The Smart Way To Your PH.D.: 200 Secrets From 100 Graduates
The Smart Way To Your PH.D.: 200 Secrets From 100 Graduates
The Smart Way To Your PH.D.: 200 Secrets From 100 Graduates
to Your Ph.D.
200 Secrets from 100 Graduates
To Your Ph.D.
“After reading all the stories, I was surprised by how many of the
situations seemed familiar to me and how much of the advice rang
true, despite differences in fields, institutions, and degree programs. I
would recommend this book for all prospective, current, and recent
graduate students. Adding this book to every graduate school library
and office of student affairs would go a long way toward giving the
students the resources they need to progress and succeed in graduate
school and beyond.”
–Heather Mernitz, Assistant Professor of Physical Science,
Alverno College
“This is a great resource for prospective and current graduate students
and their families. Dr. Farkas emphasizes that a Ph.D. requires
significant dedication and vision for the future and that graduate
school should not serve as a default option for indecisive individuals.
However, the book also makes the doctoral degree sound “within
reach” and deals with common problems that can arise during
graduate studies, such as bad advisor, bad project, lack of motivation,
staying organized, and staying healthy. I wish I read this book before
I started my own graduate school adventure!”
–Natalia Tretyakova, Associate Professor,
Department of Medicinal Chemistry, University of Minnesota
All rights reserved. Printed in the United States of America. No part of this
book may be reproduced or transmitted without written permission from the
author, except for the inclusion of quotations in a review. For more information
please visit www.yourphd.com.
First edition
ISBN: 0-9821092-0-2
ISBN-13: 978-0-9821092-0-5
Library of Congress Control Number: 2008910633
The Smart Way
to Your Ph.D.
2 0 0 secr ets from 10 0 gr a duates
Published by
Your Ph.D. Consulting
Arlington Massachusetts
Table of C ontents
Acknowledgements xiii
Introduction xv
This book compiles the contributions of over 100 people. First and
foremost, I would like to thank the 100 Ph.D.s who volunteered to be
interviewed. They generously contributed their time and offered many
valuable suggestions to make this book useful and accessible to current
and future doctoral students.
I am also grateful to the following faculty members, deans,
and counselors for contributing to and reviewing parts of this book:
Brinda Charry, Professor of English at Keene State College; Sarah
Delaney, Assistant Professor of Chemistry at Brown University; John
Essigmann, Professor of Biological Engineering at MIT; Robert Frost,
Assistant Professor of Education at Oregon State University; Brian
Hampton, Assistant Professor of Geological Sciences at Michigan State
University; John Nonnamaker, Associate Director at the MIT Careers
Office; Katherine O’Dair, Associate Dean for Graduate Student Life at
Boston College; Karl Reid, Associate Dean and Director of the Office
of Minority Education at MIT; Robin Rosenberg, Clinical Psychologist;
Steven Tannenbaum, Professor of Biological Engineering at MIT; Joel
Voldman, Associate Professor of Electrical Engineering and Computer
Science at MIT; Jessica White, Assistant Professor of Education at
Oregon State University; Ann Yelmokas McDermott, Associate
Professor at Cal Poly State University; and Mary Ziegler, Information
Technology Consultant at MIT.
A special “thank you” goes out to my two brothers-in-law,
William Jiang, Chief Librarian at the Patient and Family Library of the
New York State Psychiatric Institute, and Chung Chiang. Thank you,
Will, for revising the section on library research and for all your cre-
ative suggestions. My readers are very fortunate to benefit from your
experience! Chung, thank you for helping me design my cover and for
answering questions about graphics design. Also, thank you for doing
an outstanding job with the typesetting!
xiii
I would also like to acknowledge Karen Ivy and Scribendi
Services for editing my manuscript, and Gabor Reisz for designing the
illustrations on the cover and the inside of the book.
I am also deeply grateful to my family in Hungary. I would not
be where I am today, were it not for the support of my parents, János
and Zsuzsanna Farkas. They taught me to love math and science from
a very early age, but also emphasized the importance of writing and
communication skills (which is probably why this book came about).
Their enthusiasm and encouragement have motivated me to pursue a
Ph.D. in the first place, and then to write a resource guide for future
students. I am especially thankful to my father, who suggested the title
of this book, as well as the domain name of its website, www.yourphd.
com. I would also like to thank my brother, Ádám, for being so excited
about my research and for making me feel like a very special sister.
Finally, I would like to thank my husband, Leaf, for his uncon-
ditional love and support. His sense of humor, patience and creativity
have always lifted my spirits up and motivated me to keep writing.
Thank you, Leaf, for always believing in me and for helping me make
this book a reality.
Disclaimer
This book is not a substitute for academic or medical advice. All deci-
sions regarding your doctoral dissertation should be discussed with
your thesis supervisor. Consult with your physician if you experi-
ence any symptoms of anxiety, depression or repetitive strain injury.
Furthermore, any changes to your diet or lifestyle should be made
under the supervision of a health professional. The author and Your
Ph.D. Consulting are not liable or responsible for any loss or damage
allegedly caused by the information in this book. We have made every
effort to ensure that the information in this book was correct and
updated at the time of publication, and assume no personal responsi-
bility for any inaccuracies, omissions or typographical errors.
xiv
I n t roduc t ion
xv
reasonable hours and enjoyed hobbies on the weekends. They knew
how to work smarter, not just harder.
What does it mean to “work smarter”? Are these “smart” doc-
toral students the same ones who had perfect grades in college? The
answer to this question came to me during graduate school, when
I was a resident tutor in an undergraduate dormitory. One of my
responsibilities was to advise students who were having personal or
academic problems. I held group sessions to help them organize their
time, study efficiently and learn test-taking skills. Having been an
undergraduate just a few years before, I empathized with their dif-
ficulties: studying volumes of books for exams, solving challenging
problem sets, writing lengthy essays and fighting sleep deprivation
from the overwhelming workload.
Although college life is busy, most undergraduates know what
they need to do to graduate. Graduate school, however, will present
you with an entirely different set of challenges. Your job is to propose
and complete an original research proposal and to defend your work
in front of a committee. Unlike in college, where you might have felt
overburdened by deadlines, in graduate school you need to be your
own boss and decide what to do and when to do it. Therefore, I came
to the conclusion that an undergraduate education usually does not
instill all of the skills needed to earn a Ph.D.
During the time I worked on my own dissertation, I realized
that one of the pitfalls of the graduate school system was that students
often had to face challenges without the benefit of an organized sup-
port system. In college, there were between 20 and 100 students in
most classes, and sometimes as many 400. When the homework sets
were impossible, we commiserated together; when the tests difficult,
we all received poor grades. As one of my professors said, “There is
protection in numbers.” Such protection is not available in graduate
school, however. Your project is yours alone; you can make it or break
it. If you fail, you fail alone. Fortunately, it does not have to be this way.
What if you could learn from former doctoral students about the skills
necessary to succeed in graduate school?
In order to write this book, I interviewed 100 individuals
who had earned Ph.D.s, to find out what they considered the most
important elements of success in graduate school. I asked them
questions such as:
xvi
◆◆ What was your biggest challenge, and how did you cope with it?
◆◆ Was graduate school what you expected? If not, what were the
biggest surprises?
◆◆ How did you deal with your advisor being unsupportive (in cases
research?
◆◆ How did you choose your career path?
*Note that not all fields award a Ph.D. as the terminal degree. For example, education
majors earn an Ed.D. and fine arts majors are awarded an M.F.A.
xvii
usually “yes,” and I thus gathered my interviews primarily by word
of mouth. I was also curious about resources for minorities, married
students and international students. To learn more about their chal-
lenges, I interviewed Ph.D.s from these subpopulations and included
their advice throughout the book and in the appendix. To make this
book more complete, I also asked professors about their expectations
from graduate students, and how their perspective on the Ph.D. pro-
cess had changed since they became advisors. Finally, I consulted with
deans, counselors and librarians regarding resources and career advice
for doctoral students.
After collecting information from these interviews, I concluded
that there were fundamental differences, but also many similarities
across the various fields of study. Students in the humanities, social
sciences and arts struggled to find funding—a luxury that many doc-
toral candidates in the sciences, engineering and mathematics take for
granted. On the other hand, students in the sciences, engineering and
mathematics were frustrated by irreproducible experiments or mal-
functioning modeling software, whereas humanities, social sciences
and arts majors did most of their research in libraries, museums, stu-
dios, and offices, without worrying about instruments breaking down.
Interestingly, however, most Ph.D.s believed that the major challenges
in graduate school were not academic. As outstanding students in col-
lege, they were not intimated by difficult research projects. Most Ph.D.s
found that the major challenges of graduate school were learning how
to become independent, finding ways to motivate themselves, com-
municating with difficult advisors, dealing with stress, and finding a
suitable career path. Their stories and coping strategies are summa-
rized in the chapters that follow.
I also sought insights from guidebooks written for doctoral
students. I found advice on how to choose a department and advi-
sor, how to find financial support, how to write a thesis and how
to find a job. Most of these books, however, did not have advice on
how to be more productive in graduate school. I did come across
many productivity-enhancing guides written by business profes-
sionals, and I wondered whether the advice in these books would
be helpful for doctoral students. After reading these books and
discussing the techniques with former students, I realized that
many of the strategies developed for the corporate world were also
xviii
applicable in graduate school. Therefore, in the following chapters,
I will frequently refer to books written by management consultants
and executive coaches, and highlight their strategies for learning
how to motivate yourself, overcome worry, communicate effectively
and organize your time, space and thoughts.
How should you use this book? The book is comprised of sev-
en stand-alone chapters, which will guide you through the entire
graduate school experience, from the pre-application phase to the
job-searching stage. Reading the entire book and trying to master
all these strategies at the same time would be very difficult, if not
impossible. Many of the skills discussed might also appear nitty-
gritty or even irrelevant until you reach a particular stage in your
studies. Thus, it is best to skim through the entire book first and then
read the relevant chapters and appendices as needed. Also, check the
extensive reference section in the appendix periodically, as it will help
you find funding, online research tools, ergonomic typing aids, and
job-searching resources. If you are in the early stages of your graduate
student career, look though the later chapters on thesis-writing and
job-searching as well, so you can plan ahead for these challenges. If
you read through the entire book, you will notice some repetition of
“secrets” across the chapters, especially those regarding self-motiva-
tion and organization; this is no accident. There are some common
threads of wisdom that are applicable throughout graduate school. In
other words, the organizational skills you need during the first few
years—to pass your qualifiers and write your thesis proposal—will
also be relevant towards the end, when you need to do an in-depth
literature search and write a dissertation. With practice, you can
incorporate these strategies into your daily routine until they become
second nature.
What was the number one piece of advice from former gradu-
ate students? Briefly, before you enter graduate school, really make
sure you want a Ph.D. Do not commit to this long journey because
your friends are going, or because you do not know what else to do.
Furthermore, in order to have a fulfilling experience, you need to con-
sider the financial aspects and logistics of going to graduate school.
Thus, the first chapter of this book is about laying your foundations.
I will share with you how to find funding, how to choose an advisor,
and what types of questions to ask during your campus visit.
xix
In the second chapter, I will discuss the typical challenges faced
by students on the road to becoming independent researchers. How
do you develop a productive daily routine? How do you stay focused
throughout the day? How do you keep yourself motivated after experi-
encing inevitable setbacks? I have also compiled the top 10 secrets from
former students, to help you design an original and realistic research
project for your dissertation.
The third chapter will be particularly useful when you want
to be more efficient, without having to work longer hours. As many
Ph.D.s have observed, productivity comes in bursts, and you can har-
ness this energy if you learn how to pay attention to your work hab-
its. You will learn how to identify high-priority tasks, how to budget
your time efficiently, how to organize your space and how to manage
your to-do list.
I divided the fourth chapter into three sections, all devoted to
discussing how to take care of your mind and body. In the first sec-
tion, I will show you how to deal with anxiety and minimize stress in
your life. You will learn the top 12 ways to beat worry, and even make
it work to your advantage. One of my observations during graduate
school was that students who consumed healthy diets were also more
focused and productive. In the second section, I will discuss what
constitutes balanced nutrition: what foods are best for staying sharp
throughout the day, and how you can incorporate a healthy and afford-
able diet into your busy lifestyle.
The third section of chapter four is about a common but rarely
discussed epidemic: repetitive strain injury (RSI). RSI in your hands
and arms can prevent you from working on a computer, and it is
thought to be caused by excessive typing, pipetting, playing instru-
ments, or participating in certain sports. Given that I had never
heard of this condition before graduate school, I was surprised that
28 of the 100 Ph.D.s I interviewed (more than one in four) had suf-
fered from RSI while working on their dissertations. Some experi-
enced relatively mild symptoms (e.g., fatigue and aching in arms),
while others had to eliminate all activities involving their hands for
weeks or even months. Recovery from RSI can be time-consuming
and expensive, because it involves long periods of rest and physical
therapy. During my recovery from RSI, I realized that had I known
more about this condition earlier, I could have easily prevented it. I
xx
considered this issue so relevant to graduate students—as they heav-
ily use computers—that I dedicated the third part of chapter four to
this topic.
Good communication skills are an essential part of scientific
research. Unless you are able to communicate your results effectively,
your accomplishments will go unnoticed. Whether you want to com-
municate with your advisor, group members or a collaborator, you
need to deliver your message clearly. In chapter five, I will discuss the
principles of effective verbal communication, as well as the common
mistakes you will need to avoid in graduate school. Once you learn
these skills, you will no longer dread “the talk” with your advisor (i.e.,
when you will graduate), and you can also be sure that he or she will
listen to what you have to say.
Many students are also apprehensive of another type of com-
munication: writing. If you have little experience writing long manu-
scripts, pulling together a doctoral dissertation can seem daunting.
Yet, you need a written thesis to graduate. In chapter six, I will show
you how to develop an efficient writing process, use writing to explore
your ideas and stay motivated day after day. Many Ph.D.s commented
that graduate school was also an excellent opportunity to improve their
presentation skills, which were essential for their career advancement.
In the second part of chapter six, I will share with you their secrets for
becoming better public speakers.
What happens after you defend your thesis? Do you know what
you want to do after graduation? Do you know where to begin looking
for a job? With the increasing number of people earning Ph.D.s, it is a
challenge to find a suitable position. Many Ph.D.s also question their
career paths; they are no longer sure that they want to become faculty
members, or even stay in their fields of research. What are some other
career options for Ph.D.s? In chapter seven, I will discuss both aca-
demic and alternative careers, and strategies and resources for explor-
ing both paths.
xxi
◆◆ Decrease stress and anxiety
◆◆ Incorporate a healthy diet into your busy lifestyle
◆◆ Prevent and treat repetitive strain injury
coworkers
◆◆ Write your thesis efficiently
xxii
Whether you are thinking about going to graduate school, or are already there, The
Smart Way to Your Ph.D. will serve as your guide to getting your Ph.D. efficiently—
from the application phase to the job searching process. Based on interviews from 100
Ph.D.’s, including professors, lawyers, scientists, and deans from over 40 universities
across the United States, this book will help you to get into graduate school, find
funding, choose an appropriate research group, propose an original research project,
get along with your advisor, reduce stress, write and defend your thesis and prepare
for your job search.
“An outstanding guide to the pursuit of a Ph.D. that lays out a map
with a ‘yellow brick road’ to success. Highly recommended to graduate
students and those contemplating a Ph.D.”
–Steven R. Tannenbaum, Professor of Chemistry and Toxicology,
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
“The Smart Way to Your Ph.D. is AWESOME! This text MUST become
a book for distribution. What a wonderful and timely piece of work.”
–Larry Sass, Associate Professor, Department of Architecture,
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
U.S. $24.95
Your Ph.D.
Consulting