Green Supply Chain Management Barriers & Drivers A Review

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 10

International Journal of Engineering Research & Technology (IJERT)

ISSN: 2278-0181
Vol. 2 Issue 4, April - 2013

Green Supply Chain Management - Barriers & Drivers: A Review


Kshitij Dashore, Dr. Nagendra Sohani
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Institute of Engineering and Technology,
Devi Ahilya Vishwa Vidyalaya, Indore(MP), India

Abstract:- Green Supply Chain Management (GSCM) has Automobile sector exhaust accounts for more than 75%
emerged as an important organizational philosophy to reduce of total air pollution. Automobiles are responsible for 80% of
environmental risks, but there are many Barriers as well as total CO emission, 36% of the HC’s, 44% of the NOx, 4% of
Drivers which affects directly and indirectly to the SOx and 18% of the particulate matter. Environmental
implementation of GSCM in an organization (different at management system refers to the protection of our surrounding
different levels and with respect to organization‟s level of environment and utilizing our natural resources in most efficient
development). In this paper a total number of 20 Barriers and a way. Automobiles are responsible for over 75% of total
total number of 16 Drivers are identified through extensive pollution in India. If we look for different options for protecting
literature review and expert opinion to academics. These the environment then GSCM is the most suitable and efficient
Barriers and Drivers are almost common for various one.
organizations for the adoption and implementation of GSCM in
them. GSCM is one of the best strategies for meeting the
Keywords: - Green Supply Chain Management, Barriers and challenge to reduce carbon emission and enhance sustainability
Drivers. because of its potential to improve the environmental
RRTT
performance of any organization (S. Balasubramaniam 2012).
I. INTRODUCTION Along with the rapid change in global manufacturing scenario,
environment and social issues are becoming more important and
Today, environmental pollution is the main problem compulsory in managing any business (Sunil Luthra et al. 2010).
IIJJEE

which has the potential to lead to the extinction of mankind on


earth if not addressed at this moment. Of the various kinds of GSCM is an approach to improve performance of the
pollution, air pollution is the one which needs immediate products and processes keeping in mind to the requirements of
attention. Global warming, an effect due to the increase in the environmental regulations predefined by government and
amounts of the green house gases present in air is the most aims at confining the wastes within the industrial system so that
severe problem mankind is facing at the moment. The amount of energy resources are conserved and prevent the dissipation of
carbon dioxide which was found to be roughly around 280 parts harmful materials into the environment, including all phases of
per million before industrial revolution has reached to a product’s life cycle which includes the design phase, production
proportion of 380 parts per million, and its rise has accelerated. phase and the distribution phase to the end users of the product
At present we have been adding 2 parts per million annually. It and also its disposal at the end of product’s life cycle.
was found that a rise in carbon dioxide proportions to more than
450 parts per million would lead to an increase in temperature Patrick Penfield of the Whiteman School of
up to 2 degrees centigrade which would result in faster and Management defines Green Supply Chain Management
irrevocable melting of Greenland and Antarctic ice. The (GSCM) as “the process of using environmentally friendly
increased 2 degree centigrade in atmospheric temperature will inputs and transforming these inputs into outputs that can be
lead in increase of energy consumption to achieve and maintain reclaimed and reuse at the end of their life cycles thus, creating
the temperature of human comforts. Melting of Greenland ice a sustainable supply chain 29.”
itself is expected to increase the sea level by 23 feet, which
means that the face of earth will be changed beyond recognition. GSCM as a process includes all the processes and
Without proper action, it will be merely impossible to stop at operations of a manufacturer starting from emergence of a
450 ppm. For that to happen, large scale technological and product’s concept, its design, raw material selection and
social changes instigated by financial and political inputs are extraction from the suppliers, transport facilities from suppliers
necessary (Johnny C. Ho et. al. 2009; McKibben 2007). to manufacturing plant, manufacturing
processes/methods/operations/machines, finished product to
retailers/distributors through transport facilities, then transport

www.ijert.org 2021
International Journal of Engineering Research & Technology (IJERT)
ISSN: 2278-0181
Vol. 2 Issue 4, April - 2013

to customers and also after the end of life cycle of the product – consumers as well as end-of-life management of the product
customer to disposal of the product. after its useful life‟‟.

The environmental impacts at each stage of the supply According to Rao and Holt (2005), GSCM practices
chain are minimized and focus on the utilization of energy and should cover all SC activities, from green purchasing to the
resource (of an organization) for making environmentally sound integration of life cycle management, through the manufacturer
supply chain. and customer, to closing the loop with reverse logistics. Several
green practices at the product level are described in the
It is important to integrate environmental management literature, including eco-design (Linton et al., 2007, Zhu et
practices into the entire SC in order to achieve a greener SC and al.,2008b) and design for product recyclability (Chen and Sheu
maintain competitive advantage. Accordingly, Srivastava (2007) (2009). Another practice which is commonly referred to is
defines GSCM as, „„integrating environmental thinking into reverse logistics (Srivastava, 2007).
SCM, including product design, material sourcing and selection,
manufacturing processes, delivery of the final product to the

RRTT
IIJJEE

Figure 1: Process involved in green supply chain management (Source: Ali Daibat et. al. 2011)

www.ijert.org 2022
International Journal of Engineering Research & Technology (IJERT)
ISSN: 2278-0181
Vol. 2 Issue 4, April - 2013

II. LITERATURE REVIEW Management (GSCM) practice have been identified by various
researches; they are briefly outlined in the below Table I and the
A number of authors have referred to the green supply chain different journals which were reviewed are enlisted with their
over the past decade as a result of emerging environmental respective year of publishing is outlined in the Table II.
management topics. Approaches towards Green Supply Chain

TABLE I: Concepts and models related to environmental issues have been suggested by different researchers is summarized
in the following table:

Year Title Author Description


2012 An Overview of Green Supply Chain Nimawat Dheeraj & The paper seeks out environmental performance
Management in India Namdev Vishal index (EPI) of India and four activities of the
green supply chain management; namely green
purchasing, green manufacturing, green marketing
and reverse logistics.
2012 Examining Green Production and its Tim Banies, Steve It relates and summarizes the core knowledge on
Role within the Competitive Strategy Brown, Ornella green production, aligns to production and
of Manufacturing Benedettini, Peter Ball operations management prospective.
2012 A Hierarchical Framework of Barriers Sreejith In this paper barriers are identified and then they
to Green Supply Chain Management Balasubramanian are classified as external and internal barriers to the
in the Construction Sector organization which help policy makers to focus on
specific barriers important to the adoption of
GSCM in the UAE construction sector.
2012 Modeling the Knowledge Sharing B. P. Sharma, M. D. Variables which resists knowledge sharing (KS) in
Barriers using an ISM Approach Singh and Neha the organizations are known as Knowledge Sharing
RRTT
barriers (KSBs) were identified and ISM model is
proposed showing solutions.
2011 Barriers to implement Green Supply Sunil Luthra, Vinod An industry based approach was used to develop a
IIJJEE

Chain Management in automobile Kumar & Abid structural model of the barriers to implement green
industry using Interpretive Structural Haleem supply chain management.
Modeling (ISM) Technique – An
Indian Perspective
2011 An Analysis of the Drivers Affecting Ali Diabat & Kannan A case study approach is used to identify various
the Implementation of Green Supply Govindan drivers of green supply chain management for a
Chain Management manufacturing firm.
2011 Drivers of Green Supply Chain Large, R.O. & The paper seeks to evaluate two practices – green
Management Performance: Evidence Thomsen, C.G. supplier assessment and green collaboration which
from Germany impacts purchasing department and environmental
commitment of the firm. Out of this commitment
influences green assessment directly and
environmental performance impact purchasing
performance directly.
2011 The Influence of Greening the Chiou, T.Y., Chan, The paper aims at providing empirical proofs to
Suppliers and Green Innovation on H.K., Lettice, F., & encourage companies to implement GSC and green
Environmental Performance and Chung S.H. innovation in order to improve their environmental
Competitive Advantage in Taiwan performance, and to enhance their competitive
advantage in the global market and uses Structural
Equation Modeling that verifies the significance of
the proposed relationships among the selected
variables.
2011 Sustainable Production: Practices and Xianbiag Liu, Jie A special emphasis is laid on companies’ overall
Determinant Factors of Green Supply Yang, Sixiao Qu, green supply chain practices, which is measured by

www.ijert.org 2023
International Journal of Engineering Research & Technology (IJERT)
ISSN: 2278-0181
Vol. 2 Issue 4, April - 2013
Chain Management of Chinese Leina Wang, using data from various respondents in a
Companies Tomohiro Shishime questionnaire survey.
and Cunkuan Bao
2011 Research on the Performance Yan Li The paper tries to improve the environmental
Measurement of Green Supply Chain performance by implementing a variety of GSCM
Management in China practices in additionally top level manager’s
commitment is necessary for development of any
GSCM program.
2010 Evaluating Green Supply Chain Zhu, Q., Geng, Y., The study includes a comparison between Chinese
Management among Chinese Sarkis, J., & Lai, K.H. manufacturers and Japanese manufacturers which
Manufacturers from the Ecological implies more significant improvements made in
Modernization Perspective environmental and financial performance and
additionally four other GSCM practices were
implemented.
2009 Opportunities in Green Supply Chain Jonny C. Ho, Maurice A comparison is performed between traditional and
Management K. Shalishali, Tzu- green supply chain. It includes several important
Liang Tseng and opportunities in green supply chain management,
David S. Ang including those in manufacturing, bio-waste,
construction, and packaging.
2009 An Empirical Study of Green Supply Daine Holt and Abby The paper identifies various operational activities
Chain Management Practices Ghobadian within a supply chain and also suggests the factors
Amongst UK Manufacturers which are driving these operational changes.
2008 Environmental Management System Nicole Darnall, G. The paper evaluates a relationship between
and Green Supply Chain Jason Jolley and environmental management system (EMS) and
Management: Complements for Robert Handfield green supply chain management (GSCM)
Sustainability? practices.
2008 Influences, Practices & Opportunities Raymond P.C., Lopez This paper demonstrates that opportunities exist to
for Environmental Supply Chain J., Marche S., Perron reduce greenhouse gas emissions and solid waste
Management in Nova Scotia SMEs G.M. & Wright R. within supply chains using environmental
RRTT
performance and environmental issues as working
variables.
2008 Drivers for the Participation of Small Su-Yol Lee The paper shows that buyer’s GSC practices,
IIJJEE

and Medium-Sized Suppliers in Green readiness and participation, also government


Supply Chain Initiatives support plays a vital role in motivating small and
medium-sized suppliers towards GSCM practices.
2008 Knowledge management barriers: An M. D. Singh and R. The paper identified KM barriers to the
interpretive structural modeling Kant organization and a relationship among them is
approach made, further giving solutions by using ISM
methodology.

TABLE II: Journals Reviewed for literature

Sr. No. Year of Published Journals Reviewed


1. 2012 Research Journal of Recent Sciences (Vol. 1)
2. 2012 International Conference on Information & Knowledge Management (Vol. 45)
3. 2012, 2011 Journal of Industrial Engineering and Management
4. 2012 Journal of Sustainable Development (Vol. 5)
4. 2011, 2008 Business Strategy and the Environment
5. 2011 Resources, Conservation and Recycling
6. 2011 Journal of Purchasing and Supply Management (Vol. 17)
7. 2010 Transportation Research Part E, 47
8. 2011 Journal of Sustainable Development (Vol. 4)
9. 2008 Business Strategy and the Environment
10. 2009 The Coastal Business Journal (Vol. 8)
11. 2009 Journal of Manufacturing Technology Management (Vol. 20)
12. 2008 Journal of Cleaner Production (Vol. 16)

www.ijert.org 2024
International Journal of Engineering Research & Technology (IJERT)
ISSN: 2278-0181
Vol. 2 Issue 4, April - 2013
13. 2008 International Journal of Management Science & Engineering Management
(Vol. 3)
14. 2008 Supply Chain Management: An International Journal (Vol. 13)

III. DISCUSSION OF FINDINGS treatment and long term contracts for adopting GSCM from
government, Lack of management initiatives for transport and
Concepts and models related to environmental issues logistics, Lack of energy management and waste management of
have been suggested by different researchers. Literature was the organization.
reviewed to identify barriers and drivers to implement GSCM in The common drivers to implementation of GSCM in
an industry. We have identified more than 42 various barriers various industry sectors are: Certification of suppliers’
and 30 drivers to implement GSCM in various industry sectors environmental management system, Company’s environmental
from the literature reviews, but the paper contains a total of 20 collaboration with their suppliers, Reduction and elimination of
barriers and 16 drivers which were commonly stated by product’s harmful environmental impacts by collaborating
different authors in their respected papers. between product designer and suppliers, Government regulation
The common barriers to implementation of GSCM in and legislation, like making transparent reward system for green
various industry sectors are: Lack of integration of IT system, practitioners, Green product design, Standard quality
Lack of acceptance of advancement in new technology, Poor certifications like ISO 14001, Integrating total quality
organizational culture in GSCM, Lack of skilled human environmental management into planning and operation
resource professionals in sustainability and GSCM, Uncertainty processes, Reducing energy consumption and confining wastes,
and competition in market, Lack of government initiatives Reusing and recycling materials and packaging, Environmental
system for GSCM practitioners, Poor implementation of green collaboration with customers and making them environmentally
practices within a supply chain, Lack of top level management aware, Reverse logistics and feedback system, Establishing
commitment, Cost of implementation for GSCM, Supplier’s company’s green image locally and globally, Cost of
flexibility to change towards GSCM, Customer’s unawareness environmentally friendly goods, Cost of environmentally
towards GSCM products and services, Lack of knowledge and friendly packages, Supplier’s awareness and advances in
experience, Lack of green architects, consultants, green providing environmentally friendly packages, Sharing best
developers, contractors in the region, Lack of training in GSCM, green practices.
Lack of internal sustainability audits within the organization,
Lack of external sustainability audits for suppliers and Following are the tables which conclude the Barriers
RRTT
contactors, Lack of sustainability certification like ISO 14001, (Table III) and Drivers (Table IV) for the GSCM with their
Lack of professional treatment and long term contracts for respective references.
adopting GSCM from government, Lack of professional
IIJJEE

TABLE III: Barriers for GSCM

Sr. Barrier to Implement GSCM Description Resource


No.
1. Lack of integration of IT system It uses various computer based applications Shreejith B. (2012); Gioconda Q.
programs and various IT enabled (2011); Xianbing Lui (2011); Daine Holt
procedures and software which may be o (2009); Abby Ghobadian (2009); Wu et
utility during the various data and al. (2009); AlKhidir et al. (2009); Ravi
information exchange process. et al. (2005); Mclaren et al. (2004);
Rogers et al. (1998).
2. Lack of acceptance of It emphasis on adoption of various Shreejith B. (2012); Christian B. (2011);
advancement in new technology advancement in technology to the older Jie Yang (2011); AlKhidir et al. (2009);
established technology in existing Daine Holt (2009); Hsu et al. (2008);
organization. Hosseini (2007); Digalwar et al. (2004);
TSai et al. (1999); Gant (1996); Cooper
(1994).
3. Poor organizational culture in It directs towards the participation of top Brooks W. (2011); Cunkuan Bao (2011);
GSCM level management in motivating the Abby Ghobadian (2009); Yu Lin et al.
employee. (2008); Yu Lin (2007); Hsu et al. (2008);
Chien et al. (2007); Ravi et al. (2005).
4. Lack of skilled human resource It reflects the lack of skills in human Shreejith B. (2012); Xianbing Lui
professionals in sustainability and resource department of the organization (2011); Gioconda Q. (2011); Yu Lin et

www.ijert.org 2025
International Journal of Engineering Research & Technology (IJERT)
ISSN: 2278-0181
Vol. 2 Issue 4, April - 2013
GSCM with special context to their recruitment al. (2008); Hsu et al. (2008); Chien et al.
policies and trainings in GSCM. (2007) ; Yu Lin (2007).
5. Uncertainty and competition in Market competition and uncertainty is high Jie Yang (2011); Mudgal et al. (2010);
market due to global competitiveness and varying Daine Holt (2009); Hosseini (2007); Yu
customer’s requirements. Lin (2007).
6. Lack of government initiatives It means government not making industry Shreejith B. (2012); Gioconda Q.
system for GSCM practitioners friendly policies toward GSCM and not (2011); Xianbing Lui (2011); Sunil L.
giving special benefits to those (2010); Daine Holt (2009); Abby
organizations implementing GSCM. Ghobadian (2009); Mudgal et al.
(2010); Mudgal et al. (2009); Yu Lin et
al. (2008); Hsu et al. (2008); Srivastva
(2007); Hosseini (2007); Scupola
(2003).
7. Poor implementation of green Lack of consideration of green practices Christian B. (2011); Jie Yang (2011);
practices within a supply chain like hazardous solid waste disposal, energy Daine Holt (2009); Abby Ghobadian
conservation, reusing and recycling (2009); Mudgal et al. (2009); Yu Lin et
materials etc. al. (2008); Hsu et al. (2008); Ravi et al.
(2005).

8. Lack of top level management It means top level management resisting M.D. singh (2012); Shreejith B. (2012);
commitment towards implementation of green practices. Gioconda Q. (2011); Xianbing Lui
(2011); Sunil L. (2010); Daine Holt
(2009); Abby Ghobadian (2009);
Mudgal et al. (2010); Sarkis (2009);
Mudgal et al. (2009); Zhu (2007); Ravi
V. et al. (2005); Digalwar et al. (2004).
9. Cost of implementation for It reflects to the high initial cost investment Shreejith B. (2012); Gioconda Q.
GSCM required to implement various green (2011); Xianbing Lui (2011); Sunil L.
methodologies such as green design, green (2010); Daine Holt (2009); Abby
RRTT
manufacturing, green labeling of packing Ghobadian (2009); Mudgal et al. (2009);
etc AlKhidir et al. (2009); Hosseini (2007);
Ravi et al. (2005).
10. Supplier’s flexibility to change This means suppliers unwillingness to be B.P. Sharma (2012); Shreejith B. (2012);
IIJJEE

towards GSCM involved in design process and technology, Tomohiro Shishime (2011); Sanjay K.
which affects overall performance of whole (2010); Lettice et al. (2010); Hsu et al.
chain. (2008); Kannan et al. (2008); Srivastva
(2007); Sarkar et al. (2006); Ravi et al.
(2005).
11. Customer’s unawareness towards This reflects customers do not know about B.P. Sharma (2012); Shreejith B.
GSCM products and services green products and their benefits. (2012); Tomohiro Shishime (2011);
Sanjay K. (2010); Mudgal et al. (2009);
Zhu et al. (2008); Zhu et al. (2007);
Ravi et al. (2005).
12. Lack of knowledge and Lack of knowledge and experience among Sixiao Qu. (2011); Daine H. (2009); Yu
experience the supply chain stakeholders in executing and Hui (2008); Tsai and Ghosal (1999).
GSCM.
13. Lack of green architects, Lack of green practitioners available in the Sixiao Qu. (2011); Daine H. (2009); Yu
consultants, green developers, region for an organization. and Hui (2008); Tsai and Ghosal (1999).
contractors in the region
14. Lack of training in GSCM This reflects lack of training given to the B.P. Sharma (2012); Daine H. (2009);
employee of the organization, thus resisting Yu and Hui (2008); Bowen et al. (2001);
enhancement of overall performance of Cooper et al. (2000).
supply chain and green practices in it.
15. Lack of internal sustainability It reflects integration of all internal Walker and Preuss (2008); Min and
audits within the organization departmental issues related to the Galle (2001); Wycherley (1999).
coordination for the supply chain.
16. Lack of external sustainability It reflects integration of all external Walker and Preuss (2008); Sharfma et

www.ijert.org 2026
International Journal of Engineering Research & Technology (IJERT)
ISSN: 2278-0181
Vol. 2 Issue 4, April - 2013
audits for suppliers and contactors departmental issues related to the al. (2007); Min and Galle (2001);
coordination for the supply chain. Wycherley (1999).
17. Lack of sustainability certification It refers to authenticity of quality of B.P. Sharma (2012); Shreejith B. (2012);
like ISO 14001 products and services as per pre-established
Tomohiro Shishime (2011); Sanjay K.
norms. (2010); Yu (2007); Linton et al. (2007).
18. Lack of professional treatment It shows poor government regulations and B.P. Sharma (2012); Shreejith B. (2012);
and long term contracts for support to the GSCM practitioners. Cunkuan Bao (2011); Sanjay K. (2010);
adopting GSCM from government Yu (2007); Linton et al. (2007); Carter
and Ellram (1998).
19. Lack of management initiatives It shows poor managerial management of M.D. Singh (2012); Daine Holt (2009).
for transport and logistics logistics in the organization.
20. Lack of energy management and It shows poor management of organization M.D. Singh (2012); Daine Holt (2009);
waste management of the towards its resources. Alemayche (2008); Roger and R.S.
organization (1998).

TABLE IV: Drivers for GSCM

Sr. Drivers of GSCM Description Resource


No.
1. Certification of suppliers’ Certification of suppliers for EMS ensures Gioconda Q et. al. (2011); Ali Daibat et.
environmental management organization to have environmental al. (2010);_Paulraj (2009); Zhu et al.
system friendly services from its supplier, thus (2008); Vachon (2007); Zhu et al. (2007).
beneficial for its supply chain.
2. Company’s environmental Company can make collaboration with the Ali Daibat et. al. (2010); Abby Ghobadian
collaboration with their suppliers certified EMS suppliers to have better (2009); Vachon (2007); Zhu and Sarkis
relationship between them and quality (2006); Zhu et al. (2005, 2007a,b,
assurance with no harm to the 2008a,b,c); Hu and Hsu (2006); Yuang
environment. and Kielkiewicz-Yuang (2001); Klassen
RRTT
and Vachon (2003); Lippman (2001);
Lippmann (1999); US-AEP (1999).
3. Reduction and elimination of Mutual understanding and awareness for Kannan Govindan et. al. (2010); Holt and
product’s harmful environmental environment between product designer and Ghobadian (2009); Zhu et al. (2005);
IIJJEE

impacts by collaborating between suppliers can help a lot to reduce and Lippman (2001).
product designer and suppliers eliminate product’s harmful impacts over
the environment.
4. Government regulation and Making green practitioners friendly laws Kannan Govindan (2010); Walker et al.
legislation, like making and rewards can stimulate more and more (2008); Hall (2001); Min and Galle
transparent reward system for organizations to practice GSCM. (2001); Beamon (1999); Walton et al.
green practitioners (1998); Green et al. (1996).
5. Green product design Environmental friendly products are more Kannan Govindan et. al. (2010); Routroy
genuinely accepted. (2009); Hu and Hsu (2006); Zhu et al.
(2005, 2007a,b, 2008a,b,c); Zhu and
Sarkis (2006).
6. Standard quality certifications Certification encourage organizations Ali Daibat (2010); Abby Ghobadian
like ISO 14001 towards continue quality enhancement, (2009); Zhu et al. (2005, 2007a,b,
thus improving organization’s culture. 2008a,b,c); Vachon (2007); Zhu and
Sarkis (2006); Hu and Hsu (2006); Rao
and Holt (2005).
7. Integrating total quality It enables new innovations in production Ali Daibat (2010); Zhu and Sarkis (2006);
environmental management into and operation methodologies, confining Zhu et al. (2005, 2007a,b, 2008a,b,c); Rao
planning and operation processes wastes and reduces energy usages. and Holt (2005).
8. Reducing energy consumption It results in better usage of financial Ali Daibat (2010); Paulraj (2009); Abby
and confining wastes resources of the organization. Ghobadian (2009); Gonzalez et al. (2008);
Rao and Holt (2005).
9. Reusing and recycling materials It prevents waste of raw material Kannan Govindan (2010); Daine Holt
and packaging resources. (2009); Paulraj (2009); Vachon (2007);

www.ijert.org 2027
International Journal of Engineering Research & Technology (IJERT)
ISSN: 2278-0181
Vol. 2 Issue 4, April - 2013
Rao and Holt (2005).
10. Environmental collaboration with Making customers aware towards green Ali Daibat (2010); Paulraj (2009); Abby
customers and making them products and acknowledging benefits. Ghobadian (2009); Zhu et al. (2008);
environmentally aware Vachon (2007); Klassen and Vachon
(2003).
11. Reverse logistics and feedback Reverse logistics and feedback system Ali Daibat (2010); Routroy (2009);
system assures customer satisfaction towards Vachon (2007); Rao and Holt (2005); Zhu
product and brand. et al. (2005); Hu and Hsu (2006); Lippman
(2001).
12. Establishing company’s green Making customers satisfied with all the Gioconda Quesada et. al. (2011); Daine
image locally and globally environmental and performance aspects of Holt (2009).
product, thus making them brand loyal.
13. Cost of environmentally friendly Encourage to the customers to buy the Gioconda Quesada et. al. (2011); Daine
goods products. Holt (2009).
14. Cost of environmentally friendly Encourage to the suppliers. Christian Bailey et. al. (2011); Daine Holt
packages (2009).
15. Supplier’s awareness and Cost of environment friendly packages Brooks Woodfin et. al. (2011); Daine Holt
advances in providing encourages suppliers to provide less costly (2009).
environmentally friendly packaging.
packages
16. Sharing best green practices Sharing best green practices in supply Gioconda Quesada et. al. (2011); Daine
chain can make organization IT network Holt (2009).
strong and beneficial too.

IV. CONCLUSION Practices in the Electrical and Electronics industries and their
relation to organizational behavior. International Journal of
In this research paper various barriers and drivers of Green Science and Technology, 4(3), pg. 383-394.
Supply Chain Management (GSCM) were identified based upon [7] Chiou, T.Y., Chan, H.K., Lettice, F., & Chung S.H., The
RRTT
the GSM literature and on consultations with experts in the Influence of Greening the Suppliers and Green Innovation on
academics. For the better implementation of GSCM in any Environmental Performance and Competitive Advantage in
organization these barriers and drivers occur in most of the Taiwan, 2011, Transportation Research Part E, 47, pg. 822-
cases. Hence to overcome the difficulties and for proper
IIJJEE

836.
implementation of GSCM in the organization proper attention [8] Cooper, J. (1994). Green logistics, European logistics:
must be paid to these barriers and drivers. markets, management and strategy. Oxford: Blackwell
Business.
V. REFERENCES
[9] Daine Holt and Abby Ghobadian, An Empirical Study of
[1] Ali Diabat & Kannan Govindan, An Analysis of the Drivers Green Supply Chain Management Practices Amongst UK
Affecting the Implementation of Green Supply Chain Manufacturers, 2009, Journal of Manufacturing Technology
Management, 2011, Resources, Conservation and Recycling, Management (Vol. 20), no.7, pg. 933-966.
55, pg. 659-667. [10] Digalwar, A.K., & Metri, B.A. (2004). Performance
[2] AlKhidir, T., & Zailani, S. (2009). Going Green in supply Measurement Framework for World Class Manufacturing.
chain towards Environmental Sustainability. Global Journal International Journal of Applied Management and
of Environmental Research, 3(3), pg.246-251. Technology, 3(2), pg 83-101.
[3] B. P. Sharma, M. D. Singh and Neha, Modeling the [11] Gant, R. M. (1996). Prospering in dynamically-competitive
Knowledge Sharing Barriers using an ISM Approach, 2012, environments: Organizational capability as knowledge
International Conference on Information and Knowledge integration. Organizational Science, 7(4), pg. 375-387.
Management (Vol. 45), pg. 233-238. [12] Gioconda Quesada, Christian Bailey & Brooks Woodfin, An
[4] Beamon BM. Designing the green supply chain. Logistics Analysis of Drivers & Barriers to Innovations in Green
Information Management 1999;12(4): pg. 332–342. Supply Chain Practices in Mexico (2011).
[5] Carter, C. R., & Dresner, M. (2001). Purchasing's Role in [13] Green K, Morton B, New S. Purchasing and environmental
Environmental Management: Cross-Functional Development management: interactions, policies and opportunities
of Grounded Theory. Journal of Supply Chain Management, Business Strategy and the Environment 1996;5: pg. 188–197.
37(2), pg. 12-27. [14] Hosseini, A. (2007). Identification of Green Management of
[6] Chien, M.K., & Shih, L.H. (2007). An empirical study of the system’s factors: - A Conceptualized Model. International
Implementation of Green Supply Chain Management

www.ijert.org 2028
International Journal of Engineering Research & Technology (IJERT)
ISSN: 2278-0181
Vol. 2 Issue 4, April - 2013
Journal of Management Science and Engineering [30] Patrick Penfield- Sustainability can be competitive
Management, 2(3), pg. 221-228. advantage- Whitman School of Management
[15] Hsu, C.W., & Hu, A.H. (2008). Green Supply Chain http://www.mhia.org/news/industry/7056/thegreen-supply-
Management in the Electronic Industry. International Journal chain - Aug 7, 2007.
of Science and Technology, 5(2), pg. 205-216. [31] Paulraj A. Environmental motivations: a classification
[16] Jonny C. Ho, Maurice K. Shalishali, Tzu-Liang Tseng and scheme and its impact on environmental strategies and
David S. Ang, Opportunities in Green Supply Chain practices. Business Strategy and the Environment
Management, 2009, The Coastal Business Journal (Vol. 8), 2009;18(7): pg. 453–468.
no.1, pg. 18-30. [32] Ravi, V., & Shankar R. (2005). Analysis of interactions
[17] Kannan G, Devika K, Noorul Haq A. Analyzing supplier among the barriers of reverse logistics. International Journal
development criteria for an automobile industry. Industrial of Technological Forecasting & Social change, 72(8), pg.
Management & Data Systems 2010;110(1): pg. 43–62. 1011-1029.
[18] Large, R.O. & Thomsen, C.G., Drivers of Green Supply
[33] Raymond P.C., Lopez J., Marche S., Perron G.M. & Wright
Chain Management Performance: Evidence from Germany,
R., Influences, Practices & Opportunities for Environmental
2011, Journal of Purchasing and Supply Management (Vol.
Supply Chain Management in Nova Scotia SMEs, 2008,
17), pg. 176-184.
Journal of Cleaner Production, 16, pg. 1561-1570.
[19] Linton, J. D., Klassen, R., & Jayaraman, V. (2007).
[34] Rogers, D.S., & R.S. (1998). Tibben- lembke, Going
Sustainable supply chains: an introduction. Journal of
Backwards: Reverse Logistics Trends and Practices. Reverse
Operations Management, 25(6), pg. 1075-1082.
Logistics Executive Council, Pittsburgh, PA.
[20] Lippman S. Supply chain environmental management.
[35] Routroy S. Antecedents and drivers for green supply chain
Environmental Quality Management 2001;11(2): pg. 11–14.
management implementation in manufacturing environment.
[21] M. D. Singh and R. Kant, Knowledge management barriers:
ICFAI Journal of Supply Chain Management 2009;6(1): pg.
An interpretive structural modeling approach, 2008,
20–35.
International Journal of Management Science and
[36] Sarkis, J. (2009). A Boundaries and Flows Perspective of
Engineering Management (Vol. 3), no. 2, pg. 141-150.
Green Supply Chain Management. GPMI working papers.
[22] McKibben, Bill. “450 Ways to Stop Global Warning”.
No-7, October 2009.
Foreign Policy, May/June 2007 Issue 160, pg. 38-39.
[37] Scupola, A. (2003).The adoption of internet commerce by
[23] Mclaren, Tim S., Head, Milena M., & Yuan, Yufei (2004).
SMEs in the South of Italy: an environmental, technological
Supply Chain Management Information System Capabilities:
RRTT
and organizational perspective. Journal of Global Information
An Exploratory Study of Electronics Manufactures.
Technology Management, 6(1), pg. 52-71.
Information systems and E-business management, 2(3), pg.
[38] Sharfman, M. P., Shaft, T. M., & Anex, R. P. (2007). The
207-222.
road to cooperative supply-chain environmental
IIJJEE

[24] Min, H., & Galle, W. P. (2001). Green purchasing practices


management: trust and uncertainty among pro-active firms
of US firms. International Journal of Operations &
Business Strategy and the Environment, 18(1), pg. 1-13.
Production Management, 21(9). Pg. 1222 - 1238.
[39] Sreejith Balasubramanian, A Hierarchical Framework of
[25] Mudgal, R.K., Shankar, R., Talib, P., & Raj, T. (2010).
Barriers to Green Supply Chain Management in the
Modeling the barriers of green supply chain practices: an
Construction Sector, 2012, Journal of Sustainable
Indian perspective. Int. Journal of Logistics Systems and
Development (Vol. 5), pg. 15-27.
Management, 7, 1, pg. 81-107.
[40] Srivastva, S. (2007). Green supply State of the art Literature
[26] Mudgal, R.K., Shankar, R., Talib, P., & Raj, T. (2009).
Review. International Journal of Management Review, 9(1),
Greening the supply chain practices: an Indian perspective of
pg. 53-80.
enablers’ relationship. Int. Journal of Advanced Operations
[41] Sunil Luthra, Vinod Kumar & Abid Haleem, Barriers to
Management, 1(2 and 3), pg. 151-176.
implement Green Supply Chain Management in automobile
[27] Nagendra Sohani, Hemant Marmat, and Alok K. Singh
industry using Interpretive Structural Modeling (ISM)
(2010), “ANP with ISM based approach for supplier
Technique – An Indian Perspective, 2011, Journal of
selection”, International Conference and Colloquium
Industrial Engineering and Management, 4(2), pg. 231-257.
Excellence in Research and Education, 25-28 September
[42] Su-Yol Lee, Drivers for the Participation of Small and
2010, pg. 1-15.
Medium-Sized Suppliers in Green Supply Chain Initiatives,
[28] Nicole Darnall, G. Jason Jolley and Robert Handfield,
2008, Supply Chain Management: An International Journal
Environmental Management System and Green Supply Chain
(Vol. 13), no.3, pg. 185-198.
Management: Complements for Sustainability?, 2008,
[43] Tim Banies, Steve Brown, Ornella Benedettini, Peter Ball,
Business Strategy and the Environment, 18, pg. 30-45.
Examining Green Production and its Role within the
[29] Nimawat Dheeraj & Namdev Vishal, An Overview of Green
Competitive Strategy of Manufacturing, 2012, Journal of
Supply Chain Management in India, 2012, Research Journal
Industrial Engineering and Management Vol. 5 (1), pg. 53-
of Recent Sciences (Vol. 1) (6), pg. 77-82.
87.

www.ijert.org 2029
International Journal of Engineering Research & Technology (IJERT)
ISSN: 2278-0181
Vol. 2 Issue 4, April - 2013
[44] Tsai, W., & Ghoshal, S. (1998), Social Capital and Value [51] Xianbiag Liu, Jie Yang, Sixiao Qu, Leina Wang, Tomohiro
Creation: The Role of Intrafirm Networks. Academy of Shishime and Cunkuan Bao, Sustainable Production:
Management Journal, 41, pg. 464-476. Practices and Determinant Factors of Green Supply Chain
[45] Vachon S. Green supply chain practices and the selection of Management of Chinese Companies, 2011, Business Strategy
environmental technologies. International Journal of and the Environment, 21, pg. 1-16.
production Research 2007;45(18–19): pg. 4357–4379. [52] Yan Li, Research on the Performance Measurement of Green
[46] Walker, H., & Preuss, L. (2008), Fostering sustainability Supply Chain Management in China, 2011, Journal of
through sourcing from small businesses: public sector Sustainable Development (Vol. 4), no. 3, pg. 101-107.
perspectives, Journal of Cleaner Production, 16(15), 1600- [53] Yuang A, Kielkiewicz-Yuang A. Sustainable supply network
1609. management. Corporate Environmental Management
[47] Walker H, Di Sisto L, McBain D. Drivers and barriers to 2001;8(3): pg. 260–268.
environmental supply chain management practices: lessons [54] Yu Lin, C., & Hui Ho, Y. (2008). An Empirical Study on
from the public and private sectors. Journal of Purchasing Logistics services provider, intention to adopt Green
and Supply Management 2008;14(1): pg. 69–85. Innovations. Journal of Technology, Management and
[48] Walton S, Handfield R, Melnyk S. The green supply chain: : Innovation, 3(1), pg. 17-26.
integrating suppliers into environmental management [55] Zhu, Q., Geng, Y., Sarkis, J., & Lai, K.H., Evaluating Green
processes International Journal of Purchasing and Materials Supply Chain Management among Chinese Manufacturers
Management 1998;3(2): pg.2–11. from the Ecological Modernization Perspective, 2010,
[49] Wu, G. C., & Hang, S. Y. (2009). The study of knowledge Transportation Research Part E, 47, pg. 808-821.
transfer and green management performance in green supply [56] Zhu Q, Sarkis J, Lai K. Green supply chain management:
chain management. African journal of Business Management, pressures, practices and performance within the Chinese
4(1), pg. 44-48. automobile industry. Journal of Cleaner Production
2007b;15(11): pg. 1041–1052.
[50] Wycherley, I. (1999), Greening supply chains: the case of
[57] Zhu Q, Sarkis J, Lai K. Confirmation of a measurement
theBody Shop International. Business Strategy and the
model for green supply chain management practices
Environment, 8(2), pg. 120-127.
implementation. International Journal of Production
Economics 2008c;111(2): pg. 261–273.
RRTT
IIJJEE

www.ijert.org 2030

You might also like