Indonesia Halal Report 2021 - 2022
Indonesia Halal Report 2021 - 2022
Indonesia Halal Report 2021 - 2022
The material in this report is subject to copyright. Because the Bank Indonesia encourages dissemination of this report, this work may be
reproduced, in whole or in part, for non-commercial purposes as long as full attribution to this work is given as follows: “Produced by Bank
Indonesia in partnership with DinarStandard and Indonesia Halal Lifestyle Center.
CONTENTS
1 FOREWORD . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
2 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 105
APPENDIX.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 110
ENDNOTES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 112
Bismillahirrahmanirrahiim
Praise be to Allah SWT, God Almighty, for His guidance and mercy in the completion of the Indonesian Halal
Market Report as part of Bank Indonesia’s contribution in encouraging the development of the national
Islamic economy and finance. May prayers and greetings always be devoted to the Prophet Mohammed
SAW along with his family and companions, who struggled to deliver the sharia light that we enjoy today.
This year was marked by the global economic recovery after we struggled to face the extraordinary and
unprecedented economic challenges brought by the global Covid-19 pandemic. Severe disruptions have
been felt in the global supply chain as a corollary of the pandemic, forcing countries to optimize their
economic potential. For Indonesia, the pandemic has re-emphasized the importance of the Islamic economy
and finance as a new source of growth. Indonesia as a country with the biggest Muslim population in the
world, coupled with bonus demography opens up opportunity halal industry players to drive production
growth and become key players in the global halal industry. With this promising potential, the development
of the halal industry in Indonesia is very important to support inclusive and sustainable economic growth.
Recognizing this urgency, Bank Indonesia has committed to developing the national Islamic economy and
finance by synergizing with the authorities in the KNEKS forum and other relevant authorities. The policy
of developing Islamic economics and finance is one of the supporting policies in Bank Indonesia’s policy
mix in achieving macroeconomic stability. The sharia economic development strategy is carried out with
a halal value chain ecosystem development approach, which includes strengthening in various ecosystem
components, including the halal industry.
With our committed efforts and the aspirations of achieving global center excellence of Islamic economy
and finance, we present Indonesia Halal Markets Report 2021/2022 as part of the preparation of the
forthcoming Sharia Economy and Finance Report 2021. This report, which was prepared in collaboration
with the Dinar Standard and the IHLC, showcases the potential and opportunities for trade and investment
in the Indonesian halal industry. We hope that this report could serve as a reference for Indonesian halal
players and foreign investor alike in formulating their development strategies.
In closing, may Allah SWT always bless and guide us to accelerate the development of the post-pandemic
country towards the vision of Indonesia Maju (Advanced Indonesia). Aamiin YRA.
Bank Indonesia,
M. Anwar Bashori
Head of Sharia Islamic Economic and Finance Department
The halal economy has been envisioned to be an important engine of Indonesia’s economic growth and
realizing its vision of Indonesia Maju (Advanced Indonesia). Towards this vision, the President and Vice
President of Republic Indonesia strongly support with policies to brought Indonesia ready for becoming the
global hub for Islamic Economy in 2024. Indonesia Halal Lifestyle (IHLC) together with the DinarStandard
(bringing its global halal economy expertise) are humbled to present the Indonesia Halal Markets Report
2021/2022 delivering actionable insights on Indonesia’s halal economy trade and investment opportunities
for national and global corporates and investors.
We are inspired to see Indonesia’s young entrepreneurs, its industry leaders and government leadership
aligned towards realizing the potential of this opportunity. While we share facts, figures and practical
strategies in this report, it is the underlying values of syariah economics of equitable financing anchoring
a halal (lawful) and tayyib (wholesome, sustainable) products and services consumption that is the real
socio-economic trend we are all excited to be a part of.
As this report shows, Indonesia has the potential to realize tremendous economic value, given its stature
as the largest halal economy consumption market with a competitive production base. At the same time,
it can also serve as a role model economy for the rest of the world through its socially responsible syariah
economic policies and by positioning its halal brands as global champions.
We thank Bank Indonesia for the strong commitment to publish this report and the various industry
stakeholders that shared their expertise.
In the pursuit of Indonesia Maju (Advanced Indonesia) 2045, the shariah economy and finance (herein
referred to as ‘halal economy’) have been identified as key contributors given the vast global opportunity of
$1.9 trillion (2020 est.) and domestic opportunity of $184 billion in the related consumer spending market
that has yet to be fully tapped.
Since the launch of the shariah economy and finance blueprint by Bank Indonesia and the subsequent
Indonesia Islamic Economic Masterplan 2019-2024 by KNEKS, Indonesia has seen a rapid rise in its ranking
in DinarStandard’s Global Islamic Economy Indicator, rising from the 10th position in 2018 to 4th in 2020.
Indonesia continues to move up the halal food indicator ranking, placing 2nd this year, and ranks among the
top 10 in other halal economy sectors (except media).
Indonesia is home to the world’s largest domestic halal economy market, driven by the largest global
Muslim population of 229.6 million in 2020. This population’s domestic spending across halal economy
products and services stood at $184 billion in 2020 and is projected to increase by 14.96% CAGR to reach
$281.6 billion by 2025. The share of the Shariah economy in the national economy has expanded over the
past 5 consecutive years. The Shariah economy remained more unscathed by the effects of the COVID-19
pandemic than the national economy, with a contraction of -1.70% (YoY) compared with -2.07% (YoY) for
the national economy (Source: Sharia Economy and Finance Report 2020, Bank Indonesia).
The COVID-19 pandemic led to the first negative growth in GDP that Indonesia has experienced since
1998. To decrease the spread of the virus, the government introduced large-scale social restrictions (PSBB)
and restrictions on community activities (PPKM). These had significant impacts on the lives of citizens
and, in turn, the economy at large. Consumer spending habits were also altered, with many households
experiencing a decrease in income. Many consumers also turned to e-commerce platforms and other
digital avenues for shopping.
Overall, this report estimates Indonesia’s halal economy opportunity to further boost its GDP by $5.1
billion a year through incremental exports and FDI and import substitution opportunity. The report
presents key sectors and markets and overall strategic areas based on a National Halal Economy
Strategy framework to expand trade and investment opportunities.
Photo: Shutterstock.com
The global opportunity: The global halal economy spans Muslim consumer spending across lifestyle
categories most impacted by their faith-based values, from food and clothing to travel, pharma and
cosmetics, and totaled $1.9 trillion in 2020, according to the State of the Global Islamic Economy Report
produced in 2021 by DinarStandard. This is in addition to the $3.4 trillion in global Islamic finance assets.
The cross-sector halal economy opportunity is a lucrative, high-growth opportunity addressed increasingly
by multinationals, governments, startups and investors.
Consumer opportunity: Indonesia is home to the world’s largest Muslim population. Indonesia’s Muslim
consumers are some of the most adherent to their Islamic faith in the world, with 98% of surveyed Muslims
considering religion very important. The country’s Muslims are predominantly young, digitally native, and
fiercely loyal to domestic brands, although they are also price-sensitive, creating substantial opportunities
for new market entrants to reap significant rewards.
Business success stories: The size, structure and values-based preferences of Indonesia’s Muslims
have given rise to scaled local champions who have generated at least $500 million in revenues annually
across the food, pharma and cosmetics industries. These include Indofood, Mayora, GarudaFood, and
Kimia Farma, as well as attracting leading multinationals in setting up local ventures, including Unilever
and L’Oréal.
Relatively low imports, but room for improvement: The country has also achieved an important measure
of success in self-reliance compared to many of its peers in the 57-member Organization of Islamic
Cooperation (“OIC”). Indonesia is a net exporter for most categories in the halal economy, except for
cosmetics and pharmaceuticals. There is substantial room for Indonesia to reduce its reliance on imports
in key categories such as sugar and sugar confectionery, animal fodder and cosmetic and pharmaceutical
raw ingredients, which would, in turn, provide an incremental boost to domestic production and a $1 billion
addition to GDP.
Current capture: Trade is inherent to the halal economy, with $200 billion in halal products (requiring some
degree of compliance) imported across the OIC in 2020.
Indonesia is among the top global suppliers of halal and related products (food, fashion, pharmaceutical and
cosmetics) to the OIC countries in 2020 and can capture a much larger proportion of this trade opportunity.
Indonesia is the ninth-largest exporter to the OIC, exporting $8.6 billion in halal products (including those
halal by nature such as vegetables), far less than the leading exporter, China, which exported over $25
billion in 2020, but larger than Malaysian exports. Indonesia’s food industry has no representation in the
Global Corporate 2000 list; but its local champions have the potential to expand global reach.
Halal economy-specific FDI can be improved. In 2019, Indonesia was the highest-ranked OIC country in
terms of FDI, 81% higher than the UAE (at $13.8 billion) and 175% more than Malaysia (at $9.1 billion).
Indonesia received 43% of global investments in the halal economy. This equates to $5.01 billion out of a
total of $11.78 billion. By capturing a further 10% of halal economy investments, Indonesia can increase
GDP by $0.5 billion.
Potential: Indonesia can boost halal economy exports by $3.6 billion a year to OIC and non-OIC markets
with sizeable Muslim populations through focusing on producing processed food products, notably meat-
based products, animal feed, and women’s clothing, as well as pharmaceuticals and cosmetics.
Shortcomings: Closer cooperation is needed between halal certification institutions, producers, scholars,
researchers, and the government to efficiently meet consumer demands and create regulations that would
attract investment and position Indonesia as a leader in the halal economy. There are a limited number
of scaled market players which could participate globally, with a notable gap in the R&D space and the
manufacturing of halal-suitable ingredients.
Strategy: In this report, we recommend 17 comprehensive strategic priorities for Indonesia to cement
its leadership potential in the global halal industry, based on DinarStandard’s National Halal Economy
Development framework. Some key strategic priorities covered in this report include:
• Becoming a top halal exporter through targeting high-value OIC and non-OIC countries with large
Muslim populations and prioritized halal product segments.
• Facilitating trade promotion and international exposure for local companies while also helping them
leverage market intelligence.
• Implementing the necessary legislation to facilitate exports, attract investment to halal sectors and
develop halal industrial hubs.
• Increasing production competitiveness through adopting high-tech for the production and sourcing of
cheaper raw materials of higher quality.
• Streamlining Islamic finance regulations to enable effective convergence with halal economy
development.
Photo: Shutterstock.com
2.
Existing $10 billion imports of halal
products* by Indonesia (2020 est.)
3.
Existing $5 billion investments in halal
economy sectors* in Indonesia (2020 est.)
*Halal products include food, fashion, pharma and cosmetics products requiring some level of halal compliance.
Halal economy sectors include halal product sectors plus travel, media and finance sectors.
9th
DOMESTIC CHAMPIONS HAVE POTENTIAL TO BECOME LARGEST SUPPLIER
GLOBAL PLAYER
LEADING ISLAMIC FINANCE PLAYER $ LIMITED ISLAMIC FINANCE CONVERGENCE WITH HALAL
ECONOMY SECTORS
$2.9 fintech market size and largest Including gaps in Islamic finance experts and
BILLION sovereign sukuk issuer penetration
+
OIC EXPORT NON-OIC EXPORT Opportunity
OPPORTUNITY OPPORTUNITY Consumption
+
Apparel 1. UAE 1. Germany
(not knitted / 2. Saudi Arabia 2. France
crocheted) 3. Turkey 3. United States
FASHION ($0.44 billion)
=
PHARMA China
GOAL 1 GOAL 2
BOOST GDP BY $5.1 BILLION THROUGH INCREMENTAL DEVELOP ENABLING PILLARS THAT WILL HELP THE FULL
EXPORTS, FDI AND IMPORT SUBSTITUTION ECONOMIC POTENTIAL OF THE HALAL ECONOMY MATERIALIZE
In 2020, Muslims made up 25% of the global population and accounted for $1.9 trillion in consumer spend.
Muslims have unique, faith-based requirements across many product categories, most notably food as
well as clothing, pharmaceuticals, cosmetics, travel and media and recreation. Halal trade is truly a global
value chain with major participants worldwide, with exports of halal goods worth $200 billion. Investments
have also been directed into the halal economy, with $11.8 billion invested into the halal economy sectors
in 2019/20.
Photo: Shutterstock.com
God consciousness Food and food services Just & equitable business
Family values House financing Zakat - charity
Modesty Recreation Family values
Dietary law/healthy Clothing Fasting/Self-control
Just & equitable financing Service Wholesome food
Education Education Education
Spirituality Service/Charity
Socal responsibility Personal care
B2B infrastructure
Defining Halal:
The word ‘halal’ originates from Arabic and means allowed or permissible in Islamic law, the opposite of
which is ‘haram.’ These laws are derived from two sources: the Qu’ran, Muslims’ central religious text, and the
Sunnah, which is a record of the traditions or sayings of the Prophet Mohammed (peace be upon him).
While references typically relate to food and drink, halal directly impacts any product consumed or applied,
such as cosmetics and pharmaceuticals. It’s also important to note that Islamic values also extend beyond
halal. There is also an increasingly important emphasis on Tayyib, which means pure or wholesome, and
applies to broader ethical considerations across all of the core halal economy sectors, from organic food to
ethically sourced and manufactured products.
“He (God) has only forbidden to you dead animals, blood, the flesh of swine, and that which has been
dedicated to other than Allah. But whoever is forced [by necessity], neither desiring [it] nor transgressing
[its limit]—then indeed, Allah is Forgiving and Merciful.” Al-Quran 16:115
“O mankind, eat from whatever is on earth [that is] lawful and pure and do not follow the footsteps of
Satan. Indeed, he is to you a clear enemy.” Al-Quran 12:168
Included within the core halal economy opportunity, which is the focus of this report, is halal food, Islamic
finance, halal pharmaceuticals, halal cosmetics, modest fashion, Muslim-friendly travel, and Islamic-
themed media and recreation. While each sector is ordinarily distinct, common faith-based values bring
them together as an intrinsic whole, serving the same ethical consumer base, with a variation in Shariah
compliance by sector.
The core principles of the halal economy ensure that financial transactions are based on real assets
or projects, thus guaranteeing the halal economy plays a critical role in improving economic structure,
developing the real sector, and catalyzing sustainable economic growth1. Halal economic development
supports economic empowerment through halal value chain development, including the application of
diverse partnership-based business models, from MSMEs to large corporations, which will also increase
economic inclusivity.
Muslim-majority countries, or the Organization of Islamic Cooperation (OIC) member countries, are defined
as playing a significant role in driving the halal economy, from consumption of products to trade and
investment opportunities.
GLOBAL HALAL
ECONOMY
1 Halal economy definition as per the Sharia Economy and Finance Report of Bank Indonesia.
Across the core halal economy sectors, Muslims spent an aggregate of $1.9 trillion in 2020 on lifestyle
products (food, fashion, travel, media/recreation, pharmaceuticals/cosmetics), which was a decline of 6%
from $2 trillion in the pre-COVID-19 year (2019). However, Muslim spending in these sectors is expected
to regain momentum and grow by 7.81% CAGR reaching US$2.76 trillion in 2025. Islamic finance assets,
currently at $3 trillion in 2020, are also expected to rise steadily over the next 5 years with a CAGR of 7.9%,
reaching $4.9 trillion worth of assets by 2025. Many countries saw a surge in Islamic finance assets during
the COVID-19 year, such as Indonesia, where Islamic finance banking assets grew by 10.97% in 2020,
higher than the 7.7% registered by the conventional banks.2
$4,922
$3,374
$1,668
$1,185
$375 $308
$279 $216
$129 $189
$94 $65 $93 $58
2020 2025 2020 2025 2020 2025 2020 2025 2020 2025 2020 2025 2020 2025
FOOD & BEVERAGE FASHION PHARMACEUTICALS COSMETICS TRAVEL & TOURISM MEDIA/ ISLAMIC FINANCE
RECREATION
Source: DinarStandard, State of the Global Islamic Economy Report 2020/21
By Sector Opportunity:
Market
2020 (US$ Billion) 2025 (US$ Billion) 2019-20 (COVID-19 Impact) 5 Years CAGR% (2020-25)
opportunity
Global $1,185 $1,668 1.54% 7.08%
Indonesia $135 $204 -6.44% 14.64%
Food and beverage represent the largest sector by spend in the halal economy, with Indonesia, Bangladesh
and Egypt the top countries for Muslim spend, which includes, but is not limited to, halal food. Global Muslim
spend on food and beverage was estimated at $1,185 billion in 2020, representing 16% of global spend on
food. Despite sizeable companies addressing the opportunity, there remains a substantially fragmented
market ripe for investment and consolidation.
The regulation of halal food falls below comparable benchmarks in the food industry, with over 400 certification
bodies worldwide overseeing the sector, with limited oversight or mutual recognition.
Halal food is by far the largest segment of the Islamic economy in Indonesia. With a decrease in income for
many and the strict movement restriction orders, Muslim spend on food in Indonesia decreased by 6.44%,
while globally, Muslim spend on food increased by 1.54% compared to the previous year. Spend levels in
Indonesia are set to return to pre-COVID 19 levels by 2021.
Top 5 Food and Beverage Muslim Consumer Spend Markets, Global Islamic Economy Indicator
2020 (US$ Billion) (GIEI) Ranking 2021
HALAL FOOD
135 1 Malaysia
2 Indonesia
113 111 3 Turkey
4 Russia
Key countries
83 5 United Arab Emirates
81
FASHION
MUSLIM SPEND PARAMETERS
Market
2020 (US$ Billion) 2025 (US$ Billion) 2019-20 (COVID-19 Impact) 5 Years CAGR% (2020-25)
opportunity
Global $279 $375 0.72% 6.09%
Indonesia $15.6 $23.28 -4.99% 8.34%
Fashion represents the second-largest sector by spend in the halal economy, with Iran, Turkey and Pakistan
the top countries for Muslim spend, which includes, but is not limited to, modest fashion. Global Muslim
spend on fashion was estimated at $279 billion in 2020, representing 14% of global spend on fashion. Modest
fashion investments are expected to remain low until the economy recovers. However, the sector is ripe for
consolidation among producers and retailers.
The movement restrictions and income decrease caused spending in Indonesia’s modest fashion segment
to drop by 4.99%. Working from home and people having fewer social gatherings also caused a significant
decrease in demand for clothing. However, most fashion businesses were quick to pivot and fulfill the demand
for face masks, PPE and more comfortable home wear. Spend levels in Indonesia are set to return to pre-
COVID-19 levels by 2021.
Top 5 Fashion Muslim Consumer Spend Markets Global Islamic Economy Indicator
(Apparel & Footwear), 2020 (US$ Billion) (GIEI) Ranking 2021
MODEST FASHION
20.84 20.58
17.52
Muslim spend on pharmaceutical products, due to an obvious emergence of health care, saw a relatively
smaller drop of 0.3% in 2020, while spend on cosmetics went down by 1.52%.
Muslim demand for halal products is moving beyond food to encompass nutritional supplements,
medicinal ingredients, and cosmetics products. Halal cosmetics sales have grown in East Asia at a
faster pace than any other market, driven by Indonesian brands, small and large-sized. While South Korean
K-beauty brands have also started getting halal certification.
Pharmaceuticals and cosmetics together are increasingly falling under the scope of halal certification
bodies, as Muslim consumers push for halal alternatives to gelatin and other meat-based ingredients across
Core overview
a range of product categories, going beyond food. An increasing number of companies are addressing
increasing Muslim consumer adherence. For instance, Malaysia’s Duopharma Biotech and South Korea’s
PanGen Biotech are investing in the world’s first halal biosimilar to treat anemia. While Indonesia’s Paragon
is expanding cosmetic ranges beyond women to include men.
Key countries Top 5 Pharmaceutical Muslim Consumer Spend Markets, Global Islamic Economy Indicator
2020 (US$ Billion) (GIEI) Ranking 2021
HALAL
10.92 PHARMACEUTICAL
& COSMETICS
1 Singapore
2 Malaysia
7.76
7.04 3 Netherlands
4 Belgium
Pharmaceutical
5.36 5 France
9 Indonesia
4.04
5.88
Cosmetics 4.19
3.67 3.44 3.44
Market
2020 (US$ Billion) 2025 (US$ Billion) 2019-20 (COVID-19 Impact) 5 Years CAGR% (2020-25)
opportunity
Global $58 $189 -70% 26.65%
Indonesia $3.37 $8.03 -70% 18.96%
Travel and tourism were largely hit sectors in the global economy. Its effects were also shared by the halal
economy, where Muslim spend on travel fell by almost 70% to $58 billion in 2020. If accounting for Hajj and
Umrah travel restrictions, this number may reduce further. With lockdowns and travel restrictions easing, the
travel and tourism sector is gaining momentum, with increasing investment interests from investors. Most
governments globally and in the OIC provided various forms of stimulus packages to the tourism industry.
Total investment deals recorded in 2019/20 in the Islamic economy were $340 million (a drop of 40% from the
Core overview
previous year), but this is expected to rebound.
Top 5 Outbound Muslim Spend Travel Countries, Global Islamic Economy Indicator
2020 (US$ Billion) (GIEI) Ranking 2021
MUSLIM-FRIENDLY
TRAVEL
7.29 1 Malaysia
2 Singapore
3 Turkey
4 Bahrain
5.15
Key countries 5 Tunisia
4.26 12 Indonesia
3.89
3.37
Market
2020 (US$ Billion) 2025 (US$ Billion) 2019-20 (COVID-19 Impact) 5 Years CAGR% (2020-25)
opportunity
Global $216 $308 -2.75% 7.35%
Indonesia $20.73 $31.82 -4.65% 8.95%
Media and recreation represent the third largest area of spend among Muslim consumers. Although spending
has fallen by 8.8% since pre-COVID-19, the media sector globally was less affected by the pandemic and saw
a rise in internet usage, driven by work from home and online education.
Core overview
INDONESIA HALAL MEDIA & RECREATION MARKET OVERVIEW:
Indonesian consumer spend in media and recreation dropped by 4.65% in 2020, compared to global
consumer spend which fell by 2.75%. Spend levels in Indonesia are set to return to pre-COVID 19 levels
by 2021.
Production Distribution
Landscape
• 5 Pillar Games (Saudi Arabia, Gaming) • Peace TV (UK, TV)
• Marvel (USA, Print) • Iqra (Saudi Arabia, TV)
(3) Select key
• Barjoun Entertainment (UAE, Films) • Al Huda (Egypt, TV)
players
• Digital Durian (Malaysia, Cartoons) • Bayyinah, TV (USA, Online)
Top 5 Media & Recreation Muslim Consumer Spend Markets, Global Islamic Economy Indicator
2020 (US$ Billion) (GIEI) Ranking 2021
1 Malaysia
25.49 2 Singapore
3 United Arab Emirates
4 China
21.34
20.90 5 Turkey
Key countries
29 Indonesia
11.25
10.08
Market
2020 (US$ Billion) 2019-20 (COVID-19 Impact)
opportunity
Global $3,374 17.36%
Indonesia $119.5 20.5%
Globally, Islamic finance is rebounding from the effects of the pandemic, with Islamic banks’ profitability
recovering after 2020 drops. Many countries saw a surge in Islamic finance assets during the COVID-19
year, such as Indonesia, where Islamic finance banking assets grew by 10.97% in 2020, higher than the
7.7% registered by conventional banks.6
Core overview
Islamic finance is a rapidly growing industry, attracting both Muslims and a broader set of ethical finance
stakeholders. Several major investments can be seen, along with an upswing in Islamic fintech. There are
some 241 Islamic fintechs, with a market size of around $49 billion in 2020, which is forecast to reach
$128 billion by 2025 (based on transaction volumes).7
Select key regulators Select key banks Select key fintech services
ISLAMIC FINANCE
838 1 Malaysia
826
2 Saudi Arabia
3 Bahrain
4 Kuwait
620
5 United Arab Emirates
Key countries 6 Indonesia
251
156 144
119
Turkey Saudi Malaysia UAE Qatar Kuwait Indonesia
Arabia
Source: Refinitiv
Halal trade is truly a global value chain with major participants worldwide. It is driven primarily by imports
for the 57 mostly Muslim-majority Organization of Islamic Cooperation (OIC) member countries. Across all
halal economy sectors, food represents the largest category of OIC imports at $200 billion (2020 est.). This
is followed by modest fashion ($27 billion imports), pharmaceuticals ($39 billion imports), and cosmetics
($13 billion imports).
There were an estimated 1.9 billion Muslims around the globe in 2020, with Indonesia hosting the largest
number of Muslims at 229.6 billion.8 The large, young, and affluent Muslim population represents a core
driver of the demand for halal Islamic economy products and services.
Trade represents a key component of Muslim spending, with halal food and beverage products, fashion,
pharmaceuticals, and cosmetics being the core sectors affected by halal requirements. The figures below
show the top OIC importing markets and top supplying markets to OIC for food and beverage, fashion,
pharmaceuticals, and cosmetics.
This analysis has focused on the trade flow for products, and as such, does not look at other lifestyles and
services sectors (media, travel and finance).
Photo: Shutterstock.com
Top OIC Halal Food & Beverage* Exporters & Importers - US$ Billions, 2020
4
FOOD & BEVERAGE 3
5 5
1
$200 BILLION 14% 2
3
TOTAL F&B IMPORTS GLOBAL SHARE 2
INTO OIC MARKETS
1
29% OF TOTAL
$20.0 $30.0
41% OF TOTAL
Top OIC Clothing & Accessories Exporters & Importers - US$ Billions, 2020
3 3
FASHION 4 4
1 1
2
$27 BILLION 5.5% 2
5 5
TOTAL CLOTHING & ACCESSORIES GLOBAL SHARE
IMPORTS INTO OIC MARKETS
TOP 5 TOP 5
76% SOURCE MARKETS REPRESENT IMPORTERS REPRESENT 53%
76% OF TOTAL
$20.0 $8.0
53% OF TOTAL
9 $0.39 Indonesia
Top Exporter Top Importer Source: DinarStandard synthesis and analysis; ITC Trade Map statistics
1
24 2
PHARMACEUTICALS 5
5 4
1
$39 BILLION 6% 3
3
TOTAL PHARMACEUTICAL IMPORTS GLOBAL SHARE
INTO OIC MARKETS
47%
TOP 5 TOP 5 47%
SOURCE MARKETS REPRESENT IMPORTERS REPRESENT
47% OF TOTAL
$8.0 $4.0
47% OF TOTAL
38 $0.07 Indonesia
Top Exporter Top Importer Source: DinarStandard synthesis and analysis; ITC Trade Map statistics
5 2
1
3
COSMETICS 3
1 4
2
$13 BILLION 9% 5
TOTAL COSMETICS IMPORTS GLOBAL SHARE
4
INTO OIC MARKETS
40%
TOP 5 TOP 5
SOURCE MARKETS REPRESENT IMPORTERS REPRESENT 56%
40% OF TOTAL
$6.0 $6.0
56% OF TOTAL
20 $0.19 Indonesia
Top Exporter Top Importer Source: DinarStandard synthesis and analysis; ITC Trade Map statistics
Investments in the global halal economy fell by 13%, from $13.6 billion in 2018/19 to $11.8 billion in 2019/20.
There are around 156 investments recorded in the halal economy that include the relevant mergers &
acquisition (M&A), private equity (PE), and venture capital (VC) transactions in 2019/20. Compared to other
sectors, there has been more private investment activity in halal food, totaling $6.1 billion in 2019/20.
While the pandemic deeply impacted the HORECA (Hotel, Restaurant and Catering) sector, other sectors
such as ready-to-eat meals and food delivery witnessed explosive growth and will continue post-COVID-19
pandemic.9
Indonesia attracted the largest share of investments, 25% of all recorded transactions, showing the market
is ripe for potential investments. Together, investments in the halal food and Islamic finance sectors
accounted for more than 90% of total deal value.
Photo: Shutterstock.com
Islamic Economy
$11,781
Aggregate
• Egypt (3)
Modest Fashion $3 4 • Innovacia Sdn Bhd (Malaysia)
• Netherlands (1)
As the global Muslim population grows, becomes wealthier and more demanding, the halal economy is
expected to thrive, creating substantial trade and investment opportunities.
(1) The world Muslim population covers 25% of the global population
The global Muslim population was estimated at 1.9 billion in 2020, covering 25% of the global population.
Muslims are growing twice as much as the non-Muslim population, and this trend will remain the same
over the next decade. Muslims are projected to grow up to 2 billion in 2030. Muslims are also the
youngest of all major religious groups, with young adults (ages 15-29) covering 27.3% of the Muslim
population in 2020.10
(2) Muslim nations set to grow faster than the global average in next 6 years
Despite sluggish global economic growth due to the pandemic, OIC countries are projected to grow
faster than the rest of the world’s GDP growth. Based on the latest IMF GDP projections (April 2021), the
compounded annual growth rate (CAGR) of the OIC economy is expected to hit 7% between 2020 and 2026
compared to the global average of 6.4%.
(5) Health is becoming increasingly important among Muslims, not just taste
Many of the values underpinning the Islamic economy sectors are universal and appeal to consumers
concerned about the environment. Several global studies show that consumers are increasingly demanding
cruelty-free, organic, natural and vegan-certified products, having a proportionate impact on demand for
halal-certified products, given the shared principles. A study by IBM shows six in 10 consumers are willing
to change their shopping habits to reduce environmental impact. The demand for ethical and organic
products has heightened due to the COVID-19 pandemic.
Photo: Shutterstock.com
As the world faces the COVID-19 pandemic, technology has proven to be key in keeping businesses afloat
by enabling remote work, agile business, and digital engagement. In the long run, organizations will leverage
technology to underpin every process and value chain as they journey to the new normal.
The halal economy is a part of the wider global economy. Hence, the global impact of COVID-19 on the
economy has a direct repercussion on the halal economy. This section covers the impact of COVID-19 on
global and halal economy growth, consumer habits, supply chain and production, trade and FDI.
10%
8%
6%
4%
2%
0%
-2% -2.7%
-3.2%
-4%
-4.0%
-6% -5.6%
-8%
The global economy dropped to an all-time low in decades during the COVID-19 crisis, falling by 3.2%
in GDP in 2020 from last year. Around 8.8% of global working hours were lost in 2020, equivalent to 255
million full-time jobs, an amount that is four times greater than job losses during the 2009 financial crisis.14
OIC countries were the fasting growing economies pre-COVID-19, even compared to the advanced
economies. Following COVID-19, OIC countries economy decreased to almost twice as low as the world’s
GDP and other economies, almost by 5.6%.
As restrictions ease and people adjust back to pre-COVID-19 spending habits, the year 2021 and those
proceeding it bring a ray of hope for the economy. OIC countries’ economies will rebound, however, at a
much slower pace than the rest of the world and other emerging and advancing economies. Over the next
6 years, the OIC economy is expected to grow at a CAGR of 7% compared to the global average of 6.4%.
Drastic changes in consumer shopping habits were seen during the pandemic. Fears of the virus spreading
and social distancing measures meant that consumers avoided potentially crowded places. Trends like
delivery and take-out meals increased, while the HORECA (Hotel/Restaurant/Café) and travel industries
suffered the most. Work from home and leisure time led to increased use of the internet for gaming and
video streaming.
These trends meant that e-commerce was the winner during the pandemic. With vaccinations rolling out
and restrictions easing up, people are moving out for work, shopping and travel. However, e-commerce is a
trend that will stay and flourish in the long run. The following figures show the e-commerce categories that
were impacted due to the pandemic in 2020.
-2
-4
-6
-8
Most OIC countries were classified as developing and emerging industrial economies by UNIDO.
The world saw a major decline in manufacturing production in 2020. The previous year had already
indicated a slowdown in manufacturing growth, mainly due to the ongoing trade tensions between China
and the USA. In 2020, global manufacturing production dropped by 4.1% as many countries resorted to
containment strategies. The manufacturing output of developing and emerging industrial economies
(excl. China) fell by 7.1% in 2020, which covers many OIC countries as well (including Indonesia). East Asia
experienced a decline both pre-COVID-19 and during the pandemic: a 1.6% decline in 2019, followed by a
4.7% decline in 2020.15
8,0%
6,0%
4,0%
2,0%
0,0%
-2,0%
-4,0%
-6,0%
-8,0%
-10,0%
Food Beverages Textiles Wearing Leather Basic Computer, Other
products apparel and pharmaceutical electronic transport
related
Source: UNIDO Statistics
The COVID-19 pandemic revealed vulnerabilities in the long, complicated supply chains of many
companies. Disruptions triggered a sharp fall in maritime trade volumes (which carry 80% of the world’s
trade merchandise) across all market segments in early 2020, in particular for containerized trade, which
carries intermediate and manufactured goods.16
Food, textiles, OTC pharmaceutical products and media products saw an increase in global production.
However, disrupted supply chains meant a surge in raw material prices for food and garments and concerns
over food availability and safety. The COVID-19 pandemic has highlighted weaknesses in supply chains and
over-reliance on imports, especially for Active Pharmaceutical Ingredients (APIs) – the central ingredient in
drugs. This was as the world’s largest producer of APIs—China—curtailed industrial production to limit the
spread of COVID-19.
30,0%
20,0%
10,0%
0,0%
-10,0%
-20,0%
-30,0%
World OIC
Prospects for a quick recovery in world trade and the OIC have improved as merchandise trade expanded
more rapidly than expected in the second half of last year. According to new estimates from the WTO, the
volume of world merchandise trade is expected to increase by 8.0% in 2021 after falling drastically in 2020
(released on 31st March 2021).17
Shipping and ports handle over 80% of global merchandise trade by volume and about 70% of its value.
International maritime trade is estimated to have fallen by 4.1% in 2020 but will recover and rebound by
4.8% in 2021.18
Foreign direct investment (FDI) was also severely impacted by the COVID-19 pandemic. According to
UNCTAD, FDI is estimated to have decreased by 40% in 2020, bringing it below $1 trillion for the first time
since 2005. The outlook remains dire, with further deterioration projected in 2021 and only beginning to
recover in 2022 at the earliest. Many countries took actions to mitigate the adverse effects on FDI and
shield domestic industries from foreign takeovers.19
Regional trade deals saw significant activity in 2020, including agreements among Muslim-majority
countries. The adoption of various measures associated with the African Continental Free Trade Area
(AfCFTA) was accelerated, including requirements for members to remove 90% of tariffs on goods and
take steps to create an Africa-wide Customs union. In Asia, the Regional Comprehensive Economic
Partnership (RCEP) was signed in November, with the hope that the deal would help its 15 signatories
(including Indonesia) recover from the economic fallout of the pandemic by boosting regional trade.20
Through bilateral trade agreements, more vaccines are being produced in OIC countries than ever before,
such as in Turkey, the UAE, Egypt and Saudi Arabia.
All the sectors on which tourism has significant multiplier effects have been impacted, including agriculture
and food services. Travel services were down 63% in 2020 and are not expected to fully recover in the
short run.21
The pandemic has been the worst recorded year for international tourism. The decline of 74% in international
tourism due to the pandemic is estimated to cause a loss of $1.3 trillion in international tourism expenditure,
about 11 times that of the 2009 global crisis. This will affect the global GDP by more than $4 trillion in 2020
and 2021.22
Most governments globally and in the OIC are providing various forms of stimulus packages to the tourism
industry. It is estimated that COVID-19 related cleaning protocols will cost hospitality $9 billion each year.
And while tourism is set to rebound in many OIC countries, others are not expected to be so fortunate,
adversely hit by political instability on top of the pandemic, such as Lebanon and Tunisia.
Home to the world’s largest Muslim population, Indonesia is in the perfect position to rank amongst the
leaders of the global halal economy. Indonesia is in a positive position in terms of trade and investment
with the potential to further capitalize on their strengths.
Indonesia retains the 4th position in the overall GIEI (Global Islamic Economy Indicator, a global ranking of
countries ecosystem strength across all halal economy sectors) ranking. Indonesia continues to move up
the halal food indicator ranking, placing 2nd this year, and ranks among the top 10 in other halal economy
sectors (except media). One of the leading factors for its leading position is its trade potential.
Indonesia was among the top global suppliers of halal and related products (food, fashion, pharmaceutical
and cosmetics) to the OIC countries in 2020. With $8.5 billion exports of halal products, Indonesia is the
10th largest exporter globally and 2nd largest exporter among the OIC countries. This shows high potential
for Indonesia to emerge as the global leader in halal products exports and strengthen intra-OIC trade, given
that the COVID-19 pandemic has severely affected the supply chains of the largest supplying markets to the
OIC, such as China, India and the USA. The top OIC markets for Indonesia’s aggregate halal product exports
are Malaysia, Pakistan, Egypt, Bangladesh and Saudi Arabia, that make up 69% of the total exports to OIC.
$20.0
U$ Billion
$0.0
Turkey
Malaysia
China
India
USA
Brazil
Russia
France
Germany
Argentina
Indonesia
Ukraine
Netherlands
Thailand
United
Kingdom
Italy
Switzerland
Spain
Canada
Australia
Exporters to OIC
With the 4th largest population in the world, as well as the largest Muslim population estimated 229.6 million
Muslims in 2020, Indonesia also represents the largest market for Muslim spend globally across the halal
economy sectors, with a combined $184 billion across halal products and lifestyle sectors, representing
11.34% of global halal economy spend.
SECTOR MUSLIM SPEND, 2020 US$ BILLIONS GLOBAL MUSLIM CONSUMER RANKING
Food & Beverage $135 1
Fashion $15.60 6
Pharmaceuticals $5.13 4
Cosmetics $4.19 2
Travel & Tourism $3.37 5
Media & Recreation $20.73 2
Source: DinarStandard synthesis and analysis.
Indonesia, with US$ 199.5 billion Islamic Finance assets, is a global leader in Muslim financial inclusion. At
around 50 million accounts, Indonesia has the largest number of accounts in Shariah (Islamic) banks in the
world. It also has the largest number of Shariah rural banks, about 164 in total.
In 2020, Indonesia was the largest issuer of sovereign sukuk in the international market. Totaling $20.65
billion, Indonesia dominated 22.18% of all (foreign currency) international sovereign sukuk issued, well
above Saudi Arabia (13.97%) and the United Arab Emirates (8.83%) in the second and third positions,
respectively. This demonstrates that as a frequent sukuk issuer, governance sukuk issued by Indonesia
remain highly attractive to global investors.23
Others
Indonesia
12.67%
Oman
22.18%
4.99%
Pakistan
5.42%
Bahrain 5.63%
6.69% 19.34%
Qatar Saudi Arabia
6.72%
Turkey 7.52% 8.83%
Source: Bank Indonesia,
Sharia Economy & Finance Malaysia UAE (Dubai)
Report 2020
With its large population, Indonesia is a super consumption market. This significant demand for products
across the board creates many opportunities for domestic and multinational players. Indonesia is home to
the largest population of Muslims in the world and with ever-increasing awareness around halal products,
the demand for products in the halal economy is huge. In 2019, the vast majority of manufacturing
companies were in the food and beverage industry and making significant contributions to exports. Other
halal economy sectors such as modest fashion, media and recreation and travel are mostly dominated
by MSMEs. The eCommerce sector has seen many startups scale successfully and grow into platforms
offering a wide array of services and products. The COVID-19 pandemic left far-reaching effects across the
economy and most notably on consumer spend. In fact, it is expected to permanently alter the behavior
of consumers going forward. Analysts expect GDP growth in Indonesia to recover to pre-pandemic levels
within the next two years. This will spur consumer spend, particularly in lifestyle sectors such as fashion,
cosmetics, media and recreation and travel. Consumers are also set to increasingly embrace digital
shopping platforms.
This section shares details of Indonesian companies which are either industry leaders by revenue or are top
of mind for Indonesians when they consider that industry. International companies of similar revenue sizes
or which are industry leaders are provided as a benchmark.
Photo: Shutterstock.com
PHYSICAL
RETAILERS FOOD
DDED PRODUC
UE-A ERS
VAL
E-COMMERCE USTRY PLAYER PHARMACEUTICALS
IND S
DIS
ERS
TRI
RETAIL
BUTOR
S
229.6 MILLION
MUSLIM CONSUMER
RS
EC
TO
OS R S
SE
LA
IC YST E M PL AYE
RV
GU
EE RE
NA &
BLE E NT
LOGISTICS & RS NM GOVERNMENT
INDUSTRIAL HUB G OV E R BODIES
2 These are key select large corporates and not meant to be a comprehensive list as there are other corporates as well. These are identified
by DinarStandard team independently and with no commercial consideration.
VALUE-ADDED PRODUCERS
Halal Food
SECTOR OVERVIEW
In the first quarter of 2020, the food and beverage sector contributed 36.4% to Indonesia’s GDP.24 As of October 2019, the Halal Law
of Indonesia has been instituted. This makes it mandatory for all products (traded, distributed, and imported) within Indonesian land
to be certified halal.25 According to the National Statistical Agency (BPS), there are approximately 7,415 large and medium-sized
food and beverages companies with over 1 million employees; and 1.69 million micro and small producers in the food and beverage
industries with 3.44 million employees.26 In 2020, 252,897 products across 7,043 companies were given halal certification.
GLOBAL BENCHMARK
Danone
• Products include essential dairy and plant-based products, waters, early life nutrition and medical nutrition.
(France) • Present in over 120 countries, with 46% of sales in Asia-Pacific, Latin America, Middle East, Africa and C.I.S.
• Most Karicare and Aptamil products are halal-certified.
• AQUA as a pioneer of Bottled Drinking Water (AMDK) in Indonesia since 1973, was awarded the “Halal Award -
Halal Top Brand 2019” (after previously being entitled to the same in 2016 and 2018)
Key Learning. Danone is one of the few major corporations with a significant proportion (30%) of subsidiaries B Corporation
Certified.30 Certified B Corporations are businesses that meet the highest standards of verified social and environmental
performance, and public transparency. They are accelerating a global culture shift to redefine success in business and build a
more inclusive and sustainable economy.31 These are the values that companies in the halal economy can easily adapt to and halal
certification would assist showcasing that.
Key Learning. Products are developed to suit specific international tastes. For example, for the Chinese market, a sweet mayonnaise
that people use with fruit salad was developed. They also produced a salad dressing for a type of salad sold in North China. This is
their second-biggest seller in Beijing.
3 These are key select large corporates and not meant to be a comprehensive list as there are other corporates as well. These are identified
by DinarStandard team independently and with no commercial consideration.
Modest Fashion
SECTOR OVERVIEW
Indonesian fashion companies operate across the value chain with many large international brands choosing to have their products
manufactured in Indonesia. There are 4,899 medium to large manufacturing facilities in textile and apparel across the country33,
employing over 1.39 million people.34 SMEs also play a significant role in the fashion industry. Many have emerged during the
pandemic. In 2019, there were 909,822 businesses that were classified as micro and small enterprises in the textile and apparel
industries. These employed 1.57 million people.35 Many of the companies specialize in modest wear.
GLOBAL BENCHMARK
LC Waikiki • Tema Tekstil, the producer and licensor of LC Waikiki in Turkey, bought the worldwide rights of the LC Waikiki
(Turkey) brand in 1997.
• Currently export US$ 845 million (IDR 12 trillion) worth of goods and have over 1000 stores across 49 countries.
• Modest range available online and in selected stores.
Key Learning. Sustainability is one of the core values of the company. They have incorporated the LC Waikiki Ecology Policy, which
encompasses the full value chain of their products.
American
• A leading global specialty retailer offering high-quality, on-trend clothing, accessories and personal care
Eagle products at affordable prices under its American Eagle and Aerie brands.
Outfitters • At the end of FY2020, there were 229 licensed stores in 28 countries.
(USA)
Key Learning. AEO recently acquired a logistics company, which will enable it to provide customers with same-day delivery. The
acquisition of key-value chain components can allow businesses to differentiate themselves from their competitors. AEO is also
continuously introducing innovative ideas to the business. They are currently developing an app that will allow for live retailing.38
4 These are key select large corporates and not meant to be a comprehensive list as there are other corporates as well. These are identified
by DinarStandard team independently and with no commercial consideration.
Halal Pharmaceuticals
SECTOR OVERVIEW
As of 2019, there were 338 medium to large manufacturers of pharmaceuticals, chemical medicinal products and traditional medicines
across Indonesia. These companies employ 6,886 people. There are 14,597 micro and small enterprises in the sector that employ
24,815 people. In 2020, 4,631 products were certified halal across 208 corporations.
GLOBAL BENCHMARK
Key Learning. Offering R&D services to external companies can be an excellent source of revenue and may generally lead to
increasing Indonesia’s capability for the development of new drugs.
Key Learning. Innovation is a key differentiator in the pharmaceutical industry. If a company can successfully and continuously
produce innovative solutions, they can succeed.
5 These are key select large corporates and not meant to be a comprehensive list as there are other corporates as well. These are identified
by DinarStandard team independently and with no commercial consideration.
6 Total product and royalties revenue
Halal Cosmetics
SECTOR OVERVIEW
Between January and August 2020, Indonesia’s cosmetics product exports totaled US$ 135.67 million.45 Muslim consumer spend on
cosmetics in Indonesia was the 2nd highest globally in 2020. The pandemic lead in a shift from make-up products to skincare. In 2020,
26,197 products were certified halal across 214 corporations.
Revenue US$ 214 million46 (IDR 3.05 trillion) Employees > 10,000
• One of the largest manufacturers of cosmetics in Indonesia.
• Popular brands from the company include Wardah, Make Over, Emina, Putri and Kahf (for men).
Paragon
Technology • They have 41 distribution centers.
& Innovation • US$1.6 million (IDR 22.9 billion) worth of Wardah products was exported to Malaysia in October 2020.47
• Products are certified by the Mejalis Ulama, Indonesia.
GLOBAL BENCHMARK
BASF
• One of the largest global producers of chemicals and ingredients for food, pharmaceuticals and cosmetic
(Germany) products.
• It operates in more than 80 countries, including Muslim countries in the Middle East, Asia Pacific and Europe.
• Product categories for cosmetics include ingredients for personal care products (antiperspirants and
deodorants), body care, face care, hair coloring and styling, shampoo, skincare, and oral care.
• BASF offers 145 ingredients for personal and home care products that have been certified by the international
halal standard HAS 23000. It complies with strict halal guidelines along the entire value chain.
Key Learning. With such a large range of product offerings, BASF is easily a leader in its field. This was accomplished through
strategic acquisitions of businesses that had a positive outlook. Such acquisitions are key to becoming a leader in an industry.
Oriflame
• Oriflame cosmetics is an international social selling beauty company
Cosmetics • Operates in 60 countries across Europe, Africa, Asia and Latin America.
• Its portfolio of innovative beauty products is marketed through approximately 3 million Independent Brand
Partners.
• They currently ensure that the raw materials used are halal compliant and are working on a portfolio of halal-
certified products for key Muslim markets like Indonesia.
Key Learning. About 98% of the company’s orders are received through their online platform. When COVID-19 occurred, they were
already in a good position to prevent any severe disruptions to their business and independent business partners.
7 These are key select large corporates and not meant to be a comprehensive list as there are other corporates as well. These are identified
by DinarStandard team independently and with no commercial consideration.
Indonesia is predominantly a consumption market. With the large population, retail is a lucrative industry. The retail market in Indonesia
is separated into Wet markets and modern markets. Before the pandemic, the retail market was growing between 8-9% per year. With
the easing of PSBB restrictions, the growth has begun to increase again. The pandemic also had an impact on consumer shopping
preferences with more shoppers opting for modern markets compared to before the pandemic.
Sector Food
Revenue US$ 5.32 billion (IDR 75.83 trillion) Employees 125,045
• A mini-mart chain of supermarkets established in 1999.
Alfa Mart • In 2016, they launched AlfaMind, the first virtual store in Indonesia with Augmented Reality technology.
• In 2020, Alfamart opened its 1000th branch in the Philippines. It has over 13,600 branches in Indonesia.
GLOBAL BENCHMARK
Sector Food
Revenue US$ 100.48 billion (IDR1431.5 trillion) Employees 64,709
• Holding company, with a variety of business operations: convenience stores, superstores, department stores,
7-Eleven supermarkets, specialty stores and food services.
(Seven • In 2018, there were over 20,000 Seven-Eleven stores in Japan.
& I Holdings) • They offer a selection of halal products in different locations of their stores.
(Japan)
Key Learning. The holding operates across the supply chain for its stores. This gives it a significant advantage in broadening the
range of products and also making the products more affordable.
8 These are key select large corporates and not meant to be a comprehensive list as there are other corporates as well. These are identified
by DinarStandard team independently and with no commercial consideration.
Key Learning. WBA and VillageMD plan to open 500 to 700 “Village Medical at Walgreens” physician-led primary care clinics in more
than 30 US markets over the next five years.52 Providing customers with a one-stop-shop experience for healthcare may attract
more customers. An all-encompassing customer experience could improve sales and returning customers.
Key Learning. Many department stores in the USA did not survive the emergence of e-commerce, but with the right strategies,
Macy’s was not only able to survive but thrive. By the 2nd quarter of 2021, it is estimated that 34% of Macy’s net sales will be derived
from e-commerce sales.54
Photo: Shutterstock.com
E-COMMERCE PLATFORMS
SECTOR OVERVIEW
The movement restriction orders during the COVID-19 pandemic have encouraged growth in the e-commerce sector. The Gross Market
Value of the e-commerce industry in Indonesia was valued at US$25.3 billion in 2020.55 Food and beverage manufacturer GarudaFood
saw improved sales over the last five consecutive months, driven by collaborations with e-commerce platforms, an expansion of its
distribution network, and adding stock for seasonal products that are usually hard to find during Ramadan.56 Investors have started
showing interest in Indonesian e-commerce companies.57
INDONESIA’S SELECT KEY PLAYERS 9
HappyFresh
• Founded in 2004, the platform allows customers to shop for groceries online from shops around their area.
• It operates its own delivery fleet and staff that pick the fresh groceries from partnering supermarkets.63
• The company has operations in Indonesia, Malaysia and Thailand.
• HappyFresh closed a US$ 65 million Series D round led by Korean internet giant Naver and Netherlands-based
investor Gafina.64
GLOBAL BENCHMARK
Sector Fashion
Revenue US$ 9.42 billion (IDR 134.27 trillion) Employees 14,194
Zalando
• Offers fashion and lifestyle products to customers in 23 European markets.
(Germany) • It allows fashion companies and retailers to make sales via a Partner Program.67
• In June 2021, the company launched its new online platform in Slovenia, Lithuania and Slovakia.68
• In 2020, the group received 5.39 billion website views with 185.5 million orders.
Key Learning. In 2015, Zalando acquired a 20% stake in the software company Anatwine, an e-commerce platform used to integrate
the brands featured on the site.69 This move enabled Zalando to successfully progress from a fashion e-retailer to a fashion platform
featuring more than 4,500 brands. Strategic acquisitions and investments can assist companies in growing on a large scale.
DISTRIBUTORS
SECTOR OVERVIEW
Distributors are key to connecting manufacturers and retailers with the materials and products they require, specifically from abroad.
Sectors such as fashion are more reliant on imported raw materials. The food and beverage industry are more reliant on locally
sourced materials. Distributors can also assist manufacturers to export their products to international markets.
Sector Food
Revenue Not disclosed Employees Not disclosed
• PT Anugrah Indo Mandiri is a distributor of food and beverage products from companies in Europe, the
Americas, Australia, Japan and Asia within Indonesia.
PT Anugrah
Indo Mandiri
Sector Pharmaceutical
Revenue Not disclosed Employees Not disclosed
• Distributor for various pharmaceutical brands.
• Mangalla has developed successful distribution networks across the 5 major islands in Indonesia with
Manggalla
Pharmaceutical
distribution channel spanning supermarkets, convenience stores, independent pharmacies, clinics, and
Distribution hospitals, with more than 100 sub-distributors spread out across 24 provinces.
Centre
Sector Food
Revenue US$ 15.5 billion73 (IDR 220.96 trillion) Employees 20,000
• The largest family-operated broadline food distribution company in North America.
Gordon Food • Also operates in more than 175 Gordon Food Service Store locations in the U.S. which are open to the.72
Service (USA)
Key Learning. The Gordon Food Service company carries out an Annual Stewardship Report. This is a progress report which
focuses on 4 main areas: Sustainable Operations, Responsible Sourcing, Empowering People and Supporting Community. This
would be beneficial for companies to attract the attention of businesses and customers concerned over the sustainability of the
products they procure.
Sector Pharmaceuticals
Revenue US$ 59.1billion (IDR842.5 trillion) Employees 76,000
• Medical distribution and health care information technology company that provides prescription and over-the-
McKesson
(USA) counter drugs, medical supplies, healthcare IT, and pharmacy management software.
• Serves customers across 14 countries.
Key Learning. McKesson is the centralized distributor for COVID-19 vaccines in the USA. Medical-Surgical Solutions, a subsidiary
of McKesson, played a central role in the COVID-19 response efforts, assembling and distributing the ancillary supply kits needed
for COVID-19 vaccinations and distributing COVID-19 tests to healthcare provider customers. A company should develop its service
offerings and build a reputation of efficiency and good service such that they become the go-to company for significant occasions.
13 These are key select large corporates and not meant to be a comprehensive list as there are other corporates as well. These are identified
by DinarStandard team independently and with no commercial consideration.
ISLAMIC FINANCE/FINTECH
SECTOR OVERVIEW
The growth in Islamic Finance was greater than that of conventional finance in Indonesia for 2020. Total assets grew by 10.97%
compared to 7.7% for conventional banks. Third-party funds grew 11.56% which was higher than conventional banks’ at 11.49%.
Financing grew 9.42% while conventional banks grew by 0.55%.74 Indonesia’s workers social security agency BPJS Ketenagakerjaan
has started offering shariah services. This is expected to boost the Islamic Finance market share.75 As consumers become more
aware of Islamic Finance, the demand for products will continually increase.
GLOBAL BENCHMARK
Al Rajhi
• According to 2015 data, Al Rajhi is the world’s largest Islamic bank based on capital.
Bank (Saudi • Has over 600 branches in Saudi Arabia, Kuwait and Jordan, with subsidiaries in Malaysia and Syria.
Arabia)
Key Learning. The operations of the bank include a dedicated Shariah Group, which is completely independent of all other banking
departments. This initiative is considered an important standard of quality assurance and will be an important function for any
Islamic bank.
Wahed
• A fintech company, offering digital financial services to retail customers globally, starting with ethical wealth
Invest management. The company’s app enables users to easily invest locally and internationally with minimal
(USA) transaction fees.
• Over 200,000 customers globally in over 100 countries. They have 11 offices globally.
• Investment options include global stocks, emerging market stocks, sukuk, real estate and gold.
Key Learning. There is great value in a simple user interface, specifically when it comes to dealing with concepts that are inherently
challenging or perceived as more complex. It is the simplicity of the app and having a ready selection of shariah-approved stocks
to invest in which has made the company successful.
14 These are key select large corporates and not meant to be a comprehensive list as there are other corporates as well. These are identified by
DinarStandard team independently and with no commercial consideration.
MUSLIM-FRIENDLY TRAVEL
SECTOR OVERVIEW
Tourism is an important sector of focus for the Indonesian government, particular for Muslim-friendly tourism. The sector consists of
independent hotels, some hotel chains and travel agencies specializing in hajj and umrah trips. This industry was devastated by the
pandemic but with PSBB restrictions easing and domestic travel opening up, the industry should recover strongly.
• Rhadana Hotels and Resorts offer halal-friendly accommodation in several cities across Indonesia. There are
multiple new hotels currently being developed.
Rhadana
Hotels and
Resort
• Founded in 1972. It was one of the first providers of the Hajj Plus service.
• The company provides ticketing services, tours, travel document management (passports and visas) as well
as Hajj and Umrah services or known as PPIH (Hajj Travel Organizer). They have offices across Indonesia.
PT Patuna
Tour & Travel
GLOBAL BENCHMARK
Key Learning. Focusing on a niche segment within the travel sector will open up the customer base and will also result in a more
loyal one.
Intrepid
• Specializes in tourism packages and is made up of three tour operator brands, more than 25 destination
Group management companies, and a not-for-profit foundation.
• Globally, in 2019 they had more than 40 offices around the globe.
• Globally renowned as a leader in responsible travel, in 2018 Intrepid became the world’s largest certified travel
B Corp
Key Learning. After the severe impact that COVID-19 had on the company, they devised a solid strategy for moving forward towards
becoming a billion-dollar company by 2025. Companies should see the pandemic as an opportunity to evaluate their operations
and strategy to create a more resilient business.
15 These are key select large corporates and not meant to be a comprehensive list as there are other corporates as well. These are identified
by DinarStandard team independently and with no commercial consideration.
Muslim consumer spend on cosmetics in Indonesia was the 2nd highest globally in 2020. The pandemic lead in a shift from make-
up products to skincare. In 2020, 26,197 products were certified halal across 214 corporations.
• Nussa is an animated, Islamic children’s series featuring the main character Nussa.
• Nussa episodes began airing on YouTube in November 2018 and have received over 2 billion views to date.
• Nussa & Friends content is available via an app and the Nussa Dunya website, which offers a paid subscription
to access content such as related e-books, wallpapers and games.
Nussa • Products are also available on Shoppee and Tokopedia.
• An Islamic television channel that can be watched via MNC Vision satellites and those owned by MNC Channels.
• Content is created in Behasa.
Muslim TV
GLOBAL BENCHMARK
Key Learning. Netflix began as a DVD rental company that sent DVDs via mail. They successfully pivoted into and were one of the
front runners of the subscription streaming services companies. This highlights the importance of being able to pivot when a market
becomes obsolete or close to it.
Key Learning. Disney’s success is due to excellent brand development and key acquisitions. They have consistently adjusted the
content they produce to fit the norms of the time, and this has led to successful diversity and inclusion endeavors.
16 These are key select large corporates and not meant to be a comprehensive list as there are other corporates as well. These are identified
by DinarStandard team independently and with no commercial consideration.
With the significant growth in eCommerce, logistics partners have become increasingly important. With the widely distributed
geography of Indonesia, efficient logistics companies are important. These companies also help facilitate exports and imports. They
played a critical role during the pandemic during PSBB.
GLOBAL BENCHMARK
DHL
• DHL serves over 220 countries, delivering 1.6 billion parcels a year.
(Germany) • The company is divided into 6 divisions dealing with different aspects of logistics such as freight or global
forwarding.
• They have a dedicated division for eCommerce solutions.
Key Learning. DHL has Innovation Centers in Chicago, Cologne, Singapore, and Dubai. Workshops, tours, and events are held in
these centers to encourage innovation in the sector. They receive over 13,000 visitors a year. Constant innovation is a must for
improving services and building better relationships with customers.
Key Learning. The vision of China COSCO Shipping is to undertake the mission of globalizing the Chinese economy and provide
world-leading integrated logistics and supply chain services. A vision like this would be helpful to any country or logistics company
looking to make a significant impact.
17 These are key select large corporates and not meant to be a comprehensive list as there are other corporates as well. These are identified
by DinarStandard team independently and with no commercial consideration.
Halal Parks
SECTOR OVERVIEW
Halal parks are an important part of the Indonesian Shariah economy strategy. These parks will facilitate investment into halal
economy sectors and create a streamlined process for halal certification.
• The first industrial zone in Indonesia to receive the Halal Industrial Zone certificate from the Ministry of
Industry, enabling the creation of a complete halal ecosystem for halal industries.
Modern • It is located on 500 hectares of land and provides local and global halal food and supporting industries
Cikande Industrial a complete halal ecosystem for efficient halal production, import, domestic distribution and export to
Estate: Modern international markets.
Halal Valley
• Located in the Moderncikande Industrial Estate in Cikande (Banten), just 52 km west of Jakarta on
Java Island. The Moderncikande Industrial Estate has direct highway access through the Cikande
Toll Gate, linking Halal Valley directly to Java’s seaports, Soekarno-Hatta International Airport, and
Indonesia’s metropolis Jakarta.
• Modern Halal Valley provides also commercial space for companies active in halal business, commerce,
and Islamic banking & finance, serving Indonesia, Asia and the world.87
GLOBAL BENCHMARK
• Port Klang Free Zone (PKFZ) and Sarawak-based Regal International Group (RIG) are collaborating to
further promote two-way Halal investments between Malaysia and China.
• The industrial park has partnered with the Halal Industry Development Corporation (HDC). PKFZ Halal
Zone is supported by HDC advisory center, data warehouse, knowledge dissemination tools, and
kande business and market intelligence.
Industrial
Estate: • The halal park will feature HDC training and consultancy services in halal to support certification. Halal
Moder logistics/warehousing will also be available.
• Total investments in Malaysia’s Halal Parks amounted to US$ 2.7 billion, and employment opportunities
reached around 11,000+.
Key Learning. A halal flagship free zone can attract mainstream companies, as PKFZ received $125m (RM 500m) investment
from Cargill. Having halal certifying bodies and other services within the park will also help facilitate in drawing the attention of
mainstream companies.
18 These are key select large corporates and not meant to be a comprehensive list as there are other corporates as well. These are identified
by DinarStandard team independently and with no commercial consideration.
Ministry of Tourism Ministry of SOEs Coordinating Ministry of Coordinating Ministry Coordinating Ministry
and Creative Economy Economic Affairs for Maritime Affairs for Human Development
and Investment and Culture
There are a number of ministerial bodies and various associations across the halal economy which affect the regulations governing
the sector. These bodies also assist in the promotion and growth of the halal economy.
Halal • The BPJPH has the task and • Cooperates with the Ministry
Products function to ensure the halal of Trade and other ministries
compliance of products regarding the export
Halal Product Assurance circulating and marketed in requirements for halal-certified
Agency (BPJPH) Indonesia. products. Also provides
mentoring programs for MSEs
• Also responsible for halal
education, literacy and halal
awareness.
Tourism, • The main objective of the • The ministry backed the Modest
Modest ministry is to make Indonesia a Fund the Founder’s incubation
Fashion world-class tourism destination program
Ministry of Tourism developing world-class tourism
and Creative Economy destinations and conduct
tourism-oriented marketing.
• For the creative economy,
the ministry is tasked with
synergizing cooperation
between inventors and
investors
Overall • Majelis Ulama Indonesia - MUI) • The MUI works together with
Halal is Indonesia’s top Islamic BPJPH as an auditor of the halal
Economy scholars’ body. The MUI acts process as well as holding fatwa
Majelis Ulama as an interface between the assemblies to certify products as
Indonesia Indonesian government and halal
the Islamic communities.
On 14th May 2019, the Government, via National Islamic Finance Committee (KNEKS) that is headed by
the President of the Republic of Indonesia, launched the Indonesia Islamic Economy Masterplan (MEKSI).
MEKSI also contains the Indonesia Islamic Financial Architecture Masterplan (MAKSI) launched in August
2016. The strategy to strengthen Sharia finance in MEKSI refers to MAKSI, thus integrating the development
strategies for the Sharia economy and Sharia finance. Meanwhile, in line with another strategy initiated by
Bank Indonesia, the National Sharia Economic Development Strategy contained in MEKSI emphasizes halal
value chain (HVC) development for priority sectors. The halal value chain (HVC) is a series of activities that
generate value-add in each process, involving the production, distribution, and marketing of goods and/
or services to the consumer in compliance with sharia values and core principles. Through an ecosystem
approach, halal value chain development will drive productive, inclusive, and integrated end-to-end sharia
business growth. Various development efforts that lead to the formation of a halal value chain (HVC)
ecosystem have effectively elevated the position of Indonesia’s sharia economy and finance globally.
Bank Indonesia is currently implementing the Blueprint for the Sharia Economy and Finance, with its vision
of Indonesia becoming a global center of the Sharia economy and finance. The Blueprint, which was
launched in June 2017, became main reference for Indonesia Sharia Economic Masterplan by KNEKS in
2019, which aims to develop the real sector of the sharia economy, known as the halal industry.
The blueprint contains three complementary and mutually reinforcing development pillars. According
to the Shariah Economy and Finance Report 2020, the first pillar of the strategy is Sharia Economic
Empowerment based on the main strategy of halal value chain (HVC) ecosystem development. Ecosystem
development is achieved through the application of partnership-based business models. The second pillar
is Sharia Financial Market Deepening, which fundamentally aims to increase sources of sharia financing
for the economy. Islamic Social Finance (ISF) is also included incorporated. The third pillar is Strengthening
Research, Assessment, and Education, which aims to increase public literacy and understanding of the
sharia economy and finance. Under the third pillar, the education strategy is implemented formally to
enhance competencies and mold reliable, professional and competitive human resources.19
Photo: Shutterstock.com
19 (2020) SHARIA ECONOMY AND FINANCE REPORT 2020. Published by Bank Indonesia : https://www.bi.go.id/en/publikasi/laporan/Pages/
Laporan-Ekonomi-dan-Keuangan-Syariah-2020.aspx
Companies intending to invest in Indonesia need to consider the importance of halal certification for their
halal products. Based on the prevailing national halal regulations, such as Government Regulation No. 39 of
2021 (GR 39/2021), all products that enter, circulate, and are sold within Indonesia must be halal certified,
if otherwise originating from haram ingredients.
Products requiring halal certification include food, beverages, pharmaceuticals, cosmetics, and consumer
goods that are worn or used, originating from animals or animal products. Services that must be halal
certified are slaughterhouses, processing, storing, packaging, distribution, and sales and marketing,
including shelf display. Halal certification is not required for haram products, with clear non-halal labeling
required on such products.
Indonesia serves as a model for a sustainable halal compliance ecosystem, where no single entity
monopolizes the regulatory system. There are three key stakeholders operating independently but in
collaboration with each other and the relevant government ministries. The key stakeholder is the Halal
Product Guarantee Agency – BPJPH, which issues halal certification and works with external auditors
(LPH), such as LPPOM, and fatwa body MUI, as part of the halal certification process.
This section describes the role of these key players in building a robust regulatory ecosystem, supporting
international trade, and the process of halal certification in Indonesia.
Halal Product Guarantee Agency (BPJPH). Law No. 33 of 2014 (UU 33/2014) in relation to Halal Product
Guarantee mandates the establishment of the Halal Product Guarantee Agency (Badan Penyelenggara
Jaminan Produk Halal – “BPJPH” in Indonesian abbreviation), which is authorized to issue halal product
policies and standards. Other powers of the BPJPH include issuing and revoking halal certificates and halal
labels, registering halal certificates for foreign products, accrediting the Halal Inspection Agency (Lembaga
Pemeriksa Halal – “LPH” in Indonesian abbreviation), registration of halal auditors, and cooperating with
internal and foreign institutions in implementing halal product guarantees.
Indonesian Ulema Council (MUI). Prior to October 2019 (when UU 33/2014 came into effect), halal
certification and labeling were overseen by the Indonesian Ulema Council (Majelis Ulama Indonesia – “MUI”
in Indonesian abbreviation). MUI appointed LPH, including its own Food and Drug Supervisory Agency
(LPPOM MUI), and appointed halal auditors to assess products requiring halal certification. The LPH would
issue halal certificates.
Under the new regulation, BPJPH now oversees the entire halal product assurance system (“JPH” in
Indonesian abbreviation) and issues halal certificates, including the registration of LPH for the inspection
and testing of halal product quality. BPJPH relies on MUI for the determination of halal compliance and
accreditation of LPH and its auditors. MUI holds Fatwa Assemblies to determine whether a product has
satisfied the criteria to obtain a halal certificate.
Halal Inspection Agencies (LPH). As mentioned above, the role of halal inspection agencies (LPH) is to
examine and test the halal quality of a product. The LPH appoints a halal auditor (certified by BPJPH and
MUI) who has the capacity to carry out the examination of a product’s halal quality. At the time of writing
this report, BPJPH has only accredited LPPOM MUI as the LPH until it accredits other inspection bodies
under the new law.
SCHEME
Halal Comapnion
SCHEME
SELF DECLARE
Audits
Halal product
Comapnion
SELF DECLARE
MSE*
Audits product
MSE*
Domestic Businesses:
The halal certification process for domestic companies willing to get their products certified consists of two
schemes – the regular scheme and the “self-declare” scheme for Micro and Small-scale Enterprises (MSE).
The implementation of a regular scheme has been followed since the LPPOM MUI period. All business
actors (any person or business entity in the form of a legal entity or non-legal entity engaged in business
activities in Indonesia), both micro, small and medium enterprises (MSME) and large businesses, apply
for halal certification by submitting the required documents to BPJPH. After being reviewed by BPJPH
and declared to have met the requirements, the documents are sent to the halal inspection agency (LPH),
where the assigned halal auditor carries out the inspection. Based on the regulations, BPJPH is obliged
to cooperate with the LPH for laboratory testing requirements (if needed). The results of the inspection
are sent by the LPH directly to MUI, and BPJPH is informed. MUI will decide whether the products that
have been inspected or audited by LPH have met the halal rules or not. If the product fulfills the halal
requirements, a “Halal Decree” will be issued. Based on this Decree, BPJPH will issue a halal certificate for
the product, which will be valid for 4 years.88 Three independent parties—BPJPH, LPH and MUI—collaborate
in the process of issuing the halal certificate.
While previously, this entire process took around 97 days to complete from the time of application to the
issuance of halal certification, it is now estimated to take just 21 days for the process.89
(2)“Self-Declare” Scheme
For micro and small-scale business actor (MSE), the “Self-Declare” expedited the halal certification process.
Under the GR 39/2021 regulation, the self-declare scheme allows MSE to submit a self-declaration to the
BPJPH that proves they are an MSE (as determined under prevailing laws) and confirm the certainty of halal
products based on BPJPH standards.
Under the new regulation, MSE can self-declare after receiving a confirmation from the “halal companion.”
The halal companion could be a non-government organization, the representative of an Islam organization,
higher education, or ministry/another organization that collaborates with these institutions. The task of
the halal companion is to ensure that the production process carried out by MSE is in accordance with the
halal standards.
After validating the documents that have been prepared by the applicant, these institutions declare
the contract of halal (The Halal Oath). Documents are submitted to BPJPH, who will carry out the halal
assessment and issue the halal certificate.
Moreover, under the new regulation, MSE will not be required to pay any halal certification fee.
International Businesses:
There are two halal product certification schemes from foreign companies. The scheme can be grouped by
product category as regulated in GR 39/2021:
Applicable for food & beverage, cosmetics, medicine and other consumer products. For these categories,
halal certification must be submitted directly to BPJPH with the same procedure as for domestic products
with the regular scheme. This scheme includes the involvement of LPH in the product inspection process.
(2) Raw materials, additives, auxiliary materials, and slaughtered goods product categories
For these categories, if there is a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) between countries followed by
a Mutual Recognition Agreement (MRA) between BPJPH and the relevant state halal authority agency,
then the halal certificate from that country can be directly registered with BPJPH. Importers or official
representatives of foreign companies in Indonesia can submit applications for the registration process. In
this case, the halal certificate from the respective foreign agency is recognized in Indonesia, and the halal
logo can be used immediately. This applies reciprocally. However, if there is no MRA between BPJPH and a
foreign halal certification agency, a direct assessment will be carried out by BPJPH.
Export Support
The central and local government of Indonesia play an important role in the development of the halal
industry, especially in their role as regulators in setting and supervising halal standards, facilitators in
providing supporting infrastructure (such as fiscal and non-fiscal policies), and promoters of halal trade
domestically and internationally.
BPJPH plays a major role in supporting companies to export and expand their reach internationally.
Currently, in collaboration with several ministries, this support is available to MSEs. For instance, BPJPH
is collaborating with the Ministry of Trade to help companies learn export requirements for halal-certified
products. Special technical awareness and mentoring programs are organized for prospective exporters of
halal products. This will add value through quality products and increase consumer trust, both for domestic
needs and export purposes.
Photo: Shutterstock.com
Law No. 33 of 2014 (UU 33/2014) in relation to the Halal Product Guarantee (HPG) mandates all products
distributed in the territory of the Republic of Indonesia obtain halal certification starting from 17th October
2019, except for products that are described as non-halal on their packaging. This mandatory halal
certification aims to provide greater public convenience and assurance concerning the availability of halal
products and to increase value-add for businesses producing and selling halal products domestically and
internationally.
Amendments were made to Law No. 11 of 2020 on Job Creation (Omnibus Law) on 2nd November 2020.
One of the implementing regulations of the Omnibus Law is Government Regulation No. 39 of 2021 on Halal
Product Assurance (GR 39/2021), which replaced Government Regulation Number 31 of 2019 on Halal
Product Assurance (GR 31/2019) (issued on 2nd February 2021). It includes details on the halal compliance
process for products sold in Indonesia. Another implementing regulation detailing the certification process
and timeline is the Ministry of Religious Affairs Regulation No. 26 Year 2019 (MORA Reg 26/2019).
Business owners who fail to label their non-halal products will be imposed with administrative sanctions
in the form of a verbal warning, followed by a written warning, and finally, an administrative fee will be
imposed successively.
The law covers products and/or services related to food, beverages, drugs, cosmetics, chemicals, biological
products, genetically engineered products as well as consumer goods that are worn, used, or utilized by the
public. Halal certification for all products that are halal became mandatory in Indonesia from October 2019
(for food and beverages); however, they are phased out by categories to be implemented progressively.
This grace period differs for each category. For example, food and beverage business owners have a 5-year
grace period to comply with the mandatory halal certification, starting 17th October 2019 and ending 17th
October 2024. Below is a table compiled from the regulations, listing the commencing date and deadline to
comply with mandatory halal certification by category.
Traditional medicines and health supplements 17th October 2021 17th October 2026
Over the Counter Medicine 17th October 2021 17th October 2029
Prescription drugs (except psychotropic) 17th October 2021 17th October 2034
Wearable items (clothing, headcovers and accessories) 17th October 2021 17th October 2026
Medical Equipment classified in Risk Category A 17th October 2021 17th October 2026
Medical Equipment classified in Risk Category B 17th October 2021 17th October 2029
Medical Equipment classified in Risk Category C 17th October 2021 17th October 2034
Source: Ministry of Religious Affairs Regulation No. 26 Year 2019 (MORA Reg 26/2019), Articles 31-33
Consumer drivers are those circumstances that directly affect the consumption market. For Indonesia,
the most stand-out feature is its large population. It is the 4th most populous nation on Earth and has the
largest population of Muslims.
Indonesia is home to the world’s largest Muslim population. Muslims make up 87.2% of the country’s total
population. In a Pew Research survey, 98% of Indonesians surveyed believe religion is very important, with
the remaining 2% believing that it is somewhat important. Since 2006, this figure has only grown. God
and prayer play critical roles in the lives of almost all of those surveyed.90 The government has permitted
specific regions to adopt Shariah, such as Aceh, where the hijab is obligatory for Muslim women by law.91
With religion playing such an important role, the country’s consumers will also value making purchases in
line with their faith. Consumer spend on halal food is already the highest in the world. Lifestyle sectors such
as modest clothing have significant potential, especially since Indonesia is already a successful producer
of clothing in general and a popular tourist destination.
Growth in Income
Although the World Bank downgraded Indonesia to low-middle income status as the gross national
income per capita decreased from US$4,050 in 2019 to US$3,870 in 2020, the Presidential Special Staff for
Economic Affairs believes that Indonesia can return to its upper-middle-income status in one to two years,
if annual economic growth reaches 5-6% and the population rises by 1.2% per year.92 The World Bank’s
chief economist for East Asia and Pacific Region believes that Indonesia can grow close to 5% in 2022,
especially with a successful vaccine rollout program.93
In 2019, half of the consumption basket of the Indonesian consumer consisted of food. As income grows,
non-food categories will make up a larger proportion of this basket. A rise in spending on housing and
household facilities can be attributed to greater urbanization. Within the food categories, the proportion of
spending on prepared food and beverages is also forecasted to increase by 2030. This is due to lifestyle
changes that have people eating out more and seeking more convenience and packaged foods. This is also
linked to the higher urbanization levels.94
Given Indonesia’s high social media penetration rates, these channels offer immense growth potential for
many consumer companies. Many consumers are already on social media but do not see it as a place
to make purchases. Businesses should therefore focus on building their presences, establishing their
credibility, and scaling up their marketing efforts on these platforms to drive greater interest and sales.95
Tech-savvy population
Indonesia’s tech-savvy population pushed its internet economy to grow over 10% to reach a Gross
Merchandise Value (GMV) of $44 billion in 2020, the largest in Southeast Asia. The digital economy
contributed 4% of the country’s GDP in 2020.96 About 73.7%97 of the population have access to the
internet, which significantly exceeds the global level of 59.5%. There are 345.3 million mobile connections,
translating to 1.2 mobile connections per person in Indonesia.
Around 87.1% of users had made a purchase online. Millennials and Gen-Z’s make up 53% of the Indonesian
population. This has also contributed to the acceleration of the growth of the digital economy in the country.
Since the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic, surveys have found that consumers are most conscious
about personal hygiene and general health. A survey carried out by Bank DBS Indonesia found that more
than half of those surveyed would continue to use vitamins and supplements post-pandemic.
The consumer’s increased awareness of health is also changing their preference for grocery shopping.
Prior to COVID-19, 68% of consumers preferred purchasing packaged and fresh food from traditional
markets. This preference has now decreased to 59%. A survey by Deloitte found that 40% of respondents
have become much more conscious of the source of origin of their food and the nutritional value due to the
pandemic.98 This shift in perception offers halal food and pharmaceutical manufacturers many potential
opportunities to introduce new products and meet this emerging demand.
Photo: Shutterstock.com
The COVID-19 pandemic led to the first negative growth in GDP that Indonesia has experienced since
1998. The Central Statistics Agency (BPS) reported GDP growth for 2020 in Indonesia at -5.4%.99 In a
survey conducted by McKinsey & Company throughout 2020, 53% of respondents felt optimistic about
the recovery of Indonesia’s economy post-COVID and believed it would rebound within 2-3 months.100 To
decrease the spread of the virus, the government introduced large-scale social restrictions (PSBB) and
restrictions on community activities (PPKM) which had significant impacts on the lives of citizens and, in
turn, the economy at large.
The COVID-19 pandemic led to the first recession in Indonesia in over 20 years. The economy contracted by
5.4% in 2020. This was driven by drops in private consumption (-1.5%) and investment (-1.6%), which were
partially offset by growth in net exports (1.1%). According to the World Bank, the economy is expected to
start rebounding in 2021 and to gradually strengthen in 2022. Growth is projected to reach 4.4% in 2021.
Growth could accelerate to 5.0% in 2022, driven by reduced uncertainty and improved confidence, provided
that the vaccine rollout reaches a critical mass of the population starting in the fourth quarter of 2021.101
10%
8%
6%
4%
2%
0%
-2%
-3.2%
-4%
-5.4%
-6% -5.6%
-8%
There are 63 million MSMEs in Indonesia that contribute 60% to the country’s GDP and are responsible
for 97% of employment.102 MSMEs were more negatively affected than large enterprises, experiencing
between a 35-45% drop in sales, compared to a 25% drop in sales experienced by large enterprises.103 This
amounts to almost $100 million in revenue.104 Since most halal economy lifestyle sector players would
qualify as an MSME, this would directly impact the halal economy.
A survey carried out by McKinsey & Co. periodically throughout 2020 on the effects of COVID-19 on
consumers found that household income and savings have decreased for 60% of consumers in Indonesia.
This has led to consumers becoming more mindful of how they spend and save money Spending patterns
have shifted as consumers prioritized essential products such as groceries and healthcare products over
other lifestyle segment products. For categories such as footwear, apparel, accessories and jewelry, over
50% of consumers surveyed have decreased spend. Other categories where a vast majority, often over
50%, of consumers had decreased spend include hotel or resort stays, domestic flights, and eating at
restaurants.
More people expect to make a portion of their purchases online post-COVID-19 than before. The figure
below shows the product categories growing the most in consumer purchases during the pandemic.105
One of the Government’s strategies in suppressing the spread of Covid-19 is to establish a Large-Scale
Social Restriction ( PSBB ) policy . With the implementation of the PSBB, both the supply chain and
production were disrupted as the rules placed limitations on the movement of people and goods. Some
industries were forced to close completely, while others were allowed to operate since different PSBB rules
apply to different parts of the country. The food industry was given priority to operate to prevent a food
security crisis. However, this still caused a disruption in the overall food value chain as priority was given to
food end-product producers and didn’t necessarily consider other value chain players such as agriculture
and food ingredients. The transportation bans in April and May 2020 also led to a delay in food supply
chains.106
The manufacturing sector is one of the largest contributors to Indonesia’s GDP. The food and beverages
sector of manufacturing saw slight positive growth and the chemicals, pharmaceutical, and traditional
medicine subsector saw significant growth, becoming the 2nd largest contributor after food and beverages.
Manufacturing in textile and apparel witnessed the largest decrease in growth. 107
Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) into Indonesia increased by US$6.1 billion in June 2021 from the previous
quarter.108 FDI decreased by 23% between 2019 and 2020.109 Most investors currently involved in projects
in Indonesia have postponed their projects but have not pulled out completely. An example of a project
that has been delayed is the Jakarta-Bandung high-speed railway project, which is a joint project between
Indonesian and Chinese railway companies.110 Interestingly, domestic investment, which makes up 53% of
total investment in the country, increased by 9.3% quarter-on-quarter between January and March 2021.111
The Omnibus Bill (became law in October 2020) included FDI-related reforms that cut the number
of business lines subject to FDI restrictions dramatically from 528 to 215, including in areas critical to
industrial upgrading such as e-commerce.
In Indonesia, trade was limited by the PSBB, which restricted trade with certain countries. Exports
experienced a significant decrease between March 2020 to May 2020112 but, most recently between April
2020 and March 2021, showed steady growth from US$12.2 billion to US$18.4 billion.113 Imports showed
a similar trend in the early months of the pandemic, especially since the restrictions on Chinese trade were
particularly strong during this time. China is the largest import partner of Indonesia.114
The role and urgency of Islamic social finance (ISF) during the Covid-19 pandemic have become more
tangible. Strategically, zakat, infaq and sadaqah (ZIS)support the government’s social protection programs
to overcome the social impact of Covid-19. and provide the healthcare services required to contain
Covid-19. In addition, instruments that integrate commercial and social finance, such as cash waqf-linked
sukuk, support the development of public healthcare infrastructure.115
Globally, travel services were down by 63% in 2020 and are not expected to recover until the pandemic
settles down.116 By the first half of 2020, with restrictions on foreign visitors entering Indonesia, the number
of arrivals decreased by 60%, and 90% of those employed in the sector have been placed on unpaid leave
indefinitely.117
While the relaxation of PSBB rules allowed for domestic tourism to resume for some time, it declined again
when COVID-19 cases increased significantly due to the delta variant. With about 28.5% of the population
has been vaccinated as of October 2021,118 growth in contact-intensive services sectors is expected to
gradually increase.
By implementing a comprehensive halal economy strategy that builds on Indonesia’s existing capabilities,
Indonesia can substantially boost its production of products linked to the halal economy and contribute an
additional $5.1 billion to the economy.
This section examines Indonesia’s halal trade and investment opportunities through boosting exports in
the OIC and non-OIC markets, substituting imports of key categories by domestic production, and through
incremental FDI opportunity.
+
FOOD FASHION COSMETICS PHARMA
$8.00
$1 BILLION
IMPORT SUBSTITUTION
OPPORTUNITY IMPACT $1.20 $0.90
+
FOOD PHARMA COSMETICS
$3.13
$1.91
$0.5 BILLION
FDI OPPORTUNITY IMPACT
$0.31 $0.11 $0.03 $0.02
=
FINANCE FOOD TOURISM COSMETICS MEDIA PHARMA
Indonesia was among the top global exporters of halal products (food, fashion, pharmaceutical and
cosmetics) to the OIC countries in 2020, yet it represents 3% of total halal product trade value. This implies
a tremendous opportunity for growth. With $8.6 billion exports of halal products (including those not
requiring halal compliance, such as fresh vegetables), Indonesia is the 9th largest exporter globally and 2nd
largest exporter among the OIC countries. Of the $8.6 billion exports, $8 billion are products exported to
OIC that require some level of mandatory halal certification.
The export destinations for Indonesia’s halal product exports are mainly the OIC member countries, but
even the non-OIC countries source halal products from Indonesia, mainly the Eastern European markets.
An estimated $0.22 billion of halal products (requiring some level of mandatory halal certification) were
exported by 10 non-Muslim countries with the highest Muslim spend.20
This section provides the export opportunity for Indonesia – which product categories are ripe for export
growth, and what is the impact of incremental trade capture opportunity from the OIC and non-OIC trade
on Indonesia’s economy. The 57 OIC countries and top 10 non-OIC countries are collectively referred to as
“halal consumer markets” or “halal markets” in this sub-section.
Current state: Of the $8 billion halal products (food, fashion, pharmaceuticals, cosmetics) exports by
Indonesia to the top halal consumer markets in 2020, about 74% of exports were of animal or vegetable
fats and oils, accounting for $6 billion exports, with palm oil covering more than 80% of the category. But
other products also make an important contribution to the export earnings. These include natural resources
such as are processed food and beverages, forestry products, coffee, tea, palm products and fish. Exports
of other fashion products (apparel and footwear), pharmaceuticals and cosmetics cover about 7.5% of total
exports to halal consumer markets.
20 10 Non-OIC countries that have the highest Muslim spend (80% of the total Muslim consumption of halal products by non-OIC countries).
Countries include India, Russia, United States, China, France, Germany, United Kingdom, Italy, Ethiopia, Israel. See methodology section for details.
Export growth categories: Below are the top 10 prioritized export growth categories, led by animal or
vegetable fats and oils. The other most attractive export sectors are medicament; preparations of meat and
fish; coffee, tea, mate and spices; sugar and sugar confectionery.
These categories are scored and ranked by 5 metrics: products most imported by the halal consumer
markets, fastest-growing categories over the past 5 years, most exported by Indonesia, requiring some
degree of halal compliance, and OIC-trade intersection opportunity – halal trade flowing over Indonesia
with potential to capture halal products’ trade (refer to methodology section for details).
INDONESIA PRIORITIZED
Sector Trade Code (HS Code) Simplified Name FINAL SCORE
International Competitiveness
The OIC countries are the major destination markets for Indonesia’s halal products export. With a rich
profile of natural resources such as palm oil, Indonesia is the largest global supplier of animal or vegetable
fats and oil to the OIC countries, exporting 33% of the global exports to OIC.
But in regard to the other prioritized export categories, other countries lead the export market to the OIC. It
is key for Indonesia to assess these export markets and ascertain their competitive edge in the halal trade
market. This will help Indonesia identify the gaps in its trade and production capabilities.
Trade Code Prioritized Export Categories Current Export Value % of Total Exports
Sector Top 3 Exporters to OIC
(HS Code) (Simplified Name) (US$ Billions) to OIC
Brazil $3.54
33.0%
India $1.81
Food '02 Meat and edible meat offal 16.9%
Australia $1.33
12.4%
Indonesia (84th exporter) ($0.1 million)
The OIC countries imported $202 billion in halal products (requiring some degree of halal compliance) for food,
fashion, pharmaceuticals and cosmetics in 2020. Indonesia’s exports to the OIC countries totaled $8 billion,
4% of total exports. Hence, excluding Indonesia’s exports, the OIC imported $194 billion in halal products.
Indonesia is well-positioned to boost annual exports to the OIC by $1.95 billion. With a dedicated strategy
that supports halal economy activity, Indonesia can substantially boost its penetration of the broader $194
billion in exports to other member countries of the OIC by an incremental $1 billion (5%), $1.95 billion (10%)
or $2.93 (15%) billion per annum.
CURRENT
CURRENT TOTAL
INDONESIA 5% Capture 10% Capture 15% Capture
OIC IMPORTS POTENTIAL
EXPORTS TO OIC
Sectors OF HALAL
FOR HALAL
VALUE OF of Global Halal of Global Halal of Global Halal
PRODUCTS*, CAPTURE VIA Trade Trade Trade
PRODUCTS*,
2020 INDONESIA**
2020
US$ Billions US$ Billions US$ Billions US$ Billions US$ Billions US$ Billions
*Halal products exclude categories that are inherently halal (such as fresh vegetables) and categories identified haram.
**See methodology section for details on potential value of capture estimation.
Indonesia is also well-positioned to boost annual exports of final products to non-OIC countries by
$1.63 billion (10%).
The top 5 non-OIC countries across each of the 22 final consumer product categories imported $17 billion
of halal products across food, fashion, pharmaceuticals and cosmetic products in 2020. The import values
were adjusted based on Muslim spend in these countries (see methodology section for details). Indonesia
exported $0.64 billion (4%) of halal products to these non-OIC countries to meet end consumer demands.
Indonesia can substantially boost its penetration by an incremental $0.82 billion (5%), $1.63 billion (10%) or
$2.45 (15%) billion per annum.
CURRENT
CURRENT INDONESIA TOTAL
NON-OIC
EXPORTS TO POTENTIAL
IMPORTS OF 5% Capture of 10% Capture of 15% Capture of
Sectors FINAL HALAL
NON-OIC FOR FINAL VALUE OF
Global Halal Trade Global Halal Trade Global Halal Trade
HALAL PRODUCTS*, CAPTURE VIA
PRODUCTS*,
2020 INDONESIA**
2020
US$ Billions US$ Billions US$ Billions US$ Billions US$ Billions US$ Billions
*22 final halal products are identified from a list of 33 categories, excluding raw materials and intermediary products, and includes categories that
require some degree of halal compliance.
**See methodology section for details on potential value of capture estimation.
With $1.95 billion incremental OIC exports, and $1.63 billion incremental non-OIC exports, Indonesia can
boost its exports and the economy by a total $3.6 billion. The top 10 prioritized export categories cover
51.3% of the estimated export opportunity impact.
Summarizing OIC and Non-OIC Incremental Export Opportunity Impact on Indonesia’s GDP
Reasonable Reasonable
export capture export capture
(10% capture)
$3.6 BLN
EXPORT OPPORTUNITY IMPACT ON GDP
Photo: Shutterstock.com
Export Opportunity
Trade Code Prioritized Export Categories % of $3.6 Billion Export
Sector to OIC & Non-OIC
(HS Code) (Simplified Name) Opportunity Impact
(US$ Billion)
Photo: Shutterstock.com
Unlike many OIC countries, Indonesia is a net exporter of halal products in aggregate. In 2020, Indonesia
exported a total of $46.7 billion halal products (food, fashion, pharmaceuticals, cosmetics) globally, and
imported $14.5 billion halal products, hence a net exporter for halal products, with net exports totaling
$32 billion in 2020. Nonetheless, Indonesia is still import-dependent for many halal products that could
be replaced by domestic production. These products include ingredients for food, pharmaceuticals and
cosmetics, dairy products, animal feed, and several processed foods and beverages. For this reason,
Indonesia is aiming to develop strategies to increase domestic production efforts for import substations,
in addition to increasing global exports of halal products.
This section discusses the product categories that Indonesia heavily relies on for imports to meet its
consumer demands but which have the potential to be replaced by domestic production. The impact on
GDP of substituting such imports with local production is also estimated in the section.
In terms of halal economy sectors, Indonesia is a net exporter of halal food and fashion products, with
net exports of $22.5 billion and $10.5 billion, respectively. However, Indonesia is still a net importer of
pharmaceutical and cosmetic products, with net imports of $0.56 billion and $0.35 billion, respectively.
Net Exporter
$14.51
$11.0
$1.2
$1.2 $1.1
$0.6 $0.8
Total Halal Products Food* Fashion Pharma Cosmetics
The table below shows 17 halal product categories (food, fashion, pharmaceuticals, cosmetics) that
were import-dependent in 2020. Most of these categories can be substituted by domestic production as
Indonesia has the pertinent natural resources and capabilities.
Source: ITC Trademap, DinarStandard synthesis and analysis Indonesia Halal Markets Report 2021/2022 75
6 INDONESIA HALAL MARKET TRADE & INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITY
3 Food '02 Meat and edible meat offal 14,174 707,781 ($693,607)
15 Pharma '3003 Medicaments (not for retail sale) 15,784 27,163 ($11,379)
Domestic production: Indonesia’s domestic production capacity is a key area to develop import
substitution strategies. Current estimates show that in the year 2020, Indonesia’s halal food production
reached $214 billion, which includes production in agriculture, fisheries and processed food that comply
with shariah principles. Production in modest fashion reached $15.8 billion and the Muslim-friendly tourism
sector produced $49 billion in products that comply with shariah principles, from transport services,
accommodations and restaurants (Source: Bank Indonesia estimates).
Domestic industry interviews validated the ability and opportunity to substitute major parts of current halal
product imports. Below are summarized insights from interviews (see methodology section for interviewees):
Food import substitution: While in aggregate, Indonesia is a net exporter of halal food products, there are
several product categories that are import-dependent and can be substituted by domestic production.
These imported products largely comprise raw materials and processed food. Almost all sugar is imported
by Indonesia as ingredients. While about 80% of dairy is imported, it is difficult to self-suffice for milk powder
due to limited resources. And the same is the case with the import of corn for poultry feed. Other types of
processed food that Indonesia can self-suffice in include snacks, meat, and ingredients such as flavors and
preservatives.
Pharmaceutical/cosmetics import substitution: Most of the raw materials for pharmaceuticals and
cosmetics are imported. Intermediate products, such as polysilane, which is an imported raw material for
cosmetics, are domestically available. There is also a huge opportunity in producing packaging materials
that are also largely imported.
Fashion import substitution: Fabric and fiber production has potential for import substitution, although
Indonesia lacks the technology and a sufficient number of skilled people. Indonesia has a competitive
advantage in producing and exporting synthetic fiber but largely imports cotton, which is not feasible to
grow in the country either.
The 17 import-dependent halal product categories accounted for around $10.06 billion imports in 2020.
These cover 70% of imports of all halal products (food, fashion, pharmaceuticals, cosmetics). Through
decisive import substitution strategies, if Indonesia can reasonably substitute 10% of these imports with
domestic production, it will increase the GDP by almost $1 billion. Other scenarios include 5% and 15%
import substitution, which impact GDP by $0.5 billion and $1.5 billion, respectively.
TOTAL INDONESIA
5% Import 10% Import 15% Import
Prioritized Categories for Import Substitution IMPORTS, 2020
Substitution Substitution Substitution
US$ 000
Sectors HS Code Trade Category (Simplified Name) US$ Billions US$ Billions US$ Billions US$ Billions
$10.04 BLN
5% 10% 15%
$0.5 BLN $1 BLN $1.5 BLN
$1 BLN
IMPORT-SUBSTITUTION OPPORTUNITY IMPACT ON GDP
Source: ITC Trademap, DinarStandard synthesis and analysis
Globally, investments in the halal economy reached $11.8 billion in 2019/20,21 with Indonesia recording the
highest share of global investments at 43% ($5.01 billion). Of the 156 global investments, 38 were deals
from Indonesia in various halal products and lifestyle sectors, 24 belonging to Islamic finance and halal
food deals. These investments include the relevant mergers & acquisitions (M&A), private equity (PE), and
venture capital (VC) transactions in 2019/20.
No. of transactions
#14 #10 #4 #2 #6 #2
$3,000
$2,500
$2,000
$1,500
$1,000
$500
$0
Islamic Halal Travel & Halal Media Halal
Finance Food Tourism Cosmetics Pharma
Indonesia has become a lucrative economy for halal investments. With the 4th largest population in the
world and the largest Muslim population, estimated at 229.6 million Muslims in 2020, Indonesia also
represents the largest market for Muslim spend globally across the halal economy sectors, with a combined
$184 billion across halal products and lifestyle sectors.
Indonesia, with $199.5 billion in Islamic finance assets, is a global leader in Muslim financial inclusion.
In 2020, Indonesia was the largest issuer of sovereign sukuk in the international market, totaling $20.65
billion. The agriculture sector is also ripe for investments, as respondents of a business survey carried out
by Bank Indonesia showed that investment activity in agriculture increased during the first half of 2020, and
they are optimistic that investments will increase in the first quarter of 2021.119
With a positive outlook of investments in Indonesia and its large global share, this report assesses the
impact of increasing investments in halal products and lifestyle sectors on the economy. In an ideal
situation, if investments in each sector could increase by 10%, it could potentially impact the GDP by
$0.5 billion and raise Indonesia’s global share of investments to 45%. Other feasible scenarios are an
increase of 5% and 15%, increasing GDP by $0.25 billion and $0.75 billion, raising the global share to 43%
and 49%, respectively.22
TOTAL INVESTMENTS
$2.85 47%
ISLAMIC FINANCE
$1.74 35%
HALAL FOOD
10%
INCREASE IN
$0.28 82%
INVESTMENT
TRAVEL & TOURISM VALUES
$0.10 79%
HALAL COSMETICS
$0.03 23%
MEDIA
$0.02 14%
HALAL PHARMA
Investments in period Aug 2019 – Jul 2020, all values are in US$ billion
Modest fashion investments are insignificant and do not contribute majorly to the total investments, hence omitted.
This section introduces a comprehensive framework that identifies the essential building blocks for a
successful halal economy strategy and assesses Indonesia’s current performance against key criteria, with
benchmarking against leading countries in the halal economy.
The National Halal Economy framework by DinarStandard is a tool that links a nation’s halal economy to
economic growth, an important foundation for any successful macroeconomic halal economy strategy.
The framework looks at all applicable factors, spanning the size of addressable demand, domestic and
global competitiveness, and the current and potential capture of trade, to identify prioritized opportunities
to address in a comprehensive strategy.
Foreign investment
ENABLING PILLARS
1. Opportunity Scope and Realization: There is a sufficiently sizeable halal economy opportunity that is
being fully addressed by a country’s natural and productive resources.
Pillar 1: Globally Differentiated Proposition: Identifies the robust capture of substantial international
trade opportunities in the halal economy. Identifies global champions with a unique, differentiated
proposition.
Pillar 2: Domestic Proposition: Identifies opportunities from domestic demand for halal products,
domestic halal industry and ecosystem landscape and foreign investment.
2. Enabling Pillars: There exists a meaningful mix of enabling pillars in place to support the development
of multiple scaled, domestic and global champions addressing the global halal economy opportunity.
Pillar 3: Government Commitment: Identifies halal link to national economic agenda, regulatory support
to the halal economy, related support infrastructure.
Pillar 4: Production Capabilities: Identifies access to raw materials, halal suppliers, and R&D facilities to
support halal economy advancement.
Pillar 5: Operational Support Ecosystem: Identifies convergence with Islamic finance, dedicated
investment opportunities, and talent development for the halal economy.
Photo: Shutterstock.com
Against the above framework, Indonesia has achieved through 2020 a strong foundation for its halal economy
strategy and macro-economic impact with many areas of improvements needed as well. Collectively, the
required improvements would drive enabling and achieving the economic impact estimates.
Foreign investment
ENABLING PILLARS
As identified in the opportunity section, the potential incremental value of exports of $3.6 billion and FDI of
$0.5 billion can be achieved by addressing key internal and external challenges, with a focused effort on
prioritized growth opportunity sectors and markets by leveraging Indonesia’s core market competencies.
1. Largest halal consumer market in the world. Indonesia 1. Trade barriers hinder export. Even through free
represents the largest market for Muslim spend trade agreements (such as ASEAN), some countries
globally across the halal economy sectors, with a have special safeguard or nationalist protectionism
combined $184 billion across halal products and mechanisms. There is also tariff discrimination, for
lifestyle sectors (9.7% of global halal economy spend). instance, cocoa derivatives from Europe to Africa cost
0%, but for Indonesia, 6-9% tariffs are charged.
2. Indonesia is already the largest exporter among OIC.
With $8.6 billion exports of halal products, Indonesia 2. COVID-19 pressured existing logistics crises. Due to
is the 9th largest exporter globally and 2nd largest COVID-19, there was a worldwide container shortage
exporter among the OIC countries. which led to container tariffs increasing by 3-4 times in
Indonesia.
One of the major global destinations for Muslim-friendly
travel. The largest issuer of sovereign and green sukuk, 3. Limited expansion of local champions going global.
with tremendous momentum in Islamic fintech. Domestics champions global reach and exposure are
limited compared to other halal economy companies.
3. Domestic champions that are thriving, with the
potential to grow as global leaders.
1. Existing halal economy leaders as identified by the 1. Prioritized export categories (as discussed in the
Global Islamic Economy Indicator (GIEI) Ranking 2021. opportunity section). A large proportion of these is
processed food products. This indicates a significant
2. New energy and focus by various markets. These are opportunity for Indonesian food processors. Since
all not necessarily challenges but also opportunities for these processors already have to comply with
partnerships and joint collaborations. comprehensive halal certification rules, this would
position them well when entering the global market for
3. Quality or standard label requirements in the halal food.
destination country. Some countries require
personalized labeling, adding to cost. For instance,
starting January 2022, China will require F&B imported
product labels to be in Mandarin. Other countries have
high food safety standards which makes it difficult for
small companies exporting.
Highlighted analysis:
Prioritized export categories: The diagram below shows the top 10 export categories for Indonesia as
discussed in the opportunity section and the top consumer markets for these products.
1. Pakistan 1. India
Animal or vegetable fats
Food ’15 $0.31 2. Malaysia 2. Netherlands
and oils
4. Turkey 4. China
1. Germany
1. Saudi Arabia
2. France
Food ’04 Dairy products $0.31 2. United Arab Emirates
3. Netherlands
3. Turkey
Domestic champions that are thriving, with potential to grow as global leaders: The 2021 Forbes Global
2000 list of public companies listed just 6 Indonesian companies, almost all of which are banks. No halal
economy players were listed.
14
12
10
4
8
2 1
6 3 3
4
2
7
5 5
2 4
0
Saudi Arabia UAE Malaysia Indonesia
Photo: Shutterstock.com
As identified in the opportunity section, the domestic production opportunity, whereby select import
categories are substituted, can realistically boost Indonesia’s GDP by $1 billion a year. This can even lead
to increased exports and investments into Indonesia. Key internal and external challenges need to be
addressed, with a focused effort on Indonesia’s core competencies and growth opportunities.
1. Hosts the largest Muslim population. Indonesia has 1. Limited number of scaled participants.
the 4th largest population and the largest Muslim Pharmaceutical and modest fashion sectors are
population in the world, with 229.6 million Muslims key areas where further investment could help build
in 2020 (est.). scalable companies addressing a robust domestic
demand.
5. The largest halal consumer market in the world.
Indonesia represents the largest market for Muslim 2. Need for “Made in Indonesia” proposition. This could
spend globally across the halal economy sectors: give Indonesian companies a competitive edge to
largest for the food sector, 2nd largest for cosmetics promote domestically produced goods in the country
and media, and among the top 10 in pharmaceutical, and internationally.
travel and fashion sectors.
1. Higher food prices threaten import-dependent 1. Collaboration among industry players. Industry bodies
products. In August 2021, global food prices increased such as retail industry body APRINDO are actively
near the highest in a decade. World food prices have working to educate suppliers to the retail industry on
rallied about 33% in the past year, increasing inflation halal practices and halal law in general. This will go
risks and shipping costs. far in helping micro and small enterprises scale their
business.
2. Logistics is a key concern to foreign investors. They
are concerned that Indonesia cannot be integrated 2. FDI in the pharmaceutical sector. FDI investment is
into its supply chains without efficient logistics. The expected to enter the pharmaceutical sector, which is
33 provinces of Indonesia are geographically widely currently experiencing high growth, driven by the use
spread, which leads to expensive domestic transport of medical equipment, vaccines and medicines used
and logistics. This leads to decreased domestic during the pandemic.
and foreign investment in these regions. Most food
industries are based on Java island, but the raw 3. Special Economic Zones (SEZ) and halal parks
materials are from off the island, entailing a need for could spur investment growth. Indonesia has started
proper logistics infrastructure. investing in halal industrial parks with the added
benefits of SEZs to attract investments. It may also
3. Limited Special Economic Zones (SEZ) to attract spur on R&D in halal products and help Indonesia
foreign investments. Although the number of SEZs in become a key halal economy. The ‘Halal Modern
Indonesia has increased in recent years (15 SEZ), it is Valley’ in the Modern Cikande Industrial Estate is the
less in comparison to other halal economies. first industrial zone in Indonesia to receive the Halal
Industrial Zone certificate from the Ministry of Industry.
Highlighted analysis:
Domestic landscape and champions: Indonesia has a well-developed landscape of players, with room for
further consolidation and scaling.
Indonesia is an advancing producer of halal products – across food, pharmaceutical and cosmetics products,
with several scaled industry participants. However, there is plenty of room for further consolidation, as well
as to promote the growth of small enterprises.
Pharmaceuticals
Micro and Small Enterprises (MSE) dominate the business landscape of Indonesia. In the food and
beverage industry, micro and small enterprises employ 75.8% of all labor. However, in the pharmaceutical
industry, this is the opposite, with 79.1% of labor being employed in medium to large enterprises. There
is a limited number of scaled participants, in particular in pharmaceutical products and especially in
modest fashion, areas where further investment could help build scalable companies addressing a robust
domestic demand.
Industry bodies such as retail industry body APRINDO are actively working to educate suppliers to the retail
industry on halal practices and halal law in general. This will go far in helping micro and small enterprises
scale their business.
Government, as a key ecosystem player, can provide industry players with regulatory and infrastructure
support to enable companies to build on their core competencies and overcome internal and external
challenges. National economic agendas linked to the halal economy can provide the industry with a
direction for domestic and international growth.
1. Halal economy linked to national economic agendas. 1. Alignment of government policies. The policies of the
Bank Indonesia’s initiatives to integrate Shariah central and regional governments are still not aligned
economic and Shariah financial development have to meet halal industry-related regulations.
accelerated to the national level. The government has
also put in place the relevant regulation to expand the 2. Lack of cooperation between key stakeholders.
scope of KNEKS and establish the BPJPH. There is a Closer cooperation is needed between halal
clear synergy between the various ministerial bodies certification institutions, producers, scholars,
and other Shariah economy organizations. researchers, and the government to efficiently meet
consumer demands.
2. Reformed halal regulatory ecosystem. With the new
halal regulation reforms (namely GR 39/2021), three
bodies—BPJPH, MUI and LPH—work independently and
collaborate, removing any conflicts of interest.
1. Limited global recognition for halal products. 1. Well-defined halal certification process for
Indonesian halal product certification is still not widely importers. Foreign companies importing products
recognized in the global market. with an international halal certification require MOU
between BPJPH and the foreign halal certification body
2. Technical regulatory problems with the certification to use certification in Indonesia. This opens doors for
process hinder global reach. With the new halal collaboration with international halal agencies.
regulations, Indonesia may be able to advance its
regulatory system. 2. Partnering with international halal bodies. Indonesia
has become a member of SMIIC (as of Nov 2019).
3. Scope for improving ease of doing business. Indonesia also supported the establishment of the
Indonesia has been ranked 73rd overall in the 2020 International Halal Authority Board (IHAB), which
Doing Business rankings and is ranked 11th among consists of 84 members from 46 countries where
OIC countries. Indonesia acts as Deputy Chair.
Highlighted analysis:
Halal economy business incentivization: The government is providing financial incentives that can be
used to encourage investment and boost exports of halal products. The incentives have been delegated
to the Investment Coordinating Board (BKPM) so that it can directly grant them to increase investment in
priority areas.120 Apart from the aforementioned Omnibus Law being passed, Indonesia has also taken
other steps to improve the experience of doing business in the country, including introducing an online
platform for business licensing. An online tax filing and payment system for the major taxes was also
introduced. Trading across borders was also made easier by improving the online processing of export
customs declarations.121
While Indonesia has sought to incentivize investment, a greater focus is needed in particular on sectors
linked to the halal economy, notably food and beverage, pharmaceutical products and apparel. The US’s
R&D tax policy is a good example of a tax incentive that promotes R&D, specifically in the textile and
apparel industry.122
Photo: Shutterstock.com
Indonesia has a strong agricultural sector which contributes considerably to the GDP. However, production
in halal economy-related categories, like live animals, can be improved. Halal ingredients manufacturing
requires greater investment in R&D. Some multinational companies have a presence in the country, but the
demand is still exceeded by the supply.
1. Rich in natural resources such as palm oil. Indonesia 1. Lack of R&D and testing facilities for ingredients for
is the largest exporter of palm oil to the rest of the halal products – food, pharmaceuticals and cosmetics.
world, exporting 26 million tons valued at $17.4 billion
– 31% of the global exports in 2020.123 2. Lack of skilled workers & technology in producing
raw materials, leading to inefficiencies in production.
2. Competency in production and export of raw
materials such as synthetic fiber for fashion products 3. Lack of value-added commodities and
and ingredients for nutraceuticals. competitiveness in meeting export markets and
import substitution.
1. Other leading halal economy producers such as 1. Leading agriculture production. Indonesia generated
Malaysia, Thailand and Australia. the 3rd largest amount in primary value add across
agriculture, fishing and forestry at $145 billion in
2. Competitive pricing of halal products by non-OIC 2020. Indonesia is followed by Nigeria, Pakistan and
exporters. Indonesia may find it difficult to compete Turkey.124
with exporter’s prices.
2. There is plenty of room for Indonesia to further
reduce its reliance on imports, especially in
categories valued at $10 billion in 2020 (as discussed
in the opportunity section). These commodities include
sugar products, animal fodder (corn), meat and dairy
products.
Shariah economy education is one of the three major pillars of the Bank Indonesia Sharia Economic and
Financial Development Policy Blueprint. They have made significant strides in this area. Islamic finance
literacy and penetration is growing but at a slower pace than global halal economies, and it needs to
expedite. Halal industry training can be further propagated to improve the efficiency of the overall halal
certification process and also help grow the shariah economy as a whole.
1. In the last three years, there has been an increase 1. Low penetration of the Islamic banking sector. Public
in public financial understanding by 8.33%.125 awareness to use Islamic bank products is still low and
Islamic finance has also seen growth due to increasing needs to advance.
awareness among the younger population and a more
orchestrated approach to socialization programs by all 2. Gap in meeting the needs of the industry remains.
stakeholders. A gap between the needs of halal economy businesses
in the real sector and Islamic financing capacity
2. A leading Islamic fintech player. Indonesia placed available remains. Islamic financial institutions do not
fourth on the Global Islamic Fintech (GIFT) Index in have a specific financing target for the halal industry,
2020, totaling $2.9 billion fintech market size (based including halal tourism.
on transaction volume).126
3. Limited Islamic finance experts. There is also a gap
in Islamic finance experts in Indonesia.
1. Existing halal economy fintech leaders. Indonesia 1. Halal Industrial Estates/Parks, encouraged by the
has not been identified as the leading halal economy government, will enable the development of the halal
fintech leader in the Global Islamic Fintech (GIFT) industry in Indonesia, which is very large but has not
Index, 2020. been realized optimally.
OPPORTUNITY SCOPE
Pillar Sub-Pillar Assessment and Conclusions
Incremental and substantial $3.6 billion export opportunity: Indonesia exported $8.6
Trade
billion to the OIC markets across halal products in 2020 but lags behind the non-OIC leader
opportunity
China ($25.4 billion). Can increase halal products exports by prioritizing high-value and
capture
Globally proximate trade relationships supplying to the OIC and non-OIC markets.
Differentiated
Proposition Global Scope for leading Indonesian multinationals: Indonesian players in the food and beverage
champions and pharmaceutical sectors have the potential to expand globally.
Overall Limited: There’s substantial room to strengthen exports across the halal economy.
Large Muslim Very strong: Largest Muslim population in the world and largest Muslim consumer spend
population across halal economy sectors, totaling $184.04 billion.
Existence
Very strong: Robust Islamic values held by Indonesia’s Muslims.
of demand
Evolved domestic Sizeable $0.4 billion import substitution opportunity: Well-developed domestic companies
Domestic halal economy exist but could better meet domestic demand, replacing imports in prioritized sub-sectors in
Proposition landscape food, pharmaceuticals and cosmetics
Foreign Strong: The country has the potential to capture 50% of global investments into halal
investment economy sectors.
ENABLING PILLARS
Pillar Sub-Pillar Assessment and Conclusions
Halal link
Strong: BI’s Blueprint for the Islamic Economy and Finance and KNEKS’ Indonesia
to national
Islamic Economic Masterplan are well-linked to the overall economic strategy of the
economic
country and cover all sectors of the Islamic economy.
agenda
Strong and
Strong: Regulations that have been put in place have strengthened the halal economy
efficient
and provided for more certification processes. However, the influence on international
Government regulatory
halal regulation is still limited.
Commitment support
Adequate
Limited: Lack of targeted sector incentives and limited involvement of government
support
funds in halal.
infrastructure
Strong: A comprehensive strategy has been designed, and good regulations have been
Overall put in place. Incentive schemes should be designed to promote investment in the halal
economy.
Raw material Improving: Largest agriculture sector in the OIC but with
access substantial room for development, particularly in livestock farming.
Convergence Strong: Growing sector with good growth prospects. More conventional banks have
with Islamic also started offering Shariah-compliant products with the increase in awareness
finance among the population.
Dedicated,
Moderate: Domestic investment in halal economy segments is limited. There are not
Operational supportive
many incubator programs available for the halal economy sectors.
support investments
ecosystem Strong: BI has supported many educational initiatives, particularly in the Islamic
Talent
finance sector and collaborations with universities. More training can be conducted for
development
those involved in the halal certification process.
Strong: Education on Islamic finance is widely available and of a high standard. Further
Overall
work can be done on creating awareness around other halal economy sectors.
With the identified halal economy goals, the following section presents key strategic objectives per pillar and
related seventeen strategic priorities for stakeholders to ensure that Indonesia’s halal economy opportunity
can be fully realized.
Indonesia’s halal economy can be an engine of economic growth and give the country substantial
influence across the Muslim world.
Indonesia’s halal economy strategy needs to be comprehensive with a clearer focus on boosting GDP and
creating a world-leading infrastructure that goes beyond the accomplishments of halal economy leaders.
While each country will have its own variant of a halal economy strategy, Indonesia is in a unique and
differentiated position compared to its peers – it has the largest Muslim population in the world and the
largest agriculture sector in the OIC, with several scaled consumer goods companies already addressing
robust domestic demand. To realize its full potential and underpinning Indonesia’s halal strategy are
two clear objectives and five supporting pillars, which correspond closely to the national halal economy
framework introduced in the previous section.
Goal 1: Boost GDP by $5.1 billion through incremental exports, FDI and import substitution.
Pillar 1: Globally Differentiated Proposition: Indonesia is poised to capture a larger share of halal
economy trade through a strategic targeting of top importers and with a focus on product categories
that align closely with the halal economy.
Pillar 2: Domestic Proposition: Indonesia has the strength to collaborate with key local stakeholders—
government, industry and investors—to promote halal trade and build on market intelligence.
Goal 2: Develop enabling pillars that will help the full economic potential of the halal economy materialize.
Pillar 3: Government Commitment: Indonesia has the opportunity to leverage special economic zones
and halal industrial hubs to attract foreign investment. Ease of regulations, trade agreements, and the
dedicated halal fund can support the export opportunity proposition.
Pillar 4: Production Capabilities: Support the development of various intermediate suppliers and
processes to enhance the efficient operation of domestic halal economy propositions.
Pillar 5: Operational Support Ecosystem: Create the necessary supporting ecosystem for domestic
companies to thrive and become global success stories, with the development of clear investment
propositions, supported by a clear commitment towards creating world-class education programs.
GOAL 1:
BOOST GDP BY $5.1 BILLION THROUGH INCREMENTAL EXPORTS, FDI AND IMPORT SUBSTITUTION
STAKEHOLDERS STAKEHOLDERS
Government; Government;
Large & Medium Corporates; Industry Associations;
Industry Associations Large & Medium Corporates;
Investors
GOAL 2:
DEVELOP ENABLING PILLARS THAT WILL HELP THE FULL ECONOMIC POTENTIAL OF THE HALAL ECONOMY MATERIALIZE
Key stakeholders and strategic priorities for the globally differentiated proposition
1. Companies scale up export-driven marketing that will allow Indonesia to become a top halal economy
exporter.
Domestic companies (led by large corporates) should leverage the target market priorities identified in this
report and chart international paths that span high-value OIC and non-OIC countries with large Muslim
populations.
There are several steps to further activate and grow export propositions – the most important of which
would be expanded international marketing budgets and strategies. Attending regular global trade events
focused on the halal economy or related sector events in target markets (e.g., the GulfFood annual event
or others in target markets), along with on-the-ground marketing presence and awareness building, will be
crucial to securing a global footprint and building essential relationships.
To achieve the $3.6 billion incremental export opportunity, select target markets to export prioritized halal
categories (food, pharma, fashion, cosmetics) include:
• OIC markets: Pakistan, Malaysia, Turkey, UAE, Saudi Arabia and Egypt.
• Non-OIC markets: India, Netherlands, China, Germany, France, United States, Singapore and Hong
Kong.
Existing domestic leaders across food, fashion, pharmaceutical and cosmetics halal products are well-
positioned to evolve their product offerings to address high-value categories, as highlighted in the previous
section.
Top export potential categories under each halal product sector include:
Indonesian companies should also assess the global players in the halal economy to leverage their own
competitive advantages for international reach.
Some global halal economy players to assess include (detailed benchmark players and profiles discussed
in earlier sections):
• Danone, France (Dairy)
• BASF, Germany (Ingredients)
• Modanisa, Turkey (Fashion)
• Noor Vitamins, United States (Nutraceuticals)
3. Government to closely work with the industry to network with international partners.
Indonesia’s halal economy companies require the express support of the government’s export division,
supported by Indonesia’s embassies around the world, helping companies establish important meetings
with distributors in high-priority countries, and educating the world about Indonesia’s production capabilities.
This has been practiced by Indonesia but needs to be done more aggressively. Indonesian representatives/
embassies need to collaborate to provide companies with better networking options. It is costly for
companies to look for buyers abroad and so they need the government’s support. The government’s close
collaboration with the industry is key to finding international partners and expanding global reach.
4. Industry Associations driving ‘halal lifestyle’ as a key differentiator for the ‘Proudly Made in Indonesia’
initiative.
An industry association-led platform to engage large Indonesian brands to galvanize the ‘Made in Indonesia’
brand, especially with ‘halal lifestyle’ as a key differentiator, further across OIC and Non-OIC halal markets.
This could also be supported or led by a government agency(s).
Photo: Shutterstock.com
DOMESTIC PROPOSITION
1. Government and/or industry associations expand trade promotion for local industry activation.
Local companies need trade promotion to connect with local players and better understand the market.
Apart from networking locally, connecting with international players is also crucial for companies to
expand their global reach. The government must work with credible partners, such as the IHLC, to convene
important B2B and B2C events supported by dedicated media. An example of such media is the creation of
the Salaam Gateway, a platform co-owned by DinarStandard, which has played an important role in raising
awareness of the halal economy.
Such logistics issues within the country not only lead to unfulfillment of demand but cause a barrier to
foreign investment. Most food industries are on Java island, but raw materials are available off the island,
requiring robust infrastructure for timely delivery and production. The government must help resolve
logistics issues with the country by investing in better infrastructure and road construction.
3. Government and/or industry associations to expand actionable market intelligence for local industry
players.
There is a need for market intelligence that the Indonesian Trade Promotion Centre (ITPC) or the Ministry of
Trade is able to provide the local companies with. Such market intelligence includes the study of consumers’
demands. An independent study is needed to survey Muslim consumers in Indonesia and in target trade
markets across the OIC and non-OIC to determine the gaps in their needs. Providing access to data is a
critical step in raising awareness of the opportunity.
4. Government and local companies to expose the halal market opportunity to international investors.
Given Indonesia’s growing prominence for international investors, its domestic halal market opportunity, as
well as regional reach, should be promoted to international investors. Indonesia’s recent Sovereign Wealth
Fund, active private equity, and venture capital space should all be exposed to the halal market opportunity.
Success cases, such as GoTo and their likes, would help build confidence among investors.
GOVERNMENT COMMITMENT
STRATEGIC
PRIORITIES Ease regulations Trade agreements Dedicated halal fund Halal industrial hubs
COVID-19 resulted in a decrease in sales due to PSBB policy (Large-Scale Social Restriction). International
sales only came from loyal international customers. It also caused delays in receiving raw materials from
China and India. The government needs to rethink its strategy for export and import control that will have a
direct impact on the halal economy as well.
2. Governments to increase trade agreements to remove trade barriers and ease exports.
Trade agreements with export markets can help reduce tax. Recently, agreements that benefited the
industry include the Indonesia-Australia IA-CEPA agreement, and similar arrangements are in talks with the
UAE. Governments need to increase negotiation with target export markets for tariff relaxation or free trade
agreements (FTA) to facilitate exports.
3. Government to establish or support dedicated halal economy fund(s) to attract foreign investment.
The government must provide direct financial support to the industry and determine how best this can be
done through Indonesia’s new sovereign wealth fund (PIP) that can play a transformational role in hastening
the development of the halal economy. One of the ways is through establishing a dedicated halal fund to
direct foreign investments into halal economy companies, as well as providing capital to private equity
managers with a clear mandate.
Indonesia has 15 special economic zones (SEZ) and 3 halal industrial parks still in the development phase.
These industrial hubs bring great opportunities for foreign investment, and the government should help
expedite their production and promotion. Building halal industrial areas and halal hubs in various regions
in accordance with the comparative advantages of each superior region can prove to be a useful strategy.
PRODUCTION CAPABILITIES
Indonesia needs to increase production competitiveness through adopting high-tech for production and
sourcing cheaper raw materials of high quality. This can be efficiently achieved through collaboration with
countries with advanced technology and encouraging investments in upstream (salt, sugar, starch/corn)
and downstream industries as well. Key global partners must be encouraged and facilitated to explore
Indonesia’s vast natural resources.
The BPJPH regulation coming to full enforcement will broaden the valuable halal supplier base.
Government agencies should support their preparedness for domestic and international competitiveness
and investments. Currently, BPJPH, along with other ministries, is supporting SMEs with trade development
and awareness programs, part of which also helps connect with suppliers domestically and internationally.
These programs need to extend to large companies as well to support their trade and investment
propositions.
Photo: Shutterstock.com
STRATEGIC Streamline Islamic Fintech for individual’s Triple-helix model for Streamline Islamic
PRIORITIES finance rules investment talent pool finance rules
STAKEHOLDERS Government; Industry Associations; Large & Medium Corporates; Investors
1. Government and industry to further streamline Islamic finance regulations to enable effective
convergence with halal economy development.
It is imperative for the Islamic finance industry to respond to the diverse needs of the halal economy
companies. The Islamic finance ecosystem needs to be strengthened as the fundamental part of the
halal value chain. Several legal and regulatory issues need to be addressed in order to accelerate Islamic
finance development in Indonesia. Among the issues are regulation disharmony, overlapping in the rules
and authorities, and legal gaps. Several legal gaps, namely the guaranteed act for Shariah contracts, the
bankruptcy act, could be addressed respectively. Currently, the respective law has been proposed by the
House of Representatives and listed at the National Legislation Program.
2. Industry to utilize benefits of fintech platforms that connect with potential individuals willing to invest.
The emergence of fintech platforms such as Ethis Ventures and Launchgood enable consumers as
individuals to invest directly in halal economy propositions – an important node of development for
Indonesia is supporting crowdfunding efforts as a way to generate wealth for households. ALAMI is one
of the leading fintech case studies in Indonesia, and several other fintech platforms should be supported.
3. Government, industry and academia (triple-helix model) to work together to fill the gaps in halal
economy and finance experts.
There is a mismatch between industrial needs (demand) and the availability of human resources (supply)
produced by universities in Indonesia. The government needs to initiate a roadmap of the human resources
(HR) development in the halal economy and finance sector and set that roadmap as a national priority
program. Government, industry and academia can work together to match human resource development
and talent management through formal and non-formal education, whether organized by educational
institutions, training institutions or institutions providing certification.
Sapta Nirwandar
Senior Advisor, IHLC
M. Anwar Bashori
BANK INDONESIA is the central bank of Indonesia. The
Senior Advisor, Bank Indonesia
development of sharia economy and finance is part of
Indonesia’s economic transformation in achieving high, inclusive
Dr. Jardine A. Husman
and sustainable economic growth. To that end, the policy
Lead Economist, Bank Indonesia
of developing Islamic economics and finance is one of the
supporting policies in Bank Indonesia’s policy mix in achieving
Rafi-uddin Shikoh
its goal of achieving and maintaining the stability of the rupiah
Lead Strategy Consultant,
value. Bank Indonesia together with relevant stakeholders and DinarStandard
other authorities in synergizing national policies in the KNEKS
platform, encouraging the development of the Indonesian Islamic Iman Ali Liaqat
economy and finance as a new source of growth. Lead Author, DinarStandard
Aaliya Mia
Senior Analyst, DinarStandard
Produced by:
Jetti R. Hadi
Advisory Team, IHLC
DINARSTANDARD™ is a growth strategy and execution
management firm, empowering organizations for profitable and
Fahamah Syarifa
Report Coordinator, IHLC
responsible global impact. DinarStandard specializes in the global
halal/ethical economy, government innovation, and social impact
Mirza Zuhaib Baig
space. Led by its original research and foresight since 2008,
Project Coordinator,
DinarStandard has supported halal markets’ growth strategies for
DinarStandard
over 30 government entities, investment institutions, businesses,
and multi-laterals from over 12 countries worldwide. It is also
Bobby Naedi Sopyan
the author of the annual global halal markets reference report, Project Coordinator, IHLC
the State of the Global Islamic Economy (SGIE) Report, being
published annually since 2013. Its unique value-proposition is Astrid Tambunan
rooted in delivering original facts and foresight-driven client Project Coordinator, IHLC
impact, grounded in excellence and ethics.
CONTEXT
The halal economy has emerged as a promising driver of growth, at a microeconomic level, for leading
multinationals, entrepreneurs and investors around the world that have sought to strategically differentiate
themselves and address the unique, faith-based needs of the world’s 1.9 billion Muslim consumers. The
halal economy opportunity is also of macroeconomic importance for Muslim and non-Muslim countries
alike, with a clear link to GDP growth.
Indonesia is the 4th largest country by population and hosts the largest Muslim population worldwide. With
a rising Muslim population, Indonesia is also seeing a burgeoning demand for halal products (food, fashion,
pharmaceuticals, cosmetics) and halal services (finance, media, travel).
Indonesia has substantial potential but is yet to address a clear halal economy proposition. Now is the time
for Indonesia to address the multi-billion-dollar halal economy opportunity and take its leadership position
in a fast-growing, under-addressed global business proposition that can drive substantial GDP growth.
PURPOSE
The purpose of this report is to provide information and promote trade and investment opportunities for
national and global halal industry players, as well as a reference in formulating development strategies.
• Determine the scale and growth drivers of consumer demand for halal products and services globally
and in Indonesia
• Benchmark Indonesia’s current halal market business landscape with global players
• Ascertain the halal economy export, import substitution and investment opportunity that is addressable
by Indonesia
• Prioritize and quantify clear halal market opportunity areas per sector
• Present strategy recommendations to realize promotion for Indonesia’s trade and investment
opportunities
M. Anwar Bashori, Executive Director/Head of Sharia Economic and Finance Department, Bank Indonesia
(DEKS-BI)
Putu Rahwidhiyasa, Director of Sharia Business and Entrepreneurship, National Committee of Sharia
Economy and Finance, KNEKS
Adiwarman Karim, Head of Commission and National Syaria Board member, Bank Syariah Indonesia
Service Wahyu Hidayatullah, Sales and Marketing Manager, Modern Halal Valley
Enablers Dima Djani, CEO, ALAMI
Radhiyaksa Daulay, CEO, Rhadana Hotel
Secondary resources:
The following secondary sources were used to support the preparation of this report, including but not
limited to:
Muslim consumer spend estimates and analysis, carried out by DinarStandard, leveraged the World Bank’s
ICP 2017 consumer data as a baseline reference. Projections were baselined using the IMF Outlook from
April 2020. For detailed methodology on market sizing, please refer to the State of the Global Islamic
Economy Report 2020/21 on SalaamGateway.com.
All trade data has been sourced from ITC Trademap, and using DinarStandard’s synthesis and analysis.
Prioritized categories for export: 33 categories from food, fashion, pharmaceuticals and cosmetics were
ranked based on 5 weighted metrics. Any categories identified as haram, or not requiring any level of halal
certification have been excluded. Metrics for ranking include: (1) Indonesia Intersection score [30%], (2) OIC
+ 10 Non-OIC Imports Growth Rank Score [17.5%], (3) OIC + 10 Non-OIC Import Value Rank Score [17.5%],
(4) Indonesia Export Value Rank Score [17.5%], (5) Halal Compliance Score [17.5%].
Imports of 10 Non-OIC countries that have the highest Muslim spend were added. These make-up 80%
of the total Muslim consumption of halal products by non-OIC countries (food, fashion, pharmaceutical
and cosmetics). Countries include India, Russia, United States, China, France, Germany, United Kingdom,
Italy, Ethiopia, Israel. Their halal economy imports were calculated by multiplying the imports with Muslim
multiplier (this multiplier accounts for the Muslim population in a country and their economic wellbeing,
source: DinarStandard proprietary)
Indonesia Intersection score: Geographic intersection of halal trade flow with Indonesia. The closer
Indonesia lies geographically to the trade flow, the stronger the opportunity to capture higher exports. The
scores are 1 (strong opportunity), 0.5 (moderate opportunity), 0 (weak opportunity).
Impact assessment: OIC export opportunity: There is a significant amount of halal economy trade that is
flowing over or in proximity to Indonesia that is not being captured by Indonesia yet. For example, Indonesia
geographically intersects China’s export of coffee, tea, mate & spices to Pakistan, and can potentially gain
some benefit from the trade. Such area of trade opportunity is the OIC intersection trade opportunity for
Indonesia. More than 800 key trade relationships have been examined across 33 halal product categories,
to estimate the OIC incremental trade opportunity (see methodology section for details).
Three scenarios have been calculated (5%, 10% and 15%) to ascertain the incremental trade opportunity for
Indonesia, with 10% being a reasonable market capture.
Impact assessment: Non-OIC export opportunity: Gathered top 5 non-OIC importers across each of the 22
final consumer product categories and calculated their halal economy imports. Deducted Indonesia’s halal
economy exports to these countries to calculate untapped export opportunity.
Three scenarios have been calculated (5%, 10% and 15%) to ascertain the incremental trade opportunity for
Indonesia, with 10% being a reasonable market capture.
Impact assessment: import substitution opportunity: Net importing categories in Indonesia’s halal economy
sectors. Validated from expert insights. Three scenarios have been calculated (5%, 10% and 15%) to
ascertain import substitution of these categories on the GDP, with 10% being a reasonable market capture.
Three scenarios have been calculated (5%, 10% and 15%) to ascertain the incremental investment
opportunity for Indonesia, with 10% being a reasonable market capture.
OIC + 10
OIC + 10 Indonesia
Indonesia Indonesia Non-OIC Halal
Trade Non-OIC Export
Rank Sector Simplified Name prioritized Intersection Imports Compliance
Code Import Value Value Rank
final score score Growth Rank Score
Rank Score Score
Score
1 Food '15 Animal or vegetable fats and oils 0.74 0.67 0.49 0.59 1.00 1.00
2 Pharma '3004 Medicaments (for retail sale) 0.55 0.33 0.59 1.00 0.01 1.00
4 Food '09 Coffee, tea, maté and spices 0.55 0.71 0.62 0.26 0.05 1.00
5 Food '17 Sugars and sugar confectionery 0.54 0.63 0.60 0.39 0.01 1.00
6 Food '04 Dairy products 0.53 0.67 0.45 0.45 0.00 1.00
7 Fashion 62 Apparel (not knitted/crocheted) 0.51 1.00 0.30 0.39 0.03 0.50
8 Food '19 Cereal, pasta & bakery products 0.51 0.50 0.66 0.34 0.04 1.00
9 Food '02 Meat and edible meat offal 0.50 0.67 0.38 0.35 0.00 1.00
10 Cosmetics '3306 Oral care 0.49 0.75 0.51 0.02 0.00 1.00
11 Pharma '3005 Adhesive dressings 0.49 0.67 0.62 0.01 0.00 1.00
14 Cosmetics '3301 Essential oils 0.48 0.67 0.57 0.01 0.00 1.00
15 Food '23 Animal fodder 0.47 0.50 0.46 0.34 0.01 1.00
16 Food '20 Preparations of vegetables, fruit, nuts 0.46 0.58 0.44 0.17 0.00 1.00
18 Food '18 Cocoa and cocoa preparations 0.44 0.46 0.54 0.17 0.04 1.00
19 Food '21 Soups, sauces & other processed foods 0.44 0.33 0.57 0.31 0.05 1.00
20 Pharma '3001 Dried glands and other organs 0.42 0.25 1.00 0.00 0.00 1.00
21 Food '13 Vegetable saps and extracts 0.40 0.67 0.64 0.01 0.00 0.50
22 Cosmetics '3304 Makeup & skincare 0.40 0.42 0.47 0.11 0.00 1.00
23 Cosmetics '3307 Personal care 0.40 0.50 0.37 0.03 0.00 1.00
24 Food '03 Fish and other aquatic invertebrates 0.37 0.50 0.51 0.22 0.03 0.50
26 Food '11 Products of the milling industry 0.35 0.50 0.50 0.12 0.00 0.50
27 Cosmetics '3302 Odoriferous substances 0.33 0.00 0.73 0.12 0.01 1.00
28 Pharma '3006 Pharmaceutical preparations 0.31 0.17 0.47 0.02 0.00 1.00
29 Food '22 Beverages and vinegar 0.30 0.08 0.46 0.09 0.00 1.00
30 Food '05 Other products of animal origin 0.28 0.33 0.54 0.00 0.00 0.50
31 Pharma '3003 Medicaments (not for retail sale) 0.28 0.33 0.00 0.03 0.00 1.00
Global Indonesia
investments investments Global % 5% Global % 10% Global % 15% Global %
US$ bil US$ bil
Islamic Finance $6.11 $2.85 47% $2.99 49% $3.13 51% $3.27 54%
Halal Food $4.93 $1.74 35% $1.83 37% $1.91 39% $2.00 41%
Travel & Tourism $0.34 $0.28 82% $0.29 86% $0.31 90% $0.32 95%
Halal Cosmetics $0.12 $0.10 79% $0.10 83% $0.11 86% $0.11 90%
Media $0.12 $0.03 23% $0.03 24% $0.03 25% $0.03 26%
Halal Pharma $0.16 $0.02 14% $0.02 14% $0.02 15% $0.02 16%
Increase in
GDP US$ $0.25 $0.50 $0.75
billion
*Global modest fashion investments are insignificant and do not contribute majorly to the total investments. Value of Indonesia’s investments in
modest fashion sector are not disclosed.
Photo: Shutterstock.com
1. Springer C. (2018). The Age Gap in Religion Around the World. Retrieved from Pew Research Center:
https://www.pewforum.org/2018/06/13/the-age-gap-in-religion-around-the-world/
2. Winosa Y. (2021). Indonesia Islamic banks outgrew conventional peers in 2020. Retrieved from Salaam Gateway:
https://www.salaamgateway.com/story/indonesia-islamic-banks-outgrew-conventional-peers-in-2020
3 (2019) Food and Beverages Sector in Indonesia Published by Cekindo:
https://www.cekindo.com/sectors/food-beverages
4 Muslim consumer spend estimates & analysis by DinarStandard leveraging World Bank’s ICP 2017 consumer data as
baseline reference. Projections baselined using IMF Outlook from April 2020. Analysis is referenced in the State of the
Global Islamic Economy Report 2020/21, produced by DinarStandard
5 (2019) Indonesia - Contribution of travel and tourism to GDP as a share of GDP Retrieved from Knoema:
https://knoema.com/atlas/Indonesia/topics/Tourism/Travel-and-Tourism-Total-Contribution-to-GDP/Contribution-of-
travel-and-tourism-to-GDP-percent-of-GDP
6 Winsoa Y. (2021). Indonesia Islamic banks outgrew conventional peers in 2020.Retrived from Salaam Gateway:
https://www.salaamgateway.com/story/indonesia-islamic-banks-outgrew-conventional-peers-in-2020
7 (2021) Global Islamic Fintech Report 2021. Published by Salaam Gateway: Global Islamic Fintech Report 2021,
DinarStandard, Elipses
8 (2020) Forecasted share of the Muslim population in Southeast Asia in 2020, by country. Published by Statista:
https://www.statista.com/statistics/1113906/southeast-asia-muslim-population-forecasted-share-by-country/
9 DinarStandard, Dubai Islamic Economy Development Centre, Salaam Gateway, State of the Global Islamic Economy
Report 2020/21.
10 (2011). The Future of the global Muslim Population. Published by Pew Research Center:
https://www.pewforum.org/2011/01/27/the-future-of-the-global-muslim-population/
11 Poushter J. & Fetterolf J. (2019). How people around the world view religion’s role in their countries. Retrieved from Pew
Research Center:
https://www.pewresearch.org/global/2019/04/22/how-people-around-the-world-view-religions-role-in-their-countries/
12 The Global State of Digital 2021. Hootsuite. 2021
13 Winter P., Kobayashi N. & Byeon J. (2021). How Asia-Pacific must respond to the new, post-COVID-19 consumer.
Retrieved by EY:
https://www.ey.com/en_gl/consumer-products-retail/how-asia-pacific-must-respond-to-the-new-post-covid-19-consumer
14 (2021) How COVID-19 is changing the world: a statistical perspective Volume III Published by CCSA:
https://www.wto.org/english/tratop_e/covid19_e/ccsa_publication_vol3_e.pdf
15 (2017) Quarterly Report on Manufacturing Retrieved from United Nations Industrial Development Organization:
https://www.unido.org/resources-statistics/quarterly-report-manufacturing
16 (2020) Impact of the Pandemic on Trade and Development - TRANSITIONING TO A NEW NORMAL Retrieved from United
Nations Conference on Trade & Development: https://unctad.org/system/files/official-document/osg2020d1_en.pdf
17 (2021) World trade primed for strong but uneven recovery after COVID-19 pandemic shock Published by World Trade
Organization: https://www.wto.org/english/news_e/pres21_e/pr876_e.htm
18 (2020) Review of Maritime Transport 2020 Retrieved from UNCTAD:
https://unctad.org/webflyer/review-maritime-transport-2020
19 (2020) Impact of the Pandemic on Trade and Development - TRANSITIONING TO A NEW NORMAL Retrieved from United
Nations Conference on Trade & Development: https://unctad.org/system/files/official-document/osg2020d1_en.pdf
20 (2021). International Trade: Year in Review 2020. Published by Oxford Business Group: https://oxfordbusinessgroup.com/
news/international-trade-year-review-2020
21 (2021). World trade primed for strong but uneven recovery after COVID-19 pandemic shock. Retrieved from World Trade
Organization: https://www.wto.org/english/news_e/pres21_e/pr876_e.htm
22 (2021) Global economy could lose over $4 trillion due to COVID-19 impact on tourism. Published by UNCTAD:
https://unctad.org/news/global-economy-could-lose-over-4-trillion-due-covid-19-impact-tourism
23 (2020) SHARIA ECONOMY AND FINANCE REPORT 2020. Published by Bank Indonesia:
https://www.bi.go.id/en/publikasi/laporan/Pages/Laporan-Ekonomi-dan-Keuangan-Syariah-2020.aspx
24 (2019) Food and Beverages Sector in Indonesia Published by Cekindo:
https://www.cekindo.com/sectors/food-beverages
25 (2019) Food and Beverages Sector in Indonesia Published by Cekindo:
https://www.cekindo.com/sectors/food-beverages
26 (2019) Food and Beverages Sector in Indonesia Published by Cekindo:
https://www.cekindo.com/sectors/food-beverages
27 (2021).Mayora Indah recorded a steady IDR 2.09 trillion profit. Retrieved from IDN Financials:
https://www.idnfinancials.com/news/38646/mayora-indah-recorded-steady-idr-profit
58 Singh M. (2021). Gojek and Tokopedia merge to form GoToGroup. Retrieved from Join TechChrunch+:
https://techcrunch.com/2021/05/16/gojek-and-tokopedia-merge-to-form-goto-group/
59 Singh M. (2021). Gojek and Tokopedia merge to form GoToGroup. Retrieved from Join TechChrunch+:
https://techcrunch.com/2021/05/16/gojek-and-tokopedia-merge-to-form-goto-group/
60 (2011) HIJUP- About Us. Retrieved from HIJUP: https://www.hijup.com/en/pages/about
61 (2021) HIJUP overview, Competitors, Revenue, News & Insights. Retrieved from Owler:
https://www.owler.com/company/hijup
62 (2021) HIJUP overview, Competitors, Revenue, News & Insights. Retrieved from Owler:
https://www.owler.com/company/hijup
63 (2021) HappyFresh Profile. Retrieved from Crunchbase : https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/happyfresh
64 Niessner J. (2021) . Indonesia grocery platform HappyFresh closes $65m Series D. Published by AVCJ:
https://www.avcj.com/avcj/news/3024613/indonesia-grocery-platform-happyfresh-closes-usd65m-series-d
65 (2021) HappyFresh Profile- Overview. Retrieved from Owler: https://www.owler.com/company/happyfresh
66 (2021) HappyFresh Profile- Overview. Retrieved from Owler: https://www.owler.com/company/happyfresh
67 Scott M. (2016) In Shadow of Amazon, European Challenger Looks to China for Inspiration. Published by The NewYork
Times: https://www.nytimes.com/2016/12/16/technology/amazon-zalando-eu-online-shopping.html
68 (2021). Online fashion retailer Zalando launches platforms in Slovenia, Slovakia and Lithuania. Published by bne
IntelliNews:
https://www.intellinews.com/online-fashion-retailer-zalando-launches-platforms-in-slovenia-slovakia-and-lithuania-212178/
69 (2021) ANATWINE & TRADEBYTE ARE JOINING FORCES. Published by Tradebyte:
https://www.tradebyte.com/en/anatwine-becomes-tradebyte-uk/
70 Mguire J.(2021). Top Performing Artificial Intelligence Companies of 2021. Retrieved from Datamation:
https://www.datamation.com/artificial-intelligence/ai-companies/
71 McLaughlin B. (2018) This Week In China Tech: Alibaba Invests 1 Trillion Yuan And China Battles Against Google’s
AlphaGo. Published by Forbes: https://www.forbes.com/sites/baymclaughlin/2018/05/09/this-week-in-china-tech-
alibaba-invests-1-trillion-yuan-and-china-battles-against-googles-alphago/?sh=69c471966978
72 (2020) Gordon Food Service. Retrieved from Forbes:
https://www.forbes.com/companies/gordon-food-service/?sh=7245f45f6011
73 (2020)Gordon Food Service. Retrieved from Forbes:
https://www.forbes.com/companies/gordon-food-service/?sh=7245f45f6011
74 Winosa Y. (2021) indonesia Islamic banks outgrew conventional peers in 2020. Published by Salaam Gateway:
https://www.salaamgateway.com/story/indonesia-islamic-banks-outgrew-conventional-peers-in-2020
75 Winosa Y. (2021) Indonesia eyes bigger Islamic finance market share after launch of social security agency’s Shariah
service. Published by
Salaam Gateway: https://www.salaamgateway.com/story/indonesia-eyes-bigger-islamic-finance-market-share-after-
launch-of-social-security-agencys-shariah-s
76 https://www.aa.com.tr/en/asia-pacific/indonesia-begins-merger-of-3-state-owned-islamic-banks/2079910
77 Ibid.
78 (2021) The Strength Of Bank Syariah Indonesia Before Launching February 1: Have 14.9 Million Customers And 20
Thousand Employees. Retrieved from VOI:
https://voi.id/en/berita/27629/mengintip-kekuatan-bank-syariah-indonesia-sebelum-launching-1-februari-mendatang
79 (2021) The Strength Of Bank Syariah Indonesia Before Launching February 1: Have 14.9 Million Customers And 20
Thousand Employees. Retrieved from VOI:
https://voi.id/en/berita/27629/mengintip-kekuatan-bank-syariah-indonesia-sebelum-launching-1-februari-mendatang
80 Kastrenakes J,(2021).Netflix subscriber growth is stalling as it runs low on hits. Published by THE VERGE.:
https://www.theverge.com/2021/4/20/22394425/netflix-subscriber-growth-stalls-2021
81 (2021) JNE EXPRESS’S Homepage- Overview. Retrieved from Owler: https://www.owler.com/company/jne1
82 (2021) JNE EXPRESS’S Homepage- Overview. Retrieved from Owler: https://www.owler.com/company/jne1
83 (2019) Empat Tahun Berkiprah, J&T Express Torehkan Segudang Prestasi. Published by KOMPAS:
https://biz.kompas.com/read/2019/12/31/123111528/empat-tahun-berkiprah-jt-express-torehkan-segudang-prestasi
84 IrmaJunida A & Cindyara A. (2020) Delivery company records 3 mln shipments during Ramadan. Published by Antara
news ws: https://en.antaranews.com/news/149784/delivery-company-records-3-mln-shipments-during-ramadhan
85 (2021) J&T Express Homepage. Retrieved from Owler : https://www.owler.com/company/j-t-express
86 Harry R (2021) DHL achieves record earnings for full-year 2020. Published by Aircargo News:
https://www.aircargonews.net/business/dhl-achieves-record-earnings-for-full-year-2020/
112 Rohmi M, Jaya T & Syamsiah N (2021) The Effects Pandemic Covid-19 on Indonesia Foreign Trade .Published by UNTAR:
https://ecojoin.org/index.php/EJE/article/view/750/730
113 (2020) Indonesia Total Exports Retrieved from CEIC: https://www.ceicdata.com/en/indicator/indonesia/total-exports
114 Rohmi M, Jaya T & Syamsiah N (2021) The Effects Pandemic Covid-19 on Indonesia Foreign Trade. Published by UNTAR:
https://ecojoin.org/index.php/EJE/article/view/750/730
115 (2020) SHARIA ECONOMY AND FINANCE REPORT 2020. Published by Bank Indonesia:
https://www.bi.go.id/en/publikasi/laporan/Pages/Laporan-Ekonomi-dan-Keuangan-Syariah-2020.aspx
116 (2021) World trade primed for strong but uneven recovery after COVID-19 pandemic shock Retrieved from World Trade
Organization: https://www.wto.org/english/news_e/pres21_e/pr876_e.htm
117 Agarwal R, Santoso A, Tan K & Wilbow P (2021) Ten ideas to unlock Indonesia’s growth after COVID-19 Published by
McKinsey & Company:
https://www.mckinsey.com/featured-insights/asia-pacific/ten-ideas-to-unlock-indonesias-growth-after-covid-19
118 (2021) Indonesia- The latest Coronavirus count Retrieved from Reuters:
https://graphics.reuters.com/world-coronavirus-tracker-and-maps/countries-and-territories/indonesia/
119 (2021) SHARIA ECONOMY AND FINANCE REPORT 2020. Published by Bank Indonesia:
https://www.bi.go.id/en/publikasi/laporan/Pages/Laporan-Ekonomi-dan-Keuangan-Syariah-2020.aspx
120 Sumbar A (2020). Indonesia aims to turn into global halal hub by 2024. Retrieved from Antara News:
https://en.antaranews.com/news/162028/indonesia-aims-to-turn-into-global-halal-hub-by-2024
121 (2021) Doing Business - Business Reforms in Indonesia Published by The World Bank:
https://www.doingbusiness.org/en/reforms/overview/economy/indonesia
122 (2021) RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT TAX INCENTIVES FOR THE APPAREL AND TEXTILES INDUSTRY Retrieved from
Alliantgroup: https://www.alliantgroup.com/manufacturing/apparel-and-textiles/
123 ITC Trademap. Exports of palm oil (HS code 1511) (2020 estimates). Retrieved on 21st October 2021.
124 (2020) Agriculture, forestry, and fishing, value added (current US$) - World Bank national accounts data, and OECD
National Accounts data files. Published by The World Bank: https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NV.AGR.TOTL.CD
125 Interview with Putu Rahwidhiyasa, Business Director of Shariah Entrepreneurship, KNEKS
126 (2021) Global Islamic Fintech Report 2021 Published by Salaam Gateway:
https://www.salaamgateway.com/specialcoverage/islamic-fintech-2021