PVE PracticalGuide en
PVE PracticalGuide en
PVE PracticalGuide en
VIOLENT
EXTREMISM
THROUGH
SPORT
P RAC T I CA L G U I D E
UNITED NATIONS OFFICE ON DRUGS AND CRIME
Vienna
UNITED NATIONS
Vienna, 2021
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The present practical guide was developed for the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime
(UNODC) by Holly Collison, consultant on sport for development and peace and lecturer at
the Institute for Sport Business, Loughborough University London, with the support of doctoral
researchers Hussa K. Al Khalifa and Lin Cherurbai Sambili-Gicheha. In the UNODC Justice
Section, Georgia Dimitropoulou contributed throughout the development of the practical guide
and coordinated the review process, and Johannes de Haan and Lucia Gonzalez also contributed
to the development of the guide. Tina Mykkänen of the UNODC Regional Office in Eastern
Africa also provided comments and suggestions.
The practical guide is based on the UNODC publication Preventing Violent Extremism through
Sport: Technical Guide and is designed to provide tailored guidance for sport coaches and other
facilitators of sport-based programmes that, building on the power of sport as a tool for develop-
ment and peace, are aimed at preventing violent extremism.
The practical guide has benefited greatly from comments and suggestions provided by Kees van
den Bos (Utrecht University), Paula Isturiz Cavero of the United Nations Educational, Scientific
and Cultural Organization (UNESCO), Achaleke Christian Leke (Local Youth Corner
Cameroon), Bahruz Balayev (Save the Dream organization), Dana Podmolikova (United Nations
Children’s Fund), Ben Sanders (sportanddev.org), Hebe Schaillée (Free University of Brussels),
Ramón Spaaij (Victoria University and University of Amsterdam), Derek Daniels (Grassroot
Soccer South Africa), Azamat Alidaev (Hope Academy of Bishkek), Moses Kinobi (Uganda
Youth Development Link), Ulrich Klar and Dina Klingmann (German Agency for International
Cooperation), Caroline Baxter Tresise (UNESCO) and Kuany Simon (UNESCO Mahatma
Gandhi Institute of Education for Peace and Sustainable Development).
UNODC would also like to express its gratitude to UNESCO for its contributions throughout
the development of the present guide and for organizing an online consultation meeting on the
draft guide on 28 April 2020 with the following members of the UNESCO Youth and Sport
Task Force: Muhammad Taha Tahir, Saif Ullah Khan, Milton Angat Kisapai, Mai Sakaguchi,
Ma. Soteya Apryll Arroyo Trasadas, Yik Wai Chee, Umair Asif, Koem Nith, Qinthara Nabigha
Ridwan, Stephanie Margaux Inocando and Yeang Sethsamprathna.
Finally, UNODC gratefully acknowledges the funding provided by Qatar for the development
of the present guide as part of its support for the Global Programme for the Implementation of
the Doha Declaration.
The designations employed and the presentation of material in this publication do not
imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of the Secretariat of the
United Nations concerning the legal status of any country, territory, city or area or of
its authorities, or concerning the delimitations of its frontiers or boundaries.
Publishing production: English, Publishing and Library Section, United Nations Office
at Vienna.
CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1
CHAPTER 5.
Monitoring, evaluation and learning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 76
ANNEXES
I. Terminology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 62
INTRODUCTION
The present guide is designed as a toolkit to support coaches and other facilitators1 of sport-
based programmes in preparing and delivering sport interventions focused on key messages
and learning opportunities for preventing violent extremism. It contains concepts, resources,
suggested activities and practical tips for facilitators to enhance their knowledge and under-
standing of the key principles of strategies for preventing violence and crime, including
violent extremism, through sport-based activities. The present guide complements the
UNODC publication Preventing Violent Extremism through Sport: Technical Guide, which
provides extensive programming and policy development guidance for policymakers, imple-
menting organizations and other relevant actors, including sport and youth leaders.
The objective of the guide is to provide guidance on creating contextually relevant, safe and
inclusive sport practices for sessions conducted as part of comprehensive strategies for pre-
venting violent extremism. The following elements are essential when considering such
practices:
1
For the purposes of the present guide, the term “facilitator” (or “coach”) is used to describe all types of qualified
practitioners who deliver or implement sport-based interventions and/or programmes. Facilitators should possess profes-
sional, social and methodological competencies to instil positive values in and convey life skills to their participants
through sports. Sport coaches, workers at non-governmental organizations, teachers and/or other community workers
might act as facilitators in sport-based interventions for the prevention of violence and crime, including violent
extremism.
2
INTRODUCTION
The present publication is designed to benefit facilitators working with youth and commu-
nities through sport-based activities delivered by a variety of implementing organizations,
which may include the following:
• Governmental and State organizations and entities, including those focused on
countering and preventing violent extremism
• United Nations agencies
• International and national non-governmental organizations and programmes
• Community-based organizations
• National Olympic Committees
• International, national and local sports federations
• Other sport and youth-led organizations, projects or individuals working to prevent
violent extremism through sports
The guide is designed to support and guide facilitators of sport-based interventions for the
prevention of violent extremism. To help navigate the complexity of violent extremism and
the variety of measures and good practices required to address its root causes through such
interventions, the guide is divided into five clear chapters:
1. Understanding violent extremism. In this chapter, the dynamics and root causes of
violent extremism and radicalization for young populations are explained.
2. Sport and the prevention of violent extremism. This chapter provides coaches with an
understanding of the relationship and the potential of sport to tackle and prevent
violent extremism.
3. Human rights-based approach and safeguarding. In this chapter, human rights, gen-
der equality and child rights are discussed in the context of safeguarding and welfare
for both facilitators and participants.
4. Five zones for preventing violent extremism through sport. In this chapter, the five
zones, which are based on a theory of change identifying relevant areas for interven-
tion and intended outcomes linked to push and pull factors towards violent extrem-
ism,2 are explained. Furthermore, practical guidance is provided, including on
sport-based activities that could form part of curricula and programmes in this area.
5. Monitoring, evaluation and learning. In this chapter, the importance of monitoring
session outcomes and learning is discussed, and tips and tools are provided.
2
See also United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC), Preventing Violent Extremism through Sport:
Technical Guide, Criminal Justice Handbook Series (Vienna, 2020).
3
PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT: PRACTICAL GUIDE
The present guide was developed on the basis of a multidimensional approach to highlight
key connections between the prevention of violent extremism, sport and development out-
comes. Practical resources are also provided in the form of checklists and other guidance.
The guide also includes links to additional resources for more insights and comprehensive
information on specific topics. As mentioned above, the guide also serves as a complemen-
tary resource to the UNODC technical guide on preventing violent extremism through
sport, which contains more comprehensive guidance on the use of sport in this context and
is addressed mainly to policymakers and implementing organizations. At the same time, the
technical guide can also serve as a useful resource for those facilitators who wish to have a
broader overview and more theoretical insight on the issue of sport in the context of pre-
venting violent extremism.
1 PROTECTION
2 PREVENTION
The goal of the present guide is primary prevention, which means focusing on
addressing the causes and risks of radicalization and violent extremism and not
on the disengagement from violence of those persons already engaging with
extreme ideologies or members of extreme groups. For the latter, a different
type of tailored intervention is required.
3 TARGETED APPROACH
The activities in the guide are geared towards specific groups (i.e., children and
youth) that are identified as being at greater risk of recruitment and exploitation
by terrorist groups that can be addressed more effectively with strategies involv-
ing sport for the prevention of violent extremism. The guide can be adapted for
youths aged 12 to 24. In this regard, it is important to ensure that groups are
as homogeneous as possible and that young children are not mixed with older
ones, in order to enhance participation and learning processes and to avoid
possible injury and risk to younger participants.
4
INTRODUCTION
Figure 1 provides simple explanations of key terms used in the present guide in order to
facilitate a common understanding of the concepts addressed. A more comprehensive list of
terminology can be found in annex I.
YOUTH
For the purposes of this guide,
SPORT
Physical play, recreation, dance,
”youth” refers to persons aged
15 to 24; "children" refers to SPORT AND PVE organized, casual, competitive,
those under the age of 18 Any efforts to use traditional and indigenous sports
sport for the prevention and games in their diverse forms
of violent extremism
YOUTH AT RISK
Youth whose background and situation VIOLENT EXTREMISM
make them more vulnerable and place them Acts that promote, support,
at risk of victimization, radicalization facilitate or use violence to
and/or recruitment by terrorist groups achieve ideological, religious
and/or at risk of future YOUTH ENGAGEMENT or political goals
engagement in violent acts The inclusion of youth in all
aspects of programming,
decision-making and
policies that affect them
5
PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT: PRACTICAL GUIDE
The prevention of violent extremism through sport builds on the unique ability of sport to
engage youth actively and meaningfully, and to gain access to young people who are often
hard to reach through other, more formal interventions.
The approach taken in the present guide builds on a theory of change developed on the basis
of known drivers of violent extremism, protective factors and the potential of sport to help
young people develop key soft skills, to promote psychosocial well-being and to enable edu-
cational opportunities and youth empowerment. The overall aim is to strengthen the design,
implementation, monitoring and evaluation of sport-based interventions and to amplify
positive results.
Figure 2 shows the ways in which sport can be used to tackle the prevention of violent
extremism. The drivers shown outside the diagram represent selected root causes that may
lead to violent extremism, while the diagram itself shows the different zones (i.e., areas of
intervention) which are presented in this guide and through which sport can have an impact.
The zones are as follows: safe spaces, social inclusion, resilience, education and
empowerment.
de
fe
T
Li r LACK OF
sh
engagem OPPORTUNITIES
uth
ip
en
Yo t TO PARTICIPATE
SO
CIAL I LUSION
engagement
Meaningful
COMMUNITIES
participation
violent extremism:
NC
Primary
prevention NEGATIVE BELIEFS
ABOUT OTHERS AND
THE WORLD
Yo t
u th e en
ngage m
Pe
er g
le a in
rnin hi nk
g/Critical t
R E S I L IE N C E
NOT KNOWING HOW TO SAY NOT KNOWING HOW TO
NO WHEN PRESSURED DEAL WITH EMOTIONS
(E.G., ANGER)
6
CHAPTER 1.
UNDERSTANDING
VIOLENT EXTREMISM
1. UNDERSTANDING VIOLENT EXTREMISM
8
CHAPTER I. UNDERSTANDING VIOLENT EXTREMISM
FIGURE 3:
USE OF TECHNOLOGY BY
EXTREMIST GROUPS AND
TERRORIST NETWORKS
What can make young Although there is no single profile or pathway to radicalization that may
people susceptible to lead to violent extremism, there are certain socioeconomic, psychological
recruitment and cause and institutional “push” and “pull” factors that may lead to violent extrem-
them to join violent ism. Examples of known push factors that may drive individuals to violent
extremist groups? extremism include marginalization, inequality, discrimination and limited
access to education and other services. Pull factors that foster the appeal of
violent extremism include the existence of well-organized violent extrem-
ist groups “investing” in recruitment, for example by using online media
and propaganda or offering services, revenue and/or employment in
exchange for membership.3
Known push and pull factors towards radicalization and violent extrem-
ism include the following:
• Limited access to education and employment
• Feeling unsafe or not valued in society
• Lack of protection or positive relationships with friends or family
members
• Exposure to negative messages and recruitment tactics
• Not feeling accepted by family or social groups
• Youth feeling that they do not belong to their community
• Feelings of injustice or unfairness
• A thrill and sense of excitement to feel part of something and
important to a cause
• Girls and young women may be enticed to “fall in love” with
members of extremist groups
• Young people may see extremist groups as an opportunity to
“escape” tough realities at home
3
Note that children, i.e., persons under the age of 18, may be forced to join extremist and
terrorist networks and groups and become victims of multiple forms of violence and exploitation
by such groups. Guidance on the protection of those children and their treatment by criminal
justice systems is provided in the UNODC Handbook on Children Recruited and Exploited by
Terrorist and Violent Extremist Groups: The Role of the Justice System (Vienna, 2017).
9
PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT: PRACTICAL GUIDE
FIGURE 4.
Drivers of violent extremism
UNDERSTANDING THE
DRIVERS OF VIOLENT
EXTREMISM
Political exclusion/
Economic exclusion Radical attitudes
opportunities for
Limited opportunities for Insufficient self-corrections World views
participation/weak State
improved mobility "Us versus them"
capacity
Unfairness
Background variables
Perceptions
Age/gender Rejection of socioeconomic
Uncertainty Injustice
Education and political system
Corruption
Living environment
Mistreatment
Individual, Socialization
emotional and Radicalization (friends, family, education,
psychological church, mosques, etc.)
factors
Active recruitment
Violent extremism
FIGURE 5.
USE OF SPORT IN SPORT AND Sport can create safe spaces for children and youth
SAFE PLACES to play and have fun
PREVENTING VIOLENT
EXTREMISM
SPORT AND Sport can create opportunities for children and youth
SOCIAL INCLUSION to make friends and connect with others
SPORT AND Sport can help children and youth learn skills to
RESILIENCE never give up, even when they are challenged
SPORT AND Sport can help children and youth learn and
EDUCATION practise life skills
10
CHAPTER I. UNDERSTANDING VIOLENT EXTREMISM
Why target children The world today is more youthful than ever, with an estimated global
and youth? population of 1.8 billion 10- to 24-year-olds. This number should be
celebrated; however, a worrying statistic shows that one in four young
people (aged 15–29) is affected in some way by violence or armed conflict.
In sporting terms, that means that in a squad of 20 players, 5 players may
have been a victim, perpetrator or witness of some form of violence or
armed conflict.
Example
Islamic State in Iraq and the Levant has recruited youth fighters in
at least 34 countries, and Al-Shabaab in Somalia recruited roughly
1,770 young people in 2017 alone.a Extremists are skilled in the
tactics of peer-to-peer recruiting, appealing to youth by offering a
sense of community, enhanced status and safety. It is important to
bear those tactics in mind when recognizing who is most at risk.
a
Jessica Trisko Darden, “Tackling terrorists’ exploitation of youth” (2019).
Recognizing the Given the seriousness of violent extremism and the engagement of young
strength and people in such acts, it would be easy to think of youth as dangerous,
capabilities of youth unpredictable and vulnerable. However, within the United Nations sys-
tem, youth are regarded as teammates and partners in all efforts to prevent
violent extremism. In practice, youth and children should participate in
all aspects of a sports project and take on leadership roles. By encouraging
such participation, coaches can transform and change the flow of risk into
strength and resilience to prevent violent extremism.
11
PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT: PRACTICAL GUIDE
Preventing In the process of defining the target groups and beneficiaries of programme
stigmatization activities, special consideration must be given to the risk of stigmatization
and reinforced marginalization of individual participants or communities.
Coaches should avoid using stigmatizing language that may cause harm.
Such language includes direct references to terrorism or violent extremism
or labelling people of specific religions, beliefs or other characteristics as
potential terrorists. The relevant chapters of the present guide contain tips
and practical guidance for coaches and facilitators to help them under-
stand and mitigate the risks of labelling and stigmatization by applying
the “do no harm” principle and promoting an inclusive approach.
4
UNODC, Preventing Violent Extremism through Sport: Technical Guide.
12
CHAPTER 2.
FIGURE 6.
POSITIVE USES
OF SPORT
Sport as a Sport as a
way to create way to make
teachable moments friends and
feel supported
Sport as an
Sport as a way outlet for stress
of having fun from daily life
Sport as an
opportunity to
learn
However, it is critical to remember that sport does not always lead to pos-
itive outcomes, and coaches should be aware of its limitations, including
the following:
• The positive outcomes of sport cannot be guaranteed or presumed.
• Sport can generate conflict and incite violence.
• Th
e power and popularity of sport is not always used in positive
ways and is susceptible to abuse, exploitation and welfare concerns.
14
CHAPTER II. SPORT AND THE PREVENTION OF VIOLENT EXTREMISM
Sport can be an effective tool to engage children and youth who are vul-
nerable to the root causes of violent extremism within their communities.
In the context of preventing violent extremism through sport, the present
guide is based on a five-zone approach, as shown in figure 8 and discussed
in detail in chapter 4.
FIGURE 7.
FIVE ZONES FOR SPORT
AND THE PREVENTION OF
VIOLENT EXTREMISM Zone 2
Zone 1
Social
Safe spaces
inclusion
Zone 3
Education
Zone 4 Zone 5
Resilience Empowerment
5
Holly Collison, Youth and Sport for Development: The Seduction of Football in Liberia (London,
Palgrave McMillan, 2016).
15
PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT: PRACTICAL GUIDE
FIGURE 8.
• Appropriate space • Vocational trainers • Club/competitive sport
THE FIVE-ZONE • Equipment • Experts in specialized • Community actors
FRAMEWORK FOR • Transportation areas • Goal setting/planning
PREVENTING VIOLENT • Engagement with local • Links with employment experts
EXTREMISM THROUGH non-governmental sectors • Formal education actors
organizations • Youth support workers
SPORT
• Experienced coaches
1Safe spaces
3
Education
5
Empowerment
•
•
2
Social inclusion
• Guest speakers
• Youth leaders
• Diverse participants • Examples of resilience
• Local organizations, in sport
focused on diversity, • Local actors in conflict
disability, gender or management
displacement • Links with sports clubs
Role of sport coaches It is important for all persons acting as facilitators, including coaches, to
and other facilitators deliver effective and safe sport-based activities in sessions on preventing
violent extremism. Coaches take on many roles, including those of a role
model, a teacher, a mentor, a trusted person to talk to and a positive per-
son to follow. Their role is not easy, and many factors need to be consid-
ered for their safety, the safety of the participants and positive outcomes
and impact. Given the sensitive nature of violent extremism, it is strongly
recommended that facilitators receive training on human rights, including
on gender equality, inclusive practices, good practice principles, child pro-
tection, welfare and safeguarding, and understanding violent extremism in
their own communities.
16
CHAPTER II. SPORT AND THE PREVENTION OF VIOLENT EXTREMISM
Positive characteristics of Coaches and other facilitators must ensure that sport activities are deliv-
sport coaches and other ered safely for themselves and their participants. They should also realize
facilitators in preventing the limits of what they and sport can achieve, and they should recognize
violent extremism the need to refer participants to relevant services when needed (e.g., for
social support, mental health or substance use or abuse).
FIGURE 9.
CHARACTERISTICS OF
GOOD COACHES
EMPATHETIC
KNOWLEDGEABLE CARING
GOOD
COACHES
ARE…
GOOD
COMMUNICATORS CONSISTENT
ACTIVE
LISTENERS
17
PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT: PRACTICAL GUIDE
What do coaches Violent extremism is complicated, and the associated risks and recruit-
and sports leaders ment tactics are different in every community. Before a project begins,
need to do? therefore, it is important for coaches and other facilitators to take the time
to do the following:
18
CHAPTER II. SPORT AND THE PREVENTION OF VIOLENT EXTREMISM
ON THE FIELD
Early signs and referral Facilitators of sport-based interventions do not have the capacity and
should not have to handle the additional task of conducting risk assess-
ments for the prevention of violent extremism. However, they are impor-
tant actors within the prevention process and may identify cases that are in
need of further support. Therefore, it is important for facilitators to be
able to identify the early behavioural signs that could be tipping points
towards violent extremism.
The non-exhaustive list below includes key behavioural signs and indica-
tors that may be observed and can be used for potential referrals to special-
ized staff and services for additional support. If more than one of these
warning signs are noted, facilitators should speak to parents and others in
the participant’s support network to see if they have also noticed shifts in
behaviour and also seek more information to understand the participant’s
situation. In this process, it is essential to respect and ensure confidential-
ity in order to avoid stigmatization and ensure that support is provided.
>> T I P
Coaches may be confronted by
young people who are radicalizing
towards violence, and this can
threaten the programme and the
safety of the participants. As a
coach, you should be as inclusive
as possible, but also have clear
boundaries and rules. Make it clear
that participants who threaten the
safety of others will be removed
from the programme with the
support of specialist services.
19
PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT: PRACTICAL GUIDE
20
CHAPTER II. SPORT AND THE PREVENTION OF VIOLENT EXTREMISM
Are the facilities appropriate for boys and girls? For example, are
there separate changing areas and spaces for separate
discussions?
Ensure that each session relates to one or more of the five zones.
Ensure that the sport space and equipment is safe and used
appropriately.
21
CHAPTER 3.
HUMAN RIGHTS-BASED
APPROACH AND
SAFEGUARDING
3. HUMAN RIGHTS-BASED
APPROACH AND SAFEGUARDING
Human rights A human rights-based approach to sport and the prevention of violent
extremism recognizes that everyone, regardless of age, gender, ability,
religion, race or political views, has the same rights. Children and youth
have the right to be heard, to participate in society and to be treated fairly
and with respect.
Sport projects in this area should be designed and delivered using a partici
patory approach. This means that participants in a project should feel free
to communicate, give suggestions and work with coaches to deliver and
enjoy sessions.
Many concepts and principles in sport can be used to highlight key themes
that can then be discussed in relation to violent extremism. For example, in
promoting human rights among young participants, it is helpful to con-
sider the “fair play” ethic in sports as a point of reference. Fair play involves
far more than just following the rules of the game; it is about the attitude of
the sportspersons, as well as integrity, respect, inclusion and justice.
“We cannot understand fair play unless we link it to moral values such as the
spirit of justice, fairness and human dignity. This ‘broad’ vision makes fair play
accessible to all and underpins all its specific applications. … Respect must go
to the loser as well as to the winner. In order for there to be justice, equality of
opportunity is … necessary.”
24
CHAPTER III. HUMAN RIGHTS-BASED APPROACH AND SAFEGUARDING
Gender and preventing Violent extremist groups have recruited both boys and girls for different
violent extremism reasons and by different methods. For example, women and girls have his-
torically been used to force moral codes upon other women or used as
“wives”, caregivers, teachers and fundraisers. In more recent times, women
have been used to carry out violent attacks. On the other hand, men are
often seen as the “face” or the physical strength of violent extremism.
Gender equality and human rights should be part of the good practice
principles of all projects, and coaches should understand what that means
in their local context.
25
PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT: PRACTICAL GUIDE
Practical matters
• Ensure that facilities are gender-friendly.
– For example, provide access to separate changing facilities.
• Encourage mixed-gender coaching teams.
• At the same time, coaches must be aware of any restrictions on
single- or mixed-gender programmes.
• Within mixed-gender programmes, allow for gender
considerations.
– How can activities be delivered safely in mixed spaces?
Gender considerations
• Be aware that some sports are seen as more “masculine” than
others.
– Consider how martial arts or contact sports may prevent girls
from participating and consider ways to open them to girls, or
choose sports that are more likely to attract their participation.
• Be aware of the different ways in which girls and boys are at risk of
violent extremism.
• Injuries pose a risk to all sports participants but can be a major
deterrent for women and girls.
– Planning for risk in programme activities can be an important
element in convincing families to allow their girls to play.
• The use of female sport and non-sport role models is helpful
within communities that are not familiar with the participation of
women in sport.
Sociocultural factors
• Make sure that all participants have the support of their families to
take part in the project.
• Consider participants’ roles in the household when scheduling
programmes.
• Identify harmful gender stereotypes in communities and in sport,
including rigid masculinities.
26
CHAPTER III. HUMAN RIGHTS-BASED APPROACH AND SAFEGUARDING
Child rights Thousands of children have been abducted, recruited, and used by terror-
ist and violent extremist groups in recent years.6 Children are particularly
vulnerable to recruitment and exploitation by terrorist and violent extrem-
ist groups and are specifically targeted by such groups for a number of
reasons, including as an investment in the future of those criminal organ-
izations and groups, and they are exploited in different ways. Children are
In sport-based projects for often forced to carry out domestic duties, used as spies, exploited sexually
the prevention of violent or for forced labour or services, including the commission of crimes,
extremism, facilitators must enslaved or used in combat and, increasingly, as suicide bombers.
recognize the rights and
welfare of all participants. A Children and youth who are vulnerable to violent extremism may be radi
child safeguarding policy calized, groomed and exposed in different ways:
and a code of conduct must • They may be groomed online or in person by people who intro-
be in place for the project
duce them to extremist ideas. Youth may be radicalized over the
and the staff engaged in
Internet or through the influence of their friends.
sport activities.
• They may be groomed by family members who hold extremist
beliefs.
• They may be exposed to violence, extremist imagery, promotional
materials and writings that can lead to the development of extrem-
ist beliefs.
FIGURE 10.
KEY PRINCIPLES FOR
ENSURING CHILDREN’S
RIGHTS IN SPORT-BASED All persons under 18 years of age
are children and subject to specific
INTERVENTIONS FOR
rights under international and
THE PREVENTION OF national laws
VIOLENT EXTREMISM
6
Office of the Special Representative of the Secretary-General for Children and Armed
Conflict, Child Recruitment and Use. Available at https://childrenandarmedconflict.un.org/
six-grave-violations/child-soldiers/. 27
PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT: PRACTICAL GUIDE
Safeguarding and Safeguarding is the protection of people’s health, well-being and human
welfare considerations rights, and it enables them to live free from harm, abuse and neglect. For
in sport the purposes of this practical guide, safeguarding is used to refer to the
facilitators’ responsibility to ensure that sport-based activities and coach-
ing behaviours do no harm to participants.7
Facilitators should not expose youth to the risk of harm and abuse, which
can include excessive training and punishment. They should always safe-
guard themselves and their participants from physical and mental harm
and abuse.
If you have any concerns about a participant’s safety and protection, you must report
those concerns immediately and appropriately, ensuring confidentiality. Make sure that
you are aware of the reporting and referral procedures in place. If none are available or
you are not aware of them, you must raise this issue with the programme manager and
the implementing organization.
FIGURE 11.
ENSURING SAFETY AND
SAFEGUARDING RISKS
Bullying
SAFEGUARDING
RISKS
Peer aggression,
with participation
Sexual violence
as a potential
and exploitation
opportunity
to release
frustrations and
Emotional and aggression
psychological abuse
including in the form
of parental, coaching
or peer pressure
and bullying
7
International Service, Safeguarding Policy, “Safeguarding children, young people and vulner-
able adults policy”. Available at www.internationalservice.org.uk/safeguarding-policy.
28
CHAPTER III. HUMAN RIGHTS-BASED APPROACH AND SAFEGUARDING
>> T I P
Recognizing the specific
risks and vulnerable status
of children and youth in the
context of sport-based
activities for preventing
violent extremism,
facilitators should take part
in the process of creating
codes of conduct and good
practice measures.
8
United Nations Children’s Fund, Protecting Children from Violence in Sport: A Review with
a Focus on Industrialized Countries (Florence, Italy, Innocenti Research Centre, 2010).
29
PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT: PRACTICAL GUIDE
The list below can be used as a guide to ensure that good practice princi-
ples are understood. If you do not understand or cannot answer any of the
questions below, please ask for guidance from project managers and staff
or speak with relevant experts.
Good practice
checklist Is the space safe for communicating and delivering sport
activities?
30
CHAPTER 4.
As shown in figure 12, these five themes connect to key life skills and
educational outcomes, more specifically:
FIGURE 12.
SPORT AND PREVENTING EMP
N OW
VIOLENT EXTREMISM:
ATIO ER
M
PRIMARY PREVENTION
UC Yout EN
D ills h lea
sk
E
de
fe
T
Li r
sh
engagem
uth
ip
en
Yo t
SO
SAFE S ACES
CIAL I LUSION
engagement
Meaningful
participation
Sport and
preventing Active
P
violent extremism:
Primary NC
prevention
Yo t
u th e en
ngage m
Pe
er g
le a in
nk
rnin
g/Critical t hi
R E S I L IE N C E
32
CHAPTER IV. FIVE ZONES FOR PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT
33
PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT: PRACTICAL GUIDE
PO
PR
RT
KALEIDOSCOPE
CT
PE Psychological
ES
OW
Use sport to break the
TOLER CE AND R
NER
SAFE SPACES
SAFE S CES
SHIP OF SAFE SP
S POR T
Sociocultural
T
Experimental
PA
SAFE Create
R
AN
problem-solving familiarity
S
ED
Political
AC
AS
ZONE 1
Create meaningful
E
E
youth-led dialogue
CR
IN
CO
NFL NT
ICT MANAGEME
Sport and safe spaces Sport can enable facilitators to build safe spaces through the strategic plan-
ning of sport-based activities and through its inherent power, neutrality
and popularity.
9
United Nations, Department of Economic and Social Affairs/Division for Inclusive Social
Development Program on Youth and UN-Habitat, “International Youth Day 2018: Safe Spaces
for Youth – Informational Packet” (July 2018); Audrey Azoulay, Director General of the United
Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO), “Safe spaces for youth”,
message for the International Youth Day, Brasilia, 8 August 2018.
34
CHAPTER IV. FIVE ZONES FOR PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT
Ensure that coaches and youth leaders are aware of the potential
for their space to be used as a recruitment opportunity and aware
ZONE 1
of attempts to isolate individual participants.
35
PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT: PRACTICAL GUIDE
A CT I V I T I E S
Reflection
Creating the code of practice collaboratively increases a sense of
ownership among participants and increases emotional safety
within the space. Encourage peer-to-peer dialogue in creating the
code and have participants create a poster of the code in order to
increase familiarity with the rules.
ZONE 1
Reflection
In the course of this activity, the other participants should act as
observers and evaluate the process. After the exercise, the facilita-
tor will reveal what was on the image and ask the participants to
reflect on the challenges of communicating effectively and on how
information can be altered as it moves from person to person.
36
CHAPTER IV. FIVE ZONES FOR PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT
Post-game reflection
How did the other participants react to the act of cheating? What did
you do to resolve the conflict? Did the participants voice their frus-
tration? Encourage dialogue among participants.
ZONE 1
Have participants pass each other the ball in a circle and rotate posi-
tions. As they pass the ball, encourage them to share something
Goal: to increase and about themselves with the person receiving the ball.
create familiarity Post-game reflection
Did the participants learn more about each other? Can they explain
what they learned? What aspects of their lives or personalities did
they share? How did the participants feel about the activity?
GUIDING QUESTIONS
FOR FACILITATORS
37
PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT: PRACTICAL GUIDE
SAFE SPACES ZONE Definition: A safe space represents a place where participants and coaches
SUMMARY feel confident that they will not be exposed to discrimination, criticism,
harassment or any other emotional or physical harm.
38
CHAPTER IV. FIVE ZONES FOR PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT
ZONE 1
FIGURE 14.
SUMMARY INFOGRAPHIC FOR
THE SAFE SPACES ZONE WHAT IS IT ? W H AT IS N E E DE D?
S A F E S PACE
39
Session evaluation template for the safe spaces zone
Date of session: . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Name of facilitator: . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Access and
Facilities are welcoming and
adequate 1 2 3 4 5
fit for purpose
facilities
Participants continue to
1 2 3 4 5
participate in sessions
Reflect on why you have given these ratings and how they can be improved in the future.
What can be learned and improved?
40
SAFE SPACES: NOTES
ZONE 1
41
PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT: PRACTICAL GUIDE
ZONE 2: Social inclusion represents a defence against violent extremism and connects
strongly to building resilience and setting the mental and social bases for
SOCIAL being open to learning and making good decisions, including actively reject-
INCLUSION ing the push and pull factors towards violent extremism and terrorism.
Social inclusion is the process by which efforts are made to ensure equal
opportunities so that everyone, regardless of their background, can achieve
their full potential in life.
T EXTREMISM
FIGURE 15. LEN TH
VIO RO
SPORT, PREVENTION OF ING CIAL INTEGRATIO UG
T SO N H
VIOLENT EXTREMISM AND EN S
P OR T S
SOCIAL INCLUSION
EV
PO
PR
RT
KALEIDOSCOPE
T
EN
CO
Opportunities
EM
MM
for new social
AG
networks
UN
ENG
ITY S
SOCIAL INCLUSIO
L INCLUSION
TION AND
S
S POR T
TRUCTURES
POR T
Capacity Sense of
development SOCIAL belonging
Individual INCLUSION Build
leaders acceptance
A
Team cultures
ICIP
Social
CIA
SPA
RT
ZONE 2
protection
PA
SO
Remove political,
CE
N
cultural and
S
C
VI
religious pressures
CI
CIVIC NORMS
Sport and social As a tool for realizing and strengthening social inclusion, sport can be highly
inclusion impactful when used within the framework of a well-structured programme,
in particular one that addresses issues of social and personal development10 of
children and youth who are considered to be at risk of violent extremism.11
Social inclusion through sport increases social bonds between participants
and provides them with a feeling of purpose, thereby countering radical
activities.12
10
Public Safety Canada, “Research highlights: crime prevention – sports-based crime preven-
tion programs” (2017- H03-CP).
11
Cara Richardson, Paul A. Cameron and Katherine M. Berlouis, “The role of sport in derad-
icalization and crime diversion”, Journal for Deradicalization, No. 13 (2017).
12
Leesa Morris and others, “Sport, physical activity and antisocial behaviour in youth”, Youth
Studies Australia, vol. 23, No. 1 (March 2004), pp. 47–52.
42
CHAPTER IV. FIVE ZONES FOR PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT
Research suggests that social networks are very important in the process
of radicalization, justifying the need to incorporate a social inclusion dimen-
sion in any discussion or intervention focused on violent extremism.
Insights
ZONE 2
to be formed and should use youth leaders to prevent association
with networks linked to violent extremist groups and/or views.
43
PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT: PRACTICAL GUIDE
A CT I V I T I E S
44
CHAPTER IV. FIVE ZONES FOR PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT
Post-game reflection
Have the participants decide on behaviours that should be rewarded
through the fair play point system. This will encourage discussions
about desirable behaviours and their advantages.
ZONE 2
Prepare the session by marking out a pitch. It can be of any size, but it
must accommodate all of the players with room to move between
them. Set up a small goal at each end, marked by different coloured
Goal: to promote cones, and set up a row of cones across the pitch to mark the final third
inclusion and the on either side. The ball used can be a football, netball or volleyball.
success that results
from including all The rules of the game are a mix between hockey and netball. Once a
player has the ball, that player cannot move with it, and he or she
people on a team
can only score from within the final third of the pitch. The ball must
be passed on the floor or ground, and the opponents must defend
from at least one metre away. A team cannot score a goal until all
members of the team have touched the ball at least twice.
Post-game reflection
In sport, it is easy to “lose” players or “hide” people on a pitch
during games; this resembles life. Ask the players to reflect on the
benefits of having to use all players in a game.
45
PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT: PRACTICAL GUIDE
SOCIAL INCLUSION Definition: Social inclusion can be defined as the process of improv-
ZONE SUMMARY ing participation in society. It may also refer to a process of encour-
aging social interaction between people with different attributes
ZONE 2
46
CHAPTER IV. FIVE ZONES FOR PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT
ZONE 2
FIGURE 16.
SUMMARY INFOGRAPHIC
FOR THE SOCIAL WHAT IS IT ? W H AT IS N E E DE D?
INCLUSION ZONE Social inclusion means making everybody Team games with frequent
feel equal and included, regardless of opportunities to talk
their background, gender, beliefs, physical Development of group listening skills
appearance or differences. Delivering positive messages of
respect, fair play and equality
Strong encouragement by facilitators to
increase confidence
S OCIA L
IN CLU S ION
47
SOCIAL INCLUSION: SUMMARY
Date of session: . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Name of facilitator: . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Increased
ZONE 2
Use of
Conflicts have been resolved in
positive 1 2 3 4 5
positive ways
conflict
resolution
Participants have taken initiative
strategies
and demonstrated peer-led 1 2 3 4 5
conflict resolution
Reflect on why you have given these ratings and how they can be improved in the future.
What can be learned and improved?
48
SOCIAL INCLUSION: NOTES
ZONE 2
49
PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT: PRACTICAL GUIDE
ZONE 3: This zone provides the link to the formation of new ideas, identities and
perspectives in order to equip youth with new information and skills as
EDUCATION they begin to develop new pathways towards feeling empowered and
valued in society. This is done firstly through the continued practical use
of sport to create spaces for personal growth and critical thinking, and
secondly through interactions with key stakeholders inside and outside the
project space.
T EXTREMISM
LEN TH
FIGURE 17. VIO RO
NG SOCIAL NETW UG
I DER OR
SPORT, PREVENTION OF T I KS H
EN
W
VIOLENT EXTREMISM AND P OR T S
SP
EV
O
EDUCATION KALEIDOSCOPE
PR
RT
TR
AN
Awareness
SF
Y of community experts
LIT
ER
E ACCOUNTABI
ABL
EDUCATION
EDUCATION
S POR T
E EMPLOYABIL
S POR T
Enhanced Opportunities
communication EDUCATION for vocational
and formal
and social skills
qualifications
EAS
I
CR
TYS
Mentoring
IN
ZONE 3
KI
LL
S
TEA TS
CHABLE MOMEN
Sport and education In sport interventions, it is critical that the educational environment,
instruction and good practices complement each other. Learning opportu-
nities may arise throughout the programme, whether within formal training
workshops or through sport’s informal “teachable moments”. Ultimately, the
goal of sport programmes targeting the prevention of violent extremism is
to help participants learn and put new skills and values gained within pro-
grammes into action in their communities and daily lives.
50
CHAPTER IV. FIVE ZONES FOR PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT
ZONE 3
perceptions.
51
PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT: PRACTICAL GUIDE
A CT I V I T I E S
Reflection
Are there courses that would interest the participants but are not
available? Are the qualifications relevant to the community and job
market? Work with participants to improve the courses in terms of
their approach and scheduling in order to make them more attrac-
tive and to encourage increased enrolment and interaction.
ZONE 3
ACTIVITY 2: PLAYMAKERS
Split the group into smaller groups. Each group then has a set time
period in which their only instruction is to create an original sports
game. They are given a method of recording the rules they come up
Goal: to introduce
with. After the time is up, the groups are paired up and given time to
techniques for
set up and introduce the other team to their game.
education and practice
educational delivery Reflection
A “flipped classroom” in which students are asked to think about
leading a session and educating people about a new concept gives
them an appreciation for the challenges that surround education
and educating others. Once the teams have both had a chance to
deliver their sessions, ask each team to share positive feedback
about the game they have been shown with the larger group.
52
CHAPTER IV. FIVE ZONES FOR PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT
ACTIVITY 3: VOLUNTEERING
Reflection
Were the participants aware of the business before the training ses-
sion? Did they like the idea of volunteering or doing internships for
job skills training? Does the business have other social initiatives
that can benefit participants?
ZONE 3
ACTIVITY 4: MENTORSHIP PROGRAMME
GUIDING QUESTIONS
FOR FACILITATORS
53
PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT: PRACTICAL GUIDE
Training and Make sure the board is visible to participants as they enter and exit
apprenticeship the space.
opportunities Discuss the opportunities posted with participants at the beginning
or end of each session.
EDUCATION ZONE Definition: The education zone refers to the values that can be learned
SUMMARY through sport participation, such as fairness, team-building, equality, disci-
pline, inclusion, perseverance and respect, in addition to formal learning
opportunities for capacity-building and qualifications.
54
CHAPTER IV. FIVE ZONES FOR PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT
FIGURE 18.
SUMMARY INFOGRAPHIC FOR
ZONE 3
THE EDUCATION ZONE WHAT IS IT ? W H AT IS N E E DE D?
Education in programmes for preventing Activities that have educational value,
violent extremism through sport means such as decision-making and critical
developing life skills and knowledge and thinking
an understanding of values and social Identifying experts who can teach
skills. specific skills, such as safe Internet use
Encouragement of participants to
attend school and courses to gain
qualifications
E DU CATION
55
EDUCATION: SUMMARY
Date of session: . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Name of facilitator: . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Reflect on why you have given these ratings and how they can be improved in the future.
What can be learned and improved?
56
EDUCATION: NOTES
ZONE 3
57
PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT: PRACTICAL GUIDE
T EXTREMISM
LEN TH
VIO RO
FIGURE 19. ING
ACTER DEVELOP
ME
UG
T A R N H
SPORT, PREVENTION OF N CH T S
E P OR T
VIOLENT EXTREMISM AND
S
EV
PO
PR
RT
RESILIENCE KALEIDOSCOPE
Ability
to overcome loss
SOC
T
ITIVE MINDSE
RESILIENCE
RESILIENCE
IAL INTEGRATION
S POR T
S POR T
Develop Increase
critical thinking RESILIENCE empathy,
tolerance and
understanding
POS
ZONE 4
Conflict
resolution
EM Y
BRAC SIT
ING DIVER
Sport and reslilience Sport presents itself as a complement to resilience-building efforts. Sport
and in-game action can be used as a real-world simulation of the pressures
encountered by young people. In addition, sport can be used to foster
positive collective experiences and help individuals to recognize their
strengths.
Dealing with loss is a part of sport and can be turned into a teachable
moment for the participants.
Sport clubs can be utilized as safe spaces where participants can simulate
Insights moments of adversity (through sport) in a controlled setting.
13
United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), “Resilience building in response to the
Syria crisis” (Amman, UNDP Regional Bureau for Arab States, 2015)
58
CHAPTER IV. FIVE ZONES FOR PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT
ZONE 4
loss, and their discipline
in training make athletes Participants should be given opportunities and access to various
ideal role models for resources within their communities that help to expand their
resilience. networks and support systems.
59
PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT: PRACTICAL GUIDE
A CT I V I T I E S
60
CHAPTER IV. FIVE ZONES FOR PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT
Hide tools and materials in the playing area. Encourage the teams
to build their own mini-pitches using whatever resources they can
find. Award extra points if participants negotiate successfully to
Goal: to encourage
obtain resources from another team.
resource-seeking and
allow participants Post-game reflection
to search for Have the team that successfully negotiated the most resources
useful resources share their strategies. What worked? What did not work? Stimulate
a discussion about creative resources and about repurposing
objects.
ZONE 4
ACTIVITY 4: COMMUNITY TOURNAMENT
GUIDING QUESTIONS
FOR FACILITATORS
• Are participants more aware of
the community resources
available to them?
• Have the participants demonstrated better
conflict management attitudes and
behaviours?
• Do participant interactions reflect increased
empathy and appreciation for diversity?
61
PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT: PRACTICAL GUIDE
RESILIENCE ZONE Definition: Resilience refers to the capacity to “bounce back” from
SUMMARY setbacks and personal difficulties. It acknowledges the tragedy and
loss faced by individuals or communities.
62
CHAPTER IV. FIVE ZONES FOR PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT
ZONE 4
FIGURE 20.
SUMMARY INFOGRAPHIC FOR
THE RESILIENCE ZONE WHAT IS IT ? W H AT IS N E E DE D?
R E S ILIE N CE
63
RESILIENCE: SUMMARY
Date of session: . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Name of facilitator: . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Reflect on why you have given these ratings and how they can be improved in the future.
What can be learned and improved?
64
RESILIENCE: NOTES
ZONE 4
65
PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT: PRACTICAL GUIDE
T EXTREMISM
FIGURE 21. LEN T
VIO ARE, ACCOUNT HRO
SPORT, PREVENTION OF ING TERC EMPLOYABILI ABILI UGH
T AF AND TY TY
VIOLENT EXTREMISM EN P OR T
S
S
EV
PO
AND EMPOWERMENT
PR
RT
KALEIDOSCOPE
Capacity-building
IVE YO H VOICE
SOC
EMPOWERMENT
OWERMENT
IAL INTEGRATIO
S POR T
S POR T
Positive Self-
UT
EMPOWERMENT
identity confidence
ZONE 5
EMP
SIT
Increased
N
PO
responsibility
and knowledge
CI
VI
C NT
PA EME
RT
ICIP AG
ATION AND ENG
Sport and It is worth recognizing that the mere process of playing sport can be
empowerment empowering at times. Providing the opportunity to participate in sport
and to be part of a positive environment can have a lasting impact on the
development of youth participants.
14
United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR), International Olympic
Committee and Terre des hommes organisation, Sport for Protection Toolkit: Programming with
Young People in Forced Displacement Settings (2018).
15
Phumzile Mlambo-Ngcuka, “Op-ed: empowering women through sport”, UN-Women,
2 April 2019.
66
CHAPTER IV. FIVE ZONES FOR PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT
Establish a strategy for the next steps for participants so that they
are empowered to continue their development after the
ZONE 5
programme.
Use the values and power of sport to increase the leadership and
independence of youth who will be finishing their learning in the
programme.
67
PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT: PRACTICAL GUIDE
68
CHAPTER IV. FIVE ZONES FOR PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT
ACTIVITIES
ZONE 5
Facilitate activities that encourage reflection and
decision-making
Tell participants that they will be leading the next session. You
should select a theme for their session (e.g., social inclusion, equal-
ity, peace, fair play or respect). They will need to plan warm-up
Goal: to allow
activities and games and activities for the session. They will also
participants to
need to think of creative ways to reflect on the session at the end.
experience leadership
and opportunities to Reflection
make decisions. This
Coaches and participants should sit together on the same level. The
experience will allow key questions are as follows: Did the participants manage the ses-
reflection on how to sion well? What did they learn? What makes a good leader in sport
manage power and how and in life? What leaders do they look up to?
to be a good leader. It
will also test the
participants’ confidence,
their ability to
communicate and their
knowledge of inclusive
practices, safety and
good practice principles.
69
PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT: PRACTICAL GUIDE
GUIDING QUESTIONS
FOR FACILITATORS
70
CHAPTER IV. FIVE ZONES FOR PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT
ZONE 5
Objective and outcomes: To support youth in confidently voicing their
ideas and in making good decisions, to increase their empathy
towards people and to develop their goal-setting skills. These experi-
ences will help create youth leaders within their communities.
71
PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT: PRACTICAL GUIDE
FIGURE 22.
SUMMARY INFOGRAPHIC
FOR THE EMPOWERMENT WHAT I S I T ? W H AT IS N E E DE D?
ZONE
Empowerment means becoming more Youth should feel safe in order to
confident, understanding your ability to understand how to manage power and
lead and make decisions, and recognizing support others
the rights you have as an individual. Youth Use sport to encourage youth to solve
empowerment is a process through which their own problems and use their
youth understand themselves and can use voices to overcome problems
their voices to make positive changes in
their lives and in the lives of others Encourage youth to become leaders,
in their communities. and give them responsibility
within the programme
EMPOWERMENT
HOW D O E S IT H E L P? GOA L S
72
CHAPTER IV. FIVE ZONES FOR PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT
RESILIENCE: SUMMARY
Date of session: . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Name of facilitator: . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
ZONE 5
self-confidence voicing their ideas and
thoughts
1 2 3 4 5
Participants are confident in
making decisions
Enhanced critical Participants are leading
thinking exercises and activities
1 2 3 4 5
Participants are acting as
peer leaders for one another
Reflect on why you have given these ratings and how they can be improved in the future.
What can be learned and improved?
73
EMPOWERMENT: NOTES
ZONE 5
74
CHAPTER 5.
MONITORING, EVALUATION
AND LEARNING
5. MONITORING, EVALUATION AND
LEARNING
What have we learned? Why did certain things happen? Why did certain
things not happen? What can I do to improve next time?
Why are monitoring, Understanding the impact of a project is crucial. Monitoring, evaluation
evaluation and learning and learning are important because expected results may not be achieved
important? even though a sport-based activity may be aimed at empowering children
and youth and building their resilience to prevent victimization and/or
recruitment by violent extremism groups. The expected results and antici-
pated impact need to be questioned, measured, proven and understood.
76
CHAPTER V. MONITORING, EVALUATION AND LEARNING
77
PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT: PRACTICAL GUIDE
Reflection After each session, coaches should reflect on the activities, what they did,
how they did it and what the outcomes were. By doing so, they can under-
stand the outcomes of the session, the experiences of the participants and
reflect on their own experiences and learning opportunities to take for-
ward to the next session.
FIGURE 24.
REFLECTION QUESTIONS
ON PARTICIPANTS’
DIALOGUE PROCESS
What is the objective How did participants During the session, How did participants Did I create
of the session? settle into the did participants reflect after sports opportunities for
session? enjoy learning new activities? participants to speak
Have I planned my skills? and be heard?
activities and do I Did they enjoy the Did any participants
understand how to warm-up? Did all participants make any significant Could I be more
achieve my aims play? statements during creative in the ways
through sport? Did they understand the session? in which I ask them
the aims of the Did they understand to communicate?
How did participants session? the game and Were there any
enter the sports activities? conflicts between Are there any
area? Could I have participants? situations I feel
explained anything How did participants unsure of or where I
Were they talking to better? play together? Any changes in need more training
their peers? behaviour? or support?
Did I give them How did they
Were they happy or opportunities to lead communicate? Any debates between What kind of
did they look the start and ask participants? sports/activities are
anxious? questions? Did I need to
improvise or adapt Did participants have participants enjoying
Did they greet activities to achieve fun? or responding to the
coaches and staff? my aims? most?
Co-creation and A guiding philosophy in the present guide is the coaches’ commitment to
participation working with youth participants and the local community, including
youth and sport leaders. Coaches should apply a collaborative approach
with sports leaders and youth participants and should include them in
reflection activities.
Coaches should also be creative and think of different ways to find out
what participants enjoyed, what they did not enjoy and what kinds of
skills and knowledge they are developing. They should also consider ways
to start group discussions and ways for participants to show how they are
feeling, for example by asking them to design a poster or to act as sports
reporters on a project.
79
PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT: PRACTICAL GUIDE
Concluding remarks Figure 25 provides a visual summary of the intended impacts for our
programme participant after going through all of the zones. It is impor-
tant to note, however, that sport has the power to support prevention
aims, but it is not a magical solution, nor is it a stand-alone project. The
approach developed through the present guide is intended as a comple-
mentary framework to be integrated into wider efforts to prevent violent
extremism.
FIGURE 25.
NEW THOUGHT PROCESS “I am now a
youth leader.” “I make good
decisions.”
“I am confident
in my voice!”
“I am applying “I have a
all my learned strong sense of
skills.” self-worth.”
80
ANNEXES
ANNEX I. TERMINOLOGY
Counter-terrorism: Actions and activities to prevent, deter and disrupt terrorist acts
and to weaken terrorist organizations and networks.
Disengagement:
The social and psychological process whereby an individual’s com-
mitment to, and involvement in, violent extremism is reduced to
the extent that the person is no longer at risk of involvement and
engagement in violent activity. Disengagement from using, or
supporting the use of, violence does not necessarily mean a change
in an individual’s commitment to a radical or extremist cause.
Disengagement involves a change in behaviour (renouncing the
use of violence) rather than a change in fundamental beliefs.3
Facilitator:
For the purposes of the present guide, the term “facilitator” (or
“coach”) is used to describe all types of qualified practitioners who
deliver or implement sport-based interventions and/or programmes.
Facilitators should possess professional, social and methodological
competencies to instil positive values and convey life skills to their
participants through sports. Sport coaches, workers at non
governmental organizations, teachers and/or other community
workers might act as facilitators in sport-based interventions for the
prevention of violence and crime, including violent extremism.
Gender: “A concept that refers to the social differences, as opposed to the
biological ones, between women and men that have been learned,
are changeable over time and have wide variations both within and
between cultures”.4 Gender-based roles and other attributes there-
fore change over time and vary in different cultural contexts.
1
Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE), The Role of Civil Society in Preventing and Countering
Violent Extremism and Radicalization that Lead to Terrorism: A Guidebook for South-Eastern Europe (Vienna, 2018), p. 6.
2
UNODC, Handbook on the Management of Violent Extremist Prisoners and the Prevention of Radicalization to Violence
in Prisons, Criminal Justice Handbook Series (Vienna, 2016).
3
Ibid.
4
European Commission, Directorate-General for Employment, Industrial Relations and Social Affairs, One Hundred
Words for Equality: A Glossary of Terms on Equality between Women and Men (Luxembourg, Office for Official Publications
of the European Communities, 1998).
82
ANNEXES
Human rights approach: A conceptual framework that integrates the norms, standards and
principles of the international human rights system into the
policies, programmes and processes of development and humani-
tarian actions. It therefore focuses on both procedures and
outcomes.5
Prevention of violent extremism: Efforts to influence individual and/or environmental factors that
are believed to create the conditions in which violent extremism
can flourish, using social or educative rather than security-driven
measures.6
Safeguarding:
Protecting people’s health, well-being and human rights and
enabling them to live free from harm, abuse and neglect.9 For
the purposes of the present guide, safeguarding is used to refer to
the responsibility that organizations, programmes and individuals
have to ensure that operations, programmes and actions do no
harm to participants and beneficiaries, including children, mean-
ing that they do not expose them to the risk of harm and abuse
and that any concerns the organization has about the safety and
protection of participants are reported to the appropriate
authorities.
5
UNHCR, “The context, concepts and guiding principles”, in A Manual on a Community-Based Approach in UNHCR
Operations (Geneva, 2008).
6
William Stephens, Stijn Sieckelinck and Hans Boutellier, “Preventing violent extremism: a review of the literature”,
Studies in Conflict and Terrorism, 2 January 2019, pp. 1–16.
7
UNODC, Handbook on the Management of Violent Extremist Prisoners.
8
Kees Van Den Bos, Why People Radicalize: How Unfairness Judgments Are Used to Fuel Radical Beliefs, Extremist
Behaviors, and Terrorism (New York, Oxford University Press, 2018).
9
International Service, Safeguarding Policy, “Safeguarding children, young people and vulnerable adults policy”.
Available at www.internationalservice.org.uk/safeguarding-policy.
83
PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT: PRACTICAL GUIDE
Sport: Unless specified otherwise in the present guide, the term “sport” is
used as a generic term, comprising sport for all, physical play,
recreation, dance and organized, casual, competitive, traditional
and indigenous sports and games in their diverse forms.10
10
Kazan Action Plan, adopted at the sixth International Conference of Ministers and Senior Officials Responsible for
Physical Education and Sport, held in Kazan, Russian Federation, in July 2017.
11
Right to Play, Harnessing the Power of Sport for Development and Peace: Recommendations to Governments (Toronto,
Canada, Sport for Development and Peace Working Group, 2008).
12
UNODC, “Module 1: Introduction to international terrorism”, Education for Justice University Module Series:
Counter-Terrorism (Vienna, 2018).
13
UNODC, Handbook on the Management of Violent Extremist Prisoners.
14
UNESCO, Preventing Violent Extremism through Education: A Guide for Policymakers (Paris, 2017), p. 19.
15
Ibid.
16
United Nations, Department of Economic and Social Affairs, “Definition of youth”.
84
ANNEXES
Youth engagement: The meaningful inclusion of young people in all stages of develop-
ing, implementing, monitoring and evaluating programmes, poli-
cies and investments of resources, as well as in decision-making
that affects them and others.17
Youth violence: Violence is broadly defined as “the intentional use of physical force
or power, threatened or actual, against oneself, another person,
or against a group or community, that either results in or has a
high likelihood of resulting in injury, death, psychological harm,
maldevelopment or deprivation”.18 Youth violence is defined as
violence that occurs among individuals aged 10–29 who are
unrelated and who may or may not know each other, and that
generally takes place outside of the home.19
17
Women Deliver, “Engage youth: a discussion paper on meaningful youth engagement” (New York, April 2016).
18
World Health Organization (WHO), World Report on Violence and Health (Geneva, 2002).
19
WHO, Preventing Youth Violence: An Overview of the Evidence (Geneva, 2015).
85
ANNEX II. PRACTICAL TOOLS FOR PLANNING,
MONITORING AND LEARNING REFLECTION
SESSION OBJECTIVE:
PARTICIPANT
ORGANIZATION: FEEDBACK AND
EQUIPMENT AND LEARNING POINTS/ FACILITATOR
ACTIVITY PARTICIPANTS MESSAGES OBSERVATIONS
Warm-up
Cool-down
86
ANNEXES
Coaches can use the template below as a guide to identify how well participants are inter
acting, respecting the rules and demonstrating good values within the project.
Interaction • Has positive • Interacts well • Works well with • Is often shy or
with peers interaction with with teammates. teammates but nervous to
peers. • Has many friends not all project communicate.
• Demonstrates in the project and participants. • Tends to stand at
excellent communicates • Sometimes the back of a
communication very well with singles out peers group.
and listening peers and with critical • Does not make
skills. coaches. comments. friends easily.
• Always treats • A great addition • A good teammate • Finds it difficult
people fairly and to group/team when comforta- to contribute to
ensures that activities. ble with friends, group/team
everyone is but sometimes activities.
included. needs encour-
agement to
communicate
and listen
appropriately.
Integrity • Strong moral • Has a very good • Shows values of • Finds it difficult
principles, which understanding of honesty, kindness to play by the
include being the values and and good rules.
caring, kind, principles of the sportsmanship • Can be disruptive
truthful and project. most of the time, and can show
encouraging of • Demonstrates a but sometimes poor behaviour.
others. very good needs reminding.
• Gives up easily
• Shows a attitude and good • Mostly demon- when challenged.
“champion” behaviour strates a positive
• Tends to not care
mentality and throughout attitude but
about others and
never gives up. sessions. sometimes needs
can exclude
• Is always honest. • Occasionally has encouragement.
people from
• Shows leadership to be reminded of group work.
qualities. the rules or the
key messages
behind activities.
87
PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT: PRACTICAL GUIDE
Reduced youth • Longer-term programmes are better suited for this purpose.
violence • Mentorship and role models play a major role in adding support
systems for disadvantaged youth and helping them to envision
positive future directions.
• Certain sports have been found to increase participants’ sense of
belonging to violent representations and forms (e.g., judo, karate,
soccer and basketball), while others do not involve violent physical
behaviour (e.g., swimming, tennis, table tennis and volleyball).
Increased • Safe spaces, ease of access and mitigating the risk of injury are key
participation considerations.
of women • It is important to avoid unsafe environments (e.g., road running) and
injury-prone sports or those that are not commonly accepted within
gender norms.
• Evidence suggests that girls are more likely to practise individual
sports than team sports and more leisurely physical activities than
competitive sports. However, this is not always the case.
Social cohesion • Consider non-contact sporting activities or those with lower chances
among of physical violence (e.g., volleyball).
members of • Team sports are to be used with safeguarding in place to minimize
different violent confrontations.
factions or
• Owing to the nature of the activities involved, individual sports are
divided groups
less likely to foster positive interaction opportunities compared with
team sports, which facilitate increased interaction and communica-
tion. However, some individual sports, such as running, swimming
and boxing, can be used with a prosocial/team mindset.
Migrant • Programmes can help facilitate better learning about the local
integration culture and increased interaction opportunities with community
members.
• Learning about national sporting practices and fandom helps
migrants socialize and promotes a shared identity.
Strengthened • By encouraging greater self-control and discipline and teaching
prosocial participants how to deal with difficult situations, programmes in this
behaviours area can reduce anti-social behaviour that may lead to violent
extremism.
• Activities need to integrate reflective, collaborative group sessions to
help participants develop communication skills and greater respect
for each other.
• Programmes are more impactful when used within wider develop-
mental efforts in education and support (e.g., integrated mentoring,
training, volunteering and work experience programmes).
Reduced gang • Having a strong support network and connecting participants with
violence mentors greatly increases the chances of impact.
• Sporting activities are often complemented by employability work-
shops on writing curricula vitae or building skills to help participants
transition out of gang environments.
88
ANNEXES
Prevention of • What primary risks of violent extremism were identified at the start
violent extrem- of the programme? Are they still relevant? Are they still important?
Do they need to be reviewed?
ism changes in
• How are those risks experienced differently by women and men?
the programme
• How are changes over time being monitored and recorded? Is that
context
process effective and embedded in the standard practices of the
programme?
• How would you describe changes in the frequency or intensity of
violence risks? Have participants communicated any changes?
• Have there been any notable successes or challenges since the last
reflection meeting?
Other changes • Have there been any specific events or social/political changes in
the area since the last meeting?
• Have there been any environmental changes or local challenges
that may affect the future delivery of sessions?
• Has there been any engagement with community members,
partners or stakeholders?
Source: Adapted from Lucy Holdaway and Ruth Simpson, Improving the Impact of Preventing Violent
Extremism Programming: A Toolkit for Design, Monitoring and Evaluation (Oslo, UNDP, 2018).
89
PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT: PRACTICAL GUIDE
2. Can you think of any examples of violent extremism in your country or region?
3. What are the main causes of violent extremism for children and youth in your community?
4. Why do you think children and youth are at risk in your community?
6. Can you identify the five zones for tackling violent extremism through sport?
8. How can you make sure that all participants feel included?
10. How can you encourage participants to become leaders during your sessions?
11. How can you safely educate children and youth about extreme beliefs?
12. How can you create opportunities to discuss serious issues related to beliefs on violence?
13. How do you reflect and learn from your coaching sessions?
90
ANNEXES
ACTIVITY AND
REFLECTION
Political exclusion/
Economic exclusion Radical attitudes
opportunities for
Can you identify where Limited opportunities for Insufficient self-corrections
participation/weak State
World views
improved mobility "Us versus them"
the various causes and capacity
drivers of violent
extremism fit into the Unfairness
Background variables
zones presented in Perceptions
Age/gender Rejection of socioeconomic
Uncertainty Injustice
this guide? Corruption
Education and political system
Living environment
Mistreatment
Individual, Socialization
emotional and Radicalization (friends, family, education,
psychological church, mosques, etc.)
factors
Active recruitment
Violent extremism
Zone 2
Zone 1
Social
Safe spaces
inclusion
Zone 3
Education
Zone 4 Zone 5
Resilience Empowerment
91
ANNEX III. ADDITIONAL RESOURCES
Below is a non-exhaustive list of push and pull factors towards violent extremism that could
be addressed through sports programmes:
Violations of human rights and the rule of Sport allows the voices of young people to
law; lack of means to make voices heard or be heard through sport intervention
to vent frustrations programming, utilizing a collaborative
approach within activities and responding
flexibly to the needs of participants.
Individual backgrounds (search for identity Sport has been proven to break down
and purpose, boredom, sense of mission barriers between ethnicities and individual
and heroism, promise of adventure and backgrounds.
power, attraction to violence) Sport can provide a sense of purpose,
belonging and empowerment.
Sport sets the scene for excitement, the
creation of new heroes from professional
athletes, captains and coaches, and
recognition for good performance.
Distortion and misuse of beliefs, political Sport can create new, positive social groups
ideologies and ethnic and cultural that safely challenge notions of difference.
differences (“us versus them” mentality)
Attraction of charismatic leadership and Sport can form new, positive and charis-
social communities and networks (e.g., a matic leaders, such as youth leaders and
charismatic recruiter providing access to captains, and can inspire active youth
money and power, a sense of belonging to a engagement.
powerful group or community)
92
ANNEXES
As coaches, you need to be able to identify changes in behaviour that may be of concern or
indicate that a participant is at higher risk of violent extremism. The figure below provides
examples of such changes in behaviour.
If you see any changes in behaviour, overhear any comments about beliefs or extreme views,
you should speak with the participants in a friendly way. Try to ask them questions about
what you have seen or heard and see if you can educate them through sport to challenge
those behaviours and beliefs. You should also speak to the project manager and staff.
93
PREVENTING VIOLENT EXTREMISM THROUGH SPORT: PRACTICAL GUIDE
3. USEFUL RESOURCES
Brown, Katherine. Guidance Note: Gender Mainstreaming Principles, Dimensions and Priorities for PVE.
New York: UN-Women, 2019. Available at www.unwomen.org.
De Marinis, Valerie and Eolene Boyd-MacMillan. A mental health approach to understanding violent
extremism. Ex Post Paper RAN Policy and Practice. Paris: Radicalization Awareness Network, 2019.
Elsemann, Katrin and others. Monitoring and evaluation in sport for development. N.p.: Street Football
World, n.d.
German Agency for International Cooperation. Sport for development programme online sources.
Available at www.giz.de/en/worldwide/43770.html.
Holdaway, Lucy and Ruth Simpson. Improving the Impact of Preventing Violent Extremism Programming:
A Toolkit for Design, Monitoring and Evaluation. Oslo: UNDP, Oslo Governance Centre, 2018.
Lenos, Steven and Annelies Jansen. The role of sports and leisure activities in preventing and countering
violent extremism. RAN EX Post Paper. N.p.: Radicalization Awareness Network, March 2019.
United Nations Children’s Fund. Protecting Children from Violence in Sport: A Review with a Focus on
Industrialized Countries. Paris, 2010.
United Nations Development Programme. Regional Bureau for Africa. Journey to Extremism in Africa:
Drivers, Incentives and the Tipping Point for Recruitment. New York, 2017.
__________. Preventing violent extremism through promotion inclusive development, tolerance and
respect for diversity: a development response to addressing radicalization and violent extremism. New York,
2016.
United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization. A teacher’s guide on the prevention of
violent extremism. Paris, 2016.
United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, International Olympic Committee and Terre des
hommes. Sport for Protection Toolkit: Programming with Young People in Forced Displacement Settings.
Geneva, 2018.
United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime. “Line Up, Live Up” initiative. See www.unodc.org/doha
declaration/en/topics/crime-prevention-through-sports.html.
__________. Handbook on the Crime Prevention Guidelines: Making Them Work. Sales No. E.10.IV.9.
__________. Handbook on the Management of Violent Extremist Prisoners and the Prevention of Radicalization
to Violence in Prisons. Criminal Justice Handbook Series. Vienna, 2016.
__________. Key principles and recommendations for the management of violent extremist prisoners and
the prevention of radicalization to violence in prisons. Available at www.unodc.org.
___________. Roadmap on the treatment of children associated with terrorist and violent extremist
groups. Vienna, 2019.
__________. The Use of the Internet for Terrorist Purposes. New York, 2012.
United Nations Youth Strategy, entitled “Youth 2030: Working with and for Young People”.
United Nations, Department of Economic and Social Affairs. World Programme of Action for Youth.
__________. World Youth Report: Youth Civic Engagement. New York, 2016.
94
Vienna International Centre, P.O. Box 500, 1400 Vienna, Austria
Tel.: (+43-1) 26060-0, Fax: (+43-1) 263-3389, www.unodc.org