keynote-Speech, Kongress 2000, Ludwigshafen

1.4 Case Study: Interviewing costumers in Asia –

2. Individual interviews or focus groups

Source: Dahm, F./Schüle, U., in: UPDATE 12, SS 2011, p. 5–7

Review and Discussion Questions:

You might also like