tu€6Jd ahrd w

doa$ edA 43 od€$ 2006(sP) *rl:d,,#eif6 i{36oe>oi'

z:d;l:drJd d€J6,
- ,.1
dddd6d), Aino#24{72007.

afdGeo

M,rjr- rbd ,+q*d$E:P JEaFdd #1 ^.?8liry a:|| Pi-t'

io#.rdr3
erdd eraial &d6dd zrt''
uu{ear- r) *asa eggtd doasrsda 6 oss6a'2006,
?l'^i'^f6'
2) &hcd dldqe'd do$*rd6 5 De'6egs' 2007, 6:16-O1-2007'

t
Siajiit olx) Aradrn sd;onOp t.rt g4ryq*lea *oz:oQedod'
-.-'xOd sD&a:-ld'
8(AdH O&ad erQod{ tueSrdende' dr es0xa$rjd ob{Pt Oe8o1: dod€Ed'l
dr DJ'axilrJC doddF&3 to(O zJ6"J €e+dtJcdl
Cea{e}
do.icAdBdldod @.t-o ?rDd e:ax.$rfC d0ddrdr3 &rnrle'c ed:a$Sond1
erdQ, dlda:+ er e&xd:rlddi *ad *Axd:rJCqno3x d>od:ddJo d'@zidrJddl
$edoaadr

dod eqFFN doAgedo1;O-' ,t*i e0xdrJ?r3 6Ja dooo$ ocq/

eondr.id{ot tr{$rSEJ Edd adddgJed z-ddt[ 6arood3l'10'2oo6d t'od8eqqb9-d
.)&rJdct &adf i.F.J cJ&xdtrler3 erdrqi--drt dAs2d-.@, d-oddriddtr e,edeFndl'
:

- ,irt?d z:rl drordd a)dr doaee'tu eed. uDd dax$'J: ?Jq

x}dAed-rl+
Jaord{ &a:ld>l d$ogrl$ dre3iDd a+O$ ued dxd ,Jtb64, &3tl']Eoqf?
ero8d: &caeoit', t-dasuo. aoao+:t.tO.zOOeaod: d,aetd:d. "tqdesd f
-{or'*t^
5 os6€r.
oe;sd& 2006 #r, a;uo*ro.ol.20o7dod dodaSd:a drdged rdo*,osa
2007q dr dnd& @od ?Jd>dod &oddd']Alag'eFnd

(066
dtrdd €Fd aqa:eaar,
do@qd, E<r6ad.

edert
D ap&sd goqDE&, d#^d: &Prf db<€&'
zl effiFllb; '€eri" d)6&o.
, cDd qF.EAroorJgr,-fusi) €E "$at€' ceoe**!
4) #&qf, d:@&o aere$, Srxd:odo6 a<rga:,
(deBQaorld E$r$d)
;>w!
 $?
#.x
',
I
dastJd daasd

erda 4a. o<-FttS 20(K- diEsSd d+add dasd"JolJ

-adrdrdadr/ dlLd
erodd€&. dtipo* 3tjtO-ffi

d:d.o ed

Ado3r rfa;J orfu ed;rlde)-d. dr-a':dd ad-'.ab.,cu€fu duadcnd

trlrtja'€rdO aCotJdEdri grdaod &daa:d '4'

: - ---
rPd@Ord daoelJC eruaf, orotne,'oitr d0'idfudr-'
. erderJq..- .t),6od ,:
eroEabon - .pdo&rd d;roe{Jd oot\ Oqgiaoob 6[f
e'd6

da8l33939/l988do- 6uaod 22- 16-93 dod: S(ad "Ei&Fde?., dEliA, ?ldd

Ee&e a-d-'
Eas)addl. dJaoadlddcb eldd adoJ:uerJer.: apfrs-o.doa
sdd; eJ-dJ.rddoa8 de:€r tueArd S'e{dQ6-adrl'dr gorJd (€') domon
dxd-Dn abJ-. o5oed:rJq/dJ{ ' draoadoJ (er) ead:pd:rls'- dJt&'on d'o
aasreds){- qDdotc(ofutror/rrex (a) d:dd€od a'et &qd;J"tr* dcld:i'lad"e1
d' %a cidJ- rldd , c-udodcedaan O*
1"rt
EnddDglrdrkidr{ drfcfrd.ocoel dtd=i eads@Rt*-O,""'C orolreodr a9?ud''

ddo sjaar: s:/r:sd.d'r.d;@6t a-'-"':t'

.Errd dr)E\r;1udq er{oa 1:d'd .

epaondtr.+aer-. aueaaood.ld$j:a3a=idc +a4etit +o,*op11 c"q '

i. .ar:
ttNaA.
*ero , ze1z1OO;orro d*ide.rand' :d. qi dP
-t'ae)a6:4d olE€rd:
. :- i- '. -.

., a+oqrr eonqadoor er*r'fo-Or, c-.$i flq qTY d€ceq

6cdd aearq$1, reaoa 9l1*'€a{i,,o-ACpod;q]" d;5a-ondannd- ' '

,:.....1-.
.rsd esbxatrrlC Dd.,

t€bdrd -$+++tad exa:i*eqd*: s" . 9s8o(drfg qJF# oegcl'-.

. erap9C ,+ .esa<*S - .3o.3cr-drlf!!i{ E'be€
=o5ry,.q1:, -aqQro.la'':m:" e,
t-rdrd €e-dil'ldiir{ riorf€aJadr.ro a- ]iiadidt
i!ffig.---',-.;".r-.,--'.-^"...;----'+r';-=*,**-*---:,s"d-i-r!*ii"'a-; -- -ti-i;*' - -

egdob- oex, :dozroQC i'crDolr' ere

Eraorl{)cf .* rauo<-rd dad6trJcdl
(Ceuderoacr- zroal u&:edrrJC dodd.edrl ga'rerlele
r'J_:
U*r*rg arxq AeAdoO_
eecJ;$. dclr-d6b. er
'
aaxdxiCdrji-1iij",* "-
' : ___

ii,bbtindCo{6.aJ.x
dDodoEid.d<)€
rd.d ri a$ crtd)d.€dJ"jdd & drbe)d
d.oeritrtO.ar, 0e&SpAri
as:ar -de
eiozrdrir/idl{ dGBol)bn addex g?d(,ond_

4^g*-_
1o;e-oaf:e-#oarre<ny
ei@6, E-dorrEdgsiJrtu

&6eq n*"
rl
r) aade8d eroind-cb, afaxcql.
oea6, ,lradra.r,
2) 23etof,8 faorl_dr; ;.eart acl.,
"sareo
3) eruad eqrarra-e r-ooi-fdoa
t' 6drt} dcl., a$ g rleo
4) dtd5eerod, aio deo uaeic.,;,o,
ataei:lciiyodde8 doel€_ir,
$r6ade[J
9Plo-f.? (sgerqQ-oorJgr rrr eo6r)

5) dg* 6Jo g6rico,

.1.'
,1, -=-....=i:-.
1-" .'\. .,

! -.-

- ..,. -:::;i:-

.'.
 !..
ic

,::j:

#Fd
d@€'6Jd S@€ird deeextJ'
w
?a4* Grde 05 oe'6ege- 2007 .z:a*ArlO +{s,
dor&tadrr' 6iiaodJ60l2!q?'

d$.ecd
. S#drt
sol} tF"d .i&oed5lcels;do'-d aF\ruolr{o{p
q iio e'dd

.i1oa oe<lela;* c'q,' 6ooo*

t'"r,**- $*r-dd *'eEO e:dB lE def€$ 2006; 31J02006
'SoaE5
*3+*+i++**a+a

dF{^r''t a"dt'sSet4S.,Tr_TiT:.:ffi
, f€s*$
+,"r ".*ssd
rodr tSclojx2d t:D'i esso(dxl?{f d@JoQt4d
-';"*ri; * cs*o '"lada" oce{2 Ad*rsd
i€adra &!cdr .laa.oqdr fi;X"* -
do#6a*t' *nco "4*' €E$rtddl
-.

f",
,i#F&#.6"66'i"d'aard;; *oaasa* *r*r& ;;,g*q
t "teg
ilrod{so "@qqt
..
:.rq.dq}.sefr'(, oa"u*fc61 ";aO taax*roqrxlx
i ue+o+
d'eJdrJri> "dadf uP"t" €exdrl?rl'
JEa6@ 431-10-o6d *rU4..:":Xl- <ic6d:d
-oe,r:d a$ol#:. addmfl do8te)ld * ECoDaedo$ dodd 8:rd
e{grry{Edex t'd412
'*6xdrt?rr dE *ooot roolYooiairJa4oi C'#)dld edd dddryred
- (Redeem ed) trod" tstu'.drJ€d
c*rinri* 'tad{
osr10.06d d1dsdoJxr-d
d. J,a{SdrlVd}
*n*A*ta1 du-dFdd * d).ee>d O(Ad dJdl-
-'_1.,] .dqeJryn'eex<I €ede'oRd.
I

: ... .. (o# csdJ6cF/o6)

'-S@idd €F.! aqiedeq'
dorpod, edel- '

'9d0.L. . ' .

', l', ',,:,t) .e+ef paf"gg', *r*ao oed' d#€dl

. ,;'..2;ft@$.id,1 aearl' eg 'arato' , - '
.- '.- 3) ':GNd &FrEQ;od$,'ecat' e4, aoafea
: " ;i''64*r.;alaelo ete€ir- |fry
: ,. TIEP'
ei'iatat'its:3ra4o-

:. i-,.., :'1*efypqrfu dr6::d).

_l
g diri* t'fr3r*r;

I
.j'
r.- ;-1' ;.. ;. . .
,',.,.{I$I9-! e2

--, '
-.,---a.:"
,
-' :.,t- , ,: :
l._ :'.._,-:: . . '_ -
. ,: . .-.
i:5ffiC
 I

a-
C'
"-}"9
tuF0^}d ahed
?.
+scs+ e=e+-***pb,.-.
- . .q:=--<.EEi\
ardE$darJd Ald-
dqjd€&, 6eod lr02l2010,
eid.ged

dertJd Cra *.a$ &x

da,
1964d 79 eru &Eed edeod a$rdrJrrud
':* ."qI" 4 eg""ry.*"ma
:?.TY, -EdFca$d
$otlod, "irr**oq &Eedd drc.o.r
ebde> * **odaB eseftad
TY1 ""*4n
"}"Dad$d

' " Notwithstanding anything conained in

sub_section /1)
!u. subject ro such general or.p"e.ir, o.d..,
by the S'.ate Governintnt_fromtime to d_.
iliffi.iffi#
ar1
il ;;fu;;;;;
leing enjoyed eithcr by custom or under any order such as
. pd$.ryr _in respecr of Kumki lands, Bane lands and Kane Iands
in South Kaaara District, Betta lands and Hadi
. North Kznara District, Kan and Soppina
l"rd. i""dJ;
n"{" L;. i ;;;;;
Area, Jamma ,qi 8r,,. i. c.;;-6';;;lia
. laods) in Hyderabad Area shall .oiur,,.r".,, 1r'oorrhrl _.t

'. oqg eflxd:rlcd1 aoadn do#do*.J9rt/4qrJerr anoer_cd)

:* "+dtu€ sa? q a:aa,rs *.A
Y" ry-
erdca, #o6E a"Crfooadl{ufocj drq
qq ""gr- tsooa t:oxis €eE
Od;d"tu *""""-;*;
dDq ru dFFCrd *ooerU:sS,cicH ;ddr__"dr€*_
sod drcaroos
dSoaoic&soub Central Empoveri:d Committee(CEC) .tuod
f:*|laJal Ettqd .sd |*?1, Sr".iE **
er?9c

""i-eaxd
Y T{ T$"*q -g P qT"d .,E"ie a,oarrou,- ";d
arDa&{Ehq
€q& CEC atuo.J e,.eF *gO6,.i, eug o{:i6 *;;
^tt)
oc,, iiE"€cE a)oadmd) e.lddl CEC .l cd8erc3,
JoQ;;
d3 d,@d €bod s&], .dSrd
*l fr*.tl &ldb. ds ddodod
EdEiadeDnd:_

. . -]fccolding to Second proviso below section 9a(B) ofKLR

^4'ct..I964 where prior approval or ure centrar Go,.. under
section 2 of t]le Forest
or1e8o),",-*;.;-f;:H:,',X?Tf ;Hrj:.!.,.il.,T"1T.7
such grant shall nor be'made *itlr""t ;r;'iprior approval.
Ttrerefore ir is true that consuttad;;j;;;roval
Govt. is mandatory dnd generally of Central
- --- v
-rrr ' qj is being taken
in drefrrest areas." """nlppJi"l

I
i
 )
3. 60# *)Dd €ddqrld CE€ deod S,ttne-dt rsS'ed:dod
qpd+.jl rrdDe)JrrJC (contentions) zxi adnnb e(Ddoi t
eleeqgi dr-€#od-tsoEfffiFlD@ - .:=_=_-.
-:1...:. -iF

1) Whether kumki, Kan, Bana, E}etta, Soppin betta, Jamma

Bane, Jamma Malai are forest lands?
2) W'Mrer hmitefpriviiege--" ctrstorndfrry-afi6frAnT6 the
adjoing land owners to :-
(a) us4.leaves, twigs etc., for green mannure;
(b) minbr timber for self use for agricultural equipments, house
construction;
(c) grazing of cattle; (d) righ t to use fruit, etc.,
entititle them to alianate, sell or ottrerwise exercise proprietaqr right
over such lands?

4 dxqod ero#C zcrl uododr qeodod:o dr 8ttsodod {*eddm JeEd:

i
" In viqw -of the provision of section 79 of the Karnataka
[.and Retenue Act 1964 and ruling reported in .1971
MySijre lawjournal short note 125 Division Bench in case
of Padma Shedthi -Vs Mysore Revenue Appellate ,

Tribunal, the Hon'ble High Courlof Karnataka held that

Kan, Bena, Betta, Soppinbetta, Jamma Bane, Jamma
Malai are the Forest lands."

" The persons- having privileges of these lands would be

having limited rights of enjo5rme4t in respect'ii['.the supply
of leaf manure firewood and timber.-' required for
agricultural and domestic . purpose of cultivator. Such
persons cannot exercise their-proprietary rights'over such
lands as tJrey are not the owners of such lands. These
lands are Forest lands.

" Such persons have no rights to alienate, sell or

otherwise exercise tJle proprietary rights for suth lands."

But as per proviso to section 94(B) (t) of Karnataka Lind

Revenue Act 1964, where the prior approval of the
Central Govt. under 'section 2 of the Forest Conservation
Act 198O (Central Act 69 of !98O) is required for grant of
.snch grants shall not be
made-witliout--sueF+.pproval. "
-

t.
 ',1
,lJ
-,:l ,te
4/
"ifl
-=,:!

ln c 5. ffitd]d mru a"qcruqerte 5i5 _r,* e6

;ixd
Sdid.xHodtld:
:i --Feqdc kqu.;+3 eEd6 aEd
efrr-; 9.** fuU
<lreo$d &qdo$e* @rta Lj}:C oct eFd4i1 -.&@S,lrt;j .iexffi
En)od
8o.{dot{ &oEJ &boedd eed$dl8 .CroS.&
eo# Sd er."+dd{
l;i edrEc*B
7 T*q djadTbtu Otft.*ioro*fo ooeD@A ds drood oeF
i cqordorJgrJ -
.: {deiidca &edejDnd.

:.I
i
I (rg-o?f.il-d@o$6aq0r)
,{
t
I
;dlrorcH u-dolrciaE
I dor>on qenad_
ed0.1
t. ocl ec&6d.eroirg&ri9rl
L oeD ?9eroAr-d0rjgr1.
3. o<D eruEi SeprEqjE-dO.rA.L

4. o<D #A<Bddi-J€r3,
5. edaido €.SrJd)-

I
!
 )
t

t
 go.
fu6Ud ahFd
C
i,oa{ : ercF a l0l o€r.r*a. 2005 dG6Lrd SaF-dd

*ctJqsd)' 6ffid O3/O5l?0t0.

$doed

d-od.oi$ etDdo$ er4deob ajdcl: eeddod 6kd.J .dodde} drag CcaEolr

SJhqdffil r:* eq1 ddF$d ?j,a domos roc& t%4d doo 712_tsOJ SdeaC
d8d erAx rlead dr&3, an.d, ?nd, ,JtJ 8ry.J0) ...S"
"*t zr$xi$rttr
ie.xQS.dod d.odad(Dnd)d d) iossot dr8 red &ltl02l20t0e)_f, aC,ou^tdrJt'dl
ddreactj uiao.i zrd)dcd d)dl drroad er&d do6dx,ddrt e*la-"oSAaOddod

.trk
aEPder-dn
+lnd,i€ed(D6.J

domog ecD€d.
Edo.3
. I o€.D €*Ad uo1xd6.Je.i,
2. o(D a9e*e6-dori?r1,.
3. oeD erud &,Drrde6-doderi,
4. a(D ddaR&ddr.Jed,
5. e6znd0 €Addr.
6. a3€: dod, docDol) dd6ad (,aj 6oobF.JaFrld)

i
*
 c

1
+
#
i.i

\s\
I
{
\
arb€d

,*Art *.ua *i*msoU

.l-l:do.* #-c-ao, . cJiiili$@.Jd:*la+

(
i

I
Bq3):9*9, ;iiasc
d(Jo
fl ry <rOq-rd-Jdirr,*aqf".+d & e$+ a aJrira
S"-t,-{.ry, eefr.e trnilb,lo dee 't+g ,ifra;,; ::+qe_o.r,pO,, rsagsl
3qE
<aposryfl e'd.etkb.q.;tt,d.l'r6"E a+"+ *1"+p'.4pa-
F.UlSfF *,i1a5.qec6 e,*xcr'e.'-x4ngs*$ dqpqa .f"n W"*
grq ltprubl$-q*ryq$t-q,r,"et&rtqe'iF4p_.*.r. * ia saje6"5 l+s,a *r
a*Fsq itri:il1Adrqo6:ps2 ce4prn6d.t.rt O 'l
*io*xr*. Y
-:1

(
ahr.Eld €qDJ rroobs'dDeridr,
ili'lr , 6bcEol-) eeDs6.
:.-",-;
'rrl*
2). -g8r$eTlqEaorlCr-
,l iql;o{$ry3q994q

rj

.' r :_-: _1: a, '

USLG.1&2