Pleading
Pleading
Pleading
Pleading:
Pleadings are statements in writing of each party containing contentions
“arguments” of such party and detail of his case. Pleading is defined in Order (6)
Rule (1) of Code of Civil Procedure as plaint or written statement.
Object of Pleading:
The object of Pleading is to bring parties to an issue and the purpose of the rules
relating to Pleading is to prevent the issue being enlarged. Further that the
parties themselves know what the matters in dispute are and what facts they
have to prove at the trial.
Purpose of Pleading:
Purpose of pleadings was to led the other party to know as to what case it had
to meet as well as the facts which parties were to prove or establish the cause
of action or the defendants to establish their defence.
(2017 YLR Notes Karachi 205).
Importance of Pleading:
Importance of the pleadings and its legal value and significance could be
evaluated and gauged from the fact that it was primarily on the basis thereon
that the issues were framed.
(2015 SCMR 1698)
What Should a Pleading contain?
Every Pleading shall contain and contain only, a statement in concise form of the
material facts, on which the party Pleading (plaintiff or defendant) relies for his
claim or defence, as the case may be. It shall not contain the evidence by which
they are to be proved, and it shall, when necessary, be divided into paragraphs,
numbered consecutively. Dates, sums and numbers shall be expressed in
figures.
General Rules of Pleading:
In Civil Procedure Code Order (6), deals with Pleadings in general, Order (7),
deals with plaint, and Order (8), deals with written statement. The following is
the summary of the Rules comprised in Orders 6, 7 and 8 of CPC:
1. In Pleading A pleading must state facts and not law.
2. In Pleading state facts and not law, if any matter of law is set out in your
opponent’s Pleading do not plead to it.
3. In Pleading state only, the relevant facts on which you rely, and not the
evidence by which those facts are to be proved.
4. In pleading state material facts only and omit immaterial and unnecessary
facts, and do not plead to any matter which is not alleged against you.
5. In Pleading state, the facts of case concisely, but with precision.
6. it is not necessary to set-out the whole or any part of document, unless
the precise words thereof are necessary. It is sufficient to state the effect
of document as briefly as possible.
7. It is not necessary to allege any matter of fact which the law presumes in
your favour or as to which the burden of proof lies upon your opponent
party.
The party should not plead conclusion of law in pleading. Legal pleas, such as
Estoppel, Limitation, and Resjudicata/Res-subjudice, etc may be pleaded in
written statement.
In cases where the party Pleading relies on any misrepresentation, fraud, breach
of trust, willful default or undue influence, particulars thereof shall be stated in
the Pleading.
Case Law on Pleadings
• 2022 PLD SC 99 MUHAMMAD NAEEM KHAN vs. MUQADAS KHAN
No party can lead evidence beyond the pleadings.
• 2022 PLC(CS) 866 ISLAMABAD HOMOEOPATHIC DOCTOR PERVEIZ
AKHTER QURESHI vs. GOVERNMENT OF PAKISTAN through Secretary
Ministry of Health
Parties are bound by their pleadings and cannot urge to the contrary at the
hearing.
• 2021 SCMR 642 SADDARUDDIN vs. SULTAN KHAN
• 2022 PLD 51 QUETTA BAHADUR KHAN vs. KARIM GUL
• 2022 MLD 563 QUETTA Syed GULISTAN Vs. GULAB KHAN
• 2022 CLC 1203 KARACHI DANISH AZHAR vs. The CONSUMER
PROTECTION COURT (SOUTH), KARACHI