A Systematic Approach
A Systematic Approach
Abstract. The algebraic properties of a group can be explored through the relationship among
its elements. In this paper, we define the graph that establishes a systematic relationship among
the group elements. Let G be a finite group, the order product prime graph of a group G, is a
graph having the elements of G as its vertices and two vertices are adjacent if and only if the
product of their order is a prime power. We give the general presentation for the graph on dihedral
groups and cyclic groups and classify finite dihedral groups and cyclic groups in terms of the order
product prime graph as one of connected, complete, regular and planar. We also obtained some
invariants of the graph such as its diameter, girth, independent number and the clique number.
Furthermore, we used the vertex-cut of the graph in determining the nilpotency status of dihedral
group. The graph on dihedral group is proven to be regular and complete only if the degree of
the corresponding group is even prime power and connected for all prime power degree. It is also
proven on cyclic group to be both regular, complete and connected if the group has prime power
order. Additionally, the result turn out to show that any dihedral group whose order product prime
graph’s vertex-cut is greater than one is nilpotent. We also show that the order product prime
graph is planar only when the degree of the group is three for dihedral group and less than five for
cyclic group. Our final result shows that the order product prime graphs of any two isomorphic
groups are isomophic.
2020 Mathematics Subject Classifications: 05C25, 20F65
Key Words and Phrases: Order product prime graph, Vertex adjacency, Graph invariant,
Nilpotency of a group
1. Introduction
http://www.ejpam.com 84
c 2020 EJPAM All rights reserved.
M. Bello, N. M. Mohd Ali, N. Zulkifli / Eur. J. Pure Appl. Math, 13 (1) (2020), 84-95 85
In this section, we give some basic concepts, notations and preliminaries useful to this
paper.
All groups considered in this paper are finite and the investigation covered all dihedral
groups Dn = {a, b|an = b2 = (ab)2 = e} and cyclic groups Zn =< g > 3 g ∈ Zn . We
denoted the identity of a group G by e.
M. Bello, N. M. Mohd Ali, N. Zulkifli / Eur. J. Pure Appl. Math, 13 (1) (2020), 84-95 86
On the other hand, we consider simple undirected graphs without loop or multiple edges.
The sets of vertices and edges of a graph Γ are denoted by V (Γ) and E(Γ) respectively.
We denote the adjacency of vertices x, y by x ∼ y, number of vertices of the graph Γ
by |V (Γ)|, the degree of the vertex v by deg(v). A graph Γ is regular if all the ver-
tices of the graph have the same degree, that is if for all vertices v1 , v2 , ..., vn of Γ,
deg(v1 ) = deg(v2 ) = ... = deg(vn ) and a graph Γ is r-regular if deg(vi ) = r, i ∈ N.
A graph Γ is connected if there is a path between every pair of its vertices, and a graph
is complete if there is an edge between every pair of its vertices. A graph is planar if
it can be drawn in a plane without edge crossing. A clique is a subset U of vertices of
Γ such that the induced subgraph of U is a complete graph, the size of the maximum
such clique is refered to as the clique number of Γ and denoted by ω(Γ). An independent
set of vertices of a graph is the set of vertices such that no two vertices are adjacent,
and the independent number of a graph Γ, is the cardinality of the largest independent
set, which is denoted by α(Γ). The girth of a graph Γ, is the length of the shortest cy-
cle contained in the graph, which is ∞ if Γ has no cycle. The diameter of a graph is the
maximum distance between the pair of its vertices, which is ∞ if the graph is disconnected.
In this section, we give the formal definition of the order product prime graph and the
general presentation for its connectivity, completeness, regularity and planarity on dihedral
group and cyclic group, which help in obtaining its diameter, girth, independent number,
and the clique number. We also use the graph properties to obtain the corresponding group
properties.
The formal definition of the order product prime graph is given in Definition 1 below,
followed by an example which demonstrate the definition.
Definition 1. Let G be a finite group, the order product prime graph of G, Γopp (G) is a
graph whose vertices are the elements of G and two vertices x, y are adjacent if and only
if |x||y| = pα , α ∈ N, for some prime p .
Example 1. Consider the dihedral group of degree three which is D3 = {e, a, a2 , b, ab, a2 b}.
|e| = 1, |a| = |a2 | = 3, |b| = |ab| = |a2 b| = 2, then, there are two cliques which are the
rotations {a, a2 } and the reflections {b, ab, a2 b}, all adjacent to e. Therefore Γopp (D3 ) =
K1 + (K2 ∪ K3 ) and is given in Figure 1
M. Bello, N. M. Mohd Ali, N. Zulkifli / Eur. J. Pure Appl. Math, 13 (1) (2020), 84-95 87
The general presentation for the order product prime graph on dihedral group and
cyclic group are given in Theorem 1 to Theorem 3.
Theorem 1. Let G be the dihedral group, Dn , where n = pα , α ∈ N, then
(
opp
K2n if p = 2,
Γ (G) =
K1 + (Kn−1 ∪ Kn ) if p 6= 2.
Proof : If p = 2, then |G| = 2α+1 , pick arbitrary xi , yj ∈ G, i 6= j, then |x| 2α+1 , |y| 2α+1 ,
that is |x||y| = 2t , 1 ≤ t ≤ α. Since any element of G is of order 2t , it follows that all the
elements of G form single clique. Therefore Γopp (G) = K2α+1 = K2n .
If p 6= 2, then |G| = 2pα . Let A and B are the sets of non-trivial rotations and the
t
reflections of G respectively. pick x ∈ A, y ∈ B, then xp = e = y 2 . Now by the vertex
adjacency, A and B are distinct cliques in Γopp (G) and |(A)| = pα − 1, |(B)| = pα , then
Γopp (A) = Kpα −1 , Γopp (B) = Kpα are subgraphs of Γopp (G). So by the vertex adjacency,
a ∼ e ∼ b, therefore
Γopp (G) = Γopp (e) + Γopp (A) ∪ Γopp (B) = K1 + (Kpα −1 ∪ Kpα )
= k1 + (Kn−1 ∪ Kn )
Qd
Theorem 2. Let G be a dihedral group, Dn , where n = i=1 pαi i , then
Sd S S
K1 + i=2 K(pi i −1)
α Kn+pα1 −1 )
1
K n+d−(1+Pd pαi ) where p1 = 2,
i=1 i
Γopp (G) =
K + Sd K α S
1 i=1 (p i −1) ∪ Kn i
K n+d−(1+Pd pαi ) if n is odd,
i=1 i
d−1
[ [ [
opp
Γ (G) = K1 + K(pαi −1) Kn+2α1 −1 ) I
i
i=1
d−1
[ [ [
= K1 + K α
(pi i −1) K n+2α1 −1 ) K n+d−(1+Pd α
pi i )
i=1
i=1
If n is odd, then Z(G) is trivial and therefore each prime generate distinct clique. So
d
[ [
opp
Γ (G) = K1 + K α
(pi i −1) ∪ Kn I
i=1
[d [
= K1 + K(pαi −1) ∪ Kn K n+d−(1+Pd α
pi i )
i i=1
i=1
Theorem 3. Let G be a cyclic group, Zn , then
Kpα if n = pα ,
opp
Γ (G) =
K1 + di=1 K(pαi −1) K
S S Qd αi
n+d−(1+ d
P αi if n = i=1 pi ,
i i=1 pi )
Γopp (G) ∼
= Γopp (R)
d
[ [
= K1 + K(pαi −1) K n+d−(1+Pd α
pi i )
i i=1
i=1
The connectivity, regularity and completeness of the order product prime graph on
dihedral group and cyclic group is given in Theorem 4 and Theorem 5 below;
M. Bello, N. M. Mohd Ali, N. Zulkifli / Eur. J. Pure Appl. Math, 13 (1) (2020), 84-95 89
Theorem 4. Let G be a dihedral group, Dn , then Γopp (G) is regular and complete only if
n = 2α and connected only if n = pα , ∀ p.
Proof : We prove the theorem by considering the degree of the group in two cases below.
Case 1: If n = 2α , then |G| = 2α+1 and so all the elements of G are powers of 2, they
therefore form single clique in Γopp (G). Therefore Γopp (G) is complete since for each pair
(xi , xj ) ∈ G, xi ∼ xj , i 6= j, hence the graph is also connected and regular by the vertex
adjacency.
If n = pα , p 6= 2, then |G| = 2pα so we only have the elements of order 2 and pα but
0
not 2pα since G is not cyclic. Let R and R be the sets of non-trivial rotations and the
0
reflections of G respectively, then R and R are distinct cliques and |R| = n − 1 while
0 0
|R | = n, hence deg(xi ) < deg(yi ) ∀ xi ∈ R, yi ∈ R since n − 1 < n, therefore Γopp (G) is
not regular and also not complete since xi yi ∀i. But xi ∼ e ∼ yi , that is each element
0
of R is reachable from Q any element of R through e, therefore Γopp (G) is connected.
Case 2: Suppose n = di=1 pαi i , then we have total number of d distinct primes and each
prime generate a subgroup which is non-trivial complete clique of order pαi i . Also there
exist some elements of order di=1 pαi i which are the isolated vertices of the graph by defi-
Q
α Qd αi
p i p
nition. Let gi , gj ∈ G 3 = e = gi i=1 i , then
gi i
opp
gi gj , therefore Γ (G) is not complete and hence not regular. The fact that gi are
isolated vertices shows that the graph is not connected.
Theorem 5. Let G be a cyclic group, Zn , then Γopp (G) is regular, complete and connected
only if n = pα .
Proof : Suppose n = pα , then by Theorem 3, Γopp (G) is complete and henceQregular and
d α
p i
connected. On the other hand, if n = di=1 pαi i , then there exist x ∈ G 3 xi i=1 i = e,
Q
x is therefore an isolated vertex, hence Γopp (G) is not connected, not complete and not
αi
regular by definition since there is another element y ∈ G 3 y pi = e, then deg(y) <
deg(x)
The planarity of the order product prime graph on dihedral group and cyclic group is
given in Proposition 1 and Proposition 2 below;
Proof : By Theorem 1, the size of the maximum clique is n + 1, so the result follows since,
the maximum complete subgraph is less than K5
Proof : Observe from Theorem 3 and the above hypothesis that, if n = pα , then the max-
imum complete component is less than K5 and so Γopp (G) is planar, since the size of the
maximum clique Qd is |G| = pα .
αi
Suppose n = i=1 pi , then still by Theorem 3, the maximum complete component ≯ K3
since pαi i < 5 and therefore planar.
We start the investigation of the invariants for the order product prime graph. The
investigation begins with the diameter of the graph on dihedral group which is given in
Propositions 3.
Proof : If n = 2α , then by Theorem 4, Γopp (G) is complete, and therefore each of its
vertices is central, hence diam(Γopp (G)) = 1.
Suppose n = pα , p 6= 2, then recall that by definition, the vertices of Γopp (G) are the ele-
α
ments of G, and |G| = 2pα . So pick x, y ∈ G, 3 xp = e = y 2 , then the maximum distance
between pair of vertices of Γopp (G) occur between the vertices x and y, but x ∼ e ∼ y,
the distance to reach x from y is 2, hence diam(Γopp (G)) = 2.
that is Q
If n = di=1 pαi i , then by Theorem 4, Γopp (G) is disconnected and hence
diam(Γopp (G)) = ∞
The diameter of the order product prime graph for cyclic groups are given in Proposition
4.
1 if n = pα ,
(
opp
diam(Γ (G)) =
∞ if n = di=1 pαi i .
Q
Proof : If n = pα , then by Theorem 5, Γopp (G) is complete and so each vertex is central,
opp (G)) = 1.
Qddiam(Γ
therefore
αi
If n = i=1 pi , then still by Theorem 5, Γopp (G) is disconnected and so
diam(Γopp (G)) = ∞
The girth of the order product prime graph of the dihedral group and the cyclic group
is given in Proposition 5 and Proposition 6.
Proposition 5. Let G be the dihedral group, Dn , then girth(Γopp (G)) = 3, for all n.
M. Bello, N. M. Mohd Ali, N. Zulkifli / Eur. J. Pure Appl. Math, 13 (1) (2020), 84-95 91
Proof : Since |G| = pα , then all g1 , g2 , ..., gpα form single clique in Γopp (G) since Γopp (G) is
complete by Theorem 5. That is Γopp (G) contains triangle and hence girth(Γopp (G)) = 3.
If p = 2, α = 1, then |G| = 2, hence Γopp (G) is triangle free, infact has no any cycle,
therefore girth(Γopp (G)) = ∞
The clique number for the order product prime graph on dihedral group and cyclic
groups is given in Proposition 7 and Proposition 8.
if n = 2α ,
2n
ω(Γopp (G)) = (n + 1) if n = pα or n = di=1 pαi i , where n is odd in each case,
Q
(n + 2α ) if n = di=1 pαi , where n is even.
Q
Proof : If n = 2α , then by Theorem 1, Γopp (G) = K2n and is complete by Theorem 4 with
2n vertices, hence ω(Γ opp (G)) = 2n.
d
Suppose n = pα or i=1 pαi i , n odd, then by Theorem 2, the size of the maximum clique
Q
is n + 1.
QdTherefore ω(Γopp (G)) = n + 1.
If n = i=1 pαi , n even, then by Theorem 2, the size of the maximum clique is
(n + 2α ), so ω(Γopp (G)) = (n + 2α )
n if n = pα ,
(
opp
ω(Γ (G)) =
max pαi i if n = di=1 pαi i .
Q
Proof : If n = pα , then Γopp (G) is complete by Theorem 5, hence all the elements of
Γopp (G) form a single clique and therefore ω(Γopp (G)) = |G| = n. Q
t t d αi
Suppose n = di=1 pαi i . Pick x, y ∈ Γopp (G) 3 xp1 = e = y p2 and h i=1 pi = e, 1 ≤ t ≤ d,
Q
M. Bello, N. M. Mohd Ali, N. Zulkifli / Eur. J. Pure Appl. Math, 13 (1) (2020), 84-95 92
then h is an isolated vertex and the maximum clique size is the biggest among pαi i , there-
fore ω(Γopp (G)) = max pαi i .
In Proposition 9 and Proposition 10, we give the independent number of the order
product prime graphs for dihedral group and cyclic group.
1 if n = 2α ,
2 if n = pα p 6= 2 ,
opp
α(Γ (G)) =
n + 2d − (1 + di=1 pαi i ) if n = di=1 pαi i is even,
P Q
n + 2d + di=1 pαi i if n = di=1 pαi i is odd.
P Q
1 if n = pα ,
(
opp
α(Γ (G)) =
n + 2d − (1 + di=1 pαi i ) if n = di=1 pαi i .
P Q
Proof : If n = pα , then by Theorem 5, Γopp (G) is complete and so all the vertices are
central,Qtherefore α(Γopp (G)) = 1.
If n = di=1 pαi i , then by Theorem 3, the size of the maximum independent set is n + 2d −
(1 + di=1 pαi i ) = α(Γopp (G))
P
The strength for the connectivity of the order product prime graph of dihedral and
cyclic groups is determined in Theorem 6 to Theorem 8. This strength has been deter-
mined by the vertex-cut of the graphs.
Theorem
Qd 6. αLet G be a dihedral group, Dn or cyclic group, Zn , then Γopp (G) is 0-connected
if n = i=1 pi i
Proof : By Theorem 4 and Theorem 5, Γopp (G) is disconnected, therefore Γopp (G) is 0-
connected
M. Bello, N. M. Mohd Ali, N. Zulkifli / Eur. J. Pure Appl. Math, 13 (1) (2020), 84-95 93
Proof : We need to show that if there exist more than 1 vertices of the graph whose all
the non-isolated vertices of the graph are adjacent to them then the group is nilpotent.
Suppose k ≥ 2, then the central vertices of Γopp (G) are greater or equals to 2. This is
only possible if Z(G) is non-trivial and the non-isolated vertices of the graph are adjacent
to Z(G) and eQsince G is a group. Qd In αthis case, we can say that G has even degree and
d αi
so n = 2 or i=1 2i . If n = i=1 2i , then Γopp (G) has one cut-vertex which is e by
α i
In Theorem 10, we give the result that shows that the order product prime graph of
any two groups are isormorphic if the two groups are isomorphic.
φ(u1 ) = φ(u2 ) ⇐⇒ u1 = u2
v1 = v2 ⇐⇒ u1 = v1 and u2 = v2
REFERENCES 94
and also the vertices ui ∈ G 3 φ(ui ) = vi ∈ H, with the condition that v1 v2 ∈ E(Γopp (H))
if u1 u2 ∈ E(Γopp (G)) since G ∼
=H
Example 2. Consider the dihedral group of degree six and symmetric group of degree three.
Let G = D6 and H = S3 , then G ∼ = H, it can be easily seen that Γopp (G) ∼
= Γopp (H) since
the isomorphism preserves the order of the elements in the groups. Observe that the cycles
of length two in S3 correspond to the reflections of D6 while the cycles of length three
corresponds to the rotations. Therefore Γopp (G) ∼
= Γopp (H).
4. Conclusion
In this paper, new graph that relates the order of the group elements by prime power is
defined and some properties of the graph which include some of its invariants, its regularity,
planarity, connectivity and the strength of the connectivity have been investigated and the
nilpotency of the graph is checked using the vertex-cut of the graph.
Acknowledgements
The first author would like to thank Federal University of Kashere (FUK) for their total
support. He also like to appreciate Universiti Teknologi Malaysia (UTM) for the financial
support of International Doctoral Fellowship (IDF). The second and third authors would
like to thank Universiti Teknologi Malaysia (UTM) for its support.
References
[1] Abd Rhani, N., Muhainiah, N. M. A., Sarmin, N. H. and Erfanian, A. On the
Domination Number and Regularity of the Relative Coprime Graph of a Group
Malaysian Journal of Fundamental and Applied Sciences, 13 (2):(2017), 72–74.
doi:10.2307/2369306 2017
[2] Arthur, C. Desiderata and suggestions: No. 2. The Theory of groups: graphical repre-
sentation American Journal of Mathematics, 1 (2):(1878), 174–6. doi:10.2307/2369306
1878
[3] Akbari, A. and Eza, M. A. Groups for which the Non-Commuting Graph is a Split
Graph International Journal of Group Theory 6(1): 29-35 2017
[6] Kakeri, F., Erfanian,A. and Mansoori, F. Generalization of the non-commuting graph
of a group via normal subgroup ScienceAsia 42(2016): 231-235 2016
REFERENCES 95
[7] Kelarev, A., Ryan, j and Yearwood, J. Cayley graphs as classifiers for data mining:
The influence of asymmetries. :Discrete Mathematics 2009 309:(2009) 5360-5369.
[8] Selvakumar, K. and Subajini, M. Classification of groups with toroidal coprime graphs.
India: Australasian Journal of Combinatorics. 2017. 69(2):(2017), 174–183
[9] Tamizh, T. C., Selvakumar, K. and Raja, S. Commuting Graphs on Dihedral groups
The Journal of Mathematics and Computer Science 2011 2(2011):402-406
[10] Sharafdini, R. and Darbandi, r. Energy of Commuting Graphs of finite groups whose
Centralizers are abelian arXiv:1704.06464v1[math.co] 2017
[11] Vahidi, j. and Asghar, A. T. The Commuting Graphs on Groups D2n , Qn . The
Journal of mathematics and Computer Science 2(2010):123-127 2010