Proposal SV & FAV of PT Sariarthamas Hotel
Proposal SV & FAV of PT Sariarthamas Hotel
Proposal SV & FAV of PT Sariarthamas Hotel
Singapore : 80 South Bridge Road, #06-02, Golden Castle Building, Singapore 058710 M: (65) 977 894 00
RAO,YUHAL
K
P
P
J
Jakarta : The Boulevard Office Building #03-F1, Jl. Fachrudin Raya No. 5, Kebon Sirih, Jakarta 10250, Indonesia Tel.: (62-21) 3199 1488
India : SRI KRUPA 518 16th Cross, Indira Nagar II Stage, Bengaluru, Karnataka, India 560038 M: (91) 966 393 8946, (91) 733 768 7432
Copy of
KJPP Rao, Yuhal & Rekan
Ref. P27/KJPP/SP-BIS/05/1/IX/2023 Kantor Jasa Penilai Publik
RAO, YUHAL & rekan
Reg. License No. 2.11.0094
Wilayah Kerja: Seluruh Indonesia
To. Penilai Bisnis dan Properti
– Second level
Attn: Mr. Antonius Petrus N. Lamak
F (62 21) 3199 1487
• Third level
Re : Proposal to act as an Independent Valuer to Preparing Share Valuation and Fixed Asset Valuation of PT. Sariarthamas Hotel International
for Sarinah Share Divestment Transaction
– Fourth level
Our Understanding on the Company Transaction Pemahaman Kami mengenai Transaksi Perusahaan
» Fifth level
PT Sarinah (Persero) is a subsidiary of Indonesian Tourism Aviation which PT Sarinah (Persero) adalah anak usaha Aviasi Pariwisata Indonesia yang
operates in the retail and trade sectors. This company was founded on bergerak di bidang ritel dan perdagangan. Perusahaan ini didirikan pada
August 17, 1962 by the President of the Republic of Indonesia, Soekarno. tanggal 17 Agustus 1962 oleh Presiden Republik Indonesia Soekarno.
RAO,YUHAL
K
P
P
J
1/20 .
Copy of
KJPP Rao, Yuhal & Rekan
Sarinah wants to know the Market Value of its shares for the proposed Sarinah ingin mengetahui Nilai Pasar atas sahamnya untuk rencana
transaction. So Sarinah needs to prepare a Share Valuation and Fixed transaksi tersebut. Maka Sarinah perlu menyiapkan Laporan Penilaian
Asset Valuation Report for the Sale & Puchase Transaction purposes. Saham dan Penilaian Asset Tetap untuk tujuan transaksi.
• Click to edit Master text styles PT Bahana Sekuritas telah mengundang (terafiliasi
RAO,YUHAL
PT Bahana Sekuritas has invited (affiliated to
RAO,YUHAL TRUSCEL
TRUSCELCAPITAL LLP Singapore), to act as an Independent Valuer to dengan CAPITAL LLP Singapur), bertindak sebagai Penilai
& rekan
K
P
P
J
&level
rekan
K
P
P
J
assist Bahana in preparing Share Valuation and Fixed Asset Valuation Independen untuk membantu Bahana dalam mempersiapkan
– Second
with Market Value Definition for the Sale & Puchase Transaction
purposes.
Penilaian Saham dan Penilaian Aset Tetap dengan Definisi Nilai Pasar
untuk Tujuan transaksi Jual & Beli.
• Third level
In line with the above requirements, this letter sets out the broad Sejalan dengan persyaratan di atas, surat ini menetapkan syarat dan
– Fourth level
terms and conditions under which TRUSCELCAPITAL would undertake ketentuan yang luas di mana TRUSCELCAPITAL akan melakukan
perikatan ini sebagai Penilai Independen untuk Bahana untuk
this engagement as an Independent Appraiser to Bahana to prepare
menyiapkan tugas yang dibutuhkan untuk transaksi yang diajukan.
» Fifth level
the required assignments for the proposed transaction.
RAO,YUHAL
K
P
P
J
2/20
Copy of
KJPP Rao, Yuhal & Rekan
RAO,YUHAL
K
P
P
J
3/20
Copy of
KJPP Rao, Yuhal & Rekan
• Third level
• Sales Comparison Approach
• Pendekatan Harga Pasar
Secara Umum, Penilaian Nilai Pasar paling baik didekati dengan
– Fourth level
Generally, Market Value Valuation is best approached by
analysis of open market transactions of similar assets. The
analisis transaksi pasar terbuka dari aset serupa. Pendekatan
Perbandingan Penjualan adalah proses dimana estimasi nilai
Sales Comparison Approach is a process by which a mrket pasar diperoleh dengan menganalisis aktivitas pasar dari aset
» Fifth level
value estimate is derived by analyzing the market activity of serupa dan membandingkan aset ini dengan properti subjek yang
similar asset and comparing these assets to the subject dinilai.
property being appraised.
RAO,YUHAL
K
P
P
J
4/20
Copy of
KJPP Rao, Yuhal & Rekan
RAO,YUHAL
K
P
P
J
5/20
Copy of
KJPP Rao, Yuhal & Rekan
• Third level
total Market Value of all the assets (including the
intangible Assets Value) by the market
pasar total semua aset (termasuk Nilai Aset tidak
berwujud) dengan nilai pasar kewajiban
liabilities • Menerapkan diskon dan premi yang sesuai
– Fourth level
• Apply appropriate discounts and premiums ✓ Estimasi nilai tambah
✓ Estimation of Value Added
» Fifth level
Value Definition: Market Value according to Indonesian Definisi Nilai: Nilai Pasar sesuai Standar Penilaian Indonesia.
Valuation Standards. Market Value according to the Indonesian Nilai Pasar sesuai Standar Penilaian Indonesia adalah jumlah
Valuation Standard is the estimated amount where assets or yang diestimasikan dimana asset atau liabilitas harus
liabilities must be exchanged on the date of the assessment dipertukarkan pada tanggal penilaian antara pembeli yang
between willing buyers and sellers who are willing to in a fair bersedia dan penjual yang bersedia dalam transaksi wajar
transaction after proper marketing and where each party knows setelah pemasaran yang tepat dan dimana masing-masing pihak
each other. The value definition used must also comply with the
saling kenal. Definisi nilai yang digunakan juga harus mematuhi
Definition of Market Value as per the International Valuation
Standards. definisi Nilai Pasar sesuai International Valuation Standards.
RAO,YUHAL
K
P
P
J
6/20
Copy of
KJPP Rao, Yuhal & Rekan
RAO,YUHAL
Puchase Transaction purposes.
K
P
P
J
7/20
Copy of
KJPP Rao, Yuhal & Rekan
Limiting Condition: Valuer only responsible for providing reports Kondisi Pembatas: Penilai hanya bertanggung jawab untuk
and information to client and/or other related parties as stated in memberikan laporan dan informasi kepada klien dan/atau pihak
this Scope of Work and Bahana are required to asks for a terkait lainnya sebagaimana tercantum dalam Lingkup Pekerjaan ini
permission from TRUSCELCAPITAL for any publication of the dan Bahana diharuskan untuk meminta izin dari TRUSCELCAPITAL
– Second level
Assignments will be conducted in accordance with KEPI and Punagasan akan dilakukan sesuai dengan KEPI dan Standard
• Third level
Indonesian Valuation Standard 2018 Ed. VII, POJK 28, and POJK Penilaian Indonesia 2018 Ed. VII, POJK 28 dan POJK 35.
35
– Fourth
Bahana’s Rights level
and Obligations: Hak dan Kewajiban Bahana:
» Fifth level
1. Bahana have the rights to obtain 1 (one) copy of Fixed Asset 1. Bahana memiliki hak untuk mendapatkan 1 (satu) Salinan Laporan
Valuation Report, and 1 (one) copy of Share Valuation Report, Penilaian Aset, dan 1 (satu) Salinan Laporan Penilaian Saham,
written in Bahasa Indonesia. We will detail in our reports the dituliskan dalam Bahasa Indonesia. Jika informasi yang relevan
sources of information presented. Where any relevant telah diperoleh dengan referensi dari Bahana, maka hal ini akan
information has been obtained by reference of Bahana’s, this ditunjukkan di dalam laporan kami*.
will be indicated in our report*.
* This will be subject to the receipt of the signed management * Tergantung dari penerimaan surat representasi manajemen
representation letter as prepared by TRUSCELCAPITAL. yang sudah ditandatanganI, yang disiapkan oleh
TRUSCELCAPITAL.
RAO,YUHAL
K
P
P
J
8/20
Copy of
KJPP Rao, Yuhal & Rekan
2. Bahana have the obligation to provide the following data & 2. Bahana memiliki kewajiban untuk menyampaikan data &
information to TRUSCELCAPITAL before the initial of the project informasi kepada TRUSCELCAPITAL sebelum projek dimulai dan
and giving us the access for site visit and interview the memberikan akses kepada kami untuk site visit dan interview
management. manajemen, sebagai berikut:
– Second level
2023;
• List of the fixed assets as per 31 October 2023 (complete with
Oktober 2023;
• Daftar asset tetap milik per 31 Oktober 2023 (lengkap dengan
acquisition year, purchase price, number of unit, asset tahun perolehan, harga pembelian, jumlah unit, model/tipe
• Third level
model/type and other details);
• Financial Statement Audited as per 31 October 2023;
asset dan detail lainnya);
• Laporan Keuangan Audit per 31 Oktober 2023;
– Fourth level
• Historical Financial Statement for the period 2017-2022;
• Financial Projections for the period 2024-2028;
• Histori Laporan keuangan periode 2017-2022;
• Proyeksi Laporan Keuangan periode 2024-2028;
• Copy of Certificate » Fifth level • Copy Sertifikat
• Copy of IMB • Copy IMB
• Proof of Paying PBB • Bukti Bayar PBB
• Proof of Payment, Electricity, Telephone, Water. • Bukti Pembayaran, Listrik, Telepon, Air.
• Other related data requested as the work progress. • Data terkait lainnya yang akan diminta seiring berjalannya
pekerjaan.
3. Bahana have the obligation to pay timely the professional fees to 3. Bahana memiliki kewajiban untuk membayar secara tepat waktu
us based on agreed terms and conditions. biaya profesional kami sesuai dengan syarat dan ketentuan yang
telah disepakati.
RAO,YUHAL
K
P
P
J
9/20
Copy of
KJPP Rao, Yuhal & Rekan
RAO,YUHAL
K
P
P
J
10/20
Copy of
KJPP Rao, Yuhal & Rekan
Limiting Conditions and Liabilities (Cont.): Kondisi Pembatas dan Kewajiban (Lanjt.):
The services are limited in nature, and do not comprehend all Layanan bersifat terbatas, dan tidak memahami semua hal yang
matters relating to Bahana that might be pertinent or necessary to berkaitan dengan Bahana yang mungkin relevan atau perlu bagi
them and or their shareholders’ evaluation of the Proposed mereka dan atau evaluasi pemegang saham mereka atas Transaksi
– Second level
The sufficiency of the services to be performed hereunder by us is dijelaskan di atas. Kecukupan layanan yang dilakukan di sini oleh
solely the responsibility of Bahana. TRUSCELCAPITAL are only kami sepenuhnya merupakan tanggung jawab Bahana.
responsible for providing report(s) and information to Bahana TRUSCELCAPITAL hanya bertanggung jawab untuk menyediakan
• Third level
and/or other related parties as stated under the Scope of Works. laporan dan informasi kepada Bahana dan / atau pihak terkait
lainnya sebagaimana dinyatakan dalam Ruang Lingkup Pekerjaan.
TRUSCELCAPITAL will make no responsibility for performing any
– Fourth level
services or procedures beyond those agreed to between Bahana
TRUSCELCAPITAL tidak akan bertanggung jawab untuk melakukan
layanan atau prosedur apa pun selain yang disetujui antara Bahana
and TRUSCELCAPITAL or for updating the services performed. dan TRUSCELCAPITAL atau untuk memperbarui layanan yang
» Fifth level dilakukan.
Bahana shall ensure that our report(s) will not be quoted or Bahana harus memastikan bahwa laporan kami tidak akan dikutip
referred to or used by any other purpose except for those stated atau dirujuk atau digunakan oleh tujuan lain apa pun kecuali yang
under the Nature and Purpose of The Assignment or for any other tercantum di bawah Sifat dan Tujuan Penugasan atau untuk pihak
party unless written consent has been provided to lain kecuali persetujuan tertulis telah diberikan kepada
TRUSCELCAPITAL. TRUSCELCAPITAL.
Bahana agrees that TRUSCELCAPITAL will not be liable for any Bahana setuju bahwa TRUSCELCAPITAL tidak akan bertanggung
indirect, incidental, special, or consequential punitive or multiple jawab atas kerugian hukuman atau kerusakan-kerusakan tidak
damages, including without limitation any damages resulting from langsung, insidental, khusus, atau konsekuensial, termasuk tanpa
loss of use, loss of business, loss of revenue, loss of profits, or loss batasan kerusakan yang diakibatkan oleh hilangnya penggunaan,
of data, arising in connection with this Agreement and/or the kehilangan bisnis, hilangnya pendapatan, hilangnya keuntungan,
execution of the agreed Scope of Works and decisions made by atau hilangnya data, yang timbul sehubungan dengan Perjanjian ini
management based on the issued report(s)/ TRUSCELCAPITAL 's dan / atau pelaksanaan Lingkup Pekerjaan yang disetujui dan
performance of keputusan yang
RAO,YUHAL
K
P
P
J
11/20
Copy of
KJPP Rao, Yuhal & Rekan
Limiting Conditions and Liabilities (Cont.): Kondisi Pembatas dan Kewajiban (Lanjt.):
Scope of Works or of any other obligations relating to this dibuat oleh manajemen berdasarkan laporan yang dikeluarkan/
Agreement, even if TRUSCELCAPITAL has been advised of the kinerja TRUSCELCAPITAL tentang Lingkungan Pekerjaan atau
possibility of such damages. The foregoing limitation of liability kewajiban lain yang terkait dengan Perjanjian ini, bahkan jika
RAO,YUHAL
K
P
P
J
12/20
Copy of
KJPP Rao, Yuhal & Rekan
» Fifth level
The payments shall be scheduled as follows: Pembayaran akan dijadwalkan sebagai berikut:
First payment : 50% of the total agreed fees before the Pembayaran pertama : 50% dari total biaya yang disetujui
submission of the draft reports. sebelum penyerahan draft laporan.
Second payment : 50% of the total agreed fees before Pembayaran kedua : 50% dari total biaya yang disetujui
the submission of the final reports. sebelum penyerahan laporan akhir.
*All fees are no refundable. The fees quoted above are exclusive of *Semua biaya tidak dapat dikembalikan. Biaya yang dicantumkan di
11% VAT. The fee quoted above are inclusive out of pocket expenses atas belum termasuk PPN 11%. Biaya yang dicantumkan di atas
which may be incurred during our work, such as faxes, courier, sudah termasuk biaya uang saku yang mungkin timbul selama
photocopying, etc. pekerjaan berlangsung, seperti telepon, fax, kurir, fotokopi, dll.
RAO,YUHAL
K
P
P
J
13/20
Copy of
KJPP Rao, Yuhal & Rekan
– Second level
sejak diterima.
This Engagement Letter anticipates assistance from the management Surat Kerja Sama ini mengantisipasi bantuan dari manajemen dan
and personnel in matters such as timely preparation of schedules and personil dalam hal seperti persiapan data dan analisis yang tepat
• Third level
analyses, provision of supporting documents, preparation of various
review related letters and confirmations, and availability of the
waktu sesuai jadwal, penyediaan dokumen pendukung, penyusunan
berbagai ulasan terkait surat dan konfirmasi, dan ketersediaan
– Fourth level
management for inquiries. manajemen untuk tanya jawab.
Circumstances encountered during the performance of our services Halangan yang kami temukan selama menjalankan tugas yang
Fifthmay
that warrant additional time or»expense level
cause us to be unable menyebabkan penambahan waktu atau beban dapat menyebabkan
to deliver the services within the time and cost estimates provided to kita tidak dapat memberikan layanan dalam waktu dan perkiraan
you. We will endeavor to notify you of any such circumstances as biaya yang kami estimasikan untuk Anda. Kami akan berusaha untuk
they arise with a view to minimizing any additional costs. memberitahu Anda tentang keadaan tersebut segera saat situasi
tersebut muncul dengan maksud untuk meminimalkan biaya
tambahan.
RAO,YUHAL
K
P
P
J
14/20
Copy of
KJPP Rao, Yuhal & Rekan
Confidentiality: Kerahasiaan:
TRUSCELCAPITAL agree that TRUSCELCAPITAL will not disclose any TRUSCELCAPITAL setuju bahwa TRUSCELCAPITAL tidak akan
proprietary information in relation to any information received mengungkapkan segala informasi milik perusahaan dalam
directly or indirectly both written and unwritten from Bahana kaitannya dengan informasi yang diterima secara langsung atau
RAO,YUHAL
K
P
P
J
15/20
Copy of
KJPP Rao, Yuhal & Rekan
If Bahana is proven negligent or has violated its rights and Apabila Bahana terbukti lalai atau melakukan pelanggaran
obligations, TRUSCELCAPITAL may, at any time by giving two
atas hak dan kewajibannya, TRUSCELCAPITAL dapat
week’s prior written notice to Bahana, terminate our
mengakhiri perjanjian ini, setiap saat dengan memberikan
appointment hereunder.
pemberitahuan tertulis dua minggu sebelumnya kepada
RAO,YUHAL
K
P
P
J
16/20
Copy of
KJPP Rao, Yuhal & Rekan
If there is any conflict between the English version and the Bahasa Apabila terdapat perbedaan versi antara Bahasa Inggris dan
Indonesia version or in their interpretation toward this Agreement, Bahasa Indonesia atau dalam interpretasinya atas Perjanjian ini,
the Indonesian version shall prevail. maka versi Bahasa Indonesia yang berlaku.
RAO,YUHAL
– RAO,YUHAL
& rekan &level
Second
K
K
P
P
P
J
J
rekan
• Third level
– Fourth level Signed by :
B. Sridhar Rao Ir. Yuhal
Managing Partner » Fifth
Seniorlevel
Partner Date :
Tax Payer :
Tax ID/NPWP* : _ _ . _ _ _ . _ _ _. _ - _ _ _ . _ _ _
Address :
RAO,YUHAL
K
P
P
J
17/20
Copy of
KJPP Rao, Yuhal & Rekan
Education
• Sridhar Rao is a Chartered Valuer and Appraiser (CVA) from
Nanyang Technological University (NTU) Singapore
B. Sridhar Rao • Master of Business Management, Asian Institute of Management,
Managing Partner Philippines
• • Third level
A merger & Acquisition expert with track record of success for deal
• Licensed Business Valuer in IVSC Singapore
Work Experience
completion. • Founder TRUSCEL CAPITAL, Indonesia - Partner
• – Fourth level
A capital market expert with successful capital market fund raising • DELOITTE, Indonesia - Senior Director
through IPO & Right Issue for 5 companies.
• » Fifth level
Core competence in valuations for M&A transactions, hold a
• UBS, Indonesia - Head of Corporate Finance
• ARTHUR ANDERSEN, Indonesia - Senior Consultant
business valuation licensed from the ministry of finance and is
registered at the Indonesian capital market supervisory board • CREDIT SUISSE, Singapore - Capital market
(BAPEPAM) • PHILIPPINES DEPOSITS INSURANCE CORPORATION,
• Specialized sector knowledge in the following sectors :
Philippine, Strategic Planning Consultant
•Electricity • Agribusiness • Securities & Derivatives •
Pharmaceuticals • Food & Restaurant • Livestock Feed • Automotive • POLYSINDO, Indonesia - Finance Material Control Manager
& Parts Manufacturing • Banking & Multi Finance • Pulp & Paper • • INDORAMA, Indonesia - Costing Manager
Real Estate & Civil Construction • Hospitals • Retail & Trading • Steel
Specialized Education
Manufacturing • Textile & Garments • Hotel & Resort •
Telecommunication •Infrastructure • Petrochemical • Mining, Oil & 1. New York Society of Security Analysis, New York, “Equity Valuation
Gas • Cement • AirFreight • Fertilizer • Energy Services • of Strategies and Methodologies”, August 1999
Multimedia • Manufacture • Mining Services 2. National University of Singapore, “General Management Program”,
July 1992
RAO,YUHAL
K
P
P
J
18/20
Copy of
KJPP Rao, Yuhal & Rekan
Work Experience
• Third level ▪ TRUSCEL CAPITAL, Indonesia – Partner
▪ KJPP Yuhal
– Fourth level
Specialized sector knowledge in the following sectors : ▪ PT. Procon Indah (Jones Lang Wootton)
•Electricity • Agribusiness
» Fifth level
• Securities & Derivatives •
Pharmaceuticals • Food & Restaurant • Livestock Feed • Automotive
▪ PT. Bestimate Propindo (Edmund Tie & Co)
▪ PT. Piesta Penilai (Finch Freeman)
& Parts Manufacturing • Banking & Multi Finance • Pulp & Paper •
Real Estate & Civil Construction • Hospitals • Retail & Trading • Steel ▪ PT. CB Richard Ellis Indonesia (CBRE)
Manufacturing • Textile & Garments • Hotel & Resort •
Telecommunication •Infrastructure • Petrochemical • Mining, Oil &
Gas • Cement • AirFreight • Fertilizer • Energy Services •
Multimedia • Manufacture • Mining Services
Education
• Graduated from Universitas Persada Indonesia, Jakarta,
Indonesia, with a bachelor of Architecture.
RAO,YUHAL
K
P
P
J
19/20
Copy of
KJPP Rao, Yuhal & Rekan
RAO,YUHAL
K
P
P
J
20/20
• Click to edit Master Mr.
text styles
Sridhar Rao
Managing Partner
– Second level Email : srao@truscel.com
• Third level Hp : +62 816 777 818
– Fourth level
» Fifth level
Singapore Jakarta
80 South Bridge Road, The Boulevard Office Building #03-
#06-02, Golden Castle F1,
Building, Singapore Jl. Fachrudin Raya no.5, Kebon Sirih
058710 Jakarta 10250
www.truscel.com Tel : (62-21) 3199 1488
RAO,YUHAL
Fax : (62-21) 3199 1487
K
P
P
J
• Click to edit Master text styles
– Second level
• Third level
– Fourth level
» Fifth levelwww.truscel.com
Singapore : 80 South Bridge Road, #06-02, Golden Castle Building, Singapore 058710
Jakarta: The Boulevard Office Building #03-F1, Jl. Fachrudin Raya No. 5, Kebon Sirih, Jakarta 10250, Indonesia
Tel.: (62-21) 3199 1488
India : SRI KRUPA 518 16th Cross, Indira Nagar II Stage, Bengaluru, Karnataka, India 560038 M: (91) 966 393 8946
RAO,YUHAL
K
P
P
J