FibersPolymers 2012
FibersPolymers 2012
net/publication/257401439
CITATIONS READS
24 1,729
4 authors:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Fatigue crack growth and fatigue behaviour of AlSi10Mg LPBF specimens View project
ElastoOCT - Optical Coherence Elastography for imaging retina mechanical properties View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Mário Santos on 11 February 2019.
Abstract: The objective of this study is to characterize the fatigue strength of a Kevlar/epoxy laminate composite as well as
the benefits obtained by using an epoxy matrix filled by cork powder. Twelve ply laminates, all in the same direction, of
woven bi-directional Kevlar 292, were prepared by hand lay-up, using an SR 1500 epoxy resin. The composite sheets were
produced by a vacuum moulding process. The addition of cork powder reduces the static strength, however, in terms of
fatigue strength a similar behavior was found for both laminates.
Keywords: Composite laminates, Aramid fiber, Fillers, Fatigue, Mechanical testing
Instruction The fatigue strength in wet air was lower than that in
laboratory air and the strength degradation under cyclic
Composite materials have been applied to various engineering loading by wet environment was much larger than that under
fields such as aircraft, space, automotive, sport and marine quasistatic tensile condition. The fatigue fractured fibers
industries but, particularly, in military applications. They under the sinusoidal and the positive pulse waveform in air
offer an attractive potential for reducing the weight as also broke with fiber splitting, similar to the case of the
consequence of their high specific strength and stiffness. tensile test. Under the negative pulse waveform, the specimens
For military applications aramid fibers are a very important that fractured at 102-104 stress cycles broke with fiber splitting
reinforcement for advanced composites as consequence of and for fatigue lives higher than 105 stress cycles transverse
their high degree of toughness and damage tolerance. In fact crack to the fiber axis occur. Bunsell [27] subjected individual
these fibers do not present brittle behavior, like glass or Kevlar 49 fibers to sinusoidal tensile load and found that the
carbon fibers, but fail by a series of small fibril failures. minimum load required to develop fatigue failure of individual
These many small failures absorb much energy and, Kevlar 49 fibers was approximately 80 % of the UTS.
therefore, result in very high toughness. Similar tests were developed by LaFitte and Bunsell in
In this context the literature shows a really interest in these Kevlar 29 fibers [28]. Maximum stress levels between 56-
fibers and several studies can be found. To improve the 90 % of the fibers’ UTS were analyzed. Their results
interfacial adhesion, as consequence of the low surface indicate that, under cyclic loading conditions where the
energy and chemically inert surface of the Kevlar fiber, there maximum load is below about 75 % of the UTS, individual
are extensive works [1-9]. On the other hand to improve the Kevlar 29 fibers exhibit little or no reduction of lifetime
impact strength several techniques are proposed [10-19], compared to the creep lifetime under constant stress equal to
and, more recently the inclusion of fillers was also successful the maximum level used in the cyclic testing. At higher
used [20-24]. stress levels if the cyclic amplitude is small enough, such
For the industries mentioned above, structural components that the minimum stress applied during fatigue remains
are usually subjected to complex fatigue load histories. In above about 25 % of UTS, the creep behavior dominates and
this case the performance of the composite materials is lifetime is enhanced due to the intermittent exposure to high
strongly dependent of the fibers behavior. In case of aramid stress. On the other hand, when the cyclic amplitude is great
fibers shows time-dependent mechanical behavior, indicating enough to cause the minimum stress to fall below about
that their viscoelasticity may play an important role on the 25 % of UTS, fatigue damage ensues and lifetime is reduced.
fracture behavior of the composites [25]. Tanaka et al. [26] However for bending fatigue the main mechanisms that
investigated the influences of stress waveform and wet promoted strength degradation are: compressive fiber buckling,
environment on the fatigue fracture behavior of aramid kinking and fiber-to-fiber surface abrasion [29,30]. These
single fiber (Kevlar 49). They observed that, in air, the mechanisms result from the high tensile modulus of the fiber
fatigue strength under negative pulse waveform was higher coupled with its low compressive and transverse strengths
than those under sinusoidal and positive pulse waveforms. [31,32].
The fatigue behaviour of Kevlar fibre reinforced composites
*Corresponding author: preis@ubi.pt is a subject requiring a better understanding, particularly the
1292
Kevlar/Epoxy Composites with Filled Matrix Fibers and Polymers 2012, Vol.13, No.10 1293
fatigue behavior of the Kevlar fiber reinforced composites changed. A load cell was used to monitor the load. The load
with filled matrix. In this context the aim of this work is wave was sinusoidal, having a stress ratio of R=0.1 and a
study the bending fatigue response of a Kevlar/epoxy frequency of 25 Hz.
composite with filled epoxy matrix by cork powder. Cork The nominal bending stress (σ) was calculated using:
presents an alveolar structure and it is characterized by high
3PL
specific strength and stiffness, near zero Poisson coefficient, σ = -----------2 (1)
high damage tolerance to impact loads, impervious to liquid 2bh
and gases, resistance to reactive agents and microorganisms, being P the load, L the span length, b the width and h the
resistance to wear and fire, very low thermal conductivity, thickness of the specimen.
good acoustic insulation capacity and excellent damping The water effect on the flexural properties of the laminates
characteristics [33-36]. was also analyzed. In order to obtain the water absorption it
was used the following procedure, in accordance with BS
Material and Experimental EN ISO 62:1999. The samples were placed in an oven at
80 oC for 2 hours, then cooled and weighed in order to obtain
Twelve ply laminates, all in the same direction, of woven the dry weight (DW). Afterwards, a series of samples were
bi-directional Kevlar 170-1000P (170 g/m2), were prepared immersed in water and periodically weighted to obtain the
by hand lay-up and the overall dimensions of the plates were current wet weight (CWW). The water absorption in weight
330×330×3 mm and the fiber weight fraction was 66 %. SR percentage (W%) was calculated from equation (2):
1500 epoxy resin and a SD 2503 hardener, supplied by
Sicomin, were used. The system was placed inside a vacuum W% = CWW – DW- × 100
--------------------------- (2)
bag and a load of 2.5 kN was applied for 24 hours in order to DW
maintain a constant fiber volume fraction and uniform
laminate thickness. During the first 10 hours the bag remained Results and Discussion
attached to a vacuum pump to eliminate any air bubbles
existing in the composite. The post-cure was followed The flexural properties of the Kevlar/epoxy composites
according to manufacturer datasheet (epoxy resin) in an with pure resin and filled by cork powder were obtained by
oven at 40 ºC for 24 hours. 3PB static tests. Typical load-displacement curves for both
With the same manufacturing process were produced materials are plotted in Figure 1. Both materials show a
composite laminates with filled epoxy matrix by cork linear elastic behavior, in an early stage, with a non-linear
powder. The bulk density of the cork powder is 0.1095 gcm-3 region that starts around 150 MPa. After peak stress the load
and the particles’ size, in terms of percentile, is: d(0.1)= decreases, however, the drop is more significant for filled
18.6 µm, d(0.5)=78.9 µm and d(0.9)=208.3 µm. More details laminates. The soft decreasing of the load-displacement
about the powder characterization can be found in [37].
Before being added into the resin, the cork powder was dried
in an oven-dried (Heraus, model UT 6060) at about 120 oC
for 2 h. When dried it was placed in a desiccators, cooled to
room temperature, and stored until use.
The mixture, epoxy resin and the cork powder, was
conducted at 900 rpm for 2 hours and, at same time,
subjected to ultrasonic bath sonicator. The filler content
employed was 3 wt.% of the epoxy resin-hardener mixture.
The mixture was degassed in a vacuum oven followed by
addition of hardener agent. Special care occurs in this
process to avoid the formation of bubbles.
The specimens used in the static and fatigue three point
bending tests, were cut from these plates, with dimensions of
60×10×3 mm and tested with a span of 45 mm. The static
tests were performed according the recommendations of
ASTM D 2344 Standard in an electromechanical Shimadzu
AG-10 universal testing machine, equipped with a 5 kN load
cell and TRAPEZIUM software. Four specimens were
tested for each material. The fatigue tests were carried out in
constant displacement control, at room temperature in an Figure 1. Typical load-displacement curves for Kevlar laminates
electromechanical machine where the stress ratio can be with pure epoxy resin and filled by cork powder.
1294 Fibers and Polymers 2012, Vol.13, No.10 P. N. B. Reis et al.
occurs. These figures show an important dependency of the increases, the damage, quantified by the stress range decreasing,
initial stress range. When the cyclic displacement amplitude is faster. In all cases significant decreases of stress range
were observed, since the first cycles of fatigue life, caused
not only by matrix creep and microcracking, but essentially
by significant delaminations between laminate layers. In fact
delaminations, for Kevlar composites, are the main energy
absorption mechanism [38]. The curves presented in Figure
5 were fitted by a curve with following mathematical equation:
b
∆σ
--------- = a ⋅ ⎛ ----- + c⎞
N
(3)
∆σ0 ⎝ Nf ⎠
with
1/b
c = ⎛⎝ ---⎞⎠
1 (4)
a
The values of “a” and “b” are constants obtained by a
power trend line that fits the curves represented in Figure 4.
Parameter “c”, obtained by the equation (5), was found to
force the curve to start at 1. All constants are presented in
Table 2.
Figure 6 shows a direct comparison of the normalized
stress range, for filled and unfilled composites, relatively to
the tests carried out at initial σmax=135.9 MPa. It is possible
to observe that the curve for laminates with pure resin is
above of the curve for laminates with resin filled by cork
powder. This suggests that occurs a significant stress realize
and, consequently, a drop of the stiffness.
Figure 7 shows the UV effect on fatigue strength. Laminates
with epoxy resin filled by cork powder were exposed by 450
hours and compared with other ones without any exposition
time (control samples). The criterion of failure was defined,
Figure 5. Typical ∆σ/∆σ0 – N/Nf curves for: (a) Kevlar/epoxy again, as the moment when the loss of maximum stress
laminates and (b) Kevlar with epoxy filled by cork powder reaches 25 % of the initial value. It is possible to observe
laminates. that both laminates present similar performance, which is
parameters, measured before and after UV exposition, are Davies, J. Mater. Sci., 27, 5431 (1992).
within the same band scatter, revealing the absence of micro- 4. G. S. Sheu and S. S. Shyu, J. Adhes. Sci. Thecnol., 8, 1027
cracks promoted by the UV radiation. (1994).
Figure 9 shows the effect of the water uptake on fatigue 5. C. Y. Yue and K. Padmanabhan, Compos. Part B-Eng., 30,
strength. Again the criterion of failure was defined as the 205 (1999).
moment when the loss of maximum stress reaches 25 % of 6. T. K. Lin, B. H. Kuo, S. S. Shyu, and S. H. Hsiao, J. Adhes.
the initial value. For laminates with epoxy resin filled by Sci. Technol., 13, 545 (1999).
cork powder the immersion in water, during 100 days, 7. T. K. Lin, S. J. Wu, J. G. Lai, and S. S. Shyu, Compos. Sci.
promotes a decrease around 36 % of the fatigue strength Technol., 60, 1873 (2000).
compared with dry samples (control samples) as shown in 8. P. C. Varelidis, D. G. Papakostopoulos, C. I. Pandazis, and
Figure 9(b). Similar tendency was observed in Figure 9(a)) C. D. Papaspyrides, Compos. Part A-Appl. S., 31, 549
for laminates with pure epoxy resin, however, for long cycle (2000).
fatigue lives the effect of the water is less significant. As was 9. S.-J. Park, M.-K. Seo, T.-J. Ma, and D.-R. Lee, J. Colloid.
observed in Figure 3, it is evident the hygroscopic nature of Interf. Sci., 252, 249 (2002).
the resin and laminates. Once water infuses into matrix or 10. A. P. Mouritz, K. H. Leong, and I. C. Herszberg, Compos.
interface region of composite, the water operates as plasticizer Part A-Appl. S., 28, 979 (1997).
(spacing the polymer chains) promoting the deterioration of 11. A. P. Mouritz, Compos. Part B-Eng., 32, 431 (2001).
the glass transition temperature and the relieving of internal 12. T. J. Kang and C. Kim, Compos. Sci. Technol., 60, 773
stresses. This phenomenon makes composites softer since (2000).
the matrix becomes pliable due to the presence of the 13. G. Marom, E. Drukker, A. Weinberg, and J. Banbaji,
plasticizer, which causes significant drops of material properties. Composites, 17, 150 (1986).
On the other hand, the degradation of the laminates includes 14. J. Gustin, A. Joneson, M. Mahinfalah, and J. Stone,
debonding along the fiber/matrix interface, which is accelerated Compos. Struct., 69, 396 (2005).
by the hygroscopic nature of the aramid fibers. 15. A. Salehi-Khojin, M. Mahinfalah, R. Bashirzadeh, and B.
Freeman, Compos. Struct., 78, 197 (2007).
Conclusion 16. F. Xia and X. Wu, J. Reinf. Plast. Comp., 29, 1045 (2010).
17. Y. S. Lee, E. D. Wetzel, and N. J. Wagner, J. Mat. Sci., 38,
This paper has studied fatigue response effects in Kevlar/ 2825 (2003).
epoxy composites where cork powder was incorporated in 18. V. B. C. Tan, T. E. Tay, and W. K. Teo, Int. J. Solids Struct.,
the matrix. It was concluded that the addition of cork powder 42, 1561 (2004).
reduces the static strength. However, similar fatigue strength 19. R. Gadow and K. V. Niessen, Ceramic Trans., 151, 3
behaviors were found for both laminates. (2003).
The environmental conditions were studied in terms of 20. K. Iqbal, S.-U. Khan, A. Munir, and J.-K. Kim, Compos.
water uptake and UV effects. The static and fatigue strength, Sci. Technol., 69, 1949 (2009).
for both laminates, is not influenced until 450 hours of UV 21. A. F. Ávila, M. I. Soares, and A. S. Neto, Int. J. Impact.
exposure. No significant changes on roughness profiles were Eng., 34, 28 (2007).
observed, revealing the absence of micro-cracks promoted 22. M. V. Hosur, A. A. Mohammed, S. Zainuddin, and S.
by UV radiation. On the other hand, the water uptake Jeelani, Mater. Sci. Eng. A., 498, 100 (2008).
promotes significant decreases of static and fatigue strengths 23. M. V. Hosur, A. A. Mohammed, S. Zainuddin, and S.
for both laminates. However, this tendency was higher for Jeelani, Compos. Struct., 82, 101 (2008).
filled resin laminates. 24. A. F. Ávila, M. G. R. Carvalho, E. C. Dias, and D. T. L. da
Cruz, Compos. Struct., 92, 745 (2010).
Acknowledgments 25. Y. Wang and Y. M. Xia, Compos. Part A-Appl. S., 30, 1251
(1999).
The financial support of NATO Science for Peace and 26. K. Tanaka, K. Minoshima, T. Oya, and K. Komai,
Security Programme (Project Number: CBP.MD.CLG.983977) Compos. Sci. Technol., 64, 1531 (2004).
is gratefully acknowledged. 27. A. R. Bunsell, J. Mater. Sci., 10, 1300 (1975).
28. M. H. LaFitte and A. R. Bunsell, J. Mater. Sci., 17, 2391
References (1982).
29. M. M. Schoppee and J. Skelton, Text. Res. J., 44, 968
1. H. J. Petsalas and A. G. Andreopoulos, J. Appl. Polym. (1974).
Sci., 38, 593 (1989). 30. J. W. S. Hearle and B. S. Wong, J. Mater. Sci., 12, 2447
2. J. Kalantar and L. T. Drzal, J. Mater. Sci., 25, 4186 (1990). (1977).
3. R. J. Young, D. Lu, R. J. Day, W. F. Knoff, and H. A. 31. J. H. Greenwood and P. G. Rose, J. Mater. Sci., 9, 1809
Kevlar/Epoxy Composites with Filled Matrix Fibers and Polymers 2012, Vol.13, No.10 1299