MAJ 17 Lesson 1
MAJ 17 Lesson 1
MAJ 17 Lesson 1
Literature
Gets one acquainted with the world’s great minds, personalities and great teachers of all
ages.
Aims at helping one understand oneself as well as others.
Provides opportunity for development of sensory, affective, social, intellectual and religious
senses or faculties.
Provides vicarious experiences to those exposed to it
Trains the mind and equips the child for independent work and unbiased judgment i.e in
analysis and criticism.
Helps one operate one‟s rationale facilities. It in fact exposes one to healthy human values
and attitudes, character and behavior and to understand the complex nature of human being
(Rees 1973).
Helps one in analysis, interpreting and dealing with the world of reality.
Helps in the acquisition and reinforcement of the language skills (Gbenedio 1984).
Imposes a kind of high discipline on those who are exposed to it.
Broadens the cultural needs and horizon of the child.
Exposes the child to the beauty and potentials of language (i.e the aesthetic value of
literature).
Encourages attempts at creative writing which stems from understanding a creative
processes as well as appreciating the principal of creativity (Lawal 1985).
In fact, the nature of literature makes it so sterile that Moody (1973) says, it offers a vast reservoir of
human experience and judgment of experience, a development of imagination, an entry into human
situations which otherwise might fall outside our ken.
These imply that even though other subjects contribute to the making of the whole man, literature
has a unique effectiveness in opening the mind and illuminating it; also of purging the mind of
prejudices and received ideas and leaves it free and active. In summary literature by its nature moulds
the personality of a child more effectively than other subjects.
B. Theories
1. Transmission Theory
This theory is strict when it comes to the role of teachers and students. Teachers are always the
center of attention and the source of knowledge which their students are supposed to rely on. Students
acquire facts and knowledge about literature but its interpreting is eclipsed. Transmission theories are
rather limiting since student must completely rely on the teachers knowledge about literature, which
could be quite difficult since it does not give them many opportunities to think for themselves and make
up their own mind about the given piece of literature. Thus, the role of students is very passive and
dependent. According to Beach - “One problem with this transmission model is that it focuses on simply
2. Students-Centered Theory
Student centered theories gives freedom to students to learn what and how they want to learn it. Idea
behind is that when students are choice given, they are motivated to learn. This theory believes in
providing students choice with which they are given the motivation. Texts should not be assigned to
students but students should have given the opportunities of choosing which guarantees a certain amount
of engagement. The raising question is whether students should have all the responsibility of learning. A
potential failure would then be a student’s fault and it is questionable whether should teachers allow it.
4. Teacher-Centered Theories
a. Teaching as Performance. It believes that performance is inescapable in teaching. This
approach says that teaching is seen as the form of performance. Thus, teacher’s duty is to
choose what type of performance he wants to choose for teaching. It stresses the need of
instructors speaking and acting abilities as well as intellectual ones. Jyl Lynn Felman
believes that performance teaching allows the classroom to become a truly dynamic and
dramatic space. It makes the class a living theatre in which there will be intellectual
eruptions. Performance makes teaching effective and it is because of such performance that
the students attract towards teachers teaching. At the same time, it develops students various
skills of performance (Felman 2001).
b. Teaching as a spiritual journey. Parker J. Palmer discusses about this theory. It is direct
opposite to the performance. He believes that good teaching cannot be reduced to technique.
Good teaching comes from the identity and integrity of the teacher. It emphasizes the teacher
is inner being character and self-knowledge. It says that, the spirituality of education will
destroy the fear that destroys teaching and learning. Palmer (Palmer 10) advocates a
communal pedagogy and a community of learning that includes the teacher and the students.
He recommends the creation of a learning space characterized by openness, boundaries and
air of hospitality. Palmer also recommends that teacher develops the discipline of standing
outside their fields by teaching in general education courses and by becoming students from
time to time themselves (Palmer 1993). Stephen Brookfield produced another version of
spiritual approach that is critically reflective teaching (Brookfield 1995). In it, teacher keeps
logs of their reactions to their lives as teachers. It includes moments when they feel most
connected, engaged or affirmed or conversely disconnected, disengaged or bore, situation
that cause them anxiety or events that surprise them. In the opinion of David Perkins -“to
present literature impersonally and objectively was cardinal point of classroom morality”
(Perkins 112).The above theory is important in the sense that it gives advantages to the
5. Eclectic Theories
Presently most widespread theories of teaching literature are those having no theory at all. In this
connection Gould Axetrod points - “teachers should be pragmatic in what works in class” (Axetrod 74).
It asks for all possible meanings of the texts and does what needed at last in the classroom. It requires
substantial preparation of the topic with all possible interpretation of teachers as well as from author’s
point of view. And finally, what responses we receive in the class matters in this approach.
C. Approaches
Approaches can help us to select and design materials for classroom use as to assess the suitability of
published materials. Approaches are very important in classroom activities for the teacher. It helps to
make classroom teaching effective.
1. Language-Based Approach
Studying the language of the literary text will help to integrate the language and literature syllabi
more closely. Detailed analysis of the literary text will help students to make meaningful interpretations
or informed evaluations of it. At the same time, students will increase their general awareness and
understanding of English. Students are encouraged to draw on their knowledge of familiar grammatical,
lexical or discourse categories to make aesthetic judgments of the texts. Materials are chosen for the way
they illustrate certain stylistic features of the language but also for their literary merit.
This approach is favored because it is believed that students are helped to develop a response to
literature through examining the linguistic evidence in the text. Students are provided with analytic tools
with which to reach their own interpretations. They are encouraged to draw on their knowledge of
English. So, this approach may provide useful exposure to or revision of grammar and vocabulary in
interesting new contexts. It is a way of justifying the inclusion of literature in the language syllabus
since it fulfills student’s main aim to improve their knowledge of the language. According of some
proponents of this approach, literature texts are seen as a resource which provides stimulating language
skills. They are great source for such kind of activities because they offer a wide range of styles and
registers. They are also open to multiple interpretations and hence provide excellent opportunities for
classroom discussions. It focuses on genuinely interesting and motivating topics to explore in the
classroom.
2. Literature as Context
This is most traditional approach, frequently used in tertiary education. Literature itself is the
content of the course. It concentrates on the areas such as history and characteristics of literary
movements, social, political and historical background to a text; literary genres and rhetorical devices
etc. Students acquire English by focusing on course content, particularly through reading set texts and
literary criticism relating to them. The mother tongue of the students may be used to discuss the texts or
students may be asked to translate texts from one language into other.
Texts are selected for their importance as part of a literary canon or tradition. The most important
advantage of adopting this approach in the class is that genuinely educational approach in that
understanding of texts is enhanced by situating students within their literary and historical contexts.
Students are exposed to a wide range of authentic materials.
Some problems are there in this approach as it demands a personal response from students without
providing sufficient guidance in coping with the linguistic intricacies of the text. Some text may be so
remote from the student’s own experiences that are unable to respond meaningfully to them.
Alternatively, some groups of students may dislike having to discuss personal feelings or reactions. This
approach has got connections with the humanistic approach to language teaching as -
4. Periphrastic Approach
It deals with the surface meaning of the text. Rosli (Rosli 2007) mentions that it allows teachers to
use simpler words and sentence structures compared to the more complicated ones in the texts and
sometimes the teacher can translate it into other languages. He argued further that this approach is
suitable for beginners of the target language as it act as a stepping stone in the formulating original
assumptions of the authors work. It helps-
5. Information-Based Approach
It demands a large input from the teacher and closely related to the term literature with learning. It
describes the study of literature as –
“aesthetically patterned artifact endowed with the knowledge potential philosophy, culture, morality
and humanities” (Ganakumaran 92).
Carter and Long argues that it involves critical concepts, literary conventions and metalanguage and the
students should be able to use such terms and concepts in talking and writing about literature (Carter and
Long 1991).
Is sees literature as a source of information. Reading is prominent but its development is seen in close
connection with other communicative skills as writing, speaking and listening. Teacher plays an
important role in this approach. This approach provides teacher-centered activities in the classroom.
6. Reader-Response Approach
The reader response approach has a growing influence on EFL literature classes. Carlisle says- “it
encourages EFL learners to study literature for literature sake rather than for the mere language skills
attainment” (Carlisle 30). It focuses on reader’s response to the text. In it, teacher is looking for a
transactional relationship between the reader’s personal experiences, opinions and feelings and the text.
In it, reading is seemed as a dialogue with the text and with the other or itself. Plural interpretations are
encouraged and the text can be approached from a variety of perspectives. It provides a student-centered
and process orientated classroom. The purposes of literary education are similar. In it, literature is
considered as an authentic medium for introducing students to the specific language and culture. The
potential of literary reading across the language is to compare traditions and gain insights into various
cultural forms and developments.
From the above mentioned major approaches it is seen that some of above are considering language
and some are giving importance to literature. As there is no one way to teach literature, Duff and Maley
(1990) have emphasized an integrated approach to teaching of literature. They gave following reasons
for its inclusion (1) Linguistic: Linguistic reasons for adopting an integrational approach are that
learners are exposed to varieties to authentic materials and they come to know about types and
difficulties of English language, (2) Methodological: By means of literary discourse readers come to
know about use of schemes and strategies of intensive as well as extensive readings, and (3)
Motivational: Literary texts make reading enjoyable. It was supported by many scholars as savvidou and
others.
1. Telling Method
It is pedagogical method where teacher makes oral presentation of some fact or topic having educational
significance. It is a method of supplying the students with information about events, incidents with
information about events, incidents and simple facts. It is useful in a) supplementing information
furnished by students and textbooks, b) Developing the work of the class, c) giving inspirational talks, d)
introducing important incidental information.
Telling is an art which every teacher should know. A teacher should have rich information, accurate and
wide knowledge and a rich collection of facts, anecdotes and stories to enable according to the situation.
This method has advantages like vitalizes ideas and gives teacher chance to maintain contact
immediately with students. It gives chance of listening and taking rapid notes. At the time, it has
limitations as it makes learner passive and does not guaranteed the teachers whether pupils are
understanding the content of teaching or not. It is in the handling of teacher’s ability to make it effective
and profitable for students. Teacher should use his lecture with great care. It should be carefully planned
and teacher should be careful in its delivery.
3. Discussion Method
Discussion is an ordered process of collective decision making. It seeks agreement but if it is not
reached, it has the value of clarifying and sharpening the nature of agreement. It is used for the
following purposes:
Two types of discussions are there i) Formal discussion ii) Informal discussion. In informal
discussion, teacher is a centre and formal discussion takes the shape of debate, symposium, panel etc.
Discussion has a lot of advantages as clarifying and sharpening ideas, developing critical thinking,
tolerance at the same time having limitation as to go from the path etc. However, if proper care is taken
this method is of great value and importance.
Thus, problem solving constitutes a realistic method for presenting the type of experience that the
pupil will throughout his career. It furnishes the natural objectives. At the time it provides logical way of
thinking. Although, it is useful but applied too frequently, it becomes monotonous. There is also danger
that the selected problem may be trivial or unimportant or less important. But in all, it covers everything
scientifically. It is not a method of teaching but a method of organization of subject matter in such a way
that it can be dealt with through the study of problems.
5. Supervised Method
This is another method of teaching for promoting optimum learning. Its main aim is the self-effort of
the child carried on independently in learning new things under the supervision and guidance of the
teacher. In fact, it is a process of teaching pupils how to study by studying with them and by giving
individual help in period set apart for study. Different plans are made for supervised study. The double
period plan consists half time to class activity and second half for advanced lesson. The daily extra
period plan took one whole period for especially those students having difficulties. The library study
plan includes teacher’s supervision and students study to the library using reference materials. The
flexible supervised study plan is useful for large number of students. Some activities as memorizing,
guiding to find out materials from text, using books, maps, diagrams, preparation of notes, reading
activity, gathering and organization of data, formation of hypothesis, make conclusions application and
judgement can be carried out in this method. This technique has following advantages- It provides
considerable help as teacher supervise Pupils are benefited from individual attention
6. Structural Approach
This approach also believed to represent the old tradition and customs and discredited literature as a
tool in foreign language teaching. In it, literary texts are basically chosen to teach language structures.
So, more preference is given to grammar, vocabulary, syntax rather than the content of literature. The
functional notional method ignored literature, because in this method the importance lies on
communication function or to be the authentic examples of language use. Nonetheless, in the last decade
the interest in literature as one of the most valuable language teaching resources available has been
revived to a great extent. (Duff and Maley 1993)
7. Communicative Approach
It lays stress on communicative abilities of students and mastery to skills. It realizes that literature is the
source of providing communication skills to students. Thus, communicative approach perceive that
reading literature to make students to communicate in the second language and taking responsibility for
real, authentic communicative situations. It also perceives that literature teaching nowadays is a
communicative activity and literary texts are authentic examples of language use. However, Brumfit and
Carter (1980) discarded the existence of special literary language. Nowadays, literature plays a
paramount role in ELT and different scholars in the field have highlighted this importance.
f. Questionnaires
A teacher could give questionnaire to students to fill in to determine their attitudes to the issues
raised by the book’s central theme. For example in Kafka’s Die Verwandlung, students would be asked
to consider what they would do if they we told that they were dying and had one day to live. Students
would compare questionnaire that would focus on what they would eat their last day, whomthey would
contact, what they would do, what the topic of their final words of wisdom would be, how they would
change their will etc. After students completion of questionnaire on their own, it would be compared
notes with other students and try to convince the students that their answers were best. The entire class
would then present their ideas and they discussed and attempt to come to a consensus about what might
be most logical for each topic represented on the questionnaire.
g. Biographical Information
Some teachers prefer to talk about the author before starting the text, using some background
knowledge as a way in to the work. He or she could ask to present photos, objects, place names and
anything that is relevant to the author’s life. Then, the class is invited to speculate about the meaning of
the items in the montage, either in groups or a whole class. It would be follow-up with writing activity
as reconstructing missing entries from the author’s diaries, using the visual prompts on the montage,
writing sub-titles or a short-text about each of the item. This makes montage an illustrated biography. It
would lead students interest to read it. Sealing the Time Capsule Assuming that all students have read
the opening section of the work together, the teacher would give each student a small piece of card on
which he or she would record predications about likely events that will occur as the story unfolds. He or
she would then collect, seal them in a time capsule and open after reading and discussing the entire text
to how accurate their predications were.
i. Maintaining Momentum
These activities can be used at almost any point in a literary work and can be applied to the various
genres. If the work chosen is not a very long one (a short story, single-act play or short poem), the
k. Choosing a Moral
Sometimes teacher would ask students questions related to the moral of the short story. He could
ask-‘what would you say is he moral to this story?’ students usually come up with better ideas if they
have time to think over the question. 2.9 Exploiting Highlights. After developing progress through home
reading and snowball activities, teacher can select from an additional range of imaginative activities in
order to exploit the highlights of the work. One such example is to imagine that the text is being made
into a TV serial. These activities would encourage the students to explore their own responses. Another
authentic format is to use exploit highlights in newspaper articles. The teacher would provide samples of
articles from two or three well-known newspapers in the TL and talk about news writing. Students
would then be asked to write about the events of the text in article form. Again many cultures have some
type of advice columnist, such as Dear Abby. The teacher could display a couple of examples in English
and introduce students to one in the TL and explain that people who are seeking advice send an e-mail to
the person in hopes of a reply to solve their problem. Students would write a letter asking advice from
the perspective of the character in the story. Teacher would collect letter and ask students to read
responses. Following this activity, the teacher would return the letter and response to the original writer.
Again if a character in the story dies, a teacher introduces student’s epitaphs, eulogies or obituaries etc.
And then, ask students to write a thank you card, get well card, sympathy card, birthday card etc. to a
character in the story from perspectives of another character.
l. Endings
Coming to the ending of a literary work is really only a staging point, a temporary distancing from a
continuing process of appreciation and understanding. Here, teacher can perform various activities
regarding themes, characters, plot etc. Students could be asked to create a cover design for the book’s
paper back cover. It is a way of eliciting and crystallizing their overall response to the work they have
been reading. Along these lines, students could be asked to design a book jacket for the book which
would include a blurb about the text, a short biography of the author’s life quotes from famous authors
and a cover design. Another activity might be to have students to prepare descriptions about the plot