Background: When Does This Movie Take Place?
Background: When Does This Movie Take Place?
Background: When Does This Movie Take Place?
graduated from high school and are about to be drafted into the army. This film takes place in the
summer of 1970, during the War of Attrition (a conflict over land bordering the Suez Canal). All
of these young Israelis experience different conflicts about enlisting. One of them cannot join the
army because he is diabetic. One of them does not want to join the army because he is a pacifist.
Another is trying to decide whether to join an elite unit like his older brothers or the (less
prestigious) army band like his new girlfriend. A fourth Israeli teenager is very excited to
become a paratrooper, but he is tragically killed in training. As a result of his death, his friends
create a unique musical play as a form of political protest and perform it at their high school
graduation. (Think Hair.) This film was very popular in Israel, likely because it reflected the
experience of so many Israelis of Schorr’s generation, who found themselves torn over the War
of Attrition and questioning their government for the first time.
Background
June 1970, about one year and five months since the War of Attrition began and two months
before it ended with a ceasefire.
The War of Attrition was a conflict between Israel and Egypt, lasting from 1969 to 1970.
Resulted from the lack of serious diplomatic attempts to resolve the issues at the heart of
the Arab-Israeli conflict following the 1967 Six Day War.
As part of the September 1967 Khartoum Resolution, Arab states formulated the “Three
Nos” policy: (1) no peace, (2) no recognition of Israel and (3) no negotiations with Israel.
Egyptian President Gamel Abdel Nasser wanted Israel to withdraw from the Sinai (which had
been acquired during the 6-day war)
o This led to more hostilities along the Suez Canal, as there had been during the 6
day war.
o It started out pretty small, with limited artillery duels and small-scale incursions
into the Sinai…
But on March 8, 1969, Nasser proclaimed the official launch of the War of Attrition,
which was characterized by: large scale shelling along the Canal, extensive aerial warfare
and commando raids.
In August 1970, there was a ceasefire, even though Nasser hadn’t accomplished his goal.
o The frontiers remained the same as when the war began, and there was no
commitment to serious peace negotiations.
War of Attrition is called Milhemet haHatashah ( )מלחמת ההתשהin Hebrew…. War of the
weakening.
Takes place in Tel Aviv:
Liberal, Ashkenazic city
Little reference made to non-Ashkenazic Jewry
The wedding is very ashkenazic (klezmer clarinet, Yiddish song)
Side note: I heard from an Israeli film director named Ro’ee whom I met at a Jewish educators
conference that Tel Aviv is now too expensive for most young people to live in. The incoming
mayor will have to contend with that issue.
Generational
- Song written in 1995 about the Yom Kippur War
o Called Winter 73 (choref shiv’im v’shalosh), about those conceived immediately
after the Yom Kippur war
“You promised us doves and peace… didn’t want to send us to war”
The toll that war takes on Israeli society
Individual
- Argument at the beach, following the wedding: the groom argues that war/the army is
necessary for peace… Israel has to be strong if it wants peace (otherwise its vulnerable to
enemies) and being strong means having an army, and having an army means people get
killed. It’s just how things work.
Conservative? Accepting the status quo? Mainstream.
Even today it is relatively rare to seek exempts… although as more Israelis travel to India
and other places where they are exposed to pacifist ideals, more are against war
Counter-argument: Israel is a democracy, and speaking out against war can be part of being an
Israeli, too. (Minority opinion)