2011 N09 CO Poisoning
2011 N09 CO Poisoning
2011 N09 CO Poisoning
Volume 8, Number 9
To Pediatric Carbon Monoxide Author
Abby M. Williams, MD
Case Presentation Upon completion of this article, you should be able to:
1. Describe the mechanisms by which CO is a harmful
exposure.
You have just arrived for your 7AM shift on a chilly January morning when 2. Identify patients at risk for CO poisoning.
an unresponsive 21-month-old girl is brought in by emergency medical 3. Recognize the signs and symptoms of CO poisoning.
4. Create a treatment and follow-up plan for any patient
services. On arrival to the ED, she is noted to be lethargic and flaccid. She after CO exposure.
is immediately placed on a cardiorespiratory monitor and the following 5. Discuss the controversies related to hyperbaric
oxygen therapy for CO poisoning.
vital signs are obtained: temperature 37.5°C (99.5°F), heart rate 154 beats
per minute, respiratory rate 32 breaths per minute, blood pressure 86/57 Acknowledgment
mm Hg, and oxygen saturations of 99% on face mask oxygen. On physical
examination, you note sluggish opening of her eyes to voice. She moans and A very special thank you to the author’s local toxicology
expert, Dr. Donna Seger, for her suggestions in the writing
localizes to pain, and her skin is pale. She is not apneic or cyanotic. Other of this review.
than her altered level of consciousness, the rest of her physical examination
Prior to beginning this activity, see “Physician CME
is normal. She appears to be managing her airway appropriately. Emer- Information” on back page.
gency medical services reports that a serum glucose obtained in route was
98 mg/dL.
AAP Sponsor Medicine, University of Medicine and Medicine Department, Chief - Tommy Y. Kim, MD, FAAP Gary R. Strange, MD, MA, FACEP
Dentistry of New Jersey; Director, Pediatric Emergency Medicine Assistant Professor of Emergency Professor and Head, Department
Martin I. Herman, MD, FAAP, FACEP Pediatric Emergency Medicine, Division, Medical Director - Pediatric Medicine and Pediatrics, Loma of Emergency Medicine, University
Professor of Pediatrics, UT College Children’s Medical Center, Atlantic Emergency Department, University Linda Medical Center and of Illinois, Chicago, IL
of Medicine, Assistant Director of Health System; Department of of Florida Health Science Center Children’s Hospital, Loma
Emergency Services, Lebonheur Christopher Strother, MD
Emergency Medicine, Morristown Jacksonville, Jacksonville, FL Linda, CA
Children’s Medical Center, Assistant Professor,Director,
Memorial Hospital, Morristown, NJ Alson S. Inaba, MD, FAAP,
Memphis, TN Brent R. King, MD, FACEP, FAAP, Undergraduate and Emergency
Ran D. Goldman, MD PALS-NF FAAEM Simulation, Mount Sinai School of
Editorial Board Associate Professor, Department Pediatric Emergency Medicine Professor of Emergency Medicine Medicine, New York, NY
Jeffrey R. Avner, MD, FAAP of Pediatrics, University of Toronto; Attending Physician, Kapiolani and Pediatrics; Chairman, Adam Vella, MD, FAAP
Professor of Clinical Pediatrics Division of Pediatric Emergency Medical Center for Women & Department of Emergency Medicine, Assistant Professor of Emergency
and Chief of Pediatric Emergency Medicine and Clinical Pharmacology Children; Associate Professor of The University of Texas Houston Medicine, Director Of Pediatric
Medicine, Albert Einstein College and Toxicology, The Hospital for Sick Pediatrics, University of Hawaii Medical School, Houston, TX Emergency Medicine, Mount Sinai
of Medicine, Children’s Hospital at Children, Toronto, ON John A. Burns School of Medicine, Robert Luten, MD School of Medicine, New York, NY
Montefiore, Bronx, NY Honolulu, HI; Pediatric Advanced
Mark A. Hostetler, MD, MPH Clinical Professor, Pediatrics and
Life Support National Faculty Michael Witt, MD, MPH, FACEP,
T. Kent Denmark, MD, FAAP, FACEP Professor of Pediatrics and Emergency Medicine, University of
Representative, American Heart FAAP
Medical Director, Medical Simulation Emergency Medicine, University of Florida, Jacksonville, FL
Association, Hawaii and Pacific Medical Director, Pediatric
Center; Associate Professor of Arizona Children’s Hospital Division
Island Region Ghazala Q. Sharieff, MD, FAAP, Emergency Medicine, Elliot Hospital
Emergency Medicine and Pediatrics, of Emergency Medicine, Phoenix, FACEP, FAAEM Manchester, NH
Loma Linda University Medical AZ Andy Jagoda, MD, FACEP Associate Clinical Professor, Children’s
Center and Children’s Hospital, Madeline Matar Joseph, MD, FAAP, Professor and Chair, Department Hospital and Health Center/University Research Editor
Loma Linda, CA of Emergency Medicine, Mount
FACEP of California, San Diego; Director Lana Friedman, MD Fellow,
Sinai School of Medicine; Medical
Michael J. Gerardi, MD, FAAP, Associate Professor of Emergency of Pediatric Emergency Medicine, Pediatric Emergency Medicine,
Director, Mount Sinai Hospital, New
FACEP Medicine and Pediatrics, Assistant California Emergency Physicians, San Mount Sinai School of Medicine,
York, NY
Clinical Assistant Professor of Chair for Pediatrics - Emergency Diego, CA New York, NY
Accreditation: EB Medicine is accredited by the ACCME to provide continuing medical education for physicians. Faculty Disclosure: Dr. Williams, Dr. Kim, Dr. Rhee, and their related parties
report no significant financial interest or other relationship with the manufacturer(s) of any commercial product(s) discussed in this educational presentation. Commercial Support: This issue of
Pediatric Emergency Medicine Practice did not receive any commercial support.
Her mother arrives 20 minutes later and states relationship of Sudden Unexpected Infant Death
that the child is previously healthy, and she was in her Syndrome (SUIDS) and CO poisoning. Omalu et al
normal state of health when she placed her in the crib at reported a link between SUIDS and CO poisoning4
bedtime. Mother says she went to check on her daughter while Variend and Forrest reported no association
this morning when she did not wake at her normal time in a series of 50 infants who died unexpectedly.5
and found her unresponsive with vomitus in the crib. Further evaluation is necessary to elucidate a link
She has not had any fevers, upper respiratory symptoms, between SUIDS and CO poisoning.
diarrhea, or rashes. There is no history of trauma, and Carbon monoxide poisoning is frequently as-
the child has been in the care of her mother. When ques- sociated with inhalation injuries. When associated
tioned about sick contact exposure, the child’s mother with a thermal burn, it is easier to recognize a CO
states that she has not been feeling well, with headache exposure. However, CO poisoning may go unrec-
and nausea upon waking this morning; however, she is ognized and undetected, leading to morbidity and
currently feeling better. mortality.6 Carbon monoxide poisoning often pres-
What other history would you like to obtain from the ents to the emergency department (ED) as a constel-
mother? What diagnostic tests and therapies do you want lation of non-specific symptoms. It is not detectable
to start? on routine drug screens. The clinician must pay close
While you are entering your orders, the nurse calls attention to the details of the history and have a high
you to the bedside because the patient has started to seize. index of suspicion in order to avoid missing this
potentially lethal exposure.
Introduction
Critical Appraisal Of The Literature
Carbon monoxide is an odorless, colorless gas re-
leased from the incomplete combustion of burning The literature review was launched with Ovid
hydrocarbons. Carbon monoxide has been called a MEDLINE® and PubMed searches for articles on
“great imitator” and “silent killer.” Carbon monox- CO poisoning from 1965-2010. Keywords included
ide poisoning is the most common preventable toxic CO poisoning and inhalation injury. All searches were
exposure resulting in death in children 12 years and limited to the English language, human subjects, and
younger.1 In this age group, it is typically an unin- children ages 0-18 years. Of 251 articles identified,
tentional poisoning. In adolescents, especially males, 88 are provided for the reader’s reference. Further-
CO poisoning may be intentional.2 It has also been more, a search of the Cochrane database revealed
described as a form of child abuse by caregivers.3 one review on the use of hyperbaric oxygen (HBO)
Finally, there has been mixed evidence between the for CO poisoning. Additionally, the 2008 data from
the 26th Annual Report of the American Association
of Poison Control Centers (AAPCC) (http://www.
Table Of Contents aapcc.org) National Poison Data System (NPDS)
Abstract........................................................................ 1 was reviewed for details regarding CO poisoning
Case Presentation.......................................................1 in children. The bibliographies of the best articles
Introduction................................................................2 were also reviewed, and references were pulled from
Critical Appraisal Of The Literature....................... 2 these articles.
Epidemiology, Etiology, And Pathophysiology..... 2 Unfortunately, there are only very limited case
Differential Diagnosis................................................ 3 series and case reports in the literature describing
Prehospital Care......................................................... 3 CO poisoning in children. Most of the published
Emergency Department Evaluation........................ 5 data is inferred from published data in adults. The
Diagnostic Studies...................................................... 6 most recent studies in the literature focus on fast,
Clinical Pathway For Management Of Carbon easy, non-invasive, and inexpensive ways to detect
Monoxide Poisoning In Children..........................7 CO levels in a patient as well as newer technologies
Treatment..................................................................... 8 to detect neurological damage as a result of expo-
Prognosis..................................................................... 9 sure. There is much debate regarding HBO therapy.
Controversies And Cutting Edge.............................9 Most of the published data are from the 1980s and
Risk Management Pitfalls For Carbon Monoxide come from regional burn centers and coastal areas
Poisoning............................................................... 10 where hyperbaric chambers are available.
Cost-Effective Strategies..........................................11 For information on carbon monoxide exposure
Special Circumstances............................................. 12 in adult patients, see the February 2011 Emergency
Disposition................................................................ 12 Medicine Practice article, “Diagnosis And Manage-
Summary................................................................... 12 ment Of Carbon Monoxide Poisoning In The Emer-
Case Conclusion....................................................... 12 gency Department.”
References.................................................................. 13
CME Questions......................................................... 15
Reprinted with permission from: Weaver LK. Carbon monoxide poisoning. NEJM. 2009;360:1217-1225. Copyright
2009, Massachusetts Medical Society.
Are the history and/or symptoms suggestive of a Was the patient involved in a fire or are they at risk
potential CO exposure? for inhalational injury?
NO YES NO YES
YES
Abbreviations:
Asymptomatic/
Moderate/Severe CO, carbon monoxide;
Mild
HBO, hyperbaric oxygen;
PICU, pediatric intensive care unit.
On oxygen for at
Do symptoms
least 4 hours
continue despite
and now symp-
oxygen therapy?
toms resolved?
YES NO NO YES
Discharge home Admit to general Admit to general Consider HBO therapy after toxi-
with follow-up. ward. ward or PICU. cology consult. (Class III)
This clinical pathway is intended to supplement, rather than substitute for, professional judgment and may be changed depending upon a patient’s individual
needs. Failure to comply with this pathway does not represent a breach of the standard of care.
Copyright © 2010 EB Medicine. 1-800-249-5770. No part of this publication may be reproduced in any format without written consent of EB Medicine.
1. “I did not consider carbon monoxide on the 6. “I saw the burns on the patient’s face, but he
differential diagnosis.” was breathing fine, so I didn’t think he needed
Patients with carbon monoxide poisoning intubation.”
typically present with a constellation of non- Delay in securing the airway in a patient
specific complaints such as headache, nausea, involved in a fire with evidence of facial burns
vomiting, and lethargy. As it is more common and inhalation injury can be detrimental.
in winter months when viral syndromes are Airway edema may not occur for hours after
frequent reasons for visits to the emergency inhalation injury, and once recognized, it may
department, it is a diagnosis that may be be very difficult to secure the airway at that
easily overlooked. A good clinician should time. All children presenting with evidence of
inquire about potential carbon monoxide burns to the face and airway should have an
exposures for any patient presenting with endotracheal tube placed and be given 100%
non-specific complaints. oxygen via the tube.
2. “The patient has a normal oxygen saturation, 7. “I know the diagnosis is carbon monox-
so there is no evidence of hypoxia.” ide poisoning, so my evaluation is com-
Hemoglobin molecules become saturated at plete.”
very low partial pressures of oxygen, so the Children with carbon monoxide exposure
clinician cannot rely on a pulse oximetry to and toxicity also present with co-morbidities
show evidence of hypoxia. Carbon monoxide such as inhalation injury, dermal burns, and
exposure cannot be diagnosed using oxygen cyanide poisoning. The clinician should
saturation readings. consider these co-morbidities in addition to
treating with oxygen.
3. “The child was only exposed to a low level of
carbon monoxide, so this is not a significant 8. “The COHb level was very low, so it is okay to
exposure.” discharge the child home.”
Carbon monoxide has a higher affinity for Relying on the COHb level as an absolute
hemoglobin than oxygen, so it only takes indication of symptoms, clinical course, and
a small amount to cause toxicity. Smaller prognosis is dangerous. Studies have shown
volumes of exposure for a longer time may be that children can be symptomatic at low COHb
just as toxic as a high volume exposure for a levels.
short period of time.
9. “The child is at baseline mental status after
4. “Carbon monoxide poisoning only occurs in oxygen therapy. I can send him home because
enclosed spaces.” there is nothing else to do.”
There have been reports of children with carbon Do not forget to counsel parents about
monoxide toxicity in open air environments delayed neurological sequelae. This includes
while riding in the back of cars and trucks and neurological as well as neuropsychological
while playing outside near generators. problems that occur several days to weeks after
exposure. Ideally, the primary care physician
5. “I will just wait for the laboratory work-up to should be involved in follow-up, and the child
come back before treating the patient.” may be referred to a neurologist.
Oxygen is the antidote for carbon monoxide
poisoning. Delay in treatment with 100% oxygen 10. “It is up to the family to handle the environ-
while awaiting results of diagnostic tests may ment where the exposure occurred.”
increase morbidity and mortality. Anyone Social work may be involved during the
suspected of carbon monoxide exposure should emergency department visit to assist the family
be placed on 100% oxygen via facemask while in ensuring a safe, carbon monoxide-free
work-up is pending. environment and providing carbon monoxide
monitors for the home. Furthermore, local
fire departments and gas companies may be
involved to provide any additional assistance
and deem the home safe.
Cost-Effective Strategies
1. When CO poisoning is suspected, the patient 3. Consult toxicology colleagues and/or your local
should be placed immediately on oxygen while poison control early.
the work-up is pending. Consultation may reduce the pursuit of
100% oxygen is the antidote to CO poisoning. unnecessary tests and expensive therapies such
Its administration is safe and easy. When it as hyperbaric oxygen. These colleagues can best
is initiated early in the evaluation, it reduces guide the clinician in which patients should be
the patient’s length of stay and morbidity and admitted and which can be safely discharged
mortality. home.
2. Do not follow the COHb levels too closely. 4. If a patient is deemed safe to discharge home,
A positive COHb level only confirms an ensure that the environment where the expo-
exposure, and a negative result does not rule- sure occurred has been cleared and the fam-
out an exposure. A good history is the best way ily has a good safety plan to prevent further
to make the diagnosis of a CO exposure and exposures. This may be done in conjunction
poisoning. Once an exposure is suspected, the with a social worker, fire department, or local
child should be placed on 100% oxygen for at gas company.
least 4 hours regardless of the absolute level This may reduce repeat ED visits by the patient
result. (Caveat: some institutions’ recommend and fresh exposures, thus freeing up resources
100% oxygen for a minimum of 8 or 12 hours; for other patients.
clinicians should follow their institution’s
protocols for use of 100% oxygen.)
Summary References
Carbon monoxide is present in our daily environ- Evidence-based medicine requires a critical ap-
ments and is the most common toxicologic cause praisal of the literature based upon study methodol-
of preventable morbidity and mortality. Clinicians ogy and number of subjects. Not all references are
must stay vigilant, especially in the winter months, equally robust. The findings of a large, prospective,
as to avoid missing the nebulous presentation of randomized, and blinded trial should carry more
CO poisoning. Clinicians cannot rely on presenting weight than a case report.
symptoms and COHb levels to predict prognosis but To help the reader judge the strength of each
should immediately begin treatment by administra- reference, pertinent information about the study,
tion of 100% oxygen. Further treatment with HBO such as the type of study and the number of patients
therapy should be determined in conjunction with a in the study, will be included in bold type following
toxicologist. Prior to discharge, close follow-up and the reference, where available.
safety precautions should be arranged.
1. Bronstein AC, Spyker DA, Cantilena LR, et al 2008 An-
nual Report of the American Association of Poison Control
Case Conclusion Centers’ National Poison Data System (NPDS): 26th Annual
Report. Clin Tox. 2009;47:911-1084. (Retrospective; 4,333,012
The patient is given a dose of intravenous benzodiazepines reports)
with resolution of seizure. Once the seizure stops, the 2. Shepherd G, Klein-Schwartz W. Accidental and suicidal
adolescent poisoning deaths in the United States, 1979-1994.
nurse removes the oxygen from the child’s face and states, Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 1998;152:1181-1185. (Retrospective;
“her oxygen saturation is 97% on room air.” You obtain 4129 subjects)
further social history from the mother and learn that the 3. Lee AC, Ou Y, Lam SY, et al. Non-accidental carbon monox-
family recently had their heat turned off due to trouble ide poisoning from burning charcoal in attempted combined
paying the bill. The mother has been using a kerosene homicide-suicide. J Paediatr Child Health. 2002;38:465-468.
(Retrospective; 8 subjects)
heater for warmth in the room where she and the child 4. Omalu BI, Lindner JL, Janssen JK, et al. The role of environ-
sleep. Due to your immediate concern for CO exposure, mental factors in the causation of sudden death in infants:
you instruct the nurse to keep the child on 100% oxygen two cases of sudden unexpected death in two unrelated
by face mask despite the normal oxygen saturation on infants who were cared for by the same babysitter. J Forensic
room air. You also request the mother check in as a patient Sci. 2007;52:1355-8. Epub 2007 Sep 15. (Case report; 2 sub-
jects)
and place her on oxygen as well. Unfortunately, you do 5. Variend S, Forrest AR. Carbon monoxide concentrations in
not have access to a co-oximeter at your institution. You infant deaths. Arch Dis Child. 1987;62:417-418. (Retrospec-
order a blood gas, serum COHb level, electrolytes, blood tive; 50 subjects)
counts, thyroid studies, urinalysis, urine drug screen, 6. Dolan MC, Halton, TL, Barrows GH, et al. Carboxyhemo-
and an electrocardiogram on the child. The electrocardio- globin levels in patients with flu-like symptoms. Ann Emerg
Med. 1987; 16:782-786. (Prospective; 55 subjects)
gram shows sinus tachycardia. COHb level is elevated at 7. Carbon-monoxide poisoning resulting from exposure to ski-
26% confirming your suspicion of exposure, bicarbonate boat exhaust—Georgia, June 2002. MMWR. 2002;51:829-830.
is 17, and lactate is 1.9. The remaining lab values are (Case report; 2 subjects)
unremarkable. Interestingly, the mother’s serum COHb 8. Houseboat-associated carbon monoxide poisonings on Lake
level is much lower at 11%. You formulate your plan in Powell—Arizona and Utah, 2000. MMWR. 2000;49:1105-1108.
(Case report; 2 subjects)
conjunction with a toxicology colleague who recommends 9. Easley RB. Open air carbon monoxide poisoning in a child
continued oxygen therapy for 12 hours. The toxicologist swimming behind a boat. South Med J. 2000;93:430-432. (Case
in your area does not routinely recommend HBO therapy report; 1 subject)
for nonpregnant patients, so you opt against transferring 10. Hampson NB, Norkool DM. Carbon monoxide poison-
the child to an area where there is a chamber. You transfer ing in children riding in the back of pickup trucks. JAMA.
1992;267:538-540. (Case series; 20 subjects)
the mother to the adult hospital and admit the child to the 11. Muscatiello NA, Babcock G, Jones R, et al. Hospital emer-
hospital for continued oxygen therapy and observation of gency department visits for carbon monoxide poisoning
further seizures or changes in neurological status. At the following an October 2006 snowstorm in Western New York.
end of your shift, you go by the general ward to check on J Environ Health. 2010;72:43-48. (Retrospective; 264 subjects)
the child. Her grandmother is present and informs you 12. Carbon monoxide exposures after Hurricane Ike-Texas,
school 6 weeks after exposure Hardware/Software Requirements: You will need a Macintosh or PC with
internet capabilities to access the website. Adobe Reader is required to
d. Trouble walking and enuresis 3 days download archived articles.
after exposure Additional Policies: For additional policies, including our statement of conflict of
interest, source of funding, statement of informed consent, and statement of
human and animal rights, visit http://www.ebmedicine.net/policies.
5. At what COHb level do signs and symptoms of Method of Participation:
Print Subscription Semester Program: Paid subscribers who read all CME
carbon monoxide poisoning start to occur? articles during each Pediatric Emergency Medicine Practice six-month testing
a. 15% period, complete the post-test and the CME Evaluation Form distributed
with the June and December issues, and return it according to the published
b. 20% instructions are eligible for up to 4 hours of CME credit for each issue. You
must complete both the post-test and CME Evaluation Form to receive credit.
c. 40% Results will be kept confidential.
d. 50% Online Single-Issue Program: Current, paid subscribers who read this Pediatric
Emergency Medicine Practice CME article and complete the online post-test
e. There is no direct correlation between and CME Evaluation Form at ebmedicine.net/CME are eligible for up to 4 hours
presenting signs and symptoms, COHb of Category 1 credit toward the AMA Physician’s Recognition Award (PRA). You
must complete both the post-test and CME Evaluation Form to receive credit.
levels, and prognosis. Results will be kept confidential.
CEO: Robert Williford; President & Publisher: Stephanie Ivy; Director of Member Services: Liz Alvarez
Managing Editor & CME Director: Jennifer Pai; Managing Editor: Dorothy Whisenhunt; Director of Marketing: Robin Williford