Relationship of Debtor and Creditor
Relationship of Debtor and Creditor
Relationship of Debtor and Creditor
When a customer opens an account with a bank and if the account has a credit balance, then the
relationship is that of debtor (banker / bank) and creditor (customer).
In case of savings / fixed deposit / current account (with credit balance), the banker is the debtor,
and the customer is the creditor. This is because the banker owes money to the customer. The
customer has the right to demand back his money whenever he wants it from the banker, and the
banker must repay the balance to the customer.
In case of loan / advance accounts, banker is the creditor, and the customer is the debtor because
the customer owes money to the banker. The banker can demand the repayment of loan /
advance on the due date, and the customer has to repay the debt.
A customer remains a creditor until there is credit balance in his account with the banker. A
customer (creditor) does not get any charge over the assets of the banker (debtor). The customer's
status is that of an unsecured creditor of the banker.
The debtor-creditor relationship of banker and customer differs from other commercial debts in
the following ways:
1. The creditor (the customer) must demand payment. On his own, the debtor (banker) will
not repay the debt. However, in case of fixed deposits, the bank must inform a customer
about maturity.
2. The creditor must demand the payment at the right time and place. The depositor or
creditor must demand the payment at the branch of the bank, where he has opened the
account. However, today, some banks allow payment at all their branches and ATM
centres. The depositor must demand the payment at the right time (during the working
hours) and on the date of maturity in the case of fixed deposits. Today, banks also allow
pre-mature withdrawals.
3. The creditor must make the demand for payment in a proper manner. The demand must
be in form of cheques; withdrawal slips, or pay order. Now-a-days, banks allow e-
banking, ATM, mobile-banking, etc.
The relationship between customer and banker can be that of Pledger and Pledgee. This happens
when customer pledges (promises) certain assets or security with the bank in order to get a loan.
In this case, the customer becomes the Pledger, and the bank becomes the Pledgee. Under this
agreement, the assets or security will remain with the bank until a customer repays the loan.
The relationship between banker and customer can be that of a Licensor and Licensee. This
happens when the banker gives a sale deposit locker to the customer. So, the banker will become
the Licensor, and the customer will become the Licensee.
The relationship between banker and customer can be that of Bailor and Bailee.
1. Bailment is a contract for delivering goods by one party to another to be held in trust for
a specific period and returned when the purpose is ended.
2. Bailor is the party that delivers property to another.
3. Bailee is the party to whom the property is delivered.
So, when a customer gives a sealed box to the bank for safe keeping, the customer became the
bailor, and the bank became the bailee.
The relationship between customer and banker can be that of Hypothecator and Hypotheatee.
This happens when the customer hypothecates (pledges) certain movable or non-movable
property or assets with the banker in order to get a loan. In this case, the customer became the
Hypothecator, and the Banker became the Hypothecatee.
A trustee holds property for the beneficiary, and the profit earned from this property belongs to
the beneficiary. If the customer deposits securities or valuables with the banker for safe custody,
banker becomes a trustee of his customer. The customer is the beneficiary so the ownership
remains with the customer.
The banker acts as an agent of the customer (principal) by providing the following agency
services:
Buying and selling securities on his behalf,
Collection of cheques, dividends, bills or promissory notes on his behalf, and
Acting as a trustee, attorney, executor, correspondent or representative of a customer.
Banker as an agent performs many other functions such as payment of insurance premium,
electricity and gas bills, handling tax problems, etc.
9. Other Relationships
1. Obligation to honour cheques- the banker is under a statutory obligation to honour his
customer’s cheques in the ordinary course of business. If he wrongfully dishonors the
cheque, then he is liable to the customer for damages.
Thus the banker is bound to honour the customers cheque provided the following conditions
are fulfilled-
(a) Sufficient funds- there must be sufficient funds of the drawer in the hands of the drawee.
A banker should be given sufficient time to release the amount of the cheque sent for
collection before the said amount can be drawn upon by the customer. The banker can
dishonor the cheques if there are insufficient funds.
(b) Funds must be properly applicable- a customer might be having several bank accounts
in his various capacities. But is essential that the account on which a cheque is drawn
must have sufficient funds. If some funds are earmarked by the customer for some
specific purpose, they are not available for honouring the cheques. But where the
customer has overdraft facility the banker has the obligation to honour the cheque upto
the amount of overdraft sanctioned.
(c) The banker must be duly required to pay- the banker is bound to honour the cheque only
when hi is duly required to pay. The cheque, complete and in order, must be presented
before the banker at the proper time.
2. Obligation to maintain secrecy of accounts-The customer’s account details are
recorded in the books of the banker and the true state of his financial dealings are available
with the banker. If any of these facts are made known to others, the customer’s reputation
might suffer and he might incur losses also. The banker is therefore under an obligation to
take utmost care in keeping secrecy of the details of the customer.
However, this rule has exceptions(mention briefly)
3. Obligation to keep a proper record of transaction- the banker must keep a proper and
accurate record of all the transactions of the customer. Sometimes, he may commit some
wrong.
8. Explain the banker’s right of general lien.
Lien means a legal claim to hold property as security. According to Halsbury, lien may be
defined as “a right in man to retain that which is in his possession belonging to another, until
certain demands of the person in possession is satisfied”.
Lien is of two kinds- 1) specific or particular lien and 2) general lien
A particular lien is one which confers a right to retain the goods in connection with a
particular debt only while a general lien is a right to retain all the goods or any property of
another until all the claims of the holder are satisfied. It extends to all transactions and thus
more extensive.
Banker’s right of general lien
One of the important rights enjoyed by a banker is the right of general lien. In Brando v.
Barnet, it was held that bankers most undoubtedly have a general lien on all securities
deposited with them as bankers unless there is an express or implied contract inconsistent with
lien.
In India sec 171 of the Indian Contract Act confers general lien upon bankers as follows-
bankers…..may in absence of a contract to the contrary, retain as a security for a general
balance of account, any goods bailed to them.
Circumstances for exercising general lien
1) No agreement inconsistent with the right of lien.
2) Property must be possessed in his capacity as a banker.
3) Possession should be lawfully obtained.
4) Property should not be entrusted to the banker for a specific purpose.
Incidents of lien- lien attaches to
1) Bills of exchange or cheques deposited for collection or pending discount.
2) Dividend warrants and interest warrants paid to the banker under mandates issued by
the customer.
3) Securities deposited to secure specific loan but left in banker’s hand after loan is repaid.
4) Securities, negotiable or not, which the banker has purchased or taken up, at the
request of customer, for the amount paid.
Exceptions- banker has no general lien
1) On safe custody deposits.
2) On securities or bills of exchange entrusted for specific purpose.
3) On articles lefty by mistake or negligence.
4) On deposit account.
5) On stolen bond.
6) Until due date of the loan.
7) On trust account.
8) On title deeds of immovable properties.
9. What are the circumstances under which a disclosure by