Paytrans Survey Report 2020.en
Paytrans Survey Report 2020.en
Paytrans Survey Report 2020.en
2020
Survey on Payment Methods
2020
Survey on payment behaviour and
the use of cash in Switzerland
Contents
Page
Preface 4
1 Executive summary 5
2 Rationale, scope and methodology 7
A remarkable technological development is currently The findings from the survey are also of particularly great
underway in payment transactions, with people profiting interest in the current environment and contribute to
from a growing range of non-cash payment methods. an in-depth discussion of questions concerning payment
This trend, compounded by the coronavirus pandemic, behaviour. Furthermore, the SNB survey provides
means that the replacement of cash with innovation- important information regarding the cash requirement and
driven payment methods is increasingly a topic of public the efficiency of the existing payment transactions system.
discussion. But how significantly has the Swiss population It therefore helps the SNB to fulfil two statutory tasks
actually adapted its payment behaviour in recent years, of equal importance: ensuring the supply and distribution
and what motivates its choice of payment method? How of cash, and facilitating and securing the operation of
important are innovation-driven payment options? And, cashless payment systems. Only when the population has
more fundamentally, how much freedom of choice is there confidence in both cashless payment transactions and
among the various payment methods? Has there been in cash itself can it have genuine freedom of choice in
a change in the acceptance and availability of the various selecting a payment method.
payment methods in Switzerland?
I hope you find this study interesting and informative.
These and other questions are the focus in the second
representative survey on payment methods, commissioned Fritz Zurbrügg
by the SNB and carried out in autumn 2020. The survey Vice Chairman of the Governing Board
provides detailed insight into payment behaviour and the
population’s attitudes regarding various payment options.
Considerable thanks are thus due to the respondents.
This review is only possible thanks to their willingness
to openly provide information about their payment
behaviour and the underlying motives.
In autumn 2020, the Swiss National Bank As before, the population does not feel particularly
conducted its second representative survey on restricted in its choice of payment method.
payment methods, the first one being in 2017. Overall, it rates the availability and acceptance of both
As part of the survey, some 2,100 people resident in cash and non-cash payment instruments as good. The
Switzerland were interviewed about their payment perceived acceptance of non-cash payment methods has
behaviour and the reasons behind their choices. Following increased further since 2017. As for cash, information
the personal interviews, participants then recorded detailed provided by respondents indicates certain restrictions on
information in a payment diary on all non-recurring its acceptance. Such constraints on cash acceptance are
payments (e.g. in supermarkets and restaurants or online) likely a reflection of the fact that shops are frequently
executed over a period of seven consecutive days. Overall, recommending cashless payment as a result of the
around 22,000 such transactions were recorded in the pandemic.
payment diaries. Furthermore, at the end of the one-week
period, the respondents were requested to provide details In specific terms, the 2020 survey on payment methods
of their recurring payments (e.g. rent, insurance premiums yields the following results:
and similar), irrespective of whether or not these
payments were actually made during the reference week. Cash and debit cards continue to be the two most
widely owned payment instruments among
The survey shows significant changes in payment Switzerland’s population. In total, 97% of respondents
method use compared with 2017, with large shifts keep cash in their wallets or at home to cover day-to-day
from cash to non-cash payment methods. These expenses, while 92% own a debit card (2017: 88%) and
shifts can be observed to varying degrees across all 78% hold a credit card (2017: 63%).
population groups. They have also been more pronounced
than respondents in 2017 had anticipated. Moreover, the In terms of the number of non-recurring payments
majority of respondents expect the growing trend towards made, cash continues to be the payment instrument
cashless payments to continue in the years ahead. most frequently used by the population, although
its usage share has dropped significantly compared
On the one hand, these changes reflect the fact that with 2017. While 70% of these payments were still being
the population has become increasingly aware and settled in cash in 2017, in 2020, this share was 43%. The
appreciative of innovations in the field of cashless corresponding shares for debit and credit card payments,
payment methods. In terms of ease of use and speed, the meanwhile, have climbed to 33% (2017: 22%) and 13%
debit card now has a better ranking than cash. At highly (2017: 5%) respectively. As before, there is an above-
frequented points of sale (POS), it has replaced cash as the average number of cash-oriented consumers in Italian-
preferred payment instrument. This can be attributed speaking Switzerland, in the 55-and-over age group and
in particular to the now widespread ownership and use in households with low to medium income levels.
of payment cards with the contactless function.
In terms of the transaction value of non-recurring
On the other hand, the coronavirus pandemic has payments, the debit card has replaced cash
further accelerated the changes in payment method as the payment instrument with the highest share.
use. One-third of respondents state that they have made The value share for debit card payments currently amounts
lasting adjustments to their payment behaviour as a result to 33% (2017: 29%), that of cash stands at 24% (2017:
of the pandemic and are now making increased use of card 45%). This development is largely due to the fact that cash
payments. It is, however, not possible to make a statement is now only the most widely used payment method for
on the relative impact of the coronavirus pandemic on small amounts (of less than CHF 20), whereas in 2017,
changes in payment method use based on the survey data. it was still predominantly used for payments of up to
CHF 50.
Under the National Bank Act, the SNB is tasked with not taken into account. The term ‘payment location’
pursuing a monetary policy serving the interests of the is broadly defined for the purposes of this survey, and
country as a whole. It ensures price stability, while taking encompasses not only specific physical POS (e.g.
due account of economic developments. Among other supermarkets, restaurants), but also online purchases,
things, this requires it to ensure the supply and distribution counterparties (e.g. person-to-person, or P2P) and
of cash in Switzerland. Additionally, the SNB is entrusted payment purposes (e.g. eating and drinking out).
with the task of facilitating and securing the operation Information on when cash in wallets was replenished
of cashless payment systems. By fulfilling these equally or spent was also recorded.
important tasks, the SNB creates the necessary conditions
for the public to choose its preferred method of payment With regard to recurring payments, respondents were
for each individual transaction. asked in a supplementary question for each expenses
category to make one entry for the amounts, frequency
In-depth knowledge and understanding of the use of and payment method used. Details of these payments
cash and non-cash payment instruments1 and also of the were provided from bank statements or from memory. In
associated developments help the SNB to fulfil the a separate list, respondents were asked to specify all the
aforementioned tasks. Surveys that investigate the payment payment instruments they own. Compared with the 2017
behaviour of the public are a widely used method in this payment methods survey, this information, on recurring
regard, also internationally.2 In autumn 2020, a payment payments and ownership of payment methods, constitutes
methods survey was therefore conducted for the second a significant expansion.
time on the SNB’s behalf, following the first survey
in 2017. The market research institute DemoSCOPE was
commissioned by the SNB to conduct the survey. Between
The survey focuses on the payment behaviour of August and November 2020, the institute interviewed
households and has the following objectives: 2,126 Swiss residents aged 15 and over. Table 2.1
summarises the key aspects of the study design. Further
– Gain insights into the prevalence and use of payment details on the methodology can be found in Appendix 1.
methods as well as the reasons behind the choice of
payment instrument
Source(s): SNB
1 The median is also referred to as the middle value: 50% of respondents report
a lower amount than the median and 50% report a higher amount.
Chart 3.1
150
100
50
0
e1
l
ge
rs
rs
er
nd
00
e
ta
de
al
al
or
99
99
99
n
n
io
a
ov
0
la
la
la
A
To
ye
ye
m
g
en
4,
5,
7,
9,
er
er
er
co
re
Fe
or
34
54
an
an
to
to
to
itz
itz
itz
G
In
ge
Sw
Sw
Sw
0
th
00
00
00
to
to
rs
0
ua
,0
a
ss
0
15
35
ng
ng
ye
4,
6,
8,
10
ng
Le
in
ki
ki
55
ak
La
ea
ea
pe
sp
sp
-s
h-
n-
an
nc
lia
m
Ita
e
er
Fr
G
2017 2020
Question: How much cash (Swiss franc coins and notes) do you carry in your wallet or on your person?
Basis: All respondents (2,126 people) by socio-demographic group (cf. appendix 2)
Point of capture: At the beginning of keeping the payment diary
1 The income indicated is the monthly gross household income of respondents in Swiss francs.
Source(s): SNB
Overall, 40% of respondents indicate that they have had The main reasons given by respondents who hold
at least one 1000-franc note in their possession in the last such an account for using these digital options are the
one to two years; for the 200-franc note, the corresponding lower fees compared with traditional banks (51%)
figure was 80% (cf. chart 3.3). The share of those in and in particular the relatively low cost of international
possession of a 1000-franc note has thus remained payments (42%). In addition, just under one-third find
unchanged since 2017, while considerably more respondents them easier to use and make payments with. Digital
have reported owning a 200-franc note (2017: 66%). bank accounts are rarely used as savings or salary
The distribution across the various socio-demographic accounts. This suggests that the services offered by
characteristics has thus been retained and essentially these new providers are used to complement those of
corresponds to the distribution of cash holdings in general. traditional banks. While in the case of transaction
accounts there is a certain shift to digital banks and
fintechs for cost reasons, other banking operations
continue to be settled at traditional banks.
3 Source: SNB data portal, data.snb.ch, Table selection, Swiss National Bank,
Key figures for the SNB, Banknotes and coins in circulation.
Chart 3.2
10-franc note
20-franc note
50-franc note
100-franc note
200-franc note
1000-franc note
0 10 20 30 40 50 60
Question: In which denomination do you usually withdraw cash at the preferred source?
Basis: All respondents holding a bank account and withdrawing cash at a preferred source (2,001 people)
Source(s): SNB
Chart 3.3
100
80
60
40
20
0
e1
al
er
ge
er
on
nd
nd
nd
00
e
e
rs
rs
al
or
99
99
99
al
t
ov
d
m
a
0
la
la
la
A
To
gi
M
m
m
en
ye
ye
4,
5,
7,
9,
er
er
er
co
re
d
Fe
or
an
an
to
to
to
itz
itz
itz
G
34
54
In
e
Sw
Sw
Sw
0
th
00
00
00
ag
rs
to
to
0
,0
a
ss
0
gu
15
35
ng
ng
ng
ye
4,
6,
8,
10
Le
n
ki
ki
ki
55
La
ea
ea
ea
p
sp
sp
-s
h-
n-
an
nc
lia
m
Ita
e
er
Fr
G
which also saw a rise since 2017 (up from 62% to 78%). ��������� �� ���-���� �������
Among the non-cash payment instruments, the debit �����������
card remains at the top of the list, with 92% of respondents Shares of basis in percent (multiple answers possible); from personal
reporting owning one.7 interview
100
3.1.3 Conclusion
Overall, cash remains the most prevalent method of 80
payment in Switzerland in terms of ownership. It is
60
apparent, however, that newly emerging innovation-driven
payment methods are becoming increasingly widespread 40
among the population. In particular, a much larger
proportion of the population now owns a selection of non- 20
cash payment instruments. Owing to these developments, 0
the population has a wider range of payment methods
rd
rd
ng
ps t
ds t
rd t
ap en
ho n
ca e n
at its disposal on average than in 2017. This has further
et e
ca
ca
s
i
nk
ym
m aym
ym
it
it
ba
pa
pa
eb
ed
improved on what was already a good starting point,
p
e
D
Cr
le
er
in
in
i
th
enabling consumers to choose a payment method that is
ob
nl
nl
O
O
O
M
ideally adapted to the payment situation and best suits
their individual preferences and needs. Chapter 4 explains 2017 2020
how this is ultimately reflected in actual payment Question: Other than cash, numerous (non-cash) payment methods are also
behaviour and in the choice of payment method on available. Which of the following non-cash payment instruments do you own?
a day-to-day basis. Basis: All respondents (2020: 2,126 people; 2017: 1,968 people)
Source(s): SNB
Chart 3.4
0 20 40 60 80
Chart 3.6
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
Security Acceptance Ease of use Speed Cost
Cash Debit card Credit card Mobile payment apps 2017
Question: How do you assess the various payment methods with regard to the following aspects? It is irrelevant to your answer whether or not you own these payment
methods.
Basis: All respondents (2020: 2,126 people; 2017: 1,968 people)
Source(s): SNB
Key points
– In terms of the number of transactions, cash – Owing to the overall high level of availability and
remains the most commonly used method of acceptance of both cash and non-cash payment
payment in Switzerland for settling non-recurring instruments, the population does not feel
payments on a day-to-day basis (43%). Compared particularly restricted in its choice of payment
with 2017 (70%), however, cash has lost method at the POS. While the acceptance of
considerable ground. non-cash payment instruments has improved
– The debit card (33%) and credit card (13%) have further, acceptance of cash has seen a slight
become more prominent, with the majority of decline as a result of the coronavirus pandemic.
corresponding payments now being settled with – An individual’s perception of the ease of use and
the contactless function. Having hardly been used speed of a payment method influences their
at all in 2017, mobile payment apps have also choice of payment instrument in day-to-day
significantly increased their usage share (5%). payment situations. In this respect, the debit card
– In terms of transaction value, cashless payments has replaced cash as the preferred choice of
now have a share of 76%, compared with 55% in payment method at many key POS.
2017. In this regard, the debit card (33%) has – On the whole, the survey paints a picture of
replaced cash (24%) as the payment instrument a population that is increasingly aware and
with the highest value share. appreciative of the options available for non-cash
– By far the most widely used method for settling payment thanks to innovation in this area. The
recurring payments in Switzerland is via online coronavirus pandemic has further accelerated the
banking transfers (volume share: 49%; value changes in payment method use.
share: 62%); this is followed by direct debits and
eBill (volume share: 27%; value share: 24%).
This chapter first takes a look at Switzerland’s payment Chapter 4.3 focuses on classifying the changes in payment
method use for non-recurring payments (cf. chapter 4.1). method use observed since 2017. It explores the reasons
These include all types of everyday expenses (e.g. food, behind situational choices of payment method in everyday
clothes and restaurant visits), irrespective of whether life and describes respondents’ self-assessment of
or not these were conducted in person or remotely (online, previous and expected changes to their own payment
for instance). The evaluations are based on information behaviour.
recorded by respondents over the space of one week
in a payment diary. In addition to an overview of general
usage behaviour, chapter 4.1 focuses on the extent to
which differences in payment method use can be attributed
to the payment amount, payment location and socio-
demographic characteristics.
Charts 4.1
Cash Cash
Debit card Debit card
Credit card Credit card
Online banking Online banking
Payments at post office counter Payments at post office counter
Online payment methods Online payment methods
Mobile payment apps Mobile payment apps
Other payment methods Other payment methods
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 0 10 20 30 40 50
Chart 4.2
Cash (2,095)
Debit card (1,956)
Mobile payment apps (988)
Credit card (1,587)
Online banking (1,591)
Retail apps (497)
Other payment cards (458)
Online payment methods (639)
Reka money (442)
0 20 40 60 80 100
Daily 3–6 times per week 1–2 times per week 1–3 times per month
2–11 times per year Less or never Don't know/No answer
Question: How often do you generally use the following payment methods?
Basis: Respondents who own the respective payment instrument (cf. figures in brackets above)
Source(s): SNB
debit card usage rose in the same period by 4 percentage Source(s): SNB
Chart 4.3
Total
Up to CHF 5 (3,737)
CHF 5–20 (7,969)
CHF 20–50 (5,248)
CHF 50–100 (2,849)
CHF 100–200 (1,322)
CHF 200–1,000 (641)
CHF 1,000 or more (86)
0 20 40 60 80 100
Cash Debit card Credit card Other payment cards Online banking
Mobile payment apps Retail apps Online payment methods Other payment methods
Basis: 21,853 transactions amounting to CHF 1,094,780 (in total) or transactions by value range (cf. figures in brackets above)
Source(s): SNB
Total
Total 21 853 1.47 50.10
Gender
Male 10 957 1.49 50.65
Female 10 896 1.44 49.55
Age
15 to 34 years 5 426 1.27 42.60
35 to 54 years 8 075 1.59 50.15
55 years and over 8 352 1.51 54.90
Language region
German-speaking Switzerland 15 666 1.49 49.90
French-speaking Switzerland 5 185 1.42 51.10
Italian-speaking Switzerland 1 001 1.44 48.00
Residential environment
City/town (urban) 13 986 1.53 48.75
Conurbation (periurban) 4 566 1.41 55.00
Country (rural) 3 300 1.31 49.00
Level of education
Tertiary 10 531 1.60 50.95
Upper secondary 9 725 1.42 51.15
Compulsory 1 346 1.08 34.20
Employment status
Employed 14 647 1.54 49.95
Unemployed 487 1.28 46.10
In training/education 1 357 0.99 27.25
Retired 4 772 1.48 57.60
Source(s): SNB
Chart 4.5
0 10 20 30 40 50
2017 2020
Basis: 21,853 transactions (2020); 22,531 transactions (2017)
Source(s): SNB
Chart 4.6
Total
Shops selling day-to-day items (9,603)
Eating and drinking out (4,550)
Shops selling consumer durables (1,597)
Vending machines (1,208)
Petrol stations (1,046)
Services beyond the home (1,037)
Online purchases (843)
P2P payments (691)
Recreation (483)
0 20 40 60 80 100
Cash Debit card Credit card Other payment cards Online banking
Mobile payment apps Retail apps Online payment methods Other payment methods
Basis: 21,853 transactions (in total) or by payment location (cf. figures in brackets above)
Source(s): SNB
4 With the launch and distribution of internet-enabled debit cards, it cannot be 5 Appendix 2 describes in detail the socio-demographic characteristics
ruled out that their share will increase again. and the breakdowns by group.
Chart 4.7
Total
Gender
Male
Female
Age
15 to 34 years
35 to 54 years
55 years and over
Language region
German-speaking Switzerland
French-speaking Switzerland
Italian-speaking Switzerland
Income 1
Less than 4,000
4,000 to 5,999
6,000 to 7,999
8,000 to 9,999
10,000 or more
0 20 40 60 80 100
Cash Debit card Credit card Mobile payment apps Other payment methods
Basis: 21,853 transactions or number of transactions by socio-demographic group (cf. table 4.1)
1 The income indicated is the monthly gross household income of respondents in Swiss francs.
Source(s): SNB
Cash
Debit card
Credit card
0 10 20 30 40 50
No, 63%
Yes, 36%
adjustments in consumer behaviour, including the Other, 1%
tendency to purchase more in value terms at shops Don't know/No answer, 0%
selling day-to-day items and to eat out less frequently. Question: Do you feel that your payment behaviour, i.e. use of various payment
methods, has changed in a lasting way as a result of the coronavirus pandemic?
Basis: All respondents (2,126 people)
Moreover, according to respondents’ self-assessment,
Source(s): SNB
the pandemic has had a lasting impact on their payment
method use, with about one-third of them reporting that
their payment behaviour has changed for the long term
as a result (cf. chart below on long-term changes to
payment behaviour). Within this group of respondents, �����������: ���� �� ����-���� ������ ��
the majority state that they intend to consistently pay ������� ���������
more often by card or increasingly pay touch-free Shares of basis in percent (multiple answers possible); from personal
interview
(cf. chart below on type of long-term change to payment
behaviour). This self-assessment of sustained changes
in payment behaviour is consistent with the fact that Increased card use
in summer 2020 – in other words after the first wave of
Increased contactless use
the pandemic – cash withdrawals from ATMs recovered,
but remained below the pre-crisis level, while the Decreased cash use
number of card transactions at POS settled above the
pre-crisis level.2 No longer use cash
0 10 20 30 40 50 60
Question: How has your payment behaviour, i.e. use of various payment methods,
changed in a lasting way as a result of the coronavirus pandemic?
2 Cf. SIX BBS Ltd, Monitoring Consumption Switzerland Basis: Respondents who indicate their payment behaviour has changed in a lasting
(https://monitoringconsumption.com), and Sébastien Kraenzlin,
way as a result of the coronavirus pandemic (792 people)
Christoph Meyer and Thomas Nellen (2020), COVID-19 and regional
shifts in Swiss retail payments, SNB Working Papers, 2020-15. Source(s): SNB
Chart 4.8
Online banking
Direct debit
eBill
Cash
Debit card
Other
Credit card
Transfer at post office counter
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70
Chart 4.9
Total
Telephone bills, internet connection and TV (20,380)
Health insurance (17,380)
Rent (15,476)
Media and entertainment subscriptions (8,037)
Utilities (7,790)
Tax (7,273)
Pocket money (6,234)
Donations (4,259)
Insurance premiums (3,689)
Public transport travelcards (3,042)
Membership fees (2,283)
Support payments (2,194)
TV and radio licence (Serafe) (2,121)
Loan repayments (1,784)
Car tax (1,610)
0 20 40 60 80 100
Chart 4.10
Total (21,853)
0 10 20 30 40 50 60
Chart 4.11
Total (21,853)
0 10 20 30 40 50
Chart 4.12
Total 2017
Total 2020
Gender
Male
Female
Age
15 to 34 years
35 to 54 years
55 years and over
Language region
German-speaking Switzerland
French-speaking Switzerland
Italian-speaking Switzerland
Income 1
Less than 4,000
4,000 to 5,999
6,000 to 7,999
8,000 to 9,999
10,000 or more
0 20 40 60 80 100
Cash consumers (always or usually cash) Situational consumers (both) Cashless consumers (always or usually cashless)
Question: How do you generally pay for everyday expenses (e.g. food shopping)?
Basis: All respondents (2,126 people) or respondents by socio-demographic group (cf. appendix 2)
1 The income indicated is the monthly gross household income of respondents in Swiss francs.
Source(s): SNB
Chart 4.13
Total
Payment type
Cash consumer
Situational consumer
Cashless consumer
0 20 40 60 80 100
4.3.3 Self-assessment of changes in In addition, the primary reason given by those who expect
payment behaviour to rely increasingly on cashless payments in the future
It can be concluded from the above that a significant is that these payments will become even more widely
proportion of the population has considerably adjusted its accepted and more convenient. Meanwhile, it was stated
preferences and habits regarding the choice of payment far less frequently than in 2017 that the anticipated
method as well as its assessment of the individual payment decline in cash usage is mainly a consequence of keeping
methods since 2017. The respondents’ self-assessment of up with a social trend.
their past and expected payment behaviour also confirms
the increased willingness to change. At the same time, habit remains the most commonly cited
reason among a smaller proportion of the population who
Looking back, 60% of respondents in this survey state expect to continue paying cash with the same frequency
that they currently pay less often in cash than three years over the coming years. But here, too, the prevalence of
previously, while in the multi-year outlook in 2017, habits has decreased considerably. Three years ago, three
46% expected their cash payment frequency to decline. out of four respondents maintained that payment method
What is relevant here is that, according to half of these use was acceptable as it was, whereas in 2020, only
respondents, the decrease in their cash usage was not as every second respondent cited this as an explanation.
Chart 4.14
Supermarket (799)
Non-food shop (795)
Restaurant (781)
Bar/Cafe (772)
Specialist food store (753)
P2P payment (746)
Public transport (697)
Hotel (697)
Petrol station (680)
Take-away (669)
Parking meter (663)
Online purchase (658)
Vending machine (476)
Taxi (417)
0 20 40 60 80 100
Chart 4.15
Total
Gender
Male
Female
Age
15 to 34 years
35 to 54 years
55 years and older
Language region
German-speaking Switzerland
French-speaking Switzerland
Italian-speaking Switzerland
Income 1
Less than 4,000
4,000 to 5,999
6,000 to 7,999
8,000 to 9,999
10,000 or more
0 20 40 60 80 100
More frequent use of cash Same use of cash Less frequent use of cash Don't know/No answer
Question: Compared with today, do you think that in two years' time you will be paying with cash more often or less often than you do at present, or the same?
Basis: All respondents (2,126 people) or respondents by socio-demographic group (cf. appendix 2)
1 The income indicated is the monthly gross household income of respondents in Swiss francs.
Source(s): SNB
CHF 11–20 This is consistent with the fact that the majority of
respondents who use the contactless function consider
CHF 21–40
the current limit of CHF 80 (40%) to be appropriate
CHF 41–80 (cf. chart 5.3). While about a quarter of these respondents
could envisage a further increase in the limit to over
CHF 80 or more
CHF 80, 31% would choose a limit below CHF 80. Of
Don't know/No answer these, only 11% would like to see a return to the previous
limit of exactly CHF 40.
0 20 40 60 80
Question: For what payment amounts do you use the contactless payment function? Reasons for and against using contactless function
Basis: Respondents using the contactless function (1,580 people)
As in 2017, the main reasons for using the contactless
Source(s): SNB
function are the speed (60%) and convenience (39%) of
the payment process. In view of the coronavirus pandemic,
it is not surprising that hygiene concerns (28%) were also
cited as a factor. The most frequently given reasons for not
using the contactless function were lack of confidence
in the new technology (30%), lack of engagement with the
new technology (21%) and concerns about fraud (20%).
Mobile payment apps, such as Twint, enable payments to ������� ����� ��� ����������� �������� ���
��������� ���
be made using smartphones. These apps can be used Shares of relevant basis in percent; from personal interview
not only to buy goods and services at physical points of
sale or remotely via online purchases, but also to settle
Up to CHF 39
P2P payments. A transaction with a mobile payment app is
generally made by bank transfer (if linked to an account), CHF 40
credit card payment (if linked to a credit card), or e-money CHF 41–79
(if a prepaid app is used or if linked to a prepaid card).
CHF 80
and, in an open-ended question, 69% cited these apps as Basis: Respondents using the contactless function (1,580 people)
5 The relatively high share (65%) of mobile payment apps linked to an account
is consistent with Twint’s high share (77%) of all mobile payment apps installed
by respondents. Unlike other apps, Twint connectivity with an account is possible
and widely used.
Chart 5.6
0 20 40 60 80 100
Cash Debit card Credit/Prepaid card Bank transfer Online payment methods Don't know/No answer
Question: Which payment method did you previously use in the areas of application where you are now using a mobile payment app?
Basis: Respondents using mobile payment apps for respective area of application (cf. figures in brackets above)
Source(s): SNB
Similar to direct debit, eBill is a payment procedure used ��� �� ������ ����� ��� �����
Shares of basis in percent; from personal interview
to settle and approve invoices. In the case of direct
debit, the invoicing party directly charges the account for
which they have a debit authorisation, while with eBill,
invoices can be received directly through online banking.
Individual invoices can then be approved or rejected. It is
also possible to set up a standing approval function with
eBill for the automatic approval of invoices. This function
in eBill corresponds to a digital version of the consent
given via direct debit for the periodic collection of amounts
due, and can therefore be considered by end users as an
alternative to direct debit.
eBill only, 16%
Direct debit only, 25%
Prevalence and use of eBill eBill and direct debit, 18%
Based on their functions, direct debit and eBill are mainly Neither eBill nor direct debit, 40%
used for recurring expenses. Their value shares for Don't know/No answer, 1%
recurring costs are 17% for direct debit and 6% for eBill. Question: Do you use direct debit? / Do you use eBill?
The bulk of recurring payments (62%) are settled via Basis: All respondents (2,126 people)
Chart 5.8
100
80
60
40
20
0
e1
l
ge
rs
rs
er
nd
nd
nd
e
ta
de
al
al
or
00
99
99
99
io
a
ov
m
la
la
la
A
To
ye
ye
m
g
en
4,
5,
7,
9,
er
er
er
co
re
Fe
or
34
54
an
an
to
to
to
itz
itz
itz
G
In
ge
Sw
Sw
Sw
0
th
0
to
to
rs
0
00
00
00
ua
,0
a
ss
15
35
g
ye
4,
6,
8,
10
ng
Le
in
in
in
55
ak
ak
ak
La
pe
pe
pe
-s
s
h-
n-
an
nc
lia
m
Ita
e
er
Fr
G
1 Source: SNB data portal, data.snb.ch, Table selection, Swiss National Bank,
Key figures for the SNB, Banknotes and coins in circulation.
2 Foreign holdings of Swiss francs (transactions or store of value) are not
covered by the survey. Estimates of Swiss franc banknotes in circulation
not used for transactions can be found in Katrin Assenmacher, Franz Seitz and
Jörn Tenhofen (2019), The demand for Swiss banknotes: some new evidence,
Swiss Journal of Economics and Statistics, 155(14), pp. 1–22.
3 For this reason, this chapter does not consider the 2017 results in
comparison.
Chart 6.1
Denominations
10-franc notes, 2%
Among the respondents who hold cash as a short-term 20-franc notes, 13%
store of value, 40% opt primarily for the 100-franc note. 50-franc notes, 14%
This is followed by the 50-franc and 20-franc notes, 100-franc notes, 40%
which are cited by 14% and 13% respectively as the main 200-franc notes, 7%
denominations held (cf. chart 6.4). For cash held as 1000-franc notes, 4%
a long-term store of value, the 100-franc note is again the Coins, 12%
Don't know/No answer, 8%
most frequently cited denomination of choice (17% of
the corresponding group of respondents). This is followed Question: In which denomination(s), i.e. which banknotes, do you mainly hold this
cash for unforeseen expenses/targeted saving?
by the 200-franc and 50-franc notes, each of which are Basis: Respondents who hold cash reserves themselves or in their household for
held by 6% of respondents primarily for this purpose. It is unforeseen expenses, targeted saving and as a long-term store of value (852 people)
10-franc notes, 1%
20-franc notes, 3%
50-franc notes, 6%
100-franc notes, 17%
200-franc notes, 6%
1000-franc notes, 4%
Coins, 5%
Don't know/No answer, 58%
Question: In which denomination(s), i.e. which banknotes, do you mainly hold this
cash as a long-term store of value?
Basis: Respondents who hold cash reserves themselves or in their household for
unforeseen expenses, targeted saving and as a long-term store of value (852 people)
Source(s): SNB
Around three-quarters of respondents who hold cash Based on the information provided by respondents on cash
reserves as a short or long-term store of value5 cite the reserves, it is possible to estimate the total cash holdings
immediate availability of cash when they require it as the by households in Switzerland not intended for immediate
main reason (cf. chart 6.6.). This is supported by the fact payment purposes. It is worth noting here that this
that the majority of cash amounts held in reserve are estimate of cash holdings will tend to be too low, in view
below CHF 1,000. The second most frequently cited reason of the issues mentioned earlier in the chapter. According
by respondents with a cash reserve, albeit with a much to the estimate, cash reserves held by individuals in
smaller share of 17%, is that they want to use it as a safety Switzerland amount to a total of around CHF 10 billion, or
net for crisis situations. This could be attributable to the roughly 12% of total banknotes in circulation.6 Overall, the
fact that the 2020 survey was conducted during the importance of the use of cash as a store of value is similar
coronavirus crisis. Conversely, owing to the persistently to that already seen in 2017. Likewise, an international
low interest rate environment, households continue to comparison shows that the amounts of cash held per person
see no pressing reason to keep cash at home or in a safety in Switzerland and in the euro area are at a similar level.7
deposit box. A plausible explanation for this is that the
vast majority of individuals have so far not been directly Furthermore, the survey results suggest that holding cash
affected by negative interest rates. as a short and long-term store of value plays a subordinate
role compared with other categories of financial assets
(e.g. account deposits, savings in pillar 3 pension schemes
or securities). Specifically, the share of financial assets
held in cash by households in Switzerland is typically in
the low single-digit percentage range.
Chart 6.6
Unforeseen expenses
Safety net for crisis situations
Targeted saving for specific purpose
Piggy bank/Coin collection
Reduce frequency of visits to ATM
Reserve for cash expenses
Reserve for technical problems
Lack of confidence in banks
Protect financial privacy
Other reasons
Don't know/No answer
0 20 40 60 80
Question: Which are the three most important reasons why you/your household hold/s cash reserves?
Basis: Respondents who hold cash reserves for unforeseen expenses, targeted saving or as a long-term store of value (1,155 people)
Source(s): SNB
Survey methodology
The respondents in the survey on payment methods were of quality. These, together with an additional eight diaries
surveyed between mid-August and November 2020. The that were received after conclusion of the survey, were
sampling frame for person and household surveys used by removed from the dataset. Overall, a total of 308 responses
the Federal Statistical Office (FSO) served as the basis were eliminated, leaving a total of 2,126 correct responses
for the sampling procedure. The sampling frame uses data (interview and diary) for evaluation. All entries in the
on residents from cantonal and communal population payment diaries were also assessed for plausibility in
registers, which are updated every quarter. A stratified order to rectify any misstatements or oversights during
random sample was drawn from it for the 2020 payment the recording.
methods survey, based on the characteristics of language
region, gender and age. The adjusted dataset was weighted according to the
structural characteristics of the statistical population,
The vast majority of the personal interviews for the survey so as to be able to draw representative conclusions about
– comprising some 200 questions – were conducted in the Switzerland’s resident population aged 15 and over.
form of computer-assisted telephone interviews (CATI).1 Post-stratification weights were calculated for the dataset.
The second part of the survey involved keeping a payment Specifically, all interviews and payment diaries were
diary, for which respondents had the choice of entering weighted according to language region, age and gender,
their data digitally (via browser access) or on paper. Two- in line with the actual proportions found in the population
thirds of the respondents opted for the digital diary, which as a whole. In the report, all data on number of persons,
could be accessed via internet-enabled devices, such as number of payments or total value of payments represent
a PC, laptop, smartphone or similar. For the paper version, weighted totals.
respondents received a payment diary plus a small
notebook for recording expenses on an ongoing basis
throughout the day. Methodological differences between
2017 and 2020 surveys
By way of compensation, the participants received In contrast to the 2020 survey on payment methods,
CHF 100 after completion of the survey. In addition to the 2017 survey was based entirely on face-to-face
a thank you letter, respondents were also sent a small interviews – or computer-assisted personal interviews
package of shredded Swiss banknotes withdrawn from (CAPI) – with respondents selected by random quota
circulation. Compensation of this size is appropriate sampling. The coronavirus pandemic necessitated
and in line with market norms for surveys that take up a switch to CATI. This procedure allowed the personal
a comparable amount of participants’ time. interview to be retained and methodological effects
to be minimised, and ensured that the two survey
A total of 2,434 people were interviewed during the field findings were as comparable as possible.
phase, of which 2,144 returned a fully completed payment
diary. The high response rate of 88% can be attributed At the same time, the change in survey methodology
to a number of different factors. First, respondents were meant that the previous method of random quota
reminded about the payment diary by telephone or email sampling could no longer be used. The FSO ’s sampling
and, second, compensation was only paid following frame which was used instead, however, formed
submission of a fully completed diary. the basis for a high-quality survey of individuals.
The adjustment of the sampling procedure resulted in
After concluding the survey, DemoSCOPE then cleansed comparatively more people with high incomes and
the data. This ensured that interviews not conducted tertiary education being surveyed compared with 2017.
according to specifications or with an excessively high
item non-response rate were removed from the dataset.
Furthermore, only those interviews that could be paired
with a completed diary were included in the dataset. Upon
examination of these diaries, DemoSCOPE identified
ten diaries that did not meet the required standards in terms
Distribution of sample by
socio-demographic characteristics
socio-demographic characteristics
Number Description
in sample
Total
All respondents 2,126 Size of adjusted sample with all respondents
Gender
Male 1,048 Male participants in payment methods survey
Female 1,078 Female participants in payment methods survey
Age
15 to 34 years 610 Respondents aged between 15 and 34 years
35 to 54 years 727 Respondents aged between 35 and 54 years
55 years and over 788 Respondents aged at least 55 years
Language region1
German-speaking Switzerland 1,506 Respondents resident in German-speaking Switzerland
French-speaking Switzerland 520 Respondents resident in French-speaking Switzerland
Italian-speaking Switzerland 100 Respondents resident in Italian-speaking Switzerland
Residential environment2
City/town (urban) 1,302 Respondents resident in the category ‘urban centre’
Conurbation (periurban) 464 Respondents resident in the category ‘area under influence of urban centres’
Country (rural) 359 Respondents resident in the category ‘areas not under influence of urban centres’
Level of education3
Tertiary 941 Respondents with final education qualification from a university of applied sciences (‘Fachhochschule’),
higher technical school (‘Höhere Technische Lehranstalt’), business school, college of education,
university or the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology (ETH)
Upper secondary 982 Respondents with a final school-leaving certificate from a high school (‘Mittelschule’), vocational high
school (‘Berufsmittelschule’) or grammar school (‘Gymnasium’)
Compulsory 179 Respondents having completed primary school, lower secondary level, or no education
Income
Less than CHF 4,000 205 Respondents with monthly gross household income of less than CHF 4,000
CHF 4,000–5,999 318 Respondents with monthly gross household income of between CHF 4,000 and CHF 5,999
CHF 6,000–7,999 361 Respondents with monthly gross household income of between CHF 6,000 and CHF 7,999
CHF 8,000–9,999 360 Respondents with monthly gross household income of between CHF 8,000 and CHF 9,999
CHF 10,000 or more 721 Respondents with monthly gross household income of at least CHF 10,000
Employment status
Employed 1,357 Respondents in employment (full-time, part-time, self-employed)
Unemployed 54 Respondents (temporarily) without employment
In training/education 196 Respondents in training/education, including apprentices
Retired 461 Respondents in retirement
1 The linguistic classification of place of residence (municipality) is based on the most commonly spoken local language according to the FSO structural survey
(available in German and French only): www.bfs.admin.ch, Statistiken finden, Regionalstatistik, Atlanten, Statistischer Atlas der Schweiz, Atlaskapitel Schweiz,
Statatlas Schweiz 01 – Bevölkerung, Räumliche Gliederungen der Schweiz, Analyseregionen, Sprachgebiete, 2016 – Karte nach Gemeinden. For purposes of presentation,
Italian-speaking municipalities outside Canton Ticino are included in the category ‘Italian-speaking Switzerland’.
2 The breakdown by residential environment is based on the system applied by the FSO (available in German and French only):
www.bfs.admin.ch/bfs/de/home/statistiken/querschnittsthemen/raeumliche-analysen/raeumliche-gliederungen/raeumliche-typologien.html
3 Due to a lack of information on level of education, income and employment status, or due to rounding, the sum of the socio-demographic categories does not
necessarily correspond to the total.
Source(s): SNB
Glossary
Contactless function Facilitates the transfer of payment information between a physical device (e.g. smartphone or payment card) and a terminal at
a point of sale (POS, cf. payment location) without the need for any physical contact between the device and the terminal.
Contactless payments are typically transferred using near field communication (NFC) or bluetooth low energy (BLE) technology,
or by scanning a quick response code (QR code).
Credit card Payment card that enables the holder to make payments or cash withdrawals on credit up to an agreed threshold. Interest is
generally not charged until expiry of the deadline specified in the invoice (usually one month). Thereafter, the cardholder has the
option to pay in instalments, upon which interest is levied.
Debit card Payment card tied to a bank or postal account that enables the cardholder to charge payments and cash withdrawals directly
to their account (e.g. Maestro and PostFinance card).
Direct debit Direct debit is a payment procedure used to settle and approve invoices. In the case of direct debit, the invoicing party
(payment recipient) directly charges the account for which the invoice recipient (payer) has issued a debit authorisation.
eBill With eBill, invoices can be received and settled directly through online banking. Individual invoices can then be approved or
rejected. It is also possible to set up a standing approval function with eBill for the automatic approval of invoices. This function
in eBill thus corresponds to a digital version of the consent given through direct debit for the periodic collection of amounts due
and can be considered as an alternative to direct debit (cf. direct debit).
e-money e-money describes any electronically stored monetary value in the form of a claim against the issuer, which is issued in
exchange for the payment of funds in order to carry out transactions. This includes prepaid credit and prepaid cards with
a wide range of uses.
Mobile payment apps Mobile payment apps represent a form of mobile payment. These apps can be used not only to buy goods and services
(at physical points of sale or remotely), but also to settle P2P payments. A transaction with a mobile payment app is generally
made by bank transfer (if linked to an account), credit card payment (if linked to a credit card), or e-money (if a prepaid app is
used or if linked to a prepaid card). Payment at a point of sale works by scanning a QR code, or via BLE or NFC (cf. contactless
function), and in the case of P2P payments, by entering a telephone number. In Switzerland, the most prevalent mobile
payment app is Twint (cf. chapter 5.2).
Online banking Online banking refers to the conduct of banking transactions via the internet, irrespective of location or opening hours. Banks
(e-banking and offer their customers the corresponding websites or portals (e-banking), as well as specific apps (mobile banking or m-banking),
m-banking) through which customers can conduct their banking business online.
Online payment Payment methods via the internet that are usually paired with a payment card and are used primarily to settle online purchases
method (e.g. PayPal or Sofortüberweisung). The term is used throughout this report to encompass all payments made via the internet
that are not executed through a specific online banking application (cf. online banking), a specific mobile payment app
(cf. mobile payment apps) or a retail app (cf. retail apps).
Other payment cards Retailer cards with a payment function (e.g. those of petrol stations or retailers) as well as prepaid cards that can only be used
with certain retailers (e.g. voucher cards) or in a restricted way (university, canteen, laundry cards, etc.).
Payment instrument These include cash, payment cards (debit, credit, prepaid and other payment cards), (online banking) transfers, direct debits
and e-money. In addition, mobile payment apps and online payment methods are also covered by this term for the purposes of
this report.
Payment location Refers to the POS where goods or services are purchased and paid for. For the purposes of this report, the term ‘payment
location’ covers specific POS (e.g. supermarkets, restaurants and online platforms) as well as counterparties (e.g. P2P) and
payment purposes (e.g. ‘eating and drinking out’).
Payment method Cf. payment instrument
Point of sale (POS) Cf. payment location
Retail apps Similar to mobile payment apps (cf. mobile payment apps), retail apps facilitate payments via smartphone. In contrast to mobile
payment apps, however, retail apps are specific to the retailer. They make possible the purchase of goods and services with
the relevant retailer. An example of a widely used retail app in Switzerland is SBB Mobile. A payment with a retail app may be
based on a credit card payment, e-money (usually prepaid card payment, cf. e-money) or a bank transfer. In addition, a retail
app may also be linked to a mobile payment app so that payments with the retail app are in turn indirectly based on the
underlying payment instrument of the mobile payment app.
Further information
communications@snb.ch
Languages
German, French, English
and Italian
Design
Interbrand Ltd, Zurich
The publication time schedule can be found General information and data published without reference to
at www.snb.ch, Media, Time schedule. a copyright may be used without mentioning the source.
Many SNB publications are available To the extent that the information and data clearly derive from
in printed form, either as single copies outside sources, the users of such information and data are
or on subscription, from: obliged to respect any existing copyrights and to obtain the right
Swiss National Bank, Library of use from the relevant outside source themselves.
P.O. Box, CH-8022 Zurich
Telephone +41 58 631 11 50 Limitation of liability
Fax +41 58 631 50 48 The SNB accepts no responsibility for any information it provides.
Email: library@snb.ch Under no circumstances will it accept any liability for losses
or damage which may result from the use of such information.
This limitation of liability applies, in particular, to the topicality,
accuracy, validity and availability of the information.