COOP 30136 Performance Management Social Audit For Coops
COOP 30136 Performance Management Social Audit For Coops
COOP 30136 Performance Management Social Audit For Coops
SY
Compiled by:
Page 1 of 108
FOREWORD
After each week lessons are provided the required activity for the students to
work on. The course adviser/s shall use the assigned tasks/activities in monitoring
the performance of the students. Self- assessment checklist will be given to the
students (in rubrics form/CDA mandated tools) to determine how the students are
coping with their assignments/required activity/self-test evaluations.
The materials gathered for this IM are compiled carefully by the authors.
Deepest acknowledgements were cited for the insightful and informative articles
Page 2 of 108
gathered online. The authors and the users of this compilation swore to only utilize
this material for purpose of reference for the course on COOP 30136. Any
alterations or minimal revisions were only done in order that the coop students can
have the basic understanding of the concepts and principles behind performance
standards, performance management, and social audit in cooperatives.
Page 3 of 108
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page 4 of 108
Polytechnic University of the Philippines
College of Social Sciences & Development
DEPARTMENT OF COOPERATIVES & SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT
Mabini Campus, Sta. Mesa, Manila
Tel. No. 3511777/3511778 to 36 loc. 316
Course Title : Performance Management & Social & Audit for Cooperatives
Course Description : The course is intended to provide the cooperative students on the concepts and fundamental principles
of performance management and standards for cooperative. This shall also allow the students to recognize and internalize the social
audit undertakings for the cooperative movement. Here the students will be able to assess the social and economic performance of
cooperatives via the varied assessment tools as mandated by the Cooperative Development Authority. Among these include
performance and management audit for cooperatives, social audit for cooperatives, governance and management audit for
cooperatives, assessing the gender equality progress of primary cooperative in the country, and other financial reporting framework,
etc.
1. Creative and Critical ▪ Demonstrate high degree of analytical and At the end of the course the learners are able
Thinking creative thinking using acquired skills, to:
behaviours, characters and values anchored
on the cooperative environments and ▪ Determine the research thrusts and
learning areas. agenda of the university in relation to the
common cooperatives’ research agenda
Page 5 of 108
▪ Associate the International Cooperative
2. Effective Communication ▪ Apply learned skills of the different Alliance 2020 Blueprint with the
communication structures in the different cooperatives research concerns in the
situations needed for cooperative Philippines
businesses and endeavors and for building
relationships.
▪ Advocate in increasing public awareness ▪ Discuss the theories and concepts of
about co-peratives and their contributions to research
socio-economic development and the
achievement of the vision of the cooperative ▪ Identify the different types of researches
movement. and state their significance
Page 6 of 108
8. Sense of Personal and ▪ Practice the ethical and organizational
Professional Ethics values of cooperation. Adapt strong sense
of justice, work ethics, and social
responsibility expressed in the core values of
love of God and neighbor, honesty, integrity,
care, service, sincerity among other values.
COURSE PLAN
Week 1 ▪ Overview of the PUP At the end of the session, the Audio-Visual Digital Light Processing Oral
Vision, Mission, Goals & learners are able to: Presentation Equipment (DLP) Reflection/
Objectives
▪ The 8-Point Agenda ▪ Recognize the PUP VMGO & Discussion Power-point Presentation Impression
▪ The CSSD-DCSD Goals & ▪ Identify the 8-Point Agenda Templates
of the University in relation to Question & Answer
Objectives, Programs &
the BSC Program. Provision of Hand-Out
Activities
▪ Discuss the overall activities Materials
▪ General Orientation on the
Course and requirements for the
Internet Sourced
completion of the program
and course on COOP Materials
20053-Leadership & Social
Responsibility in
Cooperative Organizations.
Page 7 of 108
Week 2 Why and how to create After the session the learners ▪ Lecture & Fisic, Ivana, December 21, Essay Test
performance standards in an are able to: Discussion 2021, Why and how to
organization (plus examples) ▪ Small Group create performance
▪ Cite own idea of the concept Brainstorming via standards in an
and principles of zoom breakout organization (plus
performance standards and session examples),
performance management. ▪ Write up on https://clockify.me/blog/busin
▪ Discuss the purposes and reflections drawn ess/performance-standard,
levels of performance from group Retrieved March 10, 2022.
standards. discussions (Ivana Fisic is a time
▪ Determine the indicators of management researcher and
performance standards. writer. She has always been
passionate about writing,
which is why she has finished
her BA in Journalism, at the
Faculty of Philosophy, Novi
Sad. Ivana is always
exploring the new methods of
how time management can
help you organize your
workflow more effectively, as
well as how you can increase
your productivity).
Week 3 What is Performance After the session the learners ▪ Lecture & Tardi, Carla. Updated
Management? are able to: Discussion September 20, 2021. Narrative
▪ Reporting & Performance Management. Test
▪ Familiarize with the Discussion Reviewed by David Kindness
characteristics and key take- ▪ Critical reflections https://www.investopedia.co
aways of performance on the proposed m/terms/p/performance-
management. performance management.asp. Retrieved
management March 10, 2022.
Page 8 of 108
▪ Identify performance programs to be
management programs that presented before
may be undertaken by coops the class.
for effective and efficient
employee performance and
effectivity.
Week 4, 5 Training Requirements for After the session the learners ▪ Lecture & RA 9520: The Cooperative Oral
&6 Cooperative Officers: are able to: Discussion Code of the Philippines. Recitation &
Improving the Performance & ▪ Collaborative Quiz
2008. Cooperative
Productivity of Cooperative ▪ Classify the different discussions Assessment
Development Authority.
Officers education and training Comparative
requirements of the assessment and Republic of the Philippines.
cooperative officers. Brainstorming MC2011-27-Implementation-
▪ Identify at least three (3) of-Training-Requirements-
courses that are required for for-Coop-Officers
each cooperative officers
and discuss their importance
in the performance of their
functions, duties, and
responsibilities.
▪ Determine ways where
these education and training
have been significant in
terms of managing the
culture and business
operations of the
cooperative.
▪ Demonstrate awareness
and appreciation of the value
of cooperative education,
training and information in
the cooperatives.
Page 9 of 108
Week 7, 8 Social Audit & After the session the learners ▪ Lecture & Chris B. Murphy. Updated Practice Sets
&9 Social Audit for Cooperatives are able to: Discussion March 31, 2020. A practical using the
▪ Social Audit
▪ guide to social audit as a Social Audit
Determine the Simulation
significance of social participatory tool to Toolkit
audit for cooperatives. strengthen democratic
▪ Map out the areas and governance, transparency,
parameters to where the and accountability. Reviewed
cooperatives will be
assessed in relation to
by Gordon Scott. Investopia.
social audit. https://www.investopedia.co
▪ Categorize the indicators m/terms/s/social-audit.asp.
in conducting social Retrieved
auditing for cooperatives. https://www.local2030.org/lib
▪ Compute for the rary/112/A-practical-guide-
quantitative and
qualitative scales used in to-Social-Audit-as-a-
conducting social audit Participatory-Tool-to-
for cooperatives. Strengthen-Democratic-
▪ Assess the results of Governance,-Transparency,-
social audit and prepare and-Accountability.pdf
recommendations to
improve the performance Memorandum
of cooperatives socially, Circular#2013s016: Social
environmentally,
Audit for Cooperatives.
financially, etc.
Cooperative Development
Authority. Republic of the
Philippines. RA 9520:
Cooperative Code of 2008.
Memorandum
Circular#2018s01: Revised
Social Audit for
Page 10 of 108
Cooperatives. Cooperative
Development Authority.
Republic of the Philippines.
RA 9520: Cooperative Code
of 2008.
Week 10 On-line Mid Term Examination via Tesmoz, G-Form, MS-Form, etc.
Week 11 Gender & Development & After the session the learners ▪ Lecture & Asian Development Bank, Practice Sets
& 12 Assessing Gender Equality in are able to: Discussion Australian Aid. 2003. Tool using the
Primary Cooperatives ▪ Group Interactions Kit on Gender Equality CDA Toolkit
▪ Distinguish Gender & ▪ Student Self- Results and Indicators,
Development, Gender on Gender
Assessment and/or Published in 2013. Printed
Mainstreaming, and Reflections on in the Philippines. ISBN and Equality
Gender Equality (GE) as
Learning 978-92-9254-337-2 Progress of
applied to cooperatives. (Print), 978-92-9254-338- selected
▪ Assess the significance ▪ Submission of
9 (PDF) Publication Stock Primary
of gender equality in Coop’s Assessment
No. TIM135772
primary cooperatives. on Primary Cooperatives
Cataloging-In-Publication
▪ Measure the progress of Cooperatives’ Data Asian Development
primary cooperatives’ Assessment on GE Bank. Tool kit on gender
progress in gender progress. equality results and
equality using the indicators. Mandaluyong
Cooperative City, Philippines: Asian
Development Authority Development Bank, 2013
prescribed tool.
▪ Determine the primary Azad, Nandini Dr. 2017.
cooperatives’ own level of The Independent
assessment of the Commission for People’s
different Rights and Development
areas/parameters of (ICPRD) New
gender equality in their Delhi 3 Acknowledgement
organization.
Page 11 of 108
▪ Categorize the indicators “Gender is more than a
used to evaluate gender statistic”.
equality in cooperatives.
▪ Compute for the Global Campaign for
quantitative and Education. Web Post.
qualitative scales used in 2020 March 8. An equal
measuring primary world is an enabled
cooperatives’ compliance world’. Category: News,
using the CDA tool in GE Press Release.
progress. https://campaignforeducat
▪ Review some of the ion.org/en/2020/03/08/an-
results of the GE of some equal-world-is-an-
primary cooperatives in enabled-
the National Capital world/?gclid=Cj0KCQjwz
Region. 7uRBhDRARIsAFqjullDH-
vcqi18cFtYlIp270XorbilR
SissfXYCkulyHH84VFVcs
9DfHkaAvVrEALw_wcB.
Retrieved March 15,
2022.
International Labour
Organization. 2015.
Advancing gender
equality: The co-operative
way First published 2015
Publications of the
International Labour
Office. ISBN 978-92-2-
130017-5 (print) ISBN
978-92-2-130018-2 (web
pdf) International Labour
Office Enterprises Dept.
ISBN 978-92-2-130017-5
(print) ISBN 978-92-2-
130018-2 (web pdf)
Page 12 of 108
International Labour
Office Enterprises Dept.
Page 13 of 108
Gender and Development
(GAD) in Co-ops Crown
Legacy Hotel, Baguio City
29-31 March 2016.
Week 13 Governance & Management After the session the learners ▪ Lecture & MC 2017-05 | Practice Sets
& 14 Audit Report for Cooperatives are able to: Discussion Governance and using the
▪ Group Interactions Management Audit CDA Toolkit
▪ Elucidate the concepts & ▪ Student Self- Report for on
principles of cooperative Assessment and/or Cooperativesovernance Governance
governance & management. Reflections on and Management Audit
&
▪ Recognize the governance Learning Report for Cooperatives.
2017. MEMORANDUM Management
and management practices ▪ Submission of
CIRCULAR NO. 2017-05 Audit Report
of the different types of Governance & for
Series of 2017.
cooperative organization. Management Audit Cooperative Development Cooperatives
▪ Discuss the guidelines Report for Authority. Manila.
governing all types of Cooperatives Philippines.
registered cooperatives in
relation to cooperative Saxena, G. N.
governance and Cooperative Leadership &
management. Governance- An Indian
▪ Accomplish the CDA Perspective
Governance & Management G.N.SAXENA
Audit Report of selected DIRECTOR (Coop.
Development) IFFCO,
cooperatives in the National
INDIA COOPERATIVE
Capital Region. GOVERNANCE.
COOPERATIVE
GOVERNANCE IS
ABOUT STRIKING A FIN,
Retrieved March 5, 2022.
What is good
governance?
Page 14 of 108
CooperativesUK.
https://www.uk.coop/supp
ort-your-co-
p/governance/what-good-
governance. Retrieved
March 15, 2022.
Week 15, The Philippine Financial After the session the learners ▪ Lecture & Cooperative Development Practice
16, & 17 Reporting Framework for are able to: Discussion Authority. 2016. MC
Set on
Cooperatives ▪ Group Interactions 2015-06 | Philippine
Financial Reporting Coop’s
▪ Discuss the Philippine ▪ Student Self- Financial
Framework for
Financial Reporting Assessment and/or Reports
Cooperatives.
Framework for Reflections on MEMORANDUM
Cooperatives. Learning cCIRCULAR NO. 2015-
Unit Test
▪ Identify the different ▪ Submission of 06, Series of 2015.
reporting standards for all Coop’s Assessment SUBJECT : PHILIPPINE
types of cooperatives as on Primary FINANCIAL REPORTING
mandated by the Cooperatives’ FRAMEWORK FOR
Cooperative Development Assessment on GE. COOPERATIVES,
Authority (CDA). Manila, Philippines.
▪ Familiarize themselves with
the different financial reports
on cooperatives such as
PESOS, PISO, PEARL, etc.
▪ Calculate the financial
reports that needs to be
complied by all registered
cooperatives with the CDA.
Page 15 of 108
COURSE GRADING SYSTEM
CLASSROOM POLICY
(Policy as prescribed for synchronous and asynchronous classes based on University Memorandum Order)
▪ Use of cell phones is allowed when use appropriately inside the classroom e.g. reporting etc.
Page 16 of 108
▪ If a student is absent for 3 consecutive meetings, he/she should present a letter of excuse signed by his/her parents
and should secure absent slip from the Guidance Office.
▪ Cheating and plagiarism is not allowed in the class.
▪ No Smoking in class
▪ Be on time at the beginning of the day
▪ Wear proper attire/uniform
▪ The use of LCD/DLP in reporting is a must
▪ The use of English as medium of instruction is encouraged every time
▪ The classroom policy will be modified every so often depending on the instructor/professor who shall be given the
course assignment during the semester.
CONSULTATION TIME
(This will be based on the teaching assignment where consultation and advising time are indicated)
PROF. REBECCA E. PALMA ASST. PROF. MICHAEL S. PECHARDO DR. HILDA F. SAN GARIEL
Course Adviser Course Adviser Chairperson
Page 17 of 108
Week 1. At the end of the session, the learners are able to:
▪ Recognize the PUP VMGO
▪ Identify the 8-Point Agenda of the University in relation to the BSCoop Program
▪ Discuss the overall activities and requirements for the completion of the
program and course on COOP 30136-Performance Management & Social
Audit for Cooperatives
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Week 2. At the end of the lessons, the students will be able to:
▪ Cite own idea of the concept and principles of performance standards and
performance management.
▪ Discuss the purposes and levels of performance standards.
▪ Determine the indicators of performance standards.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Every job has its own description of what needs to be done when working in that
position. In addition, there are performance standards. They prove how to perform these
tasks to do the job well.
So, when evaluating your employees, you’ll compare their performance with
predetermined standards – performance standards. Be sure that these standards are
founded on specific positions, not individuals.
This IM will guide you through all the details about performance standards, such as:
Page 18 of 108
What is the purpose of performance
standards?
This process also involves giving feedback to the workers. To know how to conduct
their job with success, employees first need to see the performance standards for that
position.
The goal of performance standards is to ensure that both employers and employees
are on the same page regarding job expectations. That’s why managers need to provide
their new employees with the performance standards during the first month of employment.
Performance standards also equip employees with specific performance outlooks for every
skill.
Regarding performance standards, all workers are equal and should be treated the
same way. According to the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, both
employees with disabilities and without it, “must meet the same production standards,
whether quantitative or qualitative.”
Page 19 of 108
Performance standards should be:
• specific,
• achievable,
• easy to understand,
• relevant to the position, and
• easy to measure.
Once an employer or a manager has evaluated the employees, their expectations can be:
So, in the case of insufficient performance, the employer or supervisor has to issue a
Performance Improvement Plan (PIP). The purpose of this document is to help an
employee improve his/her performance.
The PIP happens in the last phase of the performance management cycle – the review
phase. In brief, this is the phase when managers track employee performance by
conducting evaluations. We mentioned before that this cycle starts with setting
performance standards.
Page 20 of 108
2. operational performance management, and
3. individual performance management.
The purpose of this level is to achieve overall organizational goals. Thus, this is the
highest rank of using performance management standards in the organization.
• Does this company have a strategy for achieving its goals? If so, does the company
implement this strategy?
• Is the organization bringing the expected results?
The intention here is to get operational goals. This level focuses on processes within
the organization, such as projects or activities. Thus, the intent is to find out if these specific
projects/activities are working.
Page 21 of 108
Individual performance management
Finally, this level emphasizes the performance of each employee in the company.
This process begins with setting work goals and standards, reviewing employee
performance, and enhancing learning skills of each employee.
To carry out these goals, company management needs to get answers to these
questions:
To ensure that standards are suitable for a particular position, here are four points you
should consider:
Page 22 of 108
be their driving force. Thus, they’ll be more likely to achieve exceptional levels of
performance.
As a leader, you can encourage your workers to track their working hours. Employee
time tracking is beneficial to your employees, too, because they’ll be able to review their
project progress. So, they’ll discover what part of the project they have finished, and what
still needs to be done. Moreover, workers will continue with completing their tasks the best
they can.
If performance standards contain tasks that are too simple, they’ll be too easy to
achieve. So, employees won’t be motivated because they won’t be challenged to finish a
particular task.
On the other hand, performance standards should not be too complicated. If they
are, workers will struggle to complete almost every assignment. Therefore, their
performance levels may decline.
But, how do you find the right balance between these two? Be sure that performance
standards should be daring enough. That way, workers will have to search for an ideal
strategy to finish their tasks. Whenever they succeed, employees will feel that they’re
working towards accomplishing their goals. Thus, they will be more enthusiastic about their
job.
Page 23 of 108
So, a manager has to be transparent about performance standards. Throughout the
year, leaders should remind employees about these measures. If workers need an
explanation for some part of the standard, managers should provide them with clarification.
As a manager, you don’t have to set performance standards by yourself. Let the HR
staff help you write down these measures.
Aside from the HR team, you can also include your team members as well. This
step is crucial because your employees may have some concerns about the current
measures. If so, adjust these parts of the performance standard.
Then, you should start testing these new measures by setting a trial period, which
can last from six to eight weeks. This way, you’ll get straightforward feedback from your
employees. Once the trial period is complete, ask your workers if these standards were
suitable for them. Again, if there are any current issues, be sure to slightly modify the
measures.
Let’s say that you and your team want to create a new performance standard for
several positions within the team. If you’re still unsure how to start and what requirements
you should cover, here are a few simple steps to ease this process.
Page 24 of 108
Focus on the position, not individual
If more than one employee performs the same task, standards should be identical
for conducting this particular task. This rule applies even if these workers are in diverse
positions within the company.
To perform a job successfully, employees must meet particular criteria. Here are some
indicators of an effective performance:
• precision,
• conducting job duties on time,
• customer satisfaction,
• showing signs of leadership,
• being productive,
• showing initiative,
• showing creativity, and
• quality of work.
Page 25 of 108
But, there’s more. An employee with the beyond-expectations performance will present
qualities such as:
• professionalism,
• constantly following professional protocols,
• their performance is constantly improving,
• always performing their best,
• being meticulous,
• having visionary ideas and solutions, and
• expressing their own opinions.
Generally speaking, KPI can help you find out how your company is performing and
if it’s going towards achieving its goals. As you can imagine, all workers need to align their
performance with the company’s objectives. Plus, they need to do their job following
performance standards.
But, what happens when an employee presents inferior performance, below the
acceptable standards? The above-mentioned Performance Improvement Plan is one of the
solutions.
Before starting with this plan, first, you’ll need to decide how many errors are too
many. For example, an employee can have a performance below the suitable levels twice.
But, if this happens again, you may give him/her an “Improvement needed” rating.
You may have a different plan for setting error rates. Whatever you choose, just stick to
that plan.
Page 26 of 108
Create standards for solid performance first, then the others
When creating performance standards, begin with positive aspects first. So, you can
start by writing down the qualities of a solid performance. Then, continue with the qualities
of the above-expected performance.
Once you have these two categories, focus on indicators that are below the solid levels.
You can use phrases like this:
The in-depth explanation for each sentence will depend on the employee position.
If you’re eager to see how these performance standards look like in practice, keep reading.
Performance standards can vary depending on the position and job description. The only
thing that’s common to all performance standards is that they demonstrate how one’s job
should be done well.
Let’s find out what performance standards would look like for teachers.
Page 27 of 108
As you can see from the table above, each measure has an in-depth explanation.
So, every new teacher will have to review these standards in the first month of employment.
The purpose of these measures is to find the proper ways of presenting the curriculum to
the students. To do so, teachers can use all available resources, so that the students can
Page 28 of 108
comprehend everything with ease. Besides, teachers have to maintain positive
relationships with students’ parents or guardians.
Page 29 of 108
Performance standards for technical support providers
Now, let’s take a look at an example of performance standards for technical support
providers.
As you can see from this table, performance standards for this occupation are
maintaining technical support, making recommendations to the users, and staying updated
with the latest trends in this field. The purpose of these measures is to ensure that technical
support providers offer only accurate information to the users. Besides, technical support
providers need to act friendly and to be as responsive as possible.
Page 30 of 108
So, for instance, one of the company’s objectives is to improve customer service.
Let’s take a hotel as an example of this company. The first person you see when you enter
is a receptionist. Naturally, a receptionist’s responsibility is to greet visitors.
But, how the receptionist will greet visitors is what matters. To enhance customer
service, the receptionist has to be friendly and welcome visitors with a smile. Plus, the
receptionist needs to provide them with as much information about the hotel as they need.
Moreover, if visitors have any concerns, the receptionist has to find a way to solve these
issues.
Conclusion
This article underlined the most significant aspects of performance standards. Also, we covered
several examples of these measures. Whenever you struggle to create performance standards, you can go
through it one more time. Deepest acknowledgement to the author-Ivana Fisic for the insightful and
informative article. We the users of this compilation swore to only utilize this material for purpose of reference
for the course on COOP 30136. Any alterations or minimal revisions were only done in order that the coop
students can have the basic understanding of the concepts and principles behind performance standards
and performance management.
Page 31 of 108
--------------------------------------
Required Activity. Write your answers on the space provided in each item.
Page 32 of 108
Reference:
Fisic, Ivana, December 21, 2021, Why and how to create performance standards in an
organization (plus examples), https://clockify.me/blog/business/performance-standard,
Retrieved March 10, 2022. (Ivana Fisic is a time management researcher and writer. She
has always been passionate about writing, which is why she has finished her BA in
Journalism, at the Faculty of Philosophy, Novi Sad. Ivana is always exploring the new
methods of how time management can help you organize your workflow more effectively,
as well as how you can increase your productivity).
Page 33 of 108
Week 3. At the end of the lessons, the students will be able to:
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Key Takeaways
Page 34 of 108
Performance-management programs use traditional tools such as creating and measuring
goals, objectives, and milestones. They also aim to define what effective performance
looks like and develop processes to measure performance. However, instead of using the
traditional paradigm of year-end reviews, performance management turns every interaction
with an employee into an occasion to learn.
Performance-Management Programs
Page 35 of 108
interact with clients, colleagues, and supervisors? What procedures does my job
entail?
• Creating measurable performance-based expectations. Employees should give
input into how success is measured. Expectations include results—the goods and
services an employee produces; actions—the processes an employee uses to make
a product or perform a service; and behaviors—the demeanor and values an
employee demonstrates at work.
• Defining job-development plans. Supervisors and employees together should
define a job's duties. Employees should have a say in what types of new things they
learn and how they can use their knowledge to the company's benefit.
• Meeting regularly. Instead of waiting for an annual appraisal, managers and
employees should engage actively year-round to evaluate progress.
--------------------------------------
Required Activity.
▪ Be able to group yourselves into 5. Your group needs to come up with two (2)
proposed performance management programs for coops. Prepare concept paper
for this and power-point presentation. Be sure also to select your group leader.
▪ Be ready for a zoom presentation of the 2 proposed programs. Panel of evaluators
will be selected for this purpose.
Reference:
Tardi, Carla. Updated September 20, 2021. Performance Management. Reviewed by David
Kindness. https://www.investopedia.com/terms/p/performance-management.asp.
Retrieved March 10, 2022.
Page 36 of 108
Week 4, 5 & 6. At the end of the lessons, the students will be able to:
▪ Classify the different education and training requirement of the cooperative officers.
▪ Identify at least three (3) courses that are required for each cooperative officers and
discuss their importance in the performance of their functions, duties, and
responsibilities.
▪ Determine ways where these education and training have been significant in terms
of managing the culture and business operations of the cooperative.
▪ Demonstrate awareness and appreciation of the value of cooperative education,
training and information in cooperatives.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Rule # 7. Section 1. Legal Basis: Art. 44. The functions and responsibilities of the
directors, officers and committee members, as well as their training requirement, shall be
in accordance with the rules and regulations issued by the Authority.
Rule # 7. Section 2. The Cooperative Officers: The officers of the cooperative shall include
the Members of the Board of Directors, Members of the Different Committees created by
the General Assembly, General Manager or Chief Executive Officer, Secretary, Treasurer
and Members holding other positions as maybe provided for in their By-Laws. As such
they are entrusted with the power of exercising authority within the scope of their defined
functions which is permanent in nature and include the exercise of control and discretion
in the performance of their duty.
Rule # 7. Section 3. The Committees of Cooperatives: The bylaws shall provide for the
creation of the following committees:
Page 37 of 108
▪ Audit Committee
▪ Election Committee
▪ Mediation and Conciliation Committee
▪ Ethics Committee
Other Committees as may be necessary for the conduct of the affairs of the cooperative.
Note: The members of the Audit and Election Committee shall be elected by the General
Assembly while the Board of Directors shall appoint the rest.
4.1.1 The Board of Directors shall have the following functions and responsibilities:
Page 38 of 108
▪ Act on the recommendation of the Ethics Committee on cases involving
violations of the code of Governance and Ethical Standards; and
▪ Perform such other functions as may be prescribed in the by-laws or
authorized by the General/Representative Assembly.
▪ Set the agenda for board meetings in coordination with the other members
of the Board of Directors;
▪ Preside over all meetings of the Board of Directors and of the
General/Representative Assembly;
▪ Sign contracts, agreements, certificates and other documents on behalf of
the cooperative as authorized by the Board of Directors or by the
General/Representative Assembly;
▪ Issue Certificate of Non-Affiliation with any Federation or Union; and
▪ Perform such other functions as may be authorized by the Board of Directors
or by the General/Representative Assembly.
▪ Perform all duties and functions of the Chairperson in the absence of the
latter;
▪ To act as ex-officio Chairperson of the Education and training Committee;
and
▪ Perform such other duties as maybe delegated to him/her by the Board of
Directors.
▪ Ensure that all cash collections are deposited in accordance with the policies
set by the Board of Directors;
Page 39 of 108
▪ Have custody of all funds, securities, and documentations relating to all
assets, liabilities, income and expenditures;
▪ Monitor and review the financial management operations of the cooperative,
subject to such limitations and control as may be prescribed by the Board of
Directors;
▪ Maintain full and complete records of cash transactions;
▪ Maintain a Petty Cash Fund and Daily Cash Position Report; and
▪ Perform such other functions as may be prescribed in the By-laws or
authorized by the General/Representative Assembly.
Page 40 of 108
4.4. Election Committee. The Election Committee shall:
Page 41 of 108
4.6. Mediation and Conciliation Committee. The committee shall:
Page 42 of 108
4.8 Other Committees
Page 43 of 108
Sec. 5. Training Requirements for the Officers of the Cooperative. Officers of the
cooperative shall be required to undergo necessary training conducted by cooperatives,
Federations, and/or other trainers or training institutions duly accredited by the Authority.
The training program should contain the minimum requirements in the module/curriculum
as prescribed by the Authority. The initial courses or any equivalent substitute thereof must
be undertaken.
BOARD OF DIRECTORS:
SECRETARY:
Page 44 of 108
▪ Parliamentary Procedures
▪ Basic Computer Program
TREASURER:
AUDIT COMMITTEE:
ELECTION COMMITTEE:
Page 45 of 108
ETHICS COMMITTEE:
MEDIATION/CONCILIATION COMMITTEE:
GENERAL MANAGER:
Page 46 of 108
--------------------------------------
Required Activity.
Reference:
Page 47 of 108
Week 7, 8, and 9. At the end of the lessons, the students will be able to:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Key Takeaways
Page 48 of 108
Understanding a Social Audit
The scope of a social audit can vary and be wide-ranging. The assessment can include
social and public responsibility but also employee treatment. Some of the guidelines and
topics that comprise a social audit include the following:
Page 49 of 108
▪ Worker pay and benefits
▪ Nondiscriminatory practices
▪ Diversity
There is no standard for the items included in a social audit. Social audits are
optional, which means that companies can choose whether to release the results publicly
or only use them internally.
The flexibility surrounding social audits allow companies the ability to expand or
contract the scope based on their goals. While one company might wish to understand the
impact it has on a particular town or city, other companies might choose to expand the
range of the audit to include an entire state, country, or throughout the globe.
Since social audits are voluntary, any release of the findings to the general public is
also voluntary. While positive results might be disclosed, negative results might be kept
internal and used to identify potential improvements that can make the results of the next
social audit more favorable.
For example, a company might find out through its assessment that the company
was not adequately involved in charitable activities within the community. As a result,
company executives could enact initiatives with measurable goals designed to increase
community involvement. The activities could be monitored and analyzed during the next
social audit.
Page 50 of 108
THE SOCIAL AUDIT OF COOPERATIVES
Social Audit is the process whereby a cooperative can account for its social
performance, report on and improve that performance. It assesses the social impact and
ethical performance of the cooperative in relation to its vision, mission, goals, and Code of
Social Responsibility.
It is also process to assess the cooperative’s contribution for the upliftment of the
status not only to its members’ economic needs but also social needs and the community
where it operates. The cooperative’s actual performance and accomplishment are
compared its vision, goals, and social responsibility as it relates to the impact not only to
the community but to its regular members as the immediate beneficiary of the decisions
and actions it promulgated, passed and implemented. Social Audit will serve as control
mechanism to account for its social performance and evaluate its impact in the community
taking into account the community development fund which shall be used for projects or
activities that will benefit the community where the cooperative operates.
Social Audit validates the support of the cooperative to the 7th cooperative principles,
i.e. the “Concern for Community” and determines whether the cooperative work for the
community’s sustainable development through policies approved by their members.
The audit focuses not only to the economic side of the cooperative but also the
social aspect of the organization and appraises the cooperative performance as value-
based organization usually participative, user and community oriented and non-profit but
service organization and how its social responsibility for its members and the community
as a whole was fulfilled.
Page 51 of 108
THE SOCIAL AUDIT TOOL
The social audit tool is an instrument to identify, measure, assess and to report on
their social performance. This will provide the user a framework on how to collect data and
what data is to be collected.
Similar to financial and management audit, the Social Audit has a one year cycle.
The audit steps are also comparable to activities carried out for financial audit.
The tool will also present the score of the cooperative’s social performance, whether
outstanding, very good, good, fair or poor. The score/rating should not be taken as the
end of it. Any result thereof, shall be the major consideration for improved social
performance, which is actually the first and foremost goal of Social Audit.
Social Audit for cooperative shall look into the following components with their
corresponding points:
I. Organization
This is a measurement of cooperative's fulfilment of its vision, mission and
goals, feedback mechanisms, code of good governance and ethical
standards.
II. Membership
Measurement on how the cooperative responded to the need of members,
observed governance practices, considered provision for benefits of
members, and involved members in the affairs of the cooperative.
Page 52 of 108
III. Staff/Employees
Assessment of the cooperative's fulfilment of the needs and welfare of the
employees in terms of safety workplace and sanitation, including the provision
for compensation and benefits.
--------------------------------------
Required Activity.
▪ Accomplish the Social Audit Tool uploaded in the class Channel in the MSTeams.
Submit and be ready for a zoom presentation in the next synchronous online class
session.
References:
Chris B. Murphy. Updated March 31, 2020. A practical guide to social audit as a participatory tool
to strengthen democratic governance, transparency, and accountability. Reviewed by
Gordon Scott. Investopia. https://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/social-audit.asp.
Retrieved https://www.local2030.org/library/112/A-practical-guide-to-Social-Audit-as-a-
Participatory-Tool-to-Strengthen-Democratic-Governance,-Transparency,-and-
Accountability.pdf
Page 53 of 108
Week 11 & 12. At the end of the lessons, the students will be able to:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Presented in the succeeding pages are Gender & Equality Statements from the Global Campaign Education
and the Report on the GE Context from the Asian Development Bank where we can draw the basic
understanding and stand of world nations on gender equality (copied as is)
On the International Women’s Day, the Global Campaign for Education (GCE) is
renewing its commitment to fully realise women and girls’ right to education and calls for a
focus on and for resources to be invested into challenging, undoing and transforming the
social, economic and cultural barriers that prop up gender inequality and undermine the
universal right to education.
Page 54 of 108
Gender equality is a human right and a requisite for achieving broader social,
political and economic development goals, as stated in the Agenda for Sustainable
Development/Education 2030.
Education can play a key role in challenging gender based violence and
transforming patriarchal societies into ones that value equality, inclusion and justice.
However, this requires a comprehensive approach, recognizing that no one policy or
initiative alone will lead to gender transformative education.
According to CEDAW, the elimination of prejudices and customary and all other
practices which are based on the idea of the inferiority or the superiority of either of the
sexes or on stereotyped roles for men and women constitutes the main challenge to identify
new education policies.
The Global Campaign for Education works for the full integration of gender equality
in its policy frameworks, planning processes and political engagement. GCE also calls on
States to ensure that education sector plans, policies, curricula and budgets are gender
responsive, including mainstreaming gender equality in teacher education and in-service
professional development.
Page 55 of 108
international financial institutions, rather than reducing women’s rights to an instrumental
issue.
GCE calls on States to mobilise knowledge and implement policies and programs
that eliminate School Related Gender Based Violence (SRGBV) and introduce
Comprehensive Sexuality Education programs for both boys and girls, disregarding their
sexual identity and gender orientation, while guaranteeing the full right to education of
pregnant adolescents and mothers.
The Global Campaign for Education calls for the strengthening of feminist
organizations and, in general, civil society organizations, not to falter in their fight for the
empowerment of girls and women and to join forces to claim women’s right to free, quality
transformative education.
To rebuild a just, equal, and inclusive global economy after the pandemic, we need
more female leaders and gender-focused data.
Page 56 of 108
“Women in Leadership,” the theme of the 2021 International Women’s Day
celebration, raised two big questions: What will leadership look like in the wake of COVID-
19, and why do we need more female leaders?
It’s easy to answer the first question. Leadership has become decentralized. It is no longer
limited to presidents, prime ministers and other politicians. It includes CEOs, community
leaders in cities and rural villages, civil society advocates, and academic experts.
Answering the second question–why we need more female leaders–is more complex.
There are three reasons to consider:
First, women are underrepresented as leaders. Women are heads of state in only
20 countries and hold only a quarter of parliamentary seats globally. They accounted for
just 18% of CEOs and 28% of managers in the private sector in 2019, according to the
United Nations.
In a study of financial data for Asian companies between 1997 and 2017,
researchers Soyoung Han and Marcus Noland found that those with at least one female
leader consistently outperformed those with none. Meanwhile, a 2019 study by the
Page 57 of 108
International Labour Organization concluded that companies with a gender-inclusive
culture are more likely to improve their business performance.
While leadership by women has grown in various fields in recent decades, COVID-
19 threatens these gains. The pandemic has intensified the “double shift” phenomenon–
burdening women with both office work and unpaid domestic work. In the US, 2 million
women thought about leaving the workforce between June and August 2020. This may
reduce the pool of current and future female leaders, according to McKinsey & Co.’s
Women in the Workplace 2020 study. A preference among companies for leaders with a
proven track record during the pandemic has caused female CEO appointments to fall by
almost 50%, according to the executive search firm Heidrick & Struggles.
Women are heads of state in only 20 countries and hold only a quarter of
parliamentary seats globally.
Women in senior leadership roles have also faced non-inclusive behavior and higher
rates of burnout than their male counterparts while working remotely during COVID-19.
Nearly half the women in a recent global survey by Deloitte said they felt compelled to
always be available for work, fearing their career might suffer otherwise, and that they felt
overwhelmed as a result.
Women also took on more domestic responsibilities, with a majority doing three
quarters of the care work, including childcare, elderly care, homeschooling and household
chores. The International Monetary Fund has also found that women’s mobility has been
restricted more than that of men during COVID-19. This could be an obstacle for female
community leaders who want to advance politically. Data is an important tool that can help
us tackle these challenges and nurture female leaders.
Data that’s collected and analyzed separately for men and women, known as sex-
disaggregated data, can yield insights that will help us track and understand how crises
such as COVID-19 affect men and women differently. Using this data, we can ensure that
Page 58 of 108
policy changes are gender-responsive, data-driven, and evidence-based. Without this, it is
difficult to create targeted policies for women, including efforts to promote their leadership.
Countries and organizations are already using data broken down by gender to draw
attention to gaps that might otherwise go unnoticed. In a 2016 survey, the IMF cited the
Republic of Korea’s “substantive” laws requiring gender budgeting, including balance
sheets that show whether budgets benefit men and women equally and whether they
remedy discrimination.
BMJ Global Health, an open-source online medical journal, has updated its
guidelines to ensure that reviewers comment on the gender aspects of each paper,
increasing the focus on gender differences in health data. Bloomberg launched a Gender
Equality Index and Gender Reporting Framework, which saw 380 global companies from
11 sectors across 44 countries, report on 74 sex-disaggregated metrics and document
actions they had taken to promote equality.
Leaders require solid evidence to understand women’s needs and how to meet
them, as well as how to vocalize them. Governments, companies, communities and
development partners such as the Asian Development Bank must therefore work together
to promote the use of sex-disaggregated data.
This is needed now more than ever. Female leaders are essential to help achieve a
fairer, more equal, and more inclusive world in the wake of COVID-19. (Published: 30
March 2021).
Page 59 of 108
Section 1. Title
This Circular shall be known as the Tool for Assessing Progress of Gender Equality
(GE) in Cooperatives as Supplemental to Memorandum Circular 2013-22.
Section 2. Purpose
This Circular aims to disseminate to the cooperative sector the tool for assessing
gender equality in cooperatives. This TOOL shall assess the cooperative’s progress in
mainstreaming gender and development (GAD) toward achieving GE.
Section 3. Scope
This Circular shall be applicable to all primary cooperatives duly registered with the
Cooperative Development Authority (CDA).
Page 60 of 108
The Tool for Assessing GE in Cooperatives was developed in response to the
implementation of CDA Memorandum Circular 2013-22 or the Guidelines in Mainstreaming
Gender and Development (GAD) in Cooperatives, and Baguio GAD Summit 2016
Declaration and Call for Action.
Page 61 of 108
Section 5. Adoption of the Tool
All cooperatives must adopt the Tools for Assessing GE in Cooperatives herein
attached and shall come up with their respective gender-responsive cooperative
development plan in accordance with the result of the assessment. The cooperative shall
be guided by CDA Memorandum Circular 2013-22.
Section 6. Effectivity
This Memorandum Circular shall take effect upon the approval of the Board of
Administrators of the Cooperative Development Authority and fifteen (15) days after its
publication in the Office of the National Administrative Registry (ONAR).
Approved by the CDA Board of Administrators under Resolution No. 34, S-2017 dated
March 21, 2017.
--------------------------------------
Required Activity.
Page 62 of 108
References:
Asian Development Bank, Australian Aid. 2003. Tool Kit on Gender Equality Results and
Indicators, Published in 2013. Printed in the Philippines. ISBN 978-92-9254-337-2 (Print),
978-92-9254-338-9 (PDF) Publication Stock No. TIM135772 Cataloging-In-Publication
Data Asian Development Bank. Tool kit on gender equality results and indicators.
Mandaluyong City, Philippines: Asian Development Bank, 2013
Azad, Nandini Dr. 2017. The Independent Commission for People’s Rights and Development
(ICPRD) New Delhi 3 Acknowledgement “Gender is more than a statistic”.
Global Campaign for Education. Web Post. 2020 March 8. An equal world is an enabled
world’. Category: News, Press Release.
https://campaignforeducation.org/en/2020/03/08/an-equal-world-is-an-enabled-
world/?gclid=Cj0KCQjwz7uRBhDRARIsAFqjullDH-
vcqi18cFtYlIp270XorbilRSissfXYCkulyHH84VFVcs9DfHkaAvVrEALw_wcB. Retrieved
March 15, 2022.
International Labour Organization. 2015. Advancing gender equality: The co-operative way First
published 2015 Publications of the International Labour Office. ISBN 978-92-2-130017-5
(print) ISBN 978-92-2-130018-2 (web pdf) International Labour Office Enterprises Dept.
ISBN 978-92-2-130017-5 (print) ISBN 978-92-2-130018-2 (web pdf) International Labour
Office Enterprises Dept.
Khan, Prabbiot R. & Nikore Mitali. 2021. Data Driven Female Leadership is Key to Recovering
from COVID-19. Asian Development Bank 2022.
https://www.google.com/search?q=gender+equality+in+the+philippines. Retrieved March
15, 2022.
Limocon, Ma. Elena C. Vice Chairperson, International Co-operative Alliance’s Asia Pacific
Women’s Committee; Member, Board of Trustees, Asian Women in Co-operative
Development Forum; Member, Board of Directors, National Confederation of Cooperatives
(NATCCO) —presented by Ms Emelina M. Santos, Group Head, Member Relations and
Networking Group/SP-GE Committee Member, NATCC2016 2nd National Summit on
Gender and Development (GAD) in Co-ops Crown Legacy Hotel, Baguio City 29-31 March
2016.
Page 63 of 108
Week 13 & 14. At the end of the lessons, the students will be able to:
Governance is, to put it simply, all about how running a business. And good
governance is about running a successful business. It's about people and performance;
policies and processes; rules and regulations... and lots more.
It's the same for co-operatives, but with a good twist. Co-ops exist to serve the needs
of their members. And they're founded on a set of values and principles which set the
agenda for a different, fairer and better way of doing business. So good governance has
to encapsulate those fundamental elements as well.
The code is a fantastic tool to help chart what good governance practice can look
like. The accompanying resources cover key roles and responsibilities, codes of conduct,
induction checklists and more. The wheel of good governance. To help with your
governance, our Co-operative Governance Expert Reference Panel has created a
great resource. It depicts the key areas of governance that should be in place within a
thriving co-operative businesses. They are:
Page 64 of 108
• Purpose
Four key elements. The framework supporting a co-op's purpose comprises four key
elements. Here we take a look at each of those and also offer expert support for co-ops
looking to strengthen their governance.
Governing Document. Having a good, well structured governing document is key to laying
the foundation for co-operative governance. Whether it is referred to as the constitution,
articles or rules, it's important that a co-operative's governing document is fit for purpose,
up to date and reflects how the co-operative's current governance operates. We have
created an extensive range of model rules to cover co-ops of different type, size and
operating in different sectors.
Mission and vision. Every co-operative is formed for a particular purpose or purposes. It's
important for the board, in consultation with stakeholders, to set out objectives and the
approach to meeting these in a mission and vision statement in order to focus resources
and achieve success.
Strategy and objectives. Every co-operative should plan for the future of its business.
Having a clear business strategy focusing on long term goals will provide the check and
balances the board need in order to determine what success looks like.
Culture and values. Fostering a healthy culture in a co-operative is key to its success.
Creating an environment where people are motivated, challenged and rewarded are values
that will enable them to work together to strive towards and and achieve success together.
Page 65 of 108
• An effective board
Five key elements. We identify five key elements in creating an effective board.
Composition and recruitment. A understanding of the role of the board is a vital step when
considering the optimum size of the board and the skills and experience required on the
board in order to meet the needs of the co-operative. It can also help a co-operative to
develop its recruitment processes for new directors and identify how to develop the skills
of its existing directors. Having a balanced board comprised of elected members and, in
many cases, independent non-executive directors can contribute the development of an
effective board.
Board of bad board behaviour? Work with your board to improve its dynamic with this great
guide. Board Behaviour in Co-operatives
Dynamics and behaviour. Having the correct mix of skills and experience on a co-operative
board must go hand in hand with enabling directors to develop appropriate behaviours
when carrying out their role whether this is when participating in a board meeting or when
reporting to members and other stakeholders on co-operative performance. A growing co-
operative must develop the softer skills of its directors in order to develop a healthy board
culture.
Page 66 of 108
Planning for board excellence. This short guide runs through the process of recruiting
directors to co-operative boards.
Skills. Having a good understanding of the role of the board and how this aligns with a co-
operative's business planning and strategy will assist a co-operative to identify and
celebrate the contribution of existing directors but also understand where skills gaps
are. This understanding will help underpin the personal development of existing directors
but will also assist with the evaluation of the board as a whole. Got the skills? We
undertake board and director evaluations and skills audits to provide you with a map of
strengths and areas and a board development plan.
Supercharge your board. Evaluation. Evaluating the board's performance and that of
individual directors provide a valuable insight into how well the board is working collectively
as well as examining the individual input of individual directors. Evaluation forms part of
the wider development of an effective board as done regularly it can be a useful tool to
identify the positive contributions of directors, skills gaps and assist succession planning.
Page 67 of 108
Policies and procedures. In addition to the governing document, any co-operative
regardless of size, type or business operation will need to establish a range of policies and
procedures to support its operation. From developing a detailed set of standing orders to
a statement on how the co-operative will embrace equality and diversity, a growing co-
operative should continually review and update its policies so that they are clear, workable
and complement and develop good governance.
What are the chair of the board's responsibilities? We've got the answers in our essential
guide for a co-operative chair.
Checks and balances. A key aspect of good corporate governance is to ensure that any
co-operative has the appropriate checks and balances in place to support its Board to act
in the co-operative's best interests. These checks and balances will depend on the
complexity of a co-operative's governance structure but include ensuring, where
appropriate, that there is a clear delination between the key roles of chief executive and
chair and that there are effective mechanisms in place to evaluate the performance of the
board.
Structure and plan. The Board is responsible for ensuring that its co-operative has an
appropriate system of governance in place and establish frameworks for risk management
and internal controls that are delegated, as appropriate, to committees who can
oversee this work. This framework will depend on the co-operative's size and complexity
but at a fundamental level will play a key role in the management of risks that may impact
the Board being able to carry out its role effectively.
Page 68 of 108
• Who must they consult when they make those decisions?
• What process must they use to make and record each decision?
• How will outcomes be monitored?
• How will effectiveness of the decision-making process be monitored?
✓ A co-operative is driven by its members, by the people who own and control it.
Those members take up various positions in the co-operative and have, either
individually or collectively, a range of governance responsibilities.
✓ Compliance. Like any other business, co-operatives operate in a complex
commercial setting. To trade successfully, co-operatives should have a
compliance strategy in place that keeps pace with new and existing legislation
and member and other stakeholder expectations. This strategy will enable co-
operatives to understand how they comply with governance and regulatory
requirements, such as various co-operative codes of good governance, and
specific legislation such as the UK Bribery Act.
Page 69 of 108
✓ Reporting. The amount and scale to which co-operative must report on their
business activities does vary depending on size, scale and business sector. For
a co-operative to comply with relevant legislation and remain accountable to
its members and wider stakeholders, it is important that any corporate reporting
is timely, transparent and precise. It is also important to understand basic
reporting requirements through annual reporting as well as keeping up to date
on different and new methods of reporting.
✓ Roles and duties. The people involved in steering the governance of the co-
operative are required to take on different roles and wear different hats. The
people who take on these roles must be fully informed about their duties and
responsibilities in order to carry them out effectively. Co-operatives
should support and develop people who take on these roles, recognise when
improvements may be required and take action to ensure the appropriate people
are carrying out their roles effectively.
✓ Delegation and limitations. As a co-operative grows and changes, it is
impossible for the board to discharge its duties effectively if it does not delegate
some tasks to other stakeholders and groups who can be focused on achieving
particular outcomes. It is important that the board is aware of what and how tasks
can be delegated and establish clear reporting lines so that it can remain
accountable. Co-operatives should understand limitations to the board's powers
of delegation to help establish and ensure clear lines of delegation.
✓ Stakeholder management. Co-operatives are driven by the members who own
and control it and so any board must remain accountable to that membership
with the ultimate aim of acting in the members' collective best interests. To do
this effectively, a co-operative's board must manage relationships with a range
of internal and external stakeholder.
Page 70 of 108
✓ General meetings. General Meetings act as the members' democratic
connection to the co-operative and provide the primary space in which members
can exercise their rights. General meetings provide opportunities for members
to hold the board to account and as the elected representatives it is important
that the board make general meetings accessible, encourage a wide
participation of members and promote opportunities for members to effectively
challenge decisions.
✓ As owners of the co-operative, members have a right to request and be provided
with information on the co-operative's position and prospects so that they can
adequately challenge the board on its decision-making. To enable this to happen
it is important for quality information to be provided and for members to have the
necessary skills to interpret the information put before them and to have the tools
and develop the necessary skills to effectively challenge this information.
✓ Connection to business. As owners of the co-operative, members must continue
to believe and feel that their input matters to the successful growth of their co-
operative. As co-operatives grow and the environment in which they trade
because more complex it is often easy to lose sight of the reason the co-
operative was established in the first place - to benefit the economic, social and
cultural needs of those members. Co-operatives should establish ways to
continually understand their membership base, consider their needs and
encourage involvement in the business of the co-operative.
✓ Communications and engagement. The methods a co-operative adopts to
communicate and engage with its members and encourage greater participation
in the co-operative will vary depending on the needs of those members. Those
needs may change over time and as such the way a co-operative communicates
with its members will also need to change to ensure that it is addressing the right
needs.
✓ Rights and responsibilities. Membership rights and responsibilities derive from
the co-operative's governing document and from in some cases from statute. As
a very minimum it is important the members are provided with a copy of their co-
Page 71 of 108
operative's governing document, can develop a broad understanding of the key
elements in order for them participate fully in the governance of the co-operative.
Page 72 of 108
MC 2017-05 | Governance and Management Audit Report for
Cooperativesovernance and Management Audit Report for Cooperatives
MEMORANDUM CIRCULAR NO. 2017-05
Series of 2017
SUBJECT: GOVERNANCE AND MANAGEMENT AUDIT REPORT FOR
COOPERATIVES
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Page 73 of 108
Section 4. Purpose
The purpose of the Governance and Management Audit Report is to determine the
presence of the documents needed to be maintained by every cooperative in the operation
and management of its business. Specifically, the report will serve as:
1. regulatory and supervisory tool of CDA in programming the roadmap of
developmental intervention for management and governance of cooperatives; and
2. management tool of cooperative to identify problem areas in its governance and
management practices.
Section 5. Coverage
This Guideline shall govern and cover all registered cooperatives, regardless of types and
categories, except for micro cooperatives which have the option to use and/or submit the
report.
Page 74 of 108
2. Executive Summary – presents the overview of the objectives and scope of the
audit, over-all rating and rating per component, and the summary of the key
observations and conclusions together with the key recommendations identifying
the strong points and main areas which need to be addressed by the cooperative.
3. Objectives and Scope of the Audit – presents the objectives set and brief scope of
audit including the actions chosen for audit and broad details of the procedures
carried out.
4. Observations /Findings – presents a clear and logical analysis of the identified
strong points or problems confronted by the cooperative within the auditing period.
The report should provide sufficient details of the observations and findings to
substantiate the points given
5. Recommendation and Conclusion – This part should be clear and precise on the
need for appropriate action to address the issue. The recommendation shall form
as basis for any follow-up audit, evaluation or examination.
Page 75 of 108
The summary report of analysis and intervention shall be submitted to SEU Central Office
through the Executive Director.
Approved by the CDA Board of Administrators on August 15, 2017 per BOA Resolution
No. 213 Series of 2017.
For the CDA Board of Administrators:
By:
(SGD) ORLANDO R. RAVANERA
Chairman
--------------------------------------
Required Activity.
Page 76 of 108
References:
Page 77 of 108
Week 15, 16, and 17. At the end of the lessons, the students will be able to:
Presented below are identified salient provisions of MC 2015-06. These are identified important aspects that
students need to learn pertaining to provisions indicated below. Remaining Chapters will be discussed in the
synchronous online class session via seminar type.
Pursuant to Section 3 of Republic Act No. 6939 and Republic Act No. 9520 and its
Implementing Rules and Regulations (IRR) , the Authority hereby adopts and prescribes
the use of this Philippine Financial Reporting Framework for Cooperatives:
CHAPTER I.
GENERAL PROVISIONS
Section 1. Title. This Memorandum Circular shall be known and cited as the Philippine
Financial Reporting Framework for Cooperatives.
Page 78 of 108
Section 3. Rationale
The emergence of cooperatives as a form of business enterprise in the Philippines is
indeed inevitable. Unlike the other collective organizations recognized by the Philippine
Constitution to own, manage and operate business enterprise, cooperatives do not have
financial reporting standards that truly reflect the cooperatives’ financial condition and
results of operation. The uniqueness and peculiarities of cooperatives make it necessary
for the Authority to prescribe the comprehensive financial reporting framework that will
address the needs of the users of the cooperatives’ financial statements.
Presently, cooperatives cannot strictly follow the PFRS for the reason that Republic Act
No. 9520, otherwise known as the Philippine Cooperative Code of 2008, specifically
provides for treatment of certain accounts which are unique only to cooperatives and such
peculiarities are in accord with universally-accepted cooperative principles. As a
consequence, cooperative external auditors are left with no option but to render, at times,
qualified opinion because the cooperatives could not comply with the PFRS. As a matter
of fact, other cooperative external auditors express varied opinions on the presentation of
the audited financial statements of cooperatives ranging from unmodified, qualified,
adverse and disclaimer of opinion on the items presented in the financial statements. For
so many years, the cooperative external auditors have long been clamoring for a separate
financial reporting framework that is truly applicable for Philippine cooperatives.
This Financial Reporting Framework for Cooperatives was developed from the Philippine
Financial Reporting Standards (PFRS) for Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises (SMEs) .
Modifications were made on several provisions of the standards taking into considerations
cooperative laws, rules, regulations and principles.
Page 79 of 108
CHAPTER II
CONCEPTS AND PERVASIVE PRINCIPLES
Section 1. Scope
This Chapter describes the objective of financial statements of Cooperative and the
qualities that make the information in the financial statements useful. It also sets out the
concepts and basic principles underlying the financial statements.
Page 80 of 108
the financial statements. Materiality depends on the size of the item or error judged
in the particular circumstances of its omission or misstatement. However, it is
inappropriate to make, or leave uncorrected, immaterial departures from this
framework to achieve a particular presentation of a cooperative’s financial condition,
financial performance or cash flows.
3.4 Reliability
The information provided in financial statements must be reliable. Information is
reliable when it is free from material error and bias and represents faithfully that
which it either purports to represent or could reasonably be expected to represent.
Financial statements are not free from bias if, by the selection or presentation of
information, they are intended to influence the making of a decision or judgment in
order to achieve a predetermined result or outcome.
3.5 Substance over form
Transactions and other events and conditions should be accounted for and
presented in accordance with their substance and not merely their legal form. This
enhances the reliability of financial statements.
3.6 Prudence
The uncertainties that inevitably surround many events and circumstances are
acknowledged by the disclosure of their nature and extent and by the exercise of
prudence in the preparation of the financial statements. Prudence is the inclusion of
a degree of caution in the exercise of the judgments needed in making the estimates
required under conditions of uncertainty, such that assets or income are not
overstated and liabilities or expenses are not understated. However, the exercise of
prudence does not allow the deliberate understatement of assets or income, or the
deliberate overstatement of liabilities or expenses. In short, prudence does not
permit bias.
3.7 Completeness
To be reliable, the information in financial statements must be complete and within
the bounds of materiality and cost. An omission can cause information to be false
or misleading and thus unreliable and deficient in terms of its relevance.
3.8 Comparability
Page 81 of 108
Users must be able to compare the financial statements of a cooperative through
time to identify trends in its financial condition and performance. Users must also be
able to compare the financial statements of different cooperatives to evaluate their
relative financial condition, performance and cash flows. Hence, the measurement
and display of the financial effects of like transactions and other events and
conditions must be carried out in a consistent way throughout a Cooperative and
over time for that Cooperative and in a consistent way across cooperative. In
addition, users must be informed of the accounting policies employed in the
preparation of the financial statements, and of any changes in those policies and
the effects of such changes.
3.9 Timeliness
To be relevant, financial information must be able to influence the economic
decisions of users. Timeliness involves providing the information within the decision
time frame. If there is undue delay in the reporting of information it may lose its
relevance. Management may need to balance the relative merits of timely reporting
and the provision of reliable information. In achieving a balance between relevance
and reliability, the overriding consideration is how best to satisfy the needs of users
in making economic decisions.
3.10 Balance between benefit and cost
The benefits derived from information should exceed the cost of providing it. The
evaluation of benefits and costs is substantially a judgmental process. Furthermore,
the costs are not necessarily borne by those users who enjoy the benefits, and often
the benefits of the information are enjoyed by a broad range of external users.
Page 82 of 108
b. A liability is a present obligation of the cooperative arising from past events, the
settlement of which is expected to result in an outflow from the cooperative of
resources embodying economic benefits.
c. An equity is the residual interest in the assets of the cooperative after deducting
all its liabilities.
Some items that meet the definition of an asset or a liability may not be recognized
as assets or liabilities in the statement of financial condition because they do not
satisfy the criteria for recognition as an asset or a liability. In particular, the
expectation that future economic benefits will flow to or from a cooperative must be
sufficiently certain to meet the probability criterion before an asset or liability is
recognized.
4.1 Assets
The future economic benefit of an asset is its potential to contribute, directly or indirectly,
to the flow of cash and cash equivalents to the cooperative. Those cash flows may come
from using the asset or from disposing of it.
Many assets, for example property, plant and equipment, have a physical form. However,
physical form is not essential to the existence of an asset. Some assets are intangible.
In determining the existence of an asset, the right of ownership is not essential. Thus, for
example, property held on a lease is an asset if the cooperative controls the benefits that
are expected to flow from the property.
4.2 Liabilities
An essential characteristic of a liability is that the cooperative has a present obligation to
act or perform in a particular way. The obligation may be either a legal obligation or a
constructive obligation. A legal obligation is legally enforceable as a consequence of a
binding contract or statutory requirement. A constructive obligation is an obligation that is
derived from cooperative’s actions such as when:
(a) by an established pattern of past practice, published policies or a sufficiently specific
current statement, the cooperative has indicated to other parties that it will accept particular
responsibilities, and
(b) as a result, the cooperative has created a valid expectation on the part of those other
parties that it will discharge those responsibilities.
Page 83 of 108
The settlement of a present obligation usually involves the payment of cash, transfer of
other assets, provision of services, the replacement of that obligation with another
obligation, or conversion of the obligation to equity. An obligation may also be extinguished
by other means, such as a creditor waiving or forfeiting its rights.
4.3 Equity
Equity is the residual of recognized assets minus recognized liabilities. It is classified in the
statement of financial condition as Members’ Equity, Statutory Funds, Donations and
Grants, and Revaluation Surplus.
Section 5. Performance
Performance is the relationship of the income and expenses of a cooperative during a
reporting period. Profits or losses are frequently used as measures of performance or as
the basis for other measures, such as return on investment. Income and expenses are
defined as follows:
(a) Income is increases in economic benefits during the reporting period in the form
of inflows or enhancements of assets or decreases of liabilities that result in
increases in equity, other than those relating to contributions from members and
donations.
(b) Expenses are decreases in economic benefits during the reporting period in the
form of outflows or depletions of assets or incurrence of liabilities that result in
decreases in equity, other than those relating to distributions to equity investors.
The recognition of income and expenses results directly from the recognition and
measurement of assets and liabilities.
5.1 Income
The definition of income encompasses both revenue and gains.
(a) Revenue is income that arises in the course of the ordinary activities of a cooperative
and is referred to by a variety of names including sales, service income, commission,
interest, dividends, royalties and rent.
(b) Gains are other items that meet the definition of income but are not revenue. When
gains are recognized in the statement of operation, they are usually displayed separately
because knowledge of them is useful for making performance economic decisions.
Page 84 of 108
5.2 Expenses
The definition of expenses encompasses losses as well as those expenses that arise in
the course of the ordinary activities of the cooperative.
(a) Expenses that arise in the course of the ordinary activities of the cooperative include,
for example, cost of sales, wages and depreciation. They usually take the form of an
outflow or depletion of assets such as cash and cash equivalents, inventory, or property,
plant and equipment.
(b) Losses are other items that meet the definition of expenses and may arise in the course
of the ordinary activities of the cooperative. When losses are recognized in the statement
of operations, they are usually presented separately because knowledge of them is useful
for making economic decisions.
Page 85 of 108
other cases it must be estimated. The use of reasonable estimates is an essential part of
the preparation of financial statements and does not undermine their reliability. When a
reasonable estimate cannot be made, the item is not recognized in the financial
statements.
An item that fails to meet the recognition criteria may qualify for recognition at a later date
as a result of subsequent circumstances or events.
An item that fails to meet the criteria for recognition may nonetheless warrant disclosure in
the notes or explanatory material or in supplementary schedules. This is appropriate when
knowledge of the item is relevant to the evaluation of the financial condition, performance
and changes in financial condition of a cooperative by the users of financial statements.
Page 86 of 108
accrual basis, items are recognized as assets, liabilities, equity, income or expenses when
they satisfy the definitions and recognition criteria for those items.
Allowance for probable losses on receivables shall be based on the past due amount using
portfolio at risk for purposes of prudence in financial reporting.
Page 87 of 108
operations when an increase in future economic benefits related to an increase in
an asset or a decrease of a liability has arisen that can be measured reliably.
This applies to all accounts, except for cooperatives with lending operations, where
interest income is recognized only when earned and received during the period.
9.4 Expenses
The recognition of expenses results directly from the recognition and measurement
of assets and liabilities. A cooperative shall recognize expenses in the statement of
operations when a decrease in future economic benefits related to a decrease in an
asset or an increase of a liability has arisen that can be measured reliably.
9.5 Profit or loss
Profit or loss is the arithmetical difference between income and expenses. Profit or
loss, as used in this framework, is a general term that refers to net surplus or loss
of a cooperative. It is not a separate element of financial statements, and a separate
recognition principle is not needed for it.
Unless otherwise provided, this framework does not allow the recognition of items
in the statement of financial condition that do not meet the definition of assets or of
liabilities regardless of whether they result from applying the notion commonly
referred to as the ‘matching concept’ for measuring profit or loss.
Page 88 of 108
(c) A cooperative recognizes an impairment loss relating to non-financial assets that
are in use or held for sale.
(d) A cooperative measures investment in listed securities at fair value.
Measurement of assets at those lower amounts is intended to ensure that an asset
is not measured at an amount greater than the cooperative expects to recover from
the sale or use of that asset.
11.2 Liabilities other than financial liabilities
Most liabilities other than financial liabilities are measured at the best estimate of
the amount that would be required to settle the obligation at the reporting date.
A cooperative shall not offset assets and liabilities, or income and expenses, unless
required or permitted by this framework.
(a) Measuring assets net of valuation allowances—for example, allowance for inventory
obsolescence and allowance for probable losses on receivables—is not offsetting.
(b) If a cooperative’s normal operating activities do not include buying and selling non-
current assets, including investments and operating assets, then the cooperative reports
gains and losses on disposal of such assets by deducting from the proceeds on disposal
the carrying amount of the asset and related selling expenses.
CHAPTER III
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS PRESENTATION
Section 1. Scope
This Chapter explains fair presentation of financial statements, what compliance with this
framework requires, and what a complete set of financial statements is.
Page 89 of 108
The application of this framework with additional disclosure when necessary is presumed
to result in financial statements that achieve a fair presentation of the financial condition,
financial performance and cash flows of cooperatives. The additional disclosures are
necessary when compliance with the specific requirements in this framework is insufficient
to enable users to understand the effect of particular transactions and events on the
cooperative’s financial condition and financial performance.
Page 90 of 108
Section 6. Consistency of presentation
A cooperative shall retain the presentation and classification of items in the financial
statements from one period to the next unless:
(a) it is apparent, following a significant change in the nature of the cooperative’s operations
or a review of its financial statements, that another presentation or classification would be
more appropriate having regard to the criteria for the selection and application of
accounting policies in Chapter IX Accounting Policies, Estimates and Errors, or
(b) this framework requires a change in presentation.
When the presentation or classification of items in the financial statements is changed, a
cooperative shall reclassify comparative amounts unless the reclassification is
impracticable. When comparative amounts are reclassified, a cooperative shall disclose
the following:
(a) the nature of the reclassification.
(b) the amount of each item or class of items that is reclassified.
(c) the reason for the reclassification.
If it is impracticable to reclassify comparative amounts, a cooperative shall disclose why
reclassification was not practicable.
Page 91 of 108
surrounding circumstances. The size or nature of the item, or a combination of both, could
be the determining factor.
Page 92 of 108
(a) Registration number
(b) Date of Registration.
(c) The address of its registered office (or principal place of business, if different
from the registered office )
(d) A description of the nature of the cooperative’s operations and its principal
activities.
(e) Area of Operations
CHAPTER IV
STATEMENT OF FINANCIAL CONDITION
Section 1. Scope
This section sets out the information that is to be presented in a statement of financial
condition and how to present it. The statement of financial condition presents a
cooperative’s assets, liabilities and equity as of a specific date—the end of the reporting
period. Information to be presented in the statement of financial condition:
As a minimum, the statement of financial condition shall include line items that present the
following amounts:
(a) Cash and Cash Equivalents
(b) Loans and Receivables
(c) Financial Assets (excluding amounts shown under (a) , (b) , (i) (j) and
(d) Inventories
(e) Property, Plant and Equipment
(f) Investment Property
(g) Intangible Assets
(h) Biological assets
(i) Investments in Associates
(j) Investments in Joint Ventures
(k) Investments in Subsidiaries
(l) Trade and Other Payables
(m) Interest on Share Capital Payable
Page 93 of 108
(n) Patronage Refund Payable
(o) Due to Unions and Federations (CETF)
(p) Financial Liabilities (excluding amounts shown under
(l) (m) (n) (o) and (s)
(q) Liabilities and Assets for current tax (if applicable)
(r) Deferred Tax Liabilities and Deferred Tax Assets (if applicable)
(s) Provisions
(t) Members’ Equity
(u) Donations and Grants
(v) Statutory Funds (Reserve Fund, Education & Training Fund, Optional
Fund and Community Development Fund)
(w) Revaluation Surplus
A cooperative shall present additional line items, headings and subtotals in the statement
of financial condition when such presentation is relevant to an understanding of the
cooperative’s financial condition.
Page 94 of 108
A cooperative shall classify all other assets as non-current. When the cooperative’s
normal operating cycle is not clearly identifiable, its duration is assumed to be twelve
months.
2.2 Current liabilities
A cooperative shall classify a liability as current when:
(a) it expects to settle the liability in the normal operating cycle;
(b) it holds the liability primarily for the purpose of trading;
(c) the liability is due to be settled within twelve months after the reporting
date; or
(d) the cooperative does not have an unconditional right to defer settlement
of the liability for at least twelve months after reporting date.
A cooperative shall classify all other liabilities as non-current.
Page 95 of 108
Section 4. Information to be presented either in the statement of financial condition
or in the notes
4.1 A cooperative shall disclose in the notes, the following sub-classifications of
the line items presented:
(a) Property, Plant and Equipment in classifications appropriate to the cooperative.
(b) Loans and receivables showing separately loans receivables, trade
receivables, amount due from related parties and other receivables. Disclosure
shall also present current, past due, restructured and in litigation using Portfolio at
Risk.
(c) Inventories, showing separately amounts of inventories:
(i) held for sale in the ordinary course of business.
(ii) in the process of production for such sale.
(iii) in the form of materials or supplies to be consumed in the production process
or in the rendering of services.
(d) Trade and Other Payables, showing separately amounts payable to trade
suppliers, payable to related parties, deferred income and accruals.
(e) Provisions for employee benefits and other provisions.
4.2 A cooperative shall disclose the following, either in the statement of financial
condition or in the notes:
(a) for each class of share capital:
(i) the number of shares authorized;
(ii) the number of shares subscribed;
(iii) the number of shares issued and fully paid;
(iv) par value per share;
(v) a reconciliation of the number of shares issued at the beginning and at the end
of the period;
(vi) treasury shares
(b) a description of each statutory fund within the equity.
(c) a description of each donation including the donor, amount, and condition of
donations.
(d) details of the revaluation surplus including additions to and charges made
Page 96 of 108
4.3 If, at the reporting date, a cooperative has a binding sale agreement for a
major disposal of assets, or a group of assets and liabilities, the cooperative shall
disclose the following information:
(a) a description of the asset(s) or the group of assets and liabilities.
(b) a description of the facts and circumstances of the sale or plan.
(c) the carrying amount of the assets or, if the disposal involves a group of assets
and liabilities, the carrying amounts of those assets and liabilities.
4.4 The Allocation of Net Surplus shall be presented in the Statement of
Operations in accordance with the provisions of the cooperative by-laws which
should be consistent with Articles 85 and 86 of RA 9520 (Cooperative Code) . The
balance of each of the statutory funds after allocation shall be incorporated in the
presentation of the Statement of Financial Condition for the year then ended.
CHAPTER V
STATEMENT OF OPERATIONS
Section 1. Scope
This Chapter requires a cooperative to present its financial performance for the period. It
sets out the information that is to be presented in the statement and how to present it.
Page 97 of 108
(g) Tax expense, if applicable
(h) Allocation of Net Surplus
A cooperative shall present additional line items, headings and subtotals in the statement
of operations, when such presentation is relevant to an understanding of the cooperative’s
financial performance.
Page 98 of 108
CHAPTER VI
STATEMENT OF CHANGES IN EQUITY
Section 1. Scope
This Chapter sets out requirements for presenting the changes in equity for a period in a
statement of changes in equity.
CHAPTER VII
STATEMENT OF CASH FLOWS
Section 1. Scope
This Chapter sets out the information that is to be presented in a statement of cash flows
and how to present it. The statement of cash flows provides information about the changes
in cash and cash equivalents of a cooperative for a reporting period, showing separately
changes from operating activities, investing activities and financing activities.
Page 99 of 108
Section 2. Cash equivalents
Cash equivalents are short-term, highly liquid investments held to meet short-term cash
commitments rather than for investment or other purposes. Therefore, an investment
normally qualifies as a cash equivalent only when it has a short maturity of, say, three
months or less from the date of acquisition.
Section 3. Information to be presented in the statement of cash flows
A cooperative shall present a statement of cash flows that presents movements in cash
and cash equivalent for a reporting period classified into operating activities, investing
activities and financing activities.
3.1 Operating activities
Operating activities are the principal revenue-producing activities of the cooperative.
Therefore, cash flows from operating activities generally result from the transactions
and other events and conditions that enter into the determination of profit or loss
(surplus or loss) . Examples of cash flows from operating activities are:
(a) cash receipts from: (1) sale of goods, (2) interest, penalties and other charges
on loans receivables, and (3) rendering of services
(b) cash receipts from royalties, fees, commissions and other revenue.
(c) cash payments to suppliers for goods and services.
(d) cash payments to and on behalf of employees.
(e) cash payments for income tax (if applicable)
(f) cash receipts and payments from investments, loans and other contracts held for
dealing or trading purposes, which are similar to inventory acquired specifically for
resale.
Some transactions, such as the sale of an item of property, plant and equipment,
may give rise to gain or loss that is included in profit or loss. However, the cash
flows relating to such transactions are cash flows from investing activities.
3.2. Investing activities
Investing activities are the acquisition and disposal of long-term assets and other
investments not included in cash equivalents. Examples of cash flows arising from
investing activities are:
CHAPTER VIII
NOTES TO THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
Section 1. Scope
This Chapter sets out the principles underlying information that is to be presented in the
notes to the financial statements and how to present them. Notes contain information in
addition to that presented in the statement of financial condition, statement of operations,
statement of changes in equity, and statement of cash flows. Notes provide narrative
descriptions or disaggregation of items presented in those statements and information
about items that do not qualify for recognition in those statements. In addition to the
requirements of this section, nearly every other section of this framework requires
disclosures that are normally presented in the notes.
--------------------------------------
Required Activity.
▪ Be able to secure a cooperative’s financial report (FR) and familiarize yourself with
the different FRs and assess in relation to the Memorandum Circular presented in
the lesson. Be able to discuss in the scheduled synchronous online class session
for this purpose.
NOTE: Midterm & final examination will be administered in g-form in reference to the
university calendar.
Reference:
Asian Development Bank, Australian Aid. 2003. Tool Kit on Gender Equality Results and
Indicators, Published in 2013. Printed in the Philippines. ISBN 978-92-9254-337-2 (Print), 978-92-
9254-338-9 (PDF) Publication Stock No. TIM135772 Cataloging-In-Publication Data Asian
Development Bank. Tool kit on gender equality results and indicators. Mandaluyong City, Philippines:
Asian Development Bank, 2013
Azad, Nandini Dr. 2017. The Independent Commission for People’s Rights and Development
(ICPRD) New Delhi 3 Acknowledgement “Gender is more than a statistic”.
Chris B. Murphy. Updated March 31, 2020. A practical guide to social audit as a participatory tool
to strengthen democratic governance, transparency, and accountability. Reviewed by Gordon Scott.
Investopia. https://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/social-audit.asp. Retrieved
https://www.local2030.org/library/112/A-practical-guide-to-Social-Audit-as-a-Participatory-Tool-to-
Strengthen-Democratic-Governance,-Transparency,-and-Accountability.pdf
Fisic, Ivana, December 21, 2021, Why and how to create performance standards in an organization (plus
examples), https://clockify.me/blog/business/performance-standard, Retrieved March 10, 2022.
(Ivana Fisic is a time management researcher and writer. She has always been passionate about
writing, which is why she has finished her BA in Journalism, at the Faculty of Philosophy, Novi Sad.
Ivana is always exploring the new methods of how time management can help you organize your
workflow more effectively, as well as how you can increase your productivity).
Global Campaign for Education. Web Post. 2020 March 8. An equal world is an enabled
world’. Category: News, Press Release. https://campaignforeducation.org/en/2020/03/08/an-equal-
world-is-an-enabled-world/?gclid=Cj0KCQjwz7uRBhDRARIsAFqjullDH-
vcqi18cFtYlIp270XorbilRSissfXYCkulyHH84VFVcs9DfHkaAvVrEALw_wcB. Retrieved March 15,
2022.
International Labour Organization. 2015. Advancing gender equality: The co-operative way First
published 2015 Publications of the International Labour Office. ISBN 978-92-2-130017-5 (print) ISBN
978-92-2-130018-2 (web pdf) International Labour Office Enterprises Dept. ISBN 978-92-2-130017-5
(print) ISBN 978-92-2-130018-2 (web pdf) International Labour Office Enterprises Dept.
Khan, Prabbiot R. & Nikore Mitali. 2021. Data Driven Female Leadership is Key to Recovering
from COVID-19. Asian Development Bank 2022.
https://www.google.com/search?q=gender+equality+in+the+philippines. Retrieved March 15, 2022.
Limocon, Ma. Elena C. Vice Chairperson, International Co-operative Alliance’s Asia Pacific
Tardi, Carla. Updated September 20, 2021. Performance Management. Reviewed by David
Kindness. https://www.investopedia.com/terms/p/performance-management.asp.
Retrieved March 10, 2022.