Design & Fabrication of Rocker-Bogie Mechanism: Project Report On
Design & Fabrication of Rocker-Bogie Mechanism: Project Report On
Design & Fabrication of Rocker-Bogie Mechanism: Project Report On
Project Report
On
SUBMITTED BY-
Certificate
This is to certify that the project work entitled
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
During the selection of “Design & Fabrication of Rocker-Bogie Mechanism”, the help we
received from our professors, family, and friends is invaluable and we are forever indebted to them.
We would first like to express our gratitude to our Principal Prof. G C Khursade, our HOD
Mr V. P. Rathod and our Project Guide Mrs P. C. Tikekar for their immense support,
suggestion, encouragement and interest in our project work. Without their invaluable suggestions
our project selection would be incomplete.
Last but not least, we would like to thank our friends, parents and group members for their
belief and patience in our endeavor.
Date:-
Place:- Ratnagiri
ABSTRACT
Rocker bogie mechanism was used in the mars mission to overcome the rough terrains while
maintaining stability as it has robust capabilities to deal with obstacles and uniformly distribute the
payload over its 6 wheels at all times. It consists of two arms connected through a movable joint
with wheel mounted to each arm. This enables to have a suspension based mechanism that
distributes the vehicle load evenly on bumps and irregular surfaces. The design consists of a spring
free suspension based differential drive system allowing the bogie to move over rocks. It has no
springs or stub axles for each wheel, allowing the rover to climb over obstacles that are up to twice
the wheel’s diameter in size while keeping all six wheels on ground. The system is designed to be
used at low speed of around 10 cm/s (3.9 in/sec) so as to minimize dynamic shocks & consequent
damage to the vehicle when surmounting sizable obstacles. Our propose is to design and build a
Bluetooth operated Rocker-bogie vehicle capable of surmounting obstacles like stone, bumps, etc.
The Rocker-Bogie Mobility system is designed to be used at slow speeds. It is capable of
overcoming obstacles that are of the size of its wheel. However, while surmounting a sizable
obstacle, the vehicles motion effectively stops when the front wheel climbs the obstacle. Operating
at low speed (greater than 10cm/second), dynamic shocks are minimized when this happens. Shocks
resulting from the impact of the front wheel against an obstacle could damage the payload or the
vehicle. Our aim is to develop a method of driving a rocker-bogie vehicle so that it can effectively
step over most obstacles. This method is achieved without any mechanical modification to existing
designs – only a change in control strategy.
Table of Contents
2 LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Literature Review 10
2.2 Past, Present & Future
3 METHODOLOGY
3.1 Scope of project 15
3.2 Advantages,Disadvantages and Applications
3.2.1 Advantages
3.2.2 Disadvantages
3.2.3 Applications
4 DESIGN
4.1. Related Concepts
4.1.1 Traction and Slip 17
7 REFERENCE 33
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
1.1 Introduction
There is an increasing need for mobile robots which are capable to operate in
unstructured environments with highly uneven terrain. These robots are mainly used for
tasks which cannot be performed by humans and are unsafe. Among these mobile systems,
the rocker-bogie suspension system was first used for the Mars Rover Sojourner and it’s
currently NASA’s favored design for rover wheel suspension.[5] The rocker-bogie
suspension mechanism enables a six-wheeled vehicle to passively keep all six wheels in
contact with the surface even when driving on severely uneven terrain. The two key
advantages to this feature are: The first advantage is that the wheels' pressure on the ground
is equilibrated. This is extremely important in soft terrain where excessive ground pressure
can result in sinking of the vehicle into the driving surface. The second advantage is that
while climbing over hard, uneven terrain or obstacles, all six wheels will nominally remain
in contact with the surface and under load, helping to propel the vehicle over the terrain.
Exploration rovers take advantage of this configuration by integrating each wheel with a
drive actuator, maximizing the vehicle's motive force capability.[4] One of the major
shortcomings of current rocker- bogie rovers is that they are slow. In order to be able to
overcome significantly rough terrain (i.e., obstacles) without significant risk of flipping the
vehicle or damaging the suspension, these robots move slowly and climb over the obstacles
by having wheels lift each piece of the suspension over the obstacle one portion at a time.[6]
Rocker-bogie suspension system was first used for the Mars Rover Sojourner. This is a
very less explored field of study and could be developed into exploration purpose
instrument.
By creating a rover that is suitable for operating in harsh environments, our goal is to
facilitate the development of vehicles with Rocker-bogie suspension system and their related
technologies, in addition to lowering development costs. We also hope that the platform
developed can be tested and improved upon, to potentially serve as a model for a rover that
could go to the moon or Mars in the future.[10]
Our mission is to design, develop, and test a model to serve as a research platform, suitable for testing
rough terrain surface exploration technologies in harsh earth environments. The design will focus on
incorporating features that are believed to be essential for most planetary exploration missions. The Rocker
bogie Suspension system can be sent for exploring the surrounding to give a visualisation to a person or
operator sitting somewhere for carrying the operation, by the help of a video camera. Hence, due to this
feature of the rocker bogie suspension system can be used in military operations for visualising the scenario
at a region where a bomb is planted.[4] Not only this, the rocker bogie suspension system can be developed
into a wheel chair too to take the patients from one place to another climbing the stairs on its own. It can
also be used for material delivery purposes. As explained this is a wide field of study and very less explored.
So this gave the motivation for the development of this suspension system .[4]
CHAPTER 2
LITERATURE REVIEW
Rocker bogie is a suspension arrangement used in the Mars rovers (mechanical robots)
introduced for the Mars Pathfinder & also used in the Mars Exploration Rover(MER) & Mars
Science Laboratory(MSL) Mission.[4] The initiation of rocker bogie suspension can be traced to
the development of planetary rover which are mobile robots especially move on a planet surface.
Early rovers were teleoperated like the LUNOKHOD-I while recent ones are fully automatic
such as FIDO, DISCOVERY & recently develop CURIOSITY .[3] The rovers needed to be very
robust & reliable , as it has to withstand dust , strong winds , corrosion & large temperature
changes under mysterious condition. Maximum rovers are powered by batteries which are
recharged by solar panels during the day installed over there surface. The locomotion system of
rovers remain crucial to enable it to reach objectives sites , conduct research & collect data & to
position itself according to the demand. There are three main types of rover locomotion
developed so far i.e. wheeled, legged & caterpillar locomotion. The main difference between the
miscellaneous designs of planetary robots lies in the type of locomotion system. Even after
developing many legged & hybrid robots, most researchers still focus on wheeled locomotion for
rovers because of its locomotive ease & advantages & among wheeled locomotion design, the
rocker bogie suspension system is most favored. The ancient FIDO rover & SOJOURNER
contains 6 independently steered & driven wheels suspended from a rocker bogie mechanism for
maximum suspension & ground clearance. ROCKEY 7 rover has similar suspension system just
differ in front wheels. The nanorovers & Nomad rovers have four steered wheels suspended from
two bogies & CRAB rover utilizes two parallel bogie mechanism on each side to overcome
obstacles & large holes. As far as the initial research is concerned, the software optimization
seeks for an optimum in the constrained solution space given an initial solution & Dr. Li et al.
derived a mathematical model to generalize rover suspension parameters which define the
geometry of the rocker bogie system.[3]
Space exploration can be divided into three categories: a quest to better understand our universe,
interest, and economic potential in using natural resources outside our planet, and the future
colonization of extra-terrestrial bodies. Most interest has been in our moon and Mars, as these
planetary bodies are close by, and have environments that are hospitable enough for rovers, and
potentially for future colonization. The moon is very well suited for scientific equipment such as
radio observatories or IR telescopes, as it has no atmosphere, instruments such as these can measure
signals that would otherwise be disturbed or eliminated on Earth. Interest in Mars relates to
expanding our knowledge of the planet, specifically with respect to its ability to support a human
colony. Studying more about the composition of its atmosphere and soil can tell us whether Mars
could potentially support microbial life.[5]
Since 1976, NASA has been exploring the surface of Mars with rovers, starting with the dual
landing of Viking 1 and Viking 2 landers. In 1997, The Mars Pathfinder (MPF) lander delivered the
Sojourner Rover to the surface successfully. Most recently, in early 2004, NASA again landed two
more rovers on Mars, Spirit and Opportunity. In November 2011, NASA has launched the Mars
Science Laboratory (MSL) with a rover named Curiosity.[6] Despite the multiple rovers that NASA
has sent to Mars, each mission has similar objectives. Making improvements from past Mars rovers,
NASA has continued to develop autonomous navigation to make it easier and quicker to control their
rovers, given the relatively large time delays in sending commands. To do this, on-board stereo
vision processing was used to develop an image on the environment, which identified positive and
negative obstacles relative to the ground plane. The other main features of the MERs relate to
mobility hardware, which allowed them to traverse the Martian terrain with relative ease. In
continuation of past Mars rover designs, the rocker-bogie suspension was used. It consists of six
wheels and multiple axles that allow the rover to overcome obstacles larger than its wheel diameter.
[3] The specialized wheels of the rover are approximately 26 centimetres in diameter and have a
unique aluminum flexure structure to connect the hub to the rim of the wheel. These flexure joints
act as shock absorbers which help to reduce the shock loads on other components of the rover. Each
wheel also has small cleats, which have been found to be effective both for soft sandy terrain and in
navigating over rocks.[5]
Curiosity an advantage in terms of its path planning ability. It has a three axis inertial
measurement unit (IMU), enabling the rover to make precise movements while also
monitoring the degree of tilt that the rover is experiencing. To tackle the mobility challenge,
the 900kg rover has a very similar 6 wheel rocker-bogie suspension as previous Mars
exploration rovers have. The larger size combined with the rocker- bogie suspension allows
the rover to go over obstacles 60-75cm higher, which is greater than its wheel diameter of
50cm. It can also safely traverse slopes up to 45°, but is limited to 30° slopes by software to
ensure a factor of safety. Curiosity also has cleated treads that are similar to the MER rovers,
which were found to be an optimal solution for Martian terrain. With a top speed of 4cm/sec,
it was the fastest rover sent to Mars.
In reviewing NASA’s rovers for surface exploration on Mars, there were many similarities in
both their mechanical design and software that enable the rovers to perform on-board path
planning. Autonomous planetary navigation combined with hazard avoidance and other self-
preservation autonomy makes these rovers excellent platforms to reliably transport and
position their scientific instruments. The biggest changes between missions have been the size
of the rover and the types of scientific instruments it supports.
Astrobotic Technology Inc. is one such company that has founded itself on making
space exploration profitable, by delivering payloads and performing robotic services on the
moon. They are currently in collaboration with Carnegie Mellon University and others, to
develop a rover and lander for their first surface lunar exploration mission, which if successful
will satisfy the X-prize criteria as well as other objectives. Their robot, called Red Rover, is
reviewed here because it is one of the most developed lunar exploration rovers. Red Rover is
designed to be a scout, exploring places such as polar ice fields or skylights into lunar lava
tubes. Its goal is to determine where the interesting locations are, based on its analysis of
chemical composition and high resolution 3D images. To facilitate roving about the lunar
surface, Red Rover uses a 4 wheel rocker differencing suspension system. This type of passive
suspension is based on the rocker-bogie design but is simplified by reducing the number of
wheels and free-pivoting axles. It drives the two wheels on each side of the rover together, and
thus relies on skid-steering to rotate the rover. For vision, Red Rover has a stereo camera and
flash LIDAR which will allow it to make high-resolution terrain maps. While it will likely
have some form of on-board autonomous hazard avoidance or path planning it is unclear
exactly to what extent, as available information only suggests that the rover is teleoperated.
Figure 3 is a picture of one of the recent prototypes of Red Rover.[4]
CHAPTER 3
METHODOLOGY
The rocker bogie system reduces the motion by half compared to other suspension
systems because each of the bogie's six wheels has an independent mechanism for motion and in
which the two front and two rear wheels have individual steering systems which allow the vehicle to
turn in place with zero-degree turning ratio. Every wheel has thick cleats which provides grip for
climbing in soft sand and scrambling over rocks with ease. In order to overcome vertical obstacle
faces, the front wheels are forced against the obstacle by the center and rear wheels which generate
maximum required torque. The rotation of the front wheel then lifts the front of the vehicle up and
over the obstacle and obstacle is overtaken. [3] Those wheels which remain in the middle, is then
pressed against the obstacle by the rear wheels and pulled against the obstacle by the front till the
time it is lifted up and over. At last, the rear wheel is pulled over the obstacle by the front two
wheels due to applying pull force. During each wheel's traversal of the obstacle, forward progress of
the vehicle is slowed or completely halted which finally maintain vehicles center of gravity.
Block Diagram:
POWER SUPPLY
ARDUINO
DC MOTORS
WHEELS
3.2.2 DISADVANTAGES:
3.2.3 APPLICATIONS:
CHAPTER 4
Design
passively articulated rover has a great influence on the vehicle’s effective stability, a more
advanced approach is using a static model. [8]
The lateral stability of the rover ensures that the rover does not tip sideways. As the rover
has two symmetric sides, the geometric model is used to find the lateral stability of the
vehicle.[8]
Lateral stability is computed by finding the minimum allowed angle on the slope before the
rover tips over. Lateral stability is ensured if this angle is smaller than the maximum angle of
incline α on the slope at the wheel-terrain contact points. The angles θl and θr are obtained
geometrically. The overall stability angle θstab can be computed by
θstab = min(θr,θl)
Lateral stability of the rover is ensured if the overall stability angle
θstab ≥ α
.:. min(θr,θl) ≥ α
Fig 5
Lateral Stability
Let N1 be the reaction on the right wheel and N2 be the reaction on the left wheel.
Let α be the slope of the inclination, θr & θl be the angle that the point of contact makes with
the Centre of Gravity on the left and right wheels respectively.Z be the height of the centre
of gravity. And yl and yr be the perpendicular between the point of contact and the Centre of
Gravity.
In this condition to ensure the stability the rover should not tip off the inclined. And hence
the normal reaction on any of the wheel should not be 0. Taking moment at the left wheel.
Mg > N1
( α + θl ) < (θl +θr)
α < θr
Hence to ensure stability this condition should be fulfilled.
The computation of the longitudinal stability of the rover makes use of a statical model as it
is not symmetric in longitudinal direction. Using a statical model, the mechanical properties
of the suspension system are taken into account. According to , longitudinal stability of the
vehicle is given when all wheels have ground contact and the condition Ni > 0 is satisfied,
where Ni is the normal force at wheel i. It should be noted that even though this condition is
compulsory for the statical model to work, a physical rover does not necessarily tip if a
wheel looses contact to the ground. However, it is less steerable.[8]
The Static Stability Factor (SSF) of a vehicle is one half the track width, TW, divided by h,
the height of the center of gravity above the road. The inertial force which causes a vehicle
to sway on its suspension (and roll over in extreme cases) in response to cornering, rapid
steering reversals or striking a tripping mechanism, when sliding laterally may be thought of
as a force acting at the CoG to pull the vehicle body laterally. A reduction in CoG height
increases the lateral inertial force necessary to cause rollover by reducing its leverage, and
the advantage is represented by an increase in the computed value of SSF. A wider track
width also increases the lateral force necessary to cause rollover by increasing the leverage
of the vehicle's weight in resisting rollover, and that advantage also increases the computed
value of SSF. The factor of two in the computation "TW over 2h" makes SSF equal to the
lateral acceleration in g's (g-force) at which rollover begins in the most simplified rollover
analysis of a vehicle represented by a rigid body without suspension movement or tire
deflections.[8]
Under this section we will discuss our complete rover design and discuss how our
key design decisions were made in order to meet the requirements and goals presented in the
previous sections. Each one of these is related to meeting fundamental requirements.[2]
Mobility
Mobility relates to the rover’s capacity to traverse varying terrains, slopes, and
obstacles. In beginning the process of formulating the drive architecture we reviewed current
and past rovers in consideration of chassis design, suspension methods, wheel design, and
power requirements. Since nearly all rover hardware is related to mobility, this section will
review most of the mechanical design including the chassis, suspension, and wheel
components. These rovers move slowly and climb over the obstacles by having wheels lift
each piece of the suspension over the obstacle one portion at a time. NASA’s currently
favored design, the rocker-bogie, uses a two wheeled rocker arm on a passive pivot attached
to a main bogie that is connected differentially to the main bogie on the other side. The ride
is further smoothed by the rocker which only passes on a portion of a wheel’s displacement
to the main bogie. Each wheel is independently driven. The maximum speed of the robots
operated in this way is limited to eliminate as many dynamic effects as possible, and so that
the motors can be geared down so that the wheels can individually lift a large portion of the
entire vehicle’s mass.
In order to go over an obstacle, the front wheels are forced against the obstacle by the
rear wheels. The rotation of the front wheel then lifts the front of the vehicle up and over the
obstacle. The middle wheel is the pressed against the obstacle by the rear wheel and pulled
against the obstacle by the front, until it is lifted up and over. Finally, the rear wheel is pulled
over the obstacle by the front two wheels. During each wheel’s traversal of the obstacle,
forward progress of the vehicle is slowed or completely halted. We will be using the same
mechanism the six wheel independent drive to cross the obstacles but without any
differential. To further simplify the design we choose to use one motor to directly drive each
wheel. Since it is a skid steering rover an alternative solution could be to have one motor
drive two wheels on either side, resulting in fewer motors and less mass. However, having
one motor for each wheel reduces the need for a complex power transfer system, which is
often done with belts, gears, or drive shafts. The material used for the links should be cheap
as well as light in weight thats why we will use the Acrylic material which has the required
properties of light weight and rigidity.
Hence for the light weight and cost effectiveness of the rover we will choose plastic
wheels with rubber treads available in the market depending upon the calculations. While
our wheel design may not be optimized in terms of strength and weight reduction, it will
result in a cost effective solution with minimal manufacturing time, and a wheel that should
meet all design goals.
Power Supply
The MER has to travel the surface of mars where there is no availability of power
source thus it used solar cell to charge the battery and derive the power from the battery for
the motors and other equipments. But since we are using the rover on the earth surface and
our main focus is the development of mechanism rather than the power source so we will be
using the cheapest possible alternative that is the 12 0 12 Step down Transformer and a Full
wave Rectifier for converting the AC .into DC to supply the adequate power to all motors in
connection. [7]
Control
The Control of the rover will be manual and bluetooth operated with the help of a
mobile for driving each side of the rover separately. It will be helpful while taking a turn. All
the connections will be wired and no wireless means will be used because we need to
simulate the mechanism and not the actual rover and to make it cost effective in all possible
manners.
CHAPTER 5
RESULT AND ANALYSIS
5.1 CALCULATIONS
Calculation 1
5.1.1 Diameter of Wheel
𝑉 = πDN /60
Assumed speed be 10 cm/s i.e. 100mm/s
Therefore,
100 = πDN 60
DN=1909.86
D N
10 190.99
20 95.49
30 63.66
40 47.75
50 38.2
60 31.83
70 27.28
80 23.87
90 21.22
100 19.1
=400-(35+35)
=330 mm
2302 = 2(NC) 2
NC = 162.63
Also, AN = NC = 162.63
In triangle AMN, angle AMN = 90
AM2 + MN2 = AN2 … (Pythagoras Theorem)
2AM2 = AN2
2AM2 = 162.63 2
AM = 114.99
=115 mm
Calculation-2
5.1.6 Calculation of Wheel Base
θ = tan−1 (y / x)
θ = tan−1 (140/300)
Therefore, θ = 25.016˚ Now, width of the stairs is 300 mm. So the maximum
length of the rover can be 300mm. To deduce the wheel base, Total length – (radius of front
wheel + radius of rear wheel)
=300-(35+35)
=230 mm
=81 mm
Now, due to symmetry,
AM = MN = 81 mm
BM = AB – AM
=162 – 81
=81 mm
Therefore, BM = 81 mm
5.1.8 Height Calculation:
Height2 = BC2 – NC2
(1622 –1152 )1/2 = 114.101 mm
Net height = Height + Radius of wheel
= 114.101 + 35
= 149.101 mm
𝑆𝑆𝐹 = 𝑇𝑤
2h
1.3 = Tw…..
2 × 149.101
Tw = 387.66 m
CHAPTER 6
CONCLUSIONS
6.1 Conclusion
This project will try reaching nearly all of our design requirements, and in many
respects exceeding original design goals. Furthermore all components, mechanical and
electrical, will be thoroughly tested as a completed system in real-world field testing
conditions to validate their success. Overall, preliminary estimates for the general scope,
budget, and timeline, for the project will be closely followed; with the exception if the
project goes moderately over budget.
13 PVC cap 2 12 24
CHAPTER 6
REFERENCES
[1]. Hong-an Yang, Luis Carlos Velasco Rojas*, Changkai Xia, Qiang Guo, School of Mechanical
Engineering, Northwestern Polytechnic University, Xi’an, China, Dynamic Rocker-Bogie: A
Stability Enhancement for High- Speed Traversal- Vol. 3, No. 3, September 2014, pp. 212~220
ISSN: 2089-4856.
[2]. R.E. Moore, Interval analysis (Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, 1966). (8)
[3]. Brooks Thomas; Graham Gold; Nick Sertic; DARK ROVER ROCKER-BOGIE
OPTIMIZATION DESIGN, The University of British Columbia, Project Number 1076 January 18,
2011.
[4]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rocker-bogie
[5]. mars.nasa.gov/mer/home
[6]. robots.mit.edu/publications/papers/1998_07_Hac_Dub_Bid
[7]. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bP7p5Bd2d50
[8]. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Longitudinal_static_stability
[9]. www.nhtsa.gov/cars/rules/regrev/evaluate/809868/pages/IntroBack
[10]. www.esmats.eu/amspapers/pastpapers/pdfs/2004/harrington