Ammonia Production Plant Design Project: by Alyeldin Helmy, Baihan Wang, Rajdeep Dev
Ammonia Production Plant Design Project: by Alyeldin Helmy, Baihan Wang, Rajdeep Dev
Ammonia Production Plant Design Project: by Alyeldin Helmy, Baihan Wang, Rajdeep Dev
Project
<https://images.app.goo.gl/NmJxqBJjCCV4nod57>
Submitted to
CHBE 201:
Submitted by
Here is the final design report you requested on ammonia production plant.
This report analyzes the reaction catalyst used, energy balances, process
description, process control, and safety and environmental analysis for the
ammonia production process.
Sincerely,
Alyeldin Helmy, Baihan Wang, Rajdeep Dev
Executive Summary
This report analyses the design and sustainability of the ammonia production plant
from a variety of various scopes.This report explains the design of a plant capable of
producing 350,000 tonnes per year of ammonia. All data on the plant were obtained via
research papers , articles, trusted websites and case studies. Sections mentioned below
implement the simplest pathway in producing ammonia in an efficient and sustainable
matter.
The ammonia production plant design consists of the reaction catalysts used, the
separation train, energy balances, process description and process flow diagram (PFD),
process control, safety and environment. Ammonia is produced using the Haber-Bosch
process with the help of iron as a catalyst.Iron is the recommended catalyst considering
cost and safety concerns. A condenser is used to separate ammonia from the unreacted
gases ( H2 and
N2 ) and utility used to run the condenser is the very low temperature
refrigerant (VLTR). VLTR is the simplest and least expensive way for separating the
liquefied NH3 at
required temperature. All unreacted gases are recycled back to ensure that
maximum yield of ammonia is obtained. Temperature is controlled in one of the heat
exchangers to execute the reaction. a “What-if” analysis is made to establish the
environmental and safety requirements.
Findings:
Recommendations:
→ Iron catalyst is chosen due to its cost effectiveness and environmental impact.
→ recycle unreacted gases to ensure maximum yield.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY………………………………………………….iv
LIST OF TABLES…………………………………………………………..v
LIST OF FIGURES………………………………………………………….v
1.0 INTRODUCTION…………………………………………………………
2.0 REACTION
CATALYSTS………………………………………………..
2.1 Introduction…………………………………………………………………...
2.2 Iron (Fe) based catalyst.……………………………………………………..
APPENDIX…………………………………………………………...
REFERENCES………………………………………………………...
LIST OF TABLES
LIST OF FIGURES
Ammonia is a naturally occurring compound that presents as a colourless gas or liquid. The chemical
formula NH3 reflects
the central nitrogen atom surrounded by hydrogen bonds (fig.1). Ammonia
plays a large role in fertilizer production as it is a readily available source of nitrogen; it is also used
as a disinfectant and a refrigerant [1]. Annual global production of ammonia (2016) is at around
146,000,000 tonnes per year [2]. Based on the 2016 average price of ammonia in Illinois ($578 USD
per tonne), the estimated value is $84,000,000,000 per year [3]. Currently, the largest ammonia
plants can 1,000,000 tonnes per year (3000 tonnes per day) [2]. The market of ammonia is based on
the global population. As the population grows, the demand of ammonia will follow an upward
trend.
This report explains the design of a plant capable of producing 350,000 tonnes per year of ammonia.
The plant will be located in Southern Manitoba near Winnipeg, where many chemical plants are
located. The min (-40.0°C) and max temperature (36.1°C) vary greatly in Winnipeg area [4]. The
manufacturing process requires a high temperature (450°C), high pressure (200 atm), and iron
catalytic conditions. The Haber-Bosch process utilizes two raw materials. Nitrogen is acquired from
the atmosphere, and hydrogen is obtained from natural gas and steam. A simplified input-output
diagram shows the overall reaction (fig. 2). The formula for the reaction (1) is shown below. Table 1
provides molecular weights and costs.
(g/mol) ($USD/tonne)
The design report will be submitted to both CHBE 201 and CHBE 220 course. The design process of
the project follows the 12 step process. The source of materials are cited and referenced using IEEE
format.
2.1 Introduction
Three possible catalysts are considered for the Haber-Bosch reaction: Iron(Fe), Ruthenium(Ru), and
Ruthenium Based Ba-Ca(NH2)2 catalyst. A functional decomposition is used to develop criteria that is
applied quantitatively in an evaluative matrix to score and select the best catalyst. Iron catalyst is
found to be the most suitable choice.
The formation of diazene (see mechanism 1) is the rate determining step for the complete reaction.
The triple bond found in N2 and single bond in H2 must be broken, hence the high temperatures
required. Once these temperatures are reached, an iron catalyst provides an ideal surface and the
free electrons required for the breaking of these bonds.
Ruthenium is a viable replacement for an iron catalyst. utilizing ruthenium significantly reduces the
high temperatures and pressures required for the efficiency of the Haber-Bosch process [2].
However, using ruthenium comes with the drawback of uncertain costs and supply as it is a rare
earth metal and hydrogen poisoning. Ruthenium based catalysts favour the production of single
hydrogen atoms over single nitrogen atoms. Thus the presence of excess hydrogen severely limits
the production of utilizable nitrogen.
Another catalyst is calcium amide with a small amount of added barium (Ba-Ca(NH2)2) [7]. Calcium
amide increases the activity of Ru-based catalyst and the nanometer thin particle layer of barium
forms a Ru-Ba core-shell structure to prevent hydrogen poisoning. This catalyst has 100 times
greater activity than ruthenium catalyst at low temperatures below 300 °C, and obtains a six times
higher synthesis rate than Fe-based catalyst (at 340 °C) [8]. The calcium amide catalyst requires far
less energy than ruthenium and Fe-based catalysts, which makes on-site production possible [9].
Different attributes are described by order of importance and evaluated . They are used in an
evaluative matrix to quantitatively compare and select the best catalyst used for this design project.
Each criterion is assigned a weighted, numerical value (between 1 to 5) that is applied in a table to
each of the pathways or catalysts to select the option with the highest score. Evaluation is based on
4 criteria : Cost of the catalyst, Energy Input, Efficiency, and Safety. The cost of catalyst greatly affect
plants profit and is assigned 40% weight. Energy input is how the catalyst lowers the temperature or
pressure needed in the reaction and efficiency is how the catalyst shorten the reaction time. Certain
catalyst might be hazardous or require severe reacting condition, meaning larger investments in
proper training operators of the plant. These three criteria are weighted 20% each.
Cost 40% 5 4 1
Energy 20% 2 3 5
Efficiency 20% 4 4 5
Safety 20% 2 2 3
Total 100% 3.6 3.4 3
Table 2: Evaluation of Catalysts
An iron catalyst and the Haber-Bosch process are the recommended catalyst and reaction pathway.
Calcium amide with high efficiency appears an attractive choice, but it is incredibly expensive. The
iron catalyst scores the highest in the evaluation matrix and is a well-researched field and geared
towards the dedicated large-scale production of ammonia.
The ideal reactor used in this procedure is the fixed bed reactor. This reactor operates at a
temperature of 450°C and at 200 atm of pressure to decompose. The heat transfer coefficient in the
reactor is 500 kcal/m2hr°C. The conversion rate of the reactor is relatively low at 15%-20%. The
Haber-Bosch process has no side product and all the unreacted reactants are recycled. The
conversion rate can rise to 97% after multiple passes.
3.1 Introduction
The Haber-Bosch process is used to produce ammonia. Hydrogen and nitrogen gas are mixed under
high temperature and pressure to synthesize ammonia. The reaction intermediates, diazene and
hydrazine, are consumed instantaneously. The overall reaction has a conversion rate of 15% for a
single pass, and a maximum of 97% after recycle the unreacted reactants for multiple passes [12].
The products in the exit stream need to be separated. The component of the stream are unreacted
hydrogen and nitrogen and the desired product ammonia.
Unreacted H2 and N2 is recycled to the reactor through a gas compressor. The yield of ammonia
achieves 97% after recycling H2 and N2 for multiple passes. Figure 1 shows a block model for inputs
and outputs of the separation unit.
4.1 Introduction
An energy balance is performed when ammonia and unused reactants enter the condenser.
Ammonia has a much higher boiling point than the reactants in the product stream. Condensation is
used for the separation technique. The boiling point of ammonia is -33.3°C. The stream is cooled to
-43.3°C to ensure that all possible ammonia is condensed and to give a margin of safety.
A very low temperature refrigerant (VLTR) is used for the energy balance. This is the most suitable
utility as the inlet and outlet temperature range satisfies the temperature of -43.3°C that is desired.
This utility is also less expensive than an extremely low temperature refrigerant (ELTR). It is crucial to
note again, the entire product stream containing unused reactants and products [M1] are cooled as
a whole.
Table C: Utility energy values
To cool the gaseous ammonia to a liquid state, the product stream is cooled from 450°C to -43.3°C.
Appendix A shows The mass flow rate of each component and supporting calculations. The heat
capacities (Cp) of ammonia, hydrogen, and nitrogen are 49.8 Jmol-1K-1 [14], 29.53Jmol-1K-1 [15], and
31.10Jmol-1K-1 [16], respectively. Thus, the amount of energy required to cool the stream is
calculated from these respective values. The reactants are found in the product stream, cooling the
entire stream is taken into consideration. The final energy value will be the sum of these three
separate products. The final energy value is 73.79 GJhr-1. Assuming a price of $13.11 GJ-1, the hourly
operating cost will be $967.39 hr-1. Assuming a standard 8000-hour operating year, the yearly
operational cost is $7,739,120.00 per operating year.
5.1 Introduction
The process flow diagram below focuses on the Haber-Bosch process. The main reactors are the
fixed bed reactor (FBR) and the condenser, which separates ammonia from the reactants. The
stream table listed below indicates all material balances related to the PFD.
Stream number 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Vapour 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 1
fraction
Molar flow 1.28 3.85 5.13 5.13 4.74 4.74 2.49 0.15
(tonne mol/hr)
Component
molar flow
(tonne mol/hr)
The reactants are fed directly into the FBR (R-101) which contains an extremely porous iron metal
catalyst. H2 and N2 are converted into diazene (N2H2) which forms hydrazine (N2H4). hydrazine reacts
with H2 and forms NH3. The reaction intermediates are consumed in the process and are not in the
product stream exiting the FBR (R-101). the reactants are separated from the product stream. The
product stream passes through a condenser (E-102) that cools the stream from 450°C to -43°C. Since
the ammonia condenses at a much higher temperature than H2 and N2, the reactants remain as
gases and the ammonia is pumped (P-101) from the condenser into the storage tank (TK-101) . The
storage tank is kept at a temperature below -33.34°C and no less than -77.70°C to prevent the
ammonia from evaporating or solidifying. This is achieved with the ultra-low temperature coolant.
Remaining H2 and N2 are recycled back after the mixing point through the gas compressor (C-103)
for further production of ammonia.
6.0 PROCESS CONTROL
6.1 Introduction
In this section, the control strategy in the ammonia production plant is discussed. In the ammonia
manufacturing process, high temperature is required for the Haber-Bosch process. Thus, a
temperature control system is installed in the heating column (E-101) to ensure that hydrogen and
nitrogen are heated to the desired temperature required to execute the reaction.
6.2 Control
The gas mixture of nitrogen and hydrogen is heated in the heat exchanger(E-101) to 450 °C before
sent into the reactor(R-101). The temperature of gas entering the reactor are measured through a
temperature transmitter(TT-101). A signal is sent to the temperature controller(TC-101) which
controls the control valve(CV-101) connected to the heat exchanger(E-101). The valve controls the
stream of high temperature steam which is the heating agent.
When temperature in stream 4 is higher than 450 °C, control valve(CV-101) closes, and the flow of
high temperature steam used to heat the reactants will slow down, resulting in the decrease of
temperature in the heat exchanger(E-101). When the temperature in stream 4 is lower than 450 °C,
the control valve(CV-101) will open and allow more steam to heat the reactants, resulting in the
increase of temperature in the heat exchanger(E-101).
7.0 SAFETY AND ENVIRONMENT
A Process safety and environment analysis for the heat exchanger E-101 is discussed in the section
below. This analysis uses the “what-if” process hazard analysis strategy. Its purpose is to identify
problems that could lead to terrible accidents. This process results in a list of potential problem
areas and proposes mitigation methods.
This “What-If” analysis focuses on the heat exchanger (E-101) which is shown in Figure 1:
Process Flow diagram. The “what-if” focuses on three deviations that are appropriate to E-101: 1) If
condensate valve (CV-101) fails open, 2) If condensate valve (CV-101) fails closed, 3) If a leak
develops in E-101.
The flow of high temperature steam pass the heat exchanger quickly with relatively low steam
pressure if the valve fails closed[17]. This lowers the heating temperature executing the reaction,
which is compromised. The ammonia synthesis reaction equilibrium moves to the left side if gases
with temperature below 450°C enter reactor R-101 as the reaction is reversible. It lowers ammonia
production in the reactor. An emergency shutdown valve on the steam tube can solve the problem
The flow of heated steam exiting the heat exchanger slows down if the valve fails open. This causes
increasing steam pressure in the steam tube thus the hydrogen and nitrogen in the heat exchanger
will be overheated[17]. There is a risk of pressure buildup in the reactor if gases with a temperature
higher than desired accumulated in the reactor. The gas compressor C-102 is overloaded and the
equipment is damaged. Installing a pressure relief valve in the reactor R-101 as well as an emergency
shutdown valve on the stream entering the reactor can solve this problem.
A leak in the tube leads to mixing of hydrogen, nitrogen, and ammonia gas with heated steam.
Ammonia reacts with heated steam causing a decrease in final yield of ammonia[1]. The steam cools
down after leaving the tube and exposes to the air. The leak of steam does not lead to any
hazardous situation.
Recommendations
Addition of pressure relief equipment on the steam tube and the reactor is recommended to avoid
any consequences if the condensate valve (CV-101) fails open. Installing an emergency shutdown
valve on the stream entering the reactor is recommended to mitigate accidents if CV-101 fails close.
Regular maintenance and operations are suggested to ensure no leakage in E-101.
Figure 4: Process Control Diagram
8.0 CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION
This report details the process design to produce 350,000 tonnes of ammonia per year. The
ammonia production process uses nitrogen and hydrogen as reagents and iron as a catalyst. The
overall cost of the process and the safety of the plant holds preference in each design decision.
Findings
Iron catalyst is compared to ruthenium and Ba-Ca(NH2)2 catalyst and found to be most suitable. The
synthesis reaction has a low yield so a separation unit is required to recycle unreacted H2 and N2 to
achieve a reaction yield of 97%. A process flow diagram outlines the general flow of the plant
process and equipment. Three “what if scenarios” involving failure of condensate valves and a tube
are analysed to recommend a solution.
Recommendations
Iron catalyst is recommended as it is the most cost effective with low environmental impact. A very
low temperature refrigerant is used to separate unreacted H2 and N2 to obtain maximum yield.
Installation of a pressure release valve and shutdown equipment helps to resolve any risk.
Appendix
Reference
[1] “Ammonia,” National Center for Biotechnology Information. PubChem Compound Database. [Online].
Available: https://pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/compound/Ammonia. [Accessed: 16-Sep-2019].
[2] M. Lichtarowicz, “Ammonia,” Essential Chemical Industry Online. [Online]. Available:
http://www.essentialchemicalindustry.org/chemicals/ammonia.html. [Accessed: 16-Sep-2019].
[3] “Nitrogen Prices, Rates Cuts, and 2018 Fertilizer Costs • farmdoc daily,” farmdoc daily, 18-Apr-2018.
[Online]. Available:
https://farmdocdaily.illinois.edu/2018/04/nitrogen-prices-rates-cuts-and-2018-fertilizer-cost.html.
[Accessed: 16-Sep-2019].
[4] “Temperature - Monthly data for Winnipeg,” Amateur Weather Statistics for Winnipeg, Manitoba.
[Online]. Available:
https://winnipeg.weatherstats.ca/charts/temperature-monthly.html?fbclid=IwAR1PKbWdytFRMl8i
VKeBaAt-S6DoTarXy_kebDkA2RpSSH5Dki3zGPNaGXE. [Accessed: 16-Sep-2019].
[5] “Joint Agency Staff Report on Assembly Bill 8: Assessment of Time and Cost Needed to Attain 100
Hydrogen Refueling Stations in California,” [ Online]. Available:
https://ww2.energy.ca.gov/2015publications/CEC-600-2015-016/CEC-600-2015-016.pdf.
[Accessed 16-Sep-2019].
[8] IChemE, “Highly efficient ammonia synthesis with new catalyst,” The Chemical Engineer. [Online].
Available:
https://www.thechemicalengineer.com/news/highly-efficient-ammonia-synthesis-with-new-catalyst/
. [Accessed: 23-Sep-2019].
[9] “Highly efficient ammonia synthesis catalyst developed More than three times the efficiency of current
industrial catalysts,” Tokyo Institute of Technology. [Online]. Available:
https://www.titech.ac.jp/english/news/2018/040537.html. [Accessed: 23-Sep-2019].
[10] M. Lichtarowicz, “Chemical reactors,” Essential Chemical Industry Online. [Online]. Available:
http://www.essentialchemicalindustry.org/processes/chemical-reactors.html. [Accessed:
24-Sep-2019].
[17]“Troubleshooting tips for steam heat exchangers,” ACHR News RSS, 10-Aug-2011. [Online].
Available:
https://www.achrnews.com/articles/83487-troubleshooting-tips-for-steam-heat-exchangers-1.
[Accessed: 15-Dec-2019].