MTA2 Guide
MTA2 Guide
MTA2 Guide
Management
Copyright Notice
Copyright © 2016, Bentley Systems, Incorporated. All Rights Reserved.
Preface . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7
About This Guide . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8
Related Documentation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9
Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 335
This preface contains information about the purpose and content of the
APM Maintenance Task Analysis Guide. It also points out sections in
other documents that provide information you might need.
Contents
About This Guide . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8
Related Documentation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9
Related Documentation
In addition to this guide, you will find the following Help topics useful
when developing maintenance task analyses. Cross-references to these
topics are available throughout the guide, wherever they are pertinent to
the current subject.
Contents
Overview of Maintenance Task Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12
Overview of Risk Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17
Overview of Performing Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24
Two Ways to Access Maintenance Task Analyses . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 31
Reusing Failure Modes. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 33
Setting up APM for Maintenance Task Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 34
Glossary of MTA2 Terms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 39
• Selects the assets to be analyzed, which form the analysis asset hier-
archy, a snapshot taken from the site’s physical hierarchy.
• For each of the assets, identifies the causes of asset failure (failure
modes) and the effects of the failure.
• Identifies failure consequences. For key assets, the team can perform
failure mode risk assessments to determine which failure modes have
the highest priority for implementation.
• Develops action plans to deal with each failure mode. A recommended
action is selected for each failure mode, for example, condition-based
maintenance or modification/redesign.
• Optionally evaluates the economic feasibility of implementing pro-
posed maintenance tasks. With the help of the maintenance efficiency
index (MEI), APM uses the avoidance savings and task costs to deter-
mine if the proposed tasks are justified or not.
• Depending on the type of action, adds indicators, corrective standard
tasks or jobs, or procedures to the action plan. One or more secondary
action plans can be recommended for a failure mode.
Before you can export failure modes, you must have installed the Avail-
ability Workbench with a valid license. Your APM license must include
the Reliability Strategy Development and Implementation and Perfor-
mance Management modules, and the modules must be active on the
sites where you want to use the functionality.
For example, a reliability engineer can reconcile the action plans devel-
oped in a strategy development analysis with actual maintenance items
in SAP. When creating action plans, the engineer browses the SAP data,
using filters to narrow the search for a maintenance item that matches
the action plan. When the item is selected, its number is recorded in the
action plan for later reference, and the engineer can then mark the action
plan as “Implementation completed”. At any time, APM users can view
details about the referenced maintenance item by double-clicking its icon
to open a properties window. These interoperability features help users
to quickly and accurately ensure that their action plans are properly
implemented in SAP, without having to flip back and forth between sys-
tems.
When action plans are updated from the Feasibility evaluation, the
proposed task is referenced in the SAP Tasks tab.
• In primary and secondary action plans, you can select an SAP task
list, maintenance item, or maintenance plan for corrective tasks. This
example of the Maintenance Action Plan window shows both APM
Tasks and SAP Tasks tabs because the site’s profile makes informa-
tion from both systems available.
For information about viewing, filtering, and browsing SAP objects, see
“Viewing SAP Plant Maintenance Information in APM” in Help.
When the relative risk is established, APM calculates the failure mode’s
priority using a set of customer-defined rules. The consequence priority
rules can be based on the failure mode’s severity, relative risk, downtime
costs, downtime duration, or a combination. For example, the Extreme
priority could be assigned to failure modes whose total severity is equal
to 5.0.
You can apply a confidence factor to the analysis to quantify your faith in
current maintenance or inspection practices to contain the failure mode’s
risk. The confidence factor can adjust the inspection factor or the failure
mode’s position in the risk matrix.
After you have analyzed the failure modes, you can compare failure
modes and identify the relative importance of addressing them. The Risk
Assessment view in the Strategy Development Analysis window
includes failure mode lists based on criticality, consequence priority,
severity, and relative risk, as well as a risk plot, risk matrix, and lists of
the evaluations. This view is also available for the asset.
With both methods, APM calculates the relative risk and displays it in
the risk matrix chart. The method available in the Maintenance Action
Plan window depends on the option selected in the analysis’ risk analysis
settings.
The rest of this topic provides more detail about risk assessment con-
cepts.
Risk (Criticality)
The risk number is calculated for the failure mode as the product of the
Total failure mode severity and the probability of failure.
Severity
Failure severity measures the consequences when a failure occurs. Sever-
ity can be described in terms of health and safety, environmental, reputa-
tion, and economic categories and is usually described as:
• Severe
• High
• Medium
• Low
• Negligible
An impact statement and numerical value are associated with each
severity value defined in APM. The higher the number, the more severe
the effect. Economic impact can also be associated with each severity
value to help determine avoidance savings and maintenance feasibility.
Probability of Failure
The probability of failure is the likelihood that the asset will fail due to
the failure mode. There are three ways to evaluate probability:
The rules defined for a priority can be based on any of these properties:
• Downtime cost – the total downtime cost of the failure mode or fail-
ure is used. The total downtime cost is the sum of the downtime
occurrence cost and the downtime rate costs times the length of the
downtime:
Downtime Cost = Downtime Occurrence Costs + (Downtime Rate *
Downtime Duration)
• Downtime duration
• Failure cost
• Relative risk (risk analysis only)
• Severity, which can include the sum, minimum, or maximum value
for any or all of:
• Health and safety consequences
• Economic consequences
• Environmental consequences
• Reputation consequences
• Failure mode consequences (risk analysis only)
The failure mode is assigned the highest ranking consequence priority for
which it satisfies the priority’s rules.
Risk Matrices
By combining probability and consequence priority, it is possible to group
failure modes by risk in a two-dimensional matrix. Failure modes with a
high consequence priority and a high probability are grouped together,
followed by failure modes with lower consequences and lower probability,
until at the opposite end of the matrix – the failure modes with negligible
consequence and negligible probability. For example:
Confidence Factor
Confidence factor is used to adjust the location of a failure mode on the
risk matrix based on your faith in the existing maintenance practices and
equipment history. Factors considered can include things like:
Risk Plot
A risk plot is used to map the failure modes by severity and probability of
failure. Failure modes with a high severity and high probability of failure
appear in the upper right of the plot. Failure modes with low probability
and low severity are plotted close to the bottom of the axis lines.
The risk plot provides a visual depiction of the relative risk of the failure
modes, easily identifying the failure modes with high consequence and
high probability: the failures modes that need to be addressed.
It is a good idea to review a new analysis’ settings to ensure that they are
appropriate for the asset and process. For more information:
For example, when a pump’s impeller becomes worn (failure mode), the
flow through the pump declines until it no longer delivers liquid at the
required rate.
You can perform failure mode or demand scenario risk analysis, depend-
ing on the requirements of the asset. You can also record failure data,
especially if you intend to use Isograph Availability Workbench to opti-
mize reliability programs.
Before you can export failure modes, you must have installed the Avail-
ability Workbench with a valid license. Your APM license must include
the Reliability Strategy Development and Implementation and Perfor-
mance Management modules, and the modules must be active on the
sites where you want to use the functionality.
In some cases, you might need to create secondary action plans for failure
modes. For example, a failure mode might require a condition-based
maintenance task to check for signs of wear, a secondary modification to
procedures (for example, training for maintenance personnel), and sched-
uled restoration in the future. You can add secondary actions as you are
developing the MTA2, or you can add them later.
You can define action plan task statuses for use with failure modes and
action plans in addition to the statuses provided by APM (Facilitation
Incomplete, Facilitation Completed, Implementation Completed, and
Implementation Not Required). Facilitators and implementers can then
use the additional statuses to co-ordinate their efforts, for example,
marking an action plan for follow-up or review.
You can also print several reports from the analysis, including lists of
action plan details and failure modes.
The Site window, Strategy Development view contains tabs that allow
you to review all of the site’s strategy development analyses and to view
failure modes for all assets. For example:
On the Asset window, Strategy Development view, you can view the
asset’s failure modes, indicators, functions, functional failures, and the
analyses where the asset is the primary asset. You can also view other
maintenance task analyses that include the asset’s failure modes.
Tip: To view the total estimated failure modes for assets according
to type, on the Site window, select the Assets view, Summaries
tab, and then the Failure Modes Estimate tab. This tab shows a
chart of the estimate and count by asset type.
For more information, see “Setting up Asset Types” in Help.
When defining an analysis type, you can specify the varieties of analyses
it can be used with: MTA2, RCM2, RBI, CPR, SIF, HAZOP, or a combina-
tion. For example, you could create two types of MTA2, one with risk
analysis and one without. Or you could create a type that applies to both
MTA2 and RBI analyses.
You can set up checklist items in the site’s Strategy Development set-
tings. For more information, see “Setting up Checklist Items” in Help.
You can select smart mapping settings at the site-level to determine the
default values shown in the Copy Failure Modes wizard. You can also
save the mapping settings that you define for a particular copy request to
the site level.
For more information, see “Setting Smart Mapping Defaults for Failure
Mode Copy Requests” in Help.
Tip: The numbering settings also show the number that APM will
automatically assign to the next failure mode and strategy devel-
opment analysis that is created.
For more information, see “Setting the Numbering Format for Analyses,
Failure Modes, and Unwanted Situations” in Help.
• Technologies
• Evaluation groups
• MEI override reasons for feasibility evaluations
• Symptoms
• Duty codes
• Severity of usage values
• Task effectiveness ratings
• Process flows
For more information about these options, see “Failure Mode Settings” in
Help.
For more information, see APM Interoperability Guide for SAP Plant
Maintenance.
Term Definition
Action Plan An action plan in a strategy development
analysis identifies an asset’s failure mode
and recommends an action to prevent the
failure or mitigate its consequences. For
example, MTA2 and SIF action types are con-
dition-based maintenance, failure-finding
maintenance, scheduled restoration or dis-
card, modification or redesign, and no sched-
uled maintenance (run to failure). RBI
analyses support actions such as inspections,
strategy, and modification or redesign.
Term Definition
Failure Consequence The way in which the effects of a failure
mode matter (evidence of failure, impact on
safety, the environment, operational capabil-
ity, direct and indirect repair costs).
Failure Effect What happens when a failure mode occurs.
Failure-finding Interval A failure-finding interval is the length of
time that it is considered safe to wait before
performing failure-finding maintenance. The
interval is calculated or estimated based on
the desired availability and the frequency of
failure of the protective device or system.
Failure-finding Mainte- A scheduled task used to determine whether
nance a specific failure has occurred.
Failure Mode A failure mode is a single event that causes a
functional failure. For example, if a pump’s
impeller becomes worn, the pump cannot con-
vey liquid at the required rate. Failure modes
are analyzed in maintenance task analysis
(MTA2) and reliability-centered maintenance
(RCM2) analysis, along with the action plans
that prevent or mitigate failures.
Term Definition
Failure Mode Conse- A failure’s or failure mode’s consequence pri-
quence Priority ority provides an indication of the relative
importance of the asset failure. The larger
the number, the greater the severity of the
failure. The priority can be used to recom-
mend root cause analysis for a failure or to
determine the order of action plan implemen-
tations.
Term Definition
Maintenance Task Anal- Maintenance task analysis (MTA2) is APM’s
ysis unique strategy development methodology
that enables the analysis team to quickly cre-
ate and implement basic, technically-sound
reliability programs. MTA2 is most effective
when operational and maintenance knowl-
edge about assets is well-documented and
consistently used by employees. MTA2 pro-
vides an alternative to the resource-intensive
RCM2 analysis, while still allowing you to
identify the right work to improve perfor-
mance across the plant.
Term Definition
P-F Interval The PF interval is the time between the point
at which a potential failure becomes detect-
able and the point at which it degrades into a
functional failure.
Term Definition
Strategy Development Strategy development analyses are method-
Analysis ologies for evaluating asset priority, defining
asset functions, determining how failures
occur (failure modes), evaluating the risk of
asset failure, and preventing or mitigating
the effect of failures. The varieties of strategy
development analysis include:
Term Definition
Susceptibility to Failure Susceptibility to failure evaluation examines
Evaluations the asset’s non-age related degradation pat-
terns. It can provide an alternative to proba-
bility of failure analysis for these failure
modes. For example, susceptibility evalua-
tion can be used to determine the vulnerabil-
ity of atmospheric storage tanks to corrosion
under insulation or stress cracking. The eval-
uation can result in recommended actions,
susceptibility ratings, or both.
Contents
Creating an Analysis from Scratch . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 48
Creating an Analysis From a Template . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 54
Setting Failure Mode Options for an Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 64
Setting Risk Analysis Options for an Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 77
Adding Assets to an MTA2. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 86
Excluding Assets from an Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 95
Working with Asset Scope on an MTA2 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 97
Recording the Primary Asset’s Operating Context. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 100
Adding Team Members to an Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 101
Entering and Reviewing Comments on an Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 103
Recording Team Meetings on an Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 106
Working with the Analysis Checklist . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 107
This section explains how to create an MTA2 from scratch and includes
links to more detailed explanations of some steps. For information about
basing the MTA2 on a template, see “Creating an Analysis From a Tem-
plate” on page 54.
2. From the New list, select From Scratch. The New Analysis dialog
appears.
3. Click the browse icon( ) to select the primary asset. The primary
asset is usually the top asset in the hierarchy of the system to be ana-
lyzed.
Tip: You can also create an MTA2 by opening an asset and select-
ing the Strategy Development view, Strategy Development
tab. Then select the Analyses tab. From the New list, select
MTA2. The New Analysis dialog appears, and the primary asset
information is filled in.
4. The Analysis type box shows the default type for maintenance task
analyses, if a default has been assigned. An analysis type is a collec-
tion of preferred options that can range from the default analysis title
to how risk analysis is performed (if at all). You can change or select
the analysis type to quickly set default options for the analysis.
9. Click OK. If you are including the asset’s descendants in the analysis,
a progress dialog might appear as the analysis is created. The Strat-
egy Development Analysis window appears. The Facilitation view,
Info Worksheet tab is shown.
10. To set the general properties of the analysis, select the Properties
view. The General tab displays information about the analysis. For
example:
Tip: The Optimization view is available if you are using the Iso-
graph Availability Workbench (AWB) to analyze and optimize the
data in failure modes. You can then import optimization results
into the analysis, review the recommendations in the Optimiza-
tion view, and make appropriate changes to the action plans.
Before you can export failure modes, you must have installed the
Availability Workbench with a valid license. Your APM license key
must include the Reliability Strategy Development and Implementa-
tion and Performance Management modules, and the modules must
be active on the sites where you want to use the functionality.
For information about using this functionality, see APM Integration
Guide for Isograph Availability Workbench.
11. The Details tab displays the analysis type, if one has been assigned
to the analysis. You can select an analysis type from the list to set
default options.
12. If appropriate, select a change set from the list. This is usually a
change authorization or change set number from a Management of
Change (MOC) system.
14. If required, enter reference information, for example, the number for
an external document.
15. Review the planned start and completion dates for the analysis and
change them if necessary.
18. On the Analysis Team tab, you can add team members and identify
the facilitator. For more information, see “Adding Team Members to
an Analysis” on page 101.
20. On the second Assets tab, you can view the assets in a list or select
the Hierarchy tab to see the relationship between assets. You can
add new or existing assets and exclude assets from the analysis. For
more information, see “Adding Assets to an MTA2” on page 86 and
“Excluding Assets from an Analysis” on page 95.
21. The Comments tab helps the analysis team keep track of their work
in analyzing assets. For more information, see “Entering and Review-
ing Comments on an Analysis” on page 103.
22. Use the Meetings tab to record team meetings. For more informa-
tion, see “Recording Team Meetings on an Analysis” on page 106.
23. The Checklist tab displays standard tasks for your organization’s
analysis projects. For more information, see “Working with the Anal-
ysis Checklist” on page 107.
24. Select the Documents tab to browse for standard documents that
are relevant to the analysis.
25. While the analysis progresses, you can attach documents to it using
the Attachments tab. For information about attaching a file, folder,
note, or URL to an analysis, see “Adding Attachments to Objects” in
Help.
27. Specify the sites where the analysis will be available for copies. You
can choose:
• All sites
• This site only
• This site and its descendants only
• Not available for use
28. The New asset options area shows the settings you selected on the
New Analysis dialog when creating the analysis. If you intend to add
assets, you can select a different hierarchy.
29. In some cases, assets are large enough to warrant separate analyses
for different sections. For example, when the top portion of a large
vessel contains gas and the bottom holds liquid, separate analyses are
needed to define and respond to different failure modes and effects. In
this case, select Allow the scope of the analysis to be defined by asset.
On the Assets tab, you can provide a description of the scope covered
by the analysis. The same asset can be added to the analysis as many
times as required. For more information, see “Working with Asset
Scope on an MTA2” on page 97.
30. Select the Failure Mode Options and Risk Options tabs to change
the default settings for the analysis. For more information, see:
33. Select the Activity Reports tab to view asset activity reports for this
analysis and asset activity reports in which this analysis is included.
When you have completed these steps, you are ready to develop the anal-
ysis by creating failure modes and more. Refer to the following topics for
more information:
• Use the Copy Failure Modes wizard to select a template, the assets to
analyze, and the failure modes
• Define additional failure modes as needed
• Check the team members copied from the template and make correc-
tions as needed
• Fine-tune action plans
• Document the project with a description, notes, and attachments, as
required
Note: If you base the new MTA2 on an RCM2 template, the func-
tions and functional failures are not copied from the template.
2. From the New list, select From a Template. The Copy Failure
Modes wizard appears.
3. Click the browse icon in the Analysis box to select the source tem-
plate. The Strategy Development Analysis selector dialog appears,
displaying analyses. Select an option from the Configuration list to
view templates.
4. Select a template and click OK. The Failure modes to copy table
displays the source’s failure modes. The asset type is displayed. For
example:
Tip: For quick copies (when you do not need to adjust the mapping
options or create a function), click Finish when you have selected
the asset. The wizard performs the matching process and skips to
the Confirm Selections step. Skip to step 14.
10. Click Next. The wizard matches objects as needed and presents the
mappings for your review. The Employees, Trades, and Mainte-
nance Groups tables display the mappings. For example:
The Suggestion Origin column displays the method used for match-
ing. The options are:
• Previous match – the “Use results of previous copy” option is in
effect
• Suggested – the mapping is based on another criterion, for exam-
ple, hierarchy level or attribute matching
• Default – the source object is used as the target, provided that it is
valid at the target site
• Manual – the user selected the mapping
14. Click Next or Finish. The Confirm Selections step appears. For
example:
15. Check the items that will be created or updated. If an incorrect copy
request is processed, you will have to make the corrections manually.
Click View to see more details about the items. The Failure Modes
tab displays information about the failure modes. If you wish to
remove a failure mode from the list, right-click it and click Remove.
Click Back to make adjustments on previous pages.
Open target analy- Target analyses are opened after the copy
ses request is processed.
17. Click Process or Finish if Process later is selected. One of the fol-
lowing occurs:
18. If you selected Open target analyses in the processing options, the
analysis opens. Otherwise, open the analysis.
20. Review and modify the analysis as needed. For related information,
see “Creating an Analysis from Scratch” on page 48.
When you have completed these steps, you are ready to develop the anal-
ysis by creating action plans and more. Refer to the following topics for
more information:
Note: Before you can export failure modes, you must have
installed the Availability Workbench. The Reliability Strategy
Development and Implementation and Performance Management
modules must be active on the sites where you want to use the
functionality.
5. In the Default failure effects text box, you can enter text that will
automatically appear in the Failure Effect box of new failure modes.
6. In the Default task text box, you can enter text that will automati-
cally appear in the Task boxes for new failure modes.
Hide or show step Hide or show the instructions for completing the
instructions steps in the process flow.
Savings and costs The period (for example, 1.000 year) to use when
period calculating costs, including avoidance savings.
• Simple – The evaluator can select one statement for each cate-
gory on the form.
• Detailed – The evaluator can select two statements for each cate-
gory on the form.
To Enable Optimization
1. Select the Optimization tab.
2. Set the options for the appearance of the Maintenance Action Plan
window:
3. On the Properties view, select the Risk Options tab. Click Use
evaluation forms.
Risk matrix The risk matrix specified as the default for risk
analyses of this type. The matrix displays the
results of the failure mode’s probability and
severity evaluations, as well as its relative risk
(criticality).
Default the action If this option is selected, when the risk analysis
plan strategy and has been performed, the recommended strategy
frequency from the and frequency (if applicable) are copied from the
risk matrix risk matrix entry to the action plan.
Risk plot target line Style of target line for use in charts, for exam-
ple, the failure mode risk tolerance line.
14. For each of the trades, select a value from the list defined for the site.
• Simple – The evaluator can select one statement for each cate-
gory on the form.
• Detailed – The evaluator can select two statements for each cate-
gory on the form.
Economic impact The type of values used in the evaluation for the
and range to use economic impact and range, for example, stan-
dard scores or alternates.
19. Select the Environmental and Reputation tabs in turn and set the
options for using evaluation questionnaires and buttons.
Note: If you set the positive and negative adjustments to 0.00, the
confidence evaluation questionnaire’s adjustment values are used.
Risk matrix The risk matrix specified as the default for risk
analyses of this type. The matrix displays the
results of the failure mode’s probability and
severity evaluations, as well as its relative risk
(criticality).
Default the action If this option is selected, when the risk analysis
plan strategy and has been performed, the recommended strategy
frequency from the and frequency (if applicable) are copied from the
risk matrix risk matrix entry to the action plan.
Risk plot target line Style of target line for use in charts, for exam-
ple, the failure mode risk tolerance line.
4. Select the type of values used in the evaluation, for example, stan-
dard scores or alternates.
When you create an analysis that includes the primary asset’s descen-
dants, a snapshot is taken of the asset’s physical hierarchy. This analysis
hierarchy remains static. That is, any changes made to the site’s physical
hierarchies are not automatically made to the analysis hierarchy. How-
ever, when you add assets to an analysis, the analysis hierarchy is
refreshed with any changes that have occurred to the physical hierarchy.
Also, at any time you can update the analysis hierarchy to reflect
changes. For more information, see “Updating the Asset Hierarchy Snap-
shot” on page 307.
Tip: After the analysis is completed, you can return and see a
snapshot of an asset’s properties as they were at the time the
asset was analyzed. In the Strategy Development Analysis win-
dow, select the Properties view and then the Assets tabs (or the
System Information view, Assets tab, and then the Hierarchy
tab). Right-click the asset in the table and click Asset Snapshot.
The Asset Snapshot dialog displays the information that was cur-
rent either on the date that the asset was added or on the date
that the analysis status changed to “Analysis completed”.
You can add assets to the analysis by browsing for existing assets or by
creating one or more child assets in the analysis. When creating assets,
the new child assets are added to the parent asset’s hierarchy.
3. Select the Properties view, Analysis Options tab. This tab shows
the settings that apply when you add assets to the analysis. For
example:
5. Select the Assets tab and the second Assets tab. In the New list,
click Browse. The Browse Assets dialog appears.
Tip: You can also select the Hierarchy tab and click Browse.
6. Select one or more assets.
7. Click OK. The dialog closes and the assets are added to the list to be
analyzed. If you chose to include descendants, they are also added to
the analysis hierarchy. If the new asset’s parent is not included in the
analysis hierarchy, the asset is placed beneath the primary asset.
To Create Assets
1. On the General tab, select the Assets tab and the second Assets tab.
Tip: You can also create assets on the Hierarchy tab. Click New
or right-click an asset and click Create Multiple Child Assets.
The Create Multiple Assets window appears.
Assign asset num- Select this option to specify names and numbers
ber as follows for the new assets.
Start at Specify the number for the first new item. The
second item’s number is the starting number
plus the increment amount, and so on.
Include asset num- Select this option to have the asset number
ber in the asset included in the asset name.
name
4. In the Asset details area, select the options for the new assets:
Note: You cannot create component assets using the Create Multi-
ple Assets window.
In-service Date The date that this asset was first put into ser-
vice.
5. Select the Location tab. This tab displays information about the par-
ent asset in the physical and any alternate hierarchies. For example:
6. To change the parent asset, click the browse icon and select another
analysis asset.
Tip: You can click the browse icon and point to the location on a
map to have APM assign the coordinates. For more information,
see Setting Map Coordinates.
8. When the enterprise and sites are set up in APM, up to five different
hierarchies can be created to organize assets. The first hierarchy is
the comprehensive physical hierarchy. Most (if not all) of your assets
should be included in this hierarchy.
If you are using additional hierarchies, you can select parent assets in
alternate hierarchies to establish the position of the new assets. Click
a browse icon to select a parent asset.
9. Select the Description tab to add information to be added to each
asset’s description.
10. Click OK. The child assets are created and added to the asset hierar-
chy.
To Exclude an Asset
1. Open the analysis.
The asset is added back into the analysis and action plans can be
developed for it.
For an analysis asset, you can provide a description of the analysis scope.
The same asset can be added to the analysis as many times as required,
each with a difference scope description. You can then create failure
modes for each of the analysis assets from the Facilitation view, By
Asset and By Hierarchy tabs.
The scope description appears in tables that display the analysis assets
and in reports.
2. On the second Assets tab, select the asset, click the Selected list,
and then Scope of Analysis. For example:
4. Click OK. The dialog closes and the description appears in the Analy-
sis Scope column of the Assets table.
2. On the second Assets tab, click the New list and then Analysis
Asset. The New Analysis Asset dialog appears.
3. Click a browse icon to open the Asset Selector dialog. Select the asset
and click OK. The dialog closes and the asset information is added to
the New Analysis Asset dialog.
2. In the left table, select the asset you wish to analyze. For example:
3. Click New at the bottom of the Failure modes table. The Mainte-
nance Action Plan window appears.
Note: Operating context values are defined at the site level, in the
Strategy Development settings. For more information, see “Set-
ting up Operating Contexts” in Help.
3. To quickly add one or more employees to the team, click Browse. The
Browse Employees dialog appears. Select the employees and click
OK. They are added to the Analysis Team tab.
5. If the member does not have an APM employee record, select Consul-
tant from the Type list and provide the member’s name, job title,
and company or department.
8. On the Analysis Team tab, select the team leader from the Facilita-
tor list.
2. Click Edit to modify the comment, add a response, or mark the com-
ment as reviewed. You can also add attachments and view details
about the comment’s history.
3. You can now describe the meeting, enter the date and time, identify
the team members who attended and the facilitator, and record the
minutes.
In the analysis, you can also add checklist items that were added to the
site’s Strategy Development settings after the analysis was created.
For information about adding checklist items to the site’s Strategy Devel-
opment settings, see “Setting up Checklist Items” in Help.
3. Double-click the item in the list to open the Checklist item window.
For example:
2. Click New. The Checklist Item window appears. The Checklist item
list contains any items that were defined in the site’s settings after
the current analysis was created.
3. Select an item in the list. If appropriate, you can mark the item as
performed and enter comments.
Contents
Creating Failure Modes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 112
Creating Analysis Requests for Failure Modes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 118
Evaluating Susceptibility to Failure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 124
Performing Failure Mode Risk Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 127
Performing Risk Analysis with Weighted Severities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 144
Performing Demand Scenario Risk Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 147
Viewing Risk Analyses for Failure Modes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 160
Recording Failure Data . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 164
Evaluating the Feasibility of Maintenance Tasks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 171
Developing Primary Action Plans . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 178
Creating Secondary Action Plans . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 184
Calculating a Failure-Finding Interval. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 186
Adding Indicators, Tasks, and Work to Action Plans. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 192
Reviewing Indicator Collection Information . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 203
Adding Standard Documents to Action Plans. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 205
Recording and Reviewing Failure Mode Details. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 207
Adding Symptoms to a Failure Mode . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 210
• If you subscribe to the APM Online Content Library, you can access
available libraries of failure modes using the Internet. Select the
Facilitation view and the By Asset or By Hierarchy tab. Select the
asset and click Browse APM Online Content. For more informa-
tion, see “Activating and Using APM Online Content Library” in
Help.
• The MTA2 Process Flow view is available in the analysis window if
a custom process flow has been created for MTA2 analyses. This view
provides steps that display panels in the order used by your organiza-
tion to develop failure modes. To create the first failure mode in a pro-
cess flow, select the table view by clicking .
• You can add failure modes and their action plans to an MTA2 by
copying them from another analysis or template. For more informa-
tion, see “Copying Failure Modes” on page 211.
• Create each failure mode individually using the Maintenance Action
Plan window. On the Info Worksheet tab, click the New list and
then From Scratch to open this window.
• Use the form view on the Info Worksheet tab to add two or more
failure modes. You can use this method when the analysis already
has at least one failure mode.
This section explains how to create an individual failure mode using the
Maintenance Action Plan window. When the first failure mode has been
added, you can use the form view to quickly add several failure modes
with their failure effects and recommended strategies. See:
3. Click the New list and then From Scratch. The Maintenance Action
Plan window appears.
The Failure mode reference area displays the unique identifier for
the failure mode, which consists of the asset’s sequence number and
the failure mode number.
Tip: You can hide the notes boxes by selecting an option in the
analysis’ failure mode options. In the Strategy Development Anal-
ysis window, select the Properties view and the Failure Mode
Options tab. On the Format tab, click Hide identification sec-
tion.
Tip: You can also change one or more failure mode’s assets on the
Strategy Development Analysis window by selecting the Imple-
mentation view and the Action Plans tab. Select the failure
modes, right-click, and click Change Asset.
5. On the General tab, enter a description in the Failure mode box.
6. In the Failure effects box, describe what happens when the failure
mode occurs.
8. If you wish to analyze a complex failure mode in its own MTA2, select
Analyzed separately. The Link button becomes available. You can
link the failure mode to an analysis request that is tracked by a proj-
ect. See “Creating Analysis Requests for Failure Modes” on page 118.
You can then close the Maintenance Action Plan window. The current
analysis maintains a reference to the failure mode, but you cannot
assign it a recommended strategy.
9. Select the recommended strategy. The options are:
Tip: At any time, you can select the Asset History view for infor-
mation about the asset’s checksheets, failures, work orders, and
work requests.
10. Select the Criticality tab to perform risk analysis. For more informa-
tion, see “Performing Failure Mode Risk Analysis” on page 127.
12. Select the Failure Pattern tab to record the failure pattern. For
more information, see “Recording Failure Data” on page 164.
13. Select the Documents tab to browse for standard documents that
are relevant to the analysis.
14. Select the Details tab to apply an action plan status, select a failure
type and failure classification, assign usage details, and see review
requests and related root causes. For more information, see “Record-
ing and Reviewing Failure Mode Details” on page 207.
15. Select the Notes tab to add and review the failure mode and risk
evaluation notes.
16. Select the Symptoms tab to assign keywords or phrases that sum-
marize the evidence an operator would see when the failure occurs or
is about to occur. For more information, see “Adding Symptoms to a
Failure Mode” on page 210.
17. Select the Feasibility view to evaluate whether the proposed main-
tenance strategies are worth doing; that is, whether implementing
the maintenance tasks will cost less than the savings achieved by
avoiding the failure. For more information, see “Evaluating the Feasi-
bility of Maintenance Tasks” on page 171.
18. Select the Implementation view to develop action plans. For more
information, see “Developing Primary Action Plans” on page 178 and
“Creating Secondary Action Plans” on page 184.
19. Save the failure mode and close the Maintenance Action Plan win-
dow. The failure mode is added to the Info Worksheet tab.
3. If you have not already done so, create the first failure mode for the
analysis.
4. Click to view failure modes in the form view. Click at the bot-
tom of the window to add a new failure mode. The Failure mode ref-
erence area displays the reference numbers for the new failure
mode. For example:
Button Function
Go to the first object
Go to the previous object
Go to the next object
Go to the last object
Create an object
Note: In order for the New button ( ) to work in the Form view,
you must not add filters to the Failure Modes table configuration.
When you select Analyze separately, the Link button becomes avail-
able. You can link the failure mode to an analysis request that is tracked
by a project. When you are ready to create the analysis, process the
request. Alternatively, you can cancel requests and reopen processed and
canceled requests.
• Asset to be analyzed
• Employee assigned to be the project manager
• Requested start and completion dates – These become the
planned start and completion dates in the analysis
• Estimate of the time required to perform the analysis
• Comment
6. Click OK. The project and analysis request are created. The project
number is displayed in the Project box. To open its Project window,
double-click the icon.
7. Work with the project, as required. For more information, see “Creat-
ing and Planning Projects” in Help.
You can view analysis requests and projects in the Facilitation view,
Requests tab. Select the “Analysis requests for the analysis asset” con-
figuration. Double-click an analysis request to view information about it.
2. Double-click the request that you want to process. The Request dialog
appears.
Failure mode identi- When you are linking to a failure mode in a new
fication or existing analysis, you can use a new or exist-
ing failure mode.
6. Click Finish to close the dialog. The questions, instructions, and your
answers and notes are shown in the Susceptibility tab. For exam-
ple:
7. Click Review when you wish to revisit the analysis, change your
answers, or add notes.
When the relative risk is established, APM calculates the failure mode’s
priority using a set of customer-defined rules. The consequence priority
rules can be based on the failure mode’s severity, relative risk, downtime
costs, downtime duration, or a combination. For example, the Extreme
priority could be assigned to failure modes whose total severity is equal
to 5.0.
You can apply a confidence factor to the analysis to quantify your faith in
current maintenance or inspection practices to contain the failure mode’s
risk. The confidence factor can adjust the inspection factor or the failure
mode’s position in the risk matrix.
After you have analyzed the failure modes, you can compare failure
modes and identify the relative importance of addressing them. The Risk
Assessment view in the Strategy Development Analysis window
includes failure mode lists based on criticality, consequence priority,
severity, and relative risk, as well as a risk plot, risk matrix, and lists of
the evaluations. This view is also available for the asset.
Note: Before you can perform risk analysis, the severities, proba-
bilities, confidence factors, and risk matrix entries must be set up
in the site’s risk analysis settings. If you are using evaluation
forms, they must also be set up. For more information, see “Set-
ting up APM for Maintenance Task Analysis” on page 34.
When you have finished the evaluations, the risk matrix shows the
resulting priority score. In this example, the results are Medium High
(criticality) and High (consequences):
5. “Viewing the Risk Analysis Summary” on page 143 – You can view
the most recent evaluation results by clicking Summary on the Crit-
icality tab. The Risk Summary dialog displays tabs for each of the
questionnaires used in the analysis.
3. Select the Facilitation view and the Criticality tab. For example:
Enter the amount of time and the unit of measure. When the failure
mode is saved, the corresponding probability is selected in the risk
matrix.
5. To use a questionnaire, click Probability. The Probability of Failure
Evaluation appears. The evaluation types (Simple, Detailed), catego-
ries, and questions available to you depend on the form’s design and
the asset properties. Here is an example of a simple evaluation:
You can refer to the History and Barriers tabs for information to
aid in the evaluation, for example, historical inspections, failures, and
work.
6. Complete the evaluation, selecting options for each category, entering
notes, and using the arrow buttons to move between categories. If dif-
ferent evaluation types have been defined in the form’s design, you
can select Simple or Detailed, as required by the complexity of the
failure mode that you are analyzing.
As you move through the analysis, the Probability box displays the
most severe probability assigned to your selections. For example, if
you select options for three categories, two of which have a result of
“Negligible” and one with a result of “High”, the score for the evalua-
tion as a whole will be “High”. This will be the probability used in the
risk analysis.
7. In the Analyzed by list, select the team member performing the
evaluation.
8. In the Notes box, you can provide additional information about the
analysis. Notes are collected and available in several locations.
9. When you have completed the evaluation, click OK. The evaluation
form closes and the result (for example, high, medium, low, or negligi-
ble) is selected in the risk matrix. For example:
Total labor costs Monetary cost of labor in the event of the asset’s
failure. The amount is shown in the site’s cur-
rency.
Tip: Select the FM Asset Properties tab and then the Produc-
tion Loss Accounting tab to view the downtime cost rule.
8. In the Occurrence costs box, enter the estimated fixed cost associ-
ated with a downtime occurrence. For example, this could be a fixed
cost associated with restarting a machine after it has been shut down.
10. In the Analyzed by list, select the team member who performed the
evaluation.
11. In the Notes box, you can enter additional information about the
evaluation. Notes are collected and available in several locations.
12. When you are finished the evaluation, click OK. The result of the eco-
nomic evaluation is shown in the risk matrix. For example:
At any time, you can refer to the FM Asset Properties tab for
detailed information about the asset.
As you move through the analysis, the Severity box displays the
most severe score assigned to your selections. For example, if you
select options for three categories, two of which have a result of “Neg-
ligible” and one with a result of “High”, the score for the evaluation as
a whole will be “High”. However, if a mitigation category has been
defined for the evaluation, its score can raise or lower the severity.
The resulting ranking is used in the risk matrix.
3. In the Analyzed by list, select the team member performing the
evaluation.
4. In the Note box, you can provide additional information about the
analysis. Notes are collected and available in several locations.
The Criticality box shows the result of the evaluation you performed
on the Criticality tab.
• The Confidence factor box displays the default for the degrada-
tion type. If the degradation type’s settings allow, you can select
another value from the Confidence factor list.
• If the degradation type supports confidence statements, they are
displayed in this area. For example:
For each confidence statement, click a response, for example, No, Yes,
or Intermediate. The Confidence factor box displays the result of
your selection, indicating if confidence is low or high. The inspection
factor, inspection strategy, and interval might also be supplied.
3. The Lining tab is available if the asset has lining properties that
require confidence evaluation. Select the Lining tab. You will see one
or more of the following:
Select a statement and click OK. The form closes and the state-
ment is shown in the Lining tab. The Details area displays the
inspection factor, inspection interval, or both, depending on the
evaluation form’s properties.
4. In the Details area, you can add or change the last and next inspec-
tion dates.
The Details area shows information about the criticality and confi-
dence analyses. The asset and degradation type determine whether
inspection interval, inspection strategy, life adjustment factor, or a
combination is shown. For example:
Note: If you click a button on the risk matrix, the result is shown
on the Summary tab.
When you have performed risk assessments for all of the failure modes in
the analysis, you can compare them using the Risk Assessment view.
For more information, see “Viewing Risk Analyses for Failure Modes” on
page 160.
You can apply a confidence factor to the analysis to quantify your faith in
current maintenance to contain the failure mode’s risk. The confidence
factor can adjust the relative risk up or down.
When the relative risk is established, APM calculates the failure mode’s
consequence priority using a set of customer-defined rules. The conse-
quence priority rules can be based on the failure mode’s severity, relative
risk, downtime costs, downtime duration, or a combination. For example,
the Extreme consequence could be assigned to failure modes whose total
severity is equal to 5.0.
After you have analyzed the failure modes, you can compare failure
modes and identify the relative importance of addressing them. The Risk
Analysis view in the Strategy Development Analysis window includes
failure mode lists based on criticality, consequence priority, severity, and
relative risk, as well as a risk plot, risk matrix, and lists of the evalua-
tions. This view is also available for the asset.
Note: Before you can perform risk analyses, the severities, proba-
bilities, failure mode consequence priorities, confidence factors,
and risk matrix entries must be set up in the site’s strategy Devel-
opment settings. For more information, see “Risk Analysis Set-
tings” in Help.
APM calculates the total severity for each of the categories by multi-
plying the severity by its weighting factor. The failure mode’s total
severity is calculated as the sum of the categories’ severities.
6. If probability can be based on the analysis team’s estimate of the time
between failures, the Criticality tab also displays the ETBF box:
Enter the amount of time and the unit of measure. The corresponding
probability value is displayed in the Failure probability box.
7. You can select a probability of failure from the list. If ETBF is also
available, its value changes accordingly.
APM calculates the relative risk for the failure mode by multiplying
the total failure mode severity by the probability of failure.
8. Select a confidence factor from the list. The confidence factor is used
to adjust the location of a failure mode on the risk matrix based on
your faith in the existing maintenance practices and equipment his-
tory.
When you have entered all of the information that is required by con-
sequence priority rules, APM calculates the criticality number. The
risk matrix entry is shown in the risk matrix chart.
9. Select the most important consequence of failure from the Dominant
consequences options.
When you have performed risk analyses for all of the failure modes in the
analysis, you can compare them using the Risk Analysis view. For more
information, see “Viewing Risk Analyses for Failure Modes” on page 160.
Note: Before you can perform demand scenario analysis, the like-
lihoods of failure, confidence questions, demand rates, demand
scenarios, and probability matrix must be set up in the site’s
strategy development settings. For more information, see “Failure
Probability Settings” in Help.
4. Select the degradation type from the list, for example, age-related or
non-age-related.
5. Select a likelihood of failure from the list, for example, “Has hap-
pened more than once per year at the location”.
The Scenario area displays the asset and failure mode information,
as well as the adjusted likelihood of failure. For example:
2. From the Demand scenario list, select the event that requires the
safety device to be put into operation, for example, “Power failure” or
“Blocked outlet”.
Tip: If risk analysis settings allow, you can click the impact but-
tons in the risk matrix rather than stepping through the question-
naires.
At any time, you can refer to the FM Asset Properties tab for
detailed information about the asset.
2. For the simple form, provide the following information. If you wish to
perform a detailed analysis, skip to step 3.
Total labor costs Monetary cost of labor in the event of the asset’s
failure. The amount is shown in the site’s cur-
rency.
Tip: Select the FM Asset Properties tab and then the Produc-
tion Loss Accounting tab to view the downtime cost rule.
8. In the Occurrence costs box, enter the estimated fixed cost associ-
ated with a downtime occurrence. For example, this could be a fixed
cost associated with restarting a machine after it has been shut down.
10. In the Analyzed by list, select the team member who performed the
evaluation.
11. In the Notes box, you can enter additional information about the
evaluation. Notes are collected and available in several locations.
12. When you are finished the evaluation, click OK. The result of the eco-
nomic evaluation is shown in the risk matrix. For example:
At any time, you can refer to the FM Asset Properties tab for
detailed information about the asset.
2. Complete each of the evaluations, selecting options for each category,
entering notes, and using the arrow buttons to move between catego-
ries. If different evaluation types have been defined in the form’s
design, you can select Simple or Detailed, as required by the com-
plexity of the failure mode that you are analyzing.
As you move through the analysis, the Severity box displays the
most severe score assigned to your selections. For example, if you
select options for three categories, two of which have a result of “Neg-
ligible” and one with a result of “High”, the score for the evaluation as
a whole will be “High”. However, if a mitigation category has been
defined for the evaluation, its score can raise or lower the severity.
The resulting ranking is used in the risk matrix.
3. In the Analyzed by list, select the team member performing the
evaluation.
4. In the Note box, you can provide additional information about the
analysis. Notes are collected and available in several locations.
The Selected demand scenario box displays the scenario with the
highest criticality value.
Tip: Scroll to the right in the table to see the Criticality column.
The scenario with the highest number is automatically selected to
represent the failure mode.
2. Select the Criticality tab. This tab shows the risk matrix chart for
the selected demand scenario. You can:
Tip: You can also view risk assessments and risk matrix informa-
tion for all failure modes on the site. On the Site window, select
the Strategy Development view and tab, and then the Risk
Assessment tab. To view an asset’s information, open the Asset
window, and select the Risk Assessment view.
The tabs on the Risk Assessment view provide the following informa-
tion.
Risk Assessment
On this tab, you can view the analysis’ assets by relative risk. Configura-
tions are provided that list failure modes by relative risk, criticality, con-
sequence priority, and so on. There are also summary charts for failure
modes. Here is an example of assets by relative risk:
Criticality
This tab shows a summary chart of failure modes according to criticality.
You can also select the “Failure mode list by consequence priority” config-
uration.
Risk Plot
This tab contains a plot of the failure modes based on their probability
and severity. Click a risk plot in the table to view the failure modes. For
example:
Evaluations
This tab shows lists of failure modes for which probability, economic,
health and safety, environmental, and/or reputation evaluations have
been performed. Select the Evaluation Audit tab to view lists of faiure
modes for which evaluations have not been performed.
Explorer
This tab shows summaries and details about risk analysis results. The
tree contains nodes for criticality, consequence priority, relative risk, and
probability scores. Select a node to view summary information. Select an
individual failure mode to view its risk matrix. This example shows the
criticality summary for an analysis with five failure modes:
When the team performs risk analysis on the failure mode, the costs
incurred by the consequences (health and safety, environmental, reputa-
tion) are used in the calculation that determines avoidance savings (if the
appropriate failure cost settings are enabled for the analysis).
This is also true of the economic consequence cost, although APM differ-
entiates between the cost assigned to the consequence severity value and
the result of the Economic Evaluation questionnaire. There are three
possible ways to enter the economic consequence, depending on the anal-
ysis’ settings:
The Failure Data tab displays the estimated downtime, downtime costs,
downtime per occurrence costs, failure costs, cost of multiple failures,
and secondary damage cost. This tab also shows the consequence costs, if
supported by the analysis’ failure mode settings. The following example
shows the results when the detailed economic evaluation has been per-
formed, as well as the other consequence evaluations:
• Downtime costs
• Failure costs
• Occurrence costs
• Consequence costs
• Cost of multiple failures
• Secondary damage costs
When the failure mode references an indicator with states, the avoidance
savings amount is copied from the failure mode to failure records that are
created when the indicator’s alarms are acknowledged.
On the Failure Pattern tab, you can record random, wear out, and
infant mortality patterns. Typically, you will include information about
failure patterns when you intend to use Isograph Availability Workbench
to analyze and optimize action plans.
4. On the Facilitation view, select the Failure Data tab. This example
shows the tab when criticality analysis has not been performed:
Time to repair The average time it takes to repair the asset and
return it to service after a failure occurs.
Majority will have How long after the wear-out period begins that
failed by the majority of assets of this type will have
failed.
If you have performed risk analysis on the failure mode, when you select
the Feasibility view, you will see that it displays the estimated time
between failures (ETBF), avoidance savings, and initial risk. These val-
ues are based on the following:
a maintenance task type. When you click this button, information from
the Economic Effects Evaluation from is copied to the Labor, Repairs,
and Downtime tabs.
When you establish that the tasks are justified, click Update Action
Plans to create or refresh the action plan for the recommended task. Sec-
ondary action plans are created for any additional tasks.
In some situations, you might have to implement a task that is not justi-
fied, for example, to meet regulatory inspection requirements. In this
case, you can override the result, record the reason, and update action
plans.
3. To determine the residual risk, enter the estimated time between con-
sequences (ETBC). This is the time between unexpected conse-
quences or failures when inspections and preventive maintenance are
performed on the asset. APM calculates the residual risk and displays
its description.
4. If appropriate, select a task type from the list. You can describe the
task in the text box below.
5. The Action plan details area contains information that will be cop-
ied to the task’s action plan when it is created or updated. From the
Frequency list, select the time period that indicates how often the
task should be performed. This information is used in the MEI index
calculation, along with task costs.
Tip: For proposed tasks that are performed as needed, for exam-
ple, restoration or discard, you can select the “As needed” or
“When required” frequency defined for your organization. In the
Numeric frequency box, enter an estimate of how often the task
will be performed.
6. In the Trade list, select the resource that will be copied to the task’s
action plan.
7. In the Duration box, enter the amount of time that the trade person
will need to perform the task.
8. Enter the appropriate amounts for labor, repairs, and downtime costs
in the Total costs area. The total is calculated and displayed in the
Task costs box. Alternatively, you can select one or more of the
Details options. The appropriate tabs (Labor, Repairs, Downtime)
are added, where you can itemize the costs in detail.
Note: You cannot clear Include in MEI for the first proposed
task.
11. Click Details to compare the tasks. The Details dialog displays fail-
ure mode and evaluation details. The Proposed Tasks tab lists the
tasks and their costs. For example:
Scroll to the right to view costs for each task, the number of times the
task is performed for the period, and the cost for the period. You can
also double-click a task to view more information about it.
Click Close to close the dialog.
12. When the cost is justified, you can click Update Action Plans. If
action plans have not yet been created, APM adds them to the failure
mode. The following information is copied to the action plans:
first one it finds is updated with information from the first secondary
task on the Feasibility view. If a matching task type is not found, a
secondary action plan is created.
13. On MTA2 and RCM2 failure modes, if the primary proposed task is
not justified, you have the option of selecting Accept no scheduled
maintenance result. When you click Update Action Plans, the
primary action plan’s task type is set to “No Scheduled Maintenance”.
Any existing secondary action plans are deleted.
14. If the proposed task is not justified but it needs to be performed any-
way, for example, because of regulatory requirements, select Over-
ride result. Then select a reason from the list of MEI override
reasons defined for the site, enter a comment manually, or do both.
Tip: You can also select Override result and provide a reason
when a proposed task is justified.
Developing an action plan involves describing and setting options for the
action. Depending on the action type, you can assign indicators, correc-
tive tasks, or a standard document to the plan. If a failure mode requires
more than one type of action, you can create secondary action plans for it.
Tip: If you performed risk analysis on the failure mode, the result-
ing recommended task and related information might appear in
the Implementation view, Primary Action Plan tab, depend-
ing on the analysis risk options. In that case, you cannot change
the task type, but you can develop the action plan as needed.
This topic explains how to develop action plans from the Maintenance
Action Plan window using the Implementation view, Primary Action
Plan tab.
Tip: You can also quickly add action plans from the Strategy
Development Analysis window’s Implementation view, Action
Plans tab. Select a failure mode in the table view and press F2 to
open the row for editing. Press Tab to move to the next editable
field. When you are done, press Enter to close the table to editing.
Tip: You can also open an analysis from the asset’s Strategy
Development view, Analyses tab.
2. Double-click the analysis to open the Strategy Development Analysis
window.
The following table describes the details for each of the types.
8. For some actions, you can add an inspection task, indicators, correc-
tive tasks, follow-up work, or standard documents to the analysis. If
the action supports it, the appropriate tab appears in the dialog.
This section explains how to add secondary action plans to existing fail-
ure modes.
Tip: The Action Plans view in the analysis window lists the
action plans for each failure mode. The Action Plan Type column
indicates whether the action plan is primary or secondary.
Tip: You can also open a failure mode by opening an asset and
selecting the Strategy Development view, Strategy Develop-
ment tab, and Failure Modes tab.
2. Double-click the analysis to open the Strategy Development Analysis
window.
7. Select a task type from the list. The options available change accord-
ing to the type you select.
8. Complete the options for the action as you would for a primary action
plan.
11. When you have finished developing the action plan, close the dialog.
The action plan is saved and displayed on the Secondary Action
Plans tab.
Tip: After calculating the FFI, you can view the calculation inputs
in the Facilitation view, Failure Data tab. Click the Failure
Finding Information button to open the Failure Finding Info
window.
4. Click the calculator icon next to the Failure finding interval boxes.
5. Select the formula that you wish to use. When you select a formula, it
is displayed below the list. The formula’s calculation inputs appear in
the Calculation details area. The following table provides a brief
description of each formula and its inputs.
Formula Inputs
Availability-based formula UTIVE = Unavailability of the
protective device
Formula Inputs
Single independent protected MTED = Mean time between
function failure for the protected func-
tion
Formula Inputs
K of n voting system MTIVE = Mean time between
failure for the protective device
Protected system with a set of
parallel protective devices MTED = Mean time between
failure for the protected func-
tion
r=n-k+1
Failure finding task causes a hid- MOTHER = Mean time between
den failure failure caused by phenomena
other than the test
The failure-finding task could
cause the very failure which it is MTED = Mean time between
suppose to check and so leave the failure for the protected func-
protective device in a (hidden) tion
failed state from the moment the
test is completed MMF = Allowed mean time
between multiple failures
Formula Inputs
Economic CM = cost of the multiple fail-
ure (cost per event)
6. Provide the calculation inputs for the formula. When the inputs are
supplied, the results of the calculation are shown in the Results area.
The frequency closest to the failure-finding interval, without being
longer than the failure-finding interval, is displayed.
7. Click OK. The failure-finding interval is added to the action plan and
the frequency is calculated and displayed.
Tip: After you have added an indicator to an action plan, you can
right-click it in the table and click Review Request Details. In
the Review Request Details dialog that appears, specify the reli-
ability program update required. When the action plan is marked
“Facilitation Completed” or “Implementation Completed”, the
request is created automatically.
• Corrective tasks – You can do one or more of the following, depending
on how APM is configured:
• Create or browse for one or more APM standard tasks, task tem-
plates, standard jobs, job tasks, or job templates to correct prob-
lems
• Browse for SAP Plant Maintenance items (for example, equip-
ment task lists) to correct problems if APM has been set up to
access external data
• Corrective action plan tasks – Request that the reliability program be
updated. The action plan task can reference an existing APM or SAP
object. Or you can choose to reference a task in an external CMMS
(select “Other”). You can select update options and enter notes to let
the planner know whether an object needs to be created, modified, or
deleted.
• Follow-up Work – For all types of recommended actions, you can cre-
ate work requests or work orders to define follow-up work.
In the process of creating analysis templates, you can add indicator tem-
plates, task templates, and job templates. When an analysis is created
from the template or when the action plan is copied to another analysis,
APM checks the asset for a matching indicator, standard task, or stan-
dard job. If a match is not available, a new indicator, task, or job is cre-
ated using the template. If a match is found on the asset, it is assigned to
the action plan.
4. To add an existing standard task, click Browse, select the task, and
click OK.
• In the Asset box, click the browse icon ( ) and select the asset.
The asset number and name are displayed in the dialog.
• Select a work type from the list.
• Enter a descriptive title for the new task.
• Select a collection set, if appropriate. Collection set is one of the
matching criteria that can be used to select indicators for a stan-
dard task’s dynamic inspection route.
Values for expected frequency, operating condition, maintenance
group, and technology are copied from the action plan.
10. In the Indicator collection information area, select whether
dynamic or static indicators are added to the task:
• Click New at the bottom of the Indicators tab. The Create New
Indicator dialog appears, where you can select either From
scratch or From template. To create from a template, select the
indicator template.
• When you click OK, the Indicator or Indicator Template window
appears, where you can define the indicator or template.
• When you are finished, save the indicator or template and close
the window. The indicator is listed in the table.
Tip: In the Create New Indicator dialog, you can also click Create
Multiple to add two or more indicators (not indicator templates).
The Create Multiple Indicators window appears, where you can
specify the number to create, the indicator name, number to add
to the name, indicator type, and so on. When you click OK, the
indicators are added to the table. You can then open them individ-
ually, and modify them as needed.
• On the APM Tasks tab, click New Corrective Task in the New
list. Or, on the SAP Tasks tab, click New. The Action Plan Task
dialog appears.
• In the Type list, select an object or “Other”.
• If you selected an object type, click the browse icon to select the
item to reference.
• Enter a reference to the CMMS task, if applicable.
• Click Reliability program update required. Select the update
type: create, modify, or delete a reliability program object. Provide
instructions in the text box.
• Click OK. The task is added to the appropriate Tasks tab.
2. Click New. The New Action Plan Follow Up Work dialog appears.
3. Select the type of document to create and provide the required infor-
mation.
4. When you click OK, the document is added to the appropriate table in
the Follow Up Work tab. The Work Order Task or Work Request
window appears, where you can define the document.
4. On the second Collection tab, you can select tabs to view indicators
that are not included on a standard task, that are included on two or
more tasks, and that are included on one task. The Tasks tab lists
the standard tasks that the indicators are collected on.
5. Select the Details tab to view information about the report itself, for
example, the date when it was generated.
5. Select a document.
The Status area shows the failure mode’s status in regard to facilitation
and implementation. If action plan statuses have been defined for your
organization, you can select a status from the Action plan status list.
In the Failure mode details area, you can assign a failure type and
classification to the failure mode. Failure types, along with failure classi-
fications, allow failure modes and records to be grouped for easy identifi-
cation. For example, useful failure types might be Electrical,
Environmental, Mechanical, Operational, Safety, and so on. Examples of
failure classifications are Lubrication, Operator Error, and Installation
Defect.
If the failure mode was created as the result of an analysis request, select
the Review Requests tab to view the request. You can double-click the
request to open its Request dialog, where details such as the project num-
ber and analysis estimate are shown.
If the failure mode was created as a result of a root cause analysis, the
RCA tab lists the root cause. You can double-click the root cause to open
its Properties dialog, where the cause statement, solution, and messages
are displayed.
Usage Details
If your organization requires additional usage information for failure
modes, you can review or assign values on the Usage tab. These details
are:
A Fault Diagnosis Guide lists symptoms and the failure modes that refer-
ence them. You can print a Fault Diagnosis Guide report for the site, an
asset, or a strategy development analysis (MTA2, RCM2, RBI). The
Analysis Summary view in every Strategy Development Analysis win-
dow contains the Fault Guide tab, which lists symptoms, failure modes,
and assets.
For information about printing the Fault Diagnosis Guide, see “Printing
MTA2 Reports” on page 296.
4. Select one or more symptoms and click OK. The symptoms are added
to the tab.
The copy function for failure modes includes smart asset mapping, which
uses information about the source assets to identify matching assets in
the target asset structure. Using the Copy Failure Modes wizard, you can
select source and target asset structures, the failure modes to copy, and
the criteria for identifying target assets. You can then confirm or change
the matches that the system suggests. When you click Process, the wiz-
ard performs the copy and reports the results.
Contents
Overview of the Copy Failure Modes Wizard . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 212
Setting Mapping Options for a Failure Mode Copy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 221
Browsing for Failure Modes to Add to an MTA2 or Template . . . . . . . 231
Copying Failure Modes to an Analysis or Template. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 244
Copying an Asset’s Strategy Development Program . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 258
Revisiting Failure Mode Copy Requests . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 270
The Copy Failure Modes wizard is especially useful when you have ana-
lyzed one branch of the asset hierarchy (for example, the many assets
associated with haul truck #1) and then wish to copy the failure modes to
a similar set of assets (haul truck #2). Failure modes can also be copied
from one site to another, as long as the source analysis’ settings permit it
to be used at the target site.
When a failure mode is copied, its primary and secondary action plans
are included (if the analysis’ implementation method includes action
plans). During implementation, use the wizard to efficiently update fail-
ure modes by copying indicators, standard tasks, jobs, and procedures
into the target analysis.
This topic explains the following aspects of failure mode copy requests:
• Browse for failure modes to copy into the analysis that you are work-
ing on
• Select an analysis or template and copy failure modes to a new or
existing analysis
• Create an analysis from an existing analysis’ failure modes
The steps appear at the bottom of each page. The current step is shown in
blue. Any step that is not required for your copy is disabled.
If you are copying failure modes from a source to a target, the source
analysis or template, asset or asset type, and failure modes are displayed
on the Select Source step. You can review the failure modes and de-
selected any that you do not wish to copy.
Smart asset mapping uses the source and target asset structures that
you specify to search for matches between assets, failure modes, and so
on. By default, the starting point for a structure is the primary asset on
the analysis. You might find it useful to return to the Identify Target step
and change the starting points of the asset structures to yield more
matches after you have tested the results of the matching process. The
closer to parallel that the starting assets are in their respective hierar-
chies, the more likely it is that usable matches will be found.
• Analysis option – you can have the failure modes copied to a new or
existing analysis or template
• Site – you can copy failure modes to another site, as long as the
source analysis can be used at other sites
• Analysis – if you are copying to an existing analysis, identify the tar-
get
• Asset option – if you are creating a new analysis, specify whether to
use new or existing assets. If you choose to create assets, select the
parent asset for them
• Target – specify the assets for the target structure
You can also select analysis criteria for matching assets, including:
To help find matching assets, failure modes, and so on, you can use Tri-
gram searching, a powerful method of searching for text when the exact
syntax or spelling of the target object is not known. For example, use the
Trigram option to match assets with slightly different titles. It finds
objects that match the maximum number of three-character strings in
the entered search terms; that is, it finds near matches. You can specify a
threshold as a cutoff point, after which a result is no longer considered a
match.
Note: If you are running APM with an Oracle database that has
case-sensitivity turned on, you might get unexpected results when
the matching process compares properties identified in mapping
criteria. For example, mapping assets according to their Title
attributes might not result in “PUMP” being matched with
For more information, see “Setting Mapping Options for a Failure Mode
Copy” on page 221.
Reviewing Mappings
Once you have selected the source objects, target asset structure, and
matching criteria, the system mines the source failure modes to create a
list of assets involved in the copy, as well as the trades, employees, and
maintenance groups. The system then attempts to map each of the source
objects to a corresponding target object.
Depending on the consistency of the data in your source and target struc-
tures and the mapping criteria used, this step might simply require a
visual confirmation of the system’s suggestions. In cases where the struc-
tures are not consistent or the mapping criteria provide too many or too
few matches, a more thorough review is required.
You can also change the default processing options on this page. For
example, you can have APM open the target analyses when the copy is
finished, specify that the Review Results step not appear, or delay pro-
cessing.
If Process later is selected, when you click Process, the copy request is
saved and closed. You can finish it manually later or set up a scheduled
action to process all pending copy requests for the site or enterprise. As a
guideline, use deferred processing when you do not want to tie up your
computer while the copy is performed and you do not want to start work-
ing on the new analyses right away. Deferred processing is handy when
you have a number of copies to perform (for example, an asset’s Strategy
Development program is being pushed out to a number of similar pieces
of equipment). If you want to start analyzing the new action plans right
away, you are best to process the copy now.
Reviewing Results
When the copy is completed (assuming that Process later is not
selected), the Review Results step presents a list of the failure modes
that were created or updated. You can open the Details window to view
information about the copy request.
When you copy failure modes to a different site, their standard docu-
ments are copied only if they are valid at the target site. Any employees,
maintenance groups, or trades included on the failure modes are mapped
to matching objects in the target site, as long as they are valid for use at
the target. If they are not valid, the mapping is set to “To Be Deter-
mined”, and you can specify that the object be excluded or mapped to a
different target.
Smart Mapping
The term “smart asset mapping” is used to identify the process where the
assets in one branch of the hierarchy are matched to the corresponding
assets in another branch of the hierarchy. For example, the assets of one
haul truck (HT100) are matched to those of another haul truck (HT101).
When failure modes are being copied to existing failure modes, the
Review Failure Mode Mappings page is available in the wizard. The Fail-
ure Modes page displays the failure modes and their mappings. The map-
pings are completed in the same manner as asset mappings.
All of the source information is copied to the target failure mode with the
exception of:
• Failure mode reference number – the target action plan retains its
existing FM reference
• Asset – the target failure mode remains with its existing asset
• MTA2 or RCM2 analysis – the target failure mode remains on the
same analysis; it is not moved to the source failure mode’s analysis
• Functional Failure and Function – in the case of RCM2 analyses, the
target failure mode remains linked to the same functional failure and
function; it is not moved to the source failure mode’s analysis
• RCM2 reference – the target failure mode retains its existing RCM2
reference number (RCM2 analyses only)
In addition, the source failure mode’s indicators, standard task, standard
job, trades, and maintenance group are mapped to the target failure
mode’s assets, trades, and maintenance groups using the same logic as
previously described.
1. Previous matches:
1. Assets are created as copies of their source assets for each asset map-
ping with the setting Create new.
3. Maintenance groups are created for the mappings with the setting
Create new. The maintenance group is created as a copy of the
source.
4. Analyses are created for the failure modes that are created.
5. In the case of failure modes on safety analyses (SIF and HAZOP), the
safety provisions and HAZOP checklist items are copied.
6. Functions and functional failures required for the new action plans
are created (RCM2 only).
7. Failure modes are copied. This logic maps the failure mode’s indica-
tors, standard tasks, and standard jobs to the target asset. The target
asset’s existing objects are used, if available. Otherwise, a new
instance is defined for the target asset. For example, if the failure
mode refers to the “pump pressure” indicator and a “pump pressure”
indicator already exists on the target asset, the existing indicator is
used. Otherwise, an indicator is created.
If the site’s mapping settings are not appropriate for the current copy,
you can modify them. Perhaps the asset structures involved use different
properties than your normal conventions. Using the site-level mapping
criteria would result in the system suggesting a number of incorrect map-
pings. By modifying the criteria, you can ensure that the quality of the
system’s suggestions are higher, requiring fewer manual changes.
The options are defined in the same manner as the site-level smart map-
ping options. In addition to defining the criteria for the current copy, you
have the option of replacing the site options with the values defined for
this copy request. This can be handy if the site options have not been
defined or require updating. Define the criteria you want to use and then
click Site Values and Save.
Tip: If you wish to return to the site-level settings, click Site Val-
ues and then Reset. This option is used when you have made a
number of changes to the criteria, are unhappy with the resulting
suggested mappings, and want to start over.
This topic explains how to use the mapping options in the Copy Failure
Modes wizard to ensure that objects are mapped accurately. The follow-
ing sections explain the general procedure for changing the settings.
These settings are then explained in detail:
The following example shows similar source and target asset structures
for haul trucks #1 and #2. The dotted lines show the mappings.
Source Target
HT100 HT101
HT100-1 HT101-1
HT100-1-A HT101-1-A
HT100-1-B HT101-1-B
HT100-2 HT101-2
HT100-2-A HT101-2-A
HT100-2-B HT101-2-B
Any assets in the structures that were not included in the previous copy
are mapped using the remaining criteria. If the option is not selected,
previous mappings are disregarded and the suggested mappings are
based on the other settings only.
Like all of the mapping criteria, it is wise to combine “level in the hierar-
chy” with one or more other criteria to get reasonable results. If used on
its own, this criterion can result in questionable suggestions that require
manual adjustments.
If this setting is not selected, the asset hierarchy is not considered in the
mappings. Assets from different levels and sections of the hierarchies can
be mapped.
You can specify properties for assets, employees, trades and other
resources, maintenance groups, and failure modes. Some objects have
attributes selected in the wizard by the system, and you cannot remove
them. For example, asset Classification is always a criteria in asset map-
ping to prevent problems with components and locations. Similarly, Unit
of Measure and Resource type are default attributes for resources.
Trades must be mapped to trades, services to services, and so on.
Resources can only be mapped to resources with the same unit of mea-
sure.
The list on each tab contains properties for the class that are best
suited for smart mapping.
2. To view all of the attributes that are available for use in smart map-
ping, select Show all.
4. Select the Relationships tab and make any selections you require.
5. When you are finished, click OK. The Properties table now displays
the attributes and relationships you selected.
2. Select one of the string attributes that you selected for smart map-
ping (listed in the table). For example, if you select the Title attribute,
the Trigram process searches the candidates for the object whose
Title most closely matches the source object’s Title.
• Suggested Origin displays the method used for matching. The pos-
sible values are:
• Previous match
• Suggested
• Default
• Manual
• Other
• Suggested Match Quality indicates if exact or partial (Trigram)
matching was used. Possible values are:
• No match suggested
• Complete match
• Partial match
• Closeness is the score obtained in the Trigram matching process. A
closeness value of 1.0 is an exact match.
• Single Or Multiple Candidates indicates whether multiple candi-
dates were found. Possible values are:
• No matches found
• Not applicable
• Single candidate
• Multiple candidates
The following example shows that Trigram matching was used (the sug-
gested match quality is “Partial match”), one partial match was found
(single candidate), and a score of 0.545 was obtained. An exact match has
a closeness score of 1.0.
Open target analy- Target analyses are opened after the copy
ses request is processed.
Do not use the map- Select this option when the mappings are to be
pings with future used for a single occasion. This option prevents
copies them from being used in subsequent copy
requests that specify “Use the results of previ-
ous matches”.
3. Select the default mapping option for failure modes. The options are:
Using the Copy Failure Modes wizard can involve as many as seven
steps, depending on the type of copy you are doing:
The steps appear at the bottom of each page. The current step is shown in
blue. Any step that is not required for your copy is disabled.
Note: If you copy a failure mode from a site that uses a different
currency, any monetary amounts defined on the action plan are
converted to the asset’s site currency. If an exchange rate is not
available, the amount is converted at par (for example, one U.S.
dollar is equivalent to one Canadian dollar).
There are differences in the Copy Failure Modes wizard if you are copy-
ing from or to a template. The illustrations in the procedure show an
analysis-to-analysis copy. Any differences in functionality for templates
are explained where they occur.
Tip: You can also open the Facilitation view, Failure Modes
tab, and then click the New list and Browse.
The Copy Failure Modes wizard appears showing the Select Source
step.
3. Click the browse icon ( ) in the Analysis box to select the source
analysis or template. The Strategy Development Analysis Selector
dialog appears, displaying analyses appropriate for the target. Select
an option from the configuration list to view a specific type of analy-
sis.
Tip: For quick copies (when you do not need to adjust the mapping
options), click Finish when you have selected the source and the
failure modes to copy. The wizard performs the matching process
and goes to the Confirm Selections step. Skip to step 16.
6. Click Next. The Identify Target step appears. This page differs
depending on the characteristics of the source and target analyses.
In some cases, you might wish to change the source asset struc-
ture, target asset structure, or both. When the starting assets
occupy parallel positions in their respective hierarchies, the map-
ping process is more likely to result in accurate matches.
• You can select Multiple target assets to display the analysis
assets in the Target asset structures table. For example:
You can select the target assets to use in the matching process.
• If you are copying from a template to an analysis, the list is lim-
ited to assets of the type supported by the template. To remove
this filter, clear the Limit assets to matching asset type
option.
• If you are copying from an analysis to a template, only the Source
structure starts at area is enabled. Skip to step 8.
• If you are copying from one template to another, both source and
target structure areas are disabled. Skip to step 8.
7. If the Asset mapping list is available, you can change the asset map-
ping that will be suggested if APM cannot identify a matching target.
The options are:
• Create new – a copy of the failure mode is created when the copy
request is processed
• Update existing – the source failure modes’ properties are cop-
ied to the target failure modes
asset’s failure modes, indicators, work order tasks, jobs, and job
tasks, as well as the corrective tasks, jobs, and job tasks for the
indicators. You can also view information about any secondary
action plans included in the failure modes.
11. Scroll to the right to review the mappings.
The Suggestion Origin column displays the method used for match-
ing. The options are:
• Previous match – the “Use results of previous copy” option is in
effect
• Suggested – the mapping is based on another criteria, for exam-
ple, hierarchy level or attribute matching
• Default – for assets, the source and target primary assets are
automatically matched. For employees, maintenance groups, and
trades, the source object is used as the target, provided that it is
valid at the target site.
• Manual – the user selected the mapping
The Suggested Match Quality, Closeness, and Single Or Multi-
ple Candidates columns show you the results of the smart mapping
process. The following example shows that Trigram matching was
used (the suggested match quality is “Partial match”), one partial
match was found (single candidate), and a score of 0.5454546 was
obtained. The candidate matches “Conveyor Belt” with “Conveyor”.
An exact match has a closeness score of 1.0.
To see information about mappings for other objects, select their tabs
and click Criteria and SQL.
Tip: You can also double-click a mapping to review the Asset Map-
ping dialog.
14. Click Next. If you are updating existing failure modes, the Review
FM Mappings step appears.
15. Click Next or Finish. The Confirm Selections step appears. For
example:
16. Check the items that will be created or updated. If an incorrect copy
request is processed, you will have to make the corrections manually.
Click View to see more details about the items.
The Failure Modes tab shows information about the source failure
modes. If you wish to remove a failure mode from the list, right-click
it and click Remove. Click Back to make adjustments on previous
pages.
17. On the Acknowledgment tab, in the Options area, select the pro-
cessing options:
Open target analy- Target analyses are opened after the copy
ses request is processed.
1. Select the mapping in the Asset mappings table, click the Selected
list, then Mark As and Map To.
3. If you selected “Map To”, the next step is to select a new target asset.
You can adjust the list of assets in the table using the Show options:
5. If the target asset has descendant assets in the analysis, you can
apply the mapping option to them as well. Select one of the Update
options:
Using the Copy Failure Modes wizard can involve as many as seven
steps, depending on the type of copy you are doing:
The steps appear at the bottom of each page. The current step is shown in
blue. Any step that is not required for your copy is disabled.
Note: If you copy a failure mode from a site that uses a different
currency, any monetary amounts defined on the action plan are
converted to the asset’s site currency. If an exchange rate is not
available, the amount is converted at par (for example, one U.S.
dollar is equivalent to one Canadian dollar).
The options on the Copy Failure Modes wizard differ slightly depending
on whether you are copying from an analysis or template. The illustra-
tions in the procedure show an analysis-to-analysis copy. Any differences
in functionality for templates are explained where they occur.
Tip: You can copy failure modes from an MTA2, RCM2, SIF, or
HAZOP analysis or template into an MTA2 or MTA2 template.
You can also copy action plans from a current practice review into
an MTA2 or MTA2 template.
2. Right-click the analysis or template and click Copy.
Note: You can also open the analysis or template, click the Tools
menu, Failure Modes, and then Copy To. You can also click the
Analysis menu, Create, and then Copy.
The Copy Failure Modes wizard appears showing the Select Source
step. For example:
When the source is a template, the Primary asset box displays the
asset type and Source structure starts at is not available.
Tip: You can also copy individual failure modes or action plans
from the current analysis or template to another one. Right-click
the failure mode or action plan in a table and click Copy To. The
Copy Failure Modes wizard appears, displaying the Identify Tar-
get step.
3. All of the source failure modes are selected by default. Clear any that
you do not wish to copy and click Next. The Identify Target step
appears. This example shows the step when the source is an analysis:
• Existing analysis
• New MTA2
• New MTA2 template
The options on the Identify Target step change depending on the
option you select.
Tip: In some cases, you might wish to change the source asset
structure, target asset structure, or both. When the starting
assets occupy parallel positions in their respective hierarchies,
the mapping process is more likely to result in accurate matches.
Tip: For quick copies (when you do not need to adjust the mapping
options), click Finish when you have selected the target options.
The wizard performs the matching process and goes to the Con-
firm Selections step. Skip to step 16.
7. If the Asset mapping list is available, you can change the asset map-
ping that will be suggested if APM cannot identify a matching target.
The options are:
• Create new – a copy of the failure mode is created when the copy
request is processed
• Update existing – the source failure modes’ properties are cop-
ied to the target failure modes
10. Click Next. The wizard matches objects as needed and presents the
mappings for your review. For example:
The Suggestion Origin column displays the method used for match-
ing. The options are:
• Previous match – the “Use results of previous copy” option is in
effect
• Suggested – the mapping is based on another criteria, for exam-
ple, hierarchy level or attribute matching
• Default – for assets, the source and target primary assets are
automatically matched. For employees, maintenance groups, and
trades, the source object is used as the target, provided that it is
valid at the target site.
• Manual – the user selected the mapping
To see information about mappings for other objects, select their tabs
and click Criteria and SQL.
Tip: You can also double-click a mapping to review the Asset Map-
ping dialog.
14. Click Next. If you are updating existing failure modes, the Review
FM Mappings step appears.
15. Click Next or Finish. The Confirm Selections step appears. For
example:
16. Check the items that will be created or updated. If an incorrect copy
request is processed, you will have to make the corrections manually.
Click View to see more details about the items.
The Failure Modes tab shows information about the source failure
modes. If you wish to remove a failure mode from the list, right-click
it and click Remove. Click Back to make adjustments on previous
pages.
17. On the Acknowledgment tab, in the Options area, select the pro-
cessing options:
Open target analy- Target analyses are opened after the copy
ses request is processed.
1. Select the mapping in the Asset mappings table, click the Selected
list, then Mark As and Map To.
3. If you selected “Map To”, the next step is to select a new target asset.
You can adjust the list of assets in the table using the Show options:
• Matching assets – displays candidates identified during the
original matching process
5. If the target asset has descendant assets in the analysis, you can
apply the mapping option to them as well. Select one of the Update
options:
Using the Copy Failure Modes wizard to copy strategy development pro-
grams can involve as many as five steps:
The steps appear at the bottom of each page. The current step is shown in
blue. Any step that is not required for your copy is disabled.
Note: If you copy a failure mode from a site that uses a different
currency, any monetary amounts defined on the action plan are
converted to the asset’s site currency. If an exchange rate is not
available, the amount is converted at par (for example, one U.S.
dollar is equivalent to one Canadian dollar).
2. Right-click an asset in any of the tabs, click Copy, and then Strat-
egy Development Program.
Note: You can also open the asset, click the Tools menu, and then
Copy Strategy Development Program.
The Copy Failure Modes wizard appears, showing the Select Source
step. For example:
All of the asset’s failure modes are displayed in the table and selected
by default. Because only action plans are defined in current practice
reviews, their Failure Mode and Failure Effect cells are blank.
3. Clear any failure modes or action plans that you do not wish to copy
and click Next. The Identify Target step appears. For example:
5. In the Asset option list, select “Existing asset” or “New asset”. If you
choose to create an asset, a browse icon appears in the Parent box so
that you can select its parent asset.
6. If you are copying to existing assets, select the target asset in either
of these ways:
• Click the browse icon to select the starting asset for the target
structure.
In some cases, you might wish to change the source asset struc-
ture. When the starting assets occupy parallel positions in their
respective hierarchies, the mapping process is more likely to
result in accurate matches.
• Select Multiple target assets if you wish to copy to two or more
assets and select them in the table.
7. You can change the Asset mapping option that determines what will
be suggested if APM cannot identify a matching target. The options
are:
Tip: For quick copies (when you do not need to adjust the mapping
options), click Finish when you have selected the target. The wiz-
ard performs the matching process and skips to the Confirm
Selections step. Skip to step 13.
9. Click Next. The wizard matches objects as needed and presents the
mappings for your review. For example:
The Suggestion Origin column displays the method used for match-
ing. The options are:
• Previous match – the “Use results of previous copy” option is in
effect
• Suggested – the mapping is based on another criteria, for exam-
ple, hierarchy level or attribute matching
• Default – for assets, the source and target primary assets are
automatically matched. For employees, maintenance groups, and
trades, the source object is used as the target, provided that it is
valid at the target site.
• Manual – the user selected the mapping
To see information about mappings for other objects, select their tabs
and click Criteria and SQL.
13. Click Next or Finish. The Confirm Selections step appears. For
example:
14. Review the items that will be created or updated. If an incorrect copy
request is processed, you will have to make the corrections manually.
Click View to see more details about the items.
15. The Failure Modes tab shows information about the source failure
modes. If you wish to remove a failure mode from the list, right-click
it and click Remove. Click Back to make adjustments on previous
pages.
16. On the Acknowledgment tab, in the Options area, select the pro-
cessing options:
Open target analy- Target analyses are opened after the copy
ses request is processed.
17. Click Process or Finish if Process later is selected. One of the fol-
lowing occurs:
1. Select the mapping in the Asset mappings table, click the Selected
list, then Mark As and Map To.
3. If you selected “Map To”, the next step is to select a new target asset.
You can adjust the list of assets in the table using the Show options:
• Matching assets – displays candidates identified during the
original matching process
5. If the target asset has descendant assets in the analysis, you can
apply the mapping option to them as well. Select one of the Update
options:
• Open the request to view information about the source and target,
mappings, and results
• Resume defining and processing pending copy requests
• Keep track of your review process by marking processed requests as
“to be reviewed” and “reviewed”
1. In the site’s Copy Requests tab, select Not Processed from the list
of configurations. Only copy requests that have not been completed
are displayed.
2. Right-click the request and click Resume Definition. The Copy Fail-
ure Modes wizard opens, showing the step where the definition pro-
cess stopped.
1. In the Copy Requests tab, select Processed from the list of configu-
rations. The list of copy requests changes accordingly.
In the Copy Requests tab, you can scroll to the right to see the Process-
ing Review Status column. You can also select “Processing to be
reviewed” in the list of configurations.
This chapter explains how to change and monitor the statuses of analy-
ses, modify analyses, and access analysis information.
Contents
Changing the Status of Failure Modes and Analyses . . . . . . . . . . . . . 276
Sending an Analysis for Approval . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 280
Working with Action Plan Task Statuses . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 282
Viewing Information About an Analysis or Template . . . . . . . . . . . . . 284
Reviewing Analysis Assets’ Reliability Programs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 289
Printing MTA2 Reports . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 296
Linking Action Plans to Projects . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 301
Working With a Project’s Links to Action Plans. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 303
Changing the Primary Asset on an Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 305
Updating the Asset Hierarchy Snapshot . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 307
Viewing Failure Modes and Action Plans . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 308
Viewing Failure Modes for Standard Tasks and Jobs . . . . . . . . . . . . . 310
Editing an Asset’s Failure Modes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 313
To view the statuses of failure modes, open the analysis, select the Facil-
itation view and then the By Asset or By Hierarchy tab. The Action
plan status column displays each failure mode’s status. For example:
The following table shows your activities and the resulting status of the
analysis and its failure modes. The analysis statuses are also used for
templates.
2. Open the analysis containing the failure mode. Select the Facilita-
tion view and the Info Worksheet, By Asset, or By Hierarchy tab.
• To complete a failure mode, right-click it, click Mark As, and then
Facilitation Completed, Implementation Completed, or
Implementation Not Required.
• To reopen a completed failure mode, right-click it, click Mark As,
and then Facilitation Incomplete.
1. From the site’s Strategy Development view and tab, select the
MTA2 tab.
Tip: You can also view the list of analyses from an asset’s Strat-
egy Development view and tab, Analyses tab.
2. Do one of the following:
Tip: For general information about the approval process, see “Doc-
ument Approvals” in Help. For instructions on approving
requests, see “Approving a Document” in Help.
If your organization uses the APM formal approval process, it is typically
employed to vet the analysis when implementation has been completed
for all failure modes. An analysis can be sent for approval when:
Tip: You can also right-click the analysis in a table and click Send
for Approval.
The Route Selector dialog appears. For example:
2. Select the Approval Route from the list. Only approval routes that
are valid for strategy development analyses and the analysis type are
listed.
4. Click Send for Approval. The approval request is sent to the first
approver on the approval route and the approval status is updated
(shown in the window banner). If a study status is linked to the event,
the status is updated.
You can set up the statuses required by your organization in failure mode
settings at the site level.
For information about creating action plan task statuses, see “Setting up
Action Plan Task Statuses” in Help.
Tip: To view charts of action plans by task type and status, make
sure that your employee record includes the Site sidebar setting
“APM standard sidebars”.
• To view a history of the changes made to the analysis, select the His-
tory view. The History view displays the Analysis Audit Info,
Asset Audit Info, Status, and Copy Requests tabs.
• To view the failure modes created from a template’s failure mode,
open the Maintenance Action Plan window for the template’s failure
mode and click the Usage view. This view lists the failure modes cre-
ated from the template.
This topic explains the information displayed on the Analysis Sum-
mary view and the History view.
Tip: You can also open an analysis from the asset’s Strategy
Development view and tab. Select the Strategy Development
tab.
2. Double-click the analysis or template that you wish to view. The
Strategy Development Analysis window appears.
The Action Plans by Task Type and Action Plans by Status charts
shown in the following example are set up as sidebar dashboards and
assigned to employees. For more information, see “Dashboards” in
Help.
• The Indicators tab shows counts of the action plans for each indica-
tor. Click to expand an indicator’s list of action plans.
• The Corrective Tasks tab shows counts of the standard tasks and
jobs. You can also select configurations that show counts of action
plans by task and by job. Click to see the list of tasks or jobs.
• On the Analysis Audit Info tab, the By Event and By Data Ele-
ment tabs list the actions performed on the analysis, the date when
each action was performed, and the APM user who performed it.
Whether you view the actions according to event or data element, you
can see the new and old values for each data element in the Audit
details table.
• On the Analysis Audit Info tab in the example, the By Event tab
displays an icon for the audit report created when the analysis was
marked “Closed”. Double-click a report icon to open the document.
Tip: The type of report and its format (for example, PDF or plain
text) are defined in the analysis type assigned to the analysis. For
information about enabling this feature, see “Setting up Analysis
Types” in Help.
• The General tab displays the date and time when the analysis was
created and last updated, as well as the APM users who performed
the actions.
• The Asset Audit Info tab displays actions performed on the asset by
event and by data element.
• The Status tab displays the dates on which milestones were com-
pleted on the analysis, as well as its current status.
• The Copy Requests tab lists occasions when the current analysis
was copied, including the status of the copy, the target analysis, and
the APM user who performed the action.
• The Activity Reports tab lists the asset activity reports for this
analysis, and the asset activity reports in which the analysis is
included.
The identification area at the top of the dialog shows the ID number
and name of the item you selected, as well as the site. If the request is
for a task, job, job task, or indicator, its asset is also identified.
2. Select the type of action requested: New, Modification, or Dele-
tion.
5. You can add a planning document at this time or when the request is
processed. To add a work request or work order to track the request’s
action:
• Select the Planning Document tab and click Create work doc-
ument. For example:
4. To cancel a request, select it in the table, click the Selected list and
then Cancel Request. The request’s status changes to “Canceled”.
Several types of analysis reports are provided with APM, which you can
print from the Strategy Development Analysis window or from the site’s
Strategy Development view.
You can also create custom reports or modify existing reports. For more
information, see “Reports” in Help.
Audit Reports
If audit reports are supported for an analysis type, when an analysis of
that type is marked “Closed”, an audit report can be created and added to
the analysis’s History view, Analysis Audit Info tab, By Event tab.
For example:
The type of report and its format (for example, PDF or plain text) are
defined in the analysis type assigned to the analysis. For information
about enabling this feature, see “Setting up Analysis Types” in Help.
Analysis Reports
You can print general reports that are available for all types of strategy
development analysis:
• Asset List: lists the analysis assets by number, their material types,
priority, degradation allowances, in service dates, and names.
• Criticality Analysis: lists the failure modes and the scores from
their probability, confidence, and consequences evaluations.
Tip: You can also print the Fault Diagnosis Guide for the site or
an asset. On the site window, click the Site menu, Print, Failure
modes, and then Fault Diagnosis Guide. The site report lists
all of the site’s symptoms, the failure modes that reference them,
and their primary assets. On the asset window, click the Asset
menu, Print, and Fault Diagnosis Guide. The asset report lists
all of the symptoms identified on the asset’s failure modes.
• Maintenance Feasibility: lists the analysis information followed by
the failure modes and their proposed tasks, probability and conse-
quence analysis results, MEI support, and the results of the feasibil-
ity assessment. This includes the ETBF, ETBC, avoidance savings,
and original and residual criticality.
• Modifications: lists action plans that recommend redesign as the
desired or compulsory action. The proposed modification is listed, as
well as the trade and modification type.
• Notes and Comments: lists analysis assets, failure modes, and
notes, as well as analysis comments.
• Risk Analysis: lists the analysis number and title, primary asset,
and team facilitator. Failure modes are listed by asset, along with the
results of their probability and consequence severity evaluations. For
each failure mode, the consequence priority and criticality score are
displayed.
• Work Package: lists failure modes according to the trade assigned to
them. The frequency and operating condition are listed, as well as the
asset number, recommended action description, and task duration.
The report does not include action plans that recommend “No sched-
uled maintenance” and have no action type, that are analyzed sepa-
rately, or that have not been analyzed.
This topic describes how to print analysis reports. For information about
saving a report to a file, see “Printing Documents” in Help.
Tip: You can also print the report by right-clicking the analysis in
any list, clicking Print, General, and then the report type.
2. In the Strategy Development Analysis window, click the Analysis
menu, Print, General, and then the report you’d like to print.
Tip: You can also print a failure mode’s details report. Open the
Maintenance Action Plan window, click the Failure mode menu,
Print, and then Failure Mode Details.
The Print Report dialog appears. For example:
• Click All to print files attached to the analysis and its failure
modes.
• Click Selected from list to choose the attachments to print.
When you click Print or Print with Options, the Attachments
to Print dialog appears, listing the file names, the objects they are
attached to, and their attachment types.
5. If you are printing the Work Package, select the filter criteria to
include.
6. If you are not printing attachments, you can click Preview to see
what the report will look like before printing it.
Tip: In the Preview dialog, click the File menu to print the report,
export it to a file, or send it by email in one of several formats.
7. In the Print Report dialog, do one of the following:
To view the projects linked to an analysis’ action plans, select the Imple-
mentation view, Projects tab. When viewing a Project window, you can
see a list of the action plans that are linked to it in the Properties view,
Action Plans tab.
This section explains how to link action plans to new and existing proj-
ects.
2. Right-click the failure mode in the table, click Link to Project, and
then Modifications. The Request Project for Failure Mode Modifica-
tion dialog appears.
This topic explains how to add and remove links between a project and
action plan.
3. On the Properties view, select the Action Plans tab. This tab lists
the action plans that have been linked to the project.
The original asset remains in the analysis. It is displayed under the new
primary asset in the analysis asset hierarchy. If the analysis options
specify that descendants be included, the new primary asset’s child
assets are added to the analysis.
6. In the Asset box, click the browse icon to open the Asset Selector dia-
log. Select the new primary asset and click OK. The asset is displayed
as the new primary asset.
7. Select the Hierarchy tab. The original primary asset is moved under
the new primary asset in the analysis hierarchy. Any of the original
primary asset’s descendants that are not also descendants of the new
primary asset are also moved.
Also, at any time, you can refresh the analysis hierarchy with new infor-
mation about the physical hierarchy. For example, if a descendant was
added to the primary asset in the physical hierarchy, updating the analy-
sis hierarchy adds the descendant to the analysis. If the position of an
asset changes in the physical hierarchy, the change is reflected in the
analysis.
Note: If you deleted assets from your analysis, updating the snap-
shot might add them back into the analysis. For example, if you
based the analysis on a primary asset and its descendants and
then deleted one of the descendants, the update adds it back into
the snapshot. However, assets that were excluded from the analy-
sis are not re-included when the analysis hierarchy is updated.
5. In the confirmation dialog that appears, click Yes. The assets’ hierar-
chy is updated with the latest information from the physical hierar-
chy.
To view... Select...
All of a site’s failure 1. Strategy Development view and tab
modes and action plans on the Site window
2. Either:
To view... Select...
An asset’s functions, 1. Strategy Development view and tab
functional failures, and on the Asset window
related failure modes
2. Functions tab
The Failure Modes tab displays the failure modes on which the
standard task is referenced as a corrective action. The second table
lists the failure modes that include indicators that reference the stan-
dard task. The third table lists the failure modes that reference the
standard task and indicators.
The Job Tasks tab displays information about the standard job and
its tasks. The Job tab displays the failure modes where the job is
assigned as a corrective task or candidate.
After failure modes have been created, you can view and modify them
from the site’s and the asset’s Strategy Development views. You can
change the failure mode definition, failure effect, failure type, failure
classification, and description.
The Analysis view lists the analyses that include the failure mode.
The Failures view displays information about any failures tracked
against the failure mode.
2. Make sure that editing is enabled.
5. Select the Description tab to change the long description for the fail-
ure mode.
Contents
Creating an MTA2 Template . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 318
Setting up a Template Hierarchy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 327
Viewing Template Hierarchies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 332
Moving an Analysis Template to a Different Site. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 333
• The asset type, rather than a specific asset, is displayed on the Strat-
egy Development analysis window.
• The Assets tab is not available in the Properties view.
• No information is displayed in the Asset boxes and columns in the
analysis.
• You can create or browse for an indicator template, task template, or
job template to add to an action plan. When an analysis is created
from the template or when the action plan is copied into another anal-
ysis, the system checks the asset for an existing indicator, standard
task, or standard job based on the template. If it does not find one, a
new indicator, task, or job is created using the template.
2. Click the Analysis menu, Create, and then Copy. The Copy Failure
Mode wizard appears.
3. By default, all of the failure modes are selected. Clear the boxes for
the failure modes that you wish to exclude.
7. The Asset type box displays the asset type of the primary asset of
the source analysis. Select another asset type, if appropriate.
9. Click Next to view the Review Mappings step. This page displays
matches for employees, trades, maintenance groups, and other
resources.
10. Click Next. The Confirm Selections step appears. For example:
11. Check the items that will be created or updated. If an incorrect copy
request is processed, you will have to make the corrections manually.
Click View to see more details about the items.
12. The Failure Modes tab displays information about the failure
modes. If you wish to remove a failure mode from the list, right-click
it and click Remove. Click Back to make adjustments on previous
pages.
13. On the Acknowledgment tab, in the Options area, select the pro-
cessing options:
Open target analy- Target analyses are opened after the copy
ses request is processed.
6. In the Title box, the default name for the template follows this pat-
tern:
10. To set the general properties of the template, select the Properties
view. The General tab displays information about the template. For
example:
13. To add the new template to a hierarchy, select a parent template, for
example, a hierarchy node. In the Hierarchy view, the new template
appears below the parent and its child templates. For example:
15. Select the Analysis Options tab to specify the sites where the tem-
plate’s failure modes are to be available. For example, if the template
is available at the current site only, its failure modes cannot be copied
to analyses on other sites. You can also prevent the failure modes
from being copied by selecting Not available for use.
16. Select the Failure Mode Options tab and the Template Options
tab. The Failure mode descriptions can be changed option is
selected by default. Clear this option if you want failure mode descrip-
tions to be read-only.
You are now ready to develop the template by creating failure modes and
more.
The simplest way to set up this hierarchy is to create a node for the Pump
asset type. Then, in each template’s properties, assign the node as the
template’s parent. In any template’s Hierarchy view, you can rearrange,
add, and remove templates in the hierarchy. This topic explains how:
Tip: You can also select the Administration menu, Asset Man-
agement Settings, and then Asset Management. The Asset
Management Settings dialog appears.
2. Select the Asset Types tab and open the asset type for the template
node. The Asset Type window appears.
3. Click Usage to open the Asset Type Usage dialog. Select the Strat-
egy development templates tab. From the New list, select Tem-
plate Hierarchy Node. For example:
5. The default title for the hierarchy node follows the pattern:
Asset type - Template hierarchy node
5. Click the browse icon to select a parent template, for example, a hier-
archy node. In the Hierarchy view, the template appears below the
parent and any existing child templates.
Tip: Other useful options in this list are Change Parent and
Remove from Hierarchy.
The Strategy Development Analysis Selector dialog appears. To view
a list of templates and nodes, select one of the template configura-
tions.
4. Select the template or node and click OK. The template or node is
added to the template hierarchy, along with its descendant templates
and nodes, if any.
5. You can move templates up or down and left or right in the hierarchy
using the arrow buttons at the bottom of the Template Hierarchy
tab. The availability of the buttons varies depending on the position
of the selected template.
Tip: You can also drag and drop templates to change their posi-
tions.
2. Select a template in the hierarchy to view its details and action plans.
For example:
You can move a strategy development analysis template from one site to
another.
Note: If action plans exist that are based on the template’s action
plans, the link between the template and action plans might be
broken. This occurs if the template is moved to a lower level site
or to a different branch of the site hierarchy.
6. Click OK. The template is moved to the other site and renumbered.
G
Glossary, MTA2 39
H
Hierarchy Node 327
I
Implementation Completed Status, MTA2
276
Indicator Collection Reports
For MTA2 203
Indicators
Adding to MTA2 Action Plans 192
Initial Risk
MTA2 Feasibility Evaluations 171
Inspection Tasks
Adding to MTA2 Action Plans 192
L
Linking
Removing Project Links to MTA2 Action
R
RCA
Failure Modes, Source of 207
Reliability Program Review Requests
MTA2 289
Reports, MTA2 296
S
Secondary Action Plans, MTA2 184
Severity of Usage Values, Assigning to Fail-
ure Modes
MTA2 207
Standard Documents
Adding to MTA2 Action Plans 205
Standard Jobs
Adding to MTA2 Action Plans 192
Viewing Failure Modes 310
Standard Tasks
Adding to MTA2 Action Plans 192
Viewing Failure Modes 310
Status
Changing MTA2 276
Strategy Development View, MTA2 31
Susceptibility to Failure Evaluations
MTA2 124
Symptoms, Assigning to Failure Modes
MTA2 210
T
Template Hierarchies, MTA2 327