W&E Oct 2022 - Compressed
W&E Oct 2022 - Compressed
W&E Oct 2022 - Compressed
A TED SER
IC V
CENTRAL BOARD OF IRRIGATION & POWER
D
IC
DE
NEW DELHI
95
Years
15 www.cbip.org
Manual on SUBSTATION AUTOMATION SYSTEM
Publication no. 345 cost : Rs. 2000/-
To achieve the objective of bringing out manuals, CBIP constituted an Expert Group under the chairmanship of Shri
S.G. Patki, Former Chairman CIGRE National Committee on Protection & Automation and Former VP, The Tata Power
Company, and Members from all eminent organizations/utilities and consultants. The Expert Group has made laudable
efforts and after a gap of more than 3 years of untiring work has recently prepared the Manual on SUBSTATION
AUTOMATION SYSTEM which is a unique document. This publication contains the following eight chapters:
1. Introduction and Context 5. Migration Strategies
2. Requirements of Substation Automation System and 6. Testing and Validation
Functional design specifications 7. Cyber Security Management Systems
3. Basics of IEC 61850 standard for SAS 8. IEC 61850 Process Bus and Digital substation
4. Communication Protocols and Architectures
Manual on Substation
Publication No. 342, cost : Rs. 3,500/-
CBIP published first edition of the “Manual on Substation Layout” in 2006. The manual has been well appreciated and
is widely used by engineering fraternity. Taking into account the technological developments and revision in National/
International standards, it was deemed necessary to revise the document on Substations in a comprehensive manner.
CBIP constituted an Expert Group headed by Shri S.K. Ray Mohapatra, Chief Engineer, Central Electricity Authority to
revised and rename the ‘Manual on Substation Layouts’ as ‘Manual on Substation’ to cover various aspects of Substations.
Representatives from various utilities across the country, comprising manufacturers, Power utilities, R&D and Testing
organizations were associated as members of the Expert Group.
New chapters on Type of substations, General Requirements, insulation co-ordination, Erection & Commissioning, New
Technologies, Refurbishment and upgradation / uprating of existing substations, safety, Life Cycle Management etc. have
been included for the benefit of prospective users. Copy of this document is available for sale and can be had by sending
demand draft/cheque for Rs. 3,500/- drawn in favour of Central Board of Irrigation and Power, New Delhi.
Monthly Journal Publisher, Printer and Editor Mr. A.K. Dinkar on behalf of Central Board
of Irrigation and Power, Printed at M/s Chandu Press, D-97, Shakarpur,
Monthly Subscription Rs. 200/-
Delhi, published from Central Board of Irrigation and Power, Malcha
Annual Subscription Rs. 2400/- Marg, Chanakyapuri, New Delhi 110 021
Energy Section
274 Right of Way (ROW) Challenge in Construction of Transmission Lines & its Mitigation in India –
Rajesh Gupta and Harshal Malewar 31
275 HR Digitalisation and Artificial Intelligence Research Trends in Water and Energy Sector –
Anurag Sharma, Ruchi Tyagi, Ashutosh Verma and Aparup Paul 35
276 Effect of Rural Electrification on Economic Growth and Development of Rural Odisha:
An in-Depth Empirical Study – Bijay Kumar Mohanty, Pravakar Mohanty and
Prof (Dr.) Sasmita Samanta 43
– Extract Discussion of Experts …. on Power Engineers Whats-App group
“SPARK…Ignited to Share” 49
news letter
Water Resources Section
– International Dam Safety Conference, 10-12 October 2022, Jaipur, Rajasthan 54
Energy Section
– Hands-on training on Power System Network study and analysis, 28-30 September 2022 61
– Training Program on Cyber Security, 3-4 October 2022, BBMB, Nangal 63
– 13 National Conference on Earthing Systems, 17-18 October 2022, New Delhi
th
65
– Training Program (online) on Regulatory Framework in Power Sector, 22nd October 2022 70
statistical data
• Water Resources Section 73
A.K. Dinkar
Secretary, CBIP
Abstract
Trash racks are comprised of an array of metal bars used in irrigation canals, water intakes, pumping stations, penstock
intake and other hydraulic structures to prevent the floating and submerged material that may cause damage and
operational problems to the hydraulic turbine and its other components, and subsequently result in efficiency reduction of
hydropower plants. When trash racks get clogged with trashes, it will lead to excessive head loss which results into loss
of revenue. In case of large head loss, it will result into cavitation problem in pump. Thus, hydraulic head loss is one of
the governing parameters in designing trash rack. Many past researchers have given their valuable contributions towards
performance analysis of trash rack cleaning systems. In this study, Computational Fluid Mechanics (CFD) modelling of
trash rack installed in the channel has been carried out and it has been concluded that as the blockage in trash rack
increases, losses increase abruptly. Outcomes from the CFD modelling shows that about 10% blockage of trash rack
can cause reduction of 4.3% in head. Similarly, for 19.75%, 28.89%, 37.53%, and 45.68%, blockage causes reduction in
heads are 5.54%, 6.90%, 9.22%, and 11.94% respectively. Apart from these values of trash rack blockage, head loss can
be calculated for any amount of blockage area using CFD modelling. So timely cleaning of trash rack should be done for
better performance of trash rack.
Key Words : Head loss, Trash rack, CFD, Blockage, Small hydropower
1. INTRODUCTION of India in both public as well as private. The hydro power plants generally consist
The development of a country depends The involvement of private sector in of components including diversion weir,
on the availability of various energy small hydro projects was started during intake structure, trash rack, desilting
resources and capability to extract the 1995 - 96. Since then private sector is tank, channel, forebay tank, penstock,
energy from these resources. We can playing an important role in developing power house. As the energy requirement
get energy from both renewable as well hydro power in India. Government is is increasing day by day, we need to
as non-renewable energy resources. also providing many opportunities for construct large number of small hydro
Unfortunately, we are more subject to the private sectors. In India, hydropower power plants every year. So, we need
non-renewable power source assets, for projects having installed capacity up to to construct intake structures in order
example, coal, oil, and petroleum gas. 25 MW station are categorized as small to convey clean water to the turbines.
These non-renewable power source hydropower (SHP) projects. They are With the flow of water, a large amount
assets are limited and environment further classified as Mini, Micro and Pico. of trash comes which if not stopped, can
condition are getting worse day by day. Classification of hydropower plants on damage the blades of turbine. This can
So, there is a need to utilize renewable the basis of installed capacity is shown be achieved by introducing trash racks at
resources efficiently. Among renewable in Table 1. the intake structures. The layout of trash
resources, hydro power shares the largest Table 1 : Classification of hydropower rack is shown below in Fig. 1.
contribution [1]. Hydropower plants utilize plants on the basis of installed capacity Xiang et al. [2] assessed trash catch
the flowing water to generate energy in effectiveness under 16 diverse trash
S. Types of Capacity
the form of electricity. Now-a-days, one rack arrangements, which incorporate 4
No. Hydro Projects
of the important resource of generating bars separating and 4 inclination angles,
renewable power is small hydro power. 1. Large >100MW under two stream velocity. Novik et al. [3]
For remote and inaccessible locations/ 2. Medium 25-100MW contributed towards contrasting option to
areas, small hydropower projects can be 3. Small 1-25MW physical or programmed cleaning which is
significant aspect for the improvement of the pressure driven idea of back flushing,
4. Mini 100KW-1MW
the overall energy scenario of India. The in which trash from the waste rack are
development of small hydropower project 5. Micro 5-100KW removed and flushes it out of a flushing
is excessively encouraged by Ministry of 6. Pico <5KW conductor to the contributing waterway.
New and Renewable Energy, Government Novik et al. [4] provided knowledge of back
1. Professor, Department of Hydro and Renewable Energy, Indian Institute of Technology, Roorkee
2. M.Tech Student, Department of Hydro and Renewable Energy, Indian Institute of Technology, Roorkee
3. Project Fellow, Department of Hydro and Renewable Energy, Indian Institute of Technology, Roorkee
that can quantify the water level of hydropower station channel trash rack before the dam.
method (FEM) which in turn can reduces
the computational time. Therefore, the
optimization of a simplified real water turbine trash-rack is also
present study carried
aims out to produce
to determine the the
effect on head loss due to change in the
section that yields the fewest head losses for a given configuration.
percentage of blocked area of trash rack
through CFD modelling and to develop
On the basis of above literature review, it has been found
correlation betweenthatblockage
the hydraulic
area andperforma
head loss.
trash rack has not been studied with the help of finite element method (FEM) which in tu
2. STUDY AREA AND DATA
reduces the computational time. Therefore, the presentCOLLECTION
study aims to determine the effect o
As per the requirement of the CFD
loss due to change in the percentage of blocked area of trash rack through CFD modelling
modelling of channel and trash rack,
physical
develop correlation between blockage area and head loss.parameters of trash rack are
needed. For this purpose, Mohammadpur
Power House, situated in Uttarakhand
2. STUDY AREA AND DATA COLLECTION state of India was selected. Mohammadpur
Power Plant is situated at main Ganges
As per the requirement of the CFD modelling of channel and trash rack, ph
canal, and south of Manglaur town, which
is at latitude of 29°42′12″N Power
77°51′38″E. It
Fig. parameters of ofof
trash
Fig. 1 : Schematic Trashrack
Rack are needed. For this purpose, Mohammadpur House, situa
1: Schematic Trash Rack has the capacity of 9.3MW. It consists of
flushing which is a proficient option for in pumped storage plants while pumping,
huquancleaning
et al. [6] calculated
trash racks at SHP. flowUttarakhand
Cheng fields at the
et al. [5] state of tube
thedownstream
draft Indiaor was selected.
of trash
tailrace must rack Mohammadpur
alsoand three Kaplan
havethe loss of head Power Plant
turbine is situated
generators 3.1 MW at main G
each working at a design head of 5.8 m
outlined another compose measurement the provision of trash-racks. Lucin et al.
ed by trash rack framework
and control blockage.which canal,
Armitage and
relies upon
south
et al. of
[7]carried
[10]
Manglaur
identified thetown,
mainwhich
out 2D simulations factors
for
is at (19
latitude
ft.). Theof
variousinfluencing the
29°42′12″N
discharge for which77°51′38″E.
the power It h
plant has been designed is 255 m3/s
ultrasonic sensor, that can capacity quantify the cross sections for a of variety
threeof Kaplan
trash- turbine generators 3.1 MW each workin
t of trashes
waterwhich
level of find its way
hydropower theof
intochannel
station
9.3MW.
waterrackways
Itand
designs
consists
insuggestions
order to gain are made (9,005
a better
cu ft. /s). As this location is near
for reducing
to Haridwar which is a holy place, a large
trash rack before the dam. design head of 5.8 m (19 offt.). The et discharge for which the power plant has activities,
been designed
understanding how energy losses are
uantity through catchment litter management. affected. Nascimento
Because head loss al. [8] studied
reduction due about
amount the
of trash due to religious
Shuquan et al. [6] calculated flow fields at is generated which ultimately goes to the
ms of trash-racks
the downstream of trash rackm3/s
of hydroelectric (9,005
andpower
the cu
lossplantsto ft. /s).section
cross
and As
his this
effort location
change
is is near
is highly
associated to
reliant Haridwar
with the damage
canal. which
If these is a holy
trashes place,
are not a large amo
captured,
of head produced by trash rack blockage. on trash-rack configuration, optimization
they may fall over turbine blades which
trashthedue to religious activities,
of a simplified is generated
real water whichmay
turbine trash- ultimately goes to the canal. If these trash
ms of trash-racks
Armitage et occurring at hydroelectric
al. [7] identified main power plants agitated by the water crossing
cause damage to the turbine blades
factors influencing the amount of trashes rack is also carried out to produce the and other equipment. At the same time,
not captured, they section
cross may fall over turbine blades
headwhich may cause damage to the turbine blad
h them, which
and with theway
find its analysis
into the of virtual
water waysmass effect onthatthe yields the fewest
natural frequencies along with
machines are required for trash rack
and suggestions are made other for reducing losses for a given configuration.
equipment. At the same time, machines are required for trash rack cleaning operation in order to reduce
cleaning operation in
hapes and
trashsize of the
quantity trash-racks.
through catchmentThe litterintake-structure
On the basis of interaction
above literature effect on hydro
review, head loss elastic
caused by blockage of trash
management. Nascimentotoetreduce al. [8]head lossbeen
it has caused found by that
blockage of trash rack.
the hydraulic rack.The Thespecifications
specifications of Trash
of Trash rack rack u
on assembly
studiedhas been
about thecomprised
problems ofin trash-the model and theof characteristics
performance trash rack has notofbeen model usedhave been
at Mohammadpur Power Station is
racks of hydroelectric power Mohammadpur
plants and studied Power withStation
the help is of
shown
finite below
elementin Fig.
shown 2 below
and Table
in Fig. 2.
2 and Table 2.
ined keeping
his effortinismind that the
associated withsystem
the damage to be submerged in water and in air. Xueping et al. [9]
problems of trash-racks occurring at
about power plantspower
hydroelectric whichplants use conventional
agitated by source of energy where trash-racks are installed
the water crossing through them, and
ntakes with
to guard the turbines
the analysis of virtualagainst
mass effect heavy trashes. To protect the equipment in pumped
on the natural frequencies along with
plants while pumping,
mode shapes andthe draft
size tubetrash-
of the or tailrace must also have the provision of trash-racks.
racks. The intake-structure interaction
et al. [10] carried out 2D simulations for various cross sections for a variety of trash-rack
effect on hydro elastic vibration assembly
has been comprised in the model and
s in order to gain a better understanding of how energy losses are affected. Because head
the characteristics of model have been
ductiondetermined
due to keeping in mind change
cross section that the is highly reliant on trash-rack configuration,
system to be submerged in water and in
air. Xueping et al. [9] studied about power
plants which use conventional source of
energy where trash-racks are installed at
the intakes to guard the turbines against
heavy trashes. To protect the equipment Fig. 2 : Arrangement of trash rack at Mohammadpur Power Station
8 After meshing
WATER and ENERGY of the domain,
INTERNATIONAL it is
October 2022 required to check the mesh quality. For better results, quality
A - 270
parameters such as skewness, orthogonality and aspect ratio should be within permissible limit.
parameters such as skewness, orthogonality and aspect ratio should be within permissible limit.
For this purpose, skewness is checked and kept below 0.85 for appropriate result. For solver
w&e internatioNal (Water resources section)
setting, input data provided are mass flow rate at inlet and pressure at outlet. The contour of
pressure velocity through trash rack is shown in Fig. 5
4. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
In this study, the results obtained through
CFD modelling of channel and trash rack
is carried out to determine the effect of
blockage area on head loss.
5. CONCLUSION
Fig.
Fig. 7. 7%: %
Error between
Error betweennumerical
numerical and Theoretical
and theoretical result
result The CFD modelling of trash rack helps
to visualize10that the increase in blockage
As shown in Fig. 8, second order where, A0 is constant, and its value is area of trash rack affects the head loss
4.3 Correlation
regression for the head
plotted loss prediction
between ‘ln (HL/H)’ 1132.52. abruptly. It has been found that for
The highest power in a second order values
and ‘ln (AB/A)’ provides the of is Substituting
equation two and thethe
relationship
obtained between A0, 10%
value of variables in blockage of trash rack, there is a
ugh numerical
constantanalysis
‘A0’, ‘A1’and andusing developed
‘A2’. Putting the correlation.
the developedAll results obtained
correlation using
for defining the developed
reduction of 4.3% in head. Similarly, for
second order
valuesisofexpressed
‘A0’, ‘A1’ as;
and ‘A2’, solution can head loss in % is as follows. 19.75%, 28.89%, 37.53%, and 45.68%
relation be
lies within the ±1% deviation shows a good agreement between the predicted
achieved. andreduction in heads are 5.54%,
blockage,
y = A0 + A1 x HL/H + A2 x2
= 1132.52 (AB/A)-3.8956 exp
HL/H =A0 (AB/A) -3.89506
exp (0.7079*(ln(AB/ 6.90%, 9.22%, and 11.94% respectively.
ained numerical values. Therefore, the correlation developed is2)useful for the determination
(0.7079*(ln(AB/A)) of
In log form,
A))2) eq. 5.6 can be expressed as; The obtained CFD results are validated
d loss for different blockagelnratio. using IS 11388:1995 and the deviation
y = A0 + A1 ln(x) + A2(ln(x))2 or between numerical (CFD Modelling) and
ln y = ln(anti ln A0) + ln(xA1) + ln [exp{A2(ln(x))2}] or theoretical results (IS Code) has been
found below 8.64%. Further, a correlation
ln y = ln [anti ln A0 * xA1 * exp{A2(ln(x))2}] or is developed for defining the head loss in
2 %.
y = anti ln A0 * xA1 * exp{A2(ln(x)) }
HL/H = 1132.52 (AB/A)-3.8956 exp (0.7079*
As shown in Fig. 8, second order regression plotted between ‘ln (HL/H)’ and ‘ln (AB/A)’ provides
(ln(AB/A))2)
the values of constant ‘A0’, ‘A1’ and ‘A2’. Putting the values of ‘A0’, ‘A1’ and ‘A2’, solutionThe
candeveloped correlation provides the
head loss (%) for any percentage of
be achieved. blockage area in trash rack. All results
HL/H = A0 (AB/A)-3.89506 exp (0.7079*(ln(AB/A))2) obtained using developed correlation lies
within the ±1% deviation shows a good
where, A0 is constant, and its value is 1132.52. agreement between the predicted and
Substituting the obtained value of A0, the developed correlation for defining the head loss inobtained % is numerical results. Therefore,
the correlation developed is useful for the
as follows. determination of head loss for different
blockage ratio. In CFD modelling, we have
HL/H = 1132.52 (AB/A)-3.8956 exp (0.7079*(ln(AB/A))2) considered uniform blockage of trash
For this relation,Fig. 8.Fig.
Composite
R-squared 8 : value isplot
Composite between
plot
found 0.9996ln
between (HL/H)
ln which
(HL/H) andand ln
it (AB/A).
ln (AB/A)
makes rack. At site blockage of trash rack is non-
perfect relation between
uniform so analysis in CFD modelling can
percentages
Table of
4:area
Table blocked and
4 : Comparison
Comparison head loss
between
between thethrough
the trash
numerical
numerical andrack.
and Tablevalues
predicted
predicted 4 shows the
of values
of head
values obtained
loss. loss.
head be done by discrete blocking.
Numerically obtained Results obtained through % Error REFERENCES
Numerically Results obtained through
results developed correlation
obtained results developed correlation % Error [1] Renewables 2021 (REN21). Global
5.54 5.53 0.12 Status Report. 2021
5.54 5.53 0.12
6.90 6.94 [2] Fu Xiang, M. Levent Kavvas,
6.90 6.94 -0.64-0.64
9.22 9.22 9.14 Roger Churchwell and Z.-Q. Chen.,
9.14 0.830.83 “Corrigendum to ‘Experimental
11.94 11.94 11.98 11.98 -0.40-0.40
CONCLUSION
10 WATER and ENERGY INTERNATIONAL October 2022 A - 270
e CFD modelling of trash rack helps to visualize that the increase in blockage area of trash rack
w&e internatioNal (Water resources section)
study of debris capture efficiency Measurement and Control System hydroelectric power plant trash-
of trash racks’. Hydro-environ.,” J. Based on Ultrasonic,” vol. 542– racks due to fluid-dynamic exciting
Hydro-Environment Res., vol. 4, 543, pp. 194–197, 2012. frequencies,” Lat. Am. J. Solids
no. 1, pp. 59, 2010. [6] X. F. He Shuquan, Baoyun Qiu, Struct., vol. 3, no. 3, pp. 223–243,
[3] H. Nøvik, L. Lia, and M. Wigestrand, Shiji Chu, “IMECE2014-36617,” 2006.
“Horizontal trash rack - a new intake Numer. Simul. Flow Fields Head [9] Gao Xueping, Zhang Jiabao, Ye Fei
concept for efficient backflushing,” Losses Trash- Barriering Pump. et al. (2005). Numerical simulation
vol. 2, no. 2, pp. 81–90, 2014. Stn. BASED VOF Model, pp. 1–7, of trash rack for a pumped storage
[4] H. Nøvik, L. Lia, B. Rettedal, 2017. plant. Water Resources and
and L. E. Nielsen, “Hydraulics of [7] N. Armitage and A. Rooseboom, Hydropower Engineering, 36(2) :
backflushing for efficiently cleaning “The removal of urban litter from 61~63.
hydropower trash racks,” Can. J. stormwater conduits and streams: [10] Lucin I, Carija Z, Grbcic L,
Civ. Eng., vol. 41, no. 3, pp. 263– Paper 2 - Model studies of potential Kranjcevic L. Assessment of head
269, 2014. trapping structures,” Water SA, vol. loss coefficients for water turbine
[5] H. Y. C. and H. Wang, “Design 26, no. 2, pp. 189– 194, 2000. intake trash-racks by numerical
of Trash Rack Water Level [8] L. P. Nascimento, J. B. C. Silva, modelling 2020
and V. Di Giunta, “Damage of
ABSTRACT
Taste and odour play a significant role for deciding the quality of water by the consumers. Natural sources like algae,
decaying vegetation, bacteria, etc and man-made sources such as wastes from domestic, industrial and agricultural
activities produce different taste and odour causing compounds in water. In addition, different chemicals used during
water treatment process also contribute taste and odour in water. In this paper, the chemical compounds responsible for
different types of taste and odour in water, natural and manmade sources generating taste and odour causing compounds
have been focused. Various methods like chemical, biological and ecological used for the control and removal of taste
and odours in water have also been discussed. A combination of methods has been found as a correct approach for the
control and removal tastes and odours in water.
Keywords : Taste, odour, water, chemical, biological, ecological
1. INTRODUCTION sources (Wnorowski, 1992). Taste and juices and musts before fermentation
Drinking water industries need odour compounds are produced by and its presence has been associated
more innovative and cost-effective microorganisms (algae and bacteria) with partial presence of Botrytis cineria
technologies for treatment and or chemicals (wastewater discharge (Liato and Aider, 2017). In this paper,
purification of water. Taste and odour and chemical spills) in both surface research work carried out by different
have long been associated with the and ground water. Blue-green algae researchers to find out the sources of
suitability and safety of our drinking (Cyanobacteria/Cyanophyta), diatoms tastes and odours in water and their
water. For an average consumer, taste (Asterionella) and flagellates are the control and removal techniques have
and odour is the only way of determining most common sources of taste and odour been explained.
the safety of tap water (McGuire, 1995). compounds in surface waters. Geosmin
is produced from blue-green algae and 2. SOURCES OF TASTES AND
Taste and odour issues can be attributed
is very common in most surface waters. ODOURS IN WATER
to a number of factors including algae,
organics from decaying vegetation, In ground waters, these compounds are Taste and odour problems in water may
hydrogen sulphide, natural inorganics more often associated with salts, metals generate from a variety of sources.
like iron and manganese or water and minerals instead of microorganisms Whether a source of taste and odour in
treatment chemicals such as chlorine as reported by DiToro (2012). water is a natural or man-made is not
(Stevenson and Zipfel, 2018). The most Removing taste and odour compounds clear. Algae and decaying vegetation
commonly identified taste and odour from drinking water is a significant are the principal substances related to
causing compounds of biological origin challenge for water authorities natural sources (Sigworth, 1961). The
are geosmin (trans-1,10-dimethyl-trans- internationally. In particular, the most troublesome and objectionable
9-decalol) and MIB (2-methylisoborneol). compounds 2 methylisoborneol (MIB) situations are created by man-made
These are primarily responsible for the and geosmin can be detected by sources, such as domestic and industrial
earthy-musty odour in finished water and consumers as musty-earthy odours at wastes and agricultural activities
are difficult to remove by conventional levels as low as 10 ng/L. (Cook et al., (Hartung, 1960). The types of taste
water treatment (Ridal et al., 2001). 2001). These compunds represent and odour commonly reported in water
the primary compounds responsible and their sources are given in Table 1
Most of the tastes and odours problems ((Trojan Technologies, 2010).
are the result of human influence: for taste and odour present in surface
indirectly by rapid enhancement of the waters throughout the world (Reiss 2.1 Natural Sources
growth of aquatic organisms under et. al., 2006). The earthy-musty smell
produced by Streptomyces sp. is Algae, decaying vegetation, bacteria
eutrophication or directly by wastewater and others
dumping or accidental spillage as assigned to geosmin and is responsible
well as by agricultural runoff. The for the major organoleptic defects found About 60 algal species have been
most problematic condition at present in drinking water, fruits and vegetables reported as producers of substances
appears to be algal production of such as grapes, mushrooms, carrots, leading to taste and odours in water
earthy/muddy odours in eutrophied and beet. Geosmin is also found in (Sigworth, 1961). Safferman et al.
1. Prof. & Head, Department of Civil Engineering, School of Engineering, Babu Banarasi Das University, Lucknow (UP), India
Table 1 : Types of tastes or odours and their sources actinomycete propagation and cause
tastes and odours in water. Sulfur and
Taste or Odour Source
iron are the other inorganic constituents
Earthy Geosmin likely to create tastes and odours (Lin,
Musty MIB, isopropylmethoxypyrazine (IPMP), 1977).
isobutylmethoxypyrazine (IBMP)
3. CONTROL AND REMOVAL
Turpentine or oily Methyl tertiary butyl ether (MTBE) OF TASTES AND ODOURS
Fishy/rancid 2,4-Heptadienal, decandienal, octanal 3.1 Chemical Control
Chlorinous Chlorine
The amount of copper sulphate needed
Medicinal Chlorophenols, iodoform for control varies with temperature,
Oily, gas-like, paint Hydrocarbons, volatile organic compounds (VOCs) chemical characteristics of the water,
the types of organisms to be killed, and
Metallic Iron, copper, zinc, manganese
the species of fish present. In practice,
Grassy Green algae an arbitrary dosage is normally used in
waters having a total alkalinity equal to
(1967) were the first investigators to compounds are the most frequent or greater than 40 mg/1 (Lin, 1977).
submit evidence that geosmin (C12 problems encountered in public water A free chlorine residual of 0.2-1.0 mg/1 is
H22O) is produced by algae. Jenkins supplies. The organic compounds, effective in controlling many of the algae
et al. (1967) found odourous sulfur generated from the wastes of industries, species that cause taste and odour or
compounds produced from blue- cities, and agricultural activities are filter-clogging problems. It is believed
green algae blooms, which have been not only causing tastes and odours that chlorine is often effective against
identified as methyl mercaptan, dimethyl problems but also interfering coagulation those organisms that are most resistant
sulfide, isobutyl mercaptan, and n-butyl processes, damage ion exchange to CuS04 treatment (Coarchene and
mercaptan. During the decaying process media, and create chlorine and activated Chapman, 1975). Erdei (1952) reported
of vegetation, by-products can be carbon demand. In surface waters, the that coagulation eliminated much of the
produced that not only cause odours compounds may have an adverse effect taste and odour trouble related to algae.
in water but also stimulate the growth upon the biological food chain, cause Both the tannin content and odour
of other organisms, producing odours. off-flavours in fish flesh, and be toxic to number were reduced considerably after
Decaying leaves can produce phenols fish (Smith and Grigoropoulos, 1968). coagulation of river water.
(Allen, 1960). They can also be a source Synthetic organic pesticides cause
Chlorination has been long used for control
of nutrients for algae which can produce highly objectionable tastes and odours
of tastes and odours and for disinfection.
odour and taste-causing substances in water. Solvents used in many of the
Chlorination practices generally
(Silvey, 1953). Bacteria, algae, other pesticide formulations are also highly
encompass combined residual (chlorine-
vegetation, and actinomycetes are often odorous (Robeck et al., 1965). Phenol
ammonia, or marginal chlorination), free
interrelated in the production of tastes is the by-products of coal in steel or
residual as in breakpoint chlorination,
and odours. There are cases where chemical industries. Most household
super chlorination and dechlorination,
bacterial activity in relation to mineral detergents, as well as commercial
and chlorine-chlorine dioxide treatment.
matter are the chief causes of tastes and and industrial cleaners, contain alkyl
Efficiency of chlorination depends on
odours (Silvey, 1966). Iron bacteria have benzene sulfonate. Its presence in
the species of chlorine and the quality
been responsible for tastes and odours water is an indication of contributions
of water treated, especially organic
in groundwater as well as in water from man's activity because it is not
matter, pH, and temperature (Ryckman
distribution systems independent of the found in natural sources (Lin, 1977). The
and Grigoropoulos, 1959). The use
source of water (MacKenthun and Keup, severe tastes and odours created by a
of chlorine dioxide has been widely
1970). Salt water intrusion has been ruptured petroleum pipeline. Besides
accepted and satisfactory for many
a source of taste in water. The taste material from oil refineries, the periodic
water plants to control some forms of
threshold in distilled water for chloride discharge of wastes from paint and
algae and for taste and odour problems.
as sodium chloride, potassium chloride varnish manufacturers have caused
It costs approximately 50 percent
and calcium chloride were 210 mg/1, objectionable taste and odour problems
more than liquid chlorine (Augenstein,
310 mg/1 and 222 mg/1 respectively as reported by Hartung (1960). The
1974). Chlorine dioxide does not react
(Lockhart et al., 1955). introduction of significant quantities
with ammonia and its bactericidal
of nutrients, such as nitrogen and
2.2 Man-Made Sources properties are about equal to chlorine.
phosphorus, into a water supply may
It has been used for the oxidation of
Organics and inorganics indirectly cause tastes and odours. Such
iron, manganese, phenolic, and chloro
The odours produced by organic nutrients may stimulate algal growth and
phenolic compounds, and even for fish
poisons. It also has been used for algae Xia et al. (2020) found the optimal and MIB concentrations in finished water as
control (Morris, 1972). cost-effective treatment for complex a function of filter age, initial chlorine
Potassium permanganate has been odour control involved a 1 mg O3 per residual and contact time. GAC–capped
used for taste and odour control in litre pre-ozonation in combination with filters removed on average 60% of the
water supplies for a number of years. coagulation, sedimentation, and sand MIB and 80% of the geosmin from the
It is practical, effective, immediate, filtration, followed by a post ozonation source water after 2 and 12 months of
economical and need less numbers of with a dosage of 1 mg O3 per litre, and filter operation. However, testing after
equipment. Usually, a small amount of a granular activated carbon (GAC) 24 months operation showed reduced
permanganate is needed. The dosage process having empty bed contact time efficiency.
can be determined by a jar test (Lin, for 14 minutes. They verified this solution
UV peroxide is an advanced oxidation
1977). Vanone (2018) explained that by carrying out study for a period of
process that involves dosing hydrogen
powdered activated carbon (PAC) 6-month where all the odorants were
peroxide upstream of UV. UV irradiation
shows a lot of good features that make removed simultaneously.
converts peroxide to hydroxyl radicals
it suitable for treatment of MIB and Activated carbon is an effective which rapidly oxidizes organic
geosmin, such as its high removal adsorbent because it is a highly compounds. In order to provide effective
efficiency and its flexibility in the porous material and provides a large hydroxyl generation higher power
application. The greatest challenge surface area to which contaminants UV reactors are used for advanced
related to PAC use is the competitive may adsorb. As water passes through oxidation than used for disinfection
adsorption of natural organic matter, the activated carbon, organic particles alone. UV peroxide is found to be less
that decreases the adsorption capacity and chemicals are trapped through energy efficient when compared to
of carbon and consequently its removal adsorption processes that depend on ozone UV due its lower hydroxyl radical
capacity of MIB and geosmin. That’s why different factors like the surface area formation (Zoschke et al., 2012). UV
usually treatment with PAC is preceded and pore size distribution, the chemical peroxide is an appropriate technology
by a pre-oxidation stage that removes makeup of the carbon source, chemical that has recently been introduced in New
the competitive compounds. The most makeup of the contaminant, water pH Zealand for potable water treatment. UV
important drawback of pre-oxidation and temperature, and the length of peroxide has been installed in medium
treatment is the oxidation of PAC surface, contact or exposure time to the carbon and small sized water treatment plants
with reduction of its adsorption capacity, (Crittenden 2012). Treatments with PAC at Branxholme, Paeroa and Waihi.
caused by the oxidant used (for example or GAC are usually considered to be These installations have shown good
chlorine). Hence, a study carried out the best available technologies for the performance for the removal of taste
to find out the effect of an alternative removal of odourous terpenoids from and odour and have been successful
oxidant, like potassium permanganate, surface water, while oxidation by either in addressing public taste and odour
on PAC adsorption of MIB and geosmin. oxygen, air, or chemical oxidants, like concerns and the client’s operational
Accordingly, a strong interaction between chlorine, chlorine dioxide, ozone and requirements (Stevenson and Zipfel,
PAC and KMnO4 was observed causing potassium permanganate is believed 2018).
an increase of oxidant consumption as to be the best method for the removal
the carbon concentration increased. of sulfides and oligosulfides from
3.2 Biological Control
Ozone (O3) is a very powerful oxidizing groundwater (Ortenberg et al., 2000). From studies of biological methods
agent with over 1.5 times the oxidizing Ozonation and activated carbon filtration for the control of tastes and odours,
potential of chlorine. Ozone is relatively are amongst the most powerful tools to Hohen (1965) reported that an effective
inexpensive, but not as cheap as mitigate surface-water related taste and degradation of the metabolites of
chlorine. Presently, ozone is produced odour problems during drinking water actinomycetes and rapid reduction of
commercially by the reaction of an treatment. As for conventional ozonation, odour level by Bacillus cereus occurred
oxygen containing feed gas in an this process is capable to oxidize most when the bacteria were present in
electric discharge across two plates. of the taste and odour compounds to high concentrations (1.2 x 105 /ml).
Although ozone is both toxic and more than 50% under typical drinking According to Ho et al. (2007), biological
corrosive, it presents no safety and water ozonation conditions. However, sand filtration is an effective process
handling problems when equipment the use of conventional ozonation is for the complete removal of MIB and
is properly designed and constructed limited when slow reacting compounds geosmin through biodegradation.
(Lin, 1977). Experimented conducted have to be oxidized to a higher degree Furthermore, biodegradation rates
by Peter (2008) for the treatment of (Peter, 2008). PAC can effectively were increased when the biofilm had
lake water stated that ozonation is a remove MIB and geosmin when the been re-exposed to MIB and geosmin.
powerful tool capable to oxidize most of correct dose is applied (Cook et al., Four bacteria, a Pseudomonas sp., an
the taste and odour compounds more 2001). Ridal et al. (2001) reported the Alphaproteobacterium, a Sphingomonas
than 50% under typical drinking water efficiency of the conventional GAC- sp. and an Acidobacteriaceae member
treatment conditions. Based on study, capped filters to reduce geosmin and were identified as microorganisms most
likely involved in the biodegradation of treatment of taste and odour. UV peroxide, Sigworth, E. A. (1961). “The production
geosmin within the sand filters and also an advanced oxidation process shows of palatable water”, Taste and Odour
the bioreactors. good performance for the treatment of Control Journal 27, pp.1-8.
these water quality parameters. Certain
3.3 Ecological Control Hartung, H. O. (1960). “Effects of
types of bacteria oxidize the taste and
pollutants in water supplies — taste and
In many fertile lakes, blooms of algae, odour compounds. Nuisance growth of
odour”, Journal American Water Works
especially blue-greens, grow in such algae in reservoir can be controlled by
Association, 52(11, pp. 1363-1366.
an abundance that the water forms limiting incoming nutrients, sewage and
a pea soup consistency and color. treatment plants effluents, etc. Trojan Technologies, London, Ontario,
Odours, which at first may be grassy, Canada, (2010). “Taste and Odour-
hay like, and not particularly unpleasant, REFERENCES Causing Compounds in Drinking Water”,
become especially objectionable when McGuire, M. J. (1995). “Off-flavor as the https://www.resources.trojanuv.com/wp-
the algae decay. Floating windrows of consumer’s measure of drinking water content/uploads/2018/05/Taste_and_
algae sometimes are compacted into a safety”, Water Science and Technology, Odour_Fact_Sheet_RevSep05.pdf.
scum so solid that turtles and birds can 31 (11), pp. 1-8 Safferman, R. S., Rosen, A. A., Mashni,
walk on it. Lakes in this condition have Stevenson, D. and Zipfel, H. (2018). “UV C. I. and Morris, M. E. (1967). “Earthy-
no utility for bathing, boating, fishing, Peroxide – A New Zealand Approach, smelling substance from a blue-
or any other form of recreation. These Harrison Grierson”, https://www.waternz. green alga”, Environmental Science &
damages demonstrate clearly that algal org.nz/Attachment?Action=Download& Technology, l (5), pp. 429-430.
control is necessary and justifiable Attachment_id=3373
under certain conditions. Algae may Jenkins, D., Medsker, L. L. and Thomas,
Ridal, J., Brownlee, B., Mckenna, G. J. F. (1967). “Odourous compounds in
be controlled either by limiting their
and Levac, N. (2001). “Removal of taste natural waters, some sulfur compounds
unrestricted growth or by killing existing
and odour compounds by conventional associated with blue-green algae”,
algae. Local circumstances determine
granular activated carbon filtration, Water Environmental Science & Technology, 1
which procedure is more desirable.
Quality Research Journal of Canada, 36 (9), pp. 731-735.
When feasible, nuisance growths of
(1), pp. 43–54.
algae can be limited or prevented by Allen, E. J. (1960). “Taste and odour
limiting the area of shallow water in Wnorowski, A. U. (1992). “Tastes and problems in new reservoirs in wooded
reservoirs, by maintaining high water odours in the aquatic environment: A areas”, Journal American Water Works
levels, and by limiting incoming nutrients review”, Water SA, 18(3), pp. 203-214. Association, 52 (8), pp. 1027-1032.
from soil erosion, irrigation return flows, DiToro, J. A. (2012). A study to determine Silvey, J. K. G. (1953). “Newer concepts
sewage and treatment plant effluents, the feasibility of removing taste and odor of tastes and odours in surface water
certain industries, and other sources. causing compounds with modified and supplies”, Water & Sewage Works, 100
This type of approach is sometimes unmodified ultrafiltration membranes, (11), pp. 426-429.
called biological or ecological control and the influence of other water quality
(Bartsch, 1954). Occasionally carbon parameters on this removal, BSc Project Silvey, J. K. G. (1966). “Taste and
or clay is added to increase the turbidity Report in Environmental Engineering, odour — effect of organisms”, Journal
in reservoirs by restricting the passage Worcester Polytechnic Institute (WPI). American Water Works Association, 58
of sunlight into the water. This is called (6), pp. 706-715.
Cook, D., Newcombe, G. and Sztajnbok,
as 'blackout' treatment, which reduces MacKenthun, K. M. and Keup, L. E.
P. (2001). “The application of powdered
growth rates of algae or pond weeds (1970). “Biological problems encountered
activated carbon for MIB and Geosmin
(Middlebrooks, 1965). in water supplies”, Journal American
removal: predicting PAC doses in four
4. CONCLUDING REMARKS raw waters”, Water Research, 35 (5), pp. Water Works Association, 62 (8), pp.
1325-1333. 520-526.
Tastes and odours in water are
objectionable to human beings. Algae, Reiss, C. R., Robert, C., Owen, C. Lockhart, E. E., Tucker, C. L. and
decaying of vegetations, bacteria, and Taylor, J. S. (2006). “Control of Merritt, M. C. (1955). “The effect of
discharge of industrial and domestic MIB, Geosmin and TON by membrane water impurities on the flavor of brewed
wastes, agricultural activities generate systems”, Journal of Water Supply: coffee”, Journal of Food Research, 20
tastes and odours causing compounds. Research and Technology—AQUA, 55 (6), pp. 598-605.
Copper sulphate, chlorine, potassium (2), pp. 95-108. Smith, J. W. and Grigoropoulos, S. G.
permanganate, etc can control taste Liato, V. and Aïder, M. (2017). “Geosmin (1968). “Toxic effects of odourous trace
and odour in water. Pre-ozonation as a source of the earthy-musty organics”, Journal American Water
in combination with coagulation, smell in fruits, vegetables and water: Works Association, 60 (8), pp. 969-979.
sedimentation, and sand filtration Origins, impact on foods and water, and
followed by post ozonation and GAC Robeck, G. G., Dostal, K. A., Cohen, J. M.
review of the removing techniques”, and Kreissl, J. F. (1965). “Effectiveness
can provide optimal and cost-effective Chemosphere, 181, pp. 9-18.
of water treatment processes in pesticide Morris, J. C. (1972). “Commentary 11. Ortenberg, E., Groisman, L. and Rav-
removal”, Journal American Water Works Taste and odour control with sulfamic Acha, C. (2000). “Taste and odour
Association, 57 (2), pp. 181-199. acid (by W. B. Murray)”, Journal removal from an urban groundwater
American Water Works Association, 64 establishment - a case study”, Water
Lin, S. D. (1977). “Tastes and Odours
(4), p. 261. Science & Technology, 42 (1-2), pp.
in Water Supplies — A Review”, Illinois
123–128.
State Water Survey Urbana, ISWS/ Vanone, L. O. (2018). “Potassium
CIR-127/77, Circular 127, State of permanganate application together Zoschke, K., Dietrich, N., Börnick, H. and
Illinois, Department of Registration and with powdered activated carbon for the Worch, E. (2012). “UV-based advanced
Education. removal of taste and odour causing oxidation processes for the treatment of
compounds”, São Paulo, 2018, p. 71. odour compounds: Efficiency and by-
Coarchene, J. E. and Chapman, J.
product formation”, Water Research, 46
D. (1975). “Algae control in northwest Peter, A. (2008). “Taste and Odour in
(16), pp. 5365-5373
reservoirs”, Journal American Water Drinking Water: Sources and Mitigation
Works Association, 67 (3), pp. 127-130. Strategies”, DSc thesis, Swiss Federal Hohen, R. C. (1965). “Biological methods
Institute of Technology Zurich, 2008. for the control of taste and odours”,
Erdei, J. F. (1952). “Taste and odour
Southwest Water Works Journal, 47, pp.
problems during spring runoff”, Panel Xia, P., Zhang, S., Jianwei, Yu., Hui,
3-26.
discussion, Journal American Water Ye., Zhang, D., Jiang, L., Wang, Z. and
Works Association, 44 (12), pp. 1127- Yin, D. (2020). “Complex odour control Ho, L. Hoefel, D., Bock, F., Saint, C. P. and
1133. based on ozonation/ GAC advanced Newcombe, G. (2007). “Biodegradation
treatment: optimization and application rates of 2- methylisoborneol (MIB) and
Ryckman, D. W. and Grigoropoulos,
in one full‑scale water treatment plant”, geosmin through sand filters and in
S. G. (1959). “Use of chlorine and its
Environmental Sciences Europe, 32 bioreactors”, Chemosphere, 66 (11), pp.
derivatives in taste and odour removal”,
(50), pp. 1-12. 2210-2218.
Journal American Water Works
Association, 51 (10), pp. 1268-1274. Crittenden, J. C., Trussell, R. R., Hand, Bartsch, A. F. (1954). “Practical methods for
D. W., Howe, K. J. and Tchobanoglous, control of algae and water weeds”, Public
Augenstein, H. W. (1974). “Use of
G. (2012). “MWH’s Water Treatment: Health Reports, 69 (8), pp. 749-757.
chlorine dioxide to disinfect water
Principles and Design”, (3rd ed.), John
supplies”, Journal American Water Works Middlebrooks, E. J. (1965). “Taste and
Wiley & Sons, Inc., New Jersey.
Association, 66 (12), pp. 716-717. odour control in water”, Public Works, 96
(4), pp. 127-130.
Abstract
Numerous hydraulic structures are to be provided in all irrigation canal systems for conveyance of water. Conventional
hydraulic design of these structures are costly and their performance too are not satisfactory. Performance of the
conventional practice for hydraulic design of the canal regulating and cross-drainage structures has been critically
examined. Some innovative hydraulic design of a canal fall-a regulating structure and an aqueduct -a cross-drainage
structure have been suggested for achieving economy and efficiency.
Keywords : Canals, Hydraulic Structure, Performance, Economy, Efficiency
1.0 Introduction for conveyance of water from reservoirs to cost, canal is often flumed and combined
In 1947 when India woke to freedom, the tail end of the canal system. Numerous with regulators and local communication
the country was facing stark realties canal structures including cross-drainage bridges. They are used also for gauging
of recurring famines and floods. There structures (e.g. aqueducts, super of flow in the canal for which the flow
were hardly any moisture conservation passage, siphons, siphon aqueducts, upstream of fall should be proportional
or watershed programs or any storage level crossings) and regulating structures in order to maintain depth-discharge
to meet the water demands for domestic (e.g. drops/falls, regulators, flow meters, relation with a view to minimise afflux
use, irrigation, industries and hydro- escapes ). are to be provided in irrigation and avoid siltation upstream. Different
power etc. When India was partioned in canals for conveying , distributing and types of falls have been evolved over
1947, most of the irrigation schemes in management of canal water. Design the years depending upon the height of
the Indus valley went to Western Pakistan procedure for these structures have been fall and magnitude of flow. Where both
and India had only 22 million hectare outlined in several text books[4],[5],[6]; the flow and fall height are high and the
(mha) of irrigated area. Based on limited [7];[8];[9]);[10] and [11]. Conventional canal is flumed, it is customary to provide
experience and inadequate economic and hydraulic design practice as outlined curved glacis-type fall with stilling basin
technological strengths, India embarked in most of the textbook/codes/manuals as shown in Fig.1. A pair of transitions
on its journey into water world for the is not only costly but their performance are needed at inlet and outlet to connect
future. Up to the end of XI th five year too is not up to expectation. The author the flumed structure with original canal
plan, Govt. of India has executed large wishes to introduce some innovative and section,
number of river valley projects like DVC, efficient hydraulic design procedure [12]
for only two of them, namely 3.0 Improved Hydraulic
Bhakra-Nagal, Hirakud, Nagarjunsagar
Design of Canal Fall/
etc. mainly for irrigation purpose. India (i) Canal Fall/Drop - A regulating
has now around 6,000 large dams structure
Drop for Economy &
besides small and medium ones. The Efficiency
(ii) Aqueduct - A Cross-Drainage
current irrigation potential of India is about Structure In the conventional method of hydraulic
113 mha - 58 mha by major and medium design of a fall, fluming ratio is fixed
surface irrigation schemes, 15 mha by 2.0 Hydraulic Design of arbitrarily irrespective of inflow Froude’s
minor surface irrigation schemes and 40 A Flumed Canal Fall/ number (F1). Long length of inlet and
mha by minor ground water schemes Drop outlet transitions are provided to prevent
[1]. It is proposed to further increase the flow separation. Transition and dissipation
irrigated area by 35 mha by implementing 2.1 Brief Description of Fall/Drop structures are separate resulting in
river linking schemes [2];. 30 link canals Structure high costs of the structure. Hydraulic
are proposed to transfer water from water Innumerable falls/drops are to be provided performance of the conventional stilling
surplus regions to water scarce regions in irrigation canals where ground slope basin is not satisfactory as lot of residual
of India. exceeds the permissible bed slope of kinetic energy of flow leaves the basin
a canal. Fall structures are provided to resulting in flow distortion and scour
All these developmental schemes need
dissipate the energy of falling water from downstream of fall [13].
large number of hydraulic structures on
the main, branch and distributary canals higher to lower elevation. To minimize the
1. Former AICTE Emeritus Professor of Civil Engineering, Delhi College of Engineering (Now Delhi Technology University)
Canal falls are control structures which can be used also for measuring flow through the canal. In case the
play.
s regards expanding transition, a straight expansion with 3:1 side w&e internatioNal
splay provided with boundary layer(Water
control resources section)
evice [19]. performs better than Hind’s warped type expanding transition with an average side-splay 4.5:1
A - 272 5.0 Hydraulic Design of an Aqueduct WATER and ENERGY INTERNATIONAL October 2022 19
5.1 Brief Description of Aqueduct
w&e internatioNal (Water resources section)
that head losses in transitions and in the innovative hydraulic designs in respect Structures -Pt. II” 4th Edition, Pub.
flume are minimum to avoid excessive of a flumed canal fall and an aqueduct. CRC press (T&F), New York
afflux in the canal upstream of aqueduct. Scientific method has been introduced
7. Leliavsky, S. (1979). Irrigation
The transitions in the stream are to be to decide fluming ratio. Classical design
Engineering: Canals and Barrages.
designed to minimize losses to avoid of inlet and outlet transitions have
Oxford and IBH, New Delhi
harmful afflux in the stream. been replaced with new design. It is
recommended that warped type inlet 8. Varshney, R.S., Gupta, S.C., Gupta,
5.2 Transition Design for an transition should be provided with an R.L. (1977). Theory and Design of
Aqueduct average side splay of 3:1 in order to Irrigation Structures, vol. 2, Nem
The axial length of transitions depend on obtain highest hydraulic efficiency and to Chand, Roorkee
fluming ratio which may be found on the achieve economy. In regard to both canal 9. USDI (1967) “Design Standards No.
same priciples as discussed in section fall/drop and aqueduct, it is found that a 3 -Canals and Related Structures”
3.1, keeping in mind that excessive straight expansion starting from toe of United States Department of the
contraction may cause high head loss the glacis (in fall\drop) and end of flume Interior, Bureau of Reclamation,,
within the flume due to high flow velocity (in aqueduct), provided with suitable Colorado 80225
resulting in high afflux. For important appurtences or adversely sloping floor
to control boundary layer separation, 10. IS:7784 (2000) “Design of Cross
structures, Hind’s warped type transitions
performs much better. It is cheaper and –Drainage Works”, Sec-WRD-13,
are popular in USA and Europe. These
more efficient than the classical stilling Bureau of Indian Standards, Manak
are very costly because of long lengths
basins in a fall/drop and curved outlet Bhawan, New Selhi-110003
of transitions which are to be designed as
retaining walls. For contrating transitions, transition in a aqueduct where warped 11. CBIP(2008) “Manual on Irrigation
Jaeger type transition with 3:1 average shaped transitions of long long length and Power Channels”, CBIP
side splay will suffice. In fact, axial are provided. Publication No. 171, pub.Central
length of contracting transition may be Board of Irrigation & Power, Malcha
further reduced by adopting 2:1 average
References Mag, Chanakyapuri, New Delhi
side splay, since the efficincy loss will be 1. IWRS (2007), “ Role of Water
12. Mazumder, S.K. (2020a) “ Flow
meager (Fig.3).The classical design of Resources Development &
Transition Design in Hydraulic
the transition structures of long length Management in Bharat Nirman”,
Structures” pub. CRC Press , T&F
is not only costly, their performance too theme paper presented on Water
group, London, New York
are not satisfactory. Resources Day observed by Indian
Water Resources Society (IWRS) at 13. Mazumder, S.K. (2020b) Hydraulic
In regard to expanding transition at
ICID, New Delhi, May 9th. Jump Control Using Stilling Basin
the exit of an aqueduct, the warped
With Adverse Slope pub. online in
type long transition should be replaced 2. IWRS (1996), “Interbasin Transfers
ISH J. of Hyd. Engg. by Taylor &
with straight expansion provided with of Water for National Development
Francis, Sept.2020 (Now Available
suitable appurtenances[24] to control – Problems and prospects”, pub.
ISH J. of Hyd. Engg.,Vol.28, Issue-1,
boundary layer separation[12] tested by Indian Water Resources Society
Feb.2022 on Taylor & Francis
curved transitions of different shapes (IWRS) on the occasion of Water
Online.
with varying axial lengths and found that Resources Day-1996, org. by IWRS,
flow separated due to advrese pressure New Delhi 14. Mazumder, S.K. and Deb Roy,
gradient resulting in non-uniform velocity Indraneil (1999), “Improved Design
3. NWDA (2005), “Water for life”, 11th
distribution at the exit resulting in scour of a Proportional Flow Meter” ISH
National Water Convention, org.
of the tail channel. With the introduction Journal of Hydraulic Engg. Vol. 5,
by National Water Development
of suitable appurtenace or providing No. 1, March
Agency, Govt. of India Delhi, May
adverse slope to floor, flow diffused 11th 15. Hinds, J.(1928) “Hydraulic
comletely and the vlocity distribution was Design of Flume and Syphon
uniform at the exit with high hydraulic 4. Aswa,G.L. (2008),“Ïrrigation and
Transitions”Trans.ASCE,vol.92
efficiency. Scour in the tail channel could Water Resources Engineering”,
p.1423-.59
be eliminated completely by using either pub. New Age International (P) Ltd,
appurtenances [25] or by providing New Delhi-11002 16. Mazumder, S.K. and Ahuja,
adverse slope to the expansion floor K.C.(1978) “Optimum length of
5. Mazumder, S.K.(2007), “Irrigation
[23]. contracting transition in open
Engineering” pub. Galgotia
channel sub critical flow” J1. Of CE
publications Pvt. Ltd. Ansari Road,
6.0 Conclusions Div., Inst of Engr(I), Vol. 58, pt CI-5,
Daryaganj, Delhi-110002
A large numbers of canal structures March 78.
are needed for conveyance of irrigation 6. Novak,P., Moffat, A.I.B., Nalluri,C.
17. Mazumder, S.K. (1967). “Optimum
water. Author has introduced some and Narayanan, P. (1990) “Hydraulic
length of transition in open channel
expansive sub-critical flow.” J. IE(I), 1958, 84 (HY2), Paper no. 1616, p. 23. Mazumder, S. K., (2012) "Economic
XLVIII(3), Pt.CI 2, Nov :463–478. 41-56; 1958; 84 (HY-2), paper no. and Innovative Design of a Canal
1616, p.59- 75; 1958, (HY-5), paper Drop" paper Pub.in CBIP Journal
18. Jaeger,C. (1956) “Engineering Fluid
no. 1832, p.71; 1958, 84 (HY-5), ‘Water and Energy International’,
Mechanics” Pub. by Blackie and
paper no. 1832, p.77-81 vol.69, no.12, Dec. 2012
Sons, First. Ed
21. Hager, W.H. 1992) “Energy 24. Mazumder, S.K., and Naresh, H.S.
19. Mazumder, S.K., and Sharma, A.
Dissipators and Hydraulic Jump” (1988). “Use of appurtenances
(1983) “Stilling Basin with diverging
Klewer Academic Publishers, for efficient design of Jump type
side-walls” Proc. XX, IAHR
Netherlands. dissipaters having diverging side
Congress, Vol. 7, Moscow, Sept
walls for flumed canal falls.” J. Civil
5-7 22. Mazumder S.K. (2016) “Economic
Eng. Div. The Inst. of Engrs (I),
and Efficient Method of Design of A
20. Bradley, J.N., and Peterka, A.J. 68(pt.CI6, May).
Flumed Canal Fall” presented and
(1957) “Hydraulic design of stilling
pub. in Hydro-2015, International 25. Mazumder, S.K., and Rao, J.V.
basins-stilling basins with sloping
Conference on Hydraulics, Water (1971). “Use of short triangular
apron (Basin-V)”, Proc. ASCE, J.
Resources and Coastal Engineering vanes for efficient design of wide-
of Hydraulics Division, 83 (HY-5),
organized by Indian Society for angle open-channel exansion.” J.
Paper no. 1405, p.1-32; Discussions
Hydraulics, Pune, Dec. 8-10 Inst. Eng. (I),51(9), 263–268, Pt CI
5, May.
Abstract
Whey is a fairly dilute by-product of dairy industry manufactured during production of cheese and paneer. This research
intends to recover water from the whey using an emerging membrane separation technology, Forward Osmosis (FO).
Different inorganic salt solutions such as magnesium chloride (MgCl2), calcium chloride (CaCl2), sodium chloride (NaCl),
potassium chloride (KCl) along with sucrose and citric acid are tested as the draw solutions for maximum performance of
FO. Various factors affecting FO such as Feed/Draw (F/D) ratio, temperature and concentration of different draw solution,
mode and flow type of FO are varied to get the maximum output. Highest osmotic pressure solution of aq. MgCl2 shows
maximum water recovery of 93% with flux of 6.84 L/m2/hr followed by aq. NaCl solution with 89.5% dewatering and flux of
5.97 L/m2/hr in Co flow RC mode of FO. Further efficiency of FO reduces in the descending order for citric acid, calcium
chloride, sucrose and potassium chloride. Draw such as sucrose and NaCl can be reused in the dairy itself for various
purposes eliminating the need of draw regeneration. Thus, FO successfully performs to recover water from the whey and
consequently reduce the footprint on the environment.
Keywords: Dairy industry, draw solution, forward osmosis, recovery, wastewater, whey
1. INTRODUCTION Zablocka et al., 2019; Kenkar & Kadlag, In terms of whey utilization there are so
The global water resources scenario is 2016; Velpula, 2017). many things that can be done instead
changing fast in terms of access, quantity of treating whey as waste. It can be
Whey concentrated by evaporation and whey
as well as quality of available water.
Around 600 million people in India face Whey, a fairly dilute product with 90-94% concentrates can be dried using spray, roll
acute water shortages (Karimidastenaei water, is the by-product of dairy industry or drum dryers. Heat treatments denature
et al., 2022). Industries are one of the which remains after manufacturing of whey proteins thus lot of efforts are made to
important consumers of fresh water. Dairy cheese, paneer, chhana and casein study implementation of other processes
industry is one of the fastest growing (Baldasso et al., 2011; De Souza et al., instead of thermal treatments(Blandin
sectors characterised by the high demand 2010; Panesar et al., 2007; Prazeres et et al., 2020). The introduction of new
of resources particularly water(Agrawal & al., 2012). In India, the major source of separation technologies such as ion
Sarode, 2021; Boguniewicz-Zablocka et whey is paneer and chhana. Over 160 exchange, electrodialysis, ultrasound and
al., 2019; Del Re et al., 1998). It has one million tonnes of whey is generated membrane filtration created possibilities
of the highest water consumption rates annually worldwide and amongst it of producing new range of whey products
and is one of the major effluent producers around 5 million tonnes is generated including functional food ingredients with
per unit of production(Shete & Shinkar, annually in India itself (Wit.J.N., 2001). value added products for pharmaceutical
2016). Due to strict environmental rules, About 80-90% of milk used in production and medical industries(Aydiner, Sen,
a realisation is gradually emerging among of cheese and paneer yields whey as Topcu, Ekinci, et al., 2014; Duke &
such industries that rectifying measures by-product which contains 50% of milk Vasiljevic, 2015). Processing of whey is
needs to be undertaken to augment constituents comprising proteins, lactose, sometimes limited due to less demand of
fresh water through rainwater harvesting minerals and vitamins(Barukcic et al., whey and other related products. In the
and reuse and treatment of wastewater. 2019; Rektor & Vatai, 2004; Suárez et al., factories large quantity of milk and whey
(Baskaran et al., 2003; Bortoluzzi et al., 2006). Wastewater containing whey is are processed to form powder every
2017). Most amount of water is required difficult to treat by conventional processes year(G. Q. Chen et al., 2020). Whey
in the dairy by the plants producing milk because of poor settling sludge. Whey Powder production is usually done in
powder and cheese while less in plants has high BOD ranging from 30000 – multistage evaporator followed by spray
producing drinking milk(Agrawal & Sarode, 80000mg O2/litre(De Souza et al., 2010). or roll drying(Barukcic et al., 2019). Whey
2021). Dairy waste is either generated Environmentalist and technologists look is firstly concentrated to 40-70% total
from cleaning of equipment or generated seriously upon discarding of whey due to solids and then by the use of a spray dryer
during manufacturing of products or its potent polluting strength and significant or a roll dryer moisture is removed until
unwanted milk spillage(Boguniewicz- loss of energy and nutrients along with it. the final product reaches 5% moisture
content. 1/4th (25 per cent) of total energy used in treating industrial wastewater, and fructose are most suitable for food
is consumed in concentration and drying to concentrate landfill leachate, to treat and beverages applications(Garcia-
steps(Jevons & Awe, 2010). liquid food in food industry, desalinating Castello et al., 2009). The performance
seawater, purifying water in emergency of selected draw solute is evaluated in
Forward Osmosis relief situations and also has use in drug terms of water flux and water recovered.
Forward Osmosis (FO) is an emerging release in the body(Blandin et al., 2020; Increasing ranking order of draw solution
separation technology attracting Honmane et al., 2020; Phuntsho et al., based on performance is - CaCl2, KHCO3,
increasing attention of both scientific 2011; Pramanik et al., 2019; Shaffer MgCl2, MgSO4 and NaHCO3(Chekli et al.,
research community and industries in et al., 2014; Zhao et al., 2012). Dairy 2012; Phuntsho et al., 2011). Based on
the past decade. It works on principle Samples including milk, whey, D40 whey replenishment cost is - KHCO3, MgSO4,
of osmotic pressure gradient(Chou et (demineralized whey with 40% mineral NaCl, NaHCO3 and Na2SO4 and both
al., 2010). Through the natural osmosis removal), whey protein concentrate high in performance and cost-effective
phenomenon, it drives water from the and lactose are studied using FO in draw are KHCO3, MgSO4 and NaHCO3
diluted one to the concentrated stream literature works(Y. N. Wang et al., 2017; (Phuntsho et al., 2011). Draw solution
when separated by the semipermeable Zhao et al., 2012). Using 1M, 2M and containing scale precursor ions such
membrane (Fig. 1.1). In this technology, 3M NaCl solution, 4M NH4CO3, 60°Bx as Mg2+, Ca2+, Ba2+, So42-, CO32- has to
hydraulic pressure is required only for Potassium Lactate solution whey has be limited to applications where pure
lifting the solutions to the membrane. been concentrated using CTA and TFC water is required as feed such as food
Absence of external hydraulic pressure membranes(Artemi et al., 2020; Aydiner industry(Shirazi et al., 2010). These ions
results in lesser fouling potential et al., 2012; Aydiner, Sen, Topcu, Sesli, can promote scaling on the membrane
and ultimately in low operation and et al., 2014a; G. Q. Chen et al., 2020; surface. Reverse solute flux should be
maintenance cost(Al-Amoudi & Lovitt, George Q. Chen et al., 2019; Seker et al., kept minimum especially in applications
2007). Thinner membrane and pre- 2017; J. Wang & Liu, 2021b). where the final concentrated feed needs
treating the feed solution using processes to be pure. Draw solutions containing
like ultrafiltration tends to increase the
Draw Solution larger hydrated anions such as MgSO4,
water flux and efficiency of FO process(Ali Selection of proper draw solute is very KsSO4, NaHCO3, KHCO3, Na2SO4 shows
et al., 2018). The water and solute flux important for FO technology. Required the lowest Reverse solute flux(Artemi
th
through
es 5% moisture the FO
content. 1/4membrane depends
(25 per cent) of totalupon characteristics
energy is of a draw solution are
consumed in concentration et al., 2020). When reverse solute flux
s & Awe, 2010).
the effective osmotic pressure difference stability, nontoxic nature, high solubility, is inevitable, draw solutions compatible
between the surfaces of the active layer high molecular weight, low viscosity, low with feed solution should be used. For
of the membrane(J.
) is an emerging Wang &
separation technology Liu, 2021a).
attracting cost,
increasing easilyof
attention recoverable / regenerated with
both scientific example, while concentrating the fruit
Research
d industries in the pastin FO Itisworks
decade. crucial because
on principle a low pressure
of osmotic energy input, high osmotic pressure
gradient(Chou juice reverse solute flux using sucrose as
he naturalFO has phenomenon,
osmosis a future lying in sustainability,
it drives at low
water from the diluted one concentrations,
to the concentrated not adversely the draw solution does not have any major
by the semipermeable membrane
resource recovery and(refer
newFig.1.1). In this technology,
applications. affectedhydraulic pressure is of ions from
by contamination impact on stream value or sometimes
g the solutions to the should
Its focus membrane. be Absence
on closingof external
the loop hydraulic pressure
the feed results and
solution in lesser
minimal effect on it even adds value(Jiao et al., 2004;
ltimately by
in low operation and maintenance cost(Al-Amoudi &
recovering the substances both from internal concentration Lovitt, 2007). Thinner
polarisation(Achilli Phuntsho et al., 2011). Draw solutions
ting the feed solution using processes like ultrafiltration tends to increase the water flux
feed and draw solution. et al., 2010; Ahmed et al., 2018; Hu et al., such as sodium chloride and mixture of
rocess(Ali et al., 2018). The water and solute flux through the FO membrane depends
FO difference
motic pressure shows between
very promising
the surfaces ofresults 2017).
the active layerAnof ideal draw solution should be
the membrane(J. ammonia and carbon dioxide are used in
Research for
in FOconcentrating
is crucial because FO has a future
wastewater andlying in sustainability,membrane.
benign to the FO resource It should not the previous works(Aydiner, Sen, Topcu,
ications. Its focus should be on closing the loop
dewatering difficult to treat wastewater. by have
recovering theany solute
substances membrane
both from interaction as Sesli, et al., 2014b; Garcia-Castello
It finds applications in every field. It is it will lead to scaling complications and et al., 2009). The reverse diffusion of
create excess membrane cleaning costs these solutes from the draw into the
(Ahmed et al., 2018). feed cannot be eliminated. It results in
Choice of draw directly affects the production of concentrated products and
draw recovery method. Different types it do not meet product specifications(K.
of available draw solute are classified Y. Wang et al., 2011). The back diffusion
as inorganic salt, organic salt, organic of ammonium carbonate inevitably adds
compounds, volatile compounds and new compounds that do not exist in the
other responsive solutes. Inorganic natural form of milk or whey(McCutcheon
salts such as NaCl, MgCl2, KCl, Na2SO4 et al., 2006).
etc have high osmotic pressure, low In this work, after thorough understanding
replenish cost and can be recovered of whey, forward osmosis and different
using NF/ RO/ MD process(Shon et al., draw solutions it is tried to recover water
2015). These salts have high reverse from the waste stream whey through
diffusion and scaling precursor ions like forward osmosis technology using novel
Fig. 1.1 : Concept representation of Mg+2, SO4 etc(Chekli et al., 2012). Other draw solutions. Calculating the osmotic
Fig.1.1: Concept representation of Forward Osmosis
Forward Osmosis organic compounds such as sucrose pressure of different types of draw
ing results for concentrating wastewater and dewatering difficult to treat wastewater. It
very field. ItAis- used
273 in treating industrial wastewater, to concentrate landfill leachate, to WATER and ENERGY INTERNATIONAL October 2022 23
d industry, desalinating seawater, purifying water in emergency relief situations and also
in the body(Blandin et al., 2020; Honmane et al., 2020; Phuntsho et al., 2011; Pramanik
et al., 2014; Zhao et al., 2012). Dairy Samples including milk, whey, D40 whey
w&e internatioNal (Water resources section)
solutions, its effect on the efficiency of Draw solution : The DS of different Methodology
FO are studied. The relationship between concentrations is prepared by dissolving
different draw solutions and different predetermined mass of solute into known Different Draw Solutions
factors affecting FO efficiency such as mass of DI water having TDS less than NaCl has been widely used as the
Feed/ Draw (F/D), modes and flow type 5mg/l. The chemicals used for preparing draw solution in variety of applications
of FO, temperature and concentration of different draw solutions are analytical including food production and water
draw solution is established. Efforts are to reagents (AR) grade NaCl with purity and wastewater treatment(Chekli et al.,
achieve higher dewatering and flux than 99.8%, CaCl2 with purity 99.5%, MgCl2 2012). The advantage is it is abundantly
that reported in the earlier works. with purity 98%, KCl with purity 98.5%, available on earth inexpensively in
citric acid with purity 98% and sucrose the form of sea water and can be
2. MATERIALS AND
purchased from Loba chemicals. easily concentrated using RO or other
METHODOLOGY
Membrane : The feed and draw solutions techniques. Governed by the thesis of
Materials are lifted to the membrane through Vant Hoff, draw should be highly soluble
Feed solution : Paneer whey, the the peristaltic pumps. The commercial in water, have high osmotic pressure
targeted waste material in this work is membrane used in the study is the and high diffusion coefficient. NaCl
collected from the nearby local dairies. aquaporin inside, a biomimetic hollow possess all these three qualities. It has
The physicochemical properties of the fibre module comprising an active layer of high osmotic pressure and solubility
raw whey are as shown in Table 2.1 polyamide thin film composite (TFC) with and is better than sucrose due to higher
below. These results are the average integrated aquaporin proteins (Fig. 2.1). diffusion coefficient(Chou et al., 2010).
value of three samples collected during This membrane is capable of rejecting When NaCl is used as the draw solution,
different time interval of the study. difficult contaminants and preserving Na and Cl ions diffuses to the feed side
+ -
Conforming with the available literature, valuable ones. The use of hollow fibres due to their higher concentration. Owing
the whey sample is highly organic, allows for a very high packing density. to larger diffusion coefficient of Na+ more
slightly acidic, have very high moisture Using DI water as feed and 0.5 M NaCl as Na +
diffuses in the feed solution leading
content and Chemical Oxygen Demand the draw solution at temperature of 25°C to charge imbalance between both the
(COD) as well as considerable lactose at Transmembrane Pressure (TMP) of 0.2 sides and then more cations transfer
content. The raw whey is passed through bar in single pass mode, counter current from feed to draw side to re-establish the
the nylon filter cloth of fine mesh size and flow at the feed flow rate of 60 LPH and the charge balance (Aydiner et al., 2013).
pretreated using ultrafiltration membrane draw flow rate of 25 LPH gives water flux An increased sodium concentration in
to remove suspended solids and any of 11 LMH and specific reverse salt flux a FO-concentrated-whey product may
compounds that can cause fouling of the of 0.15 g/L. It is recommended to operate also not be desirable, as excess sodium
FO membrane. this membrane in the temperature range of intake is of dietary concern(G. Q. Chen
Table 2.1: Physicochemical characteristics 5-30°C at TMP of 0.2 bar within pH range et al., 2018). Using magnesium chloride
of raw whey obtained from the dairy of 3-10. The particle size through the as the draw solution it was found that
membrane should be < 50μm. Maximum it offers more than double the osmotic
Sr. Parameter Unit Results allowed TMP and feed pressure is 4 bar. pressure of sodium chloride at the same
No. The pre-treated feed solution depending molar concentration, while its back
1 pH - 5.9 uponallows
fibres the application
for a very highshould be density.
packing run prior to DIdiffusion
Using
rate is significantly lower than
water as feed and 0.5 M NaCl as the draw solution at
2 Total Solids % 8.1% the draw of
temperature through
25°C atthis membranePressure
Transmembrane to avoid (TMP) of 0.2 bar NaCl
that of a in singledraw
pass solution(Ahmed
mode, counter currentet flow at
the feed flow rate of 60 LPH and
osmotic drying of the membrane. The the draw flow rate of al.,
25 2018;
LPH Chekli
gives water et al.,
flux of 2012).
11 LMH Since
and back
specific reverse
3 Total mg L-1 60,000 salt flux of 0.15 g/L. It is recommended to operate this membrane
diffusion in the
was temperature
less, the range of
diffusion 5-30°C
of at
small TMP of
membrane should be cleaned at maximum
Dissolved 0.2 bar within pH range of 3-10. The particle size through the membrane
quantity of should be <ions
magnesium 50μm.is Maximum
also less allowed
pressure of 0.5 bar using solution in pH
TMP and feed pressure is 4 bar. The pre-treated feed solution depending upon the application should be run
Solids likely to be
range
prior of draw
to the 2-11through
at temperature
this membrane<50°C forosmotic
to avoid drying of damaging
the membrane. to The
product quality
membrane should be
4 Ash content % 3.17 about at
cleaned minutes.pressure of 0.5 bar using solution in pH range of 2-11 at temperature <50°C forG.about 20
20maximum than other ions (Ahmed et al., 2018;
5 Moisture % 92.9% minutes.
content
6 Chemical mg L-1 1,02,045
Oxygen
demand
(COD)
7 Density g cm-3 1.0228
8 Specific - 1.02714
Gravity
9 Lactose % 4.3%
10 Protein % 1.5% Fig. 2.1 : The schematics
Fig 2.1: of the HFFO
The schematics membrane
of the HFFO and the
membrane and original module
the original module
Methodology
24 WATER and ENERGY INTERNATIONAL October 2022
Different draw solutions
A - 273
NaCl has been widely used as the draw solution in variety of applications including food production and water
and wastewater treatment(Chekli et al., 2012). The advantage is it is abundantly available on earth inexpensively
solutions w&e internatioNal (Water resources section)
widely used as the draw solution in variety of applications including food production and water
r treatment(Chekli et al., 2012). The advantage is it is abundantly available on earth inexpensively
sea water and can be easily concentrated using RO or other techniques. Governed by the thesis of
Q. Chen et al., 2020; Hu et al., 2017). At where, π is the osmotic pressure (Bar), a lactose content, its osmotic pressure is
aw should be highly soluble in water, have high osmotic pressure and high diffusion coefficient.w
the same molar concentration (2 M), the is the water activity co-efficient, V is the the lowest similar to the lactose amongst
all these three qualities. It has high osmotic pressure and solubility and is better than sucrose -1due
osmotic pressure of a calcium chloride molar volume of water = 0.018 Lmol , R all the trial draw solutions.
sion coefficient(Chou et al., 2010). When NaCl is used as the draw solution, Na+ and Cl- ions
feed side (CaCl solution is lower than that of the is the universal gas constant += 0.082 L
due to2)their higher concentration. Owing to larger diffusion coefficient of Na more Na+ Membrane setup
MgCl solution, with increase in reverse atm.mol
feed solution leading to charge imbalance between both the sides and then
2
-1
.K-1
and T is the cations
more temperature
transfer in
salt flux(Ahmed et al., 2018; Shu et al., Kelvin scale (Aydiner,
draw side to re-establish the charge balance(Aydiner et al., 2013). An increased sodium Sen, Topcu, Sesli, The membrane is arranged in two modes
2016). KCl and NaCl
in a FO-concentrated-whey exhibit
product mayhighest flux be etdesirable,
also not al., 2014b). as excess sodium intake is of Continuous Single Pass (CSP) mode and
and MgCl
n(G. Q. Chen and CaCl
et al.,2 2018). 2 produces
Using magnesium highest
chlorideUsingas the the
drawwater solution it was values
activity found that from it Recirculation mode (RC) depending upon
an doubleosmotic pressure(Hu
the osmotic pressure ofet sodium
al., 2017; Shaffer
chloride at thethe
same molar concentration, while
literature, varying osmotic pressure its back the nature of the experiments. In CSP
et al.,lower
s significantly 2014). Other
than that compounds
of a NaCl draw suchsolution(Ahmed
as of different et al., 2018; Chekli at
solutions et al.,different
2012). mode as explained in Fig.2.4, feed and
ffusion wassucrose are diffusion
less, the best fit toofbe usedquantity
small in foodof magnesium ions is also less
concentrations are calculated as shown likely to be draw solutions are not recirculated within
industry
roduct quality thanbutotherhave disadvantage
ions(Ahmed et al., of lower
2018; G. Q.below
Chenin etFig.
al., 2.2.
2020; Hu et al., 2017). At
Aq. NaCl solution is seen the the membrane. This keeps the osmotic
ncentration (2 M),pressure
osmotic the osmoticandpressure of a calcium chloride
higher viscosity. (CaCl ) solution is lower
to have highest osmotic pressure at lower
2 than that pressure same throughout the process.
solution, with increase in reverse salt flux(Ahmed et al., 2018;concentrations.
Shu et al., 2016).Fig. KCl2.3 and below
NaCl The osmotic pressure keeps on changing
t flux andCalculation
MgCl2 and CaCl of osmotic pressure solute
2 produces highest osmotic pressure(Hu et al., 2017;
shows the osmotic pressure of differentShaffer et al., in the RC mode with the concentration
ompoundsofsuchdifferent
as sucrosedraw solutions
are best fit to be used in food industry but have disadvantage of lower of feed and dilution of draw solution.
salt solutions at their maximum solubility
re and higher
The viscosity.
osmotic pressure of different at room temperature. MgCl2 solution have Working in RC mode is represented in
concentration solution at different the highest osmotic pressure followed by Fig. 2.4. The osmotic pressure gradient
osmotic pressure
temperature of different draw solutions
is determined using below NaCl solution. Lowest osmotic pressure between the lower osmotic pressure
pressure ofgiven Van’t Hoff equation.solution at differentis temperature
different concentration is determined using below feed and higher osmotic pressure draw
off equation.
their maximum solubility at room temperature. MgCl2 solution notedhave for lactose
the highest solution.
osmotic Asfollowed
pressure whey, by
thesolution.
FO feed, supposedly causes the transfer of water from the feed
NaCl solution.−RTLowest lnosmotic
a� pressure is noted for lactose As whey, the FO feed,have >92%
supposedly have
Π = ...(1)equation
percentageno(1) of water followed 4-6%by to draw side of the membrane. In co flow
>92% percentage of water
their maximum solubility
V trial
followed by 4-6% lactose content,
at room temperature. MgCl2 solution its osmotic pressure
have the highest is
osmoticthepressure by
lowest similar
followed to the
lactose amongst all
NaCl solution. the
Lowest solutions.is noted for lactose solution. As whey, the FO feed, supposedly have mode both feed and draw solution enters
draw pressure
osmotic
e osmotic>92% percentage
pressure of water
(Bar), a isfollowed by 4-6%
the water lactose
activity content, its osmotic
co-efficient, pressure
V is the molaris volume
the lowestofsimilar
water to =the through the same side of the membrane
lactose amongst all the wtrial draw solutions.
R is the universal gas constant = 0.082 L atm.mol .K and T is the temperature in Kelvin scale while in counter flow, feed enters from
-1 -1
Topcu, Sesli, et al., 2014b). one side while draw enters from another
side of the membrane. Various influencing
er activity values from the literature, varying osmotic pressure of different solutions at different parameters such as mode and type of
are calculated as shown below in Fig. 2.2. Aq. NaCl solution is seen to have highest osmotic flow through membrane, Feed/Draw
wer solute concentrations. Fig 2.2 below shows the osmotic pressure of different salt solutions at (F/D) ratio, type, osmotic pressure and
temperature of draw solution that affects
the efficiency of the process are studied
in the work. The efficiency of this process
is measured in terms of maximum
dewatering and highest flux calculated
using ofthe
pressure and temperature drawbelow equations
solution that referred
affects the efficiency of thefrom
process are studied
efficiency of this(Honmane et al.,
process is measured 2018,
in terms 2020)dewatering and highest flux calc
of maximum
below equations referred from (Honmane et al., 2018, 2020)
Water Transferred (L) ∗ 1��
Water Recovery (%) =
Water in feed inlet (L) ...(2)
equation no (2)
Fig 2.2
Fig :2.2:
Osmotic
Fig2.2:
Pressure
Osmotic
Osmotic Pressure
Comparison
Pressure Comparison ofof
Comparison of
Various
Various
Various
Solutions
Solutions
Solutions At25
At
At
25 C
250C
0 0C
Water Transferred (L)
Permeate Flux (Lm−2 h−1 ) = equation no (3)
Area (m2 ) ∗ Time (hour)...(3)
3. RESULTS AND
DISCUSSION
3.1 Performance of FO using
Sucrose Solution as the Draw
Solution
On comparison with whey, aq. sucrose
A solution has much higher osmotic pressure
B
at the room temperature (Refer Fig 2.2
and Fig.2.3). Sucrose is used as the draw
solution as it can be reused in the dairy
industry for manufacturing of various sweets
and products. This will eliminate the need of
Fig2.3:
Fig 2.3Comparison
: Comparison of osmotic
of osmotic pressure
pressure of different
of different solutions
solutions at 25°Catat25their
O
C atmaximum
their maximum
solubility regeneration of draw. The effect of different
solubility
(%w/w) (%w/w)Sucrose-67.89,
[NaCl-26.30, [NaCl-26.30,Calcium
Sucrose-67.89, Calcium
Chloride-46.59, Chloride-46.59,
Magnesium Magnesium
Chloride-38.82, Citric acid- modes of FO and different concentrations
Fig 2.3:Potassium
62.27, Comparison of osmotic pressure of different solutions at 25°C at their maximum solubility
Chloride-26.21]
Chloride-38.82, Citric acid-62.27, Potassium Chloride-26.21]
(%w/w) [NaCl-26.30, Sucrose-67.89, Calcium Chloride-46.59, Magnesium Chloride-38.82, Citric acid- such as 39°Bx, 51°Bx and 62°Bx of sugar
Membrane setup
62.27, Potassium Chloride-26.21]
TheAmembrane
- 273 is arranged in two modes Continuous Single Pass (CSP) mode and Recirculation WATER and ENERGY INTERNATIONAL October 2022
mode (RC) 25
Membrane
dependingsetup
upon the nature of the experiments. In CSP mode as explained in Fig.2.4, feed and draw solutions are
Fig2.4: Schematic representation of FO in CSP mode (A) and RC mode (B) in Co flow
not recirculated within the membrane. This keeps the osmotic pressure same throughout the process. The
The membrane
osmotic is arranged
pressure keeps oninchanging
two modes Continuous
in the RC modeSingle Passconcentration
with the (CSP) mode ofandfeed
Recirculation
and dilutionmode (RC)
of draw
w&e internatioNal (Water resources section)
4. CONCLUSION
g 3.4 (A): Effect of F/D on performance of FO Fig 3.4 (B): Effect of F/D on performance of FO
ing 10 %w/w NaCl draw solution using 26%w/w aq. NaCl draw solution Production, treatment and disposal of
organically loaded high moisture content
Cl finds many applications in the dairy industry. Using it as the draw, eliminates the draw regeneration whey is a huge problem for all the dairy
ocess as Fig 3.4 (A):
it Fig.
can be Effect
reused
3.4(A): of
in F/D
Effect the on performance
dairy
of F/D onitself. 10of%w/w
performance FO aq. Fig
NaCl
Fig. 3.4 solution
3.4(B)(B):: Effect
Effect isof F/D
used
of F/Dason performance
onthe of FO to study
draw solution
performance industries. Forward osmosis technique
usingAs
ect of F/D. 10 %w/win NaCl
Fig.draw
3.4 solution flux of 3.24 using 226%w/w aq. NaCl draw solution
of FOseen
using 10% w/w (A), highest
NaCl draw solution of FO/hr
L/m and 26%
using dewatering
w/w aq.of NaCl45.43%
draw is achieved for
successfully recovers water from this
D of 6. NaCl
Laterfinds
to study
many the effect of
applications in draw
the dairyconcentration,
industry. Usingsame
it as study
the draw, is again
solutioncarried
eliminates the out
draw using saturated
regeneration aq.
highly diluted dairy waste stream whey
Cl solution of as26it %w/w
process as thein draw
can be reused refer
the dairy Fig103.4(B).
itself. %w/w aq.Drastic changeisisused
NaCl solution observed
as the drawin performance
solution to studyof FO on
creasing effect of F/D. As seen to
the concentration in Fig. 3.4 (A),solution.
saturated highest flux of 3.24 L/m2/hr
Relationship and dewatering
between the draw of 45.43%
solutionis achieved forwith and
concentration
high efficiency using different draw
F/D of 6. Later to study the effect of draw concentration, same study is again carried out using saturated aq. solutions. Using draw solution that can
ter fluxNaCl
is not linear, at higher concentration this relationship isis observed to be logarithmic. Highest
solution of 26 %w/w as the draw refer Fig 3.4(B). Drastic change observed in performance of FO onbe reused in the dairy industry eliminate
wateringincreasing
and fluxthe of concentration
89.58% andto5.97 L/m2/hr
saturated is observed
solution. for F/D
Relationship of 5.5.
between the draw solution concentration and
the process of draw regeneration. The
water flux is not linear, at higher concentration this relationship is observed to be logarithmic. Highest
2 draw solution osmotic pressure follows
study the effect of
dewatering andchanging temperature
flux of 89.58% of draw
and 5.97 L/m solution,fortemperature
/hr is observed F/D of 5.5. is varied between 6°C to 39°C (refer
in descending order for magnesium
g.3.4 C). Flux and dewatering increases as we move from colder temperature towards room temperature and
To study the effect of changing temperature of draw solution, temperature is varied between 6°C to 39°C (referchloride, sodium chloride, citric acid,
creases Fig.3.4
after that. The change in temperature provides resistance to the fluid flow through the membrane
C). Flux and dewatering increases as we move from colder temperature towards room temperature andcalcium chloride, sucrose and potassium
ecting the FO performance.
decreases Increasing
after that. The change the temperature
in temperature of the draw
provides resistance to the solution
fluid flow enhances
through thethe water flux by
membrane
creasing affecting
the diffusion coefficient, Increasing
the FO performance. decreasingthe the water of
temperature viscosity
the drawand improved
solution enhancesmass transfer
the water chloride
across
flux by theat their maximum solubility at the
increasing the diffusion 2
coefficient, decreasing the water viscosity and improved mass transfer
embrane. Highest flux of 5.89 L/m /hr 2and dewatering of 89.2 % is observed at the room temperature of 26°C. across theroom temperature. Co flow RC mode of
membrane. Highest flux of 5.89 L/m /hr and dewatering of 89.2 % is observed at the room temperature of 26°C. magnesium chloride followed by calcium
Fig.3.4 (C): Effect
Fig..3.4(C) of temperature
: Effect of aq. Saturated
of temperature of Fig.3.5:
Fig. 3.5Comparison
: Comparisonof performance of FO of
of performance using chloride and potassium chloride gives
NaCl draw solution on performance of FO different draw solution
aq. Saturated NaCl draw solution on FO using different draw solution maximum dewatering of 93% followed
performance
3.5 Effect of different of FO on performance of FO
draw solutions by 77% and 54.25% respectively. Using
When performance of FO is compared using different draw solutions, magnesium chloride gives the best
A - 273
performance in terms of dewatering percentage and flux followed by NaCl solution (refer Fig.3.5).
WATERPotassium
and ENERGY INTERNATIONAL October 2022 27
chloride gives the lowest percentage of water recovery. The results show that the draw solutions behave
according to their osmotic pressure at their maximum solubility at the room temperature. Depending upon the
desired result, regeneration and reuse purpose, availability of draw solution, cost and back diffusion of draw
w&e internatioNal (Water resources section)
62°Bx sucrose as the draw solution, Draw Solutions Tested in Forward Aydiner, C., Topcu, S., Tortop, C., Kuvvet,
60.97% water is recovered from the whey Osmosis Process for Desalinating F., & Ekinci, D. (2012). Desalination and
with the flux of 3.86 L/m2/hr. While using Arabian Gulf Seawater. Arabian Journal Water Treatment A novel implementation
citric acid as the draw solution, at F/D of for Science and Engineering, 43(11), of water recovery from whey : “ forward –
6.75, 85% water is recovered. Increasing 6171–6180. https://doi.org/10.1007/ reverse osmosis ” integrated membrane
the NaCl concentration from 10 %w/w to s13369-018-3394-9 system. Desalination and Water
saturation of 26%w/w increases the water Treatment, 786–799. https://doi.org/10.
Al-Amoudi, A., & Lovitt, R. W. (2007).
recovery from 45.43 % to 89%. Upon 1080/19443994.2012.693713
Fouling strategies and the cleaning
varying various parameters, it is found
system of NF membranes and factors Aydiner, C., Topcu, S., Tortop, C., Kuvvet,
that high osmotic pressure draw solution
affecting cleaning efficiency. Journal F., Ekinci, D., Dizge, N., & Keskinler, B.
at F/D around 6-7 gives better results of
of Membrane Science, 303(1–2), (2013). A novel implementation of water
whey dewatering at room temperature in
4–28. https://doi.org/10.1016/j. recovery from whey: “forward- reverse
RC co flow mode. There is no one size
memsci.2007.06.002 osmosis” integrated membrane system.
solution for choosing the most suitable
Desalination and Water Treatment, 51,
draw solution it will depend on various Ali, W., James, D., Sarp, S., & Hilal, N.
786–799. https://doi.org/10.1080/19443
factors such as back diffusion, application (2018). Advances in forward osmosis
994.2012.693713
of draw solution, fouling of membrane membranes : Altering the sub-layer
etc. More research is needed to strike structure via recent fabrication and Baldasso, C., Barros, T. C., & Tessaro, I.
balance between cost incurred in water chemical modifi cation approaches. C. (2011). Concentration and purification
recovery and recovering draw solution for Desalination, 436, 176–201. https://doi. of whey proteins by ultrafiltration.
the practical applications. By treating and org/10.1016/j.desal.2018.01.035 Desalination, 278, 381–386. https://doi.
reclaiming the dairy industry wastewater org/10.1016/j.desal.2011.05.055
Artemi, A., Chen, G. Q., Kentish, S. E., &
it is possible to fulfil the three dimensions Lee, J. (2020). Pilot scale concentration of Barukcic, I., Jakopovic, K., & Bozanic,
of industrial optimality namely: reduce cheese whey by forward osmosis: A short- R. (2019). Valorisation of whey and
water footprint, conservation of water cut method for evaluating the effective buttermilk for production of functional
during consumption and production of pressure driving force. Separation and Beverages- An overview of current
various products and achieving circular Purification Technology, 250. https://doi. possibilities. Food Technology and
economy approach by treatment and org/10.1016/j.seppur.2020.117263 Biotechnology, 57(4), 448–460.
reuse of wastewater.
Aydiner, C., Sen, U., Topcu, S., Ekinci, Baskaran, K., Palmowski, L. M., &
Funding and data availability D., Altinay, A. D., Koseoglu-Imer, D. Y., & Watson, B. M. (2003). Wastewater
statement: No funding is taken from any Keskinler, B. (2014). Techno-economic reuse and treatment options for the dairy
organization or agency to carry out this viability of innovative membrane industry. Water Science and Technology,
research work. All the data generated systems in water and mass recovery 3, 85–91.
during the research work relevant to the from dairy wastewater. Journal of
manuscript is provided in the manuscript Blandin, G., Ferrari, F., Lesage, G.,
Membrane Science, 458, 66–75. https://
and still if some clarification is required Le-Clech, P., Héran, M., & Martinez-
doi.org/10.1016/j.memsci.2014.01.058
it can be asked from the corresponding Lladó, X. (2020). Forward osmosis
author. Aydiner, C., Sen, U., Topcu, S., Sesli, as concentration process: Review
D., Ekinci, D., Altinay, A. D., Ozbey, B., of opportunities and challenges.
REFERENCES Koseoglu-Imer, D. Y., & Keskinler, B. Membranes, 10(10), 284. https://doi.
Achilli, A., Cath, T. Y., & Childress, A. (2014a). Techno-economic investigation org/10.3390/membranes10100284
E. (2010). Selection of inorganic-based of water recovery and whey powder
Boguniewicz-Zablocka, J., Klosok-
draw solutions for forward osmosis production from whey using UF/RO and
Bazan, I., & Naddeo, V. (2019). Water
applications. Journal of Membrane FO/RO integrated membrane systems.
quality and resource management in the
Science, 364(1–2), 233–241. https://doi. Desalination and Water Treatment, 52,
dairy industry. Environmental Science
org/10.1016/j.memsci.2010.08.010 123–133. https://doi.org/10.1080/194439
and Pollution Research, 26(2), 1208–
94.2013.786655
Agrawal, V., & Sarode, D. D. (2021). An 1216. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-
Overview on Dairy Industry Wastewater Aydiner, C., Sen, U., Topcu, S., Sesli, 017-0608-8
and Its Indian Scenario. International D., Ekinci, D., Altinay, A. D., Ozbey, B.,
Bortoluzzi, A. C., Faitão, J. A., Di
Journal of Engineering Applied Sciences Koseoglu-Imer, D. Y., & Keskinler, B.
Luccio, M., Dallago, R. M., Steffens,
and Technology, 6(1), 363–368. (2014b). Techno-economic investigation
J., Zabot, G. L., & Tres, M. V. (2017).
https://doi.org/10.33564/ijeast.2021. of water recovery and whey powder
Dairy wastewater treatment using
v06i01.055 production from whey using UF/RO and
integrated membrane systems.
FO/RO integrated membrane systems.
Ahmed, M., Kumar, R., Al-Wazzan, Y., Journal of Environmental Chemical
Desalination and Water Treatment,
Garudachari, B., & Thomas, J. P. (2018). Engineering, 5(5), 4819–4827. https://
52(1–3), 123–133. https://doi.org/10.10
Assessment of Performance of Inorganic doi.org/10.1016/j.jece.2017.09.018
80/19443994.2013.786655
Chekli, L., Phuntsho, S., Shon, H. K., using forward osmosis. Journal of McCutcheon, J. R., McGinnis, R. L.,
Vigneswaran, S., Kandasamy, J., & Membrane Science, 338, 61–66. https:// & Elimelech, M. (2006). Desalination
Chanan, A. (2012). A review of draw doi.org/10.1016/j.memsci.2009.04.011 by ammonia-carbon dioxide forward
solutes in forward osmosis process Honmane, B., Bhansali, R., Deshpande, osmosis: Influence of draw and feed
and their use in modern applications. T., Dhand, A., Mogha, S., Mukherjee, J., solution concentrations on process
Desalination and Water Treatment, Ghosh, D., Sarode, G., Srivastava, S., performance. Journal of Membrane
43(1–3), 167–184. https://doi.org/10.10 Dive, A., Deshmukh, D., & Pushpito, K. Science, 278(1–2), 114–123. https://doi.
80/19443994.2012.672168 (2020). Harnessing the osmotic energy org/10.1016/j.memsci.2005.10.048
Chen, G. Q., Gras, S. L., & Kentish, S. of cane molasses by forward osmosis : Panesar, P. S., Kennedy, J. F., Gandhi,
E. (2018). Separation Technologies for process studies and implications for D. N., & Bunko, K. (2007). Bioutilisation
Salty Wastewater Reduction in the Dairy a sugar mill. International Journal Of of whey for lactic acid production.
Industry. Separation and Purification Environmental Studies. https://doi.org/10 Food Chemistry, 105, 1–14. https://doi.
Reviews, 325–353. https://doi.org/10.10 .1080/00207233.2020.1787036 org/10.1016/j.foodchem.2007.03.035
80/15422119.2018.1496452 Honmane, B., Deshpande, T., Dhand, Phuntsho, S., Shon, H. K., Hong, S.,
Chen, G. Q., Gras, S. L., & Kentish, A., Bhansali, R., & Ghosh, P. K. (2018). Lee, S., & Vigneswaran, S. (2011). A
S. E. (2020). The application of Channelizing the osmotic energy of novel low energy fertilizer driven forward
forward osmosis to dairy processing. proximate sea bittern for concentration osmosis desalination for direct fertigation:
Separation and Purification Technology, of seawater by forward osmosis under Evaluating the performance of fertilizer
246(116900). https://doi.org/10.1016/j. realistic conditions to conserve land draw solutions. Journal of Membrane
seppur.2020.116900 requirement for solar sea salt production. Science, 375, 172–181. https://doi.
Journal of Membrane Science, 567, org/10.1016/j.memsci.2011.03.038
Chen, George Q., Artemi, A., Lee, J.,
329–338. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
Gras, S. L., & Kentish, S. E. (2019). A Pramanik, B. K., Hai, F. I., Ansari, A. J., &
memsci.2018.09.022
pilot scale study on the concentration Roddick, F. A. (2019). Mining phosphorus
of milk and whey by forward osmosis. Hu, T., Wang, X., Wang, C., Li, X., & from anaerobically treated dairy manure
Separation and Purification Technology, Ren, Y. (2017). Impacts of inorganic by forward osmosis membrane. Journal
215, 652–659. https://doi.org/10.1016/j. draw solutes on the performance of of Industrial and Engineering Chemistry,
seppur.2019.01.050 thin-film composite forward osmosis 78, 425–432. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
membrane in a microfiltration assisted jiec.2019.05.025
Chou, S., Shi, L., Wang, R., Tang, anaerobic osmotic membrane bioreactor.
C. Y., Qiu, C., & Fane, A. G. (2010). In RSC Advances (Vol. 7, Issue 26, pp. Prazeres, A. R., Carvalho, F., & Rivas,
Characteristics and potential applications 16057–16063). https://doi.org/10.1039/ J. (2012). Cheese whey management:
of a novel forward osmosis hollow C7RA01524K A review. Journal of Environmental
fiber membrane. Desalination, 261(3), Management, 110, 48–68. https://doi.
365–372. https://doi.org/10.1016/j. Jevons, K., & Awe, M. (2010). Economic org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2012.05.018
desal.2010.06.027 benefits of membrane technology
vs. evaporator. Desalination, 250, Rektor, A., & Vatai, G. (2004).
De Souza, R. R., Bergamasco, R., da 961–963. https://doi.org/10.1016/j. Membrane filtration of mozzarella
Costa, S. C., Feng, X., Faria, S. H. B., desal.2009.09.081 whey. Desalination, 162(1–3), 279–
& Gimenes, M. L. (2010). Recovery 286. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0011-
Jiao, B., Cassano, A., & Drioli, E.
and purification of lactose from whey. 9164(04)00052-9
(2004). Recent advances on membrane
Chemical Engineering and Processing:
processes for the concentration of Seker, M., Buyuksari, E., Topcu, S.,
Process Intensification, 49(11),
fruit juices: A review. Journal of Food Babaoglu, D. S., Celebi, D., Keskinler,
1137–1143. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
Engineering, 63, 303–324. https://doi. B., & Aydiner, C. (2017). Effect of
cep.2010.08.015
org/10.1016/j.jfoodeng.2003.08.003 pretreatment and membrane orientation
Del Re, G., Di Giacomo, G., Aloisio, L., & on fluxes for concentration of whey
Karimidastenaei, Z., Avellán, T., Sadegh,
Terreri, M. (1998). RO treatment of waste with high foulants by using NH3/
M., Kløve, B., & Haghighi, A. T. (2022).
waters from dairy industry. Desalination, CO2 in forward osmosis. Bioresource
Unconventional water resources:
119(1–3), 205–206. https://doi. Technology, 243, 237–246. https://doi.
Global opportunities and challenges.
org/10.1016/S0011-9164(98)00154-4 org/10.1016/j.biortech.2017.06.101
Science of the Total Environment,
Duke, M., & Vasiljevic, T. (2015). 827(154429). https://doi.org/10.1016/j. Shaffer, D. L., Werber, J. R., Jaramillo,
Whey Ultrafiltration. Encyclopedia scitotenv.2022.154429 H., Lin, S., & Elimelech, M. (2014).
of Membranes. https://doi. Forward osmosis: Where are we now?
Kenkar, P. K., & Kadlag, P. V. (2016).
org/10.1007/978-3-642-40872-4 Desalination. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
Study of Dairy Wastewater Treatment By
desal.2014.10.031
Garcia-Castello, E. M., McCutcheon, J. Using Constructed Wetland. International
R., & Elimelech, M. (2009). Performance Journal of Advance Research in Science Shete, B. S., & Shinkar, N. P. (2016).
evaluation of sucrose concentration and Engineering, 5(12), 238–252. Comparative Study of Various Treatments
For Dairy Industry Wastewater Suárez, E., Lobo, A., Álvarez, S., Riera, Production, 280(124354). https://doi.
Comparative Study of Various Treatments F. A., & Álvarez, R. (2006). Partial org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2020.124354
For Dairy Industry Wastewater. July. demineralization of whey and milk
Wang, K. Y., Teoh, M. M., Nugroho, A., &
https://doi.org/10.9790/3021-03844247 ultrafiltration permeate by nanofiltration
Chung, T. S. (2011). Integrated forward
at pilot-plant scale. Desalination,
Shirazi, S., Lin, C., & Chen, D. (2010). osmosis-membrane distillation (FO-MD)
274–281. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
Inorganic Fouling of Pressure-Driven hybrid system for the concentration of
desal.2005.12.028
Membrane Processes - A Critical protein solutions. Chemical Engineering
Review. 250, 236–248. Velpula, S. ,. (2017). Dairy Wastewater Science, 66(11), 2421–2430. https://doi.
Treatment by Membrane Systems - A org/10.1016/j.ces.2011.03.001
Shon, H. K., Phuntsho, S., Zhang,
Review. International Journal of Pure
T. C., & Surampalli, R. Y. (2015). Wang, Y. N., Wang, R., Li, W., & Tang,
& Applied Bioscience, 5(6), 389–
Forward osmosis: Fundamentals and C. Y. (2017). Whey recovery using
395. https://doi.org/10.18782/2320-
applications. In Forward Osmosis: forward osmosis – Evaluating the
7051.5540
Fundamentals and Applications. https:// factors limiting the flux performance.
doi.org/10.1061/9780784414071 Wang, J., & Liu, X. (2021a). Forward Journal of Membrane Science, 533,
osmosis technology for water 179–189. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
Shu, L., Obagbemi, I. J., Liyanaarachchi,
treatment: Recent advances and memsci.2017.03.047
S., Navaratna, D., Parthasarathy,
future perspectives. Journal of Cleaner
R., Aim, R. Ben, & Jegatheesan, V. Wit.J.N. (2001). Lecturer ’ s Handbook
Production, 280, 124354. https://doi.
(2016). Why does pH increase with on whey and whey products.
org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2020.124354
CaCl2 as draw solution during forward
Zhao, S., Zou, L., Tang, C. Y., & Mulcahy,
osmosis filtration. Process Safety and Wang, J., & Liu, X. (2021b). Forward
D. (2012). Recent developments in
Environment Protection, 104(Part B), osmosis technology for water
forward osmosis: Opportunities and
465–471. https://doi.org/10.1016/j. treatment: Recent advances and
challenges. Journal of Membrane
psep.2016.06.007 future perspectives. Journal of Cleaner
Science, 396, 1–21. https://doi.
org/10.1016/j.memsci.2011.12.023
survey to be carried out for the estimated additional compensation in form of and land ownership confirmation & the
cost of the Compensation as well as ‘Non-usability allowance’ up to 15% of consent for the ROW compensation is
Compensation Plan for the Temporary the land value for the width of ROW used to be taken from land owner. District
Damages (CPTD) is to carried out. The corridor would also be applicable. collector and Implementing agency
notice is to be served to the land owners Some of the states that have adopted the serves the Notice under the electricity act
for the construction of the line. The NOC MOP guidelines are listed below:- 2003 clause no 164 & Clause no 68(6)
from the land owners & Village Head / of part VIII of Indian Electricity Act, 2003
Grampanchayat will have to be taken for Name of Methodology for the purpose of foundation & stringing
placing the towers. State purpose. The compensation towards land,
The Transmission lines, constructed before Maharashtra Tower Base @2 Times Demolition of houses and rehabilitation of
2015 in line with the Indian Electricity Act, (200%) of Ready reckoner Hut/House is the responsibility of owner,
rate. compensation is duly assessed by PWD
allenge &2003 read withinSection
its Mitigation 10 andSystem
Transmission 16 of the
Indian Telegraph Act, 1885, do not have Line Corridor tip to tip or authorized valuation agency/ Certified
the provision for the Land value (Tower @15%ready reckoner Chartered Engineer. In some cases
during the construction of the line, if
baserights
s left the & Corridor) and diminution
to States /UTs for taking clauseCircle
of the no
rate.
market rate/Circle
164 & Clause no 68(6) of partHouses/
some Schools/ VIII ofPlay
Indian
grounds /
land value compensation but only for
n regarding adoption of the
surface damage (Zirat Compensation/ guidelines AndhraElectricity Act, 2003
Tower Base 100% & Linefor the purpose
Huts of
/Colleges foundation
etc. are &
encountered
the final transmission line route and
g that Tree/acquisition
Crop/ Hut &of landasisverified
House) a State stringing
Pradesh purpose.
corridor 10%. The compensation
disputed party
towards
approaches
land,
the court,
by the District administration (does not
line with this,
include various
cost of land).states like Assam,
So for enhanced
Demolition
Meghalaya of houses
Tower base @ 100% and rehabilitation
the transmissionof Hut/House
company has to pay
& Odisha Line Corridor – 15%
Madhya Pradesh,
compensation and towerGujarat,
base landKerala, is the responsibility of owner, compensation is duly
the required compensation or divert the
value, the landowners used to approach Uttarakhand Tower Base 85% & Line route, based on the court decision.
Tamilnadu and Chhattisgarh have
& assessed by Nil.PWD or authorized valuation agency/
Uttar Corridor
the Courts and litigation process (C) Right
hese MOP hampers guidelines
the progressasofsame (85% for
transmission PradeshCertified Chartered Engineer. some of
In hurdles cases Way
during
in O&M Stage of
(ROW)
for enhancing the surface damage (vi) wind velocity and angle of swing. (x) Increasing Utilization of the Existing
compensation amount and landvalue (vii) Configuration towers (SC/D/C/ transmission lines through Uprate
as well as diminution of land value. For Horizontal/Delta). & Upgrade.
regular tree cutting work, compensation (xi) Use with HTLS conductors and
(viii) Electrostatic field below bottom
is required to be paid to landowner by some special conductors.
most conductor(10kV/m) and at
Line owner. Normally trees that grow
edge of ROW (5kV/m) at vegetation (xii) Use of micro pile foundation and
higher will be cut. For example, trees
effect for transmission line corridor special type tower design.
higher than 3m will be cut to maintain
and social and environmental
proper ROW under the transmission line,
study is necessary while designing
(F) Mitigation of ROW
and trees or plants can grow below 3m.
transmission lines. (i) Transmission line projects have
The condition and clearance height may
some location impact on the
differ from country to country. (E) Approaches for Reducing villagers whose lands are affected
It is also observed that in some cases ROW by Adapting New for construction of transmission
which are under litigation, some section Innovative Technologies: towers and stringing of conductors
of the Transmission line which is and on the natural resources like
(i) Compact tower design with
constructed and commissioned need to crops and trees wherever the
Insulated cross arm.
be shifted as per the order of Courts Transmissions line passes through
or any regulatory body. Even for carrying (ii) Use of Suspension towers with
the agricultural land and forest
out the replacement of the earth wire V-string or Tension towers in urban
area. Thus the main strategy /focus
by optical ground wire (OPGW) , severe and forest area to reduce ROW.
would involve undertaking the
ROW are being faced by the Utilities. (iii) Use of XLPE Underground EHV activities that benefit the persons/
In O&M stage, sometimes land owners Cables. villagers, generally impacted by the
demand enhance compensation on (iv) Gas Insulated Transmission Lines activities that will help to reverse any
the base of prospective yield theory (GITL). adverse impact on the environment
method, growth/girth of that tree during (v) CICA (Composite Insulated Cross and ecology so transmission
vegetation clearance work. They may arm) reducing cross arm. license implement the CSR
also ask for diminution of Land value, (Corporate Social Responsibility)
(vi) Raising of tower height to reduce like distributing the medicines and
Tower base land value even though it is
the tree cutting. conducting Health Checkup camps
not applicable as per the Telegraph Act ,
the Electricity Act, 2003 & IS 5613 to the (vii) 400 kV Hollow core composite post regularly as well as supporting
transmission lines constructed before Oct Insulator inner FRP tube. the women empowerment and
2015. These laws don’t have provision (viii) Use of covered Conductor up to education system as well as various
for the Land value & diminution of land 66kV level. Caging of Conductors. charity work in ROW affected area
value as well as prospective yield theory. on voluntarily basis.
(ix) Possibility of use of VSC based
Further, notification /Guidelines issued (ii) Encouraging Land Owners to
HVDC.
by MOP for the Land compensation is cultivate low growth trees below
applicable for the lines constructed after (x) Use of Multi Ckt/Multi-Voltage
tree meters like Fruit and flowers
Oct 2015. Monopole/Special towers.
instead of bamboo /Long tree in
(xi) Upgrading of the existing line to line. The farmers will get the extra
(D) in
Mitigation Factors Contributing
Transmission System to higher voltage or multi voltage in income and fruitful relationship with
ROW same ROW. Transmission licensee.
(i) Span length.
nd clearance height (Depends
(ii) Sag of Conductor may differ
on type
of conductor used and maximum
try. operating temperature of the
conductor and span length).
(iii) The utilities deputing some local in Construction phase by paying the in different facets of Power Sector. He
officer as a Tower Mitra to tower base land value and corridor land has worked in various capacities in NTPC
mitigate the ROW & educate the value after confirming their ownership and POWERGRID in the areas of design
villagers regarding the Usefulness and available circle rate. Transmission & optimisation, construction, operation
of the Transmission system and lines are constructed under the ambit & maintenance, project management
its safety. of the Electricity Act, 2003 with provision and consultancy assignments of many
(iv) ROW can be mitigated by adapting stipulated in Sec 67-68 read with section EHV AC & HVDC transmission projects.
New Innovative Technologies. 10 to 16 of the Telegraph act before Oct’ He was one of the key members in
2015 don’t have the provision for the land various domestic as well as international
(v) The Construction work is to be
compensation so new guidelines will be consultancy assignments with Nepal,
planned in off season when their
the game changer to resolve the ROW Kenya, Ethiopia, and Tajikistan under
is no standing crop.
and early completion of the Transmission World Bank/ADB funded projects. He has
(vi) The various ROW is to be resolved line corridors. The various innovative co-authored technical papers in various
with the involvement of third party technology and measures are being National and International forums.
with specific conditions. implemented by transmission companies He has been appointed as Director,
(vii) The maximum cases shall be taken for mitigation of ROW. NETCL on Board with effect from 29th
in fast track court or in Lok Adalat. September 2021.
REFERENCES
CONCLUSIONS (i) Laws of Electricity in India book by Shri Harshal Malewar is a Graduate
Demand growth is increasingly driven by S.S.Sarkar & J.P.Bhatnagar. in Electrical Engineering from Govt.
residential and commercial sector, with fast College of Engineering Chandrapur
(ii) IS Code 5613.
growing cities & increasing urbanization. (GCOEC) in 2006, Maharashtra, Nagpur
(iii) Electrical Power system Book by & has correspondence MBA in Power
Building new transmission infrastructure
C.L. Wadhava. Management in 2010.He is Certified
to meet peak demand is extremely
difficult due to high population density (iv) CBIP Transmission Line Manual. Chartered Engg from Institute of
and Right of Way (RoW) challenges. Engineers India. He has diversified
(v) Indian Electricity Act-2003 &
With the strong emphasis on renewable experience of more than 15 years in the
Telegraph Act-1885.
energy sources which are mostly located Power Transmission & Distribution with
(vi) Guide lines issued by The Ministry various power sector companies such
in remote areas, their integration to the of Power, Govt. of India vide letter no
grid requires massive transmission as RECTPCL, MSETCL, Sunflag Steel &
3/7/2015 Trans dated 15.10.2015. Power, Jyoti Structures Ltd and currently
infrastructure and that too, in a shorter
time frame. Getting RoW for transmission (vii) Guidelines for payment of working in NETCL (POWERGRID &
lines is becoming increasing difficult & compensation in Regards to Right OTPC JV). He has good exposure
very serious concern for Transmission of Way (ROW) for transmission line in Project Monitoring, Contracts &
Companies. As land owners demand in urban area dated 16.07.2020. Procurement, Project Management, O&M
enhanced compensation payment and Construction of EHV Substations &
Biopgrahical Details of Lines. He has authored & co-authored
because of their ulterior motive guided by the Authors
greed and for unlawful pecuniary gain, all technical papers in various National and
the matters are to be taken by District Shri Rajesh Gupta is a Graduate International forums like CBIP,CIGRE &
Courts & further to High Court/Supreme Electrical Engineer from Delhi College of Published papers on national journals of
Court/APTEL. The new Guidelines Engineering and also holds an MBA from power sector. He is working as Deputy
issued by MOP in 2015 plays a very FMS, Delhi University. Manager in NETCL (JV of POWERGRID
crucial role to mitigate the ROW issues He has valuable experience of 34 years & OTPC).
Abstract
The HR Digitalisation and AI research trend in Water and Energy Sector using a four-step review methodology is the aim
of this paper. The selection criteria resulted in three hundred twenty-seven publications applying the exclusion-inclusion
criterion and validation tool, MMAT leading to twenty articles for content analysis. The HR Digitalisation and AI highlight
the research trends on the role of Energy in nexus to land-water-transport infrastructure technology and its role in the
development and the importance of commoner’s awareness in using technology for sustainable practices. The findings
indicate that social and employee readiness is a category that is less addressed in HR Digitalisation and AI literature,
especially in the energy and water sector. However, the nexus approach is pretty managed. The Water & Energy (W&E)
sector’s Digitalisation literature shows the deployment of cutting-edge tools like Artificial Intelligence and Cloud-based
integration of performance management processes. Data analytics tools like predictive analytics are also being deployed
to understand employee performance patterns and inject predictability in predicting star performers. Cutting-edge tools
like AI, Cloud-based, and mobile-based solutions are now increasingly used to manage people’s performance-related
processes. The review contributes by discussing the research trend in the light of industry examples of Adani Enterprise
Limited, Tata Power, JSW Power, NTPC and NHPC.
Keywords : Water and Energy Sector, Digital Human Resource, Digital Tools, Review Methodology, Cloud-based Digital
Technology, Artificial Intelligence.
1. Research scholar at GNA Business School (GBS), Phagwara and an Industry Fellow at SoB-UPES.
2. Sr Lecturer at the Birmingham City University - RAK Campus.
3. Associate Professor (Human Resource Function) at GNA Business School (GBS), GNA University, Phagwara, Punjab (India).
4. Faculty in REC Institute of Power Management & Training (RECIPMT), the training arm of REC Ltd.
2. Literature Review Figure 1 details the review analysis as a flow chart highlighting the selection criteria. The
Onwuegbuzie et al., 2012 argued that second
a exclusion in step two is on current and last year, i.e., 2017-22, and the final
exclusion
research study can be taken by conducting is on the relevance in full text. The study for absolute exclusion includes a study
with
a literature review following the four-step a mixed-qualitative-quantitative approach; therefore, MMAT can be taken to appraise
review methodology process[10]. Reviewthe study's quality and selection as a sample.
Analysis if conducted using review
methodology, it forms the foundation
for knowledge development [15].
Figure 1 details the review analysis as a flow chart highlighting the selection criteria. The
Onwuegbuzie and Frels, say researchers
second exclusion in step two is on current and last year, i.e., 2017-22, and the final
should take care of a few components
exclusion is on the relevance in full text. The study for absolute exclusion includes a study
while taking up the literature review
with a mixed-qualitative-quantitative approach; therefore, MMAT can be taken to appraise
methodology as a research methodology.
the study's quality and selection as a sample.
The cautious points are mentioned as
myths about the scope, sequence, and
identity of the literature review [16], the
identified literature under consideration
in this study is checked for content, line
and quality by using a mixed method
assessment tool review [17]
3. Methodology
The present study follows review-
guiding questions for the direction of
purpose and quality in a 4 Step analysis
process of review methodology [18]. The
exploration included “Digital HR “ and
“Water Management” in the title, and Fig. 1 : Review Analysis Flow chart
the second search string was “Digital Figure 1: Review Analysis Flow chart
HR “ and “Energy Management” while
in the abstract the search string included
“Artificial Intelligence” and “Technology”
The first two steps in Table 1 summarise
the design and conduct of the review, Figure 1: Review Analysis Flow chart
highlighting the inclusion and exclusion
criteria. Primarily 2506 publications
appear. The selection criterion was
applied to reach 24 articles as shown in
Figure and Table number one. On quality
validation, the sample for content analysis
reach is Twenty articles.
Figure 1 details the review analysis as
a flow chart highlighting the selection
criteria. The second exclusion in step two
is on current and last year, i.e., 2017-22,
and the final exclusion is on the relevance
in full text. The study for absolute exclusion
includes a study with a mixed-qualitative-
quantitative approach; therefore, MMAT
can be taken to appraise the study’s
quality and selection as a sample.
Since the sample includes all three-method showing the suitability for MMAT application,
A - 275 the next step in the assessment is taken on “Yes
WATER and (ENERGY
), Cannot tell (C) and NoOctober
INTERNATIONAL (N)” for 2022
the 37
rating evaluation, as shown in Table 3 on the five-point scale to score and evaluate the
quality of the article (Hong et al., 2018). The quality of articles is separately assessed. The
w&e internatioNal (Energy section)
Since the sample includes all three- evaluation, as shown in Table 3 on the joint dialogue and mutuality by assessors
method showing the suitability for five-point scale to score and evaluate the in the set of two groups (two groups of
MMAT application, the next step in quality of the article (Hong et al., 2018). two authors) in the pre-evaluation stage–
the assessment is taken on “Yes (ü), The quality of articles is separately the literature under review is analysed
Cannot tell (C) and No (N)” for the rating assessed. The disagreement is set by with the study objective.
Table 3 : Mixed Method Assessment Tool Table for Quantitative Methods Study (n=6)
Ref No 3.1 Research questions are 3.2 Do samples 3.3 3.4 non-bias 3.5 Research Question and
Table 2 addressed appropriately substantially Measurement response risk statistical tool use are in
by sampling strategy. represent the target methods fit is low? sync with each other.
population? in?
5 ü ü ü ü ü
7 ü ü ü ü ü
8 ü ü ü ü ü
12 ü ü ü ü ü
13 ü ü ü ü ü
14 ü ü ü ü ü
Of the 24 studies, six used quantitative methods on a scale of five authors evaluated article quality. The assessment score is ‘Yes’
in all cases suggesting the high quality of literature included
Table 3 (a) : Mixed Method Assessment Tool Table for Qualitative Methods Study (n=10)
Ref No 3a.1 Is the qualitative 3a.2 The research 3a.3 Research 3a.4 Are the 3a.5 There is a sync
Table method fitting to question and qualitative outcomes are derived findings in the data source,
2 address the research data collection method substantially from the demonstrated collection, analysis
question? are in sync. data. by the data? and interpretation
4 ü ü ü ü ü
9 ü ü ü ü ü
11 ü ü ü ü ü
17 ü ü ü ü ü
19 ü ü ü ü ü
20 ü ü ü ü ü
21 ü ü ü ü ü
22 ü ü ü ü ü
23 ü ü ü ü ü
24 ü ü ü ü ü
Of the remaining eighteen studies, thirteen use qualitative methods, authors evaluated all of them on a scale of five and evaluated
article quality. The assessment score is ‘Yes’ in only ten cases; thus, they were included for the next stage and the remaining three
studies are dropped.
Table 3 (b) : Mixed Method Assessment Tool Table for Mixed Methods Study (n=4)
Ref No 3b.1 The research 3b.2 Are the qualitative 3b.3 Findings 3b.4 Qualitative 3b.5 The quality
Table 2 question is and quantitative of combining and quantitative of qualitative
addressed components qualitative and results are and quantitative
appropriately by appropriately answer quantitative activities separately components is
a mixed research the research question? are substantially demonstrated in properly addressed.
design addressed. the study.
2 ü ü ü ü ü
6 ü ü ü ü ü
10 ü ü ü ü ü
18 ü ü ü ü ü
Five studies are with a mixed method, the assessment is done again on a five-point scale. The assessment score is ‘Yes’ in
most cases except one; suggesting the high quality of the four articles included. Out of 24 studies, four are dropped at the quality
assessment stage therefore, only 20 studies qualify for content analysis.
Management [29]. Digitally enabled Technologies to ensure enterprise-wise Case 6 and Discussion :
people’s performance is the current trend alignment of goals from top-level to entry-
NHPC (National Hydroelectric Power
of improving performance management level executives. It deploys Cloud-based
Corporation of India is also not behind
systems’ overall effectiveness.[19] Most performance management systems that
in the adoption of digital technologies
organisations today look at holistically previously ran on ERP-based platforms
for the Transformation of its various
managing people’s performance, which and uses this technology to ensure
processes including people-related
is the most critical resource with the help goal alignment across Units, Locations,
processes [22]. NHPC has implemented
of Digital Technologies [20]. Employee Functions, positions and individuals.
ERP in almost all-important business
feedback is the key to performance This forms a foundation for an effective
functions viz. Financial Accounting, HR
management and is now being managed Performance management process
function, Project Management, Operation
using cutting-edge technology and across the Organisation. It has also
& Maintenance of Power Houses, Energy
virtual tools.[19]. An essential aspect been observed the end user perception
sales Accounting, Quality Assurance,
of managing performance is working of digital technologies is a critical factor
Design & Engineering etc at all locations
by considering people or employees’ which leads to the adoption of Digital
including remotely located difficult terrain
perspectives on what makes their life easy, Technologies for managing performance
of Himalayan regions namely Uri sector,
thus building an experience perspective management processes [31].
Tawang/ Dibang sector, Leh-Laddakh
to the performance process[21]. Another aspect is the management of goal etc. Implementation of Digitization has
Case 2 and Discussion : alignment, and goal achievement also led to online training or e-training of 3400
happens effectively with the help of Digital end users and 110 nodal officers across
Another example is Tata Power, another Technologies [28]. Finally, individual goals various locations. Other practices like
power and energy sector major in India, have to be tightly aligned with Department paperless board meetings have also
deploying cutting-edge tools like Artificial and Organisation goals, and the same been initiated by NHPC [35].
Intelligence Cloud-based integration of can be done effectively through Cloud
performance management of employees. based digital technologies [12]. Overall, 5. Conclusions and
Data analytics tools like predictive deploying Digital technologies leads to Limitations of Study
analytics are also being deployed to HR and business excellence [29]. The HR Digitalisation and AI trends in
understand employee performance
Case 4 and Discussion : water and energy research highlight the
patterns and inject predictability in
role of Energy in nexus to land-water-
predicting star performers [30]. Cutting- NTPC is famous for two initiatives for transport in commercial, communal
edge tools like AI, Cloud-based, systems it uses, significantly enhancing and social development, accenting
and mobile-based solutions are now employees’ experience while not technology infrastructure development.
increasingly used to manage people’s compromising the effectiveness of The findings indicate that millennials are
performance-related processes[22]. Data performance management across the digitally updated and technology-friendly.
management concerning performance- organisation. These systems, called The organisations are also transforming
related people data is seeing a new CLIMS (Contract Labor Information and towards Smart organisations by taking
transformation with the coming of Digital Management System) and HRUSS (HR up digitalisation in operations. Smart
Technologies [23]. Roles of employees Unified Shared Services Portal), are metering, chatbot, online billing and
and HR employees, in general, are recognised across Industry as key digital payments are common applications in
also undergoing a lot of change with platform initiatives directly impacting the water and energy sector. The Water
the arrival of new digital technologies employee performance in NTPC [32]. & Energy sector’s Digitalisation literature
[24]. There are also very close linkages
emphasises the technological aspect. The
between people’s performance and other Case 5 and Discussion :
Digital HR literature focuses on various
functions like training and development, The Power Grid Corporation continuously models emphasising a leadership role
which are also being transformed with upgrades its technology infrastructure in digital transformation and strategic
technological advancements[25]. Overall, to deliver core business and people alignment of people performance for
managing people’s performance through processes. However, it is noted that they business excellence. The Human
digital technologies leads to competitive also stress people face to face interaction, Resource Function and Enterprise
advantage, which has been proven by which is the soul of any performance Resource Planning, the Strategic goal and
various studies [26]. However, studies evaluation process. As clearly evident from alignment of Key Performance Activity for
also indicate that face-to-face interaction our review findings, conversations are measurement per se is pretty managed in
cannot be or should not be replaced, always crucial, especially in performance HR and W&E literature but based on the
especially in the case of performance assessment and evaluation or feedback case and discussion it is an area in which
feedback discussions[27]. scenarios. Technology can help through the integration of leadership, human
Case 3 and Discussion : intelligent inputs to the process to take factors such as end-user perception and
more informed decisions and improve acceptance influence fast digitisation
JSW Power is another example the effectiveness of the performance especially transforming the organisations
of a Company that deploys Digital management process [34]. with low fund availability and operating in
remote and rural India. The review has an expenditure or investment?” [12] R. Fenech, P. Baguant, and D.
minimised the myth associated to review International Journal of Power Ivanov, “The changing role of human
methodology by taking up discussion in Electronics and Drive Systems resource management in an era
line with examples of firms operating in (IJPEDS), vol. 10, no. 1, p. 504, Mar. of digital transformation,” Journal
the W&E sector and contributes through 2019, DOI: 10.11591/IJPEDS.V10. of Management Information and
industry implications of emergency I1.PP504-513. Decision Sciences, vol. 22, no. 2,
digitisation for real-time flexibility and [7] Paul Aparup and Tyagi Ruchi, “ROI pp. 176–180, 2019.
measuring of the impact and contribution Based Training Framework for [13] S. S. Ali and R. Tyagi, “Free of
of activities strategically in organisational Discoms for Rural Electrification,” Cost Energy Conservation through
goals. Water and Energy International, vol. Behavioural Training: an Indian
64, no. 11, pp. 33–39, Mar. 2022, Perspective,” Journal of The
References
Accessed: Aug. 21, 2022. [Online]. Institution of Engineers (India):
[1] R. Tyagi, S. Vishwakarma, K. K. Available: https://indianjournals. Series B 2022, pp. 1–13, Jul.
Singh, and C. Syan, “Low-Cost com/ijor.aspx?target=ijor:wei&volu 2022, DOI: 10.1007/S40031-022-
Energy Conservation Measures and me=64r&issue=11&article=005 00768-W.
Behavioral Change for Sustainable
[8] S. Vishwakarma and R. Tyagi, “Post- [14] R. K. Tyagi and N. Vasiljevienė,
Energy Goal,” pp. 1–13, 2020, DOI:
reforms training needs of frontline “The case of CSR and irresponsible
10.1007/978-3-319-71057-0_155-1.
managers in Indian power distribution management practices,”
[2] S. Vishwakarma and R. Tyagi, companies: A top managers’ Competitiveness Review, vol. 23,
“Smart cities’ success - How well perspective,” International Journal no. 4–5, pp. 372–383, 2013, DOI:
utility companies are prepared,” IET of Energy Sector Management, vol. 10.1108/CR-03-2013-0031/FULL/
Conference Publications, vol. 2020, 11, no. 3, pp. 416–425, 2017, DOI: XML.
no. CP777, pp. 149–156, 2020, DOI: 10.1108/IJESM-02-2016-0001. [15] H. Snyder, “Literature review as a
10.1049/ICP.2021.0949.
[9] J. Canedo, G. Graen, M. Grace, research methodology: An overview
[3] Paul Aparup and Tyagi Ruchi, and R. Johnson, “Navigating the and guidelines,” J Bus Res, vol.
“Affordable power for rural New Workplace: Technology, 104, pp. 333–339, Nov. 2019, DOI:
electrification in India,” Water and Millennials, and Accelerating HR 10.1016/J.JBUSRES.2019.07.039.
Energy International, vol. 64, no. Innovation,” AIS Transactions on [16] A. J. Onwuegbuzie and R. K.
6, pp. 35–42, Oct. 2021, Accessed: Human-Computer Interaction, vol. Frels, “A Framework for Using
Aug. 23, 2022. [Online]. Available: 9, no. 3, pp. 243–260, 2017, DOI: Discourse Analysis for the Review
https://indianjournals.com/ijor.aspx? 10.17705/1thci.00097. of the Literature in Counseling
target=ijor:wei&volume=64r&issue=
[10] Tyagi Ruchi and Suresh Research:” http://dx.doi.
6&article=005
Vishwakarma, “Review on Research org/10.1177/2150137813515905,
[4] Tyagi Ruchi, Shamsher Shaikh Trend and Social Sustainability vol. 5, no. 1, pp. 52–63, May 2014,
Ali, and Vishwakarma Suresh, of E-Mobility,” Water and Energy DOI: 10.1177/2150137813515905.
“Antecedents-Behaviour- International, vol. 64, no. 10, pp. [17] Q. Hong et al., “Mixed Methods
Consequences (ABC) Theory and 39–46, Jan. 2022, Accessed: Appraisal Tool (MMAT), Version
Effect of Behaviour Change Training Aug. 23, 2022. [Online]. Available: 2018. User guide,” McGill, pp. 1–11,
on Energy Conservation,” Water and https://www.researchgate.net/ 2018, [Online]. Available: http://
Energy International, vol. 65, no. 3, publication/358461632_Review_ mixedmethodsappraisaltoolpublic.
pp. 30–35, Jul. 2022, Accessed: on_research_trend_and_Social_ pbworks.com/w/file/
Aug. 21, 2022. [Online]. Available: Sustainability_of_E-Mobility fetch/127916259/MMAT_2018_
https://indianjournals.com/ijor.aspx?
[11] Sharma Anurag, Tyagi Ruchi, Verma criteria-manual_2018-08-
target=ijor:wei&volume=65r&issue=
Ashutosh, and Paul Aparup, “Review 01_ENG.pdf%0Ahttp://
3&article=006
on Digitalisation and Artificial mixedmethodsappraisaltoolpublic.
[5] R. K. Tyagi, “Sustaining by working Intelligence in Human Resource pbworks.com/
on the bottom of the pyramid: A case Function of Energy Sector,” Water [18] R. Tyagi and S. Vishwakarma,
of Jaipur Rugs India on its socially and Energy International, vol. 65, no. “Prospect of low-cost energy
responsible practices,” International 2, pp. 38–46, Jun. 2022, Accessed: conservation in residential energy
Journal of Business Performance Aug. 23, 2022. [Online]. Available: consumption,” International Journal
Management, vol. 13, no. 1, pp. https://www.researchgate.net/ of Power Electronics and Drive
46–59, Jan. 2012, DOI: 10.1504/ publication/361213725_Review_ Systems (IJPEDS), vol. 12, no. 4,
IJBPM.2012.044864. on_Digitalisation_and_Artificial_ pp. 2403–2413, Dec. 2021, DOI:
[6] S. S. Ali, R. Tyagi, and R. Chauhan, Intelligence_in_Human_Resource_ 10.11591/IJPEDS.V12.I4.PP2403-
“Energy conservation project Function_of_Energy_Sector 2413.
funding in the commercial building:
[19] A. Sengupta, S. Lalwani, S. Goswami, Optimization by Adoption of Industry Reliance. His Industry experience of around
and P. Srivastava, “Reinventing HR 4.0 Technologies,” IEEE International 22 years spans Digital Transformation of
functions with SMAC technologies- Conference on Industrial Engineering HR, Change Management, HR Operating
an exploratory study,” Mater and Engineering Management, Models, HR Analytics, and Governance. For
the last three years, he has been full-time
Today Proc, no. XXXX, 2020, DOI: pp. 374–378, 2019, DOI: 10.1109/
in Academics. Scopus Id: 57308985700 ;
10.1016/j.matpr.2020.10.875. IEEM44572.2019.8978726. Orcid Id: 0000-0002-2554-9118.
[20] M. Thite, “Digital human resource [28] B. N. Kumar, “2016 IEEE Corresponding Author: Dr. Ruchi Tyagi has
development: where are we? International Conference on undertaken postdoctoral research in “Low-
Where should we go, and how do Emerging Technologies and cost Conservation Measures for Energy
we go there?” Human Resource Innovative Business Practices for Conservation in the residential sector
Development International, vol. the Transformation of Societies, of Trinidad and Tobago”, a collaborative
00, no. 00, pp. 1–17, 2020, DOI: EmergiTech 2016,” 2016 IEEE project of the University of West Indies and
10.1080/13678868.2020.1842982. International Conference on the Ministry of Planning and Development,
Emerging Technologies and Government of Trinidad and Tobago. She
[21] A. Yadav, J. Alexander, and V. is Sr Lecturer at the Birmingham City
Shenoy, “The existentialism Innovative Business Practices for
University-RAK Campus. She has been
of digitalisation era in Human the Transformation of Societies, a visiting Professor at the Department
Resources,” vol. IX, no. April, pp. EmergiTech 2016, 2016. of Utilities, University of Trinidad and
3759–3766, 2020. [29] M. Thite, “Chapter 16: Future Tobago, an Honorary Professor at the
Directions in Electronic / Digital Nizhny Novgorod Institute of Management
[22] D. Minbaeva, “Disrupted HR?,”
HRM,” no. August 2018, 2019. and Business, Russian Federation, and a
Human Resource Management Senior Associate Professor at UPES, India.
Review, no. February, 2020, DOI: [30] https://www.adanitransmission. She was an invited speaker at a seminar
10.1016/j.hrmr.2020.100820. com/-/media/Project/Transmission/ conducted by Chartered Engineers Pacific
[23] S. Nadkarni and R. Prügl, Digital Investor/documents/Annual-Report/ in Vancouver, Canada; IEEE Mauritius, IET
transformation: a review, synthesis A d a n i - Tr a n s m i s s i o n - L i m i t e d _ Bahrain; the University of Nairobi and Asian
Integrated-Report_2019-20.pdf Institute of Technology, Thailand, Deptt of
and opportunities for future research,
Ethics, Faculty of International Business,
vol. 71, no. 2. Springer International [31] h t t p s : / / w w w. t a t a p o w e r s o l a r.
Moscow State University; Leningrad State
Publishing, 2021. DOI: 10.1007/ c o m / w p - c o n t e n t / University and Vladimir University, Russian
s11301-020-00185-7. uploads/2021/06/11080239/media- Federation. Scopus Id: 55008387700 ;
[24] S. Strohmeier, “Smart HRM–a 11june21.pdf Orcid Id: 0000-0002-6412-3216
Delphi study on the application [32] https://www.jsw.in/jsw_energy_ Dr. Ashutosh Verma is Associate Professor
and consequences of the Internet annual_report_2019_20/pdf/ (Human Resource Function) at GNA
of Things in Human Resource Human%20Capital.pdf Business School (GBS), GNA University,
Management,” International Phagwara, Punjab (India). Before academics,
[33] https://www.ntpc.co.in/en/clims-
Journal of Human Resource he worked in manufacturing, service, and
and-hruss-are-two-initiatives-have- corporate HR for 15 years in companies of
Management, vol. 31, no. 18, proven-be-%E2%80%98game- repute such as Torrent Pharmaceuticals,
pp. 2289–2318, 2020, DOI: changer%E2%80%99-ntpc Fullerton India Credit Company, Nectar
10.1080/09585192.2018.1443963. Lifesciences, and Anuvidyut Pvt Limited.
[34] https://www.deliveringondigital.
[25] L. Para-González, D. Jiménez- in/power-grid-corporation-how- Dr. Verma received his doctorate in Human
Jiménez, and A. R. Martínez- Resources Management from Himachal
digitalisation-is-bringing-new-value-
Lorente, “The link between people Pradesh University, Shimla. Scopus Id:
to-telecom-infrastructure/ 57772434100; Orcid Id: 0000-0003-0926-
and performance under the EFQM
[35] h t t p s : / / e g o v . e l e t s o n l i n e . 2747.
excellence model umbrella,”
com/2020/09/creating-digital-public- Er. Arup Paul is General Manager, faculty
Total Quality Management and
enterprises-through-technological- in REC Institute of Power Management &
Business Excellence, vol. 32,
innovation/ Training (RECIPE), the training arm of REC
no. 3–4, pp. 410–430, 2021, doi:
Ltd, conducting training of national and
10.1080/14783363.2018.1552516. BIOGRAPHIES Details of international participants. He graduated
[26] C. Tataru, “Human resources in the the AUTHORS from NIT Durgapur, PGPM from SPJIMR
digital age a manager’s realities and Anurag Sharma is an Industry Fellow at Mumbai, and pursuing a Ph.D. from SoB-
perspectives,” Review of International SoB-UPES and a research scholar at UPES under the Supervision of Dr. Ruchi
Comparative Management / GNA Business School (GBS), Phagwara. Tyagi. He has work experience of 22 years
He has Graduated from IIT Roorkee and in the power sector. He is also a certified
Revista de Management Comparat
done PGDBM from NMIMS, Mumbai. He energy auditor and has experience in
International, vol. 20, no. 4, pp. 473–
worked in various leadership roles before power generation, rural electrification, and
480, 2019. policies. Scopus Id: 57355718000; Orcid Id:
academics with conglomerates like the
[27] M. Munsamy and A. Telukdarie, Tata Group, Holcim Lafarge, Essar, and 0000-0001-5878-3237.
“Digital HRM Model for Process
ABSTRACT
Today’s interest in rural electrification has highlighted how crucial it is to connect its growth and development with useful
energy applications and poverty reduction. This has been considered important in order to speed up the electrification of
rural areas. Despite the considerable interest in rural electrification, there has been little success in illuminating isolated
rural areas. This study is set out to examine the impact of rural electrification on the development and growth of Ganjam
District in Odisha. The study would increase our understanding of the availability of energy in rural areas and may have
an impact on rural residents, inspire them, and promote rural electrification as a means of generating cash through the
productive use of power. This essay evaluates the literature on rural electrification’s contribution to economic development
and growth in two sample Blocks in the Ganjam District. It analyses the economic factors that led to the growth of rural
electrification and evaluates how electricity affected the various rural economic activities. Conclusions are established on
those who will benefit from rural electrification as well as the difficulties in igniting economic growth that will help make
it more practical and inexpensive. The results of the study will be used as a guide by policymakers, the management
of state power utilities, and field officers in distribution companies to understand changes that must be made in future
programs and to gauge rural residents’ awareness because the majority of impoverished villagers view electricity as a
luxury due to its affordability.
Keywords : Rural, Electrification, Economic Development, Growth, Energy.
INTRODUCTION taken place, the continent is still home to of their citizens, human development
several people with no access to electricity. assumes greater importance. The rise in
Millions of individuals now have access
With energy being ‘the golden thread standard and subsequently the poverty
to rural electrification programs, thanks to
that accelerates economic growth” rural elimination play an integral role in the
the introduction of the Rural Electrification
areas that don’t have access to electricity growth the country witnesses.
Administration in the United States
are missing out on great advancements. Prior to Independence, India had no
in the early 1930s. However, 16% of
Expert energy management consultants policy for rural electrification. Rural
the world’s population lacks access to
claim that excluding the rural sector from electrification in the nation began around
power, especially in the most remote
a growth plan ensures failure. For this the 1950s as a planned operation.
and underdeveloped regions. A better
reason, nations today are attempting to Around 10%, 9%, and 2% of villages
understanding of how electricity affects
bring energy to rural areas. in Tamil Nadu, Kerala, and Karnataka,
socio-economic development and how
to maximize those benefits may lead to Rural electrification results in a procedure respectively, were electrified in 1951.
better public policy in this area. that is effective enough to support Less than 1% of villages were electrified
economic expansion. There are no in the other states. Electricity for rural
Many rural areas that are part of
hindrances to growth as the whole country areas was not seen to be a necessary
developing economies don’t have access
is unified in achieving an objective. The resource in the early planning stages but
to electricity. Africa is a prime example of
benefits of electrification of rural areas rather a special amenity. As a result, only
this, there have areas without any access
are both economic and social. As nations a few states had rural electricity during
to power. Despite all the development that
seek to improve the standard of living the First Five Year Plan; however, during
datasets: I the largest energy access people worldwide without the benefits Research on the effects of rural
survey in India, ACCESS, 2015-2018, of electricity in Britain (Barnes, 2012). electrification on economic development
with 5562 observations in each round Despite the substantial progress made in India is presented in Development
and 51 districts across six states: Bihar, towards the realization of sustainable Effects of Rural Electrification (Fiona
Jharkhand, Madhya Pradesh, Odisha, development in the last decade, Burlig et al., 2016), which uses high-
Uttar Pradesh, and West Bengal; and (ii) availability, accessibility and affordability resolution geospatial data and a
the largest human development survey in of electricity for all people is still a major regression discontinuity design to identify
India, IHDS, from 2005 to 2012 (Desai et challenge around the world. Rural the medium-run economic impacts of
al., 2019). The results show that one extra electrification has been recognized as a electrification. According to the findings,
hour of power has a considerable impact key ingredient in poverty reduction and medium-term economic gains from
overall, particularly for poor households in the enhancement of social and economic electrifying rural villages may not be
rural India. In order to improve household development. In the past decades, particularly significant. Although we are
welfare and decrease financial losses for access to electricity in the rural and peri- unable to measure them, the author
the State Electricity Boards, the report urban areas has been a key challenge also noted that electrification may have
also suggests progressive pricing with and this has in turn led to slow social and significant positive effects on human well-
targeted subsidies for electrified families. economic development, (Sachs, 2005). being and big economic gains in certain
In order to calculate the causal impact According to Abdullah and Markandya settings.
of electrification using a pre-registered (2012), the government of Rwanda has As advances and public knowledge of
instrumental variable design, The effects not given rural electrification enough electricity vary quickly, the literature
of Rural Electrification in India (Daniel attention, which has widened the gap mentioned above suggests that there
Robert Thomas et al., 2020) explained between rural and urban residents access are varied effects depending on the
the household electrification policy in to power (Abdullah and Markandya, level of electrification and the time
Uttar Pradesh, India, which states that 2012). The trend has been present in period of study. By conducting a survey
only homes located within 40 metres practically all emerging nations where the in rural areas of the state of Odisha and
of an electricity pole are eligible for a governments have battled the problem of using secondary data from government
legal electrical connection. The author low rates of electrification in their rural sources, the current research will help to
demonstrates how India’s rural electricity areas. Rural areas’ use of electricity determine the socio-economic benefits
may improve lighting, irrigation, and can be divided into three categories: enjoyed by rural people in light of the
education. Rural electrification and the domestic, agricultural, small and medium- developments that have occurred in the
outcomes of the conceptual framework sized business (Karekezi and Kithyoma, past decade, including the aggressive
were linked by the research design. 2002). In rural locations, having access reach of electricity to every corner of the
The results are based on how many to electricity for illumination and using nation
appliances are utilised by families each appliances powered by electricity,
hour. The author discovered that the including refrigerators and freezers, Objectives of the Study
legal electrification of a rural area had can improve the quantity and quality of Though there is a visible growth in Rural
largely favourable medium-term impacts. agricultural goods. areas due to Rural Electrification. The
The fact that beneficial benefits were Small and medium enterprises are crucial goal of current study was to gain a more
discovered despite very little daily hours in the socio-economic development of in-depth understanding of the following
of power is also significant to note. a nation. They contribute significantly issues:
A study on the impact of reliable electricity to a country’s gross domestic product (a) To explore the variables related to
on health systems in developing nations (GDP) through the consolidation and economic activities.
(Yvonne Jie Chen, 2019) discovered mobilization of scarce resources. (b) To examine the potential of Rural
that reliable electricity can be a useful However, they also suffer from various Electrification through economic
tool in enhancing key elements of health infrastructural challenges that hamper activities related to growth and
systems through the observation that JGY their growth and development (Sachs, development in the Ganjam district
deployment considerably enhanced the 2005; Kirubi, 2006). of Odisha.
operational capacity of health facilities, The governments of most developing
in particular primary health centres (c) To suggest measures based on the
countries have recognized the positive findings of the study.
(PHCs), by boosting the availability and contribution of small and medium
functionality of a wide range of critical enterprises to the economy. One of the METHODOLOGY
devices and equipment. JGY also policy measures that developing countries The study was carried out in the Ganjam
markedly enhanced the availability of are currently pursuing is electrification of District of Odisha. In the months of
health information on television rural areas. In the last decade, Rwanda March and April 2022, a field survey
The cost and difficulty of providing has embarked on a national policy aimed was conducted to gather the research’s
electricity to rural areas in developing at building the capacities of SMEs. primary set of data. The study’s sample
countries has left an estimated 1.6 billion (Abdullah and Markandya, 2012). population comprised of 310 citizens of
Ganjam district. Based on the review Table 1 : Demographic Profile of the respondents (N=310)
of the literatures and recommendations
Category Particulars Frequency Percent
from experts, a survey questionnaire
was created. Cronbach’s α. has been Male 267 86.1
employed to guarantee the validity and Gender Female 43 13.9
reliability of the survey instrument. A Total 310 100.0
five point Likert scale was used to divide
SC 68 21.9
the administered questionnaire into two
sections: demographics and various ST 36 11.6
economic activities of the villagers. The Category OBC 160 51.6
survey participants were chosen using a General 46 14.8
simple random selection procedure. The
Total 310 100.0
SPSS 23.0 version has been used to
analyse the data for the study. Married 284 91.60
Marital Status Unmarried 26 8.40
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Total 310 100.0
In the Table 1 of demographic description
Below 20 yrs 2 0.1
of the respondents, majority are male
(86.10%) and 13.90 % are females. 21-40 yrs 134 43.50
In caste, 51.60 % of the respondents Age 41-60 yrs 156 50.6
are OBC category and then coming 61 yrs and above 18 5.8
SC (21.90 %) and General (14.80 %)
Total 310 100.0
respectively. Further in age, most of the
respondents belong to the age group of Below metric 163 52.6
41 to 60 years (50.60 %) and age group Intermediate or below 109 35.2
of 21 to 40 years (43.50 %). Few of the Education
Undergraduate & above 38 12.2
respondents are coming below 20 years
Total 310 100.0
and above 61 years.
Source: Developed from the survey data
In terms of education, majority of
responders are below metric (52.60 %) Table 2 : Reliability Analysis of Economic Activities (EA) statements
followed by intermediate or below (35.20
Std. Cronbach’s Cronbach’s Alpha N of
%). Few of the respondents (12.30 %) Items Mean
Deviation Alpha (Item wise) combined Items
are undergraduate and above (12.30 %).
EA1 3.85 1.03 0.893
Eleven statements were posed to elicit
responses for the measuring of economic EA2 3.52 1.24 0.886
activities (EA). The fact that the mean EA3 3.17 1.77 0.864
score of each item is greater than 3.5 EA4 3.70 1.67 0.850
indicates that respondents agree with EA5 3.50 1.73 0.852
the claims. Further, since the Cronbach α
EA6 3.01 1.16 0.859 0.897 11
value of each of the item and combining
eleven statement is coming more than EA7 4.86 1.22 0.853
0.8, this signifies items are reliable EA8 4.59 1.13 0.873
and contributes to study the economic EA9 3.07 1.09 0.897
activities of the Rural Odisha, especially
EA10 3.51 1.38 0.817
the Ganjam district. (Table 2)
EA11 3.79 1.68 0.830
Factor Analysis of Economic
Source: Developed from the survey data
Activities (EA) of Villagers
Table 3 : Factor Analysis (KMO and Bartlett’s Test)
Exploratory Component Analysis (EFA)
was used to condense the eleven items KMO and Bartlett’s Test
and assertions into a single factor after Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin Measure of Sampling Adequacy. 0.891
they were asked as part of a questionnaire
to help people understand the economic Approx. Chi-Square 30.534
activity. Bartlett’s Test of Sphericity Df 55
The KMO value of EFA is coming in Sig. 0.000
at 0.891 (Table 3), demonstrating the Source: Developed from the survey data
We always urge our members to be the part of knowledge driven society on sharing the
best available technical knowhow with them. Our members have already understood
the power of knowledge and gathered the happiness on sharing for the betterment of
society around them. Everyone in the world needs someone sometimes, So, Let’s join
hand to propagate the basic verse “Gaining Knowledge is the First step to Wisdom…
Sharing it, is the next to Humanity …”.
SPARK group is the platform of educated people, where every member shares, attempts to learn, plans to
transforms knowledge into action and most important link among all is that we understand the situation and
act as per the circumstances. During the crucial period when the total globe was struggling under the threat of
COVID-19, our readers kept keeping us in touch with system. The popularity and acceptance to the concept
of technical discussion got raised in multi-fold, whose impact become visible in the form of operating with 19
groups, 8 Sub-groups consisting of around 5000+ engineers under this banner.
The basic objective of this group is to summate the best versions of the discussion held in the group and
circulate the same to all Power professionals across nation. We are highly indebted to our readers of extending
unflinching support every moment the situation demands, recently on obtaining the responses from engineers
all across globe we have created the new Group 19, where we have few slots for inclusion. Hence interested
readers can extend their willingness to me (P.K. Pattanaik WhatsApp Number 9438907492).
In these groups we strictly discuss the technical points anything and everything on electrical stream and its
allied subjects. Posting of Social message in these groups is strictly prohibited and on any violation of
such, the concerned member with reminder gets removed from the group.
On behalf of our group, once again I being the admin of these groups take this unique opportunity to extend my
gratitude of heartfelt thanks to the experts and technical stalwarts, those who have never hesitated to extend
their technical deliberations for the knowledge boosting of all our esteemed members. Our special thanks to
team CBIP for making continuous effort to educate the engineers across the globe.
Finally, I wish the readers to enjoy the discussion and urge all to extend their suggestive and corrective views
to refine us and to bring the best for the days to come.
P.K. PATTANAIK
General Manager
EHT (O&M) Circle, Bhubaneswar, OPTCL
WhatsApp Number: 09438907492
Suggestion Note by Er. Senapati JK : This is going to create a lot of problems for STU.
What happens to the definition of bulk power transmission? Since the voltage level remains same, how transmission loss is going
to decrease which DISCOMs couldn’t achieve after getting so many support from Govt.?
This is first, Demerger, Then re-allocation and possibly merger again for better management.
It could have been better to abolish 11kV by adopting 33 / 0.4kV system directly to help reduce transmission losses.
Additional Support
1. Er. C. Narashima Murty Aptransco: None of reasons mentioned for handing over of 33 kv system to STUs are convincing.
DISCOMS are already implementing technologies like SCADA, Automation, fault locating indicators etc., Actually the
deficiencies are more in 11kv and LT systems rather than in 33 kv systems. The step is actually intended to facilitate easy
privatisation of DISCOMS as the investments to be made by Private players get drastically reduced by removal of 33 kv
Subtransmission system from their scope.
2. Er. R S Khandagale Retd CE MPEB: I am sorry but I am interested to know at how many places the scadda is in working
condition, At how many places the fault locators are in working conadition. Present conditions of Automation.
I agree with your honour that in 11kv and LTs are big problems.
Reason for enquiring above information that in few states 33kv substations are well maintained then why not my state will be
matter of study
3. Er. Susobhan Bhattacharya: True picture Sir. Stations in metropolis may be marginally better, otherwise you have stated
correctly.
4. Er Tripathy Pc : Very true sir. This is the real picture of the old 33 kv lines and sub-stations. In Odisha about 500 nos. of sub-
stations with incoming lines and 11 kv feeders having state of the art switchgears and protection system were constructed by
state government with the help of OPTCL, but the DISCOMS were reluctant to takeover due to lack of technical staff and funds
to operate & maintain such sophisticated sub-stations. The important thing is that in distribution system the most important
thing is to extend power supply by any means and to collect the revenue. The technical aspects take a back seat.
Query : Er S.K.Purohit : At what level a Grid s/s should maintain its 33 kv voltage to supply quality power to end customer. Any
regulation/ guidelines?
Reply : 1. Er Rajarshi Ghosh: As per Indian Electricity Grid Code, the voltage band should be within 30kV to 36kV
2. Er. S.K. Purohit: I think Grid Code didn’t address such issues. My point is something different. Even if we maintain
33 kv at Grid bus is it possible to get healthy voltage at We have few slots that got created, request to please
Recommend if any...
Some Suggestions and concerns from Er. R S Khandagale Retd CE MPEB: Reharding protection to the farmers
in the field, lightening attestors to be provided in the field used electrical systems with greater height, which shall
be sufficient to provide conical cover to all panels, DCDC convertors, Invertor and panel. Panel must be with surge
protection of sufficient rating by proper calculation. When we are using conventional type of lightening arrestor, then
conical angle coverage is considered as normally 15 degrees from tip of lightening arrestor.
So the bottom circle circferance will be right area to accommodate utilities and generation parts.
Also, hydrogeological survey is one time cost, can give proper idea of earth pit for lightening arrestor, so that
minimum resistance path can be achieved.
This survey also helps for making borewells for ground water recharge pits, so that, extra flowing water or water
accumulation can be diverted to ground. This will help to keep ground moist naturally for longer time and prevention
of wastage of rain water, rain water harvesting is also done at a time.
In such areas at least 3 lightening arestors are suggested, having depth of more than 10 feets in soil, excluding
upper hard surface.
If any arrestor fails to protect, other will take care.all conical must form good coverage for this... Else we can go for
new type of lightening arrestor having angle upto 30degrees.
But whatever it may be always go with conventional type of earth pit only.
Other Suggestions:
(1) Spacers should be provided to all L T lines conductors where ever guarding and guard loops are not provided
to avoid electrical accidents due to L T conductors snapping / breaking.
(2) Stay insulators should be immediately provided to LT lines stays. At number of places stay insulators are Broken
and number of electrocutions is going on.
Some Concerns:
One exercise to find out increasing trend of electrical hazards including electrocutions.
Since 2005, I was noticing the increasing trend of Dangerous locations on electrical networks. Some Where
substandard increasing trend of substandard works. Increasing trend of electrocutions and noticing the increasing
trend of lack of supervision.
The results at stage are tremendous Dangerous locations and nearly more than reported only 1360 yearly humans
including workers’ electrocutions in Maharashtra.
Hence I have studied the work load on and average with each section Engineer of Discom. For this I have studied
one Division.
I came to know the Following works load on average basis for one section engineer.
(1) 33kv line ___16 km o/h and 2 km u/g , (2) 33kv S/S ___1 number. , (3) 11kv lines ___ 132 km o/h and 2.5 km
u/g, (4) D T C___ 181 numbers , (5) L T lines ___ 307 km , (6) Total consumers __5 756
Maintenance of above networks + releasing of new connections + consumer grievances + various meetings +
energy bills recovery drive + Breakdowns + surveys for new works and preparation of estimates.
All this is beyond capacity of one Engineer if the Networks are to be maintained as per the provisions of all
regulations and Is codes related. If hazard free networks are expected from the Section incharge this work load is
to be reduced by increasing number of sections.
Even with this situation these section engineers are burdened with self certification work of new works before
Commissioning. Hence I fear weather the section engineer can physically inspect new works for self certification
with above work load on him. If no thought is given to this position the number does locations will increase resulting
increasing
Trend of electrical accidents and electrical hazards. In case some mistakes with work load is found is far away from
the actual work loads I maybe Informed so that necessary correction will be done.
Only my appeal to Energy departments top managements and top management of Discom is kindly give thought
to above situation so that there is no increasing trend in
Dangerous locations and electrocutions and all construction and maintenance works are done as per the provisions
under CEA regulations. 2010 AND 2011 with provisions under related IS Codes please. Our ultimate demand is Zero
electrical accidents, Zero electrical fires, Zero equipment failure, Minimum interruptions.
Some Examples:
1. In a suburb of an Industrial city, a country estate a 220-volt transmission line passed down the street in front
of the cottage. According to the regulations, electrical wiring, insulated or bare must not touch trees, branches
or bushes. Therefore branches must be treemed or cut out from time to time .
2. This must be done by the operating personnel responsible for the circuit, since there are safety measures that
must be observed.
3. During a shower two boys took shelter under the tree . A gust of wind brought the branches against the live
wires. Both boys received electrical shock and one of them died.
4. In Discom networks there are huge numbers of electrical wires passing through trees branches and there are
numerous creepers on electrical poles and D p structures.
Hence I appeal to all public in general be away from such spots. Keep their animals away from such spots . And
appeal Discom to keep adequate clearances as per I S codes of their lines / electrical networks to avoid electrical
accidents please .
Discussion Note on Ester filled Transformer by Er. Kevin Newman:
Natural and synthetic ester transformers are in use in Australia, mainly in distribution and small power transformers
particularly in the mining industry. Some larger transformers are now starting to appear. I was recently involved with
a project investigating the bunding requirements for a 330 kV transformer to be installed in a sensitive location and
filled with natural ester. In terms of fire suppression, the most common system I have seen in both UK and Australia
is the deluge system but it is by no means universally applied. I see it is usually reserved to protect adjacent critical
infrastructure such as in power stations on converter valve hall. I should also add that nitrogen injection and
depressurisation systems have been installed in a few locations, usually in large GSUs and in particular where there
have been catastrophic fires in the past almost certainly at the behest of the insurance company. Anecdotally I have
heard the nitrogen injection components are disabled for automatic operation due to concerns over mal-operation.
Supplemented by Er P. Ramachandran: Thank you Mr Newman for the detailed and illuminating reply. As your
responses are always prompt and crystal clear, I knew that you missed my query.
Certain adjectives used in your response are very important and meaningful. “ fire suppression system “ in many
markets it is claimed as fire protection system, a tall claim !
“Fire suppression provided for protection of nearby infrastructure and sparingly provided” Unfortunately in many
countries this is made mandatory and provided universally, even in small transformers.
Supplemented by Er Rajaram Shinde: Some western countries already having separate guidelines for K class fluid
like natural ester & FM global manual has all details. Yes Kevin, I am aware of that synthetic ester failure case,
Manchester university was assigned project to complete the comparative study & papers already published in ICDL.
Terna like utility in Italy is shifted to natural ester & having more than 30units of 400kv class.
Sapienza-University Prof Massimo Pompili & his team was doing doing all these studies about fire wall, fire
suppression system, soak pit etc, finally decided to use natural ester by eliminating all this stuff. Today more than 3
million natural ester filled transformers are running successfully from 6kv to 420kv class, including reactors.
Query : Er P Ramachandran Ex-Abb: Just adding to the query. Any one had seen these soak pits being really helpful? I thought
after a fire chances of oil remaining in pit are remote. What is the actual experience from the field?
Reply : 1. Er.Rajarshi Ghosh: In urban areas, in case of any oil leakage/ spillage, it is not allowed to drain it through normal
sewage or drain lines. So we have no other options but to provide oil soak pits, which are cleaned on a regular basis.
I think, other than fire, this is the main reason to keep soak pits.
2. Er Murty KK: There are as many as 410 EHV S/Ss in M.P.and about 1000 Nos of Transformers. Many S/Ss are in the
Urban area. We do not have soak pit for any of the EHV Transformers.The maintenance schedule calls for arresting
any oil leakage from the Transformer. Perhaps, there may not be any recommendation by the CEA to have a soak
pit for each and every Transformer.With kind regards.
3. Er. Rajarshi Ghosh: Yes, Sir, as per CEA, soak pits need to be provided.
4. Er. Anirban Sikdar: What about the bio-degradable argument by Natural Ester Oil suppliers....if it is so , we must not
be hesitant in discharging as well as there is low/nil fire risk. Do we still actually require the soak pit? How about our
bodies like CBIP & CEA discuss on the actual cause & effect keeping publik safety & OHAS in the core.....
5. Er P Ramachandran Ex-Abb: All these rules - soak pit or “fire protection system” or fire walls are strictly enforced
for all small industries or private sector power companies. But as Murtyji confirmed, these are not required for large
private sector companies or public sector bodies. If technically these are required why not universally enforce for
all? Or why not leave the choice to users, considering criticality in each case?
Of course these are not new issues. I still remember a meeting, attended by me as subject expert, nearly 40 years
back in Delhi. It was attended by all state chief electrical inspectors, convened by CWPC ( later CEA) Subject
of discussion was these transformer items -after 1965 war, fire walls and soak pits were meticulously enforced
as safety measure . Electricity boards refused to comply and asked for exemption, stating the huge cost. Then
chairman said why not leave to individual users? CEIs vehemently opposed and insisted that these must be there
for private sector and not essential for public sector!
Query : Er C. Siva Sankar Rao: I request opinion of our expert members whether rules accept construction of permanent stage
for conducting functions just by the side of apartment 11kv/440V. 160kva transformer fencing.
Reply : 1. Er P Ramachandran Ex-Abb: As per IEC 61936-1-2010, the clearances to non-combustible building surface is 3
metres & 7.5 metres with combustible building surface if oil content is 1-2 kL.
2. Er Gopa Kumar : Safety regulation 49 specify only the height of fence as 1.8 meter the distance between live part
and fence is not mentioned in any regulation (to my limited knowledge) hence the iec 61936-1 shall be referred.
There is an IS draft of this IEC as well.
3. Er C. Siva Sankar Rao: My doubt is whether we can conduct functions just by the side of iron fencing I mentioned.
4. Dr Y P Chawla: True that there are all these regulations, but the electrical transformers / systems are considered just
as a static asset and in India we go on doing any thing and everything. There are places in New Delhi (Capital and
not a remote Village) the spare room created for adding any transformer at a later date is converted to a temple by
ladies doing daily prayers. Is not it a mockery. A vacant space around it has been covered and is being used as an
Office for the Residents Welfare Association- of the house owners of that locality. Safety is not important. In case of
any accident, the Discom will be punished
5. Er P Ramachandran Ex-Abb: If the iron fencing is with above mentioned clearances, I think there is nothing wrong
to have permanent stage near to fence.
6. Er. R S Khandagale Retd CE MPEB: In this regard final authority is electrical Inspector. Also Local authority
permission may also be taken as for functions more people will be there. Number of times due to varios reasons the
fencing carry currents. In our culture we cannot control any person to go to near fencing or within ground potential
rise near fencing in case of some breakdowns etc.
7. Er. VM Apavoo: Sir, my point is inspection under Section 54 of the Act during VVIP visits and the related security
protocol meetings. I do not refer periodical inspection of installations under R 30, 32, 36, 43 etc.
Technical Analysis by Er. R S Khandagale Retd CE MPEB on Electrical Safety:
The first target should be for strict quality control and inspection of construction and maintenance work of 230v and
440v system which is of vital importance.
On Analysis to the district of Vidharva situation, From April 2009 to March 2014, there are total electrocutions
6075 out of which 2503 are human and 3572 are animal, apart from this there may be numbers of unreported
electrocutions.
Similarly, there may be no of non fatal electrical accidents. The 3572 animal electrocutions comprise 3448 on
electrical supply company Installation and 124 animals are private installations. Out of 2503 human electrocutions
1767 are on electricity supply company installation and 736 on private installations.
Further analysis is that on 230V system there are 1298 human electrocutions and 598 animal electrocutions making
a total of 1896. Likewise, on 240V - 671 human and 2426 animals total 3097 and on 11kv human 480 and animal
538 totaling 1018 on 33 kv human 46 and animals 10 totalling 56 and on 220 kv human 8 thus the above accidents
figures show that maximum no of accidents are on 440v system and 230v system that too 1767 humans on electric
supply company installations and 736 humans on private installations. And in Respect of animal 3448 animals’
electrocutions on electric supply company installations and 124 animals on private installations. The above figures
clearly shows that maximum electrocutions are on electricity supply company installations.
Hence today’s first requirement is, regarous quality control and inspection on 230 and 440v system construction
and maintenance works to reduce electrical accidents drastically. Also these regarous quality control and Inspection
on works of 11kv systems works is also necessary looking to the figures of electrocutions on the 11 kv system
that is 538 animals plus 480 human making 1018 electrocutions. Hence my appeal to electric supply companies
and government authorities is to enforce strict and regarous quality control and Inspection on construction and
maintenance of works from 230v system to 11kv systems as per CEA regulation 2010 standard of constructions and
saftey measures and CEA regulations 2011 regarding safety along with related IS code similar action is required on
works above 33 kv system and above as there are also some accidents reported on these systems.
l feel to get rid of electrical hazards is to work as per regulations and codes and 100%implimentation is essential
from concerned in which at present we are lacking dangerously badly and if timely remedies are not done there will
sky high rise in electrical hazards. In future to fight with substandard works and substandard services seems tobe
very big challange to maintain the promise vide artical no 21 by our constitution.
Supplemented by Er Gopa Kumar: We often discuss about the safety in distribution. Electrical safety situation in
industries and commercial buildings are also extremely poor. They use unwanted devices in the installation. one
such device, I tried explaining in this document. I tested this industry, continuous current through earth wires are
more than 10 Amps (where as the maximum limit is few mAmps). Sparks in metallic parts are common in this
industry, which could ignite fire any time.
Shri Gajendra Singh Shekhawat Hon’ble Minister for Jal Shakti Shri Pankaj Kumar, Secretary, Department of WR, RD&GR and
and Mr. Michel Lino, President, ICOLD, lighting the lamp Mr. Michel de Vivo, Secretary General, ICOLD, lighting the lamp
The 6th in the series, the International Dam Safety Conference - 2022 was held during 10-12 October, 2022 at Birla Auditorium
Jaipur, Rajasthan, is a joint initiative of the DRIP, Central Water Commission, Government of India; Committee for the
International Commission on Large Dams, India (INCOLD) and CBIP, under the aegis of International Commission on Large
Dams besides the ongoing World Bank assisted Dam Rehabilitation and Improvement Project (DRIP) as a part of institutional
strengthening.
Dam Safety Conferences are being organized as an annual event in different DRIP States in collaboration with the Implementing
Agencies and leading academic institutes, to provide a common platform for all stakeholders including non-DRIP States to
update the knowledge of dam professionals. This conference bring together the policy makers, senior functionaries and
technocrats of Ministry of Jal Shakti, Central Water Commission, Central/State/UT Governments, academicians, dam
owners in the States, public and private sector, and all stakeholders associated with the dams, dam safety governance and
related aspects besides the ICOLD experts from different countries, to focus on the best global practices; technological
advancements, emerging dam safety challenges and to deliberate on all aspects related to dam safety and the solutions for
addressing dam safety concerns.
Globally India ranks third after China and the USA in terms of the number of large dams with 5334 large dams in operation
and 411 large dams under construction. The total storage capacity of the impounded water by these dams is about 300
billion cubic meters (BCM). Dams play a vital role in water security and foster rapid and sustained growth in agricultural,
rural, urban and industrial development, which have been key priorities for the Govt. of India since independence. Over
the last seventy years, India has invested substantially in this critical infrastructure which is essentially required to store
Shri D.K. Sharma, welcoming the Shri Gajendra Singh Shekhawat View of the dais during opening ceremony
Hon’ble Minister for Jal Shakti
Technical Session I - Global Best Practices in Dam Safety Management & Governance
Chairman: Dr. R.K. Gupta, Chairman, CWC
Co-chairman: Ms. Poonam Bijonkar, Director – Civil, HPSEB
• The urgent need for the seismic safety evaluation of existing dams - Martin Wieland
• Dam Safety Management in Malaysia: Resilience Dam for Safe Communities - Lariyah Mohd Sidek, Md Nasir Md Noh,
Hazri Khambali & Hidayah Basri
• Reservoir management model optimized for flood risk periods. A Portuguese case - Dr. Juliana Mendes & R. Maia
• Implementation of Dam Safety Emergency Action Plan: The Malaysian Experience on Community-Based Disaster
• Management Approach - Lariyah Mohd Sidek, Roslan Abd Rahman, Md Nasir Md Noh, Hidayah Basri, Rahsidi Che
Muda & Sarbani Anjang Ahmad
• Best practices followed in dam safety management and governance at Subansiri Lower Dam (2000 MW) – Vipin Gupta,
Ramesh Ojha and Ram Kewal
• Two-dimensional Dam break flow analysis of cascade of Dam using HEC-RAS - Shivendra Jaiswal, Rahul Kumar Jaiswal
& A K Lohani
• Assessment of hydro cover in three revenue zones of Maharashtra by remote sensing method - Rajan Shah, Sanjiv Tatu,
Rajiv Mundada, Makarand Kulkarni and Santosh Wagh
Poster Presentation Papers
A Study on Hydro-suction method for sediment removal from reservoirs - A. Jaiswal
• Managing dam safety risks over time including climate change - Dr. Adrian Morales Torres, Helena Yarritu Sanchez &
Dr. Javier Fluixa Sanmartin
• DAMS: Mitigation & Adaption in Design as per climatological challenges - Ankur Sharma
• Post seismic shock controls on dams and the procedures of “dam risk” and “downstream valley risk” – Giulia Buffi
• Energy Infrastructure Risk against Flood in a Changing Climate: A Case Study - Dr. Viraj Loliyana & Prince Kaley
• Assessment of current reservoir sedimentation rate and storage capacity loss: an Italian overview - Dr. Ritesh Patro
Technical Session V - Dam Health Monitoring, Data Acquisition and Processing
Chairman: Mr. Michel LINO, President, ICOLD
Co-chairman: Mr. Michel De Vivo, Secretary General, ICOLD
• Dam health check & monitoring using advanced tools of geophysics- Indian Experience - Dr. Sanjay Rana
• Monitoring of landslides between Tehri and Koteshwar Dams in Uttarakhand, Himalayas - K. Kumar, A. Papnai, M. Kuri
& Alok Bhardwaj
• A Concept of Integrating Complex Dams into a SMART Dams for Chambal River Basin - S.S. Parihar, Dr. M.K. Choudhary
& Dr. R.K. Jaiswal
• Role of Instrumentation in Dam Health Monitoring- Dr.R.Rani, K.S. Senthil Kumar & S. Shenbagadevi
• Importance of Seismological Instrumentation in Dam Safety Assessment- D. Srinagesh
• Effective Analysis and Usefulness of Dam Health Investigations - Nisheeth Agnihotri, Ravi Agarwal & U.S. Vidyarthi
Poster Session Papers
• SCADA system in dam for optimum management of water resources: A case study of Bisalpur Dam - Dr. Nitin Singh
Kachhawa
• Settlement analysis of rockfill dams - Ketan Patel & Mahendra Singh
• Non-Destructive Testing (NDT) of Dams by Underwater Remotely Operated Vehicles (ROVs)- Ashish Anthony Jacob,
Santhosh Ravichandran, Vineet Upadhyay, Shanmukha Kavya Vedam, Tanuj Jhunjhunwala
• Investigating effect of shell stiffness on the dynamic response of embankment dam- Mohammad Davoodi, Reza
Afzalsoltani & Abbas Pourdeilami
• Inspection of long tunnels using ROV (Remotely Operated Vehicle) - Kannappa Palaniappan. P
• Calibration of VW sensors and its performance evaluation on a DAS -A case study - Dr. M. Selva Balan & J. K. Singh
Industry Session
Chairman: Prof. S.D. Bharti, MNIT, Jaipur
• Existing dams/reservoirs: Leveraging them for energy needs – Amitabh Tripathi, WAPCOS
• Midas FEA NX - Finite Element Analysis Software for 2D & 3D Nonlinear and Detailed Structural and Geotechnical
Problems - Ayan Srivastava MIDAS
• Dam Safety - Augmented Reality Solution Inspection and Maintenance – Team Viewer
• Rehabilitation & installation of the latest technology of instruments including the Analytics of Engineering Data’s –
Vinod Tamar, Pinnacle Geosystems
• Introduction & Portfolio – Construction Chemicals - Priyanka Patra , Normet India Pvt. Ltd.
• Injection technology - Subham Jashav, Rohhri Enterprises LLP
12th October, 2022
Technical Session VI- Safety Reviews and Risk Assessment
Chairman: Dr. Wieland Martin, Chairman, ICOLD Committee on Seismic Aspects
Co-chairman: Ms. Neeta Arora, Director, SMEC
• Seismic Analysis of 3D Model of Morrow Point Arch Dam - Deepak Khandelwal, S. D. Bharti & M. K. Shrimali
• Discordant seismicity In Himalaya and its implications in seismic hazard assessment - M. L. Sharma & Shweta Bajaj
• Evaluation of seismic design of Concrete Gravity Dams – Various Guidelines - Anil Jain
• A comparative study on seismic stability analysis of 2D and 3D concrete gravity dam -Arnab Banerjee & M.K. Alam
Chowdhury
• Probabilistic dam breach modelling of Mahi Bajaj Sagar dam using monte Carlo simulation technique - Jagadish
• Prasad Patra, Anil Kumar Lohani, Sunil Gurrapu, Pankaj Mani & Rakesh Kumar
• Attributes of local seismicity around tehri dam- Prof. Mukat Lal Sharma, S.C. Gupta, A. Sen, S.K. Jain, A.K. Jindal, R.K.
Vishnoi, A. Jain, V. Singh & S.K. Saxena
• A breach modeling of a debris-dammed lake formed aftermath of the flash flood and debris flow on 07 February 2021 in
the Rishiganga river valley - Yogesh Kumar Gupta, Ankit Kumar, Samir Kumar Shukla
Poster Session Papers
• Understanding risks associated with dams and in context to dams in Damodar Valley - Abhishek Shukla & N.K. Goel
• Evaluating flood risk at an industrial site using 1D-2D coupled hydrodynamic flow model under cascading effect of dam
failure - Dr Pankaj Mani, Rakesh Kumar, Sharda University & Jagadish P. Patra
• Assessment of in-situ quality of concrete of Rengali Power House Structure by non-destructive testing methods – A
Case Study - Vijay Ghodake, Prakash Palei, Santhosh Kumar, Rajendra Singh Gurjar, Rizwan Ali
• A review study On Indian dam failures - Dinesh Roulo & Subbarao Pichuka
• Analysis of Seepage flow through Earth Dams using Numerical Modelling - Shruti Jain, & Brijesh K. Yadav
• Risk Informed Dam Safety Management, - Ms. Anu & Kavitha
Technical Session VII - Major Rehabilitations and other Risk Reduction Investments
Chairman: Dr. R. Chitra, Director, CSMRS
Co-chairman: Shri Vivek Tripathi, Chief Engineer- E&NE, CWC
• Material selection and quality requirements for repair & rehabilitation of hydraulic structures - P N Ojha, Brijesh Singh,
Abhishek Singh & Suresh Kumar
• Instrumentation for safety of dams – issues, challenges and lessons learnt in Indian context - Hari Dev, Mahabir Dixit
and R.S. Sehra
• Underwater rehabilitation of dams using geomembrane waterproofing systems - G. Vaschetti, F. Tronel & J.
Subramanian
• Effective measure to control seepage in masonry gravity dams - A case study - R. Vigneswaran, S.J. Pillai, SarbjeetSingh,
K. Balachandran, Jai Prakash Meena & Ankit Sahu
• Dealing with large lateral forces due to creeping slope – A case study of Shongtong Karcham HEP (450 MW), HP, India
N. S. Shekhawat, M S Harshitha & A. Suhail
• Evaluation of IS Code specified method of Design for Gravity Dam by Response History Analysis - Shiyam Sundar K
P,M K Shrimali & S D Bharti
Poster Session Papers
• Probability-based design considerations for Jet Grouting in dam construction and Rehabilitation-Research and Practice
- V. Vishnu & A. Tyagi
• Damage scenarios study of concrete spillways / tunnels in large dams - S. Mandloi
• Early warning system in hydropower projects with a Case Study of its successful implementation in Rangit IV HEP -
Vishal Kumar Saini, Manjusha Mishra, Sameer Srivastava, Bhavya Shukla
• Proposal to study the feasibility of providing Piano Key Weir as an additional surplus arrangement at Anaikuttam Dam -
M. A. Jose Jerald Das
Hands-on training on
Power System Network study and analysis
28-30 September 2022
In rapidly changing environment, for growth of the
organization, individual responsible must engage in
continual professional development, which requires
continues acquisition/updation of knowledge and skill,
through training and knowledge sharing session.
The hands-on training helps, better understand the
concepts, as it blend the practical demonstrations
with theory for professionals to put the knowledge into
practice.
In line with the objective of CBIP and to promote
professional excellence in the Power Sector, the Central
Board of Irrigation & Power organized a Hands-on training
on “Power System Network study and analysis” on 28-
30 September 2022 in its CBIP Conference Hall. For the
conduction of this Hand on Training, Shri Pravinchandra
Mehta, Former Superintending Engineer, GEB and CEO, Shri Pravinchandra Mehta, Expert facalty addressing the participants
of Persotech Solutions, Vadodara, who is an expert having
more than 30 years of experience for providing training on the subject was the Faculty. He has acquired technical expertise in
the field of design of substation and line, Analysis of equipment failure in power system, load flow, short circuit, and harmonics
flow study and protection coordination of industrial plant/power system. Quality inspection of equipment, guidance on Factory
Acceptance test, site acceptance test, design (type) test of equipment and materials, study of insulation coordination, etc.
effect of renewable on grid, study of developing renewable source for rural areas etc.
The purpose of the Hands on Training was to build up confidence amongst the participants on the subject learned.
About 30 participants from various PSUs, State Utilities, and Pvt. Sector organization including manufacturers, attended this
physical hands-on training program.
The program started with a welcome address by Shri Sanjeev Singh, Director, CBIP & CIGRE India. He welcomed the
esteemed faculty Shri Mehta, the invitees, and all the participants in this program. He also explained in particular the
importance of this training program.
Shri Mehta also addressed the participants during the opening session.
He requested all the participants to take full advantage and also suggest to make this training an interactive session.
The training covered the following topics:
• Introduction to Power System Network Study
• Power Flow study and analysis
• Short circuit Study and analysis
• Harmonic Flow study and analysis
• Protection Relay coordination study
• Geomagnetic Induced Current Study
• Software – Commercial software & open-source software available in the market
• Hands-on practices on examples of IEEE bus and other practical models for the studies mentioned above
The program has been conducted based on practical aspects and Hands-on practices were given more focus. Every participant
was given personal attention by the faculty. Open-source Software (standalone mode) with several solved examples given
to each participant. A certificate of participation was distributed at the end to each of the participants. The feedback from the
participants was very encouraging.
Speaker Profile:
Pravinchandra Mehta, Graduated in 1985 Presently running a proprietary company named “Persotech
Solutions“ at Vadodara Gujarat (India) involved in design of substation and line, training the engineers,
Analysis of equipment failure in power system, load flow, short circuit, harmonics flow study and protection
coordination of industrial plant/ power system. Quality inspection of equipment, guidance on Factory
Acceptance test, site acceptance test, design (type) test of equipment and materials. Study of insulation
coordination, etc. Effect of renewable on grid, study of developing renewable source for rural areas etc.
P.B. Mehta
Pravinchandra Mehta has total experience of > 30 yrs. in power sector .He is also involved in the training, research and
development activities. Membership related activities–member IEEE,-member CIGRE and member of National Study
Committee (NSC) C4 of CIGRE India (study on system technical performance),-Member of International Study Committee
JWG-C4-42 formed by CIGRE and CIRED for study of low order harmonics at customer end.
Member of expert committee for revision of substation
layout formed by CBIP (Central Board of Irrigation and
Power New Delhi) the manual published in 2006 & 2017
(released in Jan 2019) Member of Research Advisory
Committee (RAC) to guide and review of R&D projects
carried out by Energy Research and Development
Association (ERDA) Vadodara .ERDA is one of the
renowned Third party Laboratory for testing of equipment
in India.
Member of Institute of Engineers India (MIE) and
Chartered Engineer, Member of Institute of Electronics
and Telecom Engineers MIETE,-Life member Society of
Power Engineers India (SPE). He has presented several
papers on electrical system design and study related
subjects at International/National level.
The program was concluded with a Vote of thanks,
proposed by CBIP by expressing gratitude to Shri Mehta for
View of the participants
taking three days session on the subject of Power System
Network study and analysis and also the participants for
making the session interactive & lively.
Group Photograph
Training Program on
Cyber Security
3-4 October 2022, BBMB, Nangal
The Bhakra Beas Management Board requested CBIP for a training program on the “Cyber Security” for its employees.
CBIP has successfully conducted customized classroom training programs for a number of eminent organizations, like,
DTL, SECI, THDC, DVC, UPRVUNL, NHPC, HPSEB, and others, during 2020-21, which were well appreciated and have
received excellent feedback from the participants. CBIP has also conducted multiple tailor-made online training programs,
exclusively for various utilities, like. NTPC, NHPC, TPPDL, THDC, DTL, UPRVUNL, SECI, BYPL, NHDC; besides organizing
various ‘open to all’ online training programs for the knowledge enhancement of the professionals around the nation. Over
10,000 engineers have taken advantage of the various online programs organized by CBIP in the last two years.
Accordingly, CBIP executed a training program on “Cyber Security” for BBMB, with the help of Shri Anil Sinha, Consultant/
Advisor, SCADA, and Shri D Murli Krishna, Sr. Deputy General Manager, Power Grid Corporation of India Ltd., as the faculty.
The following relevant topics of interest were taken up for knowledge-sharing during this training program:
SCADA System
• Introduction to SCADA System
• Instrumentation
• Direct Digital Control
• Communication for SCADA System
• SCADA Functionality
Cyber Security
• Introduction and Compliance requirements, including CEA guidelines
• Applicable Cyber Security Standards in Power sector
• Recent issues, Global incidents
• Cyber Security requirements in ICS
• IEDs and cyber security requirement
• Cyber Security Issues in Substation Automation -IEC 61850
• ISMS
• ISO27019
Both the faculty made detailed presentations on the 3rd and 4th October, 2022, of three hours each during this important
training program. The presentations were focused, technical, and to the point. Almost all the aspects of SCADA System and
Cyber Security were presented during this Training program.
The faculty members took special care to make it simple for the participants to grasp the subject. Various questions/
clarifications were expressed by the participants, and the specific and detailed answers/ clarifications were elucidated and
explained by faculty to their satisfaction of the participants. The program achieved its goals and was a grand success.
Faculty Profile
Shri Anil Sinha, an Electrical Engineer, with background in Electronics and Communication, with
around 48 years of experience. This includes, around 28 years with Siemens AG, Germany and
Siemens Ltd, India, in the area of Hardware and Software design, development and implementation
for SCADA System and Industrial Automation. Rich experience as Consultant/ Advisor to many
reputed organisations.
• Field of Consultancy/ Advice: SCADA & Automation systems, Business Management and
Manpower Assessment. Assignments for a number of organisations. Including:
• Central Board of Irrigation and Power, a Water and Power Sector institution.
• NHPC Ltd., a public sector company in the field of Hydropower development. Anil Sinha
• Tehri Hydropower Development Corporation Ltd., a Hydropower PSU.
Dignitaries on the dais (L-R) Shri A.K. Rajput, Chief Engineer, Central Electricity Authority, Shri U.K. Bhattacharya, Vice President,
CIGRE India and Director NTPC Limited, Shri I.S. Jha, President CIGRE India and Hon’ble Member, Central Electricity Regulatory
Commission and Chief Guest, Ms. Renuka Gera, Vice President, CIGRE India and Director, BHEL, Shri A.K. Dinkar, Secretary, CBIP.
Shri Sanjeev Singh, Director, CBIP proposing vote of thanks during inaugural session.
Earthing plays an important role in proper operation of Generation, Transmission and Distribution systems. The function of
earthing in an electric power system is to (i) maintain the potential of current carrying as well as non-current carrying parts
of equipment, apparatus and appliances connected to the system, and (ii) to ensure safety of equipment and personnel and
correct operation of protective devices during earth faults. Earthing also provides safety during lightning strikes on equipment
or structures and on occurrence of induced voltages and currents on equipments of an electric system. A proper earthing
system provides easy and shortest path to the flow of earth fault current without adversely affecting the continuity of service.
It also ensures that a person present in the station area is not exposed to danger of electric shock. The efficacy of an earthing
system depends on various factors like resistivity of general mass of earth in and around the area where earth grid is buried
and also that of surface layer of soil, duration and magnitude of fault current and grid current, shock duration, the maximum
safe current that a human body can tolerate and the permissible values of dangerous voltages that shall arise due to the flow
of grid current. Earthing of fence is another issue of importance.
In view of the importance of subject, which relates to protection of assets & human life CBIP has regularly been organising
conferences on earthing of electric power stations on almost yearly basis since 2012. The last was held in October 2019
followed by 2 online programs during 2020-21 (Pandemic
period).
13th National Conference on “Earthing Systems” was
organized by Central Board of Irrigation and Power
(CBIP) and CIGRE-India in association with International
Association on Electricity Generation, Transmission
and Distribution [AARO] from 17-18 Oct. 2022 at CBIP
Conference Hall, New Delhi with the aim to update the
knowledge of professionals about the current techniques
in Earthing Systems and to discuss the various problems
relating to reliability of electrical power system, which is
the need of the hour. The conference was sponsored by
DEHN India Pvt. Ltd. & JEF Techno Solutions Pvt. Ltd.
and supported by Inter-Tech Marconite.
Shri I.S. Jha, Chief Guest delivering inaugural address
INAUGURAL SESSION
1. Shri I.S. Jha, President CIGRE India and Hon’ble
Member, Central Electricity Regulatory Commission -
Chief Guest.
2. Shri U.K. Bhattacharya, Vice President, CIGRE India
and Director NTPC Limited – Guest of Honour
3. Ms. Renuka Gera, Vice President, CIGRE India and
Director, BHEL– Guest of Honour
4. Shri A.K. Rajput, Chief Engineer, Central Electricity
Authority – Guest of Honour
5. Shri A.K. Dinkar, Secretary, CBIP
6. Shri Sanjeev Singh, Director, CBIP.
Shri U.K. Bhattacharya, addressing the participants
Shri A.K. Dinkar, Secretary CBIP welcomed the guests
and all the participants. He informed that this conference
has been organised under the aegis of CIGRE National
Study Committee B3 on Substation. He shared that with
the excellent guidance from Governing Council of CIGRE-
India, we have attained remarkable position at International
level and are recognized one amongst the most active
National committee of CIGRE. He further brought out that
we are represented in top level governing bodies of CIGRE
through Shri I.S. Jha, who is at present the Sr. Most Steering
Committee member of CIGRE and is representing India in
the Steering Committee since 2016.
He also welcomed and appreciated the contribution of
Dr. Rajesh Arora, Sr. Manger, DTL and Shri Nihar Raj,
Chairman, CIGRE National Study Committee B3 on Shri A.K. Dinkar, Secretary, CBIP, delivering the welcome address
Substation & VP, Adani Power for their long standing
association with CBIP’s Earthing Conference since 2012.
Thereafter, Shri Dinkar welcomed all the speakers/authors
and appreciated their efforts. The sponsoring organisations
M/s. DHEN India Pvt. Ltd. & JEF techno Solution Pvt.
Limited, Inter-Tech Marconite who extending their support
and cooperation for this conference were also welcomed by
him. He appealed to everyone present to take full advantage
of the opportunity presented by the event.
Shri Nihar Raj in his address informed that he has been
associated with the CBIP in organisation of earthing
conferences since first conference and praised all the
authors for contributing very useful papers for this current Shri A.K. Rajput, addressing the participants
conference. He also brought out that the earlier conferences
proceedings on the subject and CBIP Manual on Earthing
of AC Power Systems provids lot of relevant and useful
information on the topic. He added that lot of development
is taking place on the subject in the world and updation of
knowledge is important and requested everyone to become
the member of CIGRE and refer CIGRE working reports on
the subject available on CIGRE website.
Shri A.K. Rajput emphasised the importance of Earthing
in the Power System. He acknowledged the presence of
numerous experts in the hall, and hoped for extensive
knowledge sharing. Lastly, he acknowledged the efforts of
the contributors to the conference.
Shri Nihar Raj addressing the participants
2 Conference on International conference on Dam Safety Management at Jaipur 10-12 October, 2022
Power Sector
1 Hands-on Training on ‘EHV Circuit Breaker’ jointly with Hitachi Energy 21-23 September 2022,
Vadodara
2 Practical Training on ‘Power System Network Study And Analysis’ 28-30 September 2022, New
Delhi
3 13th National Conference on Earthing Systems 17-18 October 2022, New Delhi
4 Training program on ‘Cyber Security’ exclusively for the engineers of BBMB 3-4 October 2022, Nangal
5 Training program on ‘Regulatory framework in Power Sector’ exclusively for the 22nd October 2022 (online)
engineers of Tata Power Company
6 Training program on ‘Operation & Maintenance of Substations Equipments including 2-4 November 2022, Power
System Stabilities (03 Days) Training Institute, Bhubaneswar
7 Re: RE: National Conference on 'Energy Storage including Pumped Storage - 4-5 November 2022 at Shimla
Opportunities and Challenges' on
8 National Conference on ‘Challenges in Distribution Sector and its Mitigations’ on 10-11 November 2022 at
Kolkata
9 Training program on Construction Challenges in Power Transmission Projects including 16-18 November 2022, Power
Environmental / Forest Clearances (03 Days); Training Institute, Bhubaneswar
CoE, Gurugram
1 06 Days Training Program for Operation department Contract Workers at NTPC 05 - 10 Sep 2022 NTPC
Vindhyachal Power Station (Batch 12) Vindhyachal
2 06 Days Training Program for Operation department Contract Workers at NTPC 12 - 17 Sep 2022 NTPC
Vindhyachal Power Station (Batch 13) Vindhyachal
3 03 Days Training Programme on IEC 61850 Based Substation Automation System for 19 - 21 Sep 2022 Goa
the Executives of Electricity Department of GOA
4 06 Days Training Program for Operation department Contract Workers at NTPC 19 - 24 Sep 2022 NTPC
Vindhyachal Power Station (Batch 14) Vindhyachal
5 02 Days Training Program on "Planning for Superannuation" for the executives of 20 - 21 Sep 2022 DVC, Kolkata
DVC
6 02 Days’ Training on “Condition Assessment and Maintenance of Induction Motor” of 20 - 21 Sep 2022 WBPDCL,
KTPS, WBPDCL Kolkata
7 02 Days Onsite Management Training Program for Middle & Senior Level Executives 29 – 30 Sep, 2022 PGTI, Korba
of CSPGCL at PGTI, Korba
India-India-
Land and
Land Water
and Water Resources
Resources at at a Glance
a Glance
Sources : WRS Dte, BP-1 Dte, CWC, RGI, IMD, Central Electricity Authority, Ministry of Agriculture
& FW (http://eands.dacnet.nic.in)
The President of India, Smt. Droupadi Murmu presided over the more than 60% tap water coverage category, Puducherry
the Swachh Bharat Diwas-2022 event of the Department and Goa were felicitated; in less than 60% tap water
of Drinking Water and Sanitation (DDWS), Ministry of Jal coverage category Tamil Nadu and Meghalaya secured the
Shakti, to commemorate the birth anniversary of swachhata first and second position. Smt. Murmu also gave the award
inspiration and Father of the Nation, Mahatma Gandhi. This to Burhanpur District, M.P for being the first ‘Har Ghar Jal’
year, to encourage and commend the efforts of the States/UTs, certified district in the country, where all the villages through
accelerating the ODF Plus and Har Ghar Jal momentum and Gram Sabhas declared themselves as ‘Har Ghar Jal’.
strengthening the people’s movement - Jan Andolan towards In her speech, the President remembered Gandhiji and
comprehensive sanitation, awardees for both Swachh Bharat expressed that his thoughts were eternal. Like truth and
Mission – Grameen (SBM-G) and Jal Jeevan Mission (JJM) non-violence, he also insisted on cleanliness. Celebrating
were felicitated by President. The Union Minister for Jal Shakti his birthday as ‘Swachh Bharat Diwas’ is a befitting tribute
Sh. Gajendra Singh Shekhawat along with Minister of Rural to him. Gandhiji was of the thought that if we inculcate the
Development & Panchayati Raj , Sh. Giriraj Singh, Minister of habit of cleanliness in children, from the very beginning, then
State for Jal Shakti & Tribal affairs, Sh. BishweswarTudu and they will remain conscious of cleanliness throughout their
Minister of State for Jal Shakti & Food Processing Industries life. Sanitation, for centuries, has been an integral part of
Sh. Prahlad Singh Patel, also conferred the awards to best Indian culture and way of life. Since the launch of ‘Swachh
performing States/UTs for Swachh Survekshan Grameen Bharat Mission (Grameen)’, more than eleven crore toilets
(SSG) 2022, Swachhta Hi Sewa 2022, Sujlam 1.0 & 2.0, have been constructed, and about 60 crore people have
JJM Functionality Assessment, Har Ghar Jal Certification changed their habit of open defecation. She further said that
and winners of Start-up Grand Challenge for innovative through this mission, India has achieved the Sustainable
technology for Solid and Liquid Waste Management (SLWM), Development Goal 6 (SDG-6) set by the United Nations in
National film competition for Gram Panchayats on various 2015, eleven years ahead of the deadline of 2030.
components of ODF +, National Wall painting competition
During the global pandemic of Covid-19, everyone realized
on SBM(G). The President was presented the first copies of
that individual toilets, the habit of washing hands with soap
Swachh Survekshan 2022 and JJM Functionality Assessment
and the convenience of water supply through taps in the
2022 reports by Union Minister of Jal Shakti Sh. Gajendra
house, acted as a shield during the calamity. Talking about Jal
Singh Shekhawat.
Jeevan Mission, she stated that at the time of announcement
The President, Smt. Droupadi Murmu gave the Swachh of the Mission in 2019, only 3.23 rural households in the
Survekshan Grameen 2022 awards under large state category country have provisions of tap water connection which has
to Telangana, Haryana & Tamil Nadu; under Small States & now increased to 10.27 Crore in the last 3 years. Due to
UT category to A&N Islands, DNH D&D and Sikkim in that the facility of water supply in homes, there have been a
order and to Bhiwani (Haryana) as overall Top Performing significant decrease in the water borne diseases. She further
District. This was followed by the President conferring the added that we have to set an example in the fields of water
awards for Jal Jeevan Mission Functionality Assessment. In management and sanitation to the world.
What we do
What we do
!
• Single window solution from concept to commissioning on Lightning Protection as per IS/IEC 62305.
•• Supply of Tested External Lightning Protection solution as per IS/IEC 62305 & NBC 2016
•• Supply
Supply of Tested
TestedExternal
Internal Lightning
LightningProtection solution assolution
& Surge Protection per IS/IEC 62305
as per & NBC
IS/IEC 2016
62305 & NBC 2016
Supply
! Tested Internal Lightning & Surge Protection solution as per IS/IEC 62305 & NBC 2016
• Supply
Supply of Tested
of Tested Earthing
Earthing & Bonding
& Bonding systems
systems
•
Installation, Testing & Commissioning of DEHN products
• Installation,
Consultancy onTesting & Commissioning
complete of DEHN
Protection Solution as per products
standards.
Risk Assessmenton
•• Consultancy ascomplete
per IS / IEC 62305 &Solution
Protection NBC 2016
as per standards.
Site Survey & Design Solution as per IS / IEC 62305, National Electrical code of India.
•! Risk Assessment
Advance Engineeringas per IS Lightning
Service: / IEC 62305 & NBC Power,
Adequacy, 2016 Electrical safety & Earthing Audits,
AC interference Study, EMI / EMC study
• Site Survey & Design Solution as per IS / IEC 62305, National Electrical code of India.
•• Advance Engineering Service: Lightning Adequacy, Power, Electrical safety & Earthing Audits, AC
• interference Study, EMI / EMC study
“DEHN India” is 100% owned Indian subsidiary of DEHN SE + Co KG, 100+ yrs Experienced
“DEHN India” is and
Organisation 100% ownedin Indian
Leaders the fieldsubsidiary of DEHN
of “Lightning, SE + Co KG,
Surge Protection, 100+and
Earthing yrsSafety
Experienced
Equipment”.
Organisation DEHN
and Group in
Leaders is having its global
the field presence with
of “Lightning, Surge20 subsidiaries
Protection, and represented
Earthing and Safety
in more than
Equipment”. DEHN70 countries
Group is by having
our soleits
Distributors, Partnerswith
global presence and Agencies. We are and
20 subsidiaries the leaders
represented
in more in providing
than 70 Lightning
countriesand by Surge Protection
our sole Solutions
Distributors, for Indian
Partners andRenewable
Agencies.Sector.
We areDEHN
the leaders
in providingis setting International
Lightning and trends
Surge for ProtectionSolutions
Protection Systems in INDIA
for for last
Indian two decades.
Renewable Sector. DEHN
is setting International
• Infrastructure • Transporttrends
(Metro for Protection
/ Railways, Systems
Highways in INDIA•for
and Airports) last
Solar PVtwo decades.• Manufacturing
installations
facilities / Industry • Wind Mills • Oil & Gas, Pipelines, Refineries etc, • Process Industry.
• Infrastructure • Transport (Metro / Railways, Highways and Airports) • Solar PV installations • Manufacturing
facilities / Industry • Wind Mills • Oil & Gas, Pipelines, Refineries etc, • Process Industry.
SURGE PROTECTION, LIGHTNING PROTECTION & EARTHING SOLUTIONS
SURGE PROTECTION, LIGHTNING PROTECTION
DEHN INDIA PVT. LTD. & EARTHING SOLUTIONS
Plot No. 213, Sector - 7.1MT Manesar,
DEHN INDIAGurgaon-122050
PVT. LTD. (Haryana), India
Tel: +91 124 4007630 | +-91 9971795987 Fax : +91 124 4007684 Email: info@dehn.in
Plot No. 283, Sector - 7.1MT Manesar, Gurgaon-122050 (Haryana), India
For more information about our products and services in India, please visit: www.dehn.in
Tel: +91 124 4007630 | +-91 9971795987 Fax : +91 124 4007684 Email: info@dehn.in
{100% subsidiary of DEHN SE + Co KG)
For more information about our products and services in India, please visit: www.dehn.in
{100% subsidiary of DEHN SE + Co KG)
1 National Conference on
8 th International
In Association WithR&D Conference
e
vis uar ujar by
Call for Papers
8
Re anOrganised
0 hi
J
-11 naga
G
r, PROCEEDINGS Sponsored by
on
nd Global Trends in Water Resources,
Ga
IIT Power & RE Sectors
Central Board of Society of AARO National Skill Development Forum The Institution of NTPC
08-11Power
Irrigation and January
Engineers 2023 (Revised Date),
Afro – Asian (NSDF) IIT Gandhinagar, Engineers IndiaGujarat, India
Limited
Power India Region An Autonomous Fora of HP State Centre
Visit
The Institution of Engineers (India): www.cbip8rndconf.org
ShimlaInformation Bulletin
2
National Conference
Challenges in Distribution Sector and its Mitigations
Date: 10-11 November 2022 Venue: The Institution of Engineers (India), Kolkata
Organized by Knowledge Partner Platinum Sponsor
Central Board of Irrigation & Power Sardar Sarovar Narmada Nigam Ltd. IIT
New Delhi Gandhinagar, Gujarat Gandhinagar, Gujarat