Art Fair Revenue

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 22

The International Art Gallery Industry:

A Structural Analysis

by Magnus Resch

This paper presents a detailed and comprehensive portrait of today’s art gallery
scene. It draws on the largest survey ever done on art galleries. It presents a market
size overview, including revenue and profit numbers, statistics of the number of ex-
hibitions, employees and sector focus. The paper helps to gain an insight into an
industry that has – so far – been left outside of data analysis.

Keywords: Gallery market, Performance, Market structure

JEL Classification: L11, L22

1. The global art gallery market

1.1 Introduction

Everything about the elite end of the art market is enormously attractive.
We read about millions of dollars pouring into the market, the dizzying levels
reached at auction battles, and the rich and beautiful at opening events.
The reality can sometimes bear about as much similarity to this seductive
image as an artist’s garret has to a luxury penthouse. The art world is tough,
the rules are a complete mystery to the uninitiated, and only the lucky few
make money. Life in the art market means being constantly torn between
culture and commerce, and nowhere is this more effectively illustrated than
in art galleries. They are the institutional gatekeepers to the art world and all
its paradoxes.
Art galleries are part of an exclusive social calendar, with exhibition
openings hosting a select and sophisticated crowd. They are also a big part

Economia e diritto del terziario (ISSNe 1972-5256), 2017, 1

Copyright © FrancoAngeli
Opera pubblicata con Licenza Creative Commons Attribuzione - Non commerciale - Non opere derivate.
Per i termini e le condizioni di utilizzo di questa opera consultare il sito: http://creativecommons.org/.
24 M. RESCH

of the cultural life of a city. They support young artists, helping them to de-
velop; they arrange exhibitions that attract collectors, and they manage col-
lections when artists die. They are, in short, the most significant intermedi-
aries in the art market.
Given the importance of art galleries, surprisingly little is known about
their economics, with art and business remaining reluctant bedfellows and
money talk kept to the back room. What we do know is that, unlike art mu-
seums, art galleries do not receive state subsidies – they are a business, as
much a commercial entity as a small high street shop, with a clear business
focus and a revenue model that lives or dies with sales. And, of course, they
are subject to all the same market fluctuations, limitations, and opportunities
as other entrepreneurs.
This paper gives some insight into the structure and economics of the art
gallery market. The focus lies with the three most important countries from
an art market perspective: the United States (US), Germany, and the United
Kingdom (UK).

1.2. Geographical Distribution

Rest of the
World
30% United States
34%

Switzerland
3%
Italy
5% Germany
France 12%
United Kingdom
6%
10%

Copyright © FrancoAngeli
Opera pubblicata con Licenza Creative Commons Attribuzione - Non commerciale - Non opere derivate.
Per i termini e le condizioni di utilizzo di questa opera consultare il sito: http://creativecommons.org/.
THE INTERNATIONAL ART GALLERY INDUSTRY: A STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS 25

The international art gallery market for Fine Art (1) comprises 19,087
galleries across 124 countries and 3,533 cities. The predominant markets by
number of galleries are the US (34%), Germany (12%), and the UK (10%).
Combined, they total 10,481 galleries, accounting for more than 50% of the
total market. France (6%) and Italy (5%) follow in fourth and fifth place.
Surprisingly, Switzerland occupies sixth place (3%). In the Asian market,
Japan leads the pack (2%), followed by China (1%). On a continental level,
Europe and the US are far and away the most relevant continents to the art
market, with 83% of all galleries worldwide. Asia is still relatively minor
with 9% of all galleries, although its importance should not be underesti-
mated. South America has only 1% of the world’s galleries.
Ranking of cities:
1. New York, 1,191 (6%)
2. London, 1,049 (5%)
3. Berlin, 695 (4%)
4. Paris, 664 (3%)
5. Los Angeles, 504 (3%)
6. Chicago, 314 (2%)
7. San Francisco, 298 (2%)
8. Tokyo, 231 (1%)
9. Milan, 231 (1%)
10. Amsterdam, 201 (1%)
By city, there is no real deviation from country data in terms of geograph-
ical significance. New York tops the table with 6% of total gallery distribu-
tion, followed by London with 5% and Berlin with 4%, thus accounting for
15% of total art gallery distribution. The remaining enterprises are distrib-
uted among the remaining 3,530 other cities, the most significant of which
are Paris (4%), Los Angeles (3%), Chicago (2%), and San Francisco (2%).
Emerging markets lag behind: Tokyo sits in a strong eighth position but Bei-
jing, as the second most significant Asian hub, comes only nineteenth. Mum-
bai appears at a weak thirty-seventh place, while Delhi sits at 2,061. São
Paulo is the leader in South America, ranking at seventy-two.
It is interesting to see that the primary market’s geographical distribution
is not consistent with the secondary market. In fact, it produces a different
map altogether. The US continues to lead with a market share of 34% in the
Fine Art auction trade, but the UK drops to third with 17%. (2) China, a

1. Fine Art can be divided into Old Masters, Nineteenth Century Art, Modern Art, Post-
War Art, and Contemporary Art.
2. TEFAF Art Market Report, 2014.

Copyright © FrancoAngeli
Opera pubblicata con Licenza Creative Commons Attribuzione - Non commerciale - Non opere derivate.
Per i termini e le condizioni di utilizzo di questa opera consultare il sito: http://creativecommons.org/.
26 M. RESCH

country with relatively few art galleries, presents a strong challenge to the
US for the dominant role in the auction market at number two with a 33%
market share – only one percentage point behind the US. Germany, ranking
second when it comes to its number of art galleries, does not even appear in
the global top five, with a share of 2%.
The wider reasons for China’s strength in the secondary, or auction, mar-
ket, and its weaknesses in the primary, or art gallery, market are a matter of
speculation; however, they almost certainly include the changes in business
model by auction houses, who have moved to circumvent art galleries and
take a more active role in the private dealer market. Furthermore, although
the Chinese gallery market has shown rapid rise in the last fifteen years, they
simply do not have the Western tradition of art galleries. The focus, and
value, diverts to the auction market.
The UK, USA and Germany are the richest to examine in depth.

2. A note on data sources and methodology


This paper is an extract from a larger research project that was undertaken
to generate a more detailed insight into art galleries. The outcome of the re-
search project is published in the book Management of Art Galleries (Resch,
2016). It’s based on a thorough and highly time-intensive research approach,
with the gallery market under both theoretical and practical observation for
a total of ten years. This research is based on a specific research methodol-
ogy: (1) a large survey on art galleries; (2) extensive talks with leading inter-
national experts from the art scene; (3) case studies with art galleries; and (4)
the usage of secondary sources.

2.1 Global Art Gallery Survey


The main basis for the analysis in this report is the results generated in
the world’s largest gallery survey of approximately 7,778 galleries. Such sur-
veys usually suffer from a broad reluctance to participate, but the respondent
rate for this survey reached 16 percent. In the process personalized emails
were then sent to all gallery owners, rather than the general email address. A
few weeks after the initial email, a reminder was sent. Galleries were sent an
anonymous online survey and asked to provide some structural data, as well
as a set of managerial questions. These results were then analyzed in relation
to profit margins via a regression analysis, a statistical tool frequently used
by economic researchers for analyzing large data sheets.

Copyright © FrancoAngeli
Opera pubblicata con Licenza Creative Commons Attribuzione - Non commerciale - Non opere derivate.
Per i termini e le condizioni di utilizzo di questa opera consultare il sito: http://creativecommons.org/.
THE INTERNATIONAL ART GALLERY INDUSTRY: A STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS 27

2.2 Expert Talks

Expert talks with various industry specialists helped to ensure that find-
ings are widely relevant, and applicable in the art world and beyond. Inter-
views were conducted with commercial art mediators, including art gallery
dealers, private art dealers, auction houses, and ancillary art business provid-
ers; conceptual art mediators, including critics and museum staff; collectors,
including art connoisseurs, art lovers, collector-dealers, investors, and repre-
sentatives of corporate or institutional collectors; artists; art market research-
ers; and, finally, experts from unrelated fields.

2.3 Case Studies

Case studies with art galleries were conducted to see if numbers from the
survey could withstand a sanity check. Case Studies included young and up-
coming galleries such as Carlos/Ishikawa or Rod Barton, as well as estab-
lished players such as Sprüth Magers or Salon 94.

2.4 Secondary Sources

A large number of secondary sources were used. These deliver the latest
findings on the art market, as well as guiding the reader to other trusted
sources where needed.

3. Revenue and profit

Galleries were asked to provide information on their revenue, profit mar-


gin (profit as a percentage of revenue), and other factors that might have an
impact on the revenue, such as specialism or foundation year.

Copyright © FrancoAngeli
Opera pubblicata con Licenza Creative Commons Attribuzione - Non commerciale - Non opere derivate.
Per i termini e le condizioni di utilizzo di questa opera consultare il sito: http://creativecommons.org/.
28 M. RESCH

3.1 Revenue

Revenue in the art gallery market in the US, UK, and Germany is low,
with 55% of all galleries producing revenues below two hundred thousand
dollars a year. Revenue figures, moreover, are quoted inclusive of the artist’s
share; when the usual fifty-fifty commission split is applied, only 50 percent
remains with the gallery, with the remainder going straight to the artist.
At the top end, 16% achieve revenues over one million dollars, and 7%
exceed five million dollars. Clearly, then, a few galleries do make money.
A breakdown by country shows noticeable regional differences. The US
and UK are more active at the top end, with 22% of US and UK galleries
clearing over one million dollars in revenue. In particular, the UK seems to
produce the highest gallery revenues: 13% make more than five million dol-
lars, compared to only 4% in Germany. At the other end of the scale, 66% of
German galleries fail to make two hundred thousand dollars in annual reve-
nue, compared to approximately half the gallery population in both the US
and the UK.
Can this poor performance be explained by general market conditions?
The clear answer is no. Taking auction results as an indicator, the economic
context for these numbers is strong; 2013 was, in fact, highly successful.
Auction sales reached $31 billion, up 5 percent year-on-year and only
slightly below the 2007 peak of $33 billion. There was seemingly little tur-
bulence, and no particularly severe market conditions that might have caused

Copyright © FrancoAngeli
Opera pubblicata con Licenza Creative Commons Attribuzione - Non commerciale - Non opere derivate.
Per i termini e le condizioni di utilizzo di questa opera consultare il sito: http://creativecommons.org/.
THE INTERNATIONAL ART GALLERY INDUSTRY: A STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS 29

low revenues. The high number of struggling – or failing – galleries therefore


seems to be a structural or industry-specific problem, rather than the product
of a sluggish or volatile economy.
The differences between the countries are admittedly surprising. The US
and UK outperform Germany by some distance. In theory, Germany should
be fertile ground for those who want to make a career in art dealing. The
country is justifiably proud of its art scene, a major landscape of important
museums, galleries and collectors. Or, in economic terms: a huge supply
should symbolize a huge demand. In reality, however, demand is much
weaker in Germany than in the two other countries. Collectors do not buy in
German galleries, and Berlin galleries in particular are suffering from the
weak demand. These figures align with results from the global auction mar-
ket – while the US and UK account for 34% and 17% of global auction sales,
in Germany this falls to just 2%.

3.2 Profit

Low revenue doesn’t necessarily mean slender profit, but in the gallery
world, all too often, it does. 30% of all galleries operate in the red, and only

Copyright © FrancoAngeli
Opera pubblicata con Licenza Creative Commons Attribuzione - Non commerciale - Non opere derivate.
Per i termini e le condizioni di utilizzo di questa opera consultare il sito: http://creativecommons.org/.
30 M. RESCH

18% make a healthy profit margin of over 20 percent (3). In other words, at
the top end, a few galleries have worked out how to run a highly lucrative
gallery space. At the lower end, however, there is a sea of galleries that pro-
duce little profit – or none at all. Germany’s gallery distribution is particu-
larly weighted towards poorer performers, with 34% running at a loss, com-
pared to 29% in the US and 23% in the UK. At the more profitable end,
meanwhile, only 9% of Germany’s galleries have high profit margins above
20 percent, compared to the UK, where a quarter show attractive margins.

3.2.1 Revenue vs. Profit Margin


Revenue vs. Profit Margin

United States Germany United Kingdom Average

25%

20%
Average Profit Margin in %

16%
14%
15%

10%
9% 9%
10%
7%

5% 3%
13%

12%

10%

15%

11%

13%
17%
15%

19%

18%
2%
2%
6%

6%
7%

7%
8%

9%

5%

8%
2%

0%
< $200,000 $200,000 - $400,000 - $600,000 - $800,000 - $1,000,000 - > $5,000,000
$400,000 $600,000 $800.000 $1,000,000 $5,000,000
Revenue

The relationship between revenue and profit (the profit margin or profit-
ability) is a good indicator to see how efficiently galleries are working, and
to learn more about the cost structure. Graphically analyzed, this can take the

3. Profit margin is the net income divided by revenues. It measures how much out of every
dollar of revenue a company actually keeps in earnings. Profit margin is very useful when
comparing companies in a similar industry. Profit margin is displayed as a percentage; a 20
percent profit margin, for example, means the company has a net income of $0.20 for each
dollar of sales.

Copyright © FrancoAngeli
Opera pubblicata con Licenza Creative Commons Attribuzione - Non commerciale - Non opere derivate.
Per i termini e le condizioni di utilizzo di questa opera consultare il sito: http://creativecommons.org/.
THE INTERNATIONAL ART GALLERY INDUSTRY: A STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS 31

form of a bell curve: a revenue point after which profitability goes down. Or,
the profitability graph can grow exponentially to revenue, so the more reve-
nue, the higher the profitability. In order to create this graph, the data was
regrouped to look at profit margins in the revenue clusters.
Germany, again, is weakest in almost all revenue clusters. However, the
important discovery is that profit margin does not remain constant with rev-
enue but improves as revenue increases; in other words, galleries with higher
revenue show a larger profit margin. Those with revenue above a million
dollars show profit margins of 14 percent or more, while galleries with rev-
enue under two hundred thousand dollars generate a much lower profit mar-
gin of 3 percent. It seems that the cost structure of galleries is reasonably
fixed, and does not increase in line with revenue. In practical terms, this
means that galleries profit from a better use of their resources. Operational
expenditure stays the same whether one or three works are sold at an open-
ing; if costs remain stable and revenue goes up, profitability increases.

3.3 Focus

Galleries were also asked for their focus sector, or, as students of market-
ing would say, their product mix. We included only galleries that sell Fine
Art. Fine Art is the dominant cluster in the art market, leaving Decorative

Copyright © FrancoAngeli
Opera pubblicata con Licenza Creative Commons Attribuzione - Non commerciale - Non opere derivate.
Per i termini e le condizioni di utilizzo di questa opera consultare il sito: http://creativecommons.org/.
32 M. RESCH

Art and Antiques far behind. Galleries were then asked to describe their prod-
uct split among five different Fine Art categories:
• Contemporary Art: Artists born after 1960;
• Post-War Art: Artists born after 1910;
• Modern Art: Artists born between 1875 and 1910;
• Nineteenth Century Art: Artists born between 1821 and 1874;
• Old Masters: Artists born before 1821.
Unsurprisingly, the US, UK, and Germany primarily deal in Contempo-
rary Art. An overwhelming 93% of all galleries in the survey sell Contem-
porary Art; 23% also trade in Modern Art, and 16% in Post-War Art. Nine-
teenth Century Art is sold by 10%, and only a small remainder of 5% deal in
Old Masters.
The product mix is more diversified in the US and UK, with Modern Art
sold by around 30% of galleries. In Germany, this figure drops to 15%, but
their Contemporary Art presence is marginally above average, with 97%
dealing in Contemporary Art (with or without other categories alongside
them).

Focus: Contemporary Art only

Contemporary Art and other Categories Contemporary Art only

100%
90%
80%
70%
70% 75%
60% 85%
in %

50%
40%
30%
20%
30% 25%
10% 15%
0%
United States Germany United Kingdom
Country

Contemporary Art is clearly the runaway sector of choice. And galleries


tend to focus only on this sector. 78% of all galleries sell solely Contempo-
rary Art and no other sector, a figure that rises to an incredible 90% in Berlin.
In the UK and US, the chances of seeing something other than Contemporary

Copyright © FrancoAngeli
Opera pubblicata con Licenza Creative Commons Attribuzione - Non commerciale - Non opere derivate.
Per i termini e le condizioni di utilizzo di questa opera consultare il sito: http://creativecommons.org/.
THE INTERNATIONAL ART GALLERY INDUSTRY: A STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS 33

Art are better. Around one-third of all galleries in these countries are, to some
extent, diversified.
The appeal of Contemporary Art might derive from the auction market.
Here a combination of Post-War and Contemporary Art accounts for nearly
half the Fine Art auction market (46%). Contemporary Art certainly has the
most exciting reputation – the majority of the eighty lots that sold for over
ten million dollars in 2013 were from this sector – so it’s not surprising that
gallerists expect this sector to attract the greatest number of collectors, and
show greatest profitability numbers.

3.4 Competitors

Competition is a critical factor in any market where supply exceeds de-


mand, and competitors to art galleries come from every corner. There are
direct competitors (other galleries); their suppliers (artists); their business
partners (dealers); and there are other market players that have been around
for varying periods of time, but who are now entering the competitive land-
scape in force (auction houses and online platforms).
Galleries were asked to rank these key competitors. Since most galleries
offer primarily not just art but specifically Contemporary Art, they rank other
galleries as their primary competitor, followed by dealers. It was initially a
surprise to see artists ranked in third place, but many artists sell some of their

Copyright © FrancoAngeli
Opera pubblicata con Licenza Creative Commons Attribuzione - Non commerciale - Non opere derivate.
Per i termini e le condizioni di utilizzo di questa opera consultare il sito: http://creativecommons.org/.
34 M. RESCH

output privately through their studios, cutting out the gallerist’s margin. Plac-
ing them above auction houses is suggestive of the frustration among gallery
owners that they have not found a way of preventing artists from cannibaliz-
ing gallery trade. Auction houses rank fourth, and finally online platforms
are the fifth most serious – or the least serious – competitor.
In a time of such frequent new art start-ups, it is surprising that galleries
are not beginning to see online platforms as a serious threat. However, at this
point, most online platforms partner with galleries on a commission basis to
display a selection of the gallery’s portfolio, and are therefore seen as part-
ners; other online platforms that cut out the gallery as intermediary between
artist and buyer (for example Saatchi-art.com) usually serve a separate, and
often lower-end, client base, so are not regarded as competitors for the same
clients.

3.5 Founding Year


Founding Year

United States Germany United Kingdom Average

45%
37%
40%
35%
I 30%
n 25% 21%
20% 14% 12%
% 15%
8%
10% 2% 1% 4%
14%
12%
18%

23%
20%
16%

35%
42%
33%

10%
12%
19%

5%
2%
2%
3%

2%
2%
1%

4%
4%

9%
7%
6%
4%

0%
<1950 1951 - 1961 - 1971 - 1981 - 1991 - 2001- 2010 >2010
1960 1970 1980 1990 2000
Founding Year

Given the tough market conditions, a high failure rate among galleries is
not unexpected. In general, galleries do not have long histories. Almost half
were founded after 2000 (12% since 2010) and more than 40% were founded
in the last three decades of the twentieth century. Only a small fraction, 7%,
has been operating for more than forty-five years. Galleries simply cannot
replicate the historical sustainability of auction houses. Even powerhouses
like Gagosian have no clear succession plan.

Copyright © FrancoAngeli
Opera pubblicata con Licenza Creative Commons Attribuzione - Non commerciale - Non opere derivate.
Per i termini e le condizioni di utilizzo di questa opera consultare il sito: http://creativecommons.org/.
THE INTERNATIONAL ART GALLERY INDUSTRY: A STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS 35

4. Customers and exhibitions

Galleries stand or fall by the conversion rate of visitors to buyers. Visitors


may flock through the doors in their hundreds, but buyers, those that actually
finance the gallery, form a tiny fraction of their number.

4.1 Visitors

Visitors are separated into five groups:


• Art Enthusiasts: Frequently visit galleries but no intention of buying;
• Opening Crowd: Interested in the event;
• Collectors: Buy artworks;
• Walk-ins: Do not set out to go to a gallery, and just enter on impulse;
• Art Professionals: Artists, dealers, critics, museum directors, etc.
The most frequent visitors to the gallery are the Art Enthusiast and the
Opening Crowd. Neither has any interest in buying art, but come to either
see the art or socialize. For a gallery that needs to sell, these visitors are cer-
tainly part of the life of a gallery, but they have no impact on revenue. The
most valuable group of visitors to a gallery, Collectors with the potential to
buy, come third. Ranked fourth are Walk-ins. Given the passing footfall in
the central locations where most galleries are found, the persistently low
numbers of Walk-ins is remarkable, and it suggests that there are still strong

Copyright © FrancoAngeli
Opera pubblicata con Licenza Creative Commons Attribuzione - Non commerciale - Non opere derivate.
Per i termini e le condizioni di utilizzo di questa opera consultare il sito: http://creativecommons.org/.
36 M. RESCH

psychological barriers in the public’s mind to entering a gallery. Art profes-


sionals are the least frequent visitors, and as a group it includes artists who
would like to introduce their work to the gallery.

4.2 Buyers

Buyers can be divided into six categories, each with different motivations.
• Art Lovers: Buy for the love of art, to extend their collection, or as
source of inspiration;
• One-Time Buyers: Buy to signal (or to aspire to) social status, or for
decorative purposes;
• Dealers/Professionals: Buy to resell or in the name of a client;
• Investors/Speculators: Consider art as alternative investment, art flip-
pers;
• Museums/Foundations: Public museums and foundations;
• Corporate Collectors: Corporations such as UBS, Deutsche Bank, JP
Morgan Chase, etc.
The most frequent buyer at an art gallery is the Art Lover, who represents
the old-school type of collector. A perfect (and often quoted example) are
Herbert and Dorothy Vogel, who spend most of their money on collecting
art. Art Lovers are keenly interested in the development of the artists and
usually have a lasting and strong relationship with the gallery owner. The Art
Lover is the cornerstone of any gallery’s success. The second group in the
list is One-Time Buyers. They usually do not establish a lasting relationship
with the gallery, and disappear as quickly as they emerged. However, they
are ranked in second place, and thus are a valuable source of revenue. Ranked
third are Dealers/Professionals, followed by Investors/Speculators. Natu-
rally, there is a degree of overlap between those who love art and those who
see profit in a purchase. The Mugrabi family, for example, are passionate art
collectors but also have a strong interest in its business potential. In the US,
Investors/Speculators rise to third in importance, explaining the prominent
media coverage of “art flippers” and Wall Street icons who treat art as an
asset (and are willing to resell, fast). In all three countries, the remaining
institutional buyers occupy fifth and sixth positions: Museums and, finally,
Corporate Collectors. Despite their position as the least frequent buyers, the
budgets that major firms are now allocating for their art foundation are not
without significance. Deutsche Bank, JP Morgan Chase, and Bank of Amer-
ica are only some examples of companies with heavyweight art collections.

Copyright © FrancoAngeli
Opera pubblicata con Licenza Creative Commons Attribuzione - Non commerciale - Non opere derivate.
Per i termini e le condizioni di utilizzo di questa opera consultare il sito: http://creativecommons.org/.
THE INTERNATIONAL ART GALLERY INDUSTRY: A STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS 37

The most frequent buyers in art galleries are private individuals, and all
the market indications suggest that this will not change. Larry’s List Art Col-
lector Report shows a strong dominance of collectors in the UK, US, and
Germany (4). The country with the highest collector share is the US (25% of
all global collectors), followed by Germany (8%) and the UK (7%). Of
course, New York and London are the top two collector cities. New York is
home to 9% of all collectors; 6% live in London. Berlin’s collectors as a body
are ranked a more modest seventh.
Economic variables, such as income and the wealth of a country’s popu-
lation, are also worth examination. All three countries showed positive GDP
growth in 2013. Among those classified as wealthy, HNWIs (5) are of the
strongest interest to the art market. Their number at the end of 2013 was
approximately 13.7 million, up almost 70 percent since the end of 2001 after
a period of 14.7 percent year-on-year growth.

4. Larry’s List Art Collector Report, 2014.


5. This definition of HNWI is that used in the Capgemini and RBC Wealth Management
(2014) World Wealth Report from which these figures are derived. It measures HNWIs as those
with US$1 million or more at their disposal for investing and therefore excludes personal assets
and property, collectibles and other consumables. These will be referred to as HNWIs.

Copyright © FrancoAngeli
Opera pubblicata con Licenza Creative Commons Attribuzione - Non commerciale - Non opere derivate.
Per i termini e le condizioni di utilizzo di questa opera consultare il sito: http://creativecommons.org/.
38 M. RESCH

The US saw the greatest growth among its HNWI population, which
reached four million. US-based HNWIs also allocate the highest percentage,
by country, of their so-called investments of passion to art (6): 19 percent of
their expenditure on investments of passion go on art, compared to 16 per-
cent in Germany and only 14 percent in the UK. The outlook is positive, with
market consensus that the number of collectors and investments in art will
increase as wealthy people seek investments with long-term value.

5. Costs structure
A growing customer base, yet second-rate or worse revenues and a slim
profit margin raises several questions about the cost structure of art galleries.
Galleries were asked to rank their costs from a given list of items.

5.1 Ranking of Costs

6. This term is used in the annual World Wealth Reports from Cap Gemini and RBC
Wealth Management and refers to investments in art, antiques, collectibles, sports invest-
ments, jewelry and gems, and others. Art was the third most popular; the most popular were
jewelry and watches, and wine and antiques.

Copyright © FrancoAngeli
Opera pubblicata con Licenza Creative Commons Attribuzione - Non commerciale - Non opere derivate.
Per i termini e le condizioni di utilizzo di questa opera consultare il sito: http://creativecommons.org/.
THE INTERNATIONAL ART GALLERY INDUSTRY: A STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS 39

On average, rent is generally the highest overhead for galleries, with sal-
aries, fairs and transportation costs falling into second, third, and fourth
place. A country analysis shows some regional variation in the rank position
of these four expenses, but all other costs, including advertising and insur-
ance, are identically ranked in positions five to eight.
Since most galleries are located in premium locations in major cities, rent
remains a high cost in a country breakdown, although in the UK payroll is a
slightly bigger burden. Salaries in the US are the second highest overhead,
and in Germany the third highest. Although salaries may be pushed into third
place in Germany by high expenditure on art fairs, German employees in
particular might agree with claims that pay in the sector – at least in some
regions – is too low. Art fairs are ranked third in the UK and only fourth in
the US.

5.2 Size

Size

United States Germany United Kingdom Average

100%
90%
80%
65%
70%
60%
in %

50%
40%
30% 18% 17%
20%
10% 32% 92% 71% 32% 6% 17% 36% 2% 12%
0%
0-300 m² 300-600 m² >600 m²
Size of Gallery

Rental costs are, of course, affected by the size of the space. Even by the
standards of art industry market intelligence, very little was on record about
gallery space. The survey revealed that 65% of all galleries are smaller than
300m² (3,200ft²). In fact, 30% of all galleries are under 100m² (1,100ft²).
Gallerists almost unanimously trade space for a central location in a major

Copyright © FrancoAngeli
Opera pubblicata con Licenza Creative Commons Attribuzione - Non commerciale - Non opere derivate.
Per i termini e le condizioni di utilizzo di questa opera consultare il sito: http://creativecommons.org/.
40 M. RESCH

city. Only 18% are medium-sized galleries with an area between 300m2 and
600m2 (6,500ft²), while 17% exceed 600m².
By country, it’s clear where space is an expensive commodity: galleries
in the US are much more generously-sized than in Germany or the UK. 68%
are over 300m², compared to 29% in the UK and only 8% in Germany. Only
one-third are under 300m2, compared to 92% in Germany and 71% in the
UK.

5.3 Art Fairs

Art Fair Participation

United States Germany United Kingdom Average

60%
45% 42%
50%
40%
in %

30%
20% 11%
2% 1%
10%
53%
40%
37%

36%
46%
46%

13%
15%
7%

3%
1%
0%

0%
0%
2%
0%
0 1-3 4-6 7-9 >9
Number of Art Fairs

Art fairs, for galleries, are the equivalent of an international presence,


giving gallerists a window of a few days to court collectors from around the
world.
The number of art fairs has shot up over the last decade, mostly as a con-
sequence of the increasing attempts among galleries to enlarge their cus-
tomer base and show artists internationally. Today, there are nearly three
hundred art fairs around the world.
Fair attendance is very popular. Every second gallery participates in at
least one fair. The majority of those that go to fairs participate in one to three
per year, with a notable 14% attending four or more fairs.
US galleries seem to put less faith in fair participation than their European
counterparts: 53% avoid fairs altogether, compared to 40% in Germany and
37% in the UK.

Copyright © FrancoAngeli
Opera pubblicata con Licenza Creative Commons Attribuzione - Non commerciale - Non opere derivate.
Per i termini e le condizioni di utilizzo di questa opera consultare il sito: http://creativecommons.org/.
THE INTERNATIONAL ART GALLERY INDUSTRY: A STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS 41

5.4 Employees

So far we have been talking about the structural data of art galleries. But
who is actually doing the work? This section deals with those that do the
work: the gallery’s employees. Salaries are a leading expense, according to
this survey. In a business environment where there is little opportunity to
turn to automation or outsourcing, running a gallery is always likely to re-
quire a great deal of personal input, and might therefore be expected to bear
a heavy payroll burden.

Copyright © FrancoAngeli
Opera pubblicata con Licenza Creative Commons Attribuzione - Non commerciale - Non opere derivate.
Per i termini e le condizioni di utilizzo di questa opera consultare il sito: http://creativecommons.org/.
42 M. RESCH

In practice, however, art galleries are small enterprises in terms of em-


ployment numbers. A companionless 11% of gallerists run their business
with no assistance, and only 25% employ more than four people.
Employing full-timers is evidently not common practice at art galleries.
Overall, 40% of art galleries do not have a full-time employee – a strategy
that is particularly evident in Germany – and only a small minority of 8%
have more than four full-time employed staff members. Cities reflect country
patterns.
The weighting towards part-time employees is particularly visible in Ger-
many and the UK, where 90% of solo gallery employees are part-time, and
most likely freelancers or interns. In galleries with more employees, the ratio
of part-timers to full-timers shifts more into balance, but a preference for
part-timers persists. Freelancers may work for a set number of hours per
month for the gallery, and interns – who mostly work at very low rates – are
extensively used. Only 21% of all galleries have no freelancers on their pay-
roll. Of those that employ part-timers, the majority employ two or more.
In the UK, 84% of galleries employ part-timers, a level all but matched
in Germany (83%), compared to 73% in the US. In Germany, however, gal-
leries fight shy of too many hires; only 8% employ four or more part-timers.
US and UK galleries are more likely to recruit extra hands, with 17% of US
galleries and 22% in the UK employing four or more part-timers.

Bibliography

Afuah, A. e Tucci, C. L., Internet Business Models and Strategies: Text and Cases
(2nd ed.), Boston, McGraw-Hill, 2003.
Artprice.com, Art Market Trends 2014. Retrieved from www.artprice.com. 2014.
Baumol, W., Unnatural value: or art investment as floating crap game. American
Economic Review, 1986, 10-14.
Benhamou, F., Heritage. In A Handbook of Cultural Economics, Cheltenham, UK,
Edward Elgar, 2003, pp. 255-262.
Butler, P., By Popular Demand: Marketing the Arts, in «Journal of Marketing Man-
agement», 16(4), 2000, pp. 343-364.
Byrnes, W., Management and the Arts (5th ed.), Burlington, Focal Press, 2014.
Caldwell, N., The emergence of museum brands, in «International Journal of Arts
Management», 2(3), 2000, pp. 28-34.
Capgemini & RBS, World Wealth Report 2014. Retrieved from
www.worldwealthreport.com. 2014.

Copyright © FrancoAngeli
Opera pubblicata con Licenza Creative Commons Attribuzione - Non commerciale - Non opere derivate.
Per i termini e le condizioni di utilizzo di questa opera consultare il sito: http://creativecommons.org/.
THE INTERNATIONAL ART GALLERY INDUSTRY: A STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS 43

Chanel, O., Gérard-Varet, L.-A. e Ginsburgh, V., The relevance of hedonic price
indices: the case of paintings, in «Journal of Cultural Economics», 20(1), 1996,
pp. 1-24.
Frey, B. S., Arts & Economics Analysis & Cultural Policy (2nd ed.). Berlin, Sprin-
ger, 2007.
Gérard-Varet, L.-A., On pricing the priceless: comments on the economics of the
visual art market, in «European Economic Review», 39(3-4), 1995, pp. 509-518.
McAndrew, C., TEFAF Art Market Report, Maastricht, TEFAF, 2014.
Mei, J. e Moses, M., Art as an investment and the underperformance of master-
pieces, in «American Economic Review», 92, 2002, pp. 1656-1668.
Resch, M. e Noe, C., Larry’s List Art Collector Report 2014, Nuermberg, Verlag für
Moderne Kunst, 2014.
Resch, M., Management of Art Galleries, Berlin, Phaidon, 2016.
Roberts, J. e Greene, C., Arts Entrepreneurship, The Business of the Arts, Bloom-
ingdale, United Press Services, 2008.
Velthuis, O., Talking Prices: Symbolic Meanings of Prices on the Market for Con-
temporary Art, Princeton, University Press, 2007.

Copyright © FrancoAngeli
Opera pubblicata con Licenza Creative Commons Attribuzione - Non commerciale - Non opere derivate.
Per i termini e le condizioni di utilizzo di questa opera consultare il sito: http://creativecommons.org/.
44 M. RESCH

Copyright © FrancoAngeli
Opera pubblicata con Licenza Creative Commons Attribuzione - Non commerciale - Non opere derivate.
Per i termini e le condizioni di utilizzo di questa opera consultare il sito: http://creativecommons.org/.

You might also like