Wallstreetjournal 20170930 TheWallStreetJournal
Wallstreetjournal 20170930 TheWallStreetJournal
Wallstreetjournal 20170930 TheWallStreetJournal
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
board, a surprise move that federal oversight of American Oversight Council, a group of
would bolster his clout. A1 International Group Inc., an senior financial regulators,
insurance company now about voted 6-3 to rescind the global
Trump’s search for the
half the size it was when it insurer’s designation as a “sys-
next Fed chair ramped up this
was on the brink of collapse temically important financial
week when he interviewed a
and became a poster child of institution,” indicating they no
current and a former central-
the global financial crisis. longer view AIG as a threat to
bank governor for the job. A2
The move is one of the the broader economy.
Proxy-advisory firm ISS most tangible steps yet in the The action came earlier
is recommending P&G Trump administration’s push than many analysts expected.
shareholders put Nelson to re-evaluate financial regula- Although the Trump adminis-
Peltz on the board. B1 tions, which has included a tration has recommended doz-
top-to-bottom review of rules ens of changes to financial
Hudson River Trading
put in place in response to the rules, it has so far taken action
is exploring a deal to buy
JOURNEY’S END: A Rohingya Muslim refugee on Friday mourned beside the bodies of his three children crisis. Friday’s move frees the incrementally, in part because
rival Sun Trading amid low
in Cox’s Bazar district, Bangladesh. At least 500,000 people have fled to Bangladesh from Myanmar. A6 insurance company of stricter of the slow pace of installing
volatility and rising costs. B3
oversight by the federal gov- personnel at key regulators.
Equifax could announce ernment, such as tighter capi- Please see RISK page A2
in coming days that it will
claw back compensation
Gerrymandered Into Bold Eagles: Angry Birds Are
Uber Ex-CEO Names
from some top executives. B3
A Giant Court Fight
Ripping Drones Out of the Sky
Inside Directors in Power Play The tradition of redrawing
voting maps to increase electoral
clout, in often contorted ways,
i i i
NOONAN A13 BY GREG BENSINGER the appointments without con- faces a test at the Supreme Australia’s wedge-tailed eagle uses crack
sulting the rest of the board. Court next week. A10
Partisanship Uber Technologies Inc.’s He was granted control of aerial skills to attack pricey machines
ousted chief executive, Travis three board seats as part of
Is Breaking Kalanick, is appointing two $3.5 billion investment from a BY MIKE CHERNEY above, the eagle
new directors to the ride-hail- Saudi wealth fund in 2016. used its talons to
Both Parties ing firm’s board, a surprise The appointments could SYDNEY—Dan- punch a hole in
move that would bolster his serve as an effort to push back iel Parfitt thought the carbon fiber
clout as the company faces against one of Uber’s largest he’d found the and Kevlar fuse-
CONTENTS Style & Fashion D2-3 several critical decisions in- investors, Benchmark Capital, perfect drone for lage of Mr.
Books.................... C5-16 Technology............... B4
Business News...... B3 Travel...................... D7-8 cluding a possible multibillion- which is suing Mr. Kalanick Louisiana 2rd District a two-day map- Parfitt’s drone,
Food......................... D5-6 U.S. News............ A2-4 dollar investment from Soft- over control of those two (2016) ping job in a re- which lost con-
Heard on Street...B10 Weather................... A14 Bank Group Corp. seats. The venture firm, which mote patch of the Wedge-tailed eagle trol and plum-
Opinion............... A11-13 Wknd Investor....... B5
Sports....................... A14 World News....... A6-9
Mr. Kalanick appointed for- also holds a board seat and led Australian Out- meted to the
mer Xerox Corp. CEO Ursula an investor coup to push Mr. back. The roughly $80,000 ma- ground.
Burns and former CIT Group Kalanick out, has proposed a chine had a wingspan of 7 feet “I had 15 minutes to go on
> Inc. CEO John Thain as the new voting structure for and resembled a stealth my last flight on my last day,
10th and 11th Uber directors, shareholders allowing them to bomber. and one of these wedge-tailed
effective Friday, according to a vote based on the size of their There was just one problem. eagles just dive-bombed the
statement from him to The stake, rather than the current His machine raised the hackles drone and punched it out of the
s Copyright 2017 Dow Jones &
Wall Street Journal. system which rewards the ear- Texas 33rd District of one prominent local resi- sky,” said Mr. Parfitt, who be-
Company. All Rights Reserved The Uber co-founder, who liest investors with greater (2016) dent: a wedge-tailed eagle. lieved the drone was too big for
resigned as CEO in June, made Please see UBER page A8 Swooping down from Please see BIRDS page A9
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
A2 | Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 * ******* THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
U.S. NEWS
THE NUMBERS | By Jo Craven McGinty
I
ter ain’t what it used to be. t’s a rough measure that $2.1 billion in damage would went from 1.1 million to 2.2
A dollar doesn’t stretch as doesn’t account for loss not have been economically million. And New York City
far as it once did. Building in of life or environmental important enough to make from 4.2 million to 7.4 mil-
coastal areas and other eco- harm. It captures only dam- the billion dollar list using lion. Understanding how eco-
nomic growth have increased ages to fixed assets, and even the 1980 standard.” nomic growth contributes to
the potential for damages. then it uses a national mea- Here’s another way to disaster damages could help
And NOAA’s disaster esti- surement, not a regional ad- think of it: policy makers decide
mates account for only one justment, and it doesn’t ac- whether to strengthen build-
A
of those two factors. count for offsetting ssume all houses in an ing standards, provide more
“NOAA adjusts for infla- measures, such as updated area have the same in- disaster assistance or take
tion, which is wonderful, but building codes that reduce flation-adjusted price other steps.
it doesn’t make an adjust- damages. of, say, $1 million in 2017 “Once we agree on the
ment for the amount of phys- Some experts think even dollars. If disasters of equal true scope of the problem,
ical assets in the country,” more adjustments should be changes in population. to applying the consumer- size and intensity strike the it’s a political question on
said Jay Zagorsky, an econo- made. The calculation “is a Still, it’s an easy way to price index to adjust costs area in 1980 and in 2017, de- what the optimal response
mist at Ohio State University. start, but it doesn’t fully ad- get a sense of how develop- for inflation. stroying 10% of the housing should be,” Dr. Zagorsky
“There are twice as many dress the problems with the ment has contributed to eco- “If the CPI is 100 one year, stock each time, Total Dam- said.
bridges, homes, factories and time series,” said Roger A. nomic losses when the and then it’s 110 in a later age = Number of Houses x NOAA says it will update
cars for a hurricane to de- Pielke Jr., a professor of en- weather turns ugly. year, you know prices went 10% x Price. the billion-dollar disaster list
stroy.” vironmental studies at the “NOAA estimates suggest up 10%,” Dr. Zagorsky said. In 1980, if there were on Oct. 6, when hurricanes
In a way, that observation University of Colorado in the numbers are going up “Without adjusting for infla- 10,000 homes, the loss would Harvey, Irma and Maria will
is a no-brainer, but Dr. Boulder who has studied the very quickly,” Dr. Zagorsky tion, disasters would consis- equal $1 billion. In 2017, if be added. And—for what it’s
Zagorsky came up with a economic damages of hurri- said. “I’m just disagreeing tently look more expensive there were twice as many worth—those disasters will
simple way to estimate the canes and adjusted for addi- with how fast it’s going up.” over time and constantly homes, the loss would equal likely rank among the costli-
effect. tional factors such as His calculation is similar shatter records for damage.” $2 billion. est to hit the U.S.
U.S. NEWS
Disconnected
Cell sites offline in Puerto Rico
Out of Service
100%
Working
Texas Towns Struggle to Rebuild
Harvey leaves
communities without
75
municipal waste
50 services devastated
BY QUINT FORGEY
25
DICKINSON, Texas—For
0 weeks, Austin Lutrick has been
helping neighbors in this Gulf
Sept. 21 Sept. 29 Coast town haul sodden Sheet-
Source: Federal Communications Commission rock, moldy furniture and appli-
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. ances to curbs, after Hurricane
Harvey’s devastating landfall in
An AT&T Inc. spokesman trimming company was or- In a separate civil settle- rity Investigations division.
said the wireless carrier over dered to pay $95 million in the ment, ICE said, the company Since 1986, employers have
the past few days landed four largest fine against a company agreed to pay $15 million re- been required by federal immi-
cargo planes laden with more for hiring thousands of immi- lated to its violation of immi- gration law to verify an em-
than 50 generators and other grants who didn’t have per- gration law. ployee’s legal right to work in
equipment. Additional equip- mission to work in the U.S., ICE said Asplundh decen- the U.S. They also must main-
ment had to take a multiday according to federal officials. tralized hiring so the com- tain records of each worker’s
trip by sea because of a lack of Asplundh Tree Expert of pany’s senior management employment verification and
runway capacity. Willow Grove, Pa., pleaded could “remain willfully blind” identification documents.
A T-Mobile US Inc. spokes- guilty in federal court in Phil- as lower-level mangers hired ICE routinely audits a busi-
woman said the company sent adelphia on Thursday to ille- and rehired workers they ness’s employment verification
generators and personnel by gally hiring the immigrants. knew weren’t allowed to work records and has levied tens of
air, though planes could land Some of the immigrants were in the U.S. The agency also millions of dollars in fines
only during the day. A Sprint in the U.S. illegally, none had said the lower-level managers since 2007. It is unclear what
Corp. spokeswoman said the authorization to work in the knowingly accepted false or The U.S. says Asplundh decentralized hiring so senior managers the largest fine was before
company sent helicopters to country, according to court fake identification documents. could ‘remain willfully blind’ to hiring of undocumented workers. this week’s against Asplundh.
survey the damage to its cell documents. In a statement posted on However, in 2014, the latest
towers, most of which were A federal judge ordered the the company’s website on ter being told of the federal included reviewing the iden- figures available from the De-
standing and intact. family-owned company to pay Sept. 19, Chairman and CEO investigation in 2015. The tity of every employee using a partment of Homeland Secu-
An FCC spokesman said its $80 million and adhere to an Scott Asplundh said the com- company declined to comment photo ID system based on the rity, the government opened
response team was “packed Administrative Compliance pany, which has more than further on Friday. face-recognition software used 2,022 workplace-enforcement
and ready to go and awaiting Agreement from U.S. Immigra- 30,000 employees, took “im- Policy changes, Mr. As- by ICE. cases and levied fines totaling
FEMA approval to deploy.” tion and Customs Enforce- mediate corrective action” af- plundh said in the statement, The company’s guilty plea more than $16 million.
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
A4 | Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 P W L C 10 11 12 H T G K B F A M 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 O I X X ******* THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
U.S. NEWS
for individuals near its present the year ending September with Vice President Mike Pence and stack up debt, leading to
level of 39.6% and has pro- 2018 serves chiefly as the nec- then providing a tiebreaker. cuts in programs that middle-
posed to cut deductions on essary first step for Republi- The new budget’s most im- class Americans rely on,” Sen-
state and local taxes that could cans to pass a rewrite of the portant component is that it in- ate Minority Leader Chuck
leave some wealthy house- tax code without Democratic structs the Senate Finance and Schumer (D., N.Y.) said in a
holds paying more. President support. The budget document House Ways and Means com- statement.
Donald Trump, for his part, will be debated in the Senate mittees to come up with a —Kristina Peterson
has said the party’s tax plan Rep. Kevin Brady (R., Texas) spoke as House Speaker Paul Ryan Budget Committee next week, package of tax changes and rate and Richard Rubin
wouldn’t benefit the wealthy, looked on this week at the Capitol in Washington.
including himself.
Those moves would all help the plan, including the pro- of $129,030 in 2018, boosting income thresholds where the rates has the biggest benefit, cut taxes on the wealthy, while
the GOP defend itself against posed repeal of the estate tax, their after-tax incomes by 8.5% tax brackets hit and the size of creating greater incentives for 62% favored higher taxes on
attacks that its tax policy tilts the elimination of the alterna- and lowering the share of U.S. the child tax credit. Under Fri- people to work, save and in- that group. That is a point Mr.
toward the top of the income tive minimum tax and lower taxes they would pay, accord- day’s assumptions, the plan vest. Trump’s speeches reflect.
scale. The problem, so far, is tax rates on corporations and ing to an analysis by the Tax would raise taxes on 12% of “It is the highest rates that The heirs of Mr. Trump,
that core features of the plan businesses that pay taxes Policy Center. Overall, Ameri- households in 2018, with the cause the most damage,” said who says his net worth ex-
do just that. As the party turns through their owners’ individ- cans would get a 2.1% increase biggest concentration of losers Chris Edwards of the libertar- ceeds $10 billion, would bene-
that outline into legislation ual returns. in after-tax income. in the upper middle class. ian Cato Institute. fit from estate-tax repeal. The
over the next few months, it There are benefits for the “The top income groups will Households in the bottom Many economists say there president, as the owner of nu-
will be repeatedly confronted middle class, too, but they are receive the biggest tax cuts,” half of the income scale—who is little link between lower tax merous pass-through busi-
with the challenge of reconcil- less specific and subject to said Eric Toder, co-director of often pay payroll taxes used to rates and economic growth. nesses, would also likely gain
ing Republicans’ desire for rate change. Many households, es- the center. fund Social Security and Medi- The challenge for Republi- from the 25% top rate on those
cuts with their claims about pecially in the upper middle Republicans called the anal- care but little or no income cans is that politically, tax cuts firms, down from 39.6%. Unlike
who should pay less. class, may end up experiencing ysis speculative because it tax—would get average tax at the top are unpopular. In a past presidents, Mr. Trump has
Under the framework, the tax increases. didn’t consider the pieces of cuts under $1,000. Wall Street Journal/NBC News refused to release his tax re-
top 1% of households would The top 1% of households the plan that legislators ha- Republicans argue that cut- poll this month, just 12% of turns, making even a rough
reap significant benefits from would get an average tax cut ven’t written yet, including the ting top marginal income-tax Americans said they wanted to calculation challenging.
could be construed by investi- ported. Their concern was that tigation is having on Mr. Kush-
gators as an effort to coordi- if Mr. Kushner were to speak ner; Mr. Trump’s questions
nate their stories, said three to the president or White about Mr. Kushner spring partly
people familiar the matter. House colleagues about the from family considerations, said
Two senior White House of- Russia investigation, Mr. Muel- people familiar with the matter.
ficials—then-Chief of Staff President Trump’s son-in-law, Jared Kushner, shown here in July, is under scrutiny in the Russia probe. ler could seek testimony about Newly installed Chief of
Reince Priebus and former chief what was said. Staff John Kelly has recently
strategist Steve Bannon—urged Mr. McGahn stayed, reas- A White House official said White House and its staff, in- Mr. Kushner’s role has tightened access to the presi-
Mr. McGahn not to resign, ac- sured in part by the White Mr. McGahn “did not consider cluding Jared.” caused particular concern dent, requiring aides, including
cording to people familiar with House’s hiring of a legal team resigning, and he was not con- Mr. McGahn’s concerns among some White House offi- Mr. Kushner, to schedule ap-
the conversations. One person specifically to manage the probe cerned about any one individ- from earlier in the summer il- cials as federal investigators pointments in order to meet
characterized Mr. McGahn’s of Russian meddling in the 2016 ual. He was focused on imple- lustrate the disruption and examine meetings he held with with Mr. Trump.
frustration as, “Fine, you’re not election. Attorney Ty Cobb was menting the proper processes tension that special counsel Russian officials and business- —Brody Mullins
taking my advice? Why stay?” hired to lead that group. and structures to protect the Robert Mueller’s probe is caus- people during the campaign contributed to this article.
WASHINGTON WIRE
PRESIDENT TRUMP AFL-CIO
PRICE was overdue and suggested they
would fight any nominee they
found unacceptable.
“The next HHS secretary
Continued from Page One must follow the law when it
Christians Leaders: Convention Won’t ministration’s efforts to repeal comes to the Affordable Care
Denounce Alt-Right Invite Politicians the ACA are at a standstill. After Act instead of trying to sabotage
another effort to overturn the it,” said Senate Minority Leader
MICHAEL REYNOLD/EPA/SHUTTERSTOCK
Dozens of evangelical Chris- America’s largest federation law failed Tuesday in the Sen- Chuck Schumer (D., N.Y.).
tian leaders have sent an open of labor unions is sending a ate, Republicans now must The revelations had already
letter to President Donald message to Washington politi- choose whether to work with kicked up a political storm, with
Trump, asking him to more cians: You’re not welcome. Democrats on health care, or the House Oversight Committee
clearly denounce the “alt-right The AFL-CIO, which has said continue their efforts to repeal announcing an investigation
movement.” it is seeking more political inde- the ACA. If the administration into the taxpayer-funded travel
Signed by an array of conser- pendence, announced Friday that favors regulations to change the of senior Trump administration
vative Christian pastors, the let- no Washington lawmakers or ACA, those changes would be officials, and several Democratic
ter acknowledges statements members of President Donald spearheaded by HHS. lawmakers calling for the health
Mr. Trump has already made Trump’s administration will be Dr. Price kept a low profile at secretary’s resignation.
condemning white supremacy invited to speak at the federa- times during the long legisla- The exit of HHS Secretary Tom Price, above, comes as Trump Dr. Price’s departure comes
and the Ku Klux Klan. Still, it tion’s once-every-four-year con- tive fight to undo the ACA, as administration efforts to repeal the health law are at a standstill. as other cabinet officials, includ-
says the president should more vention, to be held in St. Louis in such officials as Seema Verma, ing Treasury Secretary Steven
directly condemn the alt-right October. head of the Centers for Medi- ing first-ever requirements on travel and reimburse the gov- Mnuchin, have faced questions
movement, which the letter calls That is a major departure care and Medicaid Services, some state Medicaid programs ernment more than $50,000 for over their travel expenses.
“racist, evil and antithetical to a from past conventions, which sometimes took on a more visi- that may require enrollees to his seat on chartered flights The administration late Fri-
well-ordered, peaceful society.” have featured senators, labor ble role in talking to lawmakers. work to keep or get benefit. since May. “I will take no more day revised its travel policy to
“This movement has escaped secretaries and presidents, in- Some health experts have sug- HHS and CMS were also had private charter flights as secre- require that all travel on gov-
your disapproval,” the letter cluding Barack Obama and Ron- gested Ms. Verma could suc- backed moving away from a tary of HHS,” Dr. Price said. “No ernment-owned, rented, leased
says. “We believe it is important ald Reagan. The AFL-CIO has ceed Dr. Price. central Obama-era push under exceptions.” or chartered planes get prior
for this movement to be ad- typically endorsed Democrats for Other potential candidates the ACA to pay providers based HHS didn’t state the overall approval from the White House
dressed, for at its core it is a president, including Hillary Clin- for the post include former on patient outcomes instead for cost of the flights. chief of staff.
white identity movement and ton last year, even as many Pennsylvania Sen. Rick Santo- each service performed. Republicans praised Dr. Price The memo Friday from Mick
the majority of its members are union members support Republi- rum, former Louisiana Gov. Mr. Trump has asked Don in the wake of his resignation. Mulvaney, director of the Office
white nationalists or white su- cans. Mrs. Clinton won 56% of Bobby Jindal, Veterans Affairs Wright, the department’s acting “He has spent his entire adult of Management and Budget,
premacists.” union members, but that was secretary David Shulkin and assistant secretary of Health, to life fighting for others, first as a came at the direction of Mr.
“Alt-right” is a catchall phrase sharply narrower than Mr. John Fleming, currently HHS’s serve as interim secretary. physician and then as a legisla- Trump, Mr. Mulvaney said.
for far-right groups that em- Obama’s 65% mark four years deputy assistant secretary for Dr. Price’s repeated use of a tor and public servant,” said The memo noted that, with
brace tenets of white supremacy earlier, according to AFL-CIO sur- health technology reform, ac- chartered jet and military air- House Speaker Paul Ryan (R., few exceptions, commercial air-
or reject mainstream conserva- veys. cording to lawmakers, health of- craft raised the ire of Mr. Trump Wis.). “He was a leader in the craft is appropriate. “Put an-
tism. The letter, which was ear- Union President Richard ficials and congressional aides. and other White House officials, House and a superb health sec- other way, just because some-
lier reported by CNN, was Trumka has spoken this year HHS didn’t respond to a re- who felt his actions contradicted retary.” thing is legal doesn’t make it
emailed to the president on Fri- about the need for his organiza- quest for comment. their campaign promise to “Secretary Price’s loss will be right,” the memo said.
day morning, said Keith S. Whit- tion to have political indepen- Dr. Price was a central force “drain the swamp” of Washing- felt,” said Rep. Mark Meadows Before his tenure as secre-
field, dean of graduate studies dence. Mr. Trumka backs Mr. behind administrative steps the ton and save taxpayers money. (R., N.C.), head of a conservative tary, Dr. Price was long a fa-
at Southeastern Baptist Theo- Trump’s effort to renegotiate department has taken to roll Politico reported that Dr. bloc of lawmakers that negoti- miliar Republican face on Cap-
logical Seminary. trade agreements on more fa- back the health law known as Price had chartered at least 24 ated changes to the GOP health- itol Hill. He served in the
A White House spokesman vorable terms to American com- Obamacare. He oversaw a deci- planes to domestic events and care bill with the Trump admin- House of Representatives since
said that the president had panies and workers, but his or- sion to scale back millions of flown on military jets for trips istration. 2005 until taking over at the
made clear that he opposes ha- ganization has opposed the dollars in outreach and advertis- in Europe and Asia, with a total Democrats, however, had helm of HHS.
tred, bigotry and racism in all administration’s tax-overhaul and ing for the ACA’s coming open- price tag exceeding $1 million. united in opposition to Dr. —Eli Stokols and
forms. immigration plans. enrollment period. On Thursday evening, Dr. Price’s Senate confirmation in Louise Radnofsky contributed
—Ian Lovett —Eric Morath HHS and CMS were consider- Price pledged to end private jet February and said the decision to this article.
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * * * * * NY Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 | A5
OBITUARIES
NICOLAAS BLOEMBERGEN H I C K S WA L D R O N
1920 — 2017 1923 — 2017
A
hard to digest. gery, computer storage, shaping fter earning an engineering pier.
After the war, eager to escape of materials and printing, among degree and serving in the In a 27-year career at GE, he
his ravaged homeland, he applied other applications. His research U.S. Navy during World War moved 17 times and worked his
for graduate school in physics at also led to MRI scans producing II, Hicks Waldron wanted to design way up to group vice president for
three American universities. The crisp images inside the body. jet engines. Instead, his job at consumer products. In 1973, he be-
University of Chicago never re- Dr. Bloembergen grew up near General Electric Co. led him into came president of Heublein Inc.,
plied. The University of California, Utrecht in the Netherlands. His fa- sales and general management. whose brands included Smirnoff,
Berkeley, informed him that it ther was a chemist. In a biograph- With his GE pedigree, he was A1 steak sauce and Kentucky Fried
wasn’t admitting foreign students ical note, Dr. Bloembergen said recruited in the 1970s and 1980s to Chicken. He rose to become CEO of
at the time. Harvard accepted him. his parents lived below their run companies selling brands in- Heublein two years later.
After a 17-day crossing of the means. cluding Smirnoff vodka, Kentucky His first wife, Peg, died of can-
Atlantic on a Liberty cargo ship, As a child, he was initially con- Fried Chicken and Avon cosmetics. cer in 1975. The next year, his
he found his new home in Boston. sidered a slow learner. Relatives When he joined Avon in 1983, teenage son, Ben, died in a car ac-
“I had arrived at the right place dubbed him “Dumb Nick.” The profit was falling as fewer Ameri- cident. Mr. Waldron found himself
at the right time,” he later wrote. nickname was retired when, at can women wanted to sell cosmet- overindulging in alcohol, fatty
As a professor and researcher at age 4, he defeated an uncle at ics door to door. Mr. Hicks pur- foods and cigars. Soon he was di-
Harvard, he helped create much of checkers. sued a diversification started by agnosed with pancreatitis and
the science behind high-tech appa- He died Sept. 5 at his home in his predecessors, buying nursing forced to adopt healthier habits.
ratus now taken for granted, from Tucson, Ariz. He was 97 and had homes and other health-care busi- While recuperating, he had to
optical communications to lasers recently suffered a heart attack. nesses. At first, Wall Street investments or offering quarter- give up his CEO job at Heublein.
and magnetic resonance imaging, —James R. Hagerty cheered, but the acquisitions end discounts “that will steal He earned it back by helping lead a
flopped. By the time Mr. Waldron money out of the next quarter.” turnaround at KFC. Among other
retired at the end of 1988, Avon things, the chain repaired relations
F
D A N I E L YA N K E L O V I C H was reverting to a tight focus on or all his worries, Mr. Wal- with its founder, Harland Sanders,
1924 — 2017 direct sales of lipstick and per- dron retained an optimistic who had likened KFC’s gravy to
fume. nature. Mr. Kleinfield wrote wallpaper paste.
Mr. Waldron died Sept. 22 at that the CEO had an “intoxicating When R.J. Reynolds Industries
A
s a Harvard University un- Saatchi for $13.5 million in 1984. Mr. Kleinfield’s book, “Staying bled a football in the end zone in So he grabbed the opportunity
dergraduate in the late By then, he had established him- at the Top,” depicts the Avon CEO the final game of the season. “So if to become CEO of Avon in 1983. He
1940s, recently returned self as a public-opinion pollster, as often distracted by minor is- you ask me when did I learn humil- bought companies operating nurs-
from U.S. Army service in Eu- working with publications includ- sues, such as the design of corpo- ity, that was when,” he told Mr. ing homes and providing supplies
rope, Daniel Yankelovich consid- ing the New York Times and Time rate name tags and faulty vacuum- Kleinfield. for people recuperating at home.
ered pursuing an academic career magazine, and as a “public intel- ing of a lobby, as he struggled He attended Green Mountain When results in the health-care
in philosophy. Then he discov- lectual,” as he put it, who eventu- with the bigger picture of a com- College and the University of Mich- units faltered, the company
ered that academic philosophy ally wrote more than a dozen pany that had lost its way. igan before transferring to the Uni- changed course and began selling
had little to say about how peo- books. He worried about some Avon versity of Minnesota and earning those operations. Mr. Waldron
ple should live their lives. He In 1975, he and Cyrus Vance employees’ preference for a his mechanical engineering de- gradually came to see the Avon la-
needed another plan. founded Public Agenda, a policy makeup-free look. “I think some of gree. Before marrying, he had to dies as the company’s best bet. In-
A knack for asking ques- research organization. He later our women could be better adver- borrow from his fiancée to buy her stead of selling everything door to
tions—and listening to the an- provided funding for the Yankel- tisements of our cosmetics busi- a ring. door, they sold more to working
swers—led Mr. Yankelovich to ovich Center for Social Science ness,” he groused. “We’re not run- He played fullback for his uni- women in the office.
what he called his “accidental Research at the University of Cal- ning a steel mill or a bank. We’re versity football teams in both Mr. Waldron is survived by his
profession” of market research. ifornia, San Diego. running a beauty company.” Michigan and Minnesota. While he second wife, the former Evelyn
He later set up his own firm and Mr. Yankelovich died Sept. 22 Anxious about kidnapping risks, was at Michigan, the team lost Rumstay, as well as a daughter
helped companies including Ford at his home in La Jolla, Calif. He he devised a secret code to com- 50-0 to Minnesota. After he trans- from his first marriage and two
Motor Co., General Mills Inc. and was 92. municate with his wife in an emer- ferred to Minnesota, his new team grandchildren.
the brewers of Schlitz beer fig- “It would be a far more conve- gency and advised his daughter was crushed 52-6 by Michigan. He liked golf and the occasional
ure out what people would buy. nient world for journalists if the not to use the family name. “The common denominator was surprise: His wife, Evelyn, some-
He warned clients not to seg- public wasn’t so ornery about He recognized the dangers of a Waldron,” he liked to quip. times arranged vacations and told
ment consumers into rigid types: how it goes about making up its fixation on short-term stock price After he graduated, the Navy him the destination only at the last
A buyer of cheap watches might mind,” he wrote in his 2015 book movements. “I have the sickness,” sent him to Cornell University for minute.
have expensive taste in wine. “Wicked Problems, Workable So- he confessed, adding that it could officer’s training. He served aboard
Mr. Yankelovich’s firm was sold lutions.” lead to “some pretty stupid judg- ships during World War II but was Read a collection of in-depth
to the advertising giant Saatchi & —James R. Hagerty ments,” such as slashing needed never sent into combat. The one profiles at WSJ.com/Obituaries
SAVE 20%
to expectations of rising rates, Labor Department said, a re- Arone, chief investment strate-
with the KBW Nasdaq Bank In- port some analysts said should gist at State Street Global Advi-
dex of large U.S. commercial reassure the Fed after a string sors. Mr. Arone said he believes
lenders rising 6.8% in Septem-
‘In the last month, of muted inflation readings. central banks will keep rates on Select
ber compared with the S&P the market seems to In September, a gauge used lower for longer, despite hinting
Shavers with
500’s 1.9% increase. Shares of by central bankers to project otherwise in recent months.
industrial companies in the S&P
have completely where they think interest rates In another sign of wariness, CODE:
changed its mind.’
500 have risen 3.8%. The Rus-
sell 2000 index of small-capital-
will go showed 12 of 16 offi-
cials expected at least one
fund flows show investors are
continuing to pour money into 20YANKEES
ization companies, perceived to
be some of the biggest benefi-
more rate increase this year
and most expect at least three
technology companies, which
are thought by some to offer at Checkout
ciaries of a tax overhaul be- stocks with the highest tax more next year. the best returns in a sluggish
cause of their relatively heavy rates rallied in the two weeks The revelation surprised economic environment.
tax burden, climbed 6.1%. ended Sept. 22 after underper- some investors who thought Mutual funds and exchange-
That follows a period of un- forming the S&P 500 for most the central bank would delay traded funds that invest in
derperformance for the Russell of the year. rate increases. Investors now technology stocks drew in
2000. After rising for 15 consec- J.P. Morgan Chase & Co. an- see a 78% chance of one or about $1 billion of inflows for
utive trading days in November, alysts opined similarly, saying more additional rate increases the week ended Sept. 20, the
notching several highs, the in- in a research note earlier in by the end of the year, accord- second largest inflows for the
dex fell behind the S&P 500 for September that “now is a good ing to federal-funds futures sector on record, according to WWW.AMAZON.COM/GP/ADLP/PANASONICGROOMING
ALL NEW YORK YANKEES TRADEMARKS AND COPYRIGHTS ARE OWNED BY THE NEW YORK
months and is now back at re- time to position for tax re- tracked by CME Group Inc., up data from fund tracker EPFR YANKEES AND USED WITH THE PERMISSION OF THE NEW YORK YANKEES.
cords. The rally in bank and in- form.” The bank’s analysts from about 50% before the Sep- Global.
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
A6 | Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 * *** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
WORLD NEWS
Myanmar Child: ‘A Soldier Cut His Throat’
Rohingya refugees tell
of terror as military
raids villages, forces
thousands to flee
BY SYED ZAIN AL-MAHMOOD
TEKNAF, Bangladesh—
Twelve-year-old Sukhutara
CATHAL MCNAUGHTON/REUTERS; SYED ZAIN AL-MAHMOOD FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL (BELOW)
said she watched her family’s
final moments from a hiding
place in the bushes.
She had just finished taking
the cows to pasture that morn-
ing when soldiers in olive-
green uniform stormed her vil-
lage in Myanmar’s Rakhine
state. She said her absence
saved her life.
“The military shot my fa-
ther, and then as he lay on the
ground a soldier cut his
throat,” she said.
In a refugee camp on the
border, Sukhutara, who goes
by one name, sobbed as she
described how troops dragged
her mother and several other
women into a hut. She heard
screams from inside. Then the
soldiers came out and set the
hut ablaze.
In recent weeks, Myanmar’s
army has launched a counter-
insurgency in Rakhine, clear-
ing villages inhabited by the Rohingya refugees from Myanmar arrived on Thursday at a camp in Cox’s Bazar, Bangladesh. Below, 12-year-old Sukhutara recounted the violent killing of her family.
Rohingya Muslim minority and
prompting at least 500,000 do any kind of their accusa- close relatives: her parents,
CHINA
people to flee into Bangladesh, tions,” Col. Phone Tint, Myan- grandparents and four broth-
the United Nations said Thurs- mar’s border affairs minister, ers. Her uncle, Jahur Alam,
BHUTAN
day. The military and army- said in an interview. with whom she now lives in the
backed militias have killed Reports of atrocities have INDIA refugee camp, said there were
about 3,000 people, according pressured Ms. Suu Kyi, who in no militants in Tulatoli when
BANGLA.
to Bangladesh’s government a speech last week defended the army swept in on Aug. 30.
and rights groups. Myanmar’s treatment of Roh- Dhaka “If there were militants in
M YA N M A R
The U.N. Security Council ingya. (BURMA) the village, we would have fled
met Thursday to debate the A spokesman for Ms. Suu as soon as the troops ap-
crisis as a bipartisan group of Kyi said the military had con- Naypyitaw proached,” he said at a camp
senators in Washington urged ducted “clearance operations” RAKHINE in Bangladesh, his arm in a
the Trump administration to in accordance with its code of STATE sling after he was shot. “The
Bay of Bengal
help resolve it. “Despite inter- conduct and rules of engage- military killed the men, raped
Yangon
national condemnation, the ment. Anyone who wished to 200 miles the women, they threw little
Burmese authorities incredibly file a case against the military children into the water.”
continue to deny the atroci- could do so and it would be in- 200 km The numbers of Rohingya
ties,” they said in a letter. vestigated in accordance with THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. pouring into Bangladesh have
Aung San Suu Kyi, who leads the law, he said. overwhelmed aid services.
the government of Buddhist- Sukhutara’s account was cleansing.” “The army didn’t want to be Tulatoli, the village where Bangladesh says the refugees
majority Myanmar, says troops verified by other survivors Close observers of Myan- bogged down in a counterin- Sukhutara lived, was home to won’t be allowed to integrate
have been hunting militants of from her village who spoke to mar say the army’s operation surgency in Rakhine, taking ca- between 4,000 and 5,000 peo- into the community and that
the Arakan Rohingya Salvation The Wall Street Journal. Hu- was modeled on the “Four sualties over a number of ple before the massacre. It was Myanmar must take them back.
Army who attacked police posts man Rights Watch and Am- Cuts” strategy former dictator years,” said Richard Horsey, an victim to among the worst vio- Political analysts and hu-
and an army base Aug. 25. nesty International say there is Gen. Ne Win employed against independent political analyst lence in the military’s cam- man-rights activists say the
Myanmar rejects survivors’ evidence of such atrocities. rebels in the 1970s: targeting in Myanmar. “They were per- paign, with witnesses saying Rohingya face a bleak future in
accounts that the military The United Nations’ human- civilian areas to deny insur- fectly willing to destroy entire that at least several hundred the overcrowded camps where
committed rape, murder, and rights chief has described the gents food, funds, recruits and villages to deny safe haven to people were killed. there will be little prospect for
torched villages. “We did not army’s clearances as “ethnic information. the fighters of ARSA.” Sukhutara said she lost eight employment or education.
ern seismic and satellite overpass connecting Mumbai’s onto trains in Mumbai that of-
equipment to monitor the busy Parel and Elphinstone ficials coined a term to de-
mountain. Road train stations about scribe the crowds—often at
Even with such technology, 10:45 a.m., railway authorities 2.5 times capacity—that now
volcanologists say it is impos- said. ride at peak hours: superdense
sible to predict exactly when “The stampede occurred crush load. The same over-
the volcano will blow. Mean- due to overcrowding and crowding happens at the sta-
while, the risk of an eruption heavy rainfall,” said Anil Ku- tion platforms and stairwells.
keeps farmers from their fields mar Saxena, spokesman for In- The result is that Mumbai
and threatens to squeeze Bali’s dian Railways, adding that the trains kill thousands of people
tourism industry. panic may have been triggered a year. Hundreds are run down
Indonesia’s national volcano Indonesia’s Mount Agung last erupted in 1963. Scientists fear another eruption may be imminent. after someone yelled that the scrambling across the tracks
monitor has said that an erup- path was falling. or falling off trains and plat-
tion may be imminent but that TV footage showed a tangle forms bursting with people.
the current seismic activity Shaking Up History what is thought to be the larg- that killed nearly 100,000 peo- of fallen victims—piled at least Friday’s accident, however,
could continue for weeks. It is est eruption in human history. ple. Ash from the eruption led to four people deep—stuck on the was a rare example of a mass
difficult to estimate timing, in a gloomy summer in Europe, in- stairs, and people carrying death. Piyush Goyal, India’s
part because modern equip- Samalas, 1257: A volcano spiring Mary Shelley to begin bodies away from the crush. railways minister, tweeted that
ment wasn’t available to mea- Though Agung’s eventual on Lombok island, just east of writing ‘Frankenstein.’ The two stations are among he ordered an inquiry. Mr.
sure the last eruption, so sci- eruption isn’t expected to be Bali, erupted, sending sheets of Mumbai’s busiest. They sit in Goyal took over as railways
entists don’t know how felt much beyond the island, ash as far as Antarctica. The Krakatau, 1883: A massive the middle of one of the most minister in September after a
current activity compares with some Indonesian eruptions have eruption was recently linked to series of eruptions destroyed rapidly developing areas of the series of train derailments led
the lead-up to past eruptions. altered the course of history. widespread famine the follow- the small island of Krakatau city. The neighborhood, once to his predecessor’s departure.
“Managing the crisis at ing year in England. and turned European sunsets defined by abandoned textile Prime Minister Narendra
Agung is a new thing,” said Toba, some 75,000 years bright red for months, lowering mills, has in the past decade Modi has pledged to modernize
Devy Syahbana of Indonesia’s ago: A volcano in North Suma- Tambora, 1815: A volcano global temperatures by more transformed into a business India’s rail network. In Septem-
Center for Volcanology and tra released 2,000-3,000 cubic erupted on the Indonesian island than 2 degrees Fahrenheit the and entertainment hub full of ber, he launched construction
Geological Hazard Mitigation. kilometers of ash into the air, in of Sumbawa, creating a tsunami next year. office towers, condominiums, of India’s first bullet train.
“There was no instrumental
documentation before the
eruption of Agung in 1963.” crater, again implying that like Agung. when an eruption will occur,
When Agung began belch- magma is pushing upward. The most recent official no- even in situations like the cur-
ing steam and sulfuric gas a Meanwhile, tiltmeter data, tice warns that the magnitude rent one, where they believe
week ago, prompting the evac- which measure deformation in of earthquakes beneath the an eruption is likely.
uation of more than 130,000 the volcano’s shape, suggest volcano is increasing and that Because of the uncertainty
Balinese, the island’s volcanol- the mountain is inflating with “the probability of an eruption about timing, some Balinese
ogists had already begun de- magma. As magma and sulfu- is higher than the probability farmers are entering the erup-
tecting tremors beneath the ric gases push toward the of no eruption.” tion zone during the day to
BI XIAOYANG/XINHUA/ZUMA PRESS
base of the volcano. peak, pressure builds, eventu- Independent experts, less tend to their land, according
Recent seismographic mea- ally leading to an explosion. cautious, say that an eruption to Hevy Umbara, a geologist
surements indicate earth- Scientists say an eruption is imminent. “It’s much more volunteering near Mount
quakes are rising closer to the of Agung would lead to pyro- likely to keep going now then Agung to warn locals of the
base of the volcano, suggest- clastic flows that would kill to stop,” said Richard Arculus, dangers of returning to their
ing that red-hot magma is anyone in their path and dev- an emeritus professor of geol- fields. “I worry farmers will
coursing up through the astate farmland, as happened ogy at Australian National become victims,” he said. “We
mountain. Satellite data tell a in 1963. Such flows—made up University. need a solution so that farm-
similar story, showing new of gas, ash and rock—are pro- But scientists say they lack ers don’t enter the danger
thermal areas in the summit duced by composite volcanos the tools to predict precisely zones.” A man injured by the stampede at the Mumbai station Friday.
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 | A7
WORLD NEWS
WORLD
WATCH
Iraq Imposes Flight Ban After Kurd Vote
Iraq imposed a flight ban TURKEY
on its semiautonomous Kurd-
CANADA ish region on Friday, retaliat- SYRIA IRAN
ing against a landmark refer-
Police Seek Arrest endum this week in which the Mosul
MEXICO
Building Practices
Probed After Quake
Bomber Targets Kabul Mosque on Eve of Shiite Holy Day
BY HABIB KHAN TOTAKHIL The Taliban, which has Afghanistan’s Interior Minis- to escalate calls by the coun- 15% of Afghanistan’s over-
Mexico City Mayor Miguel Án- AND CRAIG NELSON waged a 16-year insurgency try, Najib Danish, said the at- try’s minority Shiite commu- whelmingly Sunni population
gel Mancera said local authorities against the central govern- tacker was headed for the nity for more police and army of around 30 million.
are investigating more than 80 KABUL—Just days before ment and its foreign support- crowds flooding from the Hus- protection or, failing that, lead The bombing follows an at-
cases linked to defective con- Afghanistan’s Shiite Muslims ers, denied responsibility for sainia mosque at the end of to the formation of more Shi- tack by militants this week on
struction in collapsed or damaged mark the most important the bombing, which occurred Friday prayers when he was ite militias. Kabul’s international airport,
buildings in the wake of a deadly event on their sect’s religious in the run-up to the commem- stopped at a checkpoint 200 Amid fears the Taliban or an assault the Taliban said had
earthquake on Sept. 19. calendar, a man wearing an oration of Ashura on Sunday. yards away. Blocked from his Islamic State would carry out targeted U.S. Defense Secre-
At least 355 people, including explosives vest blew himself Islamic State, another mili- destination, he triggered his attacks to coincide with Ashura tary Jim Mattis, who was vis-
more than 200 in Mexico City, up near a crowded Shiite tant Sunni fundamentalist vest, Mr. Danish said. observances, authorities or- iting to discuss President Don-
were killed in the quake. Hun- mosque in central Kabul on group operating in Afghanistan, The government of Presi- dered more security around ald Trump’s South Asia
dreds of buildings in the capital Friday, killing at least six peo- didn’t comment on the attack. dent Ashraf Ghani had no im- Shiite neighborhoods and strategy. The Pentagon chief
and nearby states were damaged. ple and wounding 14 others, The carnage could have mediate response to Friday’s mosques across the country. had already departed the air-
—Dudley Althaus Afghan authorities said. been worse. A spokesman for bombing. The attack is likely Shiites represent an estimated port at the time of the attack.
ADVERTISEMENT
U
LIM
70%
R
off
10
ER
B
BY O C TO 5. What to Expect from a Literary Agent
6. Writing Your Query Letter
7. Writing Your Novel or Memoir Synopsis
8. The Importance of Author Platform
9. Researching and Planning Your Book Proposal
10. Writing an Effective Book Proposal
11. Submissions and Publishing Etiquette
12. Networking: From Writers’ Conferences to Courses
13. Pitching Your Book
14. Avoiding Common Manuscript Pitfalls
15. Hiring a Professional Editor
16. How Writers Handle Rejection
17. Overcoming Obstacles to Writing
18. The Book Publishing Contract
19. Working Effectively with Your Publisher
20. Becoming a Bestselling Author
21. Career Marketing Strategies for Writers
22. The Self-Publishing Path: When and How
23. Principles of Self-Publishing Success
24. Beyond the Book: Sharing Ideas in the Digital Age
find such an invaluable tutorial on how to position your book for publishing success. Priority Code: 150541
For over 25 years, The Great Courses has brought the world’s foremost
Offer expires 10/10/17 educators to millions who want to go deeper into the subjects that
matter most. No exams. No homework. Just a world of knowledge
TGCU.
/4 available anytime, anywhere. Download or stream to your laptop or
PC, or use our free apps for iPad, iPhone, Android, Kindle Fire, or
1-800-832-2412 Roku. Over 600 courses available at www.TheGreatCourses.com.
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
A8 | Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 * ******* THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
WORLD NEWS
Strife Looms
Over Catalan
Referendum
BY JEANNETTE NEUMANN
lans backed independence, the
BARCELONA—Catalan sepa- most recent figures available
ratists on Friday vowed to from the region’s survey
press on with an independence agency. Around half then sup-
2,315
Number of polling stations that
hold a referendum has made
talks impossible. There have
been no formal negotiations be-
tween Madrid and Barcelona,
hadn’t spoken Catalan, this
wouldn’t have happened,’ ” Mr.
Puigdemont said.
Now 54, Mr. Puigdemont
toward a vote it has deemed il-
legal and is actively trying to
block. The once-marginal politi-
cal cause he espouses has pro-
and daughters about the possi-
bility of being imprisoned,” said
Carles Porta, a longtime friend.
Critics say Mr. Puigdemont’s
mains staunch in his conviction
that Catalonia’s future is as an
independent republic. “Indepen-
dence motivates me because it
Catalan officials say will be open Catalonia’s capital, since Mr. heads Catalonia’s campaign to pelled Spain into a full-blown push has riven Catalan society allows me to be that which I
Rajoy took power in 2011. break free of Spain. A former institutional and political crisis. and unnecessarily spun the re- am,” he said.
Spanish authorities’ heavy- journalist, Mr. Puigdemont is a Since the ballot will be gion into an institutional crisis —Marina Force
handed tactics are fanning the
regional government’s spend- flames of independence senti-
ing authority, and sent thou- ment, some say. secession on the table for
sands of police officers to the Josep Batet, a 49-year-old years to come, analysts say. Head of the Pack
northeastern region to ensure automotive worker, said the Some Catalans are fed up Catalonia has been an economically strong area when compared with the rest of Spain.
schools and other public places central government’s response with what they see as exagger-
aren’t used as polling stations. reminds him of the crackdown ated claims on the part of sep- GDP per capita in 2016
Catalan officials said voters his region faced under Fran- aratists that the rest of the
would still be able to cast their cisco Franco, Spain’s longtime country disregard their fi- $20,000 $24,000 $28,000 GDP per capita
ballots on Sunday at 2,315 dictator. “I thought it would nances and culture. B ASQU E €30,000
CAN TA B R I A C OU N T RY
polling stations by placing pa- never happen again,” Mr. Batet “I don’t feel oppressed. Cat- Catalonia
AST U R IAS NAVA R R E
per ballots into plastic ballot said. An independent Catalo- alonia is part of a democratic CATA LONIA 25,000
boxes. “Have no doubt there nia “is the only solution I see.” state,” said Carlos Rivadulla, G ALIC IA
are alternatives,” Catalan Vice Even if Spanish authorities an entrepreneur in Barcelona. CAST ILE
President Oriol Junqueras told manage to suppress turnout, “Imagine the congress of Texas AN D LEO N
20,000 Spain
reporters with a sly smile. Catalan separatists could de- saying the American Constitu- LA R I O JA
A RAG ON
The standoff over Catalonia’s clare independence soon after. tion no longer exists in Texas.”
status has moved from the mar- They have threatened to hold Unionists emphasize that M ADR ID 15,000
gins of political debate to cen- a general strike, and hundreds the Spanish kingdom has ex- BA L E A R I C
ISLANDS
ter stage only in recent years. of thousands of protesters isted since the 15th century, 10,000
CASTILLA LA VA L E NC I A
Secession became more alluring could spill out into the streets, but Spain has long struggled EXT R EM ADU RA M AN C HA
to Catalans during Spain’s eco- possibly for days on end. to respond to regionalist de-
nomic downturn, when resent- Spanish officials have said mands coming from some of 5,000
ment over the distribution of they could remove the region’s its 17 autonomous regions. M U RC I A
tax revenue from the wealthy leader and other officials, ef- Franco tried to forge a uni- CA NARY ISLANDS
AN DALUSIA
CUE TA
0
region to poorer areas melded fectively taking control of de- fied Spanish identity through
M E L I L LA 2007 2010 ’16
with long-held grudges over the cision making in Catalonia. repression, but separatist sen-
place of Catalan language and Elections would likely follow timent has been an Achilles’
culture in Spain. and pro-independence parties heel since the country returned Note: €1 = $1.18
In June, about 35% of Cata- could gain ground—keeping to democracy in the late 1970s. Source: Spain’s National Statistics Institute THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
“I am appointing these grip on the board and em- merly CEO of the New York
seats now in light of a recent power later-state sharehold- Stock Exchange and Merrill
board proposal to dramatically ers, viewing it as a critical Lynch leading up to the lat-
EDUARDO MUNOZ/REUTERS
restructure the board and sig- first step before it weighs the ter’s $50 billion sale to Bank
nificantly alter the company’s SoftBank deal, according to of America Corp. in 2008. At
voting rights,” Mr. Kalanick people familiar with the mat- CIT, he oversaw the $3.4 bil-
said in the statement. “It is ter. Uber’s early investors, in- lion acquisition of OneWest
therefore essential that the cluding Benchmark, First Bank NA’s parent and serves
full board be in place for Round Capital, Menlo Ventures now on the board of the en-
proper deliberation to occur, and Lowercase Capital hold dowment of the Massachusetts
especially with such experi- Uber’s newest directors: Former Xerox CEO Ursula Burns and former CIT Group CEO John Thain. outsize voting power relative Institute of Technology.
enced board members as Ur- to their stakes. The appointments fill out
sula and John.” Uber said in a statement mark didn’t immediately re- ter. SoftBank is seeking to ob- Ms. Burns, 59 years old, the board to 11 seats, leaving
Benchmark sued Mr. Kalan- that the appointments of Ms. spond to a request for com- tain two board seats of its own was CEO of Xerox for seven open the question of where
ick in August to return to Burns and Mr. Thain to the ment. and a 17% to 22% stake years until last year when she Uber will place a new indepen-
board control the two seats he board “came as a complete While Benchmark and Mr. through a tender offer to ex- stepped down. One of the dent chairman. It was man-
oversees and his own, arguing surprise,” adding: “That is Kalanick face off, Uber’s board isting Uber shareholders and most prominent African- dated to do so as part of a re-
he reneged on an agreement precisely why we are working and new chief executive, Dara at least a $1 billion direct in- American businesswomen in port from ex-U.S. Attorney
to relinquish them when he to put in place world-class Khosrowshahi, are weighing vestment, the people said. the U.S., she spent more than General Eric Holder whose law
stepped down in June. Mr. Ka- governance to ensure that we an investment from a consor- But the tender offer would three decades with the com- firm conducted a monthslong
lanick was pushed out by a are building a company every tium led by Japanese tech in- represent a discount of 30% or pany and helped orchestrate probe after a former software
group of investors who backed employee and shareholder can vestor SoftBank that could to- more from Uber’s last valua- its split into two companies engineer accused Uber with al-
a resignation letter for him be proud of.” tal $10 billion, according to tion of almost $70 billion, the earlier this year, resulting in lowing a culture of sexism and
drafted by Benchmark. A representative for Bench- people familiar with the mat- people said. the new Conduent Inc. fo- sexual harassment.
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 | A9
WORLD NEWS
A Security Puzzle
Rises to the Sky
Above Beijing
BY DOMINIQUE FONG The Beijing party secretary
who approved the tower left
BEIJING—Construction at office in May. In the past few
the top of the tallest building months, government officials
in China’s capital has stalled have started to rethink the top
because of government secu- level, studying whether to put
rity concerns, according to film over the windows, bullet-
people involved in its design proof the glass or remove the
and construction, in a new ex- observation deck altogether,
ample of how China’s passion the people involved said.
for skyscrapers is cooling. The final steel beam was
Government officials have hoisted atop China Zun in Au-
halted work on the planned gust, according to the Beijing
observation deck on China Zun government’s website. In a de-
Tower’s 106th floor because of parture from industry practice,
concerns that visitors would the developer, state-owned
be able to see into the com- banking and investment firm
JASON LEE/REUTERS
bounty hunters, it is now legally gave about $780,000 to Boeing days looking for the machine, In his first 2½ years flying
protected. Though a subspecies Co. for drone testing. Ama- worth about $35,000 at today’s drones at the mine, Mr. Steven
is still endangered in Tasmania, zon.com is expanding in Aus- retail price, and had to ship it to said he lost 12 drones to eagle
it is again dominating the skies tralia and could try using the manufacturer in Switzerland attacks, which cost his em-
across much of the continent. A picture of a wedge-tailed eagle taken by an Australian drone. drones for deliveries, and the for repairs. ployer, South Africa-based Gold
These highly territorial rap- machines are increasingly fa- Mr. Chapman said arming Fields Ltd., some $210,000. Dur-
tors, which eat kangaroos, have throttle to outrun them. eagles. On one occasion, he was vored by big landowners such drones with pepper spray was ing the past year, when he fo-
no interest in yielding their A long-term solution remains forced to evade nine birds all as miners and cattle ranchers. discussed but quickly dis- cused his flying in the morning,
apex-predator status to the in- up in the air. Camouflage tech- gunning for his machine. The eagles will often attack carded, out of concern it could he has lost two—with two more
creasing number of drones fly- niques, like putting fake eyes on The birds are considered big- in male-female pairs, and they harm the birds. “It’s a relief to close calls.
ing around the bush. They’ve the drones, don’t appear to be ger bullies than their more-doc- aren’t always deterred if their be planning for jobs overseas Mr. Parfitt, who began his
even been known to harass the fully effective, and some pilots ile relatives, such as the bald first foray fails. Sometimes because we know the wedgies drone business Aerial Image
occasional human in a hang have even considered arming and golden eagles in the U.S. they will come from behind, at- aren’t there,” he said, using the Works about three years ago,
glider. drones with pepper spray or Wedge-tailed eagles are the un- tack in tandem from above, or local nickname for the bird. remains vigilant. Each of his
Birds all over the world have noise devices to ward off eagles. disputed alpha birds in parts of even stagger their assault. A Rick Steven, a survey super- last three jobs attracted an ea-
attacked drones, but the wedge- They are the “ultimate angry Australia’s interior but it’s not drone operator may evade one intendent at the St. Ives gold gle attack. Other birds will “fly
tailed eagle is particularly ea- birds,” said James Rennie, who entirely clear why they’re so diving eagle with an upward mine in Western Australia, who at the drone and they’ll act in a
ger to engage in dogfights, op- started a drone-mapping and in- unusually aggressive towards climb, but the second eagle can uses drones to survey the pits, very aggressive manner, but
erators say. Some try to evade spection business in Melbourne drones. Scientists say they go then snatch it, Mr. Rennie said. debated using something like a they don’t actually touch you,”
these avian enemies by sending called Australian UAV. He fig- after drones probably because “If you take your eye off that ShuRoo—a device mounted on he said. “I’m not scared of any-
their drones into loops or steep ures that 20% of drone flights in they view them as potential aircraft even for a couple of cars that makes noise, which thing else attacking my drone
climbs, or just mashing the rural areas get attacked by the prey or a new competitor. minutes, the likelihood is it will humans can’t hear, to keep kan- except the wedge-tailed eagle.”
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
A10 | Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 * *** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
IN DEPTH
I
2010 party control 61st 62nd 63rd n 2010, a nationwide Re- 2016 party control 66th 62nd 63rd
By Brent Kendall publican wave swept the
and Jess Bravin GOP into the Wisconsin
Graphics by Renée Rigdon, governor’s mansion and leg-
Brian McGill, Max Rust islature, giving the party the 62nd
and Angela Calderon 61st power to redraw the state’s
electoral map for the first
D
63rd
emocrat Cory Mason time in half a century.
won a seat in the Wis- The new District 62 sepa-
consin Assembly by rated Mr. Mason from most 63rd
fewer than 1,000 votes in 2006. of his old constituents in Ra-
District 62 was sand- 62nd cine, Wis., and swept in rural
wiched between one heavily and conservative precincts. 66th
Democratic district and an- How much more Republican or Democratic each precinct is than He was stuck in a red dis-
other that strongly favored Wisconsin (pct. pts.)* trict. To stay in office, Mr.
Republicans. The districts Mason moved to District 66,
are outlined in black in the 15 10 0 10 15 a new island of Democratic *Based on the two-party vote in the 2008 presidential election
map to the right. More Democratic More Republican strength, shown at far right. Source: WSJ analysis of Wisconsin State Legislature and Harvard Election Data Archive data
R
epublicans engineered and Republicans have sought nationally from redistricting Voting for the Wisconsin State Assembly
similar moves across to redraw maps that increase have gone to Republicans
DEMOCRAT REPUBLICAN
Wisconsin, erecting a their party’s electoral clout, due to their election suc- 2008
firewall that helped protect largely by creating a greater cesses in 2010. The rise of 55.6% 44.4%
the GOP’s majority of 60 number of winnable seats. computer-powered voter Vote pct.
seats in the 99-member As- The Supreme Court is in a analysis, which allows elec- 52 46
Seats
sembly. The new lines with- position, if it chooses, to cre- toral maps to be redrawn
stood a shift of more than ate the first nationwide defi- with more precision than 2012
53.2% 46.8%
400,000 votes to Democrats nition of how much partisan- ever, has supercharged both Vote pct.
in the 2012 state elections. ship in redistricting is too parties’ efforts. 39 60
Seats
What happened to Mr. much. The high court has In Wisconsin, nearly two-
Mason is now part of a Su- never found a partisan ger- thirds of state assembly 2016
46.8% 53.2%
preme Court case that will rymander unconstitutional, seats were won by Republi- Vote pct.
decide the future of political partly because the justices cans last year when the 35 64
gerrymandering, a phenome- haven’t been able to agree party won 53% of votes Seats
non with a rich, bipartisan on a method to determine statewide. There was almost
Note: Percentages exclude third-party votes. Percentages don't add up to 100 due to rounding. 2008 Assembly seats include one Libertarian.
tradition. Since the founding what too much looks like. no such gap in 2008, as
of the republic, Democrats Lately, most of the gains these charts show. Source: Wisconsin Elections Commission
I
n November, federal several options and chose How much more Republican or Democratic each precinct is than Maryland (pct. pts.)*
judges in Madison, Wis., the one that was the most
More 2002 party control 6th
ruled the new maps un- partisan. “That’s their pre- Dem.
constitutional and “intended rogative,” Mr. Schimel said.
to burden the representa- “It’s a political process.”
tional rights of Democratic Mr. Schimel says using the 6th
voters…by impeding their challengers’ legal arguments MD.
ability to translate their as a constitutional test na-
votes into legislative seats.” tionwide would invalidate a 15
Wisconsin appealed, and third of the legislative maps DEL.
the Supreme Court is sched- drawn in the past 45 years.
uled to hear arguments in Running alongside the
the case Tuesday. A ruling Wisconsin case is one from
against Wisconsin could lead Maryland involving House 10
W .V A . VA .
to major changes in how po- districts. Two years ago, the
litical maps are drawn, forc- Supreme Court ordered a D.C.
ing both parties to restrain three-judge panel to consider
their partisan motives. Much whether a 2011 redistricting
0
of the impact would be felt drafted by Gov. Martin 2012 party control 6th
in the next round of redis- O’Malley, a Democrat, disen-
tricting after the 2020 cen- franchised Republicans.
sus, a process that will shape The map resulted in Dem-
the balance of power in fed- ocratic majorities in seven of 6th
10 MD.
eral, state and local districts Maryland’s eight congressio-
across the country. nal districts and helped cost
Wisconsin’s Republican at- Republicans one of their two
torney general, Brad House seats. The case is on
DEL.
Schimel, says GOP lawmak- hold until the Supreme Court 15
ers followed traditional prac- decides the Wisconsin case.
tices in producing the cur- Before the redistricting,
rent map, such as making Maryland’s Sixth Congressio- W .V A . VA .
districts compact, tidy and nal District was anchored by
with normal-looking shapes. rural, western Republican D.C.
The November ruling strongholds that, as the top More
Rep.
cited evidence Republican map shows, stretched across
leaders were presented with the West Virginia border. *Based on the two-party vote in the 2008 presidential election Source: WSJ analysis of Wisconsin State Legislature and Harvard Election Data Archive data
T T
he impact was clear in added, “Let me state un- he Supreme Court has dering of a magnitude that is How much more Republican or Democratic each precinct is than
the 2014 election, says equivocally, categorically. I been reluctant to in- qualitatively and quantita- Wisconsin (pct. pts.)*
Sharon Strine, a sev- believe that our whole coun- terfere in the process. tively different from what
enth-generation Wolfsville try needs to develop a better It wasn’t until 1962, faced we have seen in the past.”
15 10 0 10 15
resident and one of the Re- process for congressional re- with districts not revised in Mr. Gaddie was a consultant
More Democratic More Republican
publican plaintiffs. She ran districting.” decades, that the court ruled to Wisconsin Republicans
the campaign of GOP chal- The case against gerry- political maps could be chal- during the redistricting. 2010 district boundaries
lenger Dan Bongino. mandering contends the pro- lenged in court. The court There are two common re-
“We were ahead on elec- cess violates the idea that has struck down maps de- districting strategies. “Pack- City of Eau Claire
tion night, when every pre- voters should get to choose signed to disenfranchise Af- ing” crams the minority
cinct was in except for three their representatives, rather rican-Americans and other party’s voters in one district
precincts in Montgomery than the other way around. minorities, but hasn’t ruled to weaken their influence in 68th
County,” a heavily Demo- Redrawing the lines to maxi- against either party for us- other districts nearby. Parts
cratic suburb of Washington, mize partisan gains, the ar- ing redistricting power to of Eau Claire used to be in
she says. When those votes gument goes, allows parties undermine the other. two competitive districts 67th
were counted, Mr. Bongino to win seats in numbers that In 2004, conservative Su- with a mix of GOP and Dem-
lost by less than 3,000 out of disproportionately reflect preme Court justices came ocratic voters, shown in the
a total of 190,000. their popular support and one vote short of closing the top map on the right.
Ms. Strine says the dis- can turn voters into voice- door to challenges of parti- Since 2011, Eau Claire has
trict’s western end is “just a less minorities. san gerrymandering. The been largely lumped into one
different breed of people” The increasing homogene- pivotal vote belonged to Jus- Assembly district, marked as
from those tacked onto the ity can be seen in the decline tice Anthony Kennedy, who the 91st in the bottom map
district by Mr. O’Malley. of competitive House dis- rejected the claim against and filled with Democrats. 93rd
Mr. O’Malley, who left of- tricts. Such districts are de- Pennsylvania’s congressional All the districts around it are
fice in 2015, said in a deposi- fined in the chart below as map but left open the possi- now Republican.
tion he acted “constitution- “swing seats” that vote bility that voters might bring “Cracking” divides the mi-
ally and legally” under the roughly in line with the U.S. a successful claim someday. nority party’s voters into 2016 district boundaries
system he inherited. Still, he as a whole. Some historians credit the more than one district to di-
first congressional gerry- lute their voting power. In
mandering to Patrick Henry Sheboygan, about 250 miles
200 districts for drawing Virginia’s Fifth from Eau Claire, a new line
Republican 67th
leaning
District in 1788 to hurt along Superior Avenue split
175 James Madison’s election the city into two new dis-
Democratic
68th
chances. Mr. Madison won tricts, held by Republicans.
150 leaning anyway. The term comes Mr. Mason, the Democrat
from a salamander-shaped who moved to stay in office,
125
Massachusetts state Senate says he had trouble working
91st
100
district approved in 1812 by with Republicans to accom-
Gov. Elbridge Gerry. plish much beyond small is-
Political scientists Ber- sues. In 2013, he made a suc-
93rd
75
Swing nard Grofman and Ronald cessful proposal to name the
seat Keith Gaddie told the Su- kringle the official state pas-
50
preme Court in a brief filed try of Wisconsin. After seven
1997 2000 ’05 ’10 ’15 in the Wisconsin case there years in the minority, he de-
Note: Republican and Democratic districts voted at least 5 percentage points more for the is “compelling evidence that cided to run for Racine
party's candidate than the nation overall, based on presidential elections. the 2010 redistricting cycle mayor instead. “I’d like to *Based on the two-party vote in the 2008 presidential election
Source: Cook Political Report yielded partisan gerryman- try governing,” he says. Source: WSJ analysis of Wisconsin State Legislature data
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 | A11
OPINION
THE WEEKEND INTERVIEW with Ryan Zinke | By Kimberley A. Strassel
KEN FALLIN
says. “But it means you limit One of Mr. Zinke’s first trips
wants to restore the vision grandpa, you limit the disabled as secretary was to Yellowstone
of Gifford Pinchot and veteran, you limit the family that National Park. His first stop was
goes out for a day to enjoy our the Roosevelt Arch, whose cor-
use public lands ‘for the public lands.” approach to energy plays, rather Yosemite National Park with the nerstone was laid by Theodore
benefit and enjoyment Similarly, he sees energy de- than subsidizing costly renew- preservationist John Muir: Roosevelt in 1903. It is inscribed
velopment as a basic way for ables. “We are for all-of-the- “They went out on this wonder- with that phrase from the law
of the people.’ public lands to benefit the na- above energy, but the energy it- ful ride, a ride that you could that created the park: “For the
tion. “I never want our children self has to be competitive,” he not even replicate today because Benefit and Enjoyment of the
to have to fight overseas for a says. “It isn’t Interior’s role to of the dead and dying trees.” People.”
The Interior Department has commodity that we have here,” pick and choose winners.” Mr. Zinke has ordered all his As a vision, that’s pure Gif-
positioned itself at the forefront he says, “especially knowing that All this will generate more rev- agencies to put a priority on ac- ford Pinchot, who became the
of Mr. Trump’s energy revival. It we have an energy industry that enue that the federal government tive management against wild- first chief of the U.S. Forest Ser-
is eliminating or preparing to re- is the world standard for safety can use to preserve national trea- fires. “We are spending $2 bil- vice in 1905, during TR’s presi-
verse more than 150 Obama reg- and environmental regulations.” sures for future generations. The lion a year fighting fires, money dency. Pinchot was a founder of
ulations, including those curtail- Cheap American energy, he adds, Obama administration’s crack- that could be going to far better the conservationist movement,
ing coal mining and hydraulic is crucial to lowering U.S. manu- down on energy leases slowed conservation efforts,” he says, an ardent believer in market
fracturing, better known as facturing costs and boosting royalties and left the Interior De- visibly annoyed. forces, and an aggressive propo-
fracking. It has reopened Alaska’s workers’ wages. partment with an $11.5 billion in- Such mismanagement is what nent of controlled but profitable
Cook Inlet for business, made 76 “Access to our public lands frastructure backlog in the na- drives Western frustration, use of natural resources for the
million acres in the Gulf of Mex- has been limited for industry, tional parks alone. In 2008, which threatens to become a benefit of citizens. Today’s envi-
ico available for offshore oil-and- even in areas where it is abso- Mr. Zinke says, the department new Sagebrush Rebellion. “Some ronmental movement—which
gas exploration, and turbo- lutely appropriate,” Mr. Zinke pulled in $18 billion in offshore of the anger is that our grand measures the success of govern-
charged pipeline permitting. says. “It’s called the National Pe- revenue. Last year Interior’s off- bargains have been broken, and ment land management by the
On Mr. Trump’s order, the de- troleum Reserve for a reason.” shore revenues were only $2.6 those bargains said that you had number of acres locked away
partment has reviewed 27 na- The reference is to the 23 million billion. Even with the drop in oil wilderness, but you also have from public use—has largely ex-
tional monuments, which by vir- acres in Alaska that Interior is prices, Mr. Zinke estimates that grazing; you could also hunt and cised Pinchot from history in fa-
tue of that designation can be investigating reopening for drill- had drilling continued apace, In- fish,” Mr. Zinke says. Now West- vor of Muir.
off-limits to development and to ing after Obama-era restrictions. terior would have no mainte- erners “watch these cata- “But here’s the difference,”
activities such as hunting and The department is also working nance backlog today and would strophic fires, and they’ve lost says Mr. Zinke. “TR went on a
fishing. Mr. Zinke has recom- on a new five-year plan for oil- instead be making capital invest- any faith that the federal gov- nice ride with Muir. He hired
mended shrinking at least four of and-gas development in the ments of $3 billion to $4 billion ernment is capable of being a Pinchot. And that’s because Pin-
them, in line with the Antiquities Outer Continental Shelf, 94% of a year. good steward.” chot advocated using science and
U
Act of 1906, which limits the which is currently off-limits to Mr. Zinke believes the only best practices for management.”
T
designations to federal land and energy producers. It is issuing nder Mr. Zinke’s leader- way for Interior to improve its
to the smallest area necessary to coal leases in Wyoming and Utah ship, the department has performance is through a radical he conservation ethic is
protect an actual historical or and streamlining approvals for already held more onshore overhaul. He plans to devolve far where the similarity with
scientific object. the construction of the Berwind lease sales in six months than in more authority and resources to Mr. Zinke ends. Pinchot
“I’m grateful the president had coal mine on the Virginia-West all of last year. From January to front-line park and land manag- was a scion of a wealthy East
the courage to ask the question,” Virginia border. June of 2016, Interior generated ers, allowing them to make deci- Coast family, a Yale Skull and
Mr. Zinke says. His review found “Our regulatory scheme has to just $11.5 million from onshore sions more quickly and effi- Bones man. Mr. Zinke is all
past administrations had scooped be one that holds industry ac- oil and gas. For the same period ciently. “You end up with a park blue-collar Montana—the son of
up private land and relied on bo- countable, but that isn’t arbi- this year, the figure is $146 mil- superintendent of 47 years who a plumber, an Eagle Scout, a
gus historical “objects”—in one trary,” Mr. Zinke says. In the lion. And Mr. Zinke insists he apparently can’t be trusted with college football player, a geolo-
case, a World War II-era test past, “not only has our federal drives a hard bargain. “We have making the grand decision of gist, and the first Navy SEAL
bombing crater—to justify new government been arbitrary, it has a royalty committee that we es- whether and when locals can col- elected to Congress. His broader
designations. “The Antiquities been punitive.” He cites the ex- tablished to make sure the Amer- lect fiddleheads,” a type of fern, political outlook is more liber-
Act has been used not to pro- ample of Shell, which spent $10 ican public is getting value,” he he says. “They’re spending more tarian than that of the progres-
tect, but to prevent public access billion on an Arctic drilling plan says. “If you are doing commer- time behind a desk, less in the sive Pinchot. “I’ve only ever
and to prevent public use,” Mr. “only to be forced into a regula- cial work on our public lands, field, and they are getting micro- thought there are two things
Zinke says. “To make it hard on tory box that almost guarantees the No. 1 stakeholder is the managed.” our government should fund ab-
local cattlemen, who could no failure.” Mr. Zinke is unequivocal: American public, and they need a The federal bureaucracy also solutely: our military and our
longer use machinery to scoop “That’s wrong.” His department is fair return.” makes it hard for on-site staff to parks system,” Mr. Zinke says
out a pond, or on cross-country trying to prove its good faith by Mr. Zinke says his longer-term work with state authorities, In- with a laugh. “The rest is up for
skiers, who can’t have trails clearing backlogged permit appli- goal is to make his department dian tribes, and private land- discussion.”
groomed.” cations and streamlining future a better steward. He brings up owners on solutions that take
Mr. Zinke’s office in Washing- projects. Mr. Zinke is also imple- President Theodore Roosevelt’s account of local needs. Mr. Zinke Ms. Strassel writes the Journal’s
ton is a testament to his own menting a strictly market-based famous 1903 camping trip to is thinking about moving the Potomac Watch column.
OPINION
REVIEW & OUTLOOK LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
The GOP’s First Reform Test Older Workers Face Mistaken Discrimination
T
he Republican tax “framework” is at- Chuck Schumer have been on a tour of rhetori- There is no getting around the fact well-paid older employees to retire
tracting the perennial criticism from cal excess about preserving the state and local that people are living longer and are early, creating opportunities for youn-
healthier and therefore can contribute ger employees. Perhaps the authors
the left, but the bigger question is deduction. They fear the wealthy, including
their skills and experience long past should write their congressmen and
whether competing clans on many of their campaign do- the age at which their parents and suggest they make “retiree medical”
the right can hang together to So long to low tax rates nors, would suddenly feel the grandparents left the workforce part of their new health-care plan.
pass reform that grows the if Congress blinks on full pain of what they owe. (“Let’s Agree on An Age to Retire,” KRISTI DINSMORE
economy. The GOP is already That exposure could make Review, Sept. 23). This is a win for Centerville, Ohio
showing cracks on eliminating the state tax deduction. state tax increases more diffi- employers and employees alike. Age-
the state and local tax deduc- cult to pass and blowout discrimination laws aren’t the barrier The authors propose to encourage
tion, but surrendering on this spending less sustainable. to hiring older adults; the barrier is the employment of younger people by
hoary carve-out could dilute the final product Some of Mr. Schumer’s benefactors may de- ageism. Outdated assumptions about implementing mandatory retirement
and compromise its growth impact. camp for Florida, but the hope is that states older workers’ abilities and energy ages. The good professors would be
Republican Rep. Pete King of New York would be forced to confront their spending ad- levels get in the way of hiring, even well advised to consult with their uni-
interviewing, older candidates for versity’s economics department,
tweeted this week that any tax package “must dictions. Call it a last-ditch effort to save New
jobs. The result is that any job search where they would learn that the
retain” the state and local deduction, which al- Jersey. for an individual over 55 takes an av- “lump of labor” theory that forms the
lows filers who itemize to deduct taxes paid to The press has noted that 33 House Republi- erage of 20 weeks longer than for a premise to their argument is widely
lower governments. The GOP framework didn’t cans hail from the top nine states for the deduc- person under 55. And employed older regarded as a fallacy by economists.
single out the state and local deduction for exe- tion as a share of income, but not all of them adults are disproportionately pushed If workers in their 60s are truly
cution, though everyone knows the intention are as parochial as Mr. King. Devin Nunes on out before they are ready to retire. less productive, as the authors sug-
is to eliminate the special treatment and plow the tax-writing Ways and Means Committee The Age Discrimination in Employ- gest, then the answer is simple: adjust
the more than $1.25 trillion savings over 10 represents parts of California’s Central Valley, ment Act is a toothless tiger and their pay and responsibilities as ap-
years into lower rates. where the average deduction is much lower should be strengthened, not further propriate. Let’s focus on policies that
This is good tax policy. The deduction is a than in L.A. or San Francisco. Mr. Nunes’s con- watered down. create jobs, rather than policies that
classic example of a tax preference that adds stituents like taxpayers everywhere would ben- ANN MACDOUGALL trade one worker for another under
New York the dubious assumption that employ-
complexity to the code and subsidizes some efit far more from lower rates and faster eco- ment is a zero-sum game.
Americans at the expense of others. The prime nomic growth. I am in the same age group as our RAYMOND KUBIAK
beneficiaries are folks who live in states with The reality is that Republicans cannot pre- recent presidential candidates, and I Boston
high tax burdens like California, New York and serve the deduction and pass pro-growth re- am fighting to work as an educator,
New Jersey—or, respectively, the 48th, 49th and form that satisfies the arcane procedural re- attorney or at anything else I can find As an older worker who has re-
50th tax climates in the U.S. in the Tax Founda- quirements of Congress. The GOP is looking that uses my skills from those prior cently been hired, I can tell you that
tion rankings. Six states swallow more than half to pay for cuts by streamlining preferences, careers. Please don’t tell me to retire the notion that older workers start at
the cost, and the credit runs the federal fisc $100 and the $1.25 trillion over 10 years from elimi- or threaten me with Social Security a high salary and are guaranteed both
billion a year in lost revenue. nating the state and local deduction would fi- reform. I want to work. continued employment and regular in-
And zoom in closer: The credit tends to bene- nance a more than 10-point cut in the corpo- EILEEN FERRIS creases is nonsense. The market de-
Newington, Conn. termines starting pay, and results de-
fit the wealthiest people living in the most afflu- rate rate.
termine any increases and continued
ent parts of progressive outposts, not least be- No other loophole would save as much As an executive coach, I know doz- employment—as with anyone else.
cause nine in 10 filers earning north of $500,000 money. Killing or capping the mortgage-interest ens of senior-age leaders who could Corporate America has mastered
a year itemize. Some 88% of the benefits flowed deduction would bring in a good haul, but that replace their income were they to re- the art of getting rid of older workers
in 2014 to households earning more than sop to the housing lobby has been classified as tire tomorrow, but who couldn’t af- who aren’t as sharp or don’t justify
$100,000, according to Congress’s Joint Commit- politically untouchable. The GOP will also have ford, or in some cases couldn’t get, in- their pay, no matter what age-discrim-
tee on Taxation. A puny 1% went to filers who to buy off conservative redistributionists like dividual health insurance to “bridge” ination laws there are. I’m not saying
earn less than $50,000, as the Tax Foundation’s Utah Senator Mike Lee, whose King Size child them until they are eligible for Medi- that is right or wrong, it just is.
Jared Walczak noted in a March paper. tax credit could cost another $1 trillion. care. Companies used to offer “retiree KIRK SCHLUP
In New York County, N.Y., home to Manhattan, If the GOP can’t kill the entire state and local medical” that made it possible for Woodbury, Conn.
the average deduction is more than $24,000, ac- deduction, perhaps a compromise is possible.
cording to Tax Foundation county analysis. In Since the deduction so overwhelmingly flows
the Bay Area’s San Mateo County the write-off to the affluent, Republicans could work up a so-
tops $15,000. Yet further inland in California’s lution that produced most of the revenue while Abbas Shows No Sign of Wanting Real Peace
Merced County the average deduction plummets protecting low and middle-income taxpayers on In their op-ed “How Do Palestinians “We welcome every drop of blood
to less than $1,700. Taxpayers in Florida, which some portion of their property taxes. Define ‘Terrorism’?” (Sept. 12), Jona- spilled in Jerusalem. . . . With the help
doesn’t inflict an income tax on residents, can i i i than Schanzer and Grant Rumley call of Allah, every shaheed [martyr] will
take a typically much smaller write-off for their All of this gives the GOP an opening to turn on the Palestinian Authority to define be in heaven, and every wounded will
sales tax payments. the class-war argument in their favor: Since terrorism as a first step toward dis- get his reward.” This was an un-
Mr. King said in his tweet that “hard working when do Mr. Schumer and Elizabeth Warren op- couraging it and comply with the abashed endorsement of terrorism. He
New Yorkers must not be taxed twice,” but state pose raising taxes on the 1%? But more impor- soon-to-be-enacted Taylor Force Act. also dehumanized Jews in his address,
The flaw in their proposal is that it saying that the Temple Mount, the
and federal budgets are distinct. Federal taxes tant, Republicans must eliminate the deduction
presumes “moderate” Palestinian Au- Church of the Holy Sepulcher and “ev-
pay for the military, for example, while state if the party wants to deliver on its stated goals thority President Mahmoud Abbas ac- erything [in Jerusalem] is ours, all
and local taxes finance public education—or in of simplifying the code and unleashing growth. tually wants to rein in terrorism. Yet it ours,” and Jews “have no right to des-
New York and California’s case, teachers unions The alternative is a limp tax cut that doesn’t was Mr. Abbas, himself, who incited ecrate them with their filthy feet and
and public-pension liabilities. lift the economy. The state and local fight is a the current wave of deadly Palestinian we won’t allow them to.”
That’s why Democrats like Minority Leader crucial test of the GOP’s political sincerity. stabbings and car rammings of Israelis, And lest one forget, Mr. Abbas’s his-
Americans and others that included tory of supporting terrorism goes back
the murder of Taylor Force. On Sept. decades.
Paying for Standing Rock 16, 2015, during that year’s Jewish
High Holy Days, Mr. Abbas declared:
STEPHEN A. SILVER
San Francisco
T
he Standing Rock protests ended seven mon law enforcement from 11 states for backup.
months ago, but the saga is far from More than 750 protesters were arrested, and at
over. On Monday North Dakota’s De- least 107 of those charged have pleaded guilty The Truth Is Ever Green, but Not at Evergreen
partment of Emergency Ser- or been found guilty, some on Regarding Jillian Kay Melchior’s and certainly didn’t warrant the com-
vices announced that taxpay- Dakota Access Pipeline multiple counts. “Inside the Madness at Evergreen pletely over-the-top condemnation of
ers will have to pay about $43 protesters cost North Dakota’s state court State” (op-ed, Sept. 22): I’m unable to law school deans supposedly speak-
million in expenses accrued as administrator said the num- understand how our government in- ing in defense of those fragile stu-
the state struggled to respond taxpayers $43 million. ber of criminal cases filed in stitutions became incubators of hate, dents who may have been trauma-
to protesters. Morton County surged by but after reading the commentaries tized by hearing such obviously
Between 8,000 and 10,000 some 14%, at a time when the about Evergreen College and “bour- beneficial advice.
people camped out to protest the Dakota Access clerk of court’s office was already understaffed. geois norms,” I can’t escape that con- In a similar vein, when a respected
Pipeline, many from outside the state. Locals fre- To this date 323 protest-related cases are still clusion. professor questions the value of iden-
When someone speaks the inconve- tity politics, the massive overreaction
quently reported protesters who had trespassed open and pending. The state had to put aside
nient truth that people are generally of the student body and faculty is
on their land or stolen property. At state offices $2.4 million to provide public defenders for more successful if they follow a pat- reminiscent of Mao’s Red Guards.
the phones rang off the hook; throughout the protesters, though not all of that money has tern of education, marry before hav- Those who don’t exactly conform to
233-day protests almost 90,000 people called to been spent. ing children and avoid drugs and the students’ orthodoxy need to be
discuss the pipeline. A large portion of these All of this undermines the Standing Rock crime, one wouldn’t expect it to gen- shamed, vilified and physically
calls were hostile or abusive, and state employ- protesters’ claims that they were “peaceful and erate a hysterical backlash about rac- threatened for daring to speak truth
ees had to listen, screening for threats. prayerful.” The left threatens democracy when ism, bias and white supremacy. These to power. All that’s missing was
The Morton County Sheriff’s Department re- it embraces violence and vandalism, and the markers of success apply universally Mao’s “Little Red Book” being bran-
counted how rioters threw stones, feces and government has to spend money to keep rogues dished by the students. I can only
Molotov cocktails at cops, obstructed roads, set under control. North Dakotans will cover most imagine that the self-loathing ex-
fires and even rode on horseback behind a herd of these costs, but the Department of Justice The Rescue Boat Decision pressed by the white students for
their culture has been inculcated by
of bison, “attempting to stampede them toward also provided the state with a $10 million grant, Wasn’t Mine, but Was Right the schools, and now those teachings
law enforcement.” Protesters significantly out- leaving taxpayers nationwide on the hook for I am the subject of the article “A are coming back in the form of viru-
numbered local authorities, who had to sum- these criminal antics. Doctor’s Hard Decision” (page one, lent hate for any who disagree.
Sept. 16). I fear that readers will mis- GEORGE HARRISON
interpret the moral dilemma we La Selva Beach, Calif.
Trump’s Latest Casualty faced. We didn’t choose to save one
L
life over many. The Golfo Azzurro
oyalty for Donald Trump too often is a And if taking private jets is a firing offense, didn’t leave those refugees to drown Family Has Its Own Tempo
one-way escalator—up but not down— there will soon be many empty first-class seats in an effort to save just one man.
That wouldn’t have been morally de- Regarding the Pepper . . . And Salt
and the latest to discover this is Tom in Washington. A 2013 Government Account- cartoon of Sept. 22: Lethargy may run
fensible. The GPS coordinates of that
Price, who resigned late Fri- ability Office report found
drifting life raft were known to other in some families, but it walks in mine.
day as Health and Human Ser- The President doesn’t that then Attorney General rescue vessels in the vicinity besides BILL DUTCHER
vices Secretary. Mr. Trump like cabinet members Eric Holder and FBI Director ours, vessels equally competent to ef- Norman, Okla.
had all but run him out Friday Robert Mueller used govern- fect rescue.
afternoon by saying “I’m dis- who get bad press. ment jets to take personal Please note that the decision to
appointed in him” and that he trips, which they reimbursed sail north to Lampedusa was taken by Pepper ...
would determine Mr. Price’s at a rate comparable to com- Proactiva’s head of mission, not me.
fate “sometime tonight.” The cabinet member mercial flight prices. It was a carefully considered, profes-
And Salt
took the message and got out before he could Our guess is that Mr. Trump was sore at Mr. sional and in my view utterly proper THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
hear “you’re fired.” Price over the failure of ObamaCare repeal, and decision. The commitment with which
Mr. Price has been taking media heat for fly- he saw the travel flap as an excuse to send him the entire crew of the Golfo Azzurro
accepted the challenge was moving.
ing on private jets, and he surely should have packing. Mr. Price was recommended to Mr.
The questions to consider are:
known better than to give his enemies a sword. Trump as a veteran of the House who could ma- Should our vessel have been on
Yet Mr. Price had said he would reimburse the neuver repeal through Congress. Repeal did standby off the Libyan coast in the
government for the cost of his private air pass the House, only to fail in the Senate. first place? Having stationed our-
travel, cutting a check for nearly $52,000. Mr. Now Mr. Trump will have to find a replace- selves there, should we have taken a
Trump shoved him out the aircraft door any- ment even as HHS faces crucial regulatory de- 20-hour leave of absence to take this
way, saying “I was disappointed because I cisions on ObamaCare. Mr. Price knows the law one bloke up to Lampedusa?
didn’t like it cosmetically or otherwise.” and had invested nine months trying to figure JOHN R. VALLENTINE
Perhaps the President thinks dumping Mr. out the bureaucratic traps. Mr. Trump in par- Sydney
Price will send a populist message, but we ticular will need a nominee who already under-
wonder. Mr. Price is merely a political appe- stands the waiver power that the executive Letters intended for publication should
tizer. His resignation is motivation for the branch has under the Affordable Care Act. be addressed to: The Editor, 1211 Avenue
of the Americas, New York, NY 10036,
swamp denizens to go after others in the Perhaps he can coax former Oklahoma Sena- or emailed to wsj.ltrs@wsj.com. Please
Trump Administration on whatever issue they tor and medical doctor Tom Coburn to take the include your city and state. All letters
can find. Mr. Trump can expect to be answer- job. But if Mr. Trump keeps treating his cabinet are subject to editing, and unpublished
ing questions soon about how this or that cabi- officers like “The Apprentice” cast, he might letters can be neither acknowledged nor “I usually only fist-bump
returned.
net travel differs from Mr. Price’s. find that no one wants to work for him. on the first deal.”
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 | A13
OPINION
T
their way through. They thought Democrats’ response. They reverted
he subject is realism. It in- they would finally be able to do what to their own antique playbook, tak-
volves seeing clearly your the Democrats did when President ing potshots, being unserious. The
moment in time and where Obama and the Democratic Congress Republican plan is “a massive wind-
you are within it. We have bullied through Obamacare. fall for the wealthiest Americans,”
a heck of a time with this. That was a mistake. What the Dem- said Minority Leader Chuck
Our dreams, hungers and illusions ocrats did shouldn’t be emulated. Schumer. “It seems that President
get in the way. Sen. John McCain, who basically Trump and Republicans have de-
But I’ve never seen such a lack of killed the two Republican bills, did it signed their plan to be cheered in
reality among our two great political based on a central insight as to the the country clubs and the corporate
parties in Congress. facts of the moment and the issue: boardrooms.” It should be called
Their own survival as parties re- The path to a new health-care law “wealth-fare.” Sen. Bernie Sanders
quires bipartisanship—concrete runs through the Democrats. The said the plan is “morally repugnant
achievements and progress. They path to a bill better than Obama- and bad economic policy.”
have to work together and produce! Care—and it would have to be bad Republicans announce their tax-reform plan, Sept. 27. But the tax code is too big and too
Nobody likes them. The biggest indeed to be worse than Obama- complicated, as Mr. Ryan said. It
“party” in America is those who call Care—runs through the Democrats. architects that it was marketed to be accepted by America. It will have would do the country good to see it
themselves independent. Gallup has Changing one-sixth of the American take advantage of “the stupidity of to be a compromise that comes from improved.
economy cannot be successfully done the American voter,” and the revela- both parties or it will not pass the Both parties are breaking and bro-
without them. The American people tion that the central promise—“If Kimmel test, the nonsensical but ken. They both need a win. They
Republicans fail again will never accept a health-care law you like your doctor you can keep powerful showbiz bar such a bill could recover some of their standing
that is not backed by both parties. your doctor”—was a lie. must now clear. That means it will be with a bipartisan victory. It would
on health care, while That means regular order—hearings, The bill failed on its own terms, more liberal than the Republicans show America the two-party system
Democrats refuse to debate, negotiations—as Mr. McCain and it is still the law of the land. want, and more expensive. itself can win and produce something
has said. When Republicans tried to replace it, The Democrats will be hellish in needed. This would reinforce the po-
get serious about taxes. The Republicans failed because they tried to do just what the Demo- negotiations. They will not call it “re- sition of both parties. It would sug-
they tried to do what Mr. Obama, crats did—hold party-line votes on peal and replace”; they’ll call it “re- gest they’re needed! If they can’t pro-
Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Majority bills that few in the electorate fully pair and reinforce.” They’ll be de- duce something big together, more
the Democrats’ and Republicans’ fa- Leader Harry Reid did, passing understood. The difference is the manding. And this is unjust. They Americans will become certain they
vorability each at about 40%. Both ObamaCare on a party-line vote. But electorate had previously been caused the problem in the first place! are not.
parties are internally riven, warring bills that make great changes in how scalded. They’re not in a trusting They should be feeling chastened; Meanwhile, thousands of K Street
and ideologically divided. Neither is Americans live, such as Social Secu- mood. they should be desperate to create a tax lobbyists will be crawling the
as sure as it’s been in the past of its rity and Medicare, must always have Health care is experienced now as fix. Instead they’ve been amusing halls trying to affect the shape of the
philosophical reason for being. Both broad, two-party support. The Demo- a fully national issue, and there are themselves watching the hapless Re- bill for their clients.
have to prove they have a purpose. crats pushed ObamaCare without signs America is tilting left on it. (A publicans blow it again. They should Everyone is acting as if they don’t
Otherwise they will in time go down, fully understanding what the bill bipartisan health-care bill might help amuse themselves less. know what time it is, or what posi-
and it may not take that long. even contained. “We have to pass the blunt the coming movement for sin- Now the Republicans turn to tax tion they themselves are in.
Both parties go forward as if they bill so that you can find out what is gle payer.) reform. Again they move from a America is in trouble, with huge
are operating in a pre-2016 reality. in it,” said Mrs. Pelosi, mindlessly Democrats have to be part of fix- weakened position. They’re going problems. The people need improve-
But the election, now almost a year and in a way accurately: They were ing ObamaCare. And though they forward without the momentum of ments in health care, in the tax code.
ago, should have changed so many content to let regulators and admin- should be in a weak position, having victory, without the confidence of re- They’re desperate for is a sense that
assumptions. For instance, when the istrators figure out the implications lost the congressional majorities and cently demonstrated skill. As he un- improvement is actually possible.
Republican nominee promised not to of everything. the White House, they’re holding veiled the plan this week, Speaker This is no time for Democrats to
cut entitlements, his crowds—Repub- But fierce pushback followed—the strong cards. The Republicans have Paul Ryan wore a weirdly triumphant be small, tatty and cheap, to do the
licans, Democrats and indepen- tea party uprising grew; the Demo- crashed and burned twice, and smile. “Today,” he said, “we are tak- old class warfare, to issue one-liners
dents—cheered. crats lost the House in 2010. Then there’s no reason to think they’ll ing the next step to liberate Ameri- instead of thoughts. They should
Health-care reform this week went came the failure in 2013 of the web- magically succeed next time. cans from our broken tax code.” He wake up and get serious.
down, again. The Republicans did not site on which the entire program de- Health-care reform will have to compared this moment to 1986, It’s weird to see everyone going
have the votes in the Senate, again. pended, the admission by one of its come from both parties or it will not when Ronald Reagan won tax reform. through the old motions, dream-like.
T
Charlottesville, Va. it is easy to suppose that it was de- Image-smashing undoubtedly has theater in 1936, has survived to host speech solely as manifestations of
his city seems to be in mourn- signed to reinforce white supremacy. its satisfactions, but they tend to be the World Cup—all without much power, which only can be confronted
ing. On the campus where But the dedication ceremonies fea- short-lived. Pulling down statues of more notice than the occasional his- and silenced by power.
Thomas Jefferson planted the tured high-school bands, cadets from George III, Stalin and Saddam Hussein torical footnote. On a recent humid evening in Char-
“academical village” that grew up to the Virginia Military Institute, uni- was understandable when done by There have been times and places lottesville, I walked past the Lee
be the University of Virginia, the uni- versity faculty and the American Le- those who actually lived through their where monuments really were asser- statue, huddled in its improvised
versity’s statue of Jefferson was gion—not the Ku Klux Klan. outrages. Otherwise, we look with tions of white Southern defiance, like burqa. He fought for a cause that ran-
briefly swathed in black plastic. In One of the dedication speeches shudders on past iconoclasts—the the cemetery obelisk in Colfax, La., cel- kles me to the soles of my abolitionist
nearby Emancipation Park, a 26-foot- celebrated Lee for surrendering at ones who burned the Library of Alex- ebrating the perpetrators of the 1873 boots. But the armies that marched at
high equestrian statue of Robert E. Appomattox and averting “scattered andria, or who smashed religious stat- Colfax Massacre who were “fighting his orders also melted away at his or-
Lee remains swathed in black, mostly guerrilla warfare for many years” and ues during the Protestant Reforma- for white supremacy,” as the monu- ders a long time ago; and the statue is
to prevent defacement. In the wake for pointing Southerners “in the tion—as puritanical idiots. ment proclaims unashamedly. immobilized, solitary, powerless. As
of the Aug. 12 riot between fanatics shadows of the defeat of war” toward David Rieff, in his book “In Praise of But does the Lee monument serve Jefferson once said about the reli-
of the neo-Nazi right and the new “the star of hope with its radiant Forgetting,” suggested that “a decent the same purpose? The answer would gious dissenter, he neither picks my
Red Guards of the Antifa left, an un- promise and prophecy of the tri- measure of communal forgetting” be yes only if we believed that 1865 pocket nor breaks my leg. So with Lee.
easy atmosphere prevails throughout umphs of peace.” Those words came about historical offenses may be “the and 1873 were yesterday, and that ev- I can let him alone.
Charlottesville, as if awaiting, like from the Rev. M. Ashby Jones, a Bap- sine qua non of a peaceful and decent erything about the past is a state-
Pompeii, yet another eruption. tist minister whose opposition to society.” Sometimes the best revenge ment of power (or a clever conceal- Mr. Guelzo is a visiting professor at
lynching made him a target of the is living well. Hitler’s refuge in the ment of power) in the present. This is Princeton’s James Madison Program
Klan. The pedestal read only “Robert Obersalzberg today functions as a tea what links the monument-smashers in American Ideals and Institutions.
Image-smashing Edward Lee,” and the statue itself
was sculpted by Italian-born Leo Len-
undoubtedly has its
satisfactions, but they
telli and cast in Brooklyn, N.Y.
There is a difference between
monuments and memorials. Monu-
Trump Bullies the NFL Because It’s Easy
tend to be short-lived. ments invite us to see exemplars. Me- Many worry that agreeing among themselves to end to fear the police, but the issue is
morials are simply remembrances Donald Trump’s the politicization of the anthem. Let complicated. Reconcile these state-
that something happened in this tweets might in- the anthem go back to being a non- ments: Blacks are nearly three times
As a Yankee I find it a little diffi- place. Often memorials are state- flame the North event. as likely as whites to be killed by
cult to grasp why monuments to Lee ments of mourning, occasionally of Korea conflict. Alas, Sports Illustrated this week police, yet a white homicide victim
are here in the first place. He lost, repentance, but they are not about Maybe his critics supplied a metaphor for the league’s is 2.6 times as likely as a black ho-
and if there is one sin American cul- power or approval. That’s why we should step back hopeless search for the right politi- micide victim to have been killed by
BUSINESS
ture still prefers to bury from sight, don’t take the Donner Party Monu- with renewed ad- cal correctness to make its prob- police.
WORLD
it’s losing. Worse, Lee committed ment in Donner Memorial State Park miration for the lems go away. Its “unity” cover only The explanation: A black person
By Holman W.
treason against the flag and the Con- as an incitement to cannibalism. man and his subtle provoked criticism—for the pres- is so much more likely to be a homi-
Jenkins, Jr.
stitution. And behind that is the ugly The line between memorials and arts. Just notice ence of Mr. Goodell, the absence of cide victim in the U.S.—nearly seven
truth that the Confederate cause was, monuments is not always clear. The how thoroughly his Colin Kaepernick, a dearth of fe- times as likely—that police shoot-
when all the rhetorical chaff is swept Union statuary that populates the tweets have reduced the mighty males, an excess of whites. ings are a smaller proportion of
away, designed to protect chattel Gettysburg battlefield was originally NFL to impotence. Ditto Aaron Rodgers’s invitation black homicides than white
slavery, the singular birth defect of intended as a monument to the righ- Indeed, a bystander wonders to Green Bay fans on Thursday homicides.
the American republic. teousness of the Union cause. At the with what whimsical malice this night to link arms in the stands. It Not that the politics of race rela-
But statues of Lee don’t baffle me dedication of the monument to the aged man-child, blessed with super- fell almost as flat as an Odell Beck- tions is a special competence of the
more than the Whiskey Rebellion 84th Pennsylvania Infantry in 1889, powers, decided the league should ham Jr. end-zone antic. NFL—any more than North Korea
statue in Washington, Pa., or the Dorr the speaker described the Civil War be the newest target to be emascu- Mr. Trump is disdained for low policy or health-care policy, though
Rebellion Museum in Chepachet, R.I., as “the greatest of rebellions against lated and confounded by his 140- cunning, but low cunning beats no players have opinions on these mat-
or the bust of Aaron Burr in the U.S. the grandest of governments.” By the character missiles. cunning. Mr. Trump said nothing at ters too.
Senate Chamber. They all remember middle of the 20th century, visitors Actually one doesn’t wonder: It his Alabama rally or in his tweets The most deadly omen for the
treasons committed in the past, but I were more inclined to regard the was Roger Goodell. Mr. Trump knows about race or police shootings. league, however, the one that should
pass them by with a shrug. Time has monuments as memorials of a great weakness when he smells it. He said only that football players strike fear in Mr. Goodell, owners
rendered them harmless. and tragic sacrifice. Today they are Mr. Trump landed a smart bomb should stand for the anthem, a sen- and players alike, was an article by
Monuments can also be deceptive. mostly used by tourists and history on Tuesday with his tweeted sug- timent widely supported in polls. Roxanne Jones, a founding editor of
gestion that the league should ban First Amendment rights also apply ESPN magazine and former vice
protests during the national an- to the league and team owners. president of the ESPN network. She
them—thereby making it impossible They are under no obligation to declared, “I found a reason to feel
PUBLISHED SINCE 1889 BY DOW JONES & COMPANY for Mr. Goodell to enact such a ban subsidize a platform for player po- good about watching football again,”
Rupert Murdoch Robert Thomson and thus reverse the league’s plum- litical expression. It is not censor- as if the salvation of the game lies
Executive Chairman, News Corp Chief Executive Officer, News Corp met toward the abyss. ship. The NBA requires its players in picking political fights with large
Gerard Baker William Lewis Mr. Goodell could have fairly to stand respectfully for the an- chunks of its fan base.
Editor in Chief Chief Executive Officer and Publisher said, It’s time to get back to foot- them. A mystery without an answer, of
Matthew J. Murray DOW JONES MANAGEMENT: ball. Everyone had their say last Mr. Trump wins this argument course, is how this Trumpian sally
Deputy Editor in Chief Mark Musgrave, Chief People Officer; Sunday. The Cowboys knelt before hands down, which is why critics actually advances any national inter-
Edward Roussel, Innovation & Communications;
DEPUTY MANAGING EDITORS:
Anna Sedgley, Chief Operating Officer & CFO;
the anthem and then stood, the resort to attacking straw men. “Yes, est that Mr. Trump was elected to
Michael W. Miller, Senior Deputy;
Thorold Barker, Europe; Paul Beckett, Katie Vanneck-Smith, President Steelers and Seahawks chose to stay Trump’s True Aim Is to Inflame Ra- advance. A president referring to
Washington; Andrew Dowell, Asia; OPERATING EXECUTIVES: off the field, etc. cial Tensions,” insists the headline fellow citizens as SOBs in a televised
Christine Glancey, Operations; Ramin Beheshti, Product & Technology; Players have every right to express over an Al Hunt column at speech is also a new low that hope-
Jennifer J. Hicks, Digital; Jason P. Conti, General Counsel;
Neal Lipschutz, Standards; Alex Martin, News; Frank Filippo, Print Products & Services; their opinions in all the venues open Bloomberg. fully won’t soon be surpassed.
Shazna Nessa, Visuals; Ann Podd, Initiatives; Steve Grycuk, Customer Service; to them, but not here. This league CNN reporter Coy Wire, himself a Still, with trepidation, the world
Matthew Rose, Enterprise; Kristin Heitmann, Transformation; cannot afford to become an obliga- former NFL player, claimed on-air awaits to see which power or princi-
Stephen Wisnefski, Professional News Nancy McNeill, Advertising & Corporate Sales;
Jonathan Wright, International tory weekly stage for the divisive po- (emphasis added): “President pality the colossus of the White
Paul A. Gigot, Editor of the Editorial Page;
Daniel Henninger, Deputy Editor, Editorial Page
DJ Media Group: litical cause of the moment. Trump urged NFL owners to fire or House Twitter account decides to
Almar Latour, Publisher; A different NFL commissioner, suspend any NFL player who confound and humiliate next. We be-
WALL STREET JOURNAL MANAGEMENT: Kenneth Breen, Commercial
Suzi Watford, Marketing and Circulation; Professional Information Business: with a less embarrassing history, kneeled during the anthem in pro- gin to feel sorry for Kim Jong Un.
Joseph B. Vincent, Operations; Christopher Lloyd, Head; might have been able to play this test of racial injustice.” i i i
Larry L. Hoffman, Production Ingrid Verschuren, Deputy Head role without appearing to truckle to In order to get the better of Don- A version of Wednesday’s column
EDITORIAL AND CORPORATE HEADQUARTERS: the Twitter-bully of the White ald Trump, they must put words in confused Douglas Durst with his
1211 Avenue of the Americas, New York, N.Y., 10036 House. As it is, NFL players would his mouth. brother Robert. Apologies for the
Telephone 1-800-DOWJONES
do the league a favor by informally Black Americans may have reason error.
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
A14 | Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 * *** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
SPORTS
away from making statements of any sort
that make its fans uncomfortable.
GOLF In this regard, the perpetually-outspoken
Player has always been an outlier. And
About America
The things America stood for when I first
came here are gradually vanishing.”
Player joined the PGA Tour in 1957. He
went on to become an all-time great golfer,
a fitness evangelist and the first truly inter-
national golfer. From his earliest days as a
professional, he traveled the world to play
in tournaments. Now, still constantly on the
move for various business and charitable
ventures, he says he has traveled more
miles than any human in history.
But his life has also been shaped by racial
strife and how he responded to it. When he
was younger, he made statements in support
of the apartheid government in South Af-
rica, which he said were the result of him
being “brainwashed” growing up. He be-
came a target of anti-apartheid demonstra-
tors in the U.S., who frequently heckled him
at tournaments.
At the 1969 PGA Championship, which he
lost by one stroke, he said demonstrators
threw ice in his face and threw a phone
book at him during his backswing.
“These guys haven’t got to deal with a
quarter of what I dealt with,” he said, refer-
ring to today’s athletes.
Player later lobbied the South African gov-
ernment to allow Lee Elder, a black American
golfer, to play in the 1971 South African PGA
Championship, making it the first racially in-
tegrated event in the country’s history. He
visited Nelson Mandela in prison, kissing his
feet upon meeting him, and went on to be-
come a favorite of the iconic leader.
Writing about Player in an essay for Golf
Digest in 2000, Mandela wrote, “Few men in
our country’s history did as much to enact
political changes for the better.”
Player has seen the power of sports to ef-
fect social change, but said protesting dur-
ing any country’s national anthem is mis-
guided at best.
“I am a big believer that you should dem-
onstrate for your causes, but the flag and
At 81 years old, Player has seen the power of sports to effect social change but he believes protests shouldn’t involve the national anthem. the anthem are ours—everybody’s,” Player
said. “Demonstrate against your cause,
against that particular cause. People get
BY BRIAN COSTA
confused—why are they demonstrating?”
That stance was echoed earlier in the
New York week by Davis Love III, an assistant U.S.
“THE REST OF THE WORLD is laughing captain at the Presidents Cup, where the
at you,” Gary Player said, and he was only Americans built an early lead Friday as they
getting started. sought to win for the seventh time in a row.
The nine-time major champion was sitting Love said NFL players chose the wrong time
on a bench at the driving range at Chelsea to protest. “I think President Trump is
Piers, where Manhattan meets the Hudson right,” Love said on Golf Channel, adding
River, late Thursday afternoon. A few hours that anyone who wants to protest can send
earlier, he had sat alongside former presi- a letter to his or her member of Congress.
dents Bill Clinton, George W. Bush and Barack Player said he is most baffled by public
Obama to watch the opening tee shots of the antipathy toward Trump in general.
Presidents Cup. “You have a man who is a duly elected
Now, still playing at 81 years old, he was president of America and I hear a man on
taking a break from hitting balls. But golf television saying we will never recognize
was not foremost on his mind. More than him as president. I can’t comprehend it,”
anything, he wanted to talk about America, Player said. “The lack of respect.”
the closest thing to home for him outside Trump enjoys a closer relationship with
his native South Africa. golf than with any other sport. In addition
“I pass by the great Statue of Liberty in to owning a portfolio of 18 golf clubs, the
a ferry today, and I say, ‘The French gave it president has played casual rounds with
to you for a reason: freedom of speech and prominent golfers including Woods, Rory
respect,’” he said. “And I see that dying. I McIlroy, Ernie Els and Lexi Thompson since
see it dying.” the election. But Player said his message
This was not the kind of conversation was less about politics than about unity.
T-B: JULIAN HERBERT/GALLO IMAGES/GETTY IMAGES; CHRIS CONDON/PGA TOUR/GETTY IMAGES
people in the golf world like to have, at “I hear from people all the time who can’t
least in public. In the wake of President saying anything that could offend anyone. tion—to absolutely no one’s surprise. believe what they see on television,” he
Donald Trump’s spat with the NFL over Tiger Woods said he hoped that “things Their collective decision was so widely said. “They can’t believe that Americans are
demonstrations during the national anthem, can be healed.” When the national anthem expected not because golf is a conservative condemning their own country.” He added,
coupled with his spat with the NBA’s Golden was played Thursday before the start of sport, which it is by and large, but because “Anybody who lives in this country should
State Warriors, most notable golfers avoided competition, the players stood at atten- its leading figures for so long have shied kiss the ground every day.”
Weather
Shown are today’s noon positions of weather systems and precipitation. Temperature bands are highs for the day. NBA
©2017 Dow Jones & Company. All Rights Reserved. * * * * * * * THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 | B1
DJIA 22405.09 À 23.89 0.1% NASDAQ 6495.96 À 0.7% STOXX 600 388.16 À 0.5% 10-YR. TREAS. g 6/32 , yield 2.328% OIL $51.67 À $0.11 GOLD $1,281.50 g $4.00 EURO $1.1814 YEN 112.50
With the Bulls Forever Vexes Europe’s Oil Refiners direct links to the Russian
government reach viewers,
particularly in the Western
world.
BY CHRISTOPHER ALESSI dle Eastern refiners. Energy Agency. Russian state media RT,
With U.S. Plugging his phone into a Friday, reverberations con- The Volkswagen scandal which a U.S. intelligence re-
stocks hitting modem that dials up a stock- A backlash against die- tinued from the 2015 scandal, sent sales of diesel vehicles port said aimed to meddle in
highs this quotation service, he be- sel sparked mostly by the as Volkswagen said it would plummeting, particularly in the election, has 2.2 million
past week and comes more nervous as the Volkswagen AG emissions take a fresh charge of €2.5 bil- the company’s home country subscribers and 2.1 billion
the calendar day goes on and the Dow scandal has upended Europe’s lion ($2.94 billion) due to of Germany, where politicians views on its English-language
just about to Jones Industrial Average big oil refiners, which invested higher-than-expected costs of threatened to restrict diesel YouTube channel.
flip to October, think 30 falls a record 108.35 points roughly $10 billion in recent fixing cars in the U.S. The cars in some cities. Diesel, Twitter on Thursday sin-
years back with me to Fri- on unprecedented volume of years to equip plants to churn charge brings to nearly $30 which emits nitrogen oxide, is gled out RT as an advertiser
day, Oct. 16, 1987. nearly 339 million shares. out more of the fuel and now billion the total fines, penal- now considered a much more that was part of Russian inter-
The stock market is up The selling is “completely are bracing for plummeting ties and compensation Volks- serious pollutant than it was ference on its site. RT spent
more than 30% for the year. overdone,” he thinks: Stocks demand. wagen has paid since it admit- just a few years ago, when Eu- $274,100 to advertise on Twit-
But traders are jittery: Inter- are bound to bounce back Total SA of France, Repsol ted as many as 11 million of its ropean governments were pro- ter during the campaign, the
est rates are rising, tax rates big on Monday “and then I’ll SA and CEPSA of Spain, and diesel vehicles world-wide moting the fuel as a cleaner company said.
are in flux and the U.S. is get killed” for hanging on to Saras SpA of Italy are plan- contained software that alternative to gasoline. RT couldn’t immediately be
bickering with international the bearish bet. “A feeling of ning to use facilities built to helped the cars appear to “Diesel was the darling and reached, but in a note sent
trade partners and skirmish- panic washed over my entire produce diesel mostly for pas- meet standards for toxic emis- has become the devil,” said earlier Friday, RT’s editor in
ing with Iran. body,” Mr. O’Shaughnessy senger cars to instead provide sions. Dario Scaffardi, executive vice chief, Margarita Simonyan,
James O’Shaughnessy, a says. “I’ve just got to get chemically similar products Oil refiners had pinned president at Saras. said RT had been “spending
young investor in St. Paul, out.” He calls his broker a like container-shipping fuel their hopes on European diesel Total had poured more than money on our advertising
Minn., has made a “five-fig- half-hour before the market and jet fuel. They hope to at as the Continent’s fleet of per- $2.4 billion into diesel-friendly campaigns, just like every me-
ure” bet on stock-index put closes and sells it all. least minimize the latest blow sonal diesel-powered vehicles upgrades at its two largest Eu- dia organization in the world.”
options, a way of profiting That weekend, Mr. to an industry that was al- grew to 45% by 2015, com- ropean refineries. Repsol and The Russian broadcaster has
from a sharp fall in price on O’Shaughnessy feels “greatly ready being squeezed by com- pared with 2% in the U.S., ac- CEPSA invested $4.76 billion previously disputed the U.S.
a basket of big U.S. stocks. Please see INVEST page B5 petition from Asian and Mid- cording to the International Please see DIESEL page B2 intelligence report.
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
B2 | Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 * ****** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
A
Alibaba Group Holding
Goldman Sachs Group
............................... A5,B5
Q
QVT Financial..............B9
DIESEL 9 million barrels a day
Diesel Drive
...................................B10 H R Continued from Page One
Alphabet......................B1
8 Demand for diesel has risen in Europe in recent years, but
HSBC ........................... B9 Repsol..........................B1 and $2.4 billion, respectively, refiners anticipate a drop-off in the wake of the VW
Altaba........................B10
I Roivant Sciences ........ B9 on similar upgrades and mod- 7 emissions scandal. Regional consumption, 2010-16:
Amazon.com.....B3,B4,B5
American International Institutional S ernization projects. Even inde-
Shareholder Services pendent refiners like Saras that 6
Group ........................ A1 Saras ........................... B1
Ant Financial Services .....................................B1 aren’t tied to big oil-explora-
Seligman Investments 5
Group.........................B2 J .....................................B2 tion companies shelled out
Axovant Sciences ....... B9 J.P. Morgan Chase......A5 SoftBank................A1,B9 hundreds of millions of dollars. 4
B K Southeastern Asset Between 2005 and 2017, Eu-
BMW ........................... B2 Management.............B5 ropean refiners invested a to- 3
Kohn Pedersen Fox
Boeing....................A2,B4 Associates................A9 Southern ..................... B4 tal of around $10 billion equip- 2
Bombardier ................. A2 L SpaceX.........................B1 ping their plants to churn out
C Lattice Semiconductor T diesel, a capacity increase of 1
Canyon Bridge Capital .....................................B2 Toshiba........................B4 nearly 60%, according to IHS
Partners....................B2 Total ............................ B1 Markit. 0
M
Chongqing Casin Trian Fund Management The European refining in- 2010 Asia* ’16 Europe North Latin Middle East Russia† Sub-Saharan
Enterprise.................B2 Merck...........................B3
.....................................B1 America America Africa
CME Group..................A5 MoneyGram dustry was already under pres-
Twitter ........................ B1 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
International.............B2 sure. Amid greater competition *Includes Pacific islands; †Includes ex-Soviet states in Caspian Sea region Source: Wood Mackenzie
D U
N from Asian and Middle Eastern
Daimler........................B2 Uber Technologies......A1
Netflix.........................B5 refiners, two dozen refineries have announced plans to ban all commercial vehicles are likely such a shift, Mr. Cooper said.
E V closed between 2009 and 2016, gasoline- and diesel-powered to remain diesel-powered in Mr. Scaffardi of Saras said
O
Eli Lilly ........................B4 Valeant Pharmaceuticals leaving the Continent with vehicles after 2040, while the Europe.” his refineries and those of
O'Shaughnessy Asset
F Management.............B5 International...........B10 roughly 105 active refining op- French government recently un- “Refineries that invested in competitors invested heavily
Facebook................B1,B5 P Viking Global Investors erations, according to IHS veiled plans to raise taxes on complexity will have the abil- in “hydrocrackers,” high-tech
G .....................................B9 Markit. More are likely to close diesel by 10% next year. At the ity to modify output toward units that increase the amount
Procter & Gamble.......B1
Glass Lewis.................B1 Prudential Financial ... A2 W in the coming years, said Carlos same time, the Continent’s big heavier distillates [like marine of distillates like diesel or jet
GlaxoSmithKline.........B9 PTC Therapeutics......B10 Wal-Mart Stores.........B4 Navarro, vice president for re- car makers, including VW, BMW and jet fuel]. They are well fuel that can be extracted from
fining development at Compa- AG, Daimler AG and Volvo, are prepared,” said John Cooper, a barrel of crude oil. Even in
nia Espanola de Petroleos SAU, accelerating efforts to manufac- the head of refining industry Asia and the U.S., where gaso-
INDEX TO PEOPLE or CEPSA.
“I see in 20 years less than
ture electric vehicles.
Berta Cabello, head of refin-
group Fuel Europe. Switching
to shipping fuel or jet fuel is
line is more common, refiner-
ies ramped up their ability to
50 [refineries] will be in oper- ery planning and analysis at easier for upgraded refineries produce diesel for commercial
A K-L Pomerleau, Kyle..........B5 ation,” Mr. Navarro said. Repsol, said big companies because they are diesel-related and export purposes, said
Ablin, Jack.................B10 Kalanick, Travis .......... A1 R Europe still remains one of like hers should be able to distillates. Kristine Petrosyan, a senior
Aguilar, Omar ............. A5 Khosrowshahi, Dara...A8 Ramaswamy, Vivek....B9 the world’s biggest consumers shift their production to By pumping out shipping energy analyst at the IEA.
Arone, Michael ........... A5 Lundberg, Jan ............. B4 Ricks, David ................ B4 of diesel. European demand is growth areas like jet fuel, re- fuel, the refiners can take ad- Those investments, Mr.
B-C M S estimated at 6.4 million bar- gardless of the rise of electric vantage of new emissions Scaffardi said, are now the in-
Burns, Ursula..............A1 Mendes, George..........D5 Shah, Aarti..................B4 rels a day this year, over a passenger vehicles. “It’s very curbs that cut the amount of dustry’s greatest challenge.
Cates, Staley...............B5 Musk, Elon..................B1 Skovronsky, Dan.........B4 fifth of global diesel consump- difficult to see commercial sulfur allowed to be used in “I’m not trying to downplay
Crowe, Maria...............B4 O-P Smiley, Joshua............B4 tion, according to the IEA. electric planes,” Ms. Cabello marine fuel starting in 2020. the fact that there are changes
G-H T About 30% of that demand is said. Diesel-related distillates are on the horizon,” he said.
O'Neill, Myles.............B4
Galloway, Scott...........C6 O'Shaughnessy, James Thain, John.................A1 for personal vehicles. A spokeswoman for Total low in sulfur. “There is a strong push
Gold, Daniel.................B9 .....................................B1 W Yet demand is going to be in- said the company didn’t ques- But not all refiners in Eu- against fossil fuels.”
Gregory, Paul .............. B5 Parry, Gavin .............. B10 Wick, Paul...................B2 creasingly hard to sustain. In tion its investments in diesel, rope have invested in the com- —William Boston
Henriques, Diana........B5 Peltz, Nelson...............B1 Wigmore, Barrie.........B5 the U.K. and France, leaders in part because “trucks and plex upgrades needed to make contributed to this article.
Critics have said Mr. Musk’s Payload – .5 tons* The 69-year-old law-
goals are overly ambitious and maker’s focus is timely. Chi-
have noted SpaceX’s fewer-than- nese investment in the U.S.
planned launches and revenue tripled to a record $46 billion
shortfalls partly due to a pair of in 2016, according to New
accidents. 21.3 m York consultancy Rhodium
On Friday, Mr. Musk acknowl- Group. The figure is still
edged the 2022 target was small compared with invest-
largely “aspirational,” but said ment from places such as the
he was “fairly confident” that by U.K., Canada and Japan, but
2024 SpaceX could fly as many the sharp increase has raised
as four spacecraft, including two concerns in Washington be-
with crews, to the Martian sur- cause China is an economic
face to start building a fuel de- and military rival. The Com-
pot. 1.7 m 3.7 m 12 m 9m mittee on Foreign Investment
The billionaire, who has in the U.S., or CFIUS, which He is wary of challenges to U.S.
shaken up the space business Source: the company *Estimated THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. is made up of Trump cabinet dominance in tech and finance.
and notched several historic officials, reviews deals for
firsts with his reusable rockets, deeper into the solar system. nounced roughly a year ago. It is are now beginning serious de- national-security risks and CFIUS member who now
was poised to counter naysayers The engineering underpin- still slated to carry up to 150 velopment” of the new rocket has held up a number of leads Kirkland & Ellis LLP’s
who have called his grand plan a nings of the latest plan differ tons into low-earth orbit. family and “should start build- China-backed deals. CFIUS practice, says Mr. Pit-
sci-fi dream. from earlier incarnations, in- It would be roughly 10 times ing the first ship” by the sec- Mr. Pittenger says he took tenger’s voice is part of a
His updated vision of a pub- cluding a revised heavy-lift more powerful than the South- ond half of 2018, he said. Un- note of China in the 1970s larger global debate over
lic-private partnership relies less rocket more powerful than the ern California company’s flag- der Mr. Musk’s most optimistic while traveling in Asia with how countries should ap-
on major new federal programs Saturn V that blasted the first ship Falcon 9 rocket and signifi- scenario, the initial launch to Cru—then called the Campus proach Chinese investment.
supporting Mars exploration U.S. astronauts to the moon half cantly more capable than the the international space station Crusade for Christ. In the en- “He’s been vocal, persis-
and more on repurposing a century ago. long-delayed Falcon Heavy de- could come four years later. suing decades, he said, he tent and bipartisan, and all
SpaceX’s own cash flow from SpaceX’s next-generation rivative expected to blast off for Advanced versions of space- watched in dismay as China’s the while has maintained an
commercial ventures. rocket is now expected to be the first time later this year. craft slated to take astronauts rapid increase in trade with earnest, ‘Mr. Smith goes to
Mr. Musk’s comments are somewhat smaller than origi- Unlike previous, more gen- and, later, passengers on voy- the West transformed it from Washington’ quality about
likely to fan a debate over the nally conceived, featuring 31 eral presentations about Mars ages to Mars are expected to a minor player into an eco- him,” Mr. Mancuso said.
role of entrepreneurial initia- methane-fueled engines rather exploration, Mr. Musk set have capacity of roughly 100 nomic and military power- Not everyone sees it that
tives in championing exploration than the 42 Mr. Musk an- some specific milestones. “We people. house, all while Beijing re- way, particularly people who
jected values such as human are losing money because of
rights and religious freedom. the lawmaker’s efforts. After
BUSINESS NEWS
Equifax
Board
High-Speed Traders in Deal Talks
Consolidation trend in Sun after the Chicago-based according to Tabb Group LLC. pools,” people close to the firm
Sinking Fast
Weighs continues in a sector
under pressure amid
firm put itself up for sale in re-
cent months, the people said.
No deal has been finalized,
Hudson River and Sun, like
many firms in the secretive in-
dustry, are privately held and
said. One of its most lucrative
strategies involved exploiting
tiny price differences between
High-speed firms' U.S.
stock-trading revenue
BY ALEXANDER OSIPOVICH ficer Michael Deaton declined to graduates of elite universities Sun was mentioned in a 2014
BY EMILY GLAZER comment. with degrees in mathematics, lawsuit filed against Barclays by 6
AND ANNAMARIA ANDRIOTIS Hudson River Trading LLC, High-frequency trading, or physics and computer science, New York State Attorney General
one of the largest U.S. high- HFT, firms make money by us- Hudson River now has around Eric Schneiderman, who accused
Equifax could announce in speed traders, is exploring a ing computer algorithms to 180 employees globally. the bank of misleading custom- 4
coming days that it will claw deal to buy rival Sun Trading zip in and out of stocks, fu- Sun was founded in 2003 ers about how much “predatory”
back compensation from some LLC, people familiar with the tures and other assets in frac- by Jeff Wigley, a former floor HFT was allowed in its dark
top executives over its massive situation said, as the once-lu- tions of a second. trader at the Chicago Board pool. An analysis cited in the
2
data breach, a person familiar crative industry is pressured The industry has suffered Options Exchange. The firm lawsuit called Sun’s trading ac-
with the matter said. by low volatility and rising because of a slump in volatil- trades stocks in North Amer- tivity in the pool “very toxic.”
The embattled credit-report- costs. ity, which has fueled a series ica, Europe and Asia, as well Barclays last year admitted
ing company’s board has been in New York-based Hudson of consolidation deals. Reve- as currencies, bonds and fu- wrongdoing and paid $70 mil- 0
discussions about the best ap- River, which has said it trades nues at HFT firms from U.S. tures, according to its website. lion to settle the suit and a par- 2009 ’11 ’13 ’15 ’17*
proach for clawbacks, such as around 5% of U.S. equities vol- equities are projected to be It was among the first HFT allel action by the Securities and *Projected
what time frame to use when ume each day, was among sev- $850 million this year, com- firms to connect to the off-ex- Exchange Commission. Sun Source: Tabb Group estimates
calculating what to include, this eral firms that showed interest pared with $7.2 billion in 2009, change platforms called “dark wasn’t accused of any violation. THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
person said. For instance, af-
fected executives are likely to
CARLO ALLEGRI/REUTERS
outstanding,” and the disposi- During the past month, 19%
tion of those awards will await of Whole Food’s sales on Ama-
the outcome of the investiga- zon were of snacks and candy,
tion. That appeared to leave the followed by frozen fruit and
door open for clawbacks. vegetables, One Click found.
Equifax’s disclosure of the Condiments and health and
hack sparked a public and polit- beauty items drew the least A Whole Foods store in New York City. The grocer’s private-label products are finding a new sales outlet through Amazon’s website.
ical uproar since it disclosed vi- share of sales. Deli turkey
tal personal information of po- breast and coconut water year’s monthly average through
tentially 143 million Americans. were the most popular indi- In the Cart July, according to location-
In an opinion-editorial article vidual items. Since its purchase, Whole Foods has sold an estimated $1.6 million in store-brand items on Amazon’s website. based data compiled by the in-
in The Wall Street Journal Whole Foods brand pasta, Market mobile analytics firm.
Thursday, interim Equifax CEO packaged meats and other Sales by week* Top-selling categories by share of sales† Traffic is projected to be 4%
Paulino do Rego Barros apolo- goods already had a loyal fol- below average in September, it
$500,000 Snacks/candy
gized for the hack and said the lowing among customers of found.
company would provide a new the chain’s 470 stores, with Frozen fruit/vegetables “I’ve bought a bit more
service by Jan. 31 that would al- exclusive products accounting 400,000 salmon,” said Howard Levy, a
Beverages
low consumers to lock and un- for 15% of the company’s an- 67-year-old retired financial
lock access to their Equifax nual revenue. Canned goods worker, as he left a Whole
credit reports free of charge for But Amazon gives Whole 300,000 Foods store in Chicago. Mr.
Dairy/eggs
life. Foods products the potential Levy said he is buying more of
Equifax has been trying to for a new mass-market plat- Frozen meals the grocer’s newly discounted
200,000
take steps to contain the crisis, form, providing new revenue Baking/spices fish but still goes to Kroger
especially since Mr. Smith next to the struggling grocer, gro- Co’.s Mariano’s chain in the
week will testify before three cery analysts said. “When 100,000 Condiments/dressing area for many items at less ex-
congressional committees. In they blow it out, it’ll be a Health/personal care pensive prices.
the hearings, Mr. Smith is ex- much bigger number,” said Amazon and Whole Foods
0 Nutrition/wellness
pected to defend Equifax’s secu- Bob Goldin, partner for the executives have said they
rity measures by pointing to its Pentallect Inc. food consul- Sept. 2 9 16 23 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% planned to institute more dis-
IT spending directed at security, tancy. *For weeks ending date shown †For Aug. 28 through Sept. 26. Source: One Click Retail THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. count offers in the months to
which falls “within the range” The sales at present come. The chain had experi-
of other companies’ expendi- amount to a tiny portion of The online private-label stores, trying to undo the the surge subsequently sub- enced more than two years of
tures, this person said. Already, the roughly $8 billion in retail sales are among the changes chain’s “Whole Paycheck” im- sided. It will take additional declining same-store sales—a
some legislators have asked sales Amazon averages a Amazon made after taking age. measures to turn around Whole key retailer metric—prior to
why the company hasn’t clawed month. over Whole Foods on Aug. 28. Third-party data showed an Foods’ two years of steady Amazon’s deal for Whole Foods
back compensation from execu- A Whole Foods spokes- The online retailer also per- increase in traffic as curious sales declines, Mr. Goldin said. in June.
tives. woman declined to comment. manently reduced prices on shoppers flocked to Whole Spurred by Amazon’s entry, Grocers across the country
—Michael Rapoport Amazon didn’t respond to re- eggs, milk, bananas and other Foods stores several days after August traffic at Whole Food are fiercely competing on price
contributed to this article. quests to comment. high-volume items across the price cuts took effect, but stores was up 10% from the to lure shoppers to their stores.
TECHNOLOGY WSJ.com/Tech
Support
pendent energy regulators to competitors to coal and nuclear
change how electricity is plants, according to a study the
priced, proposing new rules department finished last month.
that would bolster revenue for “Distorted price signals…have
coal-fired and nuclear power resulted in undervaluation of BY MIGUEL BUSTILLO
plants. grid reliability and resiliency
The Energy Department is benefits provided by traditional The Trump administra-
mandating that the Federal baseload resources, such as coal tion offered an additional $3.7
Energy Regulatory Commis- and nuclear,” Energy Secretary billion in loan guarantees to a
sion consider new rules that Rick Perry wrote in a letter to nuclear-power-plant project in
would effectively raise power FERC. “As a first step, it is espe- Georgia that is billions over
WEEKEND INVESTOR
TAX REPORT | By Laura Saunders
portfolio insurance to mini- reinvested dividends. Group Inc. partner Barrie clustered around a Quotron
mize losses. Futures traders Ms. Henriques’s book, and Wigmore. machine putting in buy or-
in Chicago, who would nor- the story Mr. O’Shaughnessy History does offer a few ders as they watched the
mally buy, step back, expect- told me, are a reminder that clear lessons. Stocks have market crash, “and the ulti-
ing a further fall. “human nature can’t be re- been overvalued, by long- mate comfort we had that
By day’s end, the Dow has pealed,” as she says. “Histor- term standards, for most of day was holding 25% to 30%
fallen 23%, “the worst day in ical amnesia leaves us manages nearly $6 billion at stock market was over- the past three decades. So, of our portfolios in cash.”
Wall Street history,” as jour- doomed to repeat our past O’Shaughnessy Asset Man- valued. Between September on average, you were more Without it, “we couldn’t
nalist Diana Henriques calls disasters, and the only anti- agement LLC in Stamford, 1986 and the end of August likely to have missed consis- have bought stocks,” he says.
Oct. 19, 1987, in her excellent dote is to remember accu- Conn. Even though he based 1987, stocks had gone from tent gains than to have Having the cash to buy when
new book, “A First-Class Ca- rately what happened.” it on factors he no longer be- trading at 16 times earnings dodged a crash if you got out others are selling is the sur-
tastrophe.” An equivalent Take it from Mr. lieves in, his original analy- to a price/earnings ratio of of the market entirely. est source of courage in a
drop in 2017 would hack O’Shaughnessy, who today sis was absolutely right: The 21.4, a 33% rise that put the Investors today who hold crash.
MARKETS DIGEST
EQUITIES
Dow Jones Industrial Average S&P 500 Index Nasdaq Composite Index
Last Year ago Last Year ago Last Year ago
22405.09 s 23.89, or 0.11% Trailing P/E ratio 20.61 20.30 2519.36 s 9.30, or 0.37% Trailing P/E ratio 24.22 24.45 6495.96 s 42.51, or 0.66% Trailing P/E ratio * 25.69 24.32
High, low, open and close for each P/E estimate * 18.89 17.66 High, low, open and close for each P/E estimate * 19.19 18.52 High, low, open and close for each P/E estimate * 21.32 20.18
trading day of the past three months. Dividend yield 2.28 2.56 trading day of the past three months. Dividend yield 1.98 2.13 trading day of the past three months. Dividend yield 1.10 1.20
All-time high 22412.59, 09/20/17 All-time high: 2519.36, 09/29/17 All-time high: 6495.96, 09/29/17
Session high
21200 2450 65-day moving average 6200
DOWN UP
t
0.60 1.50 Yen Mexico peso .0548 18.2542 –12.0 Iceland krona .009425 106.10 –6.1
Wilmington, DE 888-720-8756 –5 s
Peru new sol .3063 3.265 –2.6 Norway krone .1256 7.9635 –7.9
0.30 Capital One 360 1.20% 0.75 –10 Uruguay peso .03427 29.1800 –0.6 Poland zloty .2739 3.6505 –12.8
t
One year ago
t
Glen Allen, VA 877-464-0333 Venezuela b. fuerte .098465 10.1559 1.6 Russia ruble .01738 57.548 –6.1
Money market 0.00 0.00 –15
Goldman Sachs Bank USA 1.20% Asia-Pacific Sweden krona .1228 8.1465 –10.5
account yields 1 3 6 1 2 3 5 710 30 Switzerland franc 1.0331 .9680 –5.0
New York, NY 855-730-7283 2016 2017 Australian dollar .7833 1.2767 –8.1
–0.30 month(s) years Turkey lira .2806 3.5637 1.1
American Express Bank, FSB 1.25% China yuan .1507 6.6366 –4.4
O N D J FMAM J J A S maturity Ukraine hryvnia .0376 26.5875 –1.8
Hong Kong dollar .1280 7.8114 0.7
2016 2017 New York, NY 866-215-8754 UK pound 1.3399 .7463 –7.9
India rupee .01532 65.285 –3.9
Sources: Ryan ALM; Tullett Prebon; WSJ Market Data Group Middle East/Africa
Indonesia rupiah .0000742 13472 –0.4
Yield/Rate (%) 52-Week Range (%) 3-yr chg Japan yen .008889 112.50 –3.9 Bahrain dinar 2.6514 .3772 ...
Interest rate Last (l)Week ago Low 0 2 4 6 8 High (pct pts)
Kazakhstan tenge .002939 340.30 2.0 Egypt pound .0567 17.6425 –2.7
Federal-funds rate target 1.00-1.25 1.00-1.25 0.25 l 1.25 1.00 Corporate Borrowing Rates and Yields Macau pataca .1243 8.0443 1.6 Israel shekel .2830 3.5335 –8.2
Malaysia ringgit .2368 4.2225 –5.9 Kuwait dinar 3.3110 .3020 –1.2
Prime rate* 4.25 4.25 3.50 l 4.25 1.00 Yield (%) 52-Week Total Return (%)
Bond total return index Close Last Week ago High Low 52-wk 3-yr New Zealand dollar .7210 1.3870 –4.0 Oman sul rial 2.5968 .3851 0.03
Libor, 3-month 1.33 1.33 0.85 l 1.34 1.10 Pakistan rupee .00949 105.410 1.0 Qatar rial .2691 3.716 2.1
Money market, annual yield 0.27 0.29 0.26 l 0.36 -0.15 Treasury, Ryan ALM 1459.707 2.062 2.009 2.237 1.360 –2.644 2.425 Philippines peso .0197 50.888 2.6 Saudi Arabia riyal .2667 3.7502 –0.01
Five-year CD, annual yield 1.44 1.43 1.19 l 1.47 -0.04 10-yr Treasury, Ryan ALM 1733.460 2.328 2.262 2.609 1.605 0.268 2.417 Singapore dollar .7366 1.3576 –6.2 South Africa rand .0738 13.5566 –1.0
30-year mortgage, fixed† 3.90 3.87 3.46 l 4.33 -0.34 South Korea won .0008731 1145.30 –5.2
DJ Corporate n.a. n.a. 2.992 n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a. Close Net Chg % Chg YTD%Chg
Sri Lanka rupee .0065325 153.08 3.1
15-year mortgage, fixed† 3.16 3.12 2.72 l 3.50 -0.21 Aggregate, Barclays Capital 1938.340 2.550 2.530 2.790 1.960 –0.168 2.682 Taiwan dollar .03297 30.330 –6.5 WSJ Dollar Index 86.30 0.03 0.03 –7.14
Jumbo mortgages, $424,100-plus† 4.41 4.36 4.22 l 4.88 -0.20 High Yield 100, Merrill Lynch n.a. n.a. 5.077 n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a. Sources: Tullett Prebon, WSJ Market Data Group
Five-year adj mortgage (ARM)† 3.41 3.37 3.13 l 4.03 -0.36
Fixed-Rate MBS, Barclays 1986.550 2.800 2.790 3.120 2.060 0.225 2.432
New-car loan, 48-month 3.05 3.06 2.85 l 3.36 -0.17
HELOC, $30,000 4.74 4.76 4.57 l 5.22 0.35
Muni Master, Merrill n.a. n.a. 1.834 n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a. COMMODITIES
Bankrate.com rates based on survey of over 4,800 online banks. *Base rate posted by 70% of the nation's largest EMBI Global, J.P. Morgan n.a. n.a. 5.400 n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a. Commodities Friday 52-Week YTD
banks.† Excludes closing costs. Pricing trends on someClose
raw materials, or commodities
Sources: SIX Financial Information; WSJ Market Data Group; Bankrate.com Sources: J.P. Morgan; Ryan ALM; S&P Dow Jones Indices; Barclays Capital; Merrill Lynch Net chg % Chg High Low % Chg % chg
WSJ
TR/CC CRB Index 0.10 166.50
stocks, new highs/lows and mutual funds. Plus, Compare the performance of selected global stock Crude oil, $ per barrel 51.67 0.11 0.21 54.45 42.53 7.11 -3.82
deeper money-flows data and email delivery of key indexes, bond ETFs, currencies and commodities at Natural gas, $/MMBtu 3.007 -0.010 -0.33 3.93 2.56 3.48 -19.25
.COM WSJ.com/TrackTheMarkets
stock-market data. Available free at WSJMarkets.com Gold, $ per troy oz. 1281.50 -4.00 -0.31 1346.00 1127.80 -2.42 11.43
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 | B7
MUTUAL FUNDS
ADVERTISEMENT Net YTD Net YTD Net YTD
Explanatory Notes Fund NAV Chg % Ret Fund NAV Chg % Ret Fund NAV Chg % Ret
Data provided by
Showroom
To advertise: 800-366-3975 or WSJ.com/classifieds
Top 250 mutual-funds listings for Nasdaq-published share classes with net assets of at least
$500 million each. NAV is net asset value. Percentage performance figures are total returns,
assuming reinvestment of all distributions and after subtracting annual expenses. Figures don’t
CapApp
EqInc
EqIndex
Growth
29.35 +0.08
34.20 +0.13
67.64 +0.25
67.10 +0.39
12.1
10.2
14.0
26.0
InfProAd
IntlGrAdml
ITBondAdml 11.44
25.68
92.57
ITIGradeAdml 9.82
-0.07
+0.74
-0.02
-0.01
1.7
37.5
3.8
4.0
TgtRe2015
TgtRe2020
TgtRe2025
TgtRe2030
15.75 +0.03
31.19 +0.08
18.25 +0.05
32.93 +0.11
8.5
10.4
11.6
12.8
reflect sales charges (“loads”) or redemption fees. NET CHG is change in NAV from previous HelSci 74.36 +0.61 25.9 LTGradeAdml 10.57 +0.03 8.4 TgtRe2035 20.20 +0.08 13.9
trading day. YTD%RET is year-to-date return. 3-YR%RET is trailing three-year return annualized. InstlCapG 37.56 +0.24 28.5 MidCpAdml 182.08 +0.79 12.9 TgtRe2040 34.73 +0.13 15.0
e-Ex-distribution. f-Previous day’s quotation. g-Footnotes x and s apply. j-Footnotes e and s IntlStk 18.93 +0.11 23.8 MuHYAdml 11.37 ... 6.3 TgtRe2045 21.80 +0.09 15.4
FERRARI CHEVROLET apply. k-Recalculated by Lipper, using updated data. p-Distribution costs apply, 12b-1. r- IntlValEq 15.26 +0.10 19.1 MuIntAdml 14.19 -0.01 4.3 TgtRe2050 35.07 +0.14 15.4
MCapGro 90.11 +0.34 19.6 MuLTAdml 11.65 ... 5.1 TgtRetInc 13.46 +0.01 6.3
Redemption charge may apply. s-Stock split or dividend. t-Footnotes p and r apply. v-Footnotes MCapVal 30.85 +0.07 6.2 TotIntBdIxInv 10.89 ... 1.2
x and e apply. x-Ex-dividend. z-Footnote x, e and s apply. NA-Not available due to incomplete MuLtdAdml 10.99 ... 2.6
Large Stock of N Horiz 54.43 +0.37 25.7 MuShtAdml 15.80 -0.01 1.4 WellsI 26.66 +0.03 6.9
price, performance or cost data. NE-Not released by Lipper; data under review. NN-Fund not N Inc 9.51 ... 3.5 PrmcpAdml r 131.45 +0.87 20.8 Welltn 42.09 +0.11 9.8
tracked. NS-Fund didn’t exist at start of period.
New Suburbans and Tahoes OverS SF r
R2020
11.18 +0.08
22.91 +0.07
23.3
12.2
REITAdml r 117.74 +0.16 3.5 WndsrII
VANGUARD INDEX FDS
38.38 +0.13 10.3
SmCapAdml 67.70 +0.15 10.6
R2025 17.63 +0.06 13.7 500 232.57 +0.87 14.1
3% over invoice. Friday, September 29, 2017 R2030 25.92 +0.11 15.0
STBondAdml 10.46
STIGradeAdml 10.69
...
-0.01
1.5
2.2 ExtndIstPl 200.51 +0.49 12.7
Will arrange delivery. Fund
Net YTD
NAV Chg % Ret Fund
Net YTD
NAV Chg % Ret Fund
Net YTD R2035
NAV Chg % Ret R2040
18.92 +0.08
27.15 +0.13
16.1
17.0
TotBdAdml 10.78 -0.01 3.1 SmValAdml
TotBd2
54.89 +0.03
10.75 ...
6.9
3.1
TotIntBdIdxAdm 21.77 ... 1.2
Contact Bryan at American Century Inv Federated Instl CapApInst
Value 37.75 +0.21
72.17 +0.59 27.4 PRIMECAP Odyssey Fds
12.2 TotIntlAdmIdx r 29.38 +0.18 21.6 TotIntl 17.57 +0.11 21.6
TotSt 63.03 +0.21 13.9
bryan.matthews@columbiachev.com Ultra NA ... NA StraValDivIS 6.42 ... 11.6 IntlInst r 70.25 +0.64 20.3 Growth r 34.64 +0.24 20.9
TotStAdml 63.05 +0.22 13.9
VANGUARD INSTL FDS
American Funds Cl A Fidelity Harding Loevner TxMIn r 13.93 +0.07 21.0
Principal Investors
ValAdml 38.95 +0.09 9.5
BalInst 33.58 +0.06 9.5
AmcpA p 30.90 +0.10 15.1 500IdxInst 88.52 +0.33 14.2 IntlEq NA ... NA DivIntlInst NA ... NA DevMktsIndInst 13.95 +0.07 21.1
LUXURY AMutlA p 40.66 +0.09 12.0 500IdxInstPrem 88.52 +0.33 14.2 Invesco Funds A WdsrllAdml 68.11 +0.22 10.3
DevMktsInxInst 21.81 +0.12
BalA p 27.00 +0.05 10.5 500IdxPrem 88.52 +0.33 14.2 EqIncA 11.22 +0.03
Prudential Cl Z & I
7.4 TRBdZ WellsIAdml 64.57 +0.06 6.9
21.1
14.53 +0.01 5.4 ExtndInst 81.25 +0.20 12.7
BondA p 12.97 -0.01 3.3 ExtMktIdxPrem r 61.85 +0.16 12.7 John Hancock Class 1 Schwab Funds WelltnAdml 72.68 +0.18 9.8 GrwthInst 68.34 +0.36 20.3
CapIBA p 62.74 +0.15 11.5 IntlIdxPrem r 42.56 +0.21 20.6 LSBalncd 15.76 ... 11.6 S&P Sel WndsrAdml 77.57 +0.39 13.0 InPrSeIn
Buy or Lease CapWGrA
EupacA p
51.22 +0.30
55.46 +0.38
18.7
25.5
TMktIdxF r
TMktIdxPrem
73.22 +0.26
73.20 +0.25
14.0
13.9
LSGwth 16.84 +0.07
John Hancock Instl
14.6 TIAA/CREF Funds
EqIdxInst
39.31 +0.14
18.90 +0.07
14.2
VANGUARD FDS
13.9 DivdGro 26.07 +0.02 13.0
InstIdx
InstPlus
10.46 -0.03
229.46 +0.86
229.47 +0.85
1.7
14.2
14.2
FdInvA p 61.81 +0.27 15.7 USBdIdxInstPrem 11.63 ... 3.1 DispValMCI 23.62 +0.08 10.0 IntlEqIdxInst 19.99 +0.12 20.8 HlthCare r 213.82 +1.57 19.0 InstTStPlus 56.56 +0.20 13.9
! "# !$% &'(
&', -./-. 0.
)!*$+
)12*+ for Less GwthA p
HI TrA p
ICAA p
49.60 +0.23
10.48 ...
40.39 +0.09
18.0
6.3
12.8
USBdIdxPrem 11.63
Fidelity Advisor I
NwInsghtI
...
32.14 +0.20
3.1
20.4
JPMorgan Funds
MdCpVal L
JPMorgan I Class
NA ...
Tweedy Browne Fds
NA GblValue 28.10 +0.16
INSTTRF2020 22.23
12.2 INSTTRF2025 22.46
INSTTRF2030 22.61
+0.06
+0.07
+0.07
10.4
11.7
12.8
MidCpInst 40.22 +0.17
MidCpIstPl 198.37 +0.86
12.9
12.9
,%
& *. )0($+ Nationwide delivery. VANGUARD ADMIRAL SmCapInst 67.70 +0.15 10.6
IncoA p 23.23 +0.06 9.6 Fidelity Freedom CoreBond NA ... NA 500Adml 232.57 +0.86 14.2 INSTTRF2035 22.78 +0.09 13.9 STIGradeInst 10.69 -0.01 2.2
,$ #
3/- )(2%+ We offer all current makes & models - N PerA p 43.54 +0.29 23.2 FF2020 16.50 +0.05 11.8 JPMorgan R Class BalAdml 33.58 +0.07 9.6 INSTTRF2040 22.93 +0.09 15.0 TotBdInst 10.78 -0.01 3.1
,! $*$
/- )02+ NEcoA p 45.78 +0.24 27.3 FF2025 14.26 +0.04 12.6 CoreBond NA ... NA CAITAdml 11.82 ... 4.6 INSTTRF2045 23.05 +0.09 15.4 TotBdInst2 10.75 ... 3.2
22 ($$
-./- )02+ for less. Call 7 days. Trades accepted. NwWrldA 64.65 +0.54 25.7 FF2030 17.82 +0.07 14.8 Lazard Instl CapOpAdml r 151.28 +0.75 21.8 IntlVal 38.73 +0.26 22.0 TotBdInstPl 10.78 -0.01 3.1
SmCpA p 55.60 +0.26 20.9 Fidelity Invest EmgMktEq 19.13 +0.16 20.5 EMAdmr 36.09 +0.33 23.6 LifeCon 19.66 +0.04 8.2 TotIntBdIdxInst 32.66 -0.01 1.3
%( --$0
3/-.
)(2+
* 0
/-. !,,
45
877.989.1500 TxExA p
WshA p
Baird Funds
12.99 ...
44.53 +0.16
4.3
12.9
Balanc
BluCh
Contra
24.57 +0.05
83.82 +0.55
121.20 +0.84
12.4
27.0
23.9
Loomis Sayles Fds
LSBondI
Lord Abbett A
14.28 ...
EqIncAdml
7.4 ExtndAdml
74.69 +0.15
81.25 +0.19
GNMAAdml 10.53 -0.01
11.4 LifeGro
12.7 LifeMod
1.9 PrmcpCor
32.55
26.55
26.33
+0.12
+0.08
+0.13
13.9
11.0
18.7
TotIntlInstIdx r 117.49 +0.74
TotItlInstPlId r 117.51 +0.74
TotStInst 63.06 +0.21
21.6
21.6
13.9
* 0 3/'
64 #55 www.LEASEFAX.com AggBdInst
CorBdInst
10.90
11.25
...
...
3.7
4.1
ContraK
CpInc r
121.19 +0.84
10.24 +0.01
24.0
9.6
ShtDurIncmA p
Lord Abbett F
NA ... NA GrwthAdml 68.34 +0.36
HlthCareAdml r 90.20 +0.66
20.3 SelValu r
19.0 STAR
32.65
26.78
+0.09
+0.10
13.4
13.9
ValueInst
Western Asset
38.95 +0.09 9.5
1 0 -./-. *. )0%$+ BlackRock Funds A DivIntl 40.68 +0.22 22.2 ShtDurIncm NA ... NA HYCorAdml r 5.99 +0.01 7.0 STIGrade 10.69 -0.01 2.1 CorePlusBdI NA ... NA
$0 -./-. 0. )0*2+ GlblAlloc p 20.12 +0.05 10.7 GroCo 175.00 +1.11 27.9 Metropolitan West
$
/-. 1. )2$+ BlackRock Funds Inst GrowCoK 174.94 +1.10 28.0 TotRetBd NA ... NA
EqtyDivd InvGB
Borrowing Benchmarks | WSJ.com/bonds
22.72 +0.10 10.8 7.94 ... 3.5 TotRetBdI NA ... NA
$ -/- (. )22+ GlblAlloc 20.24 +0.05 10.9 InvGrBd 11.31 ... 3.8 TRBdPlan NA ... NA
SHOW
! -./-. . 76 HiYldBd 7.85 +0.01 7.2 LowP r 51.86 +0.11 13.2 MFS Funds Class I
&', -./-. 0. )12*+ StratIncOpptyIns 9.97 +0.01 4.0 LowPriStkK r 51.81 +0.11 13.2 ValueI 40.19 +0.08 12.2 Money Rates September 29, 2017
,! $*$
/- )02+ Bridge Builder Trust MagIn 102.13 +0.55 18.4 MFS Funds Instl
CoreBond 10.20 ... 3.6 OTC 104.16 +0.90 30.7 IntlEq 24.94 +0.12 23.1 Key annual interest rates paid to borrow or lend money in U.S. and
Del Invest Instl Puritn 23.19 +0.10 13.5 Mutual Series
ROOM
*
3/-. . )(12+ Value 20.95 +0.08 7.8 SrsEmrgMkt 20.60 +0.20 31.2 GlbDiscA 32.63 +0.15 8.5
international markets. Rates below are a guide to general levels but
*
-./-. )($%+ Dimensional Fds SrsGroCoRetail 17.16 +0.10 28.4 GlbDiscz 33.30 +0.16 8.7 don’t always represent actual transactions.
5GlbFxdInc 11.01 -0.01 2.1 SrsIntlGrw 15.89 +0.08 24.1 Oakmark Funds Invest
* 3/'
45 EmgMktVa 29.28 +0.27 24.0 SrsIntlVal 10.77 +0.06 17.6 EqtyInc r 33.41 +0.03 9.8
1 &/'
(. )012+ EmMktCorEq 21.69 +0.22 26.8 TotalBond 10.71 -0.01 3.8 Oakmark 82.85 +0.28 14.3
Inflation Week —52-WEEK—
IntlCoreEq 14.01 +0.07 22.3 Fidelity Selects OakmrkInt NA ... NA Aug. index Chg From (%) Latest ago High Low
$ 3/-./-. (. )0!!+ ADVERTISE TODAY IntlVal
IntSmCo
19.59 +0.11
21.19 ...
19.6
23.4
Biotech r 232.77 +2.14
First Eagle Funds
33.7 Old Westbury Fds
LrgCpStr 14.61 +0.05 13.9
level July '17 Aug. '16 Britain 0.25 0.25 0.25 0.25
! "# &'( 3 )!*$+ IntSmVa 23.31 +0.13 23.3 GlbA 59.66 +0.13 10.0 Oppenheimer Y Australia 1.50 1.50 1.50 1.50
US CoreEq1 21.54 +0.07 13.1 FPA Funds DevMktY NA ... NA U.S. consumer price index
! -./-. !. )02+
(
8/
. )02+ US CoreEq2 20.52 +0.07 11.5 FPACres 34.58 +0.07 7.3 IntGrowY 42.45 +0.26 22.4 All items 245.519 0.30 1.9 Secondary market
US Small 36.11 +0.04 7.4 FrankTemp/Frank Adv Parnassus Fds
(
-/- 0. )0(2+ (800) 366-3975 IncomeAdv 2.37 ... 7.7
Core 252.460 0.21 1.7
US SmCpVal 38.70 +0.01 4.0 ParnEqFd 43.05 +0.03 10.5 Fannie Mae
FrankTemp/Franklin A
sales.showroom US TgdVal
USLgVa
24.98 +0.03
38.29 +0.15
4.9
10.7 CA TF A p 7.46 ... 4.7
PIMCO Fds Instl
AllAsset NA ... NA International rates 30-year mortgage yields
* /-. #55 @wsj.com Dodge & Cox Fed TF A p 11.99 ... 2.7 TotRt 10.32 -0.02 5.0 30 days 3.429 3.418 3.865 2.849
1
/.-
. )2$+ Balanced 108.75 +0.31 8.7 IncomeA p 2.39 ... 7.5 PIMCO Funds A Week 52-Week
$ 3/'
*. )12+ GblStock 13.99 +0.08 17.5 RisDv A p NA ... NA IncomeFd NA ... NA Latest ago High Low 60 days 3.455 3.446 3.899 2.877
Income 13.81 ... 3.9 FrankTemp/Franklin C PIMCO Funds D
$ 3/'
0. )%!+
$ /- 1. )1$+ For more information visit: Intl Stk
Stock
46.66 +0.31
200.52 +0.96
22.5
11.9
Income C t
FrankTemp/Temp A
2.42 ... 7.5 IncomeFd
PIMCO Funds Instl
NA ... NA Prime rates Notes on data:
U.S. prime rate is the base rate on corporate
! &/- . )$2+ wsj.com/classifieds DoubleLine Funds GlBond A p 12.27 +0.04 4.4 IncomeFd NA ... NA U.S. 4.25 4.25 4.25 3.50 loans posted by at least 70% of the 10 largest
( . 3/. - $. )(2+ TotRetBdI NA ... NA Growth A p 26.94 +0.15 14.3 PIMCO Funds P Canada 3.20 3.20 3.20 2.70 U.S. banks, and is effective June 15, 2017. Other
TotRetBdN NA ... NA FrankTemp/Temp Adv IncomeP NA ... NA
0 &/. - 0. )(2+ GlBondAdv p 12.22 +0.03 4.5 Japan 1.475 1.475 1.475 1.475 prime rates aren’t directly comparable; lending
Edgewood Growth Instituti Price Funds practices vary widely by location. Complete
0 -./-. . )(2+ EdgewoodGrInst 28.82 +0.18 29.8 Harbor Funds BlChip 92.66 +0.65 27.6
Policy Rates Money Rates table appears Monday through
Friday.
,%
3/'
. )!2+ Euro zone 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Sources: Bureau of Labor Statistics; SIX Financial
Switzerland 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.50
,*
3/3 0.
,1
3/'
0.
)2+
)02+ Exchange-Traded Portfolios | WSJ.com/ETFresearch Information
The Mart
To advertise: 800-366-3975 or WSJ.com/classifieds ADVERTISEMENT
Other metals
LBMA Platinum Price PM
Platinum,Engelhard industrial
*918.0
923.0
Eggs,large white,Chicago-u
Flour,hard winter KC
Hams,17-20 lbs,Mid-US fob-u
1.2250
14.65
n.a.
Platinum,Engelhard fabricated 1023.0
Palladium,Engelhard industrial 939.0 Hogs,Iowa-So. Minnesota-u 54.26
BIDS & PROPOSALS
Steel, HRC USA, FOB Midwest Mill-s
Fibers and Textiles
617 Fats and Oils
Corn oil,crude wet/dry mill-u,w 35.5400
Grease,choice white,Chicago-h 0.3000
Burlap,10-oz,40-inch NY yd-n,w 0.6150 Lard,Chicago-u n.a.
Cotton,1 1/16 std lw-mdMphs-u
Cotlook 'A' Index-t
0.6845
*78.80
Soybean oil,crude;Centl IL-u
Tallow,bleach;Chicago-h
0.3120
0.3250
!" Hides,hvy native steers piece fob-u n.a. Tallow,edible,Chicago-u n.a.
0 /0- 1, * *' KEY TO CODES: A=ask; B=bid; BP=country elevator bids to producers; C=corrected; E=Manfra,Tordella & Brooks;
G=ICE; H=Hurley Brokerage; I=Natural Gas Intelligence;
/- 1, *& *'
L=livericeindex.com; M=midday; N=nominal; n.a.=not quoted or not available; R=SNL Energy; S=The Steel Index;
2
0- 3*') T=Cotlook Limited; U=USDA; W=weekly, Z=not quoted. *Data as of 9/28
Source: WSJ Market Data Group
! "#$ %& '#()* #" '%$%) $% %&% %& $#! #'
"#$ $! + '* $## "#$ %& !, % #' #" , '% "#$ %& ADVERTISEMENT
!"
# -./ 0 1 2 &$#*& ) *' ' %& "#$ #"
$%& ' () *+, -") ./. (0+ .
0 !!#$) '* %# %& $% #' #(3
$//. % '12"3
4
!%#$ 45 %& 6478 % 743442
9:#$ "$# 0$ ; 0
<
Leisure Travel
To advertise: 800-366-3975 or WSJ.com/classifieds
- . /.
#$% &'()***
0 = > 474?6478 , '% ! "#$ #% #' '' '* #"
#)*% &()$)$
+( ,
.,
&##*'# ' )# FRANCE
0 = > 465?6478
@ ) ""$!%#%$
@ A#$!'!
!%$#%$ 0 A#$#!%$#%
ANNOUNCEMENTS TRAVEL 0 = > 468?6478 ''$% %&$ !' '* , '%
0 = > 46B?6478 & ! $!%#$ "#$ #$%#$@ ( %& *
+ % & *& +!
Save Up To 60%
& $! % #" $## #' '* ') )) '* ( % ! ' %&
First & Business '%$'% '+ $#''% % &%%3??!#$2!% ,%2' 2$2 & $, $'%
INTERNATIONAL "#$ ""!% '* %& !!$) %% #' ' %& &# '* #$% "#$ #% ' '*
Major Airlines, Corporate Travel (#$) ( %& ''#'!'% ( %& %& '"#$% #' $
Never Fly Coach Again! + "$ #" !&$* % %& %3 &%%3??!#$2!% ,%2' 2$
!" ' %& ' '#% !2 #% !' #+) %&$#*&
#$
www.cooktravel.net
%
(800) 435-8776
'%$'! #'C!% ,%2' 2$
# ) D' $# %$ 6B%& 64782
BUSINESS OPPORTUNITIES
#*E$ # ) #F
0 )) '* ! # %%
$500k investment returns $1 million
in 6 months or less and a preferred position THE
MART
in our next funding round. Established PUBLIC NOTICES
LEGAL
fintech company with high-profile
management and nine figure valuation.
NOTICES
A special opportunity for ONE investor.
Principals Only - Absolutely no brokers. ADVERTISE TODAY
Proof of funds required.
Call Mark Davis 408-800-6232 ! "###
$
$ %
"
(800) 366-3975 "#&
$
%
ADVERTISE TODAY
sales.mart@wsj.com
'(
)
* ( $
$
+! ,*
For more information visit: -
! '( (800) 366-3975
)
*
wsj.com/classifieds $
. * sales.legalnotices
/
% $
$ (
(
%
@wsj.com
$0 % 1
© 2017 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. 23 /
4 / 52((
© 2017 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.
All Rights Reserved. 6##5&6## $
/
$ $
( 7&"55"* All Rights Reserved.
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * * * Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 | B9
Federal Reserve leadership. CURRENCIES Dollar Index, Trump and Treasury Secretary
The yield on which mea- Steven Mnuchin have met with
CREDIT the benchmark sures the U.S.
MARKETS 10-year Treasury currency against 16 others,
0.7%
note rose to rose less than 0.1% Friday to
2.328% from 86.30. It gained 0.7% in Sep-
2.309% Thursday and 2.122% tember, snapping a six-month
at the end of August, capping losing streak.
its biggest one-month gain The dollar has risen in re- The dollar’s gain in September,
since November. Yields rise as Part of the Federal Reserve building. The president interviewed two men about the top Fed job. cent weeks as investors grow based on the WSJ Dollar Index
bond prices fall. more optimistic about the
Yields gained after data mer Federal Reserve Gov. have helped buoy yields this penditures, a measure of spend- prospect for U.S. interest-rate
showed the Chicago purchasing Kevin Warsh on Thursday to past week. While the plan has ing on everything from food to increases and tax cuts that
manager index hit its highest discuss his potential nomina- skeptics, an overhaul could medical expenses, rose 0.1% in some expect to boost the U.S. Fed governor Jerome Powell
level in three months, a sign of tion as the next Fed chairman. boost growth and inflation and August from July, according to economy. and former Fed governor
optimism among companies Investors may perceive Mr. increase the size of the budget the Commerce Department. Ad- Investors are now pricing in Kevin Warsh.
about business conditions. Warsh as more inclined to deficit, all of which could have justed for inflation, consumer a 78% chance that the Federal Mr. Warsh is seen by some
That number “caught inves- raise interest rates than other a negative impact on bond spending fell 0.1% in August Reserve raises interest rates on Wall Street as “hawkish,”
tors by surprise,” said Jeff candidates, analysts said. prices, some analysts said. from the prior month, the first again this year, according to or more willing to tighten
MacDonald, head of fixed-in- Mr. Trump and the Treasury Still, signs of weak inflation decline since January. CME Group data. That is up monetary policy, said Vassili
come strategies at Fiduciary secretary also interviewed Fed persist. Early Friday, yields on “This morning’s inflation re- from 34% a month ago. Serebriakov, a currency strate-
Trust Company International. governor Jerome Powell on 10-year Treasurys briefly port reminds the market that Expectations that U.S. inter- gist at Crédit Agricole. “Mar-
Yields extended gains after Wednesday. dipped after new data showed we still have a pretty muted est rates will rise help support kets are reacting to the possi-
reports that President Donald Signs of progress by Repub- that consumer spending was inflation environment that the dollar by making U.S. as- bility of having someone in the
Trump and Treasury Secretary licans in Congress toward a soft in August. continues to disappoint inves- sets more attractive to yield- Fed chair who is more hawkish
Steven Mnuchin met with for- broad overhaul of the tax code Personal-consumption ex- tors,” Mr. MacDonald said. seeking investors. than Janet Yellen,” he said.
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
B10 | Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 * *** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
MARKETS
S&P 500 Rises 4% in Quarter to a Record
BY RIVA GOLD
AND CORRIE DRIEBUSCH
Eight Straight Quarterly Gains
U.S. stocks kept rising over the past three months, as solid earnings and economic
The S&P 500 finished Sep- data supported shares despite concerns about U.S. tensions with North Korea.
tember much like it spent the
past three months—quietly Dow Jones Industrial Average quarterly performance Technology stocks posted another strong quarter, while
grinding higher. energy and financials picked up pace in September.
Solid earnings and eco-
nomic data helped support 8% 10% S&P 500 sector performance
major indexes this past sum- 6 8
Information technology
mer, with trading largely re- Energy
maining 4 6 Financials
FRIDAY’S calm de-
2 4
MARKETS spite dis-
ruptive 0 2
hurricanes
and threats between the U.S. –2 0
and North Korea.
–4 –2
The S&P 500 rose 4% to
fresh records in the quarter, –6 –4
but the index’s average daily
move during the period was –8 –6
0.3%, the lowest since 1968. 2015 2016 2017 July August September
The S&P 500 rose 9.30
points, or 0.4%, Friday to U.S. stock-trading volume posted By one measure, the S&P 500’s moves in the Wall Street's ‘fear gauge’ notched its third
2519.36, a record, while the its slowest quarter in three years*. third quarter were the smallest on record†. straight quarterly decline.
Nasdaq Composite added 42.51
10 billion shares traded, daily average 6% 40%
points, or 0.7%, to a record
6495.96 as technology stocks CBOE Volatility Index,
extended this year’s gains. The 8 5 quarterly performance
Dow Jones Industrial Average 20
gained 23.89 points, or 0.1%,
to 22405.09. 6 4
Friday’s moves leave the 0
Dow industrials up 4.9% since 4 2
the end of June, its eighth
consecutive quarterly advance. –20
“The path of least resis- 2 1
tance seems to be higher for
stocks,” said Jack Ablin, chief 0 0 –40
investment officer at BMO Pri-
vate Bank. 2015 ’16 ’17 1975 ’80 ’90 2000 ’10 2015 2016 2017
Some of the biggest gainers *Includes NYSE, Nasdaq, NYSE American and NYSE Arca volumes
in the past three months were †Trading range is calculated by subtracting the intraday low from the high and making that a percentage of the previous day’s close. Available data go back to 1975.
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
energy companies, boosted by Sources: FactSet (DJIA, sector performance, VIX); WSJ Market Data Group (volume); Thomson Reuters (moves)
the rising price of oil. U.S.-
traded crude is up 12% since should climb,” Mr. Ablin said. The Stoxx Europe 600 data on Friday showed. ally in September, with the and Hong Kong logged their
the end of June—to $51.67 a “Investors are relatively san- climbed 3.8% in September Key indexes in the Asia-Pa- Nikkei Stock Average notching first monthly declines of 2017,
barrel—lifted by unexpectedly guine with fundamentals and and ended the quarter 2.3% cific region finished the quar- its best month of 2017, up with Taiwan shares hit by re-
strong demand and signs of appear to be brushing off the higher, as solid earnings ter higher, with solid earnings 3.6%. cent worry about tech de-
slowing production. Energy big doom and gloom.” growth and a buoyant global and broadly positive risk sen- Strength in Asian equity mand, especially for Apple’s
companies in the S&P 500 fin- October brings the next test economy have drawn in inves- timent continuing to outweigh markets will likely continue iPhone.
ished the quarter up 6%. of these fundamentals, when tors. the region’s geopolitical con- through the fourth quarter as Australia’s S&P/ASX 200 re-
All but one of the 11 sectors corporations report their most Businesses and households cerns, in particular the escala- “there is still massive liquidity corded its worst run in six
in the S&P 500 ended the recent quarterly results. While across the eurozone were tion of tensions between in the markets” and “most of years by falling for a fifth
quarter higher. Consumer-sta- they might show a modest more upbeat about their pros- North Korea and the U.S. the major global economies straight month. After banks
ples stocks finished in the red. slowdown in earnings growth, pects than at any time in more The Shanghai Composite In- are still in a stimulus phase,” fell in August, a sharp retreat
“The fundamentals are the fact that Republicans are than a decade during Septem- dex gained 4.9% during the said Gavin Parry, managing di- in iron-ore prices the past sev-
good, we’re seeing economic moving forward with tax cuts ber, data from the European quarter—its best since 2015— rector of Parry International eral weeks has pressured Aus-
expansion in virtually every could offer a boost to the Commission showed Thursday, while Hong Kong’s Hang Seng Trading in Hong Kong. tralian mining stocks.
country, and as long as we just economy and stock market, while the German unemploy- added 6.9% over the period. But some markets have —Lucy Craymer
continue steady, markets some investors said. ment rate fell to a record low, Japan led the way region- paused more recently. Taiwan contributed to this article.
Email: heard@wsj.com
HEARD ON THE STREET FINANCIAL ANALYSIS & COMMENTARY WSJ.com/Heard
Why Merger Bankers Are Rooting for a Tax Overhaul that figure further, which
means less money available
for stockholders. Valeant still
Every deal banker has a to come up with a plan for visory firm Alvarez & strong negative for private- had more than $27 billion in
pile of pitches that were re- its equity stakes in Alibaba Marsal. Catalyst Needed equity deals, which are fre- long-term debt at the end of
jected by clients who said Group Holding and Yahoo He says examples include M&A deal volume targeting quently financed through the second quarter.
the tax bill made them too Japan. The most simple solu- Hewlett-Packard’s split into U.S. companies debt. The outline released Debt could still increase,
costly. tion, an outright sale of two companies in 2015, and this past week said merely despite the focus on delever-
Bankers will start dusting those stakes back to the two General Electric’s spinoff of $2.0 trillion that the deduction would be aging. Valeant filed for per-
off those pitches if the Asian companies, was off the credit-card issuer Synchrony 1.5 limited, without further de- mission with a Canadian reg-
Trump tax plan’s lower cor- table because it would trig- Financial in 2014. tails. ulator to issue up to $1.5
porate rate becomes law. ger a big tax bill. Those as- The most likely candidates 1.0 M&A deals targeting U.S. billion in bonds this
Currently, when compa- sets now sit in a rump entity for fast-pitching bankers are 0.5 companies are down 15% this week. That might be used to
nies sell units, they pay the called Altaba, which is wait- the large number of under- year, according to Dealogic refinance existing debt, but
35% corporate tax rate on ing to see how the potential performing units sitting 0 data, partly due to uncer- private debt placements typ-
the sale’s profits. This cre- tax bill will change its cir- within conglomerates that 2009 ’11 ’13 ’15 ’17* tainty over future tax rules. ically require higher interest
ates a strong disincentive to cumstances. the owners would be think- *Year to date Just getting clarity on the rates than debt sold through
dispose of assets in this way, Besides this, there were ing more seriously about Source: Dealogic changes could prompt a the public markets.
pushing companies to opt many spinoffs in recent selling if the tax penalty near-term rebound. But Memories are short when
for tax-free spinoffs instead. years that could easily have were lower, according to one also hurt deal making that overhauls that significantly stocks are rallying. No one
The most notorious recent been sales if corporate taxes M&A banker. requires a lot of borrowing. lowered corporate tax rates should forget how much
example has been the state were lower, says Ernie Perez, The tax plan, which could Details on this part of the would support deal activity money was lost by Valeant’s
of Yahoo’s Asian assets. The head of the tax practice at eliminate the tax deduction plan are still vague but if for years to come. investors.
company struggled for years M&A and restructuring ad- for interest payments, could they stick, it would be a —Aaron Back —Charley Grant
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
BOOKS | CULTURE | SCIENCE | COMMERCE | HUMOR | POLITICS | LANGUAGE | TECHNOLOGY | ART | IDEAS
© 2017 Dow Jones & Company. All Rights Reserved. * * * * THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 | C1
THE LESSONS OF
LEONARDO
History’s most creative genius was not superhuman, writes Walter Isaacson,
and following his methods can bring great intellectual rewards to anyone.
A
ROUND THE TIME that he reached the unnerving takes in arithmetic. He had a deep feel for geometry but was not adroit
milestone of turning 30, Leonardo da Vinci wrote a letter at using equations to codify nature’s laws. He left many artistic projects
to the ruler of Milan listing the reasons why he should be unfinished and pages of brilliant treatises unpublished. He was also prone
given a job. In 10 carefully numbered paragraphs, he to fantasy, envisioning flying machines that never flew and tanks that
touted his engineering skills, including his ability to design never rolled.
bridges, waterways, cannons and armored vehicles. Only To some extent, these tendencies were failings. Vision without execution
at the end, as an afterthought, did he add that he was also is hallucination. But Leonardo’s ability to blur the line between reality and
an artist. “Likewise in painting, I can do everything possible,” he wrote. imagination, just like his sfumato technique for blurring the lines of a paint-
Yes, he could. He would go on to create the two most famous paintings in ing, was a key to his creativity. He envisioned what innovators would invent
history, the “Mona Lisa” and “The Last Supper.” But in his own mind, he was centuries later, and by refusing to churn out works
just as much a man of science and engineering, pursuing studies of anatomy, that he had not perfected, he sealed his reputation
flying machines, fossils, birds, optics, geology and weaponry. His ability to Be curious, as a genius rather than a master craftsman.
combine art and science—made iconic by “Vitruvian Man,” his drawing of a
perfectly proportioned man (possibly a self-portrait) spread-eagled inside a
observe We will never be able to match Leonardo’s tal-
ents, but we can try to cultivate, in ourselves and
circle and square—is why so many consider him history’s most creative genius. attentively in our children, the skills that he used to put
Fortunately for us, Leonardo was also a very human genius. He was not
the recipient of supernatural intellect in the manner of, for example, New-
and indulge imagination to productive use. All of us have
something to learn from him about how to lead
ton or Einstein, whose minds had such unfathomable processing power fantasy. a more creative and intellectually satisfying life.
that we can merely marvel at them. His genius came from being wildly Please turn to the next page
imaginative, quirkily curious and willfully observant. It was a product of
his own will and effort, which makes his example more inspiring for us This essay is adapted from Mr. Isaacson’s new biography, “Leonardo da
mere mortals and also more possible to emulate. Vinci,” which will be published in October by Simon & Schuster. His
ILLUSTRATION BY DOUG CHAYKA
More than 7,000 pages of Leonardo’s notebooks still exist, and there previous books include “Steve Jobs,” “Einstein: His Life and Universe”
we find plenty of evidence that he was not superhuman. He made mis- and “Benjamin Franklin: An American Life.”
INSIDE
ASK ARIELY
When disappointment brews:
A behavioral economist on
controlling beer expectations.
C18
REVIEW
The Potential of
to admire the beauty of a blue sky but to ask why it is that color. knowledge to create “The Last Supper,” one of history’s most dramatic
Nor was Leonardo’s curiosity constrained by the distinctions we paintings. For his theatrical productions, he devised ingenious props
Young Intellect,
make today among different disciplines and fields. His mind wan- and mechanisms, some of which he later replicated for the real world.
dered merrily across the arts, sciences, engineering and humanities. Many people have seen the famous drawings of his aerial
Rich or Poor
His knowledge of how light strikes the retina informed the perspec- screw contraption, and some think it was a design for a real heli-
tive in “The Last Supper,” and a page of his anatomical drawings de- copter. I suspect that it was a piece of fantasy for the theater, in-
picting the dissection of lips is topped by the first sketch of the Mona tended to propel people’s imaginations rather than their bodies.
INEQUALITY starts early. In Lisa’s smile. He knew that art was a science and that science was an But eventually it led Leonardo to apply himself to designing hu-
2015, 23% of American chil- art. Whether drawing a fetus in the womb or the swirls of a deluge, man-powered flying machines—work that inspired engineers for
dren under 3 grew up in pov- he blurred the distinction between the two. the next five centuries.
erty, according to the Census Some people are geniuses in a particular arena, such as Mozart in Leonardo was a grown-up who never stopped indulging in the
Bureau. By the time children music or Euler in math, but Leonardo’s passion was to know every- sort of fantasy and speculation that we now associate with child-
reach first grade, there are al- thing there was to know about everything that could be known. This hood. There’s a lesson for us in that, amid all the practical demands
ready big gaps, based on parents’ income, in gave him a profound feel for nature’s crosscurrents and a reverence of our modern lives. We, too, can try to imagine, as he did, how to
academic skills like reading and writing. The for the harmony of its patterns. In his notebooks, he would record divert a river, or build a human-powered flying machine, or square
comparisons look even starker when you curls of hair, eddies of water and whirls of air, along with some stabs a circle using only a ruler and a compass. We are unlikely to solve
contrast middle-class U.S. children and chil- at the math that might underlie such spirals. these problems, but even by failing in the attempt we can stretch
dren in developing countries like Peru. There have been many insatiable polymaths, and even the Renais- our imaginations.
Can schooling reverse these gaps, or are sance produced other Renaissance Men. But none painted the “Mona Today we live in a world that encourages specialization,
they doomed to grow as the children get Lisa,” or did so while at the same time producing unsurpassed ana- whether we are students, scholars, workers or professionals. We
older? Scientists like me usually study pre- tomical drawings based on multiple dissections, coming up with also tend to exalt training in technology and engineering, believ-
schoolers in venues like university pre- schemes to divert rivers, explaining the reflection of light from the ing that the jobs of the future will go to those who can code and
schools and science museums. The children Earth to the moon, designing musical instruments, choreographing build rather than those who can be creative.
are mostly privileged, with parents who have pageants, using fossils to dispute the biblical account of the deluge— But the true innovators tend to be those like Leonardo who make
given them every advantage and are increas- and then drawing the deluge. no distinction between the beauties of the arts and the beauties of the
ingly set on giving instruction to even the sciences. When Einstein was stymied in his pursuit of the field equa-
youngest children. So how can we reliably Observe attentively. tions for general relativity, he would often pull out his violin and play
test whether certain skills are the birthright His curiosity was aided by the sharpness of his eye, which fo- Mozart. The music, he
of all children, rich or poor? cused on things that the rest of us barely notice. One night he said, helped to connect
My psychology lab at the University of saw lightning flash behind some buildings and for that instant him to the harmonies of
California, Berkeley has been trying to pro- they looked smaller, so he launched a series of experiments to our cosmos. At the end of
vide at least partial answers, and my col- verify that objects look smaller when surrounded by light. When many of his product pre-
leagues and I published some of the results he saw four-winged dragonflies hovering over a moat, he ob- sentations, Steve Jobs
in the Aug. 23 edition of the journal Child served exactly how their wing pairs alternated in motion. Water would display a slide that
Development. Our earlier research has found flowing into a bowl? He studied how the eddies formed, and showed the intersection
that young children are remarkably good at then wondered why. of streets labeled “Liberal
learning. For example, they can figure out In his notebooks, Leo- Arts” and “Technology.”
cause-and-effect relationships, one of the nardo set out his simple He knew that at such
foundations of scientific thinking. method for truly observ- crossroads lay creativity.
How can we ask 4-year-olds about cause ing a scene: Look sepa- There is a flip side
and effect? We use what we call “the blicket rately at each detail. He for those of us who love
detector”—a machine that lights up when compared it to looking the arts and humani-
you put some combinations of different- at the page of a book. It ties. Like Leonardo, we
shaped blocks on it but not others. The sub- was meaningless when must be able to see and
jects themselves don’t handle the blocks or taken in as a whole and embrace the beauty of a
the machine; an experimenter demonstrates had to be examined word mathematical equation
it for them, using combinations of one and by word. “If you wish to or a scientific theory.
two blocks. have a sound knowledge Cultural critics who
In the training phase of the experiment, of the forms of objects,” complain that today’s
some of the young children saw a machine he advised, “begin with students fail to learn
that worked in a straightforward way—some the details of them, and LEONARDO DA VINCI, left, began Shakespeare or civics or
individual blocks made it go, and others do not go on to the sec- his lifelong practice of keeping history should not be
didn’t. The rest of the children observed a ond step until you have notebooks in the early 1480s. complacent about their
machine that worked in a more unusual the first well fixed in Above, diagrams from his notebook. own cluelessness when
way—only a combination of two specific memory.” it comes to, say, what a
blocks made it go. We also used the demon- Leonardo knew that transistor does or how
stration to train two groups of adults. true observation requires He never a circuit processes logical sequences.
Could the participants, children and
adults alike, use the training data to figure
not only the discipline of looking very closely at something but also
the patience to process observations and patterns. While painting
outgrew the All of these topics are valuable and
enriching, especially when we can
out how a new set of blocks worked? The “The Last Supper,” he would sometimes stare at the work for an child’s need connect them to one another.
very young children did. If the training
blocks worked the unusual way, they thought
hour, finally make one small stroke, and then leave. He told the
duke of Milan that creativity requires time and patience. “Men of
to ask The best reason to learn from Leo-
nardo, however, is not to get a better
that the new blocks would also work that lofty genius sometimes accomplish the most when they work why the sky job but to live a better life. Having
way, and they used that assumption to deter-
mine which spe-
least,” he explained, “for their minds are occupied with their ideas
and the perfection of their conceptions, to which they afterwards
is blue. immersed myself in his world for sev-
eral years, I have resolved to be more
cific blocks give form.” observant of phenomena that I used
A ‘blicket caused the ma- Most of us don’t need to be encouraged to procrastinate. We to ignore. When I see sunlight hitting
detector’ chine to light up. do it naturally. But procrastinating like Leonardo requires work: drapes, I push myself to pause and
But most of the It involves gathering all the possible facts and ideas, and only af- look at the way the shadows caress the folds. I notice how the
gauges a adults didn’t get ter that allowing the various ingredients to simmer. glint of a lustrous spot on a shiny surface moves when I tilt my
key element it—they stuck As the offspring of a long line of notaries, Leonardo knew that head. When I can’t understand a math concept, I do the best I
in scientific with the obvious
idea that only
skillful observation was aided by the act of recording it. In the
early 1480s, shortly after his arrival in Milan, he began his life-
can to visualize it.
The rewards have a very real human dimension as well. At a
thinking. one block was long practice of keeping notebooks. supper with a group of compelling guests, I now try to study the
needed to make Fortunately, he could not afford to waste paper, so he crammed ev- relationship of their motions to their emotions, as if having to
the machine run. ery inch of his pages with miscellaneous drawings and looking-glass capture them on a canvas. And when I see the hint of a smile
In the Child jottings that seem random but provide intimations of his mental come across the lips of an acquaintance, I try for a moment, as
Development study of 290 children, we set leaps. The jumble might include math calculations, sketches of his Leonardo would, to fathom her inner mysteries.
out to see what less-privileged children
would do. We tested 4-year-old Americans in
preschools for low-income children run by
the federal Head Start program, which also
focuses on health, nutrition and parent in-
ILLUSTRATION BY DOUG CHAYKA; CULTURE CLUB/GETTY IMAGES (PORTRAIT); SSPL/GETTY IMAGES (DRAWING)
REVIEW
Decline of Marriage
which is why the median be difficult. The psychologist and relationship
age at marriage for Ameri- specialist Scott Stanley of the University of
can men has risen steadily Denver sees visible daily sacrifices, such as
and is now approaching 30. accepting inconveniences in order to see a
My own research points woman, as the way that men typically show
When women don’t insist on and countless other men.
Marriage in the U.S. is in open retreat. As
to a more straightforward and primal explana-
tion for the slowed pace toward marriage: For
their developing commitment. It signals the
expectation of a future together. Such small
waiting, men behave badly recently as 2000, married 25- to 34-year-olds American men, sex has become rather cheap. As instances of self-sacrificing love may sound
outnumbered their never-married peers by a compared to the past, many women today ex- simple, but they are less likely to develop
margin of 55% to 34%, according to the U.S. pect little in return for sex, in terms of time, at- when past and present relationships are
BY MARK REGNERUS
Census Bureau. By 2015, the most recent year tention, commitment or fidelity. Men, in turn, founded on the expectation of cheap sex.
for which data are available, those estimates do not feel compelled to supply these goods as Young people in the U.S. continue to marry,
KEVIN, A 24-YEAR-OLD recent college gradu- had almost reversed, with never-marrieds they once did. It is the new sexual norm for even if later in life, but the number of those
ate from Denver, wants to get married someday outnumbering marrieds by 53% to 40%. Young Americans, men and women alike, of every age. who never marry is poised to increase. In a
and is “almost 100% positive” that he will. But Americans have quickly be- This transformation was 2015 article in the journal Demography, Steven
not soon, he says, “because I am not done being come wary of marriage. driven in part by birth con- Ruggles of the University of Minnesota pre-
stupid yet. I still want to go out and have sex Many economists and soci- The big trol. Its widespread adoption dicted that a third of Americans now in their
with a million girls.” He believes that he’s fig- ologists argue that this flight changes: birth by women in recent decades 20s will never wed, well above the historical
ured out how to do that: from marriage is about men’s not only boosted their educa- norm of just below 10%.
“Girls are easier to mislead than guys just by low wages. If they were control and tional and economic fortunes Most young Americans still seek the many
lying or just not really caring. If you know what higher, the argument goes, online porn. but also reduced their depen- personal and social benefits that come from
girls want, then you know you should not give young men would have the dence on men. As the risk of marriage, even as the dynamics of today’s mat-
that to them until the proper time. If you do confidence to marry. But re- pregnancy radically declined, ing market conspire against them. It turns out
that strategically, then you can really have any- cent research doesn’t support sex shed many of the social that a world in which it is possible to satisfy
thing you want…whether it’s a relationship, sex this view. A May 2017 study from the National and personal costs that once encouraged our sexual desires much more immediately car-
or whatever. You have the control.” Bureau of Economic Research, focusing on re- women to wait. ries with it a number of unhappy and unin-
Kevin (not his real name) was one of 100 gions enriched by the fracking boom, found that These forces have been at work for more tended consequences.
men and women, from a cross-section of Ameri- increased wages in those places did nothing to than a half-century, since the birth-control pill
can communities, that my team and I inter- boost marriage rates. was invented in 1960, but it seems that our
viewed five years ago as we sought to under- Another hypothesis blames the decline of norms and narratives about sexual relationships Dr. Regnerus is an associate professor of soci-
stand how adults in their 20s and early 30s marriage on men’s fear of commitment. have finally caught up with the technology. Data ology at the University of Texas at Austin. This
think about their relationships. He sounds like Maybe they just perceive marriage as a bad collected in 2014 for the “Relationships in essay is adapted from his new book, “Cheap
a jerk. But it’s hard to convince him that his deal. But most men, including cads such as America” project—a national survey of over Sex: The Transformation of Men, Marriage and
strategy won’t work—because it has, for him Kevin, still expect to marry. They eventually 15,000 adults, ages 18 to 60, that I oversaw for Monogamy” (Oxford University Press).
competitive, alpha-male nature, as well as to my are triumphant only because disasters also occur.
deep intellectual fascination with the brain. Complacency, I have learned, is the worst of
What could be more glorious than being a brain all surgical sins. All doctors face the central
surgeon? I signed up for the specialty more or challenge of balancing professional detachment
less the next day. with painful compassion. You can care too much
Now, facing retirement, I am still in love with personality—our very being. than the probable risks of operating. My worst for your patients and become overwhelmed—be-
neurosurgery, but my view of it has changed The difficulty of neurosurgery lies not so mistakes—the times patients came to harm at cause however skillful and diligent you are,
profoundly. I soon came to understand that much in the operating as in the decision-making. my hands—have almost always stemmed from some of your patients will suffer and die.
brain surgery is very crude relative to the mi- Surgeons must balance the risks and benefits of bad decision-making on my part. But if you fail to suffer with them to at least
croscopic intricacy of the brain. Our main tool is surgery against the risks and benefits of not op- Other people are always better at seeing our some extent, you will have lost not only your
a small sucker, two millimeters in diameter, 50 erating. These are probabilities, not certainties, blunders than we are. Only toward the end of humanity but also your drive to do better. I still
times as large as the average brain cell—a low- and they are easy to misjudge. my career did I fully grasp the importance of love the struggle to find this balance—and to
tech device in the face of such complexity. Overtreatment is a major problem in modern having good colleagues willing and able to criti- justify the respect and confidence that our pa-
Worse, the brain has only a limited capacity medicine, especially in the U.S. The patient may cize me. tients have little choice but to place in us.
to recover; it doesn’t heal like bone, muscle or be perfectly well after an operation that was ac- In a safe surgical department, the senior sur-
other tissues. So brain surgery is particularly tually a mistake—one in which a less biased or geons get on well and don’t feel threatened by Dr. Marsh is the author, most recently, of
dangerous, risking not only death, paralysis or emotional assessment would have shown that each other. This often doesn’t happen. Surgical “Admissions: Life as a Brain Surgeon,” which
blindness but also changes to our intellect and the probable risks of not operating were less egos are large. One cannot carry out high-risk will be published by St. Martin’s on Oct. 3.
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
C4 | Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 * *** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
REVIEW
WORD ON
HOW TO THE STREET:
BEN ZIMMER
BREAK FREE
FROM THE ‘Hail Mary,’
Groupthink From Pigskin
To Politics
Of Washington
THE LATEST ATTEMPT by Senate
Republicans to overturn the Af-
fordable Care Act was always a bit
of a long shot. Before it was pulled
from consideration by the Senate
GOP leadership earlier this week,
In the age of Trump, the Graham-Cassidy bill was fre-
quently described in media ac-
conventional wisdom has led so counts as a “Hail Mary,” borrowing
many to get so much so wrong a familiar phrase from football.
From the football field to the
Senate chamber, the phrase de-
scribes a desperate maneuver
when no other options are avail-
able. One Republican source told
CNN last Saturday that “even a
‘Hail Mary’ might be too generous
to describe the odds at the mo-
ment.”
How did “Hail Mary” become
the go-to sports metaphor for a
last-minute bid to beat the odds
and scratch out a victory? Football
fans know the “Hail Mary play” as
a long pass attempt made as a fi-
nal play by a trailing team. Occa-
sionally the play succeeds, as
when the Florida Gators pulled off
a Hail Mary earlier this month to
send the Tennessee Volunteers
packing.
As the name of a devotional
prayer, “Hail Mary” dates back to
the 14th century in English, a
ASSOCIATED PRESS
so wrong. general and later deputy treasury secre- kings, Mr. Staubach revived the ex-
Conventional wisdom emerges with tary under President George W. Bush, pression to describe his game-win-
particular ease in Washington—a small, notes that after Vietnam, the Army ning touchdown pass, a long bomb
one-industry city in which politicians, forced itself through a painful, system-
journalists, analysts and lobbyists atic study to re-examine its practices. “A
spend a great deal of time talking to bunch of young colonels who fought in A Cowboys-
one another. “A lot of people in this
town spend a lot of time thinking about
Vietnam basically just took the Army
down to its basest point and asked the
Vikings game
what other people in this town think,” CHICAGO Mayor Rahm Emanuel predicted Trump’s win. tough questions,” he says. One of the to remember.
says Jeff Weaver, who ran Sen. Bernie study’s conclusions: The predilection for
Sanders’s decidedly unconventional 2016 Dem- fluence of conventional wisdom? Here are four “trying to achieve consensus in the analysis and
ocratic presidential campaign. “Anybody who pieces of advice I’ve gleaned. reporting of intelligence information must be
has a contrary idea runs the risk of being ridi- Get out of your bubble. In 1987, President avoided at all cost; divergent opinions and con- to wide receiver Drew Pearson. “I
culed by others in the commentator commu- Ronald Reagan defied the Kremlin—and Wash- flicting analyses should be tolerated, listened to, guess you’d call it a Hail Mary
nity.” ington conventional wisdom—by going to the and even encouraged.” pass,” he said. “You throw it up
If ever there were a time to be skeptical that Berlin Wall and declaring to his Soviet counter- Show some humility. We can all do better in and pray he catches it.”
something is true just because “everybody” part, “Mr. Gorbachev, tear down this wall.” The asking questions and actually listening to the That stupendous play solidified
says so, it is the era of Trump, where past line shocked the capital’s foreign-policy estab- answers. That’s especially important in Wash- “Hail Mary” in football circles, and
practice rather emphatically doesn’t guarantee lishment, which feared that the Soviets would ington, where impressing others with how much soon it was being used more gen-
future performance. I know whereof I speak: react badly and that West Berlin would be roiled you know sometimes gets in the way of finding erally for desperate acts with lim-
As a Washington columnist, I am a longtime by new tension. Neither turned out to be true, out what they know. ited chances of success—including
purveyor of conventional wisdom. Sometimes, and the wall would come down in just over two Public-opinion polling, which has been ma- political acts. When Democrats in
I suppose, I help to create it. years. ligned in recent years, remains a crucial tool Congress were maneuvering
I’m certainly always swimming Peter Robinson, then a ju- in gauging feelings outside the D.C. bubble. against President Ronald Reagan’s
in it. And struggling against its Get out of nior White House speechwriter, Focus groups—in-depth discussions with plan to send a military-aid package
tide is uncomfortable.
The CW has gotten plenty
your bubble, composed the famous line. How small groups of voters—are even more valu-
could he dare such a thing, able. But there is no substitute for person-to-
to the Nicaraguan Contras in 1987,
Rep. David Obey (D-Wis.) was
wrong in recent years. The con- and show knowing that his elders and person listening. quoted as saying, “You want one
sensus held that Mr. Sanders some betters would consider it too Consider two small examples from 2016. last play, even if it’s a ‘Hail Mary’
could never get traction because provocative? “I did original re- Early in the campaign, I went to a New Hamp- on either side.” And when Sen.
he was an old, rumpled socialist humility. porting,” he says. “I had gone shire town-hall meeting with New Jersey Gov. Bob Dole, trailing President Bill
who couldn’t possibly raise to the wall. Above all, I had sat Chris Christie, then a top Republican presi- Clinton in the 1996 presidential
enough money from small dona- down in West Berlin with a dential contender. I expected to hear about race, unveiled a major tax-cut
tions to mount a national cam- bunch of West Berliners. I the issues then fixating Washington—includ- plan, Mr. Clinton’s strategist Dick
paign. The same sachems—myself included— asked them, ‘I’ve been told you’ve gotten used ing the Iran nuclear deal and gay marriage— Morris characterized the move as
were sure that Mr. Trump’s candidacy had been to the wall. Is that true?’ It wasn’t…I like to but was stunned that the first two questions “a Hail Mary pass,” adding, “like
killed off when he sneered at the heroism of think I got out of the Washington bubble.” were about opioid abuse. A question that most Hail Marys, it was inter-
Sen. John McCain, a prisoner of war in Vietnam. Build a system for hearing different views. wasn’t even on the CW’s radar screen was a cepted and run back for long yard-
Then the CW was certain that the “Access Holly- The intelligence community, Mr. Gates says, burning issue in a key state. age.”
wood” tape of Mr. Trump bragging about grop- uses a technique called competitive analysis, Then, late in the campaign, I happened to Whether it’s on the gridiron or
ing women would bring his run to an end. It was which directs “a group to go off and challenge take a cab in Washington driven by an African on Capitol Hill, one thing is clear:
similarly sure that Mrs. Clinton’s advisers were the conventional wisdom.” immigrant with a thick accent, who had a It’s dangerous to count on divine
safe in presuming that Democratic voters flirt- For example, Mr. Gates remembers a debate “Make America Great Again” sticker on the intervention.
ing with third-party candidates would “come within the CIA in the 1980s over how much of center of his dashboard. I asked: Aren’t you
home” to her in the end—and that the alarms the Soviet Union’s gross domestic product went scared by Trump’s harsh words on immigra- Answers
sounded by Mrs. Clinton’s team about Russian to military spending. The CIA’s in-house experts, tion? That rhetoric, the driver replied, was di- To the News Quiz on page C19
interference in the election were exaggerated. he recalls, thought the share was about 15%. But rected toward others, not himself. He was vot-
Wrong on all counts. outside the CIA, a Russian émigré was arguing ing Trump. I was amused. I should have been 1.A, 2.B, 3.C, 4.D, 5.B, 6.C,
Robert Gates has seen the risks of groupthink that the correct figure was several times higher. listening more closely. 7.A, 8.C
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 | C5
CASSANDRE MONTORIOL
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
C6 | Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 * *** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
AUTUMN BOOKS
‘The only way of discovering the limits of the possible is to venture a little way past them into the impossible.’ —Arthur C. Clarke
BY RANDALL STROSS
Memoirs of an ‘Obamabot’
THERE’S NOTHING and political arrangements by upset- feel all the characters in your story “Most of my proudest achievements Mr. Litt writes insightfully about
quite so humorless ting settled ways of thinking. Early were basically decent, competent and in life still fell under the category of the craft of speechwriting. Politicians
as scholarly treat- seasons of “The Simpsons,” he shows, basically admirable people. ‘overcomplicated pranks.’ ” and CEOs, he observes—correctly in
ments of humor. Sig- place ordinary people in a dull town Instead of ridiculing his boss or Mr. Litt is at his best chronicling my experience—are always looking
mund Freud’s expla- within freakishly improbable circum- his colleagues, he mostly ridicules the ludicrous mayhem of campaign for a speechwriter who’ll find their
nations of humor are stances and so create a kind of absur- himself—and that’s where he scores life (he worked on the 2012 campaign, “voice.” His response: “Martin Luther
engaging in their way, and Francis dist satire of American life. Mr. Holm some laughs. Mr. Litt was still in col- too). He recalls a woman he met while King had a voice. John F. Kennedy had
Hutcheson had a point when he argued similarly sets about theorizing how lege when Barack Obama first ran canvassing for votes in Ohio who said a voice. With all due respect, you
that laughter arises mainly from the all sorts of “humorous texts” in for president. In an instant, he be- flatly she wasn’t going to vote. He probably don’t.”
juxtaposition of incongruous ideas. But popular culture—“Sein- tried to convince her of The author seems to realize that
it’s hard to talk about “humor” in the feld,” “The Office,” “The the election’s impor- his admiration for Mr. Obama de-
abstract without seeming to miss the Daily Show,” “Veep,” tance, but to no avail. prives his book of some of the satiri-
point. In “Humour as Politics” (Pal- “Borat”—achieve come- “In the movie version cal fun and narrative tension it
grave, 223 pages, $99.99) Nicholas dic success by flouting of my life, this was the might otherwise have, and he tries
expectations and turn- moment when she to solve the problem by recounting
ing tacit social conven- raced to her polling his disgust with the candidate after
David Litt faces a problem: tions upside down. place,” he writes. But the first presidential debate of 2012,
One thing is clear “in the my-life version when Mr. Obama, clearly unpre-
Political humor works best from Mr. Holm’s analy- of my life,” she chased pared, was trounced by Mitt Rom-
when it ridicules the sis: Political humor him off her porch. ney. “My days in Obamaworld
works best when it’s Another scene has weren’t finished,” he writes. “But my
powerful and influential. subversive, or when it the author trying to days as an Obamabot were done.”
ridicules the powerful take the advice of a That’s about all the displeasure with
and influential. That’s a campaign pollster who’d his boss he can muster, and to my
Holm, a lecturer in media studies at challenge for David concluded that Mr. mind it’s not enough.
Massey University, New Zealand, Litt, whose memoir Obama’s remark about I wondered, too, why Mr. Litt felt
GETTY IMAGES
attempts to elucidate the political im- “Thanks, Obama: My the economy working it necessary in a memoir as funny as
plications of contemporary comedy, Hopey, Changey White “not from the top down this one to put off half the audience
and his discussions are about as en- House Years” (Ecco, but from the middle out by taking gratuitous shots at conser-
tertaining as you’d expect: Not at all. 310 pages, $27.99) re- TV STARS Fallon, Questlove and Obama ‘Slow Jam the News.’ and the bottom up” res- vatives. Why say, for instance, that
His point is valid, though. “Like counts the author’s onated with voters. “under Ronald Reagan, conservative
any other cultural object,” he explains time as one of Barack Obama’s came an “Obamabot.” After working Campaign workers were supposed to theory held that handouts for the
in the introduction, “humorous texts speechwriters. I say it’s a challenge on the 2008 campaign and then use this improbable line while canvass- rich were good for everyone”? The
carry within them certain sets of em- because, although Mr. Litt has a ter- landing a wretched job for a public ing. “Imagine going to a cocktail party remark isn’t funny and strikes an un-
bedded ideological assumptions that rific comedic touch—he wrote lots of relations firm he calls Crisis Hut full of strangers. Now imagine being generous note. Or perhaps I just
potentially play a role in the trans- Mr. Obama’s wittiest lines—his admi- (not its real name, I think), he some- told that, in every conversation, you’re think it’s unfunny and ungenerous
mission and construction of socially ration for his old boss is largely undi- how was given a chance to write expected to say that Shake Shack owes because I’m conservative and Mr.
shared systems of interpretation.” minished and he still has high regard speeches for Mr. Obama’s adviser, its success less to savvy marketing Litt isn’t—a sad reminder that, in a
That’s an academic’s way of saying for his former colleagues. It’s tough to Valerie Jarrett. “I was twenty-four than to its proprietary blend of meats. contest between politics and humor,
that comedy often threatens social make your readers laugh when you years old,” he explains humbly. It’s weird.” politics often wins.
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 | C7
AUTUMN BOOKS
‘However far human beings may reach with their knowledge . . . in the end they carry away nothing but their own biography.’ —Friedrich Nietzsche
possible, Freud concludes, that this re- which is perhaps implicit in the very
nunciation is too high a price to pay; definition of a prophet. But like other
civilization may turn out to be “a state exploded belief systems, psychoanaly-
of affairs which the individual will be sis is so deeply embedded in our cul-
unable to tolerate.” And history would tural self-understanding that it may be
justify his pessimism. As Freud wrote, impossible to think our way entirely
fascism was on the march in Europe, biography, “Freud: The Making of an It is precisely because Freud was a placing faith as the most powerful and free of it. Unconscious motivation, sex-
promising an orgiastic release of all Illusion.” It has been some three de- kind of prophet that he was so hostile authoritative form of knowledge. It ual repression, “Freudian slips,” dream
the violent, irrational instincts civiliza- cades since critics began a sustained to all forms of traditional religion, was able to answer ancient mysteries, analysis, the family romance—not all
tion had worked so hard to repress. assault on the reputation of Freud, which he argued in “The Future of an such as the origin of man, and to these ideas were original to Freud but
If Freud’s account of how human pointing out the many grave defects in Illusion” were relics of infantile fear transform time and space, with inven- all come down to us bearing his ac-
beings feel, suffer and grow, and his his clinical practice, his professional and worship of the father. If there is tions like the railroad and the tele- cent. He is one of those thinkers who
analysis of culture and ethics, still feel ethics and his theoretical speculations. one constant in Freud’s intellectual graph. “No, our science is no illusion,” cannot be ignored, only argued with
intuitively convincing, that is because Freud bullied his patients into accept- life, it is his adamant opposition to Freud wrote. “But an illusion it would and about—which suggests that the
we still inhabit the mental universe ing his wild interpretations of their religion, especially the Judaism that be to suppose that what science can- Freud wars may be with us to stay.
that he created. It is even possible to dreams and experiences. The patients was his family’s tradition. This is not not give us we can get elsewhere,” by
argue that the course of Western civili- he wrote about in his case studies— surprising: Freud trained as a medical which he meant from religion. Mr. Kirsch is the author of “The
zation since the 1960s has been an ex- Dora, the Wolf Man, Little Hans—were man in the second half of the 19th Ironically, what gave Freudianism People and the Books: 18 Classics of
periment in Freudian de-sublimation, not actually cured by his interventions. century, a time when science was re- such appeal was its fusion of religious Jewish Literature.”
in loosening bonds—especially sexual He treated the psychoanalytic move-
ones—that had become intolerably ment more like a religious cult than a
strict. As W.H. Auden put it in the scientific endeavor, choosing favorites,
elegy he composed after Freud’s death expelling dissidents and assiduously
in 1939, “to us he is no more a person burnishing his own reputation by re-
/ now but a whole climate of opinion.” writing history when it suited him.
Yet in the same poem, Auden also The appearance of Mr. Crews’s
acknowledged that “often he was book, which focuses on the early part
wrong and, at times, absurd”: The of Freud’s career before he became
strange thing about Freud is that the world famous, has renewed all these
absurdity is often inextricable from the charges in the press. Mr. Crews is
wisdom. Take, for instance, the pas- trained as a literary critic, not a psy-
sages in “Civilization and Its Discon- chologist, yet in the course of a
tents” in which he offers an explana- decades-long obsession with Freud, he
tion for how human beings came to has made himself an expert in every-
master fire, the “quite extraordinary thing related to his quarry, from the
and unexampled achievement” that history of neurology to the side effects
was the origin of civilization itself. “It of cocaine. The Javert of psychoanaly-
is as though,” Freud writes, “primal sis, Mr. Crews aims not just to debunk
man had the habit, when he came in Freud, but to defame him, to banish
contact with fire, of satisfying an him from serious consideration for-
infantile desire connected with it, by ever. The index entries under “Freud,
putting it out with a stream of his Sigmund” give a sense of the book’s
urine.” This instinct was rooted in sex- tenor: “abandoned by patients; alcohol,
ual desire, since the “tongues of flame” recourse to; bribery on behalf of;
were symbolic phalluses, so that uri- impotence of; vindictiveness of” and
nating on them was “a homosexual more. Yet Mr. Crews’s quest remains
competition.” The first man to “damp self-contradictory, for you can’t de-
down the fire of his own sexual excita- stroy a thinker’s legacy by attacking
tion” and resist the impulse to urinate him; only oblivion can do that, and
was the first to carry off the fire and criticism is the opposite of forgetting.
use it for his own purposes. “This Reading this book, you can’t help feel-
great cultural conquest,” Freud con-
cludes, “was thus the reward for his
renunciation of instinct.”
ing that Freud must be important
indeed to inspire such anger and
warrant such effort.
Audiobooks Make
What are we to think when a sage
comes up with such a bizarre theory?
First, note that it is not really a theory
Mr. Crews’s full-spectrum attack
has the unintended effect of undermin-
ing Mr. Crews’s valid insights into the
Great Running Partners
at all, in the sense of a scientific deep flaws of Freud’s thinking. It
hypothesis, because it can neither be would be enough to prove Freud was
verified nor falsified by any imaginable not a scientist, and that psychoanaly-
evidence. If anything, it is a myth, a sis is not a science—claims that are
just-so story about prehistory. More, it now widely accepted. But when Mr.
is a tendentious myth, one that fits too Crews adds that he was a liar and
neatly into Freud’s ideas about the link thief, or speculates that he practiced
between renunciation and civilization incest with his sister and adultery with
and rests on assumptions about his sister-in-law, the reader starts to
human psychology that are, to put it lose faith in his impartiality.
mildly, counterintuitive—above all, the The Freud wars have always been
belief that every human action and as much about Freud as an individual
motive can be traced back to sexuality. as about his ideas. Indeed, Freud
But if that same assumption lies at remains inseparable from his work in
the root of Freudian psychoanalysis, a way that already marks it as some-
does that mean that psychoanalysis, thing other than science. The law of
too, is a myth? Do Freudian concepts gravity doesn’t stand or fall on the Visit TryAudiobooks.com/WSJruns
like the superego and the id, the death character of Isaac Newton; if you
drive and the pleasure principle, the found evidence that Albert Einstein for a FREE audiobook download.
dream as a wish-fulfillment, rest on was a kleptomaniac, E=mc2 would still
any firmer evidentiary basis than hold true. But when critics of Freud
Freud’s idea about urinating on fire? denounce him as an incompetent doc-
Was Freud, in short, a doctor and a tor, a thief of other people’s ideas or
scientist, as he claimed to be and as an adulterer, they mean to strike at the
his patients and disciples believed, or credibility of Freudian ideas as well.
was he a storyteller, an imaginative Freud is more like a philosopher or a
thinker, or—if you prefer—a fantasist? prophet than a scientist; to accept his
This is the main issue at stake in premises involves submission to his
the continuing series of scholarly personal authority. He resembles Karl Also available in hardcover and eBook formats.
debates known as the Freud wars, Marx more than, say, Charles Darwin,
which have flared up again with the to name two figures who dominated
publication of Frederick Crews’s quasi- the intellectual world of his youth.
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
C8 | Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 * *** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
AUTUMN BOOKS
‘Anyone who has the power to make you believe absurdities has the power to make you commit injustices.’ —Voltaire
Murder by Numbers
which includes lynchings and execu- rampage—sending the reader across The authors “feel certain” that The in with a Mr. and Mrs. Coe of Center-
The Man From the Train tions of those wrongly accused of the the Midwest, the Pacific Northwest Man From the Train committed 14 of ville, Ohio, for instance, they write:
By Bill James & Rachel McCarthy James crimes, goes on for more than 450 and the South and even to eastern the crimes, which accounts for 59 mur- “We might say they coe-habited with
Scribner, 464 pages, $30 gory pages, which may be justified by Canada—in an attempt to determine ders. They are a further 70% certain them; it’s a very dark story, and we’re
historiological necessity. The two whether the guilty party was in fact that he committed seven additional desperate for relief.” When the Pfan-
BY PETER DUFFY writers have identified, they tell us, The Man From the Train, who is not crimes (30 murders), 40% certain that schmidt family is killed in rural
“perhaps the most despicable criminal given a name until the big reveal in he was responsible for eight crimes (27 Illinois, the authors write that “the
in American history.” Chapter 40. murders) and 10% certain that he com- Schmidt hit the Pfan.”
BILL JAMES STUMBLED upon the Mr. James is a data guy, a believer They theorize that he was a wood- mitted a final nine crimes (37 mur- Despite these occasional lapses in
idea for his latest book while studying in the explanatory power of raw cutter employed seasonally in logging ders). The Jameses make a plausible judgment, this is an impressive work,
a string of murders that occurred near numbers over gut instincts. Once a camps. He would find a home within case that they have identified the mass an open-eyed investigative inquiry
railroad lines in the Midwest in 1911 lonely voice howling in the mimeo- walking distance of a rail line, pick up murderer, a German immigrant who wrapped within a cultural history of
and 1912. The most famous was the graphed pages of his self-published rural America at the turn of the 20th
slaying of six members of the Moore “Bill James Baseball Abstract,” he is century. We learn about the shock-
family, along with two young house- now an honored member of the estab- ingly amateurish level of police work
guests, in Villisca, Iowa, which is still lishment, a senior adviser for baseball in the days when unlicensed private
remembered today in the Hawkeye operations with the Boston Red Sox. detectives, often charlatans, would
State. The eight victims were struck arrive in town and assume control of
repeatedly in the head with the blunt investigations. We are offered chilling
side of an ax. Has baseball’s statistics examples of how African-Americans in
Mr. James, the famously idiosyn- the South were lynched for the flimsi-
cratic interpreter of baseball statis- guru uncovered ‘the most est of reasons, e.g., that they were in
tics, had a hunch that the Midwest despicable criminal in the area where a crime was commit-
killings were part of a much larger ted. In Texas, “the murders were
pattern and suspected that there were American history’? immediately blamed not on ‘Negroes,’
others in the series “that the contem- but on ‘Mexicans,’ ” the Jameses write
porary authorities never linked to the of a 1908 case in Watauga.
GETTY IMAGES
same criminal.” He recruited his But he is also an obsessive student In its peculiar way, the book winds
daughter, Rachel McCarthy James, as of true crime. In 2011, he published up being a celebration of the forgotten
a research assistant to help him scour “Popular Crime: Reflections on the corners of America, a paean to the poor
the databases of small-town newspa- Celebration of Violence,” offering his folks who lived out by the railroad
pers. Soon she became his co-author. distinctive take on the most notorious an ax on or near the property, and may have returned home to commit tracks. “If you read about a crime in a
The result is a painstakingly factual cases in American history. Since this break in through a back window after one final atrocity. He was a short, stout small town, you will encounter fre-
account of dozens upon dozens of is Bill James, he came up with a midnight. He would attack the family laborer with greasy hair, described by quently the comment that these people
gruesome murders, the first commit- numerical system to determine the while they slept, always using the an acquaintance as “cranky.” lived in the kind of quiet place where
ted in 1898 in Brookfield, Mass., and guilt of the accused, with zero repre- blunt—never the sharp—edge of the It is not easy to read about these nothing very interesting ever hap-
the last in 1922 in Hinterkaifeck, senting innocence and 100 pointing to ax. He would then linger, moving the murders—among the dead is a day-old pened,” the authors write. “This is a de-
Germany. The victims all lived not far guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. dead bodies around and paying infant—and the authors sometimes spicable thing to say. It is a form of big-
from railroad tracks, which left them Bruno Richard Hauptmann, who was “special attention” to the corpses of stray from good taste. Despite insist- otry directed at the past, and bigotry
vulnerable to a peripatetic serial killer executed in the Lindbergh baby case, prepubescent females in a way that ing that they will not describe The directed at people who live in small
who would hop off the train, invade a broke the scale with a 213. Lizzie would cause authorities to describe Man From the Train with a “cutesy towns—and worse yet, it’s ignorant.”
home—often at random—and use an Borden, the most prominent of Ameri- him as a “moral pervert.” He would nickname”—“Billy the Ax Man,” for in-
ax to kill multiple members of the can ax murderers, earned a 20. leave the ax behind after washing it in stance—the Jameses can’t refrain Mr. Duffy is the author of “Double
same family. In the new book, the Jameses give a bucket of water. Sometimes he from their own occasional cutesiness. Agent” and “The Killing of Major
The relentless catalog of atrocities, tick-tock accounts of each homicidal would set the house on fire. Of a newly married couple who move Denis Mahon.”
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 | C9
AUTUMN BOOKS
‘The bourgeois stands, a hungry cur, / a question mark, a question begged, / behind him crouches the old world— / a mongrel, tail between its legs.’ —Alexander Blok
argues, did what they could to foment. 1917-1932’ (Royal Academy easily understood. Stalin, no Utopian,
Lenin calculated that a great sorting, a Publications, 320 pages, $65) is a took the latter side, to the delight of
“process of clarification,” as she terms beautifully illustrated account of art artists such as Evgeny Katsman:
it, would leave the Bolsheviks alone on that followed upon, but was ultimately After a meeting in 1933 to discuss
top. The war turned out to be more discarded by, the revolution. It closes this controversy with the Soviet
terrible than even Lenin envisaged, but with a 1932 exhibition commemorating VANGUARD El Lissitzky’s ‘Beat the Whites With the Red Wedge’ (1919). leader, Katsman rhapsodized in his
he was proved right in the end. the artists of the new order’s first 15 diary over Stalin’s ‘sweet face’—a
Lenin often was, but one interest- years, a swan song for an avant-garde While “Revolution” focuses on paint- the Test’ (Art Institute of Chicago, vision that only a Socialist Realist
ing aspect of Ms. Engelstein’s discus- rapidly being eclipsed by the inspiring ing, the lavishly produced ‘Revoliutsiia! 324 pages, $65) takes a broader could see.
sion of 1917 itself is the degree to banality of Socialist Realism. Demonstratsiia! Soviet Art Put to approach with regard to types of artistic —A.S.
which she depicts the Bolsheviks as
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
C10 | Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 * *** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
AUTUMN BOOKS
‘It is our utopias that make the world tolerable to us: the cities and mansions that people dream of are those in which they finally live.’ —Lewis Mumford
A Carolina Xanadu
bilt (who later married Sen. Peter
The Last Castle Goelet Gerry, the great-grandson of
By Denise Kiernan James Madison’s vice president) cut
Touchstone, 388 pages, $28 back on expenses, sold most of the
estate’s forests to the U.S. govern-
BY STUART FERGUSON ment, helped the locals by means of
charity and kept watch over Cornelia,
who was artistic and probably really
BILTMORE HOUSE is a stupendous didn’t much like being a Vanderbilt.
sight, its towers and parapets rising Ms. Kiernan makes it clear that Edith
above a river valley outside the town was a steadying influence during the
of Asheville, in the high altitudes of years of her daughter’s minority.
western North Carolina. Its 250 As for Cornelia, the “hillbilly heir-
rooms include a Louis XV suite deco- ess,” as the papers had it, she eventu-
rated with velvet and damask wall ally married the British diplomat
coverings and a library filled with John Francis Amherst Cecil, grandson
10,000 books. Just inside the build- of the Marquess of Exeter and a
ing’s front door is a cantilevered direct descendant of William Cecil,
staircase that spirals around a 1,700- Elizabeth I’s adviser. After two sons,
pound, triple-decker chandelier. In a the marriage soured—Cornelia Cecil
second-floor hall hang two Sargent was a free spirit—and the couple
portraits. The dining room is vast, divorced. She set up a charity so that
featuring a table that seats 64. The she could give anonymously to causes
loggia at the rear of the house, she believed in, such as research into
which itself opens off a tapestry gal- mental illness. It was while dining
lery, presents a breathtaking vista: out with Edward Adamson, an inno-
acres of lawn and forest, with moun- vator in the field of art therapy, that
tains in the distance and, nearby, Cornelia noticed their handsome
GETTY IMAGES
the age of 22 married a feckless Shaw, publicly boosted the fascist which was then brought straight to tion. Ms. Moorehead never makes the
composer-hopeful named Joe Rosselli. program well into the 1930s. She also police headquarters. Heedless to the point explicitly, and she doesn’t have
The marriage dissolved after a decade, debunks some of the more persistent last of their friends’ warnings, in June to. Descriptions of Mussolini’s “glaring
by which time Amelia had borne three canards that have clung to Il Duce’s 1937 the two brothers walked unsus- looks,” or characterizations of him as
sons—the eldest, Aldo, would die in legend, such as his supposed elimina- pecting into a roadside ambush. “strutting and boastful,” a rabble-
World War I—moved with them to tion of poverty and unemployment AGITATORS Nello and Carlo Rosselli. Another problem is in the narrative rousing orator intolerant of opposi-
Florence and embarked on a success- (he merely censored mention of itself. Ms. Moorehead has a novelistic tion, with an asinine pout and a pen-
ful career as a playwright. (Literature them) or of the Mafia (they started heroes,” in reference to the 19th- feel for setting and character, but she chant for alternative facts, have an all-
ran in the family: Amelia’s nephew operating in secret). As for the pro- century Italian nationalist—indepen- often stumbles on the biographer’s pit- too-familiar ring to them. Reading
Alberto Moravia later became a world- verbial trains running on time, it dent of the left but sharing its desire fall of not being able to separate the these pages, I couldn’t help wondering
renowned novelist.) Her relationship depended where you were heading: to bring Mussolini down. relevant detail from the factoid. what histories our descendants will
with her sons, documented in copious Many citizens were not allowed to Of the two, Carlo was by far the (Charles Kaiser’s 2015 “The Cost of write 80 years from now, and what
exchanges of letters, combined unfor- leave the country, and dissidents had more active. He gave speeches, Courage,” about a French family’s re- new wounds they will need to heal.
giving discipline and devotion that little freedom of movement at all. published broadsides and financed sistance to the Occupation, shows how
bordered on amorous passion. Carlo and Nello Rosselli were insurgent activities, such as dropping you can do much more in half the Mr. Polizzotti’s new book,
The public backdrop to this pri- among those dissidents as of the protest leaflets from airplanes. length.) There are also sloppy mis- “Sympathy for the Traitor: A
vate family drama was the chaotic mid-1920s, their conviction galvanized Arrested and sent to the penal island takes: Presenting Vienna in the 1890s, Translation Manifesto,” will be
aftermath of World War I and the by the fascists’ assassination in 1924 of of Lipari, off the Sicilian coast, he she mentions Emperor Franz Joseph published next spring.
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 | C11
AUTUMN BOOKS
‘A cheese may disappoint. It may be dull, it may be naive, it may be oversophisticated. Yet it remains cheese, milk’s leap toward immortality.’ —Clifton Fadiman
BY STEVEN JENKINS
AUTUMN BOOKS
‘Yesterday’s gone on down the river and you can’t get it back.’ —Larry McMurtry
disciplined himself to write five ing of myth and of hard work had reassures him: “If we stick to the
pages a day, a pace he has main- died away. There are no cowboys truth, in principle nothing can go
tained all his working life. His sec- here, except on the movie screen, wrong.” In the meantime, he instructs
ond novel, “Leaving Cheyenne,” no horses and no cattle, except one Veum to rack his alcohol-damaged
appeared in 1963. Three years later, blind heifer who is rudely abused memory for anyone who hates him
when “The Last Picture Show” was LONE STAR Paul Newman as Larry McMurtry’s selfish anti-hero Hud Bannon. by a gang of teenagers. But what is enough to destroy him.
published, he was teaching at Rice, here in abundance is Mr. Mc-
where I had the good fortune to be observing Mr. McMurtry’s gathering a cowhand who is Gideon’s best Murtry’s understanding of the
one of his students. He read the power as a novelist. friend; and Molly Taylor, the woman minds and feelings of his charac- An aging Norwegian
final pages of “Picture Show” to us “Horseman, Pass By” is narrated, they both love and who loves them. ters. He is seldom given credit for
in class shortly after he wrote them. lyrically, by Lonnie Bannon. He is To enjoy this novel it’s necessary to this, but I believe it is his greatest detective is framed by
That book too, thanks to Peter just out of school and living in a suspend disbelief: Can two men strength as a novelist. In his most digital evidence—but who
Bogdanovich and his wife at the ranch house with his grandfather remain friends for 50 years while powerful scenes—especially en-
time, Polly Platt, became an endur- Homer Bannon, his step-grand- continuing to love the same woman counters between Ruth Popper, the wants to destroy him?
ing movie. mother and her son, Hud, who is as she openly goes back and forth wife of the Thalia football coach,
These three novels are all set in several years older than Lonnie. A between them? It seems more likely and Sonny Crawford, the high
Thalia, the name Mr. McMurtry black cook and housekeeper, that each man would come to hate school student at the center of the There’s no shortage of suspects
gave to his fictionalized North Halmea, lives in a shack near the the other—and the woman, too. But novel—the intensity builds not so from the past few years, during which
Texas hometown of Archer City. house. Homer Bannon personifies checking skepticism brings an much through events as through grief over the death of a loved one
Each is now over 50 years old, and the nobility of the ranching tradi- immense reward, as “Leaving Mr. McMurtry’s preternaturally pre- and “insane drinking binges” hin-
Liveright has had the happy idea of tion. He’s a good man, but he fool- Cheyenne” is a subtle and affecting cise rendering of what each charac- dered Veum’s detective work. In flash-
collecting them in one hardcover ishly buys some infected cattle that novel. ter is experiencing. Thoughts and backs, he recalls some less-than-
volume called “Thalia: A Texas Tril- are mingled with his herd. When There are three parts. The first, feelings culminate in actions or stellar career performances, including
ogy.” It’s good to see them all the infection is discovered, he must set in the early 1920s, is narrated spoken words that then ripple out- his surveillance of a businessman’s
together, though I wish Liveright destroy the entire herd to prevent by Gideon, a young man working on ward, provoking new joys, fears, wife for infidelity. She ended up tell-
had taken more care with the texts. an epidemic. Hud, who is greedy his father’s small ranch. He and hesitancies, hopes, longings. When ing Veum it was her husband who
Annoying typos abound. and unprincipled, schemes to get Johnny are in a rivalry over Molly Sonny hurts Ruth by ignoring her, was being unfaithful. Soon after, she
These three early efforts are the ranch away from Homer, not the reader feels her hurt, for Mr. killed herself, an act that the husband
hardly a trilogy in the usual sense. because he wants to be a cowboy McMurtry has conveyed her accu- blamed on Veum. Then there was the
While set in the same place and but because he hopes to find oil on Larry McMurtry’s first mulating damaged feelings one at a nameless man who paid Veum to help
time, they do not interlock. In the land. Lonnie is a fine observer time, each more deeply than the deliver him from blackmailers, into
“Horseman” and “Picture Show,” of Hud’s and Homer’s characters, three novels are set in the last. whose decadent milieu the private
the principal characters attend the and of the look and feel of the same fictional Texas town, Mr. McMurtry returned to Thalia eye descended and there suffered
same tiny high school circa 1954. It prairie from the porch of his grand- 21 years later in “Texasville” (1987), bodily harm. His anonymous client
seems impossible they’ve never father’s ranch house. But he is also where the rancher’s way and again in “Duane’s Depressed” never contacted him again.
met. Thalia itself remains the same so passive that you want to shake of life is withering away. (1999), “When the Light Goes” Though hinting at possible ene-
locale across all three books—a him—especially when he can’t bring (2007) and “Rhino Ranch” (2009). mies out to do him harm, Veum’s
small, isolated, empty place where himself to intervene as he watches Of these, I much prefer “Duane’s memories will not be enough to save
the epic life of horsemen and cattle Hud rape Halmea. The movie did and yet are close enough for Gid to Depressed.” Duane Moore is Sonny him, he realizes. So when a dangerous
has mostly withered away. There right to shift the focus from Lonnie give Johnny an expensive saddle as Crawford’s great friend in “Picture chance for him to take control of his
were nine cattlemen in Mr. Mc- to Hud. Hud is still despicable, but a present. The second part, set Show.” Now he’s in his 60s and Mr. fate presents itself, he seizes it.
Murtry’s family, spread out across as portrayed by Newman he is more more than 20 years later, is Molly’s. McMurtry shows him facing his age Mr. Staalesen’s latest—ably trans-
North Texas and the Panhandle. He nuanced and interesting than the She has had a son by Gid and and the complications in his life lated by Don Bartlett—employs Chan-
was born in 1936, and so growing monster in the novel. another by Johnny, and both are with the psychological sureness dleresque similes with a Nordic twist:
up witnessed the last years of the “Leaving Cheyenne” is an artistic serving in World War II. Gid has that we can see developing, fasci- He “took out a tissue and started to
cowboy’s world. These novels are step forward. It gives us characters made an unfortunate marriage and natingly, across the 700 pages of clean his glasses as if that would help
three independent attempts to who live as cowboys, and the reader been forced by his wife to move off “Thalia.” him to see backwards in time.”
portray that world and what was feels more for them than for the the ranch and into town. He has “Wolves in the Dark” may yield a few
left in the wake of its passing. Each stiff symbol of rectitude that was shrewdly bought land that neigh- Mr. Curtis, a former editor of shocking coincidences too many to be
one is better than the last—consid- Homer Bannon. There are three bors his ranch, runs his ranches Texas Monthly magazine, is the entirely credible, but in this case the
erably better. Among the many narrators—Gideon Fry, the son of a well, and is becoming rich. Johnny author, most recently, of the non- journey seems more important than
pleasures in reading “Thalia” is longtime rancher; Johnny McCloud, is happy working as a cowboy for fiction work “The Cave Painters.” its destination.
A Provocateur in Exile
Picquart, an officer in military intelli- ment he went into exile in England. Dreyfus would discredit the army and visit, though never at the same time.
The Disappearance gence; his investigation exposed the It is this English exile that is the thereby weaken France. Nor does he He wrote to both women regularly, and
of Émile Zola real culprit, at great cost to himself. focus of Michael Rosen’s “The Disap- acknowledge that the publication of much of the second half of Mr. Rosen’s
By Michael Rosen The other hero was Émile Zola, the pearance of Émile Zola.” Mr. Rosen “J’Accuse” further polarized opinion. book consists of his letters to Jeanne
Pegasus, 302 pages, $27.95 great French novelist. is best-known as an English writer of One senator, August Scheurer- in particular. They show him to have
In May 1896, Zola had published an highly regarded novels for children Kestner, who had been working for a been a fond and fussy father, if not
BY ALLAN MASSIE article in Le Figaro condemning anti- and adolescents; he is also a poet and review of Dreyfus’s case, thought the always a wise one: He told Jeanne to
Semitism. Roughly 18 months article “a mistake . . . the time tell Jacques, who was only 7, that his
later, as the Dreyfus Affair intensi- [when] stupidities began.” parents would love him more if he
IN 1894, Capt. Alfred Dreyfus, an fied, he published an inflamma- This bias doesn’t diminish the worked harder at school.
officer in the French War Ministry’s tory article headlined “J’Accuse” interest of Mr. Rosen’s book, which, Eventually, Dreyfus returned from
bureau of statistics (a threadbare in the newspaper L’Aurore. It was given the bitter passions aroused Devil’s Island, and Zola was able to
cover for military intelligence), was addressed to the president of the by the Affair, is oddly charming. end his 11-month exile. The Affair
convicted of spying for Germany, republic, Félix Faure; it exposed Zola had already visited London wasn’t quite ended. Dreyfus was again
expelled from the army and impris- the real spy, charged the army once, in 1893, as a guest of the found guilty, in 1899, but “with exten-
oned on Devil’s Island, in French command with perversion of jus- Institute of Journalists, where “he uating circumstances,” an absurd
tice, named the senior officers was . . . greeted and saluted as an verdict, and Zola was displeased
responsible, and told Faure that international hero.” But now, five when Dreyfus accepted a pardon. Zola
After ‘J’Accuse,’ Zola the Dreyfus Affair would leave “an years later, he was a refugee, un- continued to divide his time between
indelible stain on your presi- able to speak English, arriving, as Alexandrine and Jeanne—he
was threatened with dency.” Zola conceded that he was he later wrote, “with my nightshirt addressed both of them as “wife.” He
imprisonment. He left leaving himself open to the charge in a newspaper,” and keeping a low died in 1902, at age 62, of carbon-
of libel, “a punishable offense.” profile. He stayed first in a London monoxide poisoning in his Paris
Paris for London instead. This was brave, and it was suburb and then for several months apartment. A chimney was blocked.
rash. Zola was a popular novelist, in the Queen’s Hotel near the Crys- The Dreyfus Affair and Zola’s part
BRIDGEMAN IMAGES
but many thought him a scandal- tal Palace south of the Thames. in it retain their fascination. Mr.
Guiana. Dreyfus was innocent, a ous and indecent one. Moreover, There was much to displease him: Rosen’s chronicle addresses them from
victim of anti-Semitism. The real spy his private life was not respect- The food especially was detestable, an interesting angle. The book reads
was another officer in the depart- able. He still lived with his wife, for the English, he thought, didn’t easily and enjoyably and pays proper
ment, but it became imperative for Alexandrine, but his mistress, know how to cook either meat or tribute to Zola’s pertinacity and
the Army Command and for leading Jeanne (formerly his wife’s maid), ‘I ACCUSE!’ Last known portrait of Zola, 1902. vegetables. Still, he amused himself decency. One might add a grisly foot-
figures in French politics and society lived nearby, with their two bicycling and taking photographs. note. Late in Hitler’s war, Mr. Rosen’s
to insist that Dreyfus, an Alsatian children, Denis and Jacques. Now he journalist—and a Francophile. His Apart from his anxiety about the great-uncle, he tells us, was on the
Jew, was the guilty man. had challenged the state, and with coverage of the Dreyfus Affair itself is progress of the Dreyfus Affair and the same train to Auschwitz as Dreyfus’s
There were two heroes among some reluctance the state responded. conscientious but scarcely impartial. uncertainty of when it would be safe granddaughter.
those who insisted on Dreyfus’s inno- He was charged with libel and There is no recognition of the to return to France, Zola worried
cence, apart from the stoical captain sentenced to a fine and a year’s earnestness of the anti-Dreyfusards, about his family. Alexandrine and Mr. Massie’s most recent book is
himself. The first was Col. Georges imprisonment. To escape this punish- who believed that the defenders of Jeanne, with the children, were able to the novel “End Games in Bordeaux.”
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 | C13
AUTUMN BOOKS
‘Errors, like straws, upon the surface flow; / He who would search for pearls, must dive below.’ —John Dryden
group includes Jonathan Lethem, Ann Egan, with her attraction to the unfath-
Patchett and the endlessly surprising omable, finds her groove when her
Percival Everett. But the most cele- story takes to the sea. Eddie’s ship is
brated is Jennifer Egan, who contin- torpedoed by a U-boat and the sus-
ues a string of wildly various and tended as an addendum to that book is triad of main characters consists of brick sent an ominous ripple through penseful pages dramatizing his trials
imaginative books with “Manhattan the 2012 short story “Black Box,” a Eddie Kerrigan, a bagman for a penny- her belly. There was dynamism in this on the open ocean are almost worth
Beach” (Scribner, 438 pages, $28), a futuristic spy thriller first published as ante racketeer; his charismatic daugh- new foreboding, a stinging vitality, as the book’s price tag on their own.
young woman’s coming-of-age tale a thread of tweets. ter Anna; and Dexter Styles, a dapper if she’d wakened from drugged sleep.” Having finally proven her worth to
joined with a New York gangster noir It’s not that these books don’t have nightclub owner and a big cheese in a Anna seeks out the underworld in two her chauvinistic diving instructors,
and joined again with a World War II ideas in them. “A Visit From the Goon major crime syndicate. In a prologue ways—first by becoming the lone Anna comes into her own when she
nautical adventure. Squad,” which explores the damage set during the Depression, Eddie takes female diver in a civilian crew trained begins to spend much of her days un-
Ms. Egan is no stranger to the wrought by time and aging, is the easi- a job as one of Dexter’s underlings. But to repair damaged ships. And second, der water. In one fine scene she’s
unorthodox mash-up. “Look at Me” est to boil down to a thesis statement, when the book telescopes ahead to after meeting him at a nightclub, by tasked with inspecting the jammed
(2001), centering on a fashion model which may be why it was her biggest 1942 Eddie has vanished, leaving Anna giving Dexter Styles a false name and propellers of the battleship USS South
whose face is reconstructed after a car success, winning the Pulitzer Prize. to provide for her mother and disabled having an affair with him. Dakota. As she submerges she runs her
crash, begins as a satire of the preda- But mostly Ms. Egan deals less in sister by working as a welder at The plot moves along gradually in- hand along its hull. “The ship felt alert,
tory modeling industry but veers into banner-headline themes than occult Brooklyn’s Naval Yard. tersecting lines. As Anna is drawn into alive. It exuded a hum that traveled
an eerie fantasia about domestic affinities. She has a fascination with Most people think of Anna as a re- Dexter’s “shadow world,” Dexter has through her fingers up her arm: the vi-
terrorism. “The Keep” (2006) is a disappearances and doublings, with sponsible daughter, yet she secretly an attack of conscience and tries to bration of thousands of souls teeming
novel-within-a-novel set in a partially hidden identities and what a character longs for the danger and excitement turn his crime organization into a legal within. Like a skyscraper turned on its
restored medieval castle that owes as in “Look at Me” calls “the relationship she glimpses in Ellery Queen detective enterprise, crossing some powerful side.” These are the moments that Ms.
much to Dungeons & Dragons as to between interior and exterior”—sub- novels. “Now her own life seemed to people in the process. Then Eddie re- Egan produces at her best, when she
Gothic mysteries. “A Visit From the jects so evanescent that they raise have tipped into the world of those appears, as if from the ether. He’s now captures the wonder and strangeness
Goon Squad” (2010) is a linked story more questions than they answer. mysteries,” Ms. Egan writes, laying on a third mate in the Merchant Marines of existence without demystifying it.
collection that tracks the diverging Such questions arise again in “Man- the cinematic flair. “The long Novem- whose voyages take him into the thick The thrill of her novels is in the dive to
fortunes of a music impresario and his hattan Beach,” though the novel starts ber shadows leaned suggestively, and of the sea war. places unknown, not in anything she
friends and hangers-on. Possibly in- as a standard-issue crime story. Its the sheen of streetlight on Naval Yard These are a lot of stories to set in brings back to the surface.
sons are learned. Homer’s Odysseus, his students and their words, it hardly of timing. He knows when to drive a all must confront the past to under- collective paths.
the “man of many turns,” takes 10 matters. He seems like the professor narrative forward and when to hold stand the present, and to get to the
years to come home to Ithaca from the every college kid dreams about: back. Digressions are not digressions. future. Mr. Spiegelman’s books include the
Trojan War. With his gallant band of learned, sympathetic, encouraging and Jay Mendelsohn makes for a sur- The teacher wonders how his regu- essay collections “Seven Pleasures”
students, Mr. Mendelsohn makes his challenging in equal measure. prising hero. He, not his son the pro- lar students are responding to the and “Senior Moments.”
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
C14 | Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 * *** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
AUTUMN BOOKS
‘The present is the future of the past.’ —John Updike
sion, with Mars and Earth once think that two can play at that game? bitter cold, and longing hopelessly
again in perihelic opposition. World Most of all, though, the novel is a after a young woman who calls in.
War I has taken place, but with Brit- shootout between the heat-rays and The shop is a pharmacy, the
ain still recovering from the Mar- the fighting machines on the Martian STATE OF THE ART A Victorian-era water-pumping station in London. cough is fatal tuberculosis, the
tians and unable to join in, Kaiser side, and the 1920s-plus technology young woman’s name is Fanny
Wilhelm has won. France is occu- of Earth—Edisonian flux-bombs and short stories published in magazines quired age-limit. The same author Brand, and what the dying man
pied, and Britain has become a mili- the Kaiser’s Gotha bombers. Mr. Bax- like the Strand and Atlantic Monthly, provides a back-in-time story, and keeps coming out with, under the
tarized state. ter develops brilliantly the possibili- by authors now forgotten, or known Grant Allen’s “Thames Valley Catas- influence of the drug he’s been
War has moreover accelerated ties open to both sides. It’s alien in- only to a few specialist researchers. trophe” (1897) starts off the disaster given, are fragments of Keats’s erotic
technological development, as it did vasion juiced up by alternate history, One thing the collection shows genre with a tale of “fissure erup- poem “The Eve of St. Agnes.” Some-
in real life, so that this time Earth with real people as well, as com- clearly is that there was no shortage tion,” based on discoveries in Ameri- how, he’s “tuned” to Keats, dead of
has Zeppelins and airplanes to fight plexly unpredictable as Bert Cook, as of sci-fi ideas back in the earlier 19th can geology. TB 80 years before. Spooky? No
with, and “landships,” or tanks feistily daring as Julie Elphinstone. century. Some of them turned out to Ideas, though, are not enough. It’s spookier than those voices coming
(which Wells predicted in 1903). Nor is it just Earth and Mars. be nonstarters in fiction and reality an old sci-fi adage that anyone could out of the void, carried by “Hertzian
Martian technology has been scav- There are other planets in the solar both. We soon discovered that no im- think up the automobile, but to make waves.” What else might we be able
enged as well, for nuclear power- system, and the Martians’ problem proved telescopes would detect “Man- a story you have to foresee gridlocks to “tune in” to?
sources, aluminum smelters and of global cooling remains, for them, Bats on the Moon,” as Richard Adams as well. The idea has to be taken to We are much harder to shock
heat-ray-resistant hull-metal. even after their defeat. From sci-fi’s Locke proposed in a hoax published a second or third stage, and this is these days. But it was the shock
But the Martians have also up- Valhalla, the shade of Wells must be by the New York Sun in 1835. Nor are what is usually missing here. Several effect of thoughts like Kipling’s that
rated their efforts, coming this time applauding. Perhaps with just a there giant jellyfish up in the strato- of Mr. Sims’s examples read like created the audience for sci-fi. And
immunized against bacteria, in thou- touch of envy: Now, why didn’t I sphere, creating the “Horror of the reports, not stories, and once the what with wormholes and quantum
sands instead of tens, and aiming at think of that . . . ? Heights” described by Arthur Conan “Gosh, wow” effect has gone, there’s physics, the universe has gotten only
all major population centers, most of The 1890s may have been the time Doyle some 50 years later. little else. Mary E. Wilkins Freeman’s a great deal spookier.
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 | C15
AUTUMN BOOKS
‘Never marry a man you wouldn’t want to be divorced from.’ —Nora Ephron
Twentieth-Century Woman
I’ll Have What She’s Having
By Erin Carlson
Hachette, 341 pages, $27
BY JEANINE BASINGER
hero, and in this beguiling tale of How this destruction will happen boxes at the top have names such as
destiny fulfilled our champion is is a little hazy—Miss Carbunkle is “Free Toy” and “Sugar Frosted
Arthur, a gentle, foxlike 11-year-old— trying to raise capital in order to Sugar” and glow with color, whereas
with his fellow inmates, he is a distribute the beetles free, at first, the boxes near our dejected friend
hybrid creature, or “groundling”— to generate demand—but the threat are gray and dreary (“Sad Clown”
who has one ear, no childhood mem- is sufficiently awful that Arthur himself dust baths, eats insects At first, Nia includes Alfie in her and “Bland”). Humpty yearns to make
ories, and a deep yearning for beauty resolves to return and thwart her (“yuck!”) and, after many false starts, games, makes him gifts and tells him his way to the top of his wall again:
and music. When his tiny friend designs. Small sepia-colored illustra- manages to ensconce himself in a jokes that he doesn’t seem to get. “I really missed the birds and being
Trinket devises a scheme for their tions throughout add elegance to hen’s nest. It is there, in the cozy “After a while, I kind of forgot about high above the city. But I could never
escape from the orphanage, Arthur this dramatic adventure for children warmth, that something happens—or Alfie,” she confesses. “He didn’t do do it . . . because I knew that
embarks on a quest through a wild ages 8-13. perhaps we should say someone much.” Then, on the morning of her accidents can happen.” Mr. Santat
wood and into the stygian corridors Like Arthur the Wonderling, born happens—to give Trio a fluffy seventh birthday, Nia discovers that gives full weight to the power of fear,
of a subterranean city to solve the with just one ear, the feline lead of companion with a conspicuous differ- Alfie’s tank is empty. Two bleak, which can daunt anyone who has
mystery of his origins. Andrea Wisnewski’s picture book ence of her own in this amiable tale colorless pages convey the child’s woe been injured, before showing Humpty
Arthur knows only that he was “Trio” (Godine, 40 pages, $17.95) for 2- to 6-year-olds. and emptiness. Dumpty’s eventual triumph with an
born on a street called Tintagel, has come into the world with a con- The character of Trio is based on a But in truth this is Alfie’s story, inventive ending that is nothing short
which shares its name with the spicuous difference from his litter real animal. So is the doughty hero of and in the pictures that follow we of exhilarating.
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
C16 | Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 * *** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
AUTUMN BOOKS
‘No adultery is bloodless.’ —Natalia Ginzburg
1
just because I’m a Cardinals fan. After ground, you’ll have a fine time letting THE IDEA FOR this novel came by the death of Florence, the Ameri-
all, Red Sox Nation—the last baseball Mr. Cohen drive you through well- to Evelyn Waugh after a trip in can wife. It’s left to the surviving
fanbase to have waited nearly 100 known territory. the wilds of British Guiana, and characters—Dowell, the widower,
years between championships—swiftly When he at last drifts toward the eventually, as he describes it, it led and the other couple, Leonora and
became absurdly arrogant and de- modern day and the Cubs’ resurgence him to “a study of other sorts of Edward—to make sense of the
manding, waving World Series pen- under Mr. Epstein, the author hits the savages at home and the civilized endlessly complicated past. Dowell
nants in everyone else’s faces. Let’s be key point: The Cubs weren’t bad for all man’s helpless plight among them.” reluctantly confronts the fact that
honest: Winning a World Series turned those years because they were cursed The civilized man in “A Handful of his wife had been having an affair
Red Sox fans into Yankee fans. or doomed. The Cubs were bad be- Dust” is Tony Last, an English coun- with Edward for nine years. Adul-
That didn’t happen to Cubs fans cause so many owners had the same try gentleman who, above all, loves tery is tricky to maintain secretly for MS. MUHLSTEIN is the author of ‘The
after the team went all the way in his Gothic house, Sunday sermons, so long. Who was complicit? Who Pen and the Brush: How Passion for Art
2016. They’ve been . . . pretty appre- and fox hunting. His wife, Brenda, rebuffed whom? Is Edward “a raging Shaped 19th-Century French Novels.’
ciative of the whole thing. Within min- Win or lose, the Cubs had on the other hand, has in her bore- stallion”? Is Dowell “no better than
utes of their Game 7 victory in Cleve- dom taken a lover. Buoyed by her a eunuch”? The tangled themes of Mme de Rênal, a provincial aristo-
land last year, Cubs fans began writing always been beloved. friends and the pleasure of discuss- sex, money and honor deepen the crat, and the teenage tutor of her
names on the stadium wall at Wave- And this became the main ing the subject over the phone, she confusion. “I don’t know. . . . It is all children, Julien Sorel, the son of a
land Ave: names of loved ones who finally asks for a divorce, and her a darkness,” Dowell admits. In turn, brutal peasant. The seduction is a
died before they got to see their reason they never won. helpless husband agrees. But when Edward, incapable of surmounting dare that Julien sets for himself—
beloved Cubbies win it all. That my- Brenda proves greedy, Tony decides what Ford calls the “abominable in- such an unimaginable endeavor
god-it-finally-happened attitude hasn’t to divorce her without settlement of terests of sex,” decides to put an end that to succeed would be proof of
changed much since. The Cubs had a attitude as Phil Wrigley, the owner any kind, and goes off to Brazil. to his life. His parting words to his heroic nature. Mme de Rênal,
somewhat disappointing 2017 regular from 1932 to 1977: Don’t worry about She’s then swiftly abandoned by her Dowell are: “So long, old man, I used to the indifferent ways of her
season, but the wailing you’d have trying too hard to field a good team, lover, reluctant to marry a woman must have a bit of rest, you know.” husband, discovers pleasure in the
heard if the 2016 series turned out dif- because as long as that stadium is gor- who is “not provided for” and also arms of the inexperienced youth.
ferently hasn’t been there. After 108 geous and that ivy is growing on the by her friends. “It might occur [to Immediately, guilt follows. “Sud-
years, Cubs fans finally made it to the walls, fans will flock to Wrigley Field. them] to sock a girl a meal once in a The Golden Bowl denly, a word frightened her:
mountaintop, and they’ve been happy The Cubs’ charm became part of what way,” she thinks wistfully. She does By Henry James (1904) adulteress. . . . She had tasted, that
to stay up there, enjoying the view. was holding them back: The comfort of bounce back and marries Tony’s evening, a brand-new happiness;
3
Rich Cohen’s affable “The Chicago knowing they would be a part of your best friend, while he ends up AMERIGO, A CHARMING now she found herself plunged, all
Cubs: Story of a Curse” helps explain life win or lose was the primary reason trapped by a madman in the jungle. Roman prince of slender of a sudden, into atrocious
why Cubs fans are different from Red the Cubs never won. “Hard cheese on Tony,” conclude his means, and his former lover misery.” The young man leaves
Sox fans. Cubs fans went Mr. Epstein, who broke pals. For Waugh, civil society is Charlotte, an impoverished young and embarks on a brilliant career
through the pain every through with the Red doomed in this glittering world soon American woman, each attempt to that will be cut short through the
year just like Red Sox, brought an East to be shattered by war. solve their financial plights by get- actions of Mme de Rênal’s confes-
Sox fans did—and Coast impatience ting married. Amerigo marries sor. It isn’t a jealous husband who
for a lot longer, to Chicago and Charlotte’s friend Maggie, while provokes the drama but the
actually—but changed the The Good Soldier Charlotte marries Maggie’s wealthy church. Julien’s wild ambition, his
the pain team’s trajec- By Ford Madox Ford (1915) father. Prudently Amerigo and political leanings, threaten the
wasn’t the tory with the Charlotte keep their past affair order of post-Napoleonic society.
2
constant simplest THE REMARKABLE interplay secret—but can’t resist resuming it His amazing worldly success has
irritant it plan of all: between the characters here is after their respective weddings. to be curtailed, and it will be, in
was for Red Have a plan so subtle that every reading of Maggie, however, realizes the the most harrowing way.
Sox fans, to win. By the novel uncovers a new layer of truth—that “they went about
partly because the time Mr. understanding. What happened? together . . . and I don’t mean only
the Cubs never Cohen gets to Will we ever know? Two wealthy before—I mean after.” The tale has Like Death
got particularly Game 7, we have the feel of a devilish chess game. By Guy de Maupassant (1889)
close to winning a become his faith- Maggie lets her husband know he is
5
series. For Cubs fans, ful, loyal and easy discovered but leaves her father and IN THIS short novel, Any de
losing was a divine provi- companions. That game Charlotte in the dark. To protect her Guilleroy, the wife of a politi-
dence that everyone accepted, needs little embellishment, but marriage, she arranges for them to cian, asks Olivier Bertin to
a sign that even if life has suffering, Mr. Cohen makes us feel its drama go back to the States while she do her portrait. The inevitable
that doesn’t mean it’s not worth living. nonetheless. His happiness ends up remains in London, sacrificing the happens during her sittings and
Mr. Cohen documents Cubs fans being our happiness. intense relation she has with her leads to a long attachment. Very
clinging to talismans—the book opens I’m not sure we really needed an- father. The question remains: Who soon, Olivier is considered a
with Cubs president Theo Epstein, other book about the Cubs’ champion- is managing whom? “Maggie,” member of the family, loved by the
before an playoff game, encouraging ship—several authors beat Mr. Cohen James writes, “had so shuffled away wife, appreciated by the busy
Mr. Cohen to grasp a Cubs hat for to the punch—but this book is a pleas- every link between consequence and husband and adopted by their
luck—and joking about the curse ant reminder of what made last Octo- cause, that the intention remained, daughter. There’s the rub. Olivier
placed on the team by a disgruntled ber so exciting even for those who’ve like some famous poetic line in a falls in love with the girl. Her
goat owner. We hear laments about never set foot in Wrigley’s Friendly dead language, subject to varieties mother realizes it before anyone
near-misses—the Bartmans and the Confines. You can give it to the Cubs of interpretation.” else, and she doesn’t conceal her
Leon Durhams—but rarely detect any fans in your life, though they may still heartbreak. “It shouldn’t end like
anger. Mr. Cohen lays it all out in a be grinning and dancing around too this,” she tells Olivier. But Olivier,
The Red and the Black
BRIDGEMAN IMAGES
breezy, just-sort-of-cruising-by insta- much to find time to read it. aware that his love for the girl is
history of the franchise, starting with By Stendhal (1830) hopeless, hurls himself in front of
its previous championship in 1908. Mr. Leitch is a senior writer for a carriage. As he lies dying, Any
GETTY IMAGES
4
Much of this is familiar, stories of Sports On Earth, a contributing THIS IS THE STORY of an rushes to his side. For a last
Three Finger Brown and Grover Cleve- editor at New York magazine and improbable adultery commit- moment, they feel the force of old
land Alexander and the poor, doomed the founder of Deadspin. BEDFELLOWS From a 1480 book. ted by the very respectable passion restored.
Nonfiction E-Books Nonfiction Combined Fiction E-Books Fiction Combined Hardcover Business
TITLE THIS LAST TITLE THIS LAST TITLE THIS LAST TITLE THIS LAST TITLE THIS LAST
AUTHOR / PUBLISHER WEEK WEEK AUTHOR / PUBLISHER WEEK WEEK AUTHOR / PUBLISHER WEEK WEEK AUTHOR / PUBLISHER WEEK WEEK AUTHOR / PUBLISHER WEEK WEEK
Killing England 1 New What Happened 1 1 The Cuban Affair: A Novel 1 New The Cuban Affair: A Novel 1 New Principles: Life and Work 1 New
Bill O’Reilly & Martin Dugard/Henry Holt & Company, Inc. Hillary Rodham Clinton/Simon & Schuster Nelson DeMille/Simon & Schuster Nelson DeMille/Simon & Schuster Ray Dalio/Simon & Schuster
What Happened 2 1 Killing England 2 New Haunted 2 New Haunted 2 New Strengths Finder 2.0 2 2
Hillary Rodham Clinton/Simon & Schuster Bill O’Reilly & Martin Dugard/Henry Holt & Company J. Patterson & J. O. Born/Little, Brown and Company J. Patterson & J. O. Born/Little, Brown and Company Tom Rath/Gallup Press
Principles: Life and Work 3 New The TB12 Method 3 New Gone Tomorrow 3 New It 3 2 Fantasyland 3 3
Ray Dalio/Simon & Schuster Tom Brady/Simon & Schuster Lee Child/Random House Publishing Group Stephen King/Scribner Book Company Kurt Andersen/Random House
Unbelievable: My Front-Row Seat 4 2 Principles: Life and Work 4 New It 4 4 To Be Where You Are 4 New Finish: Give Yourself the Gift of Done 4 1
Katy Tur/HarperCollins Publishers Ray Dalio/Simon & Schuster Stephen King/Simon & Schuster Jan Karon/G.P. Putnam’s Sons Jon Acuff/Portfolio
Elon Musk 5 – Braving the Wilderness 5 2 A Column of Fire 5 1 A Column of Fire 5 1 Side Hustle 5 New
Ashlee Vance/Ecco Brené Brown/Random House Ken Follett/Penguin Publishing Group Ken Follett/Viking Chris Guillebeau/Crown Business
The TB12 Method 6 New The Paradigm 6 New Before We Were Yours 6 7 TheGirlWhoTakesanEyefor anEye 6 3 Emotional Intelligence 2.0 6 5
Tom Brady/Simon & Schuster Jonathan Cahn/Frontline Lisa Wingate/Random House Publishing Group David Lagercrantz/Knopf Publishing Group Travis Bradberry & Jean Greaves/TalentSmart
The Paradigm 7 New Unbelievable: My Front-Row Seat 7 3 To Be Where You Are 7 New A Legacy of Spies 7 10 The Five Dysfunctions of a Team 7 4
Jonathan Cahn/Frontline Katy Tur/Dey Street Books Jan Karon/Penguin Publishing Group John le Carré/Viking Patrick M. Lencioni/Jossey-Bass
Read My Pins 8 – Adultolescence 8 New Dear Bridget, I Want You 8 New Enemy of the State 8 6 Total Money Makeover 8 8
Madeleine Albright/HarperCollins Publishers Gabbie Hanna/Atria Books Penelope Ward &Vi Keeland /Penelope Ward Vince Flynn & Kyle Mills /Atria Books Dave Ramsey/Thomas Nelson
7 Lessons from Heaven 9 New 7 Lessons from Heaven 9 New TheGirlWhoTakesanEyeforanEye 9 3 Wonder 9 – Together Is Better 9 6
Mary C. Neal/The Crown Publishing Group Mary C. Neal/Convergent Books David Lagercrantz/Knopf Doubleday Publishing Group R. J. Palacio/Alfred A. Knopf Books For Young Readers Simon Sinek/Portfolio
Real Food/Fake Food 10 — The Autobiography of Gucci Mane 10 New Fool Me Once 10 New Dog Man: A Tale of Two Kitties 10 – Extreme Ownership 10 7
Larry Olmsted/Algonquin Books of Chapel Hill Gucci Mane with Neil Martinez-Belkin/Simon & Schuster Catherine Bybee/Montlake Romance Dav Pilkey/Scholastic Books Jocko Willink & Leif Babin/St. Martin’s Press
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 | C17
REVIEW
‘I think I kind
of became
fear-tolerant.’
Laird Hamilton
founder of the company that be-
At 53, the extreme surfer came Bally Total Fitness—wanted
to play golf with him and agreed
is still making waves to let Mr. Hamilton ride his elec-
tric scooter as they played. Mr.
LAIRD HAMILTON can’t escape his can talk in peace. Just as he’s It looks like a glamorous life: him up and picked on him, espe- Hamilton found it to be so much
fans. It’s a warm summer day on shutting the door, a woman spots The movie shows him tanned and cially because he was one of the fun that he started working on
Long Island in New York, and he him and shouts, “Laird!” He waves. buff, riding massive waves and do- few white children at his school. creating one that he could sell.
has just finished conducting an Mr. Hamilton, 53, made his ing underwater workouts, and fea- Mr. Hamilton acted up at school, He still spends about five hours
awards ceremony for a stand-up name as an extreme surfer, often tures interviews with his equally at times throwing chairs out the a day in the water and likes to ex-
paddleboard race with his wife, taking on waves more than 80 feet tall and buff wife. window and writing obscenities on periment with new water sports,
the professional volleyball player high. He was one of the pioneers The film also goes into his diffi- the chalkboard (and then eating the such as bodysurfing underwater,
Gabrielle Reece. The 6-foot-2 of tow-in surfing, in which surfers cult childhood. The son of a single bar of soap his teacher told him to like a dolphin. He says people ask
surfer, with a mop of bright blond are pulled on a rope by jet ski or mother, Mr. Hamilton spent a lot of wash his mouth out with). him whether he has a “fear de-
hair, is hard to miss. As he tries to helicopter into the path of a huge time alone at the beach as a child But he loved surfing. Ms. Reece fect.” “I’ve been scared so much,
make his way out of the tent, peo- wave that they couldn’t otherwise in Hawaii. (His mother later mar- says that Mr. Hamilton has told her, so often at such a young age that I
ple keep stopping him to ask if reach. Now he is the subject of a ried famed surfboard maker Bill “Going to sleep and dreaming, I’d think I kind of became fear-toler-
they can take a picture with him. documentary, “Take Every Wave,” Hamilton, whom Laird had met on always wished I would wake up ant,” he says. Eventually, he adds,
He gets into the back seat of a released Sept. 29 in theaters and the beach and brought home.) He brown,” so that he could be like the getting scared “made me feel re-
friend’s unlocked Jeep so that we on demand. says that other children often beat Hawaiians who created surfing. ally alive.”
have grabbed billions of views on ing; I see fun times on the way. Classics publishers have ing Beauty” turns out to be a mis-
YouTube. The obvious question: Is She’s gone, but who cares, she equally high hopes for a cheerier understood sweetheart.
there any reason his approach was a man-eater anyway. True, you version of Homer, featuring a Tro- Actually, I think somebody al-
should be limited to sprucing up ain’t nothin’ but a hound dog, but jan Horse filled with lollipops and ready tried that.
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
C18 | Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 * *** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
REVIEW
EXHIBIT
SKY HIGH
In his latest book, “Escape” (Abrams,
$45), photographer Gray Malin turned his
lens to places that “relax the mind and
help us unwind,” from parks to ski slopes
to beaches. Over the course of a few
years, he shot 22 destinations in 11 coun-
tries, often taking a birds-eye view while
hanging out of a helicopter door. The pro-
cess wasn’t exactly a vacation. “It’s sweat,
tears, a lot of jet lag and a lot of agony,”
he says. “But we all could use a little bit
of an escape.” —Alexandra Wolfe
KENSINGTON PALACE GARDENS, LONDON. Mr. Malin found oases even in big cities. ‘These shared spaces can transform even the busiest of cities into calm and tranquil places of escape,’ he writes.
THE REEF, BORA BORA. Mr. Malin writes that he likes photographing islands because PALM TREE BEACH, KAUAI. ‘The lush green grass, white sand and crystal blue water is
‘that physical break from a larger body of land provides an added mental break.’ a perfect combination for a great photograph, or a day at the beach,’ says Mr. Malin.
© 2017 GRAY MALIN
lad was musically pleas- dilemma the odds that your next beer What is the most effective pickup line?—Janet
ant. It was still new then, for Dan? will be spectacular are very
before the song became low—and then be ready to en- A good pickup line should show some interest but
associated with an actor
Email joy it if that first quaff sur- not too much, and it should put the burden of proof
in a cat costume: “I AskAriely passes your less-than-great ex- on the other person. I’d suggest trying, “You don’t
must wait for the sun- ELAINE PAIGE in 'Cats,' 1981. @wsj.com. pectations. seem like my style, but you intrigue me.”
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 | C19
PLAY
NEWS QUIZ: Daniel Akst From this week’s
Wall Street Journal VARSITY MATH Provided by the
National
1. Former judge Roy Moore D. An anonymous Saudi Museum of
won the Republican nomina- messaging app, embraced by Geometry puzzles are always a hit Mathematics
tion for a U.S. Senate seat U.S. teens with the math team, so the coach poses
from Alabama over a rival these triangular teasers.
backed by President Donald
Trump. Who was that? 5. Next year, Michelle Gass
will become the new CEO of
A. Luther Strange which major retailer?
B. Richard Baffling
C. Wendell Oddy A. Brooks Brothers
D. Gwendolyn Eerie B. Kohl’s Ten From Two
C. Wanamaker’s The coach shows the
D. Macy’s figure at right
2. Chester A. Arthur, the to the team,
subject of a new which demonstrates
biography, 6. Sonic, the fast-food chain,
how to draw a
became announced some bad news for
president customers. What was it?
straight line through a
after his pentagram to form seven
prede- A. The chain is going non-overlapping triangles,
cessor’s vegan. as indicated by the dots.
assassi- B. The bacon quintuple The team’s challenge:
nation. cheeseburger was banned by Draw two straight lines
Who was the FDA. through a pentagram to
killed? C. Hackers stole credit-card produce 10 non-
data. overlapping triangles.
A. William McKinley D. Prices are going up.
B. James Garfield ILLUSTRATION BY LUCI GUTIÉRREZ
C. John Garfield
D. Benjamin Harrison 7. Which anti-immigration
party took 13% of the German Triangular Boundary
vote, enough to gain a place in The coach then shows the team
3. The SEC is investigating Parliament? the diagram at right and asks:
whether PepsiCo fired former
What is the maximum area of a
general counsel Maura Smith A. Alternative for Germany
B. Germany First
rectangle contained entirely within a
for her handling of an internal
probe into potential C. Homeland for Germans triangle with sides of 9, 10 and 17?
wrongdoing at a Russian firm D. Pirate Party Germany
it acquired. What’s it called?
+ Learn more about the National Museum of Mathematics (MoMath) at momath.org
C L A P O S E T E A R I N T O C C S
for older women who hope to H O H U M A T M S P I E S O S O O N For previous
A. Authorship; B. Union Pacific; C. Shel Silverstein; A C E A E R I E P E P S I K E N Y A
conceive D. “Twelfth Night”; E. Euripides; F. Neck of the R OMA N T I C D A T E S R I S E F O R weeks’ puzzles,
C. A face cream made from woods; G. No-hoper; H. Off-white; I. Run into;
C
B E A T
H O
O N
O I
A C
V
A
S S
D E M I
O N
C G
S
R A
I
D
T
E
E
S
and to discuss
Sahara desert palm extract A L T R U I S T A U X R OW E strategies with
J. Tinsmith; K. “Heaven Can Wait”; L. Arsenal; G E N E R A L O R D E R S D A V I N C I other solvers, go to
E N O S N I N E H O L E S T E N C I L
M. Nevil Shute; N. Get out of Dodge; O. “Eight Days L A S S S T E M L E S S L E D G E R S WSJ.com/puzzle.
To see answers, please a Week”; P. Rodomontade; Q. Antithesis; R. Bellows;
turn to page C4. S. Bethlehem; T. Earthier; U. “You Go to My Head”
English Channel neighbor 6 Persian weapon 45 Trade show 114 Is for two Saturday’s Wall Street Journal. Solve crosswords and acrostics
47 Vicious on 93 Course 7 Colonial rule until presentations people?
online, get pointers on solving cryptic puzzles and discuss all of the
stage requirement 1947 49 Sunday deliveries 116 Shtick bit puzzles online at WSJ.com/Puzzles.
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
C20 | Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 * *** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
REVIEW
MASTERPIECE: ‘RÉPONS’ (‘RESPONSE’)
(1981), BY PIERRE BOULEZ
COMPOSING
ORGANIZED
DELIRIUM
BY STUART ISACOFF
the title suggests, the piece is based on the idea of call and
response, though the organizing principles are intricate; and
their set formulations are complicated further as the sounds
are digitally manipulated in real time. Some of the perceived
“responses” occur between the acoustic tones and their elec-
tronic reflections.
The Ensemble Intercontemporain, a group founded by Mr.
Boulez and now conducted by composer Matthias Pintscher,
will be performing the work in what
BREAKING DOWN A MYTH: Wang Guangyi’s ‘Mao Zedong: Red Grid No. 2,’ 1988 Mr. Pintscher describes as the ideal Using
venue for it. The Armory’s 55,000-
square-foot Wade Thompson Drill physical
ICONS space to
Chinese Art,
Hall, with its 80-foot-high barrel-
vaulted ceiling, brings to mind other
sites historically associated with an- hear anew.
tiphonal works, like St. Mark’s Cathe-
dral in Venice, where Baroque com-
In Your Face
poser Giovanni Gabrieli placed singers in opposing choir lofts
across the church’s expanse to take advantage of such special
effects as sound delay and echo. Mr. Boulez also had a partic-
ular spatial configuration in mind when he composed
“Répons”: The ensemble is surrounded by the audience, which
is in turn encircled by the soloists, as well as by speakers is-
From post-Tiananmen era, satire and provocations suing streams of amplified sound waves that are projected
throughout the hall.
that stirred protests—in the U.S. The challenge of fashioning these elements into a cohesive
whole was carried out through experimentation at IRCAM, the
BY SUSAN DELSON acter ‘gu’”—which suggests, among other things, chaos. government-funded French laboratory, founded at Mr. Bou-
In post-Tiananmen China, some artists produced works lez’s behest in 1977, dedicated to the development of interac-
AN EXPANSE of blowtorched plastic resembling human or- that analyzed bureaucratic power structures or pointed up tions between musicians and technology. Like the piece’s care-
gans. A well-known image from the 1989 crackdown in Bei- their absurdities. The New Measurement Group in Beijing, for fully calculated pitches and rhythms, the electronic
jing’s Tiananmen Square, with the figures of two wounded instance, carried out a series of exercises done as mathemati- enhancements of “Répons” are integral to the composition’s
students replaced, for no obvious reason, by emperor pen- cally defined, gridlike works on paper. Following the group’s structure.
guins. Men standing in their underwear amid the bloody car- self-imposed rules, these works were supposedly designed to There is an intense emotional force driving this music, ex-
casses of a butcher-shop workroom. eliminate the individual from the art-making process. Other plains Mr. Pintscher. “At the same time,” he says, “there is a
“Art and China After 1989: Theater of the World” is not a artists focused on the rapid urbanization and pervasive con- strong consciousness, even an obsession, about the construc-
soothing show. And that, one might say, is the point. sumerism that followed Deng Xiaoping’s economic liberaliza- tion. Some composers may use high-tech effects arbitrarily,
Opening Oct. 6 at New York’s Solomon R. Guggenheim Mu- tions of 1992. Still other artists became expatriates. as if adding nail polish, but in this case they are formed in a
seum, the exhibition explores a side of contemporary Chinese At the Guggenheim, flashes of poetry and acerbic humor perfect synergy, varied as a result of the particular attacks of
art not often seen in U.S. museums—“rambunctious, gritty, are on display throughout. “Sewing” (1997), a dreamlike in- each player, depending on how that player feels in the mo-
messy stuff,” as lead curator Alex- stallation by Lin Tianmiao—one of ment. It makes the whole process human.” Boulez’s instru-
andra Munroe describes it. Span- the few women artists active in mental choices are also shaped with scientific precision, using
ning from 1989 to 2008—in effect, China during these decades—fea- a “scale of resonance” based on how long each can naturally
from the Tiananmen crackdown on tures a foot-operated sewing ma- sustain a tone after a note is struck.
dissent to the Beijing Olympics— chine, meticulously wrapped in un- At the Armory, “Répons” will be performed twice at each
the work is undeniably provocative: dyed cotton thread, on which the concert, with audience members encouraged to change seats
Before the opening, several pieces video projection of a woman’s at the intermission. That way, if someone is close to the
involving animals raised such an hands endlessly feeds fabric toward glockenspiel at one sitting, he or she can choose to be near
outcry that the museum removed a phantom needle. By contrast, a piano at the next. The lighting will be changed as well.
them. Even so, the show’s nearly Zheng Guogu’s performance work How does the music sound? Boulez’s writing is virtuosic
150 works offer a bracingly fresh “Visual Art, Add Oil! March For- and dazzling, at times, a maelstrom of “organized delirium,”
perspective on China during this ward!” (1999/2005)—its title a sly in the composer’s phrase. When the six soloists enter, the ef-
era—and place Chinese artists not wink at the slogans of Mao’s era— fect is luminous and explosive. Bursts of energy alternate with
at the exotic fringes but at the cen- involved coating toy tanks in a tra- penetrating silence; abrupt transitions lead from moments of
ter of the burgeoning global art cir- ditional egg-and-flour batter and calm to improvisatory-sounding flurries of fast notes, which
cuit of the time. deep-frying them as if they were then freeze into resonant clouds. These conflicts and contra-
The exhibition’s six segments shrimp. Eight are on view. dictions form the aesthetic essence of the work.
spiral up the Guggenheim’s rotunda Even with the entire museum “How do we know when to move on?” asks Mr. Pintscher,
ramps, beginning with what is lit- AI WEIWEI satirized consumer culture with rotunda and two tower galleries at who must in fact tell the musicians when to start and stop.
erally a hole in the ground. Sunk ‘Han Dynasty Urn With Coca-Cola Logo,’ 1993. their disposal, the curators found By way of answering, he offers an insight. “Search for that
into the floor of the rotunda, the that they could not fit everything moment when the sound actually fades. Follow the decay of
video monitor in Wang Gongxin’s just-completed “Sky of Bei- in. Some artworks were simply too big. So Ms. Munroe, Mr. the resonance to its end, and it becomes extremely intimate.
jing—Digging a Hole in New York” displays recorded footage Tinari and the exhibition’s third curator—Hou Hanru of That is what the piece is about.”
of the sky over the Chinese capital. It’s the counterpart to Maxxi, the National Museum of 21st Century Arts, Rome—
“Sky of Brooklyn—Digging a Hole in Beijing” (1995), an in- found smaller-scale alternatives. They chose, for example, Wu
stallation that Mr. Wang made more than two decades ago, Shanzhuan’s “Today No Water” (1986–96), which Ms. Munroe Mr. Isacoff’s latest book is “When the World Stopped to
after several years in the U.S. Both works are a playful riff on describes as “437 pages of sarcastic commentary on the state Listen: Van Cliburn’s Cold War Triumph and Its After-
the idea of “digging a hole to China.” of Chinese bureaucracy.” math” (Knopf).
A large gallery off the first ramp was intended to display The exhibition’s final section is studded with work by art-
the caged environments of Huang Yong Ping’s “Theater of the world luminaries Cai Guo-Qiang and Ai Weiwei, who is also
World” (1993)—the exhibition’s signature work—and a com- co-curator of the documentary film series accompanying the
panion piece. Mr. Huang’s “Theater of the World” casts live show. The closing section poses the question “Whose Uto-
leopard geckos, Italian wall lizards, hissing cockroaches, goli- pia?” and includes a presentation of Mr. Ai’s performance
ath beetles and other mutual predators in a Darwinian fight piece “Fairytale” (2007)—in which he brought 1,001 ordinary
to the finish. The work was among those dropped from the Chinese citizens to Kassel, Germany, as part of a big art exhi-
show after protests by animal-rights groups and others, with bition. The exhibition will showcase a feature-length video,
much of the outrage centering on a video of pit bulls forcibly wallpaper portraits of participants and 32 pieces of luggage
restrained from fighting each other. custom-made for the trip.
To many critics, the brutal reality in the piece by Mr. Although the Guggenheim exhibition stops at 2008—
Huang reflects the shattering disillusionment that followed with the Olympics, the financial crisis and the dawn of so-
the bloody Tiananmen crackdown of 1989 and the horror that cial media—few of its artists have so much as paused for
“this very utopian, liberal push for new freedoms and new breath. Of the 71 in the exhibition, 67 are living, and about
CHRISTOPHER SERRA
ideas could end in such an awful way,” said co-curator Philip 40 of them, said Ms. Munroe, will be at the opening next
Tinari of the Ullens Center for Contemporary Art in Beijing. week. “They’re very current in the contemporary Chinese
In the early 1990s, Mr. Huang, now 63, reflected on the work: art world and internationally,” she said. Despite the history
“Is the ‘Theater of the World’ an insect zoo?” he wrote. “Or, they have lived through, or perhaps because of it, “these
rather, a modern representation of the ancient Chinese char- are very active artists.”
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
EATING | DRINKING | STYLE | FASHION | DESIGN | DECORATING | ADVENTURE | TRAVEL | GEAR | GADGETS
© 2017 Dow Jones & Company. All Rights Reserved. * * * * THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 | D1
Get Down
Tonight
This winter, the dowdy, downy
puffer goes glam enough to
take on the town. Practicality
and warmth, meet chic
ANDY RYAN FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL, HAIR BY BRITT WHITE, MAKEUP BY JOSEPH CARRILLO, MODEL: BRYNN BONNER/RED MODEL MANAGEMENT
READY FOR
ITS CLOSE-UP
Jacket, $5,930,
Dress, $1,200, and
Necklace, $555,
Miu Miu, 212-641-2980;
Earrings, $60,000,
Fred Leighton,
212-288-1872;
Blanket, $8,000,
pologeorgis.com;
Unattributed Chair,
$3,500, High Style
Deco, 212-647-0035.
Fashion Editor:
Rebecca Malinsky
insulated tube with arms. The move away from that Take Sacai’s dressy parka, a texture-rich mashup of
BY ALEV AKTAR
generic puffer, universally prized for its lightweight nubby wool and neat nylon trim—stylish for day but
T
warmth yet pitied for its deeply unsexy style, is wel- glam enough for a night out. “The idea was to hybrid-
HE HUMBLE DOWN coat has gone haute. come. “Puffer coats used to be all about function and ize a ski jacket and elegant tweed jacket into one that
Goosed by the demand for warmth and less about fashion, but brands like Balenciaga, Vete- could be worn while you ski and also in the city,” said
comfort from women unwilling to suffer ments, Public School, and Moncler have changed that,” Tokyo-based Sacai designer Chitose Abe in an email.
for fashion, designers have reinvented the said Tracy Margolies, chief merchant at Saks Fifth Av- In a similar vein, Thom Browne’s sunny yellow
cold-weather staple with the same glamor- enue. “They are offering us versions that are more de- puffer vest features haberdashery details: double-
ous intent they use for a silky blouse or drop-dead eve- signed, well-tailored and novel when rendered in the breasted buttons and a natty notched collar with con-
ning gown. There’s been a shift away from cloth and fur colors and fabrics of the season.” trast trim. “I wanted to work in the same way I do
coats, as evidenced by the fall collections: These new Indeed, the pleasingly plump new puffers have shed when making a traditional tailored piece of clothing,”
femme-fatale puffers have been lavished with luxurious that serial conformity and shapelessness that made said Mr. Browne, who also designs the Moncler
touches, from fluffy fur collars to arty prints, that make anyone wearing one resemble a vertical sleeping bag. Gamme Bleu premium down line for men.
them as sophisticated as any Chanel jacket. Many of the newest iterations are seamed to accentu- Miu Miu founder Miuccia Prada, meanwhile, fes-
For years women have resigned themselves to ate the body, providing a womanly shapeliness in tooned her sporty ski coats with lavish fox-fur collars,
wearing the drab commuter coat with its stodgy sil- place of utilitarian boxiness. These coats stand out in a look other designers are echoing with both faux and
houette and unflattering channel stitching—a sort of the crowd instead of blending into it. Please turn to page D2
[ INSIDE ]
Boss Tweed
BOW DOWN Jacket, $5,000, Instead of the predictable parka silhouette, Sacai de-
Chanel, 212-355-5050; Dress, $595, signer Chitose Abe adapted a blouson shape for her
nililotan.com; Earrings, $80,000, sophisticated wool tweed and alpaca puffer. Sacai
ANDY RYAN FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL, HAIR BY BRITT WHITE, MAKEUP BY JOSEPH CARRILLO, MODEL: BRYNN BONNER/RED MODEL MANAGEMENT (MODEL); F. MARTIN RAMIN/THE WALL STREET JOURNAL, STYLING BY JILL TELESNICKI (PUFFERS)
Stephen Russell, 212-570-6900 Coat, $3,120, Dover Street Market, 646-837-7750
BARNEYS.COM
NE W YORK B E V E R LY H I L L S SAN FRANCISCO
F O R I N S I D E R A C C E S S : T H E W I N D O W. B A R N E Y S . C O M
S A M E D AY D E L I V E RY
AVA I L A B L E I N M A N H AT TA N A N D S E L E C T Z I P C O D E S
I N T H E G R E AT E R M E T RO P O L I TA N A R E A
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 | D3
BY JACOB GALLAGHER
S
OME CLOTHES are like
periods: neat punctua-
tion marks that take an
outfit no further than ex-
pected. Other clothes are
exclamation points: amped-up
touches that elevate your look into
something more remarkable, less
routine. This fall, menswear is full
of the latter: high-impact pieces
that telegraph that you’re not an
undistinguished part of the wood-
work, that you’re stylish enough to
give them a shot. “It’s about em-
bracing the bold and saying ‘Yep,
I’m going big,’” said Mr. Porter’s
U.S. editor Dan Rookwood, who is
involved in packaging the product
assortment for the shopping site.
Big is what sells these days. So
much shopping is done online and, as
men scroll through pages of options,
clothes that just timidly whisper
“Psst, over here” are less likely to
make guys stop and buy. That might
explain why designer Jonathan An-
derson saw fit to create a rainbow-
hued shearling dreamcoat at Loewe,
you can easily add personal pa- Sweater, $2,270, Prada, 212-664-0010
nache in small, medium or large
doses. “Everyone is homing in on
what his ‘signature’ is,” Ms. Rago- LEVEL 1 LEVEL 2 LEVEL 3
lia added. “I don’t know if it’s A STANDOUT SCARF A SINGULAR COAT A GO-FOR-IT SWEATER
about grabbing attention or more Searching for a slice but not the whole pie? Forget With overcoats, the sedate look can look dated. Fearless dressers can go further. Still, when wear-
about having a strong identity.” about those trying-way-too-hard designer ensem- Trade a stiff chesterfield for a louche, unlined top- ing a sweater as unfettered as this (a much bigger
One way to achieve balance: Stick bles that mash up tie-dye swirls with Victorian em- coat such as this one from Milanese label MP commitment than the Massimo coat), restrain
to pieces that amplify classic mens- broidery. The real world—aka your friends and Massimo Piombo. The “statement” here comes not yourself. “Just have one statement piece as the
wear patterns, such as the large- loved ones—wouldn’t tolerate that kind of runway only from the oversized herringbone pattern but focal piece,” explained Mr. Rookwood. This nicely
scale herringbone of MP Massimo extravagance without mocking you. Instead, con- from the drapey, commanding silhouette. It’s a noticeable crewneck from Prada has a can’t-miss
Piombo’s topcoat (center right). sider a statement you can make with impunity, like forceful look but not one that’s so extreme you’ll diamond quilted pattern on the front. “If you
Stella McCartney blew up a picnic this two-in-one scarf from wry Russian skatewear feel conspicuous in it. Initially, you’ll probably want pair it with other stuff that’s fighting for attention,
plaid for a coat and Dries Van Noten label Gosha Rubchinskiy. One half is conservative to wear a coat like this with solid-colored support- the overall effect can really be difficult to look at
adapted a Fair Isle pattern on a bell- wool tartan, the other is chartreuse green embla- ing pieces. With time, you might find that “the because the eye doesn’t know where to go,” he
shaped sweater. zoned with the sort of ’90s soccer logo that is en- statement” isn’t so tough to pull off: “Suddenly said. Other great alternatives can be found this
Here, three levels of commitment: joying a nostalgia-fueled renaissance. Should your you’re like ‘Wait a minute, I can wear it with stripes season from designers such as RRL, Dries Van
a low-risk scarf, a bolder topper and wild streak fade at any point in the day, wind the and plaids or something colorful,’” said Ms. Rago- Noten and Sacai. Frame such high-profile knits
a sweater that you need to have con- side with modest plaid on it discreetly over the lia, “where once upon a time you thought you’d with black trousers and sturdy lace-up boots.
siderable moxy to pull off. acid-green logo’d one. only wear it with something dark.” Done, not overdone.
ITALY 1927
FURLA.COM
Frond Ambition
Inspired by the branching patterns
of ferns and palms, Irish designer
Ciara O’Neill crafted a pendant light
of textured book cloth and corru-
gated polypropylene—strong, heat-
resistent and fully recyclable—that
has a distinctly Scandinavian mien.
Frond Pendant Light, from $380,
Ciara O’Neill, 44-77-5609-2568
Coffee Mates
Whether you drip or filter, this heavyweight coffee
mill in solid copper or brass will let you hand-prep
The Top 10
your coffee beans in style. Cyprus-born, Britain-
based designer Michael Anastassiades streamlined
the nearly foot-tall totemic form by developing it
with an internal ratio cylinder, not a handle; the
fourth-generation workshop of Carl Auböck in Vi-
enna produced it to exacting standards. Coffee
Brit List
Grinder, about $2,000, sigmarlondon.com
Salt Right
South African designer Christopher Jenner’s sculptural
salt cellar has a softly curving crystal bowl and a
pukka-wood top that opens with the pull of a finger to
reveal a spade-shaped silver spoon—and plenty of room
The standout pieces from the for the white stuff. Christopher Jenner Salt Cellar by
E&Co Ltd, $600, Elkington & Co., 44-114-286-0504
2017 London Design Festival
T
wood chairs with indigo; Almira
HE BRITISH capital Sadar put Slovenian crochet
provided an un- needles to work on extra-nub-
characteristically bly baskets and throws; and
sunny backdrop for Provençal Cecile Daladier
last week’s 15th an- scarred the surfaces of her
nual London Design Festival, flower pots with dried herbs—
the citywide event highlighting harvested just outside her stu- Tile for the Camera
handsome innovations and dio door—to create ghostly, This playful, Instagrammable take on traditional geometric
fresh-to-market ideas. Stealing otherworldly works of art. In cement tile is scored on its aquamarine surface with a
the foreground this year was an all, the offerings felt more like classic cube pattern, then hand-glazed to black out ran-
unusually strong cast of global joyous passion projects than dom facets of the design—resulting in a crazy-quilt effect.
creators who infiltrated the commercial endeavors. Here, Creatively position the squares to bring it out. Huguet
U.K. talent show in myriad, un- our nods for best in show. Mallorca Rialto Cement Tile from Remedios Collection,
about $160 per square yard, info@huguetmallorca.com
EVOLUTION
CARRY ON
DRINKING
A staple of midcentury American entertaining,
the glass caddy gets a makeover
worthy of contemporary cocktail culture
THEN One byproduct of the post-WWII exo- ing tray when she could cruise around the NOW While the caddies of the past could the aged-brass caddy with his partner, glass
dus from cities: Style-cramping apartments room with a secure and chic cocktail caddy?” be gaudy, today’s superior cocktail ingredi- designer Felicia Ferrone. “This was a techni-
yielded to comparatively sprawling ranch The saucy servers added a layer of theater to ents and small-batch craftsmanship warrant cal element so when you lift it up, the bars
homes, giving more people freedom to enter- the drinking ritual and frequently outshone glassware that lets you see the drink support the glasses and make it nearly im-
tain guests. “The American housewife, who the spirits. Frosted glasses and 22-karat gold clearly, and an inconspicuous caddy to hold possible to knock [a drink] over.” The four
had been a wife, mom and housekeeper, now motifs conveyed status; more-casual glass- it in place. The Rare Whiskey Presenter Set scotch glasses subtly taper at top, allowing
had the additional responsibility of hostess,” ware involved Blendo, a dip-dye technique fittingly fetishizes and protects your tipple. imbibers to focus on the aroma first and
said New York-based event designer Bronson whose pigment faded near the vessels’ rims, “The base is made from seven cross pieces the flavor second. Rare Whiskey Presenter
van Wyck. “Why should she risk embarrass- which were finished in gold. Midcentury of solid brass,” says Christopher Gentner, a Set, $460, shophorne.com
ment and stack a bunch of drinks on a teeter- Drink Caddy, $36, chairish.com Chicago-based metal smith who designed —Miranda Agee
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * * * Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 | D5
BY MATTHEW KRONSBERG
W
HEN CHEF
George Mendes
KATE SEARS FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL, FOOD STYLING BY JAMIE KIMM, PROP STYLING BY NIDIA CUEVA
was five, he had
his first food
epiphany, on a
trip from his Connecticut home to
his parents’ native Portugal. He
and his mother attended a festival
on one of the feast days that dot
the summer calendar. “I remember
open grills of chickens and sau-
sages and bifanas,” he said, refer-
ring to the pork-cutlet sandwiches
as ubiquitous in Portugal as burg- BRUSH
ers are in the U.S. WITH GREATNESS
“My mom lost me,” said Mr. Basting with piri-piri
Mendes. “Apparently, I got a hold hot sauce, whiskey,
of a plate of sardines, took off and brandy and butter gives
sat on a tree stump off on the this chicken crisp
side, eating them. The combina- skin and robust
tion of the charred skin, lemon flavor.
and oily fish was kind of an awak-
ening for me.”
Portuguese grilling has that ef-
fect on people. It had that effect
on me (at a considerably more ad-
vanced age) on a recent trip to
Portugal; it fires up diners at Lu-
pulo, Mr. Mendes’s Manhattan res-
taurant inspired by the cervejarias on the grill. Sagres beer, codfish salad and a
(breweries) of Lisbon; and it can When I visited the Portuguese plate of sardines. Plump, rich and Piri Piri Chicken
do the same in a backyard most city of Matosinhos, just north of well charred, the sardines needed Piri piri sauce can be found at many supermarkets or online at zinger-
anywhere. Porto, the town’s portside restau- only a generous squeeze of lemon mans.com. Find directions for how to spatchcock a chicken at wsj.com/food.
“We’re not like the Argentini- rants were thronged with families and a drizzle of olive oil. TOTAL TIME 11/2 hours SERVES 4-6
ans that cook big pieces of red from around the region, drawn in Satisfying as this was, it was
meat all the time,” said José by displays of the local catch on not my only lunch that day. On the 1 stick unsalted butter 1 tablespoon brandy
Avillez, Portugal’s best known ice, waiting to be cooked on curb- drive back to Lisbon from Matos- 1 tablespoon finely minced garlic 1 tablespoon whiskey
chef, whose 10 restaurants include side grills. inhos, I turned off the highway to- 2 teaspoons of chicken base, 4 Cornish game hens or 2 small
four in the emporium-like Bairro I saw no special equipment ward the coast and the city of such as Better Than Boullion chickens, spatchcocked
do Avillez. “We’re more in the being used, no equivalent to Aveiro. At O Telheiro, a rustic res- ½ cup of piri piri sauce Coarse sea salt
chicken business and the seafood Argentina’s parrillas. And no fla- taurant just across from the city’s 1 cup white wine
business, in terms of cooking with vor-defining wood like hickory or glass-walled fish market, I found a
fire.” Radically simple and given post oak smoldering away; seem- seat on one of the heavy wood 1. In a small saucepan 3. Light a grill. 10 min- Continue cooking, un-
to bold, hearty dishes, this style ingly every grill in Portugal had stools at the bar. It was the end of over medium heat, melt utes before grilling, covered, until a meat
of grilling is particularly well a sack of Cuban lump charcoal service and the restaurant was al- butter. Add garlic and sprinkle poultry on thermometer inserted
suited to this time of year, when beneath it. most empty. The chef, Licinio sauté 1 minute. Stir in both sides with coarse into thickest part of
a chill is creeping into the air but It was grilling more or less as Simões, was at the grill. I sat at chicken base and piri sea salt. Place birds on breast reads 160 de-
you’re not nearly ready to give up you know it, but somehow better. the bar and ordered the octopus. piri, increase heat to grill, skin-side down, grees, 5 minutes. For
On a side street, the smell of When Mr. Simões brought it to medium-high and bring and brush with sauce. Cornish hens, total
smoke led me to peek into a hol- me, he stuck around to talk for a to a boil. Add wine, Cover grill and cook 5 cooking time should be
lowed out, roofless rowhouse. In- few minutes, about the 15 years he brandy and whiskey minutes, then flip birds about 25 minutes; for
side the ruin, two cooks worked spent cooking in the U.S., starting and simmer to cook off and baste again. Cover chickens, 30-35 min-
at rusted iron grills tending sil- with a stint in Newark, N.J., whose alcohol, 3-4 minutes. grill and cook, basting utes. Finish by flipping
very fresh sardines flecked with Ironbound district is one of this 2. Pour sauce into a every 5 minutes, for 15 skin-side down and
coarse salt, whole sole, dorade country’s most venerable Portu- large bowl and whisk minutes. Flip chickens, cooking to crisp skin, 2
and cuttlefish the size of small guese neighborhoods. He asked if I vigorously until sauce is baste again and cook, minutes.
footballs. A silver-haired man in a wanted to stay while he made a at room temperature uncovered, 5 minutes. —Adapted from Licinio
pink polo shirt would walk in pe- between-shifts meal for the staff— and butter is emulsi- Flip chickens skin-side Simões of O Telheiro,
riodically and issue orders, then his take on what is perhaps Portu- fied, about 10 minutes. up and baste again. Aveiro, Portugal
collect plates of cooked fish, gal’s most famous grilled dish, piri
which he carried across the street piri chicken.
to patrons of Restaurante Teresa. The dish gets its name from the white wine, brandy and whiskey, me a chicken thigh, hot off the
After a few minutes of watch- small, red and fiery piri piri pep- all emulsified with a generous grill. “I hope it’s ok for you.” It
ing the cooks work, I followed pers that go into the basting amount of butter. was more than ok. I wanted to go
Find a recipe for grilled bifana him, took a table in the restau- sauce. Mr. Simões’s version bol- “It’s too spicy to go on our find a tree stump and be by myself
sandwiches at WSJ.com/food. rant and ordered an imperial of sters a hot sauce base with garlic, menu here,” he said as he handed for a while.
WA R P + W E F T
war pwe ftwo r ld.c o m • @war pwe ftwo r ld
2016 Tenuta delle 2016 Il Poggio 2014 Arnaldo-Caprai 2015 Produttori 2016 Mastroberar-
Terre Nere Etna Bi- di Gavi $16 Montefalco $20 di Barbaresco dino Lacryma
anco $22 This vibrant white The bright and juicy Langhe Nebbiolo $17 Christi del Vesuvio
An old-vine field blend from the Cortese character of this lively Aromas of red fruit Bianco $16
of various Sicilian white grape is made in the red Sangiovese-domi- and earth and a soft, For those who think
grapes made by Etna Rovereto zone of the nant blend from su- approachable character the wine should match
maestro Marco de Gra- Piedmont. Round, me- perstar Umbrian pro- plus lively acidity make the food’s place of ori-
zia, the Etna Bianco is a dium-bodied, it seems ducer Arnaldo-Caprai this basic Nebbiolo gin, this earthy, me-
perfect bianco pizza to gain in richness makes it ideal for just from the famed Bar- dium-bodied white with
partner—though it does with pizza. Particularly about any type of pie, baresco cooperative in a mineral edge from a
pretty well by a pizza good with a mush- especially a classic Piedmont a dynamic venerable Campania
rosso as well. room-sausage pie. pizza margarita. pizza match. producer fits the bill.
Red in a bright, white space with a Southern appetites. “We are in Nashville,”
The Chef wood-burning oven, cozy banquettes and Ms. Sullivan said. “This is our answer to
Julia Sullivan a marble bar. steak and potatoes.” —Kitty Greenwald
Saugatuck, Mich.
A welcoming beach town on
the shore of Lake Michigan
A two-hour, 15-minute drive
from Chicago
LUCY HEWETT FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL; ILLUSTRATIONS BY JOÃO FAZENDA
20th century, artists from the
Chicago Art Institute colonized
beaches and waterfront houses,
and by midcentury Saugatuck
and its sister town of Douglas
had become a pioneering Mid-
west LGBTQ- and biker-friendly
resort destination. Families and
couples come for weekly con-
certs by local bands in Wicks
Park and the slew of fine arts
galleries and restaurants.
Don’t miss You can climb (or
just admire) 200-foot-tall sand
dunes after a strenuous hike Saugatuck Dunes
through Saugatuck Dunes State State Park, a 2½
Park, a 10-minute drive from drive from
town. People who’d rather not Chicago.
get sand in their shoes can take
a 40-minute tour aboard open,
elongated dune buggies (saug- views of Saugatuck and Lake Antique Pavilion, where recent at the 104-year-old Saugatuck for breakfast, lunch and dinner, industry 880 Holland St.; the-
atuckduneride.com). Or take an Michigan. A mile hike from the finds included rare Pyrex sets Drug Store, where a time-cap- serves fried chicken with honey southernermi.com).
1838 chain ferry across the Kala- lookout through forest and down and a vintage condom dispenser sule soda fountain offers root butter, shrimp and grits, and Overnighting Redone in 2016,
mazoo River and walk three to fragile grasses takes you to (saugatuckantiquepavilion.com). beer floats and 24 flavors of more dishes inspired by the cui- Hotel Saugatuck, in a converted
blocks to the base of Mount Oval Beach, an all-seasons Lake Don’t bother Skip Kilwin’s Ice soft serve (201 Butler St.). sine of Appalachian folks who 19th-century lumber mill, offers
Baldhead, then climb 282 Michigan gem. On a cloudy day, Cream, which has branches in Lunch break The Southerner, migrated north in the 1950s 18 spiffy rooms (from $239 a
wooden steps up the slope for treasure hunt at the Saugatuck Chicago, and get your sugar fix overlooking the river and open seeking jobs in Michigan’s auto night, thehotelsaugatuck.com).
Shipshewana, Ind.
A tiny Amish and Mennonite market town
A two-hour drive from Chicago
Leisure Class
A few of the grand estates on England’s Norfolk coast are field-testing new
ways to lure visitors, from glamping sites to amply inviting restaurants
ANDY SEWELL FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL; MAP ILLUSTRATION BY JASON LEE
MANOR REBORN The 18th-century Holkham
Estate now encompasses two cafes,
a gift shop and several accommodations
including a gastropub with rooms.
I
lies here [at Wiveton Hall],” he said,
T was early on a summer mournfully. “It’ll be like Dr. Zhivago.”
morning in the walled gar- For now, Mr. MacCarthy’s new status
den at Wiveton Hall, a Jaco- as a reality TV star is helping to keep
bean estate on a marshy the wolves from the door. Last year,
stretch of the north Norfolk he, along with assorted staff and his
coast, and Desmond MacCarthy was 102-year-old mother, Chloe, who still
worrying about his salad leaves. Al- lives on the estate, became the sub-
ready nudging 90 degrees, the mer- ject of the BBC’s “Normal for Nor-
cury was breaking English records, folk” series about the family’s efforts
and Mr. MacCarthy, Wiveton’s to maintain Wiveton Hall.
owner, feared that his leaves, des- A few miles up the coast,
tined for the estate cafe, would wilt. Holkham Hall is a stately home on
You can bet the 17th-century another scale, and it, too, is in the
merchant who built Wiveton Hall, a midst of a diversification drive. An
Dutch-gabled manor home whose 18th-century Palladian estate,
flint-stone coat sparkles in the sun- Holkham encompasses 25,000 acres
light, didn’t concern himself with of land, 100 times that of Wiveton
such fripperies as vegetable hus- Hall, but tourism overtook farming
bandry. But up and down England, in the revenue stakes long ago. I ESTATE OF PLAY Clockwise from
the custodians of ancient houses, half-expected a giraffe or elephant top left: Norfolk’s Gunton Arms pub,
the agricultural estates of which to emerge from the sweeping, sa- on an 18th-century deer park;
were either sold off centuries ago, vannah-like parkland (instead, herds Desmond MacCarthy, a gentleman
or whose output no longer covers of fallow deer roamed). Elsewhere farmer-cum-innkeeper; Wells-next-
their staggering maintenance costs, are swaths of woodland, grand the-Sea, part of the Holkham estate.
are being forced to come up with fountains, soaring statues and orna-
creative ways to keep the tiles on mental lakes. Built by the 1st Earl of livestock breeding and agricultural
the roof. Wiveton Hall’s crayon-col- Leicester in the mid-18th century, pioneered by the 1st Earl of Leices-
ored cafe—which serves slender as- Holkham Hall continues to be home ter opened this year. Stable blocks
paragus with fried eggs on sour- to the Leicester family and is open have been reimagined as co-working
dough for breakfast; succulent crab- three days a week between April spaces as well as a studio for Lon-
and-mayonnaise sandwiches at and October; visitors can tour the don jeweler Monica Vinader; her
lunch, and is invariably full to its grounds daily. You can peer inside gold pendants hang in the gift shop.
turquoise rafters—is one. the original, soaring kitchen, where All these efforts combine to ap-
A perpetual headache for their copper pots gleam on the shelves; peal to the increasingly sophisti-
highborn owners, this financial marvel at the collection of manu- cated visitors who “want an experi-
struggle is a boon for travelers, who ence that’s a bit more than an egg-
are being given ever more access to and-cress sandwich made by the Georgian cottages surrounding a vil- that read “Good shots never grow
sprawling stately piles—of which farmer’s wife,” said David Horton- lage green, we bought potted up, they just pick up less birds.” A
there is an abundance on Norfolk’s We tiptoed around the Fawkes, Holkham’s estate manager. shrimp and dressed crab from a large jigsaw puzzle lay half-finished
so-called Royal Coast, a three-hour ballroom, careful not to Still, Holkham’s greatest asset re- fishmonger whose accent could pass on a side-table. The Queen, we were
drive northeast of London. Des- mains its coastal nature reserve, a for an earl’s, and picnicked beside told, is an enthusiastic puzzler, and
mond MacCarthy’s program of “ag- wake the guests above. 4-mile, white-sand beach backed by the ice-cream-colored huts of Wells- encourages the staff to participate,
ricultural diversification,” as the dunes and pine forest planted by the next-the-Sea, another wide, sandy but woe betide anyone who gets a
practice is known, is extensive. As 3rd Earl of Leicester in the 19th cen- beach on the Holkham estate. piece wrong.
well as the cafe, there are pick- scripts that predate the Magna tury. The beach spans such a width I don’t think the Queen lies An Englishman’s home is his cas-
your-own strawberries and accom- Carta and poke around the Long Li- that you can feel, at low-tide, as if awake at night worrying whether tle—so goes the adage. At Sandring-
modation in chocolate-box cottages brary, where the current Earl of you’re crossing the desert, and stroll the gardener has remembered to ham, it’s the other way around: Gilt
and a field of fully furnished bell- Leicester, Thomas Coke, likes to for an hour before reaching the wa- water the vegetables at her Norfolk and crystal chandeliers notwith-
tents. My family and I glamped for work on his laptop opposite a lion ter’s edge. estate, Sandringham. Still she, too, standing, this royal retreat feels like
two nights, roasting marshmallows mosaic dating from the 2nd century On a sunny Friday evening, locals throws open its grand doors to visi- a home. But if I were the Queen, I’d
over our fire pit, while a barn owl B.C., a souvenir from an ancestor’s and their Labradors and Londoners tors between April and November, break with protocol, flip the calen-
glided overhead and a hedgehog European tour. like my family and me crammed the before traveling there herself for dar and decree that summers and
thumped through the undergrowth. Since my last visit to the honey- picnic tables outside Holkham’s pub- the Christmas holidays. I had ex- autumns, rather than winters, be
Mr. MacCarthy’s latest initiative is stone Holkham estate, over a decade with-rooms, the handsome, brick- pected the ground-floor rooms to spent at Sandringham. Swallows ca-
a maize maze, which his son, Ed- ago, a number of follies and cot- and-flint Victoria Inn. The cooks which visitors are admitted to be reening over the marshes; beaches
mund, had been tasked with scyth- tages have been turned into elegant source the menu almost entirely lobotomized of personal details; in- flecked with pastel huts and crab
ing. In Wiveton Hall’s West Wing, accommodation for visitors. We from the estate: top scorers were stead, Sandringham offers an oddly shacks; the evening light gilding ev-
which offers accommodations in stayed in the Ancient House, its the Holkham beef burgers and the intimate look at royal life (we were erything and everyone—it’s not
four of its bedrooms, Desmond and I many ornate chimneys rising from a chargrilled bacon I ate at breakfast assured that, except for the carpets, hard to see why Desmond MacCa-
tiptoed around the ground floor, pre- crenulate roof. Its Beach Café has the next morning. There’s stiff com- the rooms are unchanged when the rthy, the Earl of Leicester and the
viously a ballroom, hoping not to been given a Scandi-style makeover, petition for food in these parts. A Queen stays). In the sitting room, other titled homeowners of north
wake the guests above. For Mr. Mac- while a Field-to-Fork exhibit explor- 15-minute drive away, in Burnham we spotted a needlepoint cushion, Norfolk cling so keenly to their
Carthy, letting out portions of his ing the 18th-century innovations in Market, a collection of ivy-clad given to the Duke of Edinburgh, money-pit piles.
Getting There There are no direct trains, ENGLAND has a bold interior with mainly British
Detail
so rent a car. You’ll need one to explore Wells-next- fabrics and wallpapers. Rooms are avail-
Holkham the-Sea London
north Norfolk. It will take you around Hall Wiveton
able on a B&B basis, or you can rent the
three hours to drive from Heathrow—take Burnham Hall whole house (from about $140, stayat-
the M25, A11 and A1065. Market NORTH Felbrigg
Hall
thewhitehouse.co.uk).
NORFOLK
Houghton
Blickling
Staying There Wiveton Hall’s West Sandringham Hall
Hall Touring There If you haven’t had your fill
Wing sleeps nine people and is available ENGLAND after Wiveton Hall, Holkham Hall and
to rent by the week; its three cottages Sandringham, consider three more stately
accommodate between four and six (from about $685, wiv- historic homes to visit in north Norfolk. For starters, Houghton
etonhall.co.uk). A short walk from the cafe, six bell-tents Hall, another Palladian home, was built for Britain’s first prime
have stoves and double beds with crisp white sheets, and minister, Sir Robert Walpole. Dating back to the 17th-century,
share an immaculate shower block (about $185 per night, Felbrigg Hall encompasses a stunning walled garden and 520
two-night minimum, ambersbelltents.co.uk). The 20 rooms at acres of parkland to explore. And redbrick Blickling Hall lies on
Holkhom’s Victoria Inn sport an elegant country look (from the ruins of Anne Boleyn’s birthplace; her headless ghost is
about $240, holkham.co.uk). Each of Holkham’s four historic said to appear on each anniversary of her beheading (May 19).
lodges, deep within the estate, sleeps two (from $120, mini-
mum two nights, barefootretreats.co.uk). Just opened near For restaurant recommendations in north Norfolk,
WING MAN One of the four guest rooms in Wiveton Hall’s West Wing. Burnham Market, the 12-room White House on Sussex Farm see wsj.com/travel
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * Saturday/Sunday, Sept. 30 - Oct. 1, 2017 | D9
I
vision—recently got smart. Though my food turn out OK. But I’ve found test kitchen is run by Philip Tessier, don’t need an app or LCD display
WAS ONLY about halfway differing in approaches, each pro- that these smarter cooktops allow previously the executive sous chef at giving you thermal readings, or tell-
through the jam session vides accuracy that lets you confi- me more freedom and control. They French Laundry, Thomas Keller’s ing you when to flip your protein.
when the adrenaline kicked dently sear steak, melt chocolate, fry stoke my creativity and teach me Napa Valley restaurant, and cur- But do ask yourself why, in an age of
in. The molten strawberries eggplant or achieve perfect brown new things. They help novices be- rently the head coach of the U.S. smartphones and talking speakers,
were bubbling like cartoon butter sauce whether you’re using come self-assured and enthusiasts team that just won gold in the are we still dealing with vague rec-
lava, sometimes spattering my fran- their recipes or your own. level up. World Cup of cooking, Bocuse d’Or. ipe instructions like “medium high”?
tically revolving arm with a brief
sting. I looked down at my
phone…four and a half minutes to BRAINY ASSISTANTS // THREE INDUCTION COOKERS TO CONSIDER—WHETHER YOU’RE A NOVICE OR A KNOW-IT-ALL
go. Four and a half minutes?! At 310
degrees?! Stirring constantly?!
An eternity later, my phone
dinged, and the app, whose recipe I
was using, said I could stop. I sur-
vived unscarred and, for my trou-
bles, wound up with a jar of perfect
strawberry jam.
I’ve made jam before, plenty of
times, but there was always guess-
work: Recipes tell you to cook over FOR BEGINNERS FOR ENTHUSIASTS FOR PROFESSIONALS
low heat, turn your burner up to FirstBuild Paragon Hestan Cue Breville/PolyScience Control Freak
high heat, etc., but how do they Built by GE Appliances’ start-up-minded FirstBuild Precision comes from an included frying pan with an The commercial-grade Control Freak has a thermome-
know what stovetop I have? Does it team, the Paragon burner has a silicone mat to mea- integrated thermometer. The app walks you through ter in its cooking surface, and can generate heat up to
make a difference that I have gas in- sure pan temperature. It also has a probe, to use in- many recipes, from crispy-skin salmon to savory 482 degrees. It’s a bigger, heavier piece of equipment,
stead of electric? If not, why not? stead of the mat, to ensure exact internal temperature. crepes. Without the app and special pan, you can still and all the controls appear on its own color LCD dis-
This time, my instructions were Its app offers basic time/temperature recipes for com- set a power level, with 10 increments from low to high. play screen, rather than in an app.
calibrated to ingredients, time—and mon foods like steak, vegetables and pancakes, but Pros The in-app, video-enhanced recipes make this a Pros This heavy-duty workhorse is fast and powerful.
exact temperature—because I was you can cook whatever you want. great asset. Compact yet powerful, the burner also When cooking at high heat, it’s great to be able to set
using an induction cooktop with an Pros Because of the mat, you can use any induction- works without the bells and whistles. Hestan is team- pan temperature and also track the internal tempera-
app that knows how hot the pan is. friendly pan in your kitchen. The probe lets you main- ing up with ChefSteps to incorporate the Joule sous- ture of your food with the included probe. Controlling
Induction burners, which heat tain water at a certain temperature, so you can do vide cooker for two-step recipes—first bringing a steak everything through the screen means less chance of
pans using an electromagnetic field, sous-vide cooking at low temperatures. to the perfect temperature, then searing it on the Cue. your phone being spattered with grease.
have been around a long time. I’ve Cons Unfortunately you have to choose between us- Cons To use any of the step-by-step recipes, you need Cons Because it’s a professional tool, there’s not a lot
kept one next to my gas range for ing the mat and the probe. The cooktop’s relatively low to use the included pan—which isn’t big enough for of hand-holding. You won’t find recipes, let alone step-
years, mostly for rapidly boiling wa- power means it takes longer to boil water, and the two rib-eyes or eight strips of bacon. (You also can’t by-step videos. And if that high price tag is a concern,
ter or reducing wine or stock. But maximum temperature for precision control is 375 de- use the pan elsewhere.) Hestan says it will launch a Breville says it will introduce a consumer version in
some new models—the Hestan Cue, grees. $300, firstbuild.com larger chef’s pot in October. $500, hestancue.com 2018. $1,800, polyscienceculinary.com
MY TECH ESSENTIALS
MATT LEVATICH
The CEO of Harley-Davidson on his
therapeutic lawn tractor, preferred ear
gear and favorite teleprompter app
My corkscrew is a hand-me-down
from my great-grandfather. After
World War II, my father and his fam-
About a year ago, I took up bicycle riding ily emigrated from Slovakia to Ger-
because my right knee protested wildly many to the United States. Either my father or
about running and playing hockey. I ride my grandfather, I’m not sure which, brought
a Trek Emonda S 6 bike. It’s a well- this corkscrew as part of the family objects
made machine. I just enjoy the ride. It’s they could keep. A corkscrew is an awesome
my other two-wheeled existence. tool because it’s a simple machine. Mine has
sentimental value.
I give a lot of speeches and I have this I cut my grass and clear my driveway of snow
cool teleprompter app on my iPad with a John Deere X729 tractor (similar
MATT LEVATICH (CORKSCREW)
need to be. If I go off-script and ram- snow blower for it. Being in the yard is a WWW.DWR.COM | 1.800.944.2233 | DWR STUDIOS
ble, it stops and waits for me to get therapeutic activity. I don’t have to hire a © 2017 Design Within Reach, Inc.
TOYOTA
HR’s particular charm is
charm itself—the tartness,
the cheek, the amplitude of
attitude flickering across built in Turkey. assistance; automatic high ter—it kind of perfects the kinds of people and a wide ness to walk up and say,
its small surface. There are other costs. beams; and all-speed dy- design, graphically—you range of ages. And I’m “Hey feller, wanted to tell
You want to see a car The extra-fast roofline con- namic radar cruise control. will have to scratch up an- standing there, like, really? you, that is one stupid-
vanish before your eyes? stricts rearward visibility, Toyota claims the C-HR is other $500 for the “R- It doesn’t look like it’s hav- looking car! Have a nice
Park a Trax next to a C-HR. so a backup camera with the only minnow in the Code” package. Money well ing an allergic reaction to night.”
Poof goes the Chevy. LCD display in the rearview pond to the latter system. robbed, in my view. you? Still, the C-HR kept ring-
According to Toyota, the mirror is standard equip- Under the exhibitionist Part of this job is judg- I’m, yes, allowing for ing up second looks. Inter-
C-HR’s design inspiration ment. Cargo capacity is un- body work resides a mild- ing the vox pop, and the cognitive and behavioral bi- esting.
was the phrase “distinctive surprisingly dinky: 19 cubic mannered Toyota widget: a polling on the C-HR has ases—the shock of the new; When is less more?
diamond.” Uh-huh. “The feet behind the second row- naturally aspirated 2.0-liter been wildly positive. All people’s general unwilling- When it’s adorable.
iconic gemstone evokes uni- seats. four with supersmart valve-
versal notions of luxury, at- ware (144 hp and 139
tractiveness, sophistication, pound feet) winding up a
and strength.” Talk to me, CVT transmission and
Harry Winston. What’s notable is front-wheel drive. With
In any event, Toyota that the C-HR’s 0-60 mph acceleration of
went to ridiculous lengths around 9 seconds, the C-HR
(and costs, I bet) to wring elaborate tooling has no problem keeping up
this subtly faceted shape didn’t push up the with city traffic, as long as
out of a mass-production that city isn’t Los Angeles.
environment. Observe the car’s U.S. retail price. The C-HR blithely plagia-
fineness of the body-panel rizes the Nissan Juke
stampings, the barely-there (2011), whose pioneering
light lines that chase them-
selves across the fuselage.
This styling requires all the
The roofline also collides
with the upsweeping belt-
line at the top of the rear
weirdness and indifference
to utility helped spawn all
these small fry in the first
I M P O RTA N T
body panels, each with doors, where the door han- place. But whereas the
deep curving drafts and fin-
icky lines, to be in perfect
dles are cleverly concealed.
All in all it’s a dramatic
feisty Juke rewards driver
engagement, the C-HR is
J E W E L RY
registration, even the gas- way to obliterate rear-side fairly withholding. The e-
cap hatch. visibility. Meanwhile, look- assisted, speed-variable
It’s sometimes said that ing out from the rear seats steering is serviceable but AUCTION
good design costs nothing. is like peeking out a storm numb as a well-digger’s
Wednesday, October 18 at 10am
Yeah, no. Look at those drain. This is just another bum. The independent sus-
bulging two-piece taillight way this car lives on Rue pension is firm rather than
assemblies. How much does Sans Famille. taut, favoring ride quality L O C AT I O N
a railcar of those cost, I If the C-HR has limited over sporty handling. The
wonder? What’s notable to sightlines, it’s bristling 18-inch alloy wheels bran- Doyle, 175 East 87 Street
me is that the C-HR’s elab- with other faculties. Toy- dished at the four corners New York, NY 10128
orate tooling didn’t push up ota’s Safety Sense P pack- are there mostly for rea-
the retail price in the U.S. age includes a pre-collision sons of awesomeness.
The C-HR starts at $22,500 system with pedestrian de- And it remains a mystery EXHIBITION
in XLE trim or $24,350 in tection, forward collision to me how to love a car Sat, Oct 14, 10am – 5pm
well-furnished XLE Pre- warning and automatic with a continuously vari-
mium. This is hell of a lot emergency braking; rear able transmission. Toyota Sun, Oct 15, 12pm – 5pm
of car-craft for that price. backup camera; lane-depar- says their system has Mon, Oct 16, 10am – 5pm
Perhaps that’s why they are ture alert and lane-keeping evolved to increase respon-
siveness and reduce noise
Tues, Oct 17, 10am – 2pm
and engine droning. Yes,
but. The fuel-saving algo-
C O N TA C T
rithms built into the engine
control would very much Ann Lange
prefer my acceleration Jewelry@Doyle.com
curves were shallower. The
logic not-so-subtly inter- 212-427-4141 ext 221
venes to soften throttle re- View and bid at Doyle.com
sponse, which only tends to
draw out the now-quieter
drone. Oy. Diamond Ring, Ap. 6.41 cts.,
The ruby-red test car, in With GIA report, F color, VS2 clarity.
XLE Premium trim, was
Est: $80,000-120,000
shrewdly appointed for the
demographic: a 7-inch Sapphire and Diamond Ring,
touch screen hosts audio
functions including wireless Ap. 13.71 cts. Est: $80,000-120,000
2018 TOYOTA C-HR XLE PREMIUM music streaming from de-
vices to appeal to con- Diamond Ring, Ap. 5.01 cts.,
nected millennials. Lots of With GIA report, D color, VVS2 clarity.
Base price $24, 350 6,100 rpm/139 lb-ft at ports and plugs. Projector- Est: $125,000-175,000
Price as tested $26,794 3,900 rpm beam headlamps blaze from
Powertrain Front-transverse Length/height/width/ the squinty front light as-
mounted, naturally aspirated wheelbase 171.2/61.6/ semblies. These have Auto
2.0-liter DOHC inline four 70.7/103.9 inches on/off. Dual-zone climate
with variable-valve timing; Curb weight 3,300 pounds control, remote-keyless en-
continuously variable trans- EPA fuel economy try, the aforementioned 18- DOYLE.COM
mission with simulated six- 27/31/29 mpg, city/highway/ inch wheels round out the Principal Auctioneer: Rodney J. Lang No. 0777006
speed sequential-shift mode; combined niceties.
front-wheel drive. Cargo capacity 19 cubic Alas, if you want the
Power/torque 144 hp at feet (behind 2nd row) snappy white roof like the
one on our ruby-red tes-