Dubbel Vanos M52-M54 Seals
Dubbel Vanos M52-M54 Seals
Dubbel Vanos M52-M54 Seals
Introduction
“Vanos” is BMW’s name for its variable valve timing units. Vanos units take
on various shapes and design according to car year and model (engine
model). The vanos discussed here is BMW part # 11-36-1-440-142. It’s a
double vanos; meaning both the intake and exhaust valve timing is varied.
This vanos unit is part of BMW 6-cylinder engines M52TU, M54, and M56.
These engines were incorporated into a wide range of car models during
years 1998-2006. They are found in the 3-series E46 98-05, 5-series E39
99-03 / E60 & E61 02-05, 7-series E38 98-01 / E65 & E66 02-05, Z3 E36
98-02, Z4 E85 02-05, X3 E83 03-06, X5 E53 00-06.
This vanos has been experiencing a failure. It has been diagnosed that the
failure is due to deterioration of the vanos piston seal O-rings. It has been
determined that these O-rings are made from Buna (Buna-N, NBR, Nitrile).
Buna is a very common O-ring material, but is limited in its temperature and
chemical resistance characteristics. Unfortunately it is fairing quite badly in
the vanos/engine environment. The O-rings have been found to harden,
shrink, and have flat surfaces. This deterioration is causing the O-rings to
lose their functional characteristics and thus cause the vanos to fail. BMW
has been engaged regarding this matter, but has elected to not address the
issue, “No further development will be done”. New (rebuilt) vanos units are
being sold with the same Buna O-rings. BMW does not provide the vanos
piston seals/O-rings as a separate part.
Here is a link to the Roadfly BMW E39 forum where much of this
information was first made
public: http://bimmer.roadfly.com/bmw/forums/e39/7494631-2.html
The piston O-rings lie under and provide support to piston Teflon seal rings.
Replacing the O-rings requires removing the Teflon seals to access the O-
rings. The Teflon seals can not be practically removed from the piston seal
grooves without damaging them. Thus replacing the O-rings necessarily
requires replacing the Teflon seals.
The Buna O-rings can be replaced with O-rings made from Viton. Viton
(FKM, Fluorocarbon) has similar functional characteristics to Buna, but has
much higher temperature and chemical resistance characteristics. It’s also
recommended for the automobile engine environment. The vanos Teflon
(PTFE filled) seals are not a standard part and need to be semi-custom
manufactured.
The vanos has two pistons with seals/O-rings. Each piston utilizes two
seal/O-ring sizes to provide hydraulic sealing in two vanos cylinders of
different sizes. Each piston also utilizes one further small O-ring. This O-
ring mounts on a small cap that’s used to seal off a piston bearing. The
OEM O-ring for this cap seems to also be made from Buna and is
deteriorating in the same manner as the piston seal O-rings.
Symptoms
Cars experience:
Overall loss of torque and power, particularly in the lower RPM range, < 3k.
Bogging then surging at 3k RPM. Uneven power distribution and RPM
transition. Engine hesitations in the lower RPM range, < 3k. Louder idle and
intermittent idle RPM hiccups. Difficult takeoffs. Loss of power and bogging
when AC on. Increased fuel consumption.
Repairing the vanos seals provides:
Overall increase in torque and power, particularly in the lower RPM range, <
3k. Resolution of bogging then surging at 3k RPM. Smooth even distribution
of power and RPM transition. Resolution of engine hesitations in the lower
RPM range, < 3k. Quiet stable idle. Smooth easy takeoffs. Improved
performance when AC on. Reduced fuel consumption, by ~10%.
Cars with the M52TU engine (98/99-00) experience cold weather cold start
idle jolts and possible stall.
In some cases the engine computer will generate a fault code. The code is
usually associated with the vanos exhaust side. This is due to the powerful
spring in the vanos exhaust cylinder which forces the piston out. Fault
codes include:
P1520 (BMW 104, 0x68): B (exhaust) Camshaft Position Actuator (faulty
reference value).
P1523 (BMW 106, 0x6A): B (exhaust) Camshaft Position Actuator Tight or
Jammed (mechanically stuck).
P1397 (BMW 18, 0x12): Camshaft Position Sensor B (exhaust) Circuit.
The exhaust camshaft position sensor (CPS) is a common failure. But if
replacing the exhaust CPS (w/ OEM CPS) doesn’t work then it’s likely the
vanos failure.
On 01+ M54 & M56 engine cars codes P1520 & P1523 were removed.
Thus code P1397 appears.
Diagnosis
With M52TU engine cars (98/99-00) with cold engine idle jolt symptoms, the
vanos intake solenoid (metal cylinder) electrical connector can be removed.
If the idle jolts cease then the problem is the vanos seals.
A vanos exhaust side fault code, as described above, is most likely a vanos
seals failure indication.
Otherwise the vanos needs to be removed from the engine for inspection.
Once the vanos cylinder covers are removed, an inspection of the piston
seals fit in the cylinders will show a loose fit and thus a seals failure.
Removal of the seals from the pistons will show the inner O-rings have flat
spots and a loss of elasticity.
Repair Procedure
The following is an E46 & E39 double vanos piston seals R&R (remove and
replace) procedure.
If the valve cover gaskets are over 40k miles (64k kilometers) old, then it’s
prudent to replace them during this repair. If they are over 80k miles (128k
kilometers) old, then it is a requirement to replace them during this repair,
otherwise they might leak due to being dismounted and reused. These
gaskets have an estimated lifespan of ~60k miles (96k kilometers) and
replacing them during this repair requires no extra effort. The needed parts
and replacement procedure are included as optional.
Parts with part number pattern xx-xx-x-xxx-xxx are BMW parts and can be
acquired from a BMW dealership.
Beisan Systems only provides the vanos seals repair kit.
Double vanos seals repair kit (6-cyl) (BS001) $60/each
(www.beisansystems.com), vanos gasket (11-36-1-433-817) 6.73/each, 2 x
vanos oil hose/pipe washer (32-41-1-093-596) $.25/each
Optional Parts
M56:
Valve cover gasket replacement parts: valve cover gasket set (11-12-7-521-
009) $63.05/each & (11-12-7-521-010) $17.52/each, 15 x valve cover bolt
grommet (11-12-1-437-395) $1.73/each
Easily breakable parts: 2 x vanos piston bolt (11-36-1-748-745) $1.42/each,
fan shroud rivet (17-11-1-712-963) $.27/each
E39: Small adjustable hose clamp. Needed if radiator overflow hose OEM
clamp not previously replaced with adjustable clamp.
A Baum Tools water pump pulley holder or holder and 32mm wrench
combo can be purchased from El Paso Tool store.
Go to El Paso Tool store and perform a “Store search” for “115030”. Check
the “in titles & description” check box.
El Paso Tool store
Paper towels, water based cleaner (simple green 1:10), spray lubricant,
brake cleaner, engine oil (synthetic 5W30)
Parts plate, small oil container, large cup
RTV sealant, magic marker
Not shown: large pad (quilt), oil pan, 3 small cloth towels, 2 grocery plastic
bags
Repair
Right and Left denotations are from car front at hood orientation.
[picture]
Disconnect coil harness rail from valve cover clips.
Pry on each right side clip and pull out coil harness rail (flathead).
Pull off complete coil harness. E46: Set coil harness on intake manifold.
E39: Set coil harness on strut tower.
Remove coils.
Unscrew 2 mounting bolts w/ washers at each coil (10mm socket 3/8” / 3/8”
ratchet & extension). Note coil ground straps at coil 1 & 6.
Pull up and out all coils.
Note: Maintain coil/cylinder association for reinstallation. This is not
necessary, but is good practice.
Remove coil ground straps at Cylinders 1 & 6 (8mm socket 1/4” / 1/4”
ratchet & extension).
Note: On older models (99), third bolt/stud from front is same as the
perimeter bolts. This is due to no ground connection at this location. Note
this for reinstallation.
Remove valve cover from engine head.
Insert blade (putty-knife) between valve cover gasket and engine head at all
front end accessible locations to break gasket bond. Be sure to break RTV
sealant bond at sides of front half moon dips and vanos/head matting points
on each front side.
Pull up and remove valve cover. If resistant, insert blade (putty-knife)
between valve cover gasket and engine head at sticking locations.
Note: If valve cover can not be removed, double check valve cover 11
perimeter bolts and 4 center bolts/studs have been removed. If valve cover
is stuck, pull up on free front end of cover and right side vent pipe neck to
break gasket bond on remainder of valve cover.
Remove thermostat electrical connector. Press in on metal clip and pull off
connector.
Remove vanos intake solenoid electrical connector. Press in on metal clip
and pull off connector.
Note: If a bolt breaks, continue removal of vanos from engine. Once vanos
is removed remaining bolt in splined shaft can be easily unthreaded (pick
tool), left hand thread.
Remove vanos 6 mounting nuts at front lower half of vanos (10mm socket
3/8” / 3/8” ratchet & extension).
Remove vanos top right mounting bolt/stud (13mm socket 1/2” / 1/2”
ratchet). Note: Deep socket needed (1/2”).
Pull vanos forward off head mounting studs and lift out of engine
compartment.
Note: Cover vanos with double plastic bags with towels at bottom to catch
spilling engine oil (grocery plastic bags, towels).
Take vanos to oil receptacle and attempt to drain all oil from vanos (oil pan).
Tilt vanos to facilitate drainage of oil from vanos cylinder covers, inner oil
relieve spouts, and outer oil feed access.
Note vanos intake and exhaust orientation (picture: intake left, exhaust
right).
Mark (magic marker) an “I” and “E” on the vanos intake and exhaust pistons
respectively to maintain piston to cylinder association. This is not
necessary, but is good practice.
Note: Vanos intake and exhaust pistons are same part components and
can be interchanged. Maintaining piston to cylinder association is good
practice.
Remove vanos cylinder covers. Remove bolts at each cover (10mm socket
3/8” / 3/8” ratchet & extension). Initially break each bolt seize, then unscrew
the bolts.
Note: Exhaust side cylinder has spring behind piston that will force cylinder
cover off during removal. Push down on cover to facilitate bolt removal.
Inspect vanos cylinders (main body & covers) by feel for any marring. Walls
should be exceedingly smooth with no felt irregularities.
Note: Seal sliding wear patterns will be present, and cylinder walls will not
be as polished at ends of cylinders.
Two seal rings will be removed from each piston groove, total of four rings
removed from each piston.
Note: During seals removal, care should be taken not to nick piston groove
rims.
For each piston perform following seals removal.
Cut cross section of piston large Teflon seal in piston groove (razor knife).
Note: Rocking of blade while pressing helps create cutting motion.
Cut cross section of piston large O-ring in piston groove (razor knife).
Note: Rocking of blade while pressing helps create cutting motion.
Cut cross section of piston small Teflon seal in piston groove (razor knife).
Note: Rocking of blade while pressing helps create cutting motion.
When seals removal is complete, piston grooves will have exposed metal
with no seals.
Wipe clean piston grooves (towel).
Before new seals installation, be sure four seal rings were removed from
each piston, two from each groove, and piston grooves show exposed
metal (above picture).
Two seal rings will be installed in each piston groove, total of four rings
installed in each piston.
Verify O-ring is not twisted in piston groove. Adjust and center as necessary
(pick tool).
If Teflon seals in cold environment, < 70F (21C), soak seals in warm water
for 2+ minutes.
Remove and dry Teflon seal just before installation.
Note: Perform following step on ground over large pad while kneeling with
knees on pad. This minimizes risk of dropping piston and damaging its
surfaces.
Note: Attempt to stretch Teflon seal evenly and take care to not
scuff/damage. Some sliding of seal on piston rim is normal.
Note: Moderate force is needed to stretch Teflon seals.
Once stretched and installed, Teflon seals will fit loosely in piston grooves.
Apply coat of assembly lubricant (engine oil) to vanos piston large Teflon
seal and adjacent piston surfaces.
Insert piston large end into intake cylinder at ~60 degree angle, then rotate
piston to insert into cylinder.
Allow piston to sit in cylinder for 2 minutes then remove. Teflon seal will be
compressed close to original size.
Apply coat of assembly lubricant (engine oil) to vanos cover cylinder wall.
Be sure to include chamfer (rim bevel).
Apply coat of assembly lubricant (engine oil) to vanos piston small Teflon
seal and adjacent piston surfaces.
Insert piston small end into cover cylinder inboard side. Insert piston with a
slight tilt to cylinder. Excess seal will protrude from groove at tilted out end
of piston groove.
Press protruding seal into piston groove and rotate piston to insert into
cover cylinder.
If seal is binding, reposition piston and attempt again. With each attempt
seal will partially resized. Eventually piston can be fully rotated without
binding seal.
Allow piston to sit in cylinder for 2 minutes then remove. Teflon seal will be
compressed close to original size.
Verify piston Teflon seals have shrunk in size (resized) and recessed into
piston grooves. Note: Teflon seals will protrude some (~1mm) from piston
grooves.
Apply coat of assembly lubricant (engine oil) to all four vanos cylinder walls.
Be sure to include chamfer (rim bevel).
Clean vanos body / cover matting surfaces and all cover bolts (brake
cleaner & towels).
Install pistons fully into vanos cover cylinders. Install intake/exhaust pistons
(previously marked) into associated covers. Intake side cover has 5 bolt
holes and exhaust side cover has 4 bolt holes.
Note: Some alignment and effort will be necessary to reinsert pistons into
cover cylinders.
Mount cover bolts (10mm socket 3/8” / 3/8” ratchet & extension).
Note: Exhaust side has resistance due to spring. Push down on cylinder
cover while mounting bolts. Mount bolts evenly to insert piston evenly.
Fully tighten, 10 Nm (7 ft-lb) (10mm socket 3/8” / 3/8” torque wrench &
extension).
Note: Tighten bolts evenly in crisscross pattern.
Note: When cleaning parts, spray cleaning compound on towel then wipe
component with towel. Components can also be placed in a small container
and sprayed with cleaning compound then individually wiped with towel.
Clean vanos matting surfaces; head, valve cover, oil feed (brake cleaner &
towels).
Remove sealant compound on engine head; vanos joint and front and rear
half moon corners (gasket scraper, finger nail).
Clean coils mounting contact surfaces (at coils) (brake cleaner & towels).
Remove valve cover gaskets from valve cover and install new gaskets on
valve cover.
Remove 15 valve cover grommets from bolts/studs and install new
grommets on bolts/studs.
Remove valve cover oil fill cap. Remove oil fill neck gasket and install new
gasket. Mount valve cover oil fill cap.
Note: If oil fill neck gasket not present on valve cover, then gasket is likely
of old design and can be fond on engine cover at oil fill hole. Remove old
gasket from engine cover.
Note: If old gasket is stuck to valve cover, attempt inserting blade between
gasket and cover starting from an edge (putty-knife). This facilitates gasket
removal without breaking plasticized brittle gaskets into pieces.
Installation of vanos
Mount new vanos gasket onto engine head front. Mount top corners onto
dowels and place gasket flush with head surface.
Note: Gasket is asymmetric.
Note: Fully insert vanos intake piston into vanos cylinder. This will simplify
vanos mounting to engine head.
Mount vanos onto engine head front.
Insert vanos onto engine head studs, then vanos top corners onto head
matting dowels. Fully insert vanos to mate flush with engine head.
Screw on 6 mounting nuts and 1 stud/bolt (top right corner), and tighten
evenly working back and forth (10mm socket 3/8” / 3/8” ratchet w/ extension
& 13mm socket 1/2” / 1/2” ratchet).
Fully tighten, 8 Nm (6 ft-lb) (10mm socket 3/8” & 13mm socket 1/2” w/ 3/8”
to 1/2” socket adapter / 3/8” torque wrench & extension).
Note: Push vanos intake (right) piston from cylinder hole until it mates with
splined shaft (finger).
Install 2 vanos piston / splined shaft mounting bolts; left hand thread (T30
torx bit socket 1/4” / 1/4” ratchet & extension).
Fully tighten, 8 Nm (6 ft-lb); left hand thread (T30 torx bit socket 1/4” w/ 3/8”
to 1/4” socket adapter / 3/8” torque wrench & extension).
Install 2 vanos piston caps w/ new O-rings (medium nose pliers).
Apply light coat of engine oil to cap O-rings to ease installation.
Rotate cap to verify full insertion.
Install 2 vanos cylinder front cover bolts w/ washers (8mm hex bit socket
3/8” / 3/8” ratchet & extension).
Fully tighten, 50 Nm (37 ft-lb) (8mm hex bit socket 3/8” / 3/8” torque wrench
& extension).
Note: Route electrical harness to engine side before mounting lift bracket.
Install engine lift bracket at vanos intake solenoid.
Insert bracket top hole onto engine top stud, then rotate bracket down to
front of thermostat.
Mount top nut (11mm socket 3/8” / 3/8” ratchet & extension) and bottom bolt
w/ washer (13mm socket 3/8” / 3/8” ratchet & extension).
Fully tighten, 10 Nm (7 Ft-lb) (11mm socket 3/8” & 13mm socket 3/8” / 3/8”
torque wrench & extension)
Install vanos oil hose with bolt and 2 new washers (19mm combo wrench).
Mount first washer on bolt. Insert bolt through hose. Mount second washer
on bolt. Screw bolt onto vanos.
Fully tighten, 32 Nm (24 ft-lb) (19mm combo wrench / by feel).
Note: Insert rod (flathead) between hose pipe and vanos intake solenoid to
keep hose from turning.
Note: Route electrical cable for exhaust CPS sensor and exhaust solenoid
behind vanos exhaust solenoid and valve. Insert cable section with minimal
electrical tape between thermostat and vanos to route to rear.
Install vanos exhaust solenoid electrical connector.
Install vanos exhaust CPS sensor electrical connector.
Install Thermostat electrical connector.
Install vanos intake solenoid electrical connector.
Place thin coat of RTV sealant at 2 engine vanos/head contact points, and
at vanos/head front and rear half moon corners.
Allow sealant to solidify for 2 minutes before mounting valve cover.
[picture]
Install valve cover perimeter gasket and sparkplug well gaskets on valve
cover.
[picture]
Install valve cover onto engine head/vanos. Take care to align properly
before placement.
Lift up on rear corner hoses and cables to allow cover to fit under them.
Install 11 bolts w/ washers & grommets at cover perimeter, and 4
bolts/studs w/ washers & grommets at cover center (10mm socket 3/8” /
3/8” ratchet & extension).
Tighten bolts/studs evenly working back and forth, assuring even pressure
distribution on cover. Tighten until bolts/studs bottom out on head.
Fully tighten, 8Nm (6 ft-lb) (10mm socket 3/8” / 3/8” torque wrench &
extension).
Install pre-cat O2 sensor electrical connectors and cables and secondary
air valve vacuum hose at valve cover exhaust side brackets and metal clip.
Install cables and electric boot into valve cover rear left corner bracket.
Align cables and hose into valve cover bracket and install electrical boot on
top of cables.
Note: If silver metal cover present at rear left bracket, lift up on cover tab to
allow installing cables and electric boot without removing cover.
Install cables into valve cover rear brackets.
Install valve cover vent hose at cover front right corner. Push hose
connector onto cover neck until it snaps on.
Install engine covers.
Install right side engine cover. Mount cover right side hooks under fuel
distribution rail. Install cover 2 bolts (10mm socket 3/8” / 3/8” ratchet &
extension, magnet pickup).
Unscrew oil fill cap, install left side engine cover, reinstall oil fill cap.
Note: Push down on rear left corner electric boot to achieve proper cover fit.
Install 2 nuts at left side cover (10mm socket 3/8” / 3/8” ratchet & extension,
magnet pickup).
Clip on 2 bolt/nut cover caps at center of each engine cover.
Align silver lines on cap with cover. Insert clip at an angle and gently press
down on other end (picture).
Note: Caps are dry, brittle, and will break easily.
Allow RTV sealant to dry a minimum of one hour before driving car.
On first engine start after repair the engine can experience a couple engine
hiccups at idle. This might be related to trapped air in the vanos.
~200 miles (320 kilometers) of city driving is needed to fully break-in vanos
seals and achieve optimum performance. Spirited driving will hasten break-
in period. Initial improvements will be felt in the first few days of driving.